Regulation 3, Short Message Services (SMS) Termination Charges Regulations, 2013: Termination charges for Short Message Services (SMS)
Short Message Services (SMS) Termination Charges Regulations, 2013 - Regulation 3
Text of regulation 3
Termination charges for Short Message Services (SMS)
3. Termination charges for Short Message Services (SMS):-----
Every Originating Access Provider shall pay to the Terminating Access
Provider a termination charge of Re. 0.02 (paise two only) for each
Short Message Service (SMS) terminated by it on the network of
Terminating Access Provider;
Provided that termination charges for international incoming
Short Message Service (SMS) shall be under forbearance.
Rajeev Agrawal
Secretary
Note. -------The Explanatory Memorandum explains the objects and reasons
of the ‘Short Message Services (SMS) Termination Charges Regulations,
2013.’
1
EXPLANATORY MEMORANDUM TO ‘THE SHORT MESSAGE SERVICES
(SMS) TERMINATION CHARGES REGULATIONS, 2013 (7 of 2013)’
1. The framework of Interconnection Usage Charges (IUC) was established by
TRAI through “The Telecommunication Interconnection Usage Charges (IUC)
Regulation, 2003 (1 of 2003) dated the 24th January 2003. This regulation
was implemented from 1st May 2003. At that time the focus was on voice
related charges and Short Message Services (SMS) termination charges were
under forbearance.
2. The regulation of January 2003 was superseded by ‘The Telecommunication
Interconnection Usage Charges Regulation, 2003 (4 of 2003)’ which became
effective from 1st February 2004. While keeping the IUC for SMS under
forbearance, in these regulations, it was mentioned that IUC for SMS may be
re-visited in the near future.
3. TRAI asked the opinion of the stakeholders, inter-alia on the requirement and
method of regulating termination charge for SMS, in the consultations carried
out in 2006. After deliberations, TRAI decided vide its decision dated
21.08.2006 that the forbearance on IUC for SMS should continue.
4. During the review of the IUC regulation in 2008-09 some of the service
providers showed concern on the growing trend amongst the dominant
service providers of charging Interconnection Usage Charges for SMS from
new entrants which were not cost based. TRAI noted that, by and large, the
arrangement prevalent at the time was bill and keep. Therefore, in the IUC
regulations dated 09.03.2009, TRAI decided to continue with the policy of
forbearance in the matter of IUC for SMS with a proviso that SMS termination
charges, if any, should be transparent, reciprocal and non-discriminatory.
The relevant Schedule IV of the regulation is reproduced below:
2
“Schedule IV
INTERCONNECT USAGE CHARGE (IUC) FOR
SHORT MESSAGE SERVICE (SMS)
Interconnect Usage Charge (IUC) for Short Message Service (SMS).-
Interconnect Usage Charge (IUC) for Short Message Service (SMS) shall
be under forbearance:
Provided that such charges shall be transparent, reciprocal and non-
discriminatory.”
5. The IUC Regulations dated 09.03.2009 were challenged by some operators in
Telecom Dispute Settlement and Appellate Tribunal (TDSAT) on various
grounds. Hon’ble TDSAT vide its judgment dated 29th September 2010 gave
its observations/directions on various components of IUC and remanded the
matter to TRAI with the direction to consider the matter afresh and to
complete the consultation process in a time bound manner. On the issue of
SMS termination charge the relevant extracts of Hon’ble TDSAT’s judgment
dated 29th September 2010 regarding SMS termination charge is given below:
“118. SMS TERMINATION CHARGE
1) ETISALAT only raised the contention that TRAI should have
exercised its jurisdiction for fixing a charge in respect thereof.
It, however, appears that while leaving the matter to
forbearance it was expected the service providers to levy a
reasonable charge, having regard to the fact that no
consultation on cost based SMS Termination Charge had been
undertaken.
2) We, therefore, are of the opinion, that in the interest of the
customers vis-à-vis some of the service providers, the TRAI
may consider this aspect of the matter also.”
6. Against the said TDSAT’s judgment dated 29.9.2010, TRAI preferred a
statutory Civil Appeal before the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, under
section 18 of the TRAI Act, 1997, which was marked as Civil Appeal No.271-
281 of 2011.
3
7. TRAI also initiated a consultation process to review the IUC charges as the
IUC charges were earlier determined in the year 2009. The consultation
process carried out by TRAI include pre consultation process, which was
initiated through a communication sent to service providers on 24.12.2010. In
the pre consultation, service providers were requested to furnish information
with regard to framework of Interconnection Usage Charges, components to
be reviewed, method of calculation and level of each charge, approach/
methodology/ model to be used for estimating Interconnection Usage Charge
etc. They were also asked to provide the model, if any, developed for
estimating the level of each component with all calculation sheets along with
justification for adopting the proposed approach/ methodology. Cost and
revenue corresponding to each service like voice service, SMS, GPRS, EDGE,
roaming services and any other value added services, minutes of usage
(MOU) (off-net/ on-net), CAPEX and OPEX corresponding to each network
element, cables etc. were also asked.
8. Taking into consideration the inputs provided by the service providers and
associations, a detailed consultation paper was issued on 27.04.2011. The
consultation paper sought stakeholders’ comments on various aspects.
Stakeholders were given time until 18.05.2011 to respond on the consultation
paper. 26 stakeholders including 14 service providers, 4 associations and 8
consulting firms/consumer groups/ individuals sent written comments that
were uploaded on TRAI’s website. The issue of IUC for SMS was raised by
TRAI in its consultation paper dated 27.04.2011. In the consultation paper,
following issues were raised:
Question 3.22 Do you agree that a deterrent termination
charge should be imposed for commercial
SMS? In your view, what would be the most
appropriate level of termination charge for
commercial SMS?
4
Question 3.23 Do you agree that Bill and Keep regime should
be put in place for other types of SMS (non-
commercial SMS)? Please provide justification
for your response.
9. While the exercise to determine the IUC Charges was in progress, TRAI
confronted several serious difficulties and accordingly filed an Application in
the Hon’ble Supreme Court for direction pointing out that by selectively citing
observations of the Hon’ble TDSAT, service providers had challenged
/questioned TRAI’s power to independently determine IUC charges in exercise
of its statutory powers conferred u/s. 11(1)(b)(ii), (iii) and (iv). On 29th July,
2011, Hon’ble Supreme Court passed the following order
“… Before taking up the matter for final hearing, this Court
would like the Regulator to compute the IUC with the inclusion
of capital cost and without inclusion of the capital cost. In this
case, the TRAI, which is the original Authority, has taken the
view as a matter of law/regulation that capital cost should not
be taken into account in the matter of fixation of IUC, whereas
the Telecom Disputes Settlement and Appellate Tribunal
[`TDSAT', for short] has taken a contrary view saying that the
capital cost should be taken into account in the matter of
fixation of IUC. Therefore, we want the Regulator to give us the
computation of the IUC to be worked out on both the basis,
namely, what would be the IUC if capital cost is taken into
account and what would be the IUC if the capital cost is not
taken into account?...
…It is made clear that the Regulator will give its working
uninfluenced by the observations made in the impugned
judgement by the TDSAT. The Regulator will give its working by
31st October, 2011. …”
5
10. During the consultation process, some of the service providers were of the
view that a termination charge for all types of SMS (commercial as well as
non commercial) should be prescribed at a level, which allows the terminating
operator to recover their cost as well as successfully address the concerns of
SPAM and pesky SMSs. However, some service providers suggested that on
the basis of costs there is no case for imposing any termination charges on
any SMS; however, for consumer benefits, TRAI may impose some charge on
commercial SMS. Some of the service providers favoured “Bill & Keep” basis
for exchange of all types of SMS (both commercial and non-commercial)
between networks. These operators were of the view that the cost of
regulating, monitoring and settling inter-operator billing for SMS is
cumbersome and entail unnecessarily administrative cost; the bill and keep
regime is simpler. Summary of the responses is as follows:
(i) A termination charge for all types of SMS (A2P , P2P, Commercial
as well as non commercial) should be prescribed at a level, which
allows the terminating operator to recover their cost as well as
successfully address the concerns of SPAM and pesky SMSs.
(ii) Termination of both commercial as well as non commercial SMS
should be charged and may be a fraction of the Voice termination
charges i.e. 1/4th of the Voice (mobile) termination charges.
(iii) TRAI should mandate “Bill & Keep” basis for exchange of all types
of SMS. As far as concerns over SPAM SMS / unsolicited commercial
SMSs, alternate mechanisms for deterring such SMSs as envisaged
in TCCCP Regulation may be explored.
(iv) On the basis of cost there is no case for imposing charges on any
form of SMS. However, for consumer benefit, the rate for
commercial SMS could be 10 paise/ commercial SMS.
(v) “THE TELECOM COMMERCIAL COMMUNICATIONS CUSTOMER
Regulations 2010” has created sufficient deterrent on commercial
calls and SMS and there is no need for a further deterrence on this.
(vi) The signaling paths of the recipient networks are relatively more
loaded because of flow of commercial SMS.
6
(vii) BAK for non commercial SMS will offers unacceptable arbitrage
opportunities to originating operators who will have a strong
incentive to reroute or disguise commercial traffic. 10 paisa per
SMS is a level which would act as sufficient deterrent to spam. This
price is also well below international benchmarks for SMS
termination pricing whether regulated or commercially agreed.
(viii) The current regulation of Bill and Keep should be continued.
Considering international practices and costs base, we do not see
any reason for imposing termination charges for any type of SMSs.
(ix) Commercial SMS are nuisance and deterrent termination charges
must be imposed on bulk SMS sent for commercial purposes from
origination network, say the same as a call.
(x) The services that are not welcomed by the subscribers must be
heavily taxed.
(xi) A deterrent termination charge should be imposed for commercial
SMS. The termination charge for commercial SMS may be kept
same as the charges for voice call termination.
(xii) Most of the operators have a relatively balances P2P SMS traffic.
The traffic imbalance is primarily on account of A2P SMS.
11. A report was filed in Hon’ble Supreme court on 31.10.2011 in compliance with
its order dated 29.07.2011 in Civil Appeal No. 271-281/ 2011. Since the issue
of inclusion of capital cost has been raised by service providers in the context
of calculation of Mobile and Fixed Termination Charges before the Hon’ble
TDSAT, the Authority has computed these charges including and excluding
the capital cost and has submitted the report to this Hon’ble Court. It is
relevant to point out here that as IUC for SMS were kept under forbearance,
costing methodology, cost data and hence inclusion of the capital cost in
respect of the SMS termination charges was not an issue before the Hon'ble
TDSAT. SMS termination Charge was also not part of the Report submitted by
the Authority to Hon’ble Supreme Court.
7
12. Matter along with other concerned matters was heard on 20.11.2012 to
22.11.2012 and on 04.12.2012 by the larger bench on the question of law
involved namely whether TDSAT has the power, competence and jurisdiction
to exercise powers of judicial review, over the regulations framed u/s. 36(1)
of the TRAI Act, 1997. Arguments have been completed and judgment
reserved.
13. Meanwhile various complaints with regard to discriminatory termination
charge for SMS were received in TRAI from some of the operators wherein
they have contended that some dominant operators have imposed 10 Paise
/SMS as SMS termination charge, which is discriminatory.
14. One Service Provider informed TRAI that it has filed a petition in Hon’ble
TDSAT against the demand raised by one of the dominent service provider on
account of charging for SMS termination and also against the threat of
withdrawal of interconnection of the SMS services of its network by the
respondent. The service provider in its petition requested to declare the
demand raised (on account implementation/ imposition of SMS termination
charge @ 10 paise per SMS) as arbitrary, illegal, wrong, unilateral and
without any basis; and quash/set aside the same. It also requested to direct
the respondent not to withdraw the interconnection for SMS service with the
petitioner’s networks for non payment of the unilaterally increased and
imposed demand for SMS termination.
15. A representation was again received by the abovementioned service provider
that pending their ongoing dispute, the respondent service provider has
unilaterally disconnected the SMS services to their network over the long
Diwali weekend, thereby forcing it to sign an agreement with them for SMS
termination at 10 paise per SMS. One more petition was filed in the TDSAT
regarding interpretation of Schedule IV of the Telecommunication
Interconnection Usage Charges (10th Amendment) Regulations, 2009 and the
terms of agreements on SMS termination charge entered into between the
parties.
8
16. Hon’ble TDSAT in its judgment in Petition No. 130 of 2011 on 24. 09.2012 and
in Petition No.430 of 2011 on 30.08.2012, has observed that as per TRAI’s
regulation SMS termination charge is under forbearance; provided that such
charges shall be transparent, reciprocal and non discriminatory. In these
orders Hon’ble TDSAT observed that “Indisputably, the TRAI had prescribed
forbearance throughout. In that view of the matter, there cannot be doubt or
dispute that the parties could enter into any bilateral contract……”
17. Recently a Writ Petition (Civil) No. 198 of 2013 was filed by a Consumer
Organisation before Hon’ble Supreme Court. The Petitioner contended that
levy of 10 Paise per SMS insisted by certain operators in their bilateral
agreements under the guise of termination charges is responsible for
increasing the base tariff of SMS many fold. As per the petitioner, the
operators are jointly exploiting TRAI’s regulations that had kept the tariffs for
SMS under forbearance. The petitioner is therefore aggrieved by TRAI’s
inaction on fixing the cost based tariffs and termination charges for SMSs.
Hon’ble Supreme court has issued notice in which TRAI is required to file its
reply within four weeks.
18. In the light of developments in last one to two years, which has resulted in a
number of litigations and uncertainty in the sector, the Authority noted that
the policy of forbearance on SMS termination charge has worked satisfactorily
in the past when the use of SMS by the subscriber was limited. In the
changed circumstances especially due to exponential increase in the number
of commercial SMSs, large imbalance in SMS traffic between the networks of
interconnecting service provider, unilateral imposition of SMS termination
charge and in case of non agreement, disconnection by some dominant
service providers and growing litigations amongst the service providers, the
Authority has decided to review the policy of forbearance in SMS termination
charges. In order to create certainty in the market, exigencies created by
certain dominant players and in order to protect the interests of the
9
consumers, prescribing cost based termination charges for SMS has also
become need of the hour.
19. In continuation to its consultation paper, the Authority vide its letter dated
13.12.2012, also asked all the service providers regarding the international
practices with regard to SMS termination charge, network element used for
providing SMS termination, cost data and costing methodology for estimating
SMS termination charge. Many of the service providers have reiterated their
stand of Bill and Keep for SMS termination charge as they have submitted in
their comments on the consultation paper dated 27.04.2011. In support of
their suggestion of Bill and Keep, they have also submitted international
practices in this regard. These service providers have submitted that in case,
TRAI decides to prescribe SMS termination charge, it should be strictly on the
basis of cost and according to their submission it should be less than 1 paise.
20. In response to the letter dated 13.12.2012, some of the service providers
submitted network element wise cost bifurcation and cost estimation model
for determination of SMS termination charge. According to their submissions
the SMS termination charge ranges from 0.76 paisa per SMS to 10.4 Paise per
SMS. These service providers were called for meeting in TRAI to explain the
costing methodology used by them for estimating SMS termination charge.
During the meeting they showed their cost model estimating SMS termination
charge. Some of the service providers in their submission stated that Fully
Allocated Cost (FAC) model should be adopted in India for determining SMS
termination charge.
21. In the estimation submitted by one of the service providers, the SMS
termination charge was worked out as 10.4 paise per SMS. In its model, it
has taken 4.4% of their network cost as capital cost for earmarked capacity
for SMS and also 4.4% of total cost per year as network operating cost of
earmarked capacity for SMS. When asked to explain the rationale behind
allocation of 4.4% of total cost towards SMS cost, it stated that it will revert
10
to TRAI and provide requisite information if any. The service provider has not
submitted any further information.
22. Another service provider has estimated the SMS termination charge as 9.46
paisa per SMS. In its model it has estimated total SMS traffic in Erlang per
site in busy hour for their network and then based on estimated cost per
Erlang for different network elements used in delivering SMS to the
consumer, calculated the SMS termination charge. After an extensive
discussions, the service provider submitted a revised model to TRAI. As per
the revised model, the SMS termination charge comes out to be 8.34 paisa
per SMS. In this revised model, the SDCCH Erlang traffic was assumed to be
same as TCH Erlang traffic. In the discussions with them, it was pointed out
that the SDCCH Erlang traffic is not equal to the TCH Erlang traffic and it was
asked to provide technical documents to support this assumption. The service
provider has not submitted any documents further to support their
assumption.
23. The service provider referred in above para also submitted that they are
against Bill and Keep (B&K) approach for SMS termination charge since it is
neither consistent with the principles of cost base and work done nor an
effective deterrent to control the menace of spam. In this regard they have
submitted that Hon’ble TDSAT vide its judgement dated 29.09.2010, clearly
stated that IUC /MTC should be cost based and include all cost- CAPEX, OPEX
and depreciation. Hence the consideration of Bill and Keep (nil charge) for
any component of IUC is simply no longer an option available to the
Authority. In this regard the service provider quoted following para of Hon’ble
TDSAT:
“…Its (TRAI’s) jurisdiction being limited to determine the charges on cost
based and work done principle….”[101(5)].
“…It is not in controversy that the service providers are required to be
compensated for the resources used by other service providers.” [114(12)]
11
24. The Authority observed that the network used for delivering voice calls/ data
services is the same for delivering SMS also. Therefore, allocation of
proportionate cost for delivery of SMS plays an important role while
estimating SMS termination charge. Variation in different cost models is also
because of allocation of different proportion of the cost towards SMS
termination charge by different service providers. Even in Accounting
Separation Report (ASR), service providers have used different cost driver for
allocation of cost towards SMS which has led to wide variation among service
providers on SMS termination charges.
25. The Authority noted that cost can be divided into two parts: (a) network cost
and (b) cost other than network element; network cost corresponding to SMS
can be proportionate on the basis of network usage by SMSs. Accordingly on
the basis of BTS configuration, number of time slot allocated for SMSs for
different BTS configuration, average holding time of SMS (SDCCH seconds)
submitted by the service providers, the Authority has estimated percentage
Contribution of SMS on wireless network resources of the operators with
various BTS configurations for all service providers, as per Annexure 1.
26. With regard to cost other than network cost like administrative cost etc., the
Authority is of the opinion that it may not be appropriate that such costs also
be allocated towards SMSs on the basis of % contribution of SMS in the
wireless resource of operators. However, as any other cost driver for
allocation of these costs will have subjectivity and may be contested by
service providers, the Authority decided that such cost may be taken directly
from the Accounting Separation Report as submitted by various service
providers under the head of SMS.
27. The summary of results of top five operators on the basis of subscriber base
are as follows:
12
(Rs. in crore)
WIRELESS SEGMENT (ASR 2011-12)
Particulars Service Providers
A B C D E F Industry
average
Capital Employed
(As per Proforma F of ASR –
Wireless Segment)
As per ASR data submitted by service providers
185392
Return on Capital Employed @
15% (A)
27809
Network Element Operating
Cost (including Depreciation)
(As per Proforma B of ASR –
Wireless Segment) (B)
64231
Average number of SMS
(outgoing + incoming) per
subscriber per month (m)
103 78 131 30 82 77 81
No. of SMS per subs in a busy hour
(n=m/(30*10))
0.34 0.26 0.44 0.10 0.27 0.26 0.27
Relevant Cost to SMS :
% contribution on Wireless
Network Resources by SMS
services (x%)
(calculated from Annexure I of
Explanatory Memorandum of
Regulations)
0.93% 0.70% 1.19% 0.27% 0.74% 0.70% 0.74%
Return on Capital Employed for
SMS (x% of A) (a)
Calculation based on ASR data
204
Network Element operating
Cost for SMS (including
Depreciation) (x%
of B) (b)
472
Cost other than Network
Element Cost
(As per directly allocated to
SMS segment in Proforma B of
ASR)
(c)
688
Relevant Cost to SMS
(a+b+c)
1364
Number of SMS (O/G + I/C) (
in crore)
83764
Cost per SMS (Paisa) 1.53 1.42 2.53 0.84 1.05 0.77 1.63
Cost per SMS (Paisa) after
Loading License Fee and Govt
Chargs @ 12%
1.74 1.42 2.87 0.96 1.20 0.87 1.85
Note:
(i) Information submitted by service providers in Accounting Separation Report (ASR)
(ii) Wireless Segment: Network Element Cost is as per Proforma B and also includes depreciation
(iii) Cost other than Network Element Cost includes Admn Cost, Employees cost, Maintenance
cost, Other cost and Support Functions/ Deptt cost. It does not include LF, Govt. Charges,
Sales & Marketing cost and Finance Charges.
(iv) Loading (x%) factor was calculated from Annexure-1.
(v) Cost Other than Network Element are as directly allocated to SMS Service by Service
Providers in Proforma B of ASR.
13
28. The information furnished by service providers in ASR is confidential.
Therefore, name of the service providers and cost data submitted by them
are not mentioned in the above table. From the above table, it may be seen
that the SMS termination charge varies from 0.87 paisa to 2.87 paisa and the
Industry average is 1.85 paisa per SMS. In this exercise, total CAPEX of
wireless network submitted by the service providers has been suitably
apportioned on the basis of percentage Contribution of SMS on wireless
network resources of the operators but the operational cost has been taken
as submitted by the service providers in their ASR. In case, the total OPEX of
wireless network is also apportioned on the same basis as used for CAPEX
allocation towards SMS, the SMS termination charge comes out to be 1.1
Paise.
29. In the above Table, the cost of termination charge of operator C comes 2.87
paisa per SMS. On examination, it was observed that operator C has allocated
relatively very high cost towards ‘cost other than network elements’. If this
cost is normalized either with the similarly situated operator or with the
industry average, SMS termination charge for this operator works out to be
around 1.8 paisa per minute.
30. Keeping in view all the above analysis the Authority decided that cost based
SMS termination charge should be Re. 0.02 (Paise 2 only) per SMS.
31. Some of the large Telecom Service Providers (TSP) submitted that the smaller
operators are selling bulk SMSs to the telemarketers at comparatively cheap
price. Their contention is that the revenue earned by such service providers
through the sale of bulk SMS is primarily because they are able to send large
number of A2P SMS to their subscribers. As their subscriber base is large
compared to the subscriber base of such service providers, there is a
substantial traffic imbalance between the two networks. These service
providers further contended that as such service providers are earning
14
revenue because of the investment done by them for acquiring customers and
building the networks, in their opinion they should also be given a part of
such revenue. To take care of such externalities and to ensure that the
service providers continue to invest in building up the networks, the Authority
had earlier prescribed a promotional SMS charge of Re.0.05 on promotional
SMS sent by registered telemarketer in the Telecom Commercial
Communications Customer Preference Regulations, 2010 (6 of 2010). While
doing this exercise, the Authority has observed that apart from promotional
SMSs, there is a large traffic imbalance between different networks on
account of transactional SMSs also. Hence, with these amendments, the
Authority has also simultaneously amended the Telecom Commercial
Communications Customer Preference Regulations, 2010 (6 of 2010) to
prescribe a transactional SMS charge of Re.0.05 per transactional SMS.
15
Annexure-I
Following tables calculate % contribution of SMS on wireless network resources of
the operators with various BTS configurations:
A. SMS Traffic per subscriber in busy hour
S.No. Item Legend Value Remarks
1
No. of SMS per
subscriber per month
a 81
Source: SMS Data submitted by service
providers:
No. of SMS per subscriber per month
(outgoing + incoming)
2
No. of SMS per
subscriber in a busy
hour
b=a/(30*10) 0.27
No. of SMS per subscriber in a busy hour=
No. of SMS per subscriber in a month/ (No. of
days in a month *Equivalent no. of busy
hours in a day)
B. No. of SDCCH Erlang due to SMS per subs in a busy hour
S.No. Item Legend Value Remarks
3
Average holding time
of SMS
(SDCCH seconds)
c 5
Generally 4-5 seconds are required to
transmit an SMS across the SDCCH. Source:
Technical Information Bulletin- SMS over SS7.
4
Provisioned holding
time of SMS
(SDCCH seconds)
d=c*1.3 6.5
Provision of 30% more than average holding
time is taken to cater for bouncing busy hour.
5
No. of SDCCH Erlang
per SMS
e=d/3600 0.0018 SDCCH Erlang = Holding time in second / 3600
6
No. of SDCCH Erlang
due to SMS per
subscriber in a busy
hour
f=e*b 0.00049
= No. of SDCCH Erlang per SMS * No. of SMS
per subscriber in a busy hour
1
6
C
C
o
n
v
e
rs
io
n
F
a
ct
o
r
fo
r
S
D
C
C
H
E
rl
a
n
g
to
T
C
H
E
rl
a
n
g
S
.N
o
.
It
e
m
Le
g
e
n
d
V
a
lu
e
R
e
m
a
rk
s
1
B
T
S
C
o
n
fi
g
u
ra
ti
o
n
g
2
/2
/2
3
/3
/3
4
/3
/3
4
/4
/4
6
/6
/6
8
/8
/8
A
s
su
b
m
it
te
d
b
y
s
e
rv
ic
e
p
ro
vi
d
e
r
2
S
D
C
C
H
C
o
n
fi
g
u
ra
ti
o
n
h
1
/1
/1
1
/1
/1
1
/1
/1
2
/2
/2
2
/2
/2
2
/2
/2
A
s
su
b
m
it
te
d
b
y
se
rv
ic
e
p
ro
vi
d
e
r
3
N
o
.
o
f
ti
m
e
-s
lo
ts
fo
r
tr
a
ff
ic
i
n
a
B
T
S
i
1
4
/1
4
/1
4
2
2
/2
2
/2
2
3
0
/2
2
/2
2
2
9
/2
9
/2
9
4
5
/4
5
/4
5
6
1
/6
1
/6
1
A
s
p
e
r
D
is
cu
ss
io
n
w
it
h
s
e
rv
ic
e
p
ro
vi
d
e
rs
4
N
o
.
o
f
T
C
H
(T
ra
ff
ic
)
E
rl
a
n
g
s
p
e
r
se
ct
o
r
j
8
.2
1
4
.9
1
7
.2
2
1
3
5
.6
5
0
.6
A
s
p
e
r
E
rl
a
n
g
-B
t
a
b
le
a
t
2
%
G
O
S
T
h
e
a
v
e
ra
g
e
n
u
m
b
e
r
o
f
T
C
H
E
rl
a
n
g
f
o
r
th
e
C
o
n
fi
g
u
ra
ti
o
n
4
/3
/3
o
f
th
e
t
h
re
e
s
e
ct
o
rs
i
s
1
7
.2
E
.
5
N
o
.
o
f
S
D
C
C
H
E
rl
a
n
g
s
p
e
r
se
ct
o
r
k
2
.1
6
2
.1
6
2
.1
6
6
.6
6
6
.6
6
6
.6
6
A
s
p
e
r
E
rl
a
n
g
-B
t
a
b
le
a
t
0
.5
%
G
O
S
(
A
s
su
b
m
it
te
d
b
y
t
h
e
s
e
rv
ic
e
p
ro
vi
d
e
rs
:
2
.1
6
E
f
o
r
7
c
h
a
n
n
e
ls
a
n
d
6
.6
6
E
f
o
r
1
4
c
h
a
n
n
e
ls
)
6
N
o
.
o
f
T
C
H
E
rl
a
n
g
s
p
e
r
ti
m
e
sl
o
t
l=
j/
(
N
o
.
o
f
ti
m
e
s
lo
ts
fo
r
tr
a
ff
ic
in
a
se
ct
o
r)
0
.5
8
6
0
.6
7
7
0
.6
9
9
0
.7
2
4
0
.7
9
1
0
.8
3
0
=
T
C
H
(
T
ra
ff
ic
)
E
rl
a
n
g
s
p
e
r
se
ct
o
r/
N
o
.
o
f
T
C
H
p
e
r
se
ct
o
r
in
2
/2
/2
c
o
n
fi
g
u
ra
ti
o
n
=
8
.2
/1
4
7
N
o
.
o
f
S
D
C
C
H
E
rl
a
n
g
s
p
e
r
ti
m
e
sl
o
t
m
=
k
/
(N
o
.
o
f
ti
m
e
sl
o
ts
f
o
r
S
D
C
C
H
i
n
a
s
e
ct
o
r)
2
.1
6
2
.1
6
2
.1
6
3
.3
3
3
.3
3
3
.3
3
P
e
r
ti
m
e
s
lo
t
fo
r
S
D
C
C
H
c
h
a
n
n
e
ls
i
n
e
a
ch
s
e
ct
o
r.
8
C
o
n
ve
rs
io
n
F
a
ct
o
r
fo
r
S
D
C
C
H
E
rl
a
n
g
to
T
C
H
E
rl
a
n
g
n
=
l/
m
0
.2
7
1
0
.3
1
4
0
.3
2
3
0
.2
1
7
0
.2
3
8
0
.2
4
9
2
.7
3
S
D
C
C
H
E
rl
a
n
g
s
=
0
.5
8
6
T
C
H
E
rl
a
n
g
=
>
1
S
D
C
C
H
E
rl
a
n
g
=
0
.2
1
5
T
C
H
E
rl
a
n
g
1
7
D
%
C
o
n
tr
ib
u
ti
o
n
o
f
S
M
S
i
n
t
o
ta
l
lo
a
d
S
.
N
o
It
e
m
Le
g
e
n
d
V
a
lu
e
R
e
m
a
rk
s
9
N
o
.
o
f
S
u
b
sc
ri
b
e
rs
i
n
e
a
ch
s
e
ct
o
r
o
=
j/
0
.0
3
2
7
3
4
9
7
5
7
4
7
0
0
1
1
8
7
1
6
8
7
=
N
o
.
o
f
T
C
H
E
rl
a
n
g
s
p
e
r
se
ct
o
r/
0
.0
3
.
S
in
ce
T
C
H
E
rl
a
n
g
s
p
e
r
su
b
sc
ri
b
e
r
is
3
0
m
E
.
1
0
N
o
.
o
f
S
D
C
C
H
E
rl
a
n
g
s
g
e
n
e
ra
te
d
i
n
a
b
u
sy
h
o
u
r
fo
r
S
M
S
s
in
e
a
ch
s
e
ct
o
r
p
=
o
*
f
0
.1
3
3
0
.2
4
2
0
.2
8
0
0
.3
4
1
0
.5
7
9
0
.8
2
3
=
N
o
.
o
f
S
D
C
C
H
E
rl
a
n
g
s
d
u
e
t
o
S
M
S
p
e
r
su
b
s
in
b
u
sy
h
o
u
r
*
N
o
.
o
f
S
u
b
sc
ri
b
e
rs
i
n
e
a
ch
s
e
ct
o
r
1
1
N
o
.
o
f
S
D
D
C
H
E
rl
a
n
g
s
e
q
u
ip
p
e
d
fo
r
S
M
S
s
in
e
a
ch
se
ct
o
r
q
=
p
/0
.6
0
.2
2
2
0
.4
0
4
0
.4
6
7
0
.5
6
9
0
.9
6
4
1
.3
7
1
=
N
o
.
o
f
S
D
C
C
H
E
rl
a
n
g
s
g
e
n
e
ra
te
d
i
n
b
u
sy
h
o
u
r
fo
r
S
M
S
s
in
e
a
ch
s
e
ct
o
r/
0
.6
(
U
ti
li
za
ti
o
n
f
a
ct
o
r
a
s
su
b
m
it
te
d
b
y
se
rv
ic
e
p
ro
vi
d
e
rs
)
1
2
E
q
u
iv
a
le
n
t
n
o
.
o
f
T
C
H
E
rl
a
n
g
s
fo
r
S
M
S
in
e
a
ch
s
e
ct
o
r
r=
q
*
n
0
.0
6
0
0
.1
2
7
0
.1
5
1
0
.1
2
4
0
.2
2
9
0
.3
4
1
=
N
o
.
o
f
S
D
D
C
H
E
rl
a
n
g
s
e
q
u
ip
p
e
d
f
o
r
S
M
S
s
in
e
a
ch
se
ct
o
r*
co
n
v
e
rs
io
n
f
a
ct
o
r
1
3
%
co
n
tr
ib
u
ti
o
n
o
f
S
M
S
in
th
e
to
ta
l
lo
a
d
s=
1
0
0
*
r/
j
0
.7
3
%
0
.8
5
%
0
.8
8
%
0
.5
9
%
0
.6
4
%
0
.6
7
%
=
1
0
0
*
E
q
u
iv
a
le
n
t
T
C
H
E
rl
a
n
g
s
fo
r
S
M
S
s
p
e
r
se
ct
o
r/
N
o
.
o
f
T
C
H
E
rl
a
n
g
s
p
e
r
se
ct
o
r
1
4
%
B
T
S
M
ix
o
f
o
n
e
o
p
e
ra
to
r
t
5
%
3
0
%
1
4
%
1
8
%
2
4
%
9
%
A
s
p
ro
vi
d
e
d
b
y
o
n
e
s
e
rv
ic
e
p
ro
vi
d
e
r
in
i
ts
c
o
st
m
o
d
e
l
d
a
te
d
0
8
.0
2
.2
0
1
3
1
5
%
C
o
n
tr
ib
u
ti
o
n
o
f
S
M
S
i
n
t
h
e
t
o
ta
l
lo
a
d
u
=
s*
t
0
.7
4
%
W
e
ig
h
te
d
a
v
e
ra
g
e
s
u
m
o
f
%
c
o
n
tr
ib
u
ti
o
n
o
f
S
M
S
i
n
t
h
e
to
ta
l
lo
a
d
=
B
%
c
o
n
tr
ib
u
C
o
n
o
f
S
M
S
*
%
B
T
S
M
ix
Previous and next
All provisions of Short Message Services (SMS) Termination Charges Regulations, 2013
Questions people ask
Is regulation 3 of Short Message Services (SMS) Termination Charges Regulations, 2013 still in force?
No repeal of Short Message Services (SMS) Termination Charges Regulations, 2013 is recorded.