Regulation 27, THE DIRECT TO HOME BROADCASTING SERVICES (STANDARDS OF QUALITY OF SERVICE AND REDRESSAL OF GRIEVANCES) REGULATIONS, 2007.: Provisions of these regulations to apply to persons availing direct to home service before commencement of these regulations
THE DIRECT TO HOME BROADCASTING SERVICES (STANDARDS OF QUALITY OF SERVICE AND REDRESSAL OF GRIEVANCES) REGULATIONS, 2007. - Regulation 27
Text of regulation 27
Provisions of these regulations to apply to persons availing direct to home service before commencement of these regulations
27. Provisions of these regulations to apply to persons availing direct to
home service before commencement of these regulations.------- The
provisions of these regulations shall, as far as may be, apply to the persons
who have been availing, before commencement of these regulations, the
direct to home service and continue to do so on such commencement.
14
SCHEDULE
(See sub-regulation (2) of regulation 13)
Serial number
(1)
Parameter
(2)
Benchmarks for parameter referred to
in column (2)
(3)
1. Response time to the
direct to home
subscriber for calls
answered
electronically.
(a) Eighty per cent. of calls to be
answered within twenty seconds
electronically ;
(b) Ninety- five per cent. of calls to
be answered within forty seconds
electronically.
2. Response time to the
direct to home
subscriber for calls
answered by operator
(a) Eighty per cent. of calls to be
answered (voice to voice) by a
person (other than by electronic
means) appointed by the direct to
home operator within sixty seconds;
(b) Ninety- five per cent. of calls to
be answered (voice to voice) by a
person (other than by electronic
means) appointed by the direct to
home operator within ninety seconds.
Note.--- For the purpose of calculating percentage of calls referred to in
column (3) of the Schedule above, the total number of calls made during a
month shall be taken into account.
(R. N. Choubey)
Principal Advisor (B&CS)
Note:- The Explanatory Memorandum annexed to these regulations explain
the objects and reasons of the Direct to Home Broadcasting Services
(Standards of Quality of Service and Redressal of Grievances) Regulations,
2007.
15
Annex
EXPLANATORY MEMORANDUM
A. Background
1. In direct to home service (hereinafter referred to as DTH service), a large number
of television channels are digitally compressed, encrypted and beamed from very high
power satellites. The programmes transmitted through DTH can be directly received at
homes by installing small dish antennas at convenient locations in the buildings. DTH
transmission service does not require any commercial intermediary, since an individual
user is directly served by the direct to home operator (hereinafter referred to as DTH
operator). However, a digital receiver usually referred to as set top box is required to
receive the multiplexed signals and view them on a Television.
2. In India, DTH service is a comparatively recent entrant as compared to cable
transmission. It has certain technical advantages over cable operations. DTH is an
addressable system and covers the entire country. The authority to issue DTH licence
vests with the Government of India (Ministry of Information & Broadcasting). Leaving
aside the Doordarshan as a public service broadcaster, two DTH operators have
commenced their operations after obtaining licence from the Government of India
(Ministry of Information & Broadcasting). These are M/s ASC Enterprises (under the
brand name of Dish TV) and M/s Tata Sky Ltd. Dish TV had launched its services in the
month of October 2003 and Tata Sky launched its service in the month of August 2006.
The two DTH operators offer several pay channels along with Free to Air channels and
the number of their subscribers in the country is estimated to be about 3.2 million at
present. As compared to this, the other addressable delivery platform, namely, the
Conditional Access System (CAS) for cable television has about 5.5 lakh subscribers in
the CAS notified areas of the country. The Doordarshan provides free to air channels on
its DTH service (called DD Direct) for which the subscribers have to buy the dish and
the set top box from the open market. Since the Doordarshan signals are unencrypted and
free to air, no accurate assessment is available about the number of viewers. Recently,
licences for DTH services have also been given to M/s. Sun TV Ltd. and M/s. Reliance
Blue Magic Ltd.
16
3. The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (hereinafter referred to as the
Authority) had issued “The Standards of Quality of Service (Broadcasting and Cable
services) (Cable Television - CAS Areas) Regulation, 2006 (8 of 2006)” on the 23rd
August, 2006 to regulate the quality of service of cable television services in the CAS
areas. It was for the first time that quality of service regulations were issued by the
Authority regarding distribution of TV channels. The impact of the regulations relating
to Quality of Service for CAS areas has a bearing on issues relating to DTH service in
view of the fact that both are addressable platforms and many of the Quality of Service
issues are common to the above two delivery platforms, i.e. CAS and DTH service.
4. Since the operation of DTH services is at developing stage in India, the DTH
operators are yet to evolve an effective policy for quality of service standards in respect
of DTH service which inter alia relate to provision for redressal of grievances of
consumers of DTH service. A number of complaints are being received by the Authority
relating to the quality of service aspects of the DTH operators. The subscribers have a
right to get a certain standard of DTH service as value for their money. For this purpose,
a need has been felt to lay down such benchmarks for quality of service standards for
DTH service which are well known, measurable, verifiable and specify the response time
for different grievances.
5. The cable services in CAS areas and DTH services require the use of a set top
box along with the television set as both the platforms, namely, cable services in CAS
areas and DTH services are addressable. The basic regulatory issue in the case of the set
top box is that the consumer is required to make an upfront payment to acquire this piece
of equipment in both the above cases. If he subsequently finds the service not up to the
desired level there should be some mechanism by which he can exit the service. This can
be done in one of the two ways namely, (a) through the route of technical
interoperability; or (b) through commercial interoperability. In the DTH platform, the
licence conditions specify technical interoperability. In the CAS areas, the Authority has
specified two standard tariff packages (rental packages) which have to be offered by all
service providers in CAS areas to all subscribers in addition to any other scheme which
may be offered by them. It became necessary to do so because CAS had to be
17
compulsory introduced under the orders of the Hon’ble High Court. However, there has
been no regulation on this aspect in the case of DTH.
B. Consultation Process
6. Sub-clause (v) of clause (b) of sub-section (1) of Section 11 of the Telecom
Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997 (hereinafter referred to as the TRAI Act, 1997),
provides for the Authority to lay down the standards of quality of service to be met by
the service providers so as to protect the interests of consumers. Sub-section (4) of
Section 11 of the TRAI Act, 1997 requires the Authority to ensure transparency while
exercising its powers and discharging its functions. Accordingly, the Authority decided
to go in for a consultation process before laying down benchmarks for quality of service
standards for DTH services.
7. A consultation paper on the issues relating to DTH was circulated on 2nd March,
2007 inviting inputs from the stakeholders. Responses were received from 27
stakeholders/representatives. An open house discussion was also held on the 18th May,
2007 in Bhubaneswar with representatives of stakeholders to further deliberate on
various issues raised in the consultation paper.
C. Issues in the Consultation Process relating to DTH services
8. The issues which were inter alia raised for consultation in the consultation paper
are as under:-
(i) Should TRAI mandate Quality of Service Standards for DTH Platform as
done in the case of Cable Television services for CAS area?
(ii) In case the answer to (i) is ‘yes’
(a) Whether the list of areas identified for laying down standards in
para 3.12 would be adequate or whether the list needs
modification?
(b) Can the benchmarks stipulated in the QOS regulations for CAS
areas vide notification of 23rd August 2006 be adopted with
modifications in some of the areas relating to billing, complaint
18
handling etc or should there be separate benchmarks for DTH
service on the identified aspects of quality of service?
(iii) Alternatively should the approach suggested in the Consultation Paper for
Telecom (dated January 3, 2007) be followed in which the TRAI only
mandates the details of the grievance redressal machinery for each service
provider?
(iv) In case mandated intervention is not preferred:
(a) Should the service providers be allowed freedom to prescribe their
own quality standards and the extent of regulatory intervention be
limited to only prescribing reporting requirements for the purpose
of monitoring?
(b) Should TRAI in that case identify broad areas for prescription of
standards of quality of service and also specify a time frame
within which the industry evolved standards comes into operation.
(c) Any other methodology for arriving at standards of quality of
service/ time frame.
(v) In case QOS standards are prescribed through regulations what would the
mechanism be for enforcement of these regulations?
(vi) Whether the subscriber centric quality of service standards should be
common for cable service and DTH.
9. The consultation paper also raised following issues regarding set top boxes for
DTH services, namely:-
(i) Whether the requirement of technical interoperability of set top boxes
incorporated in the licence conditions gives an effective exit option to the
subscribers. If not, how can these conditions be made consumer friendly
through alternative schemes?
(ii) Whether offering the rental or buy back option for DTH Receiver
Equipment (set top box along with dish antenna and associated hardware)
should be made compulsory for DTH service providers?
19
(iii) If so, whether the one time deposit and the monthly rentals or the details
of the buy back scheme should be regulated?
(iv) What should be the other conditions regarding such rental options or buy
back scheme? Between the rental and the buy back scheme, should any
order of preference be indicated?
(v) If the rental option or buy back scheme is made compulsory, should the
condition of technical interoperability be done away with or suitably
modified?
D. Analysis of the responses received during the consultation process
10. The responses received during the consultation process have been examined and
analysed in detail in the background stated above. While comments received from all the
stakeholders have been considered, it is important to state here that in issues relating to
quality of service, the DTH operators and subscribers are the only directly affected
parties. Other stakeholders like broadcasters, cable operators and multi system operators
are not directly affected by the quality of service (QoS) standards laid down for DTH
services. The gist of comments received from the stakeholders during the consultation
process had been placed on the website of the Authority. The paragraphs hereunder
briefly cover the issue-wise comments received from various stakeholders and set out the
basis and rationale for the Direct to Home Broadcasting Services (Standards of Quality
of Service and Redressal of Grievances) Regulations, 2007.
E. Quality of Service (QoS) Standards issues:
11. The comments received from the consumer groups and service providers
(existing as well as potential) were diametrically opposite stands taken by consumer
groups and service providers. Whereas the consumers and consumer organisations were
of the view that the Authority should mandate the QoS standards for DTH services, the
two existing DTH service providers and most of the potential ones were of the view that
self regulation is the best solution. Most of the service providers demanded freedom to
specify their own quality standards and limiting the extent of regulatory intervention to
reporting requirements. One of the licensees recommended the approach suggested in the
20
Consultation Paper (dated the 3rd January, 2007) for Telecom wherein the Authority only
mandates the details of the grievance redressal machinery for each service provider. As
an exception, one of the potential service providers has favored Authority mandated
Quality of Service Standards for DTH platform as done in the case of cable television
services for CAS area.
12. Moreover, the consumers have suggested that the subscriber centric quality of
service standards should be common for cable service and DTH. This suggestion has
been opposed by the service providers who have favored the subscriber centric quality of
service standards for DTH to be different from such standards for cable service.
F. Set Top Box related issues in DTH Services
13. Since some of the set top box related issues pertain to technical inter-operability,
these are covered by the licence conditions and such issues are not dealt in here.
14. There are divergent views of service providers (existing as well as potential) on
the issue of commercial interoperability. While, some of the service providers have
categorically advocated that there should be no regulation on set top boxes, others have
demanded that commercial interoperability should be mandated for DTH set top boxes.
The consumers, cable operators and a Multi System Operator (hereinafter referred to as
MSO) have recommended that the Authority should not only mandate commercial
interoperability for DTH set top boxes, but also regulate commercial inter-operability as
has been done for set top boxes for CAS areas.
G. Rationale
15. The QoS standards for DTH services are being laid down in the Direct to Home
Broadcasting Services (Standards of Quality of Service and Redressal of Grievances)
Regulations, 2007 made by the Authority because the large number of subscriber
complaints relating to quality of service issues for DTH service indicates that there is an
urgent need for the same. The industry has not come up so far with QoS standards on its
own. Therefore, leaving the issue for direct to home operators to come up with such
standards is likely to delay the matter and put the growing number of DTH subscribers to
21
a lot of inconvenience. However, in respect of most of the matters, sufficient flexibility
has been given to the service providers to evolve their own procedures and specify
benchmarks and lay down service charges. Thus, the Authority has decided to go in for a
mix of self regulation and light touch regulation.
16. It is felt that the technological and commercial requirements of the two platforms,
namely DTH and cable service in CAS areas are different and having common
subscriber centric quality of service standards for cable service in CAS areas and DTH
may not be practical at this stage. This is primarily because of the reason that in case of
cable services, the subscriber directly interacts with the cable operator at a local level, the
area of operation of the cable operators is limited and collection of application forms,
activation and deactivation of service and billing are done locally. The cable service in
CAS area is quite different from DTH where the Subscriber Management System and
billing operations for the entire country are centralised. Accordingly, the QoS standards
being specified for DTH services are somewhat different from the standards specified for
cable services in CAS areas to take into account these basic differences in the two
platforms.
17. The regulation on standards of quality of service for cable services in CAS areas
issued on 23rd August, 2006 lays down the procedure for connection, disconnection,
transfer and shifting of cable service in CAS areas as well as specifies the time period
within which a service provider has to provide and activate connection on receipt of an
application. However, as compared to the cable services in CAS areas, where an existing
cable subscriber could suffer loss of content after implementation of CAS in case of
delayed provision of service, such stringent requirements need not be placed on DTH
operators as there is no possibility of loss of content of an existing subscriber. Thus, the
time limits for provision and activation of connection have been replaced by an
obligation on the DTH operator to provide connections on a non-discriminatory basis.
18. The provisions relating to standard tariff packages for set top boxes for cable
services in CAS areas were necessitated by the need for keeping entry barriers low for
subscribers opting for pay channels in CAS areas. This was required to ensure that the
existing cable subscribers could easily migrate to CAS without suffering loss of content
due to compulsory implementation of CAS. However, DTH service is purely an optional
22
service and any subscriber opting for DTH service makes a free choice and therefore
entry barrier need not be artificially lowered through regulation in the prevailing
circumstances. At the same time, it is felt that mandating rental or hire purchase schemes
has the advantage of offering an easy exit route for the subscribers who may not be
happy with their service providers. Therefore, the Authority has mandated that the
subscribers shall be given an option to procure DTH Consumer Premises Equipment
(CPE) on out right purchase basis or hire purchase basis or rental basis. However, the
hire purchase or rental schemes have not been specified by the Authority for the present
and the DTH operators are free to come out with their own schemes in this regard.
19. Provisions relating to discontinuing exhibition of any channel and disconnection
of a subscriber are different from the provisions for CAS areas in view of the fact that
possible means for giving notice to subscribers are very different for a DTH operator as
compared to the local cable operator in a CAS area. Moreover, DTH operators have
adopted prepaid service model for delivering of services.
20. The Authority had received complaints from many DTH subscribers regarding
de-activation of their DTH set top boxes by the DTH operators in case the DTH
subscribers do not want to continue with subscription of DTH services of the operator.
As a result, the subscribers were unable to use the DTH set top box for viewing the Free
to Air (FTA) DTH services being provided by Doordarshan. This puts the DTH
subscribers in a disadvantageous position. In spite of having the required hardware for
reception of Doordarshan DTH services, they are unable to access the same.
Accordingly, it was decided to prohibit the DTH operators from de-activating the DTH
Set Top Boxes so long as no arrears are payable by the subscriber.
21. Another area of a large number of complaints is relating to increase in tariffs by
the DTH operators. Similar issue of frequent changes in tariff was earlier encountered in
the field of telecom services. The Authority had dealt with the situation by issue of the
Telecommunication Tariff (Thirty first Amendment) Order, 2004 on the 7th July, 2004.
The amendment in the Tariff Order provided the following, namely-
(a) A tariff plan once offered by an Access Provider shall be available to a
subscriber for a minimum period of six months from the date of enrolment of the
subscriber to that tariff plan.
23
(b) The subscriber in the said tariff plan shall be free to choose any other tariff
plan, even during the said six months period. All requests for change of plan shall
be accepted and implemented immediately or from the start of next billing cycle.
(c) For any tariff plan, the Access Provider shall be free to reduce tariffs at any
time provided that no tariff item in that plan shall be increased within said six
months period.
A similar provision has been introduced for DTH services so that a DTH subscriber is
assured that once he subscribes to any subscription package, the tariff for the same shall
not be increased by the DTH operator for the next six months for that subscriber, even if
the same subscription package is offered at a higher price to new subscribers enrolled
after a certain date as decided by the DTH operator.
22. The Authority has also received complaints regarding insistence of DTH
operators to make payment for the period for which DTH services were not availed by a
subscriber. In a prepaid billing model, sometimes a subscriber renews his subscription
after some time has lapsed after discontinuation of services following the expiry of his
subscription. In such a situation, the subscriber should not be charged for the period for
which the services have not been availed by him. All payments in a prepaid billing
system should be towards prospective use of services against the payment made by a
subscriber. Accordingly, a provision has been made to prohibit levy of charges for the
period of discontinuance of DTH service.
23. The provisions relating to billing system for postpaid DTH service are similar to
the provisions for such provisions for cable subscribers in CAS areas. However, for the
pre-paid DTH subscribers, the provisions relating to accessing usage details have been
adopted from similar provisions for prepaid telecom subscribers as given by the Telecom
Consumers Protection and Redressal of Grievances Regulations, 2007 (3 of 2007) issued
by the Authority on the 4th May, 2007.
24. While laying down the QoS standards for DTH service, the Authority has drawn
on its experience in the Telecom sector and has specified the procedure for redressal of
grievances of DTH subscribers. The provisions relating to establishment of call centres
for registering service requests, answering queries, registering of complaints and
24
redressal of grievances are based on the present industry practice for service industries
such as telecom, banking, insurance etc. The time limits for responding to calls by such
call centres of DTH operators have been kept at the same levels as already laid down for
call centres of telecom service providers in the Regulation on Quality of Service of Basic
and Cellular Mobile Services, 2005 dated the 1st July, 2005 (11 of 2005).
25. The time limits for redressal of grievance of DTH subscribers specified by the
regulations are similar to the time limits specified for cable services in CAS areas.
However, it may be emphasized here that DTH services have a pan India footprint. It
may not be possible to meet such stringent regulations about time limits for redressal of
grievance of DTH subscribers located in remote or hilly areas or distant rural areas.
Imposition of such stringent time limits for redressal of grievance of DTH subscribers
may deter the DTH operators from making available DTH services in remote or hilly
areas or distant rural areas, whereas such remote or hilly areas or distant rural areas need
the DTH services the most because these areas are not served by other distributors of TV
channels. Therefore, it has become necessary to make an exception to the time limits in
respect of such areas.
26. The provisions for appointment of Nodal Officers for redressal of DTH
subscriber grievances are broadly on the lines of the Telecom Consumers Protection and
Redressal of Grievances Regulations, 2007 (3 of 2007) for telecom sector issued by the
Authority on the 4th May 2007. Similarly, provisions for complaints forwarded by the
Authority to DTH operators for redressal of DTH subscriber grievances are also based on
the said regulations for telecom sector issued by the Authority on the 4th May 2007.
However, considering the fact that the DTH service sector is developing and therefore
such service is being subjected to the Quality of service regulations for the first time, the
requirements on the DTH operators have been kept at bare minimum as compared to the
regulations for telecom sector issued by the Authority on the 4th May 2007.
27. The Quality of Service regulations for cable services in CAS areas provided for
making available a manual or pamphlet setting out instructions for operating the set top
box. The Telecom Consumers Protection and Redressal of Grievances Regulations, 2007
(3 of 2007) issued by the Authority on the 4th May, 2007 also required the service
providers to publish a “Manual of Practice for handling consumer complaints”
25
containing specified information relating to Basic Telephone Service, Cellular Mobile
Telephone Service and Broadband Service. Along the same lines the DTH operators
have now been mandated to publish a “Manual of Practice”. The “Manual of Practice”
for DTH operators covers both the complaint handling procedures and instructions for
operating the DTH Consumer Premises Equipment, apart from educating the customers
about his rights and duties and obligations of the DTH operator.
28. The Quality of Service regulations for cable services in CAS areas mandated that
representatives of cable operators and MSOs should carry proper identification along
with a photograph. Similar requirement has been placed on the DTH operators also.
29. The powers of the Authority relating to inspection, audit and intervention have
been specifically listed in the regulations. These are necessary to monitor compliance of
these regulations and to protect the interests of the consumers. At the same time, the
Direct to Home Broadcasting Services (Standards of Quality of Service and Redressal of
Grievances) Regulations, 2007 do not in any way take away or restrict the rights of a
DTH subscriber for protection of his interests or exercising his right under any other law.
30. Suitable provisions have been made in the Direct to Home Broadcasting Services
(Standards of Quality of Service and Redressal of Grievances) Regulations, 2007 to
protect the interest of direct to home subscribers who had opted for direct to home
service before commencement of said regulations and to extend the provisions of the
aforesaid regulations to such subscribers also as would be available to direct to home
subscribers who opt for direct to home service after commencement of such regulations.
31. While drawing up the regulations, Authority has made an effort to balance the
interests of the consumers and their concerns as well as the considerations stated above
relating to the growth of the industry. The experience gained during the implementation
in the nascent stage would be a useful tool for improvement of the standards. This may
require revisiting some of the standards and benchmarks, whenever necessary, based on
experience in implementation.
TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE GAZETTE OF INDIA,
EXTRAORDINARY,
PART III, SECTION 4
THE DIRECT TO HOME BROADCASTING SERVICES
(STANDARDS OF QUALITY OF SERVICE AND REDRESSAL OF
GRIEVANCES) (AMENDMENT) REGULATIONS, 2009
No. 3 of 2009
TELECOM REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF INDIA
NOTIFICATION
New Delhi, the 12th March, 2009
F. No. 16-2/ 2009 - B&CS.---- In exercise of the powers conferred by
section 36, read with sub-clauses (i) and (v) of clause (b) of sub-section (1)
of section 11 of the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997 (24 of
1997), read with notification of the Government of India, in the Ministry of
Communication and Information Technology (Department of
Telecommunication) No.39,-----
(a) issued, in exercise of the powers conferred upon the Central Government
under clause (d) of sub-section (1) of section 11 and proviso to clause (k) of
sub-section (1) of section 2 of the said Act, and
(b) published under notification No. S.O.44 (E) and 45 (E) dated the 9th
January, 2004 in the Gazette of India, Extraordinary, Part III, Section 4,
the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India hereby makes the following
regulations to amend the Direct to Home Broadcasting Services (Standards
of Quality of Service and Redressal of Grievances) Regulations, 2007 (8 of
2007), namely:-
1. (1) These regulations may be called the Direct to Home Broadcasting
Services (Standards of Quality of Service and Redressal of Grievances)
(Amendment) Regulations, 2009.
(2) They shall come into force with effect from the date of their publication
in the Official Gazette.
2
2. In the Direct to Home Broadcasting Services (Standards of Quality of
Service and Redressal of Grievances) Regulations, 2007, ---------
(a) after regulation 4, the following regulation shall be inserted, namely:-
“4A. Obligation of Direct to home operator to provide repair and
maintenance of Direct to Home Customer Premises Equipment. ------
(1) Every direct to home operator shall provide a warranty in respect of
Direct to Home Customer Premises Equipment which has been acquired by
a direct to home subscriber on outright purchase basis from such direct to
home operator.
(2) The direct to home subscribers who have acquired the Direct to Home
Customer Premises Equipment on outright purchase basis shall not be
required to pay any sum as charges -----
(a) for repair and maintenance of the Direct to Home Customer
Premises Equipment; or
(b) for visiting the premises of such direct to home subscriber for the
purpose of carrying out repair and maintenance of Direct to Home
Customer Premises Equipment ------
during the period of validity of such warranty.”
(b) after regulation 9, the following regulations shall be inserted, namely:-
“9A. No change in composition of a subscription package during first
six months of enrolment or during the period of validity of
subscription paid in advance. ------ (1) No direct to home operator shall
change the composition of a subscription package which has been
subscribed to by a direct to home subscriber, so as to discontinue exhibition
of any particular channel in that subscription package, -------
(a) during the period of six months from the date of enrolment of the
subscriber to such subscription package in the case of a subscriber who
pays his subscription amounts under such subscription package by
recharging or by making payments periodically to the direct to home
operator; or
(b) during the entire period of validity of the subscription package if the
subscription amount in respect of such subscription package has been paid
in advance by the direct to home subscriber or in instalments as per offer of
3
the direct to home operator, -------
if such channel continues to be available on its direct to home service on its
platform:
(2) If any particular channel included in a subscription package which has
been subscribed to by a direct to home subscriber subsequently becomes
unavailable on the direct to home service of the direct to home operator on
its platform, the direct to home operator shall reduce the subscription
charges for such subscription package on a proportionate basis from the
date of discontinuance of the channel from the direct to home service of the
direct to home operator till the expiry of a period of six months from the
date of enrolment of that subscriber, or till the expiry of the contracted
period of subscription for which the amount of subscription has been paid
in advance or in instalments as per offer of the direct to home operator,
whichever is later.
Provided that, instead of proportionately reducing the subscription charges
for such subscription package on account of non-availability of such
channel, the direct to home operator may, at its discretion, introduce in
such subscription package another channel of the same genre and language
as the channel which has so become unavailable on the direct to home
service of the direct to home operator.
Provided further that the direct to home operator shall give an option to
each one of its direct to home subscribers, who have subscribed to such
subscription package, an option to choose from the modified subscription
package with charges reduced on proportionate basis and the modified
subscription package with the removed channel replaced by another
channel of the same genre and language, and the direct to home subscriber
shall be free to exercise the option for the period from the date of
discontinuance of the channel from the direct to home service of the direct
to home operator till the expiry of a period of six months from the date of
enrolment of that subscriber, or till the expiry of the contracted period of
subscription for which the amount of subscription has been paid in advance
or in instalments as per offer of the direct to home operator, whichever is
later.
Explanation: For the removal of doubts, it is hereby declared that the
amount of reduction on proportionate basis in the subscription charges, on
account of removal of a channel from a subscription package, shall be
calculated by dividing the amount of subscription charges for the original
subscription package by the number of channels included in the original
4
package.
9B. Notice before change in composition of a subscription package. -----
Every direct to home operator shall give prior notice of fifteen days to its
direct to home subscribers subscribing to any subscription package before
changing the composition of that subscription package.”;
(c) in regulation 10, the following provisos shall be inserted, namely:-
“Provided that a direct to home operator may not discontinue the direct to
home service to a direct to home subscriber at the request of such direct to
home subscriber, if such request for suspension of subscription is for a
period which comprises part of a calendar month.
Provided further that every direct to home operator shall suspend the direct
to home service to a direct to home subscriber at the request of such direct
to home subscriber, if such request for suspension of subscription is for a
period of a calendar month or multiple of calendar months and the
requested period of suspension does not exceed three calendar months.”.
(R. N. Choubey)
Principal Advisor (B&CS)
Note.1-----The principal regulations were published vide notification F. No.
4-55/2007 - B&CS dated 31st August, 2007.
Note.2-----The Explanatory Memorandum explains the objects and reasons
of the Direct to Home Broadcasting Services (Standards of Quality of
Service and Redressal of Grievances) (Amendment) Regulations, 2009.
5
Annex
EXPLANATORY MEMORANDUM
Background
1. The Direct to Home Broadcasting Services (Standards of Quality of Service and
Redressal of Grievances) Regulations, 2007, were issued on 31st August, 2007. These
regulations were issued to lay down the standards of quality of direct to home services
and to protect the interests of direct to home subscribers. At the time of issue of these
regulations, only two direct to home operators apart from Doordarshan were providing
direct to home services in the country. Since then, three new direct to home operators
have started commercial operations and the number of direct to home subscribers has
also risen to about 11 million. With the evolution of the direct to home segment and the
increase in the number of direct to home subscribers, new issues relating to quality of
direct to home service have arisen. In order to address these issues the Authority has
decided to amend the Direct to Home Broadcasting Services (Standards of Quality of
Service and Redressal of Grievances) Regulations, 2007.
Consultation Process
2. Sub-clause (v) of clause (b) of sub-section (1) of Section 11 of the Telecom
Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997 (hereinafter referred to as the TRAI Act, 1997),
provides for the Authority to “lay down the standards of quality of service to be provided
by the service providers and ensure the quality of service and conduct the periodical
survey of such service provided by the service providers so as to protect interest of the
consumers of telecommunication services”. Sub-section (4) of Section 11 of the TRAI
Act, 1997 requires the Authority to ensure transparency while exercising its powers and
discharging its functions. Accordingly, the Authority decided to go in for a consultation
process before amending the Direct to Home Broadcasting Services (Standards of
Quality of Service and Redressal of Grievances) Regulations, 2007.
3. The process of consultation was initiated by circulating a consultation paper on
the Quality of Service issues for Cable TV Services in Non-CAS Areas and for DTH
Services on 1st December, 2008 inviting inputs from the stakeholders. Responses were
received from 26 stakeholders/ representatives. An open house discussion was also held
6
on the 6th February, 2009 in Kolkata with representatives of stakeholders to further
deliberate on various issues raised in the consultation paper.
Issues for Consultation
4. The issues which were raised for consultation in the consultation paper are as
under:-
i) Whether the DTH operators should be specifically prohibited from dropping of
channels from a subscription package for a subscriber for six months from the date of
enrolment of that subscriber, if the channel continues to be available on their platform.
ii) Within this period of six months, in case the channel ceases to be available on a
particular DTH platform, then whether it would be appropriate to have a mechanism of
reducing the subscription charges by an amount equal to the wholesale a-la-carte rate of
that channel. Alternatively, can you suggest any other methodology for such
compensation to the subscriber? Should such compensation be paid/adjusted even when
one channel in a package is dropped, and it is replaced/substituted by another channel so
that the total number of channels in that package is not affected?
iii) Whether the subscribers should also be required to subscribe to any channel/
package for a certain minimum subscription period as in CAS areas. If yes, what should
be such minimum subscription period?
iv) Whether there is any justification for visiting charges for “no signal” complaint
by the subscribers? If yes, should there be a ceiling on such visiting charges for
complaints of “no signal”?
v) Similarly, should any ceiling be placed in respect of visiting charges for repair
and maintenance of CPE for DTH services? Alternatively, should DTH operators be
required to offer Annual Maintenance Contracts (AMCs) to their subscribers?
vi) Can you suggest some form of AMCs for DTH Service covering all aspects such
as repair & maintenance charges for CPE, visiting charges, attending “no signal”
complaints, etc.?
vii) Whether the service providers should be required to make available toll-free
numbers for recharge calls for prepaid accounts?
viii) Whether the request for suspension of service for full calendar months only
should be entertained?
7
ix) Whether tariff plan or subscription package changes requested by the DTH
subscriber should be accepted and implemented immediately or from the start of next
billing cycle for DTH subscriber.
x) Whether advance notice of minimum 30 days should be given by DTH operators
to a DTH subscriber before terminating his existing tariff plan provided that no tariff
plan can be terminated within the contracted period, if any, for that package or within six
months of enrolment of that subscriber to that package.
Analysis of the responses received during the consultation process
Dropping of channels from a package
5. The DTH operators have suggested that the freedom of adding/ dropping the
channels should be with the DTH operator. On the other hand the consumers have
demanded that protection should be available not only for six months, but for the entire
contract period of subscription package, if such period exceeds six months, so long as
advance payment has been made by the subscriber. The DTH operators have expressed a
view that there need not be any reduction in subscription charges in case of any channel
being withdrawn from a subscription package. However, the consumers have taken a
stand that in case of any channel being withdrawn from a subscription package, the
subscribers should be compensated by way of reduction in subscription fee. Further,
some consumers have demanded that in case a channel is substituted by another channel,
the choice of subscribing to the new channel or to get a reduction in subscription fee
should be with the subscriber.
Minimum Subscription Period
6. The Broadcasters and the DTH operators have favoured imposition of a minimum
subscription period for any channel/ package similar to the 4 month period prescribed in
quality of service norms for CAS. However, the consumers are divided on the issue and
while some of the consumers agree with the concept of minimum subscription period,
others have opposed it.
Maintenance of Customer Premises Equipment
7. The issue of visiting charges payable by the DTH subscribers for visits made by
personnel of DTH operators for repair and maintenance of CPE also divided the
8
consumers. While some consumers opposed visiting charges or wanted a ceiling on the
visiting charges, others did not agree with them. It was pointed out by an individual that
“…warranty does NOT include transporting charges for individuals and hardware.
Therefore for customers of all categories, itemized bills must be issued detailing the
breakdown of payments sought. …”. The DTH operators did not favour any kind of
regulation of visiting charges.
8. Almost all the stakeholders were of the view that the DTH operators should offer
Annual Maintenance Contracts for maintenance of CPE to their subscribers. Different
suggestions were also received regarding the form of Annual Maintenance Contracts.
One DTH operator has suggested that all DTH operators must have their own Annual
Maintenance Contracts.
Toll Free number for recharge calls
9. The proposal has been opposed by the DTH operators and the consumers have
unanimously favoured the proposal. Only one DTH operator has suggested that all DTH
operators should make provision for toll-free numbers for calls made for recharging their
prepaid accounts.
Suspension of service or change of plan on request of Subscribers
10. All the DTH operators have suggested that the request for suspension of service
for full calendar months only should be entertained. It has been pointed out by the DTH
operators that the broadcasters are paid on the basis of calendar months and accordingly,
any suspension of service for part of the month results in financial burden on the DTH
operator. It was also suggested by an operator that “…either it should be done from the
calendar month or the operator should be allowed to charge a service fees for extending
this service…”. The consumers were divided on the issue.
11. As regards timeframe for carrying out changes in tariff plan or subscription
package on the request of a DTH subscriber, the DTH operators wanted to be permitted
to levy administrative/ additional charges for such changes. Further, it was pointed out
by some DTH operators that any upgradation is possible with immediate effect, but
downgradation of a package can be done from next billing cycle only as the broadcasters
have to be paid for supply of content. The consumers were divided on this issue. Some of
the consumers suggested that the DTH subscribers should be billed on pro rata basis but
there should not be any administrative charge.
9
Notice period for termination of a tariff plan
12. Most of the consumers wanted a notice of minimum 30 days to be given by DTH
operators to a DTH subscriber before terminating his existing tariff plan. Some of the
consumers wanted a 60 days notice, while others suggested that the DTH subscriber may
be warned about such a change 15 days in advance of exhaustion of credit limit. The
DTH operators opposed any such notice.
Rationale for making amendment to the Direct to Home Broadcasting Services
(Standards of Quality of Service and Redressal of Grievances) Regulations, 2007
13. The Authority noted that a large number of complaints have been received from
the Direct to Home subscribers regarding dropping of channels from subscription
packages offered by DTH operators. In case of subscription to DTH services, a
subscriber subscribes to the service on the basis of specific channels included in the
subscription package. If any channel is taken out of a subscription package and it is
replaced by another channel then the DTH subscriber may be getting the same number of
channels as earlier, but will be deprived of viewing the particular channel which has been
removed. In case the channel which is removed is offered to the subscriber as an add-on
package then the subscriber ends up paying more for viewing that channel which was
earlier included in his subscription package. This subverts the tariff protection provided
to DTH subscribers by Regulation 9 of the Direct to Home Broadcasting Services
(Standards of Quality of Service and Redressal of Grievances) Regulations, 2007.
14. Further, the Authority has also noted that the DTH operators are offering annual
or fixed period subscription contracts also to DTH subscribers. To protect the interests of
the DTH subscribers who have entered into annual or fixed period subscription contracts
with the DTH operators, it is necessary to ensure that the channels offered to the
subscriber at the time of entering into the subscription contract are not removed from the
package during the validity of subscription contract.
15. However, on the other hand it must be recognized that the DTH operators have to
tailor their packages according to the changing demands of their subscribers.
Accordingly it was not considered advisable to completely prohibit the DTH operators
from making changes to their subscription packages. To balance the interest of service
10
providers and subscribers, the DTH operators have been prohibited from changing the
composition of any subscription package for a minimum period of six months from the
date of enrolment of the subscriber for such subscription package, if the channel
continuous to be available on their DTH service platform from the broadcaster in any
other subscription package. In cases where the existing subscription contract between
DTH subscriber and the DTH operator is for a period longer than six months, such
prohibition would apply for the complete term of the subscription contract.
16. In case any channel has to be removed from a subscription package by the DTH
service provider during the contracted period of the subscription or six months
whichever is later due to the channel no longer being available on the DTH service
platform in any other package, then the DTH operator would be required to compensate
the DTH subscriber by way of proportionate reduction in the subscription charges for a
minimum period of six months from the date of enrolment of the subscriber for such
subscription package or for the remaining period of subscription contract whichever is
more. However, the DTH operator may replace such a channel by another channel of the
same genre and language in the subscription package without reducing the subscription
charges. This will enable the DTH operators to include more popular content in their
offerings and package the content to suit the needs of their subscribers. However, the
option to choose the modified subscription package with reduced charges or the modified
subscription package with the replaced channel shall remain with direct to home
subscriber. Further, it has been mandated that the DTH operators should give prior notice
of fifteen days before changing the composition of any package to all the subscribers
who have subscribed to that package.
17. Presently there is no restriction on the direct to home operators about offering any
channels/ packages on quarterly/ annual/ any other basis. The direct to home operators
have been designing their packages as per the demand of customers and terms and
conditions of their interconnection agreements with the broadcasters. Accordingly, the
Authority is of the view that currently there is no need to bring in any regulation
requiring the direct to home subscribers to subscribe to any channel/ package for a
certain minimum subscription period as in CAS areas.
11
18. The direct to home operators have also been mandated to offer Warranty for CPE
acquired by their subscribers on outright purchase basis from them. Although offering of
AMC by DTH operators is not being mandated, it is expected that some competition
among the direct to home operators would ensure that the repair and maintenance
services are available to the DTH subscribers. Even presently, some of the DTH
operators are already offering AMCs for DTH CPE.
19. Presently, some of the direct to home operators are not charging any visiting
charges for repair and maintenance of CPE while some are charging. The Authority is of
the view that market forces will take care of this issue. The DTH operators have to
compete with cable networks and no such charges are levied by cable operators. Further,
there are five pay DTH operators in the country and therefore there is some level of
competition among DTH operators also. Hence it was not found necessary to prohibit, by
way of regulation, the direct to home operators from charging any visiting charges after
the warranty period is over, as it was felt that competition and market forces will work
on this issue to ensure that the interests of direct to home subscribers are protected.
20. The Authority has decided against mandating the direct to home operators to
make available toll-free numbers for recharge calls for prepaid accounts. The main
reason for this decision is that ultimately the cost of operational expenses of providing
direct to home service gets passed on to the direct to home subscribers. Any additional
expenditure by direct to home operators in making available toll-free numbers for
recharge calls for prepaid accounts will result in increase in the subscription charges in
the long run negating the benefits from the toll free number. However, it is expected that
the telephone number provided for recharge calls for prepaid accounts should not have
premium charges.
21. The direct to home operators have to pay the broadcasters on the basis of number
of viewers for the entire calendar month. Any suspension of service for part of the month
puts a direct to home operator at a loss because even though the direct to home
subscriber is not required to make payment for the period of suspension, the broadcasters
have to be paid for the entire calendar month. Accordingly, the direct to home operators
have been permitted not to entertain, at their discretion, any request for suspension of
service for part of calendar months. However, it has also been mandated that the DTH
12
operators should entertain requests for suspension of service for a period which does not
comprise part of a month and which does not exceed three calendar months.
22. The issue of change of tariff plan or subscription package on the request of a
direct to home subscriber is also linked with the payments that a direct to home operator
is required to make to the broadcasters. Accordingly, any downgradation of subscription
package entails discontinuance of supply of certain channels to the direct to home
subscriber. However, the broadcasters whose channels have been discontinued have to be
paid for the entire month/ billing cycle. Therefore, such a downgradation is normally
done from the next billing cycle. The Authority has noted that the upgradations are done
by the direct to home operators immediately. Therefore, no regulation is being brought in
regarding this aspect.
23. The issue of advance notice to a direct to home subscriber before terminating his
existing tariff plan by the direct to home operator is to be seen in the context of tariff
protection being made available to the direct to home subscriber. The present amendment
regulations have extended the protection available to the direct to home subscriber
regarding composition of a subscription package for six months from the date of
enrolment or contracted period, whichever is longer. However, an advance notice will
enable the direct to home subscribers to make an informed choice out of new
subscription packages available once the existing package is discontinued after the
period of tariff protection (six months from the date of enrolment or contracted period, as
the case may be) has expired. Accordingly, a prior notice of fifteen days has been
mandated for change in composition of a subscription package.
Previous and next
Questions people ask
Is regulation 27 of THE DIRECT TO HOME BROADCASTING SERVICES (STANDARDS OF QUALITY OF SERVICE AND REDRESSAL OF GRIEVANCES) REGULATIONS, 2007. still in force?
No repeal of the DIRECT TO HOME BROADCASTING SERVICES (STANDARDS OF QUALITY OF SERVICE AND REDRESSAL OF GRIEVANCES) REGULATIONS, 2007. is recorded.