LawGrids logoLAWGRIDS.ORG

Rule 49, Uttar Pradesh Panchayai Raj (Sadsyo, Pradano aur Up Pradhano Ka Nirvachan), Rules, 1994: Procedure at the counting

Uttar Pradesh Panchayai Raj (Sadsyo, Pradano aur Up Pradhano Ka Nirvachan), Rules, 1994 - Rule 49

Text of rule 49

Procedure at the counting

49. Procedure at the counting.—On the date and at the time and place -appointed under Rule 46 the Nirvachan Adhikari shall proceed as follows : (@) The Nirvachan Adhikari shall satisfy himself that all the ballot boxes used at the poll and which are to be counted at that place have been received and accounted for. (b) The Nirvachan Adhikari shall then allow the candidates and their Nirvachan Abhikartas and Ganana Abhikartas present at the counting an opportunity to inspect the ballot boxes and the seals for satisfying themselves that they are in order. (¢) The Nirvachan Adhikari shall also satisfy himself that none of the (d) If the Nirvachan Adhikari is satisfied that all such ballot boxes are, as to be counted, at such Place, have been received and are in order, he shall take up the counting of ballot papers contained in the ballot boxeg, All the ballot boxes used at polling place shall be opened, and the counting of the ballot papers found in those 0Xes proceeded with, in accordance with the instructions in the State Election Commission, at the same time. © An account of the ballot Papers found in the boxes of the polling na Place shall pe recorded in a statement in the form specified by the State Election Commisgion, APPEN. 6—R. 49—SYN. 2] U. P. PANCHAYAT PRADHANS AND (® The Nirvachan Adhikari shall allow the candidates, their Nirvachan Abhikartas and Ganana Abhikartas, who may be Present, reasonable Opportunity to inspect all ballot papers which in the opinion of the Nirvachan Adbhikari are liable to be rejected, b\.}t shall not allow them to handle these or any other paper. The Nirvachan Adhikari shall, on every ballot paper which is rejected, endorse rejection in Hindi in Devanagri script. If any candidate or his Nirvachan Abhikarta questions the correctness of the rejection of any ballot paper, the Nirvachan Adhikari shall also record briefly on such ballot paper, the reasons for his rejection. RAJ (ELECTION OF MEMBERS, 361 UP-PRADHANS) RULES, 1994 (g) After the counting of all ballot papers contained in the ballot boxes of the polling place has been completed, the Nirvachan Adhikari shall cause all such ballot papers to be kept in a separate packet on which shall be indicated such particulars as will identify the polling place, the name of the Gram Panchayat and the constituency to which the ballot papers relate. SYNOPSIS ' 1. Recounting of votes when counting 3. Election Procedure and counting of Supervisor's signature was not affixed. ballot papers. 2. Procedure for counting of Ballot papers. 1. Recounting of votes when counting supervisor’s signature were not affixed—The instructions envisaged that in case a person affixes more than one mark of seal against the name/sample of a candidate, said vote cannot be declared invalid. The Revisional Authority considered the matter in entirety and has recorded a finding that from the original record, it was apparent that counting supervisor's signatures were not affixed thereon, which constituted breach of the rules. The order was rightly passed for recounting by the Revisional Authority and the order passed by the Prescribed Authority suffered from illegality prevailing the process of Election and Revisional Court rightly passed the order of directing recounting of votes. [Ashok v. Additional District Judge, Varanasi, 2004 (96) RD 482 at 486, 487 (All)]. 2. Procedure for counting of ballot papers—Rules 49 and 49(d) are very germane which envisage that "if Nirvachan Adbhikari is salisfied that all such ballot boxes have been received and are in order he shall take up counting of ballot papers contained in the ballot boxes. All the ballot boxes shall be opened and the counting of the ballot papers founding those boxes proceeded with in accordance with the instruction in the State Election Commission at the same lime. Under Rules 4 and 5 of the U.P. Panchayat Raj (Election of Members, Pradhans and Up-Pradhans) Rules, 1994, it is the District Magistrate who would appoint Returning Officer for every election to fill up secat or seats in the Gram Panchayat. If there was blatant violations of the above Rules then the order was rightly passed for recounting by the Revisional Authority. U. P. PANCHAYAT RAJ ACT, 1947 [APpEy ) O, 50 the consensus of judicial opinions was; favour- of the View tha To sum Upe h bore more than one mark of seal against a candidate, could o, t votes polled whic lid or cancelled. As a result of foregoing discussion in the insty, el been declared ;‘nvff;rm view that order was rightly passed by the Revisiona Auth Court was if,;nflaw for recounting of votes. [Ashok v. Additional Distric Judge, 362 Nt cag, Vority in ance Arangg; Zfir&) RD 482 at 486 10 489 (AID)]. . : p 3. Election procedure and com.m'ng of ballot l’mp-fls._l:'-llls the District Magi“‘ll’ale who would appoint Returning Officer for every el 'ecu(:in 13 i l{p §gat o seats jp the Gram Panchayat. From a perusal o.f Rulelenu'nmale a vae, it is clear thy Sy Retumning Officer or Assistant Relurnlpg Officer is appointed for an area, Indisputab] one Returning Officer could be appointed for more than one P‘?nchayat Area, |¢ ha; come in the evidence and it was also borne out from the finding of the Prescrj Authority that Assistant Returning Officer appointed for the Panchayat Area thoy present did not seem to work as another person who was not appointed for that Panchayat Area was allowed to perform duties of Assistant Returning Officer of thyt Panchayat Area. This detracts from the provisions of the rules and has 10 be read 4 blatant violation of the Rules. There was no evidence on record to show that different . mark of seal were affixed against different candidates and according to instructions of the Election Commission, even if ballot paper contained more than one mark of seals against the name/symbol of a candidate, that ballot cannot be declared or treated a5 invalid and consequently cannot be cancelled. The argument of the Counsel for the petitioner, that it amounts to fishing and roving enquiry in the garb of election petition, did not appeal to Court having regard to the fact that in view of specific pleading and categorical evidence forthcoming record adduced by the partics, illegality is too patent which was fraught with the consequence of materially affecting the result. The order was rightly passed for recounting by the Revisional Authority and the order passed by the Prescribed Authority suffers from illegality pervading the process of election and Revisional Court rightly passed the order directing recounting of votes. [Ashok v. Additional District Judge, Varanasi, 2004 (96) RD 482 at 486 (All)).

Previous and next

All provisions of Uttar Pradesh Panchayai Raj (Sadsyo, Pradano aur Up Pradhano Ka Nirvachan), Rules, 1994

Questions people ask

Is rule 49 of Uttar Pradesh Panchayai Raj (Sadsyo, Pradano aur Up Pradhano Ka Nirvachan), Rules, 1994 still in force?

No repeal of Uttar Pradesh Panchayai Raj (Sadsyo, Pradano aur Up Pradhano Ka Nirvachan), Rules, 1994 is recorded.