Annexure 1, THE ARUNACHAL PRADESH URBAN POVERTY PROFILING AND STRATEGIC PLANS RULES, 2011: ANNEXURE-1
THE ARUNACHAL PRADESH URBAN POVERTY PROFILING AND STRATEGIC PLANS RULES, 2011 - Annexure 1
Text of annexure 1
ANNEXURE-1
ANNEXURE-1
INDICATIVE METHODOLOGY FOR PREPARATION OF MUNICIPAL POVERTY
PROFILE AND MUNICIPAL POVERTY REDUCTION STRATEGY
1. The task of City Poverty Profiles shall entail the following stages :-
(a) Collection of data pertaining to urban poor: On a map of the city indicating settlements, the location
of underserved families is delineated by way of areas.
[Note : The term 'underserved' would imply any household that is unable to access the bare
minimum levels of services that is assured by the State of Arunachal Pradesh to any household
capable of paying user charges, and are considered acceptable levels of service. The inability to
4 The Arunachal Pradesh Extraordinary Gazette, April 20, 2011
access may either be due to inability to afford the same, or because of any external environment
factor that makes cost of access substantially higher then normal Alternatively , a workable
baseline would include the common pool between (a) households classified as Below Poverty
Line as per NSS ratings, 61st round, and (b) beneficiaries identified through the consumption
parameters identified under the Swarna Jayanti Sheri Ragar Yojna.]
(b) Collection of data (household survey) with respect to a resonably representative sample of identified
households with respect to the following parameters :
(i) Secure, substantive and assured tenure of land, that can be owned, mortgaged, pledged and
passed down on hereditary basis.
(ii) Access to affordable and accepted standards of housing, through ownership.
(iii) Access to clean and safe drinking water within reasonable distance at equitable/affordable cost.
(iv) Access to sanitation - by way of pour flush latrines, either owned or shared, with no instance of
open defecation or windows of systemic unavailability.
(v) Access to primary healthcare - immunization, reproductive and child health, regular
epidemiologicalcontrol, first aid and referral facilities with follow-up.
(vi) Access to Primary and Secondary Education -all minors under the age of 14 enrolled in school,
individuals between the age of 14-21 having access to secondary education/professional training.
(vii) Access to Social Security Resources - Micro Finance, credit records, access to institutionalized
credit, borrowings and repayment records, insurance and other vulnerability risk underwriting
scheme coverage.
(viii) Livelihoods capable of generating ability to pay for services and savings after expenses incurred
on food, housing an other expenses.
(ix) Household amenities/asset ownership (asset base can be derived either from SJSRY guidelines
or modified as per local asset ownership patterns prevalent in Arunachal Pradesh).
(x) Presence of vulnerable members aged persons (above 60), women headed households, disabled,
widows, chronically ill individuals, SC/ST/OBC (in case the particular group is stated to be minority
within the population at large within the city).
(xi) Wealth and consumption base : In the case of wealth base, propensity of a household to invest
into securities including land/real estate/stocks and other form of speculative instruments. In
case of consumtion base, propensity of a household to move from one qualitative benchmark to
a higher one for any paricular commodity/commodities.
(xii) Mobility: Ability/requirment to move from one location to another in order to sustain livelihoods
[time spent/cost incurred in local travel/propensity to shift base in order to sustain livelihood].
(xiii) Social cohesion and peerage : Prevalence of community base organizations, degree of
involvement, dependence for social security and assertion of rights.
(xiv) Political equity: Voting rights.representations in local/State/National Government, prevalence of
officials dedicated to ward/mohalla/settlement pocket.
(xv) Gender equity: Propensity of women/girls to access services at same propensity/instances as
men and boys.
(xvi) Growth equity: Livelihood of next filial generation being able to move out of proverty cycle be way
of propensity to earn productive value added livelihoods and pay for services.
Notes:
Parameter xvi is a secondary parameter an need not be obtained through survey, but calculated
using the order Parameter to reach a general understanding of the rate and ability of an underserved
ability to move out of the proverty trap, with respect to all supplementary support (by way of
infrastructure, services and opportunity provided to it under any State private schemes).
2. Each of the above sets shall be downsampled into a list of survey parameters, which shall be collected
through surveys of representative sample. Usually, in case pre-sampling (the practice of collecting data
from one or two analogous samples in different geographical locations), does not show great difference, a
sample size of 5% to 8% is considered adequate.
3. The survey formats for city poverty profiles shall be as per the format developed at the Yeshwantrao
Chavan Academy of Development Administration, Pune, and the all All India Institute of Local
Self Government, Mumbai, with assistance from a UNDP assisted project 'National Strategy for the
Urban Poor' during 2006-07 with required modifications by the Government of Arunachal Pradesh.
4. The survey parameters themselves shall be graded in different scales as under:
Housing condition*:
Structural Condition Kutchha-0, Semi Pucca -1, Pucca -2
No. of habitable rooms Less than 2 - 0, Equal to 2 - 1, More than 2 - 2
Adult persons per room More than 2 - 0, Equal to 2 - 1, Equal to 1 - 2
Kitchen No kitchen - 0, Shared kitchen - 1, Owned kitchen - 2
Toilet No toilet - 0, Shared toilet -1, Owned toilet - 2
* indicative, can be further resolved, as per survey requirment, which may be developed in association with
officials of the Directorate of Town Planning and Urban Local Bodies, Directorate of Urban Development, Directorate
of Housing, Directorate of Relief and Rehabilitation and Disaster Management, Civil Society Groups, Consultant
if any (including those appointed for urban reforms) and other representatives of public at large.
The Arunachal Pradesh Extraordinary Gazette, April 20, 2011 5
5. A qualifying score for each of the parameters shall be pre-set, based on the optimal standards that shall
be offered by the State Government after taking into consideration the projects that are already sanctioned/
likely to be sanctioned under JNNURM.
6. Based on the survey, urban poor settlements in a town shall be graded into three categories of priority:
(a) Critical: Settlement pockets needing immediate attention in over 50% of the parameters mentioned
in under SI. No. 1 (b) above, based on scores obtained (the score in over 50% of the parameters falls
below the qualifying score).
(b) Moderate : Settlement pockets needing immediate attention in between 30% and 50% of the
parameters mentioned in SI. No. 1 (b) above, based on scores obtained (the score in between 30%
and 50% of the parameters falls below the qualifying score).
( c) Law: Settlement pockets needing immediate attention in less than 30% of the parameters mentioned
in SI. No. 1 (b), based on scores obtained (the score in less than 30% of the parameters falls below the
qualifying score).
7. The scores against citizen perception of needs and wants of inhabitants of the settlements shall be verified.
For example, a particular settlement shall be classified as critical keeping in view parameters under i
through iv of SI. No. 1(b) above, but the perception survey indicating that more importance is placed on
parameters vii and viii by the inhabitants of the settlement. Such exceptions and aberrations required
before a poverty reduction strategy is prepared shall be adequately documented.
8. City poverty profile shall comprise of the following sections :
(a) Overview of the city, including a map of settlements, plan boundaries (municipal limits, proposed
urbanisable area boundary and plan limits/control area boundary), population, topography, climate
and other physiographic parameters.
(b) Economic, social (ethnological) and geopolitical environment.
(c) Service levels defined and mapped to all settlements - this section shall also define the levels of
service that are assured by the State Government of Arunachal Pradesh after taking into consideration
the enhanced capacity of systems developed through assistance under JNNURM/other Central/State/
External Aid sector schems. At the end of the exercise, a map indicating the following shall be
generated.
(i) Settlements (areas) already receiveing equal or excess of the assured levels of services.
(ii) Areas which will receive desired levels of services upon completion of projects which have already
been commissioned.
(iii) Areas which are receiving less than desired levels of service but no project has been envisaged
for them at present.
(iv) Areas which are receiving less than desired levels of service but no project can be envisaged for
them due to land ownership/regulatory issues.
(d) Underserved households (see note under SI. No. 1 (a) and under SI. No. 8(c) above, mapped as areas
and not points.
(e) Results and classifications of pre-sampling, in order to define sample size and quality and to establish
qualifying scores for each of the survey parameters as indicated in para 16. At this point it shall also
be decided as to how to allow the perception survey weightage supersede the household survey
weightage.
(f) Abstracts of surveys carried out in selected settlements commensurate with the designated sample
size and quality, unweighted.
(g) Abstracts of surveys carried out in selected settlements commensurate with the designated sample
size and quality, weighted and scored.
(h) Additional information from perception surveys that superseds the weighted scores from each of the
underserved settlements.
(i) Listing of underserved settlements prioritized according to (i) perception survey (ii) household survey,
weighted.
((j) Key findings from commonalities and patterns ovserved in the surveys and policy directions for
development keeping in view the needs, wants and aspirations of underserved communities.
9. The above shall be supplemented by an urban poverty reduction strategy for the city, which would take into
account.
(a) Finding from the urban poverty profile of the city.
(b) The proposed development plan of the city as a tool for facilitating poverty reduction.
10. From SI. No. 8(b), (c), (g) and (j) above, the precise nature and scope of poverty shall be captured with
respect to the city in the following areas. The same shall be analyzed and recommendations provided
the reagainst.
Area of intervention What the poverty profile
should provide
Housing and land tenure Quantum and nature of
land and serviced housing
stock required, ability to
pay and subsidy required,
including stocks that need
and to be created through
relocation.
What the poverty reduction
strategy should provide
Housing projects that can/
should be taken up and in
what manner of spatial
distribution.
What to keep in mind
while making the
poverty reduction strategy
Whether reconfigurative
arrangements such as
double or three storey units
would be acceptable in
order to better arrange
and provide for services.
6
2
The Arunachal Pradesh Extraordinary Gazette, April 20, 2011
4 3
Basic services
water, sanitation,
communication
and mobility.
Issues related to quantita
tive and qualitative shortfall.
In case settlement Morpho
logy is acceptable/workable,
projects needed to augment
water, sanitation, communi
cation and mobility to
assured standards of the
State.
Basic services - Issues related to quantita-
healthcare, education tive qualitative shortfall
and social security.
Livelihoods and
economic opportunity
Social, gender and
political equity
Current spectrum,
income generations and
growth prospects of
trades/occupations
practiced by
underserved
communities
Prevalent customs,
traditions (historical or
otherwise) that reduce
the degree of
advantages available to
certain groups within
underserved
communities, such as
people from any ethnic
group, women,
disabled etc.
Product and service
concepts that need to be
developed further in con
sultation with stakeholders,
as well as from potential
service/product providers
including from within the
urban poor themselves.
In relation to emerging
markets, what trades
and occupations would
be required to meet
inflation brought about
be general increase in
Purchase Power
Parity ; what skillsets
would be required to
pursue the same, and
what facilitation
Regulatory framework
and amalgamation
with customary
(Schedule VJ)
legislation that allows
removal of such
disadvantages/
disparities ;
This may be further
reflected in products,
services and schemes
under basic services
that may offer
affirmative action
(positive reservation)
to disadvantaged
groups in line with
appropriate orders issued
by the Government of India/
State Government from time
to time
What kind of subsidy
structure it terms of
capital, operations and
maimtenance should be
placed so as to (i) not make
the services inaccessible
to the household, and (ii)
to prevent the household
from being perpetually
dependent on subsidy.
What kind of subsidy
structure it terms of capital
operations and main
tenance should be placed
so as to (i) not make the
services inaccessible to
the household, and (ii) to
prevent the household from
being perpentually depen
dent on subsidy, and (iii)
to make reasonable growth
(profiVnet turnover increase)
oriented structures beyond
government establishment
such as through PPP/
PPCP arrangements.
The trades and
occupations may need
to be seen in the overall
context of the economic
opportunity in the State
and may therefore entail
analysis of high growth
emergenturban sectors
(Manufacturing marketing/
IT/ITeS, Rand D,
finance etc.) and
assess their
multipliers with
respect to
underserved
Communities
needs for IT skills,
communication skills,
small entrepreneur and
business development
skills etc.
should be offered by
the State to increase
such opportunity
There maybe
regulatory issues
with respect to
voting rights,
ability to contest in
elections and other
affirmative action
Jaw already in
place, which need
to be carefully
studied before any
recommendations
are made to this
effect.
The Arunachal Pradesh Extraordinary Gazette, April 20, 2011 7
11. In case the above so warrants, the State Legislature shall adopt recommendations from the same
in order to :
(a) Authorize studies for changes to development plans:
(b) Authorise earmarking of available funds/raise capital from markets to carry out projects in line with
the recommendations and ratified by the statutory development plan.
(c) Constitute structures or empower existing structures to periodically review and follow up on the
progress of poverty reduction, including re-commission, preparation of poverty profiles for a city after
every two or three years, appending fresh data and samples ;
( d) Authorise revision of poverty reduction strategy for the town/city.
INDICATIVE TERMS OF REFERENCE FOR ENGAGEMENT OF INDIVIDUAL
OR AGENCY
1.0 METHODOLOGY
1.1 The Government of India is implementing the Jawaharlal Nehru National Urban Renewal Mission with an
objective to promote planned, balanced and inclusive urban development, with emphasis on:
(a) Creation of high quality infrastructure with ownership of Urban Local Bodies (ULBs), local Governments
and public-at-large with regards to operations, sustainability and management thereof;
(b) Encouraging ULBs and local Governments to undertake reforms in terms of administration, governance,
taxation, transparency and accountability to improve their ability to generate and manage large
quantities of revenue and capital.
(c) Creation and deployment of mechanisms to include the urban poor in decision making, ensuring the
delivery of basic services, security of tenure, health, education and social security, and facilitating
opportunities for livelihoods (through other Central/State sponsored schemes).
1.2 The Mission is being administered by two Ministries through two sets of sub-Missions, indicated as below:-
Sub-Mission II :
Sub-Mission IV :
Urban Infrastructure and Governance
Urban Infrastructure Development Scheme
in small and Medium Towns
Basic Services to the Urban Poor
Integrated Housing and Slum Development
Programme
Ministry of Urban
Development
Ministry of Housing and
Urban Poverty Alleviation
Sub-Mission I :
Sub-Mission Ill:
1.3 Sub-Missions I and II are limited to a set of 63 identified cities, while sub-Missions Ill and IV apply to all
other cities and towns (as per Census of India) within the Union of India.
1.4 Insofar as the sub-Missions II and IV are concerned, the Government of India has repeatedly insisted on
systems of information management being put into place to quantify the nature and extent of urban
poverty. Both sub-Missions insist on setting baselines and benchmarks with respect to the' ?-point charter', -c
a bouquet of services and privileges that are meant to be assured to every urban poor household. These
include:
(a) Security of Tenure
(b) Affordable Housing
(c) Access to safe Water Supply
(d) Access to effective and clean Sanitation
(e) Access to Health Care
(f) Access to Education
(g) Access to social security resources - micro insurance, finance/credit/securitizations and other
instruments for vulnerable groups.
1.5 The above has also been highlighted in the Reform Agreements signed between the States and the
Government of India.
1.6 It is further understood that a portion of the Central Assistance, around 1 % of the total allocation of
' 50,000 crore will be earmarked for:
(a) Fees and professional charges for services availed of, e.g. Consultants for preparation of detailed
project report, City Development Plans.
(b) Capacity building activities, including holding of workshops, training sessions, activities under Peer
Experience And Reflective Learning (PEARL), National Programme on Capacity Building for Poverty
Reduction, City Managers Forum, Mayors' Forum, Researchers' Colloquium on Urban Poverty etc.
(c) Preparation of supplementary reports/studies/baseline surveys, not already included as part of costs
of any particular project.
1.7 Now, it has been directed by the Central Government to commence the preparation of the following
documents with respect to sub-Missions II and IV:-
(a) City Poverty Profiles
(b) State Urban Poverty Profile
(c) Urban Poverty Reduction Strategies
8
The Arunachal Pradesh Extraordinary Gazette, April 20, 2011
1.8 It is understood that the above are meant to provide qualitative and quantitative insights into the nature and
extent of urban poverty prevalent in the State of Arunachal Pradesh or any State, which is directed to
prepare the same.
1.9 It is further understood that the City Poverty Profiles would serve as a base for preparing the State Urban
Poverty Profile, and that Urban Poverty Reduction Strategies would have to be made at both city as well
as State Levels.
1.10 The State of Arunachal Pradesh has a total of 26 urban centers including 17 census towns as per Census
of India, 2001. From these, the town of Itanagar, covered under sub-Missions I and II is proposed to be
taken up in the instant proposal. The Directorate ofTown Planning and Urban Local Bodies under Department
of Urban Development, which is both the State Level Nodal Agency as well as the nodal Department of the
State with respect to JnNURM will be the Client for this work, and hence referred to as the Client hereafter.
2.0 PROPOSED SCOPE OF WORK
Phase I:
2.1 The proposed scope of work can be broadly classified under the following two phases :
Preparation of the Poverty Profile of Itanagar, based on a system of indicators developed in
accordance with the seven-point charter, and the categories of parameters suggested in our
approach for improved understanding of urban poverty.
Preparation of poverty reduction strategy for Itanagar based on the findings from phase I, and
acceptance of the results thereof.
3.0 DELIVERABLES, ACTIVITIES AND RELATED TIM ELIN ES
Phase II:
SI. No. Deliverable/activity
3.1 The following table summarises the deliverables and the proposed time line for phase I :
Indicative time frame
1. (a) Listing of indicators on
the seven point charter
plus the additional
parameters suggested
(b) Design of survey
sample and deployment
2. Survey questionnaire
3. Selection of a survey
partner for the assignment
4. Conduct of a pre-survey
meeting
5. Conduct of actual survey
6. Initial hurdles resolution
meeting
7. Survey progress review
meeting
8. Survey closure meeting
9. Grouping, categorization
and rationalisation of
collected survey formats
10. Entry of data into
computerized formats
11. Analysis of data and
preliminary results
Draft Final
Ten working days from the
period from commencement
A meeting would be held
between the Consultant
representatives, the Client and
Civil Society representatives, to
understand the indicators as
suggested and how these would
help in overall understanding of
the urban poverty scenario in
Itanagar. The comments,
objections and observations
raised in this meeting would
be incorporated in the final outputs
Two weeks from finalizing of the
indicators
This activity would start as soon as
the assignment is awarded to us and
would be complete at the same time
as when the survey questionnaire
is approved
Within five working days of approval
of the survey formats
Four weeks from conduct of survey
workshop
One week after commencement of
survey
Two weeks after commencement of
survey
Two days after completion of surveys
Ten working days after survey closure
meeting
Seven working days from
issue of the minutes of
the meeting.
Three days after receiving
approval from the Client.
Three weeks after grouping, categori
zation and rationalization of survey
formats
Two weeks after completion of data Five working days after
entry acceptance of preliminary
results
The Arunachal Pradesh Extraordinary Gazette, April 20, 2011
9
SI. No. Deliverable/activity Indicative time frame
Final
Five working days after
providing the draft poverty
profile
3.2 The following table summarises the deliverables and the proposed time line for phase II :
Draft
12. Preparation offinal poverty
profile report
A meeting would be held between
the Consultant representatives,
the Client and Civil Society
representatives to brief the same
about preliminary results. The
comments objections and
observations raised in this
meeting would be incorporated
in the final output.
Ten working days after providing
preliminary results (post comments)
SI. No. Deliverable/activity Indicative time frame
Final Draft
1. (a) Listing of issues to be
addressed in the poverty
reduction strategy
Two weeks after submission of the
poverty profile
A meeting would be held between
the Consultant representatives,
the Client and Civil Society
representatives to discuss and build
consensus on the issues and SWOT
panameters. The comments,
objections and observations
raised in this meeting would be
incorporated in the final outputs.
One week after the acceptance of
the issues and SWOT parameters
(b) SWOT analysis of the
poverty situation
2. Approach and strategy for
poverty reduction
3. Listing of projects and log
frame for poverty reduction
action plan
Final report for poverty
reduction strategy
Two weeks after acceptance of
approach and strategy
4. One week from the receipt of
acceptance of the Client of project
listing and log frame
One week from issue of
the meeting.
One week after
preparation of draft and
comment of the Client on
the same
Five working days after
comments of the Client
on the same
One week after comments
of the client on the same
Published and printed by Directorate of Printing-176/2011-DoP-250+ Secy (UD)-100-5-2011.
Published and printed by Directorate of Printing-420/2011-Director (Town Planning)-200-10-2011.
Previous and next
All provisions of THE ARUNACHAL PRADESH URBAN POVERTY PROFILING AND STRATEGIC PLANS RULES, 2011
Questions people ask
Is annexure 1 of THE ARUNACHAL PRADESH URBAN POVERTY PROFILING AND STRATEGIC PLANS RULES, 2011 still in force?
No repeal of the ARUNACHAL PRADESH URBAN POVERTY PROFILING AND STRATEGIC PLANS RULES, 2011 is recorded.