Rule 4, Madhya Pradesh Panchayat Service (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1999: Suspension
Madhya Pradesh Panchayat Service (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1999 - Rule 4
Text of rule 4
Suspension
4. Suspension.-(l) The appointingauthortty or any authority t6 which
it is subordinate, or disciplinary authority in that behalf, my place a
member of Panchayat Service under suspension :_
(a) Where a disciplinary proceeding against him iscdntemplated,
or is pending or
(b) Where a case against him in respect of any criminal offence
involvingmoral turpitude is under investigation inquiry or trial:
Provided that where the ,order of suspension is made by an,authority
subordinate to or lower in rank than the appointing authority, such
authority shall forth with report to the appointing authority the cir-
cumstances in which the order was made.
(2) A member of Panchayat Service shall be deemed to, have been
placed under suspension by an order of appointing authority :_
(a) ~ith effect from t)le d.~te.of.his detention, on a ,criminal charge .., .
or otherWise, for a period exceeding forty eight hours,
(b) With effect from the date of his' conviction, if the event of a
convictionfor an offence,he is sentenced to a term of imprison-
ment exceeding foity eight hours arid is not forthwith dismissed
or removed or compulsorily r~tired consequent, upon such
conviction. .
Explanation.-The period of forty eight hours referred to in clause'(b)
of this sub-rule shall be computed from thecomm~ncement of theim-
prisonment after the conviction and for this purpose, intermittent periods
of imprisoq.ment ifany, ,shall.be_taken-intoaccouriL, . _, .' ,~:4. _, :.~ '.'
(3) When a penalty of dismissal, removal or compulsqry retirement
from service imposed upon a member ofparichayat service under suspen-
sion is set aside in appeal or on reviewunder these rules .and the case is
remitted for further inquiry of or action or with any other directions, the
order of his suspension shall be deemed to have continued in force~With
effect on and from the date of the original order of dismissal, removal or
compulsory retirement and shall remain in force until further orders.
(4) Whether a penalty of dismissal, removal or compulsory' retirement
from service imposed upon a member of ~anchayat serviCeis set aside or
declarec;lor rendered void in consequerice'of or, by a decision of a court of
law, an4 the Disciplinary Authority on a consideration of the circumstan-
ces of the case, decides to h91d a further inquiry against him on the
allegations on. which the penalty of dismissal, removal or compulsory
retirement was originally imposed, the member of panchayat service shall
be deemed to have been placed .under _suspension by the appointing
authority from the date of the ori~irialorder of dismissal, ,removal, (;om-
pulSbry retirement and shall continue toreinclin under. suspension until
r
I
, r
i !1
I
I I
I
; I
, I
!
I
,I
\
i
,1
J .
R.5 PAl'/. SERVICE (DISCIPLiNE & APPEAL) RULES, 1999 (PR)595
further orders." .>': ..
(5) (a)An order suspension made or deellled,tQ}:J.,aye~~enmade under
this rule shall continue to remciin in force lintilltis ,modifiedor revoked
by the authority competent to do so, ....' . .' .
(b) "Vhere a member of Panchayat Service.is sw?p~nded Qris deemed
to have been suspended in connec".:ionwith cmydisciplinary proceeding or
otherwise and any other disciplinary procee~:lingis cOIIlIl}encedagainst
him during the continuance of such suspensi9J1.;the ,authority competent
. to place him under suspension may, for rea~9ns~o ,be.recorded by him. in
writing, direct that the member of Panchayat;~~rvi~~',s.hallcontinue to be
under suspension until the termination of all or any .ofsuch proceedings
(c)An order of suspension made or deemed to have been made under
this rule, may at any time be modified or revpked !bY.Jl1ea~thoritywhich
made or is deemed to have made it or by .any authority. to which. that
authority is subordinate.
COM MEN T A'R Y ..•.
. ,
5. Penalties.-The following penalties may. for good and sufficient:
rea~ons. and as herei~~ter""pr~v~ded,by ,imposed In a mellll>l'r (11' till' .
Panchayat Sen-ice."namely:- ". -, '.,
(a) Minor Penalties-
(i) Censure
Validity of order.-Suspension order of petitioner by Collector
upheld. Since the CEO is lower rank/position and class in comparison to
Collector, he must be treated as subordinate to Collector. Dashrath
.Singh v. State of M.P., 2014(2) MPLJ 17. ....' .
Before removal of an employee, enquiry is necessary.-Unless
.the admission ofguil.tlcharges.is.specific, unconstitutional, unquaHfied.:-'":-,, '-- -,-
and unequivocal, enquiry cannot be dispensed. with. The petitioner has
putforth his defence and made an effort to show that he is not resposible
for the charges and the payment cannot 'be. said that petitioner has
admitted the charges in totality and without any explanation. Annexure
P-7 will show that petitioner has givenexpla~ation against show cause
notice and. there is no unequivocal, unconditional,' unqualified and
specific admission ofguilt by the petitioner. The respondents have erred
in treati~g.AJ1.ne~ureP-7 a~,~dmission.ofguiit, cQnsequently, therespon-
__, ~ents_~~'Ye_~~_I1!I)l,i~~~~~aI!'~~rro~j~:_not~~.Q~~~~~J;lg.~4~.~~q~~ry~J!.~Q!.L,-".... "' _" _" _
shyam v. State of M.P., 2013(1) MPLJ 144=2013(2) MPHT 59.
Collector not empowered to suspend 'every body.-Collector is
.an appointing authority of the post of Secretary and Gram Panchayat is
appointing authority of Panchayat Karmi under S.69 of the Act~Since
the Collector is an appointing authority of the po.st of Secretary o,Il.ly
therefore he is empowered to suspend a Secretary from the post ..of'
Secretary and not from his post ofPanchayat:Karmi. Kamlesh Dubey v..
State of M.P., 2009 (1) MPLJ 545 =2009 (2)MPHT 372 .• '. .
-----'(
P,ART,.III.~DISCIPLINE
nt
or
of
n-
he
'ry
all
ng
TI-
Ltll
nt
n-
1s
le
th
or
b)
[l-
is
n
a
1-
:d
:h
i.
:e
1:
.y
h
h
a
r
r
(PR)596 PAN. SERVICE (DISCIPLINE & APPEAL) RULES, 1999 R. 5
(ii) Withholding of increments, stagnation allowances or promo-
tions, with or without cumulative effect
(iii). Recovery from pay of the whole or part of any pecuniary loss"
caused to the panchayat or the State Government by negligence
or breach of orders. .
.(b) Major Penalties-. .
(tv) .Reduction in rank including reduction to a lower post or time-
scale or to a lower stage in a time-scale,
(v) Compulsory retirement, .
(vi) Removal from service not disqualif)ringfor future employment.
(vii) Dismissal from service which shall ordinarily be a disqualifica-
tion for future employment:
Provided that in the case of member who have been allocated to the
panchayat service and who according to the terms and conditions of their
service which were immediately applicable to them before such allocation
were not liable to the penalty or fine, no penalty or fine shall be indicated
upon them.
. Explanation.-The follOwingshall not amount to a penalty Within the
meaning of this rule.-
(t) Withholding of increments of a member of the Panchayat Ser-
vice for failure to pass a departmental or language examination
in accordance with the rules or orders governing the service to
which fie belongs or the post which he for the time being holds
oJ;'theterms governing his appointment ;., _, _,_ '.,__ .,_, ,
(ii) Stoppage at the effiCiencyhar in the time scale of pay on the
ground of his unfitness to cross the bar,-
(iii) Non-promotion of a member of the panchayat service,. after
consideration of his case, to a post or grade to. which he is
eligible, on administrative grounds unconnected with his con-
dud;
(tv) Hcversion of a member of the Panchayat Service who is officiat-
ing in a higher service, grade or post to a lower service, grade
or post on the ground that after trials he is cO~~~~t~(Lt9 p~ _
unSUitable.for--sucIChigh-ef'serVfce--grade-- oi-post or on ad,..
.ministrative grounds not connected with his conduct;
(v), Reversion of a member of Panchayat Services, appointed -on
probation to another service, grade or post during or at the end
of the period of probation to his pen ll;1nentservice grade or post
in accordance with the terms of his; qipointment or the rules or
orders governing such prob~tion;
(vi) (a) Termination of the service of a merilber of the panchayat service
appointed on probation durihg 'or at the end of the period of
probation accordance with me terms of appointmenf:<;,or the
rules ord~r governing such probation
(b) Termination of the service of a member of the Panchayat Service
employed under an agreement in accordance with the terms of
.such agreement;
(vii). Compulsory retirement of a member of a Panchayat Service'in
accordance with the provisions relating to his superannuating
or retirement in the panchayat service and nqt on grounds of
R. 7 PAN. SERVICE (DISCIPLINE & APPEAL) RULES, 1999 (PR)597
his misconduct.
COMMENTARY
Validity oforder of termination of serviceS.-A show cause notice
was issued to the appellant and the appellant refused to take notice.
Thereafter, his services were terminated on account of registration of a
criminal case and an enquiry was not conducted against the appellant.
The appellant has also been acquitted from the criminal offences. Held,
that it was obligatory on the part of the Panchayat or the authority to .
conduct an enquiry against the appellant. Panchayat Secretary or
Panchayat Karmi could not be terminated without due procedure ofrule
laid down in Rule 7 of Rules of 1999. Naraya.n Singh v. State of M.P.,
2013(1) MPWN 70.
Previous and next
← Rule 3Protection of rights and privileges conferred by any law or agreementRule 6 →Authority to impose penalties
All provisions of Madhya Pradesh Panchayat Service (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1999
Questions people ask
Is rule 4 of Madhya Pradesh Panchayat Service (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1999 still in force?
No repeal of Madhya Pradesh Panchayat Service (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1999 is recorded.