Rule 2, The Andaman and Nicobar Police Manual, 2023: An appeal against an order
The Andaman and Nicobar Police Manual, 2023 - Rule 2
Text of rule 2
An appeal against an order
2. An appeal against an order :-
59
a) Reverting to a lower rank, grade or post a Police officer officiating in
a higher rank, grade or post, otherwise them as a penalty ;
b) Reducing or withholding the pension or denying the maximum
pension admissible under the rules; and
c) Determining the pay allowances for the period of suspension to be
paid to a Police officer on his reinstatement or determining whether
or not such period shall be treated as a period spent on duty for any
purpose, shall lie – to the authority to whom an appeal against an
order imposing upon him the penalty or dismissal from service
would lie.
Explanation- In this rule :-
a) The expression, “Police Officer”, includes a person who has ceased to
be in Government service ;
b) The expression ‘pension’ includes additional pension, gratuity and any
other retirement benefit.
9.19 Period of Limitation for Appeals
No appeal under these rules shall be entertained unless it is submitted within
a period of three months from the date on which the appellant receives a copy
of the order appealed against.
Provided that the appellate authority may entertain the appeal after the expiry
of the said period, if it is satisfied that the appellant had sufficient cause for
not submitting the appeal in time.
9.20 Form and Contents of appeal
1) Every person submitting an appeal shall do so separately and in his own
name.
2) The appeal shall be addressed to the authority to whom the appeal lies
shall contain all material statements and arguments on which the appellant
relies, shall not contain any disrespectful or improper language and shall
be complete in itself.
9.21 Records to be sent with Appeals
Every appeal shall be forwarded to the appellate authority with an expression
of opinion and with remarks on each paragraph of the appeal in regard to the
accuracy of the statements made and inferences drawn. In forwarding
60
appeals, the records connected with the order appealed against and records
of inquiry in the case of penalties should be forwarded to the appellate
authority.
9.22 Submission of appeals
Every appeal shall be submitted to the authority which made the order
appealed against :-
Provided that if such authority is not the head of the office in which the
appellant may be serving or, if he is not in service, the head of the office in
which he was last serving, or is not subordinate to the head of such officer,
the appeal shall be submitted to the head of such office who shall forward it
forthwith to the said authority.
9.23 Withholding of appeals
1) The authority which made the order appealed against may withhold the
appeal if:
i) It is an appeal against an order from which no appeal lies; or
ii) It does not comply with any of the provisions of rule 9.20 ; or
iii) It is not submitted within the period specified in rule 9.19 and no cause
is shown for the delay or
iv) It is a repetition of an appeal already decided and no new facts or
circumstances are adduced :
Provided that an appeal withheld on the ground only that it does not
comply with the provisions of rule 9.20 shall be returned to the
appellant and, if resubmitted within one month thereof after compliance
with the said provisions, shall not be withheld.
2) Where an appeal is withheld, the appellant shall be informed of the fact
and the reasons therefore.
3) At the commencement of each quarter, a list of the appeals withheld by
any authority during the previous quarter together with the reasons for
withholding them shall be furnished by that authority to the appellate
authority.
9.24 Transmission of Appeals
1) The authority which made the order appealed against shall, without any
avoidable delay, transmit to the appellate authority every appeal which is
not withheld under rule 9.23 together with its comments thereon and the
relevant records.
61
2) The authority to which the appeal lies may direct transmission to it of any
appeal withheld under rule 9.23 and there upon such appeal shall be
transmitted to that authority together with the comments of the authority
withholding the appeal and the relevant records.
In the case of an appeal against an order imposing any of the penalties
specified in rule 9.2.1 & 9.2.2, the appellate authority shall consider –
a) Whether the procedure prescribed in these rules has been complied
with and, if not whether such non-compliance has resulted in failure of
justice.
b) Whether the findings are justified; and
c) Whether the penalty imposed is excessive, adequate or inadequate
and pass orders.
i. Setting aside, reducing, confirming or enhancing the penalty; or
ii. Remitting the case to the authority which imposed the penalty or
to any other authority with such direction as it may deem fit in
the circumstances of the case.
Provided that –
1. The Appellate Authority shall not impose any enhanced penalty which
neither such authority nor the authority which made the order appealed
against is competent in the case to impose :
2. No order imposing an enhanced penalty shall be passed unless the
appellant is given an opportunity of making any representation which
he may wish to make against such enhanced penalty ; and
3. If the enhanced penalty which the Appellate Authority proposes to
impose is one of the penalties specified in 9.2.2 of Rule 9.2 and an
inquiry under rule 9.9 has not already been held in the case, the
appellate authority shall, subject to the provisions of rule 9.14, itself
hold such inquiry or direct that such inquiry be held and thereafter on
consideration of the proceedings of such inquiry and after giving the
appellant an opportunity of making any representation which he may
wish to make against such penalty, pass such orders as it may deem
fit.
In the case of an appeal against any order specified in rule 9.18, the
Appellate Authority shall consider all the circumstances of the case and
pass such orders as it deems just and equitable.
9.25 Travelling Expenses to the witnesses
Private witnesses summoned in departmental enquiries shall be entitled to
journey expenses and, if detained for more than twelve hours, to suitable
62
detention allowance. Such expenditure shall be paid out of the allotment for
‘contingencies’ Government servants who are called as such witnesses shall
be entitled to travelling allowance in accordance with the following instructions
:-
a) Every person, whether he is a central or state Government servant or not,
who is called to give evidence in a departmental inquiry by either the
Government or the government servant against whom the inquiry is being
held, shall be entitled for payment of travelling and other expenses as laid
down in these instructions.
b) Where the witness is a Central Government Servant, he shall be entitled to
receive, in respect of the attendance before the authority holding the
departmental inquiry, from the Department or Ministry under which he is
serving for the time being payment of a traveling allowance as on tour
under S.R. 154.
c) Where the Government Servant is called in the departmental inquiry to
give evidence as to facts which have come to his knowledge in the
discharge of his public duties the minimum time required to be spent by
him on the journey to and from the place where the inquiry is held and the
days on which he is required to remain present before the authority
holding the inquiry shall be treated as on duty.
Provided that if the Government servant is on leave then entire time spent
shall be treated as a part of the leave and he shall not be deemed to have
been recalled to duty.
d) Where a Government servant is called by any authority holding the
departmental inquiry to give evidence as to facts which have come to his
knowledge at a time when he was not in Government service he may be
paid travelling allowance.
e) Where the witness is a State Government Servant, he shall be entitled to
receive in respect of the attendance before the authority holding the
departmental enquiry, from the State Government such travelling
allowance and/or daily allowance as may be admissible to him under the
rules applicable.
f) Where a person who has been a Government servant is called to give
evidence as to facts which have come to his knowledge in the discharge of
his public duties or a person who is not a Central Government or a State
Government servant is called to give evidence before any authority holding
a departmental inquiry such person shall be entitled to claim from the
Ministry or Department under who the Government servant against whom
the enquiry is being held is for the time being serving travelling allowance
under S.R. 190.
63
g) The foregoing instructions shall also apply to a person nominated by the
Disciplinary Authority to present the case in support of the charge before
the authority holding the departmental inquiry, or assisting the Government
servant against whom the inquiry is held in presenting his case.
h) All expenditure on travelling allowance paid to a Government servant
under these instructions shall be debited to the Travelling Allowance grant
or the Contingent grant as the case may be.
9.26 Reinstatement and Payment of Arrears
In cases where an order of dismissal, removal or compulsory retirement
passed by the competent authority is set aside in appeal or revision or under
an order of court of law and the Police Officer is reinstated in service on
grounds of equity, the questions as to what pay and allowances should be
allowed for the intervening period and whether or not the period should be
treated as duty will be dealt with under Rules.
9.27 Register of Punishments
All the Superintendent of Police and Unit In charges will maintain a
register of punishments in which the details of all the inquiries instituted
against the Police Officers in the charge will be entered.
********
64
Appendix-9.2
Disciplinary and Appellate authority:- the table below shows the authority by whom
and the extent to which the punishments stated in rule 9.2 may be awarded to Police
Officer of various ranks; and the Appellate Authority in each case.
Sl
No.
Penalties Inspectors of
Andaman & Nicobar
Police
Sub-Inspectors or
equivalent rank,
Assistant Sub-
Inspectors or
equivalent rank
Head constable,
Police Constable,
Follower
Disciplinary
Authority
Appellate
Authority
Disciplinary
Authority
Appellate
Authority
Disciplinary
Authority
Appellate
Authority
1. Dismissal from
service which
shall ordinarily
be a
disqualification
for future
employment.
DGP HLG ADGP/IGP DGP SP DIGP
2. Removal from
service which
shall not be a
disqualification
for future
employment.
DGP HLG ADGP/IGP DGP SP DIGP
3. Compulsory
retirement.
DGP HLG ADGP/IGP DGP SP DIGP
4. Reduction to a
lower rank,
grade or post
or to a lower
time scale or to
a lower stage in
a time scale for
a specified
period.
DGP HLG ADGP/IGP DGP SP DIGP
5. Fine not
exceeding one
month’s pay.
DGP HLG ADGP/IGP DGP SP DIGP
6 Withholding of
increments or
promotion for a
DGP HLG ADGP/IGP DGP SP DIGP
65
specified period
with cumulative
effect.
7 Censure.
SP and
above
HLG SP ADGP/IGP SP DIGP
9 Forfeiture of
increment
without
cumulative
effect
DGP HLG SP ADGP/IGP SP DIGP
10 Recovery from
any of the
whole or part of
any pecuniary
loss caused to
the
Government by
negligence or
breach of
orders.
DGP HLG ADGP/IGP DGP SP DIGP
11 Punishment
drill not
exceeding 15
days
Not
applicable
Not
applicable
Not
applicable
Not
applicable
DySP Not
applicable
66
Chapter - 10
PROSECUTION AND SUITS
The provisions of Article 311 (2), Section 197 Cr.PC. and also the provisions
of limitation, as available in the Police Acts provide certain safe guards to
Police Officers, when criminal or departmental proceedings are initiated
against them. A proper appreciation of the above provisions would ensure the
ends of law and natural justice, while dealing with complaints against Police
Officers.
10.1 When a disciplinary offence on the part of a Police Officer can be adequately
punished departmentally such officer shall not be prosecuted under Section
29 of the Police Act nor shall an upper subordinate under any circumstances
be so prosecuted without the sanction of Director General. Prosecution of
Police officer for non-cognizable offences are to be deprecated. A criminal
court may award either imprisonment which involves dismissal or fine. Both
fine and dismissal can be awarded departmentally and all that can be gained
by a criminal prosecution is a few months’ imprisonment which ruins the
man’s reputation and may possibly turn him into a bad character for life. The
only cases which form an exception are:-
(a) Cases in which the offender is incorrigibly bad character and it is
desirable to make an example of him;
(b) Cases of escape from lawful custody due to culpable negligence or
collusion in which case an officer concerned should as a rule be
prosecuted and if convicted should be dismissed from the force;
(c) Cases of peculiar aggravation in which the interests of public justice
demand a public prosecution and trial.
10.2 Punishment after conviction
1) The following guidelines should be followed in awarding punishments to the
accused Police Officer after he is convicted for any offence by a court of
law.
(i) A conviction on a criminal charge does not automatically entail
dismissal, removal or reduction in rank. The penalty imposed upon
should not be arbitrary or grossly excessive or out of all proportion to
the offence committed or one, not warranted by the facts and
circumstances of the case. The disciplinary authority is to take the
conviction as sufficient proof of misconduct on the part of the officer
and has thereafter to decide
(a)Whether the conduct which has led to the conviction on a criminal
charge was such as to warrant the imposition of any penalty and
67
(b)If so what should be the penalty or quantum of penalty.
(ii) The disciplinary authority must study the judgment of the criminal court
and take into consideration all the facts and circumstances of the case
and also factors such as
(a) The entire conduct of the officer
(b) The gravity of the offence committed by him
(c) The impact of his misconduct which is likely to have on the
administration
(d) Whether the offence for which he was convicted was of a technical
or trivial nature and
(e) The extenuating factors if any present in the case.
(iii) The Disciplinary Authority should do this exercise ex-parte (Suo Moto)
and he need not hear the Police officer concerned before deciding
upon the punishment to be imposed.
(iv) If an officer appeals to a higher court and gets a stay order and is in
the meanwhile dismissed or any other punishment awarded by the
department, the stay will be infructuous. Even in case he appeals to
higher court and gets a stay for the suspension of sentence, the
process of dismissal or other punishment can be taken up by the
department, irrespective of the stay of sentence, unless the conviction
is also stayed.
(v) Conviction and sentence to pay fine or released on probation under
P.O. Act. Police officers convicted but released on probation of good
conduct under section 4 of Probation of Offenders Act can be
dismissed or removed from service or otherwise punished on the
ground of misconduct which led to conviction on criminal charge. In
criminal trial the conviction is one thing and sentence is another. The
court while invoking the provisions of section 3 or 4 of the Probation of
Offenders Act does not deal with the conviction. It only deals with the
sentence, which the offender, has to undergo. Instead of sentencing
the offender the court releases him on probation of good conduct.
However the conviction remains untouched and the stigma of the
conviction is not obliterated. Section 12 of the Act does not preclude
the department from taking action for misconduct, which leads, to the
offence and to his conviction thereon as per law.
10.3 Procedure on acquittal in a Criminal case
When a Police Officer has been tried and discharged or acquitted on a
criminal charge, he shall not be punished departmentally on the same charge
68
or on a charge based on evidence which has been rejected by the court.
Provided that when a criminal charge against a Police officer has failed solely
for technical reasons or when the court notes the facts as suspicious but gives
the accused the benefit of doubt or records the opinion that witnesses have
resiled through the exercise of influence upon them ; or when though an
acquittal is ordered on the main charge, facts are brought to light in the course
of the trial which justify a separate departmental charge the acquittal or
discharge (either as a result of the case having been compounded or
otherwise) shall not in itself be a bar to departmental action, nor shall such an
acquittal be regarded as an honorable acquittal for the purpose of
Fundamental Rule 54. In such cases the Superintendent of Police may, with
the concurrence of the Director General of Police in the case of an upper
subordinate proceed to take departmental action in accordance with these
rules. Before deciding to launch a departmental enquiry or while disposing a
pending enquiry in the case of a Police Officer, who is acquitted by the
Criminal Court, the competent authority is under an obligation to apply his
mind to the requirements prescribed to decide whether it is a fit case to defer
from the rule of verdict of the Court or not.
10.4 Rule for the defence of Police Officers in Criminal Prosecutions and
Civil Suits for acts done by them in their official capacity
(i) Police Officers will always be protected when it appears to the UT
Administration/ Police Department that they have acted in good faith.
(ii) If the UT Administration/ Police Department decides not to undertake
defence or to act on behalf of the Police Officer the officer may take such
measures, as he considers necessary at his own expense to conduct
prosecution on his behalf or to defend himself. If the verdict is in his favour
the Government will ordinarily reimburse his reasonable expenses.
(iii) When criminal proceedings are instituted against a Police Officer, either
by UT Administration/Police Department or with their sanction, the UT
Administration/ Police Department as a general rule, decline to undertake
his defence. However in exceptional cases where the Police Officer
concerned is unable to arrange his defence at his own expense on
account of financial or other valid reasons, the UT Administration/Police
Department may sanction the defence, provided that,
(a) The Police Officer undertakes to refund the entire sum incurred by the
UT Administration/Police Department in connection with the conduct of
his defence, if the case does not end in his favour and
(b) The UT Administration/Police Department are satisfied about the
possibility of recovering such sum from the Police officer.
69
(iv) When in pursuance of these rules a Police Officer engages, and is
permitted to engage, a counsel for his defence, the UT
Administration/Police Department will reimburse the expenditure to the
extent it is allowed to the UT Administration/Police Department counsel in
the concerned court as per rules prevailing.
(v) When a Civil suit is threatened to be launched against a Police Officer for
acts done in the discharge of his official duties and if a notice is given prior
to the filing of suit and/ or if a written statement is to be filed by the Police
officer in connection with the suit pending, a copy of his reply to such
notice or his written statement shall be submitted to the DGP through
proper channel. If the unit head decides to defend the Police Officer, he
should examine the reply submitted and issue suitable guidelines after
taking legal advice.
10.5 Proceedings in respect of matter not connected with official duties or
position of the Police Officer.
Government will not give any assistance to a Police Officer or reimburse the
expenditure incurred by him in the conduct of proceedings in respect of
matters not arising out of or connected with, his official duties or his official
position irrespective of whether the proceedings were instituted by a private
party against the Police Officer or vice versa.
10.6 Criminal Prosecution & Civil Suits by Police Officer
(i) Defamation: Sometimes a Police Officer faces defamatory remarks,
statements or imputations in respect of his conduct in discharge of his
official functions, made by individuals or published in newspapers. In such
cases they may decide to launch a criminal case of defamation u/s 500
I.P.C. and they may apply to the UT Administration/Police Department for
sanction to prosecute. Every complaint referred to, the UT
Administration/Police Department shall set forth the facts which constitute
the offence alleged, the nature of such offence, and such other particulars
as are reasonably sufficient to serve notice to the accused of the offence
alleged to have been committed. If the UT Administration/Police
Department accord sanction, the Public Prosecutor shall file a complaint in
the Sessions Court directly without being committed to it through the lower
court and the Public Prosecutor will conduct the prosecution at the cost of
A & N Administration. Whenever the Head of the Department or Unit
comes across such derogatory remarks published in press or otherwise
they should take initiative in the matter in this manner.
70
(ii) If the sanction of the UT Administration/Police Department could not be
obtained, the Police Officer may file a complaint on his own in the court as
per the ordinary procedure.
(iii)The institution of a civil suit on behalf of the State requires the sanction of
the UT Administration/Police Department. In all such suits and in suits by
or against Police Officers which go to the UT Administration/Police
Department for sanction the plaints and written statements should except
in cases of emergency require approval of the UT Administration/Police
Department, before they are filed. After the approval, the DGP can act
further on behalf of the UT Administration/Police Department and if a civil
suit is instituted against the UT Administration in connection with a matter
concerning the Police department, the district Superintendent of Police,
shall refer the matter to the DGP for orders. As the defence of such suits
ordinarily falls upon the Government Pleader of the area.
10.7 Under Article 351 of the Civil Service Regulations, future good conduct is an
implied condition of the grant of every pension and Government has the right
to withhold or withdraw a pension or any part of it if the pensioner is convicted
of a serious crime or found guilty of grave misconduct. It is, therefore,
necessary to ensure that cases where pensioners are convicted by a Court of
any crime are also brought to the notice of Government. Police Prosecutor
shall ensure the prompt intimation of such cases to the administrative
authorities concerned.
10.8 Assistance to be given to Police Officers - when they sue or be sued,
prosecute or be prosecuted for acts done in discharge of their Official
duties
The Police Department and the Administration should protect and support
officers who are harassed by litigation discharging his/her legitimate duties.
False and malicious allegations are often made against Police Officers with a
view to hamper and embarrass them in the proper discharge of their duties.
He/She shall be given all protection by extending legal aid, financial support
and such other departmental / administrative assistance as may be deemed
proper in each case.
10.9 Anonymous/Pseudonymous Complaint: In case of an Anonymous/
Pseudonymous complaint, DoPT’s OM & Chief Vigilance Commission’s
(CVC’s) Circular in this regard shall be followed & the complaints are to be
closed accordingly.
10.10 Claims for loss of services against members of the public for injury
caused by them to Police Officers
71
Police Officers should report promptly to DGP through their superior officers
the full facts regarding any injury sustained incapacitating them from service
either temporarily or permanently, whether on or off duty owing to the
negligence of a member or members of the public.
10.11 Legal advice to be obtained in regard to litigation affecting the UT
Administration/ Police Department
The UT Administration considers it desirable that, in regard to litigation by or
against the Administration, legal advice should always be obtained before a
suit is instituted or the defence of a suit undertaken on behalf of the UT
Administration. It is not necessary that such advice should be obtained merely
because the notice of a suit against the Administration is given under section
80 of the Code of Civil Procedure but in important cases it may be desirable
for the Officer dealing with the notice to obtain legal advice regarding it. The
Officers though are competent to sanction the filing or defence of suits on
behalf of the Administration they are not bound to follow the legal advice, and
if they decide to reject it, they must place the reasons for their decision clearly
on record.
10.12 Appearance and preparation of affidavits and counter-affidavits in writs
filed against the Police Department.
(i) In cases where the Police has been impleaded as party, the HOD/DGP will
approve counter-affidavit and swear to it before filing it in the High Court.
(ii) In other cases involving small matters of local importance, of which the
Police has no special knowledge or where no general issues are involved,
no useful purpose will be served by the counter affidavit being approved
by the DGP. In such cases, the draft counter-affidavit need not be
submitted to the DGP for approval, provided that the IGP ensures that the
public interest is safeguarded, that the counter affidavit brings out the
views of the department clearly.
10.13 Writs against Police Officers
Whenever any writ is filed against a Police Officer, the respondents concerned
who are directly involved, should promptly prepare a well drafted reports for
preparing a counter affidavit, and if necessary by consulting the prosecuting
officer or can take opinion from legal cell, before taking the approval of
Government Pleader (GP).
**************
72
Chapter – 11
SERVICE RECORDS
11.1 Records of Service
The Service Book of a Government servant is a document to record all the
events in his/ her entire service period and career, recording each and every
administrative action qua the Government servant right from the stage of his
recruitment till his retirement to reflect the history of service of a Government
employee.
11.2 Contents of Service Book
11.2.1 Part I of the prescribed format of the Service Book reflects the Bio data
of the employee and will include the following details
a) Individual record sheet containing birth proof, education qualifications
and other certificates.
b) Health Certificate and Medical Examination certificate.
c) Attestation form/Character and Antecedent certificate.
d) Offer of Appointment.
e) Appointment Order.
f) Oath of Allegiance.
g) Marital Status.
h) Home Town Declaration.
Soon after enlistment and after verification of character, a “Character Roll”
also known as Part I of service book in form 11.2 shall be prepared for each
recruit in his presence. When the roll is otherwise complete, the recruit shall
be taken before a Gazetted officer and shall in his presence sign the form or
agreement printed as item 4 in the roll and affix his signature. The Gazetted
officer before signing the roll, shall satisfy himself that the recruit understands
the purport of the agreement, and that the recruit is satisfied that his age and
other details been correctly recorded.
11.2.2 The Part II A of the Service Book includes entries of the following
certifications/nominations in respect of a Government employee
a. Family Particulars with due certification from the
Government servant that he has furnished the details of the
family members for filing nomination in GPF/NPS,
UTGEIS(Union Territory Government Employee Insurance
Scheme), DCRG and Family pension).
73
b. Nomination for Central Govt. Employees Group Insurance
Scheme (CGEGIS) with similar certification as indicated
above. Further leave encashment details, testimonials and
other documents referred to and relied upon will be
maintained in this part.
c. Declaration of Movable and Immovable property
Rule 18 (1) (i) of the CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964 prescribes that
every Government servant shall on his first appointment to any
service or post submit a return of his assets and liabilities, in
such form as may be prescribed by the Government, giving the
full particulars regarding-
i. The immovable property inherited by him, or owned or
acquired by him or held by him on lease or mortgage, either
in his own name or in the name of any member of his family
or in the name of any other person;
ii. Shares, debentures and cash including bank deposits
inherited by him or similarly owned, acquired, or held by
him;
iii. Other movable property inherited by him or similarly owned,
acquired or held by him; and
iv. Debts and other liabilities incurred by him directly or
indirectly.
11.3 Maintaining Service Book
(a) Service Books in Form F.R. 10 as required by Articles 73 and 74 Civil
Account Code, shall be maintained for all upper subordinates and
establishment appointed otherwise than under the Police Act to whole time
pensionable employment.
(b) Service Books shall be kept in the office in which the pay of the person
concerned is drawn. Entries in Service Books shall be in Hindi/English and
shall be properly attested by the Superintendent of Police.
(c) Service Books shall be taken up for verification of pensionable service in
January each year. After satisfying himself that the services of the Police
officer concerned are correctly recorded in his service book, the
Superintendent of Police should record in it a certificate in the following
form over his signature: -
“Service verified from………..to………… according to Pay Bill Register
& other records (The record from which the verification is made)”.
74
(d) When a Police officer is transferred from the force to another office, the
Superintendent should record in the service book over his signature, the
result of the verification of service with reference to pay bills and
acquittance rolls, in respect of the whole period during which the officer
was employed under him.
(e) There shall be mandatory revision of entries in service book every 10
years of service. The Establishment In-Charge shall be responsible for the
same, and the concerned officer shall counter verify the information as
submitted by him.
(f) Service Book must be shown to the Government servants once every year
and their signatures obtained therein as a token of their having inspected
the Service Book.
11.4 Personal Files
A personal file shall be maintained by the Character Roll Clerk for every
enrolled Police officer. These files are intended for the record or original
orders and papers concerning officer’s service and conduct and are
supplementary to the Character Roll. The personal file of Police officers who
have quit the service or died shall be kept in a separate bundle for three
years, after which they will be destroyed.
11.5 CONFIDENTIAL REPORTS
The performance of every Government servant is assessed annually
through his/her Annual Performance Assessment Report (earlier
Annual Confidential Report), which is an important document
providing the basic and vital inputs for assessing the performance of
the Government servant and for assessing suitability for further
advancement in his/her career on occasions like confirmation,
promotion, selection for deputation, selection for foreign assignment
etc. Performance appraisal is a tool for human resource development
in order to enable a Government servant realize his true potential.
1. The performance in respect of Upper and Lower Subordinates is assessed
annually through the Assessment Report that is written by their reporting
Officer. Performance appraisal is meant to be a joint exercise between the
Government servant reported upon and the Reporting Officer.The
Reporting Officer should, as a rule, have sufficient knowledge of the work
and qualities of the employee reported upon, and submit it to the
Reviewing Officer. If the reviewing officer does not fully agree with the
Reporting Officer, he should indicate the nature and extent of such
difference.
75
2. The Assessment Report guides the defects and shortcomings, of the
officer reported and decides the future career advancement.
3. Thus, the system of APAR has two principle objectives. First and foremost
is to improve the performance of the subordinate in his present job. The
second one is to assess his potentialities and provide him appropriate
feedback and guidance for correcting his deficiencies and improving his
performance.
4. If a Reporting/Reviewing Officer is under suspension when the Annual
Performance Assessment Report has become due to be written/reviewed,
it may be written/reviewed by the officer concerned within two months from
the date of his having been placed under suspension or within one month
from the date on which the Report was due, whichever is later.
5. The full APAR including the overall grade and assessment of integrity shall
be communicated to the concerned officer after the Report is complete
with the remarks of the Reviewing Officer and the Accepting Authority
wherever such system is in vogue.
6. The concerned officer shall be given the opportunity to make any
representation against the entries and the final grading given in the Report
within a period of fifteen days from the date of receipt of the entries in the
APAR. The representation shall be restricted to the specific factual
observations contained in the report leading to assessment of the officer in
terms of attributes, work output etc. While communicating the entries, it
shall be made clear that in case no representation is received within the
fifteen days, it shall be deemed that he/she has no representation to make.
11.6 Maintenance of APAR
APAR rolls shall be arranged according to district constabulary numbers and
kept in a locked cupboard under the custody of I/C Confidential Cell (PHQ),
who will be responsible that they are neither damaged nor tampered with.
11.7 Uniform year (Financial) for writing APAR
The reporting period of the confidential reports shall be co terminus with the
financial year (April-March) in order to fall in line with the majority of the
Services and to coincide with the period of Annual Action Plan of the
Ministries/Departments of the Government of India.
11.8 Periodicity of writing
1. The assessment of the performance of Police officers should cover a
definite period over which it is possible to form a reasonably correct
assessment. With this end in view, APARs are recorded for the period
covered by the financial year.
76
2. Normally there should be only one report covering the year. There may,
however, be occasions where it becomes necessary to write more than
one report during a year by different Reporting Officers, when the
Reporting Officer or the officer reported upon, is transferred or deputed
elsewhere for a period of more than three months, etc. In that event, the
condition stipulated is that, the Reporting Officer has at least three months’
experience on which he can base his report on the officer reported upon.
When more than one report is written, each report should indicate
precisely the period covered by it. If the period of observation happens to
be less than three months, this fact only need be indicated in the report. At
any rate, a report must be written invariably at the end of the year which
must be done within one month.
3. The annual report should be recorded within one month of the expiry of the
report period. Any delay in this regard should be adversely commented
upon. If there is delay in submission of self-appraisal by the officer
reported upon, the Reporting Officer should give the report without self-
appraisal making a suitable note.
4. If two or more Reviewing Officers are working during the year, The
Reviewing officer whose period is more than other Reviewing Officer
should be reviewed in Annual Performance Assessment Report.
11.9 Representation against adverse remarks
1. The Competent Authority for considering adverse remarks under the
existing instructions may consider the representation, if necessary in
consultation with the Reporting and Reviewing officer and shall decide the
matter objectively based on the material placed before him within a period
of thirty days from the date of receipt of the representation.
2. All representations from lower subordinates and upper subordinates
against adverse remarks should be examined by the Reviewing officer in
consultation with the Reporting Officer.
3. The decision of the officer and the final grading will be communicated to
the concerned officer reported upon within fifteen days and a copy of
communication of final grading will be kept in the dossier.
11.10 Transfer of Reporting and/or Reviewing Officer in the middle of the
reporting year
1. If an officer is transferred during the middle of the reporting year, he
should immediately write the APAR of his subordinates in respect of the
year for the period up to the date of his transfer, provided that the period is
at least four months and the reports should be submitted to the reviewing
officer who will retain them in his custody and record his remarks in the
77
reviewing portions in the last of the reports for the year, taking into account
the reports for the previous portions of the year also, submitted to him by
the transferred officers, at the time of their transfer. If the reviewing
authority is transferred not simultaneously with Reporting Officer, but after
sometime, he will hand over such reports to his successor and the
successor will review the reports if he happens to have three months
experience. Otherwise, the previous reviewing officer will review the report
at the end of the year.
2. If, however a reviewing authority retired while there is no change in the
Reporting Officer and the subsequent reviewing authority does not have
three months experience of the work and conduct of the reportee, the
reviewing portion will be left blank with a suitable note, recorded therein.
This note can be recorded by the new reviewing authority who could not
review the report because he did not have even three months experience
or by the Reporting officer himself.
11.11 Reporting of APAR
1. The annual report should be recorded within one month of the expiry of the
report period.
2. When there is no reporting officer with the requisite experience of three
months or more during the period of report, the reviewing officer himself
may initiate the report as a reporting officer, provided the reviewing officer
is the same for the entire period of report.
3. If the reporting officer/reviewing officer is under suspension, then the
confidential report may be got written/reviewed by the officer concerned
within two months of his being placed under suspension or within one
month from the date on which the report was due, whichever is later.
Previous and next
← Rule 1A Police Officer may appeal against an order whichRule 4 →With respect to officers who have undergone training in approved or at institutions in India or abroad the following procedure should be adopted
All provisions of The Andaman and Nicobar Police Manual, 2023
Questions people ask
Is rule 2 of the Andaman and Nicobar Police Manual, 2023 still in force?
No repeal of the Andaman and Nicobar Police Manual, 2023 is recorded.