Regulation 45, Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable) Services Standards of Quality of Service and Consumer Protection (Addressable Systems) Regulations, 2017.: Repeal and Saving
Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable) Services Standards of Quality of Service and Consumer Protection (Addressable Systems) Regulations, 2017. - Regulation 45
Text of regulation 45
Repeal and Saving
45. Repeal and Saving.— (1) The Direct to Home Broadcasting Services (Standards of
Quality of Service and Redressal of Grievances) Regulations, 2007 (8 of 2007), the Standards
of Quality of Service (Digital Addressable Cable TV Systems) Regulations, 2012 (12 of
2012) and the Consumer Complaint Redressal (Digital Addressable Cable TV Systems)
Regulations, 2012 (13 of 2012) along with all their amendments and directions issued
thereunder are hereby repealed:
Provided that such repeal shall not affect-
(a) the previous operation of the repealed regulations or anything done or
any action taken under the repealed regulations; or
Page 40 of 67
(b) any right, privilege, obligation or liability acquired, accrued or incurred
under the regulations so repealed; or
(c) any penalty, forfeiture or punishment incurred in respect of any offence
committed against the regulations so repealed; or
(d) any investigation, legal proceeding or remedy in respect of any such
right, privilege , obligation, liability, penalty, forfeiture or punishment as
aforesaid and any such investigation, legal proceeding or remedy may be
instituted, continued or enforced, and any such penalty, forfeiture and
punishment may be imposed, as if the aforesaid regulations had not been
repealed.
(2) The existing facilities of customer care centre, website, web based complaint management
system, subscriber management system and addressable system set up by a distributor of
television channels, wherever applicable, shall be deemed to have been set up under these
regulations provided that such facilities comply with the provisions of these regulations.
(3) Nothing contained in these regulations shall affect any packs, plans or bouquets
subscribed by an existing subscriber before the date of commencement of these regulations:
Provided that no such packs, plans or bouquets shall be valid beyond a period of one
hundred and eighty days from the date of publication of these regulations in the
Official Gazette and it shall be mandatory for all distributors of television channels to
either discontinue or modify all their existing packs, plans or bouquets in compliance
with the provisions of these regulations within such period.
(Sudhir Gupta)
Secretary,TRAI
Note.— The Explanatory Memorandum explains the objects and reasons of the
Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable) Services Standards of Quality of Service and
Consumer Protection (Addressable Systems) Regulations, 2017.
Page 41 of 67
SCHEDULE – I
(under sub-regulation (5) of regulation 3)
CONSUMER APPLICATION FORM
The consumer application form may be devised in Hindi, English and the regional language
of the area of operation of the distributor of television channels or its linked local cable
operator, as the case may be, and shall contain the following information-
Part A: Consumer information
1. Name
2. Address
3. Contact Numbers (Mobile/ landline)
4. E-mail (optional)
5. Aadhaar Number (Optional)
Part B: Service Subscription related information
6. Details of service subscribed:
(a) name of a-la-carte pay channels/bouquets of pay channels and their distributor retail
prices
(b) bouquets of FTA channels
(c) lock in period, if any
7. Network capacity fee—
(a) for up to100 SD channels
(b) additional channel capacity in the slab of 25 SD channels each
8. Mode of payment (pre-paid or post paid)
9. Subscription amount to be paid (monthly/half yearly/yearly/etc.)
Part C: CPE related information
10. Scheme opted (Outright purchase/rental/other schemes )
11. Monthly rental for CPE if it is under rental scheme
12. Refundable security deposit for CPE if any
13. Retail price of CPE if it is under outright purchase scheme/other scheme
Page 42 of 67
14. VC number
15. Type of set top box (MPEG2/MPEG4)
16. Guarantee/Warrantee/AMC details
Part D: Customer care centre related information
17. Toll free customer care centre number
18. Any other customer care centre numbers
19. Customer care centre e-mail
Part E: Distributor of television channel/Local Cable Operator related information
20. Name of the distributor of television channels/LCO
21. Address
22. Contact numbers
23. Website
Part F: Details of payment made
24. Total Amount paid
25. Refundable security deposit, if applicable
26. Monthly rental for CPE and period of rent if applicable
27. Retail price of CPE in case of outright purchase scheme or other scheme
28. Installation charges
29. Activation fee
(Note: In case of printed CAF, Part D, Part E and Part F may be provided in the form of
detachable acknowledgement receipt.)
Page 43 of 67
SCHEDULE – II
(under sub-regulation (3) of regulation 31)
CONSUMER CORNER
The Consumer Corner web page shall contain the following information including but not
limited to:
1. List of channels and bouquets available on the platform
(a) FTA channels
(b) Pay channels and their MRP and distributor retail price
(c) List of bouquets of FTA channels and their composition
(d) List of bouquets of pay channels formed by broadcaster with composition and their
respective MRP and distributor retail price
(e) List of bouquets of pay channels formed by the distributor with composition and
their distributor retail price
(f) Details of lock in period, if any, in respect of a-la-carte channel or bouquets,
2. Details of network capacity fee
(a) Network capacity fee of 100 SD channels
(b) Network capacity fee for additional capacity of 25 SD channels
(c) Composition of basic service tier of 100 SD FTA channel,
3. Subscription process for subscribing channels on a-la-carte basis
Details of the provisions made by the distributor of television channels for enabling a-
la-carte subscription of channels such as website, customer care centre, mobile apps etc
are to be provided,
4. CPE Schemes: Scheme type, CPE price, and other terms and conditions
a) Outright purchase scheme
- Price
- Guarantee/ Warranty term
- Maintenance provisions of CPE, AMC etc.
b) Rental scheme
- Rental amount
- Security deposit, if any
Page 44 of 67
- Other terms and conditions
c) Other Schemes
- Details of the scheme
- Other terms and conditions
- Price of CPE
- Price of channels and bouquets included in the scheme bundled with CPE
- Network capacity fee bundled with CPE,
5. Procedure for obtaining a new service connection and timelines,
6. Provisions for temporary discontinuation of services and details of restoration fee and
reactivation fee, if applicable,
7. Provision for relocation of connection and applicable charges,
8. Complaint redressal process:
a) Through customer care centre
b) Through Nodal Officer
c) Through Web based management System,
9. Consumer Agreement Form (CAF),
10. Manual of Practice,
11. Toll free number of customer care centre and other contact details,
12. Availability of customer care programming service with its LCN,
13. Any other information relevant for the consumers.
Page 45 of 67
SCHEDULE – III
(under sub-regulation (4) of regulation 31)
SUBSCRIBER CORNER
The Subscriber Corner shall contain the following features and information, but not limited
to:
1. Login access to the subscriber,
2. Subscriber information: Name, address, registered phone, email, Aadhar no. etc.,
3. Details of subscribed services, channels, bouquets, validity, lock in period (if any),
4. Details of selected CPE scheme,
5. Details of AMC scheme selected, if any,
6. Billing details /billing cycle/Account balance/ Dues,
7. Usage details for last six months/ provision for printing,
8. Bill Payment guidelines,
9. Payment details for last six months,
10. Complaint registering and status monitoring,
11. Completed CAF access/reprint,
12. Toll free number of customer care centre and other contact details,
13. Any other relevant information.
Page 46 of 67
SCHEDULE – IV
(under regulation 37)
MANUAL OF PRACTICE
Manual of Practice should contain the following:-
1. Name and address of the distributors of television channel,
2. Terms and conditions of service offered by the distributor of television channel,
3. Name, designation and e-mail, contact telephone number, facsimile number and address
of the Nodal Officer,
4. Details of provisions for consumer protection as specified in these regulations:-
(a) disruption in service
(b) price protection for advance subscription payment
(c) temporary discontinuation of service
(d) disconnection of services
(e) terms and conditions for billing and payment,
5. Procedure and benchmark for complaint redressal,
6. Any other relevant information.
Page 47 of 67
EXPLANATORY MEMORANDUM
1. The Broadcasting and Cable Services came under the regulatory ambit of TRAI on
01.09.2004. TRAI is vested with the responsibility of ensuring orderly growth of the
broadcasting sector while protecting the interests of the consumers. The Authority has
undertaken several measures in this regard and issued Quality of Service (QoS)
regulations for different delivery platforms such as Cable TV, DTH, etc in the past. The
first QoS regulation was issued on 23rd August, 2006 to regulate the quality of service of
cable television services in the Conditional Access Systems (CAS) areas. Subsequently,
QoS regulations for DTH services were issued in 2007. Similar regulations were issued
for cable TV services in non-CAS areas in 2009, followed by QoS regulations for
addressable Cable TV service in 2012. A separate regulation for consumer grievance
redressal mechanism for addressable cable TV systems was also issued in 2012. In
addition, some QoS issues were also addressed through tariff orders, interconnection
regulations and directions, issued by the Authority from time to time.
2. The broadcasting sector has now achieved significant level of digitization and it is
expected that digitization would be completed by March 2017. Thereafter, broadcasting
services will be delivered by different delivery platforms to the consumers through only
addressable systems. In such scenario, ICTs can be used as an effective tool in enhancing
the quality of services by enabling provisions such as subscription through electronic
means, electronic billing and payment, web enabled online complaint and redressal
mechanism, electronic CAF etc. Therefore, there is a need to provide a comprehensive
uniform QoS regulations for different delivery platforms in addressable environment for
healthy competition, transparency and growth with provision of good quality of services
to the consumers. Accordingly, the Authority decided to go in for a consultation process
before laying down benchmarks for quality of service standards for addressable systems.
3. The prime objective of the consultation was to harmonise the existing QoS regulations
issued by TRAI from time to time and to formulate a unified regulatory framework for
different platforms. It is expected to result in better awareness about the regulatory
provisions amongst the consumers while improving the compliance and monitoring of
the new regulatory framework. The consultation also laid emphasis on various measures
Page 48 of 67
for consumer protection. Another thrust area was ensuring adequate publicity of the
schemes and services offered by distribution platform operators (DPOs) for improving
consumer awareness to enable them in making informed choices.
4. The consultation paper was issued on 18th May 2016 inviting comments from the
stakeholders. A total of 29 comments and 2 counter comments were received. An open
house discussion was held on the 28th July 2016 at New Delhi. Based upon the analysis
of the comments and counter comments, draft regulations were put on TRAI website on
10th October, 2016 seeking specific comments from stakeholders. In response, 48
comments have been received from the stakeholders. These comments have been
analysed and the paragraphs hereunder briefly summarize the analysis and set out the
basis and rationale for the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable) Services
Standards of Quality of Service and Consumer Protection (Addressable Systems)
Regulations, 2016.
5. In the consultation paper, comments of the stakeholders were sought on the broad nature
of regulatory framework required in the evolving broadcasting scenario and on the need
of a common framework for different platforms. Majority of the DPOs have shown
preference for a self regulatory regime, whereas few broadcasters and consumer
organisations have suggested for regulated framework. A large number of DPOs are
providing services in different areas of the country catering to varying subscriber base
from few thousand to millions. In some areas only a single DPO is providing services to
a small subscriber base. In such scenario self-regulatory mechanism may not be an
effective approach. It is observed that consumer choice is still not being fully enabled
even in areas where digitization has completed and therefore regulatory oversight
appears necessary. An oversight mechanism by regulator would enable DPOs to create
standardized infrastructure for providing better quality of services to the consumers. The
Authority is therefore of the view that regulated framework shall be the appropriate
model for ensuring QoS and consumer protection in the broadcasting sector.
6. On the issue of having a uniform QoS regulatory framework for addressable platforms,
majority of the stakeholders have supported this requirement. However, some DPOs
oppose it stating that various DPOs work on different business models. The present
Page 49 of 67
regulatory framework caters to specific distribution platforms and it was aimed to
address prevalent issues at that time. Different QoS regulations make it difficult to create
awareness amongst consumers. From the consumer’s point of view, uniformity in the
QoS provisions would lead to improved consumer awareness as all DPOs will
disseminate information based on common QoS framework. Accordingly, the Authority
is of the view that a uniform regulatory framework for QoS shall be adopted with some
platform specific provisions, as may be, required keeping in view the nature of such
platform.
7. Provisions of TV Broadcasting services by the DPOs is the first step towards offering
services to consumers. In addressable systems, it is a prerequisite to set up a Subscriber
Management System (SMS) for managing subscriptions, management of services,
billing and payments. The SMS is to be integrated with a Conditional Access System to
provide encrypted signals to the subscribers. The SMS has to confirm to the provisions
and specifications as mandated in the applicable interconnection regulations and tariff
orders notified by the Authority from time to time.
8. In order to provide good quality of services to the consumers it is important that DPOs
have to ensure wide publicity of their offers and services for consumer awareness and
provide user friendly methods to consumers for submitting their requests through
multiple means for subscription to offered services. Consultation was held with the
stakeholders on various methods that can be useful for increasing the consumer
awareness. Stakeholders have suggested use of various means such as scrolls, short
messaging service, websites, advertisements across mass media, etc. Therefore, in
addition to customer care centre and website, other methods such as short messaging
service, email, mobile applications etc. may also be adopted by the DPOs for ease of
subscription.
9. The existing regulatory framework mandates that all channels on the DPO platform shall
be offered for a-la-carte subscription to consumers. This provision of regulation is an
important step towards enabling consumers’ choices. It has been observed that
sometimes DPOs put restrictive condition on a-la-carte subscription. For example, a
channel or bouquet can be subscribed only if an add on pack is also subscribed or it can
Page 50 of 67
be subscribed for certain specific period only. Such conditions defeat the intent of the
regulations and restrict the choices to the consumers. Therefore, in the draft regulations
it was proposed that all channels and bouquets available on DPOs platform shall be
compulsorily offered, without any condition, under monthly subscription schemes.
However keeping in view the business concerns of the DPOs, the DPOs may, in addition
to mandatory monthly schemes, offer the channels or bouquets under other schemes
which may have different lock in duration of subscription. A few stakeholders have
suggested that the provision is restrictive in nature as it may result in very frequent
change in subscriber choice. In the addressable system, the DPOs are free to offer
attractive services for shorter as well as longer durations as per their business concerns to
provide better choices to the consumers. Therefore, the provision is not restrictive.
Further, any change in the service once subscribed by the subscriber under monthly
scheme can take place only after a period of one month. The Authority is therefore of the
view that all channels and bouquets available on DPOs platform shall be compulsorily
offered, without any condition, under monthly subscription schemes.
10. The existing regulatory provision also provides six months protection to consumers with
regard to price and composition of the package subscribed by them. The need of this
provision in new MRP based framework was also consulted. The stakeholders have not
favoured continuation of the said provision. The new tariff regime is based on MRP of
channels to be declared by the broadcasters, therefore the retail tariff may not vary
arbitrarily. Further, in addressable systems, the consumers can subscribe, modify or
change their packages as per their requirements and the DPOs as per the business
requirements can also offer channels, packages with different subscription period options
e.g. on monthly, yearly basis etc. Therefore, the formation of offers and packages is
available to the DPOs, except that a monthly subscription scheme in respect of all
channels and bouquets available on DPO platform shall be mandatorily made available.
Sometimes DPOs offer attractive schemes with longer duration subscription lock in
periods for which subscribers are charged in advance. In order to protect the interest of
such subscribers, it would be justifiable if the price protection is given to the subscribers
of such schemes during the lock in period. Therefore, the Authority is of the view that
the price protection shall accordingly be limited to the period for which advance
Page 51 of 67
payment has been made by the subscribers, either under pre-paid or post-paid option,
with regard to their subscription.
11. It is important for the DPOs to declare and notify the details of terms and conditions of
their services offered to consumers, as specified in the regulation before offering such
services to consumers. Such details also need to be informed to the consumers at the
time of providing connection enabling them to take an informed decision. This
information has to be declared and notified by the DPOs through website, customer care
programming service, and other means for publicity to the consumers. The stakeholders
are in agreement with such provisions to be prescribed in the regulations.
12. Consultation was also done on standardization of information sought in the CAF and use
of electronic CAF. A few stakeholders have suggested that copy of CAF should be
allowed to be made available to the subscriber in electronic form also. Another DPO has
suggested that the CAF should be withdrawn as there are no security concerns in
subscription of TV services unlike in telecom services. It may be appreciated that CAF
constitutes the basic agreement between the subscriber and the DPO with regard to the
services being subscribed, therefore it is important that CAF is duly completed by a
subscriber and a copy is provided to him. Further the details captured in CAF are to be
registered on the SMS which is used to manage the services to the subscriber and also
for billing, payment and for determining the revenue flows along the value chain.
Therefore, the Authority is of the view that CAF is necessary for availing TV
broadcasting services from the DPOs and the services to a subscriber shall be activated
only after entering the details of relevant information obtained through CAF in the SMS.
13. DPO’s are handling millions of subscriber details which include their personal
information. Therefore, it is essential that this information should not be misused by
DPO’s in any manner. DPO’s shall ensure privacy and protection of subscribers’
personal information as per law and the same should not be used for any other purpose
except in context with provisioning of TV broadcasting services to the subscribers.
14. The process of providing a new connection was consulted with stakeholders. In the
existing regulations different timelines have been prescribed for this process depending
Page 52 of 67
on the type of platform, for example a provision of 4 days in cable and 5 days in DTH is
prescribed for providing a new connection. A few DPOs have stated that it should be
left to their discretion to devise their own timelines for providing a new connection.
While majority of DPOs have suggested timelines between 48 to 72 hrs for processing
the services request and 5-15 days for providing new connection. The broadcasters have
suggested that TRAI should formulate timelines for various stages for providing a new
connection. The Authority is of the view that timeline for providing a new connection
may vary depending upon the area where the connection is to be provided. While in
cities and urban areas it may be feasible for DPOs to provide connection quickly, in case
of remote areas it may take several days. Providing a new connection at the earliest is
also related to the business concerns of DPOs. The Authority is therefore of the view that
new connection shall be provided and activated by DPO’s within 7 days of receipt of
request from consumer subject to technical and operational feasibility. These timelines
are the upper ceilings and the DPOs are free to declare shorter timeline of less than 7
days which may be informed transparently to the consumers.
15. As per the existing regulatory framework for DTH sector, DTH operator may charge
installation charge and activation charge from the consumers at the time of providing a
new connection, subject to the ceiling prescribed in the Tariff Order. These charges were
prescribed by the Authority after a detailed consultation with the stakeholders and
obtaining inputs from the industry. The issue of installation charge and activation charge
is important in other platforms as well, where in absence of any ceilings, consumers are
being charged arbitrarily for installation and activation. In some cases, the activation fee
being charged for a STB is equal to the cost of the STB itself. It is also reported that
different installation and activation fees are being charged under different schemes for
provision of set top box. Further different activation fee is being levied for SD and HD
STB. There cannot be such difference in the installation and activation fees as per type
of scheme or type of STB, as the installation and activation process remains by and large
same.
16. Some DPOs have commented that installation and the activation charges are dynamic
and depend upon various factors including the geographical considerations. Therefore it
should not be regulated and left to the DPOs. The consumer groups on the other hand
Page 53 of 67
have opined that the Authority should consider lowering the prescribed ceiling for total
of installation & activation charges in the range of Rs. 200/- to Rs. 250/-. The present
ceilings for installation and activation charges were finalized in the TO after a due
consultation process and analysis of relevant data. An amount upto Rs.350/- towards the
installation charges and upto Rs.100/- towards the activation charge were permitted to be
charged from consumers in DTH sector. The Authority is of the view that in the interest
of consumers, these prescribed ceilings are required to be retained and applied uniformly
across all addressable platforms. DPOs are free to charge lesser installation and
activation fee if they so desire.
17. Once the services have been subscribed by a subscriber it should be open to him to
modify his subscription as per his preferences, subject to any specific terms and
conditions as might have been agreed to at the time of such subscription. At the same
time the DPOs should also not change the composition of his services without request of
the subscriber, unless it is due to conditions beyond their control. The Authority
therefore prescribes that DPOs shall activate the channels and bouquets as may be
requested by a subscriber within a reasonable time not exceeding 72 hours. The
deactivation requests shall also be completed within prescribed time frame subject to any
lock in period as agreed at the time of subscription.
18. In addition to subscriber request, the channels or bouquets may get dropped from the
platform for reasons beyond the control of DPOs. DPOs may also want to drop channels
or reconstitute an existing bouquet due to business concerns. In such cases the subscriber
should not get affected adversely. The Authority has therefore prescribed measures for
these different scenarios as explained below.
(i) No DPO shall make any changes in subscription of a subscriber, without obtaining
a request from the subscriber and such request records shall be kept for atleast period of
three months. In case of any dispute, such records shall be preserved by the DPO’s till
disposal of such disputes or three months, whichever is later.
(ii) In case of dropping of pay channels or bouquets of pay channels of broadcaster,
which become unavailable on the platform of a DPO due to any reason, the Authority
Page 54 of 67
prescribes that the DPO will not charge the subscribers for such pay channels or
bouquets of pay channels. DPOs shall not substitute for dropped channels or bouquets as
the case may be without the request from the subscriber.
(iii) If the dropped pay channels happen to be part of bouquet offered by the DPO, in
such case the DPO shall reduce the subscription charges payable by the affected
subscribers and the reduction in subscription charges shall be an amount equivalent to
discounted distributor retail price of that channel, taking into account the discount
offered by the distributor on such bouquet.
(iv) Further, a DPO is not permitted to modify the bouquet of a subscriber by dropping
or replacing channels which continue to be available on its platform. The subscriber is
restricted to modify the subscription of a-la-carte channels or bouquets during the lock-in
period, if any, for such channels and bouquets as accepted by him at the time of
subscription.
19. Any change in composition of a bouquet by a DPO when the channels continue to be
available on its platform shall be construed as a formation and introduction of a new
bouquet and discontinuation of the earlier bouquet i.e. in case a channel is dropped from
a bouquet, it shall constitute as creation of new bouquet without the dropped channel and
the earlier bouquet that contained the dropped channel shall be deemed to be
discontinued. The rules as prescribed in the regulation for introduction of a new bouquet
& dropping of a bouquet shall be followed by DPOs. However, in case the nature of
channel is changed by a broadcaster or the MRP of that channel is increased beyond
rupees nineteen and if such channel is part of a subscribed bouquet, the distributor,
irrespective of the lock-in period of the scheme, shall remove such channel from the
bouquet and reduce the subscription charges of that bouquet payable by such subscriber
by an amount equivalent to discounted distributor retail price of that channel, taking into
account the discount offered by the distributor on such bouquet. Further, if any channel
included in the subscription package of a subscriber, is removed by the distributor of
television channels due to change of nature or increase in MRP, such distributor shall not
substitute the removed channel with alternative channel in the subscription package of
such subscriber.
Page 55 of 67
20. In context with above provisions majority of the stakeholders have agreed that there
should be a provision for offering rebate to the subscriber in case of channel subscribed
by him is dropped by DPOs due to its non availability on DPO platform. Some DPOs
have suggested that they should be allowed to substitute the dropped channel after
obtaining the consent. However it has been observed that the provision regarding
substitution of similar genre channel has been misused in the past and DPOs often push
through the channel that is not wanted by the subscribers. The Authority is of the view
that above provisions adequately safeguards the interests of stakeholders and therefore
prescribes the same in the QoS regulatory framework.
21. The stakeholders were consulted for extending the existing provision relating to
temporary suspension of service upon the request of subscribers to all addressable
platforms. DPOs are of the view that they should be permitted to charge resumption fee
varying from Rs.50 to Rs.100 on each occasion and such suspension may be allowed
twice in a year limited up to total 4 months period. Accordingly, the Authority has
decided that subscribers should be empowered to suspend their services temporarily and
that the existing regulatory framework should be extended to other platforms also.
However, as the DPOs incur certain costs towards processing the request and
temporarily suspending the subscribers from the SMS, they may charge a notional fee.
As the work to be done in restoration of a temporary suspended connection is much
lower than the work involved in activation of a new connection, a restoration fee of Rs.
25/-, one fourth of the activation fee (which is Rs 100/- as per existing regulation) is
justified. If the temporary suspension continues for more than three months, it shall be
open to the DPOs to de-activate such subscriber from the SMS. Thereafter reactivation
of service in such a case will attract an activation fee, which may be upto Rs 100/- (the
existing limit of activation fee). It may be clarified here that any subscriber who is not
active for three months shall not be counted towards active subscriber while reporting
such information to TRAI.
(i) Payment defaults by subscriber may also lead to temporary suspension of service. As
the DPOs have to make payments to the broadcasters, irrespective of default at consumer
level; timely payments are important for the seamless revenue transactions along the
Page 56 of 67
value chain. As per existing QoS regulations for DTH no charges, other than charges in
respect of CPE, relating to the period during which direct to home services remain
discontinued due to any reason are payable by the subscribers and no reactivation
charges for resumption of service are to be levied by DPOs. This provision has been
reviewed and the Authority is of the view that if services to a subscriber are suspended
due to payment default, and such suspension continues for a period more than three
months, DPOs may de-activate such subscriber from the SMS and may charge a fee up
to activation fee of Rs 100/- for resumption of services. In addition to activation fee,
DPOs will also be entitled to recover the outstanding dues along with interest chargeable
at a rate not exceeding 2% higher than the base rate notified by State Bank of India from
time to time, on the amount payable by the subscriber for the period of such delay.
Further such subscriber shall not be included in the active subscribers of the DPO if it is
not active for last 3 months. The DPOs shall inform such charges, if any, prescribed by
the DPOs for restoration of temporary suspension and activation of service to the
subscribers through websites and customer care programming service.
(ii) No other charges shall be payable by the subscriber during the temporary
suspension period, except the rental charges for the CPE, if it has been obtained under
rental scheme. Further any subscriber who remains suspended beyond three months shall
not be counted as an active subscriber of the DPO. These provisions of the draft
regulation have been agreed to by most stakeholders.
22. Consultations were also held on the issue of disruption in services and how the interests
of subscribers can be protected if there is a continued disruption in services. The existing
regulatory framework provides that all complaints related to “No Signal” are to be
resolved within 3 days. This provision is being complied with by the DPOs. The
Authority is of the view that in case any disruption continues beyond 72 hours, the
subscriber shall not be charged for the entire duration of such continued disruption. The
period of such disruption shall be counted from the time a complaint to this effect is
registered by a subscriber with the DPO or concerned customer care centre in case of
individual fault and from the occurrence of fault if bulk subscribers are affected. The
adjustment to the subscribers can be provided in terms of equivalent additional
subscription days or by providing proportionate credit to subscriber’s account, as the
Page 57 of 67
case may be. In case of likely disruption due to any planned maintenance, DPOs should
give at least 15 days of advance notice to the subscribers.
23. Shifting of connection from one location to another involves dismantling of CPE, from
the subscribers premises and installing the same to another new location. Logically,
process involved in shifting of connection to another location is similar to providing a
new connection in addition to dismantling work. Subscriber details of new address are
to be updated in the SMS and thereafter the services are to be activated. Therefore DPOs
incur costs for shifting of connection also. The Authority is of the view that in case
where the dismantling of outdoor equipment is done by the DPO and the connection is
reinstalled at a new location, the DPO may charge an amount not exceeding twice the
installation charges notified by the DPO within the prescribed ceiling. However, in cases
where no shifting of outdoor equipment is involved, DPOs may charge a fee not
exceeding the installation charges as notified by the DPO within the prescribed ceiling.
24. Comments of stakeholders were sought on how to improve customer care services,
consumer complaint and grievance redressal in the addressable systems and if the
customer care centre infrastructure can be outsourced to another agency keeping in view
the constraints faced by smaller DPOs. Stakeholders have suggested that DPOs should
widely publicise their consumer care numbers, toll free number and customer care centre
details though various modes such as advertisement, scrolls on the channels, website,
short messaging service, b-mail and customer care programming service etc. DPOs have
also favoured outsourcing of customer care centre. The Authority therefore permits
outsourcing of QoS infrastructure such as website, customer care centre, web based
complaint management system etc but the responsibility of QoS compliance and
reporting shall solely lie with concerned DPO.
25. Consultation was held on the issue of accessibility of customer care centre to consumers.
DPOs have suggested varying access time such as 24 hrs, 8.00 to 00.00 hrs, 7.00 hrs to
23.00 hrs, 8.00 hrs to 23.00 hrs etc. Stakeholders generally supported the view that IVR
services and customer care centre may provide option of regional language in addition to
English and Hindi language. It was submitted by one DPO that call volume traffic gets
heavily skewed towards the prime time viewership hours, that is, during 7.00 pm to
Page 58 of 67
10.00 pm and nearly 25% of the entire day’s call volume is received during these three
hours. Therefore it is not sustainable to build capacity on the basis of these three hours
prime time peak as for the rest of the day the resources would remain idle. Accordingly,
stakeholders have requested for review of the bench mark of response time for voice to
voice response and suggested the said benchmark should either be 90% in 90 sec or 95%
in 150 sec.
26. The Authority is of the view that the operational hours of 8.00 to 22.00 hrs for operation
of customer care centre are justified as this period covers normal business hours and
prime time for television viewing. DPO may however extend accessibility hours beyond
this period depending on their business requirements. Further, the IVR response for
electronically answered calls shall be 90% calls to be answered within 40 seconds and
for voice assisted calls 90% calls to be answered within 90 seconds.
27. Comments were sought from stakeholders on the issue of recording of subscribers
consent for subscriber driven action related to their subscription. Stakeholders have
favoured such provisions in the QoS with recording of the communication for period of
several months. The Authority is of the view that services once subscribed by the
subscriber should not be modified without specific request of the subscriber to do so and
such request related communication should be duly preserved for a period of at least
three months. Different methods using registered mobile number, registered email, call
records, IVR records, etc. may be devised for receiving such request.
28. The issues relating to billing method and billing cycle were consulted with the
stakeholders. Majority of the DPOs were of the view that pre-paid payment system may
be encouraged, however choice of implementing pre-paid and post paid method may be
left to them. With regard to billing cycle for pre paid or post paid system, a few DPOs
have suggested that billing cycle for pre paid may be 30 days from the date of activation
of services while for post paid the billing cycle may be a calendar month. Some DPOs
have suggested that it should be left to them to decide. The Authority is of the view that
the DPOs or its linked local cable operator, as the case may be, may offer their services
either on pre-paid or post-paid or both pre-paid & post-paid as per their business
requirements. The billing cycle for pre paid shall be 30 days from the date of activation
Page 59 of 67
of services while for post paid the billing cycles shall be a calendar month. In case of
pre-paid model, DPOs or local cable operators, as the case may be, shall inform the
amount debited to the subscriber at the end of every billing cycle through electronic
means. In case of post paid billing, a proper bill conforming to the provisions of
applicable laws with usage details shall be provided to the subscribers. The post paid bill
can be provided in print form or in electronic form as may be opted by the subscribers.
The subscribers shall also be provided online access through website or other electronic
means for accessing their billing and payment statements for preceding six months
without any charge.
29. In order to protect the interest of consumers, the Authority has consulted with the
stakeholder for developing a consumer friendly common framework of CPE/STB
schemes in addressable systems. At present three CPE schemes viz. outright purchase,
hire-purchase and rental schemes have been prescribed by the Authority. This apart,
DPOs have also been permitted to offer other schemes where they generally bundle CPE
with the service subscription. It has been observed that complete details of CPE schemes
are not made available to the subscribers and issues related to ownership and
maintenance often lead to disputes.
30. There is a consensus among the stakeholders that essential information about CPE,
namely, price, guarantee/warrantee, AMC, provision for return and other charges
associated with CPE must be transparently informed to the consumers while offering
such schemes. The Authority has analysed the comments of stakeholders on the issues
related to CPE/STB. From a consumer’s perspective, it is of utmost importance that a
simplified and common CPE framework is developed in order to make the consumers
well aware of the provisions. Considering that digitization for the first three phases have
been completed to great extent and in the present market scenario, the Authority is of the
view that two mandatory schemes, namely, outright purchase scheme and rental scheme,
are sufficient to cater to the interests of the consumers. Additionally the DPOs may offer
other schemes as per their business concerns.
31. In the outright purchase scheme the DPO shall declare and notify the retail price of CPE
with a guarantee/warranty period of at least one year during which the subscriber shall
Page 60 of 67
not be required to pay any charge towards repair and maintenance of the CPE. The
ownership of the CPE shall remain with the subscriber under this scheme. The DPO
shall also offer an annual maintenance scheme at reasonable price for the CPE provided
under such scheme after the expiry of guarantee/warranty period.
32. In the rental scheme, the DPO shall declare and notify the monthly rental amount and
other terms and conditions, if any for CPE. The DPO may specify a refundable security
deposit under this scheme as may be considered appropriate. The ownership of CPE
shall remain with the DPO in this scheme. DPOs are also free to form other schemes as
per their business requirement; however the ownership of CPE in rental scheme and
other schemes shall remain with DPO or its linked local cable operator, as the case may
be.
33. In the draft regulations, it was prescribed that DPOs shall be responsible for maintenance
of CPE that has been offered by DPO’s under rental scheme and other schemes
(excluding the outright purchase scheme) for a minimum period of 5 years. Majority of
the DPO’s are of the view that repair and maintenance for a period of 5 years would
incur additional expenses to them and it is not financially viable. The Authority has
examined this issue keeping in mind the comments of the stakeholders and consumers
interest. It has been observed that repair and maintenance of CPE is the major bone of
contention between the subscribers and the DPO’s. Subscribers have been facing
problems with regard to maintenance and repair of CPE that has been procured under
various schemes offered by DPO’s and they have been charged heavily in case any
problem is detected in the CPE. Therefore, a provision needs to be prescribed to address
the issues related to repair and maintenance of CPE during its useful life span, under the
schemes where the ownership of CPE remains with the DPO as a safety net for the
subscribers. The Authority also considered that CPE is an electronic item where life of
such equipment is generally 3 to 4 years. The CPE technology is also changing rapidly
due to technical advancements. Hence, it appears reasonable to define average useful life
span of CPE of 3 years. Accordingly, the Authority is of the view that in case of services
obtained under rental scheme and other schemes, it shall be the responsibility of the
DPO’s to provide interruption free services to subscribers for atleast minimum period of
three years. The DPOs therefore shall ensure that CPE is maintained in good working
Page 61 of 67
condition during this period. The subscribers during this period of three years shall not
be liable to pay any amount separately towards maintenance of CPE for any incidence of
fault, except in cases where the CPE has been found tampered or physically damaged by
the subscriber. The DPOs may include expenses, if any, likely to be incurred towards
maintaining the CPE in good working condition for providing interruption free services
during the prescribed period of three years, in their schemes that are offered to the
consumers.
34. A few stakeholders submitted that there is no provision in the draft regulations for
return/surrender of CPE. In this regard the Authority is of the view that the ownership of
CPE rests with the DPO’s for the rental scheme and the other schemes being offered by
DPO’s. Therefore, the provision of surrender of CPE is inbuilt in the schemes excluding
outright purchase scheme. A provision is also made in the regulations to enable
subscribers to surrender their connection subject to terms and conditions of
subscriptions, if any. Subscribers can therefore return the CPE. A few stakeholders have
also highlighted the issue relating to interoperability of STB’s. The Authority has
already initiated an exercise to examine the feasibility of interoperability of STB’s. The
Authority would come up with its view in this matter in due course of time.
35. As per the existing regulatory framework for DTH service, there is a provision of
levying visit charges after guarantee/warrantee period in connection with visits for
servicing of CPE at subscriber premises. The DTH operator are permitted to charge an
amount not exceeding rupees two hundred and fifty as visitation charge per complaint.
There is no such provision in cable TV services. In the consultation, most of the DPOs
have supported levying visit charges from the subscribers for visits related to
maintenance activity to be undertaken at subscriber end. A few DPOs have also
suggested that it may be left to market forces to decide visit charges. After examining the
comments it is observed that in the DTH the visit charges is prescribed for the external
equipment like PDA, LNBC which may get disturbed due to faults not directly
attributable to the DPO. Such charges are not applicable to problems related to STB,
which is an indoor equipment like in case of cable connection. MSOs/HITS operators are
of the view that there should not be any discrimination amongst DPOs in regard to
levying of visitation charges and they should also be allowed to levy visiting charges.
Page 62 of 67
One consumer organization submitted that visiting charges should be made on the basis
of categories of cities. Therefore, the matter has been examined by the Authority and it is
decided that DPO’s providing direct to home services may charge an amount not
exceeding rupees two hundred and fifty as visit charges for registered complaints
requiring visit of a person to subscriber’s premises for maintenance, provided that no
visiting charges shall be levied for complaints relating to STB. Such visiting charge
shall not be debited from the pre-paid subscription account of the subscriber and receipt
for payment made towards such charges shall be issued to the subscriber by the DTH
operator.
36. Consultations were held with stakeholders on various methods that can be useful for
increasing the consumer awareness. Stakeholders have suggested that awareness can be
done through various means such as scrolls, short messaging service, websites,
advertisements across mass media, etc.
37. At present, the consumer awareness related information is being provided by DPOs in
different format and manner which is not easy to access and understand by the
consumers. The Authority is of the view that if this information is standardised and it is
provided to the consumers in a uniform manner, it will result in better publicity and
improved education of consumers. As per existing regulatory provisions, the DPOs are
mandated to set up their websites which can be effectively used for dissemination of this
standardized information. Accordingly, in the consultation paper, the Authority had
suggested for having a dedicated “Consumer Corner” link on the home page of DPO
website. The page shall also contain login provisions for existing subscribers who may
be provided access to additional information specifically related to them under
subscriber corner. The essential information to be displayed under the consumer corner
and subscriber corner was also put up for comments of stakeholders. DPOs have
welcomed and shown agreement towards the suggested measures.
38. The Authority has also prescribed various other provisions for publicity of information
and consumer awareness in the draft regulations which inter-alia include customer care
programming service and public awareness campaign by DPO’s and broadcasters. The
stakeholders have agreed with these provisions.
Page 63 of 67
39. Dissemination of information related to TV broadcasting services through dedicated
customer care programming service can be an effective communication method.
Therefore, the Authority is of the view that DPOs should provide customer care
programming service for dissemination of service related information to their
subscribers. Further, the Authority is also of the view that if a uniform LCN number
(say 999) is assigned by all DPOs for their respective customer care programming
service, it would be consumer friendly and help in creating wider publicity to such
provision.
40. The Authority had already issued order for prohibition of on screen display by DPO’s for
giving notices to subscribers about disconnection or discontinuation or non-availability
of TV channels. The Authority is of the view that such notices can be provided by
DPO’s through text scrolls at the bottom of the TV screen. However, the size of such
scrolls should not affect the viewing experience of the subscribers. Frequency of such
scrolls should also be limited so that viewing experience is not adversely affected.
41. Comments of stakeholders were sought on the technical parameters for various
addressable systems. Majority of the stakeholders are of the view that existing technical
parameters and standards for transmission are sufficient and there is no requirement to
modify the same. Accordingly, the Authority has prescribed certain technical standards
to be complied with by DPO’s and broadcasters in the draft regulations which were
agreed to by the stakeholders.
42. The stakeholders were consulted on the requirement of MoP and consumer charter to be
provided to consumers which is required as per the existing regulatory framework.
While agreeing that MoP should be made available to the subscriber, stakeholders
suggested that the same may be provided in electronic form, via e-mail and through
various electronic means. Therefore, the Authority is of the view that MoP should be
publicised by DPO’s on their website and may be provided electronically to the
subscribers. The information contained in the MoP and consumer charter is almost
similar in nature. Therefore, Authority is of the view that provision of Consumer charter
is not required.
Page 64 of 67
43. As per the new regulatory framework for interconnection, broadcasters are required to
declare their channels in any one of the nine genres viz. (1) Devotional (2) General
Entertainment, (3) Infotainment, (4) Kids, (5) Movies, (6) Music, (7) News and Current
Affairs, (8) Sports, (9) Miscellaneous. In the regulatory framework for interconnection,
certain provisions have been made in regard to listing of channels in the EPG. These
regulations provide that DPOs shall assign a unique number for each channel available
on its platform and such number shall not be altered by the DPO for a period of at least
one year. DPOs are also required to place the channel in the EPG in such a way that
channels of same genre as declared by the broadcaster are placed consecutively and one
channel shall appear at one place only. Further, all television channels of the same
language within the same genre shall appear together consecutively in the EPG.
44. EPG enables the subscriber to identify the Logical Channel Number of each channel
available on the DPO platform. Therefore, the manner of display of channel in the EPG
assumes significant importance to the subscriber. Accordingly, certain provisions were
made in the draft QoS regulations as to how channels are displayed in the EPG by the
DPOs. The intent of these provisions is to make subscribers aware of the name and price
of all channels being carried by the DPOs so as to enable them to make informed
decision for selection of channels. Further, these provisions would also enable the
subscribers to easily identify the channels which they have subscribed. In the draft QoS
regulations, it has been prescribed that every DPO shall display all channels (both pay
and FTA channels) available on its platform in the EPG under the respective genre as
declared by the broadcasters along with applicable a-la-carte MRP. It has been further
prescribed that such display of a-la-carte prices for pay channels shall be their respective
MRP declared by the broadcaster. In case of FTA channels, DPOs shall display “zero”
for the price of the channel.
45. DPOs are in agreement with the provision of display of all channels in the EPG.
However, majority of the DPO’s are of the view that since MRP, as per the draft tariff
order, varies from region to region, it would not be feasible to display MRP for the pay
channels in the EPG. A few stakeholders have suggested that there should be sub
Page 65 of 67
categorisation within each genre for easy access to the channels by the subscribers. One
DPO submitted that display of zero pricing of FTA channel should be done away with.
46. The Authority has reviewed the matter and region based pricing of the channel as
prescribed in the draft tariff order has been done away with. Therefore, the concerns
expressed by the DPOs regarding difficulty for display of channels in the EPG due to
variation of regional MRP pricing of channels has been addressed. The Authority is of
the view that DPOs should display all channels available on their platform in the EPG
with their names and their respective MRP, in case of FTA channels, the Authority is of
the view that “Free” should be displayed against the name of the FTA channels in the
EPG.
47. Further, the Authority finds merit regarding the suggestion of the stakeholders that there
should be sub categorisation within each genre. As already mentioned, the Authority has
prescribed nine genres for regulating the tariff. From the subscriber’s point of view, sub-
genre would enable them to easily navigate to similar channels available on the platform.
Therefore, the Authority is of the view that DPOs should define the sub-genre within a
particular genre on the basis of language, region, etc and the channels under sub genre
should be grouped together and assigned logical channel numbers accordingly. It should
be ensured that channels of same language are grouped together within sub-genre of a
particular genre. It is further explained that in case the genre of a channel is changed by a
broadcaster, the DPOs shall according to the regulation display the channel in
appropriate genre. This will make EPG more consumers friendly insofar as selection of
TV channels is concerned. The Authority expects that this manner of display of channels
in the EPG by the DPOs will bring in greater visibility and transparency in informing the
subscribers about all channels that are available on the platform.
48. In order to ensure good quality of TV broadcasting services to the subscribers, it is of
paramount importance that the provisions of QoS regulation are complied by the DPOs
and the local cable operators. It would be appropriate if the DPOs designate a
compliance officer for generating awareness within their organisation regarding the
provisions of the regulations and facilitating creation of required infrastructure and
practices. The compliance officer will ensure timely submission of reports and
Page 66 of 67
information to the Authority. Here it is important to note that the role and responsibilities
of the compliance officer shall be without prejudice to the provisions of the Act with
regard to the responsibilities of the DPOs towards regulatory reporting and compliance.
49. In the consultation paper, the stakeholders were asked to offer their comments on the
feasibility of building a framework for carrying out audit of DPOs for verifying QoS
compliance and for conducting surveys towards assessment of QoS perception of the
consumers. The stakeholders have supported these suggestions. The Authority is of the
view that since the broadcasting sector is at the cusp of digital transition, it may take
sometime for the industry to get stabilised. Further, the industry may also require time to
get adjusted in the new regulatory framework propounded by the Authority in respect of
tariff, interconnection and QoS. In such a scenario, the Authority may consider and
prescribe such measures regarding conduct of audit and surveys for QoS in due course.
50. Consultations were held with the stakeholders as to whether any financial disincentives
for QoS non compliance are to be imposed for violation of QoS provisions. In the draft
regulation, the financial disincentives prescribed for MSOs/LCOs in addressable TV
services were made applicable across all platforms. One stakeholder submitted that
unless TRAI ensures compliance of QoS regulations at the end of DPOs, any attempt to
implement the tariff order and/or Interconnect Regulations would have an adverse and
cascading impact on all stakeholders. Another stakeholder submitted that there are no
punitive measures prescribed in the regulations in the form of financial disincentives
and/or recommendation of cancellation of licence in the event of default. Therefore, the
Authority has made provisions for designating a Compliance Officer by DPOs who
would ensure the compliance of QoS norms prescribed in these regulations. It is
observed that the broadcasting services related to television are being delivered to
consumers through digital addressable systems in most areas of the country and the
process of digitization is expected to be completed by completion of phase-IV. In case of
major DPOs, the basic infrastructure for implementing the QoS regulations is already
available on ground. However, in case of smaller MSOs, adequate timeframe may be
required for implementation of the framework. The Authority will continue to monitor
the implementation and compliance of the QoS provisions by the DPOs and if required,
Page 67 of 67
and review the matter at appropriate stage for consideration of financial disincentive for
non compliance of prescribed QoS provisions and benchmarks.
51. These Regulations shall come into effect after 180 days from the date of their publication
in the Official Gazette. The Authority is aware that, as on the date of publication of these
regulations in the Official Gazette, there would be large numbers of packages,
bouquets/channels and plans subscribed by existing subscriber based upon the
framework of earlier QoS regulations. Therefore to protect the interests of consumers as
well as DPOs and to enable a smooth transition from the old regulatory framework to the
new one, the Authority has provided a time up to 180 days to either discontinue or
modify all their existing packages, bouquets/channels and plans in compliance with the
provisions of the regulations and the tariff orders. The DPOs are advised to modify their
existing packages, bouquets/channels and plans well in advance before commencement
of these regulations so as to ensure adequate publicity and awareness amongst the
subscribers. Accordingly, the Authority is of the view that the provisions related to
offering of services, CPE scheme, Customer Care Centre, Customer Care Programming
Service and website are implemented within 120 days from the date of publication of
these regulation in the Official Gazette. It is also necessary that an aggressive public
awareness campaign should be conducted by DPOs in regard to the provisions that are
having direct bearing on the consumers during the transition period so as to enable the
consumers to make informed decision for subscribing broadcasting services related to
television. The Authority is conscious of the fact that the existing subscribers should not
face any undue inconvenience and hardships while the DPOs move from the existing
QoS framework to the new regulatory framework. Therefore, DPOs are required to
ensure that necessary changes in the infrastructure and services to be offered in the new
regime are implemented well in advance for the smooth transition.
***
Previous and next
Questions people ask
Is regulation 45 of Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable) Services Standards of Quality of Service and Consumer Protection (Addressable Systems) Regulations, 2017. still in force?
No repeal of Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable) Services Standards of Quality of Service and Consumer Protection (Addressable Systems) Regulations, 2017. is recorded.