GST applicability on liquidated damages, compensation and penalty arising out of breach of contract or other provisions of law.
- Kind: Circular
- Under: The Maharashtra Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017
Text of this circular
6 6
Office of the
Commissioner of State Tax.
Maharashtra State, 8h floor.
GiST Bhavan, Mazgaon,
Mumbai 400010.
TRADE CIRCULAR
Dated- 1212/2022
No. DC-1(A&R/GST/MISC/2022/29/ADM-8
Trade Circular. | T of 2022
To,
Subiect: GST applicability on liquidated damages, compensation and penalty arising
out of breach of contract or other provisions of law- reg.
Ref CBIC Circular No.178/10/2022-GST, dated. 3rd August, 2022.
In certain cases / instances, questions have been raised regarding the ambit of an activity or
transaction as the supply of service of agreeing to the obligation to refrain from an act or to tolerate an act
or a situation, or to do an act. The clarification is sought about the applicability of GST on payments in the
nature of liquidated damage, compensation, penalty, cancellation charges, late payment surcharge, etc.
arising out of breach of contract, relevant provisions of law in view of the scope/ ambit of the entry at para
5 (e) of Schedule II of the GST Act(s). The scope/ ambit of said expression in context of aforesaid payments
has been examined in the following paragraphs.
2 In Service Tax law, 'Service' was defined as any activity carried out by a person for another for
consideration. As discussed in service tax education guide, the concept 'activity for a consideration'
involves an element of contractual relationship wherein the person doing an activity does so at the desire
of the person for whom the activity is done in exchange for a consideration. An activity done without such
a relationship i.e., without the express or implied contractual reciprocity ofa consideration would not be an
activity for consideration'. The element of contractual relationship, where one supplies goods or services
at the desire of another, is an essential element of supply.
3 The description of the declared service in question, namely, agreeing to the obligation to refrain
from an act or to tolerate an act or a situation, or to do an act in para 5 (e) of Schedule II of CGST Act is
strikingly similar to the definition of contract in the Contract Act, 1872. The Contract Act defines "Contract
as a set of promises, forming consideration for each other. 'Promise' has been defined as willingness of
Page 1 of 11
Office of the
Commissioner of State Tax.
Maharashtra State. 8" floor.
GST Bhavan. Mazgaon.
Mumbai-400010.
TRADE CIRCULAR
No. DC-1(A&R)/GST/ MISC/2022/29/ADM-8 _ Dated:- elt 242022
Trade Circular, | T of 2022
Severe ceseeeaereseennee
Pree eee senreeeseeeesecees
Subject: GST applicability on liquidated damages, compensation and penalty arising
out of breach of contract or other provisions of law — reg.
Ref: — CBIC Circular No.178/10/2022-GST, dated. 3 August, 2022.
In certain cases / instances, questions have been raised regarding the ambit of an activity or
transaction as the supply of service of agreeing to the obligation to refrain from an act or to tolerate an act
or a situation, or to do an act. The clarification is sought about the applicability of GST on payments in the
nature of liquidated damage, compensation, penalty, cancellation charges, late payment surcharge, etc.
arising out of breach of contract, relevant provisions of law in view of the scope / ambit of the entry at para
5 (e) of Schedule II of the GST Act(s). The scope / ambit of said expression in context of aforesaid payments
has been examined in the following paragraphs.
2. In Service Tax law, ‘Service’ was defined as any activity carried out by a person for another for
consideration. As discussed in service tax education guide, the concept ‘activity for a consideration’
involves an element of contractual relationship wherein the person doing an activity does so at the desire
of the person for whom the activity is done in exchange for a consideration. An activity done without such
a relationship i.e., without the express or implied contractual reciprocity of a consideration would not be an
‘activity for consideration’. The element of contractual relationship, where one supplies goods or services
at the desire of another, is an essential element of supply.
3, The description of the declared service in question, namely, agreeing to the obligation to refrain
from an act or to tolerate an act or a situation, or to do an act in para 5 (e) of Schedule II of CGST Act is
strikingly similar to the definition of contract in the Contract Act, 1872. The Contract Act defines ‘Contract’
as a set of promises, forming consideration for each other. ‘Promise’ has been defined as willingness of
Page 1 of 11°
1694
the 'promisor' to do or to abstain from doing anything. 'Consideration' has been defined in the Contract
Act as what the "promisee' does or abstains from doing for the promises made to him.
4. This goes to show that the service of agrecing to the obligation to refrain from an act or to tolerate
an act or a situation, or to do an act is nothing but a contractual agreement. A contract to do something or
to abstain from doing something cannot be said to have taken place unless there are two parties, one of
which expressly or impliedly agrees to do or abstain from doing something and the other agrees to pay
consideration to the first party for doing or abstaining from such an act.
5.
The expression in entry at 5 (e) of Schedule II comprises the three different sets of activities viz. (a)
the obligation to refrain from an act, (b) obligation to tolerate an act or a situation and (c) obligation to do
an act. All the three activities must be under an "agreement" or a "contract" (whether express or implied)
to fall within the ambit of the said entry. In other words, one of the parties to such agreement/contract (the
first party) must be under a contractual obligation to either (a) refrain from an act, or (b) to tolerate an act
or a situation or (c) to do an act.
6.
Further some "consideration" must flow in return from the other party to this contract/agreement
(the second party) to the first party for such (a) refraining or (b) tolerating or (c) doing. Such contractual
arrangement must be an independent arrangement in its own right. Such arrangement or agreement can take
the form of an independent stand- alone contract or may form part of another contract. Thus, a person (the
first person) can be said to be making a supply by way of refraining from doing something or tolerating
some act or situation to another person (the second person) if the first person was under an obligation to do
so and then performed accordingly.
7. There has to be an express or implied agreement; oral or written, to do or abstain from doing
something against payment of consideration for doing or abstaining from such act, for a taxable supply to
exist. An agreement to do an act or abstain from doing an act or to tolerate an act or a situation cannot be
imagined or presumed to exist just because there is a flow of money from one party to another. Unless there
is an express or implied promise by the recipient of money to agree to do or abstain from doing someth ing
in return for the money paid to him, it cannot be assumed that such payment was for doing an act or for
refraining from an act or for tolerating an act or situation.
8. Payments such as liquidated damages for breach of contract, penalties under the mining act for
excess stock found with the mining company, forfeiture of salary or payment of amount as per the
employment bond for leaving the employment before the minimum agreed period, penalty for cheque
dishonor etc. are not a consideration for tolerating an act or situation. They are rather amounts recovered
for not tolerating an act or situation and to deter such acts; such amounts are for preventing breach of
contract or non-performance and are thus mere 'events' in a contract. Further, such amounts do not
Page 2 of 11
the ‘promisor’ to do or to abstain from doing anything. ‘Consideration’ has been defined in the Contract
Act as what the ‘promisee’ does or abstains from doing for the promises made to him.
4. This goes to show that the service of agreeing to the obligation to refrain from an act or to tolerate
an act or a situation, or to do an act is nothing but a contractual agreement. A contract to do something or
to abstain from doing something cannot be said to have taken place unless there are two parties, one of
which expressly or impliedly agrees to do or abstain from doing something and the other agrees to pay
consideration to the first party for doing or abstaining from such an act.
5. The expression in entry at 5 (e) of Schedule II comprises the three different sets of activities viz. (a)
the obligation to refrain from an act, (b) obligation to tolerate an act or a situation and (c) obligation to do
an act. All the three activities must be under an “agreement” or a “contract” (whether express or implied)
to fall within the ambit of the said entry. In other words, one of the parties to such agreement/contract (the
first party) must be under a contractual obligation to either (a) refrain from an act, or (b) to tolerate an act
or a situation or (c) to do an act.
6. Further some “consideration” must flow in return from the other party to this contract/agreement
(the second party) to the first party for such (a) refraining or (b) tolerating or (c) doing. Such contractual
arrangement must be an independent arrangement in its own right. Such arrangement or agreement can take
the form of an independent stand- alone contract or may form part of another contract. Thus, a person (the
first person) can be said to be making a supply by way of refraining from doing something or tolerating
some act or situation to another person (the second person) if the first person was under an obligation to do
so and then performed accordingly.
7. There has to be an express or implied agreement; oral or written, to do or abstain from doing
something against payment of consideration for doing or abstaining from such act, for a taxable supply to
exist. An agreement to do an act or abstain from doing an act or to tolerate an act or a situation cannot be
imagined or presumed to exist just because there is a flow of money from one party to another. Unless there
is an express or implied promise by the recipient of money to agree to do or abstain from doing something
in return for the money paid to him, it cannot be assumed that such payment was for doing an act or for
refraining from an act or for tolerating an act or situation.
8. Payments such as liquidated damages for breach of contract, penalties under the mining act for
excess stock found with the mining company, forfeiture of salary or payment of amount as per the
employment bond for leaving the employment before the minimum agreed period, penalty for cheque
dishonor etc. are not a consideration for tolerating an act or situation. They are rather amounts recovered
for not tolerating an act or situation and to deter such acts; such amounts are for preventing breach of
contract or non-performance and are thus mere ‘events’ in a contract. Further, such amounts do not
Page 2 of 11
constitute payment (or consideration) for tolerating an act. because there cannot be any contract: (a) for
breach thereof, or (b) for holding more stock than permitted under the mining contract, or (c) for leaving
the employment before the agreed minimum period or (d) for doing something leading to the dishonor of a
cheque. As has already been stated, unless payment has been made for an independent activity of tolerating
an act under an independent arrangement entered into for such activity of tolerating an act, such payments
will not constitute 'consideration' and hence such activities will not constitute "supply" within the meaning
of the Act.
9. Thus. the intent of the legislature as gathered from above is to tax the activity if it is a supply. Hence,
it is essential to lay down some principle / criterion to determine whether it is supply or otherwise. Below
are some tests that need to be borne in mind for characterization of transaction or activities to be covered
in the scope and ambit of para 5 (e) of schedule lI of GST Act(s).
9.1 The transaction or activity should always be considered in view of the intention of the parties
involved as gathered from the agreement or contract of the parties. If as per the terms of contract there is
an intent to provide any/ an identifiable service for which a consideration is received. by whatever name,
they are: then such transactions or activities would be under seope and ambit of the said expression. It
means that the rendition of service of any type would only be covered in the scope and ambit.
9.2 There must be a necessary and sufficient nexus between the supply (i.e. agreement to do or to
abstain from doing something) and the consideration. The amount received shal not be mere event of
transfer of money to compensate for injury, loss or damage suffered by the aggrieved parties due to breach
of contract.
9.3 There must be an agreement, express or implied amongst parties to refrain from or tolerate an act
or to do anything, without such agreement the damages do not constitute consideration for a supply. Rather,
it would be considered as payments made for NOT tolerating an act (i.e. not tolerating the breach of
contract).
9.4 The condition to the contract need not be referred in view of the consideration of the contract. The
amount received by operation of law or by operation of condition of contract cannot be held as
consideration. The amount received out of the contract/agreement between two persons wherein one person
does something for another and the other pays the first in return can only be held as consideration. Thus,
if there is not an implied or express offer or willingness on part of the supplier that he would tolerate the
breach of law/ contract, then damages, the fine or penalty imposed are to be held as for NOT tolerating an
act and not as a consideration for any service. In most of the contracts, the parties to contract with intention
/ desires of continuing it prescribes condition of penalty, fine or surcharge. The amount received as a
penalty, fine or surcharge as a condition of the contract, which present in contract to discourage the breach
Page 3 of 11
»»
constitute payment (or consideration) for tolerating an act, because there cannot be any contract: (a) for
breach thereof, or (b) for holding more stock than permitted under the mining contract, or (c) for leaving
the employment before the agreed minimum period or (d) for doing something leading to the dishonor of a
cheque. As has already been stated, unless payment has been made for an independent activity of tolerating
an actunder an independent arrangement entered into for such activity of tolerating an act, such payments
will not constitute ‘consideration’ and hence such activities will not constitute “supply” within the meaning
of the Act.
9. Thus, the intent of the legislature as gathered from above is to tax the activity if it is a supply. Hence,
it is essential to lay down some principle / criterion to determine whether it is supply or otherwise. Below
are some tests that need to be borne in mind for characterization of transaction or activities to be covered
in the scope and ambit of para 5 (e) of schedule II of GST Act(s).
9.1 The transaction or activity should always be considered in view of the intention of the parties
involved as gathered from the agreement or contract of the parties. If as per the terms of contract there is
an intent to provide any / an identifiable service for which a consideration is received, by whatever name,
they are; then such transactions or activities would be under scope and ambit of the said expression. It
means that the rendition of service of any type would only be covered in the scope and ambit.
9.2 There must be a necessary and sufficient nexus between the supply (i.e. agreement to do or to
abstain from doing something) and the consideration. The amount received shall not be mere event of
transfer of money to compensate for injury, loss or damage suffered by the aggrieved parties due to breach
of contract.
9.3 There must be an agreement, express or implied amongst parties to refrain from or tolerate an act
or to do anything, without such agreement the damages do not constitute consideration for a supply. Rather,
it would be considered as payments made for NOT tolerating an act (i.e. not tolerating the breach of
contract).
9.4 The condition to the contract need not be referred in view of the consideration of the contract. The
amount received by operation of law or by operation of condition of contract cannot be held as
consideration. The amount received out of the contract/agreement between two persons wherein one person
does something for another and the other pays the first in return can only be held as consideration. Thus,
if there is not an implied or express offer or willingness on part of the supplier that he would tolerate the
breach of law / contract, then damages, the fine or penalty imposed are to be held as for NOT tolerating an
act and not as a consideration for any service. In most of the contracts, the parties to contract with intention
/ desires of continuing it prescribes condition of penalty, fine or surcharge. The amount received as a
penalty, fine or surcharge as a condition of the contract, which present in contract to discourage the breach
Page 3 of 11
VY
of contract need not to be viewed as consideration for supply of separate service. In that case the amounts
recoverable needs to be held as deterrence to such situations.
9.5 If the contract intends to provide certain facilities along with principle supplies under contract or
tolerating the act facilitates the recipient of principle supplies by one or other way. then said consideration
with respect to such facilitation is ancillary and naturally bundled with the main supply. The consideration
in such cases are for reason of something done which is ancillary to the principal supply for which the
contract is signed, they shall be eligible to be assessed in a similar manner to that of the principal supply.
Naturally, such payments will not be taxable if the principal supply is exempt.
10. In view of the above discussion, the enclosed Annexure A to this trade circular discusses the
transactions and taxability in some cases. Whereas, the Annexure B is the circular no.178/10/2022-GST dt.
3rd August, 2022 issued by the CBIC.
11. Field formations are advised that while the taxability in each case shall depend on facts of that
case, the above guidelines may be followed in determining whether tax on an activity or transaction needs
to be paid treating the same as service by way of agreeing to the obligation to refrain from an act or to
tolerate an act or a situation, or to do an act. This Trade Circular is clarificatory in nature. Difficulty if any.
in the implementation of this Circular may be brought to the notice of the office of the Commissioner of
State Tax, Maharashtra.
Enclosure: Annexure A and Annexure B as above
(Rajeev Kumaf ital)
Commisioner of State Tax,
Maharashtra
No. DC-1(A&R)/GST/ MISC/2022/29/ADM-8 Dated:-2/12/2DN2
Trade Circular. } ST of 2022
Copy forwarded to the Joint Commissioner of State Tax (Mahavikas) with a request to upload this Trade
Circular on the Departments website.
Copy submitted with compliments to,-
a) The Deputy Secretary, Finance Department, Mantralaya, Mumbai-21 for information.
b) Accounts Officer, Sales Tax Revenue Audit, Mumbai and Nagpur.
(R. D. Adsul)
Joint Commissioner of State Tax (HQ-1)
Maharashtra State
Page 4 of 11
. ¢ ‘ anarate Sri Ce at 206 th grounts
of contract need not to be viewed as consideration for supply of separate service. In that case the amounts
recoverable needs to be held as deterrence to such situations,
9.5 If the contract intends to provide certain facilities along with principle supplies under contra
tolerating the act facilitates the recipient of principle supplies by one or other way, then said © eidearaiion
onsiderats JS
. ees ‘ : ‘ > ; > ins yy Th oncideration
with respect to such facilitation is ancillary and naturally bundled with the main supply. The consideration
: i : ae , to incin2a! < Vv
in such cases are for reason of something done which Js ancillary to the principa! supply {
contract is signed, they shall be eligible to be assessed in a similar manner to that of the principal st
Naturally, such payments will not be taxable if the principal supply is exempt.
In view of the above discussion, the enclosed Annexure A to this trade circular discusses the
Ae
10.
transactions and taxability in some cases. Whereas, the Annexure B is the circular no.178/10/2022-GST
3" August, 2022 issued by the CBIC.
11. Field formations are advised that while the taxability in each case shal] depend on facts of that
case, the above guidelines may be followed in determining whether tax on an activity or transaction needs
to be paid treating the same as service by way of agreeing to the obligation to refrain from an act or to
tolerate an act or a situation, or to do an act. This Trade Circular is clarificatory in nature. Difficulty if any.
in the implementation of this Circular may be brought to the notice of the office of the Commis
State Tax, Maharashtra.
6 Enclosure: Annexure A and Annexure B as above r
a) A
\ \y
(Rajeev Kumar Miital )
Commissione¥ of State Tax.
Maharashtra
No. DC-1(A&R/GST/ MISC/2022/29/ADM-8 Dated:- ) 2[(2/2n22_
Trade Circular. | 4 T of 2022
Copy forwarded to the Joint Commissioner of State Tax (Mahavikas) with a request to upload this Trade
Circular on the Departments website.
Copy submitted with compliments to,-
a) The Deputy Secretary, Finance Department, Mantralaya, Mumbai-2] for information.
b) Accounts Officer, Sales Tax Revenue Audit, Mumbai and Nagpur.
(R. D. Adsul)
Joint Commissioner of State Tax (HO- 1)
Maharashtra State
Page 4ofii
T
ANNEXURE - A
1. Liquidated Damages
1. Breach or non-performance of contract by one party results in loss and damages to the other
party. Therefore, the law provides in Section 73 of the Contract Act, 1972 that when a contract has been
broken, the party which suffers by such breach is entitled to receive from the other party compensation for
any loss or damage caused to him by such breach. The compensation is not by way of consideration for any
other independent activity; it is just an event in the course of performance of that contract.
1.2 It is common for the parties entering into a contract, to specify in the contract itself, the
compensation that would be payable in the event of the breach of the contract. Such compensation specified
in a written contract for breach of non-performance of the contract or parties of the contract is referred to
as liquidated damages. Black's Law Dictionary defines Liquidated Damages' as cash compensation
agreed to by a signed, writen contraci for breach of contract, payable to the aggrieved party.
1.3 Section 74 of the Contract Act, 1972 provides that when a contract is broken, if a sum has been
named or a penalty stipulated in the contract as the amount or penalty to be paid in case of breach, the
aggrieved party shall be entitled to receive reasonable compensation not exceeding the amount so named
or the penalty so stipulated.
1.4 It is argued that performance is the essence of a contract. Liquidated damages cannot be said to
be a consideration received for tolerating the breach or non-performance of contract. They are rather
payments for not tolerating the breach of contract. Payment of liquidated damages is stipulated in a contract
to ensure performance and to deter non-performance, unsatisfactory performance or delayed performance.
Liquidated damages are a measure of loss and damage that the parties agree would arise due to breach of
contract. They do not act as a remedy for the breach of contract. They do not restitute the aggrieved person.
Itis further argued that a contract is entered into for execution and not for its breach. The liquidated damages
or penalty are not the desired outcome of the contract. By accepting the liquidated damages, the party
aggrieved by breach of contract cannot be said to have permitted or tolerated the deviation or non-fulfilment
of the promise by the other party.
1.5 In this background a reasonable view that can be taken with regard to taxability of liquidated
damages is that where the amount paid as "liquidated damages' is an amount paid only to compensate for
injury, loss or damage suffered by the aggrieved party due to breach of the contract and there is no
agreement, express or inmplied, by the aggrieved party receiving the liquidated damages, to refrain from or
tolerate an act or to do anything for the party paying the liquidated damages, in such cases liquidated
damages are mere a flow of money from the party who causes breach of the contract to the party who suffers
Page 5 of 11
»
y
ANNEXURE - A
1. Liquidated Damages
Ll Breach or non-performance of contract by one party results in loss and damages to the other
party. Therefore, the law provides in Section 73 of the Contract Act, 1972 that when a contract has been
broken, the party which suffers by such breach is entitled to receive from the other party compensation for
any loss or damage caused to him by such breach. The compensation is not by way of consideration for any
other independent activity; it is just an event in the course of performance of that contract.
1.2 It is common for the parties entering into a contract, to specify in the contract itself, the
compensation that would be payable in the event of the breach of the contract. Such compensation specified
in a written contract for breach of non-performance of the contract or parties of the contract is referred to
as liquidated damages. Black’s Law Dictionary defines ‘Liquidated Damages’ as cash compensation
agreed to by a signed, written contract for breach of contract, payable to the aggrieved party.
13 Section 74 of the Contract Act, 1972 provides that when a contract is broken, if a sum has been
named or a penalty stipulated in the contract as the amount or penalty to be paid in case of breach, the
aggrieved party shall be entitled to receive reasonable compensation not exceeding the amount so named
or the penalty so stipulated.
1.4 It is argued that performance is the essence of a contract. Liquidated damages cannot be said to
be a consideration received for tolerating the breach or non-performance of contract. They are rather
payments for not tolerating the breach of contract. Payment of liquidated damages is stipulated in a contract
to ensure performance and to deter non-performance, unsatisfactory performance or delayed performance.
Liquidated damages are a measure of loss and damage that the parties agree would arise due to breach of
contract. They do not act as a remedy for the breach of contract. They do not restitute the aggrieved person.
It is further argued that a contract is entered into for execution and not for its breach. The liquidated damages
or penalty are not the desired outcome of the contract. By accepting the liquidated damages, the party
aggrieved by breach of contract cannot be said to have permitted or tolerated the deviation or non-fulfilment
of the promise by the other party.
1.5 In this background a reasonable view that can be taken with regard to taxability of liquidated
damages is that where the amount paid as ‘liquidated damages’ is an amount paid only to compensate for
injury, loss or damage suffered by the aggrieved party due to breach of the contract and there is no
agreement, express or implied, by the aggrieved party receiving the liquidated damages, to refrain from or
tolerate an act or to do anything for the party paying the liquidated damages, in such cases liquidated
damages are mere a flow of money from the party who causes breach of the contract to the party who suffers
Page 5 of 11
TY
loss or damage due to such breach. Such payments do not constitute consideration for a supply and arenot
taxable.
1.6 Examples of such cases are damages resulting from damage to property, negligence, piracy,
unauthorized use of trade name, copyright, etc. Other examples that may be covered here are the penalty
stipulated in a contract for delayed construction of houses. It is a penalty paid by the builder to the buyers
to compensate them for the loss that they suffer due to such delayed construction and not for getting
anything in return from the buyers. Similarly, forfeiture of earnest money by a seller in case of breach of
an agreement to sell' an immovable property by the buyer or by Government or local authority in the event
of a successful bidder failing to act after winning the bid, for allotment of natural resources, is a mere flow
of money, as the buyer or the successful bidder does not get anything in return for such forfeiture of earnest
money. Forfeiture of Earnest money is stipulated in such cases not as a consideration for tolerating the
breach of contract but as a compensation for the losses suffered and as a penalty for discouraging the non-
serious buyers or bidders. Such payments being merely flow of money are not a consideration for any
supply and are not taxable. The key in such cases is to consider.whether the impugned payments constitute
consideration for another independent contract envisaging tolerating an act or situation or refraining from
doing any act or situation or simply doing an act. If the answer is yes, then it constitutes a 'supply' within
the meaning of the Act, otherwise it is not a "supply".
2. Miscellaneous Ancillary Services to Principal Services
2.1 If a payment constitutes a consideration for a supply, then it is taxable irrespective of by what
name it is called; it must be remembered that a "consideration" cannot be considered de hors an
agreement/contract between two persons wherein one person does something for another and that other
pays the first in return. If the payment is merely an event in the course of the performance of the agreement
and it does not represent the 'object', as such, of the contract then it cannot be considered 'consideration'.
For example, a contract may provide that payment by the recipient of goods or services shall be made before
a certain date and failure to make payment by the due date shall attract late fee or penalty. A contract for
transport of passengers may stipulate that the ticket amount shall be partly or wholly forfeited if the
passenger does not show up. A contract for package tour may stipulate forfeiture of security deposit in the
event of cancellation of tour by the customer. Similarly, a contract for lease of movable or immovable
property may stipulate that the lessee shall not terminate the lease before a certain period and if he does so
he will have to pay certain amount as early termination fee or penalty. Some banks similarly charge pre
payment penalty if the borrower wishes to repay the loan before the maturity of the loan period. Such
amounts paid for acceptance of late payment, early termination of lease or for pre-payment of loan or the
amounts forfeited on cancellation of service by the customer as contemplated by the contract as part of
commercial terms agreed to by the parties, constitute consideration for the supply of a facility, namely, of
Page 6 of 11
loss or damage due to such breach. Such payments do not constitute consideration for a supply and are not
taxable.
1.6 Examples of such cases are damages resulting from damage to property, negligence, piracy,
unauthorized use of trade name, copyright, etc. Other examples that may be covered here are the penalty
stipulated in a contract for delayed construction of houses. It is a penalty paid by the builder to the buyers
to compensate them for the loss that they suffer due to such delayed construction and not for getting
anything in return from the buyers. Similarly, forfeiture of earnest money by a seller in case of breach of
‘an agreement to sell’ an immovable property by the buyer or by Government or local authority in the event
of a successful bidder failing to act after winning the bid, for allotment of natural resources, is a mere flow
of money, as the buyer or the successful bidder does not get anything in return for such forfeiture of earnest
money. Forfeiture of Earnest money is stipulated in such cases not as a consideration for tolerating the
breach of contract but as a compensation for the losses suffered and as a penalty for discouraging the non-
serious buyers or bidders. Such payments being merely flow of money are not a consideration for any
supply and are not taxable. The key in such cases is to consider whether the impugned payments constitute
consideration for another independent contract envisaging tolerating an act or situation or refraining from
doing any act or situation or simply doing an act. If the answer is yes, then it constitutes a ‘supply’ within
the meaning of the Act, otherwise it is not a “supply”.
2. Miscellaneous Ancillary Services to Principal Services
2.1 If a payment constitutes a consideration for a supply, then it is taxable irrespective of by what
name it is called; it must be remembered that a “consideration” cannot be considered de hors an
agreement/contract between two persons wherein one person does something for another and that other
pays the first in return. If the payment is merely an event in the course of the performance of the agreement
and it does not represent the ‘object’, as such, of the contract then it cannot be considered ‘consideration’.
For example, a contract may provide that payment by the recipient of goods or services shall be made before
a certain date and failure to make payment by the due date shall attract late fee or penalty. A contract for
transport of passengers may stipulate that the ticket amount shall be partly or wholly forfeited if the
passenger does not show up. A contract for package tour may stipulate forfeiture of security deposit in the
event of cancellation of tour by the customer. Similarly, a contract for lease of movable or immovable
property may stipulate that the lessee shall not terminate the lease before a certain period and if he does so
he will have to pay certain amount as early termination fee or penalty. Some banks similarly charge pre-
payment penalty if the borrower wishes to repay the loan before the maturity of the loan period. Such
amounts paid for acceptance of late payment, early termination of lease or for pre-payment of loan or the
amounts forfeited on cancellation of service by the customer as contemplated by the contract as part of
commercial terms agreed to by the parties, constitute consideration for the supply of a facility, namely, of
Page 6 of 11
7
acceptance of late payment. early termination of a lease agreement, of pre-payment of loan and of making
arrangements for the intended supply by the tour operator respectively. Thercfore, such payments, cven
though they may be referred to as fine or penalty, are actually payments that amount to consideration for
supply. and are subject to GST. in cases where such supply is taxable.
Since these supplies are ancillary to the principal supply for which the contract is signed, they
shall be eligible to be assessed as the principal supply, as discussed in detail in the later paragraphs.
Naturally, such payments will not be taxable if the principal supply is exempt.
3 Compensation for Cancellation of Coal Blocks
3.1
In the year 2014, coal block/mine allocations were cancelled by the Hon'ble Supreme Court vide
order dated 24.09.2014. Subsequently, Coal Mines (Special Provisions) Act, 2015 was enacted to provide
for allocation of coal mines and vesting of rights, title and interest in and over the land and mines
infrastructure together with mining leases to successful bidders and allottees. In accordance with section 16
of the said Act. prior (old) allottee of mines were given compensation in the year 2016 towards the transfer
of their rights/ titles in the land, mine infrastructure, geological reports, consents, approvals etc. to the new
entity (successful bidder) as per the directions of Hon'ble Supreme Court.
3.2 There was no agreement between the prior allottees of coal blocks and the Government that the
previous allottees shall agree to or tolerate cancellation of the coal blocks allocated to them if the
Government pays compensation to them. No such promise or offer was made by the prior allottees to the
Government. The allottees had no option but to accept the cancellation. The compensation was given to
them for such cancellation, not under a contract between the allottees and the Government, but under the
provisions of the statute and in pursuance of the Supreme Court Order. Therefore, it would be incorrect to
say that the prior allottees of the coal blocks supplied a service to the Government by way of agreeing to
tolerate the cancellation of the allocations made to them by the Government or that the compensation paid
by the Government for such cancellation in pursuance to the order of the Supreme Court was a consideration
for such service. Therefore, the compensation paid for cancellation of coal blocks pursuant to the order of
the Supreme Court in the above case was not taxable.
Cheque Dishonor Fine/ Penalty
No supplier wants a cheque given to him to be dishonoured. It entails extra administrative cost to
him and disruption of his routine activities and cash flow. The promise made by any supplier of goods or
services is to make supply against payment within an agreed time (including the agreed permissible time
with late payment) through a valid instrument. There is never an implied or express offer or willingness on
part of the supplier that he would tolerate deposit of an invalid, fake or unworthy instrument of payment
Page 7 of 11
ptance of late payment. early termination of a lease agreement, of pre-payment of loan and of making
ngements for the intended supply by the tour operator respectively. Therefore, such payments, even
thoinch th mougn they may be referred to as fine or penalty, are.actually payments that amount to consideration for
Supp). and are subject to GST, in cases where such supply is taxable.
as
2.2 Since these supplies are ancillary to the principal supply for which the contract is signed, they
shall be eligible to be assessed as the principal supply, as discussed in detail in the later paragraphs.
Naturally. such payments will not be taxable if the principal supply is exempt.
3. Compensation for Cancellation of Coal Blocks
3.1 In the vear 2014, coal block/mine allocations were cancelled by the Hon’ble Supreme Court vide
order dated 24.09.2014. Subsequently, Coal Mines (Special Provisions) Act, 2015 was enacted to provide
allocation of coal mines and vesting of rights, title and interest in and over the Jand and mines
infrastructure together with mining leases to successful bidders and allottees. In accordance with section 16
of the said Act. prior (old) allottee of mines were given compensation in the year 2016 towards the transfer
of their rights) titles in the land, mine infrastructure, geological reports, consents, approvals etc. to the new
entity (successful bidder) as per the directions of Hon’ble Supreme Court.
32 There was no agreement between the prior allottees of coal blocks and the Government that the
previous allottees shall agree to or tolerate cancellation of the coal blocks allocated to them if the
Government pays compensation to them. No such promise or offer was made by the prior allottees to the
Government. The allottees had no option but to accept the cancellation. The compensation was given to
hem for such cancellation, not under a contract between the allottees and the Government, but under the
provisions of the statute and in pursuance of the Supreme Court Order. Therefore, it would be incorrect to
say that the prior allottees of the coal blocks supplied a service to the Government by way of agreeing to
tolerate the cancellation of the allocations made to them by the Government or that the compensation paid
by the Government for such cancellation in pursuance to the order of the Supreme Court was a consideration Usk
for such service. Therefore, the compensation paid for cancellation of coal blocks pursuant to the order of
the Supreme Court in the above case was not taxable.
4. Cheque Dishonor Fine/ Penalty
No supplier wants a cheque given to him to be dishonoured. It entails extra administrative cost to
him and disruption of his routine activities and cash flow. The promise made by any supplier of goods or
services is to make supply against payment within an agreed time (including the agreed permissible time
with late payment) through a valid instrument. There is never an implied or express offer or willingness on
part of the supplier that he would tolerate deposit of an invalid, fake or unworthy instrument of payment
Page 7 of 11
(7S
Cc
against consideration in the form of chequc dishonour fine or penalty. The fine or penalty that the supplier
or a bankcr imposes, for dishonour of a cheque, is a penalty imposed not for tolerating the act or situation
but a fine, or penalty imposed for not tolerating, penalizing and thereby deterring and discouraging such an
act or situation. Therefore, cheque dishonor fine or penalty is not a consideration for any service and not
taxable.
5. Penalty Imposed for Violation of Laws
5.1 Penalty imposed for violation of laws such as traffic violations, or for violation of pollutíon norms
or other laws are also not consideration for any supply received and are not taxable, which are also not
taxable. Same is the case with fines, penalties imposed by the mining Department of a Central or State
Government or a local authority on discovering mining of excess mineral beyond the permissible limit or
of mining activities in violation of the mining permit. Such penalties imposed for violatíon of laws cannot
be regarded as consideration charged by Government or a Local Authority for toleratingg violation of laws.
Laws are not framed for tolerating their violation. They stipulate penalty not for tolerating violation but for
not tolerating, penalizing and deterring such violatíons. There is no agreement between the Government
and the violator specifying that violation would be allowed or permitted against payment of fine or penalty.
There cannot be such an agreement as violation of law is never a lawful object or consideration. The service
tax education guide issued in 2012 on advent of negative list regime of services explained that fines and
penalties paid for violation of provisions of law are not considerations as no service is received in lieu of
payment of such fines and penalties.
5.2 It was also clarified vide Circular No. 192/02/2016-Service Tax, dated 13.04.2016 that fines and
penalty chargeable by Government or a local authority imposed for violation ofa statute, bye-laws, rules
or regulations are not leviable to Service Tax. The same holds true for GST also i.e. it is not taxable.
. Forfeiture of Salary or Payment of Bond Amount in the Event of the Employee Leaving the
Employment before the Minimum Agreed Period
An employer carries out an elaborate selection process and incurs expenditure in recruiting an
employee, invests in his training and makes him a part of the organization, privy to its processes and
business secrets in the expectation that the recruited employee would work for the organization fora certain
minimum period. Premature leaving of the employment results in disruption of work and an undesirable
situation. The provisions for forfeiture of salary or recovery of bond amount in the event of the employee
leaving the employment before the minimum agreed period are incorporated in the employment contract to
discourage non-serious candidates from taking up employment. The said amounts are recovered by the
employer not as a consideration for tolerating the act of such premature quitting of employment but as
penalties for dissuading the non-serious employees from taking up employment and to discourage and deter
Page 8 of 11
against consideration in the form of cheque dishonour fine or penalty. The fine or penalty that the supplier
or a banker imposes, for dishonour of a cheque, is a penalty imposed not for tolerating the act or situation
but a fine, or penalty imposed for not tolerating, penalizing and thereby deterring and discouraging such an
act or situation. Therefore, cheque dishonor fine or penalty is not a consideration for any service and not
taxable,
5. Penalty Imposed for Violation of Laws
Jel Penalty imposed for violation of laws such as traffic violations, or for violation of pollution norms
or other laws are also not consideration for any supply received and are not taxable, which are also not
taxable. Same is the case with fines, penalties imposed by the mining Department of a Central or State
Government or a local authority on discovering mining of excess mineral beyond the permissible limit or
of mining activities in violation of the mining permit. Such penalties imposed for violation of Jaws cannot
be regarded as consideration charged by Government or a Local Authority for tolerating violation of Jaws.
Laws are not framed for tolerating their violation. They stipulate penalty not for tolerating violation but for
not tolerating, penalizing and deterring such violations. There is no agreement between the Government
and the violator specifying that violation would be allowed or permitted against payment of fine or penalty.
There cannot be such an agreement as violation of law is never a lawful object or consideration. The service
tax education guide issued in 2012 on advent of negative list regime of services explained that fines and
penalties paid for violation of provisions of law are not considerations as no service is received in lieu of
payment of such fines and penalties.
5.2 It was also clarified vide Circular No. 192/02/2016-Service Tax, dated 13.04.2016 that fines and
penalty chargeable by Government or a local authority imposed for violation of a statute, bye-laws, rules
or regulations are not leviable to Service Tax. The same holds true for GST also i.e. it is not taxable.
6. Forfeiture of Salary or Payment of Bond Amount in the Event of the Employee Leaving the
Employment before the Minimum Agreed Period
An employer carries out an elaborate selection process and incurs expenditure in recruiting an
employee, invests in his training and makes him a part of the organization, privy to its processes and
business secrets in the expectation that the recruited employee would work for the organization for a certain
minimum period. Premature leaving of the employment results in disruption of work and an undesirable
situation. The provisions for forfeiture of salary or recovery of bond amount in the event of the employee
leaving the employment before the minimum agreed period are incorporated in the employment contract to
discourage non-serious candidates from taking up employment. The said amounts are recovered by the
employer not as a consideration for tolerating the act of such premature quitting of employment but as
penalties for dissuading the non-serious employees from taking up employment and to discourage and deter
Page 8 of 11
Such a situation. Further, the employec does not get anything in relurn from the employer npniust payent
of such amounts. Therefore, such amounts recovered by the enployer re not taxlble us consiedesutienn
the service of agrecing to tolerate an act or a situntion.
7 Compensation for not Colleeting Toll Charges
7.1 In the wake of demonetization, NI1AI directod the eoncewiomuaires (tul operalors) to nllow free
access of toll roads to the users from 8.11.2016 to 1.12.2016 for which the loss of toll elarge wins paid ns
compensation by NHAl as per the instructions of Ministry of Road Transportation nnd Ilighways, The toll
reimbursements were calculated based on the averuge mnonthly collection of tol. A question nrose whether
the compensation paid to the concessionaire by project authorities (NHAI) in lieu of suspension of toll
collection during the demonetization period (from 8.11.2016 to 1.12.2016) was taxable as a service by way
of agreeing to refrain from collection of toll from users.
7.2 It has been clarified vide Circular No. 212/2/2019-ST dated 21.05.2019 that the service that is
provided by toll operators is that of access to a road or bridge, toll charges being merely a consideration for
that service. During the period from 8.11.2016 to 1.12.2016, the service of access to a road or bridge
continued to be provided without collection of toll from users. Consideration came from the project
authority. The fact that for this period, for the same service, consideration camne from a person other than
the actual user of service does not mean that the service has changed.
8. Late Payment Surcharge or Fee
The facility of accepting late payments with interest or late payment fee, fine or penalty is a facility
granted by supplier naturally bundled with the main supply. It is not uncommon or unnatural for customers
to sometimes miss the last date of payment of electricity, water, telecommunication services ete. Almost
all service providers across the world provide the facility of accepting late payments with late fine or
penalty. Even if this service is described as a service of tolerating the act of late payment, it is an ancillary
supply naturally bundled and supplied in conjunction with the principal supply, and therefore should be
assessed as the principal supply. Since it is ancillary to and naturally bundled with the principal supply
such as of electricity, water, telecommunication, cooking gas, insurance etc.lt is taxable and it should be
assessed at the same rate as the principal supply.
9. Fixed Capacity Charges for Power
9.1
The price charged for electricity by the power generating companies from the State Electricity
Boards (SEBs/DISCOMS or by SEBs/DISCOMs from individual customers has two components, namely,
a minimum fixed charge (or capacity charge) and variable per unit charge. The minimum fixed charges
have to be paid by the SEBs/DISCOMS/individual customers irrespective of the quantity of clectricity
Page 9 of 11
such a situati ther the a a i 4 . a situation. Further, the employee does not get anything in return from the emiployer apainsl payment
of such g Mherefi re uch amounts, Therefore, such amounts recovered by the employer are not taxable ai consideration far
the service of agreeing to tolerate an act or a situation,
7, Compensation for not Collecting Toll ( ‘harges
Tl In the wake of demonetization, NHAT directed the concessionaires (toll operitors) to allow free
access of toll roads to the users from 8.11.2016 to 112.2016 for which the loss of toll charge was paid ay
compensation by NHAL as per the instructions of Ministry of Road Transportation and Highways, The toll
reimbursements were calculated based on the average monthly collection of toll, A question arose whether
the compensation paid to the concessionaire by project authorities (NHAI) in Jiew of suspension of toll
collection during the demonetization period (from 8,11.2016 to 1.12.2016) was taxable as a service by way
of agreeing to refrain from collection of toll from users.
1.2 It has been clarified vide Circular No. 212/2/2019-ST dated 21.05.2019 that the service that is
provided by toll operators is that of access to a road or bridge, toll charges being merely a consideration for
that service. During the period from 8.11.2016 to 1.12.2016, the service of access to a road or bridge
continued to be provided without collection of toll from users. Consideration came from the project
authority. The fact that for this period, for the same service, consideration came from a person other than
the actual user of service does not mean that the service has changed.
8. Late Payment Surcharge or Fee
The facility of accepting late payments with interest or late payment fee, fine or penalty is a facility
granted by supplier naturally bundled with the main supply, It is not uncommon or unnatural for customers
to sometimes miss the last date of payment of electricity, water, telecommunication services etc. Almost
all service providers across the world provide the facility of accepting late payments with late fine or
penalty. Even if this service is described as a service of tolerating the act of late payment, it is an ancillary
supply naturally bundled and supplied in conjunction with the principal supply, and therefore should be
assessed as the principal supply. Since it is ancillary to and naturally bundled with the principal supply
such as of electricity, water, telecommunication, cooking gas, insurance ete, It is taxable and it should be
assessed at the same rate as the principal supply.
9. Fixed Capacity Charges for Power
9.1 The price charged for electricity by the power generating companies from the State Electricity
Boards (SEBs)/DISCOMS or by SEBs/DISCOMs from individual customers has two components, namely,
a minimum fixed charge (or capacity charge) and variable per unit charge. The minimum fixed charges
have to be paid by the SEBs/DISCOMS/individual customers irrespective of the quantity of electricity
Page 9 of 11
rey,
scheduled or purchased by them during a month. They take care of the fixcd cost of generating/ supplying
clectricity. The variable charges are charged per unit of electricity purchased and increase or decrease every
month depending on the quantity of clectricity consumed.
The lact that the minimum lixed charges remain the same whether clectricity is consumed or not
or it is scheduled/consumed below the contracted or available capacity or a minimum threshold, does not
mean that minimum fixed charge or part of it is a charge for tolerating the act of not scheduling or
consuming the minimum the contracted or available capacity or a minimum threshold.
9.3 Both the components of the price, he minimum fixed charges/capacity charges and the
variable/energy charges are charged for sale of electricity and are thus not taxable as electricity is exempt
from GST.
10. Cancellation Charges
10.1 A supply contracted for, such as booking of hotel accommodation, an entertainment event or a
journey, may be cancelled by a customer or may not proceed as intended due to his failure to show up for
availing the same at the designated place and time. The supplier may allow cancelation of supply by the
customer within a certain specified time period on payment of cancelation fee as per commercial terms of
the contract. In case the customer does not show up for availing the service, the supplier may retain or
forfeit part of the consideration or security deposit or earnest money paid by the customer for the intended
supply.
10.2 It is a common business practice for suppliers of services such as hotel accommodation, tour and
travel, transportation etc. to provide the facility of cancellation of the intended supplies within a certain
time period on payment of cancellation fee. Cancellation fee can be considered as the charges for the costs
involved in making arrangements for the intended supply and the costs involved in cancellation of the
supply, such as in cancellation of reserved tickets by the lndian Railways.
10.3 Services such as transportation travel and tour constitute a bundle of services. The transportation
service, for instance, starts with booking of the ticket for travel and lasts at least till exit of the passenger
from the destination terminal. All services such as making available an online portal or convenient booking
counters with basic facilities at the transportation terminal or in the city, to reserve the seats and issue tickets
for reserved seats much in advance of the travel, giving preferred seats with or without extra cost, lounge
and waiting room facilities at airports, railway stations and bus terminals, provision of basic necessties
such as soap and other toiletries in the wash rooms, clenn drinking water in the waiting area ete. form part
and parcel of the transportation service; they constitute the various elements of passenger transportation
service, a composite supply.. The facilitation service of allowing cancellation against payment of
Page 10 of 11
scheduled or purchased by them during a month. They take care of the fixed cost of gencrating/ supplying
electricity, The variable charges are charged per unit of electricity purchased and increase or decrease every
month depending on the quantity of electricity consumed,
0, he fact that the minimum fixed charges remain the same whether electricity is consumed or not
or it is scheduled/consumed below the contracted or available capacity or a minimum threshold, does not
mean that minimum fixed charge or part of it is a charge for tolerating the act of not scheduling or
consuming the minimum the contracted or available capacity or a minimum threshold.
93 Both the components of the price, the minimum fixed charges/capacity charges and the
variable/energy charges are charged for sale of electricity and are thus not taxable as electricity is exempt
from GST.
10. Cancellation Charges
10.1 A supply contracted for, such as booking of hotel accommodation, an entertainment event or a
journey, may be cancelled by a customer or may not proceed as intended due to his failure to show up for
availing the same at the designated place and time. The supplier may allow cancelation of supply by the
customer within a certain specified time period on payment of cancellation fee as per commercial terms of
the contract. In case the customer does not show up for availing the service, the supplier may retain or
forfeit part of the consideration or security deposit or earnest money paid by the customer for the intended
supply.
10.2 It is acommon business practice for suppliers of services such as hotel accommodation, tour and
travel, transportation etc. to provide the facility of cancellation of the intended supplies within a certain
time period on payment of cancellation fee. Cancellation fee can be considered as the charges for the costs
involved in making arrangements for the intended supply and the costs involved in cancellation of the
supply, such as in cancellation of reserved tickets by the Indian Railways.
10,3 Services such as transportation travel and tour constitute a bundle of services. The transportation
service, for instance, starts with booking of the ticket for travel and lasts at least till exit of the passenger
from the destination terminal. All services such as making available an online portal or convenient booking
counters with basic facilities at the transportation terminal or in the city, to reserve the seats and issue tickets
for reserved seats much in advance of the travel, giving preferred seats with or without extra cost, lounge
and waiting room facilities at airports, railway stations and bus terminals, provision of basic necessities
such as soap and other toiletries in the wash rooms, clean drinking water in the waiting area etc. form part
and parcel of the transportation service; they constitute the various elements of passenger transportation
service, a composite supply.. The facilitation service of allowing cancellation against payment of
Page 10 of 11
17
cancellation charges is also a natural part of this bundlc. It is invariably supplied by all suppliers of
passenger transportation service as naturally bundled and in conjunction with the principal supply of
transportation in the ordinary course of business.
10.4 Therefore, facilitation supply of allowing cancellation of an intended supply against payment of
cancellation fee or retention or forfeiture of a part or whole of the consideration or security deposit in such
cases should be assessed as the principal supply. For example, cancellation charges of railway tickets for a
class would attract GST at the same rate as applicable to the class of travel (i.e., 5% GST on first class or
air-conditioned coach ticket and nil for other classes such as second sleeper class). Same is the case for air
travel.
10.5 Accordingly, the amount forfeited in the case of non-refundable ticket for air travel or security
deposit or earnest money forfeited in case of the customer failing to avail the travel, tour operator or hotel
accommodation service or such other intended supplies is taxable and it should be assessed at the same rate
as applicable to the service contract, say air transport or tour operator service, or other such services.
11. Forfeiture of EMD in Bidding Process etc.
However, as discussed above, forfeiture of earnest money by a seller in case of breach of 'an
agreement to sell' an immovable property by the buyer or such forfeiture by Government or local authority
in the event of a successful bidder failing to act after winning the bid for allotment of natural resources, is
a mere flow of money, as the buyer or the successful bidder does not get anything in return for such
forfeiture of earnest money. Forfeiture of earnest money is stipulated in such cases not as a consideration
for tolerating the breach of contract but as a compensation for the losses suffered and as a penalty for
discouraging the non-serious buyers or bidders. Such payments being merely flow of money are nota
consideration for any supply and are not taxable.
Page 11 of 11
on
cancellation charges is also a natural part of this bundle. It is invariably supplied by all suppliers of
passenger transportation service as naturally bundled and in conjunction with the principal supply of
transportation in the ordinary course of business.
10.4 Therefore, facilitation supply of allowing cancellation of an intended supply against payment of
cancellation fee or retention or forfeiture of a part or whole of the consideration or security deposit in such
cases should be assessed as the principal supply. For example, cancellation charges of railway tickets for a
class would attract GST at the same rate as applicable to the class of travel (i.c., 5% GST on first class or
air-conditioned coach ticket and nil for other classes such as second sleeper class), Same is the case for air
travel.
10.5 Accordingly, the amount forfeited in the case of non-refundable ticket for air travel or security
deposit or eamest money forfeited in case of the customer failing to avail the travel, tour operator or hotel
accommodation service or such other intended supplies is taxable and it should be assessed at the same rate
as applicable to the service contract, say air transport or tour operator service, or other such services.
11. Forfeiture of EMD in Bidding Process etc.
However, as discussed above, forfeiture of earnest money by a seller in case of breach of ‘an
agreement to sell’ an immovable property by the buyer or such forfeiture by Government or local authority
in the event of a successful bidder failing to act after winning the bid for allotment of natural resources, is
a mere flow of money, as the buyer or the successful bidder does not get anything in return for such
forfeiture of earnest money. Forfeiture of earnest money is stipulated in such cases not as a consideration
for tolerating the breach of contract but as a compensation for the losses suffered and as a penalty for
discouraging the non-serious buyers or bidders. Such payments being merely flow of money are not a
consideration for any supply and are not taxable.
Page 11 of 11
yy
Anne x ue B
Circular No. 178/10/2022-GST
F. No. 190354/176/2022-TRU
Government of India
Ministry of Finance
Department of Revenue
(Tax Research Unit)
*****
Room No. 146G, North Block,
New Delhi, the 3rd August, 2022
To.
The Principal Chief Commissioners/Chief Commissioners/ Principal Commissioners/
Commissioner of Central Tax (All)/
The Principal Director Generals/ Director Generals (All)
Madam/Sir,
Subiect: GST applicability on liquidated damages, compensation and penalty arising out of
breach of contract or other provisions of law - reg.
In certain cases/instances, questions have been raised regarding taxability of an activity or
transaction as the supply of service of agreeing to the obligation to refrain from an act or to tolerate
an act or a situation, or to do an act. Applicability of GST on payments in the nature of liquidated
damage, compensation, penalty, cancellation charges, late payment surcharge etc. arising out of
breach of contract or otherwise and scope of the entry at para 5 (e) of Schedule II of Central Goods
and Services Tax Act, 2017 (hereinafter referred to as, "CGST Act") in this context has been
examined in the following paragraphs.
2. Agreeing to the obligation to refrain from an act or to tolerate an act or a situation, or to do
am act has been specifically declared to be a supply of service in para 5 (e) of Schedule Il of
CGST Act if the same constitutes a "supply" within the meaning of the Act. The said expression
has following three limbs:
a. Agreeing to the obligation to refrain from an act-
Example of activities that would be covered by this part of the expression would include
non-compete agreements, where one party agrees not to compete with the other party in a
product. service or geographical area against a consideration paid by the other party.
Another example of such activities would be a builder refraining from constructing more
than a certain number of floors, even though permitted to do so by the municipal
authorities, against a compensation paid by the neighbouring housing project, which wants
to protect its sunlight, or an industrial unit refraining from manufacturing activity during
Annex Ve fA
Circular No. 178/10/2022-GST
F. No. 190354/176/2022-TRU
Government of India
Ministry of Finance
Department of Revenue
(Tax Research Unit)
ee KKK
Room No. 146G, North Block,
New Delhi, the 3™ August, 2022
To.
The Principal Chief Commissioners/Chief Commissioners/ Principal Commissioners/
Commissioner of Central Tax (All) /
The Principal Director Generals/ Director Generals (Al])
Madam /Sir,
Subject: GST applicability on liquidated damages, compensation and penalty arising out of
breach of contract or other provisions of law — reg.
In certain cases/instances, questions have been raised regarding taxability of an activity or
transaction as the supply of service of agreeing to the obligation to refrain from an act or to tolerate
an act or a Situation, or to do an act. Applicability of GST on payments in the nature of liquidated
damage. compensation, penalty, cancellation charges, late payment surcharge etc. arising out of
breach of contract or otherwise and scope of the entry at para 5 (e) of Schedule IT of Central Goods
and Services Tax Act, 2017 (hereinafter referred to as, “CGST Act”) in this context has been
examined in the following paragraphs.
2. “Agreeing to the obligation to refrain from an act or to tolerate an act or a situation, or to do
an act” has been specifically declared to be a supply of service in para 5 (e) of Schedule II of
CGST Acct if the same constitutes a “supply” within the meaning of the Act. The said expression
has following three limbs: -
a. Agreeing to the obligation to refrain from an act-
Example of activities that would be covered by this part of the expression would include
non-compete agreements, where one party agrees not to compete with the other party in a
product, service or geographical area against a consideration paid by the other party.
Another example of such activities would be a builder refraining from constructing more
than a certain number of floors, even though permitted to do so by the municipal
authorities, against a compensation paid by the neighbouring housing project, which wants
to protect its sunlight, or an industrial unit refraining from manufacturing activity during
Circular No. 178/10/2022-GST
certain hours against an agreed compensation paid by a neighbouring school, which wants
to avoid noise during those hours.
b. Agreeing to the obligation to tolerate an act or a situation-
This would include activities such a shopkeeper allowing a hawker to operate from the
common pavement in front of his shop against a monthly payment by the hawker. or an
RWA tolerating the use of loud speakers for early morning prayers by a school located in
the colony subject to the school paying an agreed sum to the RWA as compensation.
c. Agreeing to the obligation to do an act
This would include the case where an industrial unit agrees to install equipment for zero
emission/discharge at the behest of the RWA ofa neighbouring residential complex against
a consideration paid by such RWA, even though the emission/discharge from the industrial
unit was within permissible limits and there was no legal obligation upon the individual
unit to do so.
3 The description "agreeing to the obligation to refrain from an act or to 1olerate an act or
a situation, or to do an act" was intended to cover services such as described above. However.
over the years doubts have persisted regarding various transactions being classified under the said
description.
3.1. Some of the important examples of such cases are Service Tax/GST demands on-
Liquidated damages paid for breach of contract;
1.
Compensation given to previous allottees of coal blocks for cancellation of their licenses
.
pursuant to Supreme Court Order;
Cheque dishonour fine/penalty charged by a power distribution company from the
iil.
customers
Penalty paid by a mining company to State Government for unaccounted stock of river
bed material;
Bond amount recovered from an employee leaving the employment before the agreed
period
iv.
.
Late payment charges collected by any service provider for late payment of bills:
vi.
Fixed charges collected by a power generating company from State Electricity Boards
(SEBs) or by SEBs/DISCOMs from individual customer for supply of electrieity:
Cancellation charges recovered by railways for cancellation of tickets. etc.
vii.
viii.
>
J.
b.
Circular No. 178/10/2022-GST
certain hours against an agreed compensation paid by a neighbouring school. which wants
to avoid noise during those hours,
Agreeing to the obligation to tolerate an act or a situation-
This would include activities such a shopkeeper allowing a hawker to operate from the
common pavement in front of his shop against a monthly payment by the hawker. or an
RWA tolerating the use of loud speakers for early morning prayers by a schoo! located in
the colony subject to the school paying an agreed sum to the RWA as compensation.
Agreeing to the obligation to do an act-
This would include the case where an industrial unit agrees to install equipment for zero
emission/discharge at the behest of the RWA of a neighbouring residential complex against
a consideration paid by such RWA, even though the emission/discharge from the industrial
unit was within permissible limits and there was no legal obligation upon the individual
unit to do so.
The description “agreeing to the obligation to refrain from an act or to tolerate an act or
a situation, or to do an act” was intended to cover services such as described above. However.
over the years doubts have persisted regarding various transactions being classified under the said
description.
3.1.
Vill.
Some of the important examples of such cases are Service Tax/GST demands on —
Liquidated damages paid for breach of contract;
Compensation given to previous allottees of coal blocks for cancellation of their licenses
pursuant to Supreme Court Order;
Cheque dishonour fine/penalty charged by a power distribution company from the
customers;
Penalty paid by a mining company to State Government for unaccounted stock of river
bed material;
Bond amount recovered from an employee leaving the employment before the agreed
period; -
Late payment charges collected by any service provider for late payment of bills:
Fixed charges collected by a power generating company from State Electricity Boards
(SEBs) or by SEBs/DISCOMs from individual customer for supply of electricity :
Cancellation charges recovered by railways for cancellation of tickets. ete.
Circular No. 178/10/2022-GST
In some of thesc cascs, tax authorities have initiated investigation and in some advance
ruling authorities have uphcld taxability.
In Service T'ax law, "Service' was defined as any activity carried out by a person for another for 4. consideration. As discussed in service tax education guide, the concept 'activity for a
consideration' involves an element of contractual relationship wherein the person doing an activity
does so at the desire of the person for whom the activity is done in exchange for a consideration.
An activity done without such a relationship i.e., without the express or implied contractual
reciprocity of a consideration would not be an 'activity for consideration'. The element of
contractual relationship, where one supplies goods or services at the desire or another, is an
essential element of supply.
The description of the declared service in question, namely, agreeing to the obligation to
refrain from an act or to tolerate an act or a situation, or to do an act in para 5 (e) of Schedule II of
CGST Act is strikingly similar to the definition of contract in the Contract Act, 1872. The Contract
Act defines 'Contract' as a set of promises, forming consideration for each other. "Promise' has
been defined as willingness of the promisor' to do or to abstain from doing
anything. Consideration' has been defined in the Contract Act as what the promisee' does or
abstains from doing for the promises made to him.
This goes to show that the service of agreeing to the obligation to refrain from an act or to
tolerate an act or a situation, or to do an act is nothing but a contractual agreement. A contract to
do something or to abstain from doing something cannot be said to have taken place unless there
are two parties, one of which expressly or impliedly agrees to do or abstain from doing something
and the other agrees to pay consideration to the first party for doing or abstaining from such an act.
There must be a necessary and sufricient nexus between the supply (i.e. agreement to do or to
abstain from doing something) and the consideration.
6.
A perusal of the entry at serial S(e) of Schedule II would reveal that it comprises the
aforementioned three different sets of activities viz. (a) the obligation to refrain from an act, (b)
obligation to tolerate an act or a situation and (c) obligation to do an act. All the three activities
must be under an "agreement" or a "contract" (whether express or implied) to fall within the ambit
of the said entry. In other words, one of the parties to such agreement/contract (the first party) must
be under a contractual obligation to either (a) refrain from an act, or (b) to tolerate an act or a
situation or (c) to do an act. Further some "consideration"" must flow in return from the other party
to this contract/agreement (the second party) to the first party for such (a) refraining or (b)
tolerating or (c) doing. Such contractual arrangement must be an independent arrangement in its
own right. Such arrangement or agreement can take the form of an independent stand- alone
contract or may form part of another contract. Thus, a person (the first person) can be said to be
making a supply by way of refraining from doing something or tolerating some act or situation to
6.1
Circular No. 178/10/2022-GST
In some of these cases, tax authorities have initiated investigation and in some advance
ruling authorities have upheld taxability.
4. In Service Tax law, ‘Service’ was defined as any activity carried out by a person for another
for consideration, As discussed in service tax education guide, the concept ‘activity for a
consideration’ involves an element of contractual relationship wherein the person doing an activity
does so at the desire of the person for whom the activity is done in exchange for a consideration.
An activity done without such a relationship i.e., without the express or implied contractual
reciprocity of a consideration would not be an ‘activity for consideration’. The element of
contractual relationship, where one supplies goods or services at the desire or another, is an
essential element of supply.
a The description of the declared service in question, namely, agreeing to the obligation to
refrain from an act or to tolerate an act or a situation, or to do an act in para 5 (e) of Schedule II of
CGST Act is strikingly similar to the definition of contract in the Contract Act, 1872. The Contract
Act defines ‘Contract’ as a set of promises, forming consideration for each other. ‘Promise’ has
been defined as willingness of the ‘promisor’ to do or to abstain from doing
anything. ‘Consideration’ has been defined in the Contract Act as what the ‘promisee’ does or
abstains from doing for the promises made to him.
6. This goes to show that the service of agreeing to the obligation to refrain from an act or to
tolerate an act or a situation, or to do an act is nothing but a contractual agreement. A contract to
do something or to abstain from doing something cannot be said to have taken place unless there
are two parties, one of which expressly or impliedly agrees to do or abstain from doing something
and the other agrees to pay consideration to the first party for doing or abstaining from such an act.
There must be a necessary and sufficient nexus between the supply (i.e. agreement to do or to
abstain from doing something) and the consideration.
6.1 A perusal of the entry at serial 5(e) of Schedule II would reveal that it comprises the
aforementioned three different sets of activities viz. (a) the obligation to refrain from an act, (b)
obligation to tolerate an act or a situation and (c) obligation to do an act. All the three activities
must be under an “agreement” or a “contract” (whether express or implied) to fall within the ambit
of the said entry, In other words, one of the parties to such agreement/contract (the first party) must
be under a contractual obligation to cither (a) refrain from an act, or (b) to tolerate an act or a
situation or (c) to do an act. Further some “consideration” must flow in return from the other party
to this contract/agreement (the second party) to the first party for such (a) refraining or (b)
tolerating or (c) doing. Such contractual arrangement must be an independent arrangement in its
own right. Such arrangement or agreement can take the form of an independent stand- alone
contract or may form part of another contract. Thus, a person (the first person) can be said to be
making a supply by way of refraining from doing something or tolerating some act or situation to
3
Circular No. 178/10/2022-GST
another person (the second person) if the first person was under an obligation to do so and then
performed accordingly.
Agreement to do or refrain from an act should not be presumed to exist
. There has to be an express or implied agreement; oral or written, to do or abstain from
doing something against payment of consideration for doing or abstaining from such act, for a
taxable supPply to exist. An agreement to do an act or abstain from doing an act or to tolerate an act
or a situation cannot be imagined or presumed to exist just because there is a flow of money from
one party to another. Unless there is an express or implied promise by the recipient of money to
agree to do or abstain from doing something in return for the money paid to him, it cannot be
assumed that such payment was for doing an act or for refraining from an act or for tolerating an
act or situation. Payments such as liquidated damages for breach of contract, penalties under the
mining act for excess stock found with the mining company, forfeiture of salary or payment of
amount as per the employment bond for leaving the employment before the minimum agreed
period, penalty for cheque dishonour etc. are not a consideration for tolerating an act or
situation. They are rather amounts recovered for not tolerating an act or situation and to deter such
acts; such amounts are for preventing breach of contract or non-performance and are thus mere
'events' in a contract. Further, such amounts do not constitute payment (or consideration) for
tolerating an act, because there cannot be any contract: (a) for breach thereof, or (b) for holding
more stock than permitted under the mining contract, or (c) for leaving the employment before the
agreed minimum period or (d) for doing something leading to the dishonour of a cheque. As has
already been stated, unless payment has been made for an independent activity of tolerating an act
under an independent arrangement entered into for such activity of tolerating an act. . such
payments will not constitute 'consideration' and hence such activities will not constitute "supply"
within the meaning of the Act. Taxability of these transactions is discussed in greater detail in the
following paragraphs.
Liquidated Damages
Breach or non-performance of contract by one party results in loss and damages to the other 7.1
party. Therefore, the law provides in Section 73 of the Contract Act, 1972 that when a contract
has been broken, the party which suffers by such breach is entitled to receive from the other party
compensation for any loss or damage caused to him by such breach. The compensation is not by
way of consideration for any other independent activity; it is just an event in the course of
performance of that contract.
7.1.1 It is common for the parties entering into a contract, to specify in the contract itself, the
compensation that would be payable in the event of the breach of the contract. Such compensation
specified in a written contract for breach of non-performance of the contract or parties of the
Circular No. 178/10/2022-GST
another person (the second person) if the first person was under an obligation to do so and then
performed accordingly.
Agreement to do or refrain from an act should not be presumed to exist
7. There has to be an express or implied agreement; oral or written, to do or abstain from
doing something against payment of consideration for doing or abstaining from such act. for a
taxable supply to exist. An agreement to do an act or abstain from doing an act or to tolerate an act
or a situation cannot be imagined or presumed to exist just because there is a flow of money from
one party to another. Unless there is an express or implied promise by the recipient of money to
agree to do or abstain from doing something in return for the money paid to him, it cannot be
assumed that such payment was for doing an act or for refraining from an act or for tolerating an
act or situation. Payments such as liquidated damages for breach of contract, penalties under the
mining act for excess stock found with the mining company, forfeiture of salary or payment of
amount as per the employment bond for leaving the employment before the minimum agreed
period, penalty for cheque dishonour etc. are not a consideration for tolerating an act or
situation. They are rather amounts recovered for not tolerating an act or situation and to deter such
acts; such amounts are for preventing breach of contract or non-performance and are thus mere
‘events’ in a contract. Further, such amounts do not constitute payment (or consideration) for
tolerating an act, because there cannot be any contract: (a) for breach thereof, or (b) for holding
more stock than permitted under the mining contract, or (c) for leaving the employment before the
agreed minimum period or (d) for doing something leading to the dishonour of a cheque. As has
already been stated, unless payment has been made for an independent activity of tolerating an act
under an independent arrangement entered into for such activity of tolerating an act. . such
payments will not constitute ‘consideration’ and hence such activities will not constitute “supply”
within the meaning of the Act. Taxability of these transactions is discussed in greater detail in the
following paragraphs.
Liquidated Damages
7.1 Breach or non-performance of contract by one party results in loss and damages to the other
party. Therefore, the law provides in Section 73 of the Contract Act, 1972 that when a contract
has been broken, the party which suffers by such breach is entitled to receive from the other party
compensation for any loss or damage caused to him by such breach. The compensation is not by
way of consideration for any other independent activity; it is just an event in the course of
performance of that contract.
7.1.1 It is common for the parties entering into a contract, to specify in the contract itself. the compensation that would be payable in the event of the breach of the contract. Such compensation specified in a written contract for breach of non-performance of the contract or parties of the
Circular No. 178/10/2022-GST
contract is referred to as liquidated damages. Black's Law Dictionary defines Liquidated
Damages' as cash compensation agreed to hy a signed, written contract for hreach of contract,
payahle to the aggrieved party.
Section 74 of the Contract Act, I1972 provides that when a contract is broken, if a sum has
been named or a penalty stipulated in the contract as the amount or penalty to be paid in case of
brcach. thc aggrieved party shall be entitled to receive reasonable compensation not exceeding the
7.1.2
amount s0 named or the penalty so stipulated.
7.1.3 It is argued that performance is the essence ofa contract. Liquidated damages cannot be
said to be a consideration received for tolerating the breach or non-performance of contract. They
are rather payments for not tolerating the breach of contract. Payment of liquidated damages is
stipulated in a contract to ensure performance and to deter non-performance, unsatisfactory
performance or delayed performance. Liquidated damages are a measure of loss and damage that
the parties agree would arise due to breach of contract. They do not act as a remedy for the breach
of contract. They do not restitute the aggrieved person. It is further argued that a contract is entered
into for execution and not for its breach. The liquidated damages or penalty are not the desired
outcome of the contract. By accepting the liquidated damages, the party aggrieved by breach of
contract cannot be said to have permitted or tolerated the deviation or non-fulfilment of the promise
by the other party.
7.1.4 In this background a reasonable view that can be taken with regard to taxability of
liquidated damages is that where the amount paid as liquidated damages' is an amount paid only
to compensate for injury, loss or damage suffered by the aggrieved party due to breach of the
contract and there is no agreement, express or implied, by the aggrieved party receiving the
liquidated damages, to refrain from or tolerate an act or to do anything for the party paying the
liquidated damages, in such cases liquidated damages are mere a flow of money from the party
who causes breach of the contract to the party who suffers loss or damage due to such breach. Such
payments do not constitute consideration for a supply and are not taxable.
7.1.5 Examples of such cases are damages resulting from damage to property, negligence, piracy,
unauthorized use of trade name, copyright, etc. Other examples that may be covered here are the
penalty stipulated in a contract for delayed construction of houses. It is a penalty paid by the
builder to the buyers to compensate them for the loss that they suffer due to such delayed
construction and not for getting anything in return from the buyers. Similarly, forfeiture of earnest
money by a seller in case of breach of 'an agreement to sell' an immovable property by the buyer
or by Government or local authority in the event of a successful bidder failing to act after winning
the bid, for allotment of natural resources, is a mere flow of money, as the buyer or the successful
bidder does not get anything in return for such forfeiture of earnest money. Forfeiture of Earnest
money is stipulated in such cases not as a consideration for tolerating the breach of contract but as
Circular No. 178/10/2022-GST
contract is referred to as liquidated damages. Black’s Law Dictionary defines ‘Liquidated
Damages’ as cash compensation agreed to hy a signed, written contract for breach of contract,
payable to the aggrieved party.
7.1.2 Section 74 of the Contract Act, 1972 provides that when a contract is broken, if a sum has
been named or a penalty stipulated in the contract as the amount or penalty to be paid in case of
breach, the aggrieved party shall be entitled to receive reasonable compensation not exceeding the
amount so named or the penalty so stipulated.
7.1.3 It is argued that performance is the essence of a contract. Liquidated damages cannot be
said to be a consideration received for tolerating the breach or non-performance of contract. They
are rather payments for not tolerating the breach of contract. Payment of liquidated damages is
stipulated in a contract to ensure performance and to deter non-performance, unsatisfactory
performance or delayed performance. Liquidated damages are a measure of loss and damage that
the parties agree would arise due to breach of contract. They do not act as a remedy for the breach
of contract. They do not restitute the aggrieved person. It is further argued that a contract is entered
into for execution and not for its breach. The liquidated damages or penalty are not the desired
outcome of the contract. By accepting the liquidated damages, the party aggrieved by breach of
contract cannot be said to have permitted or tolerated the deviation or non-fulfilment of the promise
by the other party.
7.1.4. In this background a reasonable view that can be taken with regard to taxability of
liquidated damages is that where the amount paid as ‘liquidated damages’ is an amount paid only
to compensate for injury, loss or damage suffered by the aggrieved party due to breach of the
contract and there is no agreement, express or implied, by the aggrieved party receiving the
liquidated damages, to refrain from or tolerate an act or to do anything for the party paying the
liquidated damages, in such cases liquidated damages are mere a flow of money from the party
who causes breach of the contract to the party who suffers Joss or damage due to such breach. Such
payments do not constitute consideration for a supply and are not taxable.
7.1.5 Examples of such cases are damages resulting from damage to property, negligence, piracy,
unauthorized use of trade name, copyright, etc. Other examples that may be covered here are the
penalty stipulated in a contract for delayed construction of houses. It is a penalty paid by the
builder to the buyers to compensate them for the loss that they suffer due to such delayed
construction and not for getting anything in return from the buyers. Similarly, forfeiture of earnest
money by a seller in case of breach of ‘an agreement to sell’ an immovable property by the buyer
or by Government or local authority in the event of a successful bidder failing to act after winning
the bid, for allotment of natural resources, is a mere flow of money, as the buyer or the successful
bidder does not get anything in return for such forfeiture of earnest money. Forfeiture of Earnest
money is stipulated in such cases not as a consideration for tolerating the breach of contract but as
S
Circular No. 178/10/2022-GST
a compensation for the losses suffered and as a penalty for discouraging the non-serious buyers or
bidders. Such payments being merely flow of money are not a consideration for any supply and
are not taxable. The key in such cases is to consider whether the impugned payments constitute
consideration for another independent contract envisaging tolerating an act or situation or
refraining from doing any act or situation or simply doing an act. If the answer is yes, then it
constitutes a 'supply' within the meaning of the Act, otherwise it is not a "supply".
7.1.6 If a payment constitutes a consideration for a supply, then it is taxable irrespective of by
what name it is called; it must be remembered that a "consideration" cannot be considered de hors
an agreement/contract between two persons wherein one person does something for another and
that other pays the first in return. If the payment is merely an event in the course of the performance
of the agreement and it does not represent the 'object', as such, of the contract then it cannot be
considered 'consideration'. For example, a contract may provide that payment by the recipient of
goods or services shall be made before a certain date and failure to make payment by the due date
shall attract late fee or penalty. A contract for transport of passengers may stipulate that the ticket
amount shall be partly or wholly forfeited if the passenger does not show up. A contract for
package tour may stipulate forfeiture of security deposit in the event of cancellation of tour by the
customer. Similarly, a contract for lease of movable or immovable property may stipulate that the
lessee shall not terminate the lease before a certain period and if he does so he will have to pay
certain amount as early termination fee or penalty. Some banks similarly charge pre- payment
penalty if the borrower wishes to repay the loan before the maturity of the loan period. Such
amounts paid for acceptance of late payment, early termination of lease or for pre-payment of loan
or the amounts forfeited on cancellation of service by the customer as contemplated by the contract
as part of commercial terms agreed to by the parties, constitute consideration for the supply of a
facility, namely, of acceptance of late payment, early ternm ination of a lease agreement, of pre
payment of loan and of making arrangements for the intended supply by the tour
operator respectively. Therefore, such payments, even though they may be referred to as fine or
penalty, are actually payments that amount to consideration for supply, and are subject to GST, in
cases where such supply is taxable. Since these supplies are ancillary to the principal supply for
which the contract is signed, they shall be eligible to be assessed as the principal supply, as
discussed in detail in the later paragraphs. Naturally, such payments will not be taxable if the
principal supply is exempt.
Compensation for cancellation of coal blocks
In the year 2014, coal block/mine allocations were cancelled by the Hon'ble Supreme Court
vide order dated 24.09.2014. Subsequently, Coal Mines (Special Provisions) Act, 2015 was
enacted to provide for allocation of coal mines and vesting of rights, title and interest in and over
the land and mines infrastructure together with mining leases to successful bidders and allottees.
In accordance with section 16 of the said Act, prior (old) allottee of mines were given
7.2
Circular No. 178/10/2022-GST
a compensation for the losses suffered and as a penalty for discouraging the non-serious buyers or
bidders. Such payments being merely flow of money are not a consideration for any supply and
are not taxable. The key in such cases is to consider whether the impugned payments constitute
consideration for another independent contract envisaging tolerating an act or situation or
refraining from doing any act or situation or simply doing an act. If the answer is yes, then it
constitutes a ‘supply’ within the meaning of the Act, otherwise it is not a “supply”.
7.1.6 Ifa payment constitutes a consideration for a supply, then it is taxable irrespective of by
what name it is called; it must be remembered that a “consideration” cannot be considered de hors
an agreement/contract between two persons wherein one person does something for another and
that other pays the first in return. If the payment is merely an event in the course of the performance
of the agreement and it does not represent the ‘object’, as such, of the contract then it cannot be
considered ‘consideration’. For example, a contract may provide that payment by the recipient of
goods or services shall be made before a certain date and failure to make payment by the due date
shall attract late fee or penalty. A contract for transport of passengers may stipulate that the ticket
amount shall be partly or wholly forfeited if the passenger does not show up. A contract for
package tour may stipulate forfeiture of security deposit in the event of cancellation of tour by the
customer. Similarly, a contract for lease of movable or immovable property may stipulate that the
lessee shall not terminate the lease before a certain period and if he does so he will have to pay
certain amount as early termination fee or penalty. Some banks similarly charge pre- payment
penalty if the borrower wishes to repay the loan before the maturity of the loan period. Such
amounts paid for acceptance of late payment, early termination of lease or for pre-payment of loan
or the amounts forfeited on cancellation of service by the customer as contemplated by the contract
as part of commercial terms agreed to by the parties, constitute consideration for the supply of a
facility, namely, of acceptance of late payment, early termination of a lease agreement, of pre-
payment of loan and of making arrangements for the intended supply by the tour
operator respectively. Therefore, such payments, even though they may be referred to as fine or
penalty, are actually payments that amount to consideration for supply, and are subject to GST, in
cases where such supply is taxable. Since these supplies are ancillary to the principal supply fo