Annexure, Quality of Service of Broadband Service Regulations 2006: ANNEX
Quality of Service of Broadband Service Regulations 2006 - Annexure
Text of annexure
ANNEX.
ANNEX.
EXPLANATORY MEMORANDUM
BACKGROUND:
1. The Broadband Policy issued by the Government in October, 2004
provides for fixation of the Quality of Service standards for Broadband Service by
TRAI. At the time of issue of the Broadband Policy, Broadband connections in
India were of the order of 50,000 only. This has crossed 17 lakhs connections by
August, 2006. Alongwith the increase in the numbers of customers, the numbers
of consumer complaints pertaining to Broadband Services are also increasing.
The analysis of complaints received by the Authority indicates the customers
concern for fault repair, service provisioning, and network & billing related
problems. To address customers’ concern and to create conditions for consumer
satisfaction, a need is, therefore, felt to fix the Quality of Service benchmarks for
Broadband.
2. The Authority had undertaken public consultation by releasing a
Consultation Paper on 23rd May, 2006 and comments of stakeholders were
sought by 16th June, 2006. Open House Discussions with the stakeholders were
held at Delhi on 28th June, 2006. After the Open House Discussions, a core
group, consisting of representatives from COAI, AUSPI, ISPAI, BSNL, MTNL,
VSNL, Spectranet and an independent Consultant, was formed to further
deliberate on some of the issues relating to Quality of Service for Broadband.
3. The Authority considered the comments received from stakeholders during
the consultation process and the deliberations of the core group while finalizing
the Quality of Service norms for Broadband. The meaning of the various
parameters, its measurement methodology and rationale for the Quality of Service
Benchmarks is given below.
Objective of laying down Quality of Service Parameters:
4. The objective of laying down Quality of Service Parameters for Broadband
service is to:
i) Create transparency and monitorable standards in services through
predetermined Quality of Service norms for Broadband which the
10
service provider is required to provide and the user has a right to
expect.
ii) Measure the Quality of Service for Broadband provided by the Service
Providers from time to time and to compare them with the norms so as
to assess the level of performance.
iii) Protect the interests of consumers of Broadband service and thus
enhance consumer satisfaction.
MEANING OF THE QoS PARAMETERS & MEASUREMENT METHODOLOGY
(a) Service Provisioning/ Activation Time:
5. The service provisioning/ activation time means the time taken from the
date of receipt of an application to the date when the service is activated.
6. Core group, recommended that in case an advance payment of any sort,
for installation or service provisioning, has been taken, then the service must be
activated within 15 days. If this is not done, then the service provider must return
the money to the customer. The service provisioning benchmark of 15 days has
been prescribed accordingly.
7. Technically Non Feasible (TNF) cases such as unavailability of Broadband
infrastructure/ equipment in the Area or Spare Capacity i.e. Broadband Ports
including equipment to be installed at the customer premises for activating
Broadband connection shall be excluded from the calculation of this parameter.
Also, problems relating to customer owned equipment such as PC, LAN
Card/USB Port and internal wiring or non-availability of such equipment shall be
excluded from the calculation of this parameter.
(b) Fault Repair/ Restoration Time:
8. Fault Repair/ Restoration Time means the time taken to restore an existing
customer’s service to operational level from the time that a problem or fault is
reported.
11
9. Only those complaints, which have been registered till the close of the
business hours of the day, will be taken into account. Complaints registered after
the business hours will be taken as being registered in the next day business
hours. At the same time, faults due to the customer premises equipment which is
owned by customer such as computer hardware and software including LAN
card/USB Ports etc. shall be excluded from the measurement of performance
against this benchmark, as the service provider is not directly responsible for
these faults.
10. The benchmarks proposed for this parameter in the Consultation Paper
was different from the benchmarks prescribed in these Regulations. This is
mainly because during discussions with the core group members, it was felt that
the benchmark for Fault Restoration Time given in the ISP licence agreement
cannot be diluted. Accordingly, similar benchmarks have been prescribed in
these Regulations for Fault Repair/ Restoration Time.
11. During consultation, the service providers, core group members and
consumer organizations had accepted the proposal to give rebate/credit for
downtime, although there were different views regarding the quantum of rebate for
downtime including provision for rebate of excess down time on the same
principles as voice telephony services. . In order to have uniformity in the QoS
regulations, the Authority has prescribed rebates on the same principles as for
basic service (wireline) for excessive downtime. In all cases where the fault is not
rectified within 3 working days, rebate shall be given as per the provisions in
Regulation 3 (ii).
(c) Billing Performance:
12. The percentage of bills resulting in a customer complaint indicates the
billing performance.
Billing complaints per = Total number of disputed bills X 100
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
100 bills issued Total number of bills issued during one billing cycle.
The benchmark for this parameter has been prescribed, in line with the proposal
in the consultation paper and the views of the stakeholders. The Billing
12
Performance parameters have been specified for online charging systems as well
as for offline billing system. It also includes charging errors in preparation of bills
by the service providers.
(d) Response Time to the customer for Assistance
13. The duration from the instant a call is made to helpline number and a ring
back is received to the instant the human operator answers the calling user to
provide the service requested.
14. The calculations shall be provided based on the percentage of calls
answered within 60 seconds and within 90 seconds, averaged over a period of
one month.
15. This parameter was not proposed in the Consultation Paper. But
considering the fact that complaints/ service requests are normally made over on
telephone, it is necessary to measure the effectiveness of the customer care
helpline numbers. Only voice to voice calls to the customer care helpline/ call
centre/ help desk numbers are included in the Regulation and this does not mean
IVR response from the customer care centre of the service provider.
(e) Bandwidth Utilization/Throughput:
16. During consultation process there were different suggestions regarding
measurement of the parameter and in the core group discussions it was generally
agreed that the benchmark proposed in the Consultation Paper was difficult to
measure and implement. It was deliberated in the core group discussions and
generally agreed that measurement of the bandwidth utilisation for network links
can be made using Multi Router Traffic Grapher (MRTG).
17. The Internet Service Provider could offer a good quality of service to the
customers only if there is enough bandwidth in the Access segment, long distance
segment and Overseas NAP segment. The Access segment is entirely managed
and operated by the ISP. The broadband service can be provided through DSL,
OFC, Cable TV Network, VSAT and Broadband Wireless Access (BWA)
technologies. The national long distance segment is usually taken on lease from
13
NLDOs/ UASPs and the Overseas NAP segment is generally provided by the
ILDOs in the form of International Private Leased Circuit (IPLC) or Internet Leased
Line (ILL). Therefore, enough bandwidth should be made available in all the three
segments for ensuring good quality of service.
C
A A B B C
User
Access Long distance Upstream connectivity
Segment segment
IGSP/NIXI
National Segment including access part International Segment
18. The Authority has considered the deliberations of the core group while
fixing the benchmarks for this parameter and decided that the service providers
are required to monitor the bandwidth utilization during Time Consistent Busy
Hours (TCBH) for all network link(s)/route. ISPs/ Service Providers shall report to
TRAI the bandwidth utilization (loading) of all the upstream links going to IGSP/
NIXI with Multi Router Traffic Grapher (MRTG). However, for local links/intra-
network links the service provider need to report, only, exceptions having loading
more than 80%. In case there is more than one link, then the average utilization of
all the route links should not exceed 90% of loading level for a period of at least
one month. The broadband service provider is required to make provision for
additional bandwidth if the bandwidth utilization of the network links exceeds the
90% loading level for a period of at least one month. Average utilization of
bandwidth in a route means utilization of bandwidth capacity on all the links of the
route. For example, if there are 3 links consisting of one link of 34 Mbps, two links
of 155 Mbps each, in a route from ISP gateway to IGSP then the total bandwidth
available in the route is 344 Mbps (34+155+155) and 90% of loading means
bandwidth utilization of 309.06 Mbps.
ISP
Node
Inter-
national
Gateway
Internet
NAP
14
Measurement Methodology for Link Bandwidth Utilization/Throughput:-
19. Both in Broadband access network/ intra-network links and links to
upstream service provider, the bandwidth utilization shall be monitored using Multi
Router Traffic Grapher (MRTG). This is a tool to monitor the traffic load on
network links. MRTG generates HTML pages containing images which provide a
live visual representation of the traffic. It works on UNIX platforms and Windows
NT. MRTG uses a highly portable Simple Network Management Protocol (SNMP)
implementation to read the traffic counters of routers and creates graphs
representing the traffic on the monitored network connections. These graphs can
be embedded into web pages which can be viewed from any Web-browser. In
addition to detailed daily view, MRTG also creates visual representations of the
traffic over a period. The measurement for reporting purposes is to be made only
on working days during TCBH.
(f) Broadband Connection Speed (download):
20. In the consultation paper under the proposed benchmark Bandwidth
utilization/ throughput, it was proposed that “the bandwidth utilization between the
user and the nearest serving ISP node during download shall not be less than
70% of the subscribed level for 95% of the time”. Views of stakeholders are
different such as: (i) proposed benchmark can be committed and achieved
between the user and nearest ISP Node; (ii) the dependency of link utilization on
the availability of the content/application to be supplied from the other end is one
of the factors to be considered here and dependency is on the other end server,
far end ISP link and far end ISP’s upstream connectivity; (iii) beyond POP there is
always a sharing of bandwidth and the effective throughput at any instant depends
on the contention which increases manifold in the International domain; (iv) it is
not possible to measure throughput as a historic measure; (v) it is not possible to
establish that the traffic as less than 70% due to non-usage of the circuit, or less
usage; (vi) any measurement has to be on current basis; and (vii) bandwidth can
be effectively measured by a down-loaded server dedicated for this purpose.
21. The Authority has considered the views of the stakeholders while fixing the
benchmarks for this parameter. This parameter has been prescribed to enable the
users and service providers to measure the connection speed. As per Broadband
15
Policy, the Broadband has been defined as “an always on data connection that
has the capability of the minimum download speed of 256 kbps to an individual
subscriber from the Point of Presence (POP) of the service provider where
multiple such individual broadband connections are aggregated”. In order to
facilitate measurement of download speed from POP by the user independently, a
measurement facility is needed at each POP. However, it would be difficult for the
Broadband service provider to install the measurement facility in each POP to
facilitate the user to test independently the download speed. Therefore, service
providers can install the facility at a central location or at an ISP Node. The
measurement in this way shall include the intra-network links and loading of intra-
network links may affect the speed measurement sometime. Therefore, keeping
the reasonable loading level in intra-network links upto ISP Node, the benchmark
has been prescribed that service providers shall ensure the speed of Broadband
connection is >80% of the subscribed speed.
Measurement of Broadband Connection Speed (download):
22. The parameter can be measured on a sample basis by the user and
service provider. The service providers need to install download speed
measurement software in the Server at ISP Node to facilitate the user to measure
independently the download connection speed through a web link. The facility
shall be made available and the required procedure & information to facilitate such
testing by the customer shall be made known to the customers by the service
provider within a period of three months of coming into effect of these Regulations.
Data download speed = size of the test file (data) in ISP Server
Transmission time required for error free transfer
of the entire data
(g) Service Availability/ uptime:
23. Service availability/ uptime is the measure of the degree to which the
Broadband access network including ISP Node is operable and not in a state of
failure or outage at any point of time for all users. It also includes the upstream
connectivity uptime. Therefore, it measures the total downtime of the network for
all users, including the LAN Switches, Routers, Servers, e-mail facilities etc at ISP
Node and connectivity to upstream service providers over a period of one quarter.
16
Service Availability = (Total operational hours – Total hours of service downtime) X 100%
Total operational hours
During consultation, some of the stakeholders had suggested a lower benchmark
for this parameter. However, the Authority has fixed the benchmark for this
parameter, keeping in view the fact that Broadband being an always on
connection the downtime should be minimal.
24. Downtime for the purpose of upgrading or routine maintenance of the
network system shall be excluded from the calculation of the service availability/
uptime provided that users are informed in advance of any such upgradation or
maintenance action.
(h) Latency:
25. During consultation process the general view was that the proposed
benchmark of <90 msec for latency from User to IGSP Gateway is too
inadequate. There were also suggestions that the measurement to be made on a
sample basis and there should be a reference point for measurement. The
reference point was discussed in the core group and the group considered
reference points as User, ISP Node/POP and NIXI/IGSP nodes. Considering the
fact that the latency measurement to NIXI/IGSP Gateway reference point is more
holistic than measuring the latency for each component of the network, the
Authority felt that latency in the national leg from the User (Reference Point) to
International Gateway (IGSP/NIXI) shall be specified and decided that the
benchmark shall be <120 msec, which is achievable.
26. The ISPAI also accepted that latency of 300 msec in the international
link from NXI Node/IGSP Gateway to the nearest NAP is reasonable. Since the
measurement of latency for the international link to the nearest NAP port cannot
be made by the Broadband service provider from IGSP, it is considered to
measure the latency for international link from ISP Node, which is under the
control of the service provider. As such, the benchmark will also include the
latency from the ISP Node to the NIXI Node/IGSP Gateway. Considering this
aspect, the Authority has decided that the latency for the terrestrial link from the
17
ISP Node to the nearest NAP be < 350 msec. The core group and stakeholders
have generally agreed to the proposal in the consultation paper for the latency for
satellite media as <800msec and the same is accepted by the Authority.
(i) Packet Loss:
27. On Packet loss, different views emerged during consultation process.
Some stakeholders had raised doubt about measurement of packet loss, while
some had agreed with the parameter proposed in the Consultation Paper. In the
core group, industry representatives had proposed packet loss of <2%, while
others had indicated that it is too lenient. Considering the International practices
and the fact that benchmark of <2% is too lenient, the Authority has decided to
retain the benchmark of <1% proposed in the consultation paper.
Packet Loss and Latency Measurement:
28. Packet Loss: Packet loss is the percentage of packets lost to the total
packets transmitted between two designated CPE/ Router Ports.
29. Network Latency: Latency is the measure of duration of a round trip for a
data packet between specific source and destination Router Port/ Customer
Premises Equipment (CPE).
30. Packet Loss and Latency Parameters indicate the quality of Broadband
access network equipment including leased line resources used as well as the
equipment at the ISP/ Service Provider Node. Being responsible to the customer
for end to end QoS, the Broadband service provider needs to ensure that QoS is
maintained on all the connected links. For this purpose, the service provider
should negotiate Service Level Agreements (SLA) with the upstream service
providers, i.e., leased line providers (NLD/UASP/BSO/IP-II) and IGSP/ILDO.
There is a need to measure the packet loss and latency at different points using
ping tests.
18
31. The Packet Loss and Latency parameters proposed are for wired
Broadband access network only having Optical Fibre Technologies, Digital
Subscriber Lines (DSL) on copper loop and Cable TV Network in the access
network and terrestrial media in the national backbone. For the broadband
wireless access (BWA), since the technology is evolving and implementation is at
the nascent stage, no benchmark for packet loss and latency is proposed. The
Authority would revisit this issue later.
32. The measurement will be made for Packet Loss and Latency by the service
provider on a sample basis taking the Broadband customer (User) configuration
as User Reference Test Point at ISP Node/ POP. This configuration shall have
local loop, CPE, ADSL-router/modem or Cable modem and PC/Laptop. The
PC/Laptop shall have a minimum configuration of Pentium – IV, Windows 2000
operating system/XP/ UNIX with 256 MB RAM, hard disk 40 GB which normally a
broadband user is expected to have for getting broadband speed.
33. Minimum sample reference points for each service area shall be three in
number or multiple reference points, if needed. The Packet Loss and Latency
shall be measured from user reference points at ISP Node/ POP to IGSP/ NIXI
Gateway location and also to the nearest NAP port abroad.
34. Ping Test will be generated during the time consistent busy hour (TCBH).
For Ping test the defined Packet size shall be of 64 bytes. The test conducted on
daily basis shall be averaged for a month and the result of the Ping Test to be
indicated for the Packet Loss and Latency.
35. Packet Loss Measurement shall be done by computing the percent
packet loss of 1000 pings (with acknowledgement for each previous packet
received) of 64 byte packet each. This packet loss is the measurement of packet
lost from Broadband customer (User) configuration/ User Reference Point at ISP
Node/ POP to the IGSP/ NIXI Gateway and to the nearest NAP Port abroad.
36. Latency Measurement shall be done from user reference points at ISP
Node/ POP to IGSP/ NIXI Gateway location and to the nearest NAP Port abroad.
19
The round trip delay for the Ping packets from ISP premises to the IGSP/ NIXI
Gateway and to the nearest NAP port abroad will be measured by computing the
delay for 1000 Pings of 64 bytes each, where pings are only sent subsequent to
an acknowledgement being received for the same for the previous ping.
The following figure shows the various locations from where the packet loss and
latency can be measured by the Service Providers on sample basis during
TCBH:-
User Reference
Test Point at ISP Node/POP IGSP/NIXI Gateway
Latency < 120 msec, Packet Loss <1%
nearest NAP Port abroad
Packet Loss <1%
Latency < 350 msec (Terrestrial)
< 800 msec (Satellite)
37. All the measurements of engineering standards such as Bandwidth
Utilisation/Throughput, Packet Loss and Latency are to be carried out in the Time
Consistent Busy Hour (TCBH) as specified by ITU-T.
(j) Static I.P. Address Allocation:
38. IP address allocation for Broadband users is normally done by dynamic
allocation method on per session basis. Static/Fix IP address allocation is
required for few applications as per the requirement of customer. During
consultation process the stakeholders had generally opined that this should not
form part of the QoS benchmarks for Broadband. Therefore, considering the
views of the service providers and the normal practice followed, Static IP address
allocation is not proposed for the QoS benchmarking criteria. But in case a
Broadband customer desires to have one or more static IP addresses, it is
ISP
Gateway NAP User NIXI/
IGSP
20
expected to be made available by service provider as per normal commercial
conditions.
(k) Customer Perception of Service:
39. This parameter has been prescribed to assess the customer perception of
service.
TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE GAZETTE OF INDIA,
EXTRAORDINARY, PART III, SECTION 4
TELECOM REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF INDIA
NOTIFICATION
NEW DELHI, THE 24TH DECEMBER, 2012
F. NO. 305-21/2012-QOS.----- In exercise of the powers conferred upon it
under section 36, read with sub–clauses (i) and (v) of clause (b) of sub-section
(1) of section 11 of the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997 (24 of
1997), the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India hereby makes the following
regulations to amend the Quality of Service of Broadband Service Regulations
2006 (11 of 2006), namely:-
QUALITY OF SERVICE OF BROADBAND SERVICE
(AMENDMENT) REGULATIONS, 2012
(28 OF 2012)
1. (1) These regulations may be called the Quality of Service of Broadband
Service (Amendment) Regulations, 2012.
(2) They shall come into force with effect from 1st January, 2013.
2. After regulation 3 of the Quality of Service of Broadband Service
Regulations, 2006, (hereinafter referred to as the principal regulations),
the following regulation shall be inserted namely:-
“3A. Consequences for failure of the service provider to meet
Quality of Service benchmarks.- (1) If a service provider providing
broadband service fails to meet the benchmark of QoS parameter
specified under serial number i to viii of regulation (3), it shall,
without prejudice to the terms and conditions of its licence, or the
Act or rules or regulations or orders made, or direction issued,
thereunder, be liable to pay an amount, by way of financial
disincentive, not exceeding rupees fifty thousand per parameter and
in case of second or subsequent such contravention, to pay an
amount not exceeding rupees one lakh per parameter for each
contravention, as the Authority may, by order direct:
Provided that no order for payment of any amount by way of financial
disincentive shall be made by the Authority unless the service
provider providing broadband service has been given a reasonable
opportunity of representing against the contravention of the
regulation observed by the Authority.
(2) If the compliance report furnished by a service provider
providing broadband service for QoS parameter specified under serial
number i to viii under regulation 3 is false and which such service
provider knows or believes to be false or does not believe to be true, it
shall, without prejudice to the terms and conditions of its license, or
the Act or rules or regulations or order made, or, direction issued
thereunder, be liable to pay an amount, by way of financial
disincentive, not exceeding rupees ten lakh per parameter for which
such false report has been furnished.
Provided that no order for payment of any amount by way of financial
disincentive shall be made by the Authority unless the service
provider providing broadband service has been given a reasonable
opportunity of representing against the contravention of the
regulation observed by the Authority.
(3) The amount payable by way of financial disincentive under
these regulations shall be remitted to such head of account as may
be specified by the Authority.”
3. After regulation 4 of the principal regulations, the following regulation
shall be inserted, namely:----
“4A. Consequences for failure of the service providers to submit
compliance report.- (1) If a service provider providing broadband
service contravenes the provisions of regulation 4, it shall, without
prejudice to the terms and conditions of its licence, or the provisions
of the Act or rules or regulations or order made, or direction issued,
thereunder, be liable to pay an amount, by way of financial
disincentive, not exceeding rupees five thousand for every day during
which the default continues.
Provided that no order for payment of any amount by way of financial
disincentive shall be made by the Authority unless the service
provider providing broadband service has been given a reasonable
opportunity of representing against the contravention of the
regulation observed by the Authority.
(2) The amount payable by way of financial disincentive under
these regulations shall be remitted to such head of account as may
be specified by the Authority.”
(Rajeev Agrawal)
Secretary
Note 1.--- The principal regulations were published in the Gazette of India,
Extraordinary, Part III, Section 4 dated the 10th October, 2006 vide notification
number No. 304-6/2004-QoS dated the 6th October, 2006.
Note 2.--- The Explanatory Memorandum explains the objects and reasons of
the Quality of Service of Broadband Service (Amendment) Regulations, 2012.
Explanatory Memorandum
TRAI has laid down the Quality of Service Standards for Broadband
Service through the Quality of Service of Broadband Service Regulations, 2006
(11 of 2006) dated the 6th October, 2006. As part of compliance to these
regulations the quarterly Performance Monitoring Reports are received from
service providers providing broadband service. TRAI also conducts periodic
audit and assessment of Quality of Service (QoS) through independent agencies
across the country, to monitor the compliance of prescribed standards/
benchmarks. Analysis of these reports of several past quarters reveals that
some of the service providers are repeatedly not meeting the Quality of Service
benchmarks for some of the prescribed parameters and no consistent
improvement is noticed in spite of continuous follow up with the service
providers by TRAI. Therefore, a need has been felt to provide for financial
disincentives for failure to meet the Quality of Service benchmarks.
2. Keeping in view the need to ensure the Quality of Service provided by the
service providers and to protect the interests of the consumers by making these
regulations more effective, it is felt that the Quality of Service of Broadband
Service Regulations, 2006 (11 of 2006) dated the 6th October, 2006 need to be
amended to introduce financial disincentive in relation to the performance of
service providers with regard to the Quality of Service benchmarks so as to
strengthen the effectiveness and compliance of the said regulations.
3. The draft amendments to the Standards of Quality of Service of
Broadband Service Regulations, 2006 (11 of 2006) on financial disincentives
were released on 26.10.2012, seeking the comments of the stakeholders. Some
of the stakeholders have stated that Telecom Regulatory Authority of India Act,
1997 does not confer upon the Authority power to impose penalty in the form
of financial disincentives. In this context, it is stated that the TRAI Act confers
power on the Authority not only to regulate but also to ensure the compliance
of the provisions of the regulations. The word “ensure” has mandatory
connotation, it means “make certain”. Furthermore, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court, in its judgment dated the 17, Aug, 2007, in Civil Appeal No. 2104/2006
(Central Power Distribution Co. & Ors Vs. CERC & Anr), inter-alia, held that “it
is well settled that a power to regulate includes within it power to enforce”. It
will not be out of place to mention that there are a catena of judgments by the
Supreme Court wherein the Hon’ble Court has repeatedly re-stated the
proposition that legislation should be read and interpreted so as to further the
purpose of its enactment and not in a manner that derogates from its main
objectives. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in its judgment in the case of State of
Karnataka Vs. Vishwabharthi House Building Co-operative Societies and Ors.
[(2004) 5 SCC 430], quoted with approval the judgment of Hon’ble Guwahati
High Court in the case of Arbind Das Vs. State of Assam & Ors. [AIR 1981 Gau
18 (FB)] wherein it was inter-alia, held that where a statute gives a power, such
power implies that legitimate steps may be taken to exercise that power even
though these steps may not be clearly spelt out in the statute. The Hon’ble
Court further held that in determining whether a power claimed by a statutory
authority can be held to be incidental or ancillary to the powers specially
conferred by the statute, the court must not only see whether the power may
be derived by reasonable implication from the provisions of the statute, but
also whether such powers are necessary for carrying out the purposes of the
provision of the statute which confers power on the Authority in exercise of
such powers. The relevant part of the said judgment reads as under:-
“We are of firm opinion that where a statute gives a power, such power
implies that all legitimate steps may be taken to exercise that power even though
these steps may not be clearly spelt in the statute. Where the rule-making
authority gives power to certain authority to do anything of public character,
such authority should get the power to take intermediate steps in order to give
effect to the exercise of the power in its final step, otherwise the ultimate power
would become illusory, ridiculous and inoperative which could not be the
intention of the rule-making authority. In determining whether a power claimed
by the statutory authority can be held to be incidental or ancillary to the powers
expressly conferred by the statute, the court must not only see whether the
power may be derived by reasonable implication from the provisions of the
statute, but also whether such powers are necessary for carrying out the purpose
of the provisions of the statute which confers power on the authority in its
exercise of such power.”
In view of the above, the Authority has power to impose financial
disincentives on the service providers for non-compliance of the provisions of
the Regulations. Keeping in view the comments received from the stakeholders
and the need to ensure compliance with the Quality of Service regulations,
these regulations have been formulated.
4. Some of the stakeholders have stated that the broadband industry itself
is still at a very nascent stage and it needs lesser regulatory framework and
hence the QoS KPIs should be revised. Further, exclusions for events beyond
the control of service providers should also be taken into consideration for
calculation of KPIs, like force majeure & natural calamities, impact due to law
& order issues like curfews, bandhs etc., infrastructure issues in security
sensitive areas, site access issues due to limited availability of road network,
installation time and restoration time delay due to customer unavailability or
reasons related with customer premises, failures caused by major power grid
failures, unreliable electricity supply, impact due to fibre cuts and other
disruptions caused by ongoing- infrastructure improvement projects, repeated
theft at sites even after logging complaints with law enforcement agencies like
Police, Right of Way (ROW) issues, building access issues, field related
permission issues, customer own CPE & wiring issues, laying of aerial network
which is prone to external factors and customers who voluntarily accept the
lower QoS.
In this context, it is stated that the benchmarks for the QoS parameters
as laid down in the Quality of Service of Broadband Service Regulations 2006
(11 of 2006) are sufficiently lenient keeping in view the growth of broadband
services and customer interests. Further, it has been provisioned in the
regulations that a reasonable opportunity of representing against the
contravention of the regulation observed by the Authority shall be given to the
service provider before an order for payment of any amount by way of financial
disincentive is made.
5. The Authority will monitor the Quality of Service reported by service
providers subsequent to the coming into force of these regulations from the
point of view of non-compliance with the benchmarks. In case the benchmark
for any of the quality of service parameter for Broadband Service e.g. the
benchmark for packet loss <1%, is not met by an operator in the first quarter
after coming into force of these regulations financial disincentive not exceeding
Rs.50000/- is liable to be imposed. In case in any of the subsequent quarters
the benchmark for the same parameter i.e. packet loss <1% is not met financial
disincentive not exceeding Rs.1 lakh is liable to be imposed by the Authority.
6. It has been commented that the Broadband QoS Regulation describing
calculation methodology for some of the parameters are not fully clear which
may lead to variance in the performance of the parameter reported by service
providers vis-à-vis understanding of the regulations by independent auditors
while carrying out the audit. However, the measurement methodology of the
parameters is already explained in detail in the explanatory memorandum to
the principal regulations.
In order to prevent furnishing of false compliance reports to the
Authority, financial disincentive not exceeding rupees ten lakh per parameter
has been provisioned in the regulations. The Authority is of the view that such
provision of financial disincentive will act as a deterrent against false reporting
of performance against Quality of Service benchmarks.
7. Some of the stakeholders have stated that the proposal to impose
financial disincentives for even minor delay in submission of report for few
days is too harsh as delay in reporting is minor/technical violation in nature
especially when consumer is not harmed. The case for penalty arises only when
any harm has been caused to subscribers due to willful violation by service
providers.
It has been observed that in many cases repeated letters and reminders
are required to make service providers submit the PMRs. The Authority is of
the view that provision of financial disincentive will be a deterrent against such
lapses by service providers. Financial disincentive, not exceeding rupees five
thousand for every day of delay in submission of the Performance Monitoring
reports is liable to be imposed on service provider.
Previous and next
All provisions of Quality of Service of Broadband Service Regulations 2006
Questions people ask
Is annexure of Quality of Service of Broadband Service Regulations 2006 still in force?
No repeal of Quality of Service of Broadband Service Regulations 2006 is recorded.