LawGrids logoLAWGRIDS.ORG

4. Structure and drafting of SCN: To ensure clarity, structure, and completeness, a well- drafted SCN should i

Paragraph 4 - Circular No. 258/04/2026-GST

Text of this paragraph

4. Structure and drafting of SCN: To ensure clarity, structure, and completeness, a well- drafted SCN should ideally comprise the following parts, though it may vary from case to case: 4.1. Brief profile and introduction of the case: The SCN should clearly identify the essential particulars of the person to whom it is issued, including the name of the taxpayer/noticee, GSTIN or Temporary ID, trade or business name (if different), current GST registration status, registered principal place of business, jurisdictional details (range, division, commissionerate), and the relevant tax period(s) covered by the proposed demand or contravention. In cases involving multiple noticees, the particulars of each must be stated separately. This section should also briefly outline the background for initiation of the proceedings such as through assessment, audit, return scrutiny, or enforcement, along with the nature of the verification, investigation, or audit concerned. This requirement is supported by various judicial pronouncements, including the Hon’ble Telangana High Court judgment in M/s Nice Enterprises v. Deputy Commissioner ST [(2024) 21 Centax 554 (Telangana)], wherein it was held that an SCN merely reproducing statutory provisions without specifying the grounds or sufficient factual particulars violates natural justice, and that the notice must furnish adequate grounds and elementary details to enable the assessee to understand the case and file an effective reply. 4.2. Factual background and examination of documents and evidences: In this part of SCN, the acts of omission and commission by the noticee, leading to the proceedings, should be precisely outlined in an objective manner. As evidences form the foundation of the SCN, they should be examined and discussed objectively to identify and highlight discrepancies, omissions, or irregularities that substantiate the alleged contraventions. The SCN may also discuss corroborative evidence where relevant, using neutral expressions such as “it appears that” to maintain fairness and objectivity, avoiding terms such as "determined" or categorical conclusions that suggest a pre-judged outcome as the notice seeks an explanation from the noticee, and is not a final determination or verdict. Page 3 of 18 4.3. Discussion and legal framework: The SCN should clearly specify the legal provisions allegedly contravened, along with a clear explanation linking each omission or commission by the noticee to the violation. Care should be taken to invoke pertinent provisions, avoiding the simultaneous inclusion of unrelated sections unless each independently applies. In cases involving multiple noticees, the SCN should clearly delineate the role and involvement of each individual, so that charges are fact-based, supported by evidence and individually attributable, thereby upholding principles of natural justice and ensuring a fair and credible adjudication process. 4.4. Statement of charges: SCN should contain a concise summary of the allegations against the noticees and clearly state the grounds on which they are required to explain why action, as per statutory provisions, should not be initiated against them. The importance of ensuring that the SCN itself contains all requisite particulars and grounds is reinforced by the settled legal position in this regard. In this context, reference is invited to the judgement of Hon’ble Supreme Court in G.R Infra Project Ltd. Vs State of Madhya Pradesh (2026) 45 Centax 331 (S.C) dated 19.08.2026, wherein, it was held that the requirements necessary to sustain the validity of an alleged notice or order must be contained therein and any deficiency in the SCN, including non-application of mind or failure to meet the requisite requirements, cannot subsequently be cured or remedied. 4.5. Quantification of Demand: Where the SCN proposes demand, the same should be quantified and the basis for the said demand may also be clearly specified. In case of notices which span across multiple financial years, efforts should be made to demarcate the demand financial year wise. Further, where the determination of interest depends upon the discharge of demand by the noticee i.e. actual date of payment of tax, a suitable phrase like “why interest as applicable should not be demanded” may be mentioned in the notice for demanding the interest component on the tax demanded. 4.6. The concluding paragraph of an SCN should clearly specify the Adjudicating Authority, submission deadline for the reply, and consequences of non-compliance. This paragraph ensures clarity on procedural expectations and underscores the consequences of non- compliance, helping to conclude the SCN effectively. Page 4 of 18
Circular No. 258/04/2026-GST dated 26-10-2026, para 4.

All of Circular No. 258/04/2026-GST