Annexure D, THE HIMACHAL PRADESH NATIONAL LAW UNIVERSITY ACADEMIC REGULATIONS, 2019: ANNEXURE-D
THE HIMACHAL PRADESH NATIONAL LAW UNIVERSITY ACADEMIC REGULATIONS, 2019 - Annexure D
Text of annexure D
ANNEXURE-D
ANNEXURE-D
HPNLU Post Graduate Course Curriculum LL.M. (One Year Programme)
Sl.
No.
LL.M. (One Year) Programme
1st Semester
Course Code Compulsory Papers
1. LM-101 Legal Research Methodology
2. LM-102 Law and Justice in a Globalizing World
3. LM-103 Term Paper
Specialization Papers
Course Code Constitutional Law Course Code Criminal Law
4. LM-104 Constitutional Governance and Federalism LM-106 Criminology and Criminal Justice Administration
5. LM-105 Global Administrative Law LM-107 Criminal Justice System and Human Rights
Optional Papers
6. LM-108 Media Law
7. LM-109 Victimology
20
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
2nd Semester
Course Code Compulsory Papers
1. LM-201 Comparative Public Law
2.. LM-202 Dissertation (3 Credits)
Specialization Papers
Course Code Constitutional Law Course Code Criminal Law
3. LM-203 Constitutional Rights & Theory LM-205 International Criminal Law
4. LM-204 Service Law LM-206 Sentences and Sentencing
Optional Papers
5. LM-207 Health Law
6. LM-208 Cyber Crimes & Cyber Security
* Optional/specialisation Papers shall be offered when at least 5 students have opted the same Course.
Note: Each optional Paper LL.M. (One Year) Programme are of Two Credits, except compulsory/foundation courses and dissertation which are of three Credits each.
21
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
PART-II
The Himachal Pradesh National Law University (HPNLU), Shimla Regulations
for LL.M. (One Year) Degree Programme, 2019
Index
1. Short Title, Extent and Commencement
2. Admission
3. Course Structure
4. The Centre fir Post-Graduate Legal Studies
5. Duration of the Programme
6. The Course Curriculum
7. Dissertation
8. Term Paper
9. Examination
10. Evaluation of Students
11. Grades and Divisions
22
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
1. SHORT TITLE, EXTENT AND COMMENCEMENT
These Regulations shall be called the Himachal Pradesh National Law University
(HPNLU), Shimla Regulation for LL.M. (One Year) Degree Programme, 2019”.
These Regulations shall come into force w.e.f. 25th December, 2019.
Admission to the course of LL.M. (One Year) Degree Programme will be regulated by
the these rules.
2. ADMISSION
Admission to LL.M. (One Year) Degree Programme shall be done through Common Law
Admission Test (CLAT).
3. COURSE STRUCTURE
3.1 The course curriculum, shown in detail, in the Himachal Pradesh National Law
University Courses of Study, Admission and Curriculum Regulations, 2019, shall apply.
The relevant rules of the Himachal Pradesh National Law University Regulations for
Doctorate of Philosophy (Ph. D.) Programme, 2019, AND the Himachal Pradesh
National Law University, Shimla, Examinations Regulations, 2019, shall apply.
3.2 One Year LL.M. Degree programme under semester system shall have at least 18 weeks
of teaching/research/practical in each semester.
3.3 The one-year LL.M programme shall have 26 credits with three mandatory courses of 3
credits each (making a total of nine credits), six optional courses of 2 credits each
(making a total of 12 credits) and a dissertation of 3 credits and Term Paper of 2 credits.
3.3 The University shall offer LL.M in International and Comparative Law, Constitutional
and Administrative Law, Corporate and Commercial Law, Criminal and Security Law,
Family and Social Security Law and Legal Pedagogy, and Research.
4. THE CENTRE OF POST-GRADUATE LEGAL STUDIES
There shall be a Centre of Post-Graduate Legal Studies (CPGLS) as per UGC guidelines.
5. DURATION OF THE PROGRAMME
23
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
5.1 The duration of the Programme shall be One Year in two semesters with minimum of 30
contact hours in each week and eighteen weeks for each of the two Semesters including
class room teaching, library work, seminars and research.
5.2 The entire Programme shall be spread evenly for the duration of the programme, with not
less than 12 credits in each semester.
6. THE COURSE CURRICULUM
6.1 The course curriculum for One Year LL.M. Degree programme shall have the following
components:
i) Foundation/Compulsory Papers (3 papers of 03 credits each)
ii) Optional/Specialization Papers (6 papers of 02 credits each)
iii) Dissertation (03 credits)
iv) Term Paper (02 credits)
6.2 A student shall take a minimum of four specialization papers from any particular Group to
qualify degree of LL.M. with specialization in the particular specialization/Group. The
candidate shall opt for remaining paper/papers out of the specializations offered in order
to complete the number of courses prescribed to complete the Degree.
6.2 Foundation/Compulsory Papers:
The Foundation Courses shall consist of the following three subjects/papers:
A. Research Methods and Legal Writing
B. Law and Justice in a Globalizing World
C. Comparative Public Law
6.3 Optional/Specialization Papers:
The list of papers/subjects given in each specialization/group and of optional papers are
given in (HPNLU Curriculum) Annexure-I.
7. Dissertation
The dissertation shall carry a minimum of three credits (200 Marks).
8. Term Paper
The Term Paper shall carry a minimum of two credits (100 Marks).
24
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
9. EXAMINATION
9.1 The examinations shall be conducted semester-wise.
2.2 All Examinations of the programme shall be governed by the Himachal Pradesh National
Law University Examinations Regulations, 2019
10. EVALUATION OF STUDENTS
10.1 The evaluation of students in a course/paper shall consist of following three components:
(a) Seminar Paper and Presentation (15+10=25 Marks)
(b) Mis-Semester Test (25 Marks)
(c) End-Semester Examination (50 Marks)
10.2 Notwithstanding anything stated in Rule 7 of these Regulations, the Term Paper and
Dissertation shall be evaluated out of 100 Marks and 200 Marks respectively, and the
same shall be examined by external expert/s.
10.3 A student shall have to secure 50% marks to pass each paper/course.
10.4 A student who fails to submit Seminar Paper/Presentation or Dissertation within the
notified time, may be allowed to submit/present the same after depositing prescribed late
fee.
10.5 Student failing to secure minimum pass marks in Term Paper or Dissertation shall be
allowed to re-submit the same for evaluation once after depositing the prescribed fee.
11. GRADES AND DIVISIONS
Award of Grades and divisions shall be governed by the Himachal Pradesh National Law
University Examinations Regulations, 2019
25
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
Part-III
The Himachal Pradesh National Law University (HPNLU), Shimla Regulations
for Doctorate of Philosophy (Ph.D.) Programme, 2019
Index
12. Short Title, Extent and Commencement
13. The Board of Studies
14. Research Advisory Committee
15. Eligibility and Admission
16. Allocation of Research Supervisor
17. Research Title and Synopsis
18. Course Work
19. Time Span
20. Progress Report
21. Submission
22. Evaluation
23. Viva-Voce
24. Fees
26
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
1. SHORT TITLE, EXTENT AND COMMENCEMENT
1.1 These Regulations shall be called the Himachal Pradesh National Law University
(HPNLU), Shimla Regulations for Doctorate of Philosophy (Ph.D.) Programme, 2019.
The relevant rules of the Himachal Pradesh National Law University, Shimla,
Examinations Regulations, 2019, shall apply.
1.2 These Regulations shall come into force w.e.f. 25th December, 2019.
1.4 Admission and other matters relating to Doctorate of Philosophy (Ph.D.) Programme will
be regulated by these regulations. The Degree of Doctor of Philosophy may be granted in
Law by the University subject to the general guidance of the Academic Council, Board of
Studies, and Research Advisory Committee.
1.5 The provisions contained in this Regulation shall be applicable to candidates already
registered for Ph.D. Programme.
2. THE BOARD OF STUDIES
2.1 The Board of Studies shall consist of: -
(i) The Vice-Chancellor, who shall be the Chairperson
(ii) The Dean Academic Affairs
(iii) Two faculty members nominated by the Vice-Chancellor
(iv) Two external experts nominated by the Vice-Chancellor.
Note: However, the external experts from respective social science subject/management
subject shall be invited whenever any issue relating to social science
/management curriculum is to be considered.
27
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
2.2 The Board of Studies shall meet at least twice a year, and shall have the power to perform
the following functions:
(i) To frame, update and make recommend the courses of study for UG, PG and
Ph.D. Course Work.
(ii) To add, delete subjects/papers as per the guidelines of regulatory body.
(iii) To frame, modify the structure of the courses, term papers, dissertations, thesis
and question papers etc.
(iv) Approval of Ph.D. Synopsis as recommended by Research Advisory Committee.
(v) To prepare and recommend panel of examiners for UG, PG; appointments of
supervisors and examiners/experts for Ph.D. Course Work, and evaluation of
Ph.D. thesis.
(vi) Any other item requiring attention of the Board.
3. RESEARCH ADVISORY COMMITTEE
3.1 There shall be Research Advisory Committee constituted by Vice Chancellor for One
Year LL.M. and Ph.D. Programmes.
3.2 The Research Advisory Committee shall consist of the following:
(i) The Vice Chancellor or senior faculty member nominated by Vice Chancellor,
who shall be the Chairperson.
(ii) Dean Academic Affairs or any faculty member nominated by the Vice
Chancellor.
(iii) Two external experts nominated by the Vice Chancellor.
(iv) The respective Supervisor or the LL.M. /Ph.D. Scholar shall be the member
when the matter regarding such scholar is being considered.
3.3 There shall be a Research Advisory Committee constituted by Vice Chancellor for LL.M.
and Ph.D. Programmes.
The Research Advisory Committee shall have the following responsibilities:
(i) To finalize the topic/title of LL.M. Dissertation and Ph.D. Thesis.
(ii) To review the LL.M. and Ph.D. Synopsis and make recommendation to
Board of Studies.
28
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
(iii) To guide the research scholar to develop the study design and
methodology of research and identify the course(s) that he/she may require
to do.
(iv) To review and evaluate the research scholar’s presentation of six-monthly
progress of his/her work including Ph.D. course work.
(v) Any other item requiring attention of the Research Advisory Committee
3.4 A research scholar shall appear before the Research Advisory Committee to make a
presentation of the progress of his/her work including Ph.D. Course Work for evaluation
and further guidance.
3.5 The six-monthly progress reports shall be submitted to Board of Studies through the
Research Advisory Committee.
3.6 In case the progress of the research scholar is unsatisfactory in three consecutive six
monthly reports the Research Advisory Committee shall record the reasons for the same
and forward the same to the Board of Studies for making specific recommendation to the
Vice Chancellor.
4. ELIGIBILITY & ADMISSION:
4.1 Master’s degree in Law, with at least 55% marks in aggregate or its equivalent grade 'B'
in the UGC 7-point scale (or an equivalent grade in a point scale wherever grading
system is followed) or an equivalent degree from a foreign educational Institution
accredited by an Assessment and Accreditation Agency which is approved, recognized or
authorized by an authority, established or incorporated under a law in its home country or
any other statutory authority in that country for the purpose of assessing, accrediting or
assuring quality and standards of educational institutions.
4.2 A relaxation of 5% of marks, from 55% to 50%, or an equivalent relaxation of grade,
may be allowed for those belonging to SC/ST/differently-abled and other categories of
candidates as per the University Grant Commission guidelines from time to time.
4.3 The admission to the Ph.D. Programme shall have a two-stage process i.e. Qualifying
Entrance Test and Presentation to Board of Studies.
(a) The admission to Ph.D. Programme shall be through a qualifying Entrance Test
i.e. HPNLU Ph.D. Entrance Test. The Entrance Test shall be only a qualifying
test. The candidate who appeared in the Ph.D. Entrance Test has to secure not less
than 50% Marks (without round off) to qualify the Test. The syllabus of the
Entrance Test shall consist of 50% of Research Methodology and the remaining
50% shall be from Constitutional Law and Jurisprudence.
29
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
(b) the Candidates declared qualified through entrance test shall be required to
present their research proposal before the Board of Studies.
(c) the Candidates having already qualified UGC-NET (including JRF) shall be
exempted from appearing in the Entrance Test, and shall require to appear before
Board to present their research proposal.
(d) The Board of Studies shall examine all the proposals, and shall recommend to the
Vice Chancellor for provisional registration to the Ph.D. Programme.
(e) The approved candidate may be allowed to be registered for the Ph.D. Programme
as Full Time or Part Time Researcher.
(f) For removal of doubts, it is clarified that all the interested candidates whether
exempted from Entrance Test or not, should apply to Ph.D. Programme in the
prescribed manner and on payment of prescribed fee notified by the University in
the advertisement every year.
4.4 The candidate, on being provisionally admitted will pay the prescribed fees and will be
provisionally enrolled in the University. His/her date of enrollment will be the date of the
payment of fees.
4.5 A research scholar provisionally admitted to Ph. D. programme shall be required to
undergo Ph.D. course work as prescribed under Rule 6. The research scholar shall have to
qualify the coursework as per the Himachal Pradesh National Law University
Examination Regulations,” 2019.
The duration of the course work shall be of one semester span. A scholar failing to
qualify in the course work shall be given another chance to re-appear in the examination.
If a scholar fails to qualify even in the second attempt, his/her admission shall be
cancelled.
5 ALLOCATION OF RESEARCH SUPERVISOR
5.1 Subject to approval of the Vice Chancellor, the Board of Studies shall allocate the
Supervisor to the candidate enrolled for Ph.D. Programme.
5.2 Any regular Professor of the University with at least five research publications in
refereed journals and any regular Associate/Assistant Professor of the university with a
Ph.D. degree and at least two research publications in refereed journals may be
recognized as Research Supervisor.
Provided that only a full-time regular teacher can act as a supervisor. The external
supervisors are not allowed except in cases of interdisciplinary studies with the prior
approval of the Research Advisory Committee.
30
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
5.3 The maximum strength of students allocated to a supervisor shall be according to the
designation of the supervisor i.e. Professor-08, Associate Professor-06 and Assistant
Professor-04 students.
In case of joint supervision, the number of students enrolled will be counted as one for
each of the Joint Supervisors.
5.4 A regular faculty member, who is no more in the services of the University, will cease to
be the supervisor/joint supervisor, with immediate effect and the University will appoint
another supervisor/joint supervisor in his/her place.
Provided that where a regular faculty member retires from the active service of the
University due to superannuation, he/she may continue to work as supervisor if the
candidate enrolled under him/her has already made pre-Ph.D. submission.
6. FINALIZATION OF RESEARCH TITLE AND PH.D. SYNOPSIS
6.1 Research scholar shall finalize his/her title of research in consultation with supervisor,
and shall make presentation before the Research Advisory Committee within three
months from the date of enrollment.
Provided that the Vice Chancellor may extend the time period for approval of research
title for a maximum period of six months.
6.2 The Scholar shall prepare the Ph.D. Synopsis in consultation with the Supervisor and
submit the synopsis within six months from date of approval of the title. He/she shall
make presentation of the Synopsis before the Research Advisory Committee.
Provided that the Vice Chancellor may extend the time period for approval of Ph.D.
Synopsis for further period of six months.
6.3 The Research Advisory Committee shall, on the basis of Ph.D. Synopsis submitted and
the presentation made, may recommend, with or without modification to the Board of
Studies for approval.
6.4 The Board of Studies may:
(a) reject the synopsis,
(b) accept synopsis with or without modifications
The Scholar shall incorporate the modifications within the time period allowed by the
Board od Studies.
7. COURSE WORK
31
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
7.1 Every Student pursuing Ph.D. shall have to complete Ph.D. Course work. The duration of
the Course Work shall of be one Semester. The Syllabi are as under (Annexure-I).
7.2 COURSE STRUCTURE
(a) LEGAL RESEARCH AND METHODOLOGY (100 Marks) 04 Credit
(b) EMERGING TRENDS IN LAW (100 Marks) 04 Credit
(c) Written Assignments: (Subject/area Specifi
7.3
7.4
7.5
c)
(i) Writing of One Research Paper containing not less than 5000 words.
(ii) Conducting a pilot empirical research/field work.
(iii) Review of literature containing not less than 30 pages (MS Default).
The performance of the student in written assignments shall be evaluated by Research
Advisory Committee on satisfactory / unsatisfactory criteria.
During the Ph.D. Course Work, each Scholar shall have to undertake 03 classes at UG
level spread over the period of six months in one subject, which, along with the feedback
of students, shall be submitted to Research Advisory Committee.
........(deleted)
Subject to Rule 7.4, at the end of the Course Work, Scholar shall be evaluated through
Written Examinations and Presentation before the Research Advisory Committee. The
Components for evaluation shall be as follows:
(a) Written Examinations: ` (Total 200 Marks)
a) Legal Research and Methodology (100 Marks)
b) Emerging Trends in Law (100 Marks)
(b) Written Assignments (Satisfactory/unsatisfactory)
(c) Teaching Assignment (Satisfactory/unsatisfactory)
7.6 The result of Ph.D. Course Work shall be declared as ‘satisfactory’ or ‘unsatisfactory’. A
Candidate who has secured a CGPA of not less than 5.6 shall be deemed to have
completed the Course Work satisfactorily. The candidate failing to complete the course
work ‘satisfactorily’, will have to reappear in Written Examination or Written
Assignments as the case may be.
8. TIME SPAN FOR RESEARCH
8.1 The span period of research shall commence from the date of enrollment i.e. date of first
fee submission for the Ph.D. enrollment.
32
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
8.2` The duration of Ph.D. Programme shall be of a minimum period of three years, including
course work and a maximum of six years.
Provided that women candidate and person with disabilities (more than 40% disabilities)
may be allowed a relaxation of two years in the maximum duration.
Provided further that the women candidates may be provided maternity leave once in the
entire duration of Ph.D. for up to 240 days.
8.3 In case, the scholar is not able to submit thesis within the prescribed time limit, he/she
may apply for extension of time to the Board of Studies through the Supervisor along
with written justifications. The Board of Studies, after examining the written
justifications, may recommend to the Vice Chancellor for extension of time for a
maximum period of six months.
8.4 In exceptional case, if the scholar is not able to submit the thesis even within the
extended period of six months extended by the Board of Studies, as prescribed under
Rule 8.3, the Vice Chancellor may, upon the written justifications submitted by the
scholar, further extend the period to a maximum of one year.
8.5 In case the scholar is not able to submit the thesis even within the extended period,
his/her enrollment shall be deemed to be cancelled.
9. PROGRESS REPORT
9.1 Every candidate enrolled for Ph.D. Programme shall be required to submit six monthly
progress report through the supervisor.
9.2 Every scholar is required to submit the six-monthly progress report on or before 30th
September and 31st of March in each Academic Session. Where scholar fails to submit
the report within the prescribed time, he/she may submit the same after depositing late
fee prescribed in this behalf.
9.3 The Progress Report shall be laid before the Research Advisory Committee and Board of
Studies, and the same shall be examined as satisfactory or unsatisfactory.
9.4 Subject to Rule 3.6, where three consecutive six-monthly report of any scholar is found
unsatisfactory the Board of Studies shall make recommendation to the Vice Chancellor
for the cancellation of Ph.D. Enrollment of such scholar.
10. SUBMISSION OF PH.D. THESIS
10.1 On a report from the Supervisor that the thesis is likely to be submitted within six
months, the Dean Academic Affairs shall convene a meeting of the Board of Studies for
finalizing the panel/s of external examiners to evaluate the Ph.D. Thesis(es).
33
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
10.2 The Supervisor shall forward a panel/s of 06 (six) external examiners, who are
Professors, working or retired, with full particulars of each to the Dean Academic Affairs,
who shall place it before the Board of Studies. The Board of Studies shall forward the
same with/without modification to the Vice Chancellor.
10.3 From the panel/s of 06 examiners forwarded by Board of Studies, the Vice Chancellor
shall appoint three examiners to evaluate, amongst whom not more than one may be from
State of Himachal Pradesh.
10.4 Prior to the submission of the thesis, the research scholar shall make a pre-submission
presentation before the Board Studies, and the same will be open to all faculty members
and research students for getting feedback and comments, which may suitably be
incorporated into draft thesis under the advice of the supervisor.
10.5 The Research Scholar shall submit his/her thesis (06 Copies) along with abstracts (08
Copies) and the soft copy thereof (CD) in the prescribed format within a period of three
months from the date of Pre-Ph.D. presentation.
10.6 The research scholar shall publish one research paper (in the relevant area) in a refereed
journal, and make two paper presentations in conferences/seminar before submission of
thesis. The scholar is required to submit the same in the form of the reprint or photocopy.
10.7 The research scholar shall submit to the Thesis Section of the Examination Branch, four
copies of thesis, duly signed by the Supervisor along with the following -
(a) A certificate by the Supervisor counter signed by Dean Academic Affairs
(Annexure- II)
(b) A declaration by the candidate (Annexure- II)
(c) A certificate along with similarity index duly signed by authorized person/expert
countersigned by the Supervisor and the Dean Academic Affairs indicating the
percentage of plagiarized material which in no case should exceed 10%.
(d) Citation of the thesis in the prescribed manner signed by the Supervisor and
countersigned by the Dean Academic Affairs.
(e) A Compact Disk (CD) which shall include Citation, Research Synopsis, Abstract,
Ph.D. Thesis, and a Passport Size Photo of the Research Scholar.
10.8 The research scholar may incorporate in his thesis the contents of any work which he
may have published on.
10.9 At the time of depositing the thesis, candidate is required to provide, in the prescribed
format: -
34
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
(i) No Objection/No Dues Certificate from Library,
(ii) No Objection/No Dues Certificate from the Account Section,
(iii) No Objection/No Dues Certificate from Establishment,
(iv) No Objection/No Dues Certificate from the office of Dean Student Welfare
(v) Any other Office/Authority prescribed in this regard
11. EVALUATION OF PH.D. THESIS
11.1 A period of two months shall be given to the examiners for evaluating the thesis.
However, if the report is not received within six months from the date of dispatch, the
Controller of Examination shall initiate the process, after seeking approval from the Vice
Chancellor, to get it evaluated from another examiner.
11.2 The examiner shall examine the thesis and submit the report in the prescribed format
provided in this behalf, along with such additional observations, as she/he may deem
necessary. In his/her assessment, the Examiner shall be required to express his/her
categorical opinion on the following points:
(i) that the thesis is an original piece of research work.
(ii) that the thesis contributes to the existing knowledge either form the point of the
discovery of new facts or the interpretation of existing facts or both;
(iii) that the research scholar has given proof of consistent thinking and critical
approach to the problem enunciated by him/her;
(iv) that the literary presentation of the thesis is satisfactory;
(v) that the research scholar has adequately acknowledge the existing
sources/literature.
11.3 The examiner shall make a clear recommendation that:
(a) The thesis be accepted for the Ph.D. degree; or
(b) The thesis be rejected; or
(c) The research scholar be allowed to present his thesis in a revised form.
The report under clause (b) or (c) shall include the grounds on which the recommendation
is based. The examiner shall also indicate questions to be asked from the research scholar
during the viva voce.
35
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
11.4 When all the reports have been received, the Controller of Examination shall initiate the
process to seek the approval of the Vice Chancellor for conducting of the public Viva
Voce from any of the external examiners.
11.5 If all the three external examiners recommend rejection of the thesis, the Vice-Chancellor
shall order for the rejection of the thesis.
11.6 In case, two of the three examiners recommend the thesis for the award of the degree, the
Controller of Examination shall initiate the process mentioned under Rule 11.4 for pubic
viva voce.
11.7 Where, two of the external examiners are in favour of re-submission of the thesis in a
revised form, the research scholar shall be directed to re-submit a revised version of
his/her thesis not later than six months from the date of such a decision. The research
scholar shall be supplied extracts of the reports of the examiners indicating the line on
which the thesis is to be revised. The thesis so resubmitted shall be sent for evaluation,
preferably to the same examiners.
11.8 In case where, two of the external examiners rejected the thesis, the matter shall be laid
before the Board of Studies. The Board of Studies may accept the recommendation made
by examiners or permits re-submission of a revised version of his/her thesis not later than
six months from the date of such a decision. The thesis so revised, shall be sent for
evaluation as per the regulation.
11.9 The research scholar shall be allowed to re-submit the thesis after depositing requisite fee
notified in this regard.
12. VIVA VOCE
12.1 The Vice Chancellor shall constitute a Board of Examiners for conducting Viva Voce. The
Board of Examiners for viva voce shall consist of:
(a) Nominee of the Vice Chancellor who shall be the Chairperson
(b) External Examiner who has evaluated the thesis
(c) Supervisor
12.2 Two members including External Examiner shall constitute the quorum of the Board of
Examiners.
12.3 The research scholar shall have to defend the thesis before the Board of Examiners in the
public viva voce to be conducted by the Board of Examiners as per the date notified by the
Controller of Examination in consultation with the External Examiner in this regard.
36
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
12.4 If the Board of Examiners is satisfied with the performance of the research scholar, the
Board shall recommend the award of the degree of Doctorate of Philosophy (Ph. D.) to the
research scholar.
12.5 If the research scholar’s performance is judged to be unsatisfactory, the Board of
Examiners may give the research scholar a second chance for the defense.
12.6 The reports of the examiners and viva voce shall be submitted to Vice Chancellor, who
may pass orders for granting provisional degree, subject to the approval of the Academic
Council and the Executive Council, whose decision shall be final.
12. FEES AND REMUNERATION: The fee-structure for Ph.D. Programme and the
remuneration for evaluation etc., shall be as specified under Annexure-B of The
Himachal Pradesh National Law University (HPNLU), Shimla Courses of Study,
Admission, and Curriculum Regulation,” 2019, and Annexure-I of the Himachal
Pradesh National Law University, Shimla, Examinations Regulations, 2019,
respectively.
37
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
PART-IV
The Himachal Pradesh National Law University, Shimla, Examinations
Regulations, 2019
Index
25. Short Title, Extent and Commencement
26. Controller of Examinations
27. Attendance
28. Examination and Evaluation System
29. Question Paper Formation
30. Moderation Committee
31. Medium and Duration of Examination
32. Re-Appear and Improvement of Grade
33. Invigilation of Examinations
34. Grace Marks
35. Scrutiny
36. Re-Evaluation of Answer Scripts
37. Promotion to Subsequent Year and Award of Degree
38. Credit System
39. Use of Unfair Means
1. SHORT TITLE, EXTENT AND COMMENCEMENT
38
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
1.1 These Regulations shall be called the Himachal Pradesh National Law University,
Shimla, Examinations Regulations, 2019.
1.2 These Regulations shall come into force w.e.f. 25th December, 2019.
Admission to various Courses offered by University shall be regulated by the Himachal
Pradesh National Law University, Shimla Courses of Study, Admission, Curriculum and
Examination Regulations, 2019.
The relevant rules related to the Board of Studies, The HIMACHAL PRADESH
NATIONAL LAW UNIVERSITY REGULATIONS FOR DOCTORATE OF
PHILOSOPHY (Ph. D.) PROGRAMME, 2019, shall apply.
2. CONTROLLER OF EXAMINATIONS (COE): There shall be an office of Controller
of Examinations.
2.1 APPOINTMENT AND RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE CONTROLLER OF
EXAMINATIONS
2.2 The Vice-Chancellor shall appoint the Controller of Examination.
2.3 The Controller of Examination shall be responsible for implementation of the rules
contained in the Regulations. of the Himachal Pradesh National Law University
Examinations Regulations, 2019).
2.4 The Controller of Examinations, in consultation with the Vice-chancellor, shall plan,
organize, supervise and take decisions in all examinations related matters. The COE may
make recommendations to the Vice-Chancellor for any desired changes/modifications/
amendment of these Regulations from time to time.
2.5 The COE may make recommendations to the Vice-chancellor for approval of procedures for
maintenance of examinations and academic records by the Examination Branch.
2.6 The examination process, being confidential in nature, no person, students, faculty
members, staff or outsiders, shall seek access to the secrecy branch of the office of COE
for any reason whatsoever. Any query may be made at the inquiry counter of the
Examination Branch.
3. ATTENDANCE
3.1 Attendance in Undergraduate Courses: No student of any of the Undergraduate Courses
shall be allowed to take the end semester test in a subject if the student concerned has not
attended minimum of 70% of the classes held in the subject concerned as also the moot
court room exercises, tutorials and practical training conducted in the subject taken
together.
39
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
Provided that if a student for any exceptional reasons fails to attend 70% of
the classes held in any subject, the vice-Chancellor of the University may allow the student
to take the test if the student concerned has attended at least 65% of the classes held in the
subject concerned and attended 70% of classes in all the subjects taken together.
3.2 Attendance in Post Graduate Courses: A minimum of 75% attendance shall be
compulsory to appear in the End Semester Examinations. The Percentage shall be
calculated on the basis of average of attendance in all the papers of relevant semester. A
candidate who fails to obtain 75% of attendance shall not be allowed to sit in the
examinations.
3.3 Academic leave: The Academic leave shall only be granted by the Vice Chancellor on the
recommendation of the Dean Academic Affairs. While applying for academic leave, the
student shall specify the class hour(s) that he/she may be absent for. Academic leave shall
be given for a class hour/set of class hours, and not in terms of days. An academic leave
form shall accordingly be filed and forwarded to concerned faculty for preparing
attendance record.
3.4 The Academic leave to a student shall be considered, subject to the prior approval of the
Vice Chancellor, or any person designated by him, for participation in moot court
competitions, seminars, conferences, or any other academic, co-curricular and extra-
curricular activities. It is further clarified that academic leave shall not be granted for
participation in Summer School programmes, internships, job interviews, passport/visa
interviews or examinations of any kind internal and external etc., under any circumstances.
3.5 Invitation for participation in any of the activities, for which a student may be granted
academic leave, should be addressed to and received by the University.
3.6 Academic leave shall not exceed 15% of the total classes in any given semester. The
Academic leave shall include Travel/journey period.
3.7 It is clarified that in case a student is unable to appear in any examination, on any grounds
whatsoever, there shall not be any rescheduling of the said examination.
3.8 If a student is assigned any University assignment, duly granted by appropriate authority
with the approval of Vice-chancellor, he/she shall be granted attendance for the period.
4. EXAMINATION AND EVALUATION SYSTEM
4.1 The University follows the Credit-based Semester System for the purpose of Examination
and Evaluation and award of Degree/diploma/certificate in all the courses/programmes.
40
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
4.2 Each course run by the University shall be examined internally as well as externally to
ensure a comprehensive assessment of performance the students throughout the semester.
The distribution of marks in the examination shall be as per the following table.
Sr. No. Internal/External Assessment Marks
Internal Assessment
2 Assignment & Presentation 25 (15+10)
3 Mid-Semester Examination 25
External Assessment
5 Semester–End Examination 50
Total 100
4.3 Internal Assessment of each paper is based on the parameters of Mid-Semester Test, and
assignment & presentation made by students in each course/paper.
4.4 The assignment & presentation/viva-voce and practical examination, if any, shall be
conducted as per the Academic Calendar of HPNLU, Shimla.
4.5 ‘Mid Semester Tests’ shall be conducted after completion of at least 50 % of any given
course.
4.6 The schedule for all Examinations shall be notified by the Controller of Examinations in
consultation with Vice-chancellor, in advance, at least one week before the scheduled
date of the examination.
4.7 For the purpose of End-Semester Examinations, necessary arrangements including filling
of examination form, issuance of Admit Card etc., seating plan and other arrangement
shall be prepared as per direction of the Controller of Examinations.
4.8 The University may provide honorarium to all external/internal examiners as prescribed
under Annexure-I.
4.9 Subject to the UGC regulations/notifications, the Differently-abled students may be
allowed to use relevant assistive devices for specific papers where such devices are
necessary. Such a candidate may be provided with a scribe by the University.
4.10 Question Paper Setting and assessment of courses/subjects, in both, Mid-Term and End
Term Examinations may be internal or external as decided by the Controller of
Examination with the approval of Vice-Chancellor.
5. QUESTION PAPER FORMATION
41
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
5.1 There shall be internal/external setting of question papers for Mid/End-Semester
Examinations.
5.2 Subject to the recommendations of the Board of Studies and approval of the Vice-
chancellor, the COE shall prepare the panel of question paper setters/ examiners.
5.3 Questions set in the question paper shall cover specified syllabus in the Mid Semester
Examinations and the entire syllabus of the paper in the End-Semester Examinations. The
question papers in all courses, shall comprise of combinations of theory and problems,
designed to evaluate analytical skills of students.
5.4 Question paper of Mid Semester Examinations shall have two Sections. Section ‘A’,
shall be compulsory, containing 02 ‘Short Answer’ type questions, (at least one from
module 1 and one from module 2 of the syllabus), carrying 03 marks each.
Section ‘B’ of the question paper shall be Descriptive in nature and shall have 02
questions (i.e. one from module 1 and the other from module 2, of the syllabus), with
additional option from the respective modules, carrying 8 marks each.
5.5 Question paper for End-Semester Examination shall have two Sections. Section ‘A’,
shall be compulsory, containing 06 ‘Short Answer’ type questions, (at least one from
each module of the syllabus), carrying 3 marks each.
Section ‘B’ of the question paper shall be Descriptive in nature and shall have 04
questions (at least one from each module of the syllabus), with additional option from the
respective modules, carrying 08 marks each.
5.6 For the Mid/End-Semester Examinations, 01 sets of question papers shall be prepared by
a question paper setter and shall be submitted to the Controller of Examinations as per the
schedule notified in this regard.
6 MODERATION COMMITTEE
6.1 There shall be a Moderation Committee consisting of three-members coordinated/headed
by the Controller of Examination. The Vice-Chancellor shall nominate two-faculty
members to the Moderation Committee.
6.2 The Moderation Committee shall moderate all question papers, and shall finalize the
question paper. The Committee shall have the power to take suitable policy decisions in
this regard. Moderation Committee shall also moderate the results of the above said
examinations.
7. Medium and Duration of Examination
7.1 Except for language paper(s), the medium of examination shall be English only.
42
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
7.2 The duration of Mid Semester Examination shall be 90 Minutes with 30 Minutes
additional compensatory time to differently-abled student who are provided with a scribe.
Student who during examination is unable to write due to any physical injury may ask for
a scribe after filling up the prescribed form and submission of medical certificate.
7.3 The duration of End-Semester Examination shall be of 3 hours, with 60 Minutes
additional compensatory time to differently-abled student who have difficulty in writing.
Student who during examination is unable to write due to any physical injury may ask for
a scribe after filling up the prescribed form and submission of medical certificate.
8 RE-APPEAR AND IMPROVEMENT OF GRADE
8.1 Subject to other provisions of this Regulations, a student of any undergraduate courses
shall have to secure 45% marks to pass the course/paper.
For LL.M. one-year Programme a student shall have to secure 50% marks to pass the
course/paper.
8.2 A student who failed to secure a minimum pass marks as per Rule 8.1 or absents
himself/herself from an examination shall be declared “Failed” in that course. He/she
shall appear in the Reappear Examination for that course. If he/she passes the course in
the Reappear Examination, the grade obtained shall have ® mentioned against it in the
transcript.
8.3 If any student or a group of students, under a common understanding, intentionally
absents himself/herself/themselves from any scheduled examination, he/she/they shall not
be allowed to write the reappear examination and will be considered “Failed” in that
course. They shall have to reappear in the examination for the course as per schedule,
after due payment of the prescribed fee. The decision of the Controller of Examination as
to whether the absence was pursuant to a common understanding shall be subject to an
appeal to the Vice Chancellor.
8.4 The Reappear Examination shall generally be organized with regular Semester
Examinations i.e. with Mid Semester as well as End Semester. However, with the
approval of Vice Chancellor, special Repeat Examination(s) may be conducted for
Students of Final Year in each Programme. The Grades obtained in the Reappear
Examinations shall be indicated with ® at the top of the Grade. It is further clarified that
repeat examinations shall be for the written examination component only i.e. Mid
Semester & End Semester Examination respectively (50 + 25= 75 marks). The marks
awarded for assignment/projects and the viva voce shall remain as originally awarded.
Students who appear for repeat examination shall be allowed to do so only against the
prescribed fee.
43
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
8.5 Subject to Rule 13.6, students desirous of improving their Grades may apply formally to
the Controller of Examinations with the prescribed fee and appear in Reappear
Examinations, End-Term examination component only, as mentioned in rule 8.4 of this
Regulations. The Grade originally obtained by such candidate at the end of the semester
examination will be cancelled and the Grade obtained pursuant to the marks obtained at
the Reappear Examinations will be treated as final. However, if student fails to appear in
the Improvement Examination, then his original grade shall remain unchanged.
8.6 A student who absents himself or herself from assignment/projects and the viva voce
component of examination in a paper/subject, shall be allowed to give his/her
assignment/projects and the viva voce during regular Semester. Students who is allowed
to appear for assignment/projects and the viva voce, component of examination, under
this Regulations, shall be allowed to do so only against the prescribed fee.
8.7 The fees for duplicate hall tickets, showing of end-term answer scripts, Reappear/Repeat
Examinations, Improvement Examination shall be payable as specified in Annexure-II.
9. INVIGILATION OF EXAMINATIONS
9.1 Examination duty shall be compulsory for the teaching faculty and the non-teaching staff.
9.2 Invigilator-examinee ratio shall be 1:25. For the conduct of Mid/End Semester
examinations, there shall be a Centre Superintendent and a Deputy Superintendent and
Invigilators.
9.3 The COE shall communicate the schedule of examination duties to all the teaching and
non-teaching staff prior to commencement of the examination. The Centre
Superintendent shall ensure equitable distribution of examination duties, as far as
possible in each paper on day to day basis. .
9.5 The payment for paper setting, moderation, evaluation of answer scripts, term paper and
dissertation shall be made as prescribed under Annexure-I.
10 GRACE MARKS
10.1 A student who has failed in any subject, may get grace marks up to not more than 6
marks to clear his paper(s).
10.2 A student shall get the benefit of grace marks up to 6 marks only to the maximum of two
subjects (i.e. total of 6 grace marks can be divided between two subjects in such cases).
10.3 If a student has failed in more than two subjects, grace marks shall be given in the first
two papers according to the course code of the Subject.
11. SCRUTINY
44
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
11.1 A student not satisfied with the marks secured in the End-semester examinations can
apply for scrutiny on the prescribed format and by the payment of scrutiny fee as
prescribed under Annexure-II.
11.2 Scrutiny shall mean the evaluation of un-checked answers and re-checking of the totaling
of marks in any given paper. The student is free to apply scrutiny for any number of
papers in a given semester. However, for any paper, this facility may be availed only
once.
11.3 For scrutiny, a student shall have to fill up a scrutiny form which shall be made available
by the office of Controller of Examinations.
11.4 The Office of Controller of Examinations shall notify the instructions for Scrutiny from
time to time.
11.5 If there is any change in the marks of the student after the scrutiny, the student shall be
provided the revised Mark Sheet on the submission of his original Mark sheet.
11.6 If a failed student secures passing marks after scrutiny, he/she shall be entitled for
promotion to the subsequent semester without depositing any late fee.
12. RE-EVALUATION OF ANSWER SCRIPT
12.1 A student seeking revaluation of an answer script of an end-semester examination (or
Reappear) may apply to the Controller of Examination within 10 days from the date of
declaration of results in the prescribed form, and submit fee of Rs. 2000/- per paper. If
the result is declared during vacations, the request shall be made within one week from
the date of re-opening of the University.
12.2 The Controller of Examination shall place the request before the Vice Chancellor. The
Vice Chancellor may approve the request and nominate re-evaluator from the panel of
examiners to be approved by Board of Studies.
12.3 In case of re-evaluation being successful, the student shall be awarded the grade as per
the revaluation. However, if the difference between the original marks awarded and
marks obtained in revaluation is more than 10 marks, the average of the both shall be
treated as final award.
13. PROMOTION TO SUBSEQUENT YEAR AND AWARD OF DEGREE
13.1 Student securing at least 5.6 CGPA shall be awarded degree/diploma.
13.2 Subject to Rule 13.6, a student securing ‘C’ grade in the requisite number of papers shall
be promoted to subsequent year. If a student fails to secure ‘C’ grade or 5.6 CGPA in the
requisite number of papers for the award of Degree she/he may apply for improvement
45
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
under rule 8. If the student has secured ‘C’ Grade in all papers, but fails to secure 5.6
CGPA, she/he shall have to improve the CGPA by reappearing in papers of his/her
choice.
13.3 No student shall be promoted to the subsequent year of the Programme except by way of
rule 13.6. If a student who has been debarred from appearing in an end-semester
examination due to shortage of attendance in a compulsory paper, she/he shall not be
promoted to the subsequent year.
13.4 Subject to Rule 13.6, if a student is not being promoted to subsequent year of the
program, he/she shall be required to re-register for the said course/courses when these are
again offered, by paying the prescribed fees. Such student shall be evaluated for 100
marks (50+25+25).
13.5 A student who has declared failed due to shortage of attendance, and not been promoted
to the next year of the program, shall require to re-register himself for those said course
when they are again offered by paying the prescribed fees. Such re-registered student
shall be evaluated for 100 marks.
13.6 Promotion Scheme to subsequent years shall be based on the following rules:
For promotion to 2nd year – A student shall have passed 70% of all papers i.e., 08 out of
12 papers of the 1st year.
For promotion to 3rd year - A student shall have passed all papers of the 1st year and
passed 70% of all papers i.e., 07 out of 10 courses of 2nd year
For promotion to 4th year, a student shall have passed all courses of the 1st and 2nd years
and passed 70% of all papers i.e., 07 out of 10 courses of the 3rd year
For promotion to 5th year, a student shall have passed all courses of the 1st, 2nd and 3rd
years and passed 70% of all papers i.e., 07 out of 10 courses of the 4th year.
14. CREDIT SYSTEM
14.1 Credit connotes the unit that gives weight to the value level or time requirement of a
course. 01 Credit shall be equal to 15 Teaching Hours. If a course has 6 papers in
semester, and each paper is having 4 Credits, then the total credits of the paper of the
Semester shall be calculated 4 (credits per paper) * 6 (number of papers) = 24 (Total
Credits of the Subject).
14.2 Grade Value shall mean the value assigned to the marks obtained by a student in a paper.
Grade value is based on 10-point scale.
46
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
14.3 Letter Grade shall mean the Alphabetical Grade/s determined on the basis of Grade Value
obtained by the Student in a paper. The Grade Value on 10-Point Scale, and the letter
grade to be given to the student, is on the basis of Grade Value obtained by the Student.
The Table given below shows the marks range, grade value and corresponding letter
grade.
Sr.
No.
Marks Range
(Out of 100)
Grade Value
(10-point Scale)
Letter Grade
1 90 and above 10 A+ (Outstanding)
2 80 and above but below 90 09 A (Excellent)
3 70 and above but below 80 08 B+ (Distinction)
4 60 and above but below 70 07 B (Good)
5 50 and above but below 60 06 C+ (Average)
6 45 and above but below 50 05 C (Pass)
7 00-44 00 F (Fail)
* No round off shall be allowed in calculating Marks Percentage.
For Example: In a paper, if a student secures marks in the range of 70-79, the Grade
Value for that paper shall be 8, and the latter Grade for that paper shall be B+
(Distinction)
14.4 Grade Point shall be calculated by multiplying the Grade Value obtained by the student
and the Credits of that paper. For example, if the student secures the Grade Value 08, and
the Credit of the paper is 04, then the Grade Point of the student in that paper shall be
8*4= 32
14.5 Semester Grade Point Average (SGPA) of a student shall be calculated as the sum total of
the Grade Points secured by the student in all the papers of a semester divided by total
Credits (sum total of credits of all the papers in that semester) in a semester.
For Example: If there are 6 papers in a semester, and each paper is having 4 Credits, total
Credits of the Semester shall be calculated as 6*4=24.
If the student is securing grade points as 24 (GP1), 28 (GP2), 32 (GP3), 32 (GP4), 36
(GP5) and 40 (GP6) in Paper 1 (P1), Paper2 (P2), Paper 3 (P3), Paper 4 (P4), Paper 5
(P5), Paper 6 (P6), respectively, then the SGPA shall be calculated as (GP1) + (GP2) +
(GP3) + (GP4) + (GP5) + (GP6) divided by the total credits.
Therefore, SGPA = (24 + 28 + 32 + 32 + 36 + 40) ÷ 24
So, the SGPA = 192 ÷ 24
SGPA = 8
14.6 Quality Points (QP) is the sum total of all the grade points obtained in semester.
47
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
For Example: GP1 + GP2 + GP3 + GP4 + GP5 + GP6 = Quality Points.
There for, QP is: 24 + 28 + 32 + 32 + 36 + 40 = 192
14.7 Cumulative Grade Point Average (CGPA) shall be the sum total of Quality points of all
the Semesters of a course till date divided by Total Credits of the Course till date. CGPA
shall be considered up to two decimal places.
CGPA = Total Quality Points in a Course ÷ Total Credits of the Course
14.8 The calculation of CGPA in the second semester and the consecutive semesters shall be
done according to the following formula:
CGPA of semester II = QPI + QP II ÷ Total Credits of Semester I + II
Similarly,
CGPA of semester III = QP I + QP II + QP III ÷ Total Credits of Semester I + II + III
Other semester’s CGPA shall be calculated in the like manner.
14.9 The Division obtained shall be calculated on the basis given bellow:
14.10 University degree shall be awarded to the students securing C or above grade in all of its
papers, and an overall CGPA of not less than 5.6.
14.11 The Conversion formula for converting CGPA to the corresponding percentage of marks
shall be as follows:
X = 10Y-4.5
Where X = Percentage of Marks; Y = CGPA; 10 is 10-point scale, and 4.5 is the mean
value of Class Interval of marks range.
15. Rules against ‘Unfair means’ and Committee against Use of Unfair Means in
examinations
15.1 There shall be a Committee against Use of Unfair Means in examinations constituted by
the Vice Chancellor.
Sr. No. CGPA Division
1 8.45 and above First Division with Distinction
2 6.45 and above, but below 8.45 First Division
3 5.6 and above, but below 6.45 Second Division
48
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
15.2 The Committee against Use of Unfair Means shall submit report/recommendations to the
Controller of Examinations who shall impose the penalty with reasons in writing. An
appeal can be made to the Vice-Chancellor who shall uphold/reduce/condone the penalty.
15.3 Unfair means and other malpractices in relation to the examination shall mean as
specified in Annexure-III.
49
HPN
LU
S
HIM
LA
Previous and next
All provisions of THE HIMACHAL PRADESH NATIONAL LAW UNIVERSITY ACADEMIC REGULATIONS, 2019
Questions people ask
Is annexure D of THE HIMACHAL PRADESH NATIONAL LAW UNIVERSITY ACADEMIC REGULATIONS, 2019 still in force?
No repeal of the HIMACHAL PRADESH NATIONAL LAW UNIVERSITY ACADEMIC REGULATIONS, 2019 is recorded.