Processing of final refund under the GST.
- Kind: Circular
- Under: The Maharashtra Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017
Text of this circular
1
Office of the
Commissioner of State Tax,
(GST), 8th floor, GST Bhavan,
Mazgaon, Mumbai-400010.
TRADE CIRCULAR
To,
..............................
..............................
No. JC/HQ-I/GST/Refund/Trade Circular/01/2017-18 Mumbai, Date: 01/09/2018
Trade Cir. No. 22 T of 2018
To,
…………………..
-------------------
Subject :: : Processing of final refund under the GST.
Ref. (1) Trade Circular No. 49 of 2017 dated 28th Nov. 2017.
(2) Internal Circular No. 24A of 2017 dated 11th Dec.
2017.
(3) Internal Circular No. 27A of 2017 dated 30th Dec.
2017.
(4) Trade Circular 1T of 2018 dated 1st Jan. 2018.
(5) Trade Circular No. 8T of 2018 dated 21st Feb.
2018.
(6) Trade Circular No. 17T of 2018 dated 2nd June
2018.
(7) Internal Circular No. 19A of 2018 dated 18 July
2018
Sir/Gentlemen/Madam,
1. Background:
1.1. Your attention is invited towards the Trade and Internal Circulars
cited at Ref. above, issued to explain procedure for manual processing
of Refund claims under GST law. Central Board of Indirect Taxes and
Customs (CBIC) had also issued the Circulars on the captioned
subject matter.
1.2. Since issuance of aforesaid Circular(s), it has brought to the notice of
this office that in many cases, during the verification of the claim of
refund either provisionally or, as the case may be, the final refund,
there are instances where the tax payer, has either erroneously
claimed the refund of accumulated credit, or of the IGST paid in case
Office of the
Commissioner of State Tax,
(GST), 8th floor, GST Bhavan,
Mazgaon, Mumbai-400010.
TRADE CIRCULAR
No. JC/HQ-I/GST/Refund/Trade Circular/01/2017-18 Mumbai, Date: 01/09/2018
Trade Cir. No. 22 T of 2018
To,
Subject Processing of final refund under the GST.
Ref. (1) Trade Circular No. 49 of 2017 dated 286 Nov. 2017.
(2) Internal Circular No. 24A of 2017 dated 11 Dec.
2017.
(3) Internal Circular No. 27A of 2017 dated 30t® Dec.
2017.
(4) Trade Circular 1T of 2018 dated 1st Jan. 2018.
(5) Trade Circular No. 8T of 2018 dated 21st Feb.
2018.
(6) Trade Circular No. 17T of 2018 dated 24 June
2018.
(7) Internal Circular No. 19A of 2018 dated 18 July
2018
Sir/Gentlemen/Madam,
1. Background:
1.1. Your attention is invited towards the Trade and Internal Circulars
cited at Ref. above, issued to explain procedure for manual processing
of Refund claims under GST law. Central Board of Indirect Taxes and
Customs (CBIC) had also issued the Circulars on the captioned
subject matter.
1.2. Since issuance of aforesaid Circular(s), it has brought to the notice of
this office that in many cases, during the verification of the claim of
refund either provisionally or, as the case may be, the final refund,
there are instances where the tax payer, has either erroneously
claimed the refund of accumulated credit, or of the IGST paid in case
1
2
of exports. It has also been reported that in certain cases the refund
is claimed in respect of input tax credit that is inadmissible under the
GST law or where there is mis-match or un-match of the input tax
credit availed by the recipient and that passed on by the supplier. It
is further reported that due like reasons, Nodal Officer(s) have denied
the refund either partly or fully. Therefore, under such circumstances,
the Nodal Officers have rejected the refund so claimed.
1.3. On this background, refund claimed or granted erroneously
necessitates the initiation of proceedings for Demand and Recovery
under appropriate provisions of GST law.
1.4. For aforesaid reasons an Internal Circular 19A of 2018 dated the 18th
July 2018 was issued and certain instructions/guidelines were given
so as to examine the availment and utilization of Input Tax Credit by
the taxable person who has filed refund application.
1.5. In continuation of the said Internal Circular, it has, now, become
imperative to issue certain instructions with regards to the procedure
to be followed for verification of availment of input tax credit, rejection
of refund, re-credit of rejected refund, initiation of Audit proceedings
and subsequent actions for raising demands and recovery of the
same.
1.6. As explained above, the Internal Circular 19A of 2018 dated the 18th
July 2018 had outlined the procedure for verification input tax credit
vis-à-vis its admissibility/non-admissibility and maintenance of
refund related information in the Annexure(s) appended to said
Circular.
1.7. The verification of ITC need to be undertaken in terms of provisions
contained in CHAPTER V and more particularly section 16, 17, 18,
19, 20 and 21 of Maharashtra Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017
(hereinafter referred to as “MGST Act”) which determines the
admissibility or in-admissibility of the ITC.
2. Applicability of this Trade Circular:
2.1. The procedure and methodology laid down in this Trade Circular shall
be applicable to all the pending 10% refund claim pertaining to the
of exports. It has also been reported that in certain cases the refund
is claimed in respect of input tax credit that is inadmissible under the
GST law or where there is mis-match or un-match of the input tax
credit availed by the recipient and that passed on by the supplier. It
is further reported that due like reasons, Nodal Officer(s) have denied
the refund either partly or fully. Therefore, under such circumstances,
the Nodal Officers have rejected the refund so claimed.
1.3. On this background, refund claimed or granted erroneously
necessitates the initiation of proceedings for Demand and Recovery
under appropriate provisions of GST law.
1.4. For aforesaid reasons an Internal Circular 19A of 2018 dated the 18
July 2018 was issued and certain instructions/ guidelines were given
so as to examine the availment and utilization of Input Tax Credit by
the taxable person who has filed refund application.
1.5. In continuation of the said Internal Circular, it has, now, become
imperative to issue certain instructions with regards to the procedure
to be followed for verification of availment of input tax credit, rejection
of refund, re-credit of rejected refund, initiation of Audit proceedings
and subsequent actions for raising demands and recovery of the
same.
1.6. As explained above, the Internal Circular 19A of 2018 dated the 18th
July 2018 had outlined the procedure for verification input tax credit
vis-a-vis its admissibility/non-admissibility and maintenance of
refund related information in the Annexure(s) appended to said
Circular.
1.7. The verification of ITC need to be undertaken in terms of provisions
contained in CHAPTER V and more particularly section 16, 17, 18,
19, 20 and 21 of Maharashtra Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017
(hereinafter referred to as “MGST Act”) which determines the
admissibility or in-admissibility of the ITC.
2. Applicability of this Trade Circular:
2.1. The procedure and methodology laid down in this Trade Circular shall
be applicable to all the pending 10% refund claim pertaining to the
3
Export of goods or services or both and in respect of all the pending
refund applications pertaining to the supplies made to the Developer
of SEZ or SEZ Unit, inverted tax structure and deemed export.
2.2. To explain aforesaid aspects this Trade Circular is divided into TWO
parts as given below:
Sr.
No.
Particulars Aspects covered
1. PART-A
Legal aspects about the admissibility or in-
admissibility of ITC under MGST Act and
rules made thereunder
2. PART-B
Quantification of eligible and in-eligible
refund amount, and further process in this
behalf.
PART-A
Legal aspects about the admissibility or in-admissibility of ITC
under MGST Act and rules made thereunder:
1. Verification of refund claim and related documents:
1.1. It may be worth to note that the Refund application in FORM-GST-
RFD-1A, debit entry in the Electronic Credit Ledger/Cash Ledger
(wherever required), GSTR-3B, GSTR-1, tax invoices and auto-
drafted invoice level inward supplies details in FROM-GSTR-2A are
vital and primary documents that facilitates determination of the
eligible amount of refund under SGST Act/CGST Act/IGST Act/Cess
Act.
1.2. Among aforesaid documents, the applicant is required to submit
along with refund application in FORM-GST-RFD-01A with requisite
declarations and undertakings, the tax invoices, Statement in
Proforma (in Excel) attached to Internal Circular 19A of 2018 dated
18th July 2018 and soft copy of latest GSTR-2A consisting details of
supplies made for the month for which refund application is filed.
Export of goods or services or both and in respect of all the pending
refund applications pertaining to the supplies made to the Developer
of SEZ or SEZ Unit, inverted tax structure and deemed export.
2.2. To explain aforesaid aspects this Trade Circular is divided into TWO
parts as given below:
Sr.
N Particulars Aspects covered
oO.
Legal aspects about the admissibility or in-
1. PART-A admissibility of ITC under MGST Act and
rules made thereunder
Quantification of eligible and in-eligible
2. PART-B refund amount, and further process in this
behalf.
PART-A
Legal aspects about the admissibility or in-admissibility of ITC
under MGST Act and rules made thereunder:
1. Verification of refund claim and related documents:
1.1. It may be worth to note that the Refund application in FORM-GST-
RFD-1A, debit entry in the Electronic Credit Ledger/Cash Ledger
(wherever required), GSTR-3B, GSTR-1, tax invoices and auto-
drafted invoice level inward supplies details in FROM-GSTR-2A are
vital and primary documents that facilitates determination of the
eligible amount of refund under SGST Act/CGST Act/IGST Act/Cess
Act.
1.2. Among aforesaid documents, the applicant is required to submit
along with refund application in FORM-GST-RFD-O1A with requisite
declarations and undertakings, the tax invoices, Statement in
Proforma (in Excel) attached to Internal Circular 19A of 2018 dated
18th July 2018 and soft copy of latest GSTR-2A consisting details of
supplies made for the month for which refund application is filed.
4
1.3. In case, the supplier has carried out the amendments, to the invoices
uploaded with return in FORM-GSTR-1, in the subsequent return
period or has added certain missed invoices in the subsequent month
GSTR-1 return, it becomes necessary to provide all such information
i.e. auto-drafted GSTR-2A in order to cross-verify the ITC availed by
the refund applicant and that passed on by the supplier.
1.4. There would be situations where the refund applicant is filing return
in GSTR-1 with monthly periodicity, whereas the supplier is filing his
GSTR-1 return quarterly. Under such eventuality, to compute the
match, mis-match or un-match of ITC qua these tax payers who opts
of submit GSTR-1 quarterly, it would be absolutely necessary that
the refund applicant shall take return filing frequency into account
and submit the GSTR-2A or inward supply invoices details to the
concerned Nodal Officer.
1.5. It may be noted that the GSTR-2A has been made available on the
SAP portal. For accessing said GSTR-2A and more details please refer
USER MANUAL available on the SAP portal.
1.6. On this backdrop, to determine the refund amount correctly, the
Nodal Officer shall adhere to the procedure given in earlier Circulars
and verify the documents and GSTR-1, GSTR-2A, GSTR-3B and
FORM-GST-RFD-1A and all the documents mentioned in those
Circulars, carefully and collate all the information contained therein
and apply the appropriate provisions contained under section 16 to
section 21 as also the formula given in rule 89(4) or 89 (5) of the
MGST Rules. On careful examination of aforesaid, the Nodal Officer
shall determine ITC that is:
(1) Admissible
(2) In-admissible or in-eligible
(3) Un-match or mis-match
2. Legal provisions relating to availment of Input Tax Credit:
2.1. In order to decide the admissibility or in-admissibility or ineligible
ITC, the provisions of section(s) 16 to 21 shall be taken into
consideration. The important provisions are discussed herein under:
1.3. In case, the supplier has carried out the amendments, to the invoices
uploaded with return in FORM-GSTR-1, in the subsequent return
period or has added certain missed invoices in the subsequent month
GSTR-1 return, it becomes necessary to provide all such information
i.e. auto-drafted GSTR-2A in order to cross-verify the ITC availed by
the refund applicant and that passed on by the supplier.
1.4. There would be situations where the refund applicant is filing return
in GSTR-1 with monthly periodicity, whereas the supplier is filing his
GSTR-1 return quarterly. Under such eventuality, to compute the
match, mis-match or un-match of ITC qua these tax payers who opts
of submit GSTR-1 quarterly, it would be absolutely necessary that
the refund applicant shall take return filing frequency into account
and submit the GSTR-2A or inward supply invoices details to the
concerned Nodal Officer.
1.5. It may be noted that the GSTR-2A has been made available on the
SAP portal. For accessing said GSTR-2A and more details please refer
USER MANUAL available on the SAP portal.
1.6. On this backdrop, to determine the refund amount correctly, the
Nodal Officer shall adhere to the procedure given in earlier Circulars
and verify the documents and GSTR-1, GSTR-2A, GSTR-3B and
FORM-GST-RFD-1A and all the documents mentioned in those
Circulars, carefully and collate all the information contained therein
and apply the appropriate provisions contained under section 16 to
section 21 as also the formula given in rule 89(4) or 89 (5) of the
MGST Rules. On careful examination of aforesaid, the Nodal Officer
shall determine ITC that is:
(1) Admissible
(2) In-admissible or in-eligible
(3) Un-match or mis-match
2. Legal provisions relating to availment of Input Tax Credit:
2.1. In order to decide the admissibility or in-admissibility or ineligible
ITC, the provisions of section(s) 16 to 21 shall be taken into
consideration. The important provisions are discussed herein under:
5
2.2. On fulfilling following conditions Registered person is entitled to avail
the input tax credit [Please see section 16],
(1) recipient is in possession of the tax invoice or debit note issued
by the supplier holding the VALID GST number (GSTIN).
(2) the recipient has received the goods except in the cases where
transaction is in bill to ship to nature. [Please see Explanation to
section 16(2)(b)].
(3) tax charged in respect of supply has been actually paid to the
Government either in cash or through utilization of input tax
credit admissible in respect of said supply. (Except for
Composition tax payer, the payment of tax can only be made
through GSTR-3B and hence to allow claim of ITC qua supplier,
the filing of GSTR-3B becomes mandatory). [Please section
16(2)(c)].
(4) recipient has furnished the return in FORM-GSTR-3B and
FORM-GSTR-1.
(5) in case the goods are received in the lots then the recipient shall
be entitled to take ITC upon receipt of last lot or instalment.
(6) in case the tax payer has failed to pay to the supplier of goods or
services both (except the supplies where tax is payable on
reverse charge basis), the amount towards the value pf supply
along with tax payable thereon within a period of 180 days from
the date of issue of invoice by the supplier then such input tax
credit may be taken once said outstanding payment is made
to the supplier.
(7) In case, the registered person has claimed depreciation in
respect of the tax component of the cost of the capital goods and
plant and machinery, as per the Income Tax Act, 1961, then the
ITC in respect of said component of tax shall not be allowed. So
as to ascertain this, the Nodal Officer need to raise specific query
to the tax payer and ask for the explanation in this behalf. The
ITC claimed under this scenario is in-eligible/in-admissible. In
2.2. On fulfilling following conditions Registered person is entitled to avail
the input tax credit [Please see section 16],
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(S)
(6)
(7)
recipient is in possession of the tax invoice or debit note issued
by the supplier holding the VALID GST number (GSTIN).
the recipient has received the goods except in the cases where
transaction is in bill to ship to nature. [Please see Explanation to
section 16(2)(b)].
tax charged in respect of supply has been actually paid to the
Government either in cash or through utilization of input tax
credit admissible in respect of said supply. (Except for
Composition tax payer, the payment of tax can only be made
through GSTR-3B and hence to allow claim of ITC qua supplier,
the filing of GSTR-3B becomes mandatory). [Please section
16(2)(c}.
recipient has furnished the return in FORM-GSTR-3B and
FORM-GSTR-1.
in case the goods are received in the lots then the recipient shall
be entitled to take ITC upon receipt of last lot or instalment.
in case the tax payer has failed to pay to the supplier of goods or
services both (except the supplies where tax is payable on
reverse charge basis), the amount towards the value pf supply
along with tax payable thereon within a period of 180 days from
the date of issue of invoice by the supplier then such input tax
credit may be taken once said outstanding payment is made
to the supplier.
In case, the registered person has claimed depreciation in
respect of the tax component of the cost of the capital goods and
plant and machinery, as per the Income Tax Act, 1961, then the
ITC in respect of said component of tax shall not be allowed. So
as to ascertain this, the Nodal Officer need to raise specific query
to the tax payer and ask for the explanation in this behalf. The
ITC claimed under this scenario is in-eligible/in-admissible. In
6
other words, no refund is available in respect of such ITC; even in
the cases where refund is claimed of IGST paid.
(8) The registered person shall not be entitled to take ITC in respect
of any invoice or the debit note for supply of goods or services or
both after the due date for furnishing the return for the month
of September of the following financial year to which such tax
invoice or debit note relates or furnishing the relevant annual
return, whichever is earlier.
2.3. Apportionment of the credit: The Refund Processing Officer is
required to determine the apportionment of the credit, on the basis
of the contingencies given in section 17, 18, 19, 20 and 21 of the
MGST Act. The important provisions are briefly discussed below:
(1) Apportionment of Credit attributable to business purpose
and for other than business purposes:
(a) Section 17 of the MGST Act provides that the registered
person shall be entitled to take the credit to the extent as is
attributable to the purpose of the business or the taxable
supply.
(b) In other words, the taxable person shall not be entitled to
take the input tax credit in respect of the goods or services
or both that are used for other than the business purposes
or are used for making the exempt supplies.
(c) On this basis, admissibility or in-admissibility of the input
tax credit shall be determined proportionately. For this
purpose, please visit the provisions given in rule 42 and 43
of the MGST Rules.
(2) Banking company or a financial institution including a non-
banking financial company:
(a) Banking company or a financial institution including a non-
banking financial company (for short “Banking Company”)
that is engaged in supplying services by way of accepting
deposits, extending loans or advances. As the majority of the
supply of Banking Company relates to accepting deposits,
other words, no refund is available in respect of such ITC; even in
the cases where refund is claimed of IGST paid.
(8) The registered person shall not be entitled to take ITC in respect
of any invoice or the debit note for supply of goods or services or
both after the due date for furnishing the return for the month
of September of the following financial year to which such tax
invoice or debit note relates or furnishing the relevant annual
return, whichever is earlier.
2.3. Apportionment of the credit: The Refund Processing Officer is
required to determine the apportionment of the credit, on the basis
of the contingencies given in section 17, 18, 19, 20 and 21 of the
MGST Act. The important provisions are briefly discussed below:
(1) Apportionment of Credit attributable to business purpose
and for other than business purposes:
(a) Section 17 of the MGST Act provides that the registered
person shall be entitled to take the credit to the extent as is
attributable to the purpose of the business or the taxable
supply.
(b) In other words, the taxable person shall not be entitled to
take the input tax credit in respect of the goods or services
or both that are used for other than the business purposes
or are used for making the exempt supplies.
(c) On this basis, admissibility or in-admissibility of the input
tax credit shall be determined proportionately. For this
purpose, please visit the provisions given in rule 42 and 43
of the MGST Rules.
(2) Banking company or a financial institution including a non-
banking financial company:
(a) Banking company or a financial institution including a non-
banking financial company (for short “Banking Company”)
that is engaged in supplying services by way of accepting
deposits, extending loans or advances. As the majority of the
supply of Banking Company relates to accepting deposits,
7
extending loans or advances, which is exempted from the
GST (Notification No. 12/2017-Entry-27 Service Code-
9971). In order to facilitate better compliance, Banking
Company, may exercise the options as given below:
(i) either comply with the provisions of section 17(2) as
discussed in preceding i.e. avail the credit in the
proportion of taxable supply and exempt supply; or
(ii) alternatively, avail of, every month, an amount equal to
fifty per cent. of the eligible input tax credit on inputs,
capital goods and input services in that month and the
rest shall lapse.
(b) Once the Banking Company chooses one of the option as
above, it is not allowed to withdraw the said option during
the remaining part of the financial year.
(c) the restriction of fifty per cent. is not applicable to the tax
paid on supplies made by one registered person to another
registered person having the same Permanent Account
Number. In other words, the restriction of 50% ITC in
relation to inter-branch taxable supply is not applicable.
Example. State Bank of India, Mazgaon Branch make the tax
paid supply to State Bank of India, Delhi branch or one
business vertical of SBI is making tax paid supply to another
business vertical of SBI provided they are having the same
PAN. The aforesaid restriction of 50% ITC is not applicable.
(3) In addition to the aforesaid aspects, it may be noted that the
registered taxable person shall not take credit of input tax in
respect of the contingencies given in clause (A) to (I) below:
—
(A) motor vehicles and other conveyances except when they are
used for making the following taxable supplies, —
of such vehicles or conveyances; or
of transportation of passengers; or
for imparting training on driving, flying, navigating such
vehicles or conveyances;
extending loans or advances, which is exempted from the
GST (Notification No. 12/2017-Entry-27 Service Code-
9971). In order to facilitate better compliance, Banking
Company, may exercise the options as given below:
(i) either comply with the provisions of section 17(2) as
discussed in preceding i.e. avail the credit in the
proportion of taxable supply and exempt supply; or
(ii) alternatively, avail of, every month, an amount equal to
fifty per cent. of the eligible input tax credit on inputs,
capital goods and input services in that month and the
rest shall lapse.
(b) Once the Banking Company chooses one of the option as
above, it is not allowed to withdraw the said option during
the remaining part of the financial year.
(c) the restriction of fifty per cent. is not applicable to the tax
paid on supplies made by one registered person to another
registered person having the same Permanent Account
Number. In other words, the restriction of 50% ITC in
relation to inter-branch taxable supply is not applicable.
Example. State Bank of India, Mazgaon Branch make the tax
paid supply to State Bank of India, Delhi branch or one
business vertical of SBI is making tax paid supply to another
business vertical of SBI provided they are having the same
PAN. The aforesaid restriction of 50% ITC is not applicable.
(3) In addition to the aforesaid aspects, it may be noted that the
registered taxable person shall not take credit of input tax in
respect of the contingencies given in clause (A) to (I) below:
(A) motor vehicles and other conveyances except when they are
used for making the following taxable supplies, —
Y of such vehicles or conveyances; or
Y of transportation of passengers; or
v for imparting training on driving, flying, navigating such
vehicles or conveyances;
8
(B) motor vehicles and other conveyances for transportation of
goods;
(C) the following supply of goods or services or both—
(i) food and beverages, outdoor catering, beauty treatment,
health services, cosmetic and plastic surgery except
where an inward supply of goods or services or both of a
particular category is used by a registered person for
making an outward taxable supply of the same category
of goods or services or both or as an element of a taxable
composite or mixed supply;
(ii) membership of a club, health and fitness centre;
(iii) rent-a-cab, life insurance and health insurance except
where the services as notified are obligatory for an
employer to provide to its employees under any law for
the time being in force; or
(iv) such inward supply of goods or services or both of a
particular category is used by a registered person for
making an outward taxable supply of the same category
of goods or services or both or as part of a taxable
composite or mixed supply; and
(v) travel benefits extended to employees on vacation such
as leave or home travel concession;
(D) works contract services when supplied for construction of an
immovable property (other than plant and machinery) except
where it is an input service for further supply of works
contract service;
(E) goods or services or both received by a taxable person for
construction of an immovable property (other than plant or
machinery) on his own account including when such goods
or services or both are used in the course or furtherance of
business.
the expression “construction” includes re-construction,
renovation, additions or alterations or repairs, to the
extent of capitalization, to the said immovable property;
(F) tax paid in respect of supplies received from the tax payer
who opts to pay an amount in lieu of tax under composition
as per section 10 of the MGST Act
(B) motor vehicles and other conveyances for transportation of
goods;
(C) the following supply of goods or services or both—
(i) food and beverages, outdoor catering, beauty treatment,
health services, cosmetic and plastic surgery except
where an inward supply of goods or services or both of a
particular category is used by a registered person for
making an outward taxable supply of the same category
of goods or services or both or as an element of a taxable
composite or mixed supply;
(ii) membership of a club, health and fitness centre;
(iii) rent-a-cab, life insurance and health insurance except
where the services as notified are obligatory for an
employer to provide to its employees under any law for
the time being in force; or
(iv) such inward supply of goods or services or both of a
particular category is used by a registered person for
making an outward taxable supply of the same category
of goods or services or both or as part of a taxable
composite or mixed supply; and
(v) travel benefits extended to employees on vacation such
as leave or home travel concession;
(D
—
works contract services when supplied for construction of an
immovable property (other than plant and machinery) except
where it is an input service for further supply of works
contract service;
(E) goods or services or both received by a taxable person for
construction of an immovable property (other than plant or
machinery) on his own account including when such goods
or services or both are used in the course or furtherance of
business.
ethe expression “construction” includes re-construction,
renovation, additions or alterations or repairs, to the
extent of capitalization, to the said immovable property;
(F) tax paid in respect of supplies received from the tax payer
who opts to pay an amount in lieu of tax under composition
as per section 10 of the MGST Act
9
(G) goods or services or both received by a non-resident taxable
person except on goods imported by him;
(H) goods or services or both used for personal consumption;
(I) goods that are lost, stolen, destroyed, written off or disposed
of by way of gift or free samples; and
2.4. The availability of credit is also dependent on the conditions and
restrictions given in section 18, the important provisions are
discussed in the TABLE below, -
Sr.
No.
Conditions and
restrictions
Availability of input tax
credit
Inputs in column (c) are
held
(a) (b) (c) (d)
(1) taxable person has
applied for registration
within the 30 days
from the date on which
he has become liable
for registration.
[Section 18(1)(a)]
in respect of inputs held, -
(i) in stock and
(ii) inputs contained in
semi-finished or
finished goods held
in stock
on the day immediately
preceding the date from
which he becomes liable
to pay tax under the
provisions of this Act
(2) Registration has been
taken voluntarily [See
section 25(3) of the
MGST Act] provided
that the Turn-over has
not been exceeded the
threshold limit on the
date of registration.
[Section 18(1)(b)]
in respect of inputs held, -
(i) in stock and
(ii) inputs contained in
semi-finished or
finished goods held
in stock
on the day immediately
preceding the date of
grant of registration.
(3) Where registered
person ceases to pay
tax under section 10.
[Section 18(1)(c)]
in respect of inputs held,-
(i) in stock and
(ii) inputs contained in
semi-finished or
finished goods held
on the day immediately
preceding the date from
which he becomes liable
to pay tax at normal
rate.
(G) goods or services or both received by a non-resident taxable
person except on goods imported by him;
(H) goods or services or both used for personal consumption;
(I) goods that are lost, stolen, destroyed, written off or disposed
of by way of gift or free samples; and
2.4. The availability of credit is also dependent on the conditions and
restrictions given in section 18, the important provisions are
discussed in the TABLE below, -
Sr. Conditions and Availability of input tax | Inputs in column (c) are
No. restrictions credit held
(a) (b) (c) (4)
(1) | taxable person has | in respect of inputs held, - | e on the day immediately
applied for registration (i) in stock and preceding the date from
within the 30 days (ii)inputs contained in| which he becomes liable
from the date on which semi-finished or} to pay tax under the
he has become liable finished goods held] _ provisions of this Act
for registration. in stock
[Section 18(1)(a)]
(2) | Registration has been | in respect of inputs held, - | e on the day immediately
taken voluntarily [See (i) in stock and preceding the date of
section 25(3) of the (ii) inputs contained in| grant of registration.
MGST Act] provided semi-finished or
that the Turn-over has finished goods held
not been exceeded the in stock
threshold limit on the
date of registration.
[Section 18(1)(b)]
(3) | Where registered | in respect of inputs held,- | e on the day immediately
person ceases to pay
tax under section 10.
[Section 18(1)(c}]
(i) in stock and
(ii) inputs contained in
semi-finished or
finished goods held
preceding the date from
which he becomes liable
to pay tax at normal
rate.
10
Sr.
No.
Conditions and
restrictions
Availability of input tax
credit
Inputs in column (c) are
held
(a) (b) (c) (d)
in stock and on
capital goods
input tax credit shall be
available as determined
under rule 44 of MGST
Rules.
(4) Where an exempt
supply of goods or
services or both by a
registered person
becomes a taxable
supply.
Section 18(1)(d)]
in respect of inputs held, -
(i) in stock and
(ii) inputs contained in
semi-finished or
finished goods held
in stock and on
capital goods
exclusively used for
such exempt
supply.
on the day immediately
preceding the date from
which such supply
becomes taxable
the set-off on the
Capital Goods is to be
reduced as provided in
rule 40(1(iv).
(5) A registered person in respect of supply of goods or services or both to him after
the expiry of ONE year from the date issuance of tax invoice relating to said
supply shall not be entitled to claim ITC in aforesaid circumstances.
[Section 18(2)]
2.5. In addition to the conditions and restrictions for availment of input
tax credit, explained above, there are certain other contingencies
given in section 18 where the input tax credit is not available or
restricted. These aspects are explained in the TABLE below:
Sr.
No.
Conditions and restrictions Consequences
(1) Change in constitution on account
of sale, merger, demerger,
amalgamation, lease or transfer of
business with specific provision of
transfer of liabilities.
[Section 18(3)]
the said registered person
shall be allowed to transfer the
input tax credit which remains
unutilised in his electronic
credit ledger to such sold,
merged, demerged,
Sr. Conditions and Availability of input tax | Inputs in column (c) are
No. restrictions credit held
(a) (b) (c) (4)
in stock and on| e input tax credit shall be
capital goods available as determined
under rule 44 of MGST
Rules.
(4) | Where an exempt | in respect of inputs held, - | e on the day immediately
supply of goods or (i) in stock and preceding the date from
services or both by a (ii) inputs contained in| which such — supply
registered person semi-finished or | becomes taxable
becomes a_ taxable finished goods held |ethe set-off on the
supply. in stock and on| Capital Goods is to be
capital goods | reduced as provided in
Section 18(1)(d)] exclusively used for] rule 40(1 (iv).
such exempt
supply.
(5) | A registered person in respect of supply of goods or services or both to him after
the expiry of ONE year from the date issuance of tax invoice relating to said
supply shall not be entitled to claim ITC in aforesaid circumstances.
e [Section 18(2)]
2.5. In addition to the conditions and restrictions for availment of input
tax credit, explained above, there are certain other contingencies
given in section 18 where the input tax credit is not available or
restricted. These aspects are explained in the TABLE below:
Sr. eae + ge
No. Conditions and restrictions Consequences
(1) | Change in constitution on account |ethe said registered person
of sale, merger, demerger,
amalgamation, lease or transfer of
business with specific provision of
transfer of liabilities.
[Section 18(3)]
shall be allowed to transfer the
input tax credit which remains
unutilised
credit ledger to such sold,
merged, demerged,
in his electronic
10
11
Sr.
No.
Conditions and restrictions Consequences
amalgamated, leased or
transferred business.
FORM GST ITC-02 is required
to be used for transfer of
unutilized input tax credit
lying in his electronic credit
ledger to the transferee: [Please
see the Rule 41 of the MGST
Rules].
(2) Any registered person who has
availed of the credit, -
(a) but subsequently opt to pay tax
under Composition Scheme, or
(b) where the goods or services or
both supplied by him become
wholly exempt.
[Section 18(4)]
shall pay an amount through
debiting the electronic credit
ledger equivalent to the credit
of input tax held, -
in stock and
inputs contained in semi-
finished or finished goods
held in stock and on capital
goods on the day
immediately before the day
on which option is
exercised.
the credit in respect of
capital goods shall be
reduced as given in rule
44(3) of the MGST Rules.
it may be noted that any
balance remaining in the
electronic credit ledger
after payment as aforesaid
shall lapse.
(3) (a) In case of supply of capital
goods or plant and machinery,
on which input tax credit has
been taken,
(b) where refractory bricks, moulds
and dies, jigs and fixtures are
supplied as scrap,
[Section 18(6)]
shall pay on transaction
value as determined under
section 15, an amount equal
to the input tax credit taken
on the said capital goods or
plant and machinery
the credit in respect of capital
goods shall be reduced as
given in rule 44(3) of the
MGST Rules.
Sr.
No.
Conditions and restrictions Consequences
amalgamated, leased or
transferred business.
e FORM GST ITC-02 is required
to be used for transfer of
input tax credit
lying in his electronic credit
ledger to the transferee: [Please
see the Rule 41 of the MGST
Rules].
unutilized
(2) Any registered person who has
availed of the credit, -
(a) but subsequently opt to pay tax
under Composition Scheme, or
(b) where the goods or services or
both supplied by him become
wholly exempt.
[Section 18(4)]
e shall pay an amount through
debiting the electronic credit
ledger equivalent to the credit
of input tax held, -
¥Y in stock and
Y inputs contained in semi-
finished or finished goods
held in stock and on capital
goods on the day
immediately before the day
on which option is
exercised.
¥ the credit in respect of
capital goods shall be
reduced as given in rule
44(3) of the MGST Rules.
v it may be noted that any
balance remaining in the
electronic credit ledger
after payment as aforesaid
shall lapse.
(3) (a) In case of supply of capital
goods or plant and machinery,
on which input tax credit has
been taken,
(b) where refractory bricks, moulds
and dies, jigs and fixtures are
supplied as scrap,
[Section 18(6)]
e shall pay on _ transaction
value as determined under
section 15, an amount equal
to the input tax credit taken
on the said capital goods or
plant and machinery
e the credit in respect of capital
goods shall be reduced as
given in rule 44(3) of the
MGST Rules.
11
12
2.6. To determine the admissibility of ITC the provisions of section 19
relating to taking credit in respect of inputs and capital goods sent
for job work; section-20 manner of distribution of credit by the Input
Service Distributor and section 21-dealing with the manner of
recovery of credit pertaining to the input service distributed in excess
need to be kept in mind. These provisions may not be applicable to
all tax payers seeking refund, however, these would be useful in the
cases where aforesaid circumstances exist.
3. Availment of Transitional Credit under existing laws:
3.1. The Transitional Credit pertaining to the existing laws is allowed to
be taken into Electronic Credit Ledger as per the conditions and
restrictions provided under section 140 and 142 of the MGST Act.
These aspects are explained in Internal Circular 1A of 2018 1st
January 2018. It may be noted that the refund of Transitional Credit
is not available when the goods or services are exported or are
supplied to Developer of Special Economic Zone or SEZ Unit without
payment of tax. This aspect has also been explained vide Trade
Circular 17 T of 2018 issued on 2nd June 2018. Therefore, when the
applicant files application for refund of accumulated ITC then the
Nodal Officer shall not allow the refund on account of Transitional
ITC taken into Electronic Credit Ledger under the GST.
PART-B
Quantification of eligible and in-eligible refund amount,
and further process in this behalf.
1. The documents or information related to input tax credit that need to
be verified and kept on record: For quantification of eligible or in-eligible
refund the Nodal Officer shall verify the following documents or information:
1.1. Physical copies of the inward supply tax invoices submitted by the
refund applicant;
1.2. As explained in Internal Circular 19A of 2018 dated 18th July, 2018,
an auto-drafted GSTR-2A for the period corresponding such claim and
2.6. To determine the admissibility of ITC the provisions of section 19
relating to taking credit in respect of inputs and capital goods sent
for job work; section-20 manner of distribution of credit by the Input
Service Distributor and section 21-dealing with the manner of
recovery of credit pertaining to the input service distributed in excess
need to be kept in mind. These provisions may not be applicable to
all tax payers seeking refund, however, these would be useful in the
cases where aforesaid circumstances exist.
3. Availment of Transitional Credit under existing laws:
3.1. The Transitional Credit pertaining to the existing laws is allowed to
be taken into Electronic Credit Ledger as per the conditions and
restrictions provided under section 140 and 142 of the MGST Act.
These aspects are explained in Internal Circular 1A of 2018 1st
January 2018. It may be noted that the refund of Transitional Credit
is not available when the goods or services are exported or are
supplied to Developer of Special Economic Zone or SEZ Unit without
payment of tax. This aspect has also been explained vide Trade
Circular 17 T of 2018 issued on 274 June 2018. Therefore, when the
applicant files application for refund of accumulated ITC then the
Nodal Officer shall not allow the refund on account of Transitional
ITC taken into Electronic Credit Ledger under the GST.
PART-B
Quantification of eligible and in-eligible refund amount,
and further process in this behalf.
1. The documents or information related to input tax credit that need to
be verified and kept on record: For quantification of eligible or in-eligible
refund the Nodal Officer shall verify the following documents or information:
1.1. Physical copies of the inward supply tax invoices submitted by the
refund applicant;
1.2. As explained in Internal Circular 19A of 2018 dated 18 July, 2018,
an auto-drafted GSTR-2A for the period corresponding such claim and
12
13
containing the details of the invoices for inputs or input services or, as
the case may be the capital goods, shall be made available by the tax
payer-refund applicant (hereinafter referred to as “claimant tax payer”.
This auto-drafted GSTR-2A consists of invoice level details of the
supplies made to the tax payer [i.e. recipient-refund applicant on the
basis of which ITC is availed] which includes details of B2B invoices,
credit/debit notes, Amendment to B2B invoices and Amendment to
credit/debit notes, ISD Credit and Amendment to ISD credit etc.;
1.3. The Nodal Officer, may on SAP portal i.e. MAHAGST, raise a request
as per the MANUAL available on the said portal. On accessing the
GSTR-2A, as made available on the SAP portal, the Nodal Officer shall
take appropriate care to examine the GSTR-2A of the relevant period
including the GSTR-2A, the amendments made by the supplier in
respect of the supplies made to refund applicant qua month for which
the refund application is filed.
1.4. The return filing frequency of the supplier as also the amendments
made to the subsequent months GSTR-1 and addition of missing
invoices by the supplier shall also be taken into account while
determining the match, un-match or mis-match in the input credit
availed by the refund applicant and that is passed on by the supplier.
Example:
(a) Recipient M/s ABC has filed the refund application for Rs.
1,00,000/- for the month of December-2017 having monthly
periodicity of filing GSTR-1.
(b) M/s ABC has received the inward supply from the supplier, -
M/s XYZ whose frequency of filing return is monthly. He
has supplied the goods through 4 invoices. However, while
filing GSTR-1 he has missed one invoice and for one
invoice ITC passed on is wrongly stated i.e. instead of say
Rs, 500 of SGST and CGST credit each it has shown
Rs.300 each.
1.3.
1.4.
containing the details of the invoices for inputs or input services or, as
the case may be the capital goods, shall be made available by the tax
payer-refund applicant (hereinafter referred to as “claimant tax payer”.
This auto-drafted GSTR-2A consists of invoice level details of the
supplies made to the tax payer [i.e. recipient-refund applicant on the
basis of which ITC is availed] which includes details of B2B invoices,
credit/debit notes, Amendment to B2B invoices and Amendment to
credit/debit notes, ISD Credit and Amendment to ISD credit etc.;
The Nodal Officer, may on SAP portal i.e. MAHAGST, raise a request
as per the MANUAL available on the said portal. On accessing the
GSTR-2A, as made available on the SAP portal, the Nodal Officer shall
take appropriate care to examine the GSTR-2A of the relevant period
including the GSTR-2A, the amendments made by the supplier in
respect of the supplies made to refund applicant qua month for which
the refund application is filed.
The return filing frequency of the supplier as also the amendments
made to the subsequent months GSTR-1 and addition of missing
invoices by the supplier shall also be taken into account while
determining the match, un-match or mis-match in the input credit
availed by the refund applicant and that is passed on by the supplier.
Example:
(a) Recipient M/s ABC has filed the refund application for Rs.
1,00,000/- for the month of December-2017 having monthly
periodicity of filing GSTR-1.
(b) M/s ABC has received the inward supply from the supplier, -
“* M/s XYZ whose frequency of filing return is monthly. He
has supplied the goods through 4 invoices. However, while
filing GSTR-1 he has missed one invoice and for one
invoice ITC passed on is wrongly stated i.e. instead of say
Rs, 500 of SGST and CGST credit each it has shown
Rs.300 each.
13
14
M/s XYZ has amended the one invoice in the month of
February-2018 and shown the correct credit passed on at
Rs. 500/- CGST and SGST each.
M/s XYZ has added the missed invoice in the month of
April-2018.
(c) In this case, the Nodal Officer is required first to confirm the mis-
match or the un-match qua supplier. On confirming this, refund
applicant may be asked to explain the same and produce the
necessary details in this behalf i.e. the GSTR-2A for the month
of February-2018 and April-2018, for the purpose of amendment
to the invoice and addition of missed invoice.
1.5. In addition to the GSTR-2A available on the SAP portal, the Economic
Intelligence Unit of the Department will also provide the information
about the input tax credit passed on by the supplier and availed by the
recipient i.e. refund applicant. This data would be at GSTIN level viz.,
B2B, debit notes and credit notes, amendment to B2B invoice and
amendment to debit notes and credit notes. This data will give overall
picture about the ITC as per GSTR-3B and passed on by the supplier.
[This is the additional facility provided by the EIU].
1.6. In addition to the auto-drafted GSTR-2A, the tax payer may be asked
to submit the details of inward supplies in the Proforma appended to
the Internal Circular 19A of 2018 dated the 18th July 2018.
1.7. Further, in case the input tax credit claim pertains to the IGST on
account of import of goods then the tax payer may be asked to produce
the information in following format with the copies of the Bill of Entries
filed while clearing the goods for home consumption:
Sr.
No.
B.E.
No.
Date of B. E.
C.I.F.
Value
Basic Custom
Duty paid
Integrated tax
paid
1.5.
1.6.
1.7.
«+ M/s XYZ has amended the one invoice in the month of
February-2018 and shown the correct credit passed on at
Rs. 500/- CGST and SGST each.
“+ M/s XYZ has added the missed invoice in the month of
April-2018.
(c) In this case, the Nodal Officer is required first to confirm the mis-
match or the un-match qua supplier. On confirming this, refund
applicant may be asked to explain the same and produce the
necessary details in this behalf i.e. the GSTR-2A for the month
of February-2018 and April-2018, for the purpose of amendment
to the invoice and addition of missed invoice.
In addition to the GSTR-2A available on the SAP portal, the Economic
Intelligence Unit of the Department will also provide the information
about the input tax credit passed on by the supplier and availed by the
recipient i.e. refund applicant. This data would be at GSTIN level viz.,
B2B, debit notes and credit notes, amendment to B2B invoice and
amendment to debit notes and credit notes. This data will give overall
picture about the ITC as per GSTR-3B and passed on by the supplier.
[This is the additional facility provided by the EIU].
In addition to the auto-drafted GSTR-2A, the tax payer may be asked
to submit the details of inward supplies in the Proforma appended to
the Internal Circular 19A of 2018 dated the 18t July 2018.
Further, in case the input tax credit claim pertains to the IGST on
account of import of goods then the tax payer may be asked to produce
the information in following format with the copies of the Bill of Entries
filed while clearing the goods for home consumption:
Sr.
No.
B.E. Date of B. E. C.LF. Basic Custom Integrated tax
No. Value Duty paid paid
14
15
1.8. In case the input tax credit claim pertains to the IGST on account of
import of services then the tax payer may be asked to produce the
information in following format:
Sr.
No.
Country
of
Import
Invoice
No.
Invoice
Date
Tax
rate
(%)
Total
Invoice
Value
Total
Taxable
Value
IGST CESS
2. Verification of tax invoices for inward supply, details of GST paid on
reverse charge mechanism and other relevant documents:
2.1. Scrutiny of refund application, ARN receipt, Statement under
rule 89 and Tax invoice etc.
(1) Upon receipt of the Refund Application in FORM-GST-RFD-01A,
ARN receipt and relevant Statement depending upon the Nature
of refund, the Nodal Officer shall verify the content of the refund
application and enclosures and declarations or undertaking
enclosed therewith. These aspects had already been explained in
the earlier Circulars issued in this behalf.
(2) Comparison of Turn-over shown in refund application in FORM-
GST-RFD-01A, GSTR-3B and GSTR-1, any deviation in this
respect shall be reconciled. Unless said deviation is reconciled
properly refund shall not be granted. Any deficiency in the refund
application to be dealt with the procedure given in the earlier
Circular(s).
(3) The return filing status of refund applicant and status about the
suppliers filing of GSTR-3B and GSTR-1 shall be confirmed. This
may be done on the basis of the data provided by the EIU.
(4) In case, the supplier has failed to file return in FORM-GSTR-3B
or GSTR-1 or both, then this may be brought to the notice of the
tax payer. After giving reasonable compliance window, if the
default is not made good then the input tax credit in relation to
these non-filers shall not be allowed.
1.8. In case the input tax credit claim pertains to the IGST on account of
import of services then the tax payer may be asked to produce the
information in following format:
Sr.
No.
Country | Invoice Invoice Tax Total Total
of No. Date rate Invoice | Taxable | IGST | CESS
Import (%) Value Value
2. Verification of tax invoices for inward supply, details of GST paid on
reverse charge mechanism and other relevant documents:
2.1. Scrutiny of refund application, ARN receipt, Statement under
rule 89 and Tax invoice etc.
(1) Upon receipt of the Refund Application in FORM-GST-RFD-O1A,
ARN receipt and relevant Statement depending upon the Nature
of refund, the Nodal Officer shall verify the content of the refund
application and enclosures and declarations or undertaking
enclosed therewith. These aspects had already been explained in
the earlier Circulars issued in this behalf.
(2) Comparison of Turn-over shown in refund application in FORM-
GST-RFD-01A, GSTR-3B and GSTR-1, any deviation in this
respect shall be reconciled. Unless said deviation is reconciled
properly refund shall not be granted. Any deficiency in the refund
application to be dealt with the procedure given in the earlier
Circular(s).
(3) The return filing status of refund applicant and status about the
suppliers filing of GSTR-3B and GSTR-1 shall be confirmed. This
may be done on the basis of the data provided by the EIU.
(4) In case, the supplier has failed to file return in FORM-GSTR-3B
or GSTR-1 or both, then this may be brought to the notice of the
tax payer. After giving reasonable compliance window, if the
default is not made good then the input tax credit in relation to
these non-filers shall not be allowed.
15
16
(5) In case of refund is on account of availment of IGST credit from
the supplier who is located in other State and who has not filed
the GSTR-3B or GSTR-1 or both, then recipient may be asked to
pursue the supplier to make this default good.
(6) The Nodal Officer shall ensure that the tax invoices submitted by
the tax payer meets all the requirements given in rule 46 and rule
48 of the MGST Rules. Verification of inward supply tax invoices
shall be carried out properly,
(7) The verification of the outward supplies including confirmation
of export from ICEGATE shall be done before grant of 90% refund.
3. Claim of refund and cross-checking of the Input Tax Credit availed or
utilized:
3.1. Verification of GSTR-RFD-01A, GSTR-3B and GSTR-2A:
(1) As explained above, the verification of aforesaid
application/returns shall be carried out with appropriate
reconciliation.
(2) It is necessary to compare the ITC claimed in GSTR-3B vis-à-vis
that is claimed in FORM-GST-RFD-01A. The applicant shall be
asked to explain the discrepancy in this behalf. The explanation in
this behalf shall be kept on record.
(3) The input tax credit availed/utilized by the tax payer for making
outward supply i.e. Zero-rated supply of goods without payment of
IGST or supply of goods or services or supply to the Developer of
Special Economic Zone or Unit in SEZ with or without payment of
IGST, or on account of inverted tax structure or deemed exports,
need to be cross-checked appropriately.
(4) The admissibility of ITC shall be determined on the basis of the
provisions of MGST Act which are explained in the preceding
Para’s. Once the admissible or in-admissible ITC claim is
determined then the exercise of matching of ITC shall be carried
out.
(5) In case of refund is on account of availment of IGST credit from
the supplier who is located in other State and who has not filed
the GSTR-3B or GSTR-1 or both, then recipient may be asked to
pursue the supplier to make this default good.
(6) The Nodal Officer shall ensure that the tax invoices submitted by
the tax payer meets all the requirements given in rule 46 and rule
48 of the MGST Rules. Verification of inward supply tax invoices
shall be carried out properly,
(7) The verification of the outward supplies including confirmation
of export from ICEGATE shall be done before grant of 90% refund.
3.Claim of refund and cross-checking of the Input Tax Credit availed or
utilized:
3.1. Verification of GSTR-RFD-01A, GSTR-3B and GSTR-2A:
(1) As explained above, the verification of aforesaid
application/returns shall be carried out with appropriate
reconciliation.
(2) It is necessary to compare the ITC claimed in GSTR-3B vis-a-vis
that is claimed in FORM-GST-RFD-01A. The applicant shall be
asked to explain the discrepancy in this behalf. The explanation in
this behalf shall be kept on record.
(3) The input tax credit availed/utilized by the tax payer for making
outward supply i.e. Zero-rated supply of goods without payment of
IGST or supply of goods or services or supply to the Developer of
Special Economic Zone or Unit in SEZ with or without payment of
IGST, or on account of inverted tax structure or deemed exports,
need to be cross-checked appropriately.
(4) The admissibility of ITC shall be determined on the basis of the
provisions of MGST Act which are explained in the preceding
Para’s. Once the admissible or in-admissible ITC claim is
determined then the exercise of matching of ITC shall be carried
out.
16
17
3.2. Determination of eligible refund amount:
(1) The supply on account of exports of goods without payment of IGST
need to be verified from the ICEGATE portal. Whereas, exports of
services with or without payment of IGST need to be verified and
confirmed on the basis of the export/supply related documents
including the Foreign inward remittance Certificate/Bank
Reconciliation Certificate etc. The aspects of verification of outward
supply i.e. the deemed exports, supplies having inverted tax
structure including supplies made to merchant exporters with
0.05% SGST/CGST or 0.1% IGST had been elaborately explained
in the Circular(s) issued from time to time, in this behalf.
(2) In short, this Circular refers to the outward supply in the limited
context of determination of the output liability or, as the case may
be, confirming the nature of outward supply more particularly
exports, inverted tax structure or the deemed exports.
(3) On carrying out the verification as above, the eligible amount of
refund need to be determined on the basis of the nature of refund
viz. refund on account of IGST paid on export of services, refund of
accumulated credit on account of export of goods etc. It may be
noted that the rule 89(4) of the MGST Act/CGST Act provides for
the formula for determination of refund amount.
(4) Refund on account of inverted tax structure shall be processed as
given in rule 89(5).
(5) Retrospective change in formula for calculation of refund on
account of Inverted tax structure: The amendment to rule 89(5)
is explained below:
(a) Prior to 18th April 2018, the refund of accumulated input tax
credit on account of inverted tax structure was calculated as
per the formula given below:
Maximum Refund Amount = {(Turnover of inverted rated
supply of goods) x Net ITC ÷ Adjusted Total Turnover} -
tax payable on such inverted rated supply of goods.
3.2. Determination of eligible refund amount:
(1) The supply on account of exports of goods without payment of IGST
need to be verified from the ICEGATE portal. Whereas, exports of
services with or without payment of IGST need to be verified and
confirmed on the basis of the export/supply related documents
including the Foreign inward remittance Certificate/Bank
Reconciliation Certificate etc. The aspects of verification of outward
supply i.e. the deemed exports, supplies having inverted tax
structure including supplies made to merchant exporters with
0.05% SGST/CGST or 0.1% IGST had been elaborately explained
in the Circular(s) issued from time to time, in this behalf.
(2) In short, this Circular refers to the outward supply in the limited
context of determination of the output liability or, as the case may
be, confirming the nature of outward supply more particularly
exports, inverted tax structure or the deemed exports.
(3) On carrying out the verification as above, the eligible amount of
refund need to be determined on the basis of the nature of refund
viz. refund on account of IGST paid on export of services, refund of
accumulated credit on account of export of goods etc. It may be
noted that the rule 89(4) of the MGST Act/CGST Act provides for
the formula for determination of refund amount.
(4) Refund on account of inverted tax structure shall be processed as
given in rule 89(5).
(5) Retrospective change in formula for calculation of refund on
account of Inverted tax structure: The amendment to rule 89(5)
is explained below:
(a) Prior to 18th April 2018, the refund of accumulated input tax
credit on account of inverted tax structure was calculated as
per the formula given below:
Maximum Refund Amount = {(Turnover of inverted rated
supply of goods) x Net ITC + Adjusted Total Turnover} -
tax payable on such inverted rated supply of goods.
17
18
Adjusted TO means total Turn-over less Nil rated and
Exempted but including Zero rated supplies.
ITC was having the same meaning given in rule 89(4)
of the MGST Rules.
(b) However, vide notification No. 21/2018 State tax dated
the 18th April, 2018 formula in the sub-rule (5) of rule 89
was amended. The effect of 1st July 2017 to the said sub-
rule was given vide notification No. 26/2018 State Tax
dated 21-06-21018.
(c) The new formula made applicable retrospectively with
effect from 1st July 2017, is as under:
Maximum Refund Amount = {(Turnover of inverted rated
supply of goods and services) x Net ITC ÷ Adjusted Total
Turnover} - tax payable on such inverted rated supply of
goods and services.
“Net ITC” shall mean input tax credit availed on
inputs during the relevant period other than the input
tax credit availed for which refund is claimed under
sub-rules (4A) or (4B) or both; and
“Adjusted Total turnover” shall have the same
meaning as assigned to it in sub-rule (4).]
(d) As appears from the aforesaid formula now the turn-over
of supply of goods and services is required to be taken
into account for determination of maximum amount of
refund. Further, the term “Net ITC” after amendment
includes “ITC” on account of inputs [as defined under
2(59)] i.e. inputs on account of goods other than capital
assets.
(6) In view the said retrospective amendment the Nodal Officer
shall take this into account and accordingly determine the
maximum amount of refund allowable.
e Adjusted TO means total Turn-over less Nil rated and
Exempted but including Zero rated supplies.
e ITC was having the same meaning given in rule 89(4)
of the MGST Rules.
(b) However, vide notification No. 21/2018 State tax dated
the 18t April, 2018 formula in the sub-rule (5) of rule 89
was amended. The effect of 1st July 2017 to the said sub-
rule was given vide notification No. 26/2018 State Tax
dated 21-06-21018.
(c) The new formula made applicable retrospectively with
effect from 1st July 2017, is as under:
Maximum Refund Amount = {(Turnover of inverted rated
supply of goods and services) x Net ITC + Adjusted Total
Turnover} - tax payable on such inverted rated supply of
goods and services.
e “Net ITC” shall mean input tax credit availed on
inputs during the relevant period other than the input
tax credit availed for which refund is claimed under
sub-rules (4A) or (4B) or both; and
e “Adjusted Total turnover” shall have the same
meaning as assigned to it in sub-rule (4).]
(d) As appears from the aforesaid formula now the turn-over
of supply of goods and services is required to be taken
into account for determination of maximum amount of
refund. Further, the term “Net ITC” after amendment
includes “ITC” on account of inputs [as defined under
2(59)] i.e. inputs on account of goods other than capital
assets.
(6) In view the said retrospective amendment the Nodal Officer
shall take this into account and accordingly determine the
maximum amount of refund allowable.
18
19
3.3. Sanction or rejection of final refund of 10%:
(1) The cases where final refund of 10% is pending i.e. where refund
order in FORM-GST-RFD-06 is not issued, in all such cases the
balance 10% refund shall be given only after undertaking Audit as
provided under section 65 of the MGST Act.
(2) The Audit should be undertaken so as to verify the extent of the
ITC that is admissible. The Nodal Officer shall also verify the
match, mis-match or un-match of ITC with the claim made by the
refund applicant and that is passed on by the supplier.
(3) In case the ITC claim is prima-facie found to be in-admissible or
there is mis-match or un-match, then in all such cases the balance
refund of 10% or such percentage of refund out of balance 10%
found un-match or mis-match need to be rejected. For this show-
cause in FORM-GST-RFD-08 need to issued. On receipt of reply in
FORM-GST-RFD-09 which in case, in the opinion of the Nodal
Officer is deficient in compliance, then such balance refund shall
be rejected and refund rejection order in FORM-GST-RFD-06 shall
be issued.
(4) However, in the cases where the refund relating to the inverted
duty structure, on account of supplies made to SEZ developer or
unit or refund on account of deemed export is pending as on the
date of issuance of this Trade Circular then is all such cases the
refund shall be granted only after undertaking the Audit as
contemplated under section 65 of the MGST Act.
(5) The refund rejected as above shall be re-credited and for this the
order in FORM-GST-1B shall be issued along with issuance of
FORM-GST-PMT-03.
4. Initiation of Audit proceedings as per section 65 of the MGST Act:
4.1. Circumstances under which the Audit proceedings need to be
issued:
(1) Audit as per provisions of section shall be initiated in all the cases
where, -
3.3. Sanction or rejection of final refund of 10%:
(1) The cases where final refund of 10% is pending i.e. where refund
order in FORM-GST-RFD-06 is not issued, in all such cases the
balance 10% refund shall be given only after undertaking Audit as
provided under section 65 of the MGST Act.
(2) The Audit should be undertaken so as to verify the extent of the
ITC that is admissible. The Nodal Officer shall also verify the
match, mis-match or un-match of ITC with the claim made by the
refund applicant and that is passed on by the supplier.
(3) In case the ITC claim is prima-facie found to be in-admissible or
there is mis-match or un-match, then in all such cases the balance
refund of 10% or such percentage of refund out of balance 10%
found un-match or mis-match need to be rejected. For this show-
cause in FORM-GST-RFD-08 need to issued. On receipt of reply in
FORM-GST-RFD-09 which in case, in the opinion of the Nodal
Officer is deficient in compliance, then such balance refund shall
be rejected and refund rejection order in FORM-GST-RFD-06 shall
be issued.
(4) However, in the cases where the refund relating to the inverted
duty structure, on account of supplies made to SEZ developer or
unit or refund on account of deemed export is pending as on the
date of issuance of this Trade Circular then is all such cases the
refund shall be granted only after undertaking the Audit as
contemplated under section 65 of the MGST Act.
(5) The refund rejected as above shall be re-credited and for this the
order in FORM-GST-1B shall be issued along with issuance of
FORM-GST-PMT-03.
4. Initiation of Audit proceedings as per section 65 of the MGST Act:
4.1. Circumstances under which the Audit proceedings need to be
issued:
(1) Audit as per provisions of section shall be initiated in all the cases
where, -
19
20
(a) provisional and final refund of 90% and 10% is granted i.e.
the order in FORM-GST-RFD-04 or, as the case may be
FORM-GST-RFD-06 respectively, has been issued before the
date of issuance of Internal Circular 19A of 2018 dated the
18th July 2018.
(b) the provisional refund of 90% is given before the issuance of
Internal Circular 19A of 2018.
(c) refund relating to the inverted duty structure, on account of
supplies made to SEZ developer or unit or refund on account
of deemed export, whether or not pending as on the date of
issuance of this Trade Circular.
(2) The monetary limit for initiation of Audit under section 65 of the
MGST Act, in the cases falling in category (a) above and where the
cumulative refund granted qua tax payer (refund applicant)
exceeds Rs. 1,00,000/-.
(3) The limit of Rs. 1,00,000/- shall be computed considering the
cumulative total of the refund claimed under
SGST/CGST/IGST/Cess of all the application for refund so
received.
4.2. Initiation of Audit proceedings:
(1) The section 65 of the MGST Act empowers the tax authorities to
undertake the Audit. In order to conduct the Audit under this
section the Commissioner of State tax, Maharashtra State, is
empowered to provide the criteria for selection of the cases for
Audit under section 65 of the MVAT Act.
(2) For initiation of Audit proceedings, the Nodal Officer shall issue a
notice in FOR-GST-ADT-01. The Nodal Officer, depending upon the
record to be verified may decide as to whether the Audit to be
carried out at the business premises of the tax payer or at the office
of the concerned Nodal Officer. The place at which the Audit is to
be carried out shall be expressly marked in the said Notice.
(3) The Nodal Officer while fixing the date on which the Audit is to be
carried out shall give clear15 days’ time period. The Audit Notice
(a) provisional and final refund of 90% and 10% is granted i.e.
the order in FORM-GST-RFD-04 or, as the case may be
FORM-GST-RFD-06 respectively, has been issued before the
date of issuance of Internal Circular 19A of 2018 dated the
18th July 2018.
(b) the provisional refund of 90% is given before the issuance of
Internal Circular 19A of 2018.
(c) refund relating to the inverted duty structure, on account of
supplies made to SEZ developer or unit or refund on account
of deemed export, whether or not pending as on the date of
issuance of this Trade Circular.
(2) The monetary limit for initiation of Audit under section 65 of the
MGST Act, in the cases falling in category (a) above and where the
cumulative refund granted qua tax payer (refund applicant)
exceeds Rs. 1,00,000/-.
(3) The limit of Rs. 1,00,000/- shall be computed considering the
cumulative total of the refund claimed under
SGST/CGST/IGST/Cess of all the application for refund so
received.
4.2. Initiation of Audit proceedings:
(1) The section 65 of the MGST Act empowers the tax authorities to
undertake the Audit. In order to conduct the Audit under this
section the Commissioner of State tax, Maharashtra State, is
empowered to provide the criteria for selection of the cases for
Audit under section 65 of the MVAT Act.
(2) For initiation of Audit proceedings, the Nodal Officer shall issue a
notice in FOR-GST-ADT-01. The Nodal Officer, depending upon the
record to be verified may decide as to whether the Audit to be
carried out at the business premises of the tax payer or at the office
of the concerned Nodal Officer. The place at which the Audit is to
be carried out shall be expressly marked in the said Notice.
(3) The Nodal Officer while fixing the date on which the Audit is to be
carried out shall give clear15 days’ time period. The Audit Notice
20
21
shall also mention the record to be verified. Notice for Audit may
be given in respect of all the refund application for a financial year.
4.3. During the Audit proceedings the Nodal Officer shall seek all the
documents based upon which the claim is made including the
documents/tax invoices relating to the Input Tax Credit.
4.4. The Audit shall be completed within three months from the date of
submission of the record by the tax payer. The Audit findings shall be
communicated to the Tax payer.
4.5. In case the Tax payer accepts the Audit findings and make the payment
of tax, interest as determined, through FORM-GST-DRC-03. In such
case, the Audit proceedings shall be closed and the closure of the Audit
proceedings shall be communicated to the said tax payer.
4.6. However, in the cases where the tax payer disputes the Audit findings
and refuses to make the default good or fails to pay the amount as
determined then is all such cases, as provided under section 65(7) of
the MGST Act, the proceedings for demand and recovery shall be
initiated as per the provisions of the section 73 or 74 of the MGST Act.
5. The issues that need to be considered while issuing the Show-cause
Notice for Demand and recovery of the refund granted erroneously or
ITC availed/utilized wrongly etc. :
5.1. Legal provisions: Section 73 of MGST Act, provides for determination
of tax not paid or short paid or erroneously refunded, input tax credit
wrongly availed or utilized for any reason other than fraud or any
willful mis-statement or suppression of facts.
5.2. Whereas, the section 74 provides for determination of tax not paid or
short paid or erroneously refunded input tax credit wrongly availed or
utilized by reason of fraud or any willful misstatement or
suppression of facts.
5.3. Thus depending upon the nature of demand and recovery the
provisions of section 73 or section 74 need to be used.
5.4. Issuance of Show-cause notice:
(1) Show Cause Notice (for short “SCN”) is the starting point of legal
proceedings against the tax payer. It lays down the entire
4.3.
4.4.
4.5.
4.6.
shall also mention the record to be verified. Notice for Audit may
be given in respect of all the refund application for a financial year.
During the Audit proceedings the Nodal Officer shall seek all the
documents based upon which the claim is made including the
documents /tax invoices relating to the Input Tax Credit.
The Audit shall be completed within three months from the date of
submission of the record by the tax payer. The Audit findings shall be
communicated to the Tax payer.
In case the Tax payer accepts the Audit findings and make the payment
of tax, interest as determined, through FORM-GST-DRC-03. In such
case, the Audit proceedings shall be closed and the closure of the Audit
proceedings shall be communicated to the said tax payer.
However, in the cases where the tax payer disputes the Audit findings
and refuses to make the default good or fails to pay the amount as
determined then is all such cases, as provided under section 65(7) of
the MGST Act, the proceedings for demand and recovery shall be
initiated as per the provisions of the section 73 or 74 of the MGST Act.
5. The issues that need to be considered while issuing the Show-cause
Notice for Demand and recovery of the refund granted erroneously or
ITC availed/utilized wrongly etc. :
5.1.
5.2.
5.3.
5.4.
Legal provisions: Section 73 of MGST Act, provides for determination
of tax not paid or short paid or erroneously refunded, input tax credit
wrongly availed or utilized for any reason other than fraud or any
willful mis-statement or suppression of facts.
Whereas, the section 74 provides for determination of tax not paid or
short paid or erroneously refunded input tax credit wrongly availed or
utilized by reason of fraud or any willful misstatement or
suppression of facts.
Thus depending upon the nature of demand and recovery the
provisions of section 73 or section 74 need to be used.
Issuance of Show-cause notice:
(1) Show Cause Notice (for short “SCN”) is the starting point of legal
proceedings against the tax payer. It lays down the entire
21
22
framework for the proceedings that are intended to be undertaken
and therefore while preparing the show-cause notice these aspects
should be kept in mind.
(2) As per the provisions of section 73 and 74 of the MGST Act the
issuance of SCN is a statutory requirement and it is the basic
document for quantifying the dispute relating to tax liability or
any punitive action to be undertaken for contravention of
provisions of GST Act and the rules made thereunder, in the
present scenario excess or wrong claim or grant of refund.
(3) A SCN offers the tax payer an opportunity to submit his oral or
written submission before the Adjudicating Authority on the
charges alleged in the SCN. The issuance of show cause notice is
a mandatory requirement according to the principles of natural
justice as also the provisions of section 73(1) or 74(1) of the MGST
Act.
5.5. Structure of SCN:
(1) A SCN should ideally comprise of the following parts, though
it may vary from case to case:
(a) Introduction of the case
(b) Legal frame work
(c) Factual statement and appreciation of evidences
(d) Discussion, facts and legal frame work relating thereto
(e) Discussion on Limitation period
(f) Calculation of additional tax and other amounts due such
as interest, penalty etc.
(g) Statement of charges-exact nature of violation of law, rules
or safeguards etc.
(h) Service of Show Cause Notice and documents and evidences
relied upon.
(i) Filing of Written submissions by the Tax payer and
evidences supported.
(j) Personal hearing
(k) Record of personal hearing:
framework for the proceedings that are intended to be undertaken
and therefore while preparing the show-cause notice these aspects
should be kept in mind.
(2) As per the provisions of section 73 and 74 of the MGST Act the
issuance of SCN is a statutory requirement and it is the basic
document for quantifying the dispute relating to tax liability or
any punitive action to be undertaken for contravention of
provisions of GST Act and the rules made thereunder, in the
present scenario excess or wrong claim or grant of refund.
(3) A SCN offers the tax payer an opportunity to submit his oral or
written submission before the Adjudicating Authority on the
charges alleged in the SCN. The issuance of show cause notice is
a mandatory requirement according to the principles of natural
justice as also the provisions of section 73(1) or 74(1) of the MGST
Act.
5.5. Structure of SCN:
(1) A SCN should ideally comprise of the following parts, though
it may vary from case to case:
(a) Introduction of the case
(b) Legal frame work
(c) Factual statement and appreciation of evidences
(d) Discussion, facts and legal frame work relating thereto
(e) Discussion on Limitation period
(f) Calculation of additional tax and other amounts due such
as interest, penalty etc.
(g) Statement of charges-exact nature of violation of law, rules
or safeguards etc.
(h) Service of Show Cause Notice and documents and evidences
relied upon.
(i) Filing of Written submissions by the Tax payer and
evidences supported.
(j) Personal hearing
(k) Record of personal hearing:
22
23
(l) Analysis of issues:
(m) Body of the order:
(n) Quantification of demand and issuance of Demand Notice
in FORM-GST-DRC-07.
(2) The show cause notice under section 73(1) or the section 74(1)
shall be in FORM-GST-DRC 01.
(3) The statement under 73(3) or the section 74(3), a summary thereof
be issued in FORM-GST-DRC-02, specifying the details of the
amount payable
(4) In case before the service of notice (i.e. FORM-GST-DRC-01) or
statement (FORM-GST-DRC-02) the person chargeable with tax
discharges the liability voluntarily (Tax and Interest) in
accordance with the provisions of section 73(5) or tax liability (tax,
interest and penalty) in accordance with the provisions of section
74(5), the noticee shall intimate to the proper officer of such
payment in FORM-GST-DRC-03. The proper officer shall issue an
acknowledgment in FORM-GST-DRC 04.
(5) Where the taxpayer or person makes payment of tax and interest
under section 73(8) of the MGST Act or, as the case may be, tax,
interest and penalty equivalent to 25% as per section 74(8) of the
MGST Act, within the 30 days from the service of the notice, the
said tax payer shall intimate the proper officer of such payment in
FORM-GST-DRC-03 and the proper officer shall issue an order in
FORM-GST-DRC-05. On payment of the tax and interest (73(8)
or as the case may be, the tax, interest and penalty (74(8),
then the proceeding shall be deemed to be concluded in respect of
the said notice.
(6) If the taxpayer or person chargeable with tax does not agree with
the additional tax liability during the course of verification or
thereafter, the taxpayer shall reply to the show cause notice in
FORM-GST-DRC-06. [Please see per rule 142 (4)].
(7) The Nodal Officer/Proper Officer, after considering the
representation made by the taxpayer, shall upload electronically
(1) Analysis of issues:
(m) Body of the order:
(n) Quantification of demand and issuance of Demand Notice
in FORM-GST-DRC-07.
(2) The show cause notice under section 73(1) or the section 74(1)
shall be in FORM-GST-DRC 01.
(3) The statement under 73(3) or the section 74(3), a summary thereof
be issued in FORM-GST-DRC-0O2, specifying the details of the
amount payable
(4) In case before the service of notice (i.e. FORM-GST-DRC-0O1) or
statement (FORM-GST-DRC-0O2) the person chargeable with tax
discharges the liability voluntarily (Tax and Interest) in
accordance with the provisions of section 73(5) or tax liability (tax,
interest and penalty) in accordance with the provisions of section
74(5), the noticee shall intimate to the proper officer of such
payment in FORM-GST-DRC-O3. The proper officer shall issue an
acknowledgment in FORM-GST-DRC 04.
(5) Where the taxpayer or person makes payment of tax and interest
under section 73(8) of the MGST Act or, as the case may be, tax,
interest and penalty equivalent to 25% as per section 74(8) of the
MGST Act, within the 30 days from the service of the notice, the
said tax payer shall intimate the proper officer of such payment in
FORM-GST-DRC-O3 and the proper officer shall issue an order in
FORM-GST-DRC-O5. On payment of the tax and interest (73(8)
or as the case may be, the tax, interest and penalty (74(8),
then the proceeding shall be deemed to be concluded in respect of
the said notice.
(6) If the taxpayer or person chargeable with tax does not agree with
the additional tax liability during the course of verification or
thereafter, the taxpayer shall reply to the show cause notice in
FORM-GST-DRC-06. [Please see per rule 142 (4)].
(7) The Nodal Officer/Proper Officer, after considering the
representation made by the taxpayer, shall upload electronically
23
Scanned by CamScanner
the order in FORM-GST-DRC-07 [as given in rule 142 (5)],
specifying the amount of tax, interest and penalty payable so that
liability ledger of the taxpayer gets updated accordingly.
(8) The proper officer may for the purposes given in section 161 of the
MGST Act, pass rectification order in FORM-GST-DRC-08 [as per
rule 142 (7)].
3. This Trade Circular is clarificatory in nature and hence cannot be made use
of for interpretation of provisions of the law. Difficulty if any, in the
implementation of this Circular may be brought to the notice of the office of
the Commissioner of State Tax, Maharashtra.
Yours faithfully,
mayed é
Commissioner of State Tax (GST)
Maharashtra State, Mumbai.
No. JC/HO-I/GST/Refund/Trade Circular/01/2017-18 Mumbai, Date olf 09/2a19
Trade Cir. No.22T of 2017
Copy forwarded for information and necessary action to,-
(1) The Joint Commissioner of State Tax, (MAHAVIKAS) with a request to
upload this Trade Circular on MGSTD web-site.
(2) Deputy Secretary, Finance Department, Mantralaya, Mumbai.
(3) Accounts Officer, Sales Tax Revenue Audit, Mumbai and Nagpur.
___(Shrirgéfi. Umale)
Joint Commissioner of State Tax (H.Q )1 Page 24 -;-Maharashtra State, Mumbai _--
Scanned by CamScanner