LawGrids logoLAWGRIDS.ORG

Regulation 41, Power Regulatory Accounting Regulations, 2018: REGULATED RATE BASE

Power Regulatory Accounting Regulations, 2018 - Regulation 41

Text of regulation 41

REGULATED RATE BASE

41. REGULATED RATE BASE.—Shall be the value established for an Entity by the Commission on which Entity is allowed to earn a rate of return as approved by the Commission. The regulated rate base shall include the operating and other costs as approved by the Commission the cost of constructing new facilities, unless approved by the Commission shall be excluded from the Regulated Rate Base. 23 BIHAR GAZETTE (EXTRA), 3RD APRIL 2018 42. ALLOCATION PRINCIPLES FOR ASSETS, LIABILITIES, INCOME AND EXPENSES 42.1 Fixed Assets or Property, Plant & Equipment (a) Plant and Machinery including Generating Station, Transmission Network and Distribution Network.— Apportionment on the basis of technical parameters (contracted capacity for Generating Stations and Transmission Networks, and connected load or consumption in Million Units for Distribution Networks) will be most suitable and objective in nature. These parameters for the previous year may be used for apportionment of common assets in ensuing year. (b) Land, Buildings and Civil Structures including Furniture & Fixtures, Office Equipment and Vehicles.— Apportion such common assets on the basis of proportion of number of employees belonging to distinct business segments and utilising the common assets. It will be easy to identify the number of employees engaged with the current assets. The number of employees which do not belong to distinct business segments, but are engaged with the common asset should be excluded, and only the proportion of employees belonging to distinct businesses, engaged with the common assets should be considered for computing the proportion. (c) Other Fixed Assets.— Apportion such common assets based on the proportion of value of fixed assets directly attributable to different business activities of the Utility. Apportionment on the basis of revenue will be more subjective, as revenues from different businesses are dependent upon the type of business activity. 42.2 Current Assets (a) Stores and Spares.—Apportion value of stores and spares on the basis of proportion in which that common asset is being apportioned. In case it is not identifiable with a specific common asset, then apportionment may be done in proportion of value of total common assets allocated to different business activities. Apportionment on the basis of revenue will be more subjective, as revenues from different businesses are dependent upon the type of business activity. (b) Other Common Current Assets.—Apportion value of such common current assets on the basis of proportion of value of total common assets allocated to different business activities. Apportionment on the basis of revenue will be more subjective, as revenues from different businesses are dependent upon the type of business activity. 24 BIHAR GAZETTE (EXTRA) 3RD APRIL 2018 (c) Receivables.—Apportion of receivables is on the basis of revenue though the type of business activity and its collection cycle may have a bearing on the amount of receivables. (d) Investments.—Apportion investments on the basis of revenue as apportionment on the basis of cash accruals will be more difficult and subjective as it may involve application of apportionment principles in several heads. 42.3 Liabilities (a) Long term loans and equity.—In case the common liability is identifiable with a common asset, the same should be apportioned on the basis of which the common asset has been apportioned. In case the common liability is not identifiable with a common asset, it should be apportioned on the basis of which the total common assets have been apportioned. (b) Interest on long term loans accrued but unpaid.—In case the interest is identifiable with a common long term loan, the same should be apportioned on the basis of which the common long term loan has been apportioned. In case the interest is not identifiable with a common long term loan, it should be apportioned on the basis of which the total common long term loans have been apportioned. (c) Current liabilities and provisions.—Apportion such common current liabilities in the proportion of revenue generated by the business activity as these have direct relation with the level of operations of the business activity. (d) Revenue Income from Common Assets.—Although realisation of revenue from a business depends on the type of business, it is preferable to apportion common revenue on the basis of direct revenues from different businesses. Apportionment of common fixed assets will be done on the basis of proportion of fixed assets directly attributable to different assets. Therefore, apportionment of common revenue on the basis of common fixed assets will not be representative. 42.4 Expenses (a) Generation Expenses and Power Purchase Costs.— Apportion fixed charges and variable charges separately. Contracted or allocated capacity will be used for apportioning capacity charges, and power procurement in MU will be used for apportioning variable charges. Apportionment on the basis of average generation expenses or average power purchase costs does not reflect the actual capacity charges payable, which is based on the allocated capacity. 25 BIHAR GAZETTE (EXTRA), 3RD APRIL 2018 (b) Transmission, SLDC and Distribution Expenses.— Apportionment on the basis of allocated capacity will be most suitable, as there would be less subjectivity involved. These parameters for the previous year may be used for apportionment of common expenses in ensuing year. (c) Employee Expenses.—Apportion of employee expenses should be done on the basis of some measurable parameter. For operating staff, the basis of apportionment should be on the basis of man-hours devoted to different business activities, which can be derived from time sheets. If time devoted by any employee is not specific to any particular business, that should not be considered and only the proportion of time devoted by employees to specific businesses should be considered for apportionment of entire common employee expenses for operational staff. For other support activities, expenses should be apportioned based on some measurable parameters, e.g. common employee expenses related to procurement department may be apportioned on the basis of value of procurement for different businesses, common employee expenses related to IT department may be apportioned on the basis of number of computers used for different departments etc. Common expenses related to senior employees, like Chairman, Managing Director etc. may be apportioned on the basis of number of direct employees belonging to different businesses. (d) Repair and Maintenance Expenses.—Apportion of common Repair and Maintenance expenses should be done on the basis of apportionment of total common fixed assets as it is not always possible in most of the cases to identify the common Repair and Maintenance expenses with a specific common fixed asset. (e) Administration and General Expenses.—It is preferable to apportion the common Administration and General expenses in proportion of number of direct employees related to different businesses. Apportioning on the basis of floor space or revenues or any other method will be more difficult and subjective than apportioning on the basis of proportion of number of direct employees. (f) Depreciation.—Apportion of common depreciation expenses should be done on the basis of apportionment of total common fixed assets to different business activities, as identification of depreciation with a particular common asset is not always feasible. 42.5 Replacement of a part of asset: If any part of an asset is replaced at any stage of the useful life of the asset, then the method of charging depreciation for the purpose of regulatory accounts on the asset requires deliberation. Replacement of the old part with a 26 BIHAR GAZETTE (EXTRA) 3RD APRIL 2018 new one may extend the life of the asset. However, depreciation should be charged only for the useful life of the asset and the useful life of the asset should not increase, although the actual life may increase by replacement of the part. The asset value will increase at the time of replacement of the part to the extent of value of new part and will decrease to the extent of value of old part. Residual depreciation corresponding to the revised asset value should be charged at depreciation rates as per applicable Tariff Regulations for the residual life of the asset. 42.6 Interest and Finance Charges: Apportion of common Interest and Finance Charges should be done on the basis of apportionment of total common liabilities to different business activities, as identification of interest and finance charges with a particular common liability is not always feasible. 42.7 Return on Equity/Capital Employed Identifiable with Common Asset (for the Regulated Businesses): Apportioning of RoE/RoCE identifiable for common assets should be done on the basis of apportionment of common fixed assets to different business activities. 42.8 Income Tax: Income tax should be apportioned on the basis of proportion of RoE of different regulated businesses of the Utility. However, if there are any un-regulated business of the Utility, then income tax should be apportioned on the basis of Profit Before Tax (PBT) of the different businesses. 42.9 It may be noted here that if RoE is provided on Pre-Tax basis, then there is no requirement of separate apportionment of Income Tax. Here income tax forms a part of Pre-Tax RoE, and it will get apportioned along with RoE on the basis of principles discussed in preceding section for RoE. 43. SEGREGATION OF DISTRIBUTION BUSINESS ARR INTO WIRES BUSINESS AND SUPPLY BUSINESS 43.1 Wires Business is the business of owning and operating of the distribution system, while Retail Supply Business is the business of procuring the requisite power through long-term, medium-term, and short-term power purchase contracts for supplying to its consumers. 43.2 In case the Commission has specified the basis of allocation of expenses between Wires Business and Retail Supply Business in the Bihar Electricity Regulatory Commission (Multi Year Distribution Tariff) Regulations, 2015 and as amended from time to time, the same shall be considered for allocation of the expenses of the Distribution Licensee. 43.3 In case the above mentioned regulations do not specify any basis for allocation of expenses between Wires Business and Retail Supply Business, the Distribution Licensees shall follow a consistent basis of allocation ratios for apportionment of different components of Distribution ARR into Wires Business and Supply Business, after approval of the same by the Commission. 27 BIHAR GAZETTE (EXTRA), 3RD APRIL 2018 43.4 The allocation ratios on which the different components of Distribution ARR shall be apportioned are mentioned herein below. These allocation ratios are subject to review and customisation, depending on the cost structure of the respective Distribution Licensee, as approved by the Commission. i. Power Purchase/Transmission/SLDC Expenses.—All these expenses related to the Supply Business shall be allocated to Supply Business ARR. ii. Employee Expenses.—Direct employees for Wires Business and Supply Business shall be identified first and Employee Expenses related to these direct employees shall be allocated to respective businesses. Thereafter, all common Employee Expenses relating to employees working for both the businesses can be apportioned between Wires Business and Supply Business using the allocation principles discussed for apportionment of common Employee Expenses. However, till the time the segregation is complete, the Distribution Licensee may apportion the Employee Expenses between Wires Business and Supply Business using an appropriate ratio. Since more employees are employed for Wires Business and the employees who work for Supply Business are lower as compared to Wires Business, the proportion of employee cost allocated to Wires business shall be higher than the proportion allocated to Supply business and should be considered in 60:40 ratio. iii. Repair and Maintenance Expenses.—Cost of spares, fuel etc. and cost of services related to wires business and supply business shall be separately recorded. All direct Repair and Maintenance (R&M) Expenses related to Wires Business and Supply Business shall be allocated to the respective businesses. Thereafter all common R & M expenses can be apportioned between Wires Business and Supply Business using the allocation principles discussed for apportionment of common R & M Expenses. However, till the time the segregation is complete, the Distribution Licensee may apportion the R&M Expenses between Wires Business and Supply Business in the ratio 90:10. iv. Administration and General Expenses.—All expenses like rents, electricity charges, water charges, internet charges, office upkeep, insurance charges etc. relating to offices for distribution business shall be allocated to Supply Business, while that relating to distribution sub- stations/receiving stations shall be allocated to Wires Business. Rates and taxes, Freight, and other purchase related expenses need to be allocated based on the goods purchased – whether for Wires Business or for Supply Business. All other A&G expenses, which are common to both Wires Business and Supply Business, shall be 28 BIHAR GAZETTE (EXTRA) 3RD APRIL 2018 apportioned using the allocation principles for apportionment of common A&G Expenses. However, till the time the segregation is complete, the Distribution Licensee may apportion the A&G Expenses using the ratio 50:50. iv. Depreciation.—Major Portion of assets of Distribution Licensee relates to Wire Business, as sub-stations, HT and LT lines are for wheeling of electricity. Only the service connections and consumer meters, which are in the books of Distribution Licensee, shall be allocated to Supply Business. If asset class wise break up of assets relating to Wires Business and Supply Business are available, then depreciation relating to direct assets of Wires Business and direct assets of Supply Business shall be allocated to respective businesses. Depreciation on any common asset, if any can be apportioned between Wires Business and Supply Business using the allocation principles discussed for apportionment of common depreciation. However, if only the overall asset break-up between Wires business and Supply business is available, then the depreciation shall be apportioned in the same ratio. Till the time the segregation is complete, the Distribution Licensee may apportion depreciation for distribution business in the ratio 90:10. v. Interest on Loans.—All new loans availed by the Licensee shall be separate for Wires Business and Supply Business, based on the funding of the assets for Wires Business and Supply Business. In this way, interest on loans for Wires Business and Supply Business will be clearly identifiable and these shall be allocated to respective businesses. Other interest charges, which are common to both Wires Business and Supply Business shall be apportioned using the allocation principles discussed for apportionment of common interest and Finance Expenses. However, till the time the segregation is complete, the Distribution Licensee may apportion interest on loans between Wires Business and Supply Business in the ratio 90:10. vi. Interest on Working Capital.—All new Working Capital loans availed by the Distribution Licensee shall be separate for Wires Business and Supply Business. In this way, interest on Working Capital loans for Wires Business and Supply Business will be clearly identifiable and these shall be allocated to respective businesses. Other interest on Working Capital which is common to both Wires Business and supply Business can be apportioned using the ratio 10:90, as major portion of Working Capital loans belongs to supply business. 29 BIHAR GAZETTE (EXTRA), 3RD APRIL 2018 vii. Interest on Security Deposit.—Security deposits are collected by Distribution Licensees from the consumers for supplying electricity to them, the interest on Security Deposits shall be allocated entirely to the Supply Business. viii. Provision for Bad Debts.—Major part of bad debts relates to supply business. However, as it is not exactly possible to separate the bad debts between Wires Business and Supply Business, these expenses, if any, can be apportioned between Wires Business and Supply Business using the ratio 10:90. ix. Return on Equity.—RoE for both the businesses shall be allowed based on the Equity invested separately for both the functions. Common RoE, if any shall be apportioned between Wires Business and Supply Business using the allocation principles discussed for apportionment of common RoE. In case equity invested for both the functions cannot be segregated clearly or till the time the segregation is complete, RoE can be apportioned between Wires Business and Supply Business using the proportion of GFA between Wires Business and Supply Business using the ratio 90:10. x. Income Tax.—Tax shall be apportioned on the basis of RoE/ RoCE related to Wires Business and Supply Business, provided for apportionment of Income Tax. Non- Tariff Income- Non Tariff Income resulting from meter rent, delayed payment charges, service connection charges etc. shall be allocated to Supply Business, while income resulting from sale of scrap etc. shall be allocated to Wires Business. Other common items of Non-tariff Income, if any can be apportioned using the allocation principles discussed for apportionment of revenues. However, till the time the segregation is complete, the Distribution Licensee may apportion Non- Tariff Income between Wires Business and Supply business using ratio 10:90. xi. Licence fee.—Licence fee payable by the eligible licensees, including deemed licensees shall be as per the provisions contained in the Bihar Electricity Regulatory Commission (Conduct of Business) Regulations, 2005 and as amended from time to time notified by the Commission. Every Licensee shall disclose the actual amount payable/paid based on the audit certificate duly supported by the affidavit in this regard. Apportionment of license fee between Wires Business and Supply Business shall be in the ratio 10:90. 30 BIHAR GAZETTE (EXTRA) 3RD APRIL 2018 CHAPTER-III MISCELLANEOUS

Previous and next

All provisions of Power Regulatory Accounting Regulations, 2018

Questions people ask

Is regulation 41 of Power Regulatory Accounting Regulations, 2018 still in force?

No repeal of Power Regulatory Accounting Regulations, 2018 is recorded.