Annexure TO SCHEDULE II, Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) Regulations, 2012.: ANNEXURE TO SCHEDULE II
Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) Regulations, 2012. - Annexure TO SCHEDULE II
Text of annexure TO SCHEDULE II
ANNEXURE TO SCHEDULE II
ANNEXURE TO SCHEDULE II
LICENCE FEE RATES
(A) A LA CARTE RATES
Channels
Rate to multi system operator
(Rs.)
33
(B) BOUQUET RATES
BOUQUET – 1
Channels
Rate to multi system
operator (Rs)
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
BOUQUET- 2
Channels
Rate to multi system
operator (Rs)
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
34
6.
BOUQUET 3
Channels
Rate to multi system
operator (Rs)
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
35
Schedule – III
Performa for reporting by Multi System Operator of interconnect agreements entered into by them with
Broadcasters & Local Cable Operators
Column
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
S. No Name of
contracting
parties
Complete
Address of
party with
District,
State, Pin
Code and
telephone
number
Service
Area of
Operation
Name of the
Bouquet with
Number of
channels
Rate of
bouquet
Subscriber
Base ( Month
wise w.e.f.
July of the
previous year
and upto June
of the current
year )
Name of a-la-
carte Channel
& Number of
channels
Rate of a-
la-carte
channel
Column
10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
Discount,
if any
Subscriber
Base ( Month
wise w.e.f.
July of the
previous year
and upto June
of the current
year )
IRD/VC No.
- Channel
Wise
Term of
IRD
Agreement
Number with
date
Date of
Commence-
ment of the
agreement
Date of expiry
of the
agreement
Carriage fee
paid by the
broadcaster
Remarks,
if any
Page 36 of 45
Annexure
Explanatory Memorandum
I. Background
1. On 10.12.2004, TRAI made an interconnection regulation applicable for broadcasting
and cable TV sector. The regulation was called the “Telecommunication (Broadcasting and
Cable Services) Interconnection Regulation 2004 (13 of 2004)”. There have been six
amendments made to this regulation.
2. The interconnection regulations provide for the basic structure on the matters of
interconnection. These regulations cover arrangements among service providers for
interconnection and revenue share, for all broadcasting and cable services. The main features
of the regulations are: provision of ‘must provide’ (i.e. non discriminatory access) for the
broadcasters and the provision for ‘disconnection of TV signals’. The regulations prescribe
notice period for disconnection. In the notice for disconnection, the reasons for disconnection
are to be given. No notice for disconnection is required if there is no written agreement
permitting distribution of signals. For the information of the consumers, it has been provided
that the notice for disconnection should be published in newspapers in accordance with the
relevant provisions of the regulations. These regulations also provide for publishing of
Reference Interconnect Offer by broadcasters for non-addressable as well as addressable
cable TV systems.
3. In the last few years, the exponential growth in the number of TV channels (both Free
To Air and Pay) combined with the inherent limitations of the analogue cable TV systems,
has posed several challenges in the cable TV sector, mainly due to capacity constraints and
non-addressable nature of the network. With time and evolution of technology, new
addressable digital TV platforms like DTH, IPTV etc. were introduced to the masses. The
evolution of technology also paved way for bringing about digitization with addressability in
the cable TV sector. Accordingly, after studying the subject at length and undertaking a
public consultation process, the Authority, on 5th August 2010, gave its recommendations on
implementation of Digital Addressable Cable TV Systems (DAS) across the country along
with a roadmap to achieve the same.
Page 37 of 45
4. The Government, on 25th October, 2011, issued an Ordinance amending the Cable
Television Networks (Regulation) Act, 1995, paving way for the implementation of digital
addressable cable TV systems in India. Thereafter, the Government also issued a notification
dated 11th November, 2011, which laid down the roadmap for implementation, in a four
phased manner, from June 2012 to December, 2014. The Ordinance dated 25th October,
2011, subsequently, in December, 2011, became an Act.
5. Considering the amended provisions of the Cable Television Networks (Regulation) Act,
1995, and the notification dated 11.11.2011 mentioned above, the Authority initiated a
consultation process on the issues relating to implementation of digital addressable cable TV
systems. In this connection a consultation paper titled “Issues related to Implementation of
Digital Addressable Cable TV Systems” was issued on 22.12.2011. The issues for
consultation related to the amendments to the existing interconnection regulations, the
subscription revenue share between the MSO and LCO, whether “must carry” provision
should be mandated for the MSOs, whether the carriage fee is to be regulated and whether
there should be a specified standard interconnection agreement between service providers
applicable for DAS areas. An Open House Discussion (OHD) was also held in New Delhi on
13th March, 2012.
II. Analysis of issues
6. The following is a summary of main issues, comments of the stakeholders and analysis
thereon.
Note: To make it convenient for ease of reference and understanding by all the stakeholders,
the instant regulations consolidate all the earlier interconnection regulations and the
regulations now made are applicable for digital addressable cable TV systems.
A. Suggested Amendments to Interconnection Regulations
The issue for consideration was whether any of the existing clauses of the Interconnection
Regulations require modifications.
Page 38 of 45
7. During the course of the consultation process, broadcasters/aggregators suggested
modifications in certain clauses of the existing interconnection regulations such as
reduction in notice period for disconnection of signals, procedure for auditing of the
Subscriber Management System (SMS) of the service provider and on the technical side it
was suggest that a provision be made in the interconnection regulations for integration of
SMS and the Conditional Access System (CAS) so as to ensure complete addressability of
the system. It was also suggested that the provisions may be made in the regulations for anti
piracy and fingerprinting measures and for making provision for filing of interconnect
agreements by MSOs/LCOs and also a provision for minimum period of subscription. It was
also suggested that clause 3.2 of the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services)
Interconnection Regulation, 2004, relating to “must provide” may also be qualified by
making it inoperative in cases of service providers who have failed to comply with any of the
regulations. It was also suggested by the stakeholders that certain definitions in the existing
interconnection regulation may be required to be amended to bring them in line with the
provisions of Cable Television Act as amended in 2011. Some MSOs expressed the view that
they are not in favor of any modification in existing clauses. Some of the LCOs have
suggested that there is a need to amend the clauses of interconnection regulations relating to
the notice period for disconnection and for making provisions for revenue sharing
arrangements.
8. On the issue of filing of interconnect agreements by the MSOs, the Authority considered
the suggestion and decided to incorporate a provision in this regard in this regulation so as to
bring in the transparency in the system. A provision has been made in this regulation for
reporting the details of interconnect agreements by the MSOs along with the details of
carriage fee paid by the broadcasters. The reporting requirement, prescribed in the present
regulations, makes a provision for the broadcasters to file the details of carriage fee paid by
them. On the issue of amendments to definitions, the definitions such as “addressable
system”, “broadcaster”, “cable operator”, “multi system operator”, “pay channel” and
"subscriber management system" have been aligned with that of the amended Cable
Television Networks (Regulation) Act, 1995 and also the amended Cable Television
Networks Rules, 1994. On the issue of minimum period of subscription, a provision has been
made in the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable) Services (Digital Addressable
Cable TV Areas) Tariff Order, 2012. On the issue of Notice period for disconnection, the
Authority considered the fact that the notice period should be sufficient for the affected
Page 39 of 45
parties to be able to approach the appropriate forum to plead for intervention and to give the
consumers an opportunity to approach the necessary forum. The Authority, therefore, decided
that the existing period of the notice of 21 days is to be retained. On the suggestion of the
audit of SMS, the Authority considered the fact that the existing provisions of the
interconnect regulations provide for upto two audits in a calendar year. The Authority felt
that this is sufficient opportunity for audit and, therefore, decided that there is no need to
modify the existing provisions in this regard. On the issue of integration of SMS and CAS,
the Authority observed that the existing interconnection framework provides for integration
of SMS and CA system for activation and deactivation process from SMS to be
simultaneously done through both the systems. The Authority is of the view that this
provision is adequate and therefore no change is required. On the issue of Anti Piracy and
fingerprinting the Authority observed that the existing framework provides that operator shall
deploy finger printing mechanisms to detect any piracy, violation of copyright and
unauthorized viewing of the Channels, distributed / transmitted through its platform. The
Authority is of the view that this provision is adequate and therefore no change is required on
this issue. On the issue of Qualified “Must Provide”, the Authority observed that the
violations of regulations are to be dealt with as per the provisions of the TRAI Act, 1997.
The Authority is, therefore, of the view that no further qualifications are required in this
provision.
B. The “Must Carry” provision
9. The issue is that should the ‘must carry’ provision be mandated for the MSO. If so, what
should be the qualifying conditions and the manner in which an MSO should offer access to
its network for the carriage of TV channel. The majority of the broadcasters are in favour of
mandating must carry provisions to balance out the ‘must provide’ clause prescribed in the
existing interconnect regulations. They have suggested that the manner of offering network
access should be on a non-discriminatory basis and the qualifying conditions may include
openness to audit & transparency, non-discriminatory listing of channels and all channels
should feature genre-wise in the EPG of MSO. One broadcaster has also suggested that the
‘must carry’ provisions need not be mandated.
10. Majority of the MSOs and LCOs have suggested that there should not be any must
carry provision. Some of them have suggested that it can be mandated only for DD channels.
Regarding the manner, one LCO has suggested that Carriage fee should be the qualifying
Page 40 of 45
condition for all ‘must carry’ channels except Doordarshan channels. Few LCOs have
supported the must carry provision and stated that it should be regulated by TRAI. Other
stakeholders who have offered their comments are not in favour of ‘must carry’ provision.
11. In the digital transmission environment, the capacity to carry the channels is very high.
So one of the main advantages of a digital environment to the subscriber is the availability of
large number of channels. However, there is a component of cost to carry channels. If the
operator is compensated for the cost of carriage of a channel, there should not be any
technological or other infrastructural constraints for the operator to carry a channel. Further,
as per the Cable Television Networks (Amendment) Rules, 2012, the channel carrying
capacity of the multi system operator is to be specified by the Authority.
12. The analysis of the operational channels (Annexure-A attached with this Explanatory
Memorandum) shows that the maximum number of channels that are relevant to a State or
Union Territory, language-wise, are 473 (in Andhra Pradesh) out of the 650 operational
private channels (as on April, 2012). Besides this there are 18 channels of the Prasar Bharati
and one Lok Sabha channel (in total 19 channels) that may also be relevant for all the States
and the UTs to cater to the infotainment requirements of minority populace of these States
and UTs. It is also noted that the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting has granted
permission to 831 channels under uplinking/downlinking guidelines, as on 6th March, 2012.
It is also likely that certain more channels may get operational by 1.1.2013. Thus, it is
logical that maximum number of channels that may be required to be carried in a digital
addressable cable TV system network, for present, is taken as 500 channels per headend.
Therefore, the present regulations provide for creating a capacity of 500 channels per
headend by 1.1.2013. Further, it has been seen that there are two types of MSOs viz., large
sized MSOs having subscriber base of more than 25,000 subscribers with upper limit
running into lakhs of subscribers and smaller MSOs having around 25,000 subscribers or
lesser number of subscribers. Due to the larger size of operations, the large sized MSOs are
better equipped to have the capacity to set up digital addressable cable TV systems in lesser
time than the smaller sized MSOs. Therefore, to provide more time to smaller MSOs to
create capacity of 500 channels per head end, the time line has been prescribed as 1st April,
2013 and for the large sized MSOs, the time line has been kept as 1st January, 2013.
However, considering the fact that the four metros of Delhi, Mumbai, Kolkata and Chennai
are to go digital on 1st July, 2012, and many of the MSOs may not be able to create a capacity
Page 41 of 45
to carry a minimum 500 channels per headend by this date, in the first instant, they have been
allowed to operate with a minimum capacity of 200 channels per headend.
13. To allow the multi system operator to provide the access to its cable network smoothly, a
time frame of sixty (60) days has been provided for in the regulations which is equivalent to
the time frame given to the broadcaster under the must provide provisions. In no case this
time period be more than sixty days (60 days) from the date of request seeking access to the
network of the multi system operator.
14. A responsibility has also been cast upon the broadcaster or the access seeker to the cable
network of the MSO under the provisions of ‘must carry’ to ensure the subscription of the
channel at a minimum level of more than or equal to five per cent. (5%) of the subscriber
base of that MSO taken on an average of subscriber base for the preceding six months. In
case of failure to maintain this subscriber base, the network provider, in his discretion, can
refuse to grant further access to the network for a period of next one year. Such a refusal
would not be considered a violation of the “Must carry” provision.
C. “Carriage fee”
15. The issues are should the carriage fee be regulated and if so, should its quantum be linked
to some parameters. News Broadcaster Association is of the view that carriage fee should be
regulated. This Association is of the view that if must carry is mandated, the question of
carriage fee does not arise. Majority of the broadcasters and one association of broadcasters
are not in favor of regulating the carriage fee and have suggested that it should be based on
the mutual negotiation between the broadcaster and MSO. Few who favored suggested that
the parameters can be the subscriber base of the MSO, number of STB installed etc. One of
the broadcaster suggested that carriage fee should not exceed 10% of the subscription fee
collected for the channels not covered under the must carry mandatory clause.
16. MSOs are not in favor of any kind of regulatory intervention on carriage fee. Most of the
LCOs are not in favor of regulating the carriage fee. Some of the LCOs suggested that the
carriage fee should be regulated and can be linked with the no. of STBs installed, gross
collection of subscription amount, size and locality of the network etc. Some LCOs are
suggesting that LCO should also get a part from the carriage fee.
Page 42 of 45
17. In the addressable systems, due to transparency in ascertaining the number of
subscribers, the subscription revenue is expected to go up. Therefore, the dependence of
MSOs on the carriage fee, as a source of revenue, is likely to be reduced. Considering all the
aspects, the Authority is of the view that there is a need to regulate the carriage fee.
Accordingly, the following scheme has been worked out. The MSOs who charge carriage fee
are required to declare the carriage fee for carrying a TV channel. The carriage fee shall be
charged in a non-discriminatory and transparent manner. Also the carriage fee can not be
revised upward for a minimum period of 2 years. The details of the carriage fee is to be filed
with the Authority. In case the Authority finds it necessary, it shall intervene and ask for
appropriate modifications in the carriage fee.
D. Standard Interconnect Agreement (SIA)
18. The issue is whether TRAI prescribe a standard interconnection agreement between
service providers. Nearly half of the broadcasters who offered their comments on the issue
are not in favour of prescribing SIA by the Authority whereas others are in favour of SIA
prescription by the Authority. Those who favoured, suggested that the piracy and termination
clauses should be reviewed.
19. MSOs are in favour of SIA prescription by the Authority except for one MSO who has
suggested that RIO based mechanism, has worked well for DTH sector, so it should be
extended to DAS. Majority of LCOs are in favour of SIA whereas some of them have
suggested that there is no immediate requirement of SIA.
20. The Authority is of the view that as the interconnection regulations already provide for
the necessary regulatory framework for addressable systems, in the form of RIO, which were
not there in the year 2006 when SIA was prescribed for CAS, there is no need for prescribing
Standard Interconnect Agreement between Broadcaster and MSO and also between MSO and
LCO in the Digital Addressable Cable TV System. The Authority is of the view that the
RIO based prescription should prevail in DAS also.
E. Advertisement free (ad-free) channels
21. The issues are what should be the provisions in the interconnection regulations in respect
of advertisement free channels and what should be the revenue sharing arrangement between
the broadcasters and distributors in respect of such channels. Some broadcasters and an MSO
Page 43 of 45
stated that existing requirements/stipulations of Interconnect Regulations, viz. ‘must provide’
should not apply to advertisement free channels and the broadcasters & respective service
providers should be free to enter into agreements on mutually acceptable terms in order to
provide incentives to all the players in the value chain to create, develop and market new
innovative and non-mass-market advertisement based television content. Majority of other
stakeholders, who have responded to these issues, say that the provisions of the existing
interconnection regulations should be applicable to advertisement free channels also so that
consumers are not deprived of such channels. Some cable operators are of the view that
provisions of the interconnection regulations as applicable to the notified CAS areas should
be applied for the advertisement free channels. As far as the sharing of the subscription
revenue of the ad-free channels is concerned, all the broadcasters have expressed the views
that it should be left for the commercial negotiations between the service providers. Some of
the other stakeholders have suggested that revenue share be decided in the same way as any
other pay channel while others have suggested different percentages for broadcaster, MSO
and LCO, however, without any justification for this suggestion.
22. The issue of rates of advertisement free channels and sharing of subscription revenues
of such channels has been dealt with by separately in the provisions of the
Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable) Services (Fourth) (Addressable Systems)
Tariff (First Amendment) Order, 2012. Authority is of the view that there is no need to
change the existing policy of leaving it to the market forces. To prevent denial of the signals
of the channels by the broadcaster to the MSO or denial by the MSO to carry the channels,
such channels can not be mandated to be outside of the purview of the clauses on ‘must
provide’ and ‘must carry’ of the interconnection regulations as this would not be in the
interests of the consumers.
*******
Page 44 of 45
Annexure-A
State‐wise/UT‐wise maximum number of TV channels language‐wise relevant to the particular state
or UT out of operational 650 private channels granted permission by the Ministry of Information and
Broadcasting under the downlinking guidelines (data as on April, 2012)
Sl.
No.
States Number of
channels
Languages
1 Andhra Pradesh 473 Hindi/ English/Telgu+19 channels*
2 Arunachal Pradesh 425 Hindi/ English/NE and Assamese+19
channels
3 Assam 425 Hindi/ English/NE and Assamese+19
channels
4 Bihar 428 Hindi/ English/Bhojpuri+19 channels
5 Chhattisgarh 420 Hindi/ English+19 channels
6 Goa 438 Hindi/ English/Marathi+19 channels
7 Gujarat 428 Hindi/ English/Gujrati+19 channels
8 Haryana 441 Hindi/ English/Punjabi+19 channels
9 Himachal Pradesh 441 Hindi/ English/Punjabi+19 channels
10 Jammu and Kashmir 424 Hindi/ English/Urdu+19 channels
11 Jharkhand 428 Hindi/ English/Bhojpuri+19 channels
12 Karnataka 437 Hindi/ English/Kannada+19 channels
13 Kerala 451 Hindi/ English/Malyalam+19 channels
14 Madhya Pradesh 420 Hindi/ English/+19 channels
15 Maharashtra 438 Hindi/ English/Marathi+19 channels
16 Manipur 425 Hindi/ English/NE and Assamese+19
channels
17 Meghalaya 425 Hindi/ English/NE and Assamese+19
channels
18 Mizoram 425 Hindi/ English/NE and Assamese+19
channels
19 Nagaland 425 Hindi/ English/NE and Assamese+19
channels
20 Orissa 434 Hindi/ English/Oriya+19 channels
21 Punjab 441 Hindi/ English/Punjabi+19 channels
22 Rajasthan 420 Hindi/ English+19 channels
23 Sikkim 446 Hindi/ English/Bengali+19 channels
24 Tamil Nadu 462 Hindi/ English/Tamil+19 channels
25 Tripura 425 Hindi/ English/NE and Assamese + 19
channels
26 Uttaranchal 424 Hindi/ English/Urdu+19 channels
27 Uttar Pradesh 424 Hindi/ English/Urdu+19 channels
28 West Bengal 446 Hindi/ English/Bengali+19 channels
29 Andaman and Nicobar Islands 420 Hindi/ English+19 channels
30 Dadar and Nagar Haveli 420 Hindi/ English+19 channels
31 Daman and Diu 420 Hindi/ English+19 channels
Page 45 of 45
32 Lakshadeep 420 Hindi/ English+19 channels
33 Delhi 441 Hindi/ English/Punjabi+19 channels
34 Chandigarh 441 Hindi/ English/Punjabi+19 channels
35 Pondicherry 441 Hindi/English/ Tamil/ French+19 channels
* 19 channels includes 8 channels to be carried as per the provisions of the Cable Television
Networks (Regulation) Act, 1995 and 11 regional Prasar Bharati channels.
********
1
TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE GAZETTE OF INDIA, EXTRAORDINARY,
PART III, SECTION 4
TELECOM REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF INDIA
NOTIFICATION
New Delhi the 14th May, 2012
F. No. 3- 24/2012- B&CS – In exercise of the powers conferred by section 36, read with sub-
clauses (ii), (iii), (iv) and (v) of clause (b) of sub-section (1) of section 11 of the Telecom
Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997 (24 of 1997), read with notification of the Government
of India, in the Ministry of Communication and Information Technology (Department of
Telecommunication), No.39,-----
(a) issued, in exercise of the powers conferred upon the Central Government under clause (d) of
sub-section (1) of section 11 and proviso to clause (k) of sub-section (1) of section 2 of the said
Act, and
(b) published under notification No. S.O.44 (E) and 45 (E) dated the 9th January, 2004 in the
Gazette of India, Extraordinary, Part III, Section 4, the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India
hereby makes the following regulations, namely:-
THE TELECOMMUNICATION (BROADCASTING AND CABLE SERVICES)
INTERCONNECTION (DIGITAL ADDRESSABLE CABLE TELEVISION SYSTEMS)
(FIRST AMENDMENT) REGULATIONS, 2012
No. 14 of 2012
2
1. (1) These regulations may be called the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable
Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) (First Amendment)
Regulations, 2012.
(2) They shall come into force from the date of their publication in the Official Gazette.
2. In regulation 3 of the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection
(Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) Regulations, 2012 (hereinafter referred to as the
principal regulations), after sub-regulation (11), the following sub-regulation shall be inserted,
namely:- -
“(11A) No multi system operator shall demand from a broadcaster any placement fee.”
3. In regulation 4 of the principal regulations, after sub-regulation (8), the following sub-
regulation shall be inserted, namely:- -
“(8A) Every Reference Interconnect Offer submitted to the Authority under sub-regulation
(7) and sub-regulation (8) shall also contain the basis on which the carriage fee payable by the
broadcaster has been determined.”
4. In regulation (5) of the principal regulations, after sub-regulation (14), the following sub-
regulation shall be inserted, namely:-
“(14A) Every broadcaster shall declare the genre of its channels and such genre shall be
either News and Current Affairs or Infotainment or Sports or Kids or Music or Lifestyle
or Movies or Religious or Devotional or General Entertainment (Hindi) or General
Entertainment (English) or General Entertainment (regional language).
14(B) The multi system operator shall place the channels of a broadcaster in the genre
declared by such broadcaster.
14(C) No broadcaster shall demand from the multi-system operator to assign a particular
number to its channels.”
5. In regulation (5) of the principal regulations, after proviso to sub-regulation (15), the
following sub-regulation shall be inserted, namely:-
3
“(15A) Every multi system operator shall display, in his Electronic Programme Guide, all
the channels offered by him, in the same genre in which a particular channel has been indicated
by the broadcaster and one channel shall appear in only one genre.”
(Wasi Ahmad)
Advisor (B&CS)
Note.-----The Explanatory Memorandum explains the objects and reasons of the
Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable
Cable Television Systems) (First Amendment) Regulation, 2012.
4
Annexure
Explanatory Memorandum
1. After following an extensive consultation process, the Authority had notified the
Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable
Cable Television Systems) Regulations, 2012 ( 9 of 2012) (hereinafter referred to as the principal
Regulation) on 30th April, 2012. While the principal regulation is specifically applicable for
digital addressable cable TV systems, the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services)
Interconnection Regulation 2004 (13 of 2004) is applicable for non-addressable cable TV
systems and also addressable systems such as DTH, IPTV etc.
2. A question has arisen regarding charging of placement fee by the multi system operator. In
the digital addressable cable TV systems, the technology provides for a Electronic Program
Guide (EPG) wherein the channels being carried on an MSO’s network can be arranged in a
simple easy to understand manner so that the subscriber can easily go through this guide and
select the channel of choice instead of flipping through all the channels. This display of channels
can be genre-wise where all the channels of a particular genre can be listed under that genre in
the genre-wise list of EPG. Thus, in digital addressable cable TV systems, there is hardly any
justification for charging of the placement fee. In sub-regulation 11 of the regulation 3 of the
principal regulation dated 30th April, 2012, it has clearly been provided that insistence by multi
system operator on placement of a channel in a particular slot or bouquet amounts to imposition
of unreasonable terms. The intention of making this provision was that placement fee cannot be
charged. However, to clarify the position in this regard, in the amendment regulation, a specific
provision has been made so that the multi system operator does not charge any placement fee
from any broadcaster.
3. The matter relating to charging of carriage fee by the multi system operator has been dealt
with in sub-regulation 12 of regulation 3 and in sub-regulations 7 and 8 of the regulation 4 and
also in the paragraphs 15 to 17 of the principal regulation. The multi system operators are to file
a copy of the Reference Interconnect Offer with the Authority including the quantum of carriage
fee per channel that would be charged from the broadcasters. With digital technology, the
capacity to carry the channels is no longer a constraint. Also, the Subscriber Management
System (SMS) provides the full declaration of the subscribers, increasing the percentage of
subscription revenue to the multi system operator. With all these, the carriage fee is expected to
go down substantially. It was presumed that the Reference Interconnect Offer that would be
filed with the Authority would include the detailed basis on which the carriage fee has been
worked out. The same has been clarified in the sub-regulation which has been inserted in this
regard.
5
4. In sub-regulation 15 of regulation 5 of the principal regulation dated 30th April, 2012, a
provision has been made that it shall be open to a multi system operator to decide the packaging
of the channels offered to the subscribers from bouquet of channels provided to it by the
broadcaster. A question has arisen regarding placement of channels by the multi system
operator. To avoid any eventuality of a channel being placed in a disadvantageous position as
compared to another channel of the same genre, a provision has now been made whereunder a
broadcaster has to indicate the genre of a channel and the multi system operator has to include
that channel in the genre declared by the broadcaster. The multi system operator is required to
ensure that all the channels falling in a particular genre appear in its network’s Electronic
Programme Guide (EPG) under the same genre. With this the subscriber would be able to see
the list of channels that are available genre-wise and thus making the service more customer
friendly.
***********
Page 1 of 12
TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE GAZETTE OF INDIA, EXTRAORDINARY,
PART III, SECTION 4
TELECOM REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF INDIA
THE TELECOMMUNICATION (BROADCASTING AND CABLE SERVICES)
INTERCONNECTION (DIGITAL ADDRESSABLE CABLE TELEVISION SYSTEMS)
(SECOND AMENDMENT) REGULATIONS, 2013
(No. 12 of 2013)
NOTIFICATION
New Delhi the 20th September, 2013
F. No. 3-24/2012-B&CS----In exercise of powers conferred by section 36, read with sub-clauses
(ii), (iii), (iv) and (v) of clause (b) of sub-section (1) of section 11 of the Telecom Regulatory
Authority of India Act, 1997 (24 of 1997), read with notification of the Government of India, in
the Ministry of Communication and Information Technology (Department of
Telecommunication), No.39,-----
(a) issued, in exercise of the powers conferred upon the Central Government under clause (d) of
sub-section (1) of section 11 and proviso to clause (k) of sub-section (1) of section 2 of the said
Act, and
(b) published under notification No. 39 (S.O. 44 (E) and 45 (E)) dated the 9th January, 2004 in
the Gazette of India, Extraordinary, Part II- Section 3- Sub-section (ii),----
the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India hereby makes the following regulations to amend
the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable
Cable Television Systems) Regulations, 2013 (9 of 2012), namely:-
Page 2 of 12
1. (1) These regulations may be called the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable
Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) (Second Amendment)
Regulations, 2013.
(2) They shall come into force from the date of their publication in the Official Gazette.
2. In regulation 3 of the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection
(Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) Regulations, 2012 (9 of 2012),---
(a) in sub-regulation (2), the phrase “having the prescribed channel capacity and” shall be
omitted;
(b) in sub-regulation (2), after the second proviso, the following proviso shall be inserted,
namely:-
“Provided also that nothing contained in this sub-regulation shall apply in the case of a
multi-system operator, who seeks signals of a particular TV channel from a broadcaster,
while at the same time demands carriage fee for carrying that channel on its distribution
platform.”
(c) sub-regulation (5), sub-regulation (8) and sub-regulation (11A) shall be omitted.
(Sudhir Gupta)
Secretary(I/C), TRAI
Note.1-----The principal regulations were published vide notification no. 3-24/2012-B&CS dated
30th April 2012 and subsequently amended vide notifications No. 3-24/2012-B&CS dated 14th
May 2012.
Note.2-----The Explanatory Memorandum explains the objects and reasons of the
Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable
Cable Television Systems) (Second Amendment) Regulation, 2013 (No. 12 of 2013).
Page 3 of 12
Annexure
Explanatory Memorandum
I. Background
1. In the last few years, the exponential growth in the number of TV channels (both free-to-air
[FTA] and pay) combined with the inherent limitations of the analog cable TV systems has
posed several challenges in the cable TV sector, mainly due to capacity constraints and non-
addressable nature of the network. With time and evolution of technology, new addressable
TV platforms like direct-to-home (DTH), internet protocol television (IPTV) etc. became
available. The evolution of technology also paved way for introducing digitization with
addressability in the cable TV sector. Accordingly, after studying the subject at length and
undertaking a public consultation process, the Authority, on 5th August 2010, gave its
recommendations on implementation of Digital Addressable Cable TV Systems (DAS)
across the country along with a roadmap to achieve the same.
2. The Government has accepted the recommendations of TRAI and on 25th October, 2011,
promulgated an Ordinance amending the Cable Television Networks (Regulation) Act, 1995,
enabling the implementation of Digital Addressable Cable TV Systems in India. Thereafter,
the Government also issued a notification dated 11th November, 2011 and its amendment
dated 21st June 2012, which laid down the roadmap for implementation of Digital
Addressable Cable TV Systems in the country in a phased manner in four phases, with the
first phase by 31st Oct. 2012 and the final phase to be completed by 31st December 2014.
This will lead to sunset of Analogue Cable TV Systems in the entire country. With the
Parliament passing the bill, the Ordinance dated 25th October, 2011, became an Act on 30th
December, 2011. Subsequently, the Central Government amended the Cable television
Networks Rules 1994, vide amendment dated 28th April 2012. These legislative enactments
paved way for the implementation of DAS in the country.
3. In order to lay down a comprehensive regulatory framework for the digital addressable cable
TV systems (DAS), the Authority initiated a consultation process on the issues relating to
implementation of DAS. After following an extensive public consultation process, the tariff
Page 4 of 12
amendment order, regulations for quality of service and redressal of consumer grievances,
and the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital
Addressable Cable Television Systems) Regulations, 2012 dated 30th April 2012, were
notified. The interconnection regulations prescribe various provisions relating to the
interconnection between Broadcaster, MSO and LCO. Subsequently, an amendment to the
interconnection regulations was also notified on 14th May 2012.
4. Some of the provisions of the said interconnection regulations were challenged in appeal
numbers 5(C) of 2012, 11 (C) of 2012 and 12 (C) of 2012 before Hon’ble Telecom Disputes
and Settlement Appellate Tribunal (TDSAT) by some MSOs. The Hon’ble TDSAT vide its
judgment dated 19th October 2012 partly allowed the appeals and set aside three provisions
of the said interconnection regulations. The provisions set aside pertain to prohibition of
demanding carriage fee by the MSO while seeking signals of a channel from a broadcaster
(sub-regulation 3(5) of the said regulations), MSOs to have a minimum channel carrying
capacity of 500 channels (sub-regulation 3(8) of the said regulations) and prohibition
regarding charging of placement fee by the MSOs (sub-regulation 11A of the said
regulations).
5. While setting aside the provisions of sub-regulation 3(5) of the Interconnection Regulations
applicable for DAS, the Hon’ble TDSAT had opined, inter alia, that there should not be any
difference between 2nd proviso to sub-regulation 3.2 of “The Telecommunication
(broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection Regulation 2004 (12 of 2004)” as
amended from time to time as applicable to non-CAS/DTH operators and sub-regulation
3(5)of “The Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital
Addressable Cable Television Systems) Regulation 2012”. On the issue of provision of
capacity to carry minimum 500 channels, the Hon’ble TDSAT, in its judgment, had observed
that since market forces play an important and significant role in the matter of carrying
capacity of the MSO, the same may not be required to be regulated. It has been further
observed by the Hon’ble TDSAT that if the regulator deems fit, it may consider making
provision for MSOs to have capacity to carry number of channels based on different
categories of areas i.e. city/towns/rural area etc. in which MSO will be operating. Further, the
Page 5 of 12
Hon’ble TDSAT has set aside the provisions of sub-regulation 11A of the interconnection
regulation 2012 on the ground that the restriction placed on the MSO for demanding
placement fees in terms of May 2012, Regulation is bad in law. It has been further mentioned
that the same restriction is not applicable for the DTH operators, the placement charges, if
any, will depend upon the mutual agreement between the Broadcasters and the MSO.
Consequent to the said judgment of the Hon’ble TDSAT, the Authority initiated a
consultation process with the stakeholders to bring in finality to the provisions set aside by
the Hon’ble TDSAT.
6. In this connection, a consultation paper titled “Issues related to amendments to the
Interconnection Regulations applicable for Digital Addressable Cable TV Systems & Tariff
Order applicable for Addressable Systems” was issued on 20th December, 2012. In this
consultation paper, inter-alia, the following issues were posed for the stakeholders to offer
their comments:
(a) Introduction of following proviso (in line with the 2nd proviso to the sub-regulation 3.2
of the interconnection regulation applicable for the platforms, other than DAS) in the
sub-regulation 3(2) of the interconnection regulations applicable for DAS areas, and
deletion of the sub-regulation 3(5) from the same regulation:
“provided that the provisions of this sub-regulation shall not apply in the case of a
multi-system operator, who seeks signals of a particular TV channel from a
broadcaster, while at the same time demanding carriage fee for carrying that channel
on its distribution platform”.
(b) Need to specify certain minimum channel carrying capacity for the MSOs based on
different categories (cities/town/rural area) of areas in the interconnection regulations.
(c) Need for regulating the placement fee in all the Digital Addressable Systems and how
it should be regulated.
7. In response to this consultation paper, a total of 48 comments were received from
stakeholders. Taking into consideration the comments/views of the stakeholders and analysis
of the issues, the draft interconnection regulation was prepared and uploaded on the TRAI
website on 4th June 2013, seeking views/comments of the stakeholders on the same. In
response, 27 stakeholders put forth their views/comments. Based on the above said
Page 6 of 12
consultation process, the interconnection regulation applicable to digital addressable cable
TV systems has been amended through this interconnection amendment regulation namely
the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital
Addressable Cable Television Systems) (Second Amendment) Regulations, 2013.
II. Analysis of Issues
8. The following is the summary of issues taken up for consultation, comments of the
stakeholders and analysis thereon.
A. “Carriage Fee”
9. The issue is that whether the following proviso should be introduced in the sub-regulation
3(2) of the interconnection regulations for DAS and the existing sub-regulation 3(5) of
interconnection Regulation for DAS should be deleted:
“Provided that the provisions of this sub-regulation shall not apply in the case of a
multi-system operator, who seeks signals of a particular TV channel from a broadcaster,
while at the same time demanding carriage fee for carrying that channel on its
distribution platform.”
10. Several broadcasters, in their response to the issue, expressed the opinion that they are in
favour of continuation of the existing clauses. They have further stated that if the carriage fee
is imposed, it should be for a limited period and during such period the fee must be regulated
by TRAI which must be rational, non-discriminatory and based upon actual, verifiable
subscriber base and once the digitization is completed, no carriage fee must be chargeable at
all. Several other broadcasters were in favour of TRAI’s proposal to amend sub-regulation
3(5) and to bring it in line with that of Interconnect Regulation, 2004, applicable for DTH,
IPTV, HITS and non-addressable cable TV systems, wherein, it has been provided that the
seeker of the TV signals while seeking signals, cannot demand carriage fee at the same time.
11. Majority of the MSOs, in their response to the issue, have stated that the sub-regulation 3(5)
should be deleted while the proposed proviso should not be included in the sub-regulation
Page 7 of 12
3(2). They have further stated that the issue of carriage fee should be left to market forces
and should not be regulated as there are already adequate safeguards provided in the
interconnection regulations in the form of prescription of uniform carriage fee, to be charged
by the MSOs, for all broadcasters, and restriction on upward revision of carriage fee for a
minimum two years.
12. All private DTH operators and their association except one DTH operator, in their response
to the issue, have suggested that the issue should be left to the market forces since it is a
matter of commercial negotiations which does not involve consumers. They further stated
that even after complete digitalization, capacity will always be a constraint to carry all the
channels. DAS operators have stated that they should have the freedom to choose the
channels to carry and suitably charge in order to recover its carriage cost and since there is no
limit on advertisement rates, which is driven by demand & supply, there is no reason as to
why there should be any limit on carriage / placement fee. One DTH operator has opined that
the regularization and clarity need to be brought in carriage fee payment by regulating the
carriage fee on per active subscriber basis. Another DTH operator has suggested that to
maintain transparency, DAS operator should file details of interconnect agreement with
broadcaster w.r.t. carriage fee.
13. While one of the LCO associations has supported the proposal, another has suggested that
TRAI should fix carriage fee based on genre of the channel and its Television Rating Points
(TRP) and carriage fee received by MSO should be shared between MSO and LCO as LCOs’
infrastructure is much larger than that of MSOs’.
14. The issue has been analysed. The Interconnection Regulation applicable for DAS has the
following safeguards with regard to charging of carriage fee. (1) Carriage fee to be
transparently declared in the RIO of the MSO, (2) The carriage fee is to be uniformly
charged (3) The carriage fee not to be revised upwardly for a minimum period of 2 years, and
(4) The details of the carriage fee are to be filed with the Authority and the Authority has a
right to intervene in cases it deems fit.
Page 8 of 12
15. The intention for including the above said proviso to the sub-regulation 3(2) was to ensure
that the broadcasters are not forced to supply their channel in terms of sub-regulation 3(2)
and at the same time pay carriage fee for the same channel. Also, inclusion of such a proviso
prevents a distributor of TV channels from misusing the sub-regulation 3(2). It is worthwhile
to note that same provision (2nd proviso to sub-regulation 3.2) exists in the interconnection
regulations for other addressable and non-addressable platforms since 2009.
16. Considering all the above aspects, the Authority is of the view that the proposed proviso shall
be included in the sub-regulation 3(2) and sub-regulation 3(5) shall be deleted.
B. “Channel carrying capacity for MSOs”
17. Another issue raised in the consultation paper was whether there is a need to specify certain
minimum channel carrying capacity for the MSOs in the interconnection regulations for DAS
and if so what should be the different categories (cities/town/rural area etc.) of areas for
which minimum channel carrying capacity should be prescribed and what should be the
capacity for each category.
18. While some of the broadcasters, in their response, have suggested that the issue should be left
to the market forces, others have suggested that certain minimum channel carrying capacity
should be prescribed by TRAI to ensure effective roll out of digitization of the cable TV
sector. They have stated that if minimum capacity is not prescribed, MSO’s are not likely to
upgrade their systems and the number of channels available to the consumers will remain
limited and the broadcasters will continue paying unreasonable carriage fee. They further
stated that if the issue is left to the market forces at this time, it may lead to anti-competitive
practices through cartelization or misuse of monopolistic positions, as the case may be. Some
of the broadcasters, who are in favour of prescribing minimum channel capacity, have further
suggested that the minimum capacity of 500 channels should be prescribed universally,
irrespective of category of areas. One broadcaster has suggested that the carrying capacity
can be linked with the size of the MSO, depending upon their subscriber base.
Page 9 of 12
19. All the MSOs, in their response, have stated that the issue should be left to the market forces
since there is enough competition in the market which will compel the MSOs to carry all
relevant channels. Further, no MSO should be required to carry channels unless there is a
market demand or an opportunity, making economic sense. They have further stated that any
prescription for minimum channel carrying capacity will only help the broadcasters who do
not have a viable subscription model and the said unreasonable mandate of certain minimum
channel carrying capacity will only help such broadcasters to develop their advertising
model. One of the MSO has suggested that if the Authority deems it necessary to specify it,
the same should be limited to the minimum FTA channels as presently regulated by TRAI
and for the pay channels, the market forces should be allowed to decide.
20. DTH operators are also not in favour of fixing a minimum channel carrying capacity for the
DAS service providers. They have stated that it should be left to the discretion of the MSO to
decide, based on the market requirements. One of the DTH operators and the DTH
Association have suggested that, in case, it is prescribed by TRAI, it should be lesser than
500 channels, so that DTH operators also have a level-playing-field vis-a-vis MSOs, as DTH
is constrained due to limited satellite bandwidth capacity available to them.
21. While two LCO associations, in their response to the issue, are in favour of not regulating
the channel carrying capacity, another association has suggested that the minimum carrying
capacity should be a certain percentage of the FTA channels permitted by Ministry of
Information & Broadcasting. One consumer organization has stated that the minimum
carrying capacity for MSOs needs to be mandated otherwise it will defeat the very purpose of
digitization. The organization further suggested that the Authority may prescribe a minimum
300 channels immediately and 500, by March 2014.
22. The issue has been analysed. Sub-regulation 3(10) of the interconnection regulation for DAS
mandates the MSO to carry channel(s) if it is in the regional language of the region in which
that MSO is operating or if it is in Hindi language or in English language. Thus, in other
words, there is a ‘must carry’ provision for regional language channels (specific to a region)
and channels in Hindi and English languages. If channel(s) fall within these categories, MSO
Page 10 of 12
has to carry the channel(s). With these provisions, the concerns of the broadcasters regarding
MSOs creating artificial scarcity of channel carrying capacity for justifying charging of
unreasonable carriage fee are adequately taken care of. In view of this, there appears no real
need for prescribing a minimum channel carrying capacity. In addition to this, sub-
regulation 3(10) of the interconnection regulations also makes it mandatory for the MSOs to
provide to the broadcasters access to its cable network, within a time frame of sixty (60)
days which is equivalent to the time frame given to the broadcaster under the ‘must provide’
provisions. Further, a responsibility has also been cast upon the broadcaster under the
provisions of ‘must carry’ to ensure that the subscription of the channel does not fall below a
certain minimum level. This minimum level has been prescribed in the regulations as five
percent of the subscriber base of that MSO, taken as an average of subscriber base, for the
preceding six months. In case the channel fails to maintain this minimum subscriber base, the
MSO has the discretion to refuse access to its network for a period of next one year. Such a
refusal would not be considered as a violation of the ‘must carry’ provision. Considering all
the aspects, the Authority is of the view that the interests of the broadcasters have already
been taken care of in the ‘must carry’ provisions of the regulation and as such no further
prescription may be required.
23. The Authority has decided that the phrase “having the prescribed channel capacity”
appearing in sub-regulation 3(2) should be deleted as the same will have no relevance with
the deletion of the minimum channel carrying capacity criteria from the regulations.
24. For the time being, the Authority has decided not to specify the capacity to carry a minimum
number of channels by the MSOs, on the expectation that market dynamics will take care of
the emerging situation. However, in the event the Authority notices that the market dynamics
are not allowed to function freely by the service providers, resulting in creation of an
artificial capacity constraint, it will intervene appropriately.
Page 11 of 12
C. “Placement Fee”
25. The issue raised in the consultation paper was whether there is a need for regulating the
placement fee in all the Digital Addressable Systems. If so, how it should be regulated.
26. Some of the broadcasters, in their response to the issue, have stated that in DAS, since an
MSO is obligated to provide electronic programme guide (EPG), the requirement of
placement fee does not arise. However, broadcasters should have the flexibility to pay
reasonable amount towards tiering / packaging fee, if they so desire, as part of their
commercial negotiation and that it should be left to market forces. One of the broadcasters’
associations has stated that charging of placement fee, by whatever name called, should be
prohibited by regulation since in DAS environment broadcasters would no longer demand
any specific or preferential placement, except to the limited extent that their channels be
placed in the correct and rational genre/sub-genre. One of the broadcasters, who is in favour
of regulating the placement fee, suggested that the regulations should take into account the
carriage cost, EPG placement, packaging of channels and any other fee, called by any other
name, in a transparent and non-discriminatory manner.
27. All the MSOs, in their response to the issue, have stated that they are not in favour of
regulating the placement fee. They have stated that placement fee is purely a commercial
transaction with no impact to the end consumers. It has been further mentioned that, since,
India is a low ARPU market, recovery of infrastructure cost is not possible with such ARPU
as compared to mature markets where cost of access for the MSO's come in the form of
revenue share or through sharing of some of the advertisement time with the MSOs. They
have further stated that market will evolve over a period of time as other mature markets
have and will find its own model. Till then, it should not be regulated. They have further
stated that demand and supply will balance placement fee in the market by itself as presently
only few channels have demand for specific placements to suit their business model.
28. One DTH operator has stated that the placement fee should be regulated across all
addressable platforms in such a manner that placement fee is same for any two operators if
they carry channel with same priority. All other operators are not in favour of regulating it.
Page 12 of 12
However, one DTH operator has suggested that the MSOs should publish RIO for placement
fee and agreement details regarding placement fee should be filed under register of
interconnect regulation.
29. While two LCO associations have stated that it should be left to market forces, another LCO
association has suggested that it should be regulated by TRAI on slab-wise basis which
should be based on TRP ratings.
30. The issue has been analysed. In DAS, the technology provides for an EPG wherein the
channels being carried on an MSO’s network can be arranged in a simple, easy to
understand, manner so that the subscriber can easily go through this guide and select the
channel of his choice instead of flipping through all the channels. The genre-wise display of
channels in the EPG, where all the channels of a particular genre are listed under relevant
genre, has been mandated through regulations. Moreover, in digital systems, signal quality of
the channels is independent of the placement of the channel. Further, the Interconnection
Regulation already has a provision (sub-regulation 3 (11)) that if an MSO, before providing
access to its network, insists on placement of the channel in a particular slot or bouquet, such
precondition amounts to imposition of unreasonable terms. Thus, adequate provisions
already exist in the regulations. Accordingly, sub-regulation 11A of regulation 3 of the
interconnection regulation has been deleted.
***********
Page 1 of 20
TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE GAZETTE OF INDIA, EXTRAORDINARY,
PART III, SECTION 4
TELECOM REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF INDIA
NOTIFICATION
New Delhi the 10th February, 2014
THE TELECOMMUNICATION (BROADCASTING AND CABLE SERVICES)
INTERCONNECTION (DIGITAL ADDRESSABLE CABLE TELEVISION SYSTEMS)
(THIRD AMENDMENT) REGULATION, 2014
(No. 2 of 2014)
No. 3-24/2012- B&CS – In exercise of the powers conferred by section 36, read with
sub-clauses (ii), (iii) and (iv) of clause (b) of sub-section (1) of section 11 of the Telecom
Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997 (24 of 1997), read with notification of the
Government of India, in the Ministry of Communication and Information Technology
(Department of Telecommunication) No.39,-----
(a) issued, in exercise of the powers conferred upon the Central Government by proviso
to clause (k) of sub-section (1) of section 2 and clause (d) of sub-section (1) of section 11
of the said Act, and
(b) published under notification No. 39 (S.O. 44 (E) and 45 (E)) dated the 9th January,
2004 in the Gazette of India, Extraordinary, Part II- Section 3- Sub-section (ii), ----
Page 2 of 20
the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India hereby makes the following regulations to
further amend the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services)
Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) Regulations 2012 (9 of
2012), namely:-
1. (1)These regulations may be called the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable
Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) (Third
Amendment) Regulation, 2014 (2 of 2014).
(2) They shall come into force with effect from the date of their publication in the
Official Gazette.
2. In regulation 2 of the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services)
Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) Regulations, 2012 (9
of 2012), (hereinafter referred to as the principal regulations),---
(a) for clause (c), the following clause shall be substituted, namely:----
“(c) “authorised agent or intermediary" means any person including an
individual, group of persons, public or private body corporate, firm or any
organization or body authorised by a broadcaster or multi-system operator to
make available its TV channels to a distributor of TV channels and such
authorised agent or intermediary, while making available TV channels to the
distributors of TV channels, shall always act in the name of and on behalf of the
broadcaster or multi-system operator, as the case may be;”
(b) for clause (g), the following clause shall be substituted, namely:----
“(g) “broadcaster” means a person or a group of persons, or body corporate, or
any organization or body who, after having obtained, in its name, uplinking
permission or downlinking permission, as may be applicable for its channels,
from the Central Government, provides programming services;”
Page 3 of 20
(c) for clause (s), the following clause shall be substituted, namely:----
“(s) “multi system operator” means a cable operator who has been granted
registration under rule 11C of the Cable Television Networks Rules, 1994 and
who receives a programming service from a broadcaster and re-transmits the
same or transmits his own programming service for simultaneous reception either
by multiple subscribers directly or through one or more local cable operators;”
3. After regulation 9 of the principal regulations, the following regulation shall be
inserted, namely:----
“10. Composition of bouquet by the broadcasters.---- (1) Every broadcaster shall,
within six months of the commencement of the Telecommunication (Broadcasting
and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television
Systems) (Third Amendment) Regulation, 2014, ----
(a) ensure that bouquet of TV channels, contained in its Reference
Interconnect Offer, is provided to the distributors of TV channels without
any modification in its composition and such bouquet of TV channels, at
the wholesale level, are not bundled with the bouquet or channels of other
broadcasters:
Provided that a broadcaster may, while making a bouquet of TV channels,
combine TV channels of its subsidiary company or holding company or
subsidiary company of the holding company, which has obtained, in its
name, the uplinking permission or downlinking permission, as may be
applicable for its TV channels, from the Central Government and the
broadcaster or any of such companies, authorized by them, may publish
Reference Interconnect Offer for such bouquet of TV channels and sign
the interconnection agreement with the distributors of TV channels;
Page 4 of 20
Explanation: For the purpose of these regulations, the definition of
„subsidiary company‟ and „holding company‟ shall be the same as
assigned to them in the Companies Act, 2013(18 of 2013).
(b) publish its Reference Interconnect Offer to ensure compliance of the
provision of clause (a);
(c) enter into new interconnection agreement; and
(d) file the Reference Interconnect Offer, referred to in clause (b) and
interconnection agreement, referred to in clause (c) with the Authority.
(2) Every broadcaster, who begins its operations six months after commencement
of the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection
(Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) (Third Amendment) Regulation,
2014, shall ensure that the bouquet of channels, contained in its Reference
Interconnect Offer, is provided to the distributors of TV channels without any
modification in its composition and such bouquet of TV channels, at the wholesale
level, are not bundled with the bouquet or channels of other broadcasters.”
(Sudhir Gupta)
Secretary, TRAI
Note.1-----The principal regulation was published in the Gazette of India,
Extraordinary, Part III, Section 4,vide its notification No. 3- 24/2012- B&CS dated the
30th April 2012 and subsequently amended vide notifications No. 3- 24/2012- B&CS
dated the 14th May 2012 and No. 3-24/2012-B&CS dated the 20th September 2013.
Note.2-----The Explanatory Memorandum explains the objects and reasons of the
Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital
Addressable Cable Television Systems) (Third Amendment) Regulation, 2014 (2 of
2014).
Page 5 of 20
Explanatory Memorandum
The need for amendment
1. The value chain in the distribution of television channels comprises the
broadcaster, the Distribution Platform Operator (DPO), the last mile operator and
the end consumer. The business of distribution of TV channels from the
broadcaster to the consumer has two levels - i) bulk or wholesale level - wherein
the distributor of TV channels i.e. DPO obtains the TV channels from the
broadcasters, and ii) retail level - where the DPO offers these channels to the
consumers, either directly or through the last mile operator. Amongst the DPOs,
the Direct to Home (DTH) operator and the Internet Protocol Television (IPTV)
operator serve the consumer directly, while the Multi System Operator (MSO) and
the Headend in the Sky (HITS) operator generally serve the consumer through its
linked Local Cable Operator (LCO).
2. At the wholesale level, as per the regulatory framework prescribed by TRAI,
broadcasters are mandated to enter into interconnection agreements with the
DPOs for the carriage of their TV channels. The broadcasters are to offer their
channels on a non-discriminatory basis to all the DPOs in accordance with their
Reference Interconnect Offer (RIO). The interconnection agreements are to be
finalised on the basis of the commercial and technical terms and conditions
specified in the RIO.
3. Many broadcasters, especially the larger ones, appoint authorised distribution
agencies as intermediaries. Many such agencies operate as authorised agents for
more than one broadcaster. These authorised distribution agencies have come to
be popularly known as „aggregators‟. These aggregators have indulged in the
practice of publishing the RIOs, negotiate the rates for the bouquets/channels with
DPOs and enter into interconnection agreement(s) with them.
4. As on date there are around 239 pay channels (including HD and advertisement-
free channels) offered by 55 pay broadcasters. These channels are distributed by 30
broadcasters/aggregators/ agents of broadcasters. Table I below shows the
number of channels being distributed to the DPOs by the top three aggregators.
Page 6 of 20
Table I: Number of TV channels distributed by leading aggregators
Total number of pay TV channels : 239
Name of the aggregator Number of
channels
1 M/s Media Pro Enterprise India Private Limited 76
2 M/s IndiaCast UTV Media Distribution Private Limited 36
3 M/s MSM Discovery Private Limited 28
Total 140 (58.6%)
Thus, the distribution business of 58.6% of the total pay TV market available today
is controlled by the top three aggregators. These channels include almost all the
popular pay TV channels.
5. The bouquets being offered by the aggregators comprise popular channels of the
multiple broadcasters they represent. Thus, for purely business considerations,
DPOs have no option but to subscribe to these bouquets. It is alleged that,
exploiting this fact, the aggregators further start to piggy-back more channels on
these bouquets especially the ones that have very less standalone market value.
The aggregators being in a dominant position use their negotiating powers to
„push‟ such bouquets to the DPOs. In such a scenario, at the retail end, the DPOs
have no option but to somehow push these channels (though not necessarily in the
form of the bouquets that they purchase from the aggregators) to the consumers so
as to recover costs. Thus, in the process, the public, in general, ends up paying for
„unwanted‟ channels and this, in effect, restricts consumer choice. Moreover, since
the aggregators distribute a large number of popular channels of different
broadcasters, they are in a position to, in effect coerce DPOs and sell the channels
at terms favourable to them.
6. Recently it also came to the notice of the Authority that an aggregator M/s Media
Pro was offering channels of a broadcaster, the New Delhi Television Ltd., as a
part of certain bouquets only to platform operators of cable TV sector and not to
the DTH operators. The DTH platform was directly dealt with by the said
broadcaster. In effect, the situation was one where different distribution platforms
were being treated differently. On enquiry, the aggregator claimed that since the
broadcaster has bestowed the right only to distribute the channels to platform
operators of cable TV sector it is in full compliance with the provisions of the
regulations. However, as per the existing regulatory framework, the broadcaster is
Page 7 of 20
mandated to offer the same bouquet to all the distribution platforms. With this
kind of arrangement with its aggregator, the broadcaster was, in effect,
circumventing the regulations through an aggregator by creating a situation where
the different DPOs (platforms) could be treated differently. It is a well established
principle in law that what cannot be achieved directly, cannot be achieved
indirectly. And, that is precisely what the broadcaster was able to do using the
device of the aggregator.
7. The market distortions arising out of the current role assumed by the aggregators
were amply reflected during the implementation of digital addressable cable TV
systems (DAS), Phase I and Phase II. Several MSOs have complained that they
were forced to accept unreasonable terms and conditions to obtain signals of the
broadcasters through some of the major aggregators, that too at the fag end of the
implementation deadline. According to the non-vertically integrated MSOs as well
as smaller MSOs, they always get a raw deal. This impacted the smooth
implementation of DAS. In the Open House Discussions (OHDs) held in various
parts of the country on „Issues related to Media Ownership”, concerns have been
vehemently voiced by various MSOs and LCOs regarding the monopolistic
practices of the major aggregators. While the issue was being examined at the
Authority, the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting (MIB) also, echoed the
complaints from MSOs in this regard, through its reference to TRAI vide D.O. No.
16/1/2013-BP&L dated 23rd May 2013, requesting the Authority for reviewing the
regulatory framework on this aspect.
8. The regulatory framework has been reviewed to bring clarity in the roles and
responsibilities of the broadcasters and their authorised agents. Accordingly, a
Consultation Paper, in the form of draft amendments to the existing
interconnection regulations, tariff orders and the register for interconnect
regulations, were uploaded on the website of TRAI, seeking comments/views of
stakeholders. In response, 102 comments were received from the stakeholders. An
OHD was also held in Delhi on 12th September 2013, wherein 170 stakeholders
participated in the discussions. Further, in response to the opportunity given by
the Authority during the OHD, 26 further comments were received from
stakeholders. Taking into account the views/comments of the stakeholders and
after detailed analysis of the issues involved, amendments to the following
regulations and tariff orders are being notified simultaneously:
i. The Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection
(Seventh Amendment) Regulations, 2014 (1 of 2014),
Page 8 of 20
ii. The Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection
(Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) (Third Amendment)
Regulations, 2014 (2 of 2014)
iii. The Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable) Services (Second) Tariff
(Tenth Amendment) Order, 2014 (1 of 2014),
iv. The Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable) Services (Fourth)
(Addressable Systems) Tariff (Third Amendment) Order, 2014 (2 of 2014) and,
v. The Register of Interconnect Agreements (Broadcasting and Cable Services)
(Fifth Amendment) Regulations, 2014 (3 of 2014).
9. The amendments incorporate the following changes to the existing regulatory
framework. The framework defines a broadcaster as an entity having the necessary
Government permissions in its name. Further, that only the broadcaster can and
should publish the RIOs and enter into interconnection agreements with DPOs.
However, in case a broadcaster, in discharge of its regulatory obligations, is using
the services of an agent, such agent can only act in the name of and on behalf of the
broadcaster. Further the broadcaster shall ensure that such agent, while providing
channels /bouquets to the DPOs, does not alter the bouquets as offered in the RIO
of the broadcaster. In case an agent acts as an authorised agent of multiple
broadcasters, the individual broadcasters shall ensure that such agent does not
bundle its channels or bouquets with that of other broadcasters. However,
broadcaster companies belonging to the same group can bundle their channels.
10. A time frame of six months has been prescribed for the broadcasters to amend
their RIOs, enter into new interconnection agreements and file the amended RIOs
and the interconnection agreements with the Authority. While amending their
RIOs, certain bouquets may require reconfiguration to align them with the
amended regulatory framework. The method for working out the rate of such
reconfigured bouquets has also been illustrated.
Stakeholder comments
11. The response of the stakeholders can be broadly divided into two categories. One
group, represented by leading/big broadcasters and aggregators, is against the
proposed amendment whereas the other group, represented by DPOs, their
Page 9 of 20
associations and small broadcasters, has supported the provisions of the proposed
amendment and requested for its urgent implementation.
12. The broadcasters/aggregators have opposed the amendments on the ground that
they are in violation of Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution and on the ground of
jurisdiction of TRAI in the said matter. They have stated that it is a competition
issue and the Competition Commission of India (CCI) has sole jurisdiction over it.
Apart from this, they have also stated that aggregators play a vital role in the
distribution of TV channels and provide a balanced platform, especially to smaller
broadcasters, for negotiations with the DPOs, who, according to the aggregators/
broadcasters, have substantial negotiating power. This group of stakeholders have
also stated that the practice of broadcasters to utilize distribution
agencies/aggregators is a normal business practice as is prevalent in the other
sectors like banking, telecom, insurance etc. and cannot be considered anti-
competitive.
13. However, in contrast, and in a directly opposite stance, the small broadcasters,
DPOs and cable operator associations, have stated that the proposed amendments
would provide a level-playing-field and eliminate the monopolistic practices
arising from the role that the aggregator has assumed viz. as surrogates for
multiple major broadcasters. In support of the argument, one of the cable operator
associations has stated that 186 cases were filed by MSOs and LCOs against Media
Pro in TDSAT in the year 2012 which provides sufficient indication of the level of
discontent amongst the DPOs vis-a-vis the aggregators. It has further stated that
the maximum number of cases are against Media Pro and, unsurprisingly, there is
no case filed by either DEN or Siti Cable against the aggregator, precisely because
they are Media Pro‟s vertically integrated partners. It has also been opined by this
set of stakeholders that removing the aggregator will reduce costs to consumers.
Analysis
14. Taking into account the views/comments of the stakeholders and after detailed
analysis of the issues involved, this amendment to the interconnection regulation
for digital addressable systems is being notified. The succeeding paragraphs
explain the objects and reasons of the provisions of this amendment order along
with the analysis of the issues raised.
Page 10 of 20
Issue of jurisdiction
15. One of the objectives laid out in the preamble of the TRAI Act is to protect the
interests of the service providers and consumers of the sector as well as to promote
and ensure its orderly growth. TRAI has the powers to frame „ex-ante‟
rules/regulations to ensure that the objectives of the TRAI Act are met. In fact in a
recent Judgment dated 6th December 2013, in the Civil Appeal No. 5253 of 2010
(Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd. Vs TRAI and Ors) the Hon‟ble Supreme Court has
made following observations:
“….. under sub section 1 of Section 36 of TRAI Act, the Authority can make regulations
to carry out the purposes of the Act specified in various provisions…”
“……we hold that the power vested in the Authority under section 36(1) to make
regulations is wide and pervasive. The exercise of this power is only subject to the
provisions of the Act and the Rules framed under section 35 thereof. There is no other
limitation on the excise of power by the Authority under section 36(1). It is not
controlled or limited by section 36(2) or sections 11, 12 and 13. “
Thus, it is well within the jurisdiction of TRAI to issue regulations and
amendments thereto on the subject matter.
Right to do business-Violation of 19(1)(g)
16. Another issue is whether these amendments are violative of Art. 19(1)(g) of the
Constitution of India? As discussed earlier, the aggregators are not independent
entities; rather, they are authorised agents of the leading broadcasters whose
channels they distribute. Further, through the aggregators, the broadcasters are
able to realise dominant positions as described above. The aggregators make their
own bouquets which are a mix of channels of various broadcasters including
certain non-popular ones. The DPOs who take up these bouquets are then
compelled to offer them to the consumers to recover costs. This activity of the
aggregators is beyond the scope of their agency; it involves an act which the
broadcaster is not authorised to do under the existing regulations. It is thus not in
public interest and the protection of the right to do business cannot be claimed for
this.
Page 11 of 20
17. These amendments do not restrict a broadcaster from appointing an authorised
agent or intermediary to facilitate in carrying forward its businesses. If authorised
by a broadcaster, they have the freedom to carry out the assigned jobs. However,
the same is to be done on behalf of and in the name of the concerned broadcaster.
In no business, can any authorised agent or intermediary go beyond the scope of
the business of its principal. The present amendment prescribes certain
responsibilities for the broadcasters in order to ensure that their authorised
distribution agencies (aggregators) do not indulge in certain activities beyond the
scope of the business of their principals (broadcasters). Further, the amendments
seek to ensure that the broadcaster publishes its RIO and maintains its sanctity.
This is in conformity with various provisions of existing interconnection
regulations. Therefore, the current amendment to the interconnection regulations
does not impinge upon the fundamental rights of the broadcasters and their
authorised agents or intermediaries as granted to them under Art. 19(1)(g) of the
Constitution.
Principal and Agent
18. It is well accepted that an agent always acts on behalf and in the name of its
principal and the scope of action/activities of the agent cannot exceed that of the
principal.
19. For example in the telecom sector, an agent does everything only on behalf of and
in the name of the service provider (the principal) e.g. the consumer application
form is prescribed only by the service provider and filled up by the consumer
thereby entering into an agreement directly with the service provider. The agent,
who could also be a local corner store or a paan wallah, merely facilitates the
process. However, in the case of aggregators operating in the broadcasting sector,
it is the aggregators who are combining the offerings of different principals
(broadcasters) and are directly entering into agreements in their name with the
DPOs. Invariably, the aggregators are going beyond the scope of business of their
principals. Thus, the analogy between agents of other sectors like telecom,
insurance etc. and aggregators in the broadcasting sector does not hold any
ground. In fact, this amendment aligns them, in principle, with authorised agents
in other sectors.
Page 12 of 20
Amendment to the Definitions of broadcaster/MSO/Authorised agent or intermediary
20. In the cited amendments, the definition of a broadcaster has been amended and an
authorised agent or intermediary has been separately defined. A broadcaster of a
TV channel, prior to commencing its services, has to obtain certain clearances and
permissions following an elaborate process. This procedure and process involves
registration of its channel by the broadcaster with the MIB under the elaborate
Uplinking/Downlinking Guidelines. These Guidelines, apart from others, require
security clearance of the channel as well as clearance of the key executives
managing the business affairs of a broadcaster. The broadcaster is also required to
coordinate with the Department of Space (DoS) for getting the required satellite
bandwidth and related permission to use it. Hence, the broadcaster has a separate
and distinct identity and this should be maintained. The aggregator, on the other
hand, requires no such clearances or permission and so cannot proxy as a
broadcaster. Therefore, there is a need to bring clarity to the entire regulatory
framework.
21. The definition of the broadcaster has been amended to clarify, and place beyond
all doubt, the exclusive role of the broadcaster in publishing the RIOs and entering
into the interconnect agreements with the DPOs, as prescribed in the
interconnection regulations. The definition of authorised agent or intermediary has
been separately framed to clarify their facilitative role in the business of TV
channel distribution both for the broadcasters and MSOs. The definition of MSOs
has also been accordingly amended.
Market power of Major aggregators
22. The popularity ratings of the channels in the form of Gross Rating Points (GRP) as
provided by TAM India reveals that that the three major aggregators exercise
control over the distribution of most of the popular channels. The GRP data for the
years 2012 and 2013 have been analysed. A comparison of number of popular
channels controlled by these aggregators reveals that between 2012 and 2013, the
number of popular channels distributed/controlled by them is increasing. From
the analysis it emerges that in the year 2013, out of the 10 most popular channels of
various broadcasters, these three aggregators controlled distribution of around 9
channels (90%). Similar analysis, for the 5, 20, and 50 most popular channels, for
the years 2012 and 2013 has been carried out and is tabulated below:
Page 13 of 20
Table II: Number of channels distributed by top three aggregators, as per GRP ratings
(Source: TAM India)
S.No Name of Aggregator
Among Top
5
Among Top
10
Among Top
20
Among Top
50
2012 2013 2012 2013 2012 2013 2012 2013
1
M/s Media Pro
Enterprise India Private
Limited
2 2 5 5 10 10 20 21
2
M/s MSM Discovery
Private Limited
1 2 3 3 3 3 5 6
3
M/s IndiaCast UTV
Media Distribution
Private Limited
1 1 1 1 2 4 11 11
Total 4 5 9 9 15 17 36 38
The above analysis corroborates the claims of the independent DPOs that they
cannot afford to ignore these aggregators while finalising their business plans and
they are obliged to strike deals with these aggregators to have a viable business
proposition.
Bouquets/channels of a broadcaster not to be bundled with any other broadcaster’s offerings
23. One of the major reasons for bringing in these amendments is that aggregators,
who are authorised agents of more than one broadcaster, bundle popular channels
of the multiple broadcasters they represent. Table III below presents an analysis of
some of the large bouquets offered by the three largest aggregators.
Table III: Analysis of bouquets offered by Aggregators
S.No
Name of
the
Bouquet
Name of the aggregator
No. of
channels
in the
bouquet
No. of Broadcasters
whose channels have
been aggregated in the
bouquet
1 MP7 Media Pro Enterprise India Pvt Ltd 20 6
2 MP9 Media Pro Enterprise India Pvt Ltd 20 6
3 Bouquet 5 MSM Discovery Private Limited 15 3
4
Bouquet 2 IndiaCast UTV Media Distribution
Pvt Ltd
13 6
5
Bouquet 3 IndiaCast UTV Media Distribution
Pvt Ltd
13 9
Page 14 of 20
This shows that aggregators are offering bouquets comprising as many as 20
channels of 6 broadcasters. Another bouquet, consisting of 13 channels, has
channels drawn from 9 broadcasters.
24. As discussed earlier, aggregators tend to piggy-back less popular channels in such
bouquets to prop them up viz. to help provide market access which otherwise may
be elusive for such less popular channels. In case such channels belong to the
broadcasters who own the aggregator, the broadcasters benefit in terms of both
better advertisement and subscription revenues. In cases where such piggy-backed
channels belong to the broadcaster who do not have stakes in the aggregator, the
aggregator benefits in terms of better commission. In other words, the
broadcaster(s) who own the aggregator gets benefits for its own channels as well
as for channels of other broadcasters. Further, in both cases, the benefits accrue to
aggregators at the cost of “unwanted” channels being pushed to DPOs and
ultimately to the consumers. As a result, both the DPOs and the consumers end up
paying the inbuilt costs of such “unwanted” channels. This, in effect, also restricts
consumer choice. This, is detrimental to public interest at large as well as to one of
the prime objectives of the digitisation viz. empowering the consumer to
effectively exercise choice of channels/services.
25. It has also been noted that even though the largest bouquets offered by the
aggregators in their RIOs are in the range of 13 to 20 channels, the agreements
entered into are for a package of channels consisting of almost all the channels
they are authorised to distribute. For example M/s Media Pro has mostly entered
into agreements with MSOs for around 65 channels out of the 76 pay channels it
distributes. These MSOs include both smaller independent MSOs as well as MSOs
operating at national level. Similarly, M/s IndiaCast and M/s MSM Discovery
have mostly entered into agreements for around 30 (out of 36 channels being
distributed by it) and 20 channels (out of 28 channels being distributed by it)
respectively. This substantiates the allegation of the DPOs that the large
aggregators are virtually compelling them to enter into agreements to subscribe to
almost all of their channels. The agreements entered into with the aggregators in
the first phase of DAS implementation validate this fact, namely that aggregators
push all-channel bouquets to the DPOs.
26. The issues discussed in the preceding paragraphs prompted a study of the
ownership structure of the major aggregators. The details of the ownership
structure of these aggregators are available at Annexure I. The study reveals that
these aggregators are not independent entities; they are extensions of the major
Page 15 of 20
broadcasters they represent. In the case of M/s Media Pro, a DPO also has direct
stakes, apart from three broadcasters. Further, if the ownership structure of the
broadcasters having stakes in M/s Media Pro is analysed, it emerges that, directly
or indirectly, two leading DTH operators and two MSOs operating at national
level are vertically integrated with these broadcasters. It seems quite clear that the
objective of creation of such aggregator entities is not merely facilitation of the
channel distribution work but to serve some other extraneous considerations. In
effect, the broadcasters, through these aggregators, are able to exercise market
power (dominance) in the market to further their commercial interests. Such
cartels become even more dangerous in cases where these aggregators are also
integrated with major DPOs.
27. The channels being distributed by the three major aggregators have been analysed
with respect to the ownership of the channels, the number of channels of different
broadcasters, and the number distributed by these three major aggregators. The
results are tabulated in Table IV below:
Table IV: Analysis of channels distributed by leading aggregators
Name of the
aggregator
Number
of
channels
No. of
broadcasters
whose
channels are
aggregated
No. of channels of the
broadcaster groups owning the
aggregator
1 M/s Media Pro
Enterprise India
Private Limited
76 15 35 - Zee group
29 - Star group
5 - Turner International
2 M/s IndiaCast
UTV Media
Distribution
Private Limited
36 8 15 - Network 18 group
9 - UTV group
3 M/s MSM
Discovery Private
Limited
28 12 11 - MSM group
8 - Discovery
It is quite clear from the above table, that the majority of the channels distributed
by the aggregators belong to the broadcaster groups who own/control the
aggregator (90.7%- Media Pro, 58%- IndiaCast and 57%- MSMD).
Page 16 of 20
28. Further, if we look into the interconnection agreements entered into by these
aggregators, two distinct trends are visible: (i) agreements with the DPOs who are
vertically integrated with the aggregators and (ii) agreements with the DPOs who
are independent with respect to the aggregators. The rates being charged from
vertically integrated DPOs is considerably lower as compared to those charged
from other DPOs. The rates being charged from non-vertically integrated DPOs
are, in some cases, higher by 62% as compared to the vertically integrated DPOs.
And, this is so even though the non-vertically integrated DPO has a higher
subscriber base which commercially offers a better business proposition as
compared to the vertically integrated DPO. The situation becomes even worse in
the case of relatively smaller non- vertically integrated DPOs in which case the
rates charged are higher by about 85% as compared to the vertically integrated
DPOs. This analysis is based on the data contained in the interconnection
agreements and the subscriber base submitted by the respective DPOs to the
Authority for a particular city covered under first phase of DAS implementation.
The absolute figures of the interconnection agreements and other details, being
commercially sensitive in nature, though available with the Authority, are not
being revealed.
29. Regarding the bundling of channels/bouquets of different broadcasters, the
broadcaster-wise break-up of the top 5 and top 10 most popular channels
distributed by the aggregators has been analysed and presented in Table V below:
Table V: Number of most popular channels (as per GRP), distributed by top three aggregators
with the broadcaster wise break-up (Source: TAM India)
S.No Name of Aggregator Among Top 5 Among Top 10
2012 2013 2012 2013
1
M/s Media Pro
Enterprise India Private
Limited
2
(1-Star, 1-
Zee)
2
(1-Star, 1
Zee)
5
(3-Star, 2-Zee)
5
(3-Star, 2-Zee)
2
M/s MSM Discovery
Private Limited
1
MSM(Sony)
2
MSM(Sony)
3
MSM(Sony)
3
MSM(Sony)
3
M/s IndiaCast UTV
Media Distribution
Private Limited
1
(Viacom 18)
1
(Viacom18)
1
(Viacom18)
1
(Viacom18)
Total 4 5 9 9
30. Presently, almost all the top 5 or 10 channels are distributed by 3 aggregators,
around 50% by the leading aggregator Media Pro. With the restriction on bundling
Page 17 of 20
of channels/bouquets of different broadcasters, it can be seen that the top 5 and
the top 10 most popular channels will get distributed amongst different
broadcasters. This will not only ensure a better spread of popular channels in
different bouquets available to the DPOs but would also reduce the number of less
popular channels pushed on to such bouquets. Therefore, DPOs would be in a
better position to negotiate and enter into interconnect agreements with
broadcasters. Further, even in case a DPO fails to arrive at an agreement with a
particular broadcaster the opportunity of finalising agreements with other popular
broadcasters is not lost. Thus, DPOs would be placed in a much better position to
carry out their businesses. In order to give effect to this, sub-regulation 10(1)(a) has
been incorporated.
Bouquets /Channels to be provided to DPOs as per RIO
31. A provision has been incorporated through this amendment which mandates a
broadcaster to ensure that there is no change in the composition of the bouquet
provided to distributors of TV channels from the composition of the bouquet
published in its RIO.
32. In order to ensure a level-playing field and orderly growth of the sector, the
interconnect regulations aim at making available the content to DPOs in a
transparent and non-discriminatory manner. For this, it is important that the
offerings of the broadcasters are available in the public domain. This is why
broadcasters have been mandated to publish an RIO prescribing the technical and
commercial terms for making available their TV channels to the DPOs. Therefore,
in case, a broadcaster appoints an authorised agent or intermediary for
distribution of its channels, it is important that the bouquets of the broadcasters, as
offered in their respective RIOs, are not altered by such agent or intermediary
while making available the channels to the DPOs. To ensure this, sub-regulation
10(1)(a) has been incorporated through this amendment to the interconnection
regulations.
Broadcasters of a group to be allowed to bundle their channels
33. An issue that was not part of the original Consultation Paper but was raised
during the consultation process pertained to permitting channels of group
broadcast companies to be offered as part of a common bouquet. In this regard,
Page 18 of 20
they have requested that channels, belonging to the same „Group‟
(Parent/Promoter/Owner/ Management), though licensed under different
entities, subsidiaries, associated companies, should be allowed to be bundled in a
bouquet and distributed. They have advanced the argument that broadcasters
have established different companies/ventures at different points in time and have
also acquired or sold channels and, as a consequence, a large broadcaster may
have channels in the name of separate legal entities.
34. The Authority is of the view that forming of bouquets, through bundling of
channels of a broadcaster company with that of its, subsidiary companies, holding
company, and subsidiary companies of the holding company, may be permitted as
essentially they have a single point of control in all respects and represent the same
beneficial interest group. However, such companies should have, in their name,
the Uplinking permission or Downlinking permission, as applicable, for their
channels, from the Central Government. Moreover, for such bouquets, any one of
such companies, authorised by them jointly, shall publish the RIO, enter into
interconnection agreements and file details of interconnection agreements with the
Authority and carry out any other obligation prescribed in the regulatory
framework. Further, bouquets or channels offered by such companies, either
individually or as a group, shall be considered to be offerings of a common entity
and will have to comply with the regulatory framework, such as ‟twin conditions‟
etc., prescribed by TRAI. Accordingly, a suitable proviso to sub-regulation 10(1)(a)
has been added to achieve this objective.
35. In summary, the above discussed amendments clearly bring out the distinct roles
and responsibilities of a broadcaster and its authorised agent. This is expected to
address the market distortions caused because of the present role assumed by the
aggregators in the distribution of TV channels to various DPOs. They will also
contribute to the orderly growth and overall development of the sector.
***********
Page 19 of 20
Annexure I
Ownership structure of major aggregators
1. Media pro Enterprise India Pvt. Ltd: It is wholly (directly or indirectly) controlled by
three broadcasters, two leading DTH operators and two MSOs operating at national level.
The details of its shareholding is depicted below:
Fig. 1: Ownership structure of M/s Media pro Enterprise India Pvt.
2. MSM Discovery Pvt. Ltd.: It is wholly controlled by two broadcasters. The details of its
shareholding is depicted below:
Media Pro
Enterprise India
Pvt. Ltd.
Zee -Turner Ltd.
(50%)
Zee
Entertainment
Enterprises Ltd.
(74%)
Turner
International India
Pvt Ltd. (26%)
Star Den Media
Services Pvt Ltd.
(50%)
Star India Pvt.
Ltd.(50%)
Den Networks Ltd.
(50%)
Page 20 of 20
Fig. 2: Ownership structure of M/s MSM Discovery Pvt. Ltd.
3. IndiaCast UTV Media Distribution Pvt. Ltd.: It is wholly (directly or indirectly)controlled by
three broadcasters. The details of its shareholding is depicted below:
Fig. 3: Ownership structure of M/s IndiaCast UTV Media Distribution Pvt. Ltd.
MSM Discovery
Pvt. Ltd.
Multi Screen
Media Pvt. Ltd.
(74%)
Discovery
Communications
India (26%)
IndiaCast UTV
Media
Indiacast
(74%)
TV 18
(50%)
Viacom 18
(50%)
Viacom (50%) TV 18 (50%)
UTV Global
Broadcast (UGBL)
(26%)
Page 1 of 12
TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE GAZETTE OF INDIA, EXTRAORDINARY,
PART III, SECTION 4
TELECOM REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF INDIA
NOTIFICATION
New Delhi the 18th July, 2014
THE TELECOMMUNICATION (BROADCASTING AND CABLE SERVICES)
INTERCONNECTION (DIGITAL ADDRESSABLE CABLE TELEVISION SYSTEMS)
(FOURTH AMENDMENT) REGULATION, 2014
(No. 9 of 2014)
No. 6-33/2014- B&CS –----In exercise of the powers conferred by section 36, read with
sub-clauses (ii), (iii) and (iv) of clause (b) of sub-section (1) of section 11 of the Telecom
Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997 (24 of 1997), read with notification of the
Government of India, in the Ministry of Communication and Information Technology
(Department of Telecommunication) No.39,-----
(a) issued, in exercise of the powers conferred upon the Central Government by proviso
to clause (k) of sub-section (1) of section 2 and clause (d) of sub-section (1) of section 11
of the said Act, and
(b) published under notification No. 39 (S.O. 44 (E) and 45 (E)) dated the 9th January,
2004 in the Gazette of India, Extraordinary, Part II- Section 3- Sub-section (ii), ----
the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India hereby makes the following regulations to
further amend the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services)
Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) Regulations 2012 (9 of
2012), namely:-
Page 2 of 12
1. (1)These regulations may be called the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable
Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) (Fourth
Amendment) Regulation, 2014 (9 of 2014).
(2) They shall come into force from the date of their publication in the Official
Gazette.
2. In regulation 2 of the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services)
Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) Regulations, 2012 (9
of 2012), (hereinafter referred to as the principal regulations),---
(a) after the clause (n), the following clause shall be inserted, namely:----
“(na) “commercial establishment” means any premises wherein any trade,
business or any work in connection with, or incidental or ancillary thereto, is
carried on and includes a society registered under the Societies Registration Act,
1860 (21 of 1860), and charitable or other trust, whether registered or not, which
carries on any business, trade or work in connection with, or incidental or
ancillary thereto, journalistic, printing and publishing establishments,
educational, healthcare or other institutions run for private gain, theatres,
cinemas, restaurants, eating houses, pubs, bars, residential hotels, malls, airport
lounges, clubs or other places of public amusements or entertainment;”
(b) for clause (o), the following clause shall be substituted, namely:----
“(o) “commercial subscriber” means any person who receives broadcasting
services or cable services at a place indicated by him to a cable operator or multi
system operator or direct to home operator or head end in the sky operator or
Internet Protocol television service provider, as the case may be, and uses such
services for the benefit of his clients, customers, members or any other class or
group of persons having access to his commercial establishment;”
Page 3 of 12
(c) for the clause (za), the following clause shall be substituted, namely.-----
“(za) “subscriber” means a person who receives broadcasting services or cable
services from a multi system operator or cable operator or direct to home operator
or Internet Protocol television service provider or head end in the sky operator at
a place indicated by him to the multi system operator or cable operator or direct
to home operator or Internet Protocol television service provider or head end in
the sky operator, as the case may be, without further transmitting it to any person
and includes ordinary subscribers and commercial subscribers, unless specifically
excluded;”
3. In regulation 4 of the principal regulations, sub-regulation (3) shall be deleted.
(Sudhir Gupta)
Secretary, TRAI
Note.1-----The principal regulation was published in the Gazette of India,
Extraordinary, Part III, Section 4, vide its notification No. 3- 24/2012- B&CS dated the
30th April 2012 and subsequently amended vide notifications No. 3- 24/2012- B&CS
dated the 14th May 2012, No. 3-24/2012-B&CS dated the 20th September 2013 and
No. 3-24/2012- B&CS dated the 10th February, 2014.
Note.2-----The Explanatory Memorandum explains the objects and reasons of the
Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital
Addressable Cable Television Systems) (Fourth Amendment) Regulation, 2014 (9 of
2014).
Page 4 of 12
Annexure
Explanatory Memorandum
Background
1. The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) was entrusted with the
responsibility of regulating „broadcasting and cable TV‟ services in January, 2004.
An interim Tariff Order was issued on 15.01.2004, which provided that the cable
charges prevailing on 26.12.2003 shall be the ceilings at the respective levels.
Thereafter, following extensive consultations, a detailed Tariff Order was issued
on 01.10.2004. This order, while maintaining the sanctity of the ceiling of cable
TV charges prevailing on 26.12.2003, also provided a window for introduction of
new pay channels and conversion of existing Free-to-Air (FTA) channels to „pay
channels‟ subject to prescribed conditions. The underlying objective of these
Tariff orders was to give relief and protection to consumers of broadcasting and
cable TV services from frequent hikes in cable TV charges.
2. Subscribers of broadcasting and cable TV services are basically of two kinds.
First, there are ordinary subscribers who consume TV services domestically for
their own pleasure. The second group comprises commercial subscribers who
obtain TV services for the benefit of their clients, customers etc., at their
commercial establishment. While issuing the Tariff Orders in 2004, as mentioned
above, the Authority, however, did not differentiate between ordinary and
commercial subscribers.
3. The matter pertaining to tariffs for commercial subscribers has been under
judicial scrutiny since 2005, before the Hon‟ble Telecom Disputes Settlement
Appellate Tribunal (TDSAT), when Hotels and Restaurants Association
(Western India) (HRAWI), a sister association of Federation of Hotel and
Restaurant Associations of India (FHRAI), challenged differential tariffs
imposed by some broadcasters. The Hon‟ble TDSAT disposed of these petitions
vide its judgment dated 17.01.2006 wherein it concluded that the members of the
petitioner associations couldn‟t be regarded as subscribers or consumers. It also
asked the Authority to consider whether it was necessary or not to fix tariff for
commercial cable TV subscribers.
4. As an interim measure, on 07.03.2006, the Authority issued an amendment to the
principal Tariff Order of 01.10.2004. This Tariff Amendment Order defined the
terms „Ordinary cable subscriber‟ and „Commercial cable subscriber‟. In the
meanwhile, the aforesaid judgment of the Hon‟ble TDSAT was appealed by the
Page 5 of 12
Associations of Hotels and Restaurants before the Hon‟ble Supreme Court. In an
interim order on 19.10.2006, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court directed the Authority
to carry out the processes for framing the tariff under Section 11 of the TRAI Act,
independently and not relying on or on the basis of any observation made by
TDSAT. In its final order on 24.11.2006, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court confirmed its
interim orders and stated that it did not agree with the opinion of the Hon‟ble
TDSAT that the Authority should also consider whether it is necessary or not to
fix tariff for commercial cable TV subscribers.
5. Based on the interim order of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court dated 19.10.2006, the
Authority issued two Tariff Amendment Orders, on 21.11.2006, applicable to
commercial subscribers in non-CAS and CAS areas, respectively. This tariff
amendment order categorized commercial subscribers into the following two
groups, namely:-
(a) A specified category of commercial subscribers comprising---
(i) Hotels with rating of 3 stars and above;
(ii) Heritage hotels (as defined by the Department of Tourism, Government
of India);
(iii) Any hotel, motel, inn or commercial establishment providing board &
lodging and having 50 or more rooms; and
(b) All other commercial subscribers (not falling under the specified category of
commercial subscribers).
6. The tariff for cable TV services for the specified category of commercial
subscribers was to be mutually determined by the parties. However, the tariff for
commercial subscribers not falling in the specified categories (coming under the
second category) was subject to the same charges as ordinary cable subscribers
and thus the ceiling of rates prevailing as on 26.12.2003 was made applicable to
them. The tariff amendment order also provided that whenever a commercial
cable TV subscriber belonging to either of the two categories uses the programme
of a broadcaster for public viewing by fifty or more persons on the occasion of
special events at a place registered under the Entertainment Tax Act, the tariff
will have to be mutually decided between the parties concerned.
7. These orders too were appealed against in the Hon‟ble TDSAT by way of appeals
[Appeal No.17(C) of 2006 - East India Hotel Ltd. Vs TRAI & Ors and Appeal No.
18 (C ) of 2006 – The Connaught Prominent Hotels Limited vs. TRAI & Ors] by
the hotels and their associations. The Hon‟ble TDSAT passed its judgment on
Page 6 of 12
28.05.2010 in the two appeals filed by the hotels against the tariff amendment
orders dated 21.11.2006. The operative portion of the judgment of the Hon‟ble
TDSAT read:
“We, therefore, are of the opinion that it is a fit case where the impugned orders are
required to be set aside. We direct accordingly. We, however, do not wish to issue any
direction with regard to the refund of any amount but we would request the Authority
to consider the case of commercial establishments once over again in a broad based
manner”.
8. In sum, the sub-classification of commercial consumers into two categories was
struck down by the Hon‟ble TDSAT. Aggrieved by the TDSAT judgement dated
28.05.2010, M/s ESPN Software India Pvt. Ltd. filed an appeal (CA No. 6040-41
of 2010 -M/s ESPN Software India Pvt. Ltd. Vs TRAI and Ors.) in the Supreme
Court. The judgment of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court, dated 16.04.2014, in this
case, directs as follows:
“…… we direct that for a period of three months, the impugned tariff, which
is in force as on today, shall continue. Within the said period, TRAI shall look
into the matter de novo, as directed in the impugned judgment, and shall re–
determine the tariff after hearing the contentions of all the stake holders….”
9. Accordingly, as directed by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in its judgment dated
16.04.2014, TRAI initiated a consultation process, as part of a de novo exercise,
and issued a Consultation Paper (CP) on 11.06.2014 seeking comments/views of
the stakeholders. The CP discussed and raised related consultation issues
pertaining to various alternatives for tariff stipulations for the
commercial subscribers, manner of offering of TV services to them, the
definition of the ‘commercial establishment’, ‘shop’ and ‘commercial
subscriber’, and sub-categorization of the commercial subscribers into
similarly placed groups. In response to the CP, 24 stakeholders
submitted their views/comments to the Authority. Subsequently, to
further discuss the issues involved, an Open House Discussion (OHD)
was also held at Delhi on 4th July 2014, wherein 59 stakeholders
participated in the discussions.
10. This interconnection regulation is being notified after analyzing all the
issues involved and the inputs received from various stakeholders.
Page 7 of 12
Analysis of Issues
Definition of commercial subscribers, commercial establishment and shops
11. Draft definitions of commercial subscriber, commercial establishment and shops
were discussed in the CP and views/comments of the stakeholders were
solicited.
Stakeholder comments
12. Several broadcasters including the two prominent broadcasters, a broadcasting
industry association, a Hotel industry association as well as a couple of cable TV
operator associations have broadly agreed with the draft definitions. Some of
them have pointed out that the „profession‟ appearing in the definition of
„commercial establishments should be deleted as some court decisions have held
that the premises of doctors, lawyers, engineers etc. should not be considered
commercial establishments. Some other broadcasters have stated that shops,
factories and public viewing areas should be included in the definition of
„commercial establishment‟. It was also suggested by a broadcaster that
„publishing‟ should also be included in the definition of „commercial
establishments‟. An association of broadcasters and some other stakeholders
from the broadcasters fraternity have put forth the view that any premise, indoor
or outdoor, that is not a domestic premise should be categorized as commercial
and commercial subscribers be defined in an all inclusive manner to include all
subscribers except residential subscribers.
13. The majority of the distribution platform operators, cable and DTH, as well as a
hotel and restaurant industry association are of the view that there is no need to
make a distinction between ordinary and commercial subscribers and all
subscribers should be treated at par. It has also been suggested to include the
concept of commercial purpose and/or commercial exploitation into the
definition of commercial establishment. Another industry association has
proposed that commercial subscriber should be defined as the one who uses TV
signals as its business or commercial activity or part thereof, irrespective of
whether TV channels are charged or not from the viewers/audience.
Analysis
14. Taking into account the views of the stakeholders, the definition of „commercial
establishment‟ has been included and the definition of „commercial subscriber‟
has been accordingly amended. This is also in line with the tariff prescription
Page 8 of 12
and the manner of offering of television services to the commercial subscribers,
which have been discussed in subsequent paragraphs.
Tariff for Commercial subscribers
15. In the CP, the following four alternatives were discussed for prescribing tariff for
commercial subscribers, seeking views/comments of the stakeholders:
(i) The tariff for commercial subscribers is the same as that for ordinary
subscribers.
(ii) The tariff for commercial subscribers has a linkage with the tariff for
ordinary subscribers.
(iii) The tariff for commercial subscribers has no linkage with the tariff for
ordinary subscribers but there are some protective measures prescribed to
protect all the stakeholders such as mandatory a-la-carte offering,
conditions to prevent perverse a-la-carte pricing vis-à-vis bouquet rates etc.
(iv) The tariff for commercial subscribers is kept under total forbearance.
Stakeholder comments
16. Hotel industry associations and almost all distribution platform operators
(DPOs) have advocated for adoption of the first alternative discussed in the CP
i.e. the tariff for commercial subscribers should be same as that prescribed for the
ordinary subscribers. To support their view, the main arguments put forth have
been - (i) the ultimate consumer/viewer is the same whether the TV services are
availed at the domestic premises of the consumer or in a hotel or hospital or any
other commercial establishment, (ii) a consumer does not go to such commercial
establishment specifically to view TV channels (iii) there is no extra cost to the
broadcaster for production of content and its distribution in both the cases and
the content/quality of signal remains the same. Some of them further stated that,
in cases where the consumer goes to a commercial establishment specifically to
avail TV services and pays for it, the tariff may be different from that for the
ordinary subscribers.
17. On the other hand, all broadcasters and their representative bodies are of the
view that the fourth alternative, prescribing total forbearance on tariff for
commercial subscribers, be adopted. The main arguments presented by them in
this regard are – (i) the TV services are basically non-essential services and,
therefore, need not be regulated, (ii) in many international markets, differential
pricing is done for the commercial subscribers, (iii) commercial subscribers
exploit the TV signals for commercial gains, therefore, the broadcasters are
Page 9 of 12
entitled to a fair share of the same. In response to a query during the OHD, an
Association of broadcasters has indicated that the total revenue of the
commercial subscribers that are „known‟ to subscribe to television are estimated
at 1.5-2.2% of total distribution revenues.
18. A headend in the sky (HITS) operator has suggested for prescription of the
second alternative which provides that there should be a certain linkage between
the tariff for ordinary and commercial subscribers. A broadcaster and a couple of
cable operator associations have expressed their preference for the third
alternative. It has also been suggested by a multi system operator (MSO) that a
broadcaster should prescribe the retail price of its channels for different
categories of commercial subscribers and the revenue share for different
stakeholders in the value chain should be determined by TRAI.
Analysis
19. The end consumer, whether at his domestic premises or at any commercial
establishment, gets to view the same content with same quality of signals. In both
the cases, the cost to the content owner (broadcaster) and the DPO, for supplying
the signals, per se, does not vary on account of where the signals are supplied - at
the domestic premises or the commercial establishment. Moreover, The Hon‟ble
Supreme Court in its judgment dated 24.11.2006 in appeal (Civil) 2061 of 2006
Hotel and Restaurants Association and Anr Vs Star India Pvt. Ltd. and Ors has,
amongst others, observed as under:
“….The owners of the hotels take TV signals for their customers/ guests. While doing so,
they inter alia provide services to their customers. An owner of a hotel provides various
amenities to its customers such as beds, meals, fans, television, etc. Making a provision
for extending such facilities or amenities to the boarders would not constitute a sale by an
owner to a guest. The owners of the hotels take TV signals from the broadcasters in the
same manner as they take supply of electrical energy from the licensees. A guest may use
an electrical appliance. The same would not constitute the sale of electricity by the hotel
to him. For the said purpose, the 'consumer' and 'subscriber' would continue to be the
hotel and its management. Similarly, if a television set is provided in all the rooms, as
part of the services rendered by the management by way of an amenity, wherefor the
guests are not charged separately, the same would not convert the guests staying in a
hotel into consumers or subscribers…..”
The said judgment further quotes another judgment of the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court (in The State of Punjab v. M/s. Associated Hotels of India Ltd. [(1972) 1
SCC 472)]) on similar issue, which is reproduced as under:
Page 10 of 12
“…. When a traveller, by plane or by steam-ship, purchases his passage-ticket, the
transaction is one for his passage from one place to another. If, in the course of carrying
out that transaction, the traveller is supplied with drinks or meals or cigarettes, no one
would think that the transaction involves separate sales each time any of those things is
supplied. The transaction is essentially one of carrying the passenger to his destination
and if in performance of the contract of carriage something is supplied to him, such
supply is only incidental to that services, not changing either the pattern or the nature of
the contract. Similarly, when clothes are given for washing to a laundery, there is a
transaction which essentially involves work or service, and if the launderyman stitches a
button to a garment which has fallen off, there is no sale of the button or the thread. A
number of such cases involving incidental uses of materials can be cited, none of which
can be said to involve a sale as part of the main transaction. …."
20. From the observations of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court, cited above, it is clear that
provision of TV services in a commercial establishment in only incidental to the
service that the commercial establishment is providing to its clients. It cannot be
construed as re-distribution or re-sale of TV services. In any case, there is no re-
transmission. In sum, the question as to who is the subscriber has been settled
through this judgment. It has also been settled by the said judgment that any
service rendered to a guest by way of an amenity, wherefor the guests are not
charged separately, the same would not constitute as sale of the said service to
the guest. Further, this judgment specifically refers to the subject in hand.
Accordingly, the Authority was of the view that in the rates of TV services,
there should be no differentiation between an ordinary subscriber and a
commercial subscriber i.e. in both the cases, the charges should be the same
and on per set top box basis. In view of the above, clause 6 of the tariff order
applicable for addressable systems namely, the Telecommunication
(Broadcasting and Cable) Services (Fourth) (Addressable Systems) Tariff Order,
2010, has been suitably amended.
21. However, in case, the commercial establishment specifically charges extra to its
clients/visitors on account of viewing of channels at its premises, there is a case
for broadcasters to have a share in such revenue of the commercial
establishment. Therefore, where the commercial establishment is earning extra
revenue from its clients specifically on account of providing TV services, the
rates should be based on mutual negotiations between the broadcaster and the
commercial subscriber. In such cases also, the commercial subscriber would be
required to obtain such signals of TV channel through a DPO/cable operator
only. Accordingly, sub-clause (5) has been added to clause 6 of the
Page 11 of 12
Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable) Services (Fourth) (Addressable
Systems) Tariff Order, 2010.
Manner of offering TV channels to the commercial subscribers
22. Three models of offering of TV channels to commercial subscribers were
discussed in the CP. The first model envisages that the commercial subscriber
enters into agreement with the broadcaster and obtains signals either from the
broadcaster itself or a DPO designated by the broadcaster. In the second model,
the commercial subscriber is to enter into agreement with the DPO and obtain
the signals while DPO and broadcasters have their own mutually agreed
arrangements. The third model discussed in the CP is a combination of the first
and second models.
Stakeholder Comments
23. Almost all the broadcasters and their representative bodies and agents have
stated that only the first model is viable and should be adopted. While
suggesting a detailed procedure for implementation of this model they have
reasoned that – (a) the second model is prone to commercial subscribers not
getting signal because of potential breakdown of negotiations between
broadcasters and DPOs and (b) the third model is prone to confusion, as both
broadcasters and DPOs would be allowed to provide Reference Interconnect
Offers(RIOs).
24. Almost all the DPOs have suggested adoption of second model. A couple of
cable TV operator associations have opined that the regulator should fix the MRP
based on which the broadcasters and DPOs make the RIO. However,
broadcasters should not identify the DPO through which the commercial
subscriber should get the signals of the broadcaster. They have also stated that in
cases where commercial subscribers have their own headend, the broadcasters
can directly negotiate with the commercial subscribers as per RIO. Another cable
operator association has stated that the broadcaster and commercial subscribers
should negotiate the rates while the DPO should give the services at the same
rate as for ordinary subscriber.
25. One of the hotel and restaurant industry associations has stated the first model
should not be adopted, while another hotel industry association has expressed its
preference for the third model.
Page 12 of 12
Analysis
26. The guideline for downlinking of TV channels in India prescribe as under:
“5.6. The applicant company shall provide Satellite TV Channel signal reception
decoders only to MSOs/Cable Operators registered under the Cable Television Networks
(Regulation) Act 1995 or to a DTH operator registered under the DTH guidelines issued
by Government of India or to an Internet Protocol Television (IPTV) Service Provider
duly permitted under their existing Telecom License or authorized by Department of
Telecommunications or to a HITS operator duly permitted under the policy guidelines for
HITS operators issued by Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, Government of
India to provide such service."
So, the broadcaster cannot supply signals directly to subscribers, including the
commercial subscribers. Broadcasters should supply their signals through a
DPO. It would also ensure competition in the market if a commercial subscriber
can obtain TV signals from any MSO or its linked local cable operator /DTH
operator etc. operating in his area. Accordingly, definition of „subscriber‟ has also
been suitably amended.
Sub-categorization of commercial subscribers
27. In the CP, the issue regarding sub-categorization of commercial subscribers into
similarly placed groups and fixing the tariff therefor was discussed and views of
the stakeholders were sought. Almost all the stakeholders, across all the
segments, are of the view that any such sub-categorization and fixing of tariff for
such sub-categories may not be the appropriate way forward.
Analysis
28. In view of the tariff prescription and the provisions regarding manner of offering
of TV signals to the commercial subscribers, there is no need for sub-
categorization of the commercial subscribers into similarly placed groups for the
purpose of prescription of tariff dispensation for commercial subscribers. The
only distinction required is to place the commercial subscribers into two broad
classes – (i) those who offer television services/programmes as part of amenities
to their guests and (ii) those who charge for the same in the manner as discussed
in para 21 above. In view of the above, the sub-regulation 3 of regulation 4 has
been deleted.
***********
Page 1 of 15
TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE GAZETTE OF INDIA, EXTRAORDINARY,
PART III, SECTION 4
TELECOM REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF INDIA
NOTIFICATION
New Delhi the 14th September, 2015
THE TELECOMMUNICATION (BROADCASTING AND CABLE SERVICES)
INTERCONNECTION (DIGITAL ADDRESSABLE CABLE TELEVISION SYSTEMS)
(FIFTH AMENDMENT) REGULATION, 2015
(No. 7 of 2015)
No. 6-29/2015- B&CS –----In exercise of the powers conferred by section 36, read with
sub-clauses (ii), (iii), (iv) and (v) of clause (b) of sub-section (1) of section 11, of the
Telecom Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997 (24 of 1997), read with notification of
the Government of India, in the Ministry of Communication and Information
Technology (Department of Telecommunication) No.39,-----
(a) issued, in exercise of the powers conferred upon the Central Government by proviso
to clause (k) of sub-section (1) of section 2 and clause (d) of sub-section (1) of section 11
of the said Act, and
(b) published under notification No. 39 (S.O. 44 (E) and 45 (E)) dated the 9th January,
2004 in the Gazette of India, Extraordinary, Part II- Section 3- Sub-section (ii), ----
the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India hereby makes the following regulations to
further amend the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services)
Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) Regulations 2012 (9 of
2012), namely:-
Page 2 of 15
1. (1) These regulations may be called the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable
Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) (Fifth
Amendment) Regulation, 2015 ( 7 of 2015).
(2) They shall come into force from the date of their publication in the Official
Gazette.
2. In regulation 2 of the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services)
Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) Regulations, 2012 (9
of 2012),---
(a) sub‐clause (na) shall be deleted.
(b) for sub-clause (o), the following sub-clause shall be substituted, namely:----
“(o) “commercial subscriber” means a subscriber who causes the signals of TV channels to
be heard or seen by any person for a specific sum of money to be paid by such person;”
(c) for the sub-clause (t), the following sub-clause shall be substituted, namely.-----
“(t) “ordinary subscriber” means a subscriber who is not a commercial subscriber;”
(Sudhir Gupta)
Secretary, TRAI
Note.1-----The principal regulation was published in the Gazette of India,
Extraordinary, Part III, Section 4, vide its notification No. 3- 24/2012- B&CS dated the
30th April 2012 and subsequently amended vide notifications No. 3- 24/2012- B&CS
dated the 14th May 2012, No. 3-24/2012-B&CS dated the 20th September 2013, No. 3-
Page 3 of 15
24/2012- B&CS dated the 10th February, 2014 and No. 6-33/2014-B&CS dated the 18th
July 2014
Note.2-----The Explanatory Memorandum explains the objects and reasons of the
Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital
Addressable Cable Television Systems) (Fifth Amendment) Regulation, 2015 ( 7 of
2015).
Page 4 of 15
Annexure
Explanatory Memorandum
Background
1. The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) is a statutory body established by the
Telecom Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997 (hereinafter referred to as the TRAI Act).
Since its inception some of the prime focus areas of TRAI have been, to protect the interests
of consumers and service providers of the telecommunication sector and to promote the
orderly growth of telecommunication services.
2. The Government of India, through a Notification dated 9 January 2004, notified
“broadcasting services” and “cable services” as "telecommunication services". Accordingly,
since 2004 TRAI has been regulating the broadcasting and cable TV sector in India by
exercising its recommendatory as well as regulatory powers.
3. Soon after it came to be vested with regulation of broadcasting and cable TV services sector,
TRAI notified, in the interim, the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable) Services
Tariff Order, 2004 on 15 January 2004. Vide this order charges payable by Cable
subscribers to Cable Operators, Cable Operators to MSOs/Broadcasters and MSOs to
Broadcasters as on 26 December 2003 were prescribed to be the ceiling for Free-to-Air
(FTA) and pay channels, until final determination by TRAI. On that date, there was no
categorization made amongst the cable subscribers. Thereafter, on 01 October 2004, TRAI
notified the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable) Services (Second) Tariff Order,
2004 (hereinafter referred to as ‘Principal Non-CAS Tariff Order’) superseding the interim
tariff order issued on 15 January 2004. This tariff order also, retained the ceilings imposed
on cable TV charges. In this tariff order also, no categorization was made amongst the TV
subscribers.
4. On 08 August 2005, the Association of Hotels and Restaurants filed Petition Nos. 80(C) and
32(C) of 2005, before the Hon’ble TDSAT challenging the differential tariffs charged by
Page 5 of 15
some broadcasters. On 17 January 2006, the Hon’ble TDSAT dismissed the petition wherein
it concluded that the members of the petitioner associations couldn’t be regarded as
subscribers or consumers. It also asked the Authority to consider whether it was necessary or
not to fix tariff for commercial cable TV subscribers.
5. On 07 March 2006, TRAI, upon considering the observations made by TDSAT in its Order
dated 17 January 2006 and a representation received from Federation of Hotel and
Restaurants Association of India (FHRAI), in the interim, notified the Telecommunication
(Broadcasting and Cable) Services (Second) Tariff (Fourth Amendment) Order, 2006(2 of
2006). In this order, two classes of subscribers - ordinary cable subscribers and commercial
cable subscribers were defined. This order also provided that for the commercial cable
subscribers, the rates (excluding taxes) payable by one party to the other by virtue of the
written/oral agreement prevalent on 01 March 2006 shall be the ceiling and the principle
applicable in the written/oral agreements prevalent on 01 March 2006, should be applied for
determining the scope of the term “rates”. Similar provision was also made for all
subscribers other than commercial cable subscribers.
6. On 21 April 2006, a Consultation Paper was issued by TRAI for detailed consultations on
the issue. In the meantime, Civil Appeal No. 2061 of 2006 was filed challenging the Hon’ble
TDSAT’s order dated 17 January 2006 by Associations of Hotels and Restaurants before the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and the Hon’ble Supreme Court passed a “status quo” order
on 28 April 2006. This status quo order was modified by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, on 19
October 2006, directing the Authority to carry out the processes for framing the tariff under
Section 11 of the TRAI Act independently and not relying on or on the basis of any
observation made by TDSAT. In the said order it was also mentioned that there is no need of
issuing another consultation paper, however while issuing the Tariff Order it should be
ensured that all the provisions of the TRAI Act have been complied with.
7. Accordingly in pursuance of the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, draft tariff
amendment orders seeking comments of the stakeholders was placed on the website of
TRAI.
8. After following the due consultation process, in pursuance of the directions of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, the Authority issued two Amendment Orders on 21 November 2006, viz
The Telecommunications (Broadcasting & Cable) Services (Second) Tariff (Seventh
Amendment) Order, 2006 (8 of 2006) and The Telecommunication (Broadcasting and
Cable) Services (Third) (CAS Areas) Tariff Order, 2006 (6 of 2006), applicable to
commercial subscribers in Non-CAS and CAS areas respectively. These tariff amendment
Page 6 of 15
orders had the following main provisions:
(a) With respect to hotels with ratings of 3 stars and above, heritage hotels and hotels
with a capacity of 50 or more rooms (hereinafter referred to as “the Excluded
Categories of Hotels”), the charges were to be mutually negotiated.
(b) The charges for other categories of hotels (except excluded categories of hotels)
shall be at the same rate as for ordinary subscribers and other commercial
subscribers.
(c) In respect of programmes of a broadcaster, shown on the occasion of a special
event for common viewing, at any place registered under the Entertainment Tax
Law and to which access is allowed on payment basis for a minimum of 50
persons by the commercial cable subscribers, the tariff shall be as mutually
determined between the parties.
9. On 24 November 2006, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India decided Civil Appeal No. 2061
of 2006 and reversed the order of the TDSAT dated 17 January 2006 and remanded the
matter back to TRAI directing it to carry on the process for fresh determination of tariff
independently.
10. Hotels which formed a part of the excluded category under the Notifications dated 21
November 2006 and the Federation of Hotel and Restaurants Association of India (FHRAI),
filed Appeals No.17(c) of 2006 (East India Hotel Ltd vs. TRAI and Ors) and 18(c) of 2006
(The Connaught Prominent Hotels Ltd vs. TRAI and Ors) before the Hon’ble TDSAT
challenging inter alia the Tariff Order/ Notification dated 21 November 2006, issued by
TRAI. The Hon’ble TDSAT, by its judgment dated 28 May 2010, allowed appeals and
quashed the tariff order and, amongst others, asked the Authority to consider the case of
commercial establishments afresh in a broad based manner.
11. Civil Appeal Nos. 6040-6041 of 2010 filed by one of the broadcasters (M/s ESPN) and other
connected appeal Nos. 10476-10477 of 2010 and 8358-8359 of 2010 were filed before the
Hon’ble Supreme Court challenging the judgment of the Hon’ble TDSAT dated 28 May
2010, wherein:
Page 7 of 15
(a) On 16 August 2010, the Hon’ble Supreme Court passed an ad interim order of
stay on the order of the TDSAT dated 28 May 2010.
(b) By its judgment dated 16 April 2014, the Hon’ble Supreme Court dismissed
Civil Appeal No. 6040-41 of 2010 and other connected appeals. The Hon’ble
Supreme Court further directed TRAI to consider the matter de-novo within 3
months and to re-determine tariff.
12. Accordingly, TRAI issued a consultation paper on 11 June 2014 and subsequently, after
following the due consultative process notified the following Regulations and Orders–
(a) The Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable) Services (Second) Tariff
(Twelfth Amendment) Order, 2014 (5 of 2014) on 16 July 2014.
(b) The Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable) Services (Fourth)
(Addressable Systems) Tariff (Fourth Amendment) Order, 2014 (6 of 2014) on
18 July 2014. (c) The Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services)
Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) (Fourth
Amendment) Regulation, 2014 (9 of 2014) on 18 July 2014.
(d) The Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection
(Eighth Amendment) Regulation, 2014 (8 of 2014) on 18 July 2014.,
13. The above two Tariff Amendment Orders were challenged by the Indian Broadcasting
Foundation and Others, in Appeal No. 7(C) of 2014, before the Hon’ble TDSAT. A Writ
Petition No. 5161 of 2014 (Star India vs. TRAI and Ors.) was filed before the Hon’ble High
Court of Delhi challenging the above amendments dated 16 July 2014 and 18 July 2014, to
the Tariff Orders and to the Interconnect Regulations applicable to Non-CAS areas and to
DAS areas.
14. The Hon’ble TDSAT in its order dated 09 March 2015, allowed the appeal filed by the
Indian Broadcasting Foundation, quashing the two tariff amendment orders dated 16 July
2014 and 18 July 2014. The Hon’ble TDSAT while allowing the appeal also, inter-alia,
directed TRAI to issue fresh orders within six months from the date of the judgment.
Further, it was also mentioned in the said judgment that the Authority may also take a
decision with regard to any interim arrangement within one month from the date of the
judgment.
15. In Writ Petition No. 5161 of 2014, the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi, issued an order on 15
Page 8 of 15
May 2015, holding that while determining the tariff in terms of the order of TDSAT dated
09 March 2015, TRAI shall not consider itself bound by the regulations impugned in the
petition in any manner whatsoever.
16. TRAI has filed an appeal (Civil appeal No 4851 of 2015 (TRAI vs. IBF and others)) in the
Hon’ble Supreme Court challenging the order dated 09 March 2015, delivered in appeal No
7(C) of 2014, of the Ld. TDSAT.
17. TRAI issued a press release, dated 13 May 2015, clarifying its position with respect to the
interim arrangement referred to in the Hon’ble TDSAT order dated 09 March 2015. The
relevant extracts of the press release are given below-
“….an ad interim measure, the "Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable)
Services (Second) Tariff Order 2004" (6 of 2004) dated 01.10.2004, the
"Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable) Services (Third) (CAS Areas) Tariff
Order 2006 (6 of 2006) dated 31.08.2006 and the "Telecommunication
(Broadcasting and Cable) Services) (Fourth) (Addressable Systems) Tariff Order,
2010 (1 of 2010) dated 21.07.2010 respectively shall apply subject to the outcome
of the civil appeal filed by TRAI before the Hon'ble Supreme Court challenging the
order dated 9th March, 2015 of the Hon'ble TDSAT.”
18. The Authority, as per the Hon’ble TDSAT order initiated a consultation process and issued a
consultation paper (CP) titled “Tariff issues related to commercial subscribers” on 14 July
2015 seeking comments/ views of all the stakeholders. The CP took a fresh and holistic
approach without being biased with previous determinations to the issue. A total of 22
comments were received, however no counter-comment was received. An Open-House
discussion (OHD) was conducted on 18 August 2015 at New Delhi wherein 73 stakeholders
participated. A total of 11 post-OHD comments were also received.
19. This amendment to the interconnection regulations is being issued after comprehensive
study and analysis of the issues while taking into consideration comments/ views of all the
stakeholders in response to consultation paper as well as discussions in OHD.
Analysis of Issues
Need for differentiation between ordinary and commercial subscribers and requirement
for separate definition
Page 9 of 15
20. The consultation paper sought the views of all stakeholders on the basic issue of
whether there is a need to define and differentiate between ordinary and commercial
subscribers for provision of TV signals. The views/opinions of the stakeholders who
responded during the consultation process are summarized below.
Stakeholder comments
21. All broadcasters and their association have brought out that it is essential to define and
differentiate between ordinary and commercial subscribers for provision of TV signals.
22. Most of the DPOs have stated that there is no need to define and differentiate between
the ordinary and commercial subscribers. Some of the reasons put forward to justify
their view are as follows:
(a) In an addressable regime, each STB is a subscriber and is thereby fully
accounted for.
(b) There is no difference in the TV service that is provided to an ordinary or a
commercial subscriber.
23. Some DPOs also suggested that the only exception when such a differentiation must
actually be made is when a commercial establishment charges separately for the TV
services provided to his clients thereby exploiting the TV signals for commercial gains.
24. Almost all hotels and their associations have submitted that no differentiation is
required between the ordinary and commercial subscribers. Some of the reasons put
forth in support of their argument are as follows:
(a) Television service in hotels is a necessity by virtue of the Ministry of
Tourism guidelines issued vide letter no 8-TH-I93)/2013 dated
16.12.2014.
(b) TV service is an essential service to be provided to the guests as per the
decision of the Ld. TDSAT dated 27 February 2007.
(c) Hotels and restaurants do not recover the cost of TV subscription from their
guests.
(d) Commercial subscribers have no better bargaining power than residential
Page 10 of 15
subscribers especially vis-à-vis the broadcasters.
25. Individuals including an industry observer and an industry association have opined that there
is no need for differentiation between ordinary and commercial subscribers. However, one
individual has suggested that there should be a categorization of the subscribers as ordinary
and commercial and the commercial subscribers can be further categorized based on the
scale and type of commercial activity that is carried out at such a subscriber’s location.
Analysis
26. The penetration of TV services in the country in the last few decades has been on the rise
exponentially and most of the households and other establishments in urban and semi-urban
areas now have access to pay TV services. There has been paradigm shift from the way TV
was looked at in 2006 when initially TRAI gave separate classification for commercial
subscribers. Viewing Pay TV channels in Hotels in 2006 was considered a luxury and many
a time separate rates for similar rooms with TV and without TV were quoted. Now pay TV
has become ubiquitous and classifying hotels as commercial TV subscribers merely on the
basis that they provide TV signal viewing facility in hotel rooms does not holds ground.
Now a days, it is not only the hotels and restaurants but various other public places such as
Airports, Malls, Shopping complexes, Hospitals, Doctors’ Clinics etc., where one can have
access to viewing of TV channels. Most of the individual visiting these establishments
would have in the normal case already paid for domestic access to the TV content. Viewing
of TV programs, if at all, at such places is not novelty and in no way adds to special
experience. It can safely be presumed that an individual visiting these establishments cannot
be doing so solely for the purpose of watching TV content. Moreover, with pervasiveness of
TV services in the country and widespread availability of paid TV content, it no longer is a
distinctive value proposition for these establishments to attract clientele on the basis of such
TV services. In most cases, the TV services in a basic form are offered to the client akin to
any other basic amenity. However, there may be instances where the establishments do
charge their clients for providing premium TV content with enhanced attractiveness. In these
specific cases, such establishments may be said to be exploiting the display of premium TV
content to bring in additional revenues and thereby they do stand to benefit commercially by
causing the TV broadcast to be heard or seen by the public on payment of charges.
27. The Authority is therefore of the view that TV services being used at these establishments,
may broadly be classified in two categories - (i) where the client does not have to pay
separately to use the TV services or where use of TV services is incidental to the primary
Page 11 of 15
purpose; in other words, when the TV services are not being separately charged and (ii)
where the client does pays separately for use of the TV services and the establishments earn
revenues from provision of such TV services. Hence, depending upon the type of the usage
of TV services, there is a need to differentiate and define ‘ordinary subscriber’ and a
‘commercial subscriber’ separately.
Basis or criterion for the classification of subscribers of TV services
28. The issue raised in the consultation paper was that in case a classification of
subscribers of TV services is necessary, then what should be the basis or criterion
for such a classification. Consultation paper flagged various possibilities of such
classification based on place of viewing TV signal, type of usage criteria for TV
signals, method of provisioning of TV signals, type of content of TV signal,
perceived value of TV services and also sought suggestions from the stakeholders
for any other criteria which they may like to suggest. The views/opinions of the
stakeholders who responded during the consultation process are summarized below.
Stakeholder comments
29. Most of the broadcasters and their association have opined that it is essential to
differentiate between ordinary and commercial subscribers for provision of TV signals.
Further, differentiation based on ‘type of usage’ and the ‘place of usage’ has been
suggested by them as the most appropriate criteria. Broadcasters have also suggested
that the commercial establishments should further be classified into the following:–
a) Hotel rooms.
b) All commercial outlets that include restaurants, shops, factories and offices
with exemption however being granted to the following:-
(i) Those with less than twenty employees.
(ii)Premises of area less than 2500 sq. ft. within city limits and 5000 sq.
ft. outside city limits.
* with a caveat that exemptions under (i) and (ii) above must not apply in
metropolitan cities, state capitals and class A/B cities.
(iii)Micro-enterprises under the MSME Act 2006.
Page 12 of 15
c) Public viewing areas including airport lounges, banquet and party halls, hotel
lobbies, theatres and auditoriums etc.
30. One of the broadcasters has suggested that the classification of TV subscribers can also
be done on the basis of the fact that whether the service availed by the establishment is
“incidental” or “essential” to the core area of its business. In the event that they choose
to use an incidental service such as TV to enhance their businesses in any way, this will
be for commercial gains. Service providers (broadcasters) of such services should have
the right to charge separately as it is used for a clear commercial gain.
31. DPOs and their associations have stated that there is no need to differentiate between
ordinary household subscriber and commercial establishments such as Hotels,
Restaurants, Airports, Malls, Shopping complexes, Hospitals, Doctors’ Clinics, where one
can have access to viewing of TV channels without being charged separately. They also
mentioned that since satellite footprint is available across India, hence, possibility of shifting
DTH receiver from one location to other location by subscribers can not be ruled out. Hence,
any differentiation between commercial subscribers and ordinary household subscriber
based on location of uses of TV signals is difficult to be implemented on ground.
32. Some of them have further suggested that the only exception when such a
differentiation must actually be made is when a commercial subscriber charges his
customers separately for the TV service provided to his clients thereby exploiting the
TV service for commercial gains.
33. Almost all hotels and their associations have submitted that there is no differentiation
required between the ordinary and commercial subscribers except in case of those
subscribers who commercially exploit the TV signals by charging separate fee/entry fee.
34. An individual has opined that there is no need for any differentiation between ordinary and
commercial subscribers. An industry association has however suggested that small and
medium shop owners should not be considered as commercial subscribers while all
organizations providing 1-5 star services should be treated as commercial subscribers.
Page 13 of 15
Analysis
35. Majority of Comments/ suggestions of various stakeholders indicate that there is no need for
classification of subscribers while suggesting that the only exception that needs to be made
is when clients are charged separately for the provision of TV services. Broadcasters are of
the view that ‘type of usage’ of the TV services as well as the ‘place of usage’ of the TV
services should be the criteria for classification of subscribers. The Authority, having come
to the conclusion that while there is a need to define and differentiate subscribers of TV
services into ordinary and commercial subscriber categories, is of the opinion that the
classification must be simple, unambiguous, and practically implementable across the entire
value chain whilst interest of every stakeholder is adequately protected.
36. The Authority has noted that in 2006, the commercial subscribers were defined by relying
on “place of usage” of TV signal especially in Hotels irrespective of the type of usage,
which has been contested time and again by the Hotel Industry. Broadcasters have now
asked that commercial subscribers to be defined based on both “place of usage” and “type of
usage”. Other stakeholders are persistently demanding that no distinction should be made
either based on place of usage or on type of usage or any other criteria. They are of the view
that Authority must consider only those entities for defining commercial subscribers who
explicitly exploit the TV signals for commercial gains.
37. In view of above, the Authority has carefully considered various options for classification
suggested by the stakeholders. It is noted that in most of the cases, the TV signal in
commercial establishments is used only for the infotainment purpose without separately
charging for viewing of TV signals. Pay TV channel viewing has become ubiquitous and in
most of the places where such commercial establishment exists, almost every household has
access to pay TV programs. Therefore, provision of TV services in such establishment does
not make any value proposition for the clients visiting such establishment. Further, viewing
of TV programs in such establishments is not novelty and most of the clients would have
already subscribed for such content. It may not be out of place to mention here that from
such viewing of TV channels Broadcasters also get advantage by way of more
advertisements due to increased viewership. Further, Ministry of Tourism has mandated
provision of TV services in rooms for 3 star hotels and above and in lobby for other hotels in
Dec 2014. As such, considering the scenario where content is monopolistic in nature and
hotels are mandated to provide such content, the regulatory framework must balance the
interest of stakeholders in the value chain.
38. The Authority has noted that there may be instances where TV signals are commercially
Page 14 of 15
exploited by separately charging for exhibiting the TV programs. Therefore the
distinguishing criteria can be the ‘type of usage of TV signals’ i.e., where the signals are
commercially exploited by charging separately for its exhibition for earning revenues out of
it.
39. Moreover, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in its judgment dated 24.11.2006 in appeal (Civil)
2061 of 2006 Hotel and Restaurants Association and Anr Vs Star India Pvt Ltd. and Ors has,
amongst others, observed as under:
“….The owners of the hotels take TV signals for their customers/ guests. While doing so,
they inter alia provide services to their customers. An owner of a hotel provides various
amenities to its customers such as beds, meals, fans, television, etc. Making a provision for
extending such facilities or amenities to the boarders would not constitute a sale by an owner
to a guest. The owners of the hotels take TV signals from the broadcasters in the same
manner as they take supply of electrical energy from the licensees. A guest may use an
electrical appliance. The same would not constitute the sale of electricity by the hotel to him.
For the said purpose, the 'consumer' and 'subscriber' would continue to be the hotel and its
management. Similarly, if a television set is provided in all the rooms, as part of the services
rendered by the management by way of an amenity, wherefor the guests are not charged
separately, the same would not convert the guests staying in a hotel into consumers or
subscribers…..”
40. The said judgment further quotes another judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court (in The
State of Punjab v. M/s. Associated Hotels of India Ltd. [(1972) 1 SCC 472)]) on similar
issue, which is reproduced as under:
“…. When a traveller, by plane or by steam-ship, purchases his passage-ticket, the
transaction is one for his passage from one place to another. If, in the course of carrying out
that transaction, the traveller is supplied with drinks or meals or cigarettes, no one would
think that the transaction involves separate sales each time any of those things is supplied.
The transaction is essentially one of carrying the passenger to his destination and if in
performance of the contract of carriage something is supplied to him, such supply is only
incidental to that services, not changing either the pattern or the nature of the contract.
Similarly, when clothes are given for washing to a laundry, there is a transaction which
essentially involves work or service, and if the laundryman stitches a button to a garment
which has fallen off, there is no sale of the button or the thread. A number of such cases
involving incidental uses of materials can be cited, none of which can be said to involve a
sale as part of the main transaction. …."
Page 15 of 15
41. From the observations of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, cited above, it is clear that provision
of TV services in a commercial establishment is only incidental to the service that
the commercial establishment is providing to its clients. Thus, it has also been settled by the
said judgment that any service rendered to a guest by way of an amenity, wherefore the
guests are not charged separately, the same would not constitute as sale of the said service to
the guest.
42. In view of above deliberations, the Authority is of the view that the basic criteria for
classification of subscribers should be whether the TV services, irrespective of its place of
provisioning, are being commercially exploited, by the subscriber to earn revenues by
charging separately for such services. In other words, the criteria for classification of
subscribers should be the ‘type of usage’ of TV signals by the subscriber and not the
subscriber’s ‘place of usage of signals’. In view of the discussions in paragraphs above,
the Authority has decided that the subscribers who charge their clients separately to use the
TV services, amounting to commercial exploitation of TV services to earn revenues out of it
from their clients, shall be classified as ‘commercial subscribers’. And all other subscribers
shall be classified as ‘ordinary subscribers’. Accordingly, ‘ordinary subscriber’ and
‘commercial subscriber’ have been defined in this amendment to the interconnection
regulations.
*****
1
TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE GAZETTE OF INDIA, EXTRAORDINARY,
PART III, SECTION 4
TELECOM REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF INDIA
NOTIFICATION
New Delhi the 7
th
January, 2016
THE TELECOMMUNICATION (BROADCASTING AND CABLE SERVICES)
INTERCONNECTION (DIGITAL ADDRESSABLE CABLE TELEVISION SYSTEMS) (SIXTH
AMENDMENT) REGULATIONS, 2016
(No. 1 of 2016)
No. 3-106/2015-B&CS -------In exercise of the powers conferred by section 36, read with sub-
clauses (ii), (iii), (iv) and (v) of clause (b) of sub-section (1) of section 11, of the Telecom
Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997 (24 of 1997), read with notification of the Government of
India, in the Ministry of Communication and Information Technology (Department of
Telecommunication) No.39,-----
(a) issued, in exercise of the powers conferred upon the Central Government by proviso to clause
(k) of sub-section (1) of section 2 and clause (d) of sub-section (1) of section 11 of the said Act,
and
(b) published under notification No. 39 (S.O. 44 (E) and 45 (E)) dated the 9th January, 2004 in the
Gazette of India, Extraordinary, Part II- Section 3- Sub-section (ii), ----
the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India hereby makes the following regulations to further
amend the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital
Addressable Cable Television Systems) Regulations, 2012 (9 of 2012), namely:-
2
1. (1) These regulations may be called the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable
Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems)(Sixth Amendment)
Regulations, 2016 (1 of 2016).
(2) They shall come into force from the 1
st
day of April 2016.
2. In regulation 5 of the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection
(Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) Regulations, 2012 (9 of 2012), (hereinafter
referred to as the principal regulations),---
(a) after sub-regulation (6), the following explanation shall be inserted,----
Explanation: It shall be mandatory for the broadcaster to enter into written interconnection
agreement with the multi system operator for retransmission of its pay channels including
those pay channels for which no subscription fee is to be paid by the multi system operator to
the broadcaster.
(b) for sub-regulation (16), the following sub-regulation shall be substituted, namely:----
“ (16) Every service provider shall enter into a new interconnection agreement before the
expiry of the existing interconnection agreement:
Provided that the broadcaster or the multi system operator, as the case may be, shall, at
least sixty days prior to the date of expiry of the existing interconnection agreement, give
notice to the multi system operator or the linked local cable operator, as the case may be, to
enter into new agreement:
Provided further that in case, the service providers fail to enter into new interconnection
agreement before the expiry of the existing interconnection agreement, the broadcaster or
the multi system operator, as the case may be, shall not make available the signals of TV
channels to the multi system operator or the local cable operator, as the case may be, on
expiry of the existing interconnection agreement:
Provided also that the multi system operator shall, fifteen days prior to the date of expiry of
its existing interconnection agreement, inform the consumer.----
3
(a) the date of expiry of its existing interconnection agreement; and
(b) disconnection of signals of TV channels from the said date in the event of its
failure to enter into new interconnection agreement.”
(Sudhir Gupta)
Secretary, TRAI
Note.1-----The principal regulations were published in the Gazette of India, Extraordinary,
Part III, Section 4, vide its notification No. 3- 24/2012- B&CS dated the 30th April 2012 and
subsequently amended vide notifications No. 3- 24/2012- B&CS dated the 14th May 2012,
No. 3-24/2012-B&CS dated the 20th September 2013, No. 3-24/2012- B&CS dated the 10th
February, 2014 and No. 6-33/2014-B&CS dated the 18th July, 2014 and 6-29/2015-B&CS
dated: 14
th
September 2015.
Note.2-----The Explanatory Memorandum explains the objects and reasons of the
Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable
Cable Television Systems) (Sixth Amendment) Regulations, 2016 ( 1 of 2016).
4
Explanatory Memorandum
Background
1. The responsibility of regulating broadcasting and cable TV services was entrusted to the
Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (hereinafter referred to as the TRAI) in 2004 by the
central government. Since then, TRAI has taken a number of initiatives for regulating the
sector in exercise of both its recommendatory and regulatory powers vested with it by the
TRAI Act, 1997. TRAI has been issuing Regulations, Tariff Orders, Directions and Orders
from time to time for orderly growth of broadcasting sector.
2. The operation of cable TV networks is governed by the Cable Television Networks
(Regulation) Act 1995, as amended from time to time (CTV Act). The Government of
India made an amendment, to the CTV Act and Rules made there under, to pave a way for
implementation of Digital Addressable Cable TV Systems (DAS). TRAI has notified a
comprehensive regulatory framework for DAS encompassing inter-alia interconnection
regulations, QoS regulations, tariff orders and consumer complaint redressal regulations.
3. The Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital
Addressable Cable Television Systems) Regulations, 2012 ( 9 of 2012) dated 30
th
April,
2012 provides a framework for interconnection between Broadcasters & MSOs and MSOs
& LCOs. Based on this framework, the service providers are required to enter into a written
agreement before providing signals of TV channels for re-transmission to consumers.
4. The TRAI Act, 1997, mandates the Authority to maintain the register of interconnect
agreements between service providers. In pursuance of the same, the Authority had notified
“The Register of Interconnect Agreements (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Regulation
2004” which inter-alia, mandates annual filing of details of interconnection agreements by
service providers for retransmission of signals of TV channels.
5. While examining the details of interconnections submitted by the Broadcasters of pay
channel(s) and Multi System Operators (MSOs), it has come to the notice of the Authority
that in many cases the signals of TV channels are being provided by the broadcasters to
MSOs and MSOs to Local Cable Operators (LCOs) even in the absence of valid
interconnection agreement in writing. It has also been observed that in several cases,
agreements between service providers are delayed on the pretext of continued mutual
negotiations, but, they continue the retransmission of TV signals beyond the date of expiry
which often results into disputes and sometimes sudden disconnection that affects quality
of service to consumers. In the context of various petitions filed by broadcasters and
5
MSOs, the Hon’ble TDSAT has also made certain observations for strengthening the
existing regulatory provisions.
6. Therefore, strong need is felt to make it clear in the regulations that re-transmission of TV
signals should not take place between service providers without a valid written
interconnection agreement and new agreement is entered between them well before the
expiry of the existing interconnection agreement.
7. Accordingly, Draft Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection
(Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems)(Sixth Amendment) Regulations, 2015 was
released on 3
nd
November, 2015 seeking comments and counter comments from all
stakeholders. Subsequently, the comments and counter comments received in TRAI were
uploaded on TRAI website. Further, an Open House Discussion (OHD) was held on 11
th
December, 2015. In the OHD, on request of few stakeholders, Authority granted further
time for providing written inputs till 16
th
December, 2015. After considering all inputs of
stakeholders, the Authority has finalized the amendment.
Analysis of stakeholders’ comments:
8. Most of the stakeholders have agreed to the proposed amendment. Some broadcasters have
suggested that publication of notices in newspaper mandated under the regulation 6 in case
of disconnection of TV signal, may be reviewed. Their contention was that the publications
of such notices not only involves expenditure but are less noticed by the general public.
They have suggested that purpose of such notices can also be achieved by running scroll on
the channels which consumers consciously notice while viewing a particular
channel/program. On the contrary, in the OHD, one of the MSOs pointed out that such
scrolls on number of channels will give inconvenience to consumer, especially when the
notice of disconnection is an issue between two business entities i.e broadcaster and MSO.
They contended that viewing experience of customer will be impacted by such scrolls. The
Authority has noted the suggestions of the stakeholders and felt that this issue need detail
deliberation among stakeholders particularly the enforcement and verification mechanism
of informing through such scrolls. However, this requirement may be taken up while
reviewing interconnection regulations as a whole, in future, when such need arise.
9. One stakeholder suggested that instead of incorporating an explanation, the definition of
pay channel may be reviewed so as to consider pay channels as a channel even if a nil
subscription fee is charged by the Broadcaster. In this regard it is mentioned that the
definition of pay channel given in the regulation is in line with the Cable TV rules.
Moreover, the words ‘to be paid’ already cover the scenario when nil subscription amount
6
is paid. As such the purpose of incorporating the explanation is to inform the stakeholders
in simple words so that the provision of the sub-regulation (6) is understood in its true
spirit.
10. Few stakeholders expressed their concern stating that timeline of sixty days for starting of
negotiation will bring practical difficulties and inconvenience at the ground level in view of
large number of service providers across the country. This concern has been addressed by
adding the word “at least” before 60 days in the amendment thereby they can start
negotiations any time prior to 60 days. Moreover, several broadcasters and MSOs do their
mutual agreements for all its operating areas or pan-India basis simultaneously.
11. Few stakeholders have suggested that similar provision may be made in the regulations for
Non-DAS areas and also in other platforms such as DTH. In this context it is mentioned
that the delay in renewal of interconnection agreements is predominantly observed between
broadcasters and MSOs in areas where Digital Addressable Cable System has been
implemented. However, stakeholders request may be taken up while reviewing
interconnection regulations as a whole, in future, when such need arise.
12. In view of the above, the present amendment has incorporated mainly the following:
a. For more clarity and to understand the spirit of the sub-regulation (6) of regulation-
5 it is explained that it shall be mandatory for the broadcaster of pay channel to
enter into written interconnection agreement with the multi system operator for
retransmission of its pay channels including those pay channels for which no
subscription fee is to be paid by the multi system operator to the broadcaster as per
their mutual agreement. It will ensure that the broadcaster signs an interconnection
agreement for TV channels, declared as pay TV channels by the broadcaster to the
Authority under the requirement specified in the relevant tariff order, are distributed
by the broadcaster to the MSOs only after signing of written interconnection
agreement even if nil amount is paid by the MSO to the broadcaster of pay channel.
b. The sub-regulation (16) of regulation 5 has been amended so that :
i. Every service provider should enter into new written interconnection
agreement before expiry of existing interconnection agreement;
ii. To have sufficient time to reach mutual agreement between service
providers, for Business to Business relations, the broadcaster of pay channel
to MSO and MSO to LCO to give notice at least sixty days prior to the
expiry of existing interconnection agreement. Such notice will initiate
mutual discussion and also act as notice for disconnection to the other party,
in case of failure to enter into new agreement.
7
iii. In case service providers are not able to enter into new agreement fifteen
days before expiry of existing interconnection agreement, the MSO, in the
interest of consumer, shall inform the consumer the date of expiry of its
existing interconnection agreement and disconnection of signals of TV
channels in the event of its failure to enter into new interconnection
agreement from the said date. This will enable the consumer to take
informed decision in respect of his/her choice.
13. In order to ensure interruption free services to the end consumer and continuity of business
as usual among the service providers, it is expected that new written interconnection
agreement should be signed in all cases before 15 days from the date of expiry of the
existing interconnection agreements. Though the regulation does not bar to sign new
interconnection agreement in the last 15 days before the date of expiry of existing
interconnection agreement, it is expected that new agreements would be signed much
before that and it would be rarest where the agreements between service providers could
not be signed before 15 days of expiry of existing interconnection agreement.
14. It is expected that, with this amendment, the service providers will reach at mutual
agreement in time to minimize uncertainties in the value chain and inconvenience to
consumer.
Page 1 of 85
TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE GAZETTE OF INDIA, EXTRAORDINARY,
PART III, SECTION 4
TELECOM REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF INDIA
NOTIFICATION
New Delhi the 15
th
March, 2016
THE TELECOMMUNICATION (BROADCASTING AND CABLE SERVICES)
INTERCONNECTION (DIGITAL ADDRESSABLE CABLE TELEVISION SYSTEMS)
(SEVENTH AMENDMENT) REGULATIONS, 2016 (No. 3 of 2016)
No. 26-01/2015-B&CS -------In exercise of the powers conferred by section 36, read with sub
clauses (ii), (iii), (iv) and (v) of clause (b) of sub-section (1) of section 11, of the Telecom
Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997 (24 of 1997), read with notification of the
Government of India, in the Ministry of Communication and Information Technology
(Department of Telecommunication) No.39,-----
(a) issued, in exercise of the powers conferred upon the Central Government by proviso to
clause (k) of sub-section (1) of section 2 and clause (d) of sub-section (1) of section 11 of the
said Act, and
(b) published under notification No. 39 (S.O. 44 (E) and 45 (E)) dated the 9th January, 2004
in the Gazette of India, Extraordinary, Part II- Section 3- Sub-section (ii), ----
the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India hereby makes the following regulations to further
amend the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital
Addressable Cable Television Systems) Regulations, 2012 (9 of 2012), namely:-
1. (1) These regulations may be called the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable
Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) (Seventh
Amendment) Regulations, 2016 (3 of 2016).
(2) They shall come into force from the date of their publication in the Official Gazette.
2. For sub-regulation 14 of regulation 3 of the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable
Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) Regulations, 2012
Page 2 of 85
(9 of 2012), (hereinafter referred to as the principal regulations), the following sub-regulation
shall be substituted, namely:---
“(14) Every multi system operator or its authorized agent shall provide the signals of TV
channels to a local cable operator, in accordance with the regulation 5, within sixty days from
the date of receipt of the written request and in case the request for providing signals of TV
channels is not agreed to, the reasons for such refusal to provide signals shall be conveyed to
the local cable operator making a request within sixty days from the date of request.”
3. The sub-regulations 15 and 16 of regulation 3 of the principal regulations shall be deleted.
4. For sub-regulation 13 of regulation 5 of the principal regulations, the following sub-
regulation shall be substituted, namely:----
“(13) The multi system operator shall enter into a written interconnection agreement with the
local cable operator for providing signals of TV channels to the local cable operator, on lines
of the model interconnection agreement as set out in the Schedule IV of these regulations, by
mutually agreeing on the clauses 10, 11 and 12 of the said agreement:
Provided that the multi system operator and the local cable operator, without altering or
deleting any clause of model interconnection agreement, may add, through mutual agreement,
clauses to the model interconnection agreement, provided that no such addition shall have the
effect of diluting any of the clauses as laid down in the model interconnection agreement:
Provided further that in case the multi system operator and the local cable operator fail to
enter into interconnection agreement as provided above in this sub-regulation, the multi
system operator and the local cable operator shall enter into standard interconnection
agreement as specified in Schedule-V of these regulations.
Explanation: for removal of doubts it is clarified that in the event of any conflict between the
terms and conditions of the prescribed model interconnection agreement and new terms and
conditions added through mutual agreement by the parties, the terms and conditions of the
prescribed model interconnection agreement shall prevail.”
5. After sub-regulation 13 of regulation 5 of the principal regulations, the following sub-
regulations shall be inserted, namely:----
Page 3 of 85
“(13A) Every multi-system operator shall, within thirty days from the date of commencement
of the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital
Addressable Cable Television Systems) (Seventh Amendment) Regulations, 2016, give a
written option to all linked local cable operators to modify their existing agreements in
accordance with the model interconnection agreement or standard interconnection agreement,
as the case may be, and it shall be open to the linked local cable operator to modify their
existing agreement within thirty days from the date of receipt of such option or continue with
the existing agreement till its expiry and enter into the model interconnection agreement or
standard interconnection agreement, as the case may be, thereafter.
(13B) Every multi-system operator shall, within a period of thirty days from the date of
receipt of request from the local cable operator to provide the signals of TV channels, enter
into an interconnection agreement in accordance with the terms and conditions of the model
interconnection agreement or standard interconnection agreement, as the case may be.”
6. In the principal regulations, after Schedule III, the following Schedules shall be inserted,
namely:-
“Schedule IV
(Refer sub-regulation 13 of the regulation 5)
MODEL INTERCONNECTION AGREEMENT BETWEEN MULTI SYSTEM
OPERATOR AND LOCAL CABLE OPERATOR FOR PROVISIONING OF CABLE
TV SERVICES THROUGH DIGITAL ADDRESSABLE SYSTEMS (DAS).
[1. Each page of this Agreement shall be signed by the authorised signatory of Multi System Operator and
Local Cable Operator;
2. The numbers allotted to the clauses in this format shall not be altered and additions (if any) may either be
carried out at the end of relevant clause or after the last clause of this format].
This Technical and Commercial Interconnection Agreement along with its Schedules and
Annexures is executed on this _____ day of ______ 201_ by and between:
_______________________________________________, having its office at
___________________________________________________________________________
______, through its Authorised Signatory, hereinafter referred to as the “MSO” which
expression shall unless repugnant to the context or meaning thereof, be deemed to include its
successors, assignees, legal heirs and executors of the ONE PART.
Page 4 of 85
MSO’s Status: Individual/Firm/Company/Association of Persons/Body of Individuals
(strike out whichever is not applicable or modify suitably in case of Association of Persons or
Body of Individuals)
AND
_____________________________________________, having its office at
___________________________________________________________________________
________________________, through its Authorised Signatory, hereinafter referred to as the
“LCO” which expression shall unless repugnant to the context or meaning thereof, be
deemed to include its successors, assignees, legal heirs and executors, of the OTHER PART
LCO’s Status: Individual/Firm/Company/Association of Persons/Body of Individuals
(strike out whichever is not applicable or modify suitably in case of Association of Persons or
Body of Individuals)
The MSO and the LCO are hereinafter individually referred to as ‘Party’ and collectively
referred to as “Parties”.
WHEREAS,
A. The MSO is a cable operator, who has been granted registration No. ____________ dated
_______________ under the Cable Television Networks Rules, 1994, by the Ministry of
Information and Broadcasting, for providing cable TV services through digital addressable
systems in the areas of ____________________________________notified by the Central
Government under Section 4A of the Cable Television Networks (Regulation) Act, 1995.
B. The LCO is a cable operator, who has been granted registration under the Cable Television
Networks Rules, 1994, having postal registration No. _____________________ dated
__________, in the head post office ____________________, [Name of the head post office]
for providing Cable TV Services in ___________________________ [Mention the area].
C. The LCO has requested the MSO vide its letter No.______________
dated________________for making available signals of TV channels and the MSO has
agreed vide its letter No.______________ dated____________to provide signals of TV
channels to such LCO.
Page 5 of 85
D. TERRITORY: Territory, in the context of this Agreement is __________________
[mention the name of area(s)/ city(ies)/ district(s)/ state(s) for which this agreement is being
signed.]
E. The Parties have mutually agreed to execute this Agreement - on principal to principal and
non-exclusive basis - between them to govern the roles, responsibilities, rights, obligations,
technical and commercial arrangement in regard to the distribution of TV channels in the
Territory.
F. The Parties also mutually agree that each and every transaction including transaction of
any properties/ assets between the Parties shall be carried out in writing or in any other
verifiable means.
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing and the mutual covenants contained
herein, the Parties agree as follows: -
1. DEFINITIONS
The words and expressions used in this Agreement shall have meanings as assigned to them
in the Schedule to this Agreement. All other words and expressions used in this Agreement,
but not defined, and defined in the Act and rules and regulations made there under or the
Cable Television Networks (Regulation) Act, 1995 (7 of 1995) shall have the meanings
respectively assigned to them in those Acts or the rules or regulations, as the case may be.
2. TERM OF THE AGREEMENT
2.1 The Agreement shall commence on_________[dd/mm/yyyy] and remain in force
till__________ [dd/mm/yyyy] or the date of expiry of registration of the MSO or the LCO, as
the case may be, whichever is earlier, unless terminated by either Party as per the terms and
conditions of this Agreement.
2.2 The duration of the Agreement may be extended on terms and conditions to be
mutually agreed between the Parties and recorded in writing provided that the extended term
Page 6 of 85
does not go beyond the last date of validity of registration of the MSO or the LCO, whichever
is earlier.
3. TERMINATION OF THE AGREEMENT
3.1 Either Party has a right to terminate the Agreement by serving an advance notice of
21 days in writing to the other Party in the event of:-
(i) material breach of the Agreement by the other Party which has not been cured
within 15 days of being required in writing to do so; or
(ii) the bankruptcy, insolvency or appointment of receiver over the assets of other
Party; or
(iii) the other Party indulging in, or allowing or inducing any person to indulge in
piracy or carrying programming service provided on the channel which is in
violation of the Programme & Advertising Codes prescribed in the Cable
Television Network Rules, 1994, as amended from time to time.
3.2 The LCO has a right to terminate the Agreement in the event of the MSO
discontinuing the business of retransmission of signals of TV channels in the Territory.
3.3 The MSO has a right to terminate the agreement in the event of the LCO
discontinuing its cable TV business in the Territory.
3.4 If the MSO decides to discontinue the business of retransmission of signals of TV
channels in the Territory for any reason, it shall give a notice in writing, specifying the
reasons for such decision, to the LCO at least 90 days prior to such discontinuation.
3.5 If the LCO decides to discontinue its business of providing signals of TV channels to
the subscriber in the territory, it shall give a notice in writing, specifying the reasons for such
decision, to the MSO at least 90 days prior to such discontinuation.
4. EFFECT OF TERMINATION AND EXPIRY
4.1 In the event of termination or expiry of the term of the Agreement, as the case may be,
at the instance of either Party, each Party shall pay all amounts due and payable up to the date
of termination or expiry to the other Party.
Page 7 of 85
4.2 The LCO shall, within 15 days of the termination or expiry of the term of this
Agreement, as the case may be, in terms of the provisions mentioned herein, hand over to the
MSO all properties and assets belonging to the MSO, which are in the custody of the LCO.
The LCO shall also be liable to make good all the losses or damages, if any, caused to such
properties and assets belonging to the MSO, in custody of the LCO, within 30 days from the
receipt of notice to this effect from the MSO and in the event of inability of LCO to repair
such properties/assets, the LCO shall pay to the MSO the depreciated value of such
properties/ assets.
4.3 The MSO shall, within 15 days of the termination or expiry of the term of this
Agreement, as the case may be, in terms of the provisions mentioned herein, hand over to the
LCO all properties and assets belonging to the LCO, which are in the custody of the MSO.
The MSO shall also be liable to make good all the losses or damages, if any, caused to such
properties and assets belonging to the LCO, in custody of the MSO, within 30 days from the
receipt of notice to this effect from the LCO and in the event of inability of MSO to repair
such properties/assets, the MSO shall pay to the LCO the depreciated value of such
properties/ assets.
Explanation:- The clause 4.2 and 4.3 above shall not have any application in respect of
Hardware or any other equipment belonging to the MSO or the LCO, as the case may be,
which are installed at the premises of the subscribers.
4.4 If the LCO or the MSO, as the case may be, fails to hand over the assets or make good
losses or damages caused to such properties and assets within the above stipulated period, the
defaulting Party shall be liable to make payment for the depreciated value of the same
together with simple interest calculated at the rate 2% over and above the base rate of interest
of the State Bank of India.
5. PROVISIONING OF SERVICES
5.1 The MSO shall make available signals of TV channels to the LCO, on non-exclusive
basis, in order to re-transmit the same to the subscribers in the Territory, in terms of this
agreement and as per prevailing norms, policies, the applicable laws and rules, regulations,
directions and orders of the concerned authorities.
Page 8 of 85
5.2 The LCO shall carry signals of TV channels received from the MSO, on non-
exclusive basis, for distribution to the subscribers in the Territory.
5.3 The Parties shall compulsorily transmit, re-transmit or otherwise carry any channel,
content or programme only in encrypted mode through a digital addressable system strictly in
terms of and in accordance with the applicable laws and regulations.
5.4 The roles and responsibilities of the Parties to the Agreement for provisioning of
services are contained in clause 10 of this Agreement.
5.5 In consideration of the roles and responsibilities mentioned in clause 10 of the
Agreement, the revenue settlement between the LCO and the MSO have been mentioned in
the clause 12 of the Agreement.
6. RIGHTS OF THE MSO
6.1 The MSO shall continue to have a right of ownership of its network used to deliver
the cable TV services under this agreement and it may expand/ upgrade/ change/ replace/ re-
design any part or entire network subject to the condition that any such activity does not
interrupt or degrade the Quality of Service provided to the subscribers.
6.2 The MSO shall sign the interconnection agreement with broadcasters for re-
transmission of signals of TV Channels as per prevailing norms, policies, the applicable laws
and rules, regulations, directions and orders of the concerned authorities.
6.3 The MSO shall have the right to finalise the maximum retail price of each channel, as
payable by the subscriber in compliance with the provisions of applicable laws and rules,
regulations and tariff orders.
6.4 The MSO shall have the right to package the channels/ services offered on the
network, as per its business plan and as per prevailing norms, policies, the applicable laws
and rules, regulations and tariff orders.
Page 9 of 85
6.5 The MSO shall have the right to finalise the rate of Basic Service Tier (BST) in
compliance with the provisions of the applicable tariff orders and regulations notified by the
Authority from time to time.
6.6 The MSO shall have the right to finalise the rates of bouquets of channels, if offered
by the MSO, in compliance with the provisions of the applicable tariff orders and regulations
notified by the Authority.
6.7 The MSO shall have the right to get all requisite information from the LCO for the
purpose of fulfilling its responsibilities under the Agreement, and the applicable orders and
regulations.
7. RIGHTS OF THE LCO
7.1 The LCO shall continue to have its right of ownership of its network used to deliver
the cable TV services under this agreement and it can expand/ upgrade/ change/ replace/ re-
design any part or entire network subject to the condition that any such activity does not
interrupt or degrade the Quality of Service offered to the subscriber on its network.
7.2 The LCO shall have right to get all the requisite information from the MSO for the
purpose of fulfilling its responsibilities under the Agreement, and the applicable orders and
regulations.
8. OBLIGATIONS OF THE MSO
8.1 MSO shall set up and operationalise the Head-end, Conditional Access System (CAS)
and Subscriber Management System (SMS) for ensuring efficient and error-free services to
the subscribers by recording and providing individualized preferences for channels, billing
cycles or refunds.
8.2 The MSO shall make available to the LCO, the necessary and sufficient information
relating to the details of channels, bouquets of channels, and services offered to the
subscribers including their prices.
Page 10 of 85
8.3 The MSO shall provide web based grievance redressal mechanism for addressing the
complaints of LCOs in relation to the provision of services, roles and responsibilities,
revenue settlements, quality of services etc.
8.4 The MSO shall not issue pre-activated STBs and the STBs shall be activated only
after the details of the Customer Application Form (CAF) have been entered into the SMS.
8.5 The MSO shall generate bills for subscribers on regular basis, for charges due and
payable for each month or as per the billing cycle applicable for that subscriber, within 3 days
from the end of the billing cycle.
8.6 The MSO shall provide access to the relevant part of the SMS under its control to the
LCO for the purpose of fulfilling responsibilities by the Parties under the Agreement, and the
applicable orders and regulations.
8.7 The MSO shall not indulge in any piracy or other activities, which has the effect of, or
which shall result into, infringement and violation of trade mark and copyrights of the LCO
or person associated with such transmission.
8.8 The MSO shall comply with all the applicable statutes or laws for the time being in
force, or any rules, codes, regulations, notifications, circulars, guidelines, orders, directions
etc. issued, published or circulated under any law for the time being in force.
8.9 The MSO shall not do any act or thing as a result of which, any right or interest of the
LCO in respect of cable TV signals under this Agreement or any property of the LCO may be
infringed or prejudiced.
8.10 The MSO shall be responsible for encryption of the complete signal, up to the STB
installed at the premises of the subscriber.
8.11 The MSO shall not disconnect the signals of TV Channels, without giving three
weeks’ advance notice to the LCO clearly specifying the reasons for the proposed
disconnection as envisaged in the Interconnection Regulation.
Page 11 of 85
8.12. The MSO shall make available online payment gateway, prepaid system for
subscribers and facility for electronic acknowledgment to the subscriber on the receipt of
payment from the subscriber.
8.13 The MSO shall provide to the LCO at least 2% of the total STBs active in the network
of the LCO with an upper cap of 30 STBs as maintenance spare, which are not pre-activated,
to ensure speedy restoration of services affected due to any fault in STB. This quantity of
maintenance spare STBs shall be maintained during the term of the agreement.
8.14 The MSO shall intimate to the LCO, at least 15 days in advance, in respect of any
proposed changes in the package composition or the retail tariff being offered to the
subscriber.
8.15 The MSO shall have no right, without the prior written intimation to the LCO, to
assign or transfer any of its rights or obligations under this Agreement.
9. OBLIGATIONS OF THE LCO
9.1 The LCO shall handover a copy of CAF received from subscribers within 15 days to
the MSO;
9.2 The LCO shall be responsible for entering the details of the bill amount paid by the
individual subscriber to the LCO for the Cable TV services in the SMS.
9.3 The LCO shall not indulge in any piracy or other activities, which has the effect of, or
which shall result into, infringement and violation of trade mark and copyrights of the MSO,
or any other person associated with such retransmission.
9.4 The LCO shall have no right, without the prior written intimation to the MSO, to
assign or transfer any of its rights or obligations under this Agreement.
9.5 The LCO shall not replace the STBs of the MSO with the STBs of any other MSO
without receiving the requests from the subscribers through application forms for returning
Page 12 of 85
the STB of the existing connections and for providing new connections through Customer
Application Form. The new Set Top Box shall be activated only after entry of the details, as
provided in new Customer Application Form, into the Subscriber Management System of the
new MSO.
9.6 The LCO shall –
(i) not transmit or retransmit, interpolate or mix any signals which are not transmitted
or generated by the MSO without the prior written consent of the MSO;
(ii) not insert any commercial or advertisement or information on any signal
transmitted by the MSO. Any such tampering of signals or interpolating of signals
shall be deemed to be a violation of this Agreement and shall constitute sufficient
cause for termination of this Agreement by the MSO by giving such notice as
prescribed under the law or under this agreement;
(iii) not interfere in any way with the signals provided by the MSO and also not use
any decoding, receiving, recording equipment(s), counterfeit set top box or Smart card
and any other like equipments;
(iv) not alter or tamper the Hardware including the seal (seal to prevent opening of set
top box), misuse, replace, remove and shift the Smart card or STB without the written
consent of MSO from their respective original addresses;
(v) not use, either before or after the installation of STB, of any decoding, receiving,
recording equipment(s), counterfeit set top box(es), smart card(s) other than the
STB(s), Smart cards and any other equipments supplied/ approved by the MSO, and
to take actions as directed by the MSO against such subscribers.
(vi) intimate the MSO promptly about any alteration, tampering with the Hardware
including the seal, misuse, replacement, removal and shifting of Smart cards and
STBs, without the written consent of MSO, from their respective original addresses
and also about the use, either before or after the STBs, of any decoding, receiving,
recording equipment(s), counterfeit set top box(es) and smart card(s) other than the
STB(s), Smart card(s) and any other items of Hardware supplied by the MSO, and to
take actions as directed by the MSO against such subscribers.
Page 13 of 85
9.7 The LCO shall not provide connection to any entity for further retransmission of the
Cable TV signals.
9.8 The LCO shall not record and then retransmit Cable TV signals or otherwise to block
or add or substitute or otherwise tamper with the signal being transmitted by the MSO or with
the trunk line nor shall allow any other person to do so.
9.9 The LCO shall not do any act or thing as a result of which, any right or interest of the
MSO in respect of the Cable TV signals under this Agreement or any property of the MSO
may be infringed or prejudiced.
9.10 The LCO shall permit access to the systems under its control to the MSO, on non-
exclusive basis, for the purpose of fulfilling responsibilities by the Parties under the
Agreement, and the applicable orders and regulations.
9.11 The LCO shall not disconnect the signals of TV Channels, without giving three
weeks’ notice to the MSO clearly specifying the reasons for the proposed disconnection as
envisaged in the Interconnection Regulation.
Page 14 of 85
10. ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE MSO AND THE LCO:
Sl.
No.
Role Responsibility of the
MSO or the LCO as
mutually agreed by the
Parties - fill the cell
accordingly
Remarks
(1) (2) (3) (4)
1 Publicizing schemes for obtaining and returning the Set Top
Boxes (STBs) by the subscriber and the warranty/ repairing
policy applicable thereof.
2 Devising formats of application as specified in the schedule-I of
the QoS regulations for seeking connection, disconnection,
reconnection, transfer, and shifting of Cable TV services;
3 Publication of Manual of Practice (MoP)
4 Publication of Consumer Charter.
5 Setting up of Website containing information pertaining to
services, details of complaint centre, complaint redressal
system, complaint monitoring system, citizen charter, nodal
officer etc.
Page 15 of 85
6 a. Establishment of Complaint centre for
(i) addressing service requests of subscribers,
(ii) redressal of complaints of subscribers.
b. Establishment of web based Complaint Monitoring system.
c. Providing Toll free Consumer Care Number and its
publicity.
d. Maintenance of records of all complaints filed by the
consumer as provided in the Complaint Redressal
Regulations.
In case this responsibility is given to the
MSO then the MSO shall communicate to
the LCO the details of complaint centre for
onward communication to subscribers.
7 Specification of a system of discount or rebate to the subscriber
due to interruptions in service and creating awareness about
such scheme.
Page 16 of 85
8 a. Providing information to the subscriber about the schemes
for obtaining and returning the STB and the warranty/
repairing policy applicable thereof.
b. Providing of the application form along with the MOP to the
applicants/ subscribers and
c. Receiving of application form from applicants/ subscribers
for
(i) connection, reconnection, transfer, and shifting of
Cable TV services;
(ii) obtaining and returning of STB.
d. Returning of the duplicate copy of the application form to
the applicant/ subscriber as an acknowledgment of receipt of
application.
e. Communication of shortcomings or deficiency, in the
application form, in writing to the applicant, within 2 days of
receipt of the application.
f. Communication of technical or operational non-feasibility to
the applicant, in case it is technically or operationally non-
feasible to provide connection, reconnection, shifting of
service or supply of STB at the location, where the services
are requested by the applicant, within 2 days of receipt of the
application.
The Party who has been assigned this
responsibility shall update the information in
the Subscriber Management System (SMS)
in each case within 24 hours from the receipt
of the application.
Page 17 of 85
9 Issue of Unique Identification Number (UIN) for the applicant. The UIN shall be generated from the SMS.
In case the responsibility is assigned to the
LCO then the relevant access of the SMS
should be provided by the MSO to the LCO.
10 Installation of STB at the premises of the subscriber and
activation through SMS.
In case the responsibility is assigned to the
LCO then the MSO should provide relevant
access to SMS for STB activation.
11 Providing rebate to the subscriber for delay in installation and
activation of STB.
12 Issuance of advance notice of 15 days regarding discontinuing
or disconnection of cable service to the subscriber, indicating the
reasons for such discontinuation or disconnection.
13 Receipt of request from the subscriber for disconnection or
suspension of service and its execution through SMS.
14 Receipt of request for change in subscription package from the
subscribers and its execution through SMS.
15 Notice to the Subscribers regarding disruption of signals for
preventive maintenance.
Page 18 of 85
16 Response to the consumer complaints as per norms of the QoS
regulations.
The complaints received by the Party shall
be immediately updated in the web based
complaint monitoring system so that the
necessary corrective action can be taken by
the Parties in time and the same can be
monitored by the complainant.
17 Redressal of consumer complaints as per the norms of the QoS
regulations:-
(i) relating to ‘No signal’;
(ii) relating to STB;
(iii) relating to subscriber’s billing and receipts;
(iv) any other complaint.
The complaints redressed by the Party shall
be immediately updated in the web based
complaint monitoring system.
18 Designation of nodal officer as per the provisions of the
consumer complaint redressal regulation.
19 Communication to subscriber about redressal of the complaint
received from the Authority.
20 Printing and delivery of system generated itemized bills to
subscribers.
21 Delivery of payment receipts to subscribers.
22 Electronic acknowledgement to subscriber.
Page 19 of 85
23 Providing information relating to itemised usage showing actual
usage of service in case of prepaid bills for any period within 6
months.
The requests received by the LCO shall be
immediately updated in the SMS so that the
MSO can provide the requisite details to the
subscriber in time.
24 Payment of taxes to the Government. MSO and/ or LCO The specific details of tax payment
responsibilities need to be filled in the
adjoining cells at the time of signing of the
agreement as per the rules and regulations of
the respective Tax authorities.
Note:- The responsibilities for various roles mentioned in the column (2) above can be mutually agreed by the Parties and accordingly the cells
of the column (3) to be filled.
Page 20 of 85
11. BILLING
11.1 The billing for subscriber shall be in the name of
_________________________________. However, each Party shall ensure that the
applicable laws, rules and regulations relating to taxes are complied with.
11.2 The Party, in whose name the billing for subscribers have been agreed in the clause 11.1
above, shall receive the payment of the subscription fee paid by the subscribers. The revenue
share as per clause 12.1 of this Agreement shall be paid by this Party to the other Party on
receipt of the invoice from the other Party.
12. REVENUE SETTLEMENT BETWEEN THE LCO AND THE MSO AND
RELATED RIGHTS AND OBLIGATIONS
12.1 The revenue settlement between the LCO and the MSO shall be in the following
manner:-
(a) the charges collected from the subscription of channels of Basic Service Tier, free to
air channel and bouquet of free to air channels shall be shared in the ratio of
________:_________________ between the MSO and the LCO respectively; and
(b) the charges collected from the subscription of channels or bouquet of channels or
channels and bouquet of channels other than those specified under clause (a) shall be
shared in the ratio of ______:______ between the MSO and the LCO respectively.
Note:-
For mutual agreement cases where the roles and responsibilities of the MSO and the LCO
have been agreed as per column (3) of clause (10), this clause can be suitably amended
based on mutual agreement.
12.2*
(When the billing for subscribers is in the name of the LCO and the LCO receives the
payment of subscription fee paid by the subscribers)
The MSO shall issue monthly invoice to the LCO towards dues payable by the LCO for
revenue settlement and such invoice shall clearly specify the current payment dues and
Page 21 of 85
arrears, if any, along with the due date of payment which shall not be less than seven days.
Any demand of arrears shall be accompanied by the proof of service of invoices for the
period for which the arrears pertain. The amounts raised in the invoice shall be payable on or
before the due date as mentioned therein.
OR
12.2*
(When the billing for subscribers is in the name of the MSO and the MSO receive the
payment of subscription fee paid by the subscribers)
The MSO shall share the complete information relating to the subscribers billing and receipt
of the payments with the LCO. The LCO shall issue monthly invoice to the MSO towards
dues payable by the MSO for revenue settlement and such invoice shall clearly specify the
current payment dues and arrears, if any, along with the due date of payment which shall not
be less than seven days. Any demand of arrears shall be accompanied by the proof of service
of invoices for the period for which the arrears pertain. The amounts raised in the invoice
shall be payable on or before the due dates as mentioned therein.
(*Strike out whichever is not applicable at the time of signing individual agreement)
12.3 The Party shall update the details of the subscription amount realised from the
subscriber, in the SMS within 7 days from the due date.
13. DEFAULTS
13.1 Without prejudice to such rights and remedies that the Parties may have in law or
under the provisions of this Agreement, in the event of any delay or failure by the MSO or
the LCO, as the case may be, to make payments of dues on or before the respective due dates,
the LCO or the MSO, as the case may be, shall have the right:-
(i) to disconnect the services subject to the compliance of the applicable rules,
regulations, directions or orders of the Authority;
(ii) to terminate this Agreement, subject to compliance of the applicable laws in force;
Page 22 of 85
(iii) to charge a simple interest at the rate 2% over and above of the base rate of
interest of the State Bank of India from the date such amounts became due until those
are fully and finally paid;
13.2 In cases where any of the Parties has failed to make payment on or before due date for
three consecutive months in the past, the other Party shall have right to demand the interest
free security deposit which shall not exceed average of immediately preceding 6 months
billing amounts and the same shall be maintained for the remaining term of the agreement.
13.3 Upon disconnection of the service as mentioned in clause 13.1 above, whether
accompanied by termination of this Agreement or not, the defaulting Party shall be liable to
deposit forthwith all sums payable by it. In the case of termination, accounts shall be settled
within thirty days and for delayed payments, either Party shall be liable to pay simple interest
at the rate 2% over and above of the base rate of interest of the State Bank of India.
14. UNDERTAKINGS
14.1 Each Party shall recognize the exclusive ownership of the property owned and
installed by the other Party and shall not have or claim any right, title or interest or lien of
whatsoever nature.
14.2 Nothing contained herein shall constitute either Party as the agent or partner or the
representative of the other for any purpose and neither Party shall have the right or authority
to assume, create or incur any liability or obligation of any kind, express or implied, in the
name of or on behalf of the other Party and the relationship between the MSO and the LCO
shall remain on “Principal to Principal” basis.
14.3 It is expressly understood by the Parties that “______________” logo(s) is a
Registered Trade Mark of the MSO, and the LCO shall use the said logo only during the
currency of this Agreement for the benefit of the cable television networking business of the
MSO. Consent of the MSO is hereby given to the LCO to use the said logo, to the extent of or
in connection with the business of the MSO.
Page 23 of 85
14.4 It is expressly understood by the Parties that “______________” logo(s) is a
Registered Trade Mark of the LCO, and the MSO shall use the said logo only during the
currency of this Agreement for the benefit of the cable television networking business of the
LCO. Consent of the LCO is hereby given to the MSO to use the said logo, to the extent of or
in connection with the business of the LCO.
14.5 It is clearly understood and accepted by each Party that it shall have no right to use
any intellectual property of the other on its Cable TV service or otherwise on or after the
withdrawal by the other Party of its consent for such uses.
14.6 In case the LCO or the MSO, as the case may be, decides to transfer its interest in
respect of its business of providing Cable TV Service to any other party / person (third party),
in whole or in part, the LCO or the MSO, as the case may be, shall give prior notice to the
MSO or the LCO. One Party shall not have any objection to such transfer if the other Party
has complied with its obligations under this contract and has paid all its dues.
Provided, however, that such third party shall sign and execute a deed of adherence to the
terms & conditions of this Agreement and other undertaking/ bonds to the satisfaction of the
MSO or the LCO, as the case may be, in order to give effect to the provisions of this
Agreement.
14.7 The LCO shall maintain and continue to maintain its Postal Registration Certificate
renewed from time to time in accordance with the Cable TV Networks (Regulation) Act,
1995 and comply with the terms and conditions of the registration certificate issued by the
Postal Authority.
14.8 The MSO shall maintain and continue to maintain its Registration Certificate renewed
from time to time in accordance with the Cable TV Networks (Regulation) Act, 1995 and
comply with the terms and conditions of the registration.
14.9 Both the Parties shall comply with the Programme Codes and Advertising Codes
prescribed in the Cable Television Network Rules, 1994, as amended from time to time.
Page 24 of 85
14.10 Both the Parties shall comply with the laws for the time being in force in India, as
applicable to them.
15. PREVENTION OF PIRACY
15.1 The Parties shall not indulge or allow any person to indulge in Piracy or in reverse
engineering any technology used in the Hardware or any component thereof nor shall they
use the Hardware to be connected to any equipment for setting up a mini head-end for
retransmission of the signals generated from the same.
15.2 Signal to any subscriber shall be disconnected by the MSO or the LCO, as the case
may be, after giving due notice as required under applicable regulations, if found to be
indulged in or abetting any Piracy.
16. DISCLAIMER AND INDEMNITY
16.1 In no event, the MSO shall be liable to the LCO for any indirect, special, incidental or
consequential damage arising out of or in connection with the disruption, interruption or
discontinuance of the Service or for any inconvenience, disappointment or due to deprival of
any programme or information or for any indirect or consequential loss or damage, which is
not attributable to any act of the MSO.
16.2 In no event, the LCO shall be liable to the MSO for any indirect, special, incidental or
consequential damage arising out of or in connection with the disruption, interruption or
discontinuance of the Service or for any inconvenience, disappointment or due to deprival of
any programme or information or for any indirect or consequential loss or damage, which is
not attributable to any act of the LCO.
16.3 LCO shall indemnify the MSO for all cost, expense and damages by reason of any
claim, action or proceedings from any third party or from subscribers for any inconvenience,
loss or annoyance caused to them due to any default of the LCO or due to termination of the
Agreement or suspension of the Service due to LCO’s breach.
Page 25 of 85
16.4 MSO shall indemnify the LCO for all cost, expense and damages by reason of any
claim, action or proceedings from any third party or from subscribers for any inconvenience,
loss or annoyance caused to them due to any default of the MSO or due to termination of the
Agreement or suspension of the Service due to MSO’s breach.
17. GOVERNING LAW AND DISPUTE RESOLUTION
17.1 As mandated by the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997, the Parties
shall not institute any suit or seek injection or interim orders in any court or judicial tribunal/
authority in India with respect to any claims, dispute or differences between the Parties
arising out of this Agreement save and except before the Telecom Disputes Settlement and
Appellate Tribunal, New Delhi (“TDSAT”). The Parties agree that all disputes between the
Parties shall be resolved solely through proceedings instituted before the TDSAT.
18. FORCE MAJEURE
18.1 Failure on the part of the MSO or the LCO to perform any of its obligations, shall not
entitle either Party to raise any claim against the other or constitute a breach of this
Agreement to the extent that such failure arises from an event of Force Majeure. If through
Force Majeure the fulfilment by either Party of any obligation set forth in this Agreement is
delayed, the period of such delay shall not be taken into account in computing periods
prescribed by this Agreement. Force Majeure will include act of god, earthquake, tides,
storm, flood, lightening, explosion, fire, sabotage, quarantine, epidemic, arson, civil
disturbance, terrorist attack, war like situation, or enactment of any law or rules and
regulation made by the Authorities or revocation of registration of the Parties any
circumstances beyond the reasonable control of the Parties herein that directly or indirectly
hinders or prevents either of the Parties from commencing or proceeding with the
consummation of the transactions contemplated hereby. The Party affected by such Force
Majeure event shall promptly notify the other Party of the occurrence of such event. It is
agreed between the Parties that lack of funds shall not in any event constitute or be
considered an event of Force Majeure. If the conditions of Force Majeure to continue for a
period exceeding one month, the Parties shall meet to decide upon the future performance of
the Agreement. If the Parties are unable to agree upon a plan for future performance, then the
Page 26 of 85
Agreement shall be terminated upon notice of either Party to the other, on expiry of one
month from the date of such notice.
18.2 Any accrued payment obligation of a Party prior to the commencement of Force
Majeure shall survive the termination of this Agreement pursuant to such Force Majeure.
19. NOTICES
19.1 Any notice to be served on any Party by the other shall be deemed to have been
validly sent if sent by Registered Post Acknowledgement Due (RPAD) or speed post service
of Department of Post, Government of India or by hand delivery duly acknowledged at the
address mentioned in the beginning or at such other changed address as the Party may inform
and the date of receipt of such notice shall be the date of receipt by the other Party or 7 days
from the date of dispatch of the notice by RPAD, whichever is earlier.
20. RESTRICTION ON TRANSFER
20.1 The either Party shall not remove, sell, assign, mortgage, transfer/sublet and
encumber all or any part of the network which belongs to the other Party. If the Party
indulges in any of the above-mentioned acts, the said acts shall be illegal and void ab-initio
and the Party shall also be liable for any action under the applicable law.
21. CONFIDENTIALITY
21.1 The Parties shall keep in strict confidence, any information received by one from the
other while participating in the affairs/business of each other and shall not disclose the same
to any person not being a party to this Agreement.
21.2 The Parties shall also bind their employees, officers, advisors, associates, contractors,
agents, authorized persons and other similar persons to whom the above mentioned
information may be disclosed, to the obligations of confidentiality.
21.3 The Parties hereby agrees that the confidential information can be disclosed to the
statutory authority on demand by such authorities.
Page 27 of 85
22. MODIFICATIONS
22.1 The Agreement cannot be modified, varied or terminated except in writing. Any
variation of the Agreement, including Addendum Agreements, Annexures, Schedules or any
other document, called by whatever name, but executed in relation to this Agreement, shall
be mutually agreed to in writing and executed by or on behalf of the Parties.
23. BINDING EFFECT
23.1 This Agreement modifies all prior understanding of the Parties as to the subject matter
thereof and shall not be amended except in writing by both the Parties. Any other
understanding between the Parties (if any) with regard to any other matter or any accrued
rights and obligation of the Parties not covered under this agreement, if any, shall continue to
be in full force and effect.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF the Parties have set and subscribed their respective hands to this
Agreement on the date and year appearing hereinabove.
Signed on behalf of the MSO
(_____________________________ )
In the presence of
1. ………………..
2. ………………..
Signed on behalf of the LCO
(_____________________________ )
In the presence of
1. ………………..
2. ………………..
Note: The self attested copies of power of attorney/authorization letter, whereby the
signatories of this agreement have been authorised to sign and execute this agreement by the
Parties, shall be attached with this agreement.
Page 28 of 85
Schedule
DEFINITIONS AND INTERPRETATIONS
A. DEFINITIONS
In the Agreement unless the context requires otherwise, the following words and
expressions shall have the meanings set out herein below:
(a) “Act” means the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997 (24 of 1997), as
amended from time to time;
(b) “Addressable System” shall have the same meaning as assigned to it in the Cable
Television Networks (Regulation) Act, 1995 (7 of 1995), as amended from time to
time;
(c) “Authority” means the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India established under
subsection (1) of section 3 of the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997;
(d) “Basic Service Tier” shall have the same meaning as assigned to it in the Tariff
Order.
(e) “Bouquet” or “bouquet of channels” means an assortment of distinct channels,
offered together as a group or as a bundle;
(f) “Broadcaster”
means a person or a group of persons, or body corporate, or any
organization or body who, after having obtained, in its name, uplinking permission or
downlinking permission, as may be applicable for its channels, from the Central
Government, provides programming services;
(g) “Cable service or cable TV service” means the transmission by cables of
programmes including retransmission by cables of any broadcast television signals;
(h) “Cable television network or cable TV network” means any system consisting of a
set of closed transmission paths and associated signal generation, control and
distribution equipment, designed to provide cable service for reception by multiple
subscribers;
(i) “Channel or TV channel” means a channel, which has been registered under -----
(i) the guidelines for uplinking from India, issued vide No.1501/2/2002-
TV(I)(Pt.) dated the 2nd December, 2005; or
(ii) policy guidelines for downlinking of televisions channels, issued vide No.
Page 29 of 85
13/2/2002-BP&L/BC-IV dated the 11th November, 2005, ---------
as amended from time to time, or such other guidelines for uplinking or downlinking
of television channels, as may be issued from time to time by Government of India
(Ministry of Information and Broadcasting) and reference to the term ‘channel’ shall
be construed as a reference to “channel or TV channel”;
(j) “Complaint Centre” means a facility established by the multi-system operator or his
linked local cable operators, as the case may be, under Consumer Complaint Redressal
Regulation;
(k) “Consumer Complaint Redressal Regulation” means the Consumers Complaint
Redressal (Digital Addressable Cable TV Systems) Regulations, 2012 (13 of 2012),
dated 14
th
May 2012, as amended from time to time;
(l) “CTN Act” means the Cable Television Networks (Regulation) Act, 1995 (7 of
1995), as amended from time to time.
(m) “Encryption or encrypted” in respect of a signal of cable television network, means
the changing of such signal in a systematic way so that the signal would be
unintelligible without use of an addressable system and the expression "unencrypted"
shall be construed accordingly;
(n) “Free To Air channel” shall have the same meaning as assigned to it in the Tariff
Order.
(o) “Hardware” means a multi-system operator approved set top box to enable the
decryption of signals of Channels transmitted in encrypted form, the remote and other
associated components and accessories.
(p) “Headend” means a facility that contains satellite receivers, modulator, compression
equipment, multiplexes, and conditional access facilities, other transmission
equipments and has antennas which receive signals from Satellite and/or from local
studio for retransmission to subscribers directly or through linked LCOs;
(q) “Interconnection Regulation” means the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and
Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems)
Regulations, 2012 (9 of 2012), dated 30
th
April, 2012, as amended from time to time.
(r) “Manual of Practice (MoP)” means the Manual of Practice referred in the QoS
Regulation;
(s) “Nodal Officer” means the officer appointed or designated by the multi-system
operator or his linked local cable operator, as the case may be, under the Consumer
Complaint Redressal Regulation;
Page 30 of 85
(t) “Pay Channel” shall have the same meaning as assigned to it in the Tariff Order;
(u) “Piracy” means unauthorized reception, retransmission or redistribution of Cable TV
Signal by any person by any means and modes including but not limited to any
alteration, tampering of the seal or any component or accessory thereof or misuse,
replacement, removal and/or shifting of Hardware or any use, either before or after
the set top box, any decoding, receiving, recording equipment(s), counterfeit or
unauthorized devices or any activity, which has the effect of, or which may result
into, infringement and violation of trade mark and copyright of the MSO or the LCO
as the case may be;
(v) "Programme" means any television broadcast and includes;
(i) exhibition of films, features, dramas, advertisements and serials;
(ii) any audio or visual or audio-visual live performance or presentation and----
the expression "programming service" shall be construed accordingly;
(w) “QoS Regulation” means the Standards of Quality of Service (Digital Addressable
Cable TV Systems) Regulations, 2012 (12 of 2012), dated 14
th
May, 2012, as
amended from time to time.
(x) “Set top box or STB ” means a device, which is connected to, or is part of a
television and which allows a subscriber to receive in unencrypted and descrambled
form subscribed channels through an addressable system;
(y) “Smart Card” means the card duly approved by the multi-system operator as part of
the Hardware, which enables the subscriber to gain access to the Cable TV signals of
Channels.
(z) “Subscriber” means a person who receives broadcasting services or cable services
from a multi-system operator or cable operator at a place indicated by him to the
multi-system operator or cable operator, as the case may be, without further
transmitting it to any person and includes ordinary subscribers and commercial
subscribers, unless specifically excluded;
“For removal of doubts, it is clarified that each set top box installed at the premises
would constitute a subscriber.”
(za) “Subscriber management system or SMS” means a system or device which stores
the subscriber records and details with respect to name, address and other information
regarding the hardware being utilized by the subscriber, channels or bouquets of
channels subscribed to by the subscriber, price of such channels or bouquets of
channels as defined in the system, the activation or deactivation dates and time for
Page 31 of 85
any channel or bouquets of channels, a log of all actions performed on a subscriber’s
record, invoices raised on each subscriber and the amounts paid or discount allowed
to the subscriber for each billing period;
(zb ) “Tariff Order” means the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable) Services
(Fourth) (Addressable Systems) Tariff Order, 2010 (1 of 2010), dated 21
st
July 2010,
as amended from time to time;
(zc) “Trunk Line” means the coaxial/optic fiber cable network and other allied
equipment such as receiver nodes, amplifiers, splitters etc. owned and installed by the
multi-system operator or its associate companies for the purpose of transmitting Cable
TV Signal to various LCOs till the receiving end of various LCOs, including the
LCO, to enable them to re-transmit the Cable TV Signal to respective subscribers;
All other words and expressions used in this interconnection agreement but not
defined, and defined in the Act and rules and regulations made thereunder or the CTN
Act and the rules and regulations made thereunder, shall have the meanings
respectively assigned to them in those Acts or the rules or regulations, as the case may
be.
B. INTERPRETATION
In this Agreement, unless the context otherwise requires:
(a) Any reference to the singular in the Agreement shall include a reference to the
plural and vice versa and words importing one gender only shall include all other
genders unless the context otherwise requires;
(b) The word “person” shall include individuals, corporations, partnerships, association
of persons and any other entities;
(c) Any references to article, clauses, sub-clauses, appendices, annexure and schedules
are references to Articles, clauses, sub-clauses, appendices, annexure and schedules to
the Agreement unless the context otherwise expressly provides;
(d) References to a “month” are to a calendar month;
(e) Headings and titles are for ease of reference only and shall not affect the
interpretation of this agreement and in no way be read to give a construction not
harmonious with the interpretation of various clauses of this agreement done otherwise
independent of the title.
Page 32 of 85
(f) Any reference to law, regulation, statutory provision, order, guideline, policy, etc,
includes references to such law or regulation or provision, order, guideline, policy, etc.,
as modified, codified, amended or re-enacted from time to time.
Page 33 of 85
Schedule V
(Refer second proviso of sub-regulation (13) of regulation 5)
STANDRAD INTERCONNECTION AGREEMENT BETWEEN MULTI SYSTEM
OPERATOR AND LOCAL CABLE OPERATOR FOR PROVISIONING OF CABLE
TV SERVICES THROUGH DIGITAL ADDRESSABLE SYSTEMS (DAS).
[Each page of the Agreement shall be signed by the authorised signatory of the Multi System Operator and the
Local Cable Operator]
This Technical and Commercial Interconnection Agreement along with its Schedules and
Annexures is executed on this _____ day of ______ 201_ by and between:
_______________________________________________, having its office at
___________________________________________________________________________
______, through its Authorised Signatory, hereinafter referred to as the “MSO” which
expression shall unless repugnant to the context or meaning thereof, be deemed to include its
successors, assignees, legal heirs and executors of the ONE PART.
MSO’s Status: Individual/Firm/Company/Association of Persons/Body of Individuals
(strike out whichever is not applicable or modify suitably in case of Association of Persons or
Body of Individuals)
AND
_____________________________________________, having its office at
___________________________________________________________________________
________________________, through its Authorised Signatory, hereinafter referred to as the
“LCO” which expression shall unless repugnant to the context or meaning thereof, be
deemed to include its successors, assignees, legal heirs and executors, of the OTHER PART
LCO’s Status: Individual/Firm/Company/Association of Persons/Body of Individuals
(strike out whichever is not applicable or modify suitably in case of Association of Persons or
Body of Individuals)
The MSO and the LCO are hereinafter individually referred to as ‘Party’ and collectively
referred to as “Parties”.
Page 34 of 85
WHEREAS,
A. The MSO is a cable operator, who has been granted registration No. ____________ dated
_______________ under the Cable Television Networks Rules, 1994, by the Ministry of
Information and Broadcasting, for providing cable TV services through digital addressable
systems in the areas of ____________________________________notified by the Central
Government under Section 4A of the Cable Television Networks (Regulation) Act, 1995.
B. The LCO is a cable operator, who has been granted registration under the Cable Television
Networks Rules, 1994, having postal registration No. _____________________ dated
__________, in the head post office ____________________, [Name of the head post office]
for providing Cable TV Services in ___________________________ [Mention the area].
C. The LCO has requested the MSO vide its letter No.______________
dated________________for making available signals of TV channels and the MSO has
agreed vide its letter No.______________ dated____________to provide signals of TV
channels to such LCO.
D. TERRITORY: Territory, in the context of this Agreement is __________________
[mention the name of area(s)/ city(ies)/ district(s)/ state(s) for which this agreement is being
signed.]
E. The Parties have mutually agreed to execute this Agreement - on principal to principal and
non-exclusive basis - between them to govern the roles, responsibilities, rights, obligations,
technical and commercial arrangement in regard to the distribution of TV channels in the
Territory.
F. The Parties also mutually agree that each and every transaction including transaction of
any properties/ assets between the Parties shall be carried out in writing or in any other
verifiable means.
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing and the mutual covenants contained
herein, the Parties agree as follows: -
1. DEFINITIONS
Page 35 of 85
The words and expressions used in this Agreement shall have meanings as assigned to them
in the Schedule to this Agreement. All other words and expressions used in this Agreement,
but not defined, and defined in the Act and rules and regulations made there under or the
Cable Television Networks (Regulation) Act, 1995 (7 of 1995) shall have the meanings
respectively assigned to them in those Acts or the rules or regulations, as the case may be.
2. TERM OF THE AGREEMENT
2.1 The Agreement shall commence on_________[dd/mm/yyyy] and remain in force
till__________ [dd/mm/yyyy] or the date of expiry of registration of the MSO or the LCO, as
the case may be, whichever is earlier, unless terminated by either Party as per the terms and
conditions of this Agreement.
2.2 The duration of the Agreement may be extended on terms and conditions to be
mutually agreed between the Parties and recorded in writing provided that the extended term
does not go beyond the last date of validity of registration of the MSO or the LCO, whichever
is earlier.
3. TERMINATION OF THE AGREEMENT
3.1 Either Party has a right to terminate the Agreement by serving an advance notice of
21 days in writing to the other Party in the event of:-
(iv) material breach of the Agreement by the other Party which has not been cured
within 15 days of being required in writing to do so; or
(v) the bankruptcy, insolvency or appointment of receiver over the assets of other
Party; or
(vi) the other Party indulging in, or allowing or inducing any person to indulge in
piracy or carrying programming service provided on the channel which is in
violation of the Programme & Advertising Codes prescribed in the Cable
Television Network Rules, 1994, as amended from time to time.
Page 36 of 85
3.2 The LCO has a right to terminate the Agreement in the event of the MSO
discontinuing the business of retransmission of signals of TV channels in the Territory.
3.3 The MSO has a right to terminate the agreement in the event of the LCO
discontinuing its cable TV business in the Territory.
3.4 If the MSO decides to discontinue the business of retransmission of signals of TV
channels in the Territory for any reason, it shall give a notice in writing, specifying the
reasons for such decision, to the LCO at least 90 days prior to such discontinuation.
3.5 If the LCO decides to discontinue its business of providing signals of TV channels to
the subscriber in the territory, it shall give a notice in writing, specifying the reasons for such
decision, to the MSO at least 90 days prior to such discontinuation.
4. EFFECT OF TERMINATION AND EXPIRY
4.1 In the event of termination or expiry of the term of the Agreement, as the case may be,
at the instance of either Party, each Party shall pay all amounts due and payable up to the date
of termination or expiry to the other Party.
4.2 The LCO shall, within 15 days of the termination or expiry of the term of this
Agreement, as the case may be, in terms of the provisions mentioned herein, hand over to the
MSO all properties and assets belonging to the MSO, which are in the custody of the LCO.
The LCO shall also be liable to make good all the losses or damages, if any, caused to such
properties and assets belonging to the MSO, in custody of the LCO, within 30 days from the
receipt of notice to this effect from the MSO and in the event of inability of LCO to repair
such properties/assets, the LCO shall pay to the MSO the depreciated value of such
properties/ assets.
4.3 The MSO shall, within 15 days of the termination or expiry of the term of this
Agreement, as the case may be, in terms of the provisions mentioned herein, hand over to the
LCO all properties and assets belonging to the LCO, which are in the custody of the MSO.
The MSO shall also be liable to make good all the losses or damages, if any, caused to such
properties and assets belonging to the LCO, in custody of the MSO, within 30 days from the
receipt of notice to this effect from the LCO and in the event of inability of MSO to repair
Page 37 of 85
such properties/assets, the MSO shall pay to the LCO the depreciated value of such
properties/ assets.
Explanation:- The clause 4.2 and 4.3 above shall not have any application in respect of
Hardware or any other equipment belonging to the MSO or the LCO, as the case may be,
which are installed at the premises of the subscribers.
4.4 If the LCO or the MSO, as the case may be, fails to hand over the assets or make good
losses or damages caused to such properties and assets within the above stipulated period, the
defaulting Party shall be liable to make payment for the depreciated value of the same
together with simple interest calculated at the rate 2% over and above the base rate of interest
of the State Bank of India.
5. PROVISIONING OF SERVICES
5.1 The MSO shall make available signals of TV channels to the LCO, on non-exclusive
basis, in order to re-transmit the same to the subscribers in the Territory, in terms of this
agreement and as per prevailing norms, policies, the applicable laws and rules, regulations,
directions and orders of the concerned authorities.
5.2 The LCO shall carry signals of TV channels received from the MSO, on non-
exclusive basis, for distribution to the subscribers in the Territory.
5.3 The Parties shall compulsorily transmit, re-transmit or otherwise carry any channel,
content or programme only in encrypted mode through a digital addressable system strictly in
terms of and in accordance with the applicable laws and regulations.
5.4 The roles and responsibilities of the Parties to the Agreement for provisioning of
services are contained in clause 10 of this Agreement.
5.5 In consideration of the roles and responsibilities mentioned in clause 10 of the
Agreement, the revenue settlement between the LCO and the MSO have been mentioned in
the clause 12 of the Agreement.
Page 38 of 85
6. RIGHTS OF THE MSO
6.1 The MSO shall continue to have a right of ownership of its network used to deliver
the cable TV services under this agreement and it may expand/ upgrade/ change/ replace/ re-
design any part or entire network subject to the condition that any such activity does not
interrupt or degrade the Quality of Service provided to the subscribers.
6.2 The MSO shall sign the interconnection agreement with broadcasters for re-
transmission of signals of TV Channels as per prevailing norms, policies, the applicable laws
and rules, regulations, directions and orders of the concerned authorities.
6.3 The MSO shall have the right to finalise the maximum retail price of each channel, as
payable by the subscriber in compliance with the provisions of applicable laws and rules,
regulations and tariff orders.
6.4 The MSO shall have the right to package the channels/ services offered on the
network, as per its business plan and as per prevailing norms, policies, the applicable laws
and rules, regulations and tariff orders.
6.5 The MSO shall have the right to finalise the rate of Basic Service Tier (BST) in
compliance with the provisions of the applicable tariff orders and regulations notified by the
Authority from time to time.
6.6 The MSO shall have the right to finalise the rates of bouquets of channels, if offered
by the MSO, in compliance with the provisions of the applicable tariff orders and regulations
notified by the Authority.
6.7 The MSO shall have the right to get all requisite information from the LCO for the
purpose of fulfilling its responsibilities under the Agreement, and the applicable orders and
regulations.
7. RIGHTS OF THE LCO
7.1 The LCO shall continue to have its right of ownership of its network used to deliver
the cable TV services under this agreement and it can expand/ upgrade/ change/ replace/ re-
Page 39 of 85
design any part or entire network subject to the condition that any such activity does not
interrupt or degrade the Quality of Service offered to the subscriber on its network.
7.2 The LCO shall have right to get all the requisite information from the MSO for the
purpose of fulfilling its responsibilities under the Agreement, and the applicable orders and
regulations.
8. OBLIGATIONS OF THE MSO
8.1 MSO shall set up and operationalise the Head-end, Conditional Access System (CAS)
and Subscriber Management System (SMS) for ensuring efficient and error-free services to
the subscribers by recording and providing individualized preferences for channels, billing
cycles or refunds.
8.2 The MSO shall make available to the LCO, the necessary and sufficient information
relating to the details of channels, bouquets of channels, and services offered to the
subscribers including their prices.
8.3 The MSO shall provide web based grievance redressal mechanism for addressing the
complaints of LCOs in relation to the provision of services, roles and responsibilities,
revenue settlements, quality of services etc.
8.4 The MSO shall not issue pre-activated STBs and the STBs shall be activated only
after the details of the Customer Application Form (CAF) have been entered into the SMS.
8.5 The MSO shall generate bills for subscribers on regular basis, for charges due and
payable for each month or as per the billing cycle applicable for that subscriber, within 3 days
from the end of the billing cycle.
8.6 The MSO shall provide access to the relevant part of the SMS under its control to the
LCO for the purpose of fulfilling responsibilities by the Parties under the Agreement, and the
applicable orders and regulations.
Page 40 of 85
8.7 The MSO shall not indulge in any piracy or other activities, which has the effect of, or
which shall result into, infringement and violation of trade mark and copyrights of the LCO
or person associated with such transmission.
8.8 The MSO shall comply with all the applicable statutes or laws for the time being in
force, or any rules, codes, regulations, notifications, circulars, guidelines, orders, directions
etc. issued, published or circulated under any law for the time being in force.
8.9 The MSO shall not do any act or thing as a result of which, any right or interest of the
LCO in respect of cable TV signals under this Agreement or any property of the LCO may be
infringed or prejudiced.
8.10 The MSO shall be responsible for encryption of the complete signal, up to the STB
installed at the premises of the subscriber.
8.11 The MSO shall not disconnect the signals of TV Channels, without giving three
weeks’ advance notice to the LCO clearly specifying the reasons for the proposed
disconnection as envisaged in the Interconnection Regulation.
8.12. The MSO shall make available online payment gateway, prepaid system for
subscribers and facility for electronic acknowledgment to the subscriber on the receipt of
payment from the subscriber.
8.13 The MSO shall provide to the LCO at least 2% of the total STBs active in the network
of the LCO with an upper cap of 30 STBs as maintenance spare, which are not pre-activated,
to ensure speedy restoration of services affected due to any fault in STB. This quantity of
maintenance spare STBs shall be maintained during the term of the agreement.
8.14 The MSO shall intimate to the LCO, at least 15 days in advance, in respect of any
proposed changes in the package composition or the retail tariff being offered to the
subscriber.
8.15 The MSO shall have no right, without the prior written intimation to the LCO, to
assign or transfer any of its rights or obligations under this Agreement.
Page 41 of 85
9. OBLIGATIONS OF THE LCO
9.1 The LCO shall handover a copy of CAF received from subscribers within 15 days to
the MSO;
9.2 The LCO shall be responsible for entering the details of the bill amount paid by the
individual subscriber to the LCO for the Cable TV services in the SMS.
9.3 The LCO shall not indulge in any piracy or other activities, which has the effect of, or
which shall result into, infringement and violation of trade mark and copyrights of the MSO,
or any other person associated with such retransmission.
9.4 The LCO shall have no right, without the prior written intimation to the MSO, to
assign or transfer any of its rights or obligations under this Agreement.
9.5 The LCO shall not replace the STBs of the MSO with the STBs of any other MSO
without receiving the requests from the subscribers through application forms for returning
the STB of the existing connections and for providing new connections through Customer
Application Form. The new Set Top Box shall be activated only after entry of the details, as
provided in new Customer Application Form, into the Subscriber Management System of the
new MSO.
9.6 The LCO shall –
(i) not transmit or retransmit, interpolate or mix any signals which are not transmitted
or generated by the MSO without the prior written consent of the MSO;
(ii) not insert any commercial or advertisement or information on any signal
transmitted by the MSO. Any such tampering of signals or interpolating of signals
shall be deemed to be a violation of this Agreement and shall constitute sufficient
cause for termination of this Agreement by the MSO by giving such notice as
prescribed under the law or under this agreement;
Page 42 of 85
(iii) not interfere in any way with the signals provided by the MSO and also not use
any decoding, receiving, recording equipment(s), counterfeit set top box or Smart card
and any other like equipments;
(iv) not alter or tamper the Hardware including the seal (seal to prevent opening of set
top box), misuse, replace, remove and shift the Smart card or STB without the written
consent of MSO from their respective original addresses;
(v) not use, either before or after the installation of STB, of any decoding, receiving,
recording equipment(s), counterfeit set top box(es), smart card(s) other than the
STB(s), Smart cards and any other equipments supplied/ approved by the MSO, and
to take actions as directed by the MSO against such subscribers.
(vi) intimate the MSO promptly about any alteration, tampering with the Hardware
including the seal, misuse, replacement, removal and shifting of Smart cards and
STBs, without the written consent of MSO, from their respective original addresses
and also about the use, either before or after the STBs, of any decoding, receiving,
recording equipment(s), counterfeit set top box(es) and smart card(s) other than the
STB(s), Smart card(s) and any other items of Hardware supplied by the MSO, and to
take actions as directed by the MSO against such subscribers.
9.7 The LCO shall not provide connection to any entity for further retransmission of the
Cable TV signals.
9.8 The LCO shall not record and then retransmit Cable TV signals or otherwise to block
or add or substitute or otherwise tamper with the signal being transmitted by the MSO or with
the trunk line nor shall allow any other person to do so.
9.9 The LCO shall not do any act or thing as a result of which, any right or interest of the
MSO in respect of the Cable TV signals under this Agreement or any property of the MSO
may be infringed or prejudiced.
9.10 The LCO shall permit access to the systems under its control to the MSO, on non-
exclusive basis, for the purpose of fulfilling responsibilities by the Parties under the
Agreement, and the applicable orders and regulations.
Page 43 of 85
9.11 The LCO shall not disconnect the signals of TV Channels, without giving three
weeks’ notice to the MSO clearly specifying the reasons for the proposed disconnection as
envisaged in the Interconnection Regulation.
Page 44 of 85
10. ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE MSO AND THE LCO:
Sl.
No.
Role Responsibility in the
event of agreement
signed under the proviso
to the clause 5 of the
Tariff Order.
Remarks
(1) (2) (3) (4)
1 Publicizing schemes for obtaining and returning the Set Top
Boxes (STBs) by the subscriber and the warranty/ repairing
policy applicable thereof.
MSO
The MSO shall finalize the schemes for
provisioning/ returning STBs, warrantee/
repairing policy applicable thereof.
However the MSO shall share such details
with the LCO.
The MSO shall finalize the packaging and
pricing of channels/ services and such
details shall be shared with the LCO.
The MSO shall finalize the contents of
MOP and consumer charter. Copies of
such MoP and Consumer Charter
documents shall be shared with the LCO.
2 Devising formats of application as specified in the schedule-I
of the QoS regulations for seeking connection, disconnection,
reconnection, transfer, and shifting of Cable TV services;
3 Publication of Manual of Practice (MoP)
4 Publication of Consumer Charter.
Page 45 of 85
5 Setting up of Website containing information pertaining to
services, details of complaint centre, complaint redressal
system, complaint monitoring system, citizen charter, nodal
officer etc.
MSO
6 e. Establishment of Complaint centre for
(iii)addressing service requests of subscribers,
(iv) redressal of complaints of subscribers.
f. Establishment of web based Complaint Monitoring
system.
g. Providing Toll free Consumer Care Number and its
publicity.
h. Maintenance of records of all complaints filed by the
consumer as provided in the Complaint Redressal
Regulations.
MSO
The MSO shall communicate to the LCO the
details of complaint centre for onward
communication to subscribers.
7 Specification of a system of discount or rebate to the
subscriber due to interruptions in service and creating
awareness about such scheme.
MSO
The MSO shall communicate to the LCO, the
details of such scheme for onward
communication to subscribers.
Page 46 of 85
8 g. Providing information to the subscriber about the schemes
for obtaining and returning the STB and the warranty/
repairing policy applicable thereof.
h. Providing of the application form along with the MOP to
the applicants/ subscribers and
i. Receiving of application form from applicants/
subscribers for
(iii) connection, reconnection, transfer, and shifting of
Cable TV services;
(iv) obtaining and returning of STB.
j. Returning of the duplicate copy of the application form to
the applicant/ subscriber as an acknowledgment of receipt
of application.
k. Communication of shortcomings or deficiency, in the
application form, in writing to the applicant, within 2 days
of receipt of the application.
l. Communication of technical or operational non-feasibility
to the applicant, in case it is technically or operationally
non-feasible to provide connection, reconnection, shifting
of service or supply of STB at the location, where the
services are requested by the applicant, within 2 days of
receipt of the application.
LCO
The LCO shall update the information in the
Subscriber Management System (SMS) in
each case within 24 hours from the receipt of
the application.
Page 47 of 85
9 Issue of Unique Identification Number (UIN) for the
applicant. LCO
The UIN shall be generated from the SMS.
The relevant access of the SMS should be
provided by the MSO to the LCO.
10 Installation of STB at the premises of the subscriber and
activation through SMS.
LCO
MSO should provide relevant access to SMS
for STB activation.
11 Providing rebate to the subscriber for delay in installation and
activation of STB. MSO
In cases where the delay can be attributed to
the LCO, for such cases the MSO may recover
the rebate amount from the LCO.
12 Issuance of advance notice of 15 days regarding discontinuing
or disconnection of cable service to the subscriber, indicating
the reasons for such discontinuation or disconnection.
MSO
The MSO shall intimate the LCO in writing
before issuing such advance notice to the
subscriber.
13 Receipt of request from the subscriber for disconnection or
suspension of service and its execution through SMS.
LCO
The LCO shall update the information in the
SMS immediately.
14 Receipt of request for change in subscription package from
the subscribers and its execution through SMS.
LCO The LCO shall update the information in the
SMS immediately.
15 Notice to the Subscribers regarding disruption of signals for
preventive maintenance. MSO
If the preventive maintenance is to be carried
out by the LCO then he shall inform the MSO
to enable him to give notice to the subscribers.
Page 48 of 85
16 Response to the consumer complaints as per norms of the
QoS regulations.
MSO
The complaints received by the Party shall be
immediately updated in the web based
complaint monitoring system so that the
necessary corrective action can be taken by the
Parties in time and the same can be monitored
by the complainant.
17 Redressal of consumer complaints as per the norms of the
QoS regulations:-
(v) relating to ‘No signal’;
(vi) relating to STB;
(vii) relating to subscriber’s billing and receipts;
(viii) any other complaint.
Overall responsibility of
MSO, faults in the
network of the LCO
shall be rectified by the
LCO.
The complaints redressed by the Party shall be
immediately updated in the web based
complaint monitoring system.
18 Designation of nodal officer as per the provisions of the
consumer complaint redressal regulation.
MSO
19 Communication to subscriber about redressal of the complaint
received from the Authority.
MSO
20 Printing and delivery of system generated itemized bills to
subscribers.
MSO
In cases where the payment is collected by the
LCO from the subscriber, then in such cases
details of payment received by LCO shall be 21 Delivery of payment receipts to subscribers. MSO
Page 49 of 85
22 Electronic acknowledgement to subscriber.
MSO
updated in the SMS immediately so that
electronic acknowledgement to the subscriber
is generated automatically.
23 Providing information relating to itemised usage showing
actual usage of service in case of prepaid bills for any period
within 6 months.
MSO
The requests received by the LCO shall be
immediately updated in the SMS so that the
MSO can provide the requisite details to the
subscriber in time.
24 Payment of taxes to the Government. MSO and/ or LCO The specific details of tax payment
responsibilities need to be filled in the
adjoining cells at the time of signing of the
agreement as per the rules and regulations of
the respective Tax authorities.
Page 50 of 85
11. BILLING
11.1 The billing for subscribers shall be in the name of the MSO. However, each party shall
ensure that the applicable laws, rules and regulations relating to taxes are complied with.
11.2 The MSO shall receive the payment of the subscription fee paid by the subscribers. The
revenue share as per clause 12.1 of this Agreement shall be paid by the MSO to the LCO on
receipt of the invoice from the LCO.
12. REVENUE SETTLEMENT BETWEEN THE MSO AND THE LCO AND
RELATED RIGHTS AND OBLIGATIONS
12.1 The revenue settlement between the MSO and the LCO shall be in the following
manner:-
(c) the charges collected from the subscription of channels of Basic Service Tier, free to
air channel and bouquet of free to air channels shall be shared in the ratio of 55:45
between the MSO and the LCO respectively; and
(d) the charges collected from the subscription of channels or bouquet of channels or
channels and bouquet of channels other than those specified under clause (a) shall be
shared in the ratio of 65:35 between the MSO and the LCO respectively.
12.2 The MSO shall share the complete information relating to the subscribers billing and
receipt of the payments with the LCO. The LCO shall issue monthly invoice to the MSO
towards dues payable by the MSO for revenue settlement and such invoice shall clearly
specify the current payment dues and arrears, if any, along with the due date of payment
which shall not be less than seven days. Any demand of arrears shall be accompanied by the
proof of service of invoices for the period for which the arrears pertain. The amounts raised
in the invoice shall be payable on or before the due dates as mentioned therein.
12.3 The Party shall update the details of the subscription amount realised from the
subscriber, in the SMS within 7 days from the due date.
Page 51 of 85
13. DEFAULTS
13.1 Without prejudice to such rights and remedies that the Parties may have in law or
under the provisions of this Agreement, in the event of any delay or failure by the MSO or
the LCO, as the case may be, to make payments of dues on or before the respective due dates,
the LCO or the MSO, as the case may be, shall have the right:-
(i) to disconnect the services subject to the compliance of the applicable rules,
regulations, directions or orders of the Authority;
(ii) to terminate this Agreement, subject to compliance of the applicable laws in force;
(iii) to charge a simple interest at the rate 2% over and above of the base rate of
interest of the State Bank of India from the date such amounts became due until those
are fully and finally paid;
13.2 In cases where any of the Parties has failed to make payment on or before due date for
three consecutive months in the past, the other Party shall have right to demand the interest
free security deposit which shall not exceed average of immediately preceding 6 months
billing amounts and the same shall be maintained for the remaining term of the agreement.
13.3 Upon disconnection of the service as mentioned in clause 13.1 above, whether
accompanied by termination of this Agreement or not, the defaulting Party shall be liable to
deposit forthwith all sums payable by it. In the case of termination, accounts shall be settled
within thirty days and for delayed payments, either Party shall be liable to pay simple interest
at the rate 2% over and above of the base rate of interest of the State Bank of India.
14. UNDERTAKINGS
14.1 Each Party shall recognize the exclusive ownership of the property owned and
installed by the other Party and shall not have or claim any right, title or interest or lien of
whatsoever nature.
Page 52 of 85
14.2 Nothing contained herein shall constitute either Party as the agent or partner or the
representative of the other for any purpose and neither Party shall have the right or authority
to assume, create or incur any liability or obligation of any kind, express or implied, in the
name of or on behalf of the other Party and the relationship between the MSO and the LCO
shall remain on “Principal to Principal” basis.
14.3 It is expressly understood by the Parties that “______________” logo(s) is a
Registered Trade Mark of the MSO, and the LCO shall use the said logo only during the
currency of this Agreement for the benefit of the cable television networking business of the
MSO. Consent of the MSO is hereby given to the LCO to use the said logo, to the extent of or
in connection with the business of the MSO.
14.4 It is expressly understood by the Parties that “______________” logo(s) is a
Registered Trade Mark of the LCO, and the MSO shall use the said logo only during the
currency of this Agreement for the benefit of the cable television networking business of the
LCO. Consent of the LCO is hereby given to the MSO to use the said logo, to the extent of or
in connection with the business of the LCO.
14.5 It is clearly understood and accepted by each Party that it shall have no right to use
any intellectual property of the other on its Cable TV service or otherwise on or after the
withdrawal by the other Party of its consent for such uses.
14.6 In case the LCO or the MSO, as the case may be, decides to transfer its interest in
respect of its business of providing Cable TV Service to any other party / person (third party),
in whole or in part, the LCO or the MSO, as the case may be, shall give prior notice to the
MSO or the LCO. One Party shall not have any objection to such transfer if the other Party
has complied with its obligations under this contract and has paid all its dues.
Provided, however, that such third party shall sign and execute a deed of adherence to the
terms & conditions of this Agreement and other undertaking/ bonds to the satisfaction of the
MSO or the LCO, as the case may be, in order to give effect to the provisions of this
Agreement.
Page 53 of 85
14.7 The LCO shall maintain and continue to maintain its Postal Registration Certificate
renewed from time to time in accordance with the Cable TV Networks (Regulation) Act,
1995 and comply with the terms and conditions of the registration certificate issued by the
Postal Authority.
14.8 The MSO shall maintain and continue to maintain its Registration Certificate renewed
from time to time in accordance with the Cable TV Networks (Regulation) Act, 1995 and
comply with the terms and conditions of the registration.
14.9 Both the Parties shall comply with the Programme Codes and Advertising Codes
prescribed in the Cable Television Network Rules, 1994, as amended from time to time.
14.10 Both the Parties shall comply with the laws for the time being in force in India, as
applicable to them.
15. PREVENTION OF PIRACY
15.1 The Parties shall not indulge or allow any person to indulge in Piracy or in reverse
engineering any technology used in the Hardware or any component thereof nor shall they
use the Hardware to be connected to any equipment for setting up a mini head-end for
retransmission of the signals generated from the same.
15.2 Signal to any subscriber shall be disconnected by the MSO or the LCO, as the case
may be, after giving due notice as required under applicable regulations, if found to be
indulged in or abetting any Piracy.
16. DISCLAIMER AND INDEMNITY
16.1 In no event, the MSO shall be liable to the LCO for any indirect, special, incidental or
consequential damage arising out of or in connection with the disruption, interruption or
discontinuance of the Service or for any inconvenience, disappointment or due to deprival of
any programme or information or for any indirect or consequential loss or damage, which is
not attributable to any act of the MSO.
Page 54 of 85
16.2 In no event, the LCO shall be liable to the MSO for any indirect, special, incidental or
consequential damage arising out of or in connection with the disruption, interruption or
discontinuance of the Service or for any inconvenience, disappointment or due to deprival of
any programme or information or for any indirect or consequential loss or damage, which is
not attributable to any act of the LCO.
16.3 LCO shall indemnify the MSO for all cost, expense and damages by reason of any
claim, action or proceedings from any third party or from subscribers for any inconvenience,
loss or annoyance caused to them due to any default of the LCO or due to termination of the
Agreement or suspension of the Service due to LCO’s breach.
16.4 MSO shall indemnify the LCO for all cost, expense and damages by reason of any
claim, action or proceedings from any third party or from subscribers for any inconvenience,
loss or annoyance caused to them due to any default of the MSO or due to termination of the
Agreement or suspension of the Service due to MSO’s breach.
17. GOVERNING LAW AND DISPUTE RESOLUTION
17.1 As mandated by the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997, the Parties
shall not institute any suit or seek injection or interim orders in any court or judicial tribunal/
authority in India with respect to any claims, dispute or differences between the Parties
arising out of this Agreement save and except before the Telecom Disputes Settlement and
Appellate Tribunal, New Delhi (“TDSAT”). The Parties agree that all disputes between the
Parties shall be resolved solely through proceedings instituted before the TDSAT.
18. FORCE MAJEURE
18.1 Failure on the part of the MSO or the LCO to perform any of its obligations, shall not
entitle either Party to raise any claim against the other or constitute a breach of this
Agreement to the extent that such failure arises from an event of Force Majeure. If through
Force Majeure the fulfilment by either Party of any obligation set forth in this Agreement is
delayed, the period of such delay shall not be taken into account in computing periods
prescribed by this Agreement. Force Majeure will include act of god, earthquake, tides,
storm, flood, lightening, explosion, fire, sabotage, quarantine, epidemic, arson, civil
Page 55 of 85
disturbance, terrorist attack, war like situation, or enactment of any law or rules and
regulation made by the Authorities or revocation of registration of the Parties any
circumstances beyond the reasonable control of the Parties herein that directly or indirectly
hinders or prevents either of the Parties from commencing or proceeding with the
consummation of the transactions contemplated hereby. The Party affected by such Force
Majeure event shall promptly notify the other Party of the occurrence of such event. It is
agreed between the Parties that lack of funds shall not in any event constitute or be
considered an event of Force Majeure. If the conditions of Force Majeure to continue for a
period exceeding one month, the Parties shall meet to decide upon the future performance of
the Agreement. If the Parties are unable to agree upon a plan for future performance, then the
Agreement shall be terminated upon notice of either Party to the other, on expiry of one
month from the date of such notice.
18.2 Any accrued payment obligation of a Party prior to the commencement of Force
Majeure shall survive the termination of this Agreement pursuant to such Force Majeure.
19. NOTICES
19.1 Any notice to be served on any Party by the other shall be deemed to have been
validly sent if sent by Registered Post Acknowledgement Due (RPAD) or speed post service
of Department of Post, Government of India or by hand delivery duly acknowledged at the
address mentioned in the beginning or at such other changed address as the Party may inform
and the date of receipt of such notice shall be the date of receipt by the other Party or 7 days
from the date of dispatch of the notice by RPAD, whichever is earlier.
20. RESTRICTION ON TRANSFER
20.1 The either Party shall not remove, sell, assign, mortgage, transfer/sublet and
encumber all or any part of the network which belongs to the other Party. If the Party
indulges in any of the above-mentioned acts, the said acts shall be illegal and void ab-initio
and the Party shall also be liable for any action under the applicable law.
Page 56 of 85
21. CONFIDENTIALITY
21.1 The Parties shall keep in strict confidence, any information received by one from the
other while participating in the affairs/business of each other and shall not disclose the same
to any person not being a party to this Agreement.
21.2 The Parties shall also bind their employees, officers, advisors, associates, contractors,
agents, authorized persons and other similar persons to whom the above mentioned
information may be disclosed, to the obligations of confidentiality.
21.3 The Parties hereby agrees that the confidential information can be disclosed to the
statutory authority on demand by such authorities.
22. MODIFICATIONS
22.1 The Agreement cannot be modified, varied or terminated except in writing. Any
variation of the Agreement, including Addendum Agreements, Annexures, Schedules or any
other document, called by whatever name, but executed in relation to this Agreement, shall
be mutually agreed to in writing and executed by or on behalf of the Parties.
23. BINDING EFFECT
23.1 This Agreement modifies all prior understanding of the Parties as to the subject matter
thereof and shall not be amended except in writing by both the Parties. Any other
understanding between the Parties (if any) with regard to any other matter or any accrued
rights and obligation of the Parties not covered under this agreement, if any, shall continue to
be in full force and effect.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF the Parties have set and subscribed their respective hands to this
Agreement on the date and year appearing hereinabove.
Signed on behalf of the MSO
(_____________________________ )
In the presence of
1. ………………..
Page 57 of 85
2. ………………..
Signed on behalf of the LCO
(_____________________________ )
In the presence of
1. ………………..
2. ………………..
Note: The self attested copies of power of attorney/authorization letter, whereby the
signatories of this agreement have been authorised to sign and execute this agreement by the
Parties, shall be attached with this agreement.
Page 58 of 85
Schedule
DEFINITIONS AND INTERPRETATIONS
A. DEFINITIONS
In the Agreement unless the context requires otherwise, the following words and
expressions shall have the meanings set out herein below:
(a) “Act” means the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997 (24 of 1997), as
amended from time to time;
(b) “Addressable System” shall have the same meaning as assigned to it in the Cable
Television Networks (Regulation) Act, 1995 (7 of 1995), as amended from time to
time;
(c) “Authority” means the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India established under
subsection (1) of section 3 of the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997;
(d) “Basic Service Tier” shall have the same meaning as assigned to it in the Tariff
Order.
(e) “Bouquet” or “bouquet of channels” means an assortment of distinct channels,
offered together as a group or as a bundle;
(f) “Broadcaster”
means a person or a group of persons, or body corporate, or any
organization or body who, after having obtained, in its name, uplinking permission or
downlinking permission, as may be applicable for its channels, from the Central
Government, provides programming services;
(g) “Cable service or cable TV service” means the transmission by cables of
programmes including retransmission by cables of any broadcast television signals;
(h) “Cable television network or cable TV network” means any system consisting of a
set of closed transmission paths and associated signal generation, control and
distribution equipment, designed to provide cable service for reception by multiple
subscribers;
(i) “Channel or TV channel” means a channel, which has been registered under -----
(i) the guidelines for uplinking from India, issued vide No.1501/2/2002-
TV(I)(Pt.) dated the 2nd December, 2005; or
(ii) policy guidelines for downlinking of televisions channels, issued vide No.
Page 59 of 85
13/2/2002-BP&L/BC-IV dated the 11th November, 2005, ---------
as amended from time to time, or such other guidelines for uplinking or downlinking
of television channels, as may be issued from time to time by Government of India
(Ministry of Information and Broadcasting) and reference to the term ‘channel’ shall
be construed as a reference to “channel or TV channel”;
(j) “Complaint Centre” means a facility established by the multi-system operator or his
linked local cable operators, as the case may be, under Consumer Complaint Redressal
Regulation;
(k) “Consumer Complaint Redressal Regulation” means the Consumers Complaint
Redressal (Digital Addressable Cable TV Systems) Regulations, 2012 (13 of 2012),
dated 14
th
May 2012, as amended from time to time;
(l) “CTN Act” means the Cable Television Networks (Regulation) Act, 1995 (7 of
1995), as amended from time to time.
(m) “Encryption or encrypted” in respect of a signal of cable television network, means
the changing of such signal in a systematic way so that the signal would be
unintelligible without use of an addressable system and the expression "unencrypted"
shall be construed accordingly;
(n) “Free To Air channel” shall have the same meaning as assigned to it in the Tariff
Order.
(o) “Hardware” means a multi-system operator approved set top box to enable the
decryption of signals of Channels transmitted in encrypted form, the remote and other
associated components and accessories.
(p) “Headend” means a facility that contains satellite receivers, modulator, compression
equipment, multiplexes, and conditional access facilities, other transmission
equipments and has antennas which receive signals from Satellite and/or from local
studio for retransmission to subscribers directly or through linked LCOs;
(q) “Interconnection Regulation” means the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and
Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems)
Regulations, 2012 (9 of 2012), dated 30
th
April, 2012, as amended from time to time.
(r) “Manual of Practice (MoP)” means the Manual of Practice referred in the QoS
Regulation;
(s) “Nodal Officer” means the officer appointed or designated by the multi-system
operator or his linked local cable operator, as the case may be, under the Consumer
Complaint Redressal Regulation;
Page 60 of 85
(t) “Pay Channel” shall have the same meaning as assigned to it in the Tariff Order;
(u) “Piracy” means unauthorized reception, retransmission or redistribution of Cable TV
Signal by any person by any means and modes including but not limited to any
alteration, tampering of the seal or any component or accessory thereof or misuse,
replacement, removal and/or shifting of Hardware or any use, either before or after
the set top box, any decoding, receiving, recording equipment(s), counterfeit or
unauthorized devices or any activity, which has the effect of, or which may result
into, infringement and violation of trade mark and copyright of the MSO or the LCO
as the case may be;
(v) "Programme" means any television broadcast and includes;
(i) exhibition of films, features, dramas, advertisements and serials;
(ii) any audio or visual or audio-visual live performance or presentation and----
the expression "programming service" shall be construed accordingly;
(w) “QoS Regulation” means the Standards of Quality of Service (Digital Addressable
Cable TV Systems) Regulations, 2012 (12 of 2012), dated 14
th
May, 2012, as
amended from time to time.
(x) “Set top box or STB ” means a device, which is connected to, or is part of a
television and which allows a subscriber to receive in unencrypted and descrambled
form subscribed channels through an addressable system;
(y) “Smart Card” means the card duly approved by the multi-system operator as part of
the Hardware, which enables the subscriber to gain access to the Cable TV signals of
Channels.
(z) “Subscriber” means a person who receives broadcasting services or cable services
from a multi-system operator or cable operator at a place indicated by him to the
multi-system operator or cable operator, as the case may be, without further
transmitting it to any person and includes ordinary subscribers and commercial
subscribers, unless specifically excluded;
“For removal of doubts, it is clarified that each set top box installed at the premises
would constitute a subscriber.”
(za) “Subscriber management system or SMS” means a system or device which stores
the subscriber records and details with respect to name, address and other information
regarding the hardware being utilized by the subscriber, channels or bouquets of
channels subscribed to by the subscriber, price of such channels or bouquets of
channels as defined in the system, the activation or deactivation dates and time for
Page 61 of 85
any channel or bouquets of channels, a log of all actions performed on a subscriber’s
record, invoices raised on each subscriber and the amounts paid or discount allowed
to the subscriber for each billing period;
(zb ) “Tariff Order” means the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable) Services
(Fourth) (Addressable Systems) Tariff Order, 2010 (1 of 2010), dated 21
st
July 2010,
as amended from time to time;
(zc) “Trunk Line” means the coaxial/optic fiber cable network and other allied
equipment such as receiver nodes, amplifiers, splitters etc. owned and installed by the
multi-system operator or its associate companies for the purpose of transmitting Cable
TV Signal to various LCOs till the receiving end of various LCOs, including the
LCO, to enable them to re-transmit the Cable TV Signal to respective subscribers;
All other words and expressions used in this interconnection agreement but not
defined, and defined in the Act and rules and regulations made thereunder or the CTN
Act and the rules and regulations made thereunder, shall have the meanings
respectively assigned to them in those Acts or the rules or regulations, as the case may
be.
B. INTERPRETATION
In this Agreement, unless the context otherwise requires:
(a) Any reference to the singular in the Agreement shall include a reference to the
plural and vice versa and words importing one gender only shall include all other
genders unless the context otherwise requires;
(b) The word “person” shall include individuals, corporations, partnerships, association
of persons and any other entities;
(c) Any references to article, clauses, sub-clauses, appendices, annexure and schedules
are references to Articles, clauses, sub-clauses, appendices, annexure and schedules to
the Agreement unless the context otherwise expressly provides;
(d) References to a “month” are to a calendar month;
(e) Headings and titles are for ease of reference only and shall not affect the
interpretation of this agreement and in no way be read to give a construction not
harmonious with the interpretation of various clauses of this agreement done otherwise
independent of the title.
Page 62 of 85
(f) Any reference to law, regulation, statutory provision, order, guideline, policy, etc,
includes references to such law or regulation or provision, order, guideline, policy, etc.,
as modified, codified, amended or re-enacted from time to time.”
(S. K. Gupta)
Pr. Advisor (B&CS)
Note.1-----The principal regulations were published in the Gazette of India, Extraordinary,
Part III, Section 4, vide its notification No. 3- 24/2012- B&CS dated the 30th April 2012 and
subsequently amended vide notifications No. 3- 24/2012- B&CS dated the 14th May 2012,
No. 3-24/2012-B&CS dated the 20th September 2013, No. 3-24/2012- B&CS dated the 10th
February, 2014, No. 6-33/2014-B&CS dated the 18th July, 2014, 6-29/2015-B&CS dated:
14th September 2015 and. No. 3-106/2015-B&CS dated 7
th
January 2016.
Note.2-----The Explanatory Memorandum explains the objects and reasons of the
Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable
Cable Television Systems) (Seventh Amendment) Regulations, 2016 ( ___ of 2016).
Page 63 of 85
Explanatory Memorandum
1. The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) has notified a comprehensive
regulatory framework for Digital Addressable Cable TV Systems (DAS) encompassing
the interconnection regulations, the quality of service regulations, the tariff orders and the
consumer complaint redressal regulations. The Interconnection Regulation applicable for
DAS, namely the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection
(Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) Regulations, 2012, dated 30
th
April 2012,
as amended from time to time [herein after referred to as ‘the Interconnection
Regulations 2012’], inter alia, provides a framework for interconnection between Multi
System Operators (MSOs) and Local Cable Operators (LCOs). Based on this
framework, the MSOs and LCOs (collectively herein after referred to as ‘the Parties’) are
required to enter into written interconnection agreement before providing cable
services to subscribers.
2. In terms of the Interconnection Regulations 2012, the Parties, through mutual agreement,
are required to decide upon the responsibility for each role as envisaged in the quality of
service regulations namely the Standards of Quality of Service (Broadcasting and Cable
Services) Regulations 2012, dated 14
th
May 2012, as amended from time to time [herein
after referred to as ‘the QoS Regulations 2012’]. The tariff order applicable for
addressable systems namely the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services)
(Fourth) (Addressable Systems) Tariff Order, 2010 (1 of 2010), dated 21st July 2010, as
amended from time to time [herein after referred to as ‘the Tariff Order’], provides that
the revenue settlement between the MSO and the LCO shall be determined by mutual
agreement between the Parties. In case, the Parties fail to arrive at a mutual agreement the
charges collected from the subscribers shall be shared in a manner prescribed in the Tariff
Order.
3. As there could be various ways in which the responsibility for each role are divided
between the MSOs and the LCOs, the Authority while notifying the comprehensive
regulatory framework for DAS, in the year 2012, detailing each and every aspects of
interconnection, did not prescribe any specific terms and conditions for interconnection
agreement and left it open to market conditions. It was then envisaged that this will
provide enough flexibility to the Parties for smooth transitioning from non-addressable
systems to digital addressable systems.
Page 64 of 85
4. TRAI received a large number of complaints regarding various issues in signing of the
interconnection agreement between the Parties. On one end, the LCOs represented that
the terms and conditions of draft agreements offered by MSOs are one sided and do not
provide a level playing field. On the other end, the MSOs indicated that the LCOs are not
willing to follow the terms and conditions of interconnection agreement already executed
between the Parties. Often the roles and responsibilities of the Parties, for meeting the
quality of service norms as prescribed in the QoS Regulations 2012, are not clearly
defined in the interconnection agreement signed by the Parties and due to which, in the
event of dispute between the Parties, the quality of service delivered to the consumers is
adversely affected.
5. To get an insight into the various issues relating to signing of the interconnection
agreement between the Parties and implementation of DAS, TRAI held interactions with
the Parties in various parts of the country. The Parties, in general, were of the opinion that
it would be in the best interest of the sector if TRAI prescribes the terms and conditions
of an interconnection agreement which can be entered into by the Parties. This would
help in reducing disputes between the Parties and consequently help in improving the
quality of service delivered to consumers.
6. After considering representations from the stakeholders, the Authority decided to
intervene. The Authority contemplated to prescribe the terms and conditions for
interconnection agreement in such a way that it addresses the various concerns of the
Parties as well as it provide enough flexibility for accommodating various plausible
business models between the Parties. Moreover, the Cable Television Network Rules,
1994, as amended from time to time, provides that the Authority may notify a standard
interconnection agreement to be used for entering into commercial agreements for
distribution in the notified areas, of pay or free-to-air channels among MSOs and LCOs.
7. To prescribe such interconnection agreement, the Authority formulated a draft Model and
Standard Interconnection Agreements (MSIA). The draft MSIA consisted of a draft
Model Interconnection Agreement (MIA) and a draft Standard Interconnection agreement
(SIA) in a single document. The draft MSIA contained necessary terms and conditions, in
line with the existing regulatory framework, inter alia, defining rights, obligations, roles
and responsibilities of the Parties with an aim to provide a level playing field to them. It
was envisaged in the draft MSIA that in cases where the Parties can mutually agree upon
Page 65 of 85
the responsibility corresponding to each role and the revenue settlement, MIA part of the
MSIA would be applicable. In cases where the Parties are not able to arrive at a mutual
agreement on sharing of the responsibilities or the revenue, SIA part of MSIA would be
applicable wherein the Authority had prescribed the responsibility of the Parties
corresponding to each role listed in the draft MSIA. In such cases the revenue settlement
would be based on the ratios prescribed in the Tariff Order.
8. The Authority, accordingly, decided to initiate a consultation process with the
stakeholders before prescription of the MIA or the SIA between the Parties, as the case
may be, offering cable services through DAS. The draft MSIA along with a consultation
note was uploaded on TRAI website www.trai.gov.in on 9
th
December 2015, inviting
comments and counter comments from stakeholders.
9. The last date for submission of comments & counter-comments was 31
st
December 2015
and 7
th
January 2016, respectively. In response, a total of 18 comments & 3 counter-
comments were received from stakeholders, including some from individuals.
Subsequently, an Open House Discussion (OHD) was held on 28
th
January 2016 in Delhi,
which was attended by a large number of stakeholders. Post OHD, the stakeholders were
given a further opportunity to provide their views/ comments in writing on the issue by
01
st
February 2016. Three additional comments were received by the due date. The
comments and counter comments were uploaded on TRAI website www.trai.gov.in.
10. The following paragraphs provide gist of the comments/ views of the stakeholders
received on the issue, analysis of these comments and objects & reasons of this
amendment to the Interconnection Regulations 2012. Some of the comments received
from the stakeholders do not relate directly to the issue under consultation but are in the
nature of suggestions for amendments in the present regulatory framework. These
suggestions may be considered for consultation by the Authority separately at appropriate
time.
Analysis of the comments of stakeholders
Nomenclature of the Parties (MSOs and LCOs) and territory of operation
11. Some cable operator associations opined that MSOs may be referred to as Head-end
Service Provider (HSP) in the agreement as MSO is only a mediator or a wholesaler of
‘pay’ TV broadcasters and aggregator of FTA channels. Similarly, they stated that the
http://www.trai.gov.in/
Page 66 of 85
LCOs should be referred as Last Mile Owners (LMO) as it builds, operates, maintains and
upgrades the networks connecting all consumers. An individual was of the view that in
the Cable TV Act there is no term like the LCO or the LMO and it is the ‘cable operator’
who is responsible for management and operation of cable TV network. He suggested that
Head-end Service Provider (HSP) is the better term for the MSO. If MSO provides cable
service directly to the subscribers only then it should be treated as cable operator
otherwise it should be treated as HSP.
12. On the aspect of the territory of the operation of the LCO, one cable operators association
suggested that the map of the area of operation should be attached with the agreement.
13. The Cable TV Networks (Regulation) Act 1995 and the Cable TV Rules made there
under defines the MSO which reads as under:-
“Multi System Operator” means a cable operator who has been granted registration
under rule 11C and who receives a programming service from a broadcaster or its
authorised agencies and re-transmits the same or transmits his own programming service
for simultaneous reception either by multiple subscribers directly or through one or more
local cable operators and includes his authorised distribution agencies, by whatever
name called.”
14. Similarly, as per the Cable TV Networks (Regulation) Act 1995 and the Cable TV Rules
made there under, the LCO is registered in the head post office of the areas of its
operations for providing cable services. Since the MSO and the LCO terminologies are
used in the Cable TV Networks (Regulation) Act 1995, the Authority is of the view that
the names of these entities need not be changed. On the aspect of mandating the map of
the territory, the Authority observed that names of the territory are already part of the
MIA and SIA. Further in DAS, the subscriber's details along with names and addresses
are transparently reflected in the Subscriber Management System (SMS) and the same is
sufficient to resolve the territory related disputes, if any. Therefore attachment of the map
with the interconnection agreement may not serve any useful purpose except to increase
the cost to the Parties. However, the map of the area can be attached with mutual consent
with the model interconnection agreement.
Page 67 of 85
Term of agreement
15. On the aspect of term of agreement, a distribution agent of broadcasters commented that
the duration of the agreement may be extended, provided that the extended term does not
go beyond the date of expiry of registration of the MSO or the LCO.
16. The Authority accepted the suggestion and accordingly the relevant clause in the MIA
and the SIA has been suitably modified.
Termination of the agreement
17. On the aspect of termination of the agreement, most of the MSOs and their association
proposed that the curing period of 30 days should include 21 days notice period for
termination. Another MSO suggested that 21 days notice should be sufficient in case of
material breach. As per them, for continued breach the default should not be allowed to
continue after 30 days and therefore additional 21 days notice is not required. Whereas a
broadcaster’s association commented that the notice period for curing the breach may be
reduced from 30 days to 14 days. An individual suggested that the time to cure material
breaches/ deficiencies should be reduced to 15 days. Whereas a cable operator association
commented that the time provided in the draft MSIA is appropriate.
18. On the aspect of termination of the agreement, in the event of MSO discontinuing the
business, a cable operator association commented that period of disconnection and reason
thereof should be given and discontinuation should effect after prior notice of at least 30
days. Another association expressed that in cases where only one MSO is having
operations in a particular area and it plans to discontinue or wants to sell/ merge with
another Party, a simple notice of 90 days may not be adequate for LCO to install his own
head-end or wait for another MSO to get connected.
19. The Authority noted that the curing period of 30 days and notice period of 21 days may
result in breach continuing for 51 days and which may give undue advantage to the
defaulting Party. Therefore the Authority is of the view that the curing period should be
reduced to 15 days and in case of continued breach the notice period of 21 days should
start thereafter. Accordingly, the relevant clause has been modified.
20. On the aspect of disconnection due to a Party exiting the business, the Authority is of the
view that the time of 90 days is sufficient for the purpose and notice in writing specifying
Page 68 of 85
the reasons for such decision shall be given to the other Party. Accordingly, the relevant
clause has been modified.
Effect of Termination and Expiry.
21. In the draft agreements for consultation, comments of stakeholders were drawn on the
possible clauses for mitigating the situation in the event of termination or expiry of the
agreement. Some LCO associations commented that the list of hardware or any other
property/asset including STBs belonging to MSO and installed in the network of the LCO
for delivery of services should be attached with the agreement and MSO should be
responsible for daily upkeep and maintenance of equipment meant to provide services to
the LCO. LCO will compensate only such damage that has been caused due to his
negligence/ willful damage and not otherwise. Another LCO association commented that
definition of properties and assets should be defined irrespective of MSO and LCO.
22. Most of the MSOs suggested that in cases where the STB provided to the customer is the
property of MSO then the STB should be returned back to the MSO by the LCO. An LCO
association opined that handing over the properties shall be subject to the scheme chosen
by the subscriber in terms of TRAI Regulations.
23. On the aspects of levy of interest in case of default in handing over the asset or make
good losses or damages, an MSO suggested the interest @ 4% plus base rate of State
Bank of India (SBI) should be applied. Whereas an individual counter-commented that
since the base rate of SBI is already very high at around 9% per annum, the rate should be
fixed at SBI's base rate only. Whereas another cable operator association opined that the
financial amount should be decided mutually in writing by both the Parties.
24. On the aspect of enclosing the list of properties/assets belonging to a Party in the network
of the other Party, the Authority observed that the Parties may require to install
properties/ assets in the network of the other Party, not only at the time of interconnection
but during the currency of interconnection agreement. Therefore the Authority is of the
view that any transaction of properties/ assets between the Parties shall be carried out in
writing or any other verifiable means indicating the cost of such properties/ assets. This
would help the Parties to settle their dues in the event of termination of the agreement.
Accordingly the suitable clause provision has been added in the MIA and the SIA.
Page 69 of 85
25. The Authority observed that, the provisioning of Set Top Box at the premises of the
subscriber is governed by the conditions prescribed in the Customer Application Form
(CAF) for the option chosen by the subscriber. Further, based on the option chosen by the
subscriber, if the STB belongs to the MSO, then LCO cannot be made responsible for
returning the same in the event of discontinuation of cable services by the subscriber and
subscriber has not returned the STB to the LCO. Therefore, the Set Top Box cannot be
included in the list of hardware which is required to be handed over due to effect of
termination/ expiry of the interconnection agreement.
26. The amount of interest levied on defaulting Party should work as effective deterrent to
avoid further defaults. Keeping in view the market practices and comments-counter
comments of the stakeholders, the Authority is of the view that rate of interest on default
in payment should be retained as 2% plus the base rate of State Bank of India (SBI).
Provisioning of Services
27. The conditions of provision of service are an important part of the agreement wherein the
Parties broadly specifies the principles such as non-exclusivity, applicable laws under
which the service is provide. Some associations commented that the MSO should grant
non-exclusive right to the LCO to retransmit the signals of TV channels on the basis of
the representation, warranties and undertakings given by the LCO, and shall be subject to
LCO complying with all the terms and conditions as set out in the Agreement, and LCO
accepts such grant of rights and agrees and acknowledges them.
28. A cable operator association opined that minimum technical quality of service parameters
should be specified/ mentioned clearly in the Agreement. Financial disincentives,
penalties etc against faults, delays etc. should also be clearly specified.
29. One of the fundamental principles of the interconnection regulations is non exclusivity
and therefore, the Authority is of the view that the interconnection agreement shall be
entered into by the Parties on non-exclusive basis. Accordingly, the relevant clause has
been suitably modified. As far as the specification of minimum quality of service in terms
of technical parameters is concerned, the QoS Regulations 2012 already cover the aspect
of technical parameters and both the Parties are required to adhere to the norms
prescribed in the QoS Regulations 2012 or as modified from time to time. Therefore the
Authority has decided not to include QoS parameters in the MIA or the SIA.
Page 70 of 85
Rights of the MSO
30. An LCO Association opined that all package/ channel rates, discount schemes, STB
hiring schemes for subscribers & all business plans are made by the MSO. It was
suggested that wherever LCO network is being used, it should be decided by the MSO in
consultation with the LCOs. LCO’s area of operation and choice of consumers of that
area is very important in making business plans.
31. In DAS, it is the MSO who receives a programming service from broadcasters and
perform technical functions of a head-end (turn-around, encoding, encryption,
multiplexing, modulation, combining and subscriber management) and therefore, the
responsibility of packaging and pricing of channels/ services remains with the MSOs. It is
not practically feasible to formulate the composition of services as per the individual
requirement of each LCO. Therefore the Authority is of the view that the right of
packaging and pricing of the service offerings shall remain with the MSOs.
Rights of the LCO
32. Some associations stated that the right of ownership to LCOs should be clearly defined
with respect to their own network only. A cable operator association suggested that it
should be specified that the network which comprises of fiber, coaxial and distribution
devices including the customers belongs to LCO and MSO distribution network is limited
up to LCO point only. Whereas, another LCO association commented that the network
from the MSO to the end users should be defined as the network of LCO.
33. The cable TV distribution network generally comprises of optical fiber network and last
mile co-axial cable network. The Authority is of the view that the ownership of the
individual Party is limited to the portion which the individual Party owns. If the MSO has
laid the network till the LCO end then it belongs to the MSO and the responsibility of
maintenance and upkeep remains with the MSO. Similarly, if the LCO owns last mile
connectivity then the maintenance and upkeep of the same remains with the LCO. No
Party can claim an ownership over the other Party network which it does not own.
Accordingly suitable clause has been included in the MIA and the SIA.
Page 71 of 85
Obligations of the MSO
34. On the aspect of providing web-based LCO grievance redressal system, one MSO
suggested that, MSOs should be required to provide web based grievance redressal
facility only to the consumers, and not to LCOs, as MSOs are already entertaining the
complaints of the LCOs through emails and other mode of communication. An LCO
commented that provision for redressal of grievances of LCOs should be present along
with a provision of designating local statutory authority for grievance redressal.
35. On aspect of bill generation, an LCO association suggested that the MSOs shall generate
bills within 10 days from the end of the billing cycle and deliver to LCO in printed format
and not on CD Drive, Pen Drive or any other format. Another LCO association
commented that billing should be done through LCO/LMO whether online or offline, as
LCO/LMO gives service to the consumers and collects the subscription amount. MSO’s
Association were of the view that the period of 3 days for bill generation from the end of
the billing cycle is less and needs to be extended to 7 days as the details from LCOs take
time to be entered into the SMS.
36. An LCO stated that there should be a provision in the MIA and SIA to allow LCOs some
small percent (2% of total STBs) of demo type active Set Top Box without monthly
charges.
37. An LCO association commented that package upgrading & downgrading facility should
be operated by LCO.
38. A HITS operator suggested that pre-activated STB's along with only FTA channels
should be allowed for 7 days. If, during this period, all mandatory details are not entered,
then STB should be deactivated.
39. On the aspect of setting up of web based grievance redressal system, the Authority noted
that depending upon sharing of the roles and responsibilities between the Parties, the
Parties may need to communicate frequently to fulfill the obligations and address the
concerns of each other as per the agreement. Web based grievance redressal system is one
of the most efficient and cost effective way of managing such requirements. It encourages
healthy and transparent practices. The trail of issues and their solutions recorded in the
system can also be used to resolve the disputes between the Parties. Accordingly, for
Page 72 of 85
effective implementation of the provisions of this agreement, web-based grievance
redressal system is necessary for LCOs also.
40. The QoS Regulations 2012 puts an obligation on the MSO that the bills for the services
availed by the subscriber must be generated from the SMS automatically at the end of
billing cycle. Therefore, the obligation of bill generation cannot be assigned to the LCO.
On the aspect of the time period for generation bill from the end of the billing cycle, the
Authority is of the view that the period of 3 days is sufficient as the bills are
automatically generated in the SMS. This would also give sufficient time for delivery of
bills to the subscribers which would increase the time period between the receiving of the
bills by the subscriber and the due date for payment. Accordingly relevant clause has
been provided in the MIA and the SIA.
41. On the aspect of provisioning of spare STBs in possession of LCOs for undertaking
speedy repair/maintenance of STBs in the event of fault in STBs, the Authority noted that
the QoS Regulation 2012 mandates the service providers to replace/repair the STBs
within 24 hours. The provisioning of few STBs as a spare which can be used in place
faulty STBs, installed at premises of subscribers, would help in the speedy restoration of
services. This would also help in compliance of the QoS Regulations 2012. Accordingly,
the MIA and the SIA puts an obligation on the part of MSO to provide to the LCO, at
least 2% of the total STBs active in the network of LCO with an upper cap of 30 STBs as
maintenance spare, which are not pre-activated, to ensure speedy restoration of service
affected due to any fault in STBs. Accordingly suitable clause has been added in the
MIA and the SIA.
42. The MSO has a right to decide the composition and pricing of channels/ package subject
to the applicable Regulations/ Tariff orders. However to ensure transparency in the
business among the Parties, the Authority has included a clause in the MIA and SIA
where MSO has been asked to intimate to the LCO at least 15 days in advance in respect
of any proposed changes in the package composition or the retail tariff being offered to
the subscriber. As far as the responsibility of communicating this to the subscriber is
concerned, that still lies with the MSO only as per the relevant regulations.
43. To accrue the full benefit of DAS, it is important that the relevant details of the customer
and its choice of channels/ services are entered into the SMS so that the subscriber gets
error free services. Therefore, it is essential that the STB of the subscriber is activated
Page 73 of 85
only after the details are entered into the SMS and therefore the stakeholders request
regarding pre-activated STBs cannot be acceded to.
Obligations of the LCO
44. MSO associations commented that the LCO should not be allowed to migrate to any other
distributor of signals without following proper process. They further stated that additional
clause should be added that the LCO should not replace the STBs of MSO with STBs of
any other service provider without following the process of law.
45. On the aspect of customer application form handling, an individual suggested that instead
of handing over a copy of customer application form, the original customer application
form should be given to the MSO. An MSO opined that, if authorized by MSO, LCO
shall keep customer application form in his custody, provide its stamped copy to the
subscriber and shall produce the copies/ information of customer application form and
other documents if demanded by MSO/any other Statutory Authority.
46. On the aspect to assign or transfer rights and obligation in respect of agreement, an LCO
association opined that the LCO is an independent business entity offering its network to
the MSO to pass through its services to the consumers. Its liability to the MSO is limited
to only the services provided jointly. The LCO does not require any permission to do its
business.
47. On the aspect of migration of an LCO from one MSO to the other MSO, the Authority
noted that the regulatory framework provides that the LCO can seek interconnection with
one or more MSOs and the interconnection between them is on non-exclusive basis.
However, LCO exiting the interconnection from the MSO must provide proper notice for
disconnection and reasons thereof in the terms of the Interconnection Regulations 2012 or
as applicable from time to time. Any LCO can migrate to the other MSOs provided that it
follows the provision laid down in the Interconnection Regulations. In view of the above,
the Authority is of the view that there is no need for introducing specific clause in this
regard.
48. On the aspect of replacing one MSO’s STB with the other’s STBs, The Authority noted
that the regulatory framework mandates that the service used by a subscriber cannot be
changed without written request from the subscriber. However the Party receiving the
request of disconnection from the subscriber shall update the information in the SMS
Page 74 of 85
within 24 hours. Therefore, the Authority is of the view that the LCO shall not replace
the STBs of one MSO with the STBs of any other MSO without receiving the request
from subscriber through disconnection application form. Accordingly, suitable clause has
been added in the MIA and SIA.
49. The regulatory framework for DAS provides that a customer may submit an application
for connection or shifting of connection in the specified format, in duplicate, duly signed
and complete in all respect, to the MSO or its linked LCO who shall return the duplicate
copy of the application to the applicant as an acknowledgment of receipt of application.
However, the Parties can mutually decide about the storage of original filled application
form. Accordingly, the clause may be added by mutual agreement in the MIA. However
the copy of customer application form shall be sent to the MSO within 15 days of receipt
from subscriber, the provision for which has already been provided in the MIA and the
SIA.
50. On the aspect of transfer of rights and obligation in respect of agreement, the Authority
recognizes both the Parties as independent business entities and each Party’s right of
freedom of business. Therefore, the Authority is of the view that the Parties are is free to
assign or transfer any of its rights or obligation, however while doing so the Party shall
give prior intimation to the other Party about the same so that the other Party can take
necessary action for protection of its interests. Accordingly, relevant clause has been
suitably modified in the MIA and the SIA.
Roles and Responsibility
51. In the draft agreements for consultation, comments of stakeholders were sought on
various aspects of roles and responsibilities between the MSO and the LCO. On the
aspect of devising format for application and publication of MOP, a cable operators
association suggested that the liberty to devise the application forms, MOP should be
provided to both MSOs & LCOs. On the aspect of complaint monitoring systems, some
MSO associations opined that the responsibility of establishment of complaint monitoring
system shall also be of LCO along with MSO as the LCOs directly deal with the
subscribers and are aware of the technical issues at their network. On the specification of
system of discounts due to interruption, an MSO association commented that the
responsibility to specify such scheme should be left upon on both MSO & LCO in
accordance with the QoS regulations, instead of only an MSO.
Page 75 of 85
52. On issue of Unique Identification Number (UIN), an MSO association & an MSO opined
that this should be the responsibility of the MSO as the SMS belongs to the MSO.
However LCO shall provide the same to consumer. An individual suggested that LCO
cannot perform this role as UIN is generated in the application server whose access is
restricted.
53. A cable operator association commented that the MSO’s responsibility on STB sale / hire
plans, service supports / stand by inventory / Service Level Agreement/ Annual
Maintenance Contract should also be specified. An individual commented that STB
procurement is the sole responsibility of the MSO and STBs should be a supplied to the
consumers via LCOs, giving proper documents i.e. invoice warranty or hire purchase
agreement etc. LCO should not be held responsible by MSO if a subscriber’s STB does
not function properly or becomes faulty requiring replacement/repair.
54. On advance notice of 15 days regarding discontinuing or disconnection of cable services
to the subscriber, an LCO association commented that this responsibility of providing
notice of 15 days regarding discontinuing or disconnection of cable service to the
subscriber should be of MSO. On receipt of request from subscribers for disconnection
of service, an individual commented that cable Operator cannot do it since they do not
have access to Application Server.
55. The Authority noted that the regulatory framework applicable for DAS provides enough
flexibility and ample freedom to the Parties to carry out their business. Simultaneously
the Authority observed that, in the relationship between the MSO and the LCO, the LCO
generally interacts with the subscribers for providing service to the subscribers whereas
the MSOs carryout functions which are dependent on the SMS and other associated
systems. To provide the flexibility to the Parties and at the same time to ensure that the
quality of service to the consumer is not compromised, the Authority is of the view that
that the Parties may enter into an interconnection agreement for provision of cable service
to the subscribers by mutually agreeing on the clauses of responsibilities listed under the
clause 10 of the MIA. The Parties, without altering or deleting any clause of MIA, may
add through mutual agreement additional clause to the MIA for stipulating any additional
conditions provided that no such conditions shall have the effect of diluting or nullifying
any of the conditions as laid down in the MIA. However, the Authority has demarcated
the responsibilities of each role in the SIA. In the SIA, LCOs have been given the
Page 76 of 85
consumer centric responsibilities whereas the MSOs have been given the responsibilities
which are directly linked with the SMS including billing for the subscribers.
56. On the aspect of devising format of the application form, the Authority observed that the
Head end along with the Conditional Access System (CAS) and SMS are installed and
maintained by the MSOs and also it is the MSO which enters into an interconnection
agreement for retransmission of TV channels of the broadcasters and therefore the pricing
of channels/packages and deciding the composition of packages remain with the MSOs.
The MSOs and the LCOs are free to devise formats of application for subscribers for
connection, disconnection, reconnection, transfer and shifting of cable TV connection and
for obtaining and returning of STBs. However, while devising such formats the
information relating to the pricing channels/packages, as decided by the MSO, are to be
included in Customer Application Form (CAF). In terms of MIA, the Parties can share the
responsibility of publicizing schemes for obtaining and returning of STB,
warranty/repairing policy, connection, disconnection, transfer and shifting of cable TV
services through mutual negotiation. In terms of SIA, the responsibility has been given to
the MSO. However, it has been provided that the MSO shall supply copies of such
published schemes to the LCOs for their information. Accordingly, relevant provisions
have been suitably modified in the MIA and SIA.
57. On the aspect of establishment of web based complaint monitoring system, the Authority
observed that in terms of the QOS Regulations 2012, overall responsibility of QoS norms
lies with the MSO. In terms of the QoS Regulation 2012, this responsibility can be shared
by the Parties in the interconnection agreements. Accordingly, the Authority is of the
view that the Parties can share the responsibility of setting up of complaint monitoring
system in terms of MIA. However in the SIA, this responsibility has been given to the
MSO.
58. On the aspect of specifying discount or rebate to the subscribers due to interruptions in
service, the Authority observed that since the responsibility of generation of bills for the
subscribers lies with the MSO and hence the MSO shall communicate to the LCO the
details of such schemes for communication to the subscribers. In SIA this responsibility
has been assigned to MSO. However the Parties can share this responsibility in the terms
of MIA.
Page 77 of 85
59. On the aspect of providing UIN to the applicant, the Authority observed that the UIN can
be generated automatically from the SMS. In the cases where the responsibility of issuing
UIN has been given to LCO, the MSO should ensure that the relevant access to the SMS
is provided to the LCO for carrying out its responsibility under the agreement. Where the
responsibility rests with MSO, the MSO shall provide the reading access to the LCO.
Accordingly, the relevant clauses have been suitably modified.
60. On the aspect of issuing of advance notice of 15 days regarding discontinuing or
disconnection of cable services to the subscriber, the Authority observed that in DAS, it
the MSO who can provide the information to the subscribers through scrolls about the
disconnection of cable TV services due to some reason or the other. The Authority is of
the view that the MSO shall intimate the LCO in writing before issuing such advance
notices to the subscribers. On the aspect of notice to the subscribers regarding disruption
of signals for preventive maintenance by the Parties, the Authority is of the view that if
the preventive maintenance is to be carried out by the LCO then the LCO shall inform the
MSO to enable it to give notice to the subscribers. This will ensure better quality of
service to the subscribers. Accordingly, suitable modification has been incorporated in the
MIA and the SIA.
Billing
61. A cable operator association commented that the MSO should generate bills in joint name
with respective LCO (reading as XXX Network powered by YYY MSO). The MSO shall
raise invoice on LCO on the basis of interconnection agreement terms along with
corresponding customer base consumption details every month. Another cable operator
association opined that the consolidated subscriber ID wise Billing should be given by the
MSO to LCO for making individual bills and no prepaid payments should be permitted.
An MSO association & some MSOs commented that the LCO should issue the bills and
receive subscription payments. A HITS operator stated that transfer pricing (where MSO
will raise the invoice to subscriber and handover it to the LCO and MSO will also raise
invoice/statement of account to LCO towards his share in the total amount so that LCO
will pay MSO on actual basis) should be implemented. A broadcaster has commented
that the MSOs should communicate the billing for the period to subscribers and also set
up terminals either with themselves or with LCOs for enabling recharge by subscribers or
the LCOs as this will facilitate prompt collection and also encourage prepaid billing.
Page 78 of 85
62. On payment of taxes, an MSO association & an MSO have stated that ‘as per applicable
rules and regulations of the respective tax authorities’ should be added. And it should be
responsibility of either MSO or LCO as jointly both of them cannot be held liable at the
same time. An LCO association opined that the specific details of tax payment
responsibilities need to be filled in the adjoining cells at the time of signing of the
agreement as per the rules and regulations of the respective tax authorities. Whereas
another LCO association commented that entity that generates the bill should pay the
taxes.
63. From the above mentioned comments of the stakeholders, one thing is very clear that the
billing of subscribers can be done in different methods and different parties have different
expectations/ requirements. What is common is that every stakeholder is interested in
proper identification of billing responsibility assigned to each Party. Keeping in view the
response of the stakeholders associated with the issue and the QoS Regulations 2012, the
adequate flexibility has been provided in the MIA. It is up to the Parties to decide about
the name of the Party(ies) to be printed on the bills. In the MIA, the Parties can add
further clauses as per their requirement. However, it should be noted that even in case
where the name of the LCO appears on the bill, the service tax registration number and
entertainment tax registration number of MSO must be printed on the bill as mandated by
the QoS Regulations 2012 and applicable rules and regulations of the respective tax
authorities must be complied with. In SIA, the bills shall be issued in the name of the
MSO.
64. The QoS Regulation 2012 provides that every MSO shall be responsible for generation of
bills for the subscribers and this responsibility cannot be shared with the LCO. The
overall responsibility of delivery of bills and receipts to the subscribers lies with the
MSO. However, in cases of mutual agreement, the Parties can share the responsibility of
delivery of bills and receipts to the subscribers. The Parties can also share the
responsibility of receiving and collecting subscription amount from the subscribers and in
such cases the concerned Party (LCO or MSO as the case may be) shall update the
information in the SMS in accordance with the regulations/ directions issued by the
Authority from time to time. In case of Parties entering into interconnection agreement
through SIA, the responsibility of the providing of bills and receipts and entry of details
of payments in to SMS lies with the MSO.
Page 79 of 85
65. In terms of the QoS Regulation, 2012 the bill should contain the details of subscription
amount, applicable taxes, such as service tax, entertainment tax etc., along with the rate of
taxes levied. The Authority observed that obligation of the tax compliance differs from
state to state with respect to entertainment tax. Therefore, the Authority is of the view that
because of the reasons mentioned above it is not possible to fix the responsibility of tax
compliance on a particular Party. Therefore, the Authority has kept it open to the Parties
to decide the tax payment responsibilities in accordance with their applicable tax laws and
regulations in their respective states. The specific details of tax payment responsibilities
need to be filled in clause 10 under the ‘roles and responsibilities’ at the time of signing
of the agreement as per the rules and regulations of the respective tax authorities.
66. In order to maintain the accounting records, the Authority is of the view that the Party, in
whose name the billing for subscribers have been agreed, should receive the payment of
the subscription fee paid by the subscribers and invoice should be raised by the other
Party for getting its revenue share. Accordingly, suitable provision has been incorporated
in the MIA.
Revenue Settlement
67. An LCO association commented the term revenue share should be defined in detail and
should be shared by all stake holders as broadcasters generate revenue from subscription
from MSOs and advertisements, MSOs generate revenue from carriage fee, placement
fee, advertisement fee and revenue from LCOs but LCOs generate revenue only from
subscription. Another LCO association suggested that the revenue definition (including
customer billing, placement fee and advertising income) may be mutually decided by
MSO and LCO.
68. An LCO association opined that the revenue share should be like CAS Model and MRP
of Pay channels should be declared for the consumers as done for CAS regime where
FTA revenue was given 100% to the LCO as his basic service charges. Another LCO
association commented that the subscription revenue sharing should be mutually decided
between MSO & LCO.
69. Each stakeholder in the value chain can have multiple sources of revenue. Even LCOs
can generate additional revenue by using the same network for providing broadband
services either independently or in association with MSO/ Internet Service Providers
Page 80 of 85
(ISP), other emerging value added services like home surveillance etc. Combining all
sources of revenues for settlement purpose is possible only in the case of integrated
entities and not among the independent entities, as is the case under consideration. The
MIA and SIA are to be signed on principal to principal basis. Each entity should be able
to compete in the market on standalone basis. And therefore it is important that the parties
should mutually decide on specific amounts either in absolute terms or in percentage
terms or a combination of the two, independent of sources of revenue, keeping in view
the sharing of responsibilities and market conditions. Therefore the request of the
stakeholders regarding definition of the term 'revenue' cannot be acceded to.
70. The regulatory frame work already provides that the revenue settlement is to be decided
through mutual agreement. The Tariff order prescribes the manner in which the revenue
share will be done on failure of mutual agreement between the Parties. Therefore, the
Authority is of the view that the Parties should mutually decide the revenue settlement
and its modalities depending upon the responsibilities shared between them. All the
activities to be carried out by the Parties are to be clearly defined in the interconnection
agreement entered between them and the revenue share and modalities of revenue
settlement between the Parties are also be clearly defined in the terms of MIA. In terms of
SIA, the MSO shall share the complete information relating to the subscribers billing and
receipt of the payments with the LCO. The LCO shall issue monthly invoice to the MSO
towards dues payable by the MSO for revenue settlement.
Defaults
71. On the aspect of default in payment by Parties, a cable operators association and an MSO
suggested that the simple rate of interest shall be the base rate of interest of SBI plus 4%.
Another cable operator association opined that a penal clause should be included against
the MSO or the broadcaster if they fail to prove the default in payment. An MSO
association commented that in case of two consecutive defaults by the LCO on revenue
settlement, MSO may ask the LCO to deposit an advance.
72. The Authority is of the view that reasonable disincentives should be levied to discourage
the delay/ default in the payment. The Authority decided the interest rate of 2% over and
above the base rate of SBI is reasonable and accordingly the provision has been made in
the MIA and SIA.
Page 81 of 85
73. The Authority observed that the issue of default in payment is one of the main reasons
which lead to the dispute between the Parties. To address this problem, the Authority is of
the view that in cases where any of the Parties has failed to make payment on or before
due date for three consecutive months in the past, the other Party shall have right to
demand the interest free security deposit which shall not exceed average of immediately
preceding 6 months billing amounts and the same shall be maintained for the remaining
term of the agreement. Accordingly, suitable clauses have been added in the MIA and the
SIA.
Undertaking
74. An MSO association, some MSOs and an individual commented that LCO should be
referred as a franchise of MSO for the use of logo.
75. The Authority observed that the MSO and the LCO are independent registered entities
and any LCO can carry signals of one or more MSOs through its network. And therefore,
the Authority is of the view that there is no requirement of referring one Party as
franchise of the other Party. The roles and responsibilities of each Party must be defined
in the agreement.
Prevention of Piracy
76. Controlling the piracy is one of the prime concerns of the sector. An MSO urged that a
harsh penalty should be levied. A broadcaster and a broadcasting foundation have
suggested that the disconnection should be allowed instantly, if piracy is found out, given
that the MSOs should submit appropriate proofs of piracy.
77. The Authority noted that sufficient protection has been provided to the both the Parties in
the model and standard interconnection agreement framework as well as in the Cable TV
Networks (Regulation) Act, 1995. Therefore the Authority is of the view that there is no
requirement of such clause in the MIA and the SIA.
Disclaimer, Indemnity & Dispute Resolution
78. An LCO association commented that since TDSAT is situated only in Delhi and LCOs
are present in far flung areas, it is not possible to approach TDSAT in time. LCOs must
be permitted to approach local courts for a remedy. The TRAI Act must be amended
accordingly so that LCOs in far off areas can get immediate relief in their respective
Page 82 of 85
states. An individual commented that an arbitration clause should be incorporated in the
Agreement.
79. On the aspect of jurisdiction of local court and setting up of the TDSAT benches, the
Authority is of the view that the issue raised by the stakeholder is not a subject matter of
consultation. As far as the arbitration clause is concerned, the TRAI Act envisages
handling of disputes between the service providers by Hon’ble TDSAT. The Authority is
of the view that no separate arbitrator is required in case of dispute between the service
providers.
Force Majeure & Notices
80. An MSO association & some MSOs commented that provision should be provided that
notice can also be served on mails or through courier and first class couriers.
81. The Authority noted the suggestion and the relevant clause have been suitably modified
to include speed post as one method of sending notice.
82. The Authority observed that in case of revocation of registration of any Party, the other
Party shall have right to terminate the interconnection agreement. Therefore, the force
majeure clause should also include this situation in the MIA and SIA. Accordingly,
suitable amendment has been made in the SIA and the MIA under force majeure clause.
Restriction on Transfer
83. An LCO association opined that it should be restricted to the extent where the network
facilities of each other are being shared and used.
84. Both the LCO and MSO are independent entities registered for providing cable TV
services and they are the owner of their networks / systems and this clause is in line of the
same.
General Comments
85. An LCO association commented that the MSO should provide at least 2 to 3 spare
frequencies to LCO for local programs and DD Channels in case of failure of
transmission provided by MSO. The association also commented that prior to any change
by MSO in channel packaging, the LCO should be informed.
Page 83 of 85
86. An LCO Association stated that the language of agreement must be in English as well as
Hindi or local language.
87. An LCO Association opined that the another sub-clause ‘Co-operation And Co-ordination
Between MSO & LCO’ should be added in the interconnection agreement which binds
the Parties to achieve success in the business in the Digitization mode and shared unity of
purpose to deliver best service and content to the Cable TV Subscribers to uphold
digitization.
88. On the aspect of sparing of 2 to 3 frequencies to the LCO for transmission of FTA
channels and Doordarshan channels are concerned, the Authority noted that in DAS, it is
the MSO who can downlink and re-transmit the signals of TV channels in encrypted
form. Regarding the insertion of channels by LCOs in DAS area, the Authority is of the
view that the Parties may work out any appropriate and technologically feasible
arrangement to ensure the transmission of such channels in a digitally addressable
encrypted format in line with existing regulatory provisions. The Parties through mutual
agreement may include additional terms without prejudice to the existing provisions of
the Cable TV Act 1995 and Rules or as amended from time to time.
89. On the aspect of language of the Agreement, the Authority is of the view that both the
Parties may agree to sign a bilingual agreement in which one language must be English.
In the event of dispute on the interpretation of the clause, the English version of the
agreement shall prevail.
90. The Authority observed that through the interconnection agreement, the Parties decide
upon their rights, obligation, roles and responsibilities with an aim to provide the services
to the subscribers in terms of the intent of the regulations. The Authority is of the view
that the interconnecting Parties are independent entities and therefore inclusion of a
clause on “Co-operation and Co-ordination” in the MIA and SIA is not required.
91. The Authority has observed in the past that on many occasions the business transaction
between MSOs and LCOs are not carried out in writing and mostly they are done on oral
basis which results in frequent disputes between them. Therefore, the Authority is of the
view that the Parties must agree that each and every transaction including movable and
immovable properties/assets between the Parties shall be carried out in writing or any
Page 84 of 85
other verifiable means. Accordingly, suitable clause has been added in the MIA and the
SIA.
Rationale for amendment in the Regulation to incorporate the provisions for MIA and the SIA
92. The Authority observed that the Interconnection Regulation, 2012 requires amendment for
incorporating the provisions of the MIA and the SIA.
93. In terms of the Cable Television Networks (Regulation) Act, 1995 and the Cable TV
Rules made thereunder, the MSO can provide the signals of TV channels directly to the
subscriber or through one or more linked LCOs. The LCO is the registered entity for
providing cable TV services to the subscribers. In the Interconnection Regulation 2012,
the LCOs have been given right to receive signals of TV channels from the MSO.
However, the LCO is required to make a written request to the MSO for getting the
signal. The MSO must provide signals of TV channels after execution of written
interconnection agreement. In this amendment, the Authority has mandated that the
interconnection agreement shall be entered into by the Parties in terms of MIA or the SIA,
as the case may be, within 30 days from the date of receipt of written request from the
LCO and, in line with the existing provisions, the signals of TV channels shall be
provided to the LCO within 60 days from the date of receipt of written request.
Accordingly, amendments have been made in the regulations.
94. The Interconnection Regulation, 2012 provides that the MSOs and LCOs shall enter into
the interconnection agreement before provision of cable TV services to the subscribers.
The Parties may enter into an interconnection agreement on lines of the MIA or by
signing the agreement strictly in terms of SIA. The MIA is primarily a format of
interconnection agreement that enables the Parties to have a mutual agreement in a
structured manner in line with the regulatory framework. As per the industry practice
normally the Parties negotiate their commercial terms in terms of (i) sharing of
responsibilities, (ii) billing and/or (iii) revenue settlement. The amendment provides full
flexibility on these aspects as the Parties can enter into written interconnection agreement
by modifying clauses 10 (roles and responsibilities), 11 (billing) and/or 12 (revenue
settlement) of the MIA. They also have a freedom to add additional clauses through
mutual agreement to the MIA for stipulating any additional conditions. However it has
been mandated that the Parties shall ensure that no such addition shall have the effect of
Page 85 of 85
diluting any of the conditions laid down in the MIA. In this manner, the freedom of
contract within the regulatory framework has still been continued. This will help the
Parties to assert its rights and obligations provided to them by the regulatory framework
and avoid disputes. If the Parties fail to mutually agree on MIA, then they can enter into
interconnection agreement on the terms of SIA, where no addition, alteration and deletion
of the clauses provided therein is allowed. Accordingly sub-regulation 14 of regulation 3
and sub-regulation 13 of regulation 5 have been amended incorporating schedules IV and
V providing Model Interconnection Agreement and Standard Interconnection Agreement.
95. The sub-regulation 15 and 16 of the regulation 3 of the Interconnection Regulations, 2012
prescribes modalities of revenue settlement. It provides that MSO shall raise an invoice to
the LCO clearly specifying the current payment dues and arrears if any. The
responsibility of raising the invoice by one Party to the other Party depends upon the
nature of commercial arrangement between the Parties. Since the terms of revenue
settlement in MIA has been left to the Parties for mutual negotiations, the responsibility
of raising invoice would vary depending upon the mutually agreed arrangement by the
Parties. In view of this, the Authority has decided to delete these sub-regulations.
Therefore, with this amendment, the Parties can either mutually decide this responsibility
as per MIA or enter into SIA wherein this responsibility is assigned to MSO in the
revenue settlement clause.
96. In this amendment the Authority has prescribed a time period of 30 days for the MSO to
give an option to its existing linked LCOs to modify their existing interconnection
agreements as per SIA or MIA. It is open to the LCO to modify their existing agreement
in terms of MIA or the SIA or continue with the existing agreement till its expiry. All new
agreements shall be done based on prescribed MIA or SIA as the case may be. Pursuant
to the option, where the written request for modification of existing agreement is received
from the LCO, the MSO shall modify the existing interconnection agreement is
accordance with the MIA or SIA within 30 days.
97. The Authority is of the view that the prescription of the MIA and the SIA will pave the
way for growth of the sector, help in reduction of disputes between the MSOs and LCOs,
provide level playing field to the Parties and increase healthy competition in the sector
which ultimately will help in better quality of service to the subscribers.
***
<<
/ASCII85EncodePages false
/AllowTransparency false
/AutoPositionEPSFiles true
/AutoRotatePages /All
/Binding /Left
/CalGrayProfile (Dot Gain 20%)
/CalRGBProfile (sRGB IEC61966-2.1)
/CalCMYKProfile (U.S. Web Coated \050SWOP\051 v2)
/sRGBProfile (sRGB IEC61966-2.1)
/CannotEmbedFontPolicy /Warning
/CompatibilityLevel 1.4
/CompressObjects /Tags
/CompressPages true
/ConvertImagesToIndexed true
/PassThroughJPEGImages true
/CreateJDFFile false
/CreateJobTicket false
/DefaultRenderingIntent /Default
/DetectBlends true
/ColorConversionStrategy /LeaveColorUnchanged
/DoThumbnails false
/EmbedAllFonts true
/EmbedJobOptions true
/DSCReportingLevel 0
/EmitDSCWarnings false
/EndPage -1
/ImageMemory 1048576
/LockDistillerParams false
/MaxSubsetPct 100
/Optimize true
/OPM 1
/ParseDSCComments true
/ParseDSCCommentsForDocInfo true
/PreserveCopyPage true
/PreserveEPSInfo true
/PreserveHalftoneInfo false
/PreserveOPIComments false
/PreserveOverprintSettings true
/StartPage 1
/SubsetFonts true
/TransferFunctionInfo /Apply
/UCRandBGInfo /Preserve
/UsePrologue false
/ColorSettingsFile ()
/AlwaysEmbed [ true
]
/NeverEmbed [ true
]
/AntiAliasColorImages false
/DownsampleColorImages true
/ColorImageDownsampleType /Bicubic
/ColorImageResolution 300
/ColorImageDepth -1
/ColorImageDownsampleThreshold 1.50000
/EncodeColorImages true
/ColorImageFilter /DCTEncode
/AutoFilterColorImages true
/ColorImageAutoFilterStrategy /JPEG
/ColorACSImageDict <<
/QFactor 0.15
/HSamples [1 1 1 1] /VSamples [1 1 1 1]
>>
/ColorImageDict <<
/QFactor 0.15
/HSamples [1 1 1 1] /VSamples [1 1 1 1]
>>
/JPEG2000ColorACSImageDict <<
/TileWidth 256
/TileHeight 256
/Quality 30
>>
/JPEG2000ColorImageDict <<
/TileWidth 256
/TileHeight 256
/Quality 30
>>
/AntiAliasGrayImages false
/DownsampleGrayImages true
/GrayImageDownsampleType /Bicubic
/GrayImageResolution 300
/GrayImageDepth -1
/GrayImageDownsampleThreshold 1.50000
/EncodeGrayImages true
/GrayImageFilter /DCTEncode
/AutoFilterGrayImages true
/GrayImageAutoFilterStrategy /JPEG
/GrayACSImageDict <<
/QFactor 0.15
/HSamples [1 1 1 1] /VSamples [1 1 1 1]
>>
/GrayImageDict <<
/QFactor 0.15
/HSamples [1 1 1 1] /VSamples [1 1 1 1]
>>
/JPEG2000GrayACSImageDict <<
/TileWidth 256
/TileHeight 256
/Quality 30
>>
/JPEG2000GrayImageDict <<
/TileWidth 256
/TileHeight 256
/Quality 30
>>
/AntiAliasMonoImages false
/DownsampleMonoImages true
/MonoImageDownsampleType /Bicubic
/MonoImageResolution 1200
/MonoImageDepth -1
/MonoImageDownsampleThreshold 1.50000
/EncodeMonoImages true
/MonoImageFilter /CCITTFaxEncode
/MonoImageDict <<
/K -1
>>
/AllowPSXObjects false
/PDFX1aCheck false
/PDFX3Check false
/PDFXCompliantPDFOnly false
/PDFXNoTrimBoxError true
/PDFXTrimBoxToMediaBoxOffset [
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
]
/PDFXSetBleedBoxToMediaBox true
/PDFXBleedBoxToTrimBoxOffset [
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
]
/PDFXOutputIntentProfile ()
/PDFXOutputCondition ()
/PDFXRegistryName (http://www.color.org)
/PDFXTrapped /Unknown
/Description <<
/FRA <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>
/ENU (Use these settings to create PDF documents with higher image resolution for improved printing quality. The PDF documents can be opened with Acrobat and Reader 5.0 and later.)
/JPN <FEFF3053306e8a2d5b9a306f30019ad889e350cf5ea6753b50cf3092542b308000200050004400460020658766f830924f5c62103059308b3068304d306b4f7f75283057307e30593002537052376642306e753b8cea3092670059279650306b4fdd306430533068304c3067304d307e305930023053306e8a2d5b9a30674f5c62103057305f00200050004400460020658766f8306f0020004100630072006f0062006100740020304a30883073002000520065006100640065007200200035002e003000204ee5964d30678868793a3067304d307e30593002>
/DEU <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>
/PTB <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>
/DAN <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>
/NLD <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>
/ESP <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>
/SUO <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>
/ITA <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>
/NOR <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>
/SVE <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>
>>
>> setdistillerparams
<<
/HWResolution [2400 2400]
/PageSize [612.000 792.000]
>> setpagedevice
Previous and next
Questions people ask
Is annexure TO SCHEDULE II of Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) Regulations, 2012. still in force?
No repeal of Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) Regulations, 2012. is recorded.