Regulation 23, Standards of Quality of Service (Broadcasting and Cable Services) (Cable Television – Non-CAS Areas) Regulations, 2009.: Any cable subscriber may, at any time,
Standards of Quality of Service (Broadcasting and Cable Services) (Cable Television – Non-CAS Areas) Regulations, 2009. - Regulation 23
Text of regulation 23
Any cable subscriber may, at any time,
23. Any cable subscriber may, at any time,--
(a) during pendency of redressal of his grievance under these regulations; or
(b) before filing of complaint under these regulations,
exercise his right conferred upon him under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 (68 of
1986) or the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997, or any other law for the
time being in force and seek redressal of his grievance under that Act or law as the case
12
may be.
24. The provisions of these Regulations shall also be enforceable by any person to whom
the Authority may, by a general or special order, delegate powers for that purpose under
the relevant provisions of the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997 (24 of
1997).
R. N. CHOUBEY,
Principal Advisor (B&CS)
Note:-- The Explanatory Memorandum annexed to these regulations explains the objects
and reasons of the Standards of Quality of Service (Broadcasting and Cable Services)
(Cable Television – Non-CAS Areas) Regulations, 2009.
13
Annexure
EXPLANATORY MEMORANDUM
A. Background
1. There has been an exponential growth in the Indian Cable TV industry in the past two
decades. From just 410,000 Cable TV homes in early 1992, the number of Cable TV
homes has increased to 85 millions by the end of December 2008, being served by an
estimated 60,000 cable operators. During this period, the number of permitted
television channels has increased to about 400 channels.
2. As per section 11(1)(b)(v) of the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997 as
amended, TRAI is required to discharge the following function:
“(v) lay-down the standards of quality of service to be provided by the service
providers and ensure the quality of service and conduct the periodical survey of
such service provided by the service providers so as to protect interest of the
consumers of telecommunication services.”
3. Soon after broadcasting and cable services came under purview of TRAI in January
2004, the Authority in its recommendations on “Issues Relating to Broadcasting and
Distribution of TV Channels” dated October 01, 2004, had discussed the Quality of
Service (QoS) codes and guidelines for the cable TV industry in India. At that time, the
Authority had felt that the quality of service regulations may be issued only when the
enforcement mechanism is in place.
4. Subsequently, in a writ petition filed by a group of MSOs, a Single Judge Bench of the
Hon’ble High Court of Delhi, on 10th March 2006, directed that the Conditional
Access System (CAS) be implemented within a period of 4 weeks. In an appeal filed by
Union of India against this direction, a Division Bench of the Hon’ble High Court of
Delhi had on 20th July 2006, directed implementation of CAS in notified areas of
Delhi, Mumbai and Kolkata by 31st December 2006. Therefore, before roll out of CAS
in parts of Delhi, Mumbai and Kolkata on December 31, 2006, the Authority had
issued quality of service regulations for cable services only in CAS areas on August 23,
2006. At the time of issuance of this Regulation for CAS areas, it was indicated that the
14
Authority would address the quality of service regulations for direct to home (DTH)
and for Non-CAS areas separately at an appropriate time. Subsequently, the Authority
had also issued Quality of Service Regulations on August 31, 2007 for DTH services.
5. The Cable TV transmission in the country is predominantly analogue and limited to
transmission of TV channels in a bundled manner. The value added services are rarely
available on cable television network in India. With the gradual introduction of CAS,
DTH, HITS, IPTV, etc., the digital delivery, which has a qualitative edge over analogue
mode of delivery at the subscriber end, is becoming a reality. Because of emerging
competition from digital delivery platforms, some of the cable operators in non-CAS
areas have started digital transmission with/without conditional access system over
their cable TV networks voluntarily for having transparent operation.
6. Gradually, the expectations of the viewers on the quality of service front have
increased even in non-CAS analogue network areas over past few years. The
Authority has also got valuable experience after having issued QoS Regulations for
CAS areas, where the number of subscribers is much less, and for DTH. In view of
emerging competitive environment in delivery chain, and to ensure quality service in
non-CAS areas, the Authority has decided to empower the consumers by creating
certain rights for them (and casting corresponding obligations on cable TV operators)
with suitable enforcement mechanism for quality of service standards to be observed
by service providers in non-CAS areas.
B. Recent Initiative taken by the Authority
7. The Authority is well aware that the presence for effective enforcement machinery at
ground level is critical for the success of any quality of service regulation for cable TV
services. Therefore, the Authority has initiated an exercise for empowering the state
government machinery for effective enforcement of quality of service regulation by
delegating power of the Authority under TRAI Act. The Authority had written to the
State Governments for involving the district administration for enforcement of QoS
Regulations at the grass root level on October 21, 2008. The Ministry of Information &
Broadcasting had also been addressed on October 21, 2008 for enlarging the scope of
15
State level and District level monitoring committees, so that these committees may
also monitor implementation of QoS regulations.
8. Sub-section (4) of Section 11 of the TRAI Act, 1997 requires the Authority to ensure
transparency while exercising its powers and discharging its functions. Therefore, the
Authority had discussed various aspects of quality of service issues of cable TV
services in non-CAS areas in the consultation paper titled “Quality of Service issues
for Cable TV Services in Non-CAS areas and for DTH Services” issued on December
01, 2008, and had invited comments of the stakeholders on the issue of quality of
services of such services.
C. Issues raised for consultation
9. The main issues raised in the consultation paper were as under-
1. Please offer your comments on the areas and parameters of Quality
of Service which need to be covered in such regulations (refer para
2.16)? Please offer comments whether QoS parameters should also
be made applicable to voluntary CAS networks in non-CAS areas. If
yes, then please indicate what should these parameters be.
2. In particular, comments and suggestions are invited for effective
and transparent monitoring and implementation of proper billing,
to protect consumers’ interests.
3. There is an expectation that the State Governments and the Ministry
of Information & Broadcasting will extend necessary cooperation in
the effective implementation of QoS Regulations. Can you suggest
any other supplemental measures for further strengthening the
implementation of QOS Regulations?
4. Please offer your view on any other issues which will make the
Regulations more complete and effective.
16
10. Various parameters listed in para 2.16 of the consultation paper were as follows-
(i) Proper procedures and timelines for connections, disconnections, transfer
of cable services
(ii) Proper procedure for billing and effective mechanism for handling
technical and billing related complaints
(iii) Procedure for overall complaint handling and redressal by the service
provider
(iv) Timeline and the procedure for services relating to provision of digital
decoders and STBs in non-CAS areas, wherever service providers are
providing digital services
(v) Procedure for informing the subscribers about change of channels
alongwith their channel position
(vi) Mechanism of rebates in cases of interruption of service
(vii) Technical standards to be observed by the service providers
(viii) Effective monitoring of Quality of Service standards
11. The consultation paper was placed on TRAI’s website (www.trai.gov.in) on the same
day and comments of the stakeholders on the subject were initially invited by
December 31, 2008. The date was further extended to January 10, 2009 keeping in
view the requests of the stakeholders, and also for wider participation of stakeholders
in the consultation process. Responses were received from 27
stakeholders/representatives. These responses were posted on TRAI's website on
January 19, 2009. An open house discussion was then held on February 06, 2009 in
Kolkata with representatives of stakeholders to further deliberate on various issues
raised in the consultation paper.
D. Analysis of the responses received during the consultation process –
12. The responses received during the consultation process have been examined and
analysed in detail in the background stated above. While comments received from all
the stakeholders have been considered, it is important to state here that in issues
relating to quality of service, the cable operators and subscribers are the only directly
17
http://www.trai.gov.in/
affected parties. Other stakeholders like broadcasters, DTH operators etc. are not
directly affected by the quality of service (QoS) standards laid down for non-CAS
cable TV services. The paragraphs hereunder briefly cover the issue-wise comments
received from various stakeholders and set out the basis and rationale for the
Standards of Quality of Service (Broadcasting and Cable Services) (Cable Television –
Non-CAS Areas) Regulations, 2009.
E. Parameters for QoS Regulation
13. Almost all the stakeholders are in favor of having technical and non-technical
standards in the quality of service regulations. Some stakeholders have mentioned
that the regulation should ensure proper signals form MSO to LCO.
14. Some of the stakeholders are of the view that the parameters laid down for cable
services in CAS areas should be made applicable for cable services in non-CAS areas
also. Some others have suggested that only broad provision of CAS quality of service
regulation should be made applicable in non-CAS areas. However, the stipulation for
provision of set-top boxes should be made applicable for voluntary CAS system in
non-CAS areas. Some service providers have reservations with regard to the issue of
rebates in case of interruption of service. They are of the view that since the billing
across delivery chain is mainly in lump sum based on the negotiated subscriber base,
therefore a discount to the subscriber is not practical.
15. Regarding timelines for connection, discussions, transfer of cable services, the
stakeholders are of the view that application form details should be similar to CAS
quality of service regulations. The stakeholders, particularly consumers, are in favour
of having complaint handling mechanism, and some operators are of the view that
provisions made for CAS notified areas can be made applicable in respect of the
digital service in non-CAS areas.
16. A few stakeholders have mentioned that in the present scenario, the quality of service
parameters/regulations can be laid down only in respect of digital cable TV services.
One of the multi system operators has mentioned that at present in certain cities, the
multi system operators are providing services through digital mode on voluntary
18
basis to the subscribers in non-addressable manner. Only benefit derived by the
subscribers from these digital services is that they get better picture quality and more
number of channels on cable TV networks.
17. There is no difference of opinion about having procedure for billing and effective
mechanism for handling complaints by the cable operators in non-CAS areas. A DTH
operator is of the opinion that the provisions regarding billing and mechanism for
handling complaints as stipulated in DTH QoS regulation should be made applicable
for cable TV industry in non-CAS area. Regarding complaint handling mechanism,
some of the stakeholders are of the view that in case of digital service the MSO should
maintain 24 x 7 call centres. Similarly, cable operators should also have a provision for
receiving the consumer complaints. One of the stakeholders has suggested to exempt
cable operators in the village with population of less than 5000 from QoS
requirements.
18. Regarding timelines and procedures for services relating to digital decoders and STBs
in non-CAS areas, some of the stakeholders are of the opinion that since some of the
networks in non-CAS areas have started digital services and are competing with other
addressable systems like DTH, there should be level playing field and DTH QoS
regulations should be adopted for such digital decoders and STBs for the cable TV
network in non-CAS areas also.
19. Regarding procedure for informing the subscriber about change of channel, some of
the consumers have advocated to have proper system for informing the subscribers.
The broadcasters are of the opinion that channel positioning should not be normally
changed by the delivery platforms. One of the DTH operator is of the opinion that the
cable operator should inform the subscriber alteast six weeks in advance about change
of channels alongwith their channel position. One of the MSOs has stated that the
issue is relevant only in case of analogue cable transmission and not in digital
delivery.
20. With regard to the issue of technical standards to be observed by the distribution
chain, majority of the stakeholders are of the opinion that the delivery chain should
match the technical standards set by BIS for cable TV networks. One of the MSOs
19
distributing the channels through digital deliveries has suggested to put in place the
standards of the signals to be made available at the subscriber end by the cable
operators as laid down in BIS standards IS-13420. A simplified distribution chain to be
developed by the broadcasters was also highlighted by some of the stakeholders for
ensuring better quality service from the broadcaster.
F. Applicability for Voluntary CAS
21. Regarding applicability of QoS parameters to voluntary CAS networks in non-CAS
areas, mixed responses were received from the stakeholders. Some of the stakeholders
have indicated that CAS QoS regulations should be made applicable for voluntary
CAS in non-CAS areas. The others favoured a common QoS regulation for voluntary
CAS operations and conventional analogue operation in non-CAS areas. One of the
stakeholders has also raised the issue of defining voluntary CAS. In his view, at
present in certain cities the MSOs are providing cable services through digital mode
on voluntary basis to the subscribers and though these digital services are not yet
addressable. Thus in respect of voluntary CAS, the stipulation of CAS QoS regulation
would be of no use unless full fledged addressability is made mandatory.
G. Monitoring/implementation mechanism
22. Regarding effective and transparent monitoring of QoS standards some of the
stakeholders want consumer awareness to be created through seminars, advertising
campaigns etc. Some have suggested monitoring by authorised officers and others
have suggested post office or authorities responsible for renewal of registration. Some
of the service providers are of the opinion that issuance of bill etc. are sufficient
measures for effective implementation of the regulation.
23. Majority of stakeholders have accepted the proposal of involvement of state
governments. However, some of the stakeholders have stated that only TRAI should
monitor the implementation of QoS regulations. Some of the stakeholders have
indicated that self-certification/self-regulation by the service provider will suffice in
20
addition to involvement of State Governments. They are of the opinion that the service
provider should submit this certification annually to the registering authority or
authorized officer or even to the TRAI. Some of the stakeholders have indicated that
MSO may nominate nodal officers for grievances of the subscribers.
H. Miscellaneous issues
24. Many stakeholders who are a part of the delivery chain have raised the issue of right
of way for cable TV network. Majority of MSOs have also reiterated their demand for
extension of CAS for remaining part of three metros and 55 other cities as
recommended in 2007. Some of the stakeholders are of the opinion that broadcasters
should also come under the purview of QoS regime. Some others have raised the issue
of involving consumer groups/RWA for effective implementation of QoS regulations.
25. Some of the stakeholders have raised the issue of enforcement of the QoS regulation.
One stakeholder was of the view that any initiative to introduce and implement the
quality of service regulations/parameters in this highly fragmented sector has to be
properly backed by an effective monitoring and compliance mechanism.
I. Rationale
26. The QoS regulations for cable TV service in non-CAS areas are being laid down to
protect the interests of the consumers and to keep pace with the emerging competitive
situation among different service providers. The regulations have been formulated
considering the fact that the cable television industry in the country has not been
subjected to any prescription for quality of service standards for over a decade and
half of its development.
27. There are no known industry standards or commonly followed business practices
which can be adopted as a model for such a large fragmented cable TV networks. The
Authority during the course of implementation of its Quality of Service Regulations
for CAS areas and for DTH services has experienced that the end consumers will have
to be provided with a mechanism to seek relief and safeguard their interests on a
21
number of issues relating to quality of service aspects.
28. The introduction of digitalization and addressability in the sector is inevitable in times
to come due to competition. The Authority, time and again, has made
recommendations on this issue to Government of India. The QoS regulations now
being issued are formulated keeping in mind the compatibility factor with the QoS
regulation for cable services in CAS areas, so that the service providers in non-CAS
areas can easily migrate their systems whenever CAS is mandated in their area of
operation.
29. On the other hand, the factors that the last mile is highly fragmented and a large
number of the operators may not have the financial and technical resources, and
would need time to adjust to the new dispensations on quality of service front, has
also been kept in view, while formulating these quality of service regulations. Though
it would be desirable to have similar QoS regulations for CAS and non-CAS cable
services as far as possible, the Authority is also conscious of the fact that these
regulations should not hamper the growth of voluntarily digitalization and adoption
of addressability by the cable operators or MSOs in non-CAS areas. The objective is to
have orderly growth with more and more digitalization and addressability in the cable
TV networks in non-CAS areas.
30. The regulations for quality of services in CAS areas issued on August 23, 2006 lay
down the procedure for connection, disconnection, transfer and shifting of cable
service in CAS areas within certain specified time limits. However, the Authority felt
that such a stringent requirement is not necessary in cable service in highly
fragmented non-CAS areas. Therefore, the details in the application form and other
obligations of the cable operators have been simplified in current regulations.
31. Although the Authority by the eighth amendment tariff order dated 04.10.2007 has
earlier incorporated certain aspects of billing among other provisions, but since this
amendment order has been set aside by Hon’ble TDSAT on certain other grounds,
these provisions relating to billing are also not applicable for the time being. However
the issue of amended order is under judicial scrutiny before Hon’ble Supreme Court.
The current QoS regulations imposed simplified billing procedure for cable service in
22
non-CAS areas for transparent operation. This should also help in minimizing the
problem of correct determination of subscriber base.
32. As against round-the-clock call centre/help desk by MSOs in CAS Areas and for DTH
services, the dispensation for 12 Hrs in day time on all days of week has been made in
these regulations to start with for this highly fragmented cable TV operations in non-
CAS areas. A simplified procedure for handling complaints has also been adopted in
current regulations. These provisions would go a long way in improving consumer
satisfaction.
33. Regarding rebate to the subscriber for temporary disconnection of service at the
request of subscriber, the Authority felt it appropriate, in view of comments of the
stakeholders, not to specify any specific rebate but left it to the operators for possible
rebates. This is because the payments made by cable operators to MSOs or to
broadcasters in analogue network is based on a subscriber base negotiated annually,
and there is no possibility of such temporary disconnections being netted out once the
overall subscriber base is negotiated.
34. Since some operators in non-CAS areas have started digital operations with or without
addressability in cable services in non-CAS areas on voluntary basis, the Authority has
specified certain limited obligations with respect to provision of digital decoders and
set top boxes in non-CAS areas to protect consumers, and for orderly growth of the
sector.
35. Some stakeholders have suggested that proper technical standards of the signals at the
interface between different players in delivery chain should be specified. The
Authority has taken a note of their concerns regarding quality signals to the
consumers. However, the Authority is also well aware that there are different network
topology adopted by MSOs and LCOs across the country. The Authority at this stage
felt that it would be sufficient if mandatory provision of technical quality of service
standards at the subscriber end by the cable operators is specified. The Authority
expects the MSOs to provide necessary signal strength to enable the cable operators to
meet these provisions. They are collectively required to match the technical standards
set by the Bureau of Indian Standards IS – 13420, Part I (Revised) for cable television
23
networks, or any other standard laid down by BIS from time to time relating to
system performance in their networks and ensure delivery of proper signal at
subscriber premises.
36. These QoS Regulations for non-CAS areas also mandate that representatives of cable
operators and MSOs should carry proper identification alongwith photograph on line
with QoS regulation for cable service in CAS areas and for DTH services.
37. Some other related issues have also been raised by the stakeholders regarding right of
way (ROW), and extension of CAS in other parts of the country. The Authority is
already seized of these issues, and has made recommendations to the Government in
the past regarding extension of CAS. The Ministry of Information & Broadcasting has
also set up a Committee to examine right of way issue.
38. The Authority is aware of the fact, as rightly stated by some of the stakeholders, that
effective enforcement and implementation of any regulation is essential to extend
benefits to the consumers. As stated earlier, TRAI had already written to the State
Governments for involving the District administration for enforcement of QoS
Regulations at the grass root level. Twelve State Governments have so far extended
their consent for such proposal. Some are examining it, and responses from others are
awaited. Keeping in view the effective implementation of these regulations, the
Authority is simultaneously considering the process of delegating powers to the
officials of the State Governments as per their consent. Moreover, the QoS
Regulations for cable TV services will empower the individual cable TV subscribers in
non-CAS areas to approach the District Consumer Redressal Forums as provided
under section 14 of the TRAI Act for deficiencies in service if the QoS benchmarks are
not met.
39. Though the Authority has sought enlargement of the scope of State level and District
level monitoring committees from Ministry of Information & Broadcasting so that
these committees may also monitor implementation of QoS regulations, Ministry of
Information and Broadcasting has intimated their reservations about such
enlargement of the scope, and have not agreed with the proposal of the Authority.
40. The Authority believes that effective involvement of local District administration
24
under the State Governments and District Level Consumer Forums will go a long way
for successful implementation of QoS Regulations in protecting the interests of the
consumers at large.
41. The Authority while drawing up the regulations has made an effort to balance the
interests of the consumers and address their concerns while ensuring growth of the
cable TV segment. The experience gained during the implementation and enforcement
of these regulations would be useful for future improvements. This may require
revisiting some of the standards of QoS benchmarks, and to further strengthen the
enforcement mechanism.
_____________________________
25
Previous and next
Questions people ask
Is regulation 23 of Standards of Quality of Service (Broadcasting and Cable Services) (Cable Television – Non-CAS Areas) Regulations, 2009. still in force?
No repeal of Standards of Quality of Service (Broadcasting and Cable Services) (Cable Television – Non-CAS Areas) Regulations, 2009. is recorded.