Form II, The Jharkhand Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Rules, 2015: FORM-II
The Jharkhand Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Rules, 2015 - Form II
Text of form II
FORM-II
FORM-II
Part -A. Terms of Reference and Processing Fee for the SIA
[See sub-rule (1) of Rule 8]
The State SIA Unit will review the proposal for land acquisition sent by the
appropriate Government and produce a project-specific Terms of Reference (ToR) and
budget. Based on the ToR and budget, a processing fee will be determined, which must
be deposited by the Requiring body before the notification of the SIA can be issued. The
ToR shall include the following information:
(i) A brief description of the project, project area and the extent of lands proposed for
acquisition
(ii) The objectives of the SIA and all the activities that must be carried out by the SIA
team
(iii) Sequencing, schedule and deadlines for deliverables with dates for the SIA process,
based on the size and complexity of the project and land acquisition, and whether
consent of Gram Sabhas and/or land owners is required to be sought
(iv) The appropriate size and profile of the SIA team required (including field surveyors,
if needed) to conduct the SIA for the specific project
(v) A project-specific budget based on the ToR, with a clear break-up of costs for each
item/activity
(vi) The schedule for the disbursement of funds to the SIA team tied to clearly-defined
deliverables in the SIA process
(vii) The processing fee will be determined based on the ToR and budget developed for
each specific project and will be based on the type, size, location, and sensitivity of the
project and the land proposed for acquisition
(viii) Information regarding the processing fee and the cost for separate
components/line items must be made consistent and easily accessible so that the
requiring body can factor this into its costs in advance. These rates must be reviewed
and revised from time to time
(ix) Ten percent of the fee will go towards meeting the administrative costs of the SIA
Unit
-34-
Part-B.
Notification of the SIA
(See sub-rule (1) of Rule 6)
The Notification of the SIA must include:
(i.) Name of project, a brief description of the proposed project and the extent of the lands
proposed for acquisition, the project area and the affected areas to be covered by the SIA
(ii.) The main objectives of the SIA and key activities including (a) consultations (b) survey (c)
public hearing/s, if consent of Gram Sabhas and/or land owners is required, the notification must
state this.
(iii.) The timeline for the SIA and the final deliverables (SIA Report and SIMP) along with the
manner of their disclosure must be specified
(iv.) Statement that any attempt at coercion or threat during this period will render the exercise
null and void. Contact information of the State SIA Unit to be mentioned
-35-
FORM llI
Social Impact Assessment Report
(See sub-rule (3) of Rule 6)
Part-A. List of socio-economic and cultural parameters to be covered by the SIA:
Demographic details of the population in the project area
Age, sex, caste, religion
Literacy, health and nutritional status
Poverty levels
Vulnerable groups
- Women, children, the elderly, women-headed households, the differently abled
Kinship patterns and women's role in the family
Social and cultural organisation
Administrative organisation
Political organisation
Civil society organisations and social movements
Land use and livelihood
Agricultural and non-agricultural use
Quality of land - soil, water, trees etc.
Livestock
Formal and informal work and employment
Household division of labour and women's work
Migration
Household income levels
Livelihood preferences
Food security
Local economic activities
Formal and informal local industries
Access to credit
Wage rates
Specific livelihood activities women are involved in
-36-
Factors that contribute to local livelihoods
Access to natural resources
Common property resources
Private assets
Roads, transportation
Irrigation facilities
Access to markets
Tourist sites
Livelihood promotion programmes
Co-operatives and other livelihood-related associations
Quality of the living environment
Perceptions, aesthetic qualities, attachments and aspirations
Settlement patterns
Houses
Community and civic spaces
Sites of religious and cultural meaning
Physical infrastructure (including water supply, sewage systems etc.)
Public service infrastructure (schools, health facilities, anganwadi centres, public
distribution system)
Safety, crime, violence
Social gathering points for women
Part-B. Key impact areas:
Impacts on land, livelihoods and income
- Level and type of employment Intra-household
- employment patterns Income levels
- Food security
- Standard of living
- Access and control over productive resources
- Economic dependency or vulnerability
- Disruption of local economy
- Impoverishment risks
-37-
- Women's access to livelihood alternatives
Impacts on physical resources
- Impacts on natural resources, soil, air, water, forests
- Pressures on land and common property natural resources for livelihoods
Impacts on private assets, public services and utilities
- Capacity of existing health and education facilities
- Capacity of housing facilities
- Pressure on supply of local services
- Adequacy of electrical and water supply, roads, sanitation and waste management
system
- Impact on private assets such as bore wells, temporary sheds etc.
Health impacts
- Health impacts due to in-migration
- Health impacts due to project activities with a special emphasis on:
- Impact on women's health
- Impact on the elderly
Impacts on culture and social cohesion
- Transformation of local political structures
- Demographic changes
- Shifts in the economy-ecology balance
- Impacts on the norms, beliefs, values and cultural life
- Crime and illicit activities
- Stress of dislocation
- Impact of separation of family cohesion
- Violence against women
Impacts at different stages of the project cycle
The type, timing, duration, and intensity of social impacts will depend on and relate closely
to the stages of the project cycle. Below is an indicative list of impacts:
Pre-construction phase
- Interruption in the delivery of services
- Drop in productive investment
- Land speculation
-38-
- Stress of uncertainty
Construction phase
- Displacement and relocation
- Influx of migrant construction workforce
- Health impacts on those who continue to live close to the construction site
Operation phase
- Reduction in employment opportunities compared to the construction phase
- Economic benefits of the project
- Benefits on new infrastructure
- New patterns of social organisation
De-commissioning phase
- Loss of economic opportunities
- Environmental degradation and its impact on livelihoods
Direct and indirect impacts
- "Direct impacts" will include all impacts that are likely to be experienced by the
affected families
- "Indirect impacts" will include all impacts that may be experienced by those not
directly affected by the acquisition of land (i.e. Direct land and livelihood losers), but those
living in the project area.
Differential impacts
- Impact on women, children, the elderly and the differently abled
- Impacts identified through tools such as Gender Impact Assessment Checklists,
and Vulnerability and Resilience Mapping
Cumulative impacts
- Measureable and potential impacts of other projects in the area along with the identified
impacts for the project in question.
- Impact on those not directly in the project area but based locally or even regionally.
-39-
PART-C. Table of Contents for SIA Report and Social Impact Management Plan
Chapter Contents
Executive
Summary
Detailed Project
Description
- Project Location and public purpose
- Size and attributes of land acquisition
- Alternatives considered
- Social Impacts
- Mitigation measures
- Assessment of social costs and benefits
- Background of the project, including developers
background and governance/ management structure
- Rationale for project including how the project fits the
public purpose criteria listed in the Act
- Examination of alternatives
- Phases of project construction
- Core design features and size and type of facilities
- Need for ancillary infrastructural facilities
- Work force requirements (temporary and permanent)
- Details of SIA or EIA if already conducted and
any technical feasibility reports
- Applicable legislations and policies
-40-
Team composition,
approach, methodology
and schedule of the SIA
- List of all team members with qualifications.
- Description and rationale for the methodology and tools used
to collect information for the SIA.
- Sampling methodology used
- Overview of information/data sources used. Detailed
reference must be included separately in the forms if
required.
- Schedule of consultations with key stakeholders and brief
description of public hearings conducted. Details of the
public hearing and the specific feedback incorporated into the
Report must be included in the forms.
Land Assessment - Describe with the help of the maps, information from land
inventories and primary sources
- Entire area of impact under the influence of the project
(not limited to land area for acquisition)
- Total land requirement for the project
- Present use of any public, unutilised land in the vicinity of the
project area
- Land (if any) already purchased, alienated, leased or
acquired, and the intended use for each plot of land
required for the project
- Quantity and location of land proposed to be acquired for
the project
- Nature, present use and classification of land and if
agricultural land, irrigation coverage and cropping patterns
-41-
Estimation and
enumeration (where
required) of
affected families
and assets
- Size of holdings, ownership patterns, land distribution,
and number of residential houses
- Land prices and recent changes in ownership, transfer
and use of lands over the last 3 years
- Estimation of the following types of families that:
are directly affected (own land that is proposed to be
acquired):
are tenants/occupy the land proposed to be acquired
are Scheduled Tribes and other traditional forest
dwellers who have lost any of their forest rights
Depend on common property resources which will be
affected due to acquisition of land for their livelihood
have been settled land by the State Government or the
Central Government under any of its schemes and such
land is under acquisition;
have been residing on any land in the urban areas for
preceding three years or more prior to the acquisition of
the land
have depended on the land being acquired as a primary
source of livelihood for three years prior to the
acquisition
have indirectly impacted by the project (not affected
directly by the acquisition of own lands)
-42-
Socio-economic and
cultural
profile (of affected
area and
- Demographic details of the population in the project
area
- Income and poverty levels
resettlement site) - Vulnerable groups
- Land use and livelihood
- Local economic activities
- Factors that contribute to local livelihoods
- Kinship patterns and social and cultural organisation
- Administrative organisation
- Political organisation
- Community-based and civil society-organisations
- Regional dynamics and historical change processes
- Quality of the living environment
Social impacts - Framework and approach to identify impacts
- Description of impacts at various stages of the project
cycle such as impacts on health and livelihoods and
culture. For each type of impact, separate indication of
whether it is a direct/indirect impact, differential impacts
on different categories of affected families and where
applicable cumulative impacts
- Indicative list of impact areas include: impacts on land,
livelihoods and income, physical resources, private
assets, public services and utilities, health, culture and
social cohesion and gender based impacts
-43-
Analysis of costs
and
benefits and
recommendation on
acquisition
References and
Forms
- Final conclusions on: assessment of public purpose,
less-displacing alternatives, minimum requirements of
land, the nature and intensity of social impacts, the
viability of the mitigation measures and the extent to
which mitigation measures described in the SIMP will
address the full range of social impacts and adverse
social costs
- The above analysis will use the equity principle as a
criteria of analysis for presenting a final
recommendation on whether the acquisition should go
through or not
- For reference and further information
-44-
Previous and next
Questions people ask
Is form II of the Jharkhand Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Rules, 2015 still in force?
No repeal of the Jharkhand Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Rules, 2015 is recorded.