Form V, The West Bengal Cooperative Societies Rules, 2011: Form V
The West Bengal Cooperative Societies Rules, 2011 - Form V
Text of form V
Form V.
Form V.
(v) Register of miscellaneous letters received, in Form VI.
(vi) Minute book for the meetings of the Council.
154. Co-operative Election Commission
(1) The Co-operative Election commission shall hold meetings for the purpose of
fixing general or particular guidelines and rules of business for holding of
elections of all registered co-operative societies in West Bengal;
Provided that the Board of all registered cooperative societies shall furnish the
commission such papers, information which the Commission may require from
time to time.
(2) The Co-operative Election commissioner appointed under section 96 shall be paid
in respect of time spent on actual service, salary and allowances, last drawn by
him where he is a retired officer and his usual salary and allowances where he is
a serving officer, provided that if the person appointed as the Co-operative
Election Commissioner is in receipt of pension (other than disability or wound
pension), his salary shall be reduced by the amount of that pension and if he has,
before such appointment received any sum in lieu of a portion of the pension, his
salary shall be reduced by the amount of that portion of the pension, and the
pension equivalent to gratuity.
(3) The salaries, allowances, retirement benefits and the terms and conditions of
service (including conduct, discipline and control) of officers and other
employees of the Commission shall be such as that of the employees of the State
86
Government. Such salaries, allowances etc. and expenses of the Commission
shall be defrayed out of the consolidated fund of the State.
(4) As provided under sub-section (7) of section 96, the Cooperative Election
Commission shall have the following staff
(a) One Secretary in the rank of Joint Registrar of Cooperative Societies;
(b) One Deputy Secretary in the rank of Deputy Registrar of Cooperative
Societies;
(c) One Assistant Secretary in the rank of Assistant Registrar of Cooperative
Societies;
(d) One officer in the rank of Cooperative Development Officer;
(e) One officer in the rank of Cooperative Inspector;
(f) One Upper Division Assistant;
(g) Two Lower Division Assistants with knowledge in computer science;
(h) One Stenographer with knowledge in computer science;
(i) One Typist with knowledge in computer science; and
(j) Two peons:
Provided that the State Government shall have the power toincrease or decrease
the number of the officers and other employees of the commission in consultation with
the Chairman of the Commission and expenses of the commission shall be defrayed
out of the Consolidated Fund of the State.
(5) (a) The Zonal Joint Registrar or the Deputy Registrar and all officers of
his office shall respectively be ex-officio Returning Officer and Assistant
Returning Officer in the case of election of all Apex and Central Cooperative
Societies.
(b) The range officer of the Directorate of Cooperation and all officers of
his range shall respectively be ex-officio Returning Officer and Assistant
Returning Officer in the case of election of all Primary Cooperative Societies.
( c) The Commission shall issue order appointing Returning Officer,
Assistant Returning Officer and such other Polling Personnel as may be
required to conduct election of cooperatives from the officers and employees
of the Directorate of Cooperation.
87
CHAPTER X
Audit Inspection and Inquiry
155. Preparation of Panel of Auditors
For preparation of panel of Auditors under section 97. the State Government or the
Director of Co-operative Audit with the approval of the State Government shall invite
application from amongst the eligible persons which shall include the members of the
Institute of Cost and Works Accountant of India constituted under the Cost and Works
Accountant Act 1959, and members of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India both
having Certificate of Practice issued by the respective Institutions. Such panel of auditors
shall be prepared from the members of above named two Institutions by obtaining
applications from them as provided under sub-section (1)(b) of section 97 through
advertisement in at least one State level daily newspaper on such terms and conditions as
may be decided by the State Government and upon receiving such applications, such panel
shall be finalized by a Committee constituted by the State Government from time to time.
155A. Audit under clause (b) of sub-section (1) of section 97 of the Act
Audit under clause (b ) of sub-section (1) of section 97 of the Act shall include the
following:-
(a) examination of over due debts, if any;
(b) verification of cash balance, securities and fund investment;
(c) valuation of assets and liabilities of the cooperative and calculation of
depreciation of assets;
(d) verification of the balance at the credit of the depositors and creditors and the
amount due from the debtors of the cooperative;
(e) examination of the statements of accounts to be prepared by the cooperative
society in Form XXX or in such other form as may be provided by any law;;
(f) examination of the stocks and purchases and checking of the entries in the
stock register, purchase register and godown register with challans, invoices
and delivery orders etc.;
(g) checking of the entry of the cash book with all vouchers and checking of the
propriety of the vouchers;
(h) verification of closing balance together with reconciliation between stock
balance as per stock registers and figures found on physical verification;
(i) ascertainment of overdue loans and overdue interest together with year wise
classification of overdue loan at the end of the cooperative year;
88
(j) examination of the provisions of overdue interest in suspense;
(k) examination of the non-performing assets and year wise classification of the
same;
(l) examination of the provisions made in account in regard to the non-
performing assets as per directive of the Reserve Bank of India;
(m) examination of proper appropriation and investment of different statutory
funds;
(n) An examination of the monitory transactions including the propriety of the
transactions; and
(o) any other matter as the Director of Cooperative Audit may by order specify.
155B. Annual Audit, Monthly Running Audit, Concurrent Audit, Re-Audit etc
An audit under clause (b) of sub-section (1) of section 97 of the Act, shall include
annual audit, monthly running audit, concurrent audit, re-audit and other matters as
decided by the State Government.
156. Audit Fees
(1) A Co-operative Society shall pay audit fee calculated on the working capital on the
last day of the co-operative year for which the audit fee will be due.
(2) The fees for annual audit shall be calculated at the following rates, namely: -
(i) Where the working capital does
not exceed one lakh rupees
At the rate of five rupees for every one
thousand rupees or part thereof subject to a
minimum of one hundred rupees.
(ii)
Where the working capital
exceeds one lakh but does not
exceed fifty lakh rupees
five hundred rupees plus at the rate of
eighty rupees for every one lakh rupees or
part thereof on the amount exceeding one
lakh rupees.
(iii) Where the working capital
exceeds fifty lakhs rupees but
does not exceed one crore rupees
Four thousand five hundred rupees plus
at the rate of eighty rupees for every one
lakh rupees or part thereof on the amount
exceeding fifty lakh rupees.
(iv)
Where the working capital
exceeds one crore rupees but does
not exceed one hundred crore
rupees
Nine thousand four hundred rupees plus at
the rate of one hundred rupees for every
one crore rupees or part thereof on the
amount exceeding one crore rupees.
(v)
Where the working capital
exceeds one hundred crore rupees
Nineteen thousand three hundred rupees
plus at the rate of seventy five rupees for
every one crore rupees or part thereof on
the amount exceeding one hundred crore
rupees.
89
(3) In the case of a Housing Co-operative, the audit fee shall be assessed at the rate of
rupees thirty per member subject to a minimum of five hundred rupees.
(4) In the case of a Co-operative which is under process of being dissolved, the audit
fee shall be assessed at the rate of one percent of the realised assets of the co-operative
during the co-operative year for which the accounts are audited.
(5) In the case of West Bengal State Co-operative Union and all of district co-operative
Unions and other non-trading promotional bodies, audit fee shall be five paise for every one
hundred rupees of annual subscription received during the co-operative year from the
members subject to minimum of the hundred rupees.
(6) In addition to audit fees mentioned under this rule, an additional amount of twenty five
percent of audit fees shall be payable for monthly running audit in the case of the co-
operative society mentioned in clause (a) of sub-section (2) of section 97 and an additional
amount of ten percent for each branch of the co-operative.
Provided that the audit fee payable for concurrent audit, cost and performance audit
and internal audit shall be determined by settlement between the audit Officer and the
Director of Co-operative Audit or the co-operative society, as the case may be.
157. Payment of audit Fees
(1) Where the audit of the accounts of a co-operative society is conducted by a
Departmental Officer, the audit fees shall be deposited, within a period of three
months from the date of submission of the audit report, in the nearest Treasury or
the sub-treasury, as the case may be, under the appropriate receipt head of the State
Government and one copy of receipted challan shall be submitted to the Director of
Cooperative Audit by the cooperative society.
(2) Where the accounts of a society are audited by an Audit Officer, not being a
Departmental Officer, the audit fee shall be paid, within a period of three months
from the date of submission of the audit report, direct to such audit officer upon
proper receipt, if no objection is filed before the Registrar about audit report in the
meantime.
(3) Audit fees payable by a society shall be recoverable as Government dues and, if not
paid within the time fixed, may be recovered as an arrear of land revenue .
Provided that immediately after the audit report has been received by the society, the
Audit Officer shall get a sum not exceeding fifty percent of the audit fee payable
under sub-rule ( 2 ) of rule 156.
90
158. Audit Report
(1) The audit report referred to in sub-section (1) of section 98 shall state –
(a) Whether any of the transactions appears to him to be contrary to law or any
direction of the Registrar;
(b) Whether every sum which ought to have been but has not been brought into
account;
(c) Whether the amount of any deficiency or loss which appears to have resulted
from any negligence or misconduct, requires further investigation;
(d) Whether any money or property (including stock) belonging to the society
appears to have been misappropriated or fraudulently retained by any
person;
(e) Whether any asset appears to him to be a non-performing asset or bad or
doubtful;
(f) Whether or not the Audit Officer has obtained all the information and
explanations required by him;
(g) Whether or not, in his opinion, the balance sheet and the profit and loss
account referred to in the report are drawn up in conformity with the law;
(h) Whether or not such balance sheet exhibits a fair account of the state of the
society‟s affairs according to the best of his information and the explanation
given to him and as shown by the books of the society;
(i) Whether, in his opinion, books and accounts have been kept by the society as
required under the Act, the rules, the bye-laws and the directions of the Registrar
(if any);
(j) Whether there has been any material impropriety or irregularity in the
expenditure or in the realization of moneys due to the society.
(2) Where any of the matters referred to in sub-rule (1) is answered in the negative or in
the affirmative with any remarks, the report shall state the reason for such answer with facts
and figures in support of such reason.
(3) The audit report shall also include (a) certification of realized profits, (b) merit rating
of Co-operative Societies in such form as the Director may approve and ( c) his suggestions
for improvement of the working of the society.
159. Assessment of Audit Fee on Co-operative Society
Audit fee shall be assessed by the Director of Co-operative Audit –
91
(i) In the case of a working Primary Agricultural Co-operative which is a
member of a Central Co-operative Bank or is financed by a nationalized Commercial Bank
or Gramin Bank upon such Bank;
(ii) In the case of any other Co-operative, upon the Co-operative Society.
160. Exemption and Remission of Audit Fees
(1) All Students‟ Consumers Co-operative and Students‟ Health Co-operative shall be
exempted from payment of audit fees.
(2) All types of Women Co-operative shall be exempted for five years after registration
of the Co-operative from payment of audit fees.
(3) The Director of Co-operative Audit may, at his discretion, remit by order either
wholly or in part audit fee payable by non-working co-operative and the co-
operative having no income at all during the co-operative year.
(4) Audit of Co-operative Education Fund shall be conducted by Departmental Audit
Officer and audit fees shall be two thousand five hundred rupees.
161. Procedure of Audit
(1) Unless the Director of Cooperative Audit directs otherwise, the audit of a Co-
operative society shall be conducted in the registered office of the society and at the
branches and pay offices, if any.
(2) Previous intimation shall be given to the cooperative society before the audit is
commenced:
Provided that verification of cash balance, and securities may be carried out without
any previous intimation to the society.
(3) The officers and other employees of the society shall give the Audit Officers all
assistance necessary for the completion of the audit, and for this purpose in particular,
prepare such statements and take such action with regard to the verification or
examination of its accounts, as he may require.
162. Audit objections
While conducting the statutory audit of a co-operative society under sub- section (12) of
section 97 of the Act, the Audit officer may issue, from time to time during audit, interim
objections to the Secretary of the society or to the officer performing the duties of the
Secretary for compliance or explaining the defects and irregularities pointed out in such
objections within a period not exceeding seven days. The secretary or the officer performing
the duties of the Secretary, as the case may be, shall return the interim objection sheets with
the compliance report to the Audit Officer within the time specified by the Audit Officer.
92
The Audit Officer shall review the compliance report and waive such objections which, in
his opinion, have been complied with satisfactorily and shall incorporate the remaining
objections in the audit report.
163. Writing off Assets and Bad Debts
(1) Subject to approval of the Registrar, any debt or dues or any asset considered bad
shall be written off by the general meeting in the order below against -
(a) the bad debt fund, or any fund created out of profits as provision for non-
performing assets or bad debts, as certified by the audit officer;
(b) any other fund created out of profits but not earmarked for any specific purpose;
and
(c) the reserve fund constituted under the Act.
(2) Where the society is a member of a financing Bank and is indebted to it, the Registrar
shall consult the financing bank before sanctioning the writing off of any debt or
amount due.
164. Submission of special report by Audit Officer
When an Audit Officer notices in course of his audit that there exist a case of serious
irregularity such as misappropriation, embezzlement of funds or pilferage of stocks,
violation of provisions of law, he shall intimate such irregularities to the concerned society
and to the Registrar through Proper Channel in a sealed cover marked to the concerned
society and “confidential” as expeditiously as possible for such action as the Registrar may
consider expedient.
165. Form of Audit Statements
The statements of accounts shall be prepared by the Board in Form XXX or in such other
form as the Registrar may approve.
165A. Seizure of books and documents by the
Inspecting Officer or Inquiring Officer
As provided under sections 99 and 100 of the Act, an Inspecting Officer or Inquiry
Officer, as the case may be, during inspection or inquiry, may seize any book or document
of the cooperative society from its office as may be required by him in the interest of the
inspection or inquiry by preparing two copies of seizure list taking at least one witness and
hand over one copy to an officer or employee of the cooperative society obtaining a receipt.
93
CHAPTER XI
Settlement of Disputes
166. Reference of a dispute
A dispute to be filed before the Registrar shall be made in writing to be called the plaint
and shall, inter alia, contain –
(a) the names, description and addresses of the parties,
(b) a statement of the subject of disputes alongwith copies of documents to be relied upon,
(c) the facts constituting the cause of action and when it arose,
(d) the relief prayed for, and
(e) in a dispute relating to recovery of money, a statement of the subject matter of the
dispute for the purpose of determination of fees for filing a dispute:
Provided that the plaint shall be accompanied by as many its copies as the number of
defendants.
167. Filing of dispute
For filing a dispute under section 102 the petitioner shall in addition to the provision
contained under rule 166 have to follow the procedure under that section.
168. Persons qualified to be appointed as Arbitrators
(1) An arbitrator or Arbitrators may be nominated or appointed from –
(a) officers and retired officers of Department of Cooperation, Government of
West Bengal,
(b) officers of apex and Central Co-operatives,
(c) members of local body,
(d) chartered engineers,
(e) chartered accounts or cost accounts,
(f) advocates,
(g) any Co-operator having experience of holding office of the Director of any
Apex or Central Co-operative Society.
94
169. Disposal of Disputes
The disputes required to be disposed of under chapter XI of the Act shall be decided
as per the provisions contained in these rules subject to the provisions contained in the Act.
170. Procedure for disposal of disputes
(1) For settlement of a dispute, under sub-sections (1), (2) and (3) of section 103, the Board
of Arbitrators or the forum of Arbitrators or the arbitrator, as the case may be, shall –
(a) fix the date, hour and place of hearing of the dispute and
(b) have power to allow representation by agent, guardian or next friends.
(2) The Board of Arbitrators, forum of Arbitrators or the Arbitrator, as the case may be,
shall issue summons or notice, at least, 15 (fifteen) days before the date fixed for
hearing of the dispute to the plaintiff and the defendant requiring them to attend with
all relevant books, documents, witnesses and evidence relating to the dispute.
Provided that the summons or notice which shall be served upon the defendant shall
contain a copy of the plaint.
(3) First and subsequent summonses or notices may be served on a party to the dispute or
his agent or any, adult member of the family -
(a) by registered post with acknowledgement due or
(b) by affixing a copy of the summons or notice on the outer door or some other
conspicuous part of the last known place of residence or business of the party,
when he refuses to sign the acknowledgement or he cannot be traced out even
after adequate search.
(4) Service of summon or notice on the Chairman, the Secretary or the Chief Executive of
the Co-operative Society by whatever designation known, shall be regarded as service
on the Co-operative.
(5) Where the serving officer delivers or tenders a copy of the summons or notice
personally to the addressee or to an agent or other person on his behalf, he shall require
the signature of the person to whom the copy is so delivered or tendered, endorsed on
the original summons or notice as an acknowledgement of service.
(6) The serving officer shall, in all cases in which the summons or notice has been served
under clause (b) of sub-rule (3), cause to be endorsed on, or annexed to, the original
summons or notice, return stating the time when and the manner in which the
summons or notice, was served, and the name, signature and address of the person, if
95
any, identifying the person concerned and witnessing the delivery or tender of the
summons or notice.
(7) The sufficiency of proof of service of the summons or notice shall be decided by the
person who issued the same.
(8) (a) After summons or notice has been duly served, if on the date of hearing the plaintiff
is absent, the case shall be dismissed for default and if the defendant is absent, the case
may be decided ex parte.
(b) Where both the parties are present, the case shall proceed and the defendant shall
submit on the first date of hearing a written statement alongwith copies of documents
to be relied upon. A copy of the written statement shall be served upon the plaintiff on
or before the date of appearance and hearing.
(9) Each party may inspect the documents of the other party for verification with the
original.
(10) The Board of Arbitrators or forum of Arbitrators or the Arbitrator as the case may be,
may, at any time, during pendency of the dispute, order the production by any party of
such of the documents in his possession or power relating to any matter in question in
such dispute.
(11) The Board of Arbitrators or forum of Arbitrators or the Arbitrator, as the case may be,
may permit to call, either by summoning or otherwise, any witness to give evidence or
produce documents. A party may cross-examine witnesses of the other party.
Provided that the Board of Arbitrators or forum of Arbitrators or Arbitrators shall also
have power to recall any witness to give further evidence or to produce any specific
documents.
(12) The Board of Arbitrators or Forum of Arbitrators or the Arbitrator, as the case may be,
may invite any technical expert or any Audit officer to give opinion on any technical
matter.
(13) Where an Arbitrator, due to transfer, retirement or other cause is prevented to conclude
the settlement of a dispute, the Successor-Arbitrator may deal with the case from the
stage at which his predecessor left it.
(14) The Board of Arbitrators or Forum of Arbitrators or the Arbitrator, as the case may be,
shall give the parties to the dispute due opportunity of hearing and shall make a
96
memorandum of the statements of parties who attend and such witnesses as are
examined and cross examined and such opinion of the technical experts and record the
proceeding in writing.
171. Award or decision
(1) After conclusion of hearing of the case, the Board of Arbitrators or Forum of
Arbitrators or the Arbitrator, as the case may be, on examination of evidence on record
and on consideration of arguments – oral or written, if any, as advanced by the parties,
shall make a reasoned award in writing under his signature with date in accordance
with justice, equity and good conscience.
(2) The award shall contain the number of the reference, the names and description of the
parties and particulars of the dispute, and shall specify –
(a) the relief granted;
(b) the amount decreed;
(c) the interest including future interest, if any, allowed; and
(d) the cost awarded, if any, indicating the party or parties liable to pay
the decretal amount or the cost or both and the manner of payment of
thereof.
(3) An award may be made at once or on a date to be fixed within 15 (fifteen) days from
the date of conclusion of hearing with due notice to the parties,. It shall be
communicated to the parties –
(b) by pronouncement of the award before them and taking their signatures on the
order sheet as acknowledgement or making endorsement himself about the
communication when a party refuses to sign;
(c) by registered post with acknowledgement due to a party who may be absent on
such date.
Provided that it shall be sufficient if the particulars at clauses (a), (b), (c ) and (d) of
sub- rule (2) are read out and it shall not be necessary to read out the whole award.
172. Amendment of award, order, etc.
(1) If there are any clerical or typographical or arithmetical mistakes in the award or any
interim order or errors arising therein from any accidental slip or omission, the same
97
may be corrected by the Board of Arbitrators or forum of Arbitrators or the Arbitrator,
as the case may be, either of its or his own motion or on the application of any of the
parties. Such application shall be made within 15 days from the date of award or
order.
(2) Any amendment made under sub- rule (1) shall be communicated to all parties.
(3) An award once made and signed cannot afterwards be altered or added to save as
provided under sub-rule (1) even with the consent of the parties.
173. Withdrawal of reference by the Registrar
The Registrar may withdraw the reference from the Arbitrators and may decide the
dispute himself or may make fresh appointment of an arbitrator or arbitrators on one or
more of the following grounds :
(a) on an application stating reasons by any party to a pending arbitration
proceedings;
(b) on the application of an Arbitrator not being a Government Officer;
(c) in case of transfer of suspension or dismissal or resignation of the arbitrator
or any of the arbitrators where he is a Government officer.
174. Execution of decision or award
(1) For sums payable under an award in any dispute, recovery shall be made in the
manner specified under section 143 and the Second Schedule as a Public demand
upon requisition of the awardees.
(2) Decision of award in a dispute not involving any sum, shall, upon application by
the awardee, be enforceable by any civil court having local jurisdiction in the
same manner as a decree of such court as if it were a decree of such court.
175. Disposal of record
(1) The original records of a dispute proceedings, after the decision or award has been
delivered, shall be kept in such place and manner as the Registrar may direct.
(1) Any document or record filed by a party may, on application, be returned to the party
after the disposal of the appeal, if any, or after the expiry of the period of limitation for
preferring appeal if no appeal has been preferred.
98
176. Certified copy
(1) A certified copy of an order, decision or award or evidence of the parties shall, on
application, be given to a party by the Registrar duly certified by him typed in
double spaces.
(2) On receipt of an application for certified copy of order, decision or award, the
applicant shall forthwith, or on a date to be given to him instantly, be intimated
about the requisites required to be supplied by him.
(3) If the requisites are not supplied within seven days from the date of intimation,
the application for certified copy shall be rejected and thereafter the party may
obtain certified copy of filing fresh application.
(4) The certified copy shall be supplied, as far as practicable, within two weeks from
the date on which the requisites are supplied.
(5) It will be for the party applying for certified copy to collect the same and if he
wants it to be sent by post, then it shall be deemed to have been delivered to him
on the date on which the certified copy is sent by post.
99
CHAPTER - XII
Dissolution of Co-operative Societies
177. Order for dissolution of a Co-operative Society
(1) When the Registrar passes an order under section 106 directing the
dissolution of a Co-operative Society, he shall –
(a) publish the order in such manner in the locality as he may think
fit;
(b) communicate the order to the society by registered post with
acknowledgement due or through a messenger; and
(c) send a copy of the order to the concerned cooperative society to
which it is affiliated and the financing bank, if any, by registered
post with acknowledgement due or through a messenger.
(2) The notice under sub-section (1) of section 106 shall be in Form XXXI.
178. Appointment or removal of Liquidator
(1) Where no liquidator is appointed under section 110, the Registrar shall take
appropriate steps for dissolution of the affairs of the society as per the provisions
contained in the Act.
(2) The financial statement under sub-section ( 10) of section 111 shall be in
Previous and next
All provisions of The West Bengal Cooperative Societies Rules, 2011
Questions people ask
Is form V of the West Bengal Cooperative Societies Rules, 2011 still in force?
No repeal of the West Bengal Cooperative Societies Rules, 2011 is recorded.