Rule 33, The Karnataka Planning Authority Rules, 1965.: Publication of Outline Development Plan and Regulations under Section 13(4)
The Karnataka Planning Authority Rules, 1965. - Rule 33
Text of rule 33
Publication of Outline Development Plan and Regulations under Section 13(4)
33. Publication of Outline Development Plan and Regulations under Section
13(4).- The Outline Development Plan and the Regulations as approved by the State
Government under sub-section (3) of Section 13 shall be published in the Official
Gazette.
CASE LAW
Rule 33 and Section 13(4) – Publication of notice would be sufficient
compliance with Section 13(4) and Rule 33 Outline Development Plan and Regulation
need not be bodily incorporated – Defect, any, curable by Section 76-J.
Section 13(4) has prescribed the mode of publication of the Outline
Development Plan and the Regulations. The ‘prescribed manner’ is what is prescribed
by Rule 33, that is, publication in the official Gazette. In Sections 9(1) and 9(2) too
the Outline Development Plan is required to be published in the prescribed manner.
The prescribed manner for the purposes of Section 9(1) and 9(2) is that prescribed by
rule 32. If the entire scheme of the act and the rules is considered as an integral whole
it becomes obvious that what Section 13(4) contemplates besides permanently
displaying the plan and the particulars and keeping available a copy for the inspection
of the public is a public notice to the general public that the plan and Regulations are
permanently displayed and are available for inspection by the public. Such public
notice is required to be given by a publication in the official Gazette. This appears to
be a reasonable and a rational interpretation on Section 13(4) and Rule 33 in the
setting and the scheme. Every one concerned, thought that publication of a notice in
the Gazette inviting the attention of the public to the display and the availability for
inspection of the plan and particulars was all that was contemplated by the provisions
providing for publication. There is no reason or justification to adopt an interpretation
which departs from common understanding of the Act and the Rules. A defective
publication which has otherwise served its purpose is not sufficient to render illegal
what is published and that such defect is cured by Section 76-J. Non-publication of
the plan in the official Gazette was therefore a curable defect capable of being cured
by Section 76-J.
Section 13(4) used the words “the Outline Development Plan and the
Regulations” as well as the words”, the plan and the Regulations”. The Outline
Development Plan and the Regulations are not distinct from each other. The
Regulations are born out of the plan and the plan thrives on the Regulations. The plan
is the basis for the Regulations and the Regulations are what make the plan effective,
without the Regulations, the plan virtually becomes a dead letter. The reference in the
four clauses of Section 13, whenever the word “plan” or the “Outline Development
Plan” is used, is to the core plan without the particulars and the Regulations and not
the whole of the Outline Development Plan which must include the Regulations.
What the different phraseology is meant to convey is to emphasise the different parts
of the plan which have to be forwarded to the Government, considered by the
Government, made available for inspection by the public, as the case may be and to
the extent necessary. Merely because the words “and Regulations” are added to the
word “plan”, the Regulations are not to be treated as not constituting part of the plan.
The authority justifiable always treated the plan as including the Regulations and what
was kept for inspection was the plan along with Regulations. rel. on 1990(4) SCC 178
– B.K. Srinivasan and Others Vs State of Karnataka and Others, (1987)1 SCC 658 :
AIR 1987 SC 1059.
Previous and next
← Rule 16Members not to vote on matters in which they are interestedRule 17 →Adjournment of meetings
All provisions of The Karnataka Planning Authority Rules, 1965.
Questions people ask
Is rule 33 of the Karnataka Planning Authority Rules, 1965. still in force?
No repeal of the Karnataka Planning Authority Rules, 1965. is recorded.