LawGrids logoLAWGRIDS.ORG

5. Justification for invoking tax demand on grounds of fraud, wilful misstatement, or suppression of facts: Se

Paragraph 5 - Circular No. 258/04/2026-GST

Text of this paragraph

5. Justification for invoking tax demand on grounds of fraud, wilful misstatement, or suppression of facts: Section 74(1) or section 74A(5)(ii) of the CGST Act provides for determination of tax liability where there is fraud or wilful misstatement or suppression of facts committed by the taxpayer to evade tax. Further, Explanation 2 to section 74A defines “suppression” as non‑declaration of facts or information required to be furnished in a return, statement, report or any other document, or failure to furnish information specifically called for in writing by the proper officer. 5.1. The notice should specifically disclose the basis for invoking the provisions relating to tax demand on grounds of fraud, wilful-misstatement, or suppression of facts. In this context, reference may be made to the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in G.R Infra Project Ltd. Vs State of Madhya Pradesh (2026) 45 Centax 331 (S.C) dated 19.08.2026, wherein the Hon’ble Court underscored that the notice itself must set out the specific allegations, material facts and circumstances forming the basis for such invocation, and that a mere mechanical reproduction of the expressions ‘fraud’, ‘wilful-misstatement’ or ‘suppression of facts’, without disclosing the material that led the proper officer to draw such inference, would not suffice. The relevant part of the judgement is as follows: “….10. A bare reading of the notice would indicate that but for a bland statement of 'fraud or concealment of facts' nothing is stated as to how fraud was inferred or concealment of facts were detected. In fact, the 'or' employed indicates that even the assessing officer was not sure that the assessment was proceeded by reason of fraud or on the ground of concealment of facts. What is required for the extended time to be applied are the allegations, which lead to the inference of a fraud or the concealment as attempted by the assessee resulting in suppression of facts, should emanate from the notice itself. It cannot be a mechanical use of the words 'fraud, willful misstatement or suppression of facts' without listing out the aspects which persuades the assessing officer to conclude that there has been employed either of these surreptitious devices by the assessee….” 5.2. The phrase “fraud or wilful misstatement or suppression of facts” inherently includes the element of intent to evade tax. Therefore, suppression or misstatement must be deliberate and aimed at avoiding or reducing tax liability, mere omission to furnish correct information does not amount to suppression unless it is intentional. When the facts are known to both Page 5 of 18 parties, an omission by one party does not constitute suppression. An incorrect statement is not automatically a wilful misstatement, the latter requires a conscious making of a false statement with knowledge of its inaccuracy. Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh in the case of Sriba Nirman Company vs Commissioner (Appeals)(2025) 29 Centax 206(A.P.) had an occasion to consider the expression “suppression”, “wilful-misstatement” and held that an incorrect statement, unless knowingly false, does not constitute wilful-misstatement or suppression and this view is also affirmed by the Hon’ble Apex court. The relevant extract from the judgement is reproduced below for ease of reference: “….22. Non-payment of tax, would attract penalties, under Section 74 (1), in three circumstances. The first two circumstances are fraud and wilful misstatement. Both these require an intention to evade tax by unfair or illegal means. The third circumstance is suppression of fact, which is also defined, in Explanation-2, as non- declaration of relevant information. In view of the collocation of the terms, before this term, and in view of the requirement, under the two earlier terms of mens rea, the term —suppression of facts" would have to be read as wilful or deliberate suppression of fact, for evading tax. The term —evade" puts this issue beyond controversy, as this term means that the suppression must be for the purpose of evasion, which clearly requires intention and mens rea…..” 5.3. In view of the above, it is noted that section 74(1) or section 74A(5)(ii) of the CGST Act cannot be invoked merely on the ground of non‑payment of GST without specific evidence of fraud or wilful-misstatement or suppression of facts with intent to evade tax. These provisions are also not intended to be applied in scrutiny cases solely because a discrepancy has been noticed, as such proceedings are meant to examine the records and ascertain the nature of the issue, not to automatically presume fraud. Accordingly, these provisions may be invoked only where the investigation discloses material evidence of such conduct, which must also be clearly set out in the SCN. 5.4. Thus, the power to invoke fraud, wilful-misstatement, or suppression of facts for demand is conditional, hinging on proof of intent to evade tax, which is required to be clearly established in the SCN along with evidence. Page 6 of 18 5.5. Further, issuing a second SCN, after the first on the same facts and grounds for the subsequent period, invoking fraud, wilful-misstatement, or suppression of facts is generally not legally valid unless new and independent grounds exist, such as unreported clearances. To prevent legal complications, subsequent statements should typically be issued under sections 73 or 74A(5)(i) of the CGST Act after the first notice under section 74 or 74A(5)(ii) of the CGST Act.
Circular No. 258/04/2026-GST dated 26-10-2026, para 5.

All of Circular No. 258/04/2026-GST