Rule 7, Madhya Pradesh Panchayat Service (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1999: Procedure for imposing major penalties
Madhya Pradesh Panchayat Service (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1999 - Rule 7
Text of rule 7
Procedure for imposing major penalties
7. Procedure for imposing major penalties.-{l) No order, imposing
on a member of the Panchayat Service. any of the penalties specified in
i clause (iv)to (via)-ofrule '5'shall,be_passed except.after .~JQr:m~~t:lgl!iry-is-- - . - -
held as far as may-be',in the manner hereinafter provided. _ .. ,-- -.---.."---. -... ---
(2)When an order for formal inquiry ha~ been made, the disciplinary
authority shall frame Definite charges on the basis of allegations and shall
communicate such charges, alongwith the statement of the allegations, to
the member of the Panchayat ~ervice and also require him to submit,
within such time as may be specified a written statement of defence and
also to state whether he desires to be heard in person. .
(3)The person against whom inquiry is to be held shall, for the purpose
of preparing toe defence, be permitted to inspect and take extracts from
-such records ashe may-specify:.----------..:-----:--- - -.- ----- --------.:...------------- .. -
Provided that such permission may be refused if. for reasons to be
recorded in writing, in the opinion ofthe Enquiry Officersuch records are
not relevant for the purpose or it is against the public interest to allowhis
access thereto.
(4) On receipt of the written statement of defence or if any such
statement is not received within the time specified, the disciplinary
authority may himself enquite into such ofthe charges as are not admitted
or appoint an EnqUiryOfficer to hold the inquiry and forward to him his
report and. if advised. his recommendation alongwtth all the inquiry
papers. . ~. .
(5)The disciplinary authority may nominate any person to present the
case in support of the charges before the Enquiry Officer.The member of
the Panchayat Service may present his case with the assistance of any
other Panchayat Servant of-State Government. SerVant approved-by the
Enquiry Officerbut may-not -engagea legal practitioner for the purpose,
unless the person nominated by the disciplinary authority as aforesaid is
a legal practitioner or unless the disciplinary authority having regard to
>.
R.7(PR)598 PAN. SERVICE (DISCIPLINE & APPEAL) RULES, 1999
the circumstances of the case so permits.
(6) If the servant of the Panchayat Service desires to be heard in
person ..fie shall be s<;heard. Ifhe so.desires or.if,th~ dis~iplinaryautp.Ority;
so directs. an oral enquiry shall be he]d,by ,the ~:pq~iryqffi~.~:r. A~ sucn
inquiry evidence shall be heard as to, such C?f, t,he';?1leg31ti9If.s.a~, are, npt~
admitted and the, person charged shall be entitled to cross examine the
witness. to give evidence in. 'person; to produce documentary evidence. if
any. and to have such witness called as he may wish:
Provided that the Enquiry Officer' may. 'ro~ re,~s'pns ~().b~~ecord~din
writing. refuse to cC!.lla witn~ss ... "j, •• ," ;:,1:1' :.! ''':, i: c.,:;", ..
(7) At the conclusion of the inquiry, the Enquiry Gfficer;shalLprepare'
.•.~ .report of the inquiry. recording; his. findings.; on; each',of the; charges.
together With reasons therefor: :' . ;;"'!;~:,,.: :,"
(8)" The' proceedings conducted' against 'the' per~9h~.charged '.shall"
contain a sufficient record of. ,', "" ' ..,. " < '.
(i) the charges framed agai~stsl.H~hp~;'~~~:a!i~'t?~,,~t~t~m~pt'~f
allegations; " , ';',. .' ',.:. (\;:;'. " ;
(ii) the written statement of defence if any; ~ :''. ;' ".'
(iii) the' or~ e~idence taken id the Co~rseof th.'e inquiry; .;.
,'"I'~ ... . . . '. '. " • .'.". . . . . ::':. .". .~::.' "':..: 1 .. '. :.' .'
(iv) the documentary evidence considered in:, the course of the
.inquiry~:.:-:., :.:.; !',' ,',- ':.;'" • ,'i::',.. ...
. (v) ,the6tders, 'if arty; made by"the:'Enqciiiy'OIDcer' or' theaisc'ipH::
, nary authority as the case'may be Withre'gafd't6 theii1cl'uiry:"
(vi) a reportseth~g o~t ~hefindi~gs o~each"chCirge~d the:r~as~~~
.therefor. ., " ,
"i: '" .. :. \- _; ";. ~:.:.- l. , • .:> ~_ '.... . c' 'l. .:.-
(9) the Enquiry' Officer. if.he is other than th~ disciplinary authority;
shall submit the re.cords oftheproceedings;mentioned'in.clause,(8) above,
to .the disciplinary. authority !Without recommendation relating to the
penalty,to pe~posed. The disciplincuy authority shall consider the record
of .the,~..enqUiIy aIld its .&n<;lings on,ea,ch Gh~ge., J~ayw-g,.r~gC;l!"d~.to t~~.
findings dri~e ,~licfrg~s~d~tb;e .rec.ord(if,~t(P~o~e'e.~gsr1f~~'~:Js':otthe:-- __
opinion .thaf~Y'9f thep~tialties s~eCi~e4; .i,n':cla:4~~~:~!yl~6:(Y4f ?f'i)ile' q ..
should' be i~P.9~~~~ it.shCiP furr,iis.ll"~o:q~e'p~r~dn 'charg~q.'~r~,PPY"~(.tJ.?e'
report of th~'E;I1q~,uy' Ofnc~r,.:aItd .whe~e'ltp:e:,'~i~CiR~~: ~titli<?rity ;Ht '1Pt
the Enquiry pip-eer a:~ta~e~e~t :oq~s:~n~m-gs ~o~et~~r.V(1~J:~rr~f~~~s:ol1s
for disagreeF~~t,~ ~y~ Wl~h,}~~fi~.~.ir.~s:?'rm~;~~~'P~?ffir~r':.:,,.L. :.;. ...., '. -
(IO) The: disclplincuyautholity,: shqU-:consid~rthef T~pr~sentatipn.if;
any. made by the.:person charged in response to the notice and determine
the penalty. if any. should be imposed andishall pass appropliate order on
the case.', .....,::: . ',.: '" ,"< . I, :.: ':~:' :~ \
. i. ',-< :.' '1;:; ,":' :.,. ;" :"; ; •.. :.:, ..•... ;. ->,":.~-.~r ~,::;,:: ..:~...•>': .-:.~~.:,"::~ ..\ ~_.. '.:._; ,~;_.. ;~\.,; ,
(lJ) Th,~.:.oidets,p#s~~dJ)y'tpe 9i~cip@~i-y~~it4.o~itY'~~qlIJj~:cq:rn~uni~i'
catedto.,the.member'ofthePanchayafServiCe, who shall also be supplied
Witha'copy. :of. the. report of the iEnquiry Officer an where. disciplinary
auth~rity' is "not ithe Enquiry :Officer "~a'statement 'of:~ts;find~:ngS'together
with th~ 'brieffeasons fof d~sagree'merit" .'if 'any:.'Withthe:firidings dfUie.
Enqt;iiry.Offi~e:r, :Uiil~:sstljeY):iave.already, been supplied to the personcharged~' ,. '.". '. . . '.' , '.
lq
_i I'l
7 R.8 PM-l. SERVICE (DISCIPLINE & APPEAL) ,RULES, 1999 (PR)599
COMMENTARY
1
{
1
t
f
1
f
Validity of order of termination of services.-A show cause notice
was issued to the appellant and the appellant refused to take notice.
Thereafter, his services were terminated on account oftegistration of a
criminal case, and an enquiry w~s not conducted against the appellant.
The appellant has also been acquitted from the criminal offences. Held,
that it was obligatory on the part of the Panchayat or the authority to
conduct an enquiry against the appellant. Panchayat Secretary or
Panchayat Karmi could not be terminated withcmtdue procedure of rule
laid down in Rule 7 of Rules of 1999. Naray'an Singh v. State of M.P.,
2013(1) MPWN 70. '
Major Penaity imposed but procedure not followed.-
[1]Without charge sheet removal order from service.-Without
charge sheet removal order from service issued to Panchayat
SecretarylPetitioner. As per Rules, removal from service of Panchayat
Secretary is a major penalty and procedure for imposing major penalty
is provided in Rule 7. Thus, the said order issued in contravention of
Rule 7 hence not sustainable. Kailash Babu Rai v. State of M.P., 2008
(3) MPLJ 648 = 2008(3) JLJ 392.
[2] Order of major penalty cannot be passed unless aformalinquiry
is held. Unless the procedure laid down in Rule 7 of the Rules, 1999
,followea,' the Secretary~-6t the Gram -Pahchayat'cannot be removed or -..---,-.;----
reverted from' the post of Secretary, Gram Panchayat. Lalla Prasad
Burman v. State of M.P., 2008 (3) MPLJ 394 = 2008(3) MPHT 26 =
2008(2) MPWN 10LDB. ' , , ,
Previous and next
All provisions of Madhya Pradesh Panchayat Service (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1999
Questions people ask
Is rule 7 of Madhya Pradesh Panchayat Service (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1999 still in force?
No repeal of Madhya Pradesh Panchayat Service (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1999 is recorded.