Rule 30, The Madhaya Pradesh Panchayats (Election Petitions, Corrupt Practices And Disqualification for Membership) Rules, 1995: Repeal
The Madhaya Pradesh Panchayats (Election Petitions, Corrupt Practices And Disqualification for Membership) Rules, 1995 - Rule 30
Text of rule 30
Repeal
30. Repeal. -
I
I
!
!
I -
j
i
!
I
I
I:
;.
THE MADHYAPRADESH PANCHAYATS (ELECTION PETI~
TIONS, CORRUPT PRACTICES AND DISQUALIFICATION
FOR MEMBERSHIP) RULES, 1995 .
Notiftcation No. B-1-21 (1)95-XXII-P-2, dated 2-6-1995, Pub. in M.P. Gaz.
Ext., dt. 3-6-1995, p. 516(6) to (12), made u/s. 95(1), read with sub-section
(1) & (3) ois. 122. -
1. Short title ..:.These rules may be called the Madhya Pradesh
Panchayats (Election Petitions, Corrupt Practices and Disqualification for
Membership) Rules. 1995.
I
i
I
.1
\...
" .
R.3 ELECTION PETITIONS ... DISQUALIFI .... RULES, 1995 (PR)235
COMMENTARY
In the proceedings of the mEeting against 8arpanch of Gram
Panchayat, the names of who' were present was mentioned and all the
panchas including 8arpanch and U?-8arpanch signed the proceedings.
Collector gravely erred in setting as'de the resolution recording passing
ofno-confidence motion on the ground that presence was not mentioned.
Sukhnandan Pate' v. State of M.P., 2003 (1) MPLJ 220=2003 (2) JLJ
74.
2. Definitions.-In these rules, unless the -context otherwise re-
q~ires,-
(a) "Act"means the Madhya Praeesh Panchayat Raj Adhiniyarn, 1993
(No.1 of 1994);
(b) "Pleader" means any person entitled to appear and plead for
another in a CivilCourt and includes an Advocate, a Vakil and an Attorney ,
of a High Court;
(c) Returned Candidate" means a candidate whose name has been
published under sections 19, 26 or 33 of the Act as duly elected;
(d) "Specified Officer"means the Officerspecified in sub- section (1)of
Section 122 of the Act in relation to Gram Panchayat, Janpad Panchayat
and Zila Panchayat,?-s. the case rpar be.
COMMENTARY
I
I
Returned Candidate.-Asreqnired by 8s.19, 26 and 33 of the Act,
unless the election of a candidata is notified there is no 'returned
candidate' and no election petition can be filed without impleading as
party the returned candidate agai:l.st whom certain allegations under
Rule 21 are made and relief SOUght.Chandra Bhan Singh v. State of
M.P., Chandra Bhan Singh v. State ofM.P., 2001 (2) MPHT 242~2001
(2) MPLJ 419 (F.B.).
3. Prese~tation of election petition.-(l) All election Petition shall be
presented. to the specified Officer during the office hours by the person
making the petition, or by a person authorised in writing in this behalf by
the person making the petition.
(2) Every election petition shall be accompanied by as many copies.
thereof as there are respondents mentioned. in the petition and every such
copy shall be attested by the petitioner und~r his own signature to be a
true copy of the petition. ..
COMl\1ENTARY
.1. Requirem.ents .of Election Petition.-[I] Extra copy of
memorandum of Election Petition given to returned candidatelrespon,. ..~ ..._=-
dent NO.1 before Election Tribunal. It.was not required to be signed and
verified by the Election Petitioner. Natthulal v. Shakuntalabai, 2011 (2)
MPLJ 424 = 2011(2) MPHT 153.•
1 I
: • ~ '!
I
, \rp ~,II ,
• I >
\
I,
(PR)236 ELECTION PETITIONS ... DISQUALIFI .... RULES, 1995 R. 3,
[2]Rule 3 only provides signing and attestation of copies filed along
with the election petition. E~ectionpetition filed by the respondent was
accepted by the authority in accordance with the provjsions of Rule 3
and thereafter notice on the said election petition was issued to the
appellant. Nothing on record to establish that a signed and att~sted copy
of the election petition was not sent to the appellant along with the
notice. Appellant should have established this fact and as the best
evidence which was available to the appellant was not produced by him,
an adverse inference has rightly been drawn against him. Additional
copy,Le. an extra copywhich was give:t;lto the counsel for theappellailt
during the proceedings need not be signed and attested h~'the election-
petitioner as that is not the requirement of Rule 3. Shalnlntalabai v.
Nathulal, 2011(3) MPLJ 119 = 2011(5) MPHT 35.
2. Maintainability of petition.-[l] Election petition filed by
respondent NO.6was not duly verified and the security amount required
to be deposited at the time ofpresentation of the petition. Petitioner not
having complied with mandatory provisions of the Rules was not main-
tainable. Kana Mandal v. State of M.P., 2010(2) MPLJ 468 ~ 2010(3)
MPHT278.
[2] Election Petition not presented by the election petitiqner by
presenting it herself or through an authorized advocate. Election peti-
tion dismissed in view qf provisions ofRules 3; 8 and 21. Kamlesh Nut
v. Commissioner, 2012(4) MPLJ 385= 2012(5YMPHT 127>'... :C. "~~~. -- ,._ •.
[3]Copies of the election petition served on the respondent did not
bear the signatures of the petitioner, were not verified and did not bear
attestation as required by Rule 3(2).Election Tribunal rightly dismissed
the election petition. I;3aijulal Verma v. Additional Collector,
Chhindwara, 2009(4) MPLJ 548 = 2010(1) MPHT 477. '
[4]If a party is having the best evidence in his power and possession
he is duty bound to produce it in the Court in order to resolve the
controversy and that party, should not plaGer~liance 0I.l~he abstract
doctrine of onus of proof that it was no part of his duty to produce it.
Respondent NO.1 should have filed the copyof election petition served
upon her along witl1the summons in.the court in order to resolve the
dispute. The Election Tribunal ~rred in dismissing the election petition
by holding that there is non-compliance of Rule 3 'of the ;Rules. The
impugned order passed by the Election Trib~nal set aside. Natthulal v.
Shakuntalabai, 2011(2) MPLJ 424 = 2011(2) MPHT 153.. '
[5]Neither the 'requisite c~piesofthe Electipn Petition were filed nor
they are signed. Non-Compliance of Rule 3 ,bythe Election Petitioner.
Election petition dismissed. Rakesh v. Returning Officer 'Panchayat
Nirvachan, 2012(4) MPLJ 458 = 2012(5) MPHT H)4.
3. Invalid preseritation.- [1] Presentation by Counsel under
Vakalatnama which did not. specifically au~horise him -to present the ..
petition. Presentation was held tp be improper and petition liable to be
dismissed. Tara v. Dabla, 2002 (3) MPLJ 591=2002 (2) MPHT 554.
R. 3 ELECTION PETITIONS ... DISQUALIFI .... RULES, 1995 (PR)237
[2]The election petition was not presented by the petitioner but it
was filed by somebody else. Therefore, a election petition presented
contrary to the provisions of sub-rule (1) of Rule 3 is not maintainable
and has to be dismissed in view of the mandatory requirement of Rule
8 of the Rules, 1995.Geeta Devi Yadav v. Archana, 2008 :(1)MPLJ 261
= 2008(2) JLJ 34.
[3] Vakalatnama does not authorise an Adv:ocate in writing to
present the election petition before the Competent Authority. Urmila
Devi v. Returning Officer (PanchayatJ, 2008(4) MPHT'410 = 2008(3)
MPWN92. .
4. Electionpetition by voter in a ward different from the ward
from the person was elected. Maintainability.-The election
petitioner, though he belonged to a different ward of the Gram
Panchayat assailed the election of the writ petitioner, who had been
elected as Up-'Sarpanch though elected as Panch from a ward in which
the election petitioner was not the voter. In that event, the concept of
wards melts into insigriificanceand his election becomes a cause of
grievance for any person who belongs to Gram Panchayat. It is to be
borne in mind that in the absence of any categorisation who can file an
election petition and the only provision that throws some light being rule
__,:, :':., ..3.;.t4e.. sq~e. h?s .to...b.e::purpQsivelyint~rpre.ted. cThe,..said.provision ::...._.:....
. enshrines that an 'election petition is to be presented to the specified
officer during the office'hours by the person making a petition or by a
person authorised in writing in that behalf by the person making the
petition. It is apparent that a relief can be claimed declaring the election
of the returned candidate to be void in addition to further declaration.
Thus, a person may not claim that he himself or other candiddate has
been duly elected but may seek a relief for declaration simpliciter that
the election of the returned candidate is void. Thus the, keyword is
'person'. Though the word 'pers.on'.J.:!:a~_1?~~~~~~ti9.I!~<iLjt_~0.~l<i,.!1()t__... _..
.engiIlt iii its ariibit"or'seep'aperson from anywhere. He must have some'
connection or nexus with the election. He must be a person aggrieved.
The petitioner was therefore a person aggrieved and the election petition
'at his instance was maintainable. Hukum Singh v. Collector, Panna,
2002 (1) MPLJ 233=AIR 2002 MP 32=2001 (2) JLJ270.
5. Recounting ofvotes.-Difference ofvotes was orily17.Electricity
failed twice and votes were counted in candle light. Sufficient cir-
cumstances to order for recount. Rakib Moh,ammadv. District Collector,
AIR 2003 MP 39=2002 (3) MPLJ 415=20,02(5) MPHT 487 (DB). .
" " . \
[2]It is obligatory on part ofElection Tribunal to give specificfinding
about its satisfaction for directing recount. Smt. K(Lmlesh Gautam v. Sub
Division Offwer, AIR 2009 (NOe) 754 MP. . . .
.. -....6. Petition properlY.:~teE;ted.-A perusal ofthe-copycofthe election=~=~~-.~=
petition which was accompanied with the petition and .was supplied to "
" the petitioner, reveals that on each and everypage the third respondent
has put her signature." IIi the circumstances, Illf.lre non-mention of'true
:copy'would not be sufficient to hold that th~.Hulc 3(2) of the Rules' has
".' ..
(PR)238 ELECTION PETITIONS .,. DISQUALIFI .... RULES, 1995 -R. 4
:
-I,-
I
I
I ~
J I
1\
l
l '
!
i'! '
not been complied with. Subha Rao v. Member, .Election Tribunal, (AIR
1964 se 1072) REL. Ku. Parwati Bai Thakur v. State of M.P., 2007(3)-
MPHT 63. Photo copyofpetition supplied to the respondent was signed
by the petitioner but not mentioned words "attested true copy"held'it is
substantial compliance ofRule 3(2) and not liable to dismiss under Rule
8. Mrs. Indira Sin"gh'v. Mrs. Anjana Sharma, 2006(4) MPHT 152. See
also: Ravindra Sihgh v. SDO cum Prescribed Authority, Datia, 2006(3)
MPLJ 570 = 2006(3) MPHT 150. '
, ~
7. Petition not attested by election petitioner- Effect.-[l]
Where election petition was not attested by the petitioner as required
by sub-rule (2), the' provision of the' rule being mandatory, failure would
lead to summary dismissal of election petition. Attestation py Advocate
would not save the petitioner. Dr. Omprakash Soni v. AsholJ,Kumar
Bhargava, AIR 1996 MP 43.
[2] The provisions are mandatory. Attested copies of documents
supplied to respondents not signed by petitioner. Petition liable to be
dismissed. Defect cannot be cured after expiry of period of limitation.
Amolsingh v. Hameersingh" 1996 (I) MPWN 122.
'[3rWher~'requirenient of Hie-provision is not complied, D'-O decision
on merit can be given. Rambharosa v. State ofM.P., 1996 (I) MPWN 81.
8. Failure to file copies of election petition- Petition to be
dismissed.-:[l]Where in compliance with the provisions' of rule 3,
election petition did not accompany as,many copies of the same as there
were respondents, the requirement being mandatory, such a petition
was liable to be dismissed under the provisions of rule 8. Shivdhari
'La~h~sar v. Jaduman Bishwanath, 1999 (1) MPLJ 291.
See also:
, ,
[2]Udaysingh v. Himmatsingh, 1999 (1) JLJ 200.
[3] Petition should be attested by the election petitioner.' In its
absence the petition is liable to be dismissed. Attestation by 'advocate
would not save the petition. Omprakash Soni v.Ashokkumar, AIR 1996
MP43.
-[4] Attested copies ofdocuments supplied to respondents not signed
bypeti tioner- Petition liable to be dismissed. Defect cannot be cureq,after
pe.riodof limitation. Amolsingh v. Hamir Singh; 1996 (I) MPWN 122.
4. Parties to t~e petition.-Where the petitioner in addition to claim-
ing a declaration that the election, of all or any of the returned candidates
is void, claims a further declaration that he himself or a.nyother candidate
has been duly elected he shall join as respondents to his petition all the
contesting candidates at the election. '
COMMENTARY
1. Candidates at the election.- Person who withdrew their can~
,-" - - J_1 1_1.. L'~~.•:.L1.-,.J_ .r
•
R. 5 ELECTION PETITIONS ... DISQUALIFI .... RULES, 1995 Ct'H)239'
2. Parties to election petition.-[l] Pers~ns who withdrew their
e.andidature on the date of withdrawal of nomination are' not required
to be made party to an electjon petition. Devram v. Sadu, 1996 MPLJ
606=1996 JLJ 240.
[2]Where petitioner claims that he or any other person be declared
elected in place, of the returned candidate, he has to join only the
contest>ingcandidates as party and not those whose nomination has been
rejected or who withdrew his nomincttion. Harishankar Suryavanshi v.
State of M.p'., 1998 (2) Vidhi Bhaswar 225.
5. Contents of the petition.-An election petition shall-
(a) contain a concise statement of all material facts on which the
petitioner relies;
(b) set forth with sufficient particulars, the grounds on which the
election is called in question;
(c) be signed by the petitione:- and verified in the manner laid down
in the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (V of 1908), for the
verifications of pleadings.
COIVIMENTARY
1. Verification. SUQstantial compliance.-The object of verifying
the pleading is fix on ihe partyresportsibilityabout truthfulness of its
contents and the same Rule has been made applicab~ to the election
petition filed under 8.122 of the Panchayat Act. When the facts are
verified by affidavit, then the rule has been substantially compiled with .
.Ramrati v. S.D. 0., Sidhi, 2005 (3) MPLJ 101. '
2. Distinction between material facts and particulars.-Under
Rule 5 the election petition'requires a concise statement of all material
facts on which the petitioner relies, and sets forth with sufficient par-
____t~c~!a~~Lt~~grou~~s on which the election is called In question:,
Material facts are facts upon which election petitioner files an
election petitton showing cause of' action. What particulars could be
material facts would depend upon the facts of each case and no universal
rule can be laid down. It is however, absolutely essential that all basic
and primary facts which must be proved at the trial by the party to
establish the case are material facts and must be stated in the pleading.
by the party. Material facts are primary or basic facts which must be
pleaded by the election petitioner in support of the case set up by the
petitioner to prove the cause of action. PartiqIlars on the other hand are,
details in support ofmateriBl facts pleaded by the party. They amplify,
refine and embellish material facts by giving distinctive touch to the
bas'is contours of a picture already drawn so as to make iffull; more clear
and more informative. Ramavtar Budhollwa v. Smt. Susheela Singh,
.==- ~--'2007(~1)--JW54. _.. '
:1' •;. ~.'.
~..
, ,..
iI '
i
r,
I
I
~.
!
"
(PR)240 ELECTION.PETITlONS ... DISQUALIFI .... RULES, 1995 R. 6
•,
6. Relief that may be claimed by the petitioner.-A petitioner may
claim-
, ;
(a) a, declaration that the election of all or any of the returned
candidates is void; and
(b) in addition thereto, a further declaration that he himself or any
other candidate has been duly elected.
7. Deposit of security.-At the time of presentation of an election,
,petition; the petitioner shall deposit with the specifiedofficera sum ofRs.
fiveHundred as security. Where the election ofmore than one' candidate
is called in question, a separate deposit of an equivalent amount ~hall be
required in respect of each such returned candidates. .
COMMENTARY
D~posit of security amount is essential.-Fresh election petition
filed by the petitioner by withdrawing the earli-erpetition. While filing
the second election petition, security amount has to be deposited by the
petitioner. Amount deposited with the first election petition cannot be
treated as deposit of security for entertaining the second election peti-
tion. Election petition rightly dismissed by the Election Tribunal for
non-compliance of Rule 7 of the Rules. Roopa Singh v. State of M.P.,
2012(2) MPLJ 435 :::2012(2) MPHT 502.
Where no security deposit was accompanied with the election .peti-.
tion, the'petition cannot be entertained a,ndliable to be dismissed under
Rule 8. No deposit thereafter can remove the ,defect. Saria Tripathi
(Smt.) v. Smt. Kaushalya Devi, 2004 (2) JLJ 263 (DB).See alsoAyodhya
Prasad v. State of M.P., 2001.(2) MPLJ Notes 25.
Enclosement of receipt not compulsory in each case.-Rule 7
does not say that an,election petitioner is bound and obliged to file a copy
of the receipt along with the election petition:lf the Presiding Officer
receives the security cost in cash and does not issue the receipt immedi-
ately thereafter, then such a lapse or inaction on the part ofthe Presiding
Officer or his office,election petitioner cannot be allowed to suffer. Lata
Patle v. Smt. Kamlesh Gautam, 2008 (1) MPLJ 388.
8. Procedure on receiving petition.-If the provisions ofrule 3 or rule
4 or rule 7 have not been compliedwith,\the petition, shall be dismissed .
by the specified.officers: , , .
Provided that the petition shall not t>edismissed under this rule
without givingthe petitioner an opportunitYofbeing heard. ' ,
<COMMENTARY'
, .
1. Non-compliance of Rules hi ElectionPetition.-[l] Issue of
defect of non-compliance of the rules can be taKen up by the Election
Tribunal at any stage and it is not incumbent upon the authority to do
so only at the threshold. Baijulal Verma v. Additional Collector,
Chhindwara, 2009(4) MPLJ 548 = 2010(1) MPHT 477.
\
, .,\
:.6
R.9 ELECTION PETITIONS ... DISQUALIFI .... RULES, 1995 (PR)241
lay
,ed
ny
on
~.
lte
be
. ,
1-
~z.
a
7
y
r
g
1
~
i .
~
=~
f ~
~
~
I . H
~
, [2]Non compliance with Rules 3,4 or 7. Prescribed Authority if after
hearing the petitioner finds non-compliance of Rules 3, 4 or 7, it has no
choicebut to dismiss the petition. Di'Oisiyaw /0 Naresh Paraste v. Shanta
w/oNarayan Singh Pusham, 2011(2) MPLJ 701.
2. Provisions are niandatory.-[l] The provisions of Rules 7 and 8
are mandatory. Where security amount- was not deposited along with
the election petition, such a petition is liable to be dismissed. Udaysingh
v. Himmatsingh, 1999 (1) JLJ 200.
[2]But in a case where deposit was not made along with the election
petition but made subsequently before expiration of the period of limit a-
tion and also before cognizance of the matter was taken, the election
petition does not suffer from a fatal defect. AIR 1986 MP 49 Disting. Ravi
.' Thakur v: Shivshankar, AIR 1997 MP 136. See also Kailashnarayan v.
Namdar, 1996 JLJ 391.
[3] It is essential that an election petition should be signed and
verified. Further it is essential that it should accompany as many copies
of such a petition as there are respondents. Udaysingh v. Himmatsingh,
1999 (1) JLJ 200.
See also:
[4]Shivdhari v. Jad1:lman, 1998 (2) JLJ 183.
[5],Where deposit of security amount was not made along with
'election petitiog anc;lthe, S.D.a. took cogriizance of it, directed recount
of votes and passed order for setting aside election of the returned
candidate, the order is bad. Election petition suffered from fatal defect.
Amarsingh v. Sub-divisional Officer, 1997 (2) MPLJ 192.
3. Scope of preliminary objections.-Mter filing of the pleadings
the presiding officer heard preliminary arguments and on the basis of
this the election petition has been dismissed. Held, preliminary objec-
tions may be considered by the Election Tribunal but the scope of
preliminary objections is limited under Rule $ of the Rules, in respect of
objection relating to the presentation' of election petition under Rule 3,
non-furnishing of the security as required under Rule 7 of the Rules or
non- impleadment of parties as required under Rule 4 of the Rules.
Except these, there is no provisior: for hearing preliminary objection and .'
deciding the case at preliminary stage. The Election Tribunal committed
an error ofjuris dietion in adopting the 'aforesaid procedure. Lalamadas
s /0 Roopdas v. VidyaUJati, 2007(1) MPLJ 410.
•
9. Copyof the election petition to be s~rved on each respondent.-
The specified,officershall, as soon as may be, cause a copy of petition to
be served on each respondent.
COMMENTARY
- - =""Rule9 does nowhere say that the copyrequired to be verified under
Rule 3 is only to be served upon the respondent. However a juxtapose
reading ofRule 9 with Rule 3 we must observe that the copies submitted
IR.I0
COMME1~TAR.Y
1. Jurisdiction of specifiedofficer.-The specified Officer cannot
entertain application under 8.122 before publicati"n of notification
under Rule.22 ofthe.Nirvachari.NiY~J);!,J995.He also cannot order stay
ofissue ofnotification under the Nirvachan Niy'ain of1995. Order passed
by him staying publication ofnotification and setting aside election were
without jurisdiction and therefore quashed. Chandra Bhan Singh v.
State of M.P., 2002 (1) MPLJ 58..
2. Specified Officer.-The term 'specified officer' iri.this rule cannot
be construed to mean Collector only. The rule governs enquiry of all
election petitions questioning election to. Gram Panchayat, Janpad
Panchayat and ZHaoPanchayat. Hence the expression '~ecified officer'
has been incorporated. From tne scheme o£the Act and the M.P.Land
Revenue Code, the Additional Collector shall be deemed to be a specified
officer in case elect~onpetition is transferred. to him by the Collector
exercising his power under section 17(2)ofthe M.P.Land Revenue Code,
195'9. IJ,cijkumar Shivhare v. Anand Kumar Tiwari, 2000 (3) MPLJ
.391=2000 (2) JLJ121. . .0' • - ~.=._= ~"_ .. --
10. Election petitions to be enquired into through one or n"lore
proceedings.-When, in respect of any election of a candidate, more peti-
tions than one are presented, the specified officer may at his discretion
enquire into the petitions either in one or more proceedings as he deems.
fit. 11. Procedure before the specified' officer and his powers.-(1}
Subject to the provisions of these rules, every election petition shall be
enquired into by the.specified officeras nearly, 'as may be, in ascordance
with the procedure applicable under the Code of CivilProcedure, 1908, to
the trial of suits: .
Provided that it shall onlybe necessary for the specified officerto make
a memorandum of the substance of the evidence of any witness'examined
by him.
(22)The specified officer, shall have 'the powers which are vested in a
'Court under tlile Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, when trying a suit in
respect of the followingmatters:-
(a) discovery and inspection;
(b) enforcing the attendance of witnesses,' and requiFing the
deposit of their expenses;
(c) compelling the production of document;
• (d) examinatiori ofwitnesses on ogth; \
(e) receptlon of evidence taken on affi<;lavit;and .... _.- ,. _..... - _.... - .. ,
(f) issuing commission for examination ofwitnesses and summon-
ing and examining suo moto any person whose evidence, ap:"
pears to him to be material.
(PR)242 ELECTION PETITIONS ... DISQUALIFI .... RULES, 1995
under Rule 3(2)must onlybe supplied to the party/respondent after they
put their appearance in the Court. Lata Patle v. Smt. Kamlesh Gautam,
2008 (1) MPLJ 388.
l'
1.\
I'
I
J~.. :, .
, ~ \
R.13 ELECTION PETITIONS ... DISQUALIFI .... RULES, 1995 (PR)243
3. Enquiry essential in election petition.-Provisions of Rule 11
specifically provides that the enquiry in the election petition shall be as
nearly as may be in accordance with the procedure applicable to the trial
of suits under the Code of Civil Procedure. Lalamadas s /0 Roopdas v.
Vidyawati, 2007(1) MPLJ 410. ' ,
12. Parties to produce their witne~ses.-It shall be the duty of the
parties to produce their witnesses on the date fixed for evidence, and they
shall not be entitled to an adjournment for non-attendance of their
witnesses:' ,.
Provided that the specified officer may, at his discretion, order the
issue of summons to any witness on the necessary process fee and costs
being deposited by the party conceoed.
COM M E ,N TAR Y
No need to examine Returning Officer and to call him in
evidence .-Sub-rule (3) of Rule 80 of M.P. Panchayat Nirvachan Niyam,
1995 provides that every decision of the Returning Officer or such other
officer authorised by him under sub-rule (2) of Rule 80 shall be in writing
and contain the reasons therefor. Thus there ,is no need to examine the
Returning Officer by the specified officer in suo motu powers for deciding
whether he has passed any written order'or not, it 'can be established. by'
filing copy of the order. Kailashi 1). Bharosi Bai, 2008 (2) MPLJ 218 =
2008(5) MPHT 204 = 2008(1) MPWN l06/~ AIR 2008 (NOe) 1536 MP.
13.Withdrawal of election petition.-(l) No election petition shall be
withdrawn without the leave of the specified officer.
(2) If there are more petitioners than one, no application to withdraw
a petitiqn shall be made except with. the consent of all the petitioners.
(3) When an application for with:lrawal is made, a notice thereof fixing
a date for the hearing of the application shall be given to all other parties
to the petition.
(4) No application for withdrawal shall be entertained after the
evidence of the petitioner is over.
, (5) If the application is granted, the petitioner shall be ordered to pay
the costs of.the respondents theret.) as incurred or such portion thereof
as the specified officer may deem fit.
.COMMENTA;RY
I;
. . . \
Withdrawal of petition.- [1] Mere filing of an application for
withdrawal of election petition will not automatically result into
withdrawal of election petition. Can be withdrawn only with the leave
of the specified officer. This is a matter of common knowledge that in
elections lot' of pressure, threatening, 'money and muscle power are
.employed and this sometimes results' ihto filing of a wit~drawal applica-
tion in the election petition. Thus, a power is given to the'specified officer
to examine the genuineness of such a request .and if the said authority
..
I
I. ,
,'.", , I
. Ii.Il -
,r " .
,
I .
I,,
I .,
I
(PJl)244 ELECTION PETITIONS ... DISQUALIFI .... RULES, 1995 R 14
comes to the conclusion that in the facts and circumstances of the case,
such a leave cannot be granted, it has a power to refuse the same.
Leelawati u. Kanhaiyalal, 2011(4) MPLJ 131 = 2012(1) JLJ 33. ,.
. [2] Rule 2l(1)(d) Recount of votes-Consideration.-Held, mere
rejection of an application under Rule 80 filed by the petitioner is not a
sufficient ground for ordering recount of votes. Vidhyawati Lilhare u.
Sub-DiuisionalOfficer-cum-Frescribed Officer, Lanji, Balaghat, 2010(1)
MPLJ 115 = 2010(4) MPHT 92 = 2010(2) JLJ 29.
[3]Withdrawal of election petition by election petitioner as a result
of compromise by the petitioner and elected 'candidate-respondent. Par-
ties were closely related and withdrawal was in their domestic interest .
Moreover it was not a case involving any allegation of corrupt practice
but only a case ofrecouting ofvotes. Leave to withdraw election petition'
granted. Meena Singh u. Prescribed Authority-Cum-Collector, 1998 (2)
MPLJ309.
14. Abatement of election petition.-An election petition shall abate
duly on the death of the petitioner or of the several petitioners or of the
sole respondent.
COMMENTARY
.... Death.ofrespondent the returned candidate.- In Bhushan.v .. _
S.D.a. Janjgir [1998 (2) JLJ 79], under s~milar rules of 1991, rule 15, .
it is held that in a case where the respondent, the returned candidate
has died and. the petitioner has sought the remedy of declaring the
petitioner elected in place of returned candidate, in accordance with the
exception provided therein,. the petition shaH have to be decided pn
merits and the petition shall not abate. But under the present rules there
is no such exception provided and under the circumstances the petition
shall abate. •
-----_. '-- .. - - - '- --. - - -- --_ .. -- --
15. Recrimi'nation when se'atclaimed.-Whereas, at an enquiry- into
an election, any candidate claims, the seat for himself, the elected can-
didate or any other party may give evidence to prove that the election of
such candidate would have been void if he had been the elected candidate
arid a petition had been presented calling in question his election.
CO M'ME NTARY
. . .
Applicability.-Rule 15. appIles when'the seat is Claimed by the
'. election petitioner. A.prayer for general recount is not included in it.
".Tulsiram u. Uttamkhan,2003 (1) MPLJ 333.. ' '..
. . 16. Application of the Indian :Evidence Act. 1872.'-Subject. to the
provisions. of these rules, the pr6vi'sions of the' Indian-EVidence Act, 1872
(l of. 1872) shall apply in all respects to an enquiry into an election
petition.
I
I
I-
I
I
I
I
R.21 ELECTION PETITIONS ... LISQUALIFI .... RULES, 1995 (PR)245
17.Appearance before the specified officer.-An appearance, applica-
tion or act before the specified'officermay be made or done by the party in
person or by a -pleaderor an agent duly appointed to act on his behalf:
Provided that it shall be open to.the specified officer to direct any party
to appear in person whenever it considers if necessary.
18. Documentary evidence.-Nc. document shall be in admissible in
evidence on the ground that it is not duly stamped or registered ..
19. Secrecy of voting not to be infringed.-No witness or other person
shall be required to or allowed to.state for whom he has voted.
20. Answering of criminating questions and certificate. of indem-
nity.-(l) Nowitness shall be excuse<;l:rom answering any question as to any
matter relevant to a matter in issue in any enquiIy upon the ground that the
answer to such question may criminate or may tend to criminate him, or that
it may expose or may tend to expose him to any penalty or forfeiture:
Provided that-
(a) a witness who answered tuly all questions which he is required
to answer shall be entitled to receive a certificate of indemnity
from the specified officer.
(b) an answer given by a witness to a question put by or before the
sgecified officer shall EO •. except in the case of any criminal
proceeding for peIjury in respect of the evidence, be admissible
in evidence against him i:1any proceeding.
, .... (71Wh~~ a~e~~fi~.a_~egq~ge.ITI}?-ityl].9-s.~een,gr:antedto any witness, it
may be pleaded by him in' any Court and shall be--a- full' arid-complete"'" -
defense to or upori any criminal charge arising out of the matter to which
such certificate relates but it shall rot be d~emed to relieve him from any
disqualification in connection with an election imposed by the Act or the
rules made thereunder.. .
21. Grounds for declaring election to be void.-(l) Subject to the
provisions of sub-rule (2) if the spedfied officer is of opinion-
(a) that on the date of his election the returned candidate who was
not qualified or was disqualified to be chosen to fill the seat •
. :: under.the.Act~,or--,-.- "-.. ~- - , -.' - - -.".' ..
~ 4 + ~
(b) that any corrupt practire has been committed by a returned
candidate or his election agent or by.any other person with the
consent of a returned 'clli~didateor his election agent; or
(c) that any nomination paper has been improperly rejected; or
(d) that the result of the elel~tionin so far as it concerns returned
candidate has been materially affected- .
(i) by the improper acceptance bf any nomination; or
(ii) by a corrupt practice having b~en committed in the interest
of the returned candidate by a person acting with the con-
sent of the candidate or his agent; or
(iii) by the improper acceptance, refusal or rejection of any vote
. or the ,reception of any vote which is void; or
~'._ .-.._.._ __~,"~Uv)'.by .ap.Y.1J.9D-:_<;Q!I!RlJ~=~_~~lLtl;1~_pr:qvis~on~.of the Act or of . .
any rules or orders made thereunder;' - .. - .. "
the specified officer shall deClare the election of the returned candidate to
be void. : .
, I
COMMENTARY
22. Corrupt practices.-The following shall be deemed to be corrupt
practices for the purposes of these rules:-.
(i) Bribery as defined and explainedJn clause (1) of section 123 the
Representation' of the People Act,l1951 (No. 43 of 1951).
(ii) Undue influence as defined in clause (2) of section 123 of the
Representation of the People Act, 1951.
(iii) The systematic appeal by a candidate or his agent or by any
other person With the consent of a cgndidate or his election
agent, to vote or refrain from voting on grounds~6fcaste:- rac~
community or religion or the use of or appeal to, religious
symbols or, the use of or appeal to national symbol such as the
(2) If in the opinion of the prescribed authority a returned candidate
has been guilty by an agent of any corrupt practice, but the prescribed
authority is satisfied-
(a) that no such corrupt pra,~t1cewas committed at the election by
the candidate and evelY such corrupt practice was committed
contrary to the instructions and without the consent of the
candidate; .
(b) that the candidate took all reasonable means for preventing the
commission of corrupt practice at the election; and
(c) that in all other respect the election was free from any corrupt
practice on the part of the candidate or any of his agent;
then the prescribed authority may decide that the election of the returned
candidate is not void.
R.22 .(PR)246 ELECTION PETITIONS ... DISQUALIFI .... RULES, 1995.
1.Order of recount.- An orderofrecount cannot be passed onmere asking.
An issue should be framed, evidencebe recorded and the question should be
decided on going through such an evidence.Secrecyofvotes cannot be lightly
revealed. Udaysingh v.Himmatsingh, 1999 (1)JLJ 200.
[2] Recount. of votes cannot be ordered even on consent. Secrecy of
voting cannot be broken lightly. Gajanan v. Ramcharan, 1997 (II)
MP\VN3.
2. Result materially affected or not-cases.':
[1]. Election dechl:l-ed void ..-The nomination paper ora returned
candidate itself is found to have been improperly accepted because the
returned candidate superseded his some assets etc. Held, his result has
been obviously materially affected therefore his election properly
declared as void. Mehboob Khan v. Lallu Bhai, AIR 2909 (NOC) 532
MP = 2008 (4) MPLJ 198 = 2008(3) JLJ 307 = 2008(5) MPHT 95.
[2] Returned candidate lady superseded fact of having nine children,
it would not have caused any disqualification to her, therefore the result
of the election is not materially affected and the improper acceptance of
nomination paper due to iricomplete information-in the deClaration did
not provide a ground to set aside the election. Siyawati v. Phoolwati,
2009(1) MPHT 301 = 2009(1) JLJ 431 = AIR 2009 (NOC) 425 MP =
2008 (4) MPLJ 437.
R.23 ELECTION PETITIONS ... DISQUALIFI .... RULES, 1995 (PR)247
. ":. i-
national emblem, for national flag, for the furtherance of the
prospects of that candidate's election.
(iv) The publication by a candidate or his agent or by any other
person with the consent whether direct, indirect or implieS of
the candidate or his election agent of any statement of fact in
relation to the personnel character or conduct of any candidate,
or in relation to the candidature, or withdrawal from contest of .
any candidate being a statement reasonably calculated to
prejudice the prospects of that candidate's election.
(v) The hiring or procuring whether on payment or otherwise of any
vehicle or vessel by a candidate or his agent or any other person
with the consent of the candidate' or his election agent for the
conveyance of any elector other than the candidate himself, and
the members of his family or his agent, to or from any polling
station provided in accordance with the rules made under the Act:
Provided that the hiring of a vehicle or vessel by an elector or by
several electors at their joint costs for the purpose of conveying
him or them to or from any such polling station, shall not be
deemed to be a corrupt. practice under this clause and if the
vehicle or vessel so hired is a vehicle or vessel not propelled by
a mechanical power:
Provided further that the use of any public transport vehicle by an
elector at his own cost for the purpose of going to or coming
from, any such polling station shall not be deemed to be a
..... . ..;.-ccorruptp~act~ce.undeL:his.clause~ __ :: ::._._.. : _.. : _ .._..- .
Explanation.-In this. clause the expression 'vehicle' me,ans any
vehiCle used or capable or being, used for the purpose of road
transport whether propelled by mechanical power or otherwise
and whether used for drawing other vehicles or otherwise.
(vi) The holding of any meeting tn which intoxicating liquors are
served.
(vii) The issuing of any circular, placard or poster having a reference
to the election which does not bear the name and address of the
printer and publisher C ereof .
. '--(vii!)" Pers:on'ati'on"at--electton' as' ddinea"fu'.Sectloii"I7T-n .oCilie-- ....
Indian Penal Code, 1860.
. (ix) The employment or connivance at the employment of ,any
panchayat officer or servant or an employee' as mentioned in
sub- clause (d) of clause (1) of Section 36 of the Act as an agent
for canvassing.
(x) Acting of any Panchayat Officer or servant of an employee as
mentioned in sub-clause (d) of clause (1) of Section 36 of the Act
as an agent in connection with th;y election of the candidate.
23. Decision.-(1) At the conclusion of th~ enquiry the specified officer
shall make an order-
(a) dismissing the election petition; or
(b) declaring the election of all or any of the returned candidates to
-.be void;.or '..~ ~~-=-~-~~=~~.- ~-~= = ~.=..-.=~,-.~~.. -.
(c) declariJJ.gthe election of all or any o(ffie'returned-canaidate to
be void and the petitioner or any other candidate to have been
Appeal and Revision.-Rules framed for election petitions etc. do
not provide any appeal or revision. Decision pronounced under Rule 23
has further been declared to be final under Rule 25. Hukumchand v.
Dheerji, 2001 (1)JLJ ~29.
. ,;
24. Proced~e in ~ase of equality of vbtes.-If during the enquiry it
appears to the specified officer that there is an equality of votes between.
and candidate at the election and that an addition of a vote would entitled
any of these candidates to be declared elected then, specified officer shall
decide between them by lot and proceed as if the one in whose favour the
lot falls, had received an additional vote. - - - -__
25. ~inality of de~ision.-The decision of the specified officer shall be'
final. .
duly elected.
(2) If any person who has filed an .election petition has in addition ~o
calling in question the election of the returned candidate, claimed decla-
ration that he himse~9r any other candidate has been duly elected and
the specified officer is .of opinion-.
(a) that in fact the petitioner of such other candidate received a
majority of valid votes, or
(b) that but~r the votes obtained by the returned candidate the
petitioner" or such other candidate would have obtained a
majority of valid votes;
the specified officer' shall, after declaring the election of the returned
candidate to be vo~d,declare the petitioner or such other (";ll1didate,as the
case may be, to have been duly elected. . .
(3) At the time of making order under this rule. the specified officer.
shall also make an order- . .
(a) Where any charge is made in the PCI iUon of any corrupt
practice having been committed at the election, recording-
(i) a finding whether any corrupt practh'(' has or has not been
p:-oved to have been committed al the election and the
nature of that corrupt practice, and
(ii) the name of all person, if any, who have been proved to have
been guilty of any corrupt practice and the nature of that
practice; and .
. (b). fixing the total. amount of costs payable and specifying the
persons by whom the costs shall be paid:
Provided that a person who is not party to the petition shall not be
named in the order under sub-clause (ii)of clause (a) unless-
'(a) he has been given notice to appear before him and show
cause why he should not be so named; and
(b) if he appears in pursuance of the notice, he has been given
an opportunity of cross examining any witness who has
already been examined by the specified officer and had given
evidence against, of calling evidence in his defence and of.
being heard.
COMMENTARY
R.24(PR)248 ELECTION PETITIONS ... DISQUALIFI .... RULES, 1995
R.30 ELECTION PETITIONS ... DISQUALIFI .... RULES, 1995 (PR)249
;
,
. ,
. I,
J
\
!
26. Costs.-(l) The expenses as per the followingtable incurred by any .
person in .attending to give evidence shall unless .the specified officer
otherwise directs, be deemed to be part of the cost-
(i) Actual fares of travel by any made ofconveyance including bus,
train or taxi or combination thereof from his place of residence
or work to the court of tbe specified officer.
(ii) Rs. 40/- per day or part thereof to cover the expenses incurred
towards daily allowance.
(2)Co£ts shall be the discretion of the specified officerwho shall have
full powers to determine as to by and to whom and to what extent such
costs are to be paid.
(3)The pleader's fees payable by a party shall be determined by the
s~cified officerwhich shall not exceedmore than Rs. FiveHundred.
27. Payment of costs out of security and its refund.-(l) The costs
as determined by the specified officer shall, if they have not already been
paid, be paid in full, or so fCl!as possible, out of the security deposit under
rule 7, on an application made in writing in that behalf within a period of
three months from the date of such 0 der to the specified officer by the
person in whose favour the costs have been awarded.
(2) If there is any balance left out of the said security deposit after
payment of the costs, such balance, orwhere not costs have been awarded
.~:-or.no .application.-qs~foresaid has been.made within said -period:of three -_:_~.'.:.->. .._.-.-
months, the whole of said deposit may, on an application made in that
behalf in writing to the specified officerby th~ person bywhom deposit has
been made or if such person dies after making such deposit, by the legal
representative ofsuch person, be re:umed to the said person or to his legal
representative as the case may be.
28. Execution of orders as to costS.-An order as to costs under the
provisions of these rules may be produced before the Principal CivilCourt
of original jurisdiction within the local limits of whose jurisdiction any
person direct by such order to pay any sum of money has a piace of
. - residence- or tiusine~s, and sucli -Court"sliall-executetlie -ofder-.orcaiise.-- -----------
the same to be executed in the same manner and by the same procedure
as if it were a decree for the payment ofmoney maqe by itself in suit.
29. Disability arising'out of cDrrupt practices.-If any person, upon
the trial of an election petition, is found guilty of any corrupt practice, he
shall, for a period of six years from the date on which such finding takes'
effect. be declared by the specified officertq be disqualified for the mem-
bership of any panchayat: \ .
Providing that the State Government may! for reasons to be recorded
I.
in writing. remove the disqualification incurred under this rule, with effect
from such date as may be specified therein or reduce the period of such
disqualification.
30. Repeal.-All previous rules on the subject shall stand repealed from
the date .of final -publication -of ~e~e r!1I~_~.!:p.~~p.e--~~~c:Ihy~~~Pradesh.
Gazette".
00000001
00000002
00000003
00000004
00000005
00000006
00000007
00000008
00000009
00000010
00000011
00000012
00000013
00000014
00000015
00000016
Previous and next
Questions people ask
Is rule 30 of the Madhaya Pradesh Panchayats (Election Petitions, Corrupt Practices And Disqualification for Membership) Rules, 1995 still in force?
No repeal of the Madhaya Pradesh Panchayats (Election Petitions, Corrupt Practices And Disqualification for Membership) Rules, 1995 is recorded.