Annexure TO SCHEDULE II, Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) Regulations, 2012.: ANNEXURE TO SCHEDULE II
Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) Regulations, 2012. - Annexure TO SCHEDULE II
Text of annexure TO SCHEDULE II
ANNEXURE TO SCHEDULE II
ANNEXURE TO SCHEDULE II
LICENCE FEE RATES
(A) A LA CARTE RATES
Channels
Rate to multi system operator
(Rs.)
33
(B) BOUQUET RATES
BOUQUET – 1
Channels
Rate to multi system
operator (Rs)
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
BOUQUET- 2
Channels
Rate to multi system
operator (Rs)
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
34
6.
BOUQUET 3
Channels
Rate to multi system
operator (Rs)
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
35
Schedule – III
Performa for reporting by Multi System Operator of interconnect agreements entered into by them with
Broadcasters & Local Cable Operators
Column
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
S. No Name of
contracting
parties
Complete
Address of
party with
District,
State, Pin
Code and
telephone
number
Service
Area of
Operation
Name of the
Bouquet with
Number of
channels
Rate of
bouquet
Subscriber
Base ( Month
wise w.e.f.
July of the
previous year
and upto June
of the current
year )
Name of a-la-
carte Channel
& Number of
channels
Rate of a-
la-carte
channel
Column
10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
Discount,
if any
Subscriber
Base ( Month
wise w.e.f.
July of the
previous year
and upto June
of the current
year )
IRD/VC No.
- Channel
Wise
Term of
IRD
Agreement
Number with
date
Date of
Commence-
ment of the
agreement
Date of expiry
of the
agreement
Carriage fee
paid by the
broadcaster
Remarks,
if any
Page 36 of 45
Annexure
Explanatory Memorandum
I. Background
1. On 10.12.2004, TRAI made an interconnection regulation applicable for broadcasting
and cable TV sector. The regulation was called the “Telecommunication (Broadcasting and
Cable Services) Interconnection Regulation 2004 (13 of 2004)”. There have been six
amendments made to this regulation.
2. The interconnection regulations provide for the basic structure on the matters of
interconnection. These regulations cover arrangements among service providers for
interconnection and revenue share, for all broadcasting and cable services. The main features
of the regulations are: provision of ‘must provide’ (i.e. non discriminatory access) for the
broadcasters and the provision for ‘disconnection of TV signals’. The regulations prescribe
notice period for disconnection. In the notice for disconnection, the reasons for disconnection
are to be given. No notice for disconnection is required if there is no written agreement
permitting distribution of signals. For the information of the consumers, it has been provided
that the notice for disconnection should be published in newspapers in accordance with the
relevant provisions of the regulations. These regulations also provide for publishing of
Reference Interconnect Offer by broadcasters for non-addressable as well as addressable
cable TV systems.
3. In the last few years, the exponential growth in the number of TV channels (both Free
To Air and Pay) combined with the inherent limitations of the analogue cable TV systems,
has posed several challenges in the cable TV sector, mainly due to capacity constraints and
non-addressable nature of the network. With time and evolution of technology, new
addressable digital TV platforms like DTH, IPTV etc. were introduced to the masses. The
evolution of technology also paved way for bringing about digitization with addressability in
the cable TV sector. Accordingly, after studying the subject at length and undertaking a
public consultation process, the Authority, on 5th August 2010, gave its recommendations on
implementation of Digital Addressable Cable TV Systems (DAS) across the country along
with a roadmap to achieve the same.
Page 37 of 45
4. The Government, on 25th October, 2011, issued an Ordinance amending the Cable
Television Networks (Regulation) Act, 1995, paving way for the implementation of digital
addressable cable TV systems in India. Thereafter, the Government also issued a notification
dated 11th November, 2011, which laid down the roadmap for implementation, in a four
phased manner, from June 2012 to December, 2014. The Ordinance dated 25th October,
2011, subsequently, in December, 2011, became an Act.
5. Considering the amended provisions of the Cable Television Networks (Regulation) Act,
1995, and the notification dated 11.11.2011 mentioned above, the Authority initiated a
consultation process on the issues relating to implementation of digital addressable cable TV
systems. In this connection a consultation paper titled “Issues related to Implementation of
Digital Addressable Cable TV Systems” was issued on 22.12.2011. The issues for
consultation related to the amendments to the existing interconnection regulations, the
subscription revenue share between the MSO and LCO, whether “must carry” provision
should be mandated for the MSOs, whether the carriage fee is to be regulated and whether
there should be a specified standard interconnection agreement between service providers
applicable for DAS areas. An Open House Discussion (OHD) was also held in New Delhi on
13th March, 2012.
II. Analysis of issues
6. The following is a summary of main issues, comments of the stakeholders and analysis
thereon.
Note: To make it convenient for ease of reference and understanding by all the stakeholders,
the instant regulations consolidate all the earlier interconnection regulations and the
regulations now made are applicable for digital addressable cable TV systems.
A. Suggested Amendments to Interconnection Regulations
The issue for consideration was whether any of the existing clauses of the Interconnection
Regulations require modifications.
Page 38 of 45
7. During the course of the consultation process, broadcasters/aggregators suggested
modifications in certain clauses of the existing interconnection regulations such as
reduction in notice period for disconnection of signals, procedure for auditing of the
Subscriber Management System (SMS) of the service provider and on the technical side it
was suggest that a provision be made in the interconnection regulations for integration of
SMS and the Conditional Access System (CAS) so as to ensure complete addressability of
the system. It was also suggested that the provisions may be made in the regulations for anti
piracy and fingerprinting measures and for making provision for filing of interconnect
agreements by MSOs/LCOs and also a provision for minimum period of subscription. It was
also suggested that clause 3.2 of the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services)
Interconnection Regulation, 2004, relating to “must provide” may also be qualified by
making it inoperative in cases of service providers who have failed to comply with any of the
regulations. It was also suggested by the stakeholders that certain definitions in the existing
interconnection regulation may be required to be amended to bring them in line with the
provisions of Cable Television Act as amended in 2011. Some MSOs expressed the view that
they are not in favor of any modification in existing clauses. Some of the LCOs have
suggested that there is a need to amend the clauses of interconnection regulations relating to
the notice period for disconnection and for making provisions for revenue sharing
arrangements.
8. On the issue of filing of interconnect agreements by the MSOs, the Authority considered
the suggestion and decided to incorporate a provision in this regard in this regulation so as to
bring in the transparency in the system. A provision has been made in this regulation for
reporting the details of interconnect agreements by the MSOs along with the details of
carriage fee paid by the broadcasters. The reporting requirement, prescribed in the present
regulations, makes a provision for the broadcasters to file the details of carriage fee paid by
them. On the issue of amendments to definitions, the definitions such as “addressable
system”, “broadcaster”, “cable operator”, “multi system operator”, “pay channel” and
"subscriber management system" have been aligned with that of the amended Cable
Television Networks (Regulation) Act, 1995 and also the amended Cable Television
Networks Rules, 1994. On the issue of minimum period of subscription, a provision has been
made in the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable) Services (Digital Addressable
Cable TV Areas) Tariff Order, 2012. On the issue of Notice period for disconnection, the
Authority considered the fact that the notice period should be sufficient for the affected
Page 39 of 45
parties to be able to approach the appropriate forum to plead for intervention and to give the
consumers an opportunity to approach the necessary forum. The Authority, therefore, decided
that the existing period of the notice of 21 days is to be retained. On the suggestion of the
audit of SMS, the Authority considered the fact that the existing provisions of the
interconnect regulations provide for upto two audits in a calendar year. The Authority felt
that this is sufficient opportunity for audit and, therefore, decided that there is no need to
modify the existing provisions in this regard. On the issue of integration of SMS and CAS,
the Authority observed that the existing interconnection framework provides for integration
of SMS and CA system for activation and deactivation process from SMS to be
simultaneously done through both the systems. The Authority is of the view that this
provision is adequate and therefore no change is required. On the issue of Anti Piracy and
fingerprinting the Authority observed that the existing framework provides that operator shall
deploy finger printing mechanisms to detect any piracy, violation of copyright and
unauthorized viewing of the Channels, distributed / transmitted through its platform. The
Authority is of the view that this provision is adequate and therefore no change is required on
this issue. On the issue of Qualified “Must Provide”, the Authority observed that the
violations of regulations are to be dealt with as per the provisions of the TRAI Act, 1997.
The Authority is, therefore, of the view that no further qualifications are required in this
provision.
B. The “Must Carry” provision
9. The issue is that should the ‘must carry’ provision be mandated for the MSO. If so, what
should be the qualifying conditions and the manner in which an MSO should offer access to
its network for the carriage of TV channel. The majority of the broadcasters are in favour of
mandating must carry provisions to balance out the ‘must provide’ clause prescribed in the
existing interconnect regulations. They have suggested that the manner of offering network
access should be on a non-discriminatory basis and the qualifying conditions may include
openness to audit & transparency, non-discriminatory listing of channels and all channels
should feature genre-wise in the EPG of MSO. One broadcaster has also suggested that the
‘must carry’ provisions need not be mandated.
10. Majority of the MSOs and LCOs have suggested that there should not be any must
carry provision. Some of them have suggested that it can be mandated only for DD channels.
Regarding the manner, one LCO has suggested that Carriage fee should be the qualifying
Page 40 of 45
condition for all ‘must carry’ channels except Doordarshan channels. Few LCOs have
supported the must carry provision and stated that it should be regulated by TRAI. Other
stakeholders who have offered their comments are not in favour of ‘must carry’ provision.
11. In the digital transmission environment, the capacity to carry the channels is very high.
So one of the main advantages of a digital environment to the subscriber is the availability of
large number of channels. However, there is a component of cost to carry channels. If the
operator is compensated for the cost of carriage of a channel, there should not be any
technological or other infrastructural constraints for the operator to carry a channel. Further,
as per the Cable Television Networks (Amendment) Rules, 2012, the channel carrying
capacity of the multi system operator is to be specified by the Authority.
12. The analysis of the operational channels (Annexure-A attached with this Explanatory
Memorandum) shows that the maximum number of channels that are relevant to a State or
Union Territory, language-wise, are 473 (in Andhra Pradesh) out of the 650 operational
private channels (as on April, 2012). Besides this there are 18 channels of the Prasar Bharati
and one Lok Sabha channel (in total 19 channels) that may also be relevant for all the States
and the UTs to cater to the infotainment requirements of minority populace of these States
and UTs. It is also noted that the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting has granted
permission to 831 channels under uplinking/downlinking guidelines, as on 6th March, 2012.
It is also likely that certain more channels may get operational by 1.1.2013. Thus, it is
logical that maximum number of channels that may be required to be carried in a digital
addressable cable TV system network, for present, is taken as 500 channels per headend.
Therefore, the present regulations provide for creating a capacity of 500 channels per
headend by 1.1.2013. Further, it has been seen that there are two types of MSOs viz., large
sized MSOs having subscriber base of more than 25,000 subscribers with upper limit
running into lakhs of subscribers and smaller MSOs having around 25,000 subscribers or
lesser number of subscribers. Due to the larger size of operations, the large sized MSOs are
better equipped to have the capacity to set up digital addressable cable TV systems in lesser
time than the smaller sized MSOs. Therefore, to provide more time to smaller MSOs to
create capacity of 500 channels per head end, the time line has been prescribed as 1st April,
2013 and for the large sized MSOs, the time line has been kept as 1st January, 2013.
However, considering the fact that the four metros of Delhi, Mumbai, Kolkata and Chennai
are to go digital on 1st July, 2012, and many of the MSOs may not be able to create a capacity
Page 41 of 45
to carry a minimum 500 channels per headend by this date, in the first instant, they have been
allowed to operate with a minimum capacity of 200 channels per headend.
13. To allow the multi system operator to provide the access to its cable network smoothly, a
time frame of sixty (60) days has been provided for in the regulations which is equivalent to
the time frame given to the broadcaster under the must provide provisions. In no case this
time period be more than sixty days (60 days) from the date of request seeking access to the
network of the multi system operator.
14. A responsibility has also been cast upon the broadcaster or the access seeker to the cable
network of the MSO under the provisions of ‘must carry’ to ensure the subscription of the
channel at a minimum level of more than or equal to five per cent. (5%) of the subscriber
base of that MSO taken on an average of subscriber base for the preceding six months. In
case of failure to maintain this subscriber base, the network provider, in his discretion, can
refuse to grant further access to the network for a period of next one year. Such a refusal
would not be considered a violation of the “Must carry” provision.
C. “Carriage fee”
15. The issues are should the carriage fee be regulated and if so, should its quantum be linked
to some parameters. News Broadcaster Association is of the view that carriage fee should be
regulated. This Association is of the view that if must carry is mandated, the question of
carriage fee does not arise. Majority of the broadcasters and one association of broadcasters
are not in favor of regulating the carriage fee and have suggested that it should be based on
the mutual negotiation between the broadcaster and MSO. Few who favored suggested that
the parameters can be the subscriber base of the MSO, number of STB installed etc. One of
the broadcaster suggested that carriage fee should not exceed 10% of the subscription fee
collected for the channels not covered under the must carry mandatory clause.
16. MSOs are not in favor of any kind of regulatory intervention on carriage fee. Most of the
LCOs are not in favor of regulating the carriage fee. Some of the LCOs suggested that the
carriage fee should be regulated and can be linked with the no. of STBs installed, gross
collection of subscription amount, size and locality of the network etc. Some LCOs are
suggesting that LCO should also get a part from the carriage fee.
Page 42 of 45
17. In the addressable systems, due to transparency in ascertaining the number of
subscribers, the subscription revenue is expected to go up. Therefore, the dependence of
MSOs on the carriage fee, as a source of revenue, is likely to be reduced. Considering all the
aspects, the Authority is of the view that there is a need to regulate the carriage fee.
Accordingly, the following scheme has been worked out. The MSOs who charge carriage fee
are required to declare the carriage fee for carrying a TV channel. The carriage fee shall be
charged in a non-discriminatory and transparent manner. Also the carriage fee can not be
revised upward for a minimum period of 2 years. The details of the carriage fee is to be filed
with the Authority. In case the Authority finds it necessary, it shall intervene and ask for
appropriate modifications in the carriage fee.
D. Standard Interconnect Agreement (SIA)
18. The issue is whether TRAI prescribe a standard interconnection agreement between
service providers. Nearly half of the broadcasters who offered their comments on the issue
are not in favour of prescribing SIA by the Authority whereas others are in favour of SIA
prescription by the Authority. Those who favoured, suggested that the piracy and termination
clauses should be reviewed.
19. MSOs are in favour of SIA prescription by the Authority except for one MSO who has
suggested that RIO based mechanism, has worked well for DTH sector, so it should be
extended to DAS. Majority of LCOs are in favour of SIA whereas some of them have
suggested that there is no immediate requirement of SIA.
20. The Authority is of the view that as the interconnection regulations already provide for
the necessary regulatory framework for addressable systems, in the form of RIO, which were
not there in the year 2006 when SIA was prescribed for CAS, there is no need for prescribing
Standard Interconnect Agreement between Broadcaster and MSO and also between MSO and
LCO in the Digital Addressable Cable TV System. The Authority is of the view that the
RIO based prescription should prevail in DAS also.
E. Advertisement free (ad-free) channels
21. The issues are what should be the provisions in the interconnection regulations in respect
of advertisement free channels and what should be the revenue sharing arrangement between
the broadcasters and distributors in respect of such channels. Some broadcasters and an MSO
Page 43 of 45
stated that existing requirements/stipulations of Interconnect Regulations, viz. ‘must provide’
should not apply to advertisement free channels and the broadcasters & respective service
providers should be free to enter into agreements on mutually acceptable terms in order to
provide incentives to all the players in the value chain to create, develop and market new
innovative and non-mass-market advertisement based television content. Majority of other
stakeholders, who have responded to these issues, say that the provisions of the existing
interconnection regulations should be applicable to advertisement free channels also so that
consumers are not deprived of such channels. Some cable operators are of the view that
provisions of the interconnection regulations as applicable to the notified CAS areas should
be applied for the advertisement free channels. As far as the sharing of the subscription
revenue of the ad-free channels is concerned, all the broadcasters have expressed the views
that it should be left for the commercial negotiations between the service providers. Some of
the other stakeholders have suggested that revenue share be decided in the same way as any
other pay channel while others have suggested different percentages for broadcaster, MSO
and LCO, however, without any justification for this suggestion.
22. The issue of rates of advertisement free channels and sharing of subscription revenues
of such channels has been dealt with by separately in the provisions of the
Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable) Services (Fourth) (Addressable Systems)
Tariff (First Amendment) Order, 2012. Authority is of the view that there is no need to
change the existing policy of leaving it to the market forces. To prevent denial of the signals
of the channels by the broadcaster to the MSO or denial by the MSO to carry the channels,
such channels can not be mandated to be outside of the purview of the clauses on ‘must
provide’ and ‘must carry’ of the interconnection regulations as this would not be in the
interests of the consumers.
*******
Page 44 of 45
Annexure-A
State‐wise/UT‐wise maximum number of TV channels language‐wise relevant to the particular state
or UT out of operational 650 private channels granted permission by the Ministry of Information and
Broadcasting under the downlinking guidelines (data as on April, 2012)
Sl.
No.
States Number of
channels
Languages
1 Andhra Pradesh 473 Hindi/ English/Telgu+19 channels*
2 Arunachal Pradesh 425 Hindi/ English/NE and Assamese+19
channels
3 Assam 425 Hindi/ English/NE and Assamese+19
channels
4 Bihar 428 Hindi/ English/Bhojpuri+19 channels
5 Chhattisgarh 420 Hindi/ English+19 channels
6 Goa 438 Hindi/ English/Marathi+19 channels
7 Gujarat 428 Hindi/ English/Gujrati+19 channels
8 Haryana 441 Hindi/ English/Punjabi+19 channels
9 Himachal Pradesh 441 Hindi/ English/Punjabi+19 channels
10 Jammu and Kashmir 424 Hindi/ English/Urdu+19 channels
11 Jharkhand 428 Hindi/ English/Bhojpuri+19 channels
12 Karnataka 437 Hindi/ English/Kannada+19 channels
13 Kerala 451 Hindi/ English/Malyalam+19 channels
14 Madhya Pradesh 420 Hindi/ English/+19 channels
15 Maharashtra 438 Hindi/ English/Marathi+19 channels
16 Manipur 425 Hindi/ English/NE and Assamese+19
channels
17 Meghalaya 425 Hindi/ English/NE and Assamese+19
channels
18 Mizoram 425 Hindi/ English/NE and Assamese+19
channels
19 Nagaland 425 Hindi/ English/NE and Assamese+19
channels
20 Orissa 434 Hindi/ English/Oriya+19 channels
21 Punjab 441 Hindi/ English/Punjabi+19 channels
22 Rajasthan 420 Hindi/ English+19 channels
23 Sikkim 446 Hindi/ English/Bengali+19 channels
24 Tamil Nadu 462 Hindi/ English/Tamil+19 channels
25 Tripura 425 Hindi/ English/NE and Assamese + 19
channels
26 Uttaranchal 424 Hindi/ English/Urdu+19 channels
27 Uttar Pradesh 424 Hindi/ English/Urdu+19 channels
28 West Bengal 446 Hindi/ English/Bengali+19 channels
29 Andaman and Nicobar Islands 420 Hindi/ English+19 channels
30 Dadar and Nagar Haveli 420 Hindi/ English+19 channels
31 Daman and Diu 420 Hindi/ English+19 channels
Page 45 of 45
32 Lakshadeep 420 Hindi/ English+19 channels
33 Delhi 441 Hindi/ English/Punjabi+19 channels
34 Chandigarh 441 Hindi/ English/Punjabi+19 channels
35 Pondicherry 441 Hindi/English/ Tamil/ French+19 channels
* 19 channels includes 8 channels to be carried as per the provisions of the Cable Television
Networks (Regulation) Act, 1995 and 11 regional Prasar Bharati channels.
********
1
TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE GAZETTE OF INDIA, EXTRAORDINARY,
PART III, SECTION 4
TELECOM REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF INDIA
NOTIFICATION
New Delhi the 14th May, 2012
F. No. 3- 24/2012- B&CS – In exercise of the powers conferred by section 36, read with sub-
clauses (ii), (iii), (iv) and (v) of clause (b) of sub-section (1) of section 11 of the Telecom
Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997 (24 of 1997), read with notification of the Government
of India, in the Ministry of Communication and Information Technology (Department of
Telecommunication), No.39,-----
(a) issued, in exercise of the powers conferred upon the Central Government under clause (d) of
sub-section (1) of section 11 and proviso to clause (k) of sub-section (1) of section 2 of the said
Act, and
(b) published under notification No. S.O.44 (E) and 45 (E) dated the 9th January, 2004 in the
Gazette of India, Extraordinary, Part III, Section 4, the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India
hereby makes the following regulations, namely:-
THE TELECOMMUNICATION (BROADCASTING AND CABLE SERVICES)
INTERCONNECTION (DIGITAL ADDRESSABLE CABLE TELEVISION SYSTEMS)
(FIRST AMENDMENT) REGULATIONS, 2012
No. 14 of 2012
2
1. (1) These regulations may be called the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable
Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) (First Amendment)
Regulations, 2012.
(2) They shall come into force from the date of their publication in the Official Gazette.
2. In regulation 3 of the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection
(Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) Regulations, 2012 (hereinafter referred to as the
principal regulations), after sub-regulation (11), the following sub-regulation shall be inserted,
namely:- -
“(11A) No multi system operator shall demand from a broadcaster any placement fee.”
3. In regulation 4 of the principal regulations, after sub-regulation (8), the following sub-
regulation shall be inserted, namely:- -
“(8A) Every Reference Interconnect Offer submitted to the Authority under sub-regulation
(7) and sub-regulation (8) shall also contain the basis on which the carriage fee payable by the
broadcaster has been determined.”
4. In regulation (5) of the principal regulations, after sub-regulation (14), the following sub-
regulation shall be inserted, namely:-
“(14A) Every broadcaster shall declare the genre of its channels and such genre shall be
either News and Current Affairs or Infotainment or Sports or Kids or Music or Lifestyle
or Movies or Religious or Devotional or General Entertainment (Hindi) or General
Entertainment (English) or General Entertainment (regional language).
14(B) The multi system operator shall place the channels of a broadcaster in the genre
declared by such broadcaster.
14(C) No broadcaster shall demand from the multi-system operator to assign a particular
number to its channels.”
5. In regulation (5) of the principal regulations, after proviso to sub-regulation (15), the
following sub-regulation shall be inserted, namely:-
3
“(15A) Every multi system operator shall display, in his Electronic Programme Guide, all
the channels offered by him, in the same genre in which a particular channel has been indicated
by the broadcaster and one channel shall appear in only one genre.”
(Wasi Ahmad)
Advisor (B&CS)
Note.-----The Explanatory Memorandum explains the objects and reasons of the
Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable
Cable Television Systems) (First Amendment) Regulation, 2012.
4
Annexure
Explanatory Memorandum
1. After following an extensive consultation process, the Authority had notified the
Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable
Cable Television Systems) Regulations, 2012 ( 9 of 2012) (hereinafter referred to as the principal
Regulation) on 30th April, 2012. While the principal regulation is specifically applicable for
digital addressable cable TV systems, the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services)
Interconnection Regulation 2004 (13 of 2004) is applicable for non-addressable cable TV
systems and also addressable systems such as DTH, IPTV etc.
2. A question has arisen regarding charging of placement fee by the multi system operator. In
the digital addressable cable TV systems, the technology provides for a Electronic Program
Guide (EPG) wherein the channels being carried on an MSO’s network can be arranged in a
simple easy to understand manner so that the subscriber can easily go through this guide and
select the channel of choice instead of flipping through all the channels. This display of channels
can be genre-wise where all the channels of a particular genre can be listed under that genre in
the genre-wise list of EPG. Thus, in digital addressable cable TV systems, there is hardly any
justification for charging of the placement fee. In sub-regulation 11 of the regulation 3 of the
principal regulation dated 30th April, 2012, it has clearly been provided that insistence by multi
system operator on placement of a channel in a particular slot or bouquet amounts to imposition
of unreasonable terms. The intention of making this provision was that placement fee cannot be
charged. However, to clarify the position in this regard, in the amendment regulation, a specific
provision has been made so that the multi system operator does not charge any placement fee
from any broadcaster.
3. The matter relating to charging of carriage fee by the multi system operator has been dealt
with in sub-regulation 12 of regulation 3 and in sub-regulations 7 and 8 of the regulation 4 and
also in the paragraphs 15 to 17 of the principal regulation. The multi system operators are to file
a copy of the Reference Interconnect Offer with the Authority including the quantum of carriage
fee per channel that would be charged from the broadcasters. With digital technology, the
capacity to carry the channels is no longer a constraint. Also, the Subscriber Management
System (SMS) provides the full declaration of the subscribers, increasing the percentage of
subscription revenue to the multi system operator. With all these, the carriage fee is expected to
go down substantially. It was presumed that the Reference Interconnect Offer that would be
filed with the Authority would include the detailed basis on which the carriage fee has been
worked out. The same has been clarified in the sub-regulation which has been inserted in this
regard.
5
4. In sub-regulation 15 of regulation 5 of the principal regulation dated 30th April, 2012, a
provision has been made that it shall be open to a multi system operator to decide the packaging
of the channels offered to the subscribers from bouquet of channels provided to it by the
broadcaster. A question has arisen regarding placement of channels by the multi system
operator. To avoid any eventuality of a channel being placed in a disadvantageous position as
compared to another channel of the same genre, a provision has now been made whereunder a
broadcaster has to indicate the genre of a channel and the multi system operator has to include
that channel in the genre declared by the broadcaster. The multi system operator is required to
ensure that all the channels falling in a particular genre appear in its network’s Electronic
Programme Guide (EPG) under the same genre. With this the subscriber would be able to see
the list of channels that are available genre-wise and thus making the service more customer
friendly.
***********
Page 1 of 12
TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE GAZETTE OF INDIA, EXTRAORDINARY,
PART III, SECTION 4
TELECOM REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF INDIA
THE TELECOMMUNICATION (BROADCASTING AND CABLE SERVICES)
INTERCONNECTION (DIGITAL ADDRESSABLE CABLE TELEVISION SYSTEMS)
(SECOND AMENDMENT) REGULATIONS, 2013
(No. 12 of 2013)
NOTIFICATION
New Delhi the 20th September, 2013
F. No. 3-24/2012-B&CS----In exercise of powers conferred by section 36, read with sub-clauses
(ii), (iii), (iv) and (v) of clause (b) of sub-section (1) of section 11 of the Telecom Regulatory
Authority of India Act, 1997 (24 of 1997), read with notification of the Government of India, in
the Ministry of Communication and Information Technology (Department of
Telecommunication), No.39,-----
(a) issued, in exercise of the powers conferred upon the Central Government under clause (d) of
sub-section (1) of section 11 and proviso to clause (k) of sub-section (1) of section 2 of the said
Act, and
(b) published under notification No. 39 (S.O. 44 (E) and 45 (E)) dated the 9th January, 2004 in
the Gazette of India, Extraordinary, Part II- Section 3- Sub-section (ii),----
the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India hereby makes the following regulations to amend
the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable
Cable Television Systems) Regulations, 2013 (9 of 2012), namely:-
Page 2 of 12
1. (1) These regulations may be called the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable
Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) (Second Amendment)
Regulations, 2013.
(2) They shall come into force from the date of their publication in the Official Gazette.
2. In regulation 3 of the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection
(Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) Regulations, 2012 (9 of 2012),---
(a) in sub-regulation (2), the phrase “having the prescribed channel capacity and” shall be
omitted;
(b) in sub-regulation (2), after the second proviso, the following proviso shall be inserted,
namely:-
“Provided also that nothing contained in this sub-regulation shall apply in the case of a
multi-system operator, who seeks signals of a particular TV channel from a broadcaster,
while at the same time demands carriage fee for carrying that channel on its distribution
platform.”
(c) sub-regulation (5), sub-regulation (8) and sub-regulation (11A) shall be omitted.
(Sudhir Gupta)
Secretary(I/C), TRAI
Note.1-----The principal regulations were published vide notification no. 3-24/2012-B&CS dated
30th April 2012 and subsequently amended vide notifications No. 3-24/2012-B&CS dated 14th
May 2012.
Note.2-----The Explanatory Memorandum explains the objects and reasons of the
Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable
Cable Television Systems) (Second Amendment) Regulation, 2013 (No. 12 of 2013).
Page 3 of 12
Annexure
Explanatory Memorandum
I. Background
1. In the last few years, the exponential growth in the number of TV channels (both free-to-air
[FTA] and pay) combined with the inherent limitations of the analog cable TV systems has
posed several challenges in the cable TV sector, mainly due to capacity constraints and non-
addressable nature of the network. With time and evolution of technology, new addressable
TV platforms like direct-to-home (DTH), internet protocol television (IPTV) etc. became
available. The evolution of technology also paved way for introducing digitization with
addressability in the cable TV sector. Accordingly, after studying the subject at length and
undertaking a public consultation process, the Authority, on 5th August 2010, gave its
recommendations on implementation of Digital Addressable Cable TV Systems (DAS)
across the country along with a roadmap to achieve the same.
2. The Government has accepted the recommendations of TRAI and on 25th October, 2011,
promulgated an Ordinance amending the Cable Television Networks (Regulation) Act, 1995,
enabling the implementation of Digital Addressable Cable TV Systems in India. Thereafter,
the Government also issued a notification dated 11th November, 2011 and its amendment
dated 21st June 2012, which laid down the roadmap for implementation of Digital
Addressable Cable TV Systems in the country in a phased manner in four phases, with the
first phase by 31st Oct. 2012 and the final phase to be completed by 31st December 2014.
This will lead to sunset of Analogue Cable TV Systems in the entire country. With the
Parliament passing the bill, the Ordinance dated 25th October, 2011, became an Act on 30th
December, 2011. Subsequently, the Central Government amended the Cable television
Networks Rules 1994, vide amendment dated 28th April 2012. These legislative enactments
paved way for the implementation of DAS in the country.
3. In order to lay down a comprehensive regulatory framework for the digital addressable cable
TV systems (DAS), the Authority initiated a consultation process on the issues relating to
implementation of DAS. After following an extensive public consultation process, the tariff
Page 4 of 12
amendment order, regulations for quality of service and redressal of consumer grievances,
and the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital
Addressable Cable Television Systems) Regulations, 2012 dated 30th April 2012, were
notified. The interconnection regulations prescribe various provisions relating to the
interconnection between Broadcaster, MSO and LCO. Subsequently, an amendment to the
interconnection regulations was also notified on 14th May 2012.
4. Some of the provisions of the said interconnection regulations were challenged in appeal
numbers 5(C) of 2012, 11 (C) of 2012 and 12 (C) of 2012 before Hon’ble Telecom Disputes
and Settlement Appellate Tribunal (TDSAT) by some MSOs. The Hon’ble TDSAT vide its
judgment dated 19th October 2012 partly allowed the appeals and set aside three provisions
of the said interconnection regulations. The provisions set aside pertain to prohibition of
demanding carriage fee by the MSO while seeking signals of a channel from a broadcaster
(sub-regulation 3(5) of the said regulations), MSOs to have a minimum channel carrying
capacity of 500 channels (sub-regulation 3(8) of the said regulations) and prohibition
regarding charging of placement fee by the MSOs (sub-regulation 11A of the said
regulations).
5. While setting aside the provisions of sub-regulation 3(5) of the Interconnection Regulations
applicable for DAS, the Hon’ble TDSAT had opined, inter alia, that there should not be any
difference between 2nd proviso to sub-regulation 3.2 of “The Telecommunication
(broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection Regulation 2004 (12 of 2004)” as
amended from time to time as applicable to non-CAS/DTH operators and sub-regulation
3(5)of “The Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital
Addressable Cable Television Systems) Regulation 2012”. On the issue of provision of
capacity to carry minimum 500 channels, the Hon’ble TDSAT, in its judgment, had observed
that since market forces play an important and significant role in the matter of carrying
capacity of the MSO, the same may not be required to be regulated. It has been further
observed by the Hon’ble TDSAT that if the regulator deems fit, it may consider making
provision for MSOs to have capacity to carry number of channels based on different
categories of areas i.e. city/towns/rural area etc. in which MSO will be operating. Further, the
Page 5 of 12
Hon’ble TDSAT has set aside the provisions of sub-regulation 11A of the interconnection
regulation 2012 on the ground that the restriction placed on the MSO for demanding
placement fees in terms of May 2012, Regulation is bad in law. It has been further mentioned
that the same restriction is not applicable for the DTH operators, the placement charges, if
any, will depend upon the mutual agreement between the Broadcasters and the MSO.
Consequent to the said judgment of the Hon’ble TDSAT, the Authority initiated a
consultation process with the stakeholders to bring in finality to the provisions set aside by
the Hon’ble TDSAT.
6. In this connection, a consultation paper titled “Issues related to amendments to the
Interconnection Regulations applicable for Digital Addressable Cable TV Systems & Tariff
Order applicable for Addressable Systems” was issued on 20th December, 2012. In this
consultation paper, inter-alia, the following issues were posed for the stakeholders to offer
their comments:
(a) Introduction of following proviso (in line with the 2nd proviso to the sub-regulation 3.2
of the interconnection regulation applicable for the platforms, other than DAS) in the
sub-regulation 3(2) of the interconnection regulations applicable for DAS areas, and
deletion of the sub-regulation 3(5) from the same regulation:
“provided that the provisions of this sub-regulation shall not apply in the case of a
multi-system operator, who seeks signals of a particular TV channel from a
broadcaster, while at the same time demanding carriage fee for carryin
Previous and next
Questions people ask
Is annexure TO SCHEDULE II of Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) Regulations, 2012. still in force?
No repeal of Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (Digital Addressable Cable Television Systems) Regulations, 2012. is recorded.