Rule 6, Uttar Pradesh Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhans and Members) Inquiry Rules-1994: Con\pl.\inl
Uttar Pradesh Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhans and Members) Inquiry Rules-1994 - Rule 6
Text of rule 6
Con\pl.\inl
6. Con\pl.\inl—Cmnplinnco of sub-rules (1) to (4) 572
1. Complaint to be accompanied by affidavit.—Sub-clause (2) of Rule 3
provides that the complaint should be accompanied by the complainant’s own affidavit in support thereof and also alfidavits thereof of all persons from whom
he claims to have received information of facts relating to accusation.
2. Procedure under.—It is scen thal under Rule 3(1) of the Rules, any person
making a complaint against a Pradhan or Up-Pradhan may send his complaint
to the District Magistrate which shall be In the manner provided in sub-rule (2)
of Rule 3. Under sub-rule (5) of Rule 3, a complaint which does not comply with
any of the provisions of sub-rules (1) to (4) of Rule 3 shall not be entertained, Under Rule 4 of the Rules, the District Magistrate, on the receipt of a complaint Or report referred to in Rule 3, or otherwise, order the Enquiry Officer to conduct a preliminary enquiry with a view to finding out if there is a prima facie case for a formal enquiry in the matier. Under Rule 5 of the Rules, where the District Magistrate is of the opinion, on the basis of the report referred to in sub-rule (2) of Rule 4 or otherwise, then an enquiry should be held against a Pradhan or Up-Pradhan or Member, he shall forthwith constitute a Three Member Committee
District Magistrate while passing the order under Section 95( 1)(@) of the Act.?
3. Procedure—Non-compliance of.—The issue was examined by the Division Bench of the Court in Smt. Kesari Devi v. State of U.P. and others,? and it was also observed :
“115. Learned counsel for the petitioner invited the attention of the Court to another feature of the case and submitted that once the basic procedure of preliminary inquiry falls through as being invalid, the consequential action taken by the State Government by holding a regular inquiry and passing the impugned order has also necessarily to be treated to be invalid.
‘There can be no dispute with the settled legal proposition that if an order is bad in its inception, it cannot be made good by efflux of time or by subsequent improvement. In Upen Chandra Gogoi v. State of Assam and others,* the Apex Court held that the Writ Court should not validate an action which was not lawful at inception.
If the basic order falls being illegal, invalid or void, the consequential order cannot be given effect to as it automatically becomes inoperative.”
In Badrinath v. State of Tamil Nadu and others,5 the Court held as under :
“This flows from the general principle applicable to “consequential orders”. Once the basis of a proceeding is gone, may be, at a later point of
Anjana Devi (Smt.) v. State of U.P. and others, 2009 (107) RD 693.
Narendra Kumar v. State of U.P. and others, 2013 (119) RD 252,
2005 (4) AWC 3563 : 2005 (61) ALR 7 (Sum). ’
(1998) 3 SCC 381.
(2000) 8 SCC 395. G
0
N
e
ad UTTAR PRADESH PANCHAYAT R, (REMOVAL.... MEMBERS) ENQUIRY RULES, 1997 571
time by order of a Superior ayg mean-time like the recommend:fJ B action taken thereon would fa]] {,
ty, any intermediate action taken in the
fon of the State and by the UPSC and the
. 0 the groyng,
"[.‘he principle of consequentia] orders i
quasi-judicial proceedings is which {s applicable to judicial and (& - qually applicaple (, administrative orders.”
In view of the above, law can be
N Summaris
conducted against any such office-bearer apply;:l(; t:tircta“aszquiry is to be
erence to the
the affidavit has to be made in accordance thereof. As per Rule 5 of th
Rules, unless the State Government is of the opinion, that
the com, la;lt h: L997
processed strictly in accordance with Rule 3, and the preliminary ixf)qu_"ry haz bz:
conducted by the designated authority in accordance with the procedure prescribed
under the Rules and strict compliance has been observed, it shall be impermissible
for the State Government to proceed any further for regular inquiry. (Emphasis
supplied)
The Full Bench of the Court in Vivekanand Yadav v. State of U.P. and
another,! also observed that action under the proviso to Section 95(1)(g) of the Act
can be taken by the District Magistrate only on the basis of a report of the
“Enquiry Officer” defined under Rule 2(c) or on the basis of the preliminary
enquiry conducted by the District Magistrate himself and that the final enquiry under
Rule 5 of the Rules can be ordered only on the basis of the aforesaid preliminary
enquiry reports.
In the instant case, the final enquiry has been directed
on the basis offfithe
report submitted by the Committee appointed by the Block Develupme.nt 8er:::
and not on the basis of the preliminary enquiry conduct§d by thefng:axrlym
feer
defined under Rule 2(c) of the Rules or the District Magistrate. T te meméld 2
cannot, in such circumstances, be hel
d on the basis of the2r6p0r B )
the Committee appointed by the Block Deve
lopment OFfic:zr. -
4. Enquiry Officer—Not nominated.—The Pre(ljm:
R"‘:l}; 20 of the Rules
Conducted by an Enquiry Officer contemplated unde
t level ny other distric
Namely ejther the District Panchayat Raj Off
icer or al
] jct Magistrate,
as
fficer to be nomin
ated by the Distr
ict Magistrate. The
Di;tr;iccer e
noliced herejnabove
, had mot nom inated the Emlu‘%n’,l‘hf: District Magistr
ate
Members of the Committee were “district level officers”. ry only on the
+ould form hys prima facie satisfaction fo
r holding a flgaflir?:c;]‘::
nder Bule 2(0)
Officer de!
asis of d by the Enquiry of the he report submitted by
—ZLRues®
2010 (111) RD 699 (FB). 2013 (119) RD 252-
Wrendra Kumar v, State of ULP. and o1 20 11 o) gy 52
arendra Kuumar v. State of UL.P. and others:
2
572 UTTAR PRADESH PANCHAYAT RAJ (REMOVAL.....MEMBERS) ENQUIRY RULES, 1957 4
5. Report under.—A report by an enquiry officer defined under fiufe 4,
is also a report by a person and the manner is prescribed under the fijes
irrespective of the fact that he was so asked by thé' District Magistrete or fiof,
In the Court's opinion, it is also a preliminary report within the rreaning of
the proviso to Section 95(1)(g) of the U.P. Panchayat Raj Act.
The District Magistrate exercises the powers of the State Government tirider
Section 95(1)(g) as well as under the Enquiry Rules as the powers are delegated
to him. He also appoints the enquiry officer. He is higher than all encquiry officers,
He can himself conduct a preliminary enquiry. It would be anomalous that on 4
preliminary report of a subordinate officer, a final enquiry and cessation of power
can be ordered but the District Magistrate who appoints him, cannot conduct z
preliminary enquiry.
In the Court's opinion, action under proviso to Section 95(1)(g) can also be
taken on the preliminary report of the District Magistrate as well as on a report
of a person defined as enquiry officer under Rule 2(c) of the Enquiry Rules. Only
these reports would be covered in the word ‘otherwise’ of Rule 5. Any other report would be a report under Rule 3(b) of the Enquiry Rules or can be considered by the District Magistrate under his suo motu power to order a preliminary enquiry but final enquiry with cessation of power cannot be ordered on its basis.!
6. Complaint—Compliance of sub-rules (1) to (4).—Rule 3(5) of the Enquiry Rules provides that the complaint, which does not comply with any of the preceding sub-rules of Rule 3 should not be entertained. However, even if the complaint is not to be enterlained, yet the District Magistrate can always refer the matter for the preliminary enquiry, if he considers that it should be so enquired, he can act suo motu.2 .
4. Preliminary enquiry—3[(1) The State Government may;, on the receipt of a complaint or report referred to in Rule 3, or otherwise order the Enquiry Officer to conduct a preliminary enquiry with a view to finding out if there is a prima facie case for a formal enquiry in the matter.
(2) The Enquiry Officer shall conduct the preliminary enquiry as expedi- tiously as possible and submit his report to the State Government within thirty days of his having been so ordered.]
SYNOPSIS
- Enquiry under—Nature of.
- Enquiry—Purposeof. ... .......... . . ...
- Otherwise—Interpretation of.
. Constitution of—Committee A
W
N
R
1. Vivekanand Yadav v, State of ULP. through Principal Secretary, of U.P,, Lucknow and others, 2010 (111) RD 699.
2. Vivekanand Yadav'v. State of WP through Principal Secretary, of U.P,, Lucknow and others, 2010 (111) RD 699.
Subs. by Noti. No. 2263/XXXIII-1-2001-565--2006, dt. 5.10.2001 (we.f, §.10.2001).
(Panchayat Raj) Government
(Panchayat Raj) Government
) UTTAR PRADESH PANCHAYAT fa, (REMOVAL.... MEMBERS) ENQUIRY RULES, 1867 573
. Enquiry under—y,
ate ll,f U.P. and others,! for;t;:e;f"‘me Full Bench in Vivekanand Yadav v.
st () What is the meaning of Question Nos. 3 and 4 to the following effect :
4(11 of the Enquiry Ru;::,r 4 otherwise' in sub-rule (1) of Rule 4 [Rule
(i) Can a Pradhan object 1, a co conformity with Rule 3 of themEr:.l:l nl;,u on the ground that it is not in
The above issues came
{go be answy 1ulry Rules,
extracted hereunder
:
.
"55. Rule 3 of the Ep, e qui complaint” and provides how a cony pll’\;:is n:zyt{)tle
{5
(i) By a private person, that has t
to comply other conditi by an affidavit anq
to 3(4)]. ons of sub-rules (1) to T
d
I paragraphs 55 1 63 which are
(i) By a public servant and in that case
by a private person do not apply.
can order a preliminary enquiry on the com laint o ,
The word complaint or report refers t P T report or otherwise. o the complaint by a Pprivate person or to the report k7 a public servant under Rule 3. The report of flp;e public servant need not conform to the restrictions of a complaint by a private
person. The question is,
‘what does the word ‘otherwise’ in Rule 4 means?’
57. The counsel for the petitioner submitted that :
-— The word otherwise should take the same colour as the words
accompanying it, namely complaint or report under Rule 3:
— A complaint not satisfying Rule 3(1) to (4) cannot be entertained under
the sub-rule (5) of Rule 3 [Rule 3(5)};
— A Pradhan has a right to object to
a complaint that does not comply
with Rule 3(1) to 3(4). 250
58. Words and Phrases permanent ed
ition volume 30-A page (2
explains :
: s... one of the
‘otherwise means but for
or under other circumstances
usual meanings of otherwise is contrar
ily.
i mean,
The Black's Law Dictionary explains it t
o the
or in other w
ays.
or a fact finding
financial or oth
er
“In a different manner; in another W% eliminary
) Rule 4 is a Pr 59. The enquiry under I ie whether any iry enquiry, It has to consider primd fa;ls pradhan or not The final enquiry
Irregularities have been committed bY ;
n to give any
there is 1o :easo the
Is yet to be done. ConSidermgd m;g?&fi?e" in Rule 4 as Sugees o]
‘0 Testricted meaning to the W’I?}rl pig e
C
iti . counsel for the Peuuonegristrate has powe
dopted; the District M,
1L 2000 £194% 1 o s
14 UTTAR PRADESH PANCHAYAT RAJ (REMOVAL - MEMBERS) ENQUIRY RULES, 1997 [M
enquity even it there is no complaint or report or In other words he hag
power to act suo motit.
60. Rule 3(5) of the Enquiry Rules provides that ll}t‘, (:mlnplnl}:]l, lw]“,.h
does not comply with any ol the preceding sub-rules of Rule 3 should not
be entertained. However, even i the complaint Is nol to be entertained yet
the District Magistrate can always refer the matter for the preliminary
enquity i he consider that it should be so enquired; he can act has suo motu,
61. The counsel for the petitioner clted rulings laking the view that a
Pradhan has a right to object o the format of the complaint. With due
respect, the Court do not agree with the same.
62. 1f the District Magistrate can order for the preliminary enquiry
even in a case, where a complaint could not be entertained, then what is
the purpose of permitting a Pradhan to object regarding its non-conformity
with Rules 3(1) to 3(4). To Court it appears to be futile exercise. It is for the
District Magistrate to consider whether he should entertain the complaint
or not.
63. In Court's opinion :
() The word ‘otherwise’ in Rule 4 means that the District Magistrate has
Suo motu powers to order a preliminary enquiry;
(i) In an appropriate case, the District Magistrate may order a preliminary
enquiry even if there is,
(a) No complaint or report; or
(b) A defective complaint, not in accordance with Rules FS[I) to 3(4).
(iii) A Pradhan has a right to object that a complaint is not in accordance
with Rule 3(1) to 3(4) of the Enquiry Rules."
A careful perusal of paragraphs 59, 60, 62 and 63 of the judgment would
manifest that the Full Bench was conscious of the fact that considering the object
of Rules 3 and 4, there was no reason to give any restricted meaning to the word
‘otherwise’ in Rule 4 and that even if the complaint is not entertainable, in view
of a statutory prohibition, yet the District Magistrate could always refer the matter
for the preliminary enquiry, if he considers that it should be so enquired; he can
act suo motu. Once the Full Bench refused to give restrictive meaning to the word
‘otherwise’ in Rule 4 the justification for doing so is implicit in the said observation
itself, as stated hereunder : :
It is well settled that if a literal interpretation of a statute is leading to
absurdity, a purposive construction is advancing the cause of justice, then the latter is to be preferred over the former. Reference may be made to S. Sundaram
Pillai etc. v. VR, Pattabiraman etc.! A literal interpretation of Rule 3(5) and that (t:g ?al:(l: 4(1) v'vould mean that the District Magistrate stands denuded of the power
not sup?frx&?gce Inrespect of a complaint of a private person against a Pradhan,
view that the ally an affidavit, even though the District Magistrate may be of the
a preliminary eneg‘;uons In the complaint are of such a nature, that it warrants
the District M cilu 1y. On the other, if recourse is taken to purposive construction,
agistrate can direct for a preliminary enquiry on a complaint of a
1. 1985(1) SCC 591,
- . |
g UTTARPRADESH PANCHAYAT Ry (EMOVAL.... MEMBERS) ENQUIRY RULES, 1997 575
ate pers U supported 1y , N jvate person ol pI d by an ; )
(L‘ (:t' such a nature that it calls fo. davy, provided he is satisfied that the case
wwes flexibility to the Districy M:\:l:)(r.e“"“lliuy enquiry. The purposive construction
L“ sfied that the case s such (i \ vl(:\lluln direeq for preliminary enquiry, if he is
;1;(‘1. This dm:l ::()]‘I“:L;“\\(lhm Rule G(S)I) N Wit an affidavit is to be enqutltrlecti
ivate complainant is st gatory for the reason tha Mun.\(t‘ ! are gatory
so that (l\? Llllt(‘i,‘fiilu.‘j of the allegationg Is v|1<;1|';Lflllmlmmm R el {o reckless :‘ L\L-;\n‘)l_ls ;"‘}lmul any m‘.cuuntal)lllly él gy €19¢ It may give rise cannot 8 & MALEr of right 1o ey s complai, milarly, a priyage complainant enquired into. But this would ne( be Plaint not Supporte
direct for a preliminary enquiry op District M . a complajng agistrate to Je is of the view that there jg Justification for (“r'(‘:ztlsljppurtcd by an affidavit, i 2. Enquiry—Purpose of.—Rule . neap enquiry With a view to find oyt
in the matter.
1s0 to clause (g) of sub-section
quiry Officer, other th, €r sub-rule (2) of Ryle 4, to hold the enquirya.Ié
q.uiry under Rule
4. Constitution of—Co.
that where the State Govern:
referred to in sub-rule (2) of
against a Pradhan or Up-Pr:
mmittee.—Rule 5 of the Rules, 1997 then provides
ment is of the opinion, on the basis of the report
Rule 4 or otherwise that an enquiry should be held
adhan or Member under the proviso to clause (g) of
Sub-section (1) of Section 95 of the Act it shall forthwith constitute a committee
nvisaged by Proviso to clause (g) of sub-section (1) of Section 95 of the Act and
Y an order ask an Enquiry Officer, other than the Enquiry officer nominated under suh-ryyle (2) of Rule 4, to hold the enquiry.*
5. Where the State Government is of the opinion, on the b(?sis of the
Teport referred to in sub-rule (2) of Rule 4 or otherwise that an enquiry slpuld
¢ held against o Pradhan or Up-Pradhan or Member under the proviso to
1. Sahab Singh v. State of U.P. through Secretary, Panchayat Raj UL.P. Government, Lucknow
and others 2018 (139) RD 59
S
4 . : cknozw and others, 2, Rflj Kumar Singh v. State of UL.P. through Secretary, Panchayat Raj, ULP,, Lucknozw and other:
2014 (122) RD7
i nment foekanang Yadnlv v. State of ULP. through Prin cipal Secretary, ( Panchayat Raj) Governme
4 ‘;};U.P., Lucknow and others, 2010 (111) RD 699.
s ahida (Spt.) v, State of U.P. and others, 2017 (137)RD 28. e.f, 5:10.2001). ubs, by Noti, No. 2263/XXXIII'1'2001'565'2000/ dt. 5.10.2001 (w-e:
576 UTTAR PRADESH PANCHAYAT RAJ (REMOVAL.... MEMBERS) ENOUIRY AULES, 1777
clause (g) of sub-section (1) of Section 95 it shall for'lhwi!h constitute ,
committee envisaged by proviso to clause (g) of sub-section (1) of Section, 95,
of the Act and by an order ask an Enquiry Officer, other than the I:ruw,,./
Officer nominated under sub-rule (2) of Rule 4, to hold the enquiry.|
6. Procedure for the enquiry.—(1) The substance of the imputations,
and a copy of the complaint referred to in Rule 3, if any, shall be forwarded
to the Enquiry Officer by the State Government.
(2) The Enquiry Officer shall draw up,—
(a) the substance of the imp{ltafions into definite and distinct articles
of charge; and -
(b) a statement of the imputations in support of each article of charge,
which shall contain a statement of all relevant facts and z list of
documents by which, and list of witnesses by whom, the articles zre
proposed to be sustained.
(3) The Enquiry Officer shall deliver or cause to be delivered o the person against whom he is to hold the enquiry, a copy of the articles of charge, the statement of the imputations and a list of documents and witnesses by which each article of charge is proposed to be sustained and shall require that person by a notice in writing, to submit within such time as may be specified, a written statement of his defence and to state whether he desires to be heard in person, and to appear before him on such day and at such time as may be specified.
(4) On receipt of the written statement of defence, the Enquiry Officer shall enquire into such of that articles as are not admitted and where all the
articles of charge have been admitted in the written statement of defence, the
Enquiry Officer shall record his findirigs on each charge after taking such
evidence as he may think fit.
(5) If the person who has admitted any of the articles of charge in his
written statement of defence, appears before the Enquiry Officer, he shall ask
him whether he is guilty or has any defence to make and if he pleads guilty to
any of the articles of charge, the Enquiry Officer shall record the plea, sign the
record and obtain the signature of that person thereon, and return a finding of
guilt in respect of those charges.
(6) If the person fails to appear within the specified time or refuses or omits
to plead, the Enquiry Officer shall take the evidence, and if there is a complaint,
require him to produce the evidence by which he proposes to prove the articles
of charge, and shall adjourn the case to a later date not exceeding fifteen davs,
after recording an order that the said person may, for the purpose of preparing
his defence,—
(a) Inspect within five days of the order or within such further time not
exceeding five days as the Enquiry Officer may allow, the documents
specified in the list referred to in sub-rule (2);
(b) submit a list of witnesses to be examined on his behalf;
AUATFIEADL R RANG) Ay na AIAD O MOVNL . O ENOUIY 1008, 1007 b W BV natee Wiy, ton (|
' ! her
ikl RO e arder o within such fur
I 0L evegg n\ll\)‘. Loy oy M e ulry Officer may allow, for the dircovery o Moduetiog iy i e onguiey ayg HOcuments that are relovant 1o ] ‘llmm,ml” nob mentiong | | YO the St ¢ wovernment, but byl (2),
ey |y Dolng ot may take the UGN D behalf, and 1 linquiry enonting Offleoy 1 anlst him n
0 The person anadnsg Whom he o fstanee OF any Other oy, | ‘\\\‘(;um may appoint any wdueting e enquivy,
I '
Provided that a log, al Practitioney ule thix sl Shall nog 1y Npaped o APpoInted ape ey 8 1 the person applios orally oy gy, Wrlting, ) the statements of witnesgey Mentione| I the fig the Eaquiry Officer aha ) faenish iy WIh suely coples ay Carly as possibe )
and fnany case, not later than [hree “",\'“ before the l"illlllll'lk't'xm'nl of the
evamination of the Wilhessey by whom my of (he articles of charge iy {
ftn: the BUpply of Coples of referred (g in Sb-pgle (2),
proposed to be prove,
) The Enquiry Offieey
production of documenty,
mwhose custody or
the production of ()
ruisition,
shall, on voee
forward (e Possession (e
¢ documenty |
IpLof (he notice fSame op coples (hereof tot documenty are ke Y such date ag gy
for the Lll,-;cnvvry or
he authorjy PL with o requisition for Wy be specified jn such Provided that the inquiry Officey may, for reasong (o be
writing, refuse 1o requisition sucl of the recorded in documents gy are,
relevant o the case, , in his opinion, not
10) On recej
h.nmy, the custo
Produce (he
PLof the requisition referred (o in sub-rle dy or possession of (e requisitioned same before (he
(9), every authority
Enquiry Officer,
documents shall
Provided that if the uisitione documenty j 2 production of all or leregy oy seeurily of (he and (e linquiry Officer Matioy 0 the person
isition
) Ony
authority having the custody or pussession of the s salisfied for reasons (o be recorded in writing that any of such documents would be against the public *State, it shall inform the Enquiry ()Hu:or accordingly shall, on being so informed, communicate ”!Ul ul\[ur- against whom (he enquiry is h.omy, held ?ll;l fvxt \.\url.:w made hy him for the production or discovery of documents,
by \\’I(li]:] r e date fixed for shall ]. e articles of charge
ity .L'U“""”“ld’ by the S one, ang may be Whopy, the
the fequ
the enquiry, the oral and «locul'm'nlfily lt‘\vnt::‘u\\:-
are proposed shall be produced l‘"-“- \:’l i |m
Enquiry Officer by or on behalf nfll \.L g.n|'1 ’}“ ‘.‘ '\‘in‘i;
cross-examined by or on behalf uf { ‘L\l::\::ul R l?): t];e nquipy o SNy s being held, The wilnesses may be re- LX; s by e heliry O icer or the complainant, as the case may be, on any pe
'w matler, without the leave
Of (o [ o CCN Cross-examined, but not on any new matter, \o I',nquiry Officor,
T
T
—
—
Y
578 UTTAR PRADESH PANCHAYAT RAJ (REMOVAL.... MEMBERS) ENQUIRY RULES, 1597 -
(12) The Enquiry Officer may allow production of evidence not includeq
in the list given to the person against whom the enquiry is t?emg held, or may
itself call for new evidence or recall and re-examine any w1tn'ess and in such
case the said person shall be entitled to have if he demand§ it, a copy of the
list of further evidence proposed to be produced and an adj.ournment of the
enquiry for three clear days before the production of suc}} E\{lden;e, exclusive
of the day of adjournment and the day to which the enquiry is adjourned. The
Enquiry Officer shall give the said person an opportunity of inspecting such
documents before they are taken on the record. The Enquiry Officer may also
allow the said person to produce new evidence, if he is of the opinion that the
production of such evidence is necessary in the interest of justice.
Note.—New evidence shall not be permitted or called for or any witness
shall not be recalled to fill up any gap in the evidence. Such evidence may be
called for only when there is an inherent lacuna or defect in the evidence
which has been produced originally. '
(13) When the evidence for proving the articles of charge against the
person against whom the enquiry is being held, is closed, the said person shall
be required to state his defence orally or in writing as he may prefer. If the defence
is made orally it shall be recorded, and the said person shall be required to
sign the record. In either case, a copy of the statement of defence shall be given
to the complainant, if any.
(14) The evidence on behalf of the person against whom the enquiry is
being held shall than be produced. The said person may examine himself in
his own behalf if he so prefers. The witnesses produced by the said person shall
then be examined and shall be liable to cross-examination, re-examination and
examination by the Enquiry Officer according to the provisions applicable to
the witnesses for proving the articles of charge.
(15) The Enquiry Officer may, after the person against whom the enquiry
is being held closes his case, and shall, if the said person has not examined himself,
generally question him on the circumstances appearing in the evidence against
him.
(16) The Enquiry Officer may, after the completion of the production of
evidence, hear the complainant, if any and the person against whom the enquiry
is being held, or permit them, or him, as the case may be, to file written briefs
of their respective cases.
(17) If the person to whom a copy of the articles of charge has been
delivered does not submit the written statement of defence on or before the
date specified for the purpose or does not appear in person before the Enquiry
Officer or otherwise fails or refuses to comply with the provisions of this rule,
the Enquiry Officer may hold the enquiry ex parte.
(18) Whenever the Enquiry Officer after having heard anfi rgco;dgd .the
whole or any part of the evidence in‘an enquiry, ceases to exercise jurisdiction
therein and is succeeded by another Enquiry Officer, the Enquiry Officer so
succeeding may act on the evidence so recorded by his predecessor or
partly
recorded by himself.
579
LES, 1997 R.6] UTTAR PRADESH PANGHAYAT RAJ (REMOVAL ... EMBERS) ENGURY i
+ is of the opin
ion that
ady been
Provided that if the succeedin i ffice g Enquiry Offic I
any of the witnesses V\Yhose evidence has alre
further examination of
recorded is necessary in the interest of justice he my recall, examine, Cross” examine and re-examine any such witness as hereinbefore provided.
SYNOPSIS
1 Appropriate safeguards. .. ... ..., 579
2 Procedureunder. . ... LouL L
579 8. Conduct of proceedings. . ..., ... 0 580 4 Final enquiry—Requirementof. . ......... ... ... ... . ... 581
1. Appropriate safeguards.—A
Legislature has given a
by the authorities. The
plain reading of the Rules indicates that the ppropriate safeguards to check the arbitrary use of power
specific provision has been given in Rule 6 for mquiry.1
2. Procedure under.—The procedure provided in Rules 6 to 8 is for the final enquiry and not for the preliminary enquiry. A report by an enquiry officer defined under Rule 2(c) is also a report by a person prescribed. It is not necessary for the enquiry officer to conduct the preliminary inquiry only on the direction
given by the District Magistrate. His job is to submit a report, so that the District
Magistrate may take a decision :
(@) Whether there is a prima facie case against the Pradhan or not;
(b) Whether the final enquiry should be held after ceasing his power.
It is not necessary for District Magistrate to specifically ask the enquiry
officer to conduct a preliminary enquiry. There seems to be no point in asking the
enquiry officer to conduct a preliminary enquiry again even if he submitted a
report after the enquiry. It would be a futile exercise unless the District Magistrate
with the report of the enquiry officer.
A report by an enquiry officer defined under Rule 2(c) is also a report by a
person and the manner is prescribed under the Rules irrespective of the fact that
he was so asked by the District Magistrate or not. In Court's opinion it is also a
preliminary report within the meaning of the proviso to Section 95(1)(g) of the
Panchayat Raj Act. The District Magistrate exercises the powers of the State
" Government under Section 95(1)(g) as well as under the enquiry rules as the
powers are delegated to him. He also appoints the enquiry officer. He is higher
than all enquiry officers. He can himself conduct a preliminary enquiry. It would
be anomalous that on a preliminary report of a subordinate officer, a final enquiry
and cessation of power can be ordered but the District Magistrate who appoints
him cannot conduct a preliminary enquiry.
In Court's opinion, action under proviso to Section 95(1)(g) can also be taken
on the preliminary report of the District Magistrate as well as on a report of a
person defined as enquiry officer under Rule 2(2) qf the enquiry rules. Only these
reports would be covered in the word “otherwise” of Rule 5. Any other report would
be a report under Rule 3(6) of the enquiry rules or can be considered F)y the
District Magistrate under his suo motu power to order a preliminary enquiry but
final enquiry with cessation of power cannot be ordered on its basis.
i hiers, 2009 (108) RD 5. L dri Begum v. State of U.P. and others,
2 %;Zk;;nsfi Yadav v. State of U.P. and others, 2011 (1)
AWC 488 (B).
580
...... MEMBERS) ENQUIRY RULES, 1997
1Rg "ate procedure has been preseribed 1
Ruleg R ¢s clearly indicate thaf the Enquiry Officer shall dr; ; ule
of y D) y sha aw (he SUbS a0 of tli'zilnr:mllflllons into definlte and distinet, articles of charge and that o m““""ll:n(i "Putations in su port ach article of charge all ¢ ;
which shall PI of each arlicle of ch wrge, shall also b ¢ drawn up,
) contain statement of all relevant facts and (he list of do
ist of Witnesses
mder Rule 6 of (he
sty
cuments apg ¢ which are all required to be Indicated and supplieq {
Pradhan. The ro
3 Ay
required (o py 1%11:;3?6 thereafter as provided under Rule 6 of the Ruleg Is
3. Conduct
aragraphs 74, 94 and 96 of
. Is as follows :
Pinion there can be a proceeding for removal of a ng his financial and administrative powers.
94. The procedure
and not for the prelimin
under Rule 2(c) is also
"74. In Court's o
Pradhan without ceas;
provided in Rules 6 to 8 is
ary inquiry. A report by an e
a report by a person prescrib
to conduct the preliminary direction given by the District Magistrate. His job is t that the District Magistrate ma
Jacie case against the Pradhan
for the final enquiry
nquiry officer defined
ed. It.is not necessary
inquiry only on the
0 submit a report, so
y take a decision. Whether there is prima
or not and,
whether the final inquiry should be held after ceasing his powers.
96. A report by an inquiry officer defined under Rule 2(c) is also a
report by a person and the manner is prescribed. Under the rules
irrespective of the facts that he was so asked by the District Maglstr'z;te m—f
not. In Court's opinion it is also a preliminary report wit‘}lfln the meaning of
the proviso to Section 96(1)(g) of the Panchayat Raj Act.
The petitioner complainant shall have an opportunity during t}‘xnedzc(;u;:: ;ar:
regular enquiry to lead oral and documentary evidence ashis p:l fmotesits
sub-section (11) of Section 6 of the Rules and further will alsoS a;iecnoi o o
of hearing as contemplated under sub-section (16) of Rule 6. Su
sub-section (16) of Rule 6 reads as follows :
) ment: "(11) On the date fixed for the enquiry, the oril 1?‘;‘2 ;zf;:l . ;’l‘é
evidence by which the articles of charge are proposed Sba r on behalf of the the witness shall be examined, by the Enquiry Officer );Ob or on behalf of complainant, if there is one, and may be cross-examinehelg The witnesses the person against whom the Enquiry Officer is being § m:ant 25 the case
may be re-examined by the Enquiry Officer or the complai meé but no on may be, on any point on which they have been cross-exam :
any new matter, without the leave of the Enquiry Officer.
e nment of Mukesh Kumar (Pradhan) v. State of U.P. through Secretary, Panchayati Raj, Gover U.P, Lucknow and others, 2014 (122) RD 70. 2. 2010 (111) RD 699 (FB).
e
81
UTTAR PRADESH PANCHAYAT Ry (FENOUABERHENRERS)
ENOURY RULES, 1957
:
(16) The Eunc
{
_——
“Nauly Ofeey 0: (\ildx'm ¢ hear the mmplulnn:‘\‘l\y;f ‘~‘~(11(‘(““ Is hplng held, o Permit 1‘1\01
written brjefy of theiy respective
opg, Thus, it s evident fropy, the
tk
the complainant
only has q pyg
e
o ey 0t extent
rules provided for, bt he | Ipate In the regular enquiry to the extent
Magistrate 0 challenge the
either on th \ order passed by District 4. Final enquiry—Re, nary enquiry or conducted in accordance it} Rules of 1997 and
of the Rules of 1997. The Procedure conte officer shall draw the > Serve such articles of
in support . of such s
instant ¢
after the completion of the productjfin
any and the person against whom the
M, or him, as the case may be, to file es,"
138 1o locys t,
€ report of prelim;
to cross-examine
ed to submit an
the statement of the assessment of the evidence
(a) the articles of charge and the s
(b) the defence of the person agai
(c) the assessment of the evidenc
(d) the findings on each article o
Explanation.—If in the opinion of the Enquiry Officer the proceedings of the enquiry establish any article of charge different from the original articles of charge, he may record his findings on such article of charge.
Provided that the findings on such article of charge shall not be recorded
unless the person against whom the enquiry has been held has either admitted
the facts on which such article of charge is based 1or hfashhad a reasonable
i i i inst such articles of charge. opportunity of defending himself agains
" ! it h t, the i i rovides that while submitting the report, the nquiry
mce;{z :1]12]’17 rc::;::)‘:g ::;;sflf finding wm; regard to certain points keeping in view o
the facts and circumstances of a case.
tatement of the imputations;
nst whom the enquiry has been held;
e in respect of each article of charge;
f charge and reasons therefor.
1. RajKi Singhv. State of LLP. through Secretary, Panchayat Raj, U.P,, Lucknow and others, . j Kumar A §
014 (122) RD 7. .
2. 12711511;511 ( S?nt.) v. State of LL.P. and others, 2(2)1049((11202;)1;%155-5
3. Quadri Begum v. State of ULP. and Dflfers, 2
582
(@) the report prepared by him under Rule 7; (B) the written statement of defence, if any, the enquiry has been held;
(©) the oral ang document the enquiry;
(@) Written briefs, if any, filed during the course of the enquiry; and (e) the orders, if any, made by the State Government and the Enquiry Officer in regard to the enquiry.]
NOTES
—Rule 8 of the Rules provide that the Inquiry
Officer shall conclude the Inquiry within six months from the date of the receipt
of the complaint and forward to the State Government the record of enquiry. Since
the inquiry is pending for past 20 months, it is expected that it shall be concluded expeditiously within three months from th e date of production of certified copy of the order.?
of the person against Whom
ary evidence produced during the course of
Enquiry—Conclusion of.
No. 2263/XXX
5-:
01). 01 (w.e.f. 5.10.20 000, dt. 5.10.20
o i
-1-2001-565-2
Rai. U.P,, Lucknow
hers
i. No. 2263/ - omau Danchavat Ral, 1. Subs. by Noti.
%
Previous and next
All provisions of Uttar Pradesh Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhans and Members) Inquiry Rules-1994
Questions people ask
Is rule 6 of Uttar Pradesh Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhans and Members) Inquiry Rules-1994 still in force?
No repeal of Uttar Pradesh Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhans and Members) Inquiry Rules-1994 is recorded.