Regulation 15, the Intelligent Network Services in Multi Operator and Multi Network Scenario Regulations, 2006 (13 of 2006): Summary of the main comments of Stakeholders
the Intelligent Network Services in Multi Operator and Multi Network Scenario Regulations, 2006 (13 of 2006) - Regulation 15
Text of regulation 15
Summary of the main comments of Stakeholders
15. Summary of the main comments of Stakeholders:-
i) Network architecture wherein the SSP of originating access
provider connects to the SCP of the interconnecting operator over
CCS-7 link for authentication and other purposes has a number of
technological pitfalls, integrating SSPs based on different
technologies within existing SCPs is a difficult task.
ii) It would be very difficult and cost prohibitive for any Access
Provider to not only procure SCP equipment to cater to its own
customer base but also to size it for current and future customer
base of all other Access Provider’s in the absence of any
knowledge of the business plans of the competitor.
iii) For services which rely only on signalling network, and do not rely
at all on bearer network, this would require investment on small
signalling platforms to be able to screen and account signalling
messages and generate CDRs for inter-operator billing.
iv) Appropriate TEC GR does not define the capability set for SCPs
supporting all protocols on one platform. In the absence of this and
limitations of existing SCPs, implementation and that too uniform
implementation across all operators is doubtful.
13
v) IN service is a value addition over Basic services. Such value
added services have so far not been regulated by TRAI.
Accordingly, IN services also need a similar treatment.
vi) All efforts should be made for Integrating SSP of all technologies
with SCP of different technologies as SSP of one Service Provider
interacting with SCP of different Service Providers at signalling
interconnect level is the final solution for all kind of IN services.
Protocol for IN services needs to standardized.
vii) There is an overlap in the domains of Access Providers and
NLDOs and the service can be provided jointly by Access Provider
and NLDO. These services will yield the best result if left for
mutual arrangements to be made amongst the operators.
viii) Commercial arrangements and revenue share for IN services
should be left for the mutual negotiation between the operators.
ix) IN regulations should be in conformity with the various court
orders/license agreements/commercial requirements.
x) Security aspect will need to be kept in mind while finalising the IN
Regulation.
xi) The issue of interconnect seeker and interconnect provider will
need to be addressed.
xii) A list of allowed / not allowed services should be given to help in
avoiding potential misinterpretation of the Regulation and
subsequent litigations.
xiii) In order to avoid ambiguity and achieve the objective of providing
free choice to all subscribers for IN services of all Intelligent
Network Service Providers (INSPs), very clear billing, charging and
14
revenue share guidelines for each type of IN service need to be
specified.
xiv) The start up cost for IN services and also for continued investment
for platform upgrades for deployment in a Multi Operator, Multi
Service environment will have to be borne by INSPs.
xv) The issue who provides intelligent peripherals (like announcement)
needs to be addressed.
xvi) How the location based IN services – when accessed by a
subscriber of other access provider will be handled.
xvii) Issue of how the national and international roamers could use the
IN services needs to be addressed.
xviii) There are chances of misuse, if 18xx call is handed over by the
access provider to the INSP. Access provider will not able to know
what service INSP is providing, once call is handed over to INSP.
xix) The interest of access provider should be protected.
xx) There are IN service providers (generally vendors) outside India
who already have infrastructure and workable architecture for
providing these services. These models should be studied and
analysed in our context. Option of IN services provided by the third
parties should also be explored.
16. Analysis of the issues
The Authority has taken the various comments and inputs into
consideration and analysed the matter in details. The views of the
Authority on main issues are as follows.
15
i) The Authority observed that most of the service providers are of
the opinion that integrating SSP based on different technologies
with an existing SCP of other operators may not be feasible at all
times. Inter-working of SSP and SCP of different vendors may
require software and hardware modification. This may be time
consuming process. This may also add unnecessary cost to the
operators. Because of this, most of the service providers are of the
opinion that SSP and SCP are to be owned by the Service provider
who is providing IN services and All access provider would hand
over the 18xx(IN) calls as voice call to the closest POI switch
designated for this purpose.
ii) Authority has also noted the points made by the representatives of
MTNL that integrating SSP based on different technologies with an
existing SCP of other operators would be the final solution for all IN
services. Authority has also noted that TEC GR does not define the
capability set for SCP supporting all protocols at one platform.
Therefore, operator may also require to implement different
protocols for fixed line, wireless (WLL(M), WLL(F), Cellular) etc.
Therefore Integrating SSP of one service provider with all SCP of
all other service providers would be a time consuming process.
iii) In view of the above, Authority is of opinion that exact
implementation of the architecture should be left open to the
operators. They themselves may decide the Architecture on case-
by-case basis.
iv) A crucial factor in favour of leaving architecture open for service
providers is that IN service would get implemented quickly at least
for Free Phone service and VCC. The Authority has also noted the
technical difficulties in implementing location based Intelligent
Network Services as well as provision of services through
Intelligent Peripherals in case the architecture is specified. IN
committee also recognised that Free Phone and VCC (Voice
16
Calling Cards) should be the first set of IN services to be
implemented.
v) Authority has also noted the fact that as of now all operators have
dimensioned their IN resources as per their own requirements and
subscribers base. Once it is opened for interconnection with other
operators there may be requirement of more signalling links and
other resources like enhancement of Intelligent Peripherals etc. In
fact, requirement of signalling will increase substantially as many
IN services rely more on signalling network i.e. tele-voting etc.
There may also be some legacy switches in the incumbent’s
network which may require extensive up-gradation in hardware and
software.
vi) Therefore, Authority is of the opinion that one more month after
agreement be required to the operators for implementing the IN in
multi operator multi network scenario after their mutual agreement
take place. Authority expects that at many places implementation
may happen in a shorter span where switches do not require much
up-gradation or no up-gradation at all.
vii) Authority considered the fact that signalling information may cross
the boundaries of the service area to make IN services available
nationwide, it may lead to usage of SCPs of NLDOs by Basic
Operators / CMSP / UASL as provision of the services by Access
Provider is limited to their service areas only. Authority has also
noted that as per license conditions NLDOs / ILDOs cannot access
subscriber directly. In a communication to one of the NLDOs on
28.10.2005 the licensor had clarified that Toll Free number
services and split charge (UAN) services by NLD operator is in
contravention to the NLD license conditions because these
services are subscriber based and an NLDO cannot directly access
the subscriber in terms of clause 2.2 (a) of NLD license.
17
viii) In this regard, submission has been received from one of the
NLDOs on 15.09.06 wherein it was requested that decision on the
subject of IN regulation should be in the perspective of its general
applicability and need of the industry taking care of the
interconnection issues of the IN network/services of the Long
distance Service Providers as well. It further mentioned that any
restriction on provision of IN based bearer services by the Long
distance operators would tantamount to rewriting of the license
provision of these Long Distance operators in terms of placing new
prohibitions in the license.
ix) Authority has taken note of the submissions of the NLDO and of
the view that all service provider should provide the IN services as
per terms and conditions of their Licenses and legal position and
access the subscriber only if they are permitted to do so by the
licensor.
x) During the meeting with Cellular Operators’ Association of India
(COAI), members of the Association mentioned that charging and
revenue sharing guidelines for each type of the IN Services need to
be specified. But for this purpose COAI has not been able to
provide the relevant data for analyzing the above requirement, yet.
xi) Authority has taken note of the fact that in general members of the
Committee were of the opinion that charging, billing and sharing of
the revenue depends on the service features and therefore,
charging, billing and sharing of revenue for resources used for IN
Services may be decided by the concerned service provider
through mutual commercial arrangement. The Authority
accordingly, accepts the suggestion of the Committee in this
regard. However, Authority is also in the process of finalising the
standard agreement which would be applicable if service providers
are not able to arrive at mutually acceptable agreement within a
18
specific time. Authority would also ask the relevant data from the
service providers shortly.
xii) IN Services as such, is not a separate class of Services Neither
NTP’ 99 recognizes this as a separate Service nor has licensor
categorized it as a separate Service. It is only a different means of
providing a service. Therefore, Interconnect Usage Charges (IUC)
as applicable from time to time will apply for the IN services
provided by operator in multi-operator multi-network scenario.
Interconnect Agreement between Service Providers shall include
Intelligent Network (IN) access.
xiii) In the interest of security, the Service providers shall make suitable
arrangement so that Service providers in mutual association can
provide data records of all the calls handled by them as per the
requirement of Security Agencies/License Conditions.
xiv) During the meeting, members of the COAI have also raised issue
of seeker and provider for IN Services. As mentioned above, IN
service as such is not a separate class of service, it is only a
means of providing advanced services. Therefore, there is no
separate case of seeker and provider in this scenario. Present
Point of Interconnection (POI) will continue for IN Services also.
There would be only additional requirement of signalling links
which may be mutually negotiated among the service providers.
xv) As set of IN services currently defined are all Circuit Switched or
Packet Switched Voice Services, the Quality of Service (QoS)
already mandated for voice services, shall apply. Therefore, all
Service Providers involved will be required to ensure that there
shall be no dilution in the Quality of Service (QoS) standards
applicable to the underlying Bearer Network.
19
xvi) The Numbering plan for the IN Services shall be as per applicable
National Numbering Plan (NNP). All Service Providers shall ensure
that IN Services on Multi-Operator, Multi-Network platform are
launched after getting adequate Access Code allocations from the
NNP Administrator (Licensor).
20
Previous and next
Questions people ask
Is regulation 15 of the Intelligent Network Services in Multi Operator and Multi Network Scenario Regulations, 2006 (13 of 2006) still in force?
No repeal of the Intelligent Network Services in Multi Operator and Multi Network Scenario Regulations, 2006 (13 of 2006) is recorded.