Regulation 12, Domestic Leased Circuits Regulations, 2007.: Inspection and Auditing
Domestic Leased Circuits Regulations, 2007. - Regulation 12
Text of regulation 12
Inspection and Auditing
12. Inspection and Auditing.----- (1) The Authority may, if it considers
it expedient so to do, and to ensure compliance of the provisions of these
regulations, by order in writing, direct any of its officers or employees or
through one or more persons appointed by the Authority to inspect any
the records maintained under regulation 6, and submit to the Authority
a report in respect of such inspection.
(2) The Authority, if it considers it expedient so to do, may require any
specified service provider to whom a request has been made under
regulation 4, to,--
(a) get the records maintained under regulation 6 audited through one or
more officers or persons appointed by the Authority and submit the
report in respect of such audit to the Authority;
(b) get the records maintained under regulation 6 audited through an
independent agency as may be specified by the Authority and submit
the report in respect of such audit to the Authority.
(3) The cost of inspection by one or more persons appointed by the
Authority under sub-regulation (1) or the audit under clause (b) of sub-
regulation (2) shall be borne by the concerned specified service provider
(4)The Authority may, by order or direction, from time to time, intervene,
for the purpose of protecting the interest of the subscribers or specified
service providers or for monitoring and ensuring provision of the
Domestic Leased Circuits or Local Lead of Domestic Leased Circuit, as
the case may be, under these regulations so as to promote and ensure
orderly growth of the telecom sector
(Lav Gupta)
Principal Advisor(FN)
Note.-----The Explanatory Memorandum explains the objects and
reasons of the Domestic Leased Circuits Regulations, 2007.
10
EXPLANATORY MEMORANDUM TO DOMESTIC LEASED
CIRCUITS REGULATIONS, 2007 (10 OF 2007)
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 Generally Leased Circuit is a facility for communication between
two or more designated points set aside for exclusive use by a
customer. It could be set up as one or more point-to-point
connections or as Virtual Private Network (VPN) over a shared
network. Public switched network should not be connected with
the leased circuit. This service may be provided over facilities
owned or operated by a service provider or over transmission
capacity sold or leased by another service provider. It may use
terrestrial or satellite facilities, may use any media copper, fiber or
wireless and may be provided through passive, circuit switched or
packet switched network. Leased circuit does not involve central
office switching operations. Unlike broadband, a leased line is not
contended or shared but delivers dedicated guaranteed bandwidth
1.2 ITU defines Leased Circuit as “a two-way link for the exclusive use
of a subscriber regardless of the way it is used by the subscriber.”
1.3 Domestic Leased Circuits (DLC) are important elements in the
telecom market that telecom service providers provide to connect
two or more customer sites or customers to their own or other
service providers networks.
1.4 The various elements of an end-to-end Domestic Leased Circuit
(DLC) include the following segments:
11
(a) Local Lead (To the nearest Point of Presence (PoP)/Point of
Interconnection(POI) of Access Provider or National Long
Distance Operator)
(b) Access Segment
(c) Trunk Segment
The schematic diagram indicating various elements of a Domestic
Leased Circuit (DLC) is given below.
Customer Site Customer Site End-to-End
Domestic Leased
Circuit (DLC)
PoP of
NLDO
Access
Segment
Access
Segment
Trunk
Segment
Local Lead Local Lead
PoP of
NLDO
Local Lead Local Lead
PoP of
Access
Provider
PoP of
Access
Provider
Customer
PoP
Customer
PoP
NLDO: National Long Distance Operator PoP: Point of Presence
Figure1. Schematic diagram of a Domestic Leased Circuit(DLC)
1.5 Local lead forms an essential part of the DLC. This is also referred
to as terminating segment, partial circuit, tail end, local end or
local leased circuit. In instances where the local lead consists of
copper links, it is usually known as a local loop. It is like a leased
circuit from the customer’s premises to Point of Presence (PoP) or
Point of Interconnection (PoI) to the network operator from whom
the customer obtains leased line capacity. The local lead may be
12
provided by a service provider other than that having contract with
the customer for provision of DLC.
1.6 Local lead is part of the service provider’s access network. It could
take diverse forms: for a telephone customer it would primarily be
copper pairs, for broadband users it could be copper pairs or fiber,
for connecting enterprise EPABX it could be copper or fiber, for
leased line it could be copper, fiber or wireless.
Figure2. Schematic diagram depicting local lead
Customer
PoP
Customer Site
Local Lead
PoP/POI Service
Provider
providing DLC
1.7 Virtual Private Netwrok (VPN) achieves the same purpose as
physical leased circuits. VPN is configured within a public network
(a carrier's network or the Internet) in order to take advantage of
the economies of scale and management facilities of large
networks. Therefore, in most situations, VPNs provide a user
organization with the same capabilities as leased lines but at a
much lower cost. Though a VPN is usually architectured using the
shared public infrastructure, privacy and security are maintained
through security procedures and tunneling protocols. In effect, the
protocols used, by encrypting data at the sending end and
decrypting it at the receiving end, send the data through a "tunnel"
that cannot be "entered" by data that is not properly encrypted. An
additional level of security involves encrypting not only the data,
but also the originating and receiving addresses.
13
Virtual Private Network VPNs are widely used by enterprises to
create wide area networks (WANs) that span large geographic
areas, to provide site-to-site connections to branch offices and to
allow telecommuters to dial up their company LANs.
1.8 Service Providers in DLC and VPN segment
1.8.1 As on date, domestic bandwidth is provided to the end users by
following categories of Operators in the country:
a) National Long Distance Operators (NLDOs)
b) Access Service Providers (BSOs/UASPs)
1.8.2 As per the guidelines of Department of Telecommunications (DOT)
dated 14th December 2005, the IP-II category has been abolished
and no new IP-II licenses will be granted. The erstwhile IP-II
players were provided option to migrate to NLD/ILD service license
by paying the requisite licensing fee for each licence. Further, IP-II
licensees not interested in migrating to NLD/ILD shall not be
permitted to provide national/international leased line/bandwidth
to individual subscribers as per existing IP-II license guidelines. As
per the guidelines of DOT dated 14th December 2005, NLDOs can
only access the subscribers for provision of Leased Circuits/Close
User Groups (CUGs).
1.9 Demand for Leased Line and VPN
1.9.1 According to analysis of IP VPN services by IDC, the market for
domestic VPN was around Rs. 216 Crores in 2003 and is expected to
reach Rs 831 Crores by 2008 as shown in Table 1 below
14
INDIA IP-VPN SERVICES MARKET REVENUE FORECAST, IN
CRORES OF RUPEES, 2003-2008
Year 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
National IP VPN 215.6 329.5 474.9 586.8 704.1 830.9
International IP VPN 14.7 32.9 61.5 108.3 186.4 310.3
Total 230.3 362.4 536.4 695.1 890.6 1141.2
Source: IDC Report, 2003
Table 1
A similar analysis carried out by Frost & Sullivan, shows almost
similar revenue projections:
IP VPN MARKET: REVENUE FORECASTS (INDIA), 2003-2009
Revenue Revenue Year
(Rs. Crores) Growth Rate
2003 226.80 -
2004 281.70 24.1
2005 387.90 37.6
2006 508.50 31.5
2007 672.30 32.0
2008 894.60 33.1
2009 1198.35 33.9
IP VPN Market: Revenue Forecast (India), 2003-2009 Source: Frost & Sullivan
Table 2
1.9.2 TRAI’s Consultation Paper on “Issues Related to ISP Licence with
Virtual Private Network (VPN) Dated 24th June 2005” expected
point-to-point leased line market to reach Rs 1400 Crores by 2006-
07
REVENUE ON ACCOUNT OF DOMESTIC LEASED CIRCUITS (IN
CRORES OF RUPEES)
Actual Revenue Projected Revenue
FY 2002-03 2003-04 2004-05 2005-06 2006-07
Revenue
(in Crores) 577 783.52 901.05 1081.26 1405.63
Source: TRAI’s Consultation Paper on “Issues Related to ISP Licence with Virtual Private
Network (VPN) Dated 24th June 2005”
Table 3.
1.9.3 Revenue from point-to-point leased line reported by service
providers under Basic/Unified Access License and National Long
Distance License are Rs. 905 Crores and Rs. 1291 Crores
15
respectively for the year 2004-05 and 2005-06. It may be noted
that this amount does not include the revenue generated through
VPN services under Internet License. Thus the Domestic Leased
circuit market is growing at very fast pace.
1.9.4 From the available data the aggregate DLC market (including VPN)
is estimated to be Rs 3000 cr by 2008 and Rs 4500 cr by 2010.
1.10 Importance of DLCs to the economy: leased lines are and will
remain a key component for the economic growth of the country. In
addition these are crucial building blocks for e-business, e-
governance, Internet access, BPO and IT industry. Financial, ITES,
and manufacturing sector are expected to lead the IP VPN Market
growth. In the financial sector banks are automating and
expanding their branch networks to smaller cities. The need to
connect these branches would drive the uptake for VPNs. VPNs are
also being seen as a more cost effective alternative to point to point
connections like VSATs. Trends by vertical segment in Indian IP
VPN services over the 2003-2009 period were also given in the
Frost & Sullivan Report on “Market Engineering Research for the
Indian IP VPN Market.”
IP VPN Market: Trends by Vertical Segment (India), 2003-2009
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Vertical Market
(%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (%)
FMCG 35 25 20 20 20 15 15
Healthcare 25 20 20 20 25 20 20
Telecom/IT/High Technology 31 31 30 25 20 20 20
Banks 0 7 10 15 15 20 20
Government 5 5 5 5 5 10 10
Education 0 7 8 8 10 10 10
Others 5 5 7 7 5 5 5
IP VPN Market: forecast 2003-2009 Source: Frost & Sullivan
Table 4
16
1.11 Leased Lines are normally used by businesses that need high
quality 24/7 interconnection, with SLA (Service Level Agreement),
between geographically separated offices to run critical
applications with fast upstream/downstream speeds or access to
the internet. For example, remote workers accessing office-based
applications will be retrieving rich multimedia data from their office
databases that would require high downstream bandwidth.
Knowledge Process Outsourcing (KPO)/companies and businesses
providing valued added services might require high upstream
bandwidth to upload large volumes of data. Internet Service
Providers (ISPs) also make use of DLCs for connecting their
customers to their Node for provision of leased line Internet access.
Access to DLCs is therefore a critical requirement for new
businesses and service providers.
1.12 Keeping in view the emerging competition arising out of certain
policy initiatives of the Government like reduction in the entry
barriers and license fee payable and increase in the scope of the
service i.e. allowing the NLDOs to access the subscriber directly for
provision of leased Circuits/Closed User Groups (CUGs), entry of
number of players and increasing competitive pressure, Domestic
Leased Circuit Market including the IP VPN Market is expected to
grow at a healthy rate in the coming years.
1.13 The telecom services provided by the service providers to their end
users largely depend on the quality and timely availability of such
leased circuits. Competition in supply of all segments of end-to-
end connectivity is vital to deliver retail products at a reasonable
price to users. New entrants generally find it difficult to compete in
domestic leased line market because of non-availability of parts of
DLC, specially the access part. The Authority is of the view that
17
customer should have the ability to choose their preferred service
provider of DLC without artificial and anti competitive constraint
limiting their choices as they are able to do in other segments of
the telecom sector
1.14 In today’s multi operator, multi service scenario, the term access
has a wide range of meanings. The Authority recognizes that in
markets where some service providers rely on essential facilities
provided by others for delivery of their services, it is appropriate to
establish a framework to ensure that the market functions
effectively.
1.15 In view of the above, the Authority is of the opinion that service
providers shall meet other service providers’ request for a complete
DLC or access in terms of local lead, since denial of such request
by the service provider or adduction of unreasonable terms and
conditions having a similar effect, would hinder the emergence of a
competitive market, or would not be in the end-user's interest. The
Authority therefore, after due diligence, decided to issue these
regulations.
1.16 These regulations provide a framework to ensure transparency,
predictability and reasonableness and allow provision of DLC/local
lead in a non-discriminatory manner. The Authority has not opted
for compulsory mandation but would watch and take necessary
steps as warranted by the situation in future.
1.17 These regulations deal specifically with domestic leased circuits and
recognizing that access is essential part of building up a DLC, it
becomes necessary for service providers not only to provide DLC on
18
request from other service providers but also the local lead in the
access network in cases where the contracting service provider is
able to build rest of the DLC except the local lead.
1.18 While providing DLC and/or local lead, service providers have
obligation to apply equivalent conditions to other service providers
providing equivalent services, and provide services under the same
conditions and of the same quality as it provides to its own
customers unless there are specific SLAs specifying different terms
and conditions of the provision.
1.19 Consultation Process In order to enhance competition in Domestic
Leased Circuits (DLC), the Authority initiated a consultation
process in November 2006 and issued a consultation paper on
“Measures to Enhance Competition in Market in India” dated 17th
November 2006. Open House Discussion on the subject was also
held at Delhi on 29th January 2007.
1.20 The Authority in its consultation paper Dated 17th November 2006
highlighted various issues related to promotion of competition in
country's Domestic Leased Circuits (DLC) market. Following issues
were raised by the Authority in the Consultation paper.
(i) Limiting Factors for competition in DLC Market
(ii) Whether the operator with Significant Market Power (SMP)
be mandated to provide local lead for DLC and also for
engineering CUGs to other operators.
(iii) Responsibility for the Security issues.
19
(iv) Whether there is a case for considering provision of DLC as
an interconnection element and needs to be included in
RIO(Reference Interconnect Offer)
(v) Any other measures for promoting effective competition in
DLC market.
2. EXAMINATION OF MAIN COMMENTS MADE AND
ISSUES RAISED BY STAKEHOLDERS
2.1 The Authority has taken various comments and inputs of the
stakeholders into consideration and analysed the matter in detail.
For the sake of clarity the comments made and issues raised by
stakeholders are given in italics followed by consideration and
decision of the Authority on the points.
2.2 ISSUE 1: Limiting Factors for competition in DLC Market
2.2.1 The comments received from the stakeholders on this issue are
summarized below in points (a) to (m) and dealt with in the
paragraphs following thereafter.
(a) Competition in Leased Circuit Market is not limited.
(b) Competition required that competing operators should build
adequate infrastructure.
(c) Lack of will of private operators to develop infrastructure in all
parts of their service area.
(d) Private operators should be mandated to roll out their own
networks to enable customers to have a choice.
(e) Sharing of resources with incumbent.
(f) Incumbent do not want to share their capacity for the last mile.
(g) Difficulties and cost of getting ROW
(h) Prices for DLC elements, timeframe of delivery
(i) High cost and no fiscal incentives for laying copper
(j) Microwave spectrum fee to be rationalized.
(k) Absence of interconnect regulations
(l) Govt policy for DLCs in rural areas
20
(m) It should be mandated that one operator should provide local
lead for DLC or CUG to other operator.
2.2.2 Along with the above comments, the Authority has also taken note
of other factors that were responsible for limiting competition in
DLC market. The Authority also recalled various recommendations
given to the Government from time to time on the subject. The
Government has also taken decisions either suo-moto or based on
recommendations of the Authority that have resulted in removal of
some of the barriers. Some of the examples are:
Reduction of entry fee from Rs 100 crores to to Rs. 2.5 Crore and
reduction of license fee from 15% to 6% for for NLD Licenses. IP-II
service providers have also been allowed to migrated to NLD
license. NLD Licensees and IP-II service providers after migration
to NLD license can now access their subscribers directly for
lease/data circuits for CUG and are expected to build their own
last mile access network for end-to-end connectivity.
2.2.3 The Authority is of the view that further steps need to be taken to
enhance competition and to exploit full potential of DLC/VPN
segment. Exploitation of this market will not only benefit the
service provider and the country’s economy but also provide ability
to the customer to choose service provider of DLC/VPN. New
entrants generally find it difficult to compete in domestic leased
line market because of non-availability of parts of DLC, specially
the access part and financial non-viability of expanding network in
greenfield areas. The Authority is therefore of the opinion that
there is an urgent need to issue regulations to
comprehensively remove the remaining limiting factors to
competition in the DLC /VPN segment.
21
2.3 ISSUE 2: Whether the operator with significant market power
(SMP) be mandated to provide local lead for DLC and also for
engineering CUGs to other operators.
2.3.1 The comments received from the stakeholders on this issue are
summarized below in points (a) to (d) and dealt with in the
paragraphs following thereafter.
(a) Concept of SMP is not relevant after 10 years of entry of private
operators.
(b) Incumbent is not always SMP. In case of optical/metro Ethernet
and long distance bandwidth in lucrative areas Pvt. operators are
SMP.
(c) Incumbent should be mandated to provide DLC/ local lead to avoid
duplication of resources.
(d) Incumbent should provide local lead with disclosed and
transparent terms and conditions.
2.3.2 Taking stock of the current market situation and deployment of
different technologies specially in the access network the Authority
feels that narrowing the obligation to only selected service
providers would be a retrograde step. The concept of SMP is
therefore not very relevant at this stage and any service provider
who has spare capacity of copper, fiber or wireless should share it
with other service providers. The available capacity of all service
providers should be fully utilized for the benefit of the consumers.
The Authority also expects that further development of the
network would also continue in the long-term interest of the
service providers and the consumers.
2.3.3 The Authority also noted that a provision already exists in the “The
Telecommunication Tariff (Thirty Sixth Amendment) Order, 2005”
dated 21st April 2005 to provide domestic leased circuits through
utilisation of spare capacity when such capacity is available and
when not available, on Rent and Guarantee Terms/ Special
22
Construction/Contribution basis. The relevant clause is
reproduced here:
Clause 2(b) “ It is mandatory for domestic leased circuits to be
provided through utilization of spare capacity when such capacity is
available and when not available, on Rent and Guarantee / Special
Construction /Contribution basis etc. schemes, under the provisions
of TTO relating to reporting requirement.”
The Authority is of the view that there is a need not only for
providing DLC but also for providing local leads in case the service
provider having contract or arrangement with the customer
requires them.
2.3.4 The Authority has also observed that though mandate was
available in the mentioned TTO, the quality of implementation
would further improve if a framework or modality is prescribed
through these regulations. There is also a need to make it
obligatory for the service providers to intimate to the seeker within
a specified time frame the availability of the DLC/local lead or
otherwise. The provider should also intimate in writing to the
seeker the reasons thereof. A record of all cases where the requests
could not be met should be kept by the providers for future
reference.
2.4 Issue 3: Responsibility for security Issues in case of usage of
resources from multiple service providers in a CUG Network:
2.4.1 The comments received from the stakeholders on this issue
are summarized below in points (a) to (h) and dealt with in the
paragraphs following thereafter.
23
(a) It will be highly inappropriate to make the prime service
provider (in most cases BSNL) responsible for the security
issues. It will be double penalty on BSNL along with the
penalty of unbundling of local lead.
(b) Disputes will arise among the service providers and objective
of unbundling will not be met.
(c) In view of security issues, difficulty in coordination in case of
fault leading to service deterioration usage of resources from
multiple service providers is not recommended.
(d) All the service providers are to be responsible for security
issues.
(e) The prime service provider responsible for security issues.
(f) The complete responsibility of security issues must be with in
the CUG’s themselves specially if customer forms his own
CUG by procuring links from multiple providers
(g) In case customer gets into an agreement with prime service
provider for Managed Services, like VPN’s, it should be the
responsibility of prime service provider.
(h) Segment wise responsibility of the service provider to be fixed.
2.4.2 In this matter, the Authority noted that the licensor has already
issued instructions vide its letter no. 824-42/2000-LR dated
15.07.2003 regarding utilization of resources by CUG customers
through multiple licensed service operators for establishing CUG
networks. The contents are, in fact, equally applicable to the
provision of a leased line wherein an attempt is made to provide
the long distance segment of the circuit from one operator and the
local segment from another. The first paragraph, inter alia,
indicates that a leased line with circuits taken from different
operators on different segments is entirely permissible and does
not require any approval or permission from the DoT, and a latter
paragraph indicates that this has to be done through mutually
agreed commercial agreements between the operators. Further, the
last paragraph states that it shall be the responsibility of the
operators to ensure that the telecom resources are used for
genuine and lawful purposes.
24
2.4.3 The Authority noted the concern of the service providers that the
incumbent is reluctant to provide `local lead’ connection as well as
partial built up option to the competing service providers for the
provision of leased circuits to their customers, on the plea that the
incumbent has to ensure genuine and lawful use of the resources.
Therefore these operators are finding it difficult to provision the
resources for CUG/ Data Networks in a proper/ timely manner to
their customers. In view of the above the Authority felt that there is
immediate need for defining the responsibility for security issues in
case of usage of resources from multiple service providers in a
CUG Network.
2.4.4 The decision of the Authority regarding the responsibility of
security issues in case of usage of resources from multiple service
providers in a CUG Network is:
In case of usage of resources from multiple service providers
in a CUG Network, the prime service provider, who is having
the agreement with the customer and arranges end-to-end
solution to its customers by utilising resources from different
service providers, should be responsible for security issues. In
case, a user/customer procures sources from different service
providers to engineer a CUG, then all the operators involved in
the CUG having agreement with user/customers are the prime
service providers and responsible for security issues.
25
2.5 Issue 4: considering provision of DLC as an interconnection
element and its inclusion in RIO (Reference Interconnect
Offer)
2.5.1 The comments received from the stakeholders on this issue are
summarized below in points (a) to (f) and dealt with in the
paragraphs following thereafter.
(a) The unbundling of local loop cannot be equated with
interconnection.
(b) Interconnection amongst the operators is to ensure
communication among the subscribers of interconnected
operators or through them with any other operator’s
subscriber. In the case of unbundling of this type (for CUG),
one operator hires capacity from other operator for connecting
its subscriber at both end of the circuit. Thus, there is no case
for terming this as interconnection.
(c) Provision of copper local lead should be considered as
interconnect element to be included in RIO.
(d) Provision of DLC as an interconnect element is a welcome
step.
(e) Provision of DLC should be part of RIO which should be
mandated to be issued by incumbents.
(f) Due to imbalance in the negotiating power of incumbents and
other private operators, it should be included in RIO.
2.5.2 The Authority noted that as per normal practice RIO is issued by
Significant Market Power (SMP). As mentioned earlier different
service providers may be significant market power in different
access technologies and asymmetric regulation in the local
segment is not considered necessary at this stage. The Authority
has therefore preferred to watch the developments after
promulgation of these regulations and inclusion of provision of
DLC/Leased Circuits in RIO is not considered necessary at this
stage.
26
2.6 Issue 5: Any other measures for promoting competition in DLC
market.
2.6.1 The comments received from the stakeholders on this issue are
summarized below in points (a) to (h) and dealt with in the
paragraphs following thereafter.
(a) There is enough competition. Service providers should develop
own infrastructure
(b) Right of Way (ROW) issues to be taken care of.
(c) Review price ceilings for various DLCs. Discounts to be
transparent and non-discriminatory.
(d) Restrictions in NLD/ILD licences to be removed
(e) Fiscal incentives for infrastructure
(f) Permission to commission multiple service providers circuits at
customer premises
(g) Incumbent should provide DLC in a time bound manner
(h) Speed up RF spectrum allocation
2.6.2 A number of issues raised have either been addressed earlier or
through these regulations. Right of way (ROW) is still a crucial
factor and needs to be addressed so that more access/last mile is
built by various service providers who have been permitted to do
so. However, the complexity of the issue due to involvement of the
various state agencies, the Authority does not find it appropriate to
address this issue in the present regulations.
Previous and next
All provisions of Domestic Leased Circuits Regulations, 2007.
Questions people ask
Is regulation 12 of Domestic Leased Circuits Regulations, 2007. still in force?
No repeal of Domestic Leased Circuits Regulations, 2007. is recorded.