Form OF CABLE LANDING STATION-REFERENCE, International Telecommunication Access to Essential Facilities at Cable Landing Stations Regulations, 2007: FORM OF CABLE LANDING STATION-REFERENCE
International Telecommunication Access to Essential Facilities at Cable Landing Stations Regulations, 2007 - Form OF CABLE LANDING STATION-REFERENCE
Text of form OF CABLE LANDING STATION-REFERENCE
FORM OF CABLE LANDING STATION-REFERENCE
FORM OF CABLE LANDING STATION-REFERENCE
INTERCONNECT OFFER (CLS-RIO)
(See regulation 3 of International Telecommunication Access to
Essential Facilities at Cable Landing Stations Regulations, 2007)
PART-I
Form of application for request to Access Facilitation at Cable
Landing Station for International Submarine Cable Capacity
(See regulation 4)
M/s ………………...…………...……….(Name of eligible Indian International
Telecommunication Entity) hereby request for Access Facilitation to
below mentioned Reference Capacity, which is subject to the Terms and
Conditions published in “Cable Landing Station-Reference Interconnect
Offer (CLS-RIO) made under the provisions of the International
Telecommunication Access to Essential Facilities at Cable Landing
Stations Regulations, 2007 for Access Facilitation to essential facilities
including landing facilities for submarine cables at cable landing stations
for International submarine cable capacity at cable landing station.
M/s ………………...…………...……….furnish the necessary details as
follows:-
1. Name of the company and its
Address
2. Billing address
3. Contact person
3.1 Name:
3.2 Phone No:
3.3 Email:
3.4 Fax:
4. Particulars of eligible Indian International Telecommunication
Entity, being Access Seeker:
4.1 International Long Distance
Operator
4.2 Internet Service Provider
20
4.3 Licence number:
4.4 Date of issue of Licence
(Please attach an attested copy of
licence and valid International gateway
permission as applicable)
5. Technical details of Reference Capacity (Please provide or enclose the
relevant information and details, as the case may be)
5.1 Reference Capacity details: Speed
(STM-1/STM-4/STM-16/ STM-64 etc.)
5.2 Number of capacity units
5.3 Indefeasible Right of Use or
Lease
5.4 Period (in case of Lease)
6. Technical details of Reference Capacity of submarine cable:
6.1 Cable Station Backhaul Port details
(capacity and type-STM-1e/ STM-
1o/STM-4/ STM-16/STM64 etc.)
6.2 Assignment provided by submarine
cable system capacity owner to be
attached if available (slot or Fiber Pair
allocation in submarine cable, Bearer
Designation, Cable System Owner
Internal ID etc.)
6.3 Proposed/tentative date of testing of
backhaul circuit
6.4 Proposed test schedule and copy of
work-order/document issued by owner of
cable system along with any other related
technical information to facilitate
planning of Reference Capacity testing.
6.5 End to end testing (between the
station of eligible Indian International
Telecommunication Entity and distant
end submarine cable station) schedule
and provisioning of access of the
Reference Capacity at cable landing
station.
21
7. Details of Reference Capacity owner(s)/submarine cable capacity
owner(s) (See clause (c) under sub-regulation (1) of regulation 4)
7.1 Name of the company and
address
7.2 Contact person
7.2.1 Name:
7.2.2 Phone:
7.2.3 Email:
7.2.4 Fax:
8.Details of backhaul circuit provider(s) (Domestic Link including local
loop)
8.1 Name of the company and address
8.2 Contact person
8.2.1 Name:
8.2.2 Phone:
8.2.3 Email:
8.2.4 Fax:
9. Registration fee payment details
9.1Cheque/Banker’s Cheque/Demand Draft No. __________ dated
________ for Rs . ________________Drawn on (bank/branch)
_______________________
10. Name of authorized signatory of
this form (Please attach authorization)
11. Any other details required to be
given but not specified at serial
numbers 1 to 10 of this Form.
AUTHORIZED SIGNATORY
Date: _____________ Name: ___________________
Signature: ________________
Official Seal:
22
PART – II
(See regulations 3, 7, 10, 12, 14 and 16)
Details of Charges
(1)
Amount payable
(Rupees)
(2)
1. Access Facilitation Charges for eligible Indian International
Telecommunication Entity, being access seeker
1.1 In case of Indefeasible Rights of Use, one time Access Facilitation
Charges per unit capacity payable on execution of the Access Facilitation
agreement
Sl.No. Per Unit Capacity
(i) STM-1
(ii) STM-4
(iii) STM-16
(iv) STM-64
1.2 In case of lease, recurrent Access Facilitation Charges per annum per
unit capacity payable on execution of the Access Facilitation agreement
and thereafter before the due date (anniversary of commissioning date)
each year subsequently. (applicable only for first three years or period as
applicable for each unit capacity)
Sl.No. Per Unit Capacity
(i) STM-1
(ii) STM-4
(iii) STM-16
(iv) STM-64
2. Annual Operation & Maintenance (O&M) charges for eligible
Indian International Telecommunication Entity, being access seeker
2.1 Charges per annum per unit payable on the execution of the Access
Facilitation agreement and thereafter before the due date (anniversary of
commissioning date) each subsequent year.
Sl.No. Per Unit Capacity
(i) STM-1
(ii) STM-4
(iii) STM-16
(iv) STM-64
23
3. Restoration charges one time per unit capacity in the event of
termination or discontinuance of access facilities
Sl.No. Per unit capacity
(i) STM-1
(ii) STM-4
(iii) STM-16
(iv) STM-64
4. Co-location charges: (Please specify the items
and their charges separately i.e. building space
charges per sq feet, duct & cable runway charges,
distribution frame, AC power including standby AC
Power, DC power, air conditioning including other
physical / environmental services, security and site
maintenance etc)
5. Cancellation charges for eligible Indian
International Telecommunication Entity, being
access seeker (See Regulation 12)
Sl.No. Per Unit Capacity
(i) STM-1
(ii) STM-4
(iii) STM-16
(iv) STM-64
6. Any other charges or details for eligible Indian
International Telecommunication Entity, being
access seeker but not specified at serial numbers
1 to 5 of this Form
Note: The owner of cable landing station shall provide to the Authority, the
costing elements considered, their costs and costing methodology employed
along with calculations sheet in arriving at the charges submitted above in
Part-II of the Schedule of these regulations for international submarine
cable capacity access and co-location facilities etc., while submitting the
Cable Landing Station-Reference Interconnect Offer as per clause (d) of
sub-regulation (1) of regulation 3.
24
PART - III
TIME PERIOD FOR PROVISION OF ACCESS FACILITATION
SERVICES AND CO-LOCATION SERVICES BY OWNER OF CABLE
LANDING STATION
(See regulation 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 15 and 16)
Activity
(1)
Days
(Time limit)
A. TIME PERIOD FOR PROVISION OF ACCESS FACILITATION
SERVICES
1.Eligible Indian International Telecommunication
Entity, being access seeker submits request to owner of
cable landing station
Day 1
2. Owner of cable landing station checks feasibility and
reverts to eligible Indian International
Telecommunication Entity, being access seeker with
acceptance or modified schedule for access facilitation
and testing; provides proforma for invoice
Day 11
(max 10 days)
3. Date of firm demand {x is the time taken by of eligible
Indian International Telecommunication Entity, being
access seeker to sign the Access Facilitation agreement
including the payment as per invoice}; x is the time limit
max 5 days as per clause (a) and also 5 days as per
clause (b) below:-
Day 11+x
(a) Time limit for Access Facilitation agreement by
eligible Indian International Telecommunication
Entity
5 days
(b) Time limit for payment as per invoice by eligible
Indian International Telecommunication Entity
5 days
4. Eligible Indian International Telecommunication
Entity, being access seeker arranges and provides
backhaul {y is the time taken by eligible Indian
International Telecommunication Entity to arrange and
provide the backhaul circuit}; y is the time limit max 10
days as per clause (a) below:-
Day 11+x+y
(a) Time limit for eligible Indian International
Telecommunication Entity to arrange for backhaul
circuit from any of the service providers including
cable landing stations owner having backhaul
circuit capacity at the cable landing station
10 days
25
5. Owner of cable landing station Cable Landing Station
to complete all actions with a view to facilitate access to
reference capacity
Day 22+x+y
(max 10 days)
6. Owner of cable landing station extend Reference
Capacity to cable landing station and provide cross
connection immediately but not more than 2 days after
completion of step 5.
Day 22/24
+x+y
(max 2 days)
7. Any other details required to be given but not specified
at serial numbers 1 to 6 of the Para A of this Form
B. TIME PERIOD FOR PROVISION OF CO-LOCATION SERVICES
1.Eligible Indian International Telecommunication
Entity, being access seeker submits Request to owner of
cable landing station
Day 1
2. Owner of cable landing station checks feasibility and
reverts to eligible Indian International
Telecommunication Entity, being access seeker with
acceptance or rejection with reasons and with alternative
proposal
Day 11
(max 10 days)
3. Owner of cable landing station provides provision of
Co-location at cable landing station (z is the time taken
by of eligible Indian International Telecommunication
Entity, being Access Seeker to sign the co-location
agreement and payment of charges); Z is the time limit
max 5 days as per clause (a) and also 5 days as per
clause (b) below:-
Day 12+z
(a) Time limit for the co-location agreement by
eligible Indian International Telecommunication
Entity
5 days
(b) Time limit for payment of charges for Co-location
by eligible Indian International Telecommunication
Entity
5 days
4. Any other details required to be given but not specified
at serial numbers 1 to 3 of the Para B of this Form
26
PART-IV
Form of Request for Co-Location Facility and Services
(See regulation 15)
Application for Request to Co-location Facility at Cable Landing
Station for International Submarine Cable Capacity
M/s ………………...…………...……….(Name of access seeker) hereby
request for Co-location facility, which is subject to the terms and
conditions published in “Cable Landing Station-Reference Interconnect
Offer (CLS-RIO) made under the provisions of the Telecommunication
Access to Essential Facilities at Cable Landing Stations regulations,
2007.
M/s ………………...…………...……….furnish the necessary details as
follows.
1. Name of the company and its
address
2. Billing address
3. Contact person
3.1 Name:
3.2 Phone No:
3.3 Email:
3.4 Fax:
4. Particulars of eligible Indian International Telecommunication
Entity, being Access Seeker:
4.1 International Long Distance
Operator
4.2 Internet Service Provider
4.3 Licence number:
4.4 Date of issue of Licence
27
5. Details of eligible Indian International Telecommunication Entity
requesting for Co-location
5.1 Date of application
5.2 Application reference No.
5.3 Approval for physical access is
sought for the purpose of:
5.4 Reference date /time of access
5.5 Estimated duration of access
No Name of Person Contact No.
1
2
3
5.6 Name of Person(s) for which
physical access is required
4
5.7 The Co-location site at which
Co-location space is requested:
5.8 Purpose of accessing
submarine cable capacity:
5.9 Co-location equipment
proposed to be installed:
5.10 The space and power
requirements:
5.11 The floor loading of the Co-
location equipment:
5.12 The capacity of the
Transmission Tie-Cable required:
5.13 The type of optical fibre cable
to be used:
28
6. On Behalf of eligible Indian International Telecommunication
Entity
6.1 Name:
6.2 Designation
6.3 Contact Number
6.4 Fax Number
6.5 e-mail id
6.6 Company Seal
6.7 Signature
7. Owner of Cable Landing Stations’ (Name) reply to the requesting
eligible Indian International Telecommunication Entity
7.1 Application returned –
incomplete / illegible
7.2 Not approved
7.3 Reasons for rejection
8. Approved subject to details & conditions given in the attached
letter of authorization
8.1 Alternative date & time
8.2 Alternative co-location site (if
applicable)
8.3 Owner of cable landing station
approval code
9. On Behalf of owner of cable landing station
9.1 Name
9.2 Designation
9.3 Contact number
9.4 e-mail id
9.5 Fax No.
29
9.6 Company seal
9.7 Signature
PART-V
CO-LOCATION EQUIPMENT INSTALLATION AND MAINTENANCE
GUIDELINES
(See regulation 19)
1. INSTALLATION OF EQUIPMENT AT CO-LOCATION SPACE
1.1 Installation of Co-location equipment
(a) Prior to commencing installation of its Co-location equipment, the
eligible Indian International Telecommunication Entity, being access
seeker must submit detailed installation plans and installation schedule.
(b) The eligible Indian International Telecommunication Entity, being
access seeker, must ensure that the floor loading of its Co-located
equipment shall be limited to as specified by owner of cable landing
station. The eligible Indian International Telecommunication Entity,
being access seeker shall certify that the floor loading limit will not
exceed as specified.
(c) The eligible Indian International Telecommunication Entity, being
access seeker must install its Co-location equipment in the Co-location
space within ninety days after the final site inspection or as mutually
agreed. If the eligible Indian International Telecommunication Entity,
being access seeker, failure to complete installation is attributable to
circumstances beyond the reasonable control of eligible Indian
International Telecommunication Entity, owner of cable landing station
will grant a reasonable extension of time for installation to the eligible
Indian International Telecommunication Entity, at his request. Eligible
Indian International Telecommunication Entity, being access seeker,
request under this clause must describe the circumstances beyond its
control and such request must be received prior to the expiry of the
aforementioned ninety days period.
(d) The eligible Indian International Telecommunication Entity, being
access seeker must not locate equipment other than Co-location
equipment in the Co-location space.
30
1.2 Optical Fibre Cable
Unless otherwise agreed by the parties, the eligible Indian International
Telecommunication Entity, being access seeker, must not install more
than two physical optical fibre cables in the Co-location space and up to
the lead-in manhole outside Co-location space.
1.3 Power & Earth
Owner of cable landing station shall, if the eligible Indian International
Telecommunication Entity, being access seeker so desires, designate and
provide the Exchange Earth and Power Distribution Point for the eligible
Indian International Telecommunication Entity. The eligible Indian
International Telecommunication Entity, being access seeker, shall pay
owner of cable landing station the charges for the provision of the
Exchange Earth and power installation and termination in accordance
with owner of cable landing station published Co-location charges.
1.4 Interference
Each Party shall ensure that its Co-location equipment does not cause
any interference to the other Party’s equipment, plant, facilities, Networks
and the equipment of other occupying eligible Indian International
Telecommunication Entity, being access seeker, in the Co-location space,
including when installing equipment. In the event of any interference, the
parties shall take in good faith reasonable measures to resolve the
problem promptly. Where the eligible Indian International
Telecommunication Entity’s equipment is causing interference to existing
equipment and the interference cannot be resolved, the eligible Indian
International Telecommunication Entity shall remove the source of
interference immediately.
1.5 Standard Operating Procedures and Safety
(a) Regarding the installation, operation and maintenance of its Co-
located equipment located in the Co-location space, the eligible Indian
International Telecommunication Entity, being access seeker, must
comply with owner of cable landing station Standard Operating
Procedures for Co-location space and any written instructions, which are
provided to the eligible Indian International Telecommunication Entity by
owner of cable landing station.
(b) Regarding the physical access to the Co-location space, the eligible
Indian International Telecommunication Entity shall comply with owner
of cable landing station Standard Physical Access Procedures as
amended from time to time and any written instructions, which are
provided to the eligible Indian International Telecommunication Entity by
owner of cable landing station.
31
(c) Owner of cable landing station will get the Co-location space inspected
by its representatives/staff to which access has been approved for the
installation, modification, replacement or addition of the equipment to
verify that the eligible Indian International Telecommunication Entity,
being access seeker, is undertaking the installation, modification,
maintenance, operation, replacement or addition of the equipment in
accordance with the plan and such other written instructions provided to
the eligible Indian International Telecommunication Entity.
(d) The eligible Indian International Telecommunication Entity, being
access seeker, shall consult with and obtain the consent of owner of
cable landing station before carrying out any hacking or drilling work on
the floor, wall and ceiling slabs.
(e) No work shall be performed by the eligible Indian International
Telecommunication Entity, being access seeker, on any of equipment,
facilities, plant or Networks including, but not limited to earth bars and
Power Distribution Points/boards of the owner of cable landing station.
(f) Owner of cable landing station staff shall carry out all the
interconnection of the eligible Indian International Telecommunication
Entity, being access seeker, Co-location equipment to owner of cable
landing station earth bars and Power Distribution Points/boards.
Charges for the work shall be borne by the eligible Indian International
Telecommunication Entity, as set out in owner of cable landing station
published Co-location charges.
(g) Where, during the course of installation, operation, maintenance,
replacement or repair of its Co-located equipment the eligible Indian
International Telecommunication Entity, being access seeker, causes any
damage to owner of cable landing station Co-location site, plant, network,
equipment or facilities, the eligible Indian International
Telecommunication Entity, being access seeker, must report the damage
immediately to owner of cable landing station. Owner of Cable Landing
Station shall rectify the damage in any way it deems fit, the cost and
expense thereof shall be borne by the eligible Indian International
Telecommunication Entity, being access seeker.
1.6 Final Inspection
(a) Upon completion of the installation of the Co-location equipment in
the Co-location space, the eligible Indian International
Telecommunication Entity, being access seeker, shall advise owner of
cable landing station and request owner of cable landing station to
32
conduct a final inspection and confirm that the installation conforms to
the approved detailed installation plans.
(b) Where the final inspection reveals that the installation does not
materially conform to the approved detailed installation plans; owner of
cable landing station shall notify the eligible Indian International
Telecommunication Entity, being access seeker. The eligible Indian
International Telecommunication Entity, being access seeker must
reinstall or take other appropriate corrective action within ten (10)
working days of notification, or such other time as is otherwise agreed.
(c) If the eligible Indian International Telecommunication Entity, being
access seeker, fails to reinstall or take the appropriate corrective action
referred to in clause 1.6(b) above, the owner of cable landing station may
take appropriate corrective action including removal of the eligible Indian
International Telecommunication Entity’s Co-location equipment. The
reasonable costs for the corrective action shall be borne by the eligible
Indian International Telecommunication Entity, being access seeker.
2. MAINTENANCE OF CO-LOCATION EQUIPMENT IN CO-LOCATION
SPACE
2.1 The eligible Indian International Telecommunication Entity, being
access seeker, shall be responsible for the operation and maintenance of
its Co-location equipment or as mutually agreed with the owner of cable
landing station.
2.2 If a fault, defect or problem with the Co-location equipment of the
eligible Indian International Telecommunication Entity, being access
seeker, causes damage to the Co-location space or facilities of the owner
of cable landing station, the eligible Indian International
Telecommunication Entity, being access seeker must:
(a) notify owner of cable landing station as soon as practicable; and
(b) repair the fault, defect or problem or take other appropriate corrective
action immediately.
2.3 The Co-location equipment must only be used by the eligible Indian
International Telecommunication Entity, being access seeker, for the
purpose of connecting the eligible Indian International
Telecommunication Entity’s Network to access Reference Capacity on
specified international submarine cable at cable landing station under
this Schedule or for interconnection with other service providers’
equipment/ network located in cable landing station for provisioning of
backhaul circuit.
33
2.4 Compliance
(a) The eligible Indian International Telecommunication Entity, being
access seeker, must ensure that its employees, agents and approved sub
contractors comply with the provisions of this document including all
reasonable procedures and directions of owner of cable landing station as
notified from time to time.
(b) The eligible Indian International Telecommunication Entity, being
access seeker, must comply with all laws, standards, authorizations and
leases when performing works.
(c) The eligible Indian International Telecommunication Entity, being
access seeker, must ensure that it has all necessary permits, approvals
and leases from any person, governmental, regulatory or relevant
authority in order to perform works or provide service.
d) The eligible Indian International Telecommunication Entity, being
access seeker, will vests no right, title or proprietary interest in the Co-
location site.
2.5 Marking of Equipment
The Co-location equipment must be marked by the eligible Indian
International Telecommunication Entity, being access seeker, to clearly
indicate that it is leased by the eligible Indian International
Telecommunication Entity, and in such manner as owner of cable
landing station may reasonably direct.
PART - VI
Form of Letter of Authorization for Physical Access to Co-Location
Space
(See regulation 20)
This Letter of Authorization is issued in conjunction with the final
approval given to the request application via reference _________________
date _________________
It must be carried in the possession of the designated supervisor/person
at all time during the period of access granted to the Co-location space as
indicated below
Location of Co-location space granted for access:
[Location / Building name]
Photo identity
1. Approved date of access
34
2. Approved time of access
3. Approved duration of access
On behalf of owner of cable landing station
Signature …………………..…….
Name ………………………….
Contact phone number…………….
Fax No………………
PART - VII
Form of Name and Details of Personnel to be Authorized
(See regulation 20)
Sl.No. Name of the Persons/
Representatives/
Contractor of eligible
Indian International
Telecommunication
Entity (access seeker)
Identity
Card No.
Contact Tel. No. Fax No.
1
2
3
4
-
(R.K. Arnold)
Secretary
Note. -------The Explanatory Memorandum explains the objects and
reasons of the International Telecommunication Access to Essential
Facilities at Cable Landing Stations Regulations, 2007 (5 of 2007).
35
EXPLANATORY MEMORANDUM TO THE INTERNATIONAL
TELECOMMUNICATION ACCESS TO ESSENTIAL FACILITIES AT
CABLE LANDING STATIONS REGULATIONS, 2007 (5 OF 2007)
1. BACKGROUND
1.1 International Private Leased Circuits (IPLC) is one of the significant
elements of international connectivity for Internet, Broadband and IP
enabled services. The international connectivity consists of distant end
IPLC half circuit, near end IPLC half circuit and access to submarine
cable landing stations. At the time of opening of the international long
distance telecom services to private sector in the year 2002, the
Government had realized that submarine cable landing station is
essentially a bottleneck facility and the fact that access to international
connectivity would be severally influenced by monopolistic position of the
incumbent International Long Distance (ILD) operator.
1.2 In order to enhance competition in international connectivity
segment, Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) initiated a
consultation process in June 2005. TRAI made recommendations to
Department of Telecommunications (DOT) on measures to promote
competition in International Private Leased Circuits in India on December
16, 2005. TRAI’s recommendations pertaining to access to essential
facilities including landing facilities for submarine cables have been
accepted by the licensor. The Department has also amended relevant
clauses in ILD licence to enable TRAI to bring out regulations to ensure
efficient, transparent and non-discriminatory Access to Essential
Facilities (including landing facilities) for submarine cables at Cable
Landing Stations.
1.3 The Authority has, thereafter, for the purpose of bringing out
regulations to ensure efficient, transparent and non-discriminatory
access to Essential Facilities, including landing facilities for submarine
cables, at Cable Landing Stations released a Consultation Paper on 13th
April, 2007 including the draft regulations with detailed description to
various terms & conditions proposed for access facilitation for submarine
cables at Cable Landing Station (CLS) and co-location of equipment at
CLS. The stakeholders were to submit written comments by the 30th April
2007. On the request of some of the stakeholders, the date for
submission of written comments was extended till the 7th May 2007.
Written comments were received from AT&T, Orange Business Services,
BT Global Services, BSNL, MTNL, Bharti, VSNL, Reliance, Cables &
Wireless, Sify Communications Ltd., Verizon Communications Pvt. Ltd.,
ISPAI, Telxess Consulting Service Pvt. Ltd. and Asia Pacific Carriers’
Coalition. Gist of comments received from stakeholders by the extended
date of submission of comments i.e. 7th May 2007 was placed on the
TRAI’s website. Open House Discussion was held on 14th May 2007 in
36
Delhi with the stakeholders wherein stakeholders had expressed their
views on various aspects of the subject.
2. EXAMINATION OF MAIN COMMENTS MADE AND ISSUES
RAISED BY STAKEHOLDERS
2.1 The Authority has taken various comments and inputs of the
stakeholders into consideration and analysed the matter in detail. For
the sake of clarity the comments made and issues raised by stakeholders
are given in italics followed by consideration and decision of the Authority
on the points.
2.2 ISSUE 1: APPLICABILITY AND NECESSITY OF REGULATION
2.2.1 The comments received from the stakeholders on this issue are
summarized below in Paras (a) to (d) and dealt with in the paragraphs
following thereafter.
(a) The scope of the proposed Regulation should be narrowed to focus
on access, co-location and backhaul arrangement at cable landing stations
controlled only by dominant operators.
(b) CLS-RIO to access the essential facilities and co-location at cable
landing stations should be voluntarily published by the concerned landing
station operator, and no ex-ante Regulation should be resorted to.
(c) Access facilitation Regulation for CLS is urgently required to facilitate
access to international capacities as well as co-location facilities at CLS.
(d) This Regulation should not extend to mandating landing
arrangements for new submarine cables.
2.2.2 In this matter, the Authority noted that majority of the
stakeholders are in favour of mandating access and co-location to
submarine cable landing station, which is an essential input for many
international telecommunication services. The Authority further noted
that limiting the scope of this regulation to mandate access, co-location
and backhaul arrangement at cable landing station controlled only by
dominant / incumbent operators would not yield the optimum results
and will also hinder the emergence of sustainable competitive market. It
may also impose burden and obligation only on dominant / incumbent
operators to meet request for access and would, therefore, not be fair.
The Authority is of the view that adequate competition is not there at
present in accessing international bandwidth. Therefore, to create
effective competition in the sector, Cable Landing Station-Reference
Interconnect Offer (CLS-RIO) needs to be mandated for the owner of all
cable landing stations including those would be commissioned in the
future.
37
2.3 ISSUE 2: TIME FRAME FOR SUBMISSION OF DRAFT CLS-RIO
BY OWNER OF NEW CABLE LANDING STATIONS TO THE
AUTHORITY
2.3.1 Following comment received on the issue.
Relevant CLS owner should provide the draft RIO terms no less than
six months prior to a new cable system being activated.
2.3.2 Submitting the draft CLS-RIO six months prior to commissioning a
new cable landing station by owner to the Authority for approval would
not be feasible in some of the cases. Discussion with industry suggested
that establishing an international cable system in India is a time
consuming and complex process involving various clearances including
security clearance, maritime clearance and civil authority permission etc.
Thus it may not be possible for the owner of the cable landing station to
determine the exact date of commissioning of the cable landing station.
Therefore, the Authority is of the opinion that it is sufficient that owner of
the cable landing station submits its CLS-RIO to the Authority on or
before the date of commissioning of the cable landing station.
2.4 ISSUE 3: COMMENT OF OTHER PARTIES ON CLS-RIO
SUBMITTED BY OWNER OF CABLE LANDING STATION (OCLS)
TO THE AUTHORITY FOR APPROVAL
2.4.1 Following comment received on the issue:
Other parties may wish to comment on the proposed CLS-RIO terms
which is submitted to the Authority for approval.
2.4.2 The Authority has noted this point of view of one of the
stakeholders and is of the view that this is not relevant and appropriate
to seek the comments on the CLS-RIO submitted by the OCLS to the
Authority for approval. Since OCLS, while submitting the CLS-RIO, has
been mandated to submit the detail of network cost elements and costing
methodology adopted to arrive at the charges prescribed in various parts
of the CLS-RIO. Therefore, the Authority is of the opinion that seeking
comments again of stakeholders may unnecessarily delay the whole
process and at the same time adequate opportunity has already been
given to stakeholders.
2.5 ISSUE 4: TIME FRAME FOR UPGRADATION
2.5.1 The comments received from the stakeholders on this issue are
summarized below in Paras (a) and (b) and dealt with in the paragraphs
following thereafter.
38
(a) Any facilitation of upgrade facility should be in accordance with a
specified time frame.
(b) There is a no provision in the Regulation to mandate the OCLS to
upgrade the co-location space in case of non-availability.
2.5.2 The capacity upgradation to access the submarine cable capacity
requires procurement of equipment by the requesting eligible Indian
International Telecommunication Entity (ITE) as the entire cost of such
upgradation required to be borne by the requesting ITE or foreign
submarine cable capacity owner with whom the ITE has entered into an
agreement for acquisition of reference capacity. Moreover, basic
ingredients of the upgradation to meet the new landing requirement may
not be uniformly applicable. Therefore, it would suffice if Owner of Cable
Landing Station (OCLS) are mandated to be non-discriminatory and
transparent in their charging for upgradation and time frame and it
should be best left to mutual negotiations in line with the global
practices.
2.6 ISSUE 5: NOTICE BEFORE ACCESS FACILITATION
TERMINATION
2.6.1 Following comment received on the issue:
In addition to the 30 days payment period, the CLS owner would be
required to give the eligible Indian International Telecommunication
Entity (ITE) 14 days prior written notice (with opportunity to rectify
the breach) before the CLS owner could terminate the service.
2.6.2 The Authority considered the concern raised by the stakeholders
regarding notice before termination and decided that if annual operation
and maintenance charges due and payable by the eligible Indian
international telecommunication entity remain unpaid for more than 15
days from the date such charges become payable, the owner of cable
landing station may discontinue the Access Facilitation provided to the
eligible ITE after giving notice, in writing, of not less than 15 days of such
discontinuance to the eligible ITE. The Authority is also of the view that
by having a notice period before termination, may also avoid the
disputes. Moreover, there would be one more advantage by way of notice
period to the affected party i.e eligible Indian International
Telecommunication entity would be able to rectify the breach and also
end consumers will not be affected.
39
2.7 ISSUE 6: INTERCONNECTION AND MANDATING LEASING OF
BACKHAUL FACILITY AT CABLE LANDING STATION FOR
PROVISIONING BACKHAUL CIRCUIT
2.7.1 The comments received from the stakeholders on this issue are
summarized below in Paras (a) and (b) and dealt with in the paragraphs
following thereafter.
(a) Regulation should allow interconnection between co-locating ITEs at
cable landing station. This would offer the ability for international traffic
handoff amongst the ITEs and would offer them access to multiple
backhaul service providers within the cable landing station.
(b) TRAI should mandate the leasing of backhaul facility by dominant
cable station operators for an interim period at cost oriented rates to ensure
that competitive ILDOs do not pay unreasonable charges for these services
before the development of competitive backhaul services at each cable
landing station.
2.7.2 Mandating leasing of backhaul facility to dominant owner of the
cable landing station would discourage any fresh creation of additional
backhaul infrastructure. Instead of mandating owner of cable landing
station to provide backhaul facility, it is better to provide flexibility to
eligible ITE to take backhaul facility from any of the service providers.
This will provide more options to eligible ITEs for backhaul facility. The
primary objective of this Regulation is to mandate access facilitation for
the available international bandwidth and backhaul circuit provisioning
be made available at reasonable terms with flexibility.
2.7.3 Interconnection between co-locating ITEs / backhaul service
providers at CLS would facilitate the provisioning of backhaul circuit
speedily and at competitive rates. Eligible ITE shall also get the benefit of
accessing international reference capacity even without placing its own
equipment at CLS by utilizing the backhaul circuit capacity of other
service providers located there. This would ease the pressure for Co-
location space at cable landing station. The other benefit for not
mandating OCLS for provisioning of backhaul circuit is that the ITE will
get the flexibility of taking backhaul circuits at competitive terms from
any of the service provider including the OCLS. Therefore, the Authority
has made suitable provision accordingly in these regulations.
2.8 ISSUE 7: CHARGES FOR ACCESS FACILITATION AND
OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE TO BE CAPACITY
INDEPENDENT
2.8.1 The comments received from the stakeholders on this issue are
summarized below in Paras (a) to (b) and dealt with in the paragraphs
following thereafter.
40
(a) Charges for cross-connection services should be capacity
independent. The annual recurrent access charges available
commercially at CLS are levied on a per STM-1 or 155 Mbps of cable
capacity. There is a no nexus between the capacity and the cost for
service provision.
(b) Charges should be cost-oriented, access facilitation charges,
annual operation and maintenance charges and restoration charges
should not be structured on a “per unit capacity” basis. Under a cost-
oriented fee structure, only access costs that are incurred on a per
unit capacity basis should be charged on that basis.
2.8.2 The Authority has provided the basic frame work through Schedule
annexed with these regulations for disclosure of charges to be published
by OCLS after the approval of the Authority. The Authority would
consider these points after owners of the CLSs submit their CLS-RIO for
approval with the details of cost of network elements, costing
methodology and calculation sheets etc.
2.9 ISSUE 8: SHARING OF SECURITY MONITORING FACILITY
2.9.1 The comments received from the stakeholders on this issue
are summarized below in Paras (a) to (c) and dealt with in the paragraphs
following thereafter.
(a) the sharing of security monitoring facilities at CLS with new ILD
operators should be mandated.
(b) In the new ILD license conditions there is a provision for sharing
of monitoring capabilities under mutual agreement with existing
licensees from whom international connectivity is taken to provide
layer 2 and layer 3 VPN services. This provision in the license can
enable a new ILD operator to start offering the services in a short
timeframe without waiting to install its own security monitoring
equipment thereby lowering a potential barrier to entry for new
operators.
(c) International telecommunication entities that are accessing the
capacity from cable landing station, should have their own data &
voice monitoring system. The International telecommunication entity
should be responsible for all security guidelines, set as per the
licensing conditions.
2.9.2 The International Long Distance Operators (ILDOs) are fully
responsible to comply with the security conditions imposed on them
through the licence conditions. Licensor has already mandated security
conditions for ILDOs through ILD licence wherein installation of suitable
41
monitoring equipment is necessary for the ILDOs. Mandatory access to
cable landing station should not dilute any of the security condition
which is required as per respective licences. National security is of the
great importance, therefore, sharing of security monitoring facility at CLS
with eligible ITEs/new ILDOs should be governed as per the respective
licences and licensing conditions specified in such regards thereto.
Therefore, the Authority is of the opinion that no regulation or mandating
provision needed for the issue in these regulations
2.10 ISSUE 9: PRE-APPROVAL OF INTERCONNECT AGREEMENT BY
THE TRAI
2.10.1 Following comment received on the issue:
In principle, all agreements between the owner of cable landing
station and eligible ITEs pursuant to the CLS-RIO should be pre-
approved by TRAI. In this respect, the Access Facilitation Agreement
should form part of the pre-approved CLS-RIO. This would avoid any
potential delays and stalemate if it were to be commercially
negotiated and better achieve timely provision of access to and
collocation of essential facilities at Cable Landing Stations.
2.10.2 The Authority is of the opinion that the role of TRAI should be
purely on need basis and once the Cable Landing Station - Reference
Interconnect Offer (CLS-RIO) is approved by the TRAI and published by
OCLS and on the basis of which such Access Facilitation Agreement is
made should be adequate. Further to maintain transparency and non–
discrimination, it would be appropriate if the interconnect agreement is
submitted to the Authority for registration within 15 days from the date
of the agreement. Accordingly provision has been made in these
regulations.
2.11 ISSUE 10: INTERNATIONAL GATEWAY PERMISSION FOR ISP
2.11.1 Following comment received on the issue:
Eligible ITE such as an ISP with international gateway permission
should include both types of permission i.e. submarine cable
gateway and / or satellite gateway.
2.11.2 In this regard, it is understood that there is no separate
international ISP gateway permission for meeting the Internet bandwidth
requirement through International Leased Circuits (IPLCs) provided
either through cable landing stations on submarine cable capacity and
through satellite earth station on satellite media. The ISPs with
International Gateways are fully responsible to comply with the security
conditions imposed on them through the licence conditions. Licensor
42
has already mandated security conditions for ISP through its licence in
this regard wherein installation of suitable monitoring equipment and
obtaining approval/ permission from Department of Telecommunications
(DoT) to operate the ISP International Gateway after security agencies
clearance is necessary for it. Therefore, the Authority is of the opinion
that if an ISP has the permission and security monitoring facilities to
meet the security requirement, it may seek access facilitation being
eligible ITE for international reference capacity at the cable landing
stations.
2.12 ISSUE 11: APPROVAL OF THE ACCESS AND CO-LOCATION
CHARGES
2.12.1 The comments received from the stakeholders on this issue
are summarized below in Paras (a) to (b) and dealt with in the paragraphs
following thereafter.
(a) charges for collocation and access should be determined in the
first instance by the cable landing station owner based on the
relevant costs and should be submitted to the TRAI for approval with
information concerning the underlying cost components. The TRAI
should evaluate these charges on the basis of an international
benchmarking approach by comparing them with similar charges in
other countries.
(b) Cost of real estate, power, human resources, air-conditioning,
taxes etc. and also the cost of extending of capacity from CLS to a
convenient location for access provisioning may be different from
place to place. It would suffice if OCLS are mandated to be non-
discriminatory and transparent in their charging.
2.12.2 The Authority examined the principle that whether the cost based
charges for access facilitation and co-location charges are required to be
prescribed in the regulations or OCLS are mandated to publish non-
discriminatory and transparent charges for access facilitation and co-
location etc. The Authority observed that in most of the countries the
charges are published by the OCLS with the prior approval of the
regulator. The Authority is also of the view that to have reasonable and
fair charges, the need is to have such charges on cost oriented basis and
also to provide first opportunity to the owner of the cable landing station.
It is appropriate that OCLS determine the charges on the basis of cost
oriented principles taking into account the cost involved in access
facilitation, operation & maintenance, cancellation and in provisioning of
co-location facilities including Co-location space and submit to the
Authority. However, these charges will be approved by the TRAI on the
basis of well-established costing methodology already in vogue in the
Authority. Prior-approval of the TRAI will ensure transparency, fairness
and reasonability and also OCLS will not tend to adopt an arbitrary
43
approach in prescribing various charges. Therefore, the Authority has
made provisions in these regulations to address this issue.
2.13 ISSUE 12: PROVISION FOR COMPLAINTS BEFORE THE
AUTHORITY
2.13.1 The comments received from the stakeholders on this issue are
summarized in Paras (a) to (d) and dealt with in the paragraphs following
thereafter.
(a) TRAI should also allow ITEs and other international operators to
bring complaints before the Authority in the event that cable landing
station owners attempt to impede cable station access in any manner,
including in ways not anticipated by these regulations.
(b) Once this framework is implemented, failing which, either
disputing party should be able to call upon TRAI to intervene and provide
resolution to the dispute.
(c) In the case of dispute the jurisdiction lies with TDSAT.
(d) TRAI facilitation is always welcome.
2.13.2 Dispute resolution mechanism lies with the Hon’ble TDSAT.
However, in case of owner of a cable landing station and the eligible
Indian International Telecommunication Entity fail to enter an
agreement, in that case both of them may jointly, without prejudice to
the provisions of the Section 14A of the Act, at any time request the
Authority to facilitate in the process of entering into agreement. For
effective enforcement and implementation of these regulations or any
other regulation made thereto, the Authority may intervene at any time
as per the provision of the TRAI Act. Therefore, the Authority is of the
opinion that there is no need to make separate provision in these
regulations for such complaints. However provision has been made for
facilitating the process of entering into agreements if required by parties
involved.
2.14 ISSUE 13: PENALTIES
2.14.1 The comments received from the stakeholders on this issue are
summarized in Paras (a) to (d) and dealt with in the paragraphs following
thereafter.
(a) Penalties for failure to adhere to mandated time frames are
required to be included.
(b) the mandate may not come into actual practice in spirit and in
words, if there are no provisions for penalties for delay at any step.
44
The authority may kindly include suitable and deterrent financial
penalties in case of proven delays.
(c) The provisions of the proposed regulation will not be effective in
true spirit unless strict penalties are recommended in case of any
contravention. Hence, we would like the Authority to implement
penalties on both the OCLS and the eligible ITE through appropriate
regulations in all cases where the party involved has contravened
any of the provisions put forth by this regulation.
(d) Imposing unnecessary or unnecessary complicated procedures
that increase risks of a requesting party’s non-compliance (thereby
exposing applicant to penalties or to termination of an application)
2.14.2 As per TRAI Act:
“Penalty for contravention of directions of Authority
29. If a person violates directions of the Authority, such person
shall be punishable with fine which may extend to one lakh rupees
and in case of second or subsequent offence with fine which may
extend to two lakh rupees and in the case of continuing
contravention with additional fine which may extend to two lakh
rupees for every day during which the default continues.”
2.14.3 The case of failure to adhere to mandated time frame by the
service providers is a violation of the regulation of the TRAI and would be
dealt with as per the provisions of TRAI Act. Therefore, the Authority is of
the opinion that there is no need to make specific provisions in this
regard.
2.15 ISSUE 14: MANDATING ACCESS TO CAPACITY FOR PRIVATE
CABLE LANDING IN INDIA
2.15.1 Following comments were received on the issue:
The proposed Regulation may not be effective in case of private
cables landing in India. In order to make the proposed Regulation
effective in a real sense, the integrated cable owner should be
obligated to a must provide Regulation, subject to technical
feasibility and availability of the capacity.
2.15.2 The scope of the present regulation is to mandate access to the
cable landing station on fair, non-discriminatory and transparent
manner. There is no rationale for TRAI to make any such separate
provision in these regulations for integrated cable landing station owners
having reference capacity for access facilitation. All OCLSs are subjected
45
to uniformly to these regulations. However, if required at later date that
such integrated cable landing station owners are resorting, in access
facilitation / provisioning of Co-location facilities, to non-discriminatory
and unfair practices than the TRAI would consider appropriate regulatory
intervention as per the situation and the circumstances.
2.16 ISSUE 15: WHILE SUBMITTING CLS-RIO, COSTING ELEMENTS
AND COSTING METHODOLOGY TO BE PROVIDED TO TRAI
2.16.1 The comments received from the stakeholders on this issue are
summarized in Paras (a) to (c) and dealt with in the paragraphs following
thereafter.
(a) Dominant cable landing station owner should submit their
proposed charges for access facilitation and co-location to the TRAI for
approval with information concerning the underlying cost components.
(b) Since there is an adequate competition, there is a no need to
mandate provisioning of costing elements / methodology by OCLS.
(c) The OCLS may be asked to declare the various cost elements of
cable landing station to TRAI in confidence.
2.16.2 Charges for co-location and access should be determined first by
the cable landing station owner based on the relevant cost and should be
submitted to the TRAI for approval with information concerning the costs
components, costing methodology and calculation sheets. Without
having details of the costing elements and methodology adopted by the
OCLS it would be very difficult for the TRAI to evaluate these charges and
approve the same. Access facilitation charges are based on the non-
recurring initial cost of the new access arrangement, including such
elements as the cost of construction, equipment and cross-connect
access which are specific to such arrangements. Similarly, co-location
cost will also comprise the recurring rental and operation and
maintenance cost of building support and maintenance, leasehold, power
and other utilities. These costs also are specific to each access
arrangement or co-location facilities and, therefore, the Authority is of
the view that OCLS should submit CLS-RIO as per the various provisions
in these regulations and as per the Schedule annexed with these
regulations along with the details of costing elements, methodology
employed and calculation sheets etc.
46
2.17 ISSUE 16: MINIMUM COMMITMENT PERIOD FOR CO-
LOCATION SERVICE
2.17.1 The comments received from the stakeholders on this issue are
summarized in Paras (a) to (d) and dealt with in the paragraphs following
thereafter.
(a) A minimum commitment period of three years would provide a
reasonable balance between the need to encourage the competition, by
reducing entry barriers for ITEs.
(b) When the existing resources are utilized there should be no minimum
period of commitment.
(c) General term could be three years initially with six months notice
period in case of early termination and minimum one year payment of co-
location charges even if he vacates before one year period.”
(d) A term of co-location should be co-terminus with the term of reference
capacity. In case of leased capacity there should be provision for
automatic extension of co-location term to match with the term of reference
capacity.
2.17.2 In case of Co-location many times the large amount of resources
need to be created to fulfill the specific requirements of eligible ITE. A
minimum commitment period of three years would provide a reasonable
balance between the need to encourage competition and ensure that Co-
location arrangement are maintained for a sufficient period necessary for
reasonable returns to OCLS. Normally reference capacity is being taken
on Indefeasible Right of Use (IRU) or annual lease or on long lease basis,
therefore, Co-located eligible ITEs would like to have a certainty for such
facilities till the arrangement exist for access facilitation for reference
capacity. The Authority considered that since eligible ITE would take
international reference capacity on IRU basis or on lease basis for certain
number of years, therefore, it would be desirable that extension of t
Previous and next
Questions people ask
Is form OF CABLE LANDING STATION-REFERENCE of International Telecommunication Access to Essential Facilities at Cable Landing Stations Regulations, 2007 still in force?
No repeal of International Telecommunication Access to Essential Facilities at Cable Landing Stations Regulations, 2007 is recorded.