Appendix V, TAMIL NADU INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT BOARD REGULATIONS 2013: APPENDIX - V
TAMIL NADU INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT BOARD REGULATIONS 2013 - Appendix V
Text of appendix V
APPENDIX - V
APPENDIX - V
PROJECT MANAGEMENT PRINCIPLES
(see regulation 16)
1. Functions of Project Management Facility or Project Manager before signing of Concession Agreement/ Contract:- The PMF or Project Manager shall
perform the following functions after the Letter of Award (LOA) has been issued to
the Lowest Tenderer:
(a) Finalize schedules and project specific information in the contract;
(b) Obtain performance bonds or guarantees from the Private agency as per
the terms of the RFP;
(c) Receive or make any payments to be made by either party as per RFP;
(d) Obtain all documentation required from Private agency and monitor
fulfillment of all obligations of the Private agency relating to approvals, consents
and licenses to sign the Concession Agreement/Contract; and
(e) Procure all approvals required for the Sponsoring Agency or Public agency
as the case may be for the signing of the Concession Agreement or contract.
2. Fulfillment of Conditions Precedent:- (a) The Project Management
Facility shall be responsible for monitoring the fulfilment of Condition Precedents
for Sponsoring Agency and the Private agency in the Concession Agreement or
Contract.
(b) The Project Management Facility shall submit a periodic report to the
Sponsoring Agency on the progress of the fulfillment of individual Conditions
Precedent. The periodicity of such reports would be defined by the Sponsoring
Agency depending on the size and complexity of the Public-Private Partnership
Project.
(c) The Project Management Facility shall notify the Sponsoring Agency of
any potential failure or delay in the fulfillment of Conditions Precedent and shall
recommend any actions for correction or avoidance, as the case maybe, of such
potential failure or delay.
(d) The Project Management Facility shall periodically review the activities
undertaken and progress made by the Concessionaire or Contractor for the
fulfillment of the Condition Precedents for Concessionaire or Contractor in the
Concession Agreement or contract. The Project Management Facility shall report
the result of such review in the report referred to in paragraph (2) of this article.
The Project Management Facility shall also notify the Sponsoring Agency or Public
Agency of any potential failure or delay on the part of the Concessionaire or
contractor in fulfillment of Conditions Precedent, and recommend actions to be
taken by the Concessionaire for correction or avoidance, as the case maybe, of such
potential failure or delay.
3. Responsibility during Construction Period:- (a) Once the construction
starts the PMF shall be responsible for monitoring the progress of construction as
per the schedule and contract terms. For this it will:
26
(i) Monitor progress by the Sponsoring Agency or Public Agency of providing
remaining land as per project schedule;
(ii) Undertake periodic site-visits, to monitor the progress; and
(iii) Review monthly and quarterly progress through Independent Engineer
inspection reports.
(b) Through the Independent Engineer, perform tests 30 (thirty) days prior to
likely commissioning date to ensure quality, and provide for Completion Certificate.
(c) Monitor and review the continued fulfilment of mutual obligations and
implement course corrections, if any.
(d) Invoke contractual terms in case of non-compliance by the Private
agency.
(e) Report on a monthly basis on project status to the State Government.
(f) Approve the operations and maintenance manual submitted by the
Concessionaire.
4. Responsibility during Operations Period:- (a) Once the construction is
completed the PMF shall, undertake periodic site-visits, to monitor the operations
and maintenance of the Public-Private Partnership Project as per the contract
terms. This shall include:
(i) Monitoring service delivery quality, safety, user satisfaction, and
emergencies;
(ii) Monitoring the quality of maintenance (preventive, routine, periodic,
major) as per standards and in accordance with O&M manual;
(iii) Reviewing the progress and performance indicators;
(iv) Monitoring the financial performance, including revenues, revenue
sharing, and other parameters; and
(v) Reviewing the continued fulfilment of mutual obligations and implement
course corrections, if any.
(b) In case of non-compliance by the private party, the PMF shall invoke the
contractual terms.
(c) Send monthly reporting on the status of the Public-Private Partnership
Project to the Sponsoring agency or public agency and to the TNIDB.
5. Performance Management:- (a) To achieve high standards of
performance from the Project including a Public-Private Partnership Project, it is
vital to continuously monitor its service delivery and compliance to performance
standards. Therefore, the Public Agency or Sponsoring Agency, through the PMF,
shall put in place requisite performance monitoring mechanisms.
(b) The PMF shall prepare, prior to signing of the Concession Agreement or
contract, a performance management plan as part of Project Management Plan,
27
such a plan shall, clearly define performance requirements for each stage in the
project lifecycle, which shall include:
(i) Development requirements covering the standards of civil and engineering
works;
(ii) Commissioning requirements covering testing requirements prior to
commissioning of Public-Private Partnership Project;
(iii) Service delivery requirements covering output requirements for efficient
service delivery;
(iv) Handover requirements which shall include the specific standards and
requirements of assets at the time of handover and project exit; and
(v) Effectively link the payment mechanism to performance standards.
(c) Monitor the fulfilment of performance standards are satisfied and any
default is appropriately dealt as per the contract terms.
(d) Monitor that all payments are made and penalties are imposed within the
timeframes specified in the concession agreement or contract.
(e) Ensure that performance is always assessed with respect to performance
standards specified in the concession agreement or contract.
(f) Document clearly performance monitoring procedures and ensure a
common understanding of processes within Project Management Facility.
(g) Prepare and circulate performance reports periodically to facilitate a
shared understanding of delivery process, establish a system for collecting and
documenting feedback on the Project and ensure trends in substandard service
delivery are identified & documented.
6. Key Performance Indicators:- (a) Key Performance Indicators (KPI) for
each of the performance requirements as defined in the concession agreement or
contract, shall be periodically monitored by PMF. Such KPIs shall be:
(i) both qualitative and quantitative measures; and
(ii) a combination of the service quality, financial efficiency and process
efficiency.
(b) The nature of specific indicators, frequency of their monitoring shall be in
line with the nature and criticality of service delivery and the criticality of its impact
on project lifecycle.
(c) The Sponsoring Agency or Public Agency, through the PMF, shall monitor
performance through KPIs, wherein it shall, as part of performance management
framework:
(i) Establish reporting and monitoring systems and procedures,
(ii) Define data collection methods & data sources,
(iii) Specify timeframes for reporting and monitoring of indicators, and
28
(iv) Assign responsibilities for reporting and monitoring activities.
(d) The Sponsoring Agency or Public Agency, through the PMF, particularly
in long term Concession Agreements and contracts wherein performance standards
for service delivery are likely to evolve over time, shall establish a system of
continuous improvement in project service delivery. Herein, target indicators may
be based on past performance with an incremental improvement envisaged so that
principles of continuous improvement apply.
7. Risk Management:- (a) Based on the risks identified and allocated during
the procurement and contracting phases, a response plan to risks materializing
shall be prepared by the Procuring Entity. This shall be a set of possible escalations
and actions to be made by the Sponsoring Agency for managing risks and
responding to possible risk outcomes.
(b) This shall include a risk reporting, monitoring and control system for
continuous reporting, monitoring and updating of risks allocated to either party
throughout the project lifecycle. And also to establish procedures to be used by the
Sponsoring Agency or Public Agency to deal with failure of the private party to
manage the risk, such as penalties and other suitable measures, as also
contingency procedures to restore service delivery.
8. Contingency Management:- (a) Many of the facilities and services under
the Public-Private Partnership Projects will be of an essential nature and hence
would require to be restored to citizens or users at the earliest possible and even in
case of private party failure.
(b) Contingency planning is vital to a Public-Private Partnership Project, as it
may not be possible to fully transfer responsibility for the risk of service delivery
failure to the private party. Need for a contingency plan arises on account of
possible service disruption or private party default. Wherein, contingency can be
classified into:
(i) Disruption in service delivery not on account of private party default such
as, force majeure events;
(ii) Disruption in service delivery on account of private party default on
contract terms; and
(iii) Default by private party but no disruption in service delivery.
(c) In light of this Sponsoring Agency shall cause development of a
Contingency Management Plan. It shall include the following:
(i) Business continuity plan, Its objective is to mitigate the impact of service
delivery disruption on the key stake holders, i.e. contracting parties and end users.
It shall include:
(a) Potential events that could disrupt service delivery;
(b) Immediate actions in response to such events;
(c) Priority and timeframes for restoring critical services;
(d) Service levels for each critical service;
29
(e) Identified resources for implementing the plan;
(f) Allocation of roles and responsibilities for response management;
(g) Information required to implement the plan;
(h) Stakeholder communication; and
(i) Periodic testing requirement, of the plan.
(ii) Step-in plan, allows the Procuring Entity, under exigent circumstances,
to “step-in” and temporarily take control of project facilities to ensure continued
service delivery, it shall include:
(a) Potential events that may trigger step in clause of contract;
(b) Contractual conditions to be satisfied before step in;
(c) Institutional roles & responsibilities in implementation of step in clause;
(d) Prior authorizations required prior to exercise of right;
(e) Obligations & liabilities incurred in exercising step in rights;
(f) Resources required to implement the plan;
(g) Communication to implement the step in plan; and
(h) Whether “step-out” is possible or feasible.
(iii) Default plan, to be implemented when default clause of the contract is
invoked, it shall include:
(a) Potential events likely to lead to a default;
(b) Impact of default on service delivery;
(c) Time period before institution can act on the default;
(d) Contractual remedies and impact on service delivery;
(e) Institutional roles and responsibilities;
(f) Resources required to implement the plan; and
(g) Communication to implement the default plan.
(d) However due process should be observed in invoking these contractual
provisions. Action should be taken keeping in mind the nature of relationship with
the private party.
(e) The PMF shall be responsible for carrying out contingency management
activities and monitoring implementation of the contingency plan.
9. Managing Relationship and Communication:- (a) It is essential that
there exists mutual trust amidst contracting parties, through open communication
30
and information sharing. On each side, the roles and responsibilities of respective
Project Management Facility should be finalized, channels for communication
should be clearly set out and communication should be consistent across levels
and under-pinned by a culture of information sharing and prompt action.
(b) It is important to periodically review the relationship between contracting
parties. The objective of such an exercise should be to identify any issues that may
have arisen during the course of project execution and the resolution of which has
had an impact on the relationship between contracting parties. Initiating steps to
overcome any issues early on will help avoid any escalation of such issues into
larger disputes.
(c) It is also important to conduct periodic one-to-one and group interactions
between the project management facility’s of the contracting parties as well as with
the users and societal stakeholders of the project.
10. Dispute Resolution:- (a) Effective measure should be put in place
through the contract to settle disputes between the contracting parties.
(b) Mutual discussions, wherein the parties to the agreement can come
together to discuss a mutually agreeable settlement, is one of the most effective
tools for dispute resolution in terms of management time, cost, range of possible
solution and relationship management and thus it shall be the preferred method to
resolve disputes.
(c) Thereafter, Sponsoring Agency or public agency shall follow the
procedures specified in the Concession Agreement to resolve disputes between
parties.
(d) It shall be the responsibility of Project Management Facility to ensure that
the dispute resolution procedure laid down in contract is adhered to and informing
contracting parties and all relevant stakeholders on dispute resolution progress.
11. Project Administration:- The Project Management Facility shall be
responsible for project administration, supported by such resources as are
required. It shall encompass the fulfilment of the set of activities mentioned herein
to meet contractual requirements.
12. Financial Administration:- (a) Financial adminis-tration shall include
implementation of the payment mechanism as defined in the contract and
developed in the Project Management Plan. The Project Management Facility shall
be responsible for fulfilling the activities related to financial administration listed
herein.
(b) In case of availability based Public-Private Partnership Projects (Annuity),
ensure timely payments by the authority as set out in the contract.
(c) In case of user fee based Public-Private Partnership Projects:
(i) Effective monitoring of revenues earned by the private operator and
collection of revenue share or any other payments due to authority; and
(ii) Ensure timely disbursals of capital or revenue grants (if any) by the
authority.
31
(d) In both types of Public-Private Partnership Projects, as applicable, the
process would also involve:
(i) Imposition of penalties (including suspension of revenue collection rights);
(ii) Adjustments for inflation and other factors; and
(iii) Develop and implement reporting systems for the above.
(e) The PMF shall ensure that, payment mechanism links payments to
achievement of performance standards set out in the contract, such that payment
mechanism shall:
(i) Fully reflect actual service delivery;
(ii) Incorporate a system of penalties such as deductions based on severity of
service failure; and
(iii) award penalty points for non-compliance, leading to contractual
remedies taking affect in the event of repeated offence.
13. Information and knowledge management:-(a) The Project Management
Facility shall be responsible for put in place effective mechanisms for information
and knowledge management. It shall extend to, but not limited to responsibilities
listed herein below:
(i) Identification of information resources;
(ii) Capturing, collating, classifying, storing and appropriate security of
information;
(iii) Sharing of information to users, likely users and to those required under
any law; and
(iv) Reviewing, maintaining and purging of information to meet contractual
compliance requirement.
(b) To ensure continuous availability of project related knowledge and
information through the project lifecycle, efficient information management would
require, among others:
(i) Maintaining a document/information management system; and
(ii) Establishing necessary tools & processes such as policies & procedures
for managing information, records & documents;
(c) Fostering an appropriate culture for adhering to specified policies &
procedures and information/knowledge exchange at appropriate levels.
* * *
Previous and next
All provisions of TAMIL NADU INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT BOARD REGULATIONS 2013
Questions people ask
Is appendix V of TAMIL NADU INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT BOARD REGULATIONS 2013 still in force?
No repeal of TAMIL NADU INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT BOARD REGULATIONS 2013 is recorded.