Regulation 5, The International Telecommunication Cable Landing Stations Access Facilitation Charges and Co-location Charges Regulations, 2012: Review
The International Telecommunication Cable Landing Stations Access Facilitation Charges and Co-location Charges Regulations, 2012 - Regulation 5
Text of regulation 5
Review
5. Review-------(1) The Authority may, from time to time, review and
modify Access Facilitation charges and co-location charges.
7
SCHEDULE-I
ANNUAL ACCESS FACILITATION CHARGES
TABLE-I
ANNUAL ACCESS FACILITATION CHARGES AT CABLE LANDING
STATIONS
Sl.No. Per Unit Capacity Access Facilitation Charges Per Unit
Capacity Per Annum (In Rs.)
(i) STM-1 36,000
(ii) STM-4 93,000
(iii) STM-16 2,40,000
(iv) STM-64 6,25,000
TABLE-II
ANNUAL ACCESS FACILITATION CHARGES AT
ALTERNATE LOCATION
Sl.No. Per Unit Capacity Access Facilitation Charges Per Unit
Capacity Per Annum (In Rs.)
(i) STM-1 1,11,000
(ii) STM-4 2,88,000
(iii) STM-16 7,50,000
(iv) STM-64 19,50,000
8
SCHEDULE-II
ANNUAL OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE CHARGES FOR CAPACITY
PROVIDED ON IRU BASIS
TABLE-A
ANNUAL OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE CHARGES AT CABLE
LANDING STATIONS FOR CAPACITY PROVIDED ON IRU BASIS
Sl.No. Per Unit Capacity Operation and Maintenance
Charges Per Unit Capacity Per
Annum (In Rs.)
(i) STM-1 19,000
(ii) STM-4 48,000
(iii) STM-16 1,24,000
(iv) STM-64 3,23,000
TABLE-B
ANNUAL OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE CHARGES AT ALTERNATE
LOCATION FOR CAPACITY PROVIDED ON IRU BASIS
Sl.No. Per Unit Capacity Operation and Maintenance
Charges Per Unit Capacity Per
Annum (In Rs.)
(i) STM-1 58,000
(ii) STM-4 1,50,000
(iii) STM-16 3,89,000
(iv) STM-64 10,10,000
9
SCHEDULE-III
CO-LOCATION CHARGES
Sl.No. Description Co-location Charges Per Rack (Rack
space= 16 sq.ft.) Per Annum (In Rs.)
(i) For Mumbai 6,00,000 (upto 2KW Power)
(ii) For cities other than
Mumbai
4,00,000 (upto 2KW Power)
Rajeev Agrawal
Secretary
Note. -------The Explanatory Memorandum explains the objects and
reasons of the International Telecommunication Cable Landing Stations
Access Facilitation Charges and Co-location Charges Regulations, 2012.
10
EXPLANATORY MEMORANDUM TO ‘THE INTERNATIONAL
TELECOMMUNICATION CABLE LANDING STATIONS ACCESS
FACILITATION CHARGES AND CO-LOCATION CHARGES
REGULATIONS, 2012 (27 of 2012)’
A. Introduction
1. TRAI issued ‘International Telecommunication Access to Essential
Facilities at Cable Landing Stations Regulations, 2007’ on
07.06.2007. The Regulations provides that the owner of cable
landing station (OCLS) shall provide access to any eligible Indian
International Telecommunication Entity (ITE) on fair and non-
discriminatory terms and conditions, at its cable landing stations.
It further provides that OCLS is required to submit a ‘Cable landing
Station Reference Interconnect Offer (CLS RIO)’ to TRAI, in a
specified format, containing the terms and conditions of access
facilities and co-location facilities including landing facilities for
sub-marine cables at its cable landing stations for its approval.
After getting approval from TRAI, OCLSs are required to publish
the RIO. Accordingly, in 2007, after approval of the Authority,
owners of cable landing stations published their RIO containing
access facilitation charges and co-location charges.
2. In order to further review the Access Facilitation and Co-location
charges, TRAI issued a consultation paper on ‘Access Facilitation
Charges and Co-location Charges at Cable Landing Stations’ on
22.03.2012. On the basis of comments received from the
stakeholders, the Authority noted that since the process of
approval of the charges involve scrutiny by TRAI of costing
elements considered, costs and costing methodology employed by
OCLS, discussion with OCLS and final approval by TRAI, it takes
time and provides competitive advantage to the owner of cable
landing station as OCLS is also integrated operator owning
bandwidth in submarine cable system. The Authority further
noted that though the work done in providing Access Facilitation is
11
same irrespective of specific cable landing station, the Access
Facilitation and Co-location charges varies between different
operators based on their network configuration and costing
methodology.
3. In view of the above, on 19th October, 2012, the Authority has
issued International Telecommunication Access to Essential
Facilities at Cable Landing Stations (Amendment) Regulations,
2012, wherein suitable provisions have been made for specifying
Access Facilitation Charges, Co-location Charges and other related
charges like Cancellation Charges and Restoration Charges.
4. Further, on the basis of cost data and comments received from
stakeholders, TRAI has estimated such charges and issued another
consultation paper titled “Estimation of Access Facilitation Charges
and Co-location Charges at Cable Landing Stations”
simultaneously on 19th October, 2012 for further comments and
counter comments of stakeholders by 6th November, 2012and 14th
November, 2012 respectively.
B. Comments received from stakeholders on the Consultation
paper dated 19th October, 2012:
5. On the Consultation Paper dated 19.10.2012, 22 stakeholders
including 19 service providers, 2 associations and 3 others have
sent written comments that were uploaded on TRAI’s website.
Counter comments were received from 12 stakeholders including 2
associations and 10 service providers.
C. Examination of the main comments/ issues raised by the
stakeholders:
6. Stakeholders have generally agreed to the costing methodology
adopted by TRAI. However, M/s. Tata Communications has
submitted that Access Facilitation Charges should have been
12
estimated as per the network architecture employed by Tata
Communications Ltd. and TRAI should not have taken different
network design for the calculations. M/s. Tata Communications
have also indicated few cost elements which according to them
have not been considered in the calculation of such charges.
Similarly, M/s. Bharti Airtel Ltd. have also submitted that costing
data and methodology applied to arrive at proposed charges by
TRAI are not very clearly understood and there are items which
have not been considered in arriving at the cost. They have
submitted that the cost elements that form a part of arriving at
Access Facilitation Charges as submitted by them in their earlier
submissions should be considered fully.
7. To provide fair opportunity to these service providers and
understand their point of view meetings with M/s. Tata and M/s.
Bharti Airtel were held on 29.11.2012 and 04.12.2012 respectively.
In the meetings cost data, costing methodology used by TRAI was
discussed in detail.
8. Based on the discussion held in the above meetings and
submission of stakeholders in response to the consultation paper,
Access Facilitation Charges both at Cable Landing Stations and
alternate location have been re-estimated with the cost data
submitted by these two service providers. Subsequent paragraphs
give a detail explanation on the costing methodology adopted to
arrive at the revised charges given in the regulations.
D. Estimation of Access Facilitation Charges:
(i) Network Elements considered:
9. After several discussions with the OCLSs and also taking into
consideration the submissions made by various stakeholders, TRAI
identified network elements required for estimating access
13
facilitation charges at cable landing station and alternate location
and indicated in the Figure-1 and Figure-2 of the consultation
paper dated 19.10.2012. Both the figures are reproduced below for
ready reference:
Figure-1 of the Consultation Paper dated 19.10.2012
Figure-2 of the Consultation Paper dated 19.10.2012
10. In response to the consultation paper a large number of the service
providers have reiterated that for providing access facilitation at
Cable Landing station DXC (Digital Cross Connect) equipments is
not required. According to them the cost of DXC equipment at CLS
is borne by the consortium. They also submitted that similarly
requirement of DXC after DWDM at alternate location is not
required. Hence they suggested that DXC and its related costs
should be excluded from the calculations. They have also
Access Facilitation at Cable Landing Station
Submarine Cable
O
D
F
DXC
O
D
F
Access Facilitation at Alternate Co-location
Submarine Cable
DWDM DWDM
O
D
F
DXC
O
D
F
DUCT
&
Optical Fible
Cable
O
D
F
DXC
O
D
F
O
D
F
O
D
F
14
submitted that all types of interfaces needed by the ITEs for access
facilitation are provided by the consortium. On the other hand,
M/s. TCL and M/s. Bharti Airtel were of the view that Access
Facilitation Charges should be estimated as per the architecture
design adopted by them and should not be based on any other
model. As per them, DXC is an integral part of their network design
and therefore costs related to DXC needs to be included in the
estimation.
11. The Authority has considered the above submissions and has
decided to include the costs related to DXC both at CLS and
alternate locations.
(ii) CAPEX items used for provisioning of AFC at CLS and
Alternate location
12. CAPEX items used for providing access facilitation at cable landing
station and alternate location were listed in Table 1 and Tables
2(a), 2(b) and 2(c), of the consultation paper respectively.
13. On the CAPEX items considered in the consultation paper, M/s
TCL was of the view that costs incurred for manpower for
Installation, Network Management System (NMS) and test
equipments both at CLS and alternate location have not been
considered by TRAI in the calculations. Considering the
submission made by M/s TCL, the above CAPEX elements as
suggested by M/s TCL have been now included. The revised Tables
of CAPEX items used for providing access facilitation at cable
landing station and alternate location are listed below in Table-A
and Tables-B, respectively.
15
Table-A
CAPEX items used for access facilitation at CLS
Sl.No. Description
(i) ODF (Optical Distribution Frame)
(ii) Digital Cross Connect (DXC)
(iii) Fiber Patch Cords
(iv) Inter Floor cabling and tray work
(v) Manpower towards installation
(vi) NMS
(vii) Test Instruments
(viii) Project Management cost
Table-B (i)
CAPEX items used for access facilitation at alternate location
(At CLS Access Section)
Sl.No. Description
i ODF (Optical Distribution Frame)
ii Digital Cross Connection
iii DWDM Equipment
iv Fiber Patch Cords
v Inter Floor cabling and tray work
vi Manpower towards installation
vii NMS
viii Test Instruments
ix Project Management cost
Table-B (ii)
CAPEX items used for access facilitation at alternate location
(Link between CLS Access Section and MMR)
Sl.No. Description
i Fiber between CLS and MMR
Table-B (iii)
CAPEX items used for access facilitation at alternate location
(At MMR Section)
Sl.No. Description
i ODF (Optical Distribution Frame)
ii Digital Cross Connection
iii DWDM Equipment
iv Fiber Patch Cords
v Inter Floor cabling and tray work
vi Manpower towards installation
vii NMS
viii Test Instruments
ix Project Management cost
16
(iii) Cost data used for the CAPEX items
14. In the consultation paper, cost for each CAPEX item for providing
one STM64 (10G) was derived from the costs submitted by both
OCLSs. As per the data submitted by them for their CLSs at
Mumbai, one OCLS is using a DXC with 640 G capacity, while the
other OCLS is using 4 DXCs with 120 G capacity each for providing
access facilitation. Therefore, in the consultation paper, in order to
calculate the cost for provision of one 10 G/ STM-64, the cost of
fully loaded DXC i.e. loaded with only 10 G/ STM-64 cards in all
slots in protected mode was taken.
15. In their comments, both M/s Bharti Airtel and TCL submitted that
though it is feasible to equip the DXC with all 10 G interfaces,
keeping in view the existing demand of the sector, the DXC are
normally equipped with different interfaces i.e. STM-1, STM4,
STM16 and STM-64 in varying numbers. They suggested that
design capacity should be taken on the basis of market projections
and while designing this capacity TRAI should ensure that all
interface i.e. STM-1, STM4, STM16 and STM-64 are available in the
equipment. TRAI has considered their submission and discussed
different combinations for provisioning of interfaces in DXC with
them. As per the discussions with them and demand projection for
various interfaces and capacity of DXC used by them, the network
design has been modified for 60 G capacity ensuring availability of
all interfaces i.e. STM-1, STM4, STM16 and STM-64 and AFC both
at CLS and alternate location has been re estimated. However,
while estimating the AFC at alternate location, the DXC used at
CLS access section has been loaded with STM-64 (10G) cards only
for delivering 60 G capacity in protection mode. Following Table
(Table-C) provides DXC configuration taken for 60 G capacity in
protection mode.
17
Table-C
DXC configuration for 60-G Capacity
Sl.No. Interface Total No. of
interfaces
No. of interfaces
available (in
protection mode)at
client side for sale
Equivalent
Capacity in
Gbps
(i) STM-1 128 64 10
(ii) STM-4 32 16 10
(iii) STM-16 32 08 20
(iv) STM-64 16 02 20
Total 60
16. For the access facilitation at alternate location, the costs submitted
by OCLSs for fibre link and DWDM have been also apportioned for
carrying 60 G capacity. Similarly the cost of passive network
elements i.e. ODF, fiber patch cord, inter floor cabling and tray
work have been appropriately apportioned for provisioning of 60G,
on the basis of cost data submitted by these OCLSs for respective
passive elements.
17. M/s TCL has submitted that the TRAI has taken cost from
Purchase Order(PO) submitted by them which does not include
taxes paid to various agencies by TCL. Accordingly, in the revised
calculations, Taxes @ 18% have been taken into account. M/s TCL
has also submitted that the project management cost, which was
allowed by TRAI as 10% of CAPEX items, should be based on
actual costs. As per the data submitted by M/s TCL their project
management cost was around 6% of the CAPEX. The other OCLS
viz. M/s Bharti Airtel in its calculation has taken project
management cost as 10% of CAPEX items. Therefore, TRAI has
taken project management cost @ 10% of CAPEX.
18. Both the OCLSs had provided the costs of the equipments in US
Dollars. In the consultation paper, conversion rate used was Rs.50
18
for 1 US Dollar. On the basis of submissions by the service
providers and the period of Purchase Orders submitted by the
OCLSs, the conversion rate has been revised upward from Rs. 50
to Rs. 52.
19. The apportioned capital cost for 60 G (in protection mode) for each
CAPEX item for OCLS-1 and OCLS-2, for access facilitation at CLS
is given in the following Table-D. Keeping in view the commercial
sensitivity of data, details of items and names of the OCLSs have
not been provided.
Table-D
Apportioned Capital Cost for 60 G (in protected mode) used for
Access Facilitation (in Rs.)
Sl.No. CAPEX item OCLS-1 OCLS-2
(i) Apportioned Capital Cost for 60 G (in
protected mode) used for Access
Facilitation at CLS
1,34,31,961 1,03,47,315
(ii)(a) Apportioned Capital Cost for 60-G (in
protected mode) used for Access
Facilitation at Alternate location (For
both CLS Access and MMR Section)
3,58,16,799 3,06,08,722
(ii)(b) Apportioned Capital Cost for Optical
Fiber Link between CLS and MMR
7,80,000 32,25,000
(iv) Annual recovery of capital cost:
20. Following parameters have been used for estimating annualized
capital cost in the consultation paper:
(i) Life of network element (except optical fiber) = 10 years
(ii) Life of link of optical fiber between CLS and MMR = 18 years
(iii) Method of depreciation = Straight Line Method (SLM)
(iv) Pre-tax WACC = 15%
21. In response to the consultation paper, most of the stakeholders
agreed on value of Pre-tax WACC and Straight Line Method (SLM)
to workout depreciation for each year. However, M/s TCL
submitted that Pre tax WACC has to be taken at 23.9% while M/s
19
Bharti has suggested to use WACC as 20% as against 15%. TRAI
has analyzed the Accounting Separation Report of various telecom
service providers and found that pre-tax WACC @ 15% is
reasonable.
22. Regarding life of the equipment, M/s TCL has submitted that it
should be taken as 5 years instead of 10 years. However, most of
the stakeholders including M/s Bharti Airtel have supported for 10
years as life of equipment. Similarly, regarding life of Optical Fiber,
M/s TCL submitted that this should be taken as 15 years instead
of 18 years.
23. In its various other earlier regulations like IUC, Port Charges etc.,
wherein transmission equipments are also used, in order to
calculate the depreciation of the different network elements on a
uniform basis, TRAI has used Straight Line Method (SLM) adopting
an average asset life of 10 years. Therefore, in these calculations
also, the Authority has decided to continue with the assumption of
Life of the equipment as 10 years. However, keeping in view the
submissions of these two OCLSs, life of Optical Fiber link has been
revised as 15 years from 18 years.
(v) Operational cost
24. In the consultation paper TRAI has taken operational cost as 30%
of capital cost of network element.
25. M/s Bharti Airtel has submitted that OPEX is the cost of variable
factors and is based on market dynamics. Therefore, it cannot be a
fixed percentage of the CAPEX. M/s TCL has also submitted that
the linkage between CAPEX and OPEX is not linear. Both of the
service providers requested that rather than using a fixed %, actual
operating costs should be used.
20
26. Therefore, in the revised calculations, actual value of OPEX has
been estimated on the basis of data submitted by the two OCLS.
One of the OCLS has submitted market prevailing rental and
annualized cost of external fit out and internal fit-out for Mumbai.
On the basis of its data, TRAI had earlier in the consultation paper,
estimated the space charges for calculating the co-location charges.
Therefore, same estimated space charge for Mumbai has been now
used as space charges in these revised calculations for OPEX for
that OCLS. The other OCLS has submitted the Cost of land,
building and other fixture for their data center wherein it is
providing Access facilitation in place of prevailing market rent for
the space. For estimating space charges for this OCLS, RoCE of
15% has been provided for the cost of land (book value) as
submitted by the OCLS. Cost of building has been annualized by
taking 20 years life of building. For estimating annual cost of other
capital expenditure for fit-out etc, life has been taken as 10 years.
On both item Pre Tax WACC of 15% has been taken.
27. M/s Bharti has submitted that AMC for equipment and optical
fibre should be 4% and 3%. Accordingly, AMC of equipment and
Optical fiber has been revised as 4% and 3% of capital costs
respectively. As per accounting Separation report submitted by
service providers, employee cost for private telecom service
providers varies from 0.92% to 3.11% of Gross block. Therefore,
Manpower Cost has been taken as 2% of CAPEX.
28. Summary of various OPEX items taken and annual OPEX in the
revised calculations are given in Table-E and Table-F, respectively:
21
Table-E
OPEX ITEMS
Sl.No. Description
(i) AMC of equipments @ 4%
(ii) AMC of Optical Fiber @ 3%
(iii) Space Charges/Sq.ft./Annum for Mumbai (Including External
fit outs (transformers, DG sets, HT panels, LT panels, cables,
air conditioner), Internal fit outs (UPS, battery, internal
electrical panel, precision AC, power distribution units, fire
alarm and access control and cabling), Security services
charges)
@ for OCLS-1 Rs. 8636 and for OCLS-2 Rs.9926.
(iv) Electricity Charges @ Rs. 15.64 Per unit
(v) Manpower Cost @ 2% of CAPEX
(vi) Miscellaneous (Corporate Overhead, IT etc) @ 10% of OPEX
Table- F
OPEX for 60 G used for Access Facilitation (in Rs.)
Sl.No. item OCLS-1 OCLS-2
(i) OPEX for 60 G used for Access
Facilitation at CLS
19,93,789 25,01,028
(ii) OPEX for 60 G used for Access
Facilitation at Alternate location (For
both CLS Access and MMR Section)
69,69,511 78,30,337
(vi) Utilization
29. Utilization factor of 70% was taken into account in the estimation
of charges in consultation paper. In their comments to the
consultation paper, most of the stakeholders have supported the
utilization factor of 70% and mentioned that it is in-line with the
best international regulatory practices. Moreover in the revised
calculations, the network design has been revised for provision of
60G capacity with combination of all interfaces as suggested by the
two OCLSs. Therefore the Authority is of the view that the
utilisation factor of 70% is reasonable.
22
(vii) Calculation of Access Facilitation Charges
30. Estimation of access facilitation charges for 60G at CLS and MMR
are as follows:
Table-G
Calculation of Access Facilitation Charges (in Rs.)
for 60 G (in protected mode) at CLS
Sl.No. Description OCLS-1 OCLS-2
(a) Average Annualized CAPEX
(Annualised value of apportioned capital
cost indicated in item (i) of Table-D)
24,51,333 18,88,385
(b) OPEX per annum
(Item (i) of Table-F)
19,93,789 25,01,028
(c) Total Annual charges per annum {(a)+(b)} 44,45,122 43,89,413
(d) Total Annual charges per annum with
utilisation @ 70% {(c) ÷ 70%}
63,50,174 62,70,589
(e) Annual charges per annum (Including
Licence Fee @ 8%) {(d) ÷ (1-0.08)}
69,02,363 68,15,858
Table-H
Calculation of Access Facilitation Charges (in Rs.) for
60 G(in protected mode) at Alternate location
Sl.No. Description OCLS-1 OCLS-2
(a) Average Annualized CAPEX
{( Annualised value of apportioned capital
cost indicated in item (ii)(a) of Table-D) +
(Annualised value of apportioned capital
cost indicated in item (ii)(b) of Table-D)}
66,50,966 60,59,092
(b) OPEX per annum
(Item (ii) of Table-F)
69,69,511 78,30,337
(c) Total Annual charges per annum {(a)+(b)} 1,36,20,477 1,38,89,429
(d) Total Annual charges per annum with
utilisation @ 70% {(c) ÷ 70%}
1,94,57,824 1,98,42,042
(e) Annual charges per annum (Including
Licence Fee @ 8%) {(d) ÷ (1-0.08)}
2,11,49,808 2,15,67,437
31. TRAI is of the opinion that work done to provide access facilitation
at a cable landing station is same for all cable landing stations.
Therefore, it is not required to estimate the cost based charges
separately for each cable landing stations. The only variation could
be due to space and electricity charges if the cable landing stations
23
are located in two different cities. Therefore, in its calculations,
TRAI has used space and electricity charges for Mumbai, which are
the highest among various locations. During the consultation
process also, stakeholders were generally of the view that
determination of Access Facilitation charges, one for CLS and other
one for alternate location (MMR) would be adequate. As these
charges are ceiling charges, the Authority is of the opinion that
higher of the costs of the two OCLSs, calculated separately for CLS
and MMR may be taken for prescribing these charges.
(viii) Access Facilitation Charges for various capacities i.e. STM-1,
STM-4, STM-16 or STM-64
32. In the consultation paper, for estimating access facilitation charge
for lower capacities i.e. STM-1, STM-4 and STM-16 from 10 G/
STM-64 capacity, a conversion factor of 2.6 has been used keeping
in view two important factors in mind : (a) scale of economy for
higher capacities (b) prevailing market factor in domestic leased
circuit. Most of the stakeholders favored using the factor of 2.6.
However, the two OCLSs were of the view that using a factor of 4 is
more appropriate. They were also of the view that irrespective of the
conversion factor taken into account for the calculations, the
charges determined should be such that they are able to recover
their total cost for providing various capacity interfaces. Therefore,
keeping the submissions of the two OCLSs in view, in the revised
estimated charges, the charges of various capacity interfaces has
been calculated so that total cost is recovered from the interfaces
for which DXC has been configured.
Total Cost of 60 G
= [{(No of STM-1 Interfaces) *(AFC of one STM-1 Interface)} + {(No.
of STM-4 Interfaces) * (AFC of one STM 4 Interface)} + {(No. of
STM-16 Interface) * (AFC of one STM 16 Interface) + {(No. of
STM-64 Interface)* (AFC of one STM 64 Interfaces)}]
24
33. TRAI is of the opinion that if the higher factor of 4 as proposed by
OCLSs is used for calculation, then price of STM-1 will be very low
and price of STM 64 will be on higher side and this will also not
provide advantage of scale of economy for higher capacities.
Therefore, keeping in view the prevalent conversion factor in the
market which is also generally agreeable to most of the
stakeholders, TRAI has used factor of 2.6 in place of 4, ensuring
that the cost incurred is recovered. Accordingly, AFC for various
interfaces has been calculated using following formula:
Total Cost of 60 G
= [{(No of STM-1 Interfaces) *( AFC of one STM-1 Interface)} + {(No. of
STM-4 Interfaces) * (2.6)* (AFC of one STM-1 Interface} + {(No. of STM-
16 Interface) * (2.6*2.6) * (AFC of one STM-1 Interface)} + {(No. of STM-
64 Interface)* (2.6*2.6*2.6)* (AFC of one STM-1 Interfaces)}]
34. Accordingly, the charges for various interfaces comes out to be as
given in Table-I and Table-J.
Table-I
Access Facilitation Charges per annum (in Rs.) at
Cable Landing Station
Sl.
No.
Capacity Charges per unit Interface
OCLS-1 OCLS-2 Ceiling
prescribed
(a) STM-1 35,427 34,983 36,000
(b) STM-4
{(a)* 2.6}
92,111 90,956 93,000
(c) STM-16
{(b)* 2.6}
2,39,488 2,36,487 2,40,000
(d) STM-64
{(c)* 2.6}
6,22,669 6,14,866 6,25,000
25
Table-J
Access Facilitation Charges per annum (in Rs.) at
Alternate location (Meet Me Room)
Sl.
No.
Capacity Charges per unit Interface
OCLS-1 OCLS-2 Ceiling
prescribed
(a) STM-1 1,08,554 1,10,698 1,11,000
(b) STM-4
{(a)* 2.6}
2,82,241 2,87,814 2,88,000
(c) STM-16
{(b)* 2.6}
7,33,826 7,48,316 7,50,000
(d) STM-64
{(c)* 2.6}
19,07,946 19,45,621 19,50,000
(ix) Access facilitation charges on Indefeasible Right of Use (IRU)
basis:
35. In the consultation paper, the access facilitation charges were
estimated only on annual basis and Access facilitation charges on
IRU basis were not estimated.
36. On this issue, divergent views have been received from the
stakeholders. In this regard one of the main comments received
from an OCLS is that submarine cable life is much longer than the
life of network equipment used for provisioning of access
facilitation. According to them, if capacities are provided on IRU
basis then OCLS is bound to provide access facilitation for life of
the submarine cable which sometimes requires replacement of
network equipment to provide access facilitation without charging
any capital cost from the ITE.
37. Keeping in view the fact that AFC and Co-location charges are to be
periodically reviewed to reflect actual cost and life of submarine
cable is normally longer than the life of network equipment to
provide access facilitation, the Authority is of the view that there is
no need to prescribe charges on IRU basis for access facilitation
26
provided after the commencement of these regulations. However, to
maintain level playing field and to protect the interest of those ITEs
who have already entered into agreement on IRU basis before
commencement of these regulations, revised annual Operation and
Maintenance Charges on the basis of estimated OPEX may be
prescribed. For calculating annual operation and maintenance
charges for various interfaces same formulae as used for Annual
Access facilitation charges has been applied after utilization factor
of 70% on OPEX given in Table-F. Accordingly, Annual Operation
and Maintenance Charges for various interfaces are given in Table-
K and Table-L.
Table-K
Annual Operation and Maintenance Charges at Cable Landing
Stations for Capacity Provided on IRU basis
Sl.
No.
Capacity Operation and Maintenance Charges Per
Unit Capacity Per Annum (In Rs.)
OCLS-1 OCLS-2 Ceiling
prescribed
(a) STM-1 14,619 18,338 19,000
(b) STM-4
{(a)* 2.6}
38,010 47,680 48,000
(c) STM-16
{(b)* 2.6}
98,825 1,23,967 1,24,000
(d) STM-64
{(c)* 2.6}
2,56,945 3,22,315 3,23,000
Table-L
Annual Operation and Maintenance Charges at Alternate location
(Meet Me Room) for Capacity Provided on IRU basis
Sl.
No.
Capacity Operation and Maintenance Charges Per
Unit Capacity Per Annum (In Rs.)
OCLS-1 OCLS-2 Ceiling
prescribed
(a) STM-1 51,103 57,415 58,000
(b) STM-4
{(a)* 2.6}
1,32,867 1,49,278 1,50,000
(c) STM-16
{(b)* 2.6}
3,45,454 3,88,123 3,89,000
(d) STM-64
{(c)* 2.6}
8,98,181 10,09,119 10,10,000
27
(x) Restoration/ Cancelation Charge:
38. Presently the restoration charges specified by the two OCLS are
around Rs. 1,00,000. Stakeholders are generally of the view that
the existing charges are on higher side. Some of them suggested
that these charges should be revised downwards to around
Rs.10,000/-. One of the views expressed is that restoration charge
should be based on cost of reconnecting the relevant facilities.
Other view was that these charges should be based on percentage
of AFC, from 5% to 10%. M/s Bharti is of the view that as the
efforts required for restoring and cancelling the connection remain
the same, the present charges should be continued.
39. After analyzing the view, the Authority has decided that the
cancellation and restoration charges for a particular unit capacity
may be as per mutual agreement between the owner of the cable
landing station and eligible Indian International
Telecommunication Entity, subject to a ceiling of ten percent (10%)
of the Access Facilitation charges specified for that unit capacity in
Schedule-I to these regulations or Rs. One Lakh per unit capacity,
whichever is lower.
E. Co-Location Charges:
40. On the basis of data submitted by one OCLS, the co-location
charges for Chennai and Mumbai were estimated and provided in
the Consultation paper in Table 9(a) and 9(b) respectively. Space
charges on which mainly collocation charges depend are in the
same range as is evident from estimation of space charges by
taking cost of land, building and other fixture of data centre for
other OCLs. Some of the stakeholders preferred uniform Co-
location charge for all locations, while some of them suggested that
location based range for the collocation charges, based on cost
oriented principle may be prescribed. On the other hand M/s
Bharti and M/s TCL are of the view that unification of co-location
28
charges is not tenable. As per them there cannot be uniform
collocation charges for different locations as the factors
determining the collocation charges are location dependent.
Collocation charges are basically dependent on space and
electricity charges and as per the data submitted by the two
OCLSs, space and Electricity charges are higher in Mumbai as
compared to other cities. Therefore Authority is of the opinion that
one collocation charges for Mumbai and the other common for all
other cities may be prescribed.
Summary of the main results:
(i) Annual Access Facilitation Charges:
Table-M
Sl. No. Capacity Access Facilitation Charges Per Unit
Capacity Per annum (in Rs.)
At
Cable Landing
Station
At
Alternate location
(Meet Me Room)
(a) STM-1 36,000 1,11,000
(b) STM-4 93,000 2,88,000
(c) STM-16 2,40,000 7,50,000
(d) STM-64 6,25,000 19,50,000
(ii) Annual Operation And Maintenance Charges for Capacity
Provided on IRU Basis:
Table-N
Sl.No. Per Unit
Capacity
Operation and Maintenance Charges Per
Unit Capacity Per Annum (In Rs.)
At Cable Landing
Station
At Alternate location
(Meet Me Room)
(i) STM-1 19,000 58,000
(ii) STM-4 48,000 1,50,000
(iii) STM-16 1,24,000 3,89,000
(iv) STM-64 3,23,000 10,10,000
29
(iii) Cancellation Charges and Restoration Charges: Subject to a
ceiling of ten percent of the Access Facilitation charges specified
for that unit capacity in Schedule-I to these regulations or Rs.
One Lakh per unit capacity, whichever is lower.
(iv) Co-location Charges:
Table-O
Sl.No. Description Co-location Charges Per Rack
(Rack space= 16 sq.ft.) Per
Annum (In Rs.)
(i) For Mumbai 6,00,000 (upto 2KW Power)
(ii) For Cities other than
Mumbai
4,00,000 (upto 2KW Power)
**********
Previous and next
Questions people ask
Is regulation 5 of the International Telecommunication Cable Landing Stations Access Facilitation Charges and Co-location Charges Regulations, 2012 still in force?
No repeal of the International Telecommunication Cable Landing Stations Access Facilitation Charges and Co-location Charges Regulations, 2012 is recorded.