Order regarding M/s HDFC Bank Ltd., Suryakiran, K.G. Marg, Connaught Place, New Delhi.
Order - The Delhi Value Added Tax, 2004
- Kind: Order
- Under: The Delhi Value Added Tax, 2004
Text of this order
OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER, VAT
DEPARTMENT OF TRADE AND TAXES
GOVERNMENT OF N.C.T. OF DELHI
VYAPAR BHAWAN, NEW DELHI
no fepvat/2015/25"4 Date: rar \ | cr
Name & Address of the Dealer : M/s. HDFC Bank Ltd.,
Suryakiran,
Kastruba Gandhi Marg,
\ Connaught Place,
| New Delhi.
Registration Number : 07960258934
Asscssmenti Ycar : 2005-06
(for April 2005 to November 2005)
Present for the Dealer ; Sh.Shammi Kapoor, Adv.
Ms.
Present for the Department : Sh. M.K. Aggarwal, Departmental Representative
tds) 6 fh ontee
Vhis Order is passed under the provisions of Section 74A of the
qn Delhi Value Added Tax Act, 2004. The default assessment of tax and
interest under section 32 of the DVAT Act 2004 and assessment of
d- penalty under section 33 of the DVAT Act 2004, in respect of the
Oy dealer M/s HDFC Bank Limited (Tin no- 07960258934), was done by
Que the VATO, ward-42(KDU). Aggrieved by the order the dealer filed
objection before the Objection Hearing Authority contending that the
V wy, orders passed by the assessing officer are barred by limitation period.
i ee The Ld. Special Commissioner, the OHA, after hearing the matter held
that the orders passed by the assessing officer are barred by limitation
ii and hence set aside.
543 A detailed examination of the case reflects that the orders passed
guculacs al by the Ld OHA are both erroneous and prejudicial to the interest of
V3
revenue. Hence, I am revising the orders suo-moto under the
provisions of section 74(A) of the DVAT Act 2004.
Brief facts of the case, leading to the revision of the order of Ld
OHA are as under:-
1. The special Audit of the dealer M/s HDFC Bank Limited was
conducted u/s S58(A) of the DVAT Act 2004 for the year 2005-06.
2. On the basis of the findings of the audit, default assessment of tax,
interest and penalty for the period April 2005 to November 2005 was
made by the VATO Ward-42(KDU) and the following demands of tax &
penalty were raised:-
_ September 2005 |04.11.2011
_ October 2005
| November 2005
si. ! Tax Period ' Date of Notice of | Total Demand i.e.
No. Default Assessment | Tax + interest
' _of Tax _| (Rs. In Lakh)
1. April 2005 _27.05.201 ACL 47 2174.06 |
2. | May 2005 _ 24.06.2011 ae 25.13
3. June 2005 (25. 07. 2011 i 113.00
4. | July 2005 26.08.2011 ____ 55.58 |
5. | August 2005 | 28.09.2011 fe
6. | September 2005 | 28.10.2011
7. (October 2005 _ 13. 11201) |
8. | Nuvewibe: 2005 | 20.12.2011 | _ 4
So Toll} 48,012.11
Sl. Tax Period [Date of Noticeof | Demand
No. Default Assessment | (Rs. In Lakh)
ul - st of J Penalty _ —
1, April2005 © | 28. 1O.2011
2. May 2005 eee
3. June2005 26.08.2011 /
4. July 2005 27.07.2011
5. August 2005 __| 07.12.2011
6.
7.
8.
S
e
[
=
=
Ww The dealer filed objection before the special commissioner on the
ground that the return for the period April 2005 would have
been filed by the objector on or before 28.05.2005 and
correspondingly the assessing authority should have passed the
order on or before 27.05.2011, keeping the limitation period as
prescribed by section 34 in mind. But the order framed on
27.05.2011 was dispatched on 24.06.2011 hence the date of
passing of the order would be 24.06.2011 and not 27.05.2011
i.e. the date on which the order was dispatched. The Ld OHA
considers the submissions made by the dealer, passed the
orders and set aside the assessment orders passed by the VATO.
4. Further, the Ld. OHA directed the assessing authority to frame
fresh orders, tax period wise for the tax period not barred by
limitation.
D. Based on the order of Special Commissioner all the orders
framed for the period April 2005 to November 2005 were held
time barred by limitation and set aside.
With this background notice issued to the dealer under sub-
section (2) of section 74(A) in form DVAT 24(B) to present for hearing
vit 23.02.2015, 04-03-2015, and 11-U3-2U15 at 11.30 am. finally on
11-03-2015 Sh. Shammi Kapoor, Adv and Ms. Counsel/Adv of the
dealer, along with POA were present. The Counsel made the following
submissions:-
(a). That the dealer is a leading and renowned banking company
incorporated as a private sector bank, under the provisions of
Banking Regulation Act, 1949 and the Reserve Bank of India
(hereinafter referred to as ‘RBI), having its registered office in the
State of Maharashtra. The Dealer also has its place of business
situated at 1st Floor, Kailash Building, 26 Kasturba Gandhi
Marg, New Delhi.
(1).
. That the Dealer being a banking company is primarily engaged in
the business of borrowing, lending, opening of bank accounts
and various other banking activities within the parameters of the
Banking Regulation Act and the objects stated in the
Memorandum of Association of the Dealer.
. That the Dealer is also engaged in the sale of gold bullion within
India and has thereby got itself registered under the provisions
of DVAT Act and the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 (hereinafter
referred to as ‘CST Act’) vide TIN No.07960258934.
. That the Dealer is not into the business of sale and purchase of
vehicles under the provisions of DVAT Act and is only acting as a
facilitator for the purpose of recovering its outstanding loan back
from the defaulter.
. That under the provisions of Section 26 (1) - Every registered
dealer who is liable to pay tax under this Act shall furnish to the
Commissioner such returns for each tax-period and by such
dates as may be prescribed in the prescribed form and manner.
Further, Section 2(1)(y) defines the work ‘prescribed’ as
“prescribed means prescribed by rules made under this Act’.
Accordingly, the date of filing return u/s 26 is to be taken as the
date prescribed under the Act. The due date for filing return
under Section 26 was 28 of subsequent month. Accordingly,
the period of limitation had elapsed when assessment order was
passed, when the assessment order was passed by the Assessing
Authority.
Intention of the legislature was always to provide for a limitation
specified under Section 34 of DVAT Act prescribing the time limit
for the Authority to act in passing the order before the said
period of limitation. In the present facts of the case, as the
Assessing Authority has passed the assessment order beyond
the period of limitation. Therefore, the order of Ld.OHA is legally
correct.
The D. R represented that :
| 6. The contention of the dealer that the date of dispatch of order
shall be taken as the date of passing of the order, is wrong, as
the assessing officer passed the order before the expiry of the
limitation period and once the orders are done through the
system, the date and contents of the order cannot be changed
without making any change in the original order by means of
rectification or review. Hence, the order once passed is beyond
the control of the assessing authority for any possible change or
modification so it can be safely concluded that the order is
passed within the period of limitation though its actual service
may be done beyond the period of limitation.
7. Further, Section 34(1) of the DVAT Act reads as under :-
Limitation on assessment and reassessment-
(1) No assessment or re-assessment under section 32 of this Act
shall be made by the Commissioner after the expiry of four
years from:—
(a). the date on which the person furnished a return under
section 26 or sub section (1) of section 28 of this Act; or
(b). the date on which the Commissioner made an assessment of tax for the tax period, whichever is the earlier:
PROVIDED that where the Commissioner has reason to
believe that tax was not paid by reason of concealment, omission
or failure to disclose fully material particulars on the part of the
i
|
|
|
person, the said period shall stand extended to six years.
\
It is clear from the above that
a. The assessment could be made after the expiry of four years
from the date on which a person furnishes a return or revise
return.
b. The period of four years shall be extended to six years where the
tax was not paid by reason of concealment, omission. However,
as per section 34(1)(a), the four year and similarly six years are
to be counted from the date on which a person furnishes a
return.
In the present case, the dealer has filed its return for the months
of April 2005 to November 2005 on 30% December 2005, hence the
limitation period expires on 29th December 2011, which is well within
6 years of date of the order Or dispatch of the orders. Thus the notice
of assessment of tax, interest and penalty cannot be said to be
debarred by limitation.
I have heard the argument put forward from both the sides. |
agree with the views of the DR. A simple reading of section 34(1)(a) of
the DVAT Act 2004 shows that the period of 4 years commences from
the date when the person furnished a teluim and similar is for the
period of 6 years as in the proviso. Hence the orders passed by the Ld
VATO cannot be held as time barred.
In view of the above discussion the orders passed by the Ld OHA
are set aside and the orders of Ld AA stands.
(Sanjeev }firwar)
Commissioner, VAT
6.
Copy to:
1. All Special Commissioners
2. Addl. Commissioner (L&J)
3. Addl. Commissioner (System)
4 Assistant Commissioner (Policy)
5 Guard File.
Assessing Authority Ward-42 (KCS) with the direction to issue
notice for recovery of tax immediately.
(Sanjeevhirwar)
Commissioner, VAT