Rule 11, The Chhattisgarh Panchayat (Gram Panchayat Ke Sarpanch Tatha UP-Sarpanch, Janpad Panchayat Tatha Zila Panchayat ke President Tatha Vice-President ke Virudh Avishwas Prastav) Niyam, 1994.: Prescribed authority fixing date of meeting beyond 15 days-Motion of no confidence passed cannot be held invalid
The Chhattisgarh Panchayat (Gram Panchayat Ke Sarpanch Tatha UP-Sarpanch, Janpad Panchayat Tatha Zila Panchayat ke President Tatha Vice-President ke Virudh Avishwas Prastav) Niyam, 1994. - Rule 11
Text of rule 11
Prescribed authority fixing date of meeting beyond 15 days-Motion of no confidence passed cannot be held invalid
11. Prescribed authority fixing date of meeting beyond 15
days-Motion of no confidence passed cannot be held invalid.-
Although the date of meeting fixed by the Prescribed Authority was
beyond 15 days from the date of receipt of notice still, the motion of
no-confidence passed cannot be held invalid for the reason that the will
.. of members in relation to the no-'confidencemotion cannotbedefeated.-.- -.--- -
on account of inaction or delayed action ofthe Prescribed Authority. But
it was observed that in case the meeting is not held within 15 days, the
members have the right to approach the High Court for its compliance
and this judgment should not be held to have authorised the Prescribed
Authority to fixdate ofmeeting for consideration ofno-confidencemotion
beyond 15 days. Dhumadandhin v. State of M.P., 1997 (2) MPLJ 175... .
4. Appointment of Pre~iding Officer.-Tlie Prescribed Authority shall
appoint an Officerof the Government under sub-section (2)of Section 21.
~ub-sectiQn (2).of Section 28. or sub-section (2) of Section 35 to preside
over. the meeting of the Gram Panchayat .. J anapad Panchayat or Zila
Panchayat. as the case may be. For the purpose of considering the no
confidence motion against Sarpanch or Up-Sarpanch. a Revenue Officer
not below the rank of Naib Tehsildar. against President or Vice-President
of Jan~pad Panchayat l[Officer not below the rank of Deputy Collector]
1 Subs. by Notification dated 23-12-1995 [26-12-1995].
and. against President or Vice-President ofZila Panchayat the Collector or
Additional Collector shall be ap,poin::edtopreside over such meeting and
the prescribed authority shall inforn::.the Secretary of the Gram Panchayat
or Chief Executwe Officerof Janapad Panchayat or Zila Panchayat as the
case may be. and the Collector of the district about such appointment at
least 3 days before the date fixed for-the meeting.
COMMENTARY
I
(
R.5 GRAM PANCH. KE SARPAJ.VCH ... PRASTAV) NIYAM, 1994 (PR)203
In the matter of no confidence motion against 8arpanch of Gram
Panchayat, if information is not sent to the. Collector of appointment of
presiding officer under Rule 4, it cannot nullify the resolution of non-
confidence which is passed by overwhelming majority. Suhhriandan
Patel v. State of M.P., 2003 (1) MPLJ 220=2003 (2) JLJ 74.
5. Conduct of meeting.-(l) The Presiding Officer shall record the
attendance of the members of the Panchayat present at the meeting.
IIx xx]
2[(3) The Presiding Officershall ask any of the signatories to the notice
to lllove the motion.] .
(4) After the motion is moved the mover shall first speak on the motion
arid thereafter other members may, if they so desire. speak on the motion .
.- - (5)Oh th~"~o:iitiu~i6r{6"rtii~::aebii~~oii~th~~~ti~i.--tl~~-'.P~~~f~ti~~goiii~~t::~~:-.~.==:::=--~
shall call the members present in tl-e meeting one by one and shall give
them ballot paper duly signed oy-nirif to indicate itsauthentldty:' to 'cast
his vote for or against the motion. The member who wants to vote in favour
of the motion shall affix the symbol (-/)and the member who wants to vote
against the motion shall affix the symbol 'X'. After the member has
recorded his vote, he shall fold tlWballot paper to maintain secrecy and
put it in the ballot box kept on the table of the Presiding Officer.
(6) After the voting is .over, the Presiding Officer shall take out the
ballot papers fr011?-_tl)~..1?c~JI.qt~~~_Cl:I?.9~9rtoutJh~YQt~~_fQr.9J!c;l_~gq!n.~tthe._. ._
. motf6n:If ilie-number of votes in favour of the motion fulfills the require-
ment of sub-section (1) of Section 21, sub-section (1) of Section 28, or
sub-section (1) of Section 35, as the case may be, the Presiding Officer
shall declare that the motion of no confidence is passed. 3[xxx].
COMMENTARY
1.Validity ofresolution-Sarpanch has a right to speak.-A no-
confidence motion against a 8arpanch was considered in a meeting
called for the purpose and a reso.ution was; passed by the majority of
members reql!.ired lQ.do.fi9but the c)ncerneq 8arpanch was not.allowed. _
to speak in that meeting. Held that although the motion was passed by
. the requisite" majority still,' the resolution was- invalid because the
8arpanch was not allowed to-speak in that meeting. See comments under
8.21. Nagsai v. State of M.P., AIR 1998 MP 81.
1 Sub-rule (2) omitted by Notification dated 23-12-1995 [26-12-1995J.
2 Subs. by Notification dated 23-12-1995 [26-12-1995J.
3 Omitted by Notification dated 23-12-1~95 [26-12-1995].
,.------------------------.~~
;
(PR)204 GRAM PANCH. KE SARPANCH ... PRASTAV) NIYAM, 1994 R.6
," ,
2. Mark on ballot paper c'onstrued.-[l] Looking to t9.emarks put
on three ballot papers, the Court came to the conclusion that these marks
were put to vote in favour of the no- confidence motion. Shardabai v.
State of M.P., 1997 (2) MPLJ 291. _
[2]Mark on ballot paper's back side treated as no expression
of intention.-A voter was required to cast his vote in favour of no
confidence motion by putting the symbol of right mark and against it
by putting a symbol ofcross mark (x).One disputed ballot paper is liable
to reject for the reason that reverse mark of right symbolwas put on the
blank back side. Held, it will not convey any intention in specific of the
voter and the same cannot be treated as a expression ofintention within
the meaning of election laws. Such ballot paper rightly rejected. Sunita
Patel u. Collector, 2008 (3) MPLJ 248 = 2008(1) MPHT 302 = 2008(2) "
JLJ 26 =AIR 2008 (NOC) 802 MP.
2-A. Nirvachan Niyam, 1995 are" applicable.-M.P. Nirvachan
Niymn, 1995 are quite exhaustive and they would also cover the meet-
ings ofno confidencewith regard to various things forwhich no provision
has been made in the Avishwas Prastav Niyam, 1994. Illustratively,
Chap. X ofNirvachan Niyam provides for counting ofvotes for which no
specificprovision made in Avishwas Prastav Niyam and although count-
ing is requi.red tQbe_madeeyen5nthe meetingJorno.cC?P.:fi~_~.J?~~.~.$~~(t~~.__~:.~._"._._
-.Patel u.ColleCtor,200S(3)MPLf24S';;;; 2008U)"MPlIT 302 = 2008(2)
JLJ 26 =AI~ ~Q~8JNQ.~2_~0_2MP. I _ ••. _ •.• _ •• __ ••
3. Sub-rule (5)-Opportunity to speak.- The facts showing that
deliberations were made showed that opportunity was given to speak at
the meeting called for consideration of no confidence against the Sar-
panch. Provisions of sub-rule (3) were complied. Sukhnandan Patel v.
State of M.P., 2003 (1) MPLJ 220=2003 (2) JLJ 74.
4. Sub-rule (5)-Votingby women members with assistance of
their husbands.-Wl1i~e ~~.~tjI].g.votes in the__pr.oceedings_of.no-:con- .... 1
fidence motIon-meeting, the women members were permitted to take
assisstance of their husbands by the Presiding Officer and no objection
to such course was taken"by anyone, the motion carried out by 3/4th
majority ofvotes cannot be set at nought in the absence ofany allegation.
to the effect that the votes were casted by the women candidates under
the influence of their husbands. Kamla Durga Solanki v. State of M.P.,
2004 (2) MPLJ 140=2004 (2) MPHT 76 (DB).
5. Conclusiop.- No meeting could be ,held due to difference of
opinion between the presiding officer and,:the members present." No
conclusion can be drawn that the motion was rejected;-Baboolal Baiga
u. State of M.P., 2002 (3) MPLJ 529=:2002(5) MPHT 32.
•, ""(2] N0 ~o~fide~cem:9tionwas not validly passed forwant ofrequisite
strength i.e. 3/4th. Sunita Patel v. Collector, 2008 (3) MPLJ 248 =
2008(1) MPHT 302 = 2008(2) JLJ 26 =AIR 2008 (NOC) 802 MP.
6. Minutes of the Proceedings.-Minutes of the proceedings of the
meeting called under rule 4 shall be drawn up by the Presiding.Officerand
R. 7 GRAM PANCH. KE 8ARPANCH ... PRA8TAV) NIYAM, 1994 (PR)205
recorded in the minute book kept i:1 the Panchayat for recording the
pro~eedings of-11smeetings and sign it.
7. Safe keeping of Records.-(l) The Presiding Officer shall keep in
safe custody the ballot papers referrerl to in sub-rule (5) of rule 5, in his
officeduly sealed along with a copy 0= the minutes of the proceedings for
period of one year. .
(2) The minutes of proceeding re~orded under'sub-rule (1) shall in-
c1ude,-
(i) name of the officebearers :;>resent;
(il) the decision of the meeting on the motion ofno-confidence; and
(iil) when such decision is not unanimous the number of vates for
and against such motion 3.ndthe number of those wh::>have
remained neutral. .
8. Decision.to be communicated to the Prescribed Authority and
theCollector.-\Vhen the Panchayat takes a decision on any motion of
no-confidence, the Presiding Officer shall communicate forthwith a copy
of the proceeding drawn under rule E to the prescribed authority and the
Collector.
9. Repeal.-All previous rules on the subject shall stand repealed from
the date of final publication of Liese rules in the "Madhya Pradesh
Gazette". .
Previous and next
Questions people ask
Is rule 11 of the Chhattisgarh Panchayat (Gram Panchayat Ke Sarpanch Tatha UP-Sarpanch, Janpad Panchayat Tatha Zila Panchayat ke President Tatha Vice-President ke Virudh Avishwas Prastav) Niyam, 1994. still in force?
No repeal of the Chhattisgarh Panchayat (Gram Panchayat Ke Sarpanch Tatha UP-Sarpanch, Janpad Panchayat Tatha Zila Panchayat ke President Tatha Vice-President ke Virudh Avishwas Prastav) Niyam, 1994. is recorded.