Rule 12, PCR Rules 1995: MEASURES TO BE TAKEN BY THE DISTRICT ADMINISTRATION
PCR Rules 1995 - Rule 12
Text of rule 12
MEASURES TO BE TAKEN BY THE DISTRICT ADMINISTRATION
12. MEASURES TO BE TAKEN BY THE DISTRICT ADMINISTRATION :-
(1) The District Magistrate and the Superintendent of Police shall visit the place or area
where the atrocity has been committed to assess the loss of life and damage to the property and
draw a list of victim their family members and dependents entitled for relief.
(2) Superintendent of Police shall ensure that the First Information Report is registered in the
book of the concerned police station and effective measures for apprehending the accused are
taken.
7-
-7-
(3) The Superintendent of Police, after spot inspection, shall immediately appoint an
investigation officer and deploy such police force in the area and take such other preventive
measures as be may deem proper and necessary.
(4) The District Magistrate or the Sub Divisional Magistrate or any other Executive Magistrate
shall make arrangements for providing immediate relief in cash or in kind or both to the victims of
atrocity, their family members and dependents according to the scale as in the schedule
annexed to these Rules (Annexure-| read with Annexure-ll). Such immediate relief shall also
include food, water, clothing, shelter, medical aid, transport facilities and other essential items
necessary for human beings.
(5) The relief provided to the victim of the atrocity or his/her dependent under sub-rule (4) in
respect of death, or injury to, or damage to property shall be in addition to any other right to claim
compensation in respect there of under any other law for the time being in force.
(6) The relief and rehabilitation facilities mentioned in sub-rule (4) above shall be provided by
the District Magistrate or the Sub-Divisional Magistrate or any other Executive Magistrate in
accordance with the scales provided in the Schedule annexed to these rules.
(7) A report of the relief and rehabilitation facilities provided to the victims shall also be
forwarded to the Special Court by the District Magistrate or the Sub-Divisional Magistrate or the
Executive Magistrate or Superintendent of Police. In case the Special Court is satisfied that the
payment of relief was not made to the victim or his/her dependent in time or the amount of relief
or compensation was not sufficient or only a part of payment of relief or compensation was made,
it may order for making in full or part the payment of relief or any other kind of assistance.
13. SELECTION OF OFFICERS AND OTHER STAFF MEMBERS FOR COMPLETING THE
WORK RELATING TO ATROCITY:
(1) The State Government shall ensure that the administrative officers and other staff
members to be appointed in an area prone to atrocity shall have the right aptitude and
understanding of the problems of the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes.
(2) It shall also be ensured by the State Government that person from the Scheduled Castes
and the Scheduled Tribes are adequately represented in the administration and in the police force
at all levels, particularly at the level of police posts and police station.
14. SPECIFIC RESPONSIBILITY OF THE STATE GOVERNMENT:
The State Government shall make necessary provisions in its annual budget for providing
relief and rehabilitation facilities to the victims of atrocity. It shall review at least twice in a
calendar year, in the month of January and July the performance of the Special Public Prosecutor
specified or appointed under Section 15 of the Act, various reports received, investigation made
and preventive steps taken by the District Magistrate, Sub-Divisional Magistrate and
Superintendent of Police, relief and rehabilitation facilities provided to the victims and the reports
in respect of lapses on behalf of the concerned officers.
15. CONTINGENCY PLAN BY THE STATE GOVERNMENT:
(1) The State Government shall prepare a model contingency plan for implementing the pro-
8/-
-8-
visions of the Act and notify the same in the Official Gazette of the State Government. It should
specify the role and responsibility of various departments and their officers at different levels, the
role and responsibility of Rural/Urban Local Bodies and Non-Government Organisations. Inter
alia this plan shall contain a package of relief measures including the following.
(@) scheme to provide immediate relief in cash or in kind or both;
(b) allotment of agricultural land and house sites;
(c) the rehabilitation packages;
(d) scheme for employment in Government or Government undertaking to the dependant
or one of the family members of the victim;
(e) pension scheme for widows, dependant children of the deceased, handicapped or
old age victims of atrocity;
(f) mandatory compensation for the victims;
(g) scheme for strengthening the socio-economic condition of the victim;
(h) provisions for providing brick/stone masonary house to the victims;
(i) such other elements as health care, supply of essential commodities, electrification,
adequate drinking water facility, burial /cremation ground and link roads to the
Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes habitats.
(2) The State Government shall forward a copy of the contingency plan or a summary
thereof and copy of the scheme, as soon as may be, to the Central Government in the Ministry of
Welfare and to all the District Magistrates, Sub-Divisional Magistrates, Inspector General of
Police and Superintendents of Police.
16. CONSTITUTION OF STATE-LEVEL VIGILANCE AND MONITORING COMMITTEE:
(1) The State Government shall constitute a high power vigilance and monitoring committee
of not more than 25 members consisting of the following:
@) Chief Minister/Administrator — Chairman (in case of a State under President's Rule
Governor - Chairman).
(i) Home Minister, Finance Minister and Welfare Minister - Members (in case of a State
under the President’'s Rule Advisors - Members).
(iii) All elected Members of Parliament and State Legislative Assembly and Legislative
Council from the State belonging to the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes —
Members.
(iv) Chief Secretary, the Home Secretary, the Director General of Police, Director/Deputy
Director National Commission for the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes —
Members.
9/-
-9-
(v) The Secretary in-charge to the welfare and development of the Scheduled Castes and
the Scheduled Tribes — convener.
(2) The high power vigilance and monitoring committee shall meet at least twice in a
calendar year, in the month of January and July to review the implementation of the provisions of
the Act, relief and rehabilitation facilities provided to the victims and other matters connected
therewith, prosecution of cases under the Act, role of different officers/agencies responsible for
implementing the provisions of the Act and various reports received by the State Government.
17. CONSTITUTION OF DISTRICT LEVEL VIGILANCE AND MONITORING COMMITTEE:
(1) In each district within the State, the District Magistrate shall set up a vigilance and
monitoring committee in his district to review the implementation of the provisions of the Act, relief
and rehabilitation facilities provided to the victims and other matters connected therewith,
prosecution of cases under the Act, role of different officers/agencies responsible for
implementing the provisions of the Act and various reports received by the District Administration.
(2) The district level vigilance and monitoring committee shall consist of the elected
Members of Parliament and State Legislative Assembly and Legislative Council, Superintendent
of Police, three group ‘A’ officers/Gazetted officers of the State Government belonging to the
Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes, not more than 5 non official members belonging to
the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes and not more than 3 members from the
categories other than the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes having association with
Non-Government Organisations. The District Magistrate and Distt. Social Welfare Officer shall
be chairman and Member Secretary respectively.
(3) The district level committee shall meet at least once in three months.
18. MATERIAL FOR ANNUAL REPORT:
The State Government shall every year before the 31 March. forwarded the report to
the Central Government about the measures taken for implementing provisions of the Act and
various schemes/plans framed by it during the previous calendar year.
[File No.11012/1/89-PCR(Desk)]
GANGA DAS, Jt. Secy.
ANNEXURE - |
SCHEDULE
(See Rule 12.(4)
NORMS FOR RELIEF AMOUNT
S. Name of offence Minimum amount of relief
No.
1. Drink or eat inedible or obnoxious substance Rs. 25.000 or more depending upon the nature
[Section 3 (1) (i)] and gravity of the offence to each victim and
also commensurate with the indignity, insult,
10/-
-10-
2. Causing injury insult or annoyance [Section
3(1)(Gi]
3. Derogatory act [Sec. 3(1) (iii)]
4. Wrongful occupation or cultivation of land,
etc. [Section 3(1)(iv)]
5. Relating to land, premises and water
[Section 3(1)(v)]
6. Begar or forced or bonded labour [Section
3(1) (vl
7. Relating to right to franchise [Section 3(1)
(vii)]
8. False, malicious or vexatious legal proceed-
ings [Section 3(1) (viii)]
9. False and frivolous information [Section 3
(M)
10. Insult, intimidation and humiliation [Section
3 (1)1
11. Outraging the modesty of a woman
[Section 3 (1)(xi)]
12. Sexual exploitation of a woman [Section
3(1)(xi)]
13. Fouling of water [Section 3 (1) (xiii)]
14. Denial of customary rights of passage
[Section 3(1) (xiv)]
15. Making one desert place of residence
[Section 3(1) (xv)]
injury and defamation suffered by the victim.
Payment to be made as follows:
|. 25% when the charge sheet is sent to the
Court
Il. 75% when accused are convicted by the
lower court.
Atleast Rs.25,000 or more depending upon the
nature and gravity of the offence. The
land/premises/water supply shall be restored
where necessary at Government cost, Full pay-
ment to be made when charge-sheet is sent to
to the Court.
Atleast Rs.25,000/- to each victim. payment of
25% at FIR stage and 75% on conviction in the
lower court.
Upto Rs.20,000/ - to each victim depending
upon the nature and gravity of the offence.
Rs. 25,000/ - or reimbursement of actual legal
expenses and damages or whichever is less
after conclusion of the trial of the accused.
Upto Rs. 25,000/- to each victim depending
upon the nature of the offence . Payment of 25%
when charge-sheet is sent to the court and rest
on conviction.
Rs.50,000/- to each victim of the offence .50%
of the amount may be paid after medical
examination and remaining 50% at the conclu-
sion of the trial.
Upto Rs.1,00,000 or full cost of restoration of
normal facility,including cleaning when the water
is fouled. Payment may be made at the stage as
deemed fit by District Administration.
Upto Rs.1,00,000 or full cost of restoration of
right of passage and full compensation of the
loss suffered, if any. Payment of 50% when
charge sheet is sent to the court and 50% on
conviction in lower-court.
Restoration of the site/right to stay and compen-
sation of Rs.25,000/- to each victim and recons-
truction of the house at Govt. cost, if destroyed,
To be paid in full when charge sheet is sent to
the lower court.
1/
16. Giving false evidence [Section 3(2)(i)
and (ii)]
17. Committing offences under the Indian
Penal Code punishable with imprisonment
for aterm of 10 years or more [Section 3
(2]
18. Victimization at the hands of a public
servant [Section 3(2)(vii)]
19. Disability. The definitions of physical &
mental disabilities are contained in the
Ministry of Welfare, G.O.l. notification
No.4-2/83-HW.III, dated 6-8-1986 as
amended from time to time. A copy of
the notification is at Annexure — II.
(a) 100% incapacitation
(i) Non- earning Member of a family
(i) Earning Member of a family
(b) Where incapacitation is less than
100%
20. Murder /Death
(a) Non-earning Member of a family
(b) Earning Member of a family
-11-
At least Rs.1,00,000 or full — compensation of
the loss or harm sustained. 50% to be paid
when charge-sheet is sent to Court and 50% on
conviction by the lower court.
Atleast Rs.50,000 depending upon the nature
and gravity of the offence to each victim and or
his dependents. The amount would vary if speci-
fically otherwise provided in the Schedule.
Full compensation on account of damages or
loss or harm sustained. 50% to be paid when
charge-sheet is sent to the Court and 50% on
conviction by lower court.
At least Rs.1,00,000 to each victim of offence.
50% on FIR and 25% at chargesheet and 25%
on conviction by the lower court.
At least Rs.2,00,000 to each victim of offence,
50% to be paid on FIR/Medical examination
stage, 25% when charge-sheet sent to court and
25% at conviction in lower court.
The rates as laid down in a(i) and (ii) above shall
be reduced in the same proportion, the stages
of payments also being the same. However, not
less than Rs.15,000 to non earning member and
not less than Rs.30,000 to a earning member of
a family.
At least Rs.1,00,000 to each case. Payment of
75% after postmortem and 25% on conviction by
the lower court.
At least Rs. 2,00,000/- to each case. Payment of
75% after postmortem and 25% on conviction by
the lower Court.
12/-
-12-
21. Victim of murder, death, massacre, rape In addition to relief amounts paid under above
mass rape and gang rape, permanent items, relief may be arranged within three
incapacitation and dacoity months of date of atrocity as follows:-
(i) Pension to each widow and/or other
dependents of deceased SC and ST @ Rs.
1,000/- per month, or Employment to one
member of the family of the deceased, or
provision of agricultural land, an house, if
necessary by outright purchase.
(i) Full cost of the education and maintenance
of the children of the victims. Children may
be admitted to Ashram Schools/ residential
schools.
(iii) Provision of utensils, rice, wheat, dals,
pulses, etc. for a period of three months.
22. Complete destruction/burnt houses. Brick/stone masonary house to be constructed
or provided at Government cost where it has
been burnt or destroyed.
ANNEXURE - Il
NO. 4-2/83-HW.III
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
MINISTRY OF WELFARE
New Delhi, the 6" August, 1986.
Subject: Uniform Definitions of the Physically Handicapped.
At present, different definitions for various categories of handicapped are adopted in
various schemes/programmes of the Central and State Governments. In order to have a
standard set of definitions, authorised certification authorities and standard tests for purpose of
objective certification, Government of India in Ministry of Welfare set up three committees under
the Chairmanship of Director General of Health Services — one each in the area of visual
handicaps, speech and hearing disorders and locomotor disabilities and a separate Committee
for mental handicaps.
2. After having considered the reports of these committees and with the concurrence of the
State Governments/UTs and the concerned Ministries/Departments the undersigned is directed to
convey the approval of the President to notify the definitions of the following categories of
physically handicapped:-
Vsually handicaps
Locomotor handicaps
Speech and hearing handicaps
Mental handicaps. H
P
O
N
=
Report of the Committee as indicated in the Annexure I.
13/-
-13-
3. Each category of handicapped persons has been divided into four groups viz. mild
moderate, severe and profound/total. It has been decided that various concessions/benefits
would in future be available only to the moderate, severe and profound/total groups; and not to
the mild groups. The minimum degree of disability should be 40 per cent in order to be eligible
for any concession/benefits.
4. It has been decided that the authorised certifying authority will be a medical board at the
district level. The board will consist of the Chief Medical Officer/Sub-Divisional Medical Officer in
the District and another expert in the specified field viz. opthalmic surgeon in case of visual
handicaps, either an ENT Surgeon or an audiologist in case of speech and hearing handicaps; an
orthopaedic surgeon or a specialist in physical medicine and rehabilitation in case of locomotor
handicaps, a psychiatrist or a clinical psychologist or a teacher in special education in case of
mental handicaps.
5. Specified tests as indicated in Annexure should be conducted by the medical board and
recorded before a certificate is given.
6. The certificate would be valid for a period of three years.
7. The State Govts./UT Admn. may constitute the medical boards indicated in para 4 above
immediately.
M. C. NARSIMHAN, Jt. Secy. to the Govt. of India.
ORDER
Ordered that the above notification be published in the Gazette of India for general
information. Copies of the Gazette nonfiction may be sent to all Ministries/Deptt. of the Central
Govt. all State Govts/UT Admn. President Sectt. P.M.’s Office, Lok Sabha, Rajya Sabha Sectt.
for information and necessary action.
M. C. NARSIMHAN, Jt. Secy. to the Govt. of India.
COMBINE REPORT OF THREE COMMITTTEES RECOMMENDING UNIFORM SET OF
DEFINITIONS, AUTHROITIES FOR CERTIFICATION AND STANDARD TESTS FOR VISUAL,
HEARING AND SPEECH AND LOCOMOTOR DISABILITIES
List of the Members of the Committees at Annexure I.
Introduction
India is a vast country with variable social, cultural, geographical and economic back
ground. Despite breakthrough in health services, a number of disabilities continue to appear due
to polio communicable and congenital diseases, increased industrialisation and mechanisation
vehicular traffic leading to locomotor disabilities; vitamin — A deficiency, cataract and infectious
injuries, nutritional deficiency leading to visual loss; ear infection, external injuries, noise pollution
contributing to hearing loss. These are the three major disabilities which manifest themselves as
a result of one or more of such factors.
2. Government of India are providing a large number of facilites and concessions to
disabled persons. In order to provide these facilities and concessions it is imperative that
standard definition of these disabilities is decided upon. Consequent to recommendation of the
14/-
-14 -
National Council for Handicapped Welfare the Committees under the chairmanship of Director
General of Health Services met for the adoption of standard set of definitions which should be
uniformly applicable through out the country.
The exercise of evolving a uniform set of definition should not be however to construed to
mean that no definitions have been set forth at present. Definitions of these three major
disabilities which are prevalent at present for extending various concessions and facilities to
handicapped are given in Annexure .
Recommended Definitions
Physical impairment leads to functional limitation and functional limitation leads to
disability. Physical impairment, functional limitation and disability have been defined by WHO
and this Committee would recommend adopting this classification, which is as follows:-
(i) Impairment : An impairment is a permanent or transitory psychological or anatomical loss
and /or abnormality. For example a missing or effective part, tissue organ or “Mechanism”
of the body such as an amputated limb, paralysis after polio, myocardial infarotion,
cerebrovascular thrombosis, restricted pulmonary capacity, diabetes, myopia,
disfigurement, mental retardation, hypertension, perceptual disturbance.
(ii) Functional limitation : Impairment may cause functional limitations which are the partial or
total inability to perform those activities necessary for motor, sensory, or mental functions
within the range and manner of which a human being is normally capable such as walking,
lifting loads, seeing, speaking, hearing, reading, writing, counting, taking interest in and
making contact with surroundings. A functional limitation may last for a short time a long
time be permanent or reversible. It should be quantifiable whenever possible. Limitations
may be described as “Progressive” or “regressive”.
(iii) Disability : Disability is defined as an existing difficulty in performing one or more activities
which, in accordance with the subject’s age, sex and morative social role, are generally
accepted as essential, basic components of daily living, such as self-care, social relations
and economic activity. Depending in part on the duration of the functional limitation
disability may be short-term, long-term or permanent.
Medically, disability is physical impairment and inability to perform physical functions
normally. Legally, disability is a permanent injury to body for which the person should or should
not be compensated.
The disability can be divided into 3 periods.
(i) Temporary total disability is that period in which the affected person is totally unable to
work. During this time he may receive orthopaedic, opthalmological auditory or speech
or any other medical treatment.
(i) Temporary partial disability is that period when recovery has reached the stage of
improvement so that person may begin some kind of gainful occupation.
(i) Permanent disability, applies to permanent damage or loss of use of some part/parts of
the body after the stage of maximum improvement from any medical treatment has
been reached and the condition is stationary.
15/-
-15-
The classifications & various concessions being recommended are for the permanent
disability only.
Evaluation and Assessment of Visual Disabilities
The group recommended the classification of visual impairment/disability may be
categorised in four groups for considering various concessions to visually handicapped.
The question regarding one eyed person was considered at length. The Committee is of
the view that the guidelines recommend for evaluation of visual loss of persons who have lost one
eye but have the other eye normal should be totally unambiguous. The Committee feels that
such persons may not be clubbed with other visually handicapped so that facilities/concessions
available to severely/profoundly visually handicapped and totally blind are not eroded. If one
eyed persons are clubbed with severely/profoundly visually handicapped and totally blind
persons, the Committee feels that most of the concessions especially jobs reserved for the blind
persons shall go to one-eyed persons as their visual loss is minimal compared to other 2
categories and in this manner most of the Government offices/public sector undertakings will be
fulfilling the quota but in actual practice will not be giving jobs to totally blind and persons with
severe visual loss. The Committee, however, feels that it should be made clear that loss of one
eye will not be considered as a disqualification on medical grounds unless a particular post is of
such a technical nature that it requires of a person the use of both the eyes or 3 dimensional
vision. The Committee also recommends that if a person has been declared unfit due to some
temporary visual loss/defect, it should not be construed to mean as disabled if such a temporary
impairment in the opinion of a Medical Board can be overcome with treatment or visual aids.
Guidelines for evaluation & categorisation of visual disabilities are given in Appendix IIl.
2. Evaluation & Assessment of Hearing & Speech Disability
The Committee recommended that the definitions which are internationally accepted and
have been adopted by WHO may be adopted in this country also for evaluation and categori-
sation of hearing & speech loss.
The recommended classification and guidelines for evaluation of hearing loss are given in
Appendix Il. The Committee also considered various facilities/concessions which may be given
to hearing handicapped persons and suggestions of the facilities which may be offered to the
hearing handicapped for rehabilitation are also given in Appendix II.
3. Evaluation & Assessment of Orthopaedic Disabilities
The Committee recommends that Kessler's method may be taken as a general guideline
for evaluating orthopaedic disability. Since issues have been raised regarding the quantification
of degree of disability, the authorised Medical Board may also consult any other suitable method
and use Kessler's method as a basic guideline.
The Committee is aware that there are other methods of quantification which are at
variance with the Kessler's guidelines. However, Kessler's guidelines for evaluation of various
degrees of disability. It is expected, would hold good for most of the time. The individual Medical
Board could take into consideration other methods which may help the board in evaluating dis-
ability in an individual case.
16/-
-16-
The Authorities to give Certification
A permanent disability certificate will be issued by a board duly constituted by the Central
and the State Governments. It is recommended that Medical Board for evaluation of disability
should be available minimum at the district level. It is also recommended to have atleast 3
members in the board, out of which atleast one should be a specialist in the particular field for
assessing locomotor/visual/hearing & speech disability as the case may be.
It is also recommended that the competent authority may also appoint an appellate
medical board to resolve any dispute.
Concessions/Facilities which may be offered to Disabled Persons
Keeping in view the set of definitions and the categorisation being recommended, various
Ministries/Departments and the State Govemments shall have to also specify the facilities and
concessions which would be available to different categories of the handicapped. The Committee
recommends that if a person has the degree of disability below 40 per cent in a particular
category, no such benefits/concessions may be given to such a person. All other categories may
be extended concessions/facilities like scholarships, job reservation, aids and appliances either
free of cost or at confessional rates, conveyance allowance etc. For hearing handicapped, the
Committee recommends that 3 language formula may be revised so that the hearing
handicapped have to study one language only.
Ministry of Social & Women’s Welfare may make out proposal based on these
recommendations with the appropriate Ministry for necessary modifications in the policy of 3
language formula.
The Committee also recommended that Ministry of Health and Family Welfare may also
take up amending medical standards for necessary relaxations in respect of mild handicapped in
all the categories so that on account of their mild disability, they are not put in a position that
neither they are able to get the facility of job reservations nor are eligible otherwise for entering
into services in the general category. The medical rules may also indicates in clear terms that
loss of one eye will not be considered a disqualification unless the particular post is of such a
technical nature that it requires of a person the use of both the eyes or three-dimensional vision.
The same medical board at the district level may examine suitability or otherwise of a one eyed
person for a particular post.
The degree and extent of disability of the 3 types, namely visual, hearing and orthopaedic
will be indicated as follows:-
(a) mild — less than 40 per cent
(b) Moderate — 40 per cent & above
(c) Severe — 75 per cent & above
(d) Profound/total — 100 per cent
For persons suffering from cardio pulmonary diseases, there may be no reservations in
jobs. These persons may, however, be considered for extending other concessions such as
exemption in typing etc.
The Director General of Health Services, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare will be the
final authority, should there arise any controversy/doubt regarding the interpretation of the
definitions/classification/evaluation tests etc.
171-
-17-
Only those persons who have disability more than 40 per cent and above shall be eligible
for registration in Employment Exchanges in the category of handicapped and considered against
jobs in public sector reserved for the physically handicapped.
Annexure - |
Dr. D. B. Bisht,
Director General of Health Services
Ministry of Health & Family Welfare,
Nirman Bhawan, New Delhi.
On Visually Handicapped
1. Dr. Madan Mohan,
Head Deprtt. of Opthalmology,
All India Institute of Medical Sciences
New Dedlhi.
Dr. G. H. Gidwani,
Assistant Director General of Health
Services, Ministry of Health & Family
Welfare, Nirman Bhawan, New Delhi
Shri R. S. Srivastava,
Joint Director,
Director General of Employment &
Training, Ministry of Labour,
Sharam Shakti Bhawan, New Delhi.
Director,
National Institute for the Visually
Handicapped, Rajpur Road, Dehradun,
(Represented by Shri S. R. Shukla,
Asstt. Director).
Dr. G. Venkataswamy,
Arvind Eye Hospital,
Madurai, Tamilnadu.
Dr. J. M. Pahwa,
Chief Medical Officer,
Gandhi Eye Hospital,
Aligarh.
Shri Harcharanijit Singh,
Under Secretary,
Ministry of Social & Women’s Welfare
Composition of Committees to recommend standard definitions of Disabilities
Chaiman
(Of all the three
Committees)
Member
Member
Member
Member
Member
Member
Member Secretary
18/-
-18-
On Hearing Handicapped
1. Dr. G. H. Gidwani,
Assistant Director General of Health
Services,
Ministry of Health and Family Welfare,
Nirman Bhawan, New Delhi. Member
2. Shri R. S. Srivastava,
Joint Director,
Director, General of Employment &
Training, Ministry of Labour,
Sharam Shakti Bhawan, New Delhi. Member
3. Dr. S. K. Kacher,
All India Institute of Medical Sciences,
New Delhi. Member
4. Dr. M. Nithya Seelan,
Director,
All India Institute of Speech & Hearing,
Mysore. Member
5. Dr. N. Rathna,
Director,
Ali Yavar Jung Institute of Hearing
Handicapaped, Haji Ali Parh,
Mahalaxmi, Bombay — 400 034.
(Represented by Dr. M. N. Nagaraja,
Dy. Director in the meeting on 25-6-84) Member
6. Shri Harcharanjit Singh,
Under Secretary,
Ministry of Social & Women'’s Welfare,
New Delhi. Member Secretary
Orthopaedically Handicapped
1. Dr. G. H. Gidwani,
Assistant Director General of Health
Services,
Ministry of Health and Family Welfare,
Nirman Bhawan, New Delhi. Member
2. ShriR. S. Srivastava,
Joint Director,
Director, General of Employment &
Training, Ministry of Labour,
Sharam Shakti Bhawan, New Delhi. Member
3. Dr. Narendra Kumar,
Indian Council of Medical Research,
Ansari Nagar, New Delhi. Member
19/-
-19-
4. Director,
National Institute of Orthopaedically
Handicapped, B. T. Road, Bon Hooghly,
Calcutta. Member
5. Dr. A. K. Mukherjee,
Director,
All India Institute of Physical Medicine
and Rehabilitation,
Haji Ali Parh, Bombay. Member
6. Dr. S. K. Verma,
Head of Deptt. Of Physical Medicine and
Rehabilitation, All India Institute of
Medical Sciences, New Delhi. Member
7. Dr. B. P. Yadav,
Head Rehabilitation Department,
Safdarjung Hospital,
New Delhi. Special Invitee
8. Dr, J. S. Guleria,
Prof. & Head of Deptt. of Medicine,
Dean, All India Institute of Medical
Sciences, New Delhi. Special Invitee
9. Shri Harcharanijit Singh,
Under Secretary,
Ministry of Social & Women'’s Welfare. Member- Secretary
ANNEXURE - Il
()] Visually Handicapped
The definition adopted for visual handicapped for extending the concession, scholarships
admission to Integrated education system, reservation in jobs, assistance for purchaseffitting of
aids and appliances : -
The blind are those who suffer from either of the following conditions.-
(a) Total absence of sight.
(b) Visual acquity not exceeding 6/60 or 20/200 (snellen) in the better eye with correcting
lences.
(c) Limitation of the field of vision substanding and angle of degree or worse.
Definition of Hearing Handicapped under various Schemes.
SCHOLARSHIPS
20/-
-20-
The deaf are those in whom the sense of hearing is non-functional for ordinary purposes
of life. They do not hear/understand sound at all even with amplified speech. The cases
included in this category will be those having hearing loss more than 70 decibles in the better ear
(profound impairment) or total loss of hearing in both ears.
Assistance to Disabled Persons for Purchase/Fitting of Aids/Appliances
The partially hearing are those falling under any one of the categories indicated below:-
Category Hearing aquity
Mild impairment More than 30 but not more
than 45 decibles in better ear.
Serious impairment More than 45 but not more
than 60 decibles in better ear.
Severe impairment More than 60 but not more than
90 decibles in the better ear.
Reservation Orders Issued by Department of Personnel and Administrative Reforms
The deaf are those in whom the sense of hearing is non-functional for ordinary purposes
of life. The do not hear/understand sounds at all events with emplifield speech. The cases
included in this category will be whose having loss more than 90 decibles in the better ear
(profound impairment) or total loss of hearing in both ears.
Locomotor Handicapped
Similarly the definition adopted for orthopaedically handicapped is not uniform as all
orthopaedically handicapped are eligible for getting a scholarship but only those orthopaedically
handicapped person can get the facility of reservation in jobs as have a minimum of 40%
disability.
Situation in State Governments
Various State Governments have also adopted different sets of definition. For example,
Govt. of Tamil Nadu declared one eyed persons in the same category as blind persons and have
extended various concessions including the reservation in jobs under the State government to
one eyed person also. The Central Government on the other hand has declared that a one eyed
person with one eye good vision is not medically unfit and can be considered for jobs which do
not require a three dimensional vision to the specific requirement of the jobs.
21/-
-21-
Appendix - Il
Visual Impairment disability Categories bases on its severity and proposed disability
percentages
All with corrections
Category O 6/9 — 6/18 6/24 to 6/36 20%
Category | 6/18 —6/36 6/60 to Nil 40%
Category Il 6/60 — 4/60 3/60 to Nil 75%
or
Field of vision
110 -20
Category llI 3/60 to 1/60
or
Field of vision FC. at 1 ft. 100%
100 to Nil
Category IV F.C.at1ft F.C.at1ft 100%
to Nil to Nil
or
Field of vision
100
6/6
Field of vision
One eyed persons
The method of evaluation shall be the same as recommended in Hand Book of Medical
examination. Impairment of 20% - 40% or less may only be entitled to aids and appliances.
Annexure — IV
A. Recommendations about the Categories and the Tests Required
1. Recommended classification
S. Category Type of DB level Speech discrimi- Percentage of
No. impairment and/or nation impairment
1. | Mild Hearing dB 26 to 80 to 100% in Less than
impairment 40 dBin better ear 40%
better ear
2. 1} Moderate hearing 41to 55dB 50 to 80% 40% - 50%
Impairment in better ear better ear
3. n Severe hearing 56 to 70 40 to 50% 50 to 75%
impairment Hearing Im-
pairment in
better ear
4 V. (a) Total deafness No hearing No discrimination 100%
(b) Near total 91 dB and ---do-- 100%
deafness above in
better ear
(c) Profound hear- 71to90dB Less than 40% 75% - 100%
ing impairment in better ear
-22-
(Pure tone average of hearing in 500, 1000 and 2000 Hz by air conduction should be
taken as basis for consideration as per the test recommendations).
Further it should be noted that —
(a)
(b)
When there is only an Island of hearing present in one or two frequencies in better
ear, it should be considered as total loss of hearing.
Wherever there is no response (NR) at any of the 3 frequencies (500, 1000, 2000
Hz), it should be considered as equivalent to 130 dB loss for the purposes of
classification of disability and in arriving at the average. This is based on the fact that
maximum intensity limits in most of the Audiometers is 110 dB’s and some
audiometers has additional facilities for + 20 dB for testing.
Il. Recommendations about the categories of disability (Hearing Impairment — Physical aspect
only — Test recommended).
(a)
(b)
(c)
Pure tone audiometry (ISO R 382 — 1970 at present, is being used as Audiometric
Standards in most of the audiometers. Hence the audiometers used in testing should
be accordingly calibrated). Three frequency average at 500, 1000 and 2000 Hz by
Air Conditions (A.C.) will be used for categorization.
Wherever possible the pure tone audiometric results should be supplemented by the
Speech discrimination score — Tested at Sensation level (S.L.) i.e. the speech
discriminations test is conducted at —dB above the patient’s hearing threshold. The
stimuli used be either phonetically balance words (Pb) of the particular language or
its equivalent material. At present only a few Indian languages have standard
speech material for testing. Hence wherever the standardised test material is not
available, either standardised Indian English Test could be made use of, with English
knowing population or equivalent material to Pb. be used.
Wherever children are tested and pure tone audiometry becomes not possible free
field testing should be employed.
Suggestions of the Facilities to be Offered to the Disabled for Rehabilitation.
Category |. No special benefits.
Category II. Considered for Hearing Aids at free or concessional costs only.
Category Ill. Hearing aids free of cost or at concessional rates. Job reservation-
benefit of special Employment Exchange.
Scholarships at School : Single language formula.
Category IV. Hearing Aids — facilities of reservation — special employment exchange.
Special facilities in schools like Scholarship. Hearing aids — Exemption
from 3-language formula (to study in recommended single language).
It is felt that for consideration of admission under special category for courses conducted
by institutions like Indian Institute of Technology (IIT), Industrial Training Institute (ITl) and others,
categories 1 and 2 only should be considered for reservation of seats, provided they fuffill the
other educational stipulations for the course.
23/-
-23-
We have considered the different type of hearing affection i.e. conductive VS Sensory
neural, and agree that the disability will be judged by the conditions prevalent in the patient at the
time of referral and examination. In case of failure of surgery or other therapeutic interventions,
the patient will be considered and categorized on the basis of the recommended tests.
Appendix - V
1. Guidelines for Evaluation of Various Disabilities
(1) Locomotor Disability
1. UPPERLIMB
1. The estimation of permanent impairment depends upon the measurement of functional
impairment and is not expression of a personal opinion.
2. The estimation and measurement must be made when the clinical condition is fixed and
unchangeable.
3. The upper extermity is divided into two component parts, the arm component and the
hand component.
4. Measurement of the loss of function of arm component consists in measuring the loss of
motion, muscle strength and co-ordinated activities.
5. Measurement of the loss of function of hand component consists in determining the
Prehension, Sensation & Strength. For estimation of Prehension Opposition, lateral pinch,
cylindrical grasp spherical grasp and hook grasp have to be assessed as shown in the
column of “prehension component” in the proforma.
6. The impairment of the entire extremity depends on the combination of the functional
impairment of both components.
ARM COMPONENT
Total value of arm component is 90%.
Principles of Evaluation of range of motion of joints —
1. The value of maximum R.O.M. in the arm component is 90%.
2. Each of the three joints of the arm is weighed equally (30%).
Example :
A fracture of the right shoulder joint may affect range of motion so that active abduction
is 90%. The left shoulder exhibits a range of active abduction of 180%. Hence there is loss of
50% of abduction movement of the right shoulder. The percentage loss of arm component in the
shoulder is 50 X 0.30 or 15 per cent loss of motion for the arm component.
If more than one joint is involved, same method is applied and the losses in each of the
24/-
-24-
affected joints are added. Say,
60%
40%
Loss of abduction of the shoulder
Loss of extension of the wrist
Then, Loss of range of motion for
the arm = (60 X 0.30) + (40 X 0.30) = 30%
Principles of Evaluation of Strength of muscles
1. Strength of muscles can be tested by manual testing like 0 — 5 grading.
2. Manual muscle gradings can be given percentages like —
- 100 %
- 80 %
- 60 %
40 %
- 20 %
- 0% O
p
O
N
S
O
i
3. The mean percentage of muscle strength loss is multiplied by 0.30.
4. If there has been a loss of muscle strength of more than one joint, the values are added
as has been described for loss of range of motion.
Principles of Evaluation of co-ordinated activities
1. The total value for co-ordinated activities is 90%.
2. Tendifferent co-ordinated activates are to be tested as given in the Proforma.
3. Each activity has a value of 9%.
Combining value for the Arm Component
1. The value of loss of function of arm component is obtained by combining the value of range of
movement, muscle strength & co-ordinated activities, using the combining formula -
higher value
lower value
Example
Let us assume that an individual with a fracture of the right shoulder joint has in addition
to 16.5% of motion his arm, 8.3% loss of strength of muscles, and 5% loss of coordination. We
combine these values as:
Range of motion : 16.5% }
Strength of Muscles : 8.3% }
25/-
-25-
8.3 (90 - 16.5)
— =23.3%
Co-ordination : 5% =270%
90
So total value of arm component = 27.0%.
Hand Component
Total value of hand component is 90%.
The functional impairment of hand is expressed as loss of prehension, loss of sensation,
loss of strength.
Principles of Evaluation of Prehension
Total value of Prehension is 30%. It includes:
(A) Opposition (8%). Tested against Index finger (2%), Middle finger (2%), Ring
finger (2%) & Little finger (2%)
(B) Lateral pinch (5%). Tested by asking the patient to hold a key.
(C) Cylindrical raps (6%). Tested for
(a) Large object of 4 inch size (3%)
(b) Small object of 1 inch size (3%)
(D) Spherical Grasp (6%). Tested for
(a) Large object 4 inch size (3%)
(b) Small object 1 inch size (3%)
(E) Hook Grasp (5%). Tested by asking the patient to lift a bag.
Principles of Evaluation of Sensations
Total value of sensation is 30%. It includes :
Radial side of thumb (4.8%)
Ulnar side of thumb (1.2%)
Radial side of each finger (4.8%)
Ulnar side of each finger (1.2%) P
O
N
=
Principles of Evaluation of Strength
Total value of sensation is 30%. It includes :
1. Grip Strength (20%)
2. Pinch Strength (10%)
Strength will be tested with hand dynamo-meter or by clinical method (Grip Method).
26/-
-26-
10% additional weightage to be given to the following factors :
Infection
Deformity
Malalignment
Contractures
Abnormal Mobility
Dominant Extremity (4%) O
N
R
O
N
=
Combining value of the hand component
The final value of loss of function of hand component is obtained by summing up values
of loss of prehension, sensation and strength.
Combining Values for the Extremity
Values of impairment of arm component and impairment of hand component are
combined by using the combining formula.
Example
Impairment of the arm = 27.0%
Impairment of the hand = 64%
27 (90 — 64)
64 + =71.8%
90
Guidelines for Evaluation of Permanent Physical Impairment in Lower Limbs
The lower extremity is divided into two component and Stability component
Mobility Component
Total value of mobility component is 90 per cent. It includes range of movement and
muscle strength.
Principles of Evaluation of Range of Movement
1. The value of maximum range of movement in the mobility component is 90 per cent.
2. Each of the three joints i.e. hip knee, foot-ankle component, is weighed equally —
0.30.
Example
A fracture of the right hip joint may affect range of motion so that active abduction is 27
degree. The left hip exhibits a range of active abduction of 54 degree. Hence, there is loss
of 50 per cent of abduction movement of the right hip. The percentage loss of mobility
component in the hip is 50 X 0.30 or 15 per cent loss of motion for the mobility component.
If more than one joint is involved, same method is applied and the losses in each of the
affected joints are added.
For Example:-
Loss of abduction of the hip = 60%
27/-
-27-
Loss of extension of the knee = 40%
Loss of range of motion for mobility component (60 x 0.30) + (40 x 0.30) = 30%
Principles of Evaluation of Muscle Strength
1.
2.
The value for maximum muscle strength in the leg is 90 per cent.
Strength of muscles can be tested by manual testing like 0 — 5 grading.
Manual muscle gradings can be given percentages like
Grade 0 = 100 %
Grade 1 80 %
Grade 2 = 60 %
Grade 3 = 40 %
Grade 4 = 20 %
Grade 5 = 0%
Mean percentage of muscle strength loss is multiplied by 0.30.
If there has been a loss of muscle strength of more than one joint, the values are added
as has been described for loss of range of motion.
Combining Values for the Mobility Component
Let us assume that the individual with a fracture of the right hip joint has in addition to 16
per cent loss of motion, 8 per cent loss of strength of muscles.
Combining Values
Motion 16% 8 (90— 16)
Strength 8% 16 + ------mmmmmememmme = 22.6%
Where a = higher value b = lower value
Stability Component
1.
2.
Total value of stability component is 90 per cent.
It is tested by 2 methods.
(i) Based on scale method
(i) Based on clinical method.
Three different readings (in kilograms) are taken measuring the total body weight (W).
Scale ‘A’ reading and scale ‘B’ read.
Guidelines for Evaluation of Permanent Physical Impairment of Trunk (Spine)
lesions.
The local effects of lesions of spine can be divided into traumatic and non—-traumatic
28/-
-28-
TRAUMATIC LESIONS
Cervical Spine Fracture
A. Vertebral compression 25 per cent, one or two
vertebral adjacent bodies, no fragmentation,
no involvement of posterior elements, no nerve
root involvement, moderate neck rigidity and
persistent soreness.
B. Posterior elements with X-ray evidence of moderate
partial dislocation.
(a) No nerve root involvement, healed
Percent Whole Body Perm-
anent Physical Impairment
and Loss of Physical Function
to Whole Body.
20
15
(b) with persistent pain, with mild motor and sensory
manifestations 25
(c) With fusion, healed, no permanent motor or sensory
changes
C. Severe dislocation, fair to good reduction with
surgical fusion.
(a) No residual motor or sensory changes
(b) Poor reduction with fusion, persistent radicular
pain, motor involvement only slight weakness
and numbness
(c) Same as (b) with partial paralysis, determine
20
25
35
additional rating for loss of use of extremities and
sphincters.
Cervical Intervertebral Disc
1. Operative, successful removal of disc, with relief of acute
pain, no fusion, no neurologic residual. 10
2. Same as (1) with neurological manifestations, persistent
pain, numbness, weakness in fingers
Thoracic and Dorsolumbar Spine Fracture
A. Compression 25 per cent, involving one or two
vertebral bodies, mild, no fragmentation,
healed, no neurological manifestations.
B. Compression 50 per cent, with involvement
posterior elements, healed, no neurologic mani-
festations, persistent pain, fusion, indicated.
20
Percent Whole Body Permanent
Physical Impairment and Loss
of Physical Function to Whole
Body
10
20
29/-
-29-
C. Same as (B) with fusion, pain only on heavy use of back. 20
D. Total paraplegia 100
E. Posterior elements, partial paralysis with or without
fusion, should be rated for loss of use of extremities
and sphincters.
Low Lumbar
1. Fracture
A. Vertebral compression 25 per cent one or two adjacent
vertebral bodies little or fragmentation, no definite
pattern or neurologic changes. 15
B. Compression with fragmentation posterior elements,
persistent pain, Weakness and stiffness, healed, no fusion,
no lifting over 25 pounds 40
C. Same as (B), healed with fusion, mild pain 25
D. Same as (B), nerve root involvement to lower extre-
mities, determine additional rating for loss of industrial,
function to extremities.
E. Same as (C), with fragmentation of posterior elements, with
persistent pain after fusion, no neurologic findings. 35
F. Same as (C), with nerve root involvement to lower extre-
mities, rate with functional loss to extremities.
G. Total paraplegia. 100
H. Posterior elements, partial paralysis with or without
fusion, should be rated for loss of use of extremities
and sphincters.
2. Neurogenic Low Back Pain-Disc Injury
A. Periodic acute episodes with acute pain and persistent
body list, test, tests for sciatic pain positive, temporary
recovery 5 to 8 weeks. 5
B. Surgical excision of disc, no fusion, good results, no
persistent sciatic pain. 10
C. Surgical excision of disc, no fusion, moderate persistent
pain and stiffness aggravated by heavy lifting with
necessary modification of activities. 20
D. Surgical excision of disc with fusion, activities of
lifting moderately modified. 15
30/-
-30-
E. Surgical excision of disc with fusion, persistent pain
and stiffness aggravated by heavy lifting, necessitating
modification of all activities requiring heavy lifting 25
Non-Traumatic Lesions
Scoliosis
The whole Spine has been given rating of 100 per cent and regionwise the following
percentages are given :
Dorsal Spine - 50 per cent
Lumbar Spine - 30 per cent
Cervical Spine - 20 per cent
Kobb’s method for measurement of angle of curve in standing position is to be used. The
curves have been divided into three sub groups.
Thoracic
Spine Spine
Less than 30° (Mild)
31° - 60° (Moderate) 3% 15% 12%
Above 60° (Severe) 5% 25% 33%
In the curves ranging above 60 degree, cardio-pulmonary complications are to be graded
separately. The junctional curves are to be given that rating depending upon level of apex of
curve. For example, if apex of dorso-lumbar curve falls in the dorsal spine the curve can be taken
as a dorsal curve. When the scoliosis is adequately compensated, 5 per cent reduction is to be
given from final rating (for all assessment primary curves are considered for rating).
Kyphosis
The same total rating (100 per cent) as that suggested for scoliosis is to be given for
kyphosis. Region-wise percentages of physical impairment are:
Dorsal 50 per cent
Cervical Spine 30 per cent
Lumbar Spine 20 per cent
For dorsal spine the following further grading are:
Less than 20 degree 10 per cent
21 degree — 40 degree 15 per cent
41 degree — 60 degree 20 per cent
Above 60 degree 25 per cent
31/-
-31-
For kyphosis of lumbar and cervical spine 5 per cent and 7 per cent respectively have
been allocated.
Paralysis of Flexors and Extensors of Dorsal and Lumbar Spine.
The motor power of these muscles to be grouped as follows:-
Normal
Weak 5 per cent
Paralysed 10 per cent
Paralysis of Muscles of Cervical Spine
For cervical spine the rating of motor power is as follow:
Flexors 0 5% 10%
Extensors 0 5% 10%
Rotators 0 5% 10%
Side bending 0 5% 10%
Miscellaneous
Those condition of the spine which cause stiffness and pain efc., are rated as follows:
% physical
impairment
A. Subjective symptoms of pain. No involun-
tary muscle spasm. Not substantiated by
demonstrable structural pathology 0%
B. Pain, Persisent muscle spasm and stiffness
of spine, substantiated by demonstrable
mild radiological changes. 10%
C. Same as B, with moderate radiological
changes 15%
D. Same as B, with severe radiological
changes involving and one of the region
of spine (cervical, dorsal or lumbar) 20%
E. Same as D, involving whole spine 30%
In kypho-scoliosis, both curves to be assessed separately and then percentage of disability to
be summed.
32/-
-32-
Guidelines for Evaluation of Permanent Physical Impairment in Amputees
Basic Guidelines
1. In case of multiple amputees, if the total sum of percentage permanent physical
impairment is above 100 per cent, it should be taken as 100 per cent.
Amputation at any level with uncorrectable inability to wear and use prosthesis, should be
given 100 per cent permanent physical impairment.
In case of amputation in more than one limb percentage of each limb is counted and
another 10 per cent will be added, but when only toes or fingers are involved only another
5 per cent will be added.
Any complication in form of stiffness, neuroma, infection etc. has to be given a total of 10
per cent additional weightage.
Dominant upper limb has been given 4 per cent extra percentage.
Upper Limb Amputations
Per cent Permanent
Physical Impairment
and loss of physical
function of each limb
1. Fore-quarter amputation 100 percent
2. Shoulder Disarticulation 90 per cent
3. Above Elbow upto upper 1/3 of arm 85 per cent
4. Above Elbow upto lower 1/3 of arm 80 per cent
5. Elbow disarticulation 75 per cent
6. Below Elbow upto upper 1/3 of forearm 70 per cent
7. Below Elbow upto lower 1/3 of forearm 65 per cent
8. Wrist disarticulation 60 per cent
9. Hand through carpal bones 55 per cent
10. Thumb through C.M. or through 18! MC Joint 30 percent
11. Thumb disarticulation through metacarpo-
phalangeal Joint or through proximal phalanx 25 per cent
12. Thumb disarticulation through inter phalanageal
Joint or through distal phalanx. 15 per cent
33/-
Index Middle Ring Lit
Finger Finger Finger Fin
(15%) (5%) (3%) (2%)
13. Amputation through 15% 5% 3% 2%
promimal phalanx or
disarticulation through
MP joint
14. Amputation through 10% 4% 2% 1%
middle phalanx or disarti-
culation through PIP joint
15. Amputation through distal 5% 2% 1% 1%
phalanx or disarticulation
through DIP joint
Lower Limb Amputations
1. Hind quarter 100 per cent
2. Nip disarticulation 90 percent
3. Above knee upto upper
1/3 of thigh 85 per cent
4. Above knee upto lower
1/3 of thigh 80 per cent
5. Through knee 75 per cent
6. B.K.upto 8cm 70 per cent
7. B.K.upto lower 1/3 of leg 60 per cent
8. Through Ankle 55 per cent
9. Syme’s 50 per cent
10. Upto mid-foot 40 per cent
11. Upto fore-foot 30 percent
12. All toes 20 per cent
13. Loss of first toe 10 percent
14. Loss of second toe 5 per cent
15. Loss of third toe 4 per cent
16. Loss of fourth toe 3 per cent
17. Loss of fifth toe 2 per cent
34/-
-34-
Guidelines for Assessment of Physical Impairment in Neurological Conditions
1. Assessment in neurological conditions is not the assessment of disease but it is the
assessment of the effects. i.e. clinical manifestations.
2. Any neurological assessment has to be done after six months of onset.
3. These guidelines will only be used for Central and upper motor neurone lesions.
4. Proforma A & B will be utilized for assessment of lower motor neurone lesions,
muscular disorders and other locomotor conditions.
5. Total percentage of physical impairment in neurological conditions will not exceeds
100 per cent.
6. In the mixed cases the highest score will be taken into consideration. The lower
score will be added to it and calculations will be done by the formula :
b (100 - a)
100
7 Additional rating of 4 per cent will be given for dominant upper extremity.
8 Additional 10 per cent has been given for sensation in each extremity, but the maxi -
mum total physical impairment will not exceed 100 per cent.
Motor System Disability
Disability Rate
Monoparesis 25 percent
Monoplegia / Hemiparesis 50 per cent
Paraparesis 75 percent
Paraplegia 100 percent
Hemiplegia / Quadriparesis 75 per cent
Quadriplegia 100 percent
Sensory System Disability
Disability Rate
Anaesthesia/Rypoaesthesia/
Paraesthesia Each Limb 10 per cent
FOR INVOLVEMENT
For involvement of hand/hands 25 per cent
foot/feet
35/-
-35-
Guidelines for Assessment of Physical Impairment in Neurological Conditions
1. Assessment in neurological conditions is not the assessment of disease but it is the
assessment of the effects, i.e. clinical manifestation.
2. Any neurological assessment; has to be done after six months of on set.
3. These guidelines will only be used for Central and upper motor neurone lesions.
4. Proforma A & B will be utilized for assessment of lower motor neurone lesions,
muscular disorders and other locomotor conditions.
5. Total percentage of physical impairment in neurological conditions will not exceed 100
per cent.
6. In the mixed cases the highest score will be taken into consideration. The lower score
will be added to it and calculations will be done by the fomula:
b (100-a
100
7. Additional rating of 4 per cent will be given for dominant upper extremity.
8. Additional 10 per cent has given for sensation in each extremity, but the maximum total
physical impairment will not exceed 100 per cent.
Speech disability
Disability Rate
Mild 25 per cent
Moderate 50 per cent
Severe 75 per cent
Very Severe 100 per cent
Tested by a 100 word text. Ability to read (in educated), comprehend when read out,
answer question on text clearly and ability to write a synopsis (in educated).
Guidelines for Evaluation of Physical Impairment due to Cardio Pulmonary Diseases
Basic Guidelines.
1. Modified New York Heart Association subjective classification should be utilised to
assess the functional disability.
2. The physician should be alert to the fact that patients who come for disability claims are
likely to exaggerate their symptoms. In case of any doubt patients should be referred for detailed
physiological evaluation.
3. Disability evaluation of cardiopulmonary patients should be done after full medical,
surgical and rehabilitative treatment available, because most of these diseases are potentially
treatable.
36/-
-36 -
4. Assessment of a cardiopulmonary impairment should also be done in diseases which
might have associated cardiopulmonary problems, e.g. amputees, myopathies etc.
The proposed modified classification is as follows:-
Group 0 : A patient with cardiopulmonary disease who is a symptomatic (i.e. has no
symptoms of breathlessness palpitation, fatigue or chest pain).
Group 1: A patient with cardiopulmonary disease who becomes symptomatic during
his ordinary physical activity but has mild restriction (25 per cent) of his
ordinary physical activities.
Group 2 : A patient with cardiopulmonary disease who becomes symptomatic during his
ordinary physical activity and has 25 — 50 per cent restriction of his ordinary
physical activity.
Annexure -V
Mental Disorders
Source : Glossary and guide to their classification A Publication by W.H.O.
“MENTAL RETARDATION” . A condition of arrested or incomplete development of mind
which is especially characterized by subnormality of intelligence. The coding should be made on
the individual’s current level of functioning without regard to its nature of causation - such as
psychosis, cultural deprivation. Down’s syndrome etc, where there is a specific cognitive
handicap — such as in speech — the four digit coding should be based on assessments of
cognition outside the area of specific handicap. The assessment of intellectual level should be
based on whatever information is available, including clinical evidence, adaptive behaviour and
psychometric findings. The IQ levels given are based on a test with a mean of 100 and a
standard deviation of 15 — such as the Wechsle scales. They are provided only as a guide and
should not be applied rigidly. Mental retardation often involves psychiatric disturbances and may
often develop as a result of some physical disease or injury. In these cases, an additional code
or codes should be used to identify and associated condition, psychiatric or physical. ~ The
impairment and Handicap codes should also be consulted.
(b) MILD MENTAL RETARDATION
Feeble - minded Moron
High Grade defect 1Q 50 - 70
Mild mental subnormality
(c) OTHER SPECIFIED MENTAL RETARDATION
(i) Moderate mental retardation Imbecile IQ 35 — 49 - Moderate mental
subnormality
(i) Severe mental retardation IQ 20 -34 - Severe mental subnormality
(iii) Profound mental retardation Idiocy IQ under 20 - Profound mental subnormality.
(d) UNSPECIFIED MENTAL RETARDATION
Mental deficiency NOS Mental subnormality NOS.
Previous and next
Questions people ask
Is rule 12 of PCR Rules 1995 still in force?
No repeal of PCR Rules 1995 is recorded.