Clause(s) of Section 97 (2) of CGST/DGST Act, 2017, under which the question raised
- Kind: Order
- Under: THE DELHI GOODS AND SERVICES TAX ACT, 2017
Text of this order
DELHI AUTHORITY FOR ADVANCE RULING
GOODS AND SERVICES TAX
DEPARTMENT OF STATE TAXES
7THFLOOR, VYAPAR BHAWAN, IP ESTATE, NEW DELHI -110002
ADVANCE RULING NO. 02/DAAR/2018 dated 28.03.2018
(In Application No: 02/DAAR/2017 dated 29.12.2017)
Name and Address of the : M/s Deepak & Co.
Applicant A-96, Chander Vihar, Opp. Rama Krishna Apartment, IP
Extension, Patparganj, Delhi-110092
GSTIN of the Applicant : 07 AADFD84S7H1Z3
Date of Application : 29.12.2017
Clause(s)of Section 97(2) of : (a) Classification of any goods or services or both
CGST/DGSTAct, 2017, under
which the question raised
Date of hearing(s) for : 19.01.2017, 23.02.2018
admission
Date of Final Hearing(s) : 09.03.2018, 16.03.2018
Date of receipt of written : 23.03.2018
submission from the
Apolicant
Date of receipt of comments : 23.02.2018
from Revenue (Centre)
Date of receipt of comments : Not Received
from Revenue (State)
Present for the Applicant : Shri Puneet Agrawal, Advocate
Present for the Revenue : Shri Arun Nautiyal, Superintendent, Mayur Vihar
(Centre) Division, GST East Commissionerate.
Present for the Revenue : Shri Anand Dabas, GSTO (W-84)
(State)
pagel of 15
ADVANCE RULING NO. 02/DAAR/2018 dated 28.03.2018
Statement of Facts as per the Applicant:
The applicant has entered into agreements with IRCTC/lndian Railways, for supply of
food and beverages (packed/ MRP/ cooked) to the passengers of Rajdhani Trains as also
Mail/ Express Trains. Pursuant to these agreements, the applicant is engaged in supplying
of food on board the trains to the passengers travelling on these trains vide the menu
approved by the Indian Railways/ IRCTC. Likewise, the applicant is also engaged in supply of
food items to passengers/ public through food plaza/ food stall on the railway station.
2. The different modus operandi with respect to supply of food for human
consumption on board a train are as follows:
A) SUPPLY OF FOOD THROUGH THE FOOD PLAZA ON THE RAILWAY PLATFORM
(WITHA/C)/ FOOD STALLS ON THE RAILWAY PLATFORM (WITHOUTA/Cl
a. In these places, food and beverages {packed/ MRP I cooked) are supplied to
the passengers/ general public at the rates fixed by Indian Railways/ IRCTC. Food
plaza has space for the consumer to consume the said items on premises, if he
so wish. Food stalls also has a small counter offering the consumers to use the
same and consume the food. Else, the consumer may take away the same and
rnns11mP as per his wish.
B) SUPPLY OF FOOD ON BOARD THE RAJDHANI TRAINS
a. In the Rajdhani trains, menu for the purpose of supplying food items/
beverages is fixed by IRCTC, with respect to each class of travel preferred by the
passengers. The Bid Document for services in such trains specifically provides
tariff for meals supplied. The above-mentioned document also provides defined
"MENU" as per which, meals are supplied to passengers. Food is supplied and
served to the passengers and money for the same charged from the Indian
Railways/ IRCTC by the Applicant.
b. Further, in some cases, IRCTC supplies some items of dinner/lunch menu
from its own base kitchens/approved sources, to be picked-up by the
representative of the Applicant. The Applicant charges money for the same from
the Indian Railways/ IRCTC.
c. Also, it is mandatory for the Applicant to supply newspaper to the
passengers. Railways is to pay to the Applicant with respect to said supply of
,1
ADVANCE RULING NO. 02/DAAR/2018 dated 28.03.2018
C) SUPPLY OF FOOD ON BOARD THE MAIL/EXPRESSTRAINS
a. The menu of food items and the price at which the same are to be served on
board the trains is defined by the Indian Railways/ IRCTC. The applicant supplies
food from its Pantry/ storage as per the said defined menu to the passengers
desiring to obtain the same as per the menu price. Apart from the above, there
are certain MRP items which are also supplied by the applicant. The same is
supplied through the team of waiters which keeps moving in the train and takes
orders and supplies the food items/ beverages to the passengers and collect
price from them. It is not compulsory for the passengers to buy any thing.
3. Details of Question on which Advance Ruling is
requested:
A. What is the applicable rate of tax on the activity of applicant of supplying
food/ beverages, in each of the cases mentioned above in light of the
amendment made in Notification No. 11/2017-Central Tax (Rate) dated
28.06.2017 vide Notification No. 46/2017 - Central Tax {Rate) dated 14.11.2017;
amendment made in Notification No. 8/2017- Integrated Tax (Rate) dated
28.06.2017 vide Notification No. 48/2017 Integrated Tax (Rate) dated 14.11.17;
amendment made in Notification No. 11/2017 - State Tax {Rate) dated
30.06.2017 vide Notification No. 46/2017 - State Tax (Rate) dated 28.11.17 in
the NCT of Delhi?
B. What is the applicable rate of tax on supply of newspaper as elaborated in
the cases mentioned above?
4. Views of the Applicant:
(i) As per Entry in Column (3) at S. No. 7 of Notification No. 11/2017 - Central
Tax (Rate) dated 28.06.2017 amended vide Notification No. 46/2017 -Central
Tax (Rate) dated 14.11.2017, supply of any food article/ drink in any manner,
whatsoever, by a restaurant, eating joint, etc., for consumption on or away from
the premises is taxable at the rate of 2.5% each under the CGST & Delhi GST.
Thus, it is submitted that the supply of food from on Food Plaza/ Food Stall falls
under the above said category.
(ii) As per Entry in Column (3) at S. No. 7 of Notification No 11/2017 - Central
Tax (Rate) dated 28.06.2017 vide Notification No. 46/2017 -Central Tax (Rate)
dated 14.11.2017, supply of any food article/ beverage in any manner,
page3 of 15
ADVANCE RULING NO. 02/DAAR/2018 dated 28.03.2018
whatsoever, for consumption on or away from the premises is taxable at the
rate of 2.5%. In this case, food is supplied by waiters on premises of a running
train. Thus, the supply of food falls under the above said category and is taxable
under CGST @ 2.5 % and Delhi GST @ 2.5 %. IGST, wherever is applicable, is
applicable at the rate of 5%.
(iii)
·
In respect of supply of newspaper, it is submitted that the same being
exempt vide Entry at S. No. 120 of Notification No. 2/2017 - Central Tax (Rate)
dated 28.06.2017, Entry at S. No. 120 of Notification No. 2/2017-lntegrated Tax
(Rate) dated 28.06.2017 and Entry at S. No. 120 of Notification No. 2/2017 -
State Tax (Rate) dated 30.06.2017, no tax is payable.
5. Comments of Jurisdictional Officer (CGST):
With respect to supply of food In Food Plaza/ Food Stalls :
For the purpose of this activity, the applicants perusal of relevant portion in entry
in column {3) at S. No. 7 entry (i) of Notification No. 46/2017-Central Tax (Rate)
dated 14.11.2017 seems to be correct.
With respect to supply of food on board the trains:
The applicant seeks to classify these services under S. No. 7 Entry (i) with the
CGST rate applicable at 2.5% but the said activity seems to fall under the entry (v) as
the said activities seems to be that of Outdoor Catering as the applicant is engaged
by the railways in providing services in connection with supply of food and beverages
in a place other than the applicant's premises. The applicable duty rate is 9% In this
case.
With respect to supply of newspapers:
In respect of supply of newspaper is nil rated on account of being exempt vide
entry S. No. 120 of Notification No. 2/2017-Central Tax (Rate) dated 28.06.2017. Also
newspapers fall under GST HSN Chapter 4902 which attracts Nil rate of duty.
6. RELEVANT NOTIFICATIONS:
The S. No. 7 (i), (v) & (ix) and Annexure of Notification No. 11/2017 -CentraJ Tax
(Rate) dated 28.06.2017 as amended vide Notification No 46/2017- Central Tax
(Rate) dated 14.11.2017 and parallel Notifications issued under IGST and Delhi GST,
reads as under:
ADVANCE RULING NO. 02/DAAR/2018 dated 28.03.2018
S. Chapter, Section Description of Service
No. or Heading
Rate
(per
cent.)
Condition
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Provided that
credit of input tax
charged on goods
and services used
in supplying the
service has not
been taken [Please
refer to
7
Heading 9963 (i) Supply, by way of or as part of
(Accommodation, any service or in any other manner
food and whatsoever, of goods, being food or
beverage services) any other article for human
consumption or drink, where such
supply or service Is for cash,
deferred payment or other valuable
consideration, provided by a
restaurant, eating joint including
mess, canteen, whether for
consumption on or away from the
premises where such food or any
other article for human
consumption or drink is supplied,
other than those located In the
premises of hotels, inns, guest
houses, clubs, campsites or other
commercial places meant for
residential or lodging purposes
having declared tariff of any unit of
accommodation of seven thousand
five hundred rupees and above per
unit per day or equivalent.
Explanation.· "declared tariff"
Includes charges for all amenities
provided in the unit of
accommodation (given on rent for
stay) like furniture, air conditioner,
refrigerators or any other
amenities, but without excluding
any discount offered on the
published charges for such unit.
2.5
Explanation
(iv)]
no.
Explanation:· For the purposes of this notification,·
(iv) Wherever a rate has been prescribed in this notification subject to the
condition that credit of input tax charged on goods or services used in
supplying the service has not been taken, it shall mean that,·
(a) credit of input tax charged on goods or services used exclusively in
supplying such service has not been taken; and
(b) credit of input tax charged on goods or services used partly for
supplying such service and partly for effecting other supplies eligible for
input tax credits, exempt
ADVANCE RULING NO. 02/DAAR/2018 dated 28.03.2018
supply and attracts provisions of sub-section (2) of section 17 of the
Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 and the rules made thereunder.
s. Chapter, Section
No. or Heading
(1) (2)
Heading 9963
(Accommodation,
food and
beverage
services)
7
Heading 9963
(Accommodation,
food and
beverage services
Description of Service
(3)
(v) Supply, by way of or as part of
any service or in any other manner
whatsoever in outdoor catering
wherein goods, being food or any
other article for human
consumption or any drink (whether
or not alcoholic liquor for human
consumption), as a part of such
outdoor catering and such supply
or service Is for cash, deferred
payment or other valuable
consideration
(ix) Accommodation, food and
beverage services other than (Ii),
(iii), (v), (vi), (vii) and (viii)above.
Explanation.- For the removal of
doubt, it is hereby clarified that,
supply, by way of or as part of any
service or in any other manner
whatsoever, of goods, being food
or any other article for human
consumption or drink, where such
supply or service Is for cash,
deferred payment or other
valuable consideration, provided
by a restaurant, eating joint
including mess, canteen, whether
for consumption on or away from
the premises where such food or
any other article for human
consumption or drink is supplied,
other than those located in the
premises of hotels, inns, guest
houses, clubs, campsites or other
commercial places meant for
residential or lodging purposes
having declared tariff of any unit of
accommodation of seven thousand
Rate
(per
cent.)
(4)
9
9
Condition
(S)
ADVANCE RULING NO. 02/DAAR/2018 dated 28.03.2018
above and shall not be levied at the
rate as specified under this entry.
Annexure: Scheme of Classification of Services
S.No. Chapter, Section, Service Code Service Description
Heading or Group (Tariff)
(1) (2) (3) (4)
1 Chapter 99 All Services
71 Heading 9963 Accommodation, food and beverage services
80 Group 99633 Food, edible preparations, alcoholic and non-
alcoholic beverages serving services
81 996331 Services provided by restaurants, cafes and similar
eating facilities including takeaway services, room
services and door delivery of food
82 996332 Services provided by Hotels, Inn, Guest House, Club
and the like including room services, takeaway services
and door delivery of food
83 996333 Services provided in canteen and other similar
establishments
84 996334 Catering Services in exhibition halls, events, marriage
halls and other outdoor/indoor functions
85 996335 Caterina services in trains, flights and the like
86 996336 Preparation or supply services of food, edible
preparations, alcoholic and non-alcoholic beverages to
airlines and other transportation operators
87 996337 Other contract food services
88 996339 Other food, edible preparations, alcoholic and non-
, alcoholic beverages serving services nowhere else
classified
7. The S.No. 120 of Notification No. 2/2017 Central Tax (Rate) dated 28.06.2017 and
parallel Notifications of IGST and Delhi GST reads as under:
Schedule
S. No Chapter I Heading I Sub- Description of Goods
heading I Tariff item
(1) (2) (3)
120. 4902 Newspapers, journals and periodicals, whether or not
illustrated or containing advertising material
ADVANCE RULING NO. 02/DAAR/2018 dated 28.03.2018
DISCUSSIONS:
8. The applicant has submitted a copy of 'Letter of Award' dated 02.08.2016
issued by IRCTC to them for setting up of and to operate 'Fast Food Unit' at Old Delhi
Railway Station on payment of specified annual licence fee. The applicant has
submitted that food and beverages (packed/ MRP/ cooked) are supplied by them to
passengers at the rates fixed by the Indian Railways/ IRCTC. However, details of food
and beverages supplied, the method of prices and details of services have not been
submitted.
9. The applicant has also submitted a copy of agreement dated 29.09.2017
between IRCTC and the applicant for temporary licence to manage on board catering
services on Rajdhani Express Train. The consideration for these services is included in
the fare charged by Indian Railways from the passengers and the applicant is paid by
Indian Railways/ IRTC for the catering services provided to the passengers. Under the
'Scope of Work' in the said agreement, the applicant is required to provide catering
services to the passengers as per the menu and instructions issued by the Railways.
They are also required to provide baby food to infants Jess than five years of age.
They are also required to pick-up duly packed dinner/ lunch menu from the base
kitchens/ approved sources of IRCTC. Only service charges are payable to the
applicant where IRCTC has supplied the food ond both service charges end catering
charges are payable to the applicant where material is also supplied by them. The
applicant is required to arrange necessary service gears and equipments including
disposables viz. Service trays, paper napkins, tray mat, paper cup, thermo flask etc.
for provision of onboard services. The applicant is also required to serve newspaper
at a fixed rate of Rs. 2 per passenger. It is mandatory for the applicant to supply Rail
Neer (Packaged Drinking Water) at rates fixed at Rs. 15 per bottle of one litre. The
payment for on-board catering services is made by IRCTC to the Service Provider on
agreed rates. The applicant is required to submit separate bills for supply of food
item-wise and service charges. In the rates accepted by the IRCTC,separate rates for
each item viz. Tea, Breakfast, Dinner supplied by the applicant and separate service
charges are given for serving tea, breakfast, dinner, whether provided by the
applicant or provided by IRCTC from their base Kitchens. In the invoices issued by
the applicant to IRCTC, similarly separate rates of each item and their respective
service charges wherever applicable are separately mentioned. However, rates of
newspaper, packed drinking water are fixed and no service charges are paid on the
same.
10.
Indian Railways, second
IRCTC and the applicant.
.•
ADVANCE RULING NO. 02/DAAR/2018 dated 28.03.2018
case i.e. between IRCTC and the catering contractor. The applicant raises invoice to
IRCTC showing separate value of food & beverages, newspaper and services, in
respect of number of passengers who actually boarded the train.
11. Similarly, the applicant has submitted a copy of agreement dated 07.08.2017
between IRCTC and the applicant for temporary licence to manage on board catering
services on Duronto Express Train. The said agreement is similar to the agreement
for on-board catering on Rajdhani Trains as mentioned above.
12. The applicant has also submitted a copy of Master Licence agreement dated
OS.01.2015 between North Eastern Railway and the applicant for provision of pantry
car/ catering services in Shiv Ganga Express Train. Under the scope of 'Catering
services on Train' in the said agreement, it is mentioned that the applicant shall
supply and service of fully cooked meals/ food to passengers on demand viz.
breakfast, lunch, dinner, snacks tea, coffee etc. These meals/ food will be prepared,
packed and transported from Railway approved/ nominated/ authorised kitchens.
The food has to be prepared and supplied to passengers as per recipe framed by the
Railways. The menus and rates for each item is fixed by the Railways. The applicant
is also required to distribute/ serve Rail Neer/ Packaged Drinking Water at rates
decided by the Railways. The food/ meals are served by staff of the applicant. The
applicant shJII ovoid cooking food in the pantry cer except snacks, tea, wrr.,., d?.
The standard tariff for each item has been fixed by Railways. The payment is made
by the passengers directly to the applicant. The applicant issues invoice for each
item. As per sample invoice submitted by the applicant, they supplied, Biscuits @ Rs.
20, Namkeen @ Rs. 5, Tetra Juice @ Rs. 35, Flavoured Milk @ Rs. 25, Bread Pakoda
@ Rs. 24, standard veg Breakfast@ Rs. 30, Tea @ Rs. 7, Mutter Paneer@ Rs. 35 etc.
No service charges were received by the applicant from the passengers over and
above the fixed rates for each item.
13. It is observed that, for any supply to be covered in the said Notification No.
11/2017 -Central Tax (Rate) dated 28.06.2017 as amended vide Notification No
46/2017- Central Tax (Rate) dated 14.11.2017 and parallel Notification of JGST and
Delhi GST, the activity must be a service i.e. a pure supply of goods even if intended
to be used as a food is not covered in the said notification. Further, it is observed
that as per Section 7(1)(d) of CGST Act, 2017 and as per Schedule II, Point 6, the
following composite supplies shall be treated as a supply of services, namely:-
(a) Warks contract as defined in clause (119) af Section 2; and
(b) Supply, by of or as part of any service in any other manner whatsoever, af
goads, being food or ony other article for human consumption or any drink
,
ADVANCE RULING NO. 02/DAAR/2018 dated 28.03.2018
(other than alcoholic liquor for human consumption), where such supply of
service is for cash, deferred payment or other valuable consideration.
14. The applicant has claimed that their supply is a composite supply and hence
should be treated as supply of services. However, In view of the nature of supply
involving several types of goods and services, it is important to determine whether
the said supply is a composite supply or not. It is observed that separate values of
supply of good and services are available in the case of supply of food and beverages
on board the trains. 'Composite supply' is defined in Section 2 (30) of the CGST Act,
2017 as follows:
"composite supply" means a supply made by o taxable person to a recipient
consisting of two or more taxable supplies of goods or services or both, or any
combination thereof, which are naturally bundled and supplied in conjunction
with each other in the ordinary course of business, one of which is a principal
supply;
Illustration.- Where goods ore packed and transported with insurance, the
supply of goads, packing materials, transport and insurance is a composite
supply and supply of goads is a principal supply;
15. From the above, it is observed that though a composite supply of various
ennrl? nnt invnlvine ?PrvirPs wn11lrl hP rnvPrPrl '" ? mmrnsitP s11rrly 11nrlPr Section
2(30) of the CGST Act, 2017 but still it would not be considered as a supply of
services under Section 7(1) (d) of CGST Act, 2017 r/w Point 6 of Schedule II of the
Said Act, because it is not covered in clause (b) of Point 6 of Schedule II. Only a
composite supply containing services can be considered as supply of services.
16. The following clarifications has been Issued by CBEC regarding "Composite
Supply" under GST:
A composite supply would mean a supply made by a taxable person to o
recipient consisting of two ar more taxable supplies of goods or services or
bath, or any combination thereof, which are naturally bundled and supplied in
conjunction with each other in the ordinary course of business, one of which is a
principal supply:
A works contract and restaurant services are classic examples of composite
supplies, however the GST Act identifies both as supply of services and
chargeable to specific rate of tax mentioned against such services (works
contract and restaurants)
In respect of composite supplies (other than the two categories mentioned
above), the need ta determine the supply as a composite one, will arise, so as to
determine the appropriate classification. It will be necessary to determine as to
pagelO of 15
...
ADVANCE RULING NO. 02/DAAR/2018 dated 28.03.2018
whether a particular supply is naturally bundled in the ordinary course of
business and what constitutes principal supply in such composite supplies.
The concept of composite supply under GST is identical to the concept of
naturally bundled services prevailing in the existing service tax regime. This
concept hos been explained in the Education Guide issued by CBEC in the yeor
2012 as under:
"Bundled service meons a bundle of provision of various services wherein on
element of provision of one service is combined with on element or elements of
provision of any other service or services. An example of 'bundled service'
would be air transport services provided by airlines wherein on element of
transportation of passenger by air Is combined with on element of provision of
catering service on board. Each service involves differential treatment as a
manner of determination of value of two services for the purpose of charging
service tax is different."
The rule is - 'If various elements of a bundled service ore naturally bundled in
the ordinary course of business, it shall be treated as provision of a single
service which gives such bundle its essential character'
1/lustrations :
• A hotel provides a 4-D/3-N µu?kuye with the fur:ililyuf /.Jreukfu,L.Thi,
is a natural bundling of services in the ordinary course of business. The
service of hotel accommodation gives the bundle the essential character
and would, therefore, be treated as service of providing hotel
accommodation.
• A 5 star hotel is booked for a conference of 100 delegates on a lump
sum package with the following facilities:
• Accommodation for the delegates
• Breakfast for the delegates
• Teo and coffee during conference
• Access to fitness room for the delegates
• Availability of conference room
• Business centre
As is evident, a bouquet of services is being provided, mony of them
chargeable to different effective rotes of tax. None of the individual
constituents ore able to provide the essential character of the service. However,
if the service is described as con
,.
If)
•
ice, it is able to capture the entire
essence of the package. Thus,
§'
ef,ee
·
'a be judged as convention service
. y ;2 \ '
pagJ'??-/ \ \
?
? o/'
ADVANCE RULING NO. 02/DAAR/2018 dated 28.03.2018
and chargeable to full rate. However, it will be fully justifiable far the hate/ ta
charge individually far the services as fang as there is na attempt to offload the
value of one service an ta another service that is chargeable at a concessional
rate.
Whether the services are bundled in the ordinary course a/ business, would
depend upon the normal ar frequent practices fol/awed in the area a/ business
to which services relate. Such normal and frequent practices adapted in a
business con be ascertained /ram several indicators same of which are listed
be/aw:
• The perception of the consumer or the service receiver - If large number
of service receivers a/ such bundle a/ services reasonably expect such
services to be provided as a package, then such a package could be treated
as naturally bundled in the ordinary course of business.
• Majority of service providers in a particular area a/ business provide
similar bundle a/ services. Far example, bundle of catering an board and
transport by air is a bundle offered by a majority of airlines.
• The nature of the various services in o bundle of services will also help in
determining whether the services are bundled in the ordinary course of
business. If the nature of services is such that one of the services is the
moin service ond the other services combined with such service are In the
nature nf tnridenm! or ancillary services which help in better ell]Oy111tt11luf
a main service. For example, service of stay in a hotel is often combined
with a service or laundering of 3-4 items of clothing free of cast per day.
Such service is an ancillary service to the provision of hotel accommodation
and the resultant package would be treated as services naturally bundled
in the ordinary course of business.
• Other illustrative indicators, not determinative but indicative of bundling
of services in the ordinary course of business are:
- There is a single price or the customer pays the same amount, no
matter haw much package they actually receive ar use
- The "elements ore normally advertised as a package
- The different elements ore not available separately
- The different elements are integral to one overall supply. ff one or
more is removed, the nature of the supply would be affected
No straight jacket formula can be laid down to determine whether a service
is naturally bundled in the ordinary course of business. Each case has to be
individually examined in the backdrop of several factors some of which are
... '
ADVANCE RULING NO. 02/DAAR/2018 dated 28.03.2018
supply constitutes a composite supply under GST and if so what constitutes the
principal supply so as to determine the right classification and rate of tax of
such composite supply.
17. It is observed that the various goods and services supplied by the applicant have
separate values, no supply is principal supply and various components of supply are
not naturally bundled. Accordingly, the contract between IRCTC and the applicant
does not appear to be a composite contract for supply of good and services. Hence,
Section 7(1}(d)of the CGST Act, 2017 and Point 6 of Schedule II of the said Act are
not applicable. Hence, it is not possible to classify the whole contract as supply of
services.
18. The Applicant has referred to the High Court of Delhi judgement dated
19.07.2010 in the case of IRCTC V/s Government of NCT of Delhi reported in 2010
{20) STR 437 (Del) to argue that supply of food on board the trains cannot be
considered as outdoor catering service. It has been held by the Hon'ble High Court
that providing of food, snacks and water to passengers on board trains is different
from outdoor catering service. The IRCTC or passengers have no choice of articles or
quantity served as the same is supplied as per menu fixed by Railway Board. The
passengers have no choice as to time and place of services of food. No refund is
allowed if food provided is not accepted. No element of service is involved except
heating and serving cooked food. Service element in providing food in this case is
incidental and base minimum required for selling food. The impugned contract/
transaction is not for providing service nor a composite contract but is one of pure
sale of goods. Service component in respect of sale of food in a restaurant is much
more than supply of food to a passenger in a compartment of a train.
19. The Hon'ble High Court has also held in the abovementioned case that a
catering contract has been brought under fiction of "deemed sale" under Article
366(29A) of Constitution and splitting up of such contract is constitutionally
permissible. A catering contract is covered in sub-clause (f) of Article 366 (29A) of
Constitution.
20. A restaurant, In addition to sale of food, provide services like an elegant decor,
uniformed waiters, good linen, crockery, cutlery and could even provide music and
dance floor. Further, in outdoor catering, service element is much more as
compared to service element in case of service provided by the Restaurant.
21. Hence, taxing authorities in each case have to ascertain whether a transaction
'•
>
ADVANCE RULING NO. 02/DAAR/2018dated 28.03.2018
services. They are also required to determine whether services are incidental to the
supply of goods or whether services component is predominant in the contract.
22. The contention of the applicant that a train is covered under entry (i)of S.No. 7
of Notification No. 11/2017- Central Tax (Rate) dated 28.06.2017 being a restaurant,
eating joint including mess, canteen is not acceptable as a train is a mode of
transport and passenger travel in a train to go to various far away places they do not
visit trains for the purpose of having food. The fact that food is consumed by them
during their travel does not mean that a train should be considered as a restaurant
or an eating Joint.
RULING
23. In the case of supply of food and beverages (cooked/ MRP/ packed), at defined
menu and tariff, by the applicant to IRCTC/passengers on behalf of IRCTC,on board
the Rajdhani/ Duronto Express trains, the service charges are covered under Service
Code (Tariff) 996335 in Group 99633 of heading 9963 of Annexure/ Scheme of
Classification of Services as "catering services in train". The same are covered under
S. No. 7 (ix) of Notification No. 11/2017 - Central Tax (Rate) dated 28.06.2017 as
amended vide Notification No. 46/2017 - Central Tax (Rate) dated 14.11.17 and
parallel Notifications of IGST and Delhi GST. A train is a mode of transport and hence
cannot be called as a restaurant, eating joint, mess or canteen etc. and hence
catering services provided on-board a train are not covered under S. No. 7 (i) of the
said Notifications as claimed by the applicant. The supply of goods i.e. food, bottled
water etc. shall be charged to GST on value of goods (excluding the service charges)
at applicable rates as pure supply of goods, as the same have no element of service.
The supply of newspaper is separately invoiced and hence it shall be at 'Nil" GST
under S. No. 120 of Notification No. 2/2017- Central Tax (Rate) dated 28.06.2017 and
parallel Notifications of IGST and Delhi GST.
24. In the case of supply of food and beverages (cooked/ MRP/ packed) on board
the Mail/ express trains by the applicant directly to the passengers as per the menu/
rates fixed by IRCTC/Railways does not have any element of service and hence the
same shall be considered as pure supply of goods and GST shall be charged on
individual items at their respective applicable rates. The benefit of S. No. 7 of
Notification No. 11/2017-Central Tax (Rate) dated 28.06.2017 vide Notification No.
46/2017 - Central Tax (Rate) dated 14.11.2017; amendment made in Notification
No. 8/2017- Integrated Tax (Rate) dated 28.06.2017 vide Notification No. 48/2017 -
)
ADVANCE RULING NO. 02/DAAR/2018 dated 28.03.2018
State Tax (Rate} dated 30.06.2017 vide Notification No. 46/2017 - State Tax (Rate)
dated 28.11.17 are not admissible to the applicant.
25. The supply of food and beverages (cooked/ MRP/ packed) by the applicant to
the passengers/ general public at the rates fixed by the Indian Railways/ IRCTC at
food stalls at Railway platforms does not have any element of service and hence the
same shall be considered as pure supply of goods and GST shall be charged on
individual items at their respective applicable rates. The mere heating/ cooling of
beverages or similar other services are incidental and minimal required to supply of
goods and such supply cannot be called composite supply. The benefit of S. No. 7 of
Notification No. 11/2017-Central Tax (Rate) dated 28.06.2017 vide Notification No.
46/2017 - Central Tax (Rate) dated 14.11.2017; amendment made in Notification
No. 8/2017- Integrated Tax (Rate) dated 28.06.2017 vide Notification No. 48/2017 -
Central Tax (Rate) dated 14.11.17; amendment made in Notification No. 11/2017 -
State Tax (Rate) dated 30.06.2017 vide Notification No. 46/2017 - State Tax (Rate)
dated 28.11.17 are not admissible to the applicant.
26. For the supply of food (Cooked/ MRP/ Packed) in food plaza, the relevant
document pertaining to details of items supplied, pricing detains, extent of services
provided are not submitted. Hence, no ruling can be given in respect of supply from
Food Plaza on the Railway Platform
Pankaj Jain
Member {Centre)
page15 of 15
\J ?
Jumar
Member (State)