LawGrids logoLAWGRIDS.ORG

SOP FOR EXPERT OPINION UNDER SECTION 39, 61-63 OF BHARATIYA SAKSHYA ADHINIYAM FOR COLLECTION OF DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE(PRIMARY AND SECONDARY) INCLUDING ELECTRONIC OR DIGITAL RECORD AND ADMISSIBILITY OF ELECTRONIC RECORDS

Order - THE BHARATIYA NAGARIK SURAKSHA SANHITA, 2023

Text of this order

Chandigarh Police OFFICE OF THE DIRECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE UT, CHANDIGARH ADDL. DELUXE BUILDING, SECTOR 9, CHANDIGARH- 160009 _"_____‘_______A_S_L'_STANDING ORDER No. (I-2024 SOP FOR EXPERT OPINION UNDER SECTION 39, 61-63 OF BHARATIYA SAKSHYA ADHINIYAM FOR COLLECTION OF DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE(PRIMARY AND SECONDARY) INCLUDING ELECTRONIC OR DIGITAL RECORD AND ADMISSIBILITY OF ELECTRONIC RECORDS As a general rule, the opinion of a third person is irrelevant and considered inadmissible. However, there are certain cases in which the court is not in a position to form a correct opinion, like when the question involved is beyond the range of common experience or common knowledge or when special knowledge of a subject or experience is necessary. I these cases, the general rule is relaxed and put on hold and an expert evidence is admitted to enable the court to come to a proper decision Expert Opinion An expert opinion means a specialized opinion provided by a person who is expertise in a particular field like foreign law, science, art, handwriting, or any other technical area. These opinions are deemed relevant in legal cases when the matter requires a knowledge that goes beyond the understanding of an average person Section 39 to 45 of Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA) deals with the opinion of third persons and makes them a Relevant Fact, which is discussed as under: - ¢ Opinion of Experts-Section 39(1) e Opinion of Examiner of Electronic Evidence- Section 39(2) « Opinion 85 (0 handwriting-Section 41(1) ¢ Opinion as to electronic signature-Section 41(2) ¢ Opinion 85 to existence of right or custom-Section 42 ¢ Opinion as to usages, tenets, etc-Section 43 « Opinion on relationship-Section 44 EXPERT OPINION MAY BE GIVEN OF - e Foreign law or e Science or art or any other field or - e Handwriting or ¢ Finger impressions Section 40 Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA) provides that facts, which are not otherwise relevant, are relevant if they support or are inconsistent with Expert Opinion under Section 39(1) of BSA. Section 45 Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA), provides that the ground on which such opinions of experts is based is also relevant, EVIDENTIARY VALUE OF EXPERT OPINION It is only a weak piece of evidence and cannot be taken as a substantial piece.of evidence and bind the Court unless corroborated by other evidence. In conclusion, Expert ‘Opin]on plays a vital role in ensuring a comprehensive and informed evaluation of evidence, contributing to the fair and effective administration of justice within the Indian legal system. 1. Expert Opinions Relevance (Section 39) The opinions of experts in these fields are considered relevant when the court needs to form an opiniori on matters the foreign law, science, भा, handwriting, fingerprints etc. For example if the court is trying to find out whether the death of a person was due to poison, the opinion of a medical expert on the symptoms of that poison will be considered relevant. The opinion under this section is supportive and corroborative in nature. (Earlier Section 45 of IEA) 2. Digital and Electronic Evidence (Section 39) In cases, like information stored on a computer, the opinion of an Examiner of Electronic Evidence, provided in the Information Technology Act will be considered relevant. (Earlier Section 45-A of IEA) It also includes matters related to electronic signatures and the integrity of digital documents Section 61 and 62: These provisions in BSA state that electronic or digital records cannot be denied admissibility as evidence solely because they are electronic or digital Electronic or digital records have the same legal effect, validity and enforceability as other documents. Moreover, Section 62 of BSA states that the contents of electronic records can be proven in accordance with the provisions of Section 63 BSA Section 63 BSA: Admissibility of electronic records. 1. Computer output Any information contained in an electronic record which is:- s Printed on a paper, ¢ stored, recorded or copied in optical or magnetic media or semiconductor memory which is produced- by a computer or any communication device or otherwise stored, recorded or copied in any electronic form produced by a computer ¢ shall be deemed to be a document, ¢ If satisfy the conditions mentioned in clause (2) then shall be admissible in evidence without any further proof or production of the original. 2.Conditions for Admissibility of Computer Outputs ¢ Regular Use: The computer output must be from a computer 07 communication device used to create store, or process information by someone with lawful control who was using it for activities routinely carried out during that time ¢ Routine Information Input: Information must have been regularly fed into the computer in the ordinary course of activities. ¢ Proper Operation: The computer or a communication device must have been functioning properly during the relevant period, or any malfunctions should not affect the accuracy of the electronic record ¢ Accurate Reproduction of Information: The information contained in the electronic record must reproduce or be derived from the information fed into.the computer in the ordinary course of the specified activities. 3. Multiple Computers or Devices Single System Consideration: When the creation, storage, or processing of such information was carried out using multiple computer or communication devices, all of them are considered a single computer or communication device for the purposes of this section: whether used a) in standalone हज 0) on व computer system, 0) on a computer network d) on a computer resource enabling information creation or processing or storation, or e) through an intermediary, 4. Certification for Admissibility: | For an electronic record to be admissible as evidence, the production of a certificate complying with Sub- section 4 is a condition precedent. Such certificate must accompany the electronic " record, including: - a) Identification of the electronic record and description of how it was produced. b) Particulars of any device involved in producing the electronic record to demonstrate it was produced by the computer or communication device as defined in Sub-section 3. —— c) Details related to compliance with the conditions in Sub-section 2. Certification Authority: Such certificate must be signed ¢ by a person in charge of the computer or communication device or-the management of the relevant activities, or s by an expert. ¢ The certificate must be signed in the forms prescribed under the schedule part A and part B of BSA, 2023. 5. For the purposes of this section: - (व Supply of Information: Information is considered to be supplied to a computer or communication device if it is provided in any appropriate form, either directly or with or without human intervention using any appropriate equipment. (b) Production of Computer Output: A computer output is deemed to have been produced by a computer or communication device if it was generated either directly by the device or with or without human intervention using appropriate equipment or other electronic means as referred (0 in sub-Section (3). 6. The investigating officer shall follow the aforesaid guidelines/directions during the course of investigation for the purpose of collection of evidences. The investigating officer shall search and seize (Sec 185, 106 BNSS, Sec 23 BSA) or by हो) production through summons (Sec 94 BNSS). While doing seizure the Hash value of the electronic record must be calculated and noted in the case diary to ensure preservation of integrity of the data. It is noteworthy to mention that calculation of 'Hash value' of the electronic record was not a condition in the old law. When the original computer-generated output is collected and produced before the court, it is called primary evidence (Sec. 57 BSA) eg. DVR/NVR machine itself which was connected to the CCTV camera. When a copy of the computer output of a part of it is collected and produced before the court, it is called secondary evidence (such as CCTV footage, present in the DVR/NVR machine, is copied on a CD/DVD or a pen drive or hard disk. When any secondary evidence 15 presented before the court, a certificate U/S 63 BSA is also to be submitted to support the admissibility of the digital evidence. Safeguard measures such as using of bubble wrap, anti- static bags, Faraday bags etc. can be used by the Investigation officer to prevent tampering/ damage to electronic records. This SOP 15 subject to modifications on the basis of feedback from the investigating officers/ Supervisory officers. Issued for meticulous compliance. 9४ (Sur Afldra Singh Yadav, 19९5) Director General of Police, Union Territory, Chandigarh No. // 2५८6 - ८ JUT/HAC/Dated Chandigarh the:- R 2.4/ 9"7(4 « Copy toall concerned 2६ (० Secvion e e AT 05

All of THE BHARATIYA NAGARIK SURAKSHA SANHITA, 2023