Rule 19, State Human Rights Commission Service Rules, 2005: Penalties
State Human Rights Commission Service Rules, 2005 - Rule 19
Text of rule 19
Penalties
19. Penalties.—The following penalties may, for good and sufficient reason and as
hereinafter provided, be imposed upon every person who is member of the service in the
Commission and every person holding a post under the Commission specified in Rule 7,
namely:—
(i) Censure
(ii) Fine (in the case of persons in Section II of Division III under Rule 7 of these rules)
(iii) Withholding of increments or promotion:
Provided that in cases where the punishment of withholding of increments cannot be given
effect to fully, the monetary value equivalent to the amount of increments ordered to be withheld
for the unexpired period of the punishment, shall be recovered from the person:
Provided further that in cases of stoppage of increment with cumulative effect, the
monetary value equivalent to three times the amount of increments ordered to be withheld, may
be recovered:
Provided also that the penalty of withholding of increments shall not be imposed on a
person when no increments are to be earned by such person before the date of superannuation:
Provided also that the recovery of monetary value equivalent to withholding of increments
shall be resorted to only in cases where the punishment of withholding of increment cannot be
implemented fully consequent on the promotion of the person to a higher post prior to imposition
of the punishment.
(iv) Reduction to a lower rank in the seniority list or to a lower post not being lower than
that to which he was directly recruited, whether in the same Division or in another Division, or to
a lower time-scale, not being lower than that to which he was directly recruited, or to a lower
stage in a time-scale:
Provided that in cases where the punishment of reduction to a lower stage in a time-scale
cannot be given effect to fully, the monetary value equivalent to the difference in emoluments as
a result of reduction to such lower stage in the time-scale for the unexpired period of the
punishment shall be recovered from the person;
(v) Recovery from pay of the whole or part of any pecuniary loss caused to the
Commission or the State Government or the Central Government or to any Government
Company or Organization or Local Authority or to a local body, while on deputation by
negligence or breach of orders;
(vi) Compulsory retirement;
(vii) Removal from the service of the Commission;
(viii) Dismissal from the service of the Commission; and
(ix) Suspension, where a person has already been suspended under Rule 25(e) to the
extent considered necessary by the authority imposing the penalty.
The penalties mentioned in items (i) to (iii), (v) and (ix) will be deemed to be minor
penalties and those in (iv), (vi), (vi) to (viii), as a major penalties.
The penalties mentioned in items {vi), (vii) or (viii), as the case may be, shall be imposed
on the member of service in the Commission for the violation of Rule 19 of the Tamil Nadu
Government Servants' Conduct Rules, 1973.
Explanation I.—The discharge—
(i) of a person appointed on probation before the expiry or at the end of the prescribed or
extended period of probation, or
(ii) of a person appointed otherwise than under contract to hold a temporary appointment
on the expiration of the period of the appointment, does not amount to the removal or dismissal
within the meaning of this rule.
Explanation II.—The following shall not amount to a penalty within the meaning of this rule,
namely:—
(i) non-promotion of a member of the service in Commission, whether in a substantive or
officiating capacity, after consideration of his case, to a Division or Category for promotion to
which he is eligible;
(ii) reversion of member of the service in Commission officiating in a higher Division or
Category to a lower Division or Category on the ground that he is considered to be unsuitable for
such higher Division or Category or on any administrative ground unconnected with his conduct;
(iii) reversion of member of the service in Commission, appointed on probation to any other
Division or Category to his permanent service, grade or post during or at the end of the period of
probation in accordance with the terms of his appointment or to the rules and orders governing
such probation;
(iv) replacement of the service of a member of the service in Commission, whose services
had been borrowed from a State Government or the Central Government or an authority under
the control of a State Government or the Central Government at the disposal of the State
Government or the Central Government or the authority from which the services of such member
of the service in Commission had been borrowed; and
(v) compulsory retirement of a member of the service in Commission in accordance with the
provisions relating to superannuation or retirement;
Explanation III.—The removal of person from the Commission shall not disqualify him from future
employment but the dismissal of a person from the service of the Commission shall ordinarily
disqualify him from future employment.
20. (1) The Governor or any other authority empowered by him by general or special order
may—
(i) initiate disciplinary proceedings against any member of the service in Commission;
(ii) direct a disciplinary authority to initiate disciplinary proceedings against any member
of the service in Commission on whom that disciplinary authority is competent to impose under
these rules any of the penalties specified in rule 20.
(2) The authority competent under these rules to impose any of the penalties specified in
items (i) to (iii) and (v) of rule 19 may initiate disciplinary proceedings against any member of the
service in Commission for the imposition of any of the penalties specified in items (iv) and (vi) to
(viii) of the rule 20, notwithstanding the fact that such authority is not competent under these
rules to impose any of the latter mentioned penalties.
21. In any case where more than one member of the service in the Commission are involved,
the authority competent to initiate disciplinary proceedings and impose any of the penalties
specified in rule 19 shall be the authority in respect of the member of the service in Commission
who holds the highest category and the disciplinary proceedings against all of them shall be
taken together.
22. (a) (1) The authority, which may impose suspension referred to in rule 25(e) or penalties
specified in rule 19 on a member of service in the Commission shall be the appointing authority or
any higher authority:
Provided that in the case of person appointed to the service by any authority higher than
the appointing authority, the penalties mentioned in clause (iii) relating to withholding of
promotion and in clauses (iv), (vi), (vii) and (viii) in rule 19 shall not be imposed by any authority
subordinate to such higher authority;
(2) The authority who may impose the minor and major penalties mentioned in rule 19
on the members of the service in the Commission are specified in Schedule III to these rules.
(b)Where in any case a higher authority has imposed or declined to impose a penalty
under this rule, a lower authority shall have no Jurisdiction to proceed under this rule in respect of
the same case.
(c) The fact that lower authority has imposed or declined to impose a penalty in any case
shall not debar a higher authority from exercising his jurisdiction under this rule in respect of the
same case.
(d)The order of higher authority imposing or declining to impose in any case a penalty
under this rule shall supersede any order passed by a lower authority in respect of the same
case.
(e)The fact that a lower authority has dropped a charge against a person as not proved
shall not debar a higher authority from reviving it, or reasons to be recorded in writing and taking
suitable action on the charged so revived.
(f) Where, on promotion or transfer, a member of service holding a category in a Division is
holding an appointment in another category thereof or in another Division no penalty shall be
imposed upon him in respect of his work or conduct before such promotion or transfer except by
an authority competent to impose the penalty upon a member of the service in the latter Category
or Division, as the case may be.
(g)Where a person has been reverted or reduced from one Division to another Division or
one Category to another Category, no penalty shall be imposed upon him in respect of his work
or conduct while he was a member of the service in the Division or category, as the case may be,
from which he was reverted or reduced except by an authority competent to impose the penalty
upon a member of such service in the Division or category, as the case may be.
23. (1) Where an order of suspension is made or a disciplinary proceeding is conducted
against a person whose services have been borrowed from any Company, Corporation,
Organization, Autonomous Boards or other authority, the authority lending his services
(hereinafter in this rule referred to as the "the lending authority") shall forthwith be informed of the
circumstances leading to the order of the suspension of the member of the service in
Commission or of the commencement of the disciplinary proceedings, as the case may be;
(2) In the light of the findings in the disciplinary proceeding conducted against the member
of the service in Commission if the disciplinary authority is of the opinion that any of the penalties
specified in clause (i) to (iii) and (v) of rule 19 should be imposed on him it may after consultation
with the lending authority pass such orders on the case, as it may deem necessary:
Provided that in the event of a difference of opinion between the borrowing authority and
the lending authority, the services of the member of the service in Commission shall be replaced
at the disposal of the lending authority:
Provided further that if the borrowing authority is of the opinion that any of the penalties
specified in items (iv) and (vi) to (viii) of rule 19 should be imposed on the member of the service
in Commission, it shall replace the services of such member of the service in Commission at the
disposal of the lending authority and transmit it to the proceedings of the inquiry for such action,
as it may deem necessary.
24. (a) in every case where it is proposed to impose on a member of service in Commission
or a person holding a category under the Commission, any of the penalties specified in items (i),
(ii), (iii), (v) and (ix) in rule 19, he shall be given a reasonable opportunity of making any
representation that he may desire to make and such representation, if any, shall be taken into
consideration before the order imposing the penalty is passed:
Provided that the requirements of the sub-rule shall not apply where it is proposed to
impose on a member of a service in Commission, any of the penalties aforesaid on the basis of
facts which have led to his conviction by a court martial or where the officer concerned has
absconded or where it is for other reason impracticable to communicate with him:
Provided further that, in every case where it is proposed, after considering the
representation, if any, made by the member of the service in Commission to withhold increment
of pay and such withholding of increments is likely to affect adversely the amount of pension
payable to the member of the service in Commission or to withhold increments of pay without
cumulative effect for a period exceeding three years or to withhold increment of pay with
cumulative effect for any period of the procedure laid down in sub-rule (b) shall be followed
before making any orders imposing on the member of the service in Commission any such
penalty.
(b)(i) Without prejudice to the provisions of the Public Servants' Inquiries Act, 1850
(Central Act XXXVII of 1850), in every case where it is proposed to impose on a member of a
service on a person holding a post in the Commission, any of the penalties specified in items (iv),
(vi), (vii) and (viii) in rule 19 the grounds on which it is proposed to take action shall be reduced to
the form of a definite charge or charges, which shall be communicated to the person charged,
together with a statement of the allegation, on which each charge is based and of any other
circumstances which it is proposed to take into consideration in passing orders on the case. He
shall be required, within a reasonable time to put in a return statement of his defence and to state
whether he desires an oral inquiry or to be head in person or both. An oral inquiry shall be held if
such an inquiry is desired by the person charged or is directed by the authority concerned. Even
if a person charged has waived an oral inquiry, such inquiry shall be held by the authority
concerned in respect of charges which are not admitted by the person charged and which can be
proved only through the evidence of witnesses. At that inquiry, oral evidence shall be heard as to
such of the allegations as are not admitted, and the person charged shall be entitled to cross-
examine the witnesses to give evidence in person and to have such witnesses called as he may
wish, provided that the officer conducting the inquiry may, for special and sufficient reason to be
recorded in writing, refuse to call a witness. Whether or not the person charged desired for an
oral inquiry he shall be heard in person at any stage if he so desires before passing of final
orders. A report of the inquiry or personal hearing, as the case may be, shall be prepared by the
authority holding the inquiry or personal hearing whether or not such authority is competent to
impose the penalty. Such report shall contain a sufficient record of the evidence, if any, and a
statement of the findings and the grounds thereof; Whenever any inquiry authority, after having
heard and recorded the whole or any part of the evidence in any inquiry ceases to exercise
jurisdiction thereon and is succeeded by another inquiring authority which has, and which
exercise such jurisdiction, the inquiring authority so succeeding may act on the evidence so
recorded by its predecessor; or partly recorded by its predecessor and partly recorded by itself:
Provided that if the succeeding inquiring authority is of the opinion that further examination
of any of the witness whose evidence has already been recorded is necessary in the interest of
justice, it may recall, examine, cross-examine and re-examine any such witnesses as herein
before, provided:
Provided further that the member of the service in Commission may take the assistance of
any retired member of the service in Commission to present the case on his behalf, but may not
engage a legal practitioner for the purpose unless the inquiring authority is a legal practitioner or
the inquiring authority, having regard to the circumstances of the case, so permits.
Explanation.—A member of the service in Commission shall not take the assistance of any
retired member of the service in Commission, who has two pending disciplinary cases on hand,
in which he has to give assistance.
(ii) After the inquiry or personal hearing referred to in clause (i) has been completed,
the authority competent to impose the penalty specified in that clause is of the opinion, on the
basis of the evidence adduced during the inquiry, that any of the penalties specified in rule 19
should be imposed on the person charged, it shall, before making an order imposing such
penalty, furnish to him a copy of the report of the inquiry or personal hearing or both, as the case
may be, and call upon him to submit his further representation, if any, within a reasonable time,
not exceeding fifteen days. Any representation received in this behalf within the period shall be
taken into consideration before making any order imposing the penalty, provided that such
representation shall be based on the evidence adduced during the inquiry only. It shall not be
necessary to give the person charged any opportunity of making representation on the penalty
proposed to be imposed;
(c) (i) (1) The requirements of sub-rule (b) shall not apply where it is proposed to impose
on a member of a service in Commission any such penalty as is referred to clause (i) of that sub-
rule on the basis of facts which have led to his conviction in a criminal court (whether or not he
has been sentenced at once by such court to any punishment); but he shall be given a
reasonable opportunity of making any representation that he may desire to make such
representation if any, shall be taken into consideration before the order imposing the penalty is
passed.
(2) The requirements of sub-rule (b) shall not apply where it is proposed to impose
on a member of a service in Commission, any of the penalties mentioned in rule 19 on the basis
of facts which have led to his conviction by a court martial or where the officer concerned has
absconded or where it is for other reasons impracticable to communicate with him.
(ii) The provisions of sub-rule (b) shall not apply where the Governor is satisfied that in
the interest of the security of the State it is not expedient to follow the procedure prescribed in
that sub-rule.
(d) (i) All or any of the provisions of sub-rules (a) and (b) may, in exceptional cases, for
special and sufficient reasons to be recorded in writing, be waived where there is difficulty in
observing exactly the requirements of the sub-rules and those requirements can be waived
without injustice to the person charged.
(ii) if any question arises whether it is reasonably practicable to follow the procedure
prescribed in sub-rule (b), the decision thereon of the authority empowered to dismiss or remove
such person or reduce him in rank, as the case may be, shall be final.
(iii) The procedure prescribed in sub-rule (b) shall be followed also in the case of person
appointed or promoted under rule 18 and those paid from contingencies provided the termination
of appointment is made as a measure of punishment.
(e) (1) a member of a service in Commission may be placed under suspension from
service, where—
(i) an enquire into grave charges against him is contemplated, or is pending; or
(ii) a complaint against him, of any criminal offence is under investigation or trial
and if such suspension is necessary in the public interest.
(2) A member of the service in Commission, who is detained in custody whether on a
criminal charge or otherwise, for a period longer than forty-eight hours shall be deemed to have
been suspended under this rule.
(3) Where a penalty of dismissal, removal or compulsory retirement from service
imposed upon a member of the service in Commission under suspension is set aside in appeal or
on review/revision under these rules and the case is remitted for further inquiry or action or with
any other directions, the order of his suspension shall be deemed to have continued in force on
and from the date of the original order of dismissal, removal or compulsory retirement and shall
remain in force until further orders.
(4) Where a penalty of dismissal, removal or compulsory retirement from service
imposed upon a member of the service in Commission is set aside or declared or rendered void
in consequence of or by a decision of a Court of law and the disciplinary authority, on a
consideration of the circumstances of the case, decides to hold a further inquiry against him on
the allegations on which the penalty of dismissal, removal or compulsory retirement was originally
imposed, the member of the service in Commission shall be deemed to have been placed under
suspension by the appointing authority from the date of the original order of dismissal, removal or
compulsory retirement and shall continue to remain under suspension until further order:
Provided that no such further inquiry shall be ordered unless it is intended to meet a
situation where the Court of law has passed an order purely on technical grounds without going
into the merits of the case.
(5) Where a member of the service in Commission is suspended or is deemed to have
been suspended whether in connection with any disciplinary proceedings or otherwise, and any
other disciplinary proceeding are commenced or any other criminal complaint is under
investigation or trial against him during the continuance of that suspension and where the
suspension of the member of the service in Commission is necessary in public interest as
required under clause (i), the authority competent to place him under suspension may, for
reasons to be recorded by him in writing direct that the member of the service in Commission
shall continue to be under suspension until the termination of all or any of such proceedings
including departmental proceedings taken on the basis of facts which led to the conviction in a
criminal court.
(6) An order of suspension made or deemed to have been made under this rule may at
any time be revoked by the authority which made or is deemed to have made the order or any
authority to which that authority is subordinate.
(f) If the member of the service in Commission, to whom a copy of the charges together
with a statement of the allegation on which each charge is based and of any other circumstances
which it is proposed to take into consideration in passing orders on the case, is communicated,
does not submit the written statement of his defence on or before the date specified for the
purpose or does not appear in person before the inquiring authority or otherwise fails or refuses
to comply with the provisions of this rule, the inquiring authority may hold the inquiry ex-parte.
{g) Whenever the disciplinary authority is on the opinion that there are grounds for
inquiring into the truth of any imputation of misconduct or misbehavior against a member of the
service in Commission, it may itself inquire into, or appoint an authority to inquire into the truth
thereof.
Explanation.—Where the disciplinary authority itself holds the inquiry, any reference to the
"inquiring authority" shall be construed as a reference to the disciplinary authority.
25. (a) The authority imposing any penalty under these rules shall maintain a record
showing,— (i) the allegations upon which action was taken against the person punished;
(ii) the charges framed, if any;
(iii) the person's representation, if any, and the evidence taken, if any; and
(iv) the finding and the grounds thereof, if any
(b) All orders of punishment shall also state the grounds on which they are based and
shall be communicated in writing to the person against whom they are passed.
(c) Every order, notice and other process made or issued under these rules shall be
served in person on the member of the service in Commission concerned or send to him by
registered post with acknowledgement due or if such person is not found by leaving it at his last
known place of residence or by giving or tendering it to an adult member of his family or if none of
the means aforesaid is available by affixing it in some conspicuous part of his last known place of
residence.
(d) While passing final orders, the disciplinary authority shall also pass orders regarding
the manner of disposal of the material objects marked during the enquiry. After the appeal time is
over, the officers concerned shall accordingly dispose of the material objects.
Previous and next
All provisions of State Human Rights Commission Service Rules, 2005
Questions people ask
Is rule 19 of State Human Rights Commission Service Rules, 2005 still in force?
No repeal of State Human Rights Commission Service Rules, 2005 is recorded.