circular_no_2425035
Circular - THE UTTAR PRADESH GOODS AND SERVICES TAX ACT, 2017
- Kind: Circular
- Under: THE UTTAR PRADESH GOODS AND SERVICES TAX ACT, 2017
Text of this circular
Civeudan No-24050354%%
Office of the Commissioners
State Tax, Uttar pPradesh
(GST Scction)
Letter No. GST/2024.25) ( 03 /State Tax
Lucknow: Dated: 0P November, 2024
To,
All Zonal Additional Commissioner ,
Additional Commissioner Grade -2 (S.1.B.)
Joint Commissioner (Exccutive/Corporate Circle/ S.1.B)
State Tax, Uttar Pradesh.
Subject: Clarification on various issucs pertaining to tax
ability and valuation of
supply of services of providing corporate guarantee b
etween related persons.
1.1 As per the recommendations of the GST Council, sub-rule (
2) was inserted in Rule 28
of Uttar Pradesh Goods and Services Tax Rules, 2017 (hereinafter
referred to as the “UPGST
Rules™) vide Notification No. 207/X1-2-24-9(42)/17-T.C.69-U.P.GST Rules-2017-Order-
(315)-2024 Dated : February 27, 2024 (w.e.f. 26.10.2023 ) to provide for a specific clause for
valuation of supply of services of providing corporate guarantee to any bankin
g company or
financial institution by an entity on behalf of a related person. Besides, Circular No.
2425023 dated 16.07.2023 was also issued as per the recommendations of the
GST Council,
to provide clarity regarding the applicability of the said sub-rule. Subsequently, based on th
e
recommendations of the GST Council, sub-rule (2) of Rule 28 of UPGST Rules has been
amended retrospectively with effect from 26.10.2023 vide notification No.721 dated
26.10.2024.
1.2 In this regard, various representations have been received from trade and industry,
seeking clarifications on various issues pertaining to the taxability and valuation of the
supply of services of providing corporate guarantee between relateg persons as per the said
rule.
2. Therefore, in order to ensure uniformity in the implementation of the provisions of law
across the field formations, the Commissioner, in exercise of its powers conferred by section
168 of the Uttar Pradesh Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (hercinafler referred to as
“UPGST Act”), hereby clarifies the issues as under:
S. No., Issuc Clarification
1 |Whether sub-rule (2) of rule 28 | It is to be clarified that the snppl_\'fluf service of
of UPGST Rules will apply to | providing corporate guarantee to any banking company
lh(lz corporate guarantees issued | or financial institution by a supplicr to a related
prior 10 insertion of the said | recipient, on behalf of the said recipicnt, was taxable |
Page 1 of'§
sub-rule on 26™ October 20237
Also, where intra-group
corporate guarantees have been
lissued before 26" October
2023, which are still in force
today, would they be liable to
pay GST on “1% of the amount
of such guarantee offered” on
such guarantees?
|
|
|
{ |
|
mhe insertion of sub-rule (2) in rule 28 of
UPGST Rules with effect from 26" October 2023. Rule 28(2) of UPGST Rules is only for determination of the value of the taxable supply of providing corporate guarantee o any banking company or financial nstitution by a supplicr to a related recipient, on behalf of the said recipient and not regarding the taxability of the said supply itself. Prior to the insertion of the said | sub-rule, i.c., before 26th October 2023, the valuation | of service of providing corporate guarantee to any banking company or financial institution by a supplier to a related recipient, on behalf of the said recipient, | Was to be done as per the provisions of Rule 28 of | UPGST Rules, as it existed then. |
) Therefore, in respect of supply of services of | provnding corporate guarantee between related persons. In respect of corporate guarantee issued or renewed before 26™ October 2023, the valuation of the said supply is to be done in accordance with Rule 28, as it
existed during that time. However, if the corporate
guarantee is issued or renewed on or after 26% October
2023, then the valuation of the said supply will be
required to be done as per Rule 28(2) of UPGST Rules. |In cases where the corporate
| guarantee s provided for a
| particular amount, whereas the
|loan is only partly availed or
[not availed at all by the
recipient, what will be the
value of supply of corporate
guarantee. Also, whether the
recipient would be eligible to
avail full ITC (Input Tax
Credit) even before total loan js
disbursed?
actually disbursed.
The activity of supply of the service of providing a
corporate guarantee is not linked with the actual
disbursal of the loan. The service that is provided by
the guarantor to the guarantee is that of taking on the
risk of default. Therefore, it is clarified that the value of
supply of the service of providing a corporate
guarantee will be calculated based on the amount
guaranteed and will not be based on the~amount of loan
actually disbursed to the recipient of the corporate
guarantee.
Further, it is also clarified that the recipient of
the service of providing corporate guarantee shql! be |
eligible to avail the ITC, subject to other conditions
spccificd in the Act and the l‘{ulcs made Fherel‘mdcr,
irrespective of when the lqun is f\cllla\lly dlsburs\c]d 'm.
the recipient, and irrespective of the amount of loan
In the case of takeover of
cxisting loans, since there is
merely an assignment of ap
alrcady issued corporate
guarantee, whether GST would
be applicable again?
In the service of providing corporate ‘guummcc‘ to ?n\r
banking company or Iinuncml‘m§muno_n b)
:f.‘ ‘stlp(ptl}:c
related recipient, on behalf of the said recipient, t ¢
o ¢ of the service is the corporate entity providing
supplie recipient is the related the rporate guarantee and
t relted
o cyorzr whom the corporate guarante
is provided by
J
entit; )
he said supplier.
Therefore, if the loan issued by the bankin
|
PR I o 4
Where corporate guarantee is
provided by more than one
entity / co-guarantor, what is
the amount on which GST is
payable by each co-guarantor?
[——N COompany/ financial institution b y/ Htution is taken over by another 0?"(‘?2;1 company/rfini\ncia’[ institution, the saj aking over of the loan docs noy f Service of providing corporate guars
bHNking company or financial institutic
10 a recipient. Therefore, it is clarif
cases, there will be no impact on GST, unless there is 1ssuance of fresh corporate guarantee or there is a
fenewal of the existing corporate guarantce. However, [ the takeover of the loan is followed/ accompanied by’
uance of fresh corporate guarantee, then GST would
be payable on the same.
In cases where corporate guaraEm
provided by multiple related entitics, the value of such
services of providing corporate guarantee shall be the
sum of the actual consideration paid/ payable to co-
guarantors, if the said amount of total consideration is
higher than one per cent of the amount of such
guarantee offered. In cases where the sum of the actual
consideration is less than one per cent of the amount of
such guarantee offered, then GST shall be payable by
each co-guarantor proportionately on onc per cent of
the amount guaranteed by them.
' said activity
all under the
antee to any
ion by a supplier
icd that in such
For instance, if there are two co-guarantors, A
and B, who jointly provide a corporate guarantee to a
banking/ financial institution on behalf a related
recipient C for Rs. 1 crore, then A and B shall each pay
GST on 0.5% of the amount guaranteed.
However, if in the above casc of A and B
providing corporate guarantee jointly to a banking/
financial institution on behalf a related recipient C for
Rs 1 crore, A provides guarantee for 60% of the
guarantee amount and B provides guarantee for the
remaining 40% of the guaranteed amount, then GST
shall be payable by A and B proportionately i.e., 0.6%
and 0.4% of the amount guaranteed. This is to say that
A shall pay GST on 1% of the amount guaranteed by
A, i.e, 1% on Rs. 60 lakhs and B shall pay GST on 1%
of the amount guaranteed by B, i.c., 1% on Rs. 40
lakhs.
Where intra-group corporate
guarantee is issued, whether
GST may be paid by the
recipient under reverse charge,
as in the absence of actual
invoice and payment, the
recipient entity may not be able
to claim input tax credit of tax
It is clarified that in cases where domestic corporates
issue intra-group guarantecs, GST is to be paid under
forward charge mechanism, and invoice is to be issued
by the supplier of the service of providing corporate
guarantee to the related recipient under Scction 31 of
UPGST Act, 2017 read along with the rclevant rules.
However, in cases where such guarantee is
paid by the domestic
provided by the foreign/ overscas entity 1%
entity located in India, then GST would be p2
Page 3 of 5
guarantor?
Whether the discharge of tax
liability on corporate guarantee
@ 1% of such guarm_\lce
offered is to be done one time
or on ycarly basis or on
monthly basis and when issued
for a fixed term of say, five
years or ten years as per tenure
of the loan?
under reyerse charge mechanism, by the recipient of
| SCrvice, i.c., the related entity located in India, Rule "28(2) of UPGST Rules has been amendeq retrospectively with effect from 26" October 2023, vide notification No. 721 dt 26.10.2024,
Therefore, it is clarified that the value of supply jof ll{c service of providing corporate guarantee to a banking company or a financial institution on behalf of fa related recipient shall be one per cent of the amount guarantced per annum or the actual consideration, whichever is higher.
|
Accordingly, the value of supply of the service of providing corporate guarantee to a banking company | or a financial institution on behalf of a related recipient “ for a particular number of years shall be one per cent of | the amount of such guarantee offered multiplied by the | number of years for which the said guarantee s offered |
jor the actual consideration whichever is higher. }
|
In addition to the above, in cases where the |
corporate guarantee is provided for a period less than a |
year, say 6 months (half a year), then in those cases as
well, the valuation may be done on proportionate basis
for the said period, i.e., in this case, the value ofthei
said supply of services may be taken as half of one per
cent of the amount of such guarantee offered (6/12 *
one per cent), or the actual consideration, whichever is |
higher.
|
To illustrate the same, if a corporate guarantee |
is issued for a period of say five years, then the value
of such guarantee is to be calculated at one per cent per |
year of the amount of such guarantee oi}cred. or the
actual consideration, whichever is higher, i.e., the value
of such corporate guarantee provided would !)e S‘V? of
the amount guaranteed or the actual consideration,
whichever is higher. Therefore, GSTl\vouId be payable
on such amount at the time of issuance of such
corporate guarantec, ic, 5% of the im.\ou{\t guaranteed
or the actual consideration, whichever is higher.
However, if a corporate guarantee is i_ssued, say
for a period of one year and is renewed five nmes';lfo:) ra‘
period of one year each, then tax would be paya“cred
one per cent of the amyunt or.such gl{nrapt(}z’e oos th
é
or the actual consideration, \vhlche\{er is higl ir, on the
issue of such corporate _guaranlce in the first y« =
well as on every renewal in subsequent
years.
Page 4 of 5
Proviso to sub-rule (1), which
states that value declared i
invoice is deemed to be the
open market value in cases
where full input tax credit is
available to the recipient of
services, is not applicable in
cases falling under sub-rule
@7
Wi ————— Whether the benefit of second Proviso has been inserted in sub-rule (2) of
Rule 28 of UPGST Rules, retrospectively with effect
from 26" October 2023 vide notification No. 721 dt
26.10.2024, similar to that provided in the second
Proviso o sub-rule (1) of Rule 28 of UPGST Rules, to
provide the benefit in cases involving supply of service
of corporate guarantees provided between related
persons,
Accordingly, it is clarified that in cases involving the
supply of service of corporatc guarantecs provided
between related persons, where full input tax credit is
available to the recipient of services, the value declared
in the invoice shall be deemed to be the value of supply
of the said service.
Whether the valuation in terms
of Rule 28(2) of UPGST Rules
will apply to the export of the
service of providing corporate
guarantee between related
persons?
As per the amendment done in sub-rule (2) of rule 28 of
UPGST Rules retrospectively w.c.f. 26" October 2023
ide notification No. 721 dt 26.10.2024, the provisions
lof the said sub-rule will not apply in cases where the
recipient of the services of providing corporate
lguarantee between related persons is located outside
India. Accordingly, the provisions of the said sub-rule |
ishall not apply to the export of the services of providing
lcorporate guarantee between related persons.
3.
4,
This circular. is being issued in pursuance of CBIC's Circular No 225/19/2024 dt
11.07.2024-.
It is requested that suitable trad:
this Circular.
5.
e notices may be issued to publicize the contents of
Difficulty if any, in the implementation of this circular, may be brought to the
notice of the Undersigned.
Copy To:
By Order,
(Dr. Nitin Bansal)
Commissioner, State Tax, U.P.
Joint Commissioner (I.T.), State Tax HQ, Lucknow for uploading the Circular on the
Departmental Website.
Joint Comn\uncr(GS'l')
State Tax 1Q, Lucknow.
Page 5of §