Regulation 13, Quality of Service (Code of Practice for Metering and Billing Accuracy) Regulation 2006: The auditor shall evaluate inter alia the correctness of the following
Quality of Service (Code of Practice for Metering and Billing Accuracy) Regulation 2006 - Regulation 13
Text of regulation 13
The auditor shall evaluate inter alia the correctness of the following
13. The auditor shall evaluate inter alia the correctness of the following: -
(i) The generation process of the Call Data Records (CDR) - raw CDRs.
(ii) Of the entries in the direction table which is used for rating the raw
CDRs.
(iii) Of the rated CDR vis-à-vis the rate applied, duration mentioned,
origination and destination codes.
(iv) In charging of VAS services to the subscribers.
(v) In charging of the roaming services to the mobile subscribers.
(vi) In charging of SMS on blackout days.
(vii) In charging of processing fee on Top Up Vouchers.
14. The auditor shall undertake the verifications of billing and charging by
service providers both for prepaid and postpaid customers in accordance
with the Code of Practice for Metering and Billing Accuracy in a
representative manner within the overall sample size. The number of
sample size to be checked in each tariff plan verification should be such so
as to achieve a confidence level of ninety five percent with a confidence
interval of three percent.
15. The one month period of the CDRs shall be selected in such a manner that
it would be easy for the service providers to effect refunds, if any, when the
CDRs are live on the billing system. As far as possible, CDR audit for a
Quarter shall be conducted within the same Quarter.
16. The auditor shall take the raw CDRs post-mediated and unrated and
process the same to generate the bill and then verify with already generated
bill for any discrepancy. In all cases metering and mediation process is to be
checked first by sample test calls to ascertain that metering and mediation
process is accurate and no systemic deficiency is noticed. After doing the
functional testing of the mediation process/software, unrated post-mediated
CDRs may be used for generating the bills for audit analysis.
17. In the case of prepaid, rated CDRs are produced by the IN system. In the
absence of any un-rated CDRs, sample test calls shall be made using test
SIM Cards/ telephone for every possible charge scenario and corresponding
accuracy of rating procedures by the IN system may be established.
Backward reconciliation of rated CDRs from IN system shall be done to
further establish correctness of rating procedures.
18. The auditor shall also undertake backward reconciliation of billing
complaints both for post-paid and pre-paid to establish correctness of rating
procedures.
19. The Audit Agency shall analyse the discrepancy if detected, and find out the
root cause of the same. The discrepancy analysis is done by execution of
the rating engine that performs analysis of the rated CDRs in order to
establish causes of the discrepancy based on CDR, subscriber and pricing
plan data. After several cycles of event level discrepancy analysis and
database adjustment, when all the event level discrepancies are taken care
of, the next step is of bill level discrepancy. The bill level discrepancy
reports shall be produced and analysed by the auditor. The auditor shall
perform verification of successful implementation of the corrective action.
20. The auditor shall, while undertaking audit of the metering and billing system
of service provider, check whether, in accordance with the directions of the
Authority dated 12th June, 2012, (i) a Master Table is maintained, service
area-wise, to record the events relating to configuration of new number
series and (ii) a Master Table is maintained, service area-wise, to record the
events relating to configuration of new tariff plans and shall record his
findings in the audit report after auditing the entries therein.
21. Areas of concern identified by the auditor during the assessment of a
service provider’s Metering and Billing System against each item of the
Code of Practice for Metering and Billing Accuracy may be identified in the
form of:
(a) A non-compliance ~ an instance of failure to comply with an established
requirement. The nature of the failure and the requirement in question need
to be made explicit in documenting any non-compliance.
(b) A Deficiency ~ an instance of a lack of adequacy in meeting a
requirement. An example might be where a billing system has no facility to
detect duplication of records for the same service usage. This would be
likely to lead to a breach of Code of Practice for Metering and Billing
Accuracy, but the absence of a detection facility only causes a problem
when such duplication occurs.
(c) An observation ~ a comment about something that has been seen during
an assessment, but is not considered sufficiently serious to be a deficiency.
However, it may possibly lead to corrective and / or preventative action.
22. The areas of concern identified during audit shall be categorised into three
categories as described below:-
(a) Category 1: An important matter of non-compliance or deficiency for
which corrective action must be undertaken urgently. In view of the grave
consequences of a Category 1 matter, it is expected that a service provider
shall resolve it as a matter of utmost importance. In any event a detailed
corrective action plan must be agreed within one month and put into effect
immediately.
(b) Category 2: A matter of concern, which is to be resolved within a period,
agreed with the auditor. In any event a detailed corrective action plan must
be agreed and put into effect within three-months.
(c) Category 3: A matter worthy of consideration by the service provider,
possibly leading to corrective and / or preventative action, but not of
sufficient importance to warrant Category 1 or 2 status.
23. The auditor shall check the integration of Billing System in respect of rent
rebate of basic service during the audit and see whether rent rebate is being
given to customers in respect of faults not rectified within three days, in
accordance with the Standards of Quality of Service of Basic Telephone
Service (Wireline) and Cellular Mobile Telephone Service Regulations, 2009
(7 of 2009).
24. The auditor shall verify from the system of the service providers whether
there has been any case of levy or collection of migration charges from its
subscribers which have been prohibited vide TRAI’s direction dated
15.3.2001 and include such findings in the audit report.
25. The auditor shall verify whether TRAI’s direction dated 27.06.2005 and
07.06.2005 relating to credit limit is being complied with.
26. The auditor shall verify whether the tariff for any item in the tariff plan with
validity of more than six months, including tariff plans with lifetime or
unlimited validity and also involving an upfront payment to be made by the
subscriber towards such validity period, is increased during the validity
period of such plans. The auditor shall verify whether the tariff for any item
in other tariff plan is not increased within six months of enrolment in the tariff
plan in accordance with the Telecommunication Tariff (43rd Amendment)
Order notified on 21.03.2006.
27. The auditor shall verify whether CLIP charge is levied as a compulsory item
in the tariff plan.
28. The auditor shall verify, check and report to TRAI the true and correct
position about specific instances of billing complaints having systemic/
generic implications that are referred to it by TRAI from time to time.
29. The auditor shall obtain from the service provider the audit report, action
taken report and details of any unresolved or outstanding matters of
previous year of audit and shall verify the action taken on such audit report
and action taken report. He shall record his observations thereon in the
audit report.
30. The auditor shall check the metering electronically using software or
equipments and there shall not be any manual checking of metered
duration. He shall record his findings in the audit report along with the
details of the test calls made.
31. The auditor shall submit its progress report on a quarterly basis within three
weeks from the date of closure of the quarter.
32. The auditor shall prepare the audit report expeditiously in the format
prescribed by the Authority, in accordance with clauses (i) and (j) of sub-
regulation (2) of regulation 6B of in the Quality of Service (Code of Practice
for Metering and Billing Accuracy) Regulation 2006 dated 21-03-2006, as
amended by Quality of Service (Code of Practice for Metering and Billing
Accuracy) (Amendment) Regulations, 2013 dated 25-03-2013, checklist for
audit and guidelines for audit so as to enable the service provider to submit
the audit report to the Authority by 31st July of every year.
33. The auditor shall not delay the preparation of the audit report, waiting for the
comments of the service provider on any audit observation.
34. The auditor shall report to Advisor (QOS), TRAI in all matters.
35. The auditor shall treat all the information provided by the service provider as
confidential and shall not share this information without the written approval
of the service providers.
36. The auditor shall after completing audit of a License Service Area (LSA) of a
service provider for Mobile or Basic Service shall submit to TRAI key
findings of the audit report along with the process/procedure and shall also
make a presentation to TRAI.
37. TRAI may call the auditor for meetings/ presentation on audit findings or
audit reports or for seeking/ providing clarifications or for reviewing the
progress of audit. The auditor shall attend such meetings/ presentation at
their own expenses.
38. During the audit, TRAI may entrust the auditor to undertake special audit on
any issue. The auditor shall undertake audit on such issue as part of the
annual audit of metering and billing system and shall report to TRAI about
the findings of such audit in such format and in such time frame TRAI may
specify in this regard.
Checklist for audit as per Quality of Service (Code of Practice
for Metering and Billing Accuracy) Regulation, 2006, as
amended by Quality of Service (Code of Practice for Metering
and Billing Accuracy) (Amendment) Regulations, 2013
Preliminary
1. Obtain from the service providers list of officers in each billing centre who
can be contacted for audit purposes.
2. Establish with the service provider the chain of reporting of audit
observations to the service provider for comments.
3. Obtain from the service provider the billing centres of the service provider.
4. Obtain from the service provider the details of the billing system and
software deployed by them.
5. Establish with the service provider the contact point(s) for obtaining call data
records.
6. Obtain from the service provider the contact details of the complaint centre.
7. Familiarise with the Quality of Service (Code of Practice for Metering and
Billing Accuracy) Regulation, 2006 dated 21.3.2006, the Quality of Service
(Code of Practice for Metering and Billing Accuracy) (Amendment)
Regulations, 2013 dated 25.3.2013, Guidelines for Audit, Checklist for Audit,
formats for (i) audit report; (ii) action taken report; (iii) quarterly progress
report; (iv) monthly report on action taken by service provider on instances
of overcharging, various Tariff Orders, Directions and Regulations relating to
tariff.
Process Review
Compliance with regard to Code of Practice for Metering and
Billing Accuracy
(Table – A)
Sr.
No
Audit Area (item name) Test to be performed Observation Observation
Category
1 Information relating to
Tariffs
1.1 Before a customer is enrolled
for any telecommunication
service, he shall be provided
the detailed information
relating to the tariff applicable
for that service.
Verify the process for
enrolment of a customer
and check whether he
was given information
relating to tariff.
1.2 (a) The customer shall be
provided a copy of the
Customer Acquisition Form at
the time of enrollment
(b) The customer shall also
be informed in writing, in
accordance with the
regulations, directions and
orders issued by the
Authority, not later than one
week after the activation of
service, about ----
(i) the tariff plan subscribed
by him;
(ii) quantity related charges
such as the charge for each
SMS message, or kilobyte of
data etc.;
(iii) accuracy of measurement
of time, duration and of
quantity, and also the
resolution and rounding rules,
including the underlying units,
Verify the process for
giving copy of the
Customer Acquisition
Form (CAF) and also
verify on sample basis
whether the customer
has been provided a
copy of the CAF.
Verify whether the
customer has been
informed in writing,
within one week after
activation of service,
about the tariff plan
subscribed by him and
other charges
applicable (take
sample cases and test
check).
Verify availability of
accuracy of
measurement and
Sr.
No
Audit Area (item name) Test to be performed Observation Observation
Category
used when calculating the
charges for an individual
event or an aggregation of
event; and
(iv) contractual terms and
conditions for provision,
restriction and termination of
service:
rounding rules and
whether information
relating to this has
been provided to
customer within one
week after activation of
service.
Verify contractual
terms and conditions
for provision,
restriction and
termination of service
and whether
information relating to
this has been provided
to customer within one
week after activation of
service.
Verify contractual
terms and conditions
with reference to bill
printed.
(Information at item(i),
(ii), (iii) and (iv) can be
given along with the
Start-up Kit (SUK) or in
the CAF, a copy of
which is given to the
customer)
1.3 Where a value-added service
(e.g. download of content,
such as a film clip or ring
tone) or entry to an interactive
service (such as a game) can
be selected through a choice
of the service user (e.g. by
dialing a specific number)
then the charge for the
service must be provided to
him before he commits to use
the service.
Take a list of all such
value-added services.
Take sample from
each value-added
services and check the
procedures completely.
Verify whether the
charge for the service
is indicated before
subscriber commits to
use the service
1.4 The information about the Obtain website URL.
Sr.
No
Audit Area (item name) Test to be performed Observation Observation
Category
tariff plans, Plan Vouchers,
Top Up Vouchers, Special
Tariff Vouchers and Combo
Vouchers on offer shall be
available on the website of
the service provider in
accordance with the
regulations, directions and
orders issued by the
Authority, from time to time.
Log onto website and
verify whether
mentioned details are
available for each
Tariff plan.
Establish whether
above information is
available on the
website in accordance
with TRAI directives
dated 16.1.2012.
2 Provision of Service
The services provided to the
customer and all subsequent
changes therein shall be
those agreed with him in
writing prior to providing the
service or changing its
provisions.
Verify procedures to
log customer requests
for services
Verify procedures for
applying such
customer requests
3 Accuracy of
Measurement
3.1 All charges levied for
telecommunication services
levied on the customer shall
be consistent with the tariff
applicable to the customer.
Verify with one month
CDRs in each Quarter
with reference to tariff
plan selected for audit
and also by making
calls in each selected
plan
3.2 Unless otherwise specified in
the published Tariff or
previously agreed Tariff, a
charge shall be determined in
accordance with the following
limits:
a) Where the charge is
dependent upon duration,
the recorded duration
shall be measured to
within:
Between +1 seconds
and –1 second; or
Between +0.01%
(1:10,000) to –0.02%
(1:5,000) whichever is
less stringent; and
Test check on sample
basis electronically or
using software to
establish correctness
of recorded duration.
Sr.
No
Audit Area (item name) Test to be performed Observation Observation
Category
b) where the charge is
dependent upon the time
of day, the time of day
shall be recorded to
within ±1 second,
traceable to an
appropriate time
reference; and
Check the reference
time used in the
switches/exchanges
and whether the
reference time is
uniform in the network.
Check whether
variation is there
between the reference
time and timing of the
switch/exchange
Test check sample
records to establish
correctness of
parameters.
c) where the charges are
dependent upon the
counting of occurrences
of a particular type, the
count shall be accurate to
no more than plus
1/25,000 (0.004%) or
minus 1/1,000 (0.1%).
Test check sample
records to establish
correctness of
parameters.
3.3 Where measurement under
clauses 3.2 (a), (b) & (c)
reveals systematic errors in
timing or counting that result
in overcharged events which
are not stated in published
Tariffs then correction should
take place to ensure accurate
Bills.
Verify with the records
whether corrective
action has been taken.
4 Reliability of Billing
4.1 The performance of a Total
Metering and Billing System
shall be, subject to the
tolerances specified in clause
3.2:
a) the numbers of items of
service usage that are
overcharged events or
undercharged events, as
a proportion of the total
number of chargeable
Based on the audit
procedures applied above,
take the total deviation
and verify whether the
same is in accordance
with the limits stated by
TRAI
Sr.
No
Audit Area (item name) Test to be performed Observation Observation
Category
events, shall not exceed
the limits shown in Table
1; and
b) the sum of the values of
the errors in the
overcharged events or
undercharged events, as
a proportion of the total
value of the total number
of Chargeable events,
shall not exceed the limits
shown in Table 1.
Table 1 – Total Metering
and Billing System
reliability performance
requirements
Chargeable
Events
Performance
Number
under or not
Charged
0.1% (1 in
1000)
Number
overcharged
0.004% (1 in
25,000)
Value under
or not
charged
0.05% (1 in
2000)
Value
overcharged
0.002% (1 in
50,000)
4.2 Where implementation of an
order for a service, feature or
discount which depends on
the number or duration of
chargeable events is applied
at variance with published
Tariffs, each chargeable
event within the scope of the
incorrectly applied order shall
be an undercharged event or
an overcharged event, as
appropriate, for the purposes
of clause 4.1.
Verify with reference to
tariff plan or Special Tariff
Voucher activated by the
customer to determine
undercharged or
overcharged events for
the purpose of clause 4.1.
Overcharged events to be
considered for refunds.
4.3 Where an item of service
usage is completed other
than intended, but the charge
applied is correct for the
Observation
Sr.
No
Audit Area (item name) Test to be performed Observation Observation
Category
service as delivered, this shall
not be regarded as either an
undercharged event or an
overcharged event.
4.4 The increase in duration or
number of items of service
usage resulting from
degraded transmission
performance shall not be
taken into account when
computing the performance of
the system.
Observation
5 Applying Credit to
Accounts
5.1 For post-pay accounts,
payments made by a
customer shall be credited to
his account within 3 working
days of receipt of the cash/
cheque. Where credit is given
by the service provider, this
shall be applied within one
working day of its agreement.
Review the payment
credit system.
Take payments
sample to check
whether the credit is
applied correctly.
Check that the
payments made by the
customer are regularly
updated in the billing
system.
Updation in respect of
post-pay customers to
be credited within 3
working days of receipt
of the cash/cheque.
5.2 For pre-pay accounts, top-
up credit shall be applied to a
customer’s account within 15
minutes of its application.
Where credit is given by the
service provider, this shall be
applied within 1 day of its
agreement.
Review the system
settings and take
sample cases to test
whether the conditions
are met.
6 Timeliness of Post Pay
Sr.
No
Audit Area (item name) Test to be performed Observation Observation
Category
Billing
6.1 The timeliness of bill issue or
bill data file issue shall be
subject to systematic
processes.
Review process and
procedures for
issuance of bill
6.2 Any chargeable events the
details of which are not
available when the bill is
prepared shall be included in
a subsequent bill, but not
later than the fourth monthly
bill after the chargeable
events occurred. Any details
not so presented shall be
written off and if significant be
counted against the
performance for
undercharged events in
clause 4.1. Exceptionally,
event details from a separate
service provider may be billed
up to three months after
receipt.
Review the process of
chargeable events.
Take sample for such
cases (typically where
the customers are
National or
International Roaming)
Obtain list of all such
events (that have
occurred) for the
period under review
Review procedures of
inclusion of such
events in subsequent
bill (Whether such
charges are separately
identifiable)
Review procedures for
writing off of such
charges.
Verify whether all such
charges have been
included for calculation
of ‘undercharged
events’
Check that all calls
billed are in respect of
the billing period
referred on the bill and
also to verify whether
the discounts, if any,
have been properly
passed on to the
customers without any
errors.
6.3 Agreement to extend the
timescales described in
clause 6.2 may be sought
from the TRAI. An extension
will only be available on an
irregular basis. Decisions will
be made on application for an
Sr.
No
Audit Area (item name) Test to be performed Observation Observation
Category
extension concerning:
a) The method in which
how customers will be
informed of a
protracted delay in
rendering call records
onto a subsequent bill;
and
b) The integrity of the
billing process audit
arrangements.
Review any exceptions
sought from TRAI for
extension.
Review the method in
which such clients
have been intimated
and verify the process
for such issues
Verify whether there is
appropriate audit
procedures
implemented within the
company to address
such issues
6.4 The service provider shall
contract with its delivery
agent to ensure that an
effectual bill or bill data file
delivery schedule is in place.
The existence of such a
contract shall be subject to
audit.
Obtain & verify all bill
delivery vendor
contracts
Test & establish
effectiveness and
adequacy of
procedures and
process
7 Restriction and Removal
of Service
Where the service provider
unilaterally intends to restrict
or cease service to the
customer, a notice shall be
provided to the customer in
advance of such action so
that the customer has
reasonable time to take
preventive action to avoid
restriction or cessation of
service.
Understand related
procedures and
establish adequacy
thereof
Test similar instances
during review period
and establish
adherence
Check that proper
notices are sent to the
customer in advance
where the service
provider unilaterally
intends to restrict or
cease service to a
customer.
In case of
disconnection due to
payment made beyond
credit period, to check
that the services get
Sr.
No
Audit Area (item name) Test to be performed Observation Observation
Category
restored once the
payments are made
within the period as
stipulated by TRAI.
8 Complaint Handling
8.1
8.2
8.3
8.4
The service provider shall
have a documented process
for identifying, investigating
and dealing with billing
complaints and creating
appropriate records thereof.
The service provider shall
carry out a root cause
analysis for each upheld
billing complaint, categorise
the cause and establish
proportionate remedial action
to correct it.
Where the root cause affects
multiple customer accounts,
then all affected Bills shall, if
practicable, be included in a
recovery programme.
Where remedial action has
not been completed and the
cause is likely to affect other
bills when issued, then the
service provider shall take
reasonable steps to ensure
that they are checked and, if
necessary, corrected, before
being sent to the customer. If
not checked and corrected
such Bills shall be included in
a recovery programme
(clause 8.3).
Check whether the
service provider has a
documented process
for identifying,
investigating and
dealing with billing
complaints.
Review the Billing
Complaint system
Review process
manual for addressing
customer complaints
and establish
adequacy of
procedures
Test instances during
review period and
establish adherence to
documented
procedures
Review & verify
procedures for root
cause categorization
and analyses
Check whether the
service provider
carries out root cause
analysis for each
upheld billing
complaint and where
the root cause affects
multiple customers,
whether all affected
bills is included in a
recovery program.
Test and verify
instances of remedial
action, including
refund of overcharges
to all affected
customers.
Verify adequacy of
procedures in this
Sr.
No
Audit Area (item name) Test to be performed Observation Observation
Category
regard
Check the true and
correct position about
specific instance of
billing complaints
having systemic/
generic implications as
referred by TRAI.
9 Materiality
Compliance with the
requirements contained in
this regulation shall need to
be demonstrated only in
relation to products and
services that have a material
impact on the customer’s bill.
This materiality is deemed to
be:
a) where the service
provider’s turnover from a
product or service
comprises 5% or more of
its total turnover with the
customers targeted for
that product or service; or
b) where the number of
customers subscribing to
a product or service
offered by the service
provider comprises 5% or
more of the customers
targeted for that product
or service; or
c) at the specific direction of
the TRAI.
When taking samples for
test checking, the
parameter shall be
followed in selecting the
sample category.
10 Submission of
Compliance
The service providers shall
submit the compliance of
above code of practice to
TRAI on yearly basis.
Verify the circumstances
for delay, if any, in
submitting the audit report
of the current year and
audit report and action
taken report of the
previous year and report
thereon.
Billing & Metering System Review (Transaction Review)
(Table – B)
Sr.
No.
Audit Area (item name) Test to be performed Observation Observation
Category
1 The auditing Agency shall
evaluate inter alia the
correctness of the
following: -
(a) In generation process
of the CDR-raw
CDRs.
Test check
procedures for CDR
recording for both pre-
paid and post-paid
plans
Verify whether CDR’s
are editable
(b) Of the entries in the
direction table which
is used for rating the
raw CDRs.
Verify rating masters
to establish
procedures for
creating and
modification of service
charges
Obtain information
about all new tariff
plans launched during
the Quarter and
To verify the proper
configuration of all the
tariff plans, especially
the new tariff plans, in
billing system with
reference to the
entries in the Master
Table prescribed vide
direction dated
12.06.2012.
Obtain information
about all the new
number series and
verify the correctness
of the rating charges
and configuration with
reference to the
entries in the Master
Table prescribed vide
direction dated
12.06.2012.
Verify rating masters
to establish charges
mapped to each tariff
plan
Test whether rated
CDR’s are modifiable.
(c) In charging of VAS
services to the
subscribers.
Obtain list of all VAS
services and its
process and
procedure for
subscription/ activation
and for unsubscription
of service.
Verify procedures for
mapping of charges to
VAS services
Verify whether the
processes and
requirements
prescribed by TRAI for
obtaining the explicit
consent of the
consumer, as per
directions of TRAI,
were followed and
whether any VAS
provided without
consumer’s consent
and charged.
In respect of services
provided during “Free
Trial Period” to
subsequently check
whether the customer
has confirmed the
continuance of
services once the free
trial period has ended
and accordingly billed
for.
Verify the availability
of toll free facility of
unsubscription of
service as per TRAI
directions and through
common short code
155223.
Verify whether the
customer is charged
for unsubscribing any
value added service.
Verify whether the
records relating to
explicit consent is
preserved for one
year.
(d) Of the rated CDR vis- Verify procedures for
à-vis the rated
applied, duration
mentioned,
origination and
destination codes
including STD/ISD
destinations, both for
mobile and fixed.
mapping of call
origination and
destination locations.
Raw CDR’s to be
rated according to the
Tariff Plans/Special
Tariff Voucher and
Rating Algorithms (set
of tables/ rate
masters)
Check all billable
activities occurring on
the network are
accurately captured,
rated and billed in
accordance with
customer agreement.
Check that there is no
delay in updation of
billing with latest
agreed upon rates/
tariff implementation.
Due to non-updation /
rating, a CDR
generated may go to
suspended CDR’s
pool which may be
billed subsequently. In
such cases to check
that it is billed
subsequently for the
same period and is in
line with the agreed
Tariff Plans.
To check discounts /
schemes not forming
part of the original
contract are properly
passed on by the
Service Providers in
respect of the various
marketing schemes
promoted by the
Service Provider from
time to time.
To check the
correctness of
charging for calls to
each of the new
number series
configured during the
year.
(e) In charging of the
roaming services to
the mobile
subscribers
Verify procedures for
applying roaming
charges and also
evaluate inter alia the
correctness as per the
tariff applicable to the
customer and orders
of TRAI.
(f) In charging of SMS on
blackout days.
Obtain the list of
blackout days.
Verify on sample basis
the charges applied
viz-a-vis the tariff as
per the tariff plan
subscribed by the
customer.
Verify whether the
direction dated
14.9.2012 are
complied with.
(g)In charging of
processing fee on Top
Up Vouchers.
Obtain the list of Top
Up Voucher.
Verify on sample basis
the processing fee
levied on these
vouchers viz-a-vis the
process fee prescribed
by TRAI.
(h) In applying credit limits
to postpaid customers
Verify on sample basis
whether postpaid
customers were
informed about their
credit limits in advance
as per TRAI direction
dated 27.06.2005 and
07.06.2006.
Verify whether the bills
issued to customers
contain information
about their credit limit.
Verify whether the
customers are
informed when they
reach 80% of their
usage as per direction
dated 27.7.2012.
Verify whether the
service was
discontinued in cases
where the amount due
is less than the
security deposit.
(i) In increasing any item of
tariff in a tariff plan.
Verify from bills to
ensure that no tariff
item has been hiked
during the prescribed
validity period
specified in the Tariff
Plans.
Verify that no tariff
item in a tariff plan is
increased by the
access provider -
(a) In respect of tariff
plans with prescribed
periods of validity of
more than six months
including tariff plans
with lifetime or
unlimited validity and
also involving an
upfront payment to be
made by the
subscriber towards
such validity period,
during the entire period
of validity specified in
the tariff plan;
(b) In respect of other
tariff plans, within six
months from the date
of enrolment of the
subscriber.
Telecommunication
Tariff Order (43rd
amendment) notified
on 21.03.06 refers.
(j) In the charging of CLIP
charges
Verify from bills and
also from details of
new plans launched
during the year to
ensure that CLIP is not
charged as a
compulsory item in the
tariff plan.
(k) In moving from one
tariff plan to another
tariff plan without
Verify from bills of
subscribers who have
changed their tariff
paying any fee as the
customer is free to
move from one tariff
plan to another without
paying any fee for
migration.
plans to ensure that no
migration charges
have been levied.
Verify on sample basis
whether any charges
were deducted from
the accounts of
prepaid customers for
migration to another
tariff plan.
2 The audit Agency will take
the raw CDRs & process
the same to generate the
Bill and then verify with
already generated bill for
any discrepancy. The
CDRs of one month in
every Quarter are to be
processed.
Obtain CDR’s for
selected audit sample
Apply procedures on
selected sample
Compare the results to
ensure that the service
provider systems are
functionally correct.
3 The audit Agency will
analyse the discrepancy if
detected, and find out the
root cause of the same.
Discrepancy Analysis: The
discrepancy analysis is
done by execution of the
inference engine that
performs analysis of the
rated CDRs in order to
establish causes of the
discrepancy based on
CDR, subscriber and
pricing plan data.
Discrepancy analysis
of the rated CDR’s to
be done.
If required perform
further functional
testing on system to
identify the cause
4 Bill level discrepancy
analysis: After several
cycles of event level
discrepancy analysis and
database adjustment,
when all the event level
discrepancies are taken
care of, the next step is of
bill level discrepancy. The
bill level discrepancy
reports will be produced &
analysed by the audit
Agency.
To analyze the bill level
discrepancy reports as
generated by the Service
Provider.
5 Verification of corrective
actions: In this important
stage, a verification of
successful implementation
Analyse and test check
the corrective actions.
of the corrective action is
performed
6 Verification of complaints
referred by TRAI
Verify from the
complaint records the
factual position of the
complaint.
Investigate the
complaint, including
checking with the
complainant
7 Billing system integration
for rental rebates (for basic
service). (Reference – The
Standards of Quality of
Service of Basic
Telephone Service
(Wireline) and Cellular
Mobile Telephone Service
Regulations, 2009)
Verify that the billing
system is integrated so as
to ensure that proper
rental rebates are passed
on to the customer in
cases where the faults
are not rectified within
three days (for basic
service).
Faults pending for >3
days and ≤7 days: Rent
rebate for 7 days.
Faults pending for >7
days and ≤15 days:
Rent rebate for 15 days
Faults pending for >15
days: rent rebate for 1
month
Format No. TRAI/M&B Audit/3
(Format for reporting progress report on audit of the
metering and billing system)
Progress report on audit of the metering and billing system of -----
---------------- (service provider) for ------- (service) in ----- service
area for the Quarter ending -----------
(Indicate service provider, service, service area and Quarter)
1. Details of tariff plans selected for audit along with sample size for prepaid tariff
plans, Special Tariff Vouchers, prepaid data plans, postpaid tariff plans and
postpaid data plans as per sub-regulation (1) of regulation 6A.
2. Date of request to the service provider for CDRs, separately for each category
of tariff plan selected.
3. Date of provision of CDRs for the selected samples by the service provider,
separately for each category of tariff plan selected.
4. Status of analysis of CDRs undertaken during the Quarter, separately for each
category of tariff plan selected.
5. Details of cases of overcharging observed during CDR analysis, which has
been accepted by the service provider.
6. Details of cases of overcharging observed during CDR analysis, which has
been not been accepted by the service provider, along with the observations of the
auditor.
7. Details of cases of overcharging observed during CDR analysis, on which
comments of the service provider is pending.
8. Details of other activities undertaken during the Quarter with reference to the
Checklist for audit, separately for items in Table A and Table B:
Item No. Description of item Details of action taken (with date of start of
activity and date of completion of activity)
9. Status of verification of complaints referred by TRAI.
10. Status of verification of action taken on the audit observations in the preceding
year.
11. Status of preparation of audit report, as may be applicable:
12. Constraints, if any, in undertaking the audit.
13. Items on which guidance of TRAI is required.
Place: (Name of the representative of the auditor)
Date: Designation
For ------------ (Name of auditor)
Format No. TRAI/M&B Audit/4
(Format for the monthly progress report on action taken by the service
provider on instances of overcharging reported during audit of the
metering and billing system)
Progress report on action taken by the service provider on
instances of overcharging reported during audit of the metering
and billing system of --------------------- (service provider) for -------
(service) in ----- service area for the month of -----------
(Indicate service provider, service, service area and month)
S
No
Description
of
overcharging
Date
of
report
to SP
Date of
receipt of
comments
from SP
accepting
overcharge
Status of Refund Remarks
No of
customers
affected
Total
amount
involved
No of
customers
refunded
Amount
of
refund
Amount
deposit
ed in
TECEPF
SP = Service Provider
TCEPF = Telecom Consumers Education and Protection Fund
Place: (Name of the representative of the auditor)
Date: Designation
For ------------ (Name of auditor)
F.No. 302-22/2012-QoS
Telecom Regulatory Authority of India,
Mahanagar Door Sanchar Bhavan, J.L.N. Marg, New Delhi-110002
….
Dated: 16th May 2013
ORDER
Sub: Implementation of the Quality of Service (Code of Practice for Metering and Billing
Accuracy) (Amendment) Regulations, 2013 (4 of 2013) dated the 25th March, 2013
F.No.302-22/2012-QOS---- Whereas the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (hereinafter
referred as the Authority), established under sub-section (1) of section 3 of the Telecom
Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997 (24 of 1997) (hereinafter referred to as TRAI Act), has
been entrusted with discharge of certain functions, inter alia, to regulate the telecommunication
services, ensure technical compatibility and effective inter-connection between different service
providers, lay-down the standards of quality of service to be provided by the service providers
and ensure the quality of service and conduct the periodical survey of such service provided by
the service providers so as to protect the interest of the consumers of telecommunications
service;
2. And whereas the Authority has, in exercise of its power conferred by section 36, read
with sub-clauses (i) and (v) of clause (b) and clause (d) of sub-section (1) of section 11, of
TRAI Act, made the Quality of Service (Code of Practice for Metering and Billing Accuracy)
Regulation, 2006 (5 of 2006) dated the 21st March, 2006 (hereinafter referred to as the metering
and billing regulation), providing for annual audit of the metering and billing system of the
service providers, including compliance with the Code of Practice for metering and billing
accuracy laid down in Annexure-1, through one of the auditors from the panel of auditors to be
notified by the Authority and submission of audit report and action taken report by the
prescribed date;
3. And whereas the Authority has, in exercise of its power conferred by section 36, read
with sub-clauses (i) and (v) of clause (b) of sub-section (1) of section 11, of TRAI Act, made
the Quality of Service (Code of Practice for Metering and Billing Accuracy) (Amendment)
Regulations, 2013 (4 of 2013) dated the 25th March, 2013, amending the Quality of Service
(Code of Practice for Metering and Billing Accuracy) Regulation 2006 (5 of 2006) dated the 21st
March, 2006;
4. And whereas sub-regulation (5) of regulation 6A of the metering and billing regulation
provides that every service provider shall submit to the Authority by the 31st July of every year
in which audit of their metering and billing system is completed, an audit report certified by the
auditor separately, for Basic Telephone Service (wireline) and Cellular Mobile Telephone
Service, for each service area, in such format as the Authority may specify, from time to time,
by an order;
5. And whereas sub-regulation (6) of regulation 6A of the metering and billing regulation
provides that every service provider shall submit to the Authority by the 15th November of every
year, an action taken report on each audit observation containing therein the details of the action
taken on such observations, in such format, as may be specified by the Authority, from time to
time, by an order and such details shall include----
(a) reasons for occurrence of the problem;
(b) date of occurrence of the problem;
(c) date of rectification of the problem;
(d) action taken to address the problem;
(e) number of customers affected in respect of cases where overcharging was observed by the
auditor and total amount involved;
(f) number of customers under item (e) to whom refunds were made within the time limit
specified under sub-regulation (3) and total amount so refunded;
(g) number of customers to whom refunds were made beyond the time limit specified under sub-
regulation (3) and the total amount so refunded; and
(h) number of customers to whom refunds could not be made and total amount which could not
be refunded;
6. NOW, THEREFORE, in exercise of power conferred by sub-regulation (5) and sub-
regulation (6) of regulation 6A of the Quality of Service (Code of Practice for Metering and
Billing Accuracy) Regulation, 2006 (5 of 2006), the Authority hereby specifies the following
formats, annexed to this Order:-
(a) the format number TRAI/M&B Audit /1 for submitting, by the 31st July of every
year, the audit report referred to in sub-regulation (5); and;
(b) the format number TRAI/M&B Audit /2 for submitting, by the 15th November of
every year, the action taken report referred to in sub-regulation (6),----
of regulation 6A of the Quality of Service (Code of Practice for Metering and Billing
Accuracy) Regulation, 2006 (5 of 2006).
(A. Robert J. Ravi)
Advisor (CA&QOS)
To
1. All Access Service Providers.
2. Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd.
3. Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Ltd.
Copy to:
1. All empanelled auditors of metering and billing system.
2. COAI
3. AUSPI.
Format No. TRAI/M&B Audit/1
Format for Audit Report
Audit Report for -------- Service in ______Service Area for the year--
(Indicate service, service area and year of audit)
1. Preliminary Sheet:
Sr.
No.
Particulars
1. Name of Service Provider
2. Name of Licensed service Area
3. Licence No.
4. Service covered under audit (Basic services,
Cellular Mobile services (GSM & CDMA)
separately)
5. Is billing centralized for all circles? If not,
specify decentralized locations
6. Software Application(s) used for metering &
billing functions (also specify the version)
7. Switches( also specify the version)
8. Date of Commencement of Audit
9. Date of Completion of audit
10. Date on which Report was closed with
responses from the auditee
2. The detailed methodology for carrying out the audit. The methodology should
cover all points stated in the Guidelines for audit and the Quality of Service (Code of
Practice for Metering and Billing Accuracy) Regulation 2006 dated 21.03.2006 as
amended by the Quality of Service (Code of Practice for Metering and Billing Accuracy)
(Amendment) Regulations, 2013 dated 25.03.2013.
3. Report on Tariff Plans audited in each Quarter:
(a) Prepaid plans available at the beginning of each Quarter:
Quarter-1 Quarter-2 Quarter-3 Quarter-4
Plan No. of
customers
Plan No. of
customers
Plan No. of
customers
Plan No. of
customers
(b) Prepaid plans selected for audit in each Quarter from out of the prepaid plans
available at the beginning of each Quarter:
Quarter-1 Quarter-2 Quarter-3 Quarter-4
S.
No.
Plan
selected
Sample
size
Plan
selected
Sample
size
Plan
selected
Sample
size
Plan
selected
Sample
size
1
2
3
(c) Prepaid plans launched during each Quarter selected for audit:
Quarter-1 Quarter-2 Quarter-3 Quarter-4
S.
No.
Plan
selected
Plan selected Plan selected Plan selected
1
2
(d) Special Tariff Vouchers (STVs) available at the beginning of each Quarter:
Quarter-1 Quarter-2 Quarter-3 Quarter-4
STV No. of
customers
STV No. of
customers
STV No. of
customers
STV No. of
customers
(e) STVs selected for audit in each Quarter from out of the STVs available at the
beginning of each Quarter:
Quarter-1 Quarter-2 Quarter-3 Quarter-4
S.
No.
STV
selected
Sample
size
STV
selected
Sample
size
STV
selected
Sample
size
STV
selected
Sample
size
1
2
(f) Prepaid data plans available at the beginning of each Quarter:
Quarter-1 Quarter-2 Quarter-3 Quarter-4
Data
Plan
No. of
customers
Data
Plan
No. of
customers
Data
Plan
No. of
customers
Data
Plan
No. of
customers
(g) Prepaid data plans selected for audit in each Quarter from out of the data plans
available at the beginning of each Quarter:
Quarter-1 Quarter-2 Quarter-3 Quarter-4
S.
No.
Data
Plan
selected
Sample
size
Data
Plan
selected
Sample
size
Data
Plan
selected
Sample
size
Data
Plan
selected
Sample
size
1
2
(h) Post paid plans available at the beginning of each Quarter:
Quarter-1 Quarter-2 Quarter-3 Quarter-4
Plan No. of
customers
Plan No. of
customers
Plan No. of
customers
Plan No. of
customers
(i) Post paid plans selected for audit in each Quarter from out of the post paid plans
available at the beginning of each Quarter:
Quarter-1 Quarter-2 Quarter-3 Quarter-4
S.
No.
Plan
selected
Sample
size
Plan
selected
Sample
size
Plan
selected
Sample
size
Plan
selected
Sample
size
1
2
(j) Post paid plans launched during each Quarter selected for audit:
Quarter-1 Quarter-2 Quarter-3 Quarter-4
S.
No.
Plan
selected
Plan selected Plan selected Plan selected
1
2
(k) Post paid data plans available at the beginning of each Quarter:
Quarter-1 Quarter-2 Quarter-3 Quarter-4
Data
Plan
No. of
customers
Data
Plan
No. of
customers
Data
Plan
No. of
customers
Data
Plan
No. of
customers
(l) Post paid data plans selected for audit in each Quarter from out of the data plans
available at the beginning of each Quarter:
Quarter-1 Quarter-2 Quarter-3 Quarter-4
S.
No.
Data
Plan
selected
Sample
size
Data
Plan
selected
Sample
size
Data
Plan
selected
Sample
size
Data
Plan
selected
Sample
size
1
2
(m) Other observations on tariff plan selection, selection of samples, provision of
CDRs by service provider etc. :
4. Comment on clarity/transparency in respect of bill presentation to the customers.
5. Report whether the service provider meet the defined levels of accuracy vis-à-vis
the Quality of Service (Code of Practice for Metering and Billing Accuracy)
Regulation 2006.
6. Certificate that the Auditor has received all information and explanation from the
service provider, necessary for the purpose of audit. In case of any deficiency on
the part of the service provider, comment on that.
7. Comment about the authenticity of the information received from the service
provider for carrying out the audit.
8. Audit observations on each item in Table A and Table B of the Checklist of Audit:
Item
No.
Quarter Description
of item
Audit
observation
Category Auditee
comments
Remarks
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Note-1: Item No. means Item No. of the Checklist for Audit.
Note-2: Quarter denotes the Quarter in which the test cases or verifications were
undertaken.
Note-3: The observation shall contain details of test cases undertaken (detailed
test report can be enclosed as Annexure) and reasons/cause for occurrence of
deficiency.
Note-4: The auditee comments shall contain service provider’s views on audit
observations; date of occurrence and date of rectification of the problem; time
frame agreed with the auditor for taking action; action taken, if any; details, if
any, relating to number of customers affected, amount involved, number of
customers to whom refunds were made and amount involved, number of
customers to whom refunds could not be made and amount involved.
Note-5: Remarks column may contain auditor’s observations on the comments
of the auditee.
9. A certificate of compliance with reference to Guidelines for audit and the Quality
of Service (Code of Practice for Metering and Billing Accuracy) Regulation 2006
dated 21.03.2006 as amended by the Quality of Service (Code of Practice for
Metering and Billing Accuracy) (Amendment) Regulations, 2013 dated
25.03.2013.
10. Verification report on action taken by the service provider on each item of the
previous year’s action taken report:
Item
No.
Description
of item
Audit
observation
Category Action taken
as per action
taken report
Observations on
verification of action
taken
Format No. TRAI/M&B Audit/2
Format for Action Taken Report
Action Taken Report for -------- Service in --------Service Area for the
year -----------
(Indicate service, service area and year of audit)
1. Preliminary Sheet:
Sr.
No.
Particulars
11. Name of Service Provider
12. Name of Licensed service Area
13. Licence No.
14. Service covered under action taken report
(Basic services, Cellular Mobile services
(GSM & CDMA) separately)
15. Year of audit
16. Details of auditor who had done the auditing
17. Details of billing centres
18. Software Application(s) used for metering &
billing functions (also specify the version)
19. Switches( also specify the version)
20. Date of certification of the audit report by the
auditor
21. Date of completion of action taken on audit
observations
1. Observations on the comments of the auditor on Clarity/transparency in respect of
bill presentation to the customers (item 4 of the audit report).
2. Observations on the report of the auditor as to whether the service provider meets
the defined levels of accuracy vis-à-vis the Quality of Service (Code of Practice for
Metering and Billing Accuracy) Regulation 2006 (item 5 of the audit report).
3. Observations on the comments of the auditor, if any, on deficiency on the part of
the service provider in providing information and explanation (item 6 of the audit report).
4. Observations on the comments of the auditor on the authenticity of the information
received from the service provider for carrying out the audit (item 7 of the audit report).
5. Action taken on audit observations on each item in Table A and Table B of the
Checklist of Audit (as per item 8 of the audit report):
Table (indicate A or B)
1. Item No.
2. Quarter
3. Description of item
4. Audit observation
5. Category
6. Reasons for occurrence of the
problem, and
7. Date of occurrence of the problem
8. Date of rectification of the problem
9. Action taken to address the
problem
10. Number of customers affected by
overcharging and the total amount
involved
No. of customers Total amount
involved
11. Number of customers to whom
refunds were made within two
months of reporting of
overcharging by the auditor and
total amount so refunded
No. of customers Total amount
involved
12. Number of customers to whom
refunds were made beyond two
months of reporting of
overcharging by the auditor and
total amount so refunded
No. of customers Total amount
involved
13. Number of customers to whom
refunds could not be made and
total amount which could not be
refunded
No. of customers Total amount
involved
6. Observations on the certificate of compliance given by the auditor (item 9 of the
audit report)
Place: (Name of the representative of the service provider)
Date: Designation
Short title, extent and commencement
5. Applying Credit to Accounts
Previous and next
Questions people ask
Is regulation 13 of Quality of Service (Code of Practice for Metering and Billing Accuracy) Regulation 2006 still in force?
No repeal of Quality of Service (Code of Practice for Metering and Billing Accuracy) Regulation 2006 is recorded.