circular_no_2425023
Circular - THE UTTAR PRADESH GOODS AND SERVICES TAX ACT, 2017
- Kind: Circular
- Under: THE UTTAR PRADESH GOODS AND SERVICES TAX ACT, 2017
Text of this circular
Lr Urtadan Mo —2425023
Office of the Commissioner,
State Tax, Uttar Pradesh
(GST Section)
Letter No. GST/2024-25/ €} | /State Tax
Lucknow: Dated: (4, July, 2024
To,
All Zonal Additional Commissioner Grade -1,
Additional Commissioner Grade -2 (S.1.B.)
Joint Commissioner (Executive/Corporate Circle/ S.1.B)
State Tax, Uttar Pradesh.
Subject: Clarification on issues pertaining to taxability of personal guarantee and
corporate guarantee in GST-reg.
Representations have been received from the trade and field formations seeking
clarification on certain issues with respect to taxability of activity of providing personal
bank guarantee by Directors to banks for securing credit facilities for the company. Similarly,
clarifications are being sought with respect to taxability and valuation of the activity of
providing corporate guarantee by a related person to banks/financial institutions for another
related person, as well as by a holding company in order to secure credit facilities for its
subsidiary company.
2 In order to ensure uniformity in the implementation of the provisions of law across
the field formations, the Commissioner, in exercise of its powers conferred bysection 168 of
the Uttar Pradesh Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (hereinafter referred to as “UPGST
Act”), hereby clarifies the issues as under:
S g =)
N Issue Clarification
=
‘persunal guarantee by the Director of a| UPGST Act, the director and the company
company to the bank/ financial| are to be treated as related persons. As per
l‘insximlions for sanctioning of credit| clause (c) of sub-section (1) of section 7
‘facililies to the said company without| of the UPGST Act, 2017, read with S. No.
any consideration will be treated as a| 2 of Schedule I of UPGST Act, supply of
l * Whether the activity of providing| As per Explanation (a) to section 15 of
' sfipply of service or not and whether the,
same will attract GST or not.
P
goods or services or both between related
persons, when made in the course or
furtherance of business, shall be treated as
supply even if made without
consideration. Accordingly, the activity of
providing personal guarantee by the
Director to the banks/ financial institutions
for securing credit facilities for their
companies is to be treated as a supply of
service, even when made without
consideration.
Rule 28 of Uttar Pradesh Goods and
Services Tax Rules, 2017 (hereinafter
referred to as “UPGST Rules™) prescribes
the method for determining the value of
the supply of goods or services or both
between related parties, other than where
the supply is made through an agent. In
terms of Rule 28 of UPGST Rules, the
taxable value of such supply of service
shall be the open market value of such
supply.
RBI has provided guidelines for obtaining
personal guarantee of promoters, directors
and other managerial personnel of the
borrowing concerns vide Para 2.2.9 of its
Circular No. RBI/2021-22/121 dated 9"
November, 2021, which is reproduced
below:
“2.2.9 Guidelines relating to obtaining of
personal guarantees of promoters,
directors, other managerial personnel,
and shareholders of borrowing concerns
Banks should take personal guarantees of
promoters, directors, other managerial
personnel or major shareholders for the
credit facilities granted to corporates,
public or private, only when absolutely
warranted afier a careful examination of
the circumstances of the case and not as a
matter of course. In order to identify the
cumstances under which the guarantee.
may or may not be considered necessary,
banks should be guided by the following
broad considerations:
C. Worth of the guarantors, payment of
guarantee commission, etc
Where personal guarantees of directors
are warranted, they should bear
reasonable proportion to the estimated
worth of the person. The system of
obtaining guarantees should not be used
by the directors and other managerial
personnel as a source of income from the
company. Banks should obtain an
undertaking from the borrowing
company as well as the guarantors that
no consideration whether by way of
commission, brokerage fees or any other
form, would be paid by the former or
received by the latter, directly or
indirectly. This requirement should be
incorporated in the bank's terms and
conditions for sanctioning of credit
limits. During the periodic inspections,
the bank's inspectors should verify that
this stipulation has been complied with.
There may, however, be exceptional
cases where payment of remuneration
may be permitted e.g. where assisted
concerns are not doing well and the
existing ~ guarantors are no longer
connected with the management but
continuance of their guarantees is
considered essential because the new
management’s guarantee is either not
available or is found inadequate.
Accordingly, as per mandate provided by
RBI in terms of Para 2.2.9 (C) of RBI’s
Circular No. RBI/2021-22/121 dated 9"
November, 2021, no consideration by way
of commission, brokerage fees or any
other form, can be paid to the director by
the company, directly or indirectly, in lieu
B S S S O [
of providing personal guarantee to the—‘
bank for borrowing credit limits. As such,
when no consideration can be paid for the
said transaction by the company to the
director in any form, directly or indirectly,
as per RBI mandate, there is no question
of such supply/ transaction having any
open market value. Accordingly, the
open market value of the said
transaction/ supply may be treated as
zero and therefore, taxable value of
such supply may be treated as zero. In
such a scenario, no tax is payable on
such supply of service by the director to
the company.
There may, however, be cases where the
director, who had provided the guarantee,
is no longer connected with the
management but continuance of his
guarantee is considered essential because
the new management's guarantee is either
not available or is found inadequate, or
there may be "other exceptional cases
where the promoters, existing directors,
other managerial personnel, and
shareholders of borrowing concerns are
paid remuneration/ consideration in any
manner, directly or indirectly. In all these
cases, the taxable value of such supply of
service shall be the remuneration/
consideration provided to such a person/
guarantor by the company, directly or
indirectly.
[
|
\
2N [W@fmw;flivhy of providing Where the corporate guarantee s ‘corporate guarantee by a person on provided by a company to the bank/financial Ibehalf of another related person, or by |institutions for providing credit facilities to the| the holding company for sanction of other company, where both the companies are. credit - facilities to its subsidiary related, the activity is to be treated as a supply company, to the bank/ financial of service between related parties as per| institutions, even when made without Erovisions of Schedule I of UPGST Act, even| lany consideration will be treated as a {when made without any consideration.
faxable supply of service or not, and if ‘ Similarly, where the corporate guarantee taxable, what would be the valuation of fis provided by a holding company, for its such supply of services. subsidiary company, those two entities alsol |
fall under the category of ‘related persons’. “ Hence the activity of providing corporate;
guarantee by a holding company to the ‘ bank/financial institutions for securing credit ‘
facilities for its subsidiary company, even,
when made without any consideration, is also |
to be treated as a supply of service by holding
company to the subsidiary company, being a
related person, as per provisions of Schedule 1
f UPGST Act.
In respect of such supply of services by a ‘
person to another related person or by a ‘
holding company to a subsidiary company, in ‘
form of providing corporate guarantee on their, |
‘bcha![‘ to a bank/ financial institution, the
taxable value will be determined as per rule 28 ‘ ‘ f UPGST Rules.
Considering different practices being
followed by the field formations and taxpayers
in determining such taxable value, in order to|
rovide uniformity in practices and ease of] /
implementation, sub-rule (2) has been inserted
in rule 28 of UPGST Rules vide Notification [ 0. 207/X1-2-24-9(42)/17-T.C.69-UP GST! | Rules-2017-Order-(315)-2024 dated ‘ 26.10.2023, for determining the taxable value
‘uf such supply of services between related
persons in respect of providing corporate |
guarantee. Accordingly, consequent to!
‘insenion of the said sub-rule in rule 28 off
UPGST Rules, in all such cases of supply of]
services by a related person to another person,|
VI - S P
company, in the form of providing corporate
gguarantee on their behalf to a bank/ financial
institution, the taxable value of such supply of
services, will henceforth be determined as per
the provisions of the sub-rule (2) of Rule 28 o
UPGST Rules, irrespective of whether full
ITC is available to the recipient of services or,
not.
It is clarified that the sub-rule (2) of Rule
28 shall not apply in respect of the activity of]
providing personal guarantee by the Director!
to the banks/ financial institutions for securing
credit facilities for their companies and the
same shall be valued in the manner provided
in S. No. (1) above.
3. It is requested that suitable trade notices may be issued to publicize the contents of
this Circular.
4. Difficulty if any, in the implementation of this circular may be brought to the notice
of the Undersigned.
Copy To:
" By Order,
16|11y
(Dr. Nitin Bansal)
Commissioner, State Tax, U.P.
1. Joint Commissioner (I.T.), State Tax HQ, Lucknow for uploading the Circular on the
Departmental Website.
/
Joint Commissioner (GST)
State Tax HQ, Lucknow.