Rule 9, Madhya Pradesh Panchayat Samvida Shala Shikshak (Appointment and Conditions of Contract) Rules, 2001: Extensjon in Contract Period
Madhya Pradesh Panchayat Samvida Shala Shikshak (Appointment and Conditions of Contract) Rules, 2001 - Rule 9
Text of rule 9
Extensjon in Contract Period
9. Extensjon in Contract Period.-(l) Mter completIOn of every three
years service, the 'contract period of "Samvida Shala Shikshak" maybe
extended for a further period of three years by the Panchayat. On'recom-.
mendation of ~he Committee specified in Schedule-III. The Comrriittee
shall recommend the extension on the basis of work,' conduct; perfor-
mance and the' result ofannual examination of the students of the classes,
which he/she has been teaching. On completion of every three year period
of contract employment. "Samvida Shala Shikshak" shall be entitled to
15% increa~e in his/her previous contract remuneration: .
. Provided that after every completion of nine years of the contract
period of "Samvida Shala Shikshak", it may be .extended for further three
. years by the Panchayat on the basis of the recommendation of the
Committee specified inSchedule-UI. The Committee shall recommend the
extension o'n the basis ofmedical examination, opinion of Parent Teacher
Association of the concerned schod and assessment of performance, work
and result of last nine years of annual examinations of the students of
classes in which he/she has been teaching.
(2) Mter the expiry of every contract period, in case of extension in
contract period a new contract wi[ have to be exeouted.
(3) The extension in the contract period of "Samvida Shala Shikshak"
.under sLib-rule (1) may be made up to 62 years of age of "Samvida Shala
Shikshak" . . . .
COMMENTARY
- - ~-:_-~: ..~:~;:.;.~~-i..::.'.,".:.':-~~'-A"~'-~ A •• -:_ •• __ -=.~":".-..~. __ ._-._ '.__ ~ ~_'_'_'_' .. __ .(-::. . .. ,._ .•..._
[1] Rules 9, 10 & 11.-Recruitment process for appointment of
Shiksha Karmi.-Petitioner applied for being appointed as Shiksha
Karmi. Even being more meritorious not selected. Action challenged.
Mass irregUlarities found in the entire selection process. Held, It is well
settled principle of law that when, the entire selection is being cancelled
due to writ large irregularities hearing to individually candidates is not ~
necessary. Respondents directed to conduct fresh recruitment process in.
pursuance to the aforesaid order shall be limited to on such candidates
' who had. applied _~!!"p~rti~p-at~ ipJhe_previo,us.s.election process and. . _ . _
.. - - -_.-the-same-be completed within a period of 3 months. Kanchan Upadhyay
(Ku.) v. State of M.P. , ILR 2009 M.P. 155.
[2] Rule. 9 'of the rules is pari materia and indentically worded for
urban as well as Panchayat area ..•\1anoj Kumar Pandya v. State ofM.P. ,
2008 (2) MRLJ 302 = 2008(3) JLJ 203 = 2008(3) MPHT 343 ..
[3] Explanation 5 to Rule 9(b) is not arbitrary & no violation
of Art.l.(-Intelligible classification has been made and teaching ex-
perienceniarks are being awarded rightly for the kind of experience
which is possessed for the p~rticular post of 40ntract teacher grade I,ll
and III to teach the very class ofwhich they are having experience, thus
it cannot be said that there is arbitrainess violating Art. 14 of the
Constitution of.Jndia in the Explanation 5 to Rule 9(b) of the aforesaid
Rules. Manoj Kumar Pandya v. State of M.P., 2008 (2) MPLJ 302 = .
2008(3) JLJ 203-= 2008(3) MPHT343. :
[4] Rule 9(c)-Special skill may' get weightage to teach at
primary level- Not awarding of special marks for higher educa-
Rules 10, 12, 12(a) & 12(h).-Age relaxation.-Petitioner working as.
Samvida Shala Shikshak Class-II in the Government School. He applied
.for the post of Civil Judge claiming relaxation of 3 years on the ground
that he is a Government Servant. ~~ld,. Appointing authority of the. ._
petitioner isJ anpad Panchayat mId thus he is not a Government Servant .
and cannot be granted age relaxatiol). Arun Singh Bhadouriya v. State
of M.P., 2009(2) MPHT 277 = 2009(2) MPWN 112 = ILR 2009 M.P.
1939 (DB): . .
(PR)480 PAN. SAM. SHALA SHIKSHAK (EMPLOY. ...J RULES, 2005 R. 10
HOD isjustified.-For appointment of teachers for primary classes, Rule
9(c) excludes grant of weight age marks to the candidates having B.Ed.
qualification is in tune with the note 1 of the Notification issued by
National Council of teacher Education. Special skill is possessed by
D.Ed/B.T.C./D.S.E. candidates to impart education at primary level
children obtaining instructions at that level. Though differentiation is
made under the rules in eligibility for awarding marks but that is based
on intelligible classification, which is permissible within the ambit of
Art. 14 of the Constitution. 20 Marks which have been reserved as per
Rule 9(c) have been rightly reserved for special category of candidates
having special skill to impart primary education, the incumbents having
B.Ed. degree have not been totally excluded from staking their claim but
they are not to be awarded marks of special educational qualification as
they are not having expertise qualification to teach at primary level.
Though they may be having qualification to teach at higher level but
B.Ed. is not the higher qualification to teach at primary level but special
skill for the purpose of teaching at primary level as held by the Apex
Court. Manoj Kumar Pandya v. State of M.P., 2008 (2) MPLJ 302 =
2008(3) JLJ 203 = 2008(3) MPHT 343.
Previous and next
Questions people ask
Is rule 9 of Madhya Pradesh Panchayat Samvida Shala Shikshak (Appointment and Conditions of Contract) Rules, 2001 still in force?
No repeal of Madhya Pradesh Panchayat Samvida Shala Shikshak (Appointment and Conditions of Contract) Rules, 2001 is recorded.