LawGrids logoLAWGRIDS.ORG

11. Adjudication Order: Rules 100 and 142 of the CGST Rules provide for issuance of an adjudication order alon

Paragraph 11 - Circular No. 258/04/2026-GST

Text of this paragraph

11. Adjudication Order: Rules 100 and 142 of the CGST Rules provide for issuance of an adjudication order along with the summary to be uploaded electronically in FORM GST DRC-07 on the portal. In view of the statutory requirement, due care must be taken to ensure that the summary is issued along with the order and uploaded electronically on the portal in FORM GST DRC-07. 11.1. Drafting of the Adjudication Order: The process of adjudication necessitates the issuance of a "speaking order", that is, an order which clearly articulates its rationale and is expected to withstand scrutiny on grounds of legality, fairness, and reasonableness at higher appellate forums. Various judicial pronouncements have categorically emphasized the need for all adjudicating authorities to issue well-drafted, structured, and reasoned orders, as such orders form the foundation of fairness, transparency, and judicial credibility in the tax administration. Page 9 of 18 Judgement of the Apex Court in the case of Joint Commissioner of Income Tax, Surat vs Saheli Leasing & Industries Ltd., 2010 (253) E.L.T. 705 (S.C.) is reproduced below for ready reference: “…..7. These guidelines are only illustrative in nature, not exhaustive and can further be elaborated looking to the need and requirement of a given case :- (a) It should always be kept in mind that nothing should be written in the judgment/order, which may not be germane to the facts of the case; It should have a co-relation with the applicable law and facts. The ratio decidendi should be clearly spelt out from the judgment/order. (b) After preparing the draft, it is necessary to go through the same to find out, if anything, essential to be mentioned, has escaped discussion. (c) The ultimate finished judgment/order should have sustained chronology, regard being had to the concept that it has readable, continued interest and one does not feel like parting or leaving it in the midway. To elaborate, it should have flow and perfect sequence of events, which would continue to generate interest in the reader. (d) Appropriate care should be taken not to load it with all legal knowledge on the subject as citation of too many judgments creates more confusion rather than clarity. The foremost requirement is that leading judgments should be mentioned and the evolution that has taken place ever since the same were pronounced and thereafter, latest judgment, in which all previous judgments have been considered, should be mentioned. While writing judgment, psychology of the reader has also to be borne in mind, for the perception on that score is imperative. (e) Language should not be rhetoric and should not reflect a contrived effort on the part of the author.” (f) After arguments are concluded, an endeavour should be made to pronounce the judgment at the earliest and in any case not beyond a period of three months. Keeping it pending for long time, sends a wrong signal to the litigants and the society….” 11.2. The introductory part of adjudication order should include details of the issuing authority, relevant statutory provisions, taxpayer's appellate rights, designated appellate forum, and pre-deposit conditions for appeals. It should begin with a concise summary of facts covering taxpayer details, SCN particulars, tax period(s) involved, proposed demand, interest, penalty, source and grounds of proceedings, along with all multiple noticees listed separately for clarity and context. Page 10 of 18 11.3. The discussion of issues to be decided should clearly set out and elaborate upon all the issues that require determination, specifying the questions of law and fact that need to be decided. 11.4. Examination of evidences vis-à-vis allegations: The Adjudicating Authority should undertake a careful and reasoned examination of evidences with reference to the allegation(s) in the SCN. Mere reference to documents or reproduction of their contents is not sufficient, the authority should endeavour to analyse them critically, highlighting their relevance and reliability. Wherever the documents do not support the allegation or are inconclusive, the Adjudicating Authority may record the same in its finding with reasons. 11.5. Consideration of submission/ defence and additional evidences submitted by the taxpayer: Each adjudication order should independently examine the submissions made by the taxpayer through FORM GST DRC-06 or during personal hearing(s). The order should clearly record findings on the relevance, credibility, and evidentiary value of the materials submitted, specifying whether they have been accepted, partially accepted, or rejected along with reasons for each conclusion. Care should be taken to avoid generic expressions such as “reply has been considered”. 11.6. Upholding procedural fairness and due process: Section 75(7) of the CGST Act provides that the amount of tax, interest and penalty determined in the order shall not be in excess of the amount specified in the notice and no demand shall be confirmed on the grounds other than the grounds specified in the notice. Therefore, the Adjudicating Authorities should limit their findings to the allegations and grounds mentioned in the SCN. Any new issue identified may be pursued through a separate SCN. 11.7. Discussion of case laws cited by department as well as taxpayer: While referring to judgments of higher judicial forums, accuracy of citations and their relevance to the case should be ensured, and the relevant extracts thereof may be reproduced. The authenticity of the source as well as the current legal status of these judgments should be verified to ensure that these have not been overruled by a higher judicial forum. Preference may be given to the decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court and jurisdictional High Courts, for balanced, defensible outcomes. Further, judgments cited by the noticee should be duly considered and discussed. In Page 11 of 18 case the said judgement is not found to be applicable to the matter under consideration, reasons for the same must be recorded in the order. 11.7.1. Wherever, Artificial Intelligence (AI) or other technological tools are utilized to enhance the efficiency and effectiveness in adjudication proceedings, such use must be accompanied by appropriate human oversight as AI tools are not always reliable due to concerns regarding their accuracy, transparency, and the unknown nature of underlying information. The information obtained through AI tools should be independently verified for accuracy before reliance or incorporation into the adjudication order, as the ultimate responsibility for the correctness of the order lies with the issuing authority irrespective of the technological tools used by the officer. 11.8. Discussions and findings: This section should contain detailed analysis of each issue identified in the preceding section. The Adjudicating Authority should objectively evaluate the facts, evidences, and legal provisions relevant to each issue and record clear findings thereon. While arriving at conclusion, the Adjudicating Authority should correlate the findings with the allegations made in the SCN, the defense submissions of the noticee, the applicable statutory provisions, circulars, and judicial precedents. The findings should culminate in a logical determination of whether the charges are established or not, issue by issue, forming the foundation for the final order. 11.9. Quantification of tax amount, interest and penalty: The Adjudicating Authority should ensure that the tax demanded is re-calculated based on findings for each issue in the SCN and must not exceed the original amount proposed, as stipulated under section 75(7) of the CGST Act. The final order should contain a clear, accurate, and issue-wise quantification of the tax, interest applicability and penalty. It should not be left open-ended or estimated. 11.9.1. Interest on tax that has been short paid or not paid continues to accrue until the date of actual tax payment. The amount of interest as on the date of the adjudication order, wherever possible, may be quantified in the order, with a clear mention that interest shall be payable up to the date of actual payment. It is pertinent to note that section 75(9) of the CGST Act provides that interest on short-paid or unpaid tax is payable regardless of whether it is specifically mentioned in the order. Page 12 of 18 11.9.2. As far as possible, quantification should be presented financial year-wise and issue- wise, distinctly under CGST, SGST, IGST and UTGST. To improve clarity, all computations may be shown in a tabular format, indicating the period involved, issue or head of demand, tax amount determined, corresponding interest, penalty imposed, and any pre-deposits or payments made. 11.9.3. Whenever any part of the demand is dropped, either fully or partially, the order should specify both the original amount demanded and the amount confirmed after adjudication. If the taxpayer has already deposited any amount towards tax, interest, or penalty before the issuance of the order, such payments should be appropriated or adjusted clearly, and the balance payable or refundable should be clearly mentioned in the order. 11.10. Penalty justification for each taxpayer: The Adjudicating Authority should record clear and reasoned findings before imposing any penalty, it should not be levied mechanically but after establishing the nature of the default and the applicable legal provision. Adherence to the general discipline related to the penalty as provided under section 126 of the CGST Act should be ensured during the adjudication proceedings. 11.11. Conclusion: Adjudication order should conclude with a clear, concise, and reasoned closing paragraph summarizing the outcome of the proceedings. The quantum of tax, interest, and penalty confirmed or dropped, as the case may be, should be clearly specified, along with a clear reference to the specific legal provisions invoked while confirming or waiving such liabilities.
Circular No. 258/04/2026-GST dated 26-10-2026, para 11.

All of Circular No. 258/04/2026-GST