Form, TELECOM CONSUMERS PROTECTION AND REDRESSAL OF GRIEVANCES REGULATIONS, 2007 (3 OF 2007): FORM
TELECOM CONSUMERS PROTECTION AND REDRESSAL OF GRIEVANCES REGULATIONS, 2007 (3 OF 2007) - Form
Text of form
FORM
FORM
(See regulation 11 of the of Telecom Consumers Protection and Redressal
of Grievances Regulations, 2007}
Appeal under regulation 11 of the Telecom Consumers Protection and
Redressal of Grievances Regulations, 2007 to the appellate authority
appointed by-------------------------------------------------------------
(mention name and address of service provider)
1. The Name, Address, Telephone Number,
Facsimile number and the e-mail address of
the Appellant.
2. Telephone Number or Cellular Mobile
Telephone Number or Broadband
Connection Identity, as the case may be, for
which appeal is filed
3. The name of the city /district of the origin
of complaint
4. The name of the State or licensed service
area, as the case may be, of the origin of
complaint.
5. Nature of Complaint (specify, whether
complaint relates to
Provisioning/Activation/Billing/ Fault-
Repair/Service disruption /disconnection of
service/ Value Added Service / Closure /
Termination or specify if any other).
6. The docket number allotted by the Call
Centre at the time of lodging complaint
under clause (a) of sub-regulation (1) of
regulation 4 and date of lodging the
complaint with the Call Centre.
7. The unique complaint number
communicated by the Nodal Officer under
clause (c) of regulation 8, and date of lodging
the complaint with the Nodal Officer.
8. Date of decision of the Nodal Officer and
decision intimated by the Nodal Officer
20
under clause (d) of regulation 8, if any.
9. Statement of Facts relating to grievance or
appeal:
(attach separate sheet signed by Appellant if
required)
10. Grounds of Appeal:
A full description of the matter, which is the
cause of the grievance, including copies of
any relevant and supporting documents, if
any, and the relief claimed in Appeal
(attach separate sheet signed by Appellant if
required).
11. A statement to the effect that same
subject matter or issue, for which an appeal
has been filed under these regulations, is not
covered in any proceedings before any court
or tribunal or under the Consumer Protection
Act,1986 (68 of 1986) or any other law for
the time being in force.
12. Details of any other relevant
material or document.
13. Whether the Appellant
requests to grant him exemption
from appearing in person and
decide the appeal on the basis of
information, document or record
filed by him.
Form for verification
I,_____________________________________________ (name in full and in
block letters), the appellant, son/daughter of
_____________________________ do hereby declare that to the best of my
knowledge and belief, the information given in this appeal and the
annexure and statements accompanying the appeal are correct, complete
and truly stated.
21
……………………………
Signature of appellant
(Name of appellant)…………………
(Specify status of the appellant, whether a
company/firm/society/ individual/ others
………………………………..…….. )
Note1. The Form of appeal, grounds of appeal and the Form of
verification appended shall be signed by the appellant.
Note2. The appellant shall submit in duplicate the appeal in this Form.
SCHEDULE
(See regulation 5)
Service Parameters and Time Limit for Service Request or Redressal
of Complaint of Telecom Consumers by Call Centres
A. Basic Service (Wire line):
Serial
Number
(1)
Service Parameter
(2)
Time Limit for service request or
redressal of complaint
(3)
(i) Provision of Telephone All cases within seven days
(subject to technical feasibility)
(ii) Fault Repair Within three days
(iii) Shift of Telephone Within three days
(iv) Closures Within twenty four hours
(v) Percentage of Billing
Complaints resolved
with in four weeks
All billing complaints to be resolved
within four weeks.
(vi) Time taken for refund
of deposits after closure
All cases of refund of deposits to be
made within sixty days after
closure.
B. Basic Service (Wireless) and Cellular Mobile Telephone Service:
Serial Service Parameter Time Limit for service request or
redressal of complaint
22
Number
(1)
(2) (3)
(i) Billing Performance
(a) Percentage of Billing
Complaints resolved
with in four weeks
(b) Period of all refunds
/payments due to
customers from
the date of
resolution of
complaints
(a) All billing complaints to be
resolved within four weeks.
(b) All cases of refunds or payments
due to customers to be made within
four weeks from the date of
resolution of billing complaints.
C. Broadband Service:
Serial
Number
(1)
Service Parameter
(2)
Time Limit for service request or
redressal of complaint
(3)
(i) Service Provisioning
/Activation Time
All cases within fifteen days
(subject to technical feasibility).
(ii) Fault Repair /
Restoration Time
Within three days
(iii) Billing Performance
(a) Percentage of Billing
Complaints
resolved.
(b) Time taken for
refund of deposits
after closure
(a) All billing complaints to be
resolved within four weeks.
(b) All cases of refund of deposits to
be made within sixty days after
closure.
(R.K. Arnold)
Secretary
23
Note. -------The Explanatory Memorandum explains the objects
and reasons of the Telecom Consumers Protection and Redressal of
Grievances Regulations, 2007.
EXPLANATORY MEMORANDUM TO THE TELECOM CONSUMERS
PROTECTION AND REDRESSAL OF GRIEVANCES REGULATIONS,
2007 (3 OF 2007)
DATED THE 4TH MAY, 2007
1. BACKGROUND
1.1 Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) has been receiving a
large number of complaints from telecom consumers relating to the
telecom services provided by the service providers. Though the Telecom
Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997 confers powers upon the TRAI to
lay down the standards of quality of service to be provided by service
providers and to ensure the quality of service and conduct the periodical
survey of such service provided by the service providers so as to protect
the interest of consumers of telecommunication service, there is no
specific provision in the TRAI Act imposing obligation or duty upon the
TRAI for redressal of individual complaints and therefore such
complaints by a consumer is to be addressed by courts or other
appropriate forum under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986. Under the
provisions of the TRAI Act, a group of consumers can petition the
Telecom Dispute Settlement and Appellate Tribunal (TDSAT) for redressal
of any dispute between a service provider and a group of consumers.
However, TRAI does take cognizance of complaints of generic nature i.e.
complaints affecting a large number of consumers or showing systemic
inadequacy or cases indicating alleged violation of orders/ regulations /
directions issued by the TRAI.
1.2 The conditions of the licence issued under Section 4 of the Indian
Telegraph Act, 1885, inter alia requires the licensee to notify in writing all
the arrangements with respect to repair, fault rectification, compensation
or refunds. The conditions in the licence also provide that all complaints
in this regard will be addressed/ handled as per the guidelines, order or
regulation or direction issued by the licensor or TRAI from time to time.
1.3 TRAI has laid down the Quality of Service standards for basic,
cellular mobile telephone, Internet (dial-up) and Broadband service.
TRAI has also issued the Quality of Service (Code of Practice for Metering
and Billing Accuracy) Regulation providing for independent audit of the
metering and billing system. Though these Orders, Directions and
Regulations address the concerns of consumers, TRAI has not notified
any Regulation detailing the procedure for handling consumer
complaints or consumer grievance redressal mechanism.
24
1.4 The Department of Telecommunications (DoT) vide their direction
No.16-6/2005-BS-II dated 22.09.2005 had directed all Access Service
Licensees, all Cellular Mobile Telephone Service Licensees, Bharat
Sanchar Nigam Limited and Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Limited to set
up a Consumer Grievance Redressal Mechanism at the (a) Call Centre
level and (b) an Appellate Authority within the company.
1.5 TRAI has institutionalized mechanism for registration for
consumer organizations with TRAI. TRAI interacts periodically with
these consumer organizations or Consumer Advocacy Groups (CAGs)
registered with it. Through mutual discussions between these consumer
organizations and service providers, a Common Charter of Telecom
Service was finalized, under the aegis of TRAI, to be adopted by the
service providers on a voluntary basis. Through this Common Charter
human interface with responsible company executives called Nodal
Officers was envisaged and accordingly the service providers appointed
Nodal Officers in licensed service areas.
1.6 Absence of defined framework for functioning of the existing
redressal mechanisms is leading to customer dissatisfaction. Also going
by the number and nature of complaints being received at TRAI, it is
seen that the present institutional mechanism for handling consumer
complaints is not effective. The redressal of grievances of individual
consumer through courts or forum or commission under the Consumer
Protection Act, 1986 is time consuming and at times costly, considering
the stakes involved. As a result, the consumers have been filing
complaints to various authorities in the Government and TRAI. There is a
need for an effective mechanism for a speedy, effective, transparent and
inexpensive complaint redressal, within the company i.e. service
provider. It is in this background that the Authority issued a
consultation paper including draft regulations on the proposed
institutional mechanism on 3rd January 2007.
2. INSTITUTIONAL MECHANISM FOR REDRESSAL OF
CONSUMER GRIEVANCES PROPOSED IN THE CONSULTATION
PAPER
2.1 Before making the Telecom Consumers Protection and Redressal of
Grievances Regulations, 2007, the Authority initiated a detailed
consultation process, including issue of a Consultation Paper on the
subject and making available the draft of said regulations to the public
and initiating open house discussions.
2.2 The institutional mechanism for redressal of consumer grievances
proposed in the Consultation Paper is summarized below:-
25
(a) The proposed institutional mechanism focuses on resolution of
consumers grievances within the company. It defines institutional
mechanism at the level of Call Centre, Nodal Officer and appellate
authority. It also outlines the processes and procedures and time
limits for redressal of grievances at these levels.
(b) Consumers may contact the Call Centre of service provider on toll
free number at the first instance for redressal of their grievances. All
the complaints, pertaining to fault/ service disruption, shall be
attended within three days and all other complaints shall be attended
by the Call Centre within seven days, subject to time limits laid down
in Regulations on Quality of Service.
(c) In case the consumer is not satisfied with the redressal of his
grievance at the Call Centre level or in case the Call Centre within the
above time limit does not attend to the complaint, he may approach
the Nodal Officer for redressal of his grievance. All grievances received
by the Nodal Officer with respect to fault or service disruption or
repair/ restoration of fault shall be got redressed within three days
and other grievances shall be redressed by the Nodal Officer within
ten days of the registration of the grievance.
(d) In case the consumer is still not satisfied with the redressal of his
grievance by the Nodal Officer or in case his complaint is not
redressed by the Nodal Officer within the above time limit or no reply
is received regarding resolution of the complaint from Nodal Officer,
he may appeal to the appellate authority for redressal of his grievance
and the appellate authority shall decide on the appeal within thirty
days.
(e) The service provider shall publish a “Manual of Practice for
handling consumer complaints” outlining the various provisions, time
limits, benchmarks and procedures for seeking redressal of grievances
including information which affects the consumers.
3. VIEWS OF STAKEHOLDERS RECEIVED ON THE ISSUES FOR
CONSULTATION AND ANALYSIS THEREOF:
3.1 Comments were sought on the issues raised in the consultation
paper by 20.2.2007 and Open House Discussions were held at Delhi on
27.2.07 and at Bangalore on 28.2.07. The Authority received comments
from 20 stakeholders viz. service providers – Bharat Sanchar Nigam
Limited (BSNL), Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Limited (MTNL), Reliance
Communications Ltd., Tata Teleservices Ltd., Videsh Sanchar Nigam
Limited and Sify, industry associations Cellular Operators Association of
26
India (COAI) and Association of Unified Telecom Service Providers
of India (AUSPI), Consumer Organisations - National Consumer Helpline
(NCH), Consumer Online Resource & Empowerment Centre (CORE
Centre), Voluntary Organization in Interest of Consumer
Education(VOICE), Consumer Rights, Education and Awareness Trust
(CREAT), Palakkad District Consumers’ Association, Mumbai Telephone
Users Association, Consumers’ Forum Sagar, Telecom Users Group
(TUG), Consumer Care Society and a few individuals and telecom
consultants etc.
3.2 The Authority has considered the responses received from
stakeholders while finalizing these regulations. The comments by
stakeholders are discussed briefly hereafter. For the sake of clarity, the
comments of the stakeholders are given in the italic font followed by the
analysis and consideration of the authority.
3.3 ISSUE NO.1 - WHETHER THE INSTITUTIONAL MECHANISM TO
HANDLE CONSUMER GRIEVANCES SATISFY THE REQUIREMENTS
OF CONSUMERS FOR SPEEDY, EFFECTIVE AND INEXPENSIVE
REDRESSAL OF COMPLAINTS?
3.3.1 The comments of the stakeholders are summarized in para (a) to (f)
and analysed in the paragraphs following thereafter.
(a) The proposed mechanism will help in improving the handling of
customer complaints.
(b) Presently, main complaint of consumer is “Where should he go? The
Call Centres and IVRS [inter active voice response system] are ineffective
and lack human face. The mechanism is an improvement towards
complaint redressal.
(c) Proposed duration of disposal of appeal does not inspire speedy
disposal.
(d) Existing mechanisms already implemented by service providers are
adequate. There does not seem to be any need for any regulatory
intervention.
(e) COAI supports the initiative of the Authority to evolve a mechanism
for handling consumer grievances in a speedy and effective manner and to
make the existing mechanism more transparent, accessible and effective.
These efforts should be implemented in a self regulated manner and
should not be regulated through a regulation. COAI is already in an
advanced stage for implementing the scheme for setting up / establishing
a Telecom Sector Ombudsman (TSO) which was initiated at the behest of
the Authority some months ago.
(f) The provisions at para 2, page 24 of Consultation Paper (provisions
relating to time limit for compliance in case of complaints relating to non-
27
compliance with QoS Regulations) appear to be unrealistic as its
effectiveness is debatable.
Need for strengthening institutional mechanism:
3.3.2 The complaints being received at TRAI and feedback from
Consumer Advocacy Groups, belies the claim that the existing
mechanism which has already been implemented by service providers is
adequate for speedy, effective and inexpensive redressal of customer
complaints. During the Open House Discussions held at Delhi on
27.02.07, some of the Consumer Advocacy Groups had pointed out that
more than half the licence period is over and so far the service providers
have not taken any steps to address the grievances of consumers in an
effective way. The Authority is of the view that there is a need to revamp
the existing institutional mechanism to make it responsive, sensitive and
answerable to the consumer. The need is to strengthen and specify the
process for institutional mechanism, procedure and time limit for
handling complaints at Call Centres, Nodal Officer level and the appellate
authority. Also there is a need for consumer education and prevention of
grievances through provisioning of information by Manual of Practice to
consumers. The present regulation has been finalized keeping the
inadequacies in view.
Telecom Sector Ombudsman:
3.3.3 Regarding “the initiative of industry associations for implementing
the scheme for setting up / establishing a Telecom Sector Ombudsman
(TSO)”, the Authority welcomes any such step by the industry for
effective and inexpensive redressal of grievances of consumers. But this
step will not replace the mechanism specified in these regulations for
redressal of grievances of telecom consumers as the mechanism
functions within the company.
3.4 ISSUE NO. 2 - PROCEDURE AND TIME LIMIT FOR THE CALL
CENTRE:
3.4.1 The comments of the stakeholders on the procedure and time limit
for the Call Centre are summarized in para (a) to (l) and analysed in the
paragraphs following thereafter.
(a) It is acceptable provided monitoring the performance of Call Centres
is effective and transparent.
(b) Please add: If the consumer is not satisfied, the Call Centre must
provide the contact details of Nodal Officer to the complainant and inform
him that he has a right to approach to the Nodal Officer as per TRAI
guidelines.
28
(c) The procedure and time limit for the Call Centre specified in the
consultation paper is adequate.
(d) Call Centre should be able to give the maximum detailed
information to the callers/ the consumers established “under regulation 3
by the service providers for redressal of Grievances of its consumers on
telephone or other electronics means.”
(e) Docket no. or action taken can be retrieved/ produced by
complainant any time in the future.
(f) We would like to address this issue in the Manual of Practice that is
proposed to be drafted on behalf of the entire industry, which would also
be approved by the Authority.
(g) Regarding time limit of 3 days and 7 days it is submitted that cases
where no parameter/ benchmark is specified in any regulation, the SLA for
complaint redressal would vary and depend on the nature of the
complaint. In case it is still considered necessary then, benchmarks
should be specified in terms of percentages similar to those given in the
TRAI’s QOS Regulations.
(h) The issue of centralized or decentralized Call Centre should be left to
the service providers. Location within or outside the Licensed Service Area
(LSA), should not matter.
(i) No time limit should be specified where no QOS parameters have
been laid down. Instead, SLAs can be recommended by TRAI on
percentage basis as provided in the QoS regulations.
(j) The Call Centre for the Broadband services should be mandated to
operate through other electronic means such as e-mail with all other
parameters regarding grievance handling as it will not be a practical
proposition for internet service providers because of higher
overheads/costs.
(k) The Call Centre should have web based tracking system, should
have a schedule of financial compensation for non-compliance of QOS
parameter, should have features of ISO 10001, ISO 10002, ISO 10003 and
IS 15700 and provide for an independent periodic audit of the system by
independent certified auditor.
(l) While our customer care centre puts in its best efforts to resolve the
complaint of the customer instantly, there is no necessity to specify a
defined time limit (i.e. 3 days) as suggested in the consultation paper.
Time limits for redressal of grievances by Call Centre:
3.4.2 The objective of the proposed regulation is to aim for redressal of
the grievance in a time bound manner with the facility of escalation of
complaints to the next level, if not satisfied with the redressal within the
time limits specified thereto. Also it is difficult to link the QoS parameter
with individual consumer perspective in case the benchmark is indicated
in percentage terms. Accordingly provisions have been made in these
regulations and time limits have been specified in the Schedule for Call
Centre. The time limits that have been specified in these regulations are
29
without prejudice to the benchmarks specified in the
“Quality of Service Regulations” for specific services. In respect of item
relating to Closures in the Schedule annexed with these regulations, the
time limit of 24 hours shall be applicable in respect of closure request
received by the service provider in writing. In respect of closure or
termination requests received through fax, e-mail ID registered with the
service provider, telephone call, SMS and e-mail the time limit and other
conditions for closure or termination of service shall be as per Authority’s
Direction on “Docket Number for Customer Complaints and Termination
of Service” dated 29th August, 2006. The Authority has mandated that
information relating to right of consumer for termination or
disconnection of the service, in accordance with the above direction of
the Authority, shall be incorporated in the Manual of Practice.
3.4.3 As regards the issue raised by one of the stakeholders that in cases
where no parameter/ benchmark is specified in any regulation, the SLA
for complaint redressal would vary and depend on the nature of the
complaint, the Authority is of the view that there should be firm time
limit for redressal of consumer grievances as time limit is the essence of
any grievance redressal mechanism. Leaving the time limit to the service
providers may not lead to effective and timely redressal of complaints.
The Authority has given due importance to fault repair, disruption of
service or disconnection of service and the authority has considered to
specify a maximum of three days for redressal in such cases as
appropriate. However for other complaints or requests for which no
parameter or no time limit is specified in any regulation, for such cases
seven days time limit is considered appropriate by the Authority to
redress the complaint or request by Call Centres. Regarding the service
parameters such as provisioning of telephone or provisioning/activation
of broadband connection where it is not possible to address the request
or redress the complaint due to technical non-feasibility within the time
limits specified in these regulations, Call Centres shall intimate the
reasons for non- redressal and the likely time frame by which the request
will be addressed.
Web based tracking system for grievance redressal:
3.4.4 For the suggestion of web based tracking system for the Call
Centre the authority is of the view that at the Call Centre level the
number of complaints would be large and that the Call Centres may be
operational at different locations/areas for some of the service providers,
especially in basic service. Also a large number of customers may not
have Internet access. Hence, the authority has decided not to mandate
web based tracking system for the Call Centre. However, Service
providers may voluntarily adopt such a system for enabling their
customers to track the complaints made to the Call Centres and Nodal
officers. The Authority is of the view that such a facility should be there
30
for the appellate authority to indicate, at its website or website of
the service provider, the status and details of appeals pending for
disposal. Accordingly, suitable provisions have been made in these
regulations to indicate the status of appeals at the website.
ISO standards for grievance redressal mechanism:
3.4.5 Regarding the suggestion that the “complaint redressal mechanism
should have basic features of ISO 10001, ISO 10002, ISO 10003 and IS
15700”, the Authority has viewed the Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS)
‘IS 15700: 2005’ standard for quality management system – requirement
for service quality by public service organisations and also this matter
was dealt in the consultation paper by mentioning its salient features.
These regulations have been framed considering some of the important
provisions of the said BIS standard. The Authority is not in favour of
mandating the ISO or BIS standards and expects that the service
providers may voluntarily adopt ISO or BIS standards.
Centralised Call Centres:
3.4.6 Referring to the suggestion that the “issue of centralized or
decentralized Call Centre should be left to the service providers to decide,
based on economy in operations and that location within or outside the
Licensed Service Area (LSA) should not matter”, the Authority is aware
that presently some of the service providers have centralized Call Centre
covering many licensed service areas. The Authority acknowledges the
fact that technology enables service providers to have centralized Call
Centre catering to many licensed service areas. Therefore, the Authority
has decided that for different services in a licensed service area or for two
or more licensed service areas, service provider may set-up, at its option,
one or more call centre, being common or separate for such services or
service areas.
Mode of communication with the Call Centre:
3.4.7 Regarding the suggestion that “the Call Centre for the Broadband
services should be mandated to operate through other electronic means
such as e-mail with all other parameters regarding grievance handling as
it will not be a practical proposition for internet service providers because
of higher overheads/costs”, the Authority examined the suggestion and
noted that in case Internet access or broadband connectivity is faulty
then consumers will not be able to contact Call Centre of Broadband
Service provider if there is no access to toll free telephone at its Call
Centre. Therefore, the Authority is not in favour of the Call Centre of
ISPs to operate only through other electronic means such as e-mail and
31
such service providers also have to establish Call Centres as per the
provisions in these regulations.
Information about where to escalate the grievance:
3.4.8 On the issue that the Call Centre must provide the contact details
of Nodal Officer to the complainant, the Authority is of the view that
provision for communication of the contact details of the Nodal Officer,
while communicating the action taken on the complaint by the Call
Centre, would enable consumers to escalate the complaint, in case they
are not satisfied with the redressal of the complaint by the Call Centre.
Monitoring the performance of Call Centres:
3.4.9 On the issue of monitoring the performance of Call Centres,
already there is a parameter “Response time to the customer for
assistance” in the Regulation on Quality of Service of Basic and Cellular
Mobile Telephone Services, 2005 and Quality of Service for Broadband
Service Regulations, 2006 for assessing the efficiency of Call Centres in
responding to the request made to the Call Centre. The performance of
service providers against the benchmarks for this parameter is monitored
on a quarterly basis. Also the performance of service providers against
the benchmark for this parameter is assessed through live test done by
independent agency appointed by the Authority. These regulations also
provide for inspection/ audit of the redressal of grievances of consumers
by Call Centre, Nodal Officer and appellate authority. Issues relating to
inspection and audit are discussed under Issue No.8.
3.5 ISSUE NO. 3 - APPOINTMENT, OBLIGATIONS AND
GEOGRAPHICAL AREA OF NODAL OFFICER:
3.5.1 The comments of the stakeholders on appointment, obligations
and geographical area of Nodal Officer are summarized in para (a) to (h)
and analysed in the paragraphs following thereafter.
(a) Nodal officer must be so located that a subscriber can visit / access
him easily; to be located in a town or tehsil or the local point; and should
provide “Complaint Number & time frame for redressal” instantly.
(b) Appointment of Nodal Officers with defined Geographical Area. His
name, Telephone Number/ Mobile Number/ E-Mail details may please be
got printed on the face of the bills issued by the Service Providers.
(c) We suggest that the Nodal Officers are appointed in each of the
Districts where the service provider is operating.
(d) The coverage area for each Nodal Officer must be a 2 kilometer
radius at the maximum. The number of nodal officers may be also
32
considered in proportion to the total connections in any service area of
that service provider.
(e) The Nodal Officer should be SSA level as well as at Circle level. The
time limit for acknowledgement of complaint by Nodal Officer and its
redressal may modified as per the directive of Ministry of Personnel, Public
Grievances and Pension dated 5.5.2006 which provides for
acknowledgement within 3 days and redressal of grievance within 2
months of its receipt.
(f) The proposal with regard to appointment and obligations of the
Nodal Officers as has been agreed voluntarily in the Common charter of
telecom services, is already in place and functional. It is not necessary to
define the geographical area of Nodal officer. Service providers should be
allowed to appoint nodal officers in areas in such a manner that they are
easily accessible to consumers for their grievances.
(g) We suggest that the number of Nodal officers should be dependent
on the quantum of complaints. The complaint handling procedure proposed
to be mandated is essentially hierarchical in nature.
(h) COAI would like to address the issues regarding appointment,
obligations, geographical area and scope of responsibility of the Nodal
Officer(s), through Manual of Practice that is proposed to be drafted in
coordination with other industry associations.
Location and coverage of the Nodal Officer:
3.5.2 Presently the Nodal Officer is designated by service provider for the
circle or licensed service area as a whole as per the Common Charter.
According to the feedback given by the consumers and consumer
organizations, the system of Nodal Officer is not functioning properly.
The intention for providing a Nodal Officer in the Common Charter was
to enable human interface. Each service provider is expected to provide
speedy and effective grievance redressal mechanism for its consumers
and with this objective the service provider may have to decide, from time
to time, the appropriate locations and coverage for the Nodal Officer. The
Authority would not like to prescribe any yardstick for the geographical
location and coverage of the Nodal Officer. However, the Authority has
mandated in these regulations that every service provider shall appoint
or designate Nodal Officers who are easily accessible and available for
redressal of grievances of the consumers.
Accessibility of Nodal Officer:
3.5.3 While examining the issue of accessibility of Nodal Officer, it is felt
that provisions should be there for consumers directly approaching the
Nodal Officer rather than going through a Call Centre in emergent
situations. The Authority has considered this issue and suitable
provision has been made in these regulations.
33
3.5.4 Regarding the suggestion that the name, Telephone Number/
Mobile Number/ E-Mail details of the Nodal Officer may be got printed on
the bills issued by the Service Providers, the Authority has considered
this suggestion and suitable provisions have been made in these
regulations for publishing the contact details of the Call Centre, Nodal
Officer and appellate authority in the bills, if any, issued to its
consumers by service providers.
Time limit for redressal of grievances by the Nodal Officer:
3.5.5 Regarding the suggestion that the “time limit for acknowledgement
of complaint by Nodal Officer and its redressal may be modified as per
the directive of Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pension
dated 5.5.2006 which provides for acknowledgement within 3 days and
redressal of grievance within 2 months of its receipt”, the Authority is of
the view that the direction of Ministry of Personnel is applicable for
Government Departments for redressal of grievances. This cannot be
linked to complaints/ grievances of telecom consumers who need speedy
redressal. Further in these regulations the concept of Call Centres, Nodal
Officers and appellate authority exists with time limits for each level for
redressal of grievances.
3.6 ISSUE NO. 4 - APPOINTMENT OF AN APPELLATE AUTHORITY
AND THE PROCEDURE FOR DISPOSAL OF APPEALS:
3.6.1 The comments of the stakeholders on appointment of appellate
authority and the procedures for disposal of appeals are summarized in
para (a) to (j) and analysed in the paragraphs following thereafter.
(a) Appellate authority is needed but be designated as Senior Complaint
Redressal Officer. Total time for appeal disposal is very large.
(b) Designation need be changed to a more polite and friendly word.
(c) The procedure for appointment of Appellate Authority by the service
provider and the procedure for disposal of appeals are adequate, but
reservations about its composition.
(d) Appellate authority is essential. But it should not be appointed by
the service providers. The Appellate authority should be at State level.
(e) Each service provider has provided for an appellate officer. It is
better to address the designation, obligations, geographical area and scope
of responsibility of the Presiding (Appellate) Officer(s), in the Manual of
Practice. The office of Telecom Sector Ombudsman (TSO) as finalized by
COAI will be implemented at an early date.
(f) The appellate authority should be appointed from within the service
providers’ organization only. The tenure of the appellate authority and
formal procedure for setting up of secretariat for appellate authority should
be left to service providers.
34
(g) It is recommended to have service provider neutral common
Appellate Authority in place of each service provider establishing its own
Appellate Authority. The existing Telecom Monitoring Cells of DOT could be
assigned the responsibility to act as Appellate Authority for the whole of
telecom sector. Also as per the DoT letter no. 10-8/2006/VTMHQ/gen/3
dated 27-10-2006 one of the responsibility of the VTM cell is “Grievance
Redressal of subscribers in respect of deficiency by various operators”.
(h) The appellate authority can be centrally located at the HQ of the
Internet service provider.
(i) TRAI should be the Apex forum to decide matters not settled by the
appellate authority.
(j) TRAI be the final authority for all such appeals from the consumers
who wish to appeal against the decision of the Appellate Authority.
Designation of the appellate authority:
3.6.2 There have been suggestions regarding re-designation of the
Appellate Authority. Through the proposed regulation it is intended to
define the structural framework of the existing mechanism, of which
“appellate authority” is mandated by DOT. As such, the Authority does
not agree with the suggestions to redesignate “appellate authority”.
Appointment of an appellate authority:
3.6.3 Regarding the appointment of the appellate authority, most of the
consumer organisations agree that appellate authority is essential, but
should not be appointed by the service providers. The Authority has
considered this suggestion and is of the view that the objective of the
proposed regulation is to structurally define the framework of the
consumer grievance redressal mechanism and as per the directions of
DOT the appellate authority should be from the company. The Authority
favours the key role of service provider in this regard. For the same
reason, the functions of appellate authority cannot be taken over by the
VTM Cell of DOT, as suggested by one of the stakeholder. It is also not
possible to have a common neutral appellate authority for all service
providers in a licensed service area.
3.6.4 Some reservations were expressed about its composition. The
Authority evaluated the suggestion but is of the view that an appellate
authority shall consist of one or more persons to be determined and
appointed by the service provider. The issue of composition of the
Authority has been discussed in detail under Issue No.9 also.
3.6.5 For the suggestion that for an all India level ISP, an appellate
authority at the HQ of the Internet Service Provider (ISP) would suffice,
the Authority is of the view that the service area of an all India ISP
licensee is the whole country and, therefore, for the purpose of disposal
35
of appeals of its consumers the ISP, who has an all India licence, may
appoint one or more appellate authority for the whole of India.
3.6.6 To maintain the transparency and independence of the appellate
authority and to provide for an effective consumer grievance redressal
mechanism, the Authority expects that the service providers shall
appoint the person or persons as an appellate authority with such
qualification and experience from amongst the persons of ability and
integrity who have special knowledge and professional experience in
telecommunications.
3.6.7 Regarding the suggestion that “TRAI should be the Apex forum to
decide matters not settled by the Appellate Authority”, this suggestion
cannot be agreed to as the TRAI Act does not envisage such a role for
TRAI.
3.7 ISSUE NO. 5 - PUBLICATION OF MANUAL OF PRACTICE FOR
HANDLING CONSUMER COMPLAINTS AND CONTENTS THEREOF:
3.7.1 The comments of the stakeholders on Manual of Practice for
Handling Consumer Complaints and Contents thereof are summarized in
para (a) to (g) and analysed in the paragraphs following thereafter.
(a) The title may be changed as ‘Your Rights and Responsibilities as a
Telecom Customer’.
(b) A common industry Manual of Practice in close coordination with
other industry associations may be attempted.
(c) The proposal of publishing a hard printed copy “Manual of Practice
for Handling Consumer Complaints” should not be made mandatory
instead it may be made mandatory to publish on the website of the
concerned service provider.
(d) Publishing of manual through the web only instead of making it
available at the offices of service provider, call centre, help desk, nodal
officer etc (clause 21).
(e) Publishing of manual indicating the procedure of complaints
handling can be considered.
(f) We suggest this manual should be in English/Hindi for Internet
service providers.
(g) The manual of practice for handling consumer complaints should be
simple and easily understood by common consumers. It should not contain
technical and legal terms as consumer is generally not familiar with such
terms.
Title of the Manual of Practice:
36
3.7.2 The Manual of Practice is basically an obligation of the
service providers to educate the consumers about the terms and
conditions of service, practices and procedures followed for redressal of
grievances, subscriber-centric parameters in the Quality of Service
Regulations etc, therefore, the title need not be changed
Publication of the Manual of Practice:
3.7.3 It is noted that the stakeholders, in general, have agreed to have a
Manual of Practice. The Authority is of the view that the “Manual of
Practice” needs to be made and published by service providers as per the
provisions of these regulations.
3.7.4 Regarding the suggestion that publication of the “Manual of
Practice” only at the web site of the service providers, the Authority is of
the view that publishing the Manual only at the web site will not meet
the purpose of facilitating provision of information and education of
consumers because of low Personal Computers (PC) and Internet
penetration. Presently the mobile phones are being used by common
man and they need the “Manual of Practice” for reference as and when
required, particularly for redressal of grievances.
3.7.5 It has been suggested that the Manual of practice for handling
consumer complaints should be simple and easily understood by
common consumers and it should not contain technical and legal terms
as consumer is generally not familiar with such terms. The intention for
the proposal to have a Manual of Practice is for the education and
information of the consumers. As such, the Authority accepts the above
suggestion and expects that the service providers while preparing and
publishing the Manual of Practice, as per the provisions of these
regulations, will see that the content of the Manual of Practice is
provided in simple language so that it is easily understood by
consumers. Also the font used should be legible for the consumers to
read without any difficulty. Apart from the mandatory items to be
covered under the Manual of Practice, the service providers may
incorporate any additional information, in particular which affects the
consumers, at their discretion.
3.8 ISSUE NO. 6 - VIEWS ON DRAFT REGULATIONS ON THE
INSTITUTIONAL MECHANISM TO HANDLE CONSUMER GRIEVANCES
AND THE MANUAL OF PRACTICE FOR HANDLING CONSUMER
GRIEVANCES:
3.8.1 The comments of the stakeholders on the draft regulations on the
Institutional Mechanism to Handle Consumer Grievances and the
37
Manual of Practice for Handling Consumer Grievances are
summarized in para (a) to (i) and analysed in the paragraphs following
thereafter.
(a) The mechanism appears to be a great facilitator in Redressal of
Grievances in Speedy, effective and inexpensive manner. However, its
implementation will depend on enforcement. Need of Ombudsman may not
be ignored / lost sight of and issue be revived with Government.
(b) The draft regulation on the institutional mechanism to handle
consumer grievances is adequate.
(c) Draft regulation and manual of practice are apt and appropriate and
best suits the need of consumers.
(d) The Consultation Paper is very timely and certainly expected to
facilitate resolution of complaints of consumers provided, of course, the
service providers implement same in both the letter and spirit.
(e) The Authority should refrain from issuing a Regulation on this
subject, but rather address this issue through light touch regulatory
manner, encouraging a voluntary and self regulatory approach by the
industry. The Authority may exercise an overall supervision of the
industry by approving the Manual of Practice and assessing the
implementation and performance of the TSO scheme.
(f) COAI supports the proposal of the Authority that each service
provider will publish a Manual of Practice. COAI in close coordination with
other industry associations will undertake to draft a common industry
Manual of Practice.
(g) The present mechanism to handle consumer grievances is adequate
and we believe that any such regulation from TRAI would complicate the
issue or delay the redressal process.
(h) Due to existence of various options, there is no need for any regulation
to be mandated by the Authority on consumer redressal.
(i) Draft Regulation is going to benefit the telephone subscribers and is
required. It will facilitate speedy, inexpensive and effective redressal of
complaints.
Need for Regulation:
3.8.2 During the Open House Discussions at Delhi and Bangalore, the
service providers and their associations were of the view that there is no
need of a regulation and instead the industry will address the issue
through a Manual of Practice; however the consumer organizations had
strongly opposed this and expressed that a regulation is necessary. The
main objection of the consumer organisations was that the service
providers have not yet done anything effective for the redressal of
grievances of its consumers. The Authority has considered all the
suggestions and it has come to a conclusion that any measure taken by
the industry will not have any legal or regulatory backup. With no legal
or regulatory obligations there may be lack of commitment on the part of
38
service providers to address the grievances of consumers
expeditiously, effectively and in a time bound manner. The Authority,
decided to specify the institutional framework including process and time
limits for the grievance redressal mechanism as the existing institutional
mechanism is not effective enough. Also no alternate dispute resolution
mechanism independent of the service provider exists for the telecom
sector at present and recourse to consumer courts or TDSAT is time
consuming, expensive and the efforts not commensurate with the stakes
involved. The Authority has, therefore, decided to address these issues in
these regulations rather than leaving it totally for self regulation by
industry/ service providers. However, the Authority has provided for self
regulation by the service providers, within the overall framework of these
regulations. The Authority also appreciates the suggestion of the
industry association for undertaking to draft a common industry Manual
of Practice, but the Manual of Practice should contain all the items
provided under these regulations.
3.9 ISSUE NO. 7 - WHETHER ALL THE SERVICE PROVIDERS
SHOULD BE MANDATED TO ESTABLISH THE INSTITUTIONAL
MECHANISM FOR HANDLING CONSUMER GRIEVANCES AND
PUBLISH THE MANUAL OF PRACTICE AND WHO SHOULD BE
EXEMPTED FROM THE REGULATIONS?
3.9.1 The comments of the stakeholders as to whether all the service
providers should be mandated to establish the Institutional Mechanism
for Handling Consumer Grievances and publish the Manual of Practice
and who should be exempted from the regulations are summarized in
para (a) to (e) and analysed in the paragraphs following thereafter.
(a) No exemption should be allowed.
(b) There is a need to establish institutional mechanisms to redress
consumers’ grievances.
(c) It should not be mandatory to establish separate institutional
mechanism for handling consumer grievance in case a service provider is
providing more than one service.
(d) All access service providers should be required to publish the
Manual of Practice for handling consumer complaints.
(e) It should be applicable for all service providers irrespective of
turnover. The manual of practice for handling of consumer complaints may
be done in one language only (preferably in English).
Criteria for exemption from Regulation:
3.9.2 The Department of Telecommunications’ Direction No.16-6/2005-
BS-II dated 22nd September, 2005 is applicable to all access service
licensees, including BSNL and MTNL. These regulations mandate them
39
to establish Consumer Grievance Redressal Mechanism at (a) the
Call Centre level; (b) at the Nodal Officer level; and (c) an appellate
authority within the company. In the wake of a large number of
complaints received from consumers of Broadband service and the
importance of Broadband connectivity for the consumers, the Authority
had proposed, in its Consultation Paper, to extend the proposed
institutional mechanism for redressal of consumer grievances to all
service providers providing Broadband Service. However, in the case of
ISPs providing Broadband Service, it was proposed to cover only those
ISPs whose turnover in any preceding financial year is more than Rs.25
crores, as many of the ISPs providing Broadband Service have very low
subscriber base. During public consultation the general view was to
include all service providers under these regulations irrespective of
turnover. However, the Authority is of the view that considering the low
subscriber base of many of the ISPs providing Broadband Service, all of
them need not be covered under these regulations. However, keeping in
view the comments of stakeholders, the Authority decided to revise the
criteria of exemption from turnover in any preceding financial year of
more than Rs.25 crores to Rs.5 crores or whose total number of
broadband subscribers in any preceding year exceeds 10,000 broadband
subscribers. The Authority also provided a provision in these regulations
for those service providers, who are not covered by these regulations, so
that they may set up appropriate consumer grievances redressal
mechanism for their consumers.
3.10 ISSUE NO. 8 - PROCEDURE OUTLINED IN THE DRAFT
REGULATIONS FOR MAKING COMPLAINTS:
3.10.1 The comments of the stakeholders on the procedure outlined in
the draft regulations for making complaints are summarized in para (a)
to (g) and analysed in the paragraphs following thereafter.
(a) Call centre must provide the contact details of Nodal Officer,
appellate authority and complaint number.
(b) The procedure outlined for making complaints is adequate.
(c) While the procedure is all right TRAI must make sure that service
providers adhere to these on an ongoing basis and it is not a one time
effort. This could be surprise checks and audits carried out by TRAI or
their accredited CAGs must be so authorized.
(d) Procedure outlined for making complaints by the consumers given in
the Draft Regulation appears to be OK, subject to our comments mentioned
hereunder against various issues raised in the consultation paper.
40
(e) (i) Time limit for redressal of complaints by call centre relating to
non-compliance with QOS regulations shall be 7 working days
instead of 3 days, complaints relating to fault or disruption of
service shall be addressed within 10 working days instead of 3
days and for other complaints within 10 working days, subject to
technical feasibility, instead of 7 days (1st, 2nd and 3rd proviso
of clause 5).
(ii) Acknowledgement by Nodal Officer within 3 days instead of 2
days (clause 8(d)). Time limit for redressal of grievances by
Nodal Officer 2 months instead of 10 days (clause 9).
(iii) The information regarding coverage for cellular mobile service
may have competitive repercussions in favour or against some of
the service providers and hence may not be insisted upon for
publication (clause 21(f)).
(f) We broadly agree with the procedure outlined in the consultation
paper for making complaints. However, a regulation should not be
prescribed by the Authority.
(g) It should be mandated to have PIN Code Based Guide on each
operators Website, so consumer can check that the Operator have the
Service to that PIN Code Before taking any Mobile Connection. This Method
is widely used in USA.
Inspection and audit of institutional mechanism:
3.10.2 Regarding the suggestion for independent audit, presently, the
Authority has provided in the Regulation on Quality of Service of Basic
and Cellular Mobile Telephone Service, 2005 and Quality of Service of
Broadband Services Regulation, 2006 a parameter on “Response time to
the customer for assistance” for reporting of the efficiency of the Call
Centre. The Authority also undertakes objective assessment of Quality of
Service Parameters for various services provided by the service providers
through an independent agency. The efficiency of Call Centres in
attending to the calls of consumers is also assessed by the agency
through live tests. The Authority has also provided under the Quality of
Service (Code of Practice for Metering and Billing Accuracy) Regulation,
2006 for audit of the billing system through the auditor appointed by the
service provider from the panel of auditors notified by TRAI to certify the
metering and billing system of service providers. However, this
independent assessment of efficiency of Call Centres and audit of the
metering and billing system do not cover the disposal of complaints by
Call Centres. Therefore, the Authority has made suitable provisions in
these regulations for inspection and audit by any of its officers,
employees, person or persons appointed by it. The provision has also
been made to direct the service provider to get the audit through an
independent agency as may be specified by the Authority.
Information about cellular mobile coverage and service availability:
41
3.10.3 The suggestion that the information regarding coverage for
cellular mobile service may have competitive repercussions in favour or
against some of the service providers and hence may not be insisted
upon for publication, the intention for making this provision in these
regulations is to facilitate information about mobile coverage to a
prospective consumer. Such a provision is very vital for a consumer to
understand whether mobile coverage and availability of service is there in
places where he ordinarily plans to use the service. Such information
will facilitate reduction of incidences of complaints and also their
prevention. Also none of the stakeholders, except one service provider,
has raised any objection to the inclusion of such a provision in these
regulations. Therefore, the Authority has mandated the provision of
information in the ‘Manual of Practice’ relating to service availability and
coverage of cellular mobile service.
3.10.4 The Authority had received a suggestion that pin code based
information about service availability and mobile coverage should be
mandated. In rural areas people may not know about their pin code.
The Authority is of the view that it should be left to the service providers
whether to give the name of the area or name of the area followed by pin
code of the place/area where service is available.
Providing docket number and contact details of Nodal Officer and
appellate authority by Call Centres:
3.10.5 On the suggestion that the Call Centre must provide the
contact details of Nodal Officer, Appellate Authority and instant
complaint number to the complainant, the Authority has considered
these suggestions and the Authority has decided to make provisions in
the regulations for the Call centre to provide contact details of the Nodal
Officer while communicating the decisions taken on the complaint, if the
consumer is not satisfied with the redressal of his grievance by the Call
Centre or when requested by him. Provisions have also been made in
these regulations for the Call Centre to communicate at the time of
lodging the complaint the unique identification number to be called the
docket number.
Acknowledgement of Complaints and Appeals:
3.10.6 The authority also considered the suggestion for
acknowledgement by the Nodal Officer within 3 days, instead of 2 days
proposed in the Consultation Paper, and has decided that the Nodal
Officer shall communicate to the complainant the unique complaint
number within 3 days of making the complaint. The Authority also
decided that the appellate authority has to acknowledge after the
registration of the appeal within 3 days of receipt of appeal, instead of 5
42
days proposed in the Consultation Paper, along with the serial
number of the appeal registered.
Time limit for redressal of complaints relating to faults or disruption of
service or disconnection of service:
3.10.7 The need for prescribing time limit for Call Centres is
addressed at para 3.4.2 referred to above. The Authority has considered
the suggestion of stakeholders regarding increasing the time limit for
redressing complaints relating to faults or disruption of service or
disconnection of service and is of the view that these types of complaints
need urgent redressal and hence a time limit of 3 days has been specified
in these regulations.
Time limit for redressal of complaints by Nodal Officer:
3.10.8 Regarding the suggestion of stakeholders for extending the
time limit for redressal of complaint by the Nodal Officer to 2 months
from 10 days proposed in the Consultation Paper, the Authority has
considered this suggestion and is of the view that the maximum
complaints should be satisfactorily addressed at the Call Centre level and
only exceptional cases of complaints need attention of Nodal Officer. The
Authority expects that the service provider will make appropriate systems
and processes to effectively and speedily deal with the consumer
complaints at the Call Centre level. Provision of two months to the Nodal
Officer for redressal of complaints is too long a period, considering the
expectation of consumers for speedy redressal of grievances. Therefore,
the Authority has mandated that the Nodal Officer shall redress the
complaints relating to fault or disruption of service or disconnection of
service within 3 days and all other cases within 10 days of receipt of
complaints.
3.11 ISSUE NO. 9 - WHETHER THE COMPOSITION OF APPELLATE
AUTHORITY WITHIN THE COMPANY IS APPROPRIATE FOR (I)
SPEEDY AND INEXPENSIVE ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION
MECHANISM AND (II) MAINTAINING TRANSPARENCY AND
INDEPENDENCE?
3.11.1 The comments of the stakeholders as to whether the
composition of appellate authority within the company is appropriate for
(i) speedy and inexpensive dispute resolution mechanism and (ii)
maintaining transparency and independence are summarized in para (a)
to (h) and analysed in the paragraphs following thereafter.
(a) The proposed composition of Appellate Authority is not properly
made out. The Appellate Authority should consist of three members i.e.
43
chairperson, representative of Service provider and representative
of CAG registered with TRAI.
(b) TRAI must select and give a panel of retired judges out of which
service provider can choose an appellate authority. An appellate authority
each at district level should be established. Violation of TRAI regulations,
orders and directives should be made an offense and a penal provision
should be provided to punish the service provider and compensate the
consumer. Customer service guarantee section in UK Code of Practice (CoP)
is ideal. Licensee must have a website for CoP and it must be published in
all its advertisement.
(c) The entire spirit and purpose of appointing an Appellate Authority by
the Service Provider is totally unacceptable. The appointment and
superintendence of the appellate authority should rest with TRAI. There
should be a three Member Appellate Authority and a Secretary with a
Secretariat. Of the three Member appellate authority, one Member is also
the Chairman and Presiding Officer and the other two are Members. The
service providers' body nominates one Member, TRAI one from among the
CAGs and also TRAI nominates one as Member cum Chairman from among
a panel of three suggested by the District Forums in the City where the
service providers are situated on a request by TRAI. To avoid having too
many appellate tribunals the TRAI can constitute only one single Tribunal
per each location which will hear all Appeals from all customers.
Expenses to be borne by service provider’s body.
(d) Appellate authority should include representative from COAI,
AUSPI, Broadband Service Providers, Cable TV Service providers and CAG
member registered with TRAI.
(e) Appellate authority within the company already exists. We would
like to address the designation, obligations, geographical area and scope
of responsibility of the Presiding (Appellate) Officer (s), in the Manual of
Practice. Industry finalized Ombudsman will be implemented.
(f) We do not agree with the proposed composition of the appellate
authority. The appellate authority should be appointed from within the
service providers’ organization only. The proposal should also be
evaluated against industry’s voluntary proposal for setting up an
independent office of ombudsman.
(g) It is recommended to have service provider neutral common
appellate authority in place of each service provider establishing its own
appellate authority. The existing Telecom Monitoring Cells of DOT could be
assigned the responsibility to act as appellate Authority for the whole of
telecom sector.
(h) We feel that the service providers should be allowed to decide the
composition, tenure and other aspects related to formation and functioning
of appellate authority.
Composition of the appellate authority:
44
3.11.2 Regarding composition of the appellate authority, the
Authority has received different views from stakeholders. In the
consultation paper the proposal was to have a single person appellate
authority, who will act as the presiding officer. The general view of the
consumer organisations is for multi-member appellate authority. The
DOT direction is there to have an appellate authority within the
company. Considering the views of stakeholders, the Authority is of the
opinion that unless the intention is to have appellate authority appointed
by different agencies there may not be much advantage about having
multiple member appellate authority. Since the direction of DOT is to
have appellate authority within the company, it would be appropriate to
prescribe the composition of appellate authority as one or more persons
to be determined and appointed by the service provider. However, for
assisting in receipt, acknowledgement of appeal and other secretarial
work including disposal of appeals, a Secretariat would be required with
one Secretary for speedy disposal of appeals. Therefore, the Authority
has decided to make provisions in these regulations for a composition of
an appellate authority with one or more persons to be determined by the
service provider and also provisions have been made to appoint one or
more appellate authorities by service provider to ensure that every appeal
is decided within three months. Further, the provision of secretariat with
one Secretary for an appellate authority has been made in these
regulations.
3.11.3 The issues relating to neutral common appellate authority
and assigning the responsibility to act as appellate authority to VTM Cell
of DOT are discussed under Issue No.4.
3.12 ISSUE NO. 10 - PROCEDURE FOR DISPOSAL OF APPEAL FOR
THE APPELLATE AUTHORITY IN THE DRAFT REGULATIONS:
3.12.1 The comments of the stakeholders on the procedure for
disposal of appeal for the appellate authority in the draft regulations are
summarized in para (a) to (l) and analysed in the paragraphs following
thereafter.
(a) Provision for electronic submission of appeal and online tracking of
complaints; five days provided to secretary be reduced to two days for
intimation of allotted number and copy to service provider; service
provider must file the reply within a week; appellate authority to decide
appeal within 15 days; and reporting requirements prescribed at point 18
under Chapter IV must be applied to Nodal Officer too and he should be
able to settle most of the cases.
(b) Procedure for disposal of appeal is correct and suits the requirement
of consumers.
45
(c) Proposed duration does not inspire speedy disposal of appeal;
(d) The possibility of monetary quantification of such failure could be
explored and suitably incorporated in the Regulation. QOS and
benchmarks will never be followed unless it is tagged to a monetary
compensation. The Draft Regulation should include a table specifying the
service and a fixed amount to be paid as compensation/penalty to the
customer if the time specified in the benchmark is not followed/adhered to.
(e) Appellate authority within the company already exists. We would
like to address the designation, obligations, geographical area and scope
of responsibility of the Presiding (Appellate) Officer (s), in the Manual of
Practice. Industry finalized Ombudsman will be implemented.
(f) Procedure appears to be in order, but need to be observed before
finalizing the procedure and time frame for disposal of appeal.
(g) Proposed procedure is acceptable.
(h) The redressal of consumer grievances escalated to the Appellate
authority should be dealt with in a time bound manner to better serve the
customers.
(i) The power to pass orders for compensation to the appellants should
be limited up to direct loss and not for indirect, intangible or any other kind
of compensation (clause 17(11)).
(j) The time period for deciding the appeal by the appellate authority
should at least be 4 months (clause 17(12)).
(k) The time period for compliance of orders of appellate authority by the
service provider shall be 30 days instead of 15 days (clause 17(14)).
(l) The power to fix shorter time period for reporting by the appellate
authority has been proposed to the Licensor rather than TRAI (Clause 18).
Rebate and compensation:
3.12.2 There have been suggestions that the possibility of monetary
quantification of such failure could be explored and suitably
incorporated in the regulations. Also, there is a view that Quality of
Service (QOS) and benchmarks will never be followed unless it is tagged
to a monetary compensation and these regulations should include a
table specifying the service and a fixed amount to be paid as
compensation/penalty to the customer if the time specified in the
benchmark for redressal of grievance is not followed/adhered to by the
service provider. The Authority has considered the issue of
compensation to consumer under such cases and is of the view that it is
not possible to include all cases of grievances and link it to monetary
compensation. Already provisions exist in the QOS Regulation for rental
rebate for delayed rectification of fault and also provision is there for
payment of interest for delayed refund of security deposits. Therefore,
46
the Authority decided that no provision is needed to be made in
these regulations for such monetary compensation.
Time limit for disposal of appeals by appellate authority:
3.12.3 Regarding the time limit for disposal of appeals by the
appellate authority, the suggestions received by the Authority from
stakeholders varied from 15 days to 4 months. According to some of the
stakeholders the period of one month, for disposal of appeals proposed in
the draft regulations is too short considering the procedure outlined in
the draft regulations. At the same time some of the stakeholders,
especially the Consumer Advocacy Groups, want a shorter period to be
specified for the appellate authority for the disposal of appeals. For the
suggestion of “7 days time for the service provider to provide the
information, 15 days time for the appellate authority to dispose off the
appeal”, the Authority is of the opinion that the time limit of 15 days may
not be sufficient for disposal of appeals by following transparent
procedures and providing a reasonable opportunity for hearing to the
parties. Since the appeals come to the appellate authority after
consideration of the grievances by the Call Centre and the Nodal Officer,
the appellate authority has to take into account all the facts relating to
the action and remedial measures taken by the Call Centres and Nodal
Officers, therefore, there should be a reasonable time period for the
appellate authority to address the appeals. Therefore, the Authority has
decided that every appeal shall be decided by an appellate authority of
every service provider within three months from the date of filing the
appeal.
3.12.4 Regarding the suggestion that “five days provided to
Secretary of an appellate authority be reduced to two days for
acknowledgement of allotted serial number of appeal after registering it
to the appellant and forwarding a copy of appeal to the service provider
and the service provider must file the reply within a week”, the
Authority considered the suggestion and decided to reduce the time limit
for providing acknowledgement to the appellant from five days to three
days in these regulations. However, the Authority is of the view that the
service provider requires adequate time to reply to the appeal. Hence,
the Authority decided to allow 15 days time limit to the service provider
for filing its reply to the appeal.
3.12.5 Regarding the suggestion “to have the time period for compliance
or orders of appellate authority by the service providers as 30 days
instead of 15 days proposed in the Consultation Paper”, the Authority is
of the view that 15 days is reasonable and sufficient for implementation
of the orders of the appellate authority.
47
Electronic submission of appeals and exhibit status of pending
appeals at website:
3.12.6 Regarding the suggestion for electronic submission of appeal
and online tracking of complaints, the Authority considered these views
and is of the opinion that while filing appeals many a times supporting
documents or documentary evidences needed to be attached and these
cannot be submitted online. The Authority has considered such
suggestions and decided to make suitable provisions in these regulations
for making or filing of complaints to Call Centre and Nodal Officer
through e-mail and other electronic means. The Authority has also
decided that an appellate authority shall exhibit at its website or website
of the service provider, the status of each appeal pending for the
disposal.
Reporting of status of appeals:
3.12.7 Regarding the suggestion that the “power to fix shorter time
period for reporting by the appellate authority should be with the
Licensor”, the Authority is of the view that since these regulations are
issued by the Authority such obligations cannot be made to the licensor
by the Authority.
3.13 ISSUE NO. 11 - PROCEDURE FOR MAKING THE MANUAL OF
PRACTICE FOR HANDLING CONSUMER COMPLAINTS BEING MADE
ACCESSIBLE TO CONSUMERS:
3.13.1 The comments of the stakeholders on the procedure for
making the Manual of Practice for Handling Consumer Complaints being
made accessible to consumers are summarized in para (a) to (e) and
analysed in the paragraphs following thereafter.
(a) “Sales Outlet” Para (o) 3 on page 45 be amplified to “available with
every pre-paid recharge card at sales outlet” and along with post paid
bills.
(b) It is well documented. As explained in the letter, majority of the
subscribers are pre-paid mobile subscribers. Hence it is suggested that
the “Manual of Practice‘’ should also be made part of recharge coupons
sold to pre-paid subscribers.
(c) Giving access for manual to consumer should be made compulsory
and it should be widely publicized.
(d) The Manual of Practice should form part of the instruction manual at
the Point of provision of service. It should also be available on the service
provider’s website and all company outlets.
(e) The Manual should be published on the website of the concerned
service provider.
48
Accessibility of Manual of Practice:
3.13.2 One of the suggestions is that majority of the subscribers are
pre-paid mobile consumers and hence the “Manual of Practice” should
also be made part of recharge coupons sold to pre-paid subscribers. The
Authority examined the suggestion and also noted that presently
recharges can be made without purchasing any recharge coupons, such
as easy recharge through electronic means and also considered that it is
not reasonable to mandate such a provision of giving the “Manual of
Practice” along with every pre-paid recharge coupon or card. Similarly,
with every postpaid bill, it is not reasonable to provide the “Manual of
Practice”.
3.13.3 However keeping in view the stakeholders suggestions, the
Authority has mandated in these regulations that the Manual shall be
available for reference at every office of the service provider, Call Centre,
customer care centre, help desk, the Nodal Officer, the appellate
authority, at the sales outlets and at the website of the service provider.
The Authority has also mandated that a copy of the Manual or its
abridged version (containing salient features such as terms and
conditions of service, contact details of Call Centre, the Nodal Officer
and the appellate authority, procedure and time limit for redressal of
grievances and time limit specified in the Schedule) shall be provided by
the service provider or his agent to each consumer at the time of his
subscription of service.
3.14 ISSUE NO. 12 - WHETHER USAGE DETAILS TO BE GIVEN TO
PRE-PAID MOBILE CUSTOMERS?
3.14.1 The comments of the stakeholders as to whether usage
details to be given to pre-paid mobile customers are summarized in para
(a) to (g) and analysed in the paragraphs following thereafter.
(a) This is radical move which will infuse confidence / satisfaction in
subscribers and boost the image of service providers and lead to a friendly
regime.
(b) The Internet usage charge and SMS charge should also be included.
(c) We welcome the regulation and it will definitely help the consumers.
(d) It is not practically feasible for service providers to provide usage
details in respect of pre-paid mobile consumers and that the same if done
for individual requests will involve inordinate amount of effort, time and
49
cost to the service provider besides disruption of normal functioning of
the network. The additional cost involved will be quite substantial and will
have to be borne by the concerned subscriber.
(e) Usage details in respect of pre-paid subscribers should not be
mandated.
(f) The Draft Regulation No. 22 is agreed but decision about
reasonableness of price should be left to the service providers.
(g) While the prepaid customers are able to view their balance after
every usage, there are technical issues involved in providing usage details
for prepaid customers, which will need to be evaluated before making this
facility available to such subscribers.
Provision of usage details to pre-paid customers:
3.14.2 From the above views of service providers it is clear that it is
technically possible to provide usage details relating to the itemized
usage charges showing actual service usage details in terms of all call
data records and their monetary value to the customers, but there are
cost implications. Since we have received a number of representations
from pre-paid consumers about provision of itemized bills and also there
were a large number of applications received under the RTI Act on
information relating to provision of itemized usage details and charges to
pre-paid customers, to protect the interest of pre-paid consumers, the
Authority has mandated provision of usage details to pre-paid customers
on request on payment basis at a reasonable charge. The determination
of actual charges is left to the service providers, subject to a ceiling limit.
3.14.3 Keeping in view the observations made above, the Authority
decided to mandate that on request from any pre-paid mobile connection
consumer for any period falling in the preceding six months, the service
provider shall supply such a consumer, at a reasonable cost, the
information relating to the itemized usage charges showing actual service
usage details in terms of all call data records including value added
services, premium rate services and roaming charges, and their
monetary value. The Authority also considered that service provider may
have to incur cost in provisioning of this information and accordingly
specified a ceiling limit for charging such cost to the pre-paid consumer
as the cost or price not exceeding rupees fifty or the cost or price payable
by the post paid consumers of the same service provider for obtaining
similar information or cost or price payable in accordance with the terms
and conditions of the licence of the service provider, which ever is lowest.
4. CONSUMER COMPLAINTS REFERRED BY TRAI TO SERVICE
PROVIDERS FOR REDRESSAL:
50
4.1 The consumers generally look up to the Authority to evolve
mechanisms and approaches that enable the protection of the
consumers’ interest. The Authority has been receiving large number of
complaints from consumers. Some of these complaints relate to
complaints which are of a generic nature affecting a large number of
consumers or showing systemic inadequacy or complaints alleging
violation of the Act or regulations or directions or orders made under the
Act or complaints alleging practices adopted by the service providers
adversely affecting the interest of the consumers. TRAI looks into
various issues raised in the complaints and these complaints are referred
to the concerned service provider for effective redressal of the complaints
and also to undertake root-cause analysis of the complaints and
remedial action on similar cases in a time bound manner.
4.2 The Authority has observed that in many cases service providers
either do not redress the complaints in a time bound manner or do not
report to the Authority the action taken on the complaints referred to it
and the result of the root-cause analysis. The Authority has, therefore,
decided to mandate the service providers to investigate all such
complaints referred by the Authority and resolve or redress such
complaints within one month of referring the complaint by the Authority.
The Authority has also mandated that the service provider shall inform
the consumer and the Authority regarding resolution or redressal of the
complaint within one month from the date of referring such complaints.
Further, the Authority has mandated that if the investigation reveals
general deficiency or systemic inadequacy in the practice and procedure
or operation adopted by the service provider, the service provider shall
take measures in respect to all such similarly placed consumers and
intimate to the Authority within two months of referring such complaints
regarding general deficiency or systemic inadequacy revealed and
remedial measures taken by it.
5. After the detailed consultation process and taking into account the
comments of all the stakeholders, the Authority is of the view that the
service providers must provide an in-house Consumer Grievance
Redressal Mechanism for speedy resolution of complaints of individual
telecom consumers with minimum cost without affecting or taking away
their legal rights to approach the courts or tribunal or forum or
commission under any law in force. It has become necessary to regulate
the issue of redressal of grievances of telecom consumers as the service
providers have failed to provide adequate and effective in-house
provisions for redressal of grievances of telecom consumers to their
satisfaction. The Authority has, therefore, made the “Telecom Consumers
Protection and Redressal of Grievances Regulations, 2007” without
affecting the consumers’ legal right to approach the courts or tribunal or
forum or commission under any law in force at any time during the
redressal of grievances under the said regulations or thereafter and to
51
ensure cost effective and speedy redressal of grievances of individual
consumers.
6. The Consumer Grievance Redressal Mechanism specified in these
regulations is on the principles of soft touch regulation focusing
primarily on self-regulation by service providers for the redressal of
grievances of telecom consumers. The Authority hopes that “Telecom
Consumers Protection and Redressal of Grievances Regulations, 2007”
would ensure effective, speedy and inexpensive redressal of grievances of
consumers of telecom sector and would reduce the litigations in the
forums, commissions and courts constituted under the law to adjudicate
individual complaints of consumers of telecom sector.
Previous and next
Questions people ask
Is form of TELECOM CONSUMERS PROTECTION AND REDRESSAL OF GRIEVANCES REGULATIONS, 2007 (3 OF 2007) still in force?
No repeal of TELECOM CONSUMERS PROTECTION AND REDRESSAL OF GRIEVANCES REGULATIONS, 2007 (3 OF 2007) is recorded.