LawGrids logoLAWGRIDS.ORG

Action against Government servants who get appointment on the basis of false SC, ST and OBC certificates, Rules

Circular - The Chhattisgarh Lok Seva (ST, SC and OBC) Reservation Act, 1994

Text of this circular

/ . . , 'c9 ,i:'17 f!l I qi ~ 1~ W~lltFl fcr:TTTf i.f-~C'flf °Gl\h cfi~T ffi~ 'ffcl-4, ~- q:;l=fiEP t;tfi· 13-3/2006/1-3 ~x, ~qfcfi 15~, 2007 w, " ·~fffR 'cf> .. ·~ fctiTFT, 31'cZleT, 'f§ ;rr. ~ l=f~. ~~. ~ fcl'lfflT!t::-:feT, ~~- ~·1 fcl~;- ~ tiffl~/~W"-cm ~!TI/~ fq~ q.f cf~ w=rrrr 1:f5l1 cf 3Tf'%ITT rix ~fcm ~ ffi cl@ ~ ~nfl<:TT 'cf> WI(<)~ cfiT'(cJTf I . ·- ·- 0·-··- ' ~ f~;q- ~ '<Tv'<:! W'1'f'T 'cf> ·~ 01j'<1~d \iflfcl / 31:!f~ ~'Rf/ 3Rl f4FF-$ q<f <15 ~6 l)lTIVf ~ 'cf> ~OOH CR ~gfcl'rl mtff qw,:'f q@ ~ ¢4t11R<.l'1 'cf> ~ fcrR:r 1;fcflN cflT4crrm ~ ~. ~.,. Fcn:nw-Jl·.-r m 1 ~, x=mt:l' 1T 'BT~Zf ~ if 'lfl <W<.J 111.f~,ffe-r %g ~ti TTPm Tf<:lT I 2 / '+'.II'@ "'Hxcf5T"i(, cfiTfl'l"cfi C'ftc/5 ~F'BTmf TI~ If~Fi ' ,::f?!lcvl<-! ·;c)· ~-'<'] ·fi~tl i'j ~ ~-q.,- wJ:ffcfi 42011 / 22 / 2006__:Estt.(Res) fu."ajcfi 29 llli!, 2007 \Jrr~ 'cfR' \IZ·f"co't YTT7" x-lm ,ff\J'<J x'l~<1?RT .cITT -~ %g •TGJT 6 I ~ ~fCR lT '<iKcl x-lxcf>lx cf lcT ii' vff~ -qf1lr3J ~ajcp 19.05.1993 <15 ~'f cB' <>l':P,:TH cnPlcJrtt 3N~ ·qmt ~ s 1 \1CRj -cr~ :.St ~11s1 xiic! x'f ·a~ ~~<m 5 fcn:-. "<f~ ~Tr x-Jxc!5ft qTTfiH0 ·q'; ·fi~l't 'i:j Il"i3 "CfmT \JlITiT ·~ fcp 'cf§' 1-ffiT f-qa.q1 ~~- q'\· 31¥ITT .ircrf l'i 1,]fficp 'l'.@f 'c$ f~ m•<1 ~61' m 2,:r~r ~~ ~ -qpr cY, ~ ~ · ~ cft m ~ 'LC'@ w=rrrr ~ fu.m ~. (ff \'!'"fl ircrf Tf -;fm -ZX:s/T vfF!l. ~. 1:f~ 'cf§' m,<fremTR 3Tv.cff 3'R:imm ~- • cj5"-l-W]': ... 2 ' ~ · I I / /3// ~ ~x...«iiH1 Gtr;wrur/~ ~ cfi f.wr x'lfqq/f.wr m, Uq1'h·PI (p, 5. x'lfqq, ~t§-c\~,\--,l{i.,..,tl~q; ~ WIT 3TWT, ~. 6. :!&l ~ ~. 't9rnlfPlq, ~. 7. ~cf.~~ 3TTtrrT \:htll-Hll<t, ~. 4 , " 8. l-\t;l("jxsll¢1'!, rTt§-o=!CT1,t.,,lfl.,..,,1,..,,,.q;, ~. 9. ~. GFH-iq$ t§~fllli$ WxR, ~ <til 3ffi ~~ 10. ~ . ~-f'T(p 'l-"fcA, ~ ~. . 11. ~-~ ~ 3Wl11T, xr:r~. 12. ~ ~. ~ ~ ~ --ll~lll-lC'l=ll ~. ff1c1lfl'.f<. 13. ~ '8"ftlcr, "ff+ffi1 ~clf4tllc1ll, t§ffilfl 1!<$, 14. 3r:PTf'T ~. ~ mmr,, fcriwT ("ff+ffi'f cn&:r) ~ ~ U.Tf. 15 :!&l x'lfqq cfi ~ ~. 1f-511C'flf "ff.TT.~. ............~ . 16. 31::ffl1T ~. ~ mITTA" fcr:rr,r cn&:r-6 $1 3ffi clEJ-<11$c "CJx c;Gt cn'{"J,T tg I (:I) $1 oITT ~ ~ o~ ~ tg ~1 A~~~~~f- (~.3lR. / ) ...--.? 3TTR X'f"fqq I '-./ ' [P)- t§t(fl fl•! q, ~. ~ "ITTITTA" fcriwT I -~- , ·p • •,·· .. ,~; t-~=~f~;~iSfil~,::;3; t l' :;i•.: ·--¼~~ No.42011/22/2006-Estt.(Re~) ' · Ministry of Personnel, P.G & Pensions Department of Personnel <!<, Training Government of India **'-'* New Delhi, D.ited: the 291h March, 2007 OFllJCE MEMORANDUM Subject: Action against Government servants who get appointment on the !' basis of false SCISTIOBC certificates. ****, ..._.-,Respondent no.] in Civil Appeal No. 2294/1986·[$tate ofMa11arasl1lrn Vs Milind & OrsJ befo1:c the Supreme Court hnd got admission ,1:; a Sc;h~,duled Tribe candidate to MBBS degree course for the year 1985-86 on the strength of a Scheduled Tribe Certificate issued to Jiim by the competent authority. The Supreme Conrt held him i10t to belong to a Scheduled Tribe but did not winul his adllt.ission or affected his degree. Tfie Hor1'bJe Court observed that abou1 J 5 years had passed since he took admission and had already co111p leted the course, At that 'length or time it was for nobody's benefit to aonul bis admission inasmuch as any · action against the ca11didate might lead to depriving tlie sooiety of the service of a doctor on whom public money had already been spe1it. The Court' in that case also :f. elq that the admissions and appointments that had become final would remain j F~ maffe~~ted by the judgement. . ;,, I.: ~ gl f 1 ; 2. A qu;sWon has been mised whether in >icw of the above , efon·cd judgement, ~!J, •he appointments made against the >acancies cesemd fo,· SCsiSTs/OBC:s on Llie }i'fi basis of false SC!STIOBC certificates shall not be disturbed if soeh appointn1ents I. , i '-: •1, have br;;cn made final or are continuing-for a long tune. . ;~; - . . l : 'v (.;;- . . . -.!...!:/ 3. 'fhe mal[e, has been examined in consultation with the Depru-tmem of Legal Affairs und it has been found that admissions nnd appointments of SOl!le candidates in the case, of Milind and in so111e other similar cases were not annul!c.d by the ·-r-'"•~1 Supcem: Couct as a special case kc:ping in v!ew 1he special ~i""'?~•mccs of ihose i ', cases. I he cel,cf accorded by the Sup,·eme Court wos spec,t,c ,-el,et prnv,dcd only i • i Ito die candidates who wccc pw-ty in those CfCes. The cases <>the,· Iha" thos, i ~ / /p1otected by the specific order of the Apex Cou1t should be dealt with in ; #it:\ . --~- "'·' ;.f ::; with the instructions contained in this Department's OlVl 1-Estt(A) dated 19.5.1993 which provides as fo)lows: '' Whcn::JV,er iLis f'uuml Lhc1tf1 Ci()vernnn:ml servant, who was 11ol qua Ii lied pr eligible in tenns _of the n,cn1itmeoA ruks etc, for initi<'LI n:crnitmem in service 01' had furnished false inforn,ation or pr·<)(iuced ,i hilsc oertifi9<J.,te in order to secure appointment, he should not be retaineU in service. it', he 1s a probationer or a temporary Government servant, he should be discharged or his services should by terminated. lf he has. b.econ1e a permanent Goverrn1'.ent serv~mt, )ut ir~.qliiry ·as' prespribed in Rule 14 of CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965 may be · held and if the charges are ,proved, the Government servant should be removed or dism1ssed from service. ln no circumstances should any other penalty be imposed", 4. The above refet:i:ed instructions am strenglhened by the, observations ol' the Supreme Court in Milind K1.11mir'S case (SUPRA) to trie eJJecl that if the bem:fits of reservation are taken away by tbose for whom they me not meant, the people for · whom they are really meant or intended will be deprived of tht1 same and their · suffering will continue. Allowing the candidates n:ot belonging to the re1,erved categories to have the benefit of reservation either i11 admissions or appointm6nts w0uld lead to making mockery of the very reservation against the mandate and scheme of Constitution. · · Contents of this OM may be broLtght to the r1otice of ull coi{ccrned l. All MinistriesiDepartments 9f the Government oflndia. LK.(3. Vernia) Director 2. All Officers ,and Sections in the Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pens.ions and all attached/subordinate offices of the Ministry. 3. Department of Economic Affairs (Banking Division), New Delhi . 4. Departmqnt of Economic Affair$ (In;,urance Division), New Qell,L S. l)epanment of Public Emcrprh,cs, Nmv Dc:lhi. 6. Railway Board. 7. Union Public Service Comniission/Suprcnte Comt of lndi::L1Flection Co1r1mission/L,ok Sabha Secretarit11./Rajya Sabha Secretari;il/C'ab111et \ \, \ icretariat/Ce'ntral Vigilance , Commission/Presidenl's , SecretariatfPl'ime Minister's On1ce/Planning Commission. Staff Selection Commission, COO ComfJJex, Lodi Road, New Delhi. Ministry ofSocial Justice and Erhpowerrnent, Shastri Bhavan, New Delhi . l 0. National Commission for SCs, Lok Nayak Bhavan, New f:)elhi. 1 l . National Commission for STs, Lok Nayak Bhavan, New Delhi. 12. National Colhmi$sion for Htj,ckward Clasrtes, Trikoot-1, Bhikaji Cama Place, R.K. Puram:New Delhi. · 13. Offic.e of the Comptroller and Auditor General of India, 10, Bahadurshah Zafar Marg, New Delhi - 110002. 14. CBI, LBSNAA, ISTM, PESB, Central Se;ctt. Libi·ary, MHA Library. 15, lnfon11ation and Facilitation Centre, DCWt, North Block, New Delhi. · The Chief Secretaries of all States/UTs. i- '<rom 420i i/22/2/J06 · 'f~TIXf'1T ('31H~M) -i:im~xcl'iJx ·q;1f~, ~cfj f~Thl<T~ ·~ if~"i lf?f~ (cfil fi'r<J? 31lx J;ITTT&1W 'fcl'i]FT) ~> ~ ~/3lj"f1f·""'1 isl';::r'5flfa/&i~ fill"¥ wt ~ ir'fd 'ITTffl:'T·"9?11 'fl'i ,1H€1Tx 9\'I' ~ ~ 'PTT <Im W{cb~ <1>-i'iITITT!T ~ f.t~·Qirfci~ I ~ffl ~K>TT{ it c:TTIR ~~ '3l"itr'B 'ajxRl'f 2294(1986 (l'ffiT~ ;(:fGi'.f ~F'ITFf ~R eftx ;,~) -$t >ITT'fcr1.f'r •~r 1 'i;' ~l\'l'"ff :ITTR:fq;r-!=t' wxr 'tl"Rl' ~ ·rit; ir1xit~ 'G1''fti'f!'f~ I Yfl'fTl1f-<Bl' ~ 0lltJW tR cf~ 1985-86 ir; ~ ,Z.1 .rt .jj· lf{-f, fum ~W'i if '31"-J,~ tij,fGfITT, i:n ~<ffi' 'm- ~ ·~ >fffl furm QJT I 'i.'t'"~ -.·~:rrimq·lf ~~~~ct 'G'FfvJTfu clTT ~~ •rtff '.l'fFi[ ~ ~ ~T 'cF,I' ~ ~<TT ful.ir cm :;f'):ffr1'{'1 ~ .'1~ 1Wm I 'l=fr"A'm "xll?:ff~l ,:y 1:rrm Jc}; ,HI xFm qq\ff "<'ri' Wlcf 15 cf~ '6!TTfrd tT Wn i)' err~ ~<h7 trRr.l-fmf.f 1'(1 'ITT ~-cf;r :rn· I ~?r~ ~· ~Hri::r. ·::o· ITT~ B'~d.5 ~~r 'q'/)" ~ <r>T'i' z-l fcl'R:fi cfiT ci';r:{ ·c-11'11 ,i"!fi tm'fT l \:fTT&'i RfBrci, cr"r ·i:!.,~ ,'rr{ ~'t ~\if q,:r \J'cfi tr~ :irrcR.x ~T Z-fcfl •ft ~ci W'iT ~r ftrn tR u;;;"ctr cfii i:J~-n x::,rti fzf,,J1 vfl ''.f"ffl ~.rr · I ~TlflZ17:f ~- 1:f-t, .:1r:im- # ·i.TTf T\-t f9·6fu- ftm fr), ~'l 5f<r~ <>TR F•n:§'mlf'f ,'n -.-rr/'.J,g urr ;itfu'i:'f '{lit/ ~ "¥' Ql', ~ ir; '3m f.'!u'm '(t Gl™ffm=r ,reT\' I 2, 'i3'tl'trn i'.l,~<-1 <1i trR*IRJ ri ·lrtr ~"I ~oi:;i.:rr r,r,.,rr t ~ ·if!Tr :ar-J,'J_~;[TT 'CiffR'f/'3f'j'(if2i11 ~/9l'v{[ ~ ct.t in ~ '3l"TfflRf ~ • trx qt1- ·irt w ~Rn~1r ·,~r 0T:f{il~e1 ·~;sir:1-<:J:f'cra- v--rr.;:;rifu/;:ir;;i:r fcr\:ll·t ,rrr m· !l1t3 sri:rruff:sfi c'r; :;intrr;r cr;r ~-.f'·k~, <1\'t ·,r:t -~1 ,.r'r ~'l "flt[ vr ~7!5T tt S'l~l 'GfT ,.;:ii:;q qT1'f7oT fr Dim t, ,:;-,')' x-PTT~i fi):;,:n \ifl ff"lfi.:crr '@ ,swrc;,r -.Tf:\' I G. ~'ff wr~ it filfa q;T<f nrirr1 x~ 1RT'+f'-<T %7.lr ·11'l!l' Gt'R i:r1~r 11m i~ri r.~n:Fi'~ &i'h ,3',!'rt Wfi]x &, iJiU $Alf lW!'ffi ~ ~fl'[ ,,:m:m'.'.flI ~ wtp \Wl~ &1 W)°\!f i6W-.; frf'{Ifl.15' cir :~r:, l'frtn.it cJ~ ~)1!{ i:lftf?-trrfi'i<TT cfh ~xsi~ w ~- "liff 1~;,rr 1 · '3"'~.,- ;xm:n.m:r ~ ~cf'~ ,:,.:i;fJ i:rmC:-cITTT ·cm fcr~ iffiIB ~ urr \09 ~ ii· ~ ~ I -~ .qj'lf~ m- fcn,}psf 31Y~lf imT "f&1~r l=frir01r m. ~qf wrr ~ if ~ fcri-m ~ ITTt<J? 19.05.1993 i,; :zy,:r;moflf ~nlFf m.<2TI i 1012/7 /9i ~~ .(cfi) it f.imi:i ~ ~ <W:fHH ~t 1f,r 3l•tf~m . 11 1 ·(mi cr,rik~,1<1 'ffltf"i cfiT S!F:fc!FI "'\'f"il R;,m •1111 ~ : .. ''lf~ fcn"ffl "f{x'qiT{! q;~r~ m. ffltf. it ~ ~ vltliV i . fcn· q5' trn1 ~~~'i ~-~nf'f: ~ (>f,Jt!R ·'ffc!T ~ m'<'fl':iq, -.:rar ~ ~ mn:r •nft. \!:IT o!Q.Tc!T ~~ •i'rcrifl tiR zy; . f~ 11~::r xrci~ cft ~ m 1Tff<l >fl1rrrrq?f f~ \!:IT ~fl s.:r01 x~'~T ·i'f :;r~ft "{,m "n:.rr ,:rrft,r , ·,.11\': ,Jt ~ ~<lt!ffltlR 3TQ.Tc!T ~ ~;rq,m V;il,l~ % (ll ~ cf>,~ q,;r ~"ff ,,;,rrfisq -,\'.f:?~H ~q,"'T ~ ~~ Wf cfi ·;;,r4r tllTI51?' I~~~ c1jft'p '-'ll:ffl';T ~%T-ft :'fthf@ ofi'l r1w -~ ci1· ;:s~<)'; ~ m-~~ ftm ~ ~--:;'Tfrcfm, 1965 m f.ra., 1,4 'ir t~l'Ri1 mc1t1Fr i:r, 31:[·HR vlfcl' Q?..,. -crfA'l: ~ '31N ~ B"'R clx w'r 3,H'rq ~ 6R'r t clT '3~ ft<TI l~ t'r,t'.T ~r ~ <TT <RmttT ct,-;r ~,ff ~ I fq:;-m' '+ft 1:l~ i'f ~ ocffi'ii 11{ ~;,.9ip 3'.fi~n Wil° arR ;?TTR-<'f ~ -wi,t vlT.fi ;;nfg-q I" 4. ~ 3~T c.fil' ~ ~~ ctl' ~ fco:luTI· ~ ~ ·f?-rffi,r t fu; ·-rife. , 3lR1fi\1[ 'mfc)~n~ ~-~ aWT iW:n:!T "ffi \ifffiT % v!T if,~ Cff.:f .nff i 'fil if1 >l~~'rrofi i'r <HZ-a'f~:n Bc),G"R 1ri'Rf 'i:tf£rci ~ v11qi:'t ot)x ~ ~mi '.l'cf,{lFr ·\:rnra ~-'r 1 3ITT1itr~ '>lfo1<rt ~ ~+iit:r ., x~~ ' . ~ . cf@ "3"H-TKclm ~~;:ii-~ ~1 -4 3TR&lUT qi'[ mH·<r,-ff ~ m ~]H!l'l\11 >fl~TPI ;}; 3~,ll 31'rx <TIGr,-ff <'m -~ qiz.'IT m,rr i 5. ~, ~ ~ er;) 'ff'm ~~ cp'\ -;:;rFf1ITT:tl it Q1f ~ '1fT'(; I 1. m'IB ~ m wt) :i:p;,ff~/~r I . ( ;::~:~, ... , ~· \ .. ~()1 ./ \ ~-... ..... ,,, _. .... .. ;.,_, __ .,.,./ (rli -~~ . ell=![} f.,·2;-~rcl'i 2. c:t,--rfiT<,f;, ~'lei; ~<nl<.@ ~ q~ .:j?[r~ ~j '<'1'1'11 ~i:!ITTl/31:'?:fflT <>i"'R "fr.-'n \91~;:j~· \rci ()T~R-ltf cfil<TT~ I 3. ~ ci>i-4· fcl'.wT (~ ~. ~ ~ I 4 ◊~ ffl f<l1:rr1 (<TTl=fl ~11[11). ~· ~ ! 5, ~ ~ fcr::rr1, '9""~ R <:"~ I 6 ~ts!'rtl 7. ~ #i-q; ~ ;mmrr/'lfi«l cpT ""er.rm ,~:rritro'r.:i/f'1<1licfii ;mzi'r1/Ql]cf> ·ffi:rr ~,ftftlf,~'ll/ ,rr:,'<l· ~TT 11ftrcfRif'l! /4f·:,1tt~ 'l:f~<li<.•Vlf~P~ '(,c-f'ch-ctT _ (~fn:rl-<T/x~ x'lf~EiT~,~ /J;f\:fl"f :s:f::,fr • ~.i:i/~-'IT am I s. ~~-mmrr, '(f):~.311. ~- ("]tfl m. ~ ~~ 1 \ ,-wnfGrc.o "l+!'<'.f afR' mrmm -~~ra, ~'1R0.-lt qrcA, -r.{ lr-;("Al 1 xtt\ifrll ~Tuft@ ;:;nm G'fflfr1, ~'fq;-;m:fcp ~'fcl"i, ~ t~z~~- I ·, 1. ~•.T ~~ ·;,r~ GWWT; ~r~cf; 'l'fcF\·, .rt f~ 1. i 2 ~ ~ mhmmrr, ~-1, 'li'f<m:GTJ' 'qf!T-TT ~, ~x:ir. W11, ~ fe;;~ I 13. 'lTT«'f -in t;i .. t?tc!Y .(I.ITT' •®~ ~g; ·q;-r cf>rmi.>flf, 1 o or~Tffi' ~ .,pi, .:nf f~-~t ! ~-~ · 14. ~ w~~ ~x'i, ~ :&m"';;'x ~Tff?Tl' ~ Wffi'fA 0fiFfqTl1. ~m;:,rzr 11ftr~f1J'1 ~~-n >toi~ ~~'1. -~ i:f'll'i:i ffl 6!'tt, ~m·~fqqrazr· ~<fiK"flr, 'lJ'f. +Bft.._,,~· :f"<:l<rr&m 1 i l1, \(1'.AT ~ ~fcrarr ~, q5Wfc'fi stR >{fQWi\'tlf fcMTrT, ;"Hl.?t ~T'cµ, ~ fe;·Q'~ I .

All of The Chhattisgarh Lok Seva (ST, SC and OBC) Reservation Act, 1994