Form 19, Regulations for the Navy: FORM No. 19
Regulations for the Navy - Form 19
Text of form 19
FORM No. 19
FORM No. 19
MINUTES OF PROCEEDINGS
(See Regulation 190)
(Note: The minutes should be recorded in the following form as far as possible
with such variations as are necessitated by the circumstances of each case.)
Minutes of proceedings at a court-martial held on board I. N. S.--------------------
on shore at--------------------------------) at---------------------------------------------on--
-------------------day of-----------------------or the trial of---------------------------------
of I.N.S.--------------------------------
Officers summoned to sit on court-martial:-
Captain A. B. C., I. N. S. “ “ “ President
Commander D.E.F., I.N.S “ “ “ Member
Commander G.H.I., I.N.S. “ “ “ Member
Commander J.K.L., I.N.S. “ “ “ Member
Lt. Cdr. M.N.O., I. N. S “ “ “ Member
Lt. Cdr. P. Q. R., I. N. S. “ “ Spare member
Lt. Cdr. S. T. U., I. N. S. “ “ Spare Member
The court as finally constituted:-
Captain A.B.C., I. N. S. “ “ “ President
Commander, D.E.F., I. N. S. “ “ “ Member
Lieut. Cdr. P. Q. R., I. N. S. “ “ “ Member
Mr ……………………………, Trial Judge Advocate
Officer of the court…………………………………….
The President declared the court open at 0902.
The accused………………….of I. N. S……………..was brought in
by…………………………….Provost Marshal.
Mr………………………..Advocate appeared in court to assist the
accused.
The Prosecutor, Commander ………………………of I. N.
S……………………….. and the audience admitted.
The trial judge advocate read out the warrant for assembling the court and
the names officers exempted from attending under sub-section (20)of section 97
of the Navy Act, 1957 together with the reasons for such exemption. (here insert
the court-martial warrant and the list of officers forwarded by the convening
authority to the President) (From ).
The trial Judge Advocate read out the names of the officers composing
the court.
The Prosecutor on being asked whether he objected to any member of the
court stated that he had no objection.
The accused on being asked whether he objected to any member of the
court stated that he objected to Lieutenant Commander, M. N. O. on the ground
that he had previously sat on a Board of Inquiry held to investigate the incident
from which the court-martial had arisen. He also stated that he had no objection
to the other member of the court.
The court was cleared to consider the objection.
On re-opening the trial Judge Advocate announced that the court has
upheld the objection. Lieutenant-Commander M.N.O. withdrew and Lieutenant –
Commander P.Q.R. took his seat as member of the court.
The Prosecutor on being asked whether he objected to court as now
constituted stated that he had no objection.
The accused on being asked whether he had any further objection
respecting the constitution of the court stated that he had no objection.
The President and members of the court and the trial Judge Advocate were
then duly sworn.
The accused on being asked whether he objected to
Mr………………………..as Shorthand writer stated that he had no
objection……………………………………was duly sworn to act as Shorthand
Writer.
The trial Judge Advocate read the first charge to the accused and asked
him whether he pleaded guilty or not guilty.
The accused pleaded guilty.
The trial Judge Advocate then explains to the accused the precise meaning
of the charge in the following words and pointed out the difference in procedure
which would result from the plea of guilty.
………………………………………
………………………………………….
The trial Judge Advocate considered that the accused should not plead
guilty and he advised him to withdraw his plea. The accused withdrew his plea.
The Prosecutor opened his case by reading the circumstantial letter and
addressed the court further as follows (here insert the circumstantial letter and a
record of the Prosecutor’s opening speech); -
(NOTE:- The evidence of each witness should commence on a fresh page.
The questions and answers must be numbered serially throughout.)
Lieutenant of I. N. S. was Called, sworn and examined by the prosecutor.
Examination-in-Chief
1. Q. Are you Lieutenant of I. N. S.?
A. Yes.
2. Q. What are your duties in the ship?
A. I am the Supply Officer
3. Q. Do you know the accused by sight?
A. Yes. He is sitting over there (witness here pointed at the accused).
4. Q. Have you examined the books of your ship? Do you find that the accused
is borne on these books
A. Yes.
5 Q. Were you on the quarterdeck of I. N. S. about 0900-0n
Ist January
19 ?
A I was
6. Q. Please tell the court what happened about that time?
A. I was standing at the starboard side on the quarter deck. Then Petty
Officer A and the Accused came on board I thought
that he…………………..
By trial Judge Advocate
7 Q. You must not tell the court what you thought. Please try to confine your
evidence to describing what actually happened.
Witness : The accused went up to the officer of the Watch.
8. Q.
A.
9. Q.
A.
Cross-examined by Defence counsel
10. Q.
A.
11. Q
Re-examined by prosecutor
12. Q.
A.
13. Q.
A.
Examined by Court
14. Q.
A.
15. Q.
A.
Examined by trial Judge Advocate
16. Q.
A.
17. Q.
A.
Witness withdrew.
Second witness:- Lieutenant called, sworn and examined by the Prosecutor.
18. Q. Are you Lieutenant of I. N. S. ?
A. Yes.
19. Q. What were your duties on day of 19 ?
A. I was Officer of the Watch.
20. Q. Do you recognize the accused?
A. Yes.
21. Q. Was he brought before you on ?
A. Yes.
22. Q. Why was he brought before you?
A. It was reported that he struck Petty Officer.
23. Q. In the course of your investigation did you question the accused?
A. Yes.
24.. Q. Before questioning him, did you give him any caution?
A. Yes. I warned him as follows:-
………………………………………………..
…………………………………………………
25. Q. What was his reply?
A. The Defence counsel objected to this question as being inadmissible. The trial
judge advocate considered it desirable that arguments and evidence as to the
admissibility of the evidnce sought to be adduced by the prosecutor should not
be heard in the presence of the court. He thereupon so advised the President
of the Court.
The President:- I consider that it would be convenient for the court to retire:
The President and members of the court then left the court room.
The counsel for the accused stated that the question asked was for the purpose
of eliciting the alleged confession of the accused. He objected to the
confession being admired, as it was not free and voluntary. The trial judge
advocate informed the prosecutor that he must adduce evidence in the first
instance to show that the statement was free and voluntary.
224. Naval-18
Examination by the Prosecutor
26. Q.
A.
Cross-examination by defence counsel
26. Q.
A.
Examination by trial judge advocate
27. Q.
A.
The trial judge advocate held that the confession was not admissible.
The court re-assembled.
By trial Judge Advocate : I have disallowed he question. Prosecutor will
continue his examination-in-Chief.
Examination by Prosecutor
29. Q.
A.
Cross-examined by defence counsel
30. Q.
A.
Re-examined by Prosecutor
31. Q.
A.
Witness withdrew.
Examined by trial judge advocate
32. Q.
A.
The evidence of other witnesses is to be recorded in similar form.
Prosecution closes its case.
The trial judge advocate to the accused
You may give evidence as witness on you own behalf. Should you desire to do
so, your should make a request in writing to do so but you must remember that you will
thereby render yourself liable to cross-examination. If you do not wish to give evidence,
you may make a statement as to the facts of the case.
The defence counsel submitted that the accused wished to give evidence on oath
and he accordingly submitted an application duly signed by him and the accused. (Here
insert the application)
The accused-sworn and examined by defence counsel
Examination – in - Chief
34. Q.
A.
Cross-examined by Prosecutor
35. Q.
A.
Re-examined by defence counsel
36. Q.
A.
Examined by court
37. Q.
A.
Examined by trial judge advocate
The accused had no other witness (If the accused has witnesses, they are to be
examined here. Thereafter, the accused friend must sum up the case and
prosecutor must reply.)
The Prosecutor summed up the case as follows:-
……………………………………………………………………
The Defence Counsel replied as follows.
……………………………………………………………………..
The trial judge advocate proceeded to sum up the case as follows:-
…………………………………………………………………….
The court cleared for the finding
The court re-assembled at at on 19
Trial judge advocate to the court:
38. Q. Mr. President, Sir, what is the finding of the court on the first charge.
39. Q. What is the finding of the court on the second charge?
A.
The trial judge advocate then drew up the finding.
The defence counsel made a submission in mitigation of punishment.
The defence counsel called as witness to give evidence of
general character.
Q.
A.
First examined by prosecutor.
Re-examined by accused
Examination by defence counsel
Examination by court
Examination by trial judge advocate
The trial judge advocate read the entries against the accused in the
Conduct On re-opening the President directed the trial judge advocate to
pronounce the sentence.
The trial judge advocate pronounced the sentence as drawn up by the
court
The President ordered the accused to be removed and dissolved the court.
Previous and next
Questions people ask
Is form 19 of Regulations for the Navy still in force?
No repeal of Regulations for the Navy is recorded.