Annexure E - A, The Telecommunication Interconnection (Port Charges) Regulation 2001: ANNEXE - A
The Telecommunication Interconnection (Port Charges) Regulation 2001 - Annexure E - A
Text of annexure E - A
ANNEXE - A
ANNEXE - A
EXPLANATORY MEMORANDUM
1. With the induction of new Basic and National Long Distance Operators in the Indian Telecommunication
Network, a Multi-Operator environment has emerged and therefore, the Authority decided to undertake a
review exercise relating to charging of ‘ports’. The charges for ‘ports’ specified in this Regulation are a result
of such a review. In the course of this review, the Authority has taken into account the inputs received from
operators including the incumbent, who is the main supplier of ‘ports’ at present.
2. The new entrants have been representing to the Authority that there was a reluctance on the part of the
incumbent to supply ‘ports’ at the prices specified by the Authority in the past. It was also represented by the
incumbent that the prevailing charges had an anomaly in that they encouraged the Interconnection Seeker
to place more than the justified demand for ‘ports’, because the annual ‘port’ charges for 8 ‘ports’ were of the
same order as that for 33 ‘ports’. It, thus, transpired that the ‘port’ charges needed to be re-evaluated and
the existing anomaly corrected, so that there is no economic disincentive for supplying the ‘ports’.
3. When a set of ‘ports’ or Digital Trunk Interfaces (DTIs) are added in an existing Switching System, the
Directly Attributable Incremental Costs (DAIC) are not only of the ‘port’ terminals, but also of other elements
such as associated CCS7 Signalling Equipment, Processor, Switching Matrix etc. In this review, all such
significant associated costs have been computed as overhead in the various ‘port’ slabs. These common
costs have been found to be a step function which varies over a range of ‘port’ sizes. In this review, cost
data for various types of Switching Systems and components thereof, which are directly attributable to the
termination of a E1 link on a Switching node, were collected and a weighted average was computed. Other
costs e.g. costs in respect of Network Management, Operations and Maintenance Centre (OMC), Fault
Management System, etc., have been excluded, as these are not directly attributable to the Interconnection.
4. In this review, the number of slabs for ‘port’ charges have been increased to five, based on the costs of
common control and Switching matrix which are observed to vary in five steps corresponding to five slabs
of ‘port’ charges.
5. Based on the cost data supplied by the Operators for the Switching Systems in the Network, costs have
been worked out for the various configurations. To these costs, overheads @ 10% representing freight,
storage and installation costs, have been added. For arriving at the Annual Recurring Expenditure (ARE), a
rate of 22% has been applied to the capital cost so worked out. The ‘port’ charges, which are in the nature of
annual rentals, have been equated to the ARE so computed.
6. The Authority has considered the point made by network operators that due to provision of an
Interconnection ‘port’ and consequent traffic flow, capacity enhancement would be required at other nodes
as also in the interconnecting links for smooth flow of traffic across the network. However, the Authority is of
the view that the cost of downstream augmentation of the network resources should be recovered from the
usage charges of network elements involved in call carriage. The underlying principle is that all costs are to
be recovered and that no cost elements should be double counted.
7. To remove the anomaly in the earlier exercise on ‘port’ charges, the following algorithm has been
employed to determine the charges in the five ranges indicated in Schedule I.
(i) For up to 16 ‘ports’, a per ‘port’ charge of Rs. X1 is specified.
(ii) For ‘ports’ between 17 and 32 PCMs, the charge will be 16X1 + (N-16) X2, where X2 corresponds to the
average cost for the capacity slab going upto 32 PCMs and X1 is for the capacity slab 1 to 16 PCMs.
(iii) For ‘ports’ between 33 and 64 PCMs, the charge will be 16X1 + 16X2 + (N-32) X3, where X3
corresponds to the average cost for the capacity slab 33 to 64 PCMs.
(iv) For ‘ports’ between 65 and 128 PCMs, the charge will be 16X1 + 16X2 + 32 X3 + (N-64) X4, where X4,
corresponds to the average cost for the capacity slab 65 PCMs to 128 PCMs.
(v) For ‘ports’ above 128 PCMs, the charge will be 16X1 + 16X2 + 32 X3 + 64 X4 + (N-128) X5, where X5
corresponds to the average cost for the capacity above 128 PCMs.
By Order
[DR. HARSHA VARDHANA SINGH]
Secretary-cum-Principal Adviso
TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE GAZETTE OF INDIA, EXTRAORDINARY, PART
III, SECTION 4
TELECOM REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF INDIA
NOTIFICATION
New Delhi, the 02 February, 2007
THE TELECOMMUNICATION INTERCONNECTION (PORT CHARGES)
AMENDMENT REGULATIONS, 2007
No. 1 of 2007
File No. 409-10/2006-FN.---------- In exercise of the powers conferred
upon it under section 36, read with sub-clauses (ii), (iii) and (iv) of clause
(b) of sub-section (1) of section 11 of the Telecom Regulatory Authority of
India Act, 1997 (24 of 1997), the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India
hereby makes the following regulations to amend the Telecommunication
Interconnection (Port Charges) Regulation, 2001 (6 of 2001), namely :-
1. (1) These regulations shall be called as the Telecommunication
Interconnection (Port Charges) Amendment Regulations, 2007.
(2) These regulations shall come into force on the 1st day of April, 2007.
2. In the Telecommunication Interconnection (Port Charges) Regulation
2001 (6 of 2001) after regulation 2, the following regulation shall be inserted,
namely:-
“2A. Port charges on or after the 1st April, 2007. - (1) Every
interconnection seeker shall, on or after the 1st day of April, 2007, make his
demand, for every Point of Interconnection for the total number of Ports
required by him on or after the said date to the interconnection provider.
(2) Every interconnection seeker shall make demand under sub-
regulation (1) on the basis of traffic projection (in Erlangs) on half yearly
basis.
(3) Every interconnection provider shall charge, on or after the 1st day of
April, 2007, the Port charges in accordance with the Port charges specified in
Schedule II to these regulations and raise the demand note or the invoice, as
the case may be, for the Ports demanded on or after the said date by the
interconnection seeker under sub-regulations (1) and (2).
2
(4) In case where interconnection provider does not allot and provide all the
Ports on the date, or, within such period, as requested by the
interconnection seeker and in accordance with the demand made by him
under sub-regulations (1) and (2), the Port charges for the Ports allotted and
provided shall be calculated on the basis of the total number of Ports so
demanded (taking into account the Ports allotted and provided and also the
remaining ports not allotted and provided by the interconnection provider as
per his demand) and charges for the Ports so allotted and provided shall be
calculated on the basis of the total Ports so demanded based on traffic
projections (in Erlangs) and the charges for the Ports shall be calculated in
accordance with the charges specified against the slabs in Schedule II to
these regulations.
(5) In case where interconnection seeker does not take all the Ports in
accordance with the demand made by him under sub-regulations (1) and (2),
the Port charges for the Ports allotted and provided shall be calculated on
the basis of the total number of Ports so actually taken by him, and, the
Ports not taken by him as per his demand shall be ignored for determining
the slab for calculating the Port Charges and the charges for the Ports shall
be calculated on the basis of actual Ports taken by him and not on the basis
of Ports demanded by him under sub- regulations (1) and (2), in accordance
with the charges specified against the Port slabs in Schedule II to these
regulations.
(6) The Port charges for every Port demanded, allotted and provided before
the 1st day of April 2007 shall be charged before the said date in accordance
with the Port charges specified in Schedule I to these regulations and the
interconnection provider shall accordingly raise the demand note or the
invoice, as the case may be, for such Ports demanded, allotted and provided.
(7) The Port charges for every Port demanded, allotted and provided before
the 1st day of April, 2007 shall be charged on or after the said date in
accordance with the Port charges specified in Schedule II to these
regulations and the interconnection provider shall raise the demand note or
the invoice, as the case may be, for such Ports provided by him before the
aforesaid date accordingly.
(8) The slab for calculation of Port charges under sub-regulation (7) shall
continue to be with reference to the slabs specified in the Schedule I to these
regulations, which were taken into account for determining the Port charges
before the 1st day of April, 2007.
(9) Nothing contained in the Schedule II to these regulations shall apply in
case the interconnection provider and the interconnection seeker mutually
agree to charge and pay charges lower than those specified in the Schedule II
to these regulations.”
3. After the Schedule I to the Telecommunication Interconnection (Port
Charges) Regulation 2001, the following Schedule II shall be inserted,
namely:-
3
“SCHEDULE II
{See regulation 2A. }
PORT CHARGES
ITEM PORT CHARGES
(1) Date of
implementation
1st April, 2007
(2) Coverage
Charges for ‘Ports’ (other than the Port Charges for
Internet, which are specified in Schedule VI of the
Telecommunication Tariff Order 1999)
No. of ‘Ports’ ‘Port’ Charges ( in Rs.)
per annum
1 to 16 PCMs N*39,000
17 to 32 PCMs 6,24,000 + (N-16)*22,500
33 to 64 PCMs 9,84,000 + (N-32)*14,500
65 to 128 PCMs 14,48,000 + (N-64)*11,500
(3) ‘Port’ Charges
covering all
switches
129 to 256 PCMs 21,84,000 + (N-128)*10,500
Note.----N refers to the number of ‘Ports’ within the capacity ranges under
the column ‘No. of Ports’.”
(Rakesh Kacker)
Acting Secretary
Note1. The principal regulations were published vide F.No. 311-6/2001-
TRAI (Econ.) dated 28th December 2001 (6 of 2001).
Note 2. The Explanatory Memorandum explains the objects and reasons
of these regulations.
4
EXPLANATORY MEMORANDUM
Background:
1. With the induction of the competition in telecom sector in the
country, the interconnection among the operators has become an
essential requirement for the development of the sector. In the
multi-operator multi service scenario, establishment of
interconnection helps the consumers of one network to
communicate to the consumers of other network. Port is an
essential part for the establishment of the interconnection between
two networks.
2. On the 28th May 1999, the Authority had notified the
Telecommunication Interconnection (Charges and Revenue Sharing)
Regulation 1999, which specified arrangement among service
providers for interconnection charges and revenue sharing for all
telecommunication services including Port charges. Schedule III of
the Telecommunication Interconnection (Charges and Revenue
Sharing) Regulation 1999 specifies average annual charges per Port.
These Port charges were derived on the basis of cost based charges
for a unit of 8 PCMs (E1s), starting from 8 E1s and going up to 256
E1s.
3. The entrants in the telecom sector, before commencement of the
Telecommunication Interconnection (Port Charges) Regulation
2001, had been representing to the Authority that there was
reluctance on the part of the some operators to supply Ports at the
prices specified by the Authority in the past. It was also
represented by the BSNL that charges specified in the
Telecommunication Interconnection (Charges and Revenue Sharing)
Regulation 1999 had an anomaly in that these charges encouraged
the interconnection seeker to place more than the actual demand
for Ports. It thus transpired that the Port charges needed to be re-
5
evaluated and the existing anomaly to be corrected so that there
should not be any economic disincentive for provision of more
Ports. Therefore, Authority decided to undertake a review exercise
relating to Port Charges.
4. The Authority, after discussion with the industry notified a revised
Regulation on Port charges the Telecommunication Interconnection
(Port Charges) Regulation 2001 on 28th December 2001 (hereafter
referred to as the said regulation). The said regulation inter-alia
specifies the Port charges payable by interconnection seeker to the
interconnection provider. In the said regulation, the number of
slabs for Port charges were increased to five from three.
5. For specifying the Port Charges in the said regulation, the Authority
had considered only incremental or additional cost directly
attributable to the provision of Ports by the interconnection
provider. The Directly Attributable Incremental Cost (DAIC) are not
only taken for Port terminals but also for all other relevant elements
such as CCS7 signalling equipment, processors, and switching
matrix etc. All such associated costs have been computed as
overhead in the various Port slabs. These common costs have been
found to be a function, which varies over a range of Port sizes.
Based on the cost data supplied by the operators for the Switching
Systems in the Network, costs have been worked out for the various
configurations. To these costs, overheads @ 10% representing
freight, storage and installation costs had been added. For arriving
at the Annual Recurring Expenditure (ARE), a rate of 22% had been
applied to the capital cost so worked out. The `Port` charges, which
were in the nature of annual rentals, had been equated to the ARE
so computed.
6. In considering the point made by network operators that due to
provision of an Interconnection `Port` and consequent traffic flow,
6
capacity enhancement would be required at other nodes as also in
the interconnecting links for smooth flow of traffic across the
network. A decision therefore, was taken that the cost of
downstream augmentation of the network resources should be
recovered from the usage charges of network elements involved in
call carriage. The underlying principle is that all costs are to be
recovered but that no cost elements should be counted twice.
7. The “Telecommunication Interconnection (Port Charges) Regulation
2001 (6 of 2001)”, provides that the Authority may also at any time,
on reference from any affected party, and for good and sufficient
reasons, review and modify the Port charges. Besides, there has
been long pending basic demand of interconnection seekers that
Port charges need to be reviewed so as to align it with the current
switch/exchange cost.
8. The Authority has, therefore for the purpose of revisiting the Port
Charges and review thereof, initially asked the service providers to
furnish the cost details of the various elements used for expansion
of Digital Trunk Automatic Exchange (DTAX) / Tandem to provide
Ports for interconnectivity. Most of the service providers including
the Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited (BSNL), being the incumbent
operator with legacy network spread out in 2647 Short Distance
Charging Areas (SDCAs), Level-II Trunk Automatic Exchanges
(TAXs) at 322 locations and Level-I Trunk Automatic Exchanges
(TAXs) at 21 locations and is also the main provider of the Ports,
furnished the cost details of the various network elements. A
consultation was done by TRAI with BSNL, MTNL, COAI and AUSPI
for review of the Port charges specified in these regulations and
matter was also discussed in series of meetings with them for the
said purpose.
7
9. For the purpose of Port Charges review as made by this notification,
the service providers were asked to submit cost of the network
elements and detailed traffic trend analysis to the Authority. On the
basis of the substantial data provided by the interconnection
seekers and interconnection providers, the Authority undertook the
calculations for determining Port Charges and found some gaps and
even inconsistencies in data in certain cases provided by
interconnection seeker and interconnection provider. The Authority
has made a reasonable check with due diligence while taking the
network elements and costs thereof for expansion of exchange /
switch. For calculating Port Charges, the Authority has adopted the
similar approach as used in the said regulation in year 2001, with
alignment of the costing methodology adopted by the Authority in
recent regulations and tariff orders.
10. List of network elements used for the calculation of the Port charges
is given in Table-1 in this Explanatory Memorandum. The network
elements listed in Table-1 are normally required to expand the OCB
exchanges, which are mostly used for providing the interconnection
to other service provider by the incumbent operators. Separate cost
is calculated for expansion of the exchanges by 16 E1s, 32 E1s, 64
E1s, 128 E1s and 256 E1s and accordingly different slabs are
specified in these regulations.
11. In the present review for calculation of the Port charges, the
reasonable returns (Pre-tax Weighted Average Cost of Capital )
@ 14% per annum on the capital employed (net block only) has
been considered after providing depreciation @10% per annum
based on Straight Line Method of depreciation. Additionally,
overhead @ 10% on CAPEX recovery has been added. The Authority
has not adopted Annual Recurring Expenditure (ARE) method for
present review of Port Charges.
8
12. The Authority released the draft of the proposed amending
regulations on Port charges along with detailed Explanatory
Memorandum after due diligence on inputs from stakeholders and
particularly major interconnect provider such as BSNL. The draft of
the proposed amending regulations was released on the 12th
January 2007, for seeking the comments of stakeholders. The last
date for receiving the comments of the stakeholders was the
22nd January 2007.
Examination of the main comments / issues raised by the
stakeholders:
13. Some of the stakeholders requested for extension of time for
submission of comments. The Authority considered the requests of
extension and found that issue involved is relating to review of Port
charges only, for which meetings were also held earlier by TRAI with
the stakeholders namely BSNL, MTNL and other service providers
represented through COAI and AUSPI. In addition, the calculations
for Port Charges in the present review are based on the costs details
furnished by both interconnect providers and interconnect seekers.
The draft amendment regulations on Port charges were released
with detailed Explanatory Memorandum for seeking the comments
of the stakeholders with clear indication of the 22nd January 2007
as the last date of submission of comments. Therefore, the
Authority decided not to extend the time limit for submission of
comments and also intimated accordingly. However the comments
received from the BPL Mobile Communications Limited, the Bharti
Airtel Ltd, the TATA Teleservices Ltd, the MTNL, the BSNL and a
joint response from the COAI and the AUSPI have been fully
considered and addressed.
14. The Authority has taken the various comments and inputs into
consideration and analysed the matter in detail. For sake of clarity
the comments/issues raised by stakeholders are shown below in
9
italic fonts and the analysis/consideration of the Authority is made
thereafter.
Issue 1: Date of Applicability of Regulations:
Revised Port charges Regulations should be made effective from the date of
its notification.
15. The demand of the interconnection seekers / stakeholders
regarding the date of application of the new Port Charges has been
examined and the Port charges as specified in the Schedule II to the
Telecommunication (Port Charges) Amendment Regulation, 2007 have
been made applicable with reference to the financial year beginning on
and after the 1st April 2007 for following reasons namely:
(a) It is easier for reconciliation and implementation that payments,
which are on an annual basis, should coincide with the financial
year.
(b) Moreover interconnection seeker is required to properly assess their
traffic before placing the demand on the basis of traffic projection
on six monthly basis. Thus there is a need to give sufficient time to
interconnection seeker for assessing their demand.
(c) Since Port charges are specified on per annum basis and the
revised port charges are applicable to existing working ports.
Therefore, the Authority is of the view that the date of applicability
should be the 1st April 2007 instead from the date of its notification.
Issue 2: The new Regulations should replace or amend the
existing 2001 Regulation:
It will be more appropriate that the proposed Regulation should replace the
existing 2001 Regulation instead of amending the existing 2001 Regulation.
This will have implication for extending connectivity and for the operators
who have already got POI.
16. There was a long pending basic demand of the interconnection
seekers that costs of the network elements have been reduced over the
10
period and also costing methodology for calculation of the Port charges
needs to be aligned with the costing methodology used by the Authority in
various other regulations / orders. The Authority has taken note of these
demands and found that the basic demand can be met by amending the
Telecommunication Interconnection (Port Charges) Regulation, 2001 (6 of
2001).
Issue 3: Port Charges Calculations:
(a) The Authority has permitted reduction in domestic leased line and
long distance tariff to a great extent in 2005. The cost of equipment
has gone down further thereafter. Therefore, there is an ample
justification for 80% reduction in the Port charges.
(b) BSNL will be able to get the benefit of economy of scale for the
purchase of the equipment and these benefits should be reflected in
the reduced Port charges.
(c) Only the portion of the cost element be considered, which is
associated with additional Port provisioning by BSNL / MTNL. How
much proportion of central equipment costs has been apportioned for
various slabs of E1s should be tabulated along with the capacity.
(d) There have been reductions in the domestic leased line tariffs by the
Authority and in IUC for carriage charges.
(e) First price slab should not exceed Rs.31200/- and corresponding
adjustment is required for other slabs.
(f) In the interest of the transparency, it is proposed that detailed
calculations made by TRAI in arriving at Port charges in Schedule II
may be put on its website to enable operators to examine and
respond back.
17. The Authority has made all the calculations on the basis of the
substantial data provided by the interconnection seekers and
interconnection providers. The Authority has also found some gaps and
even inconsistencies in data in certain cases provided by interconnection
seeker / provider. The Authority has made reasonable checks with due
11
diligence while taking the network elements and costs furnished by some
of the stakeholders thereof for expansion of exchange / switch. The
Table-1 in this Explanatory Memorandum provides details of network
elements considered for determining the Port charges. It was also noted
that while furnishing the costs details of network elements, some of the
stakeholders marked it ‘Confidential’. Therefore the cost has not been
indicated against the network elements listed in Table-1.
18. In the present review, the Authority has taken cost of the network
elements provided by the service providers (interconnection seekers and
interconnection providers) and also aligned the costing methodology with
current practices adopted by the Authority in various regulations / tariff
orders and specifies the Port charges by amending the Telecommunication
Interconnection (Port Charges) Regulation, 2001 (6 of 2001).
19. In the present review, the Authority considered only incremental or
additional cost directly attributable to the provision of Ports by the
interconnection provider. The Directly Attributable Incremental Cost
(DAIC) are not only taken for Port terminals but also for all other relevant
elements such as CCS7 signalling equipment, processors, switching
matrix etc. All such associated costs have been computed as overhead in
the various Port slabs. These common costs have been found to be a
function, which varies over a range of Port sizes.
20. The five slabs for Port charges have been specified, based on the
cost of common control and switching matrix which are observed to vary
in five steps.
Issue 4: Pricing Methodology, Depreciation, Rate of Return on
Incremental CAPEX:
(a) The returns allowed are much higher than 14% in the proposed draft
Regulations. In 10 years the service provider would get returns @
16%.
12
(b) Equating annual Port rental to 22% ARE may not be justified
specially in new nodes / tandems where switches may be required
before completing 10 years life (as 10% depreciation with Straight
Line Method has been assumed by the Regulator for calculation of
ARE). In fact, for new nodes, the depreciation should be 20% in view
of plans to migrate to IP switches and chances of non-support of
conventional switches by vendors in near future.
(c) The Authority has taken the incremental CAPEX as taken in previous
Regulations. This may not always be the case as some times, new
tandems will be required for providing E1s from nodes / tandems
that are fully grown (45K).
21. For calculation of the Port charges, the reasonable returns (Pre Tax
Weighted Average Cost of Capital) @ 14% per annum on the capital
employed (net block only) has been considered after providing
depreciation @10% per annum based on Straight Line Method of
depreciation. The Authority has not used Annual Recurring Expenditure
(ARE) method in the present review of Port Charges. Therefore, in view of
the methodology used by the Authority for calculations of the Port
charges, the view of the stakeholders that interconnection provider would
get returns @ 16% is not correct.
22. The Port charges payable by the interconnection seeker have been
classified on the basis of number of Ports falling in a particular slab. The
first such slab begins from 1 to 16 PCMs and the last such slab ends at
128 to 256 PCMs. Further, if higher capacity new switches are to be
installed by interconnection provider then it is expected that about 50% of
the ports of the total capacity will be used by interconnect provider for its
own network connectivity for intra-network links and remaining will be
used for provisioning of ports to interconnect seekers for inter-network
links. The economies of scale will also bring down the CAPEX of higher
capacity switches. Therefore, the Authority is of the view that incremental
13
CAPEX for port charges calculations for various slabs is reasonable as
specified in the Schedule II to these regulations.
Issue 5: Applicability of Port Charges for Cellular Services of BSNL:
Port utilization for CellOne POI is 100% and, therefore, the Port charges for
CellOne POIs, irrespective of the demand, should be charged at average
rate of 256 E1s.
23. The Authority is of the view that applicability of port charges on
uniform basis would make implementation smooth and reconciliation of
port charges easier. As far as charging at average rate of 256 E1s is
concerned, interconnection seeker can always take the advantage by
placing demand on the basis of their traffic projection as the slab of 129
to 256 PCMs is available for Port charges in schedule II of these
regulations.
Issue 6: Recovery of CAPEX for existing Ports and sunset clause:
(a) Cost of POI working for more than three years has been recovered by
the interconnection providers and, therefore, there is no rational for
continuation of payments for the same.
(b) Cost of 7 years old Ports have already been recovered as per TRAI’s
own calculations and as such no further payments should be
applicable for at least such Ports and, therefore, sunset clause should
apply to these Ports immediately.
(c) There should be sunset clause for payment of Port charges.
24. The Authority has also considered the view of the stakeholders
regarding recovery of the cost for the existing ports and is of the view that
interconnection provider generally is required to replace the existing
equipment necessary for continuance of interconnection from time to time
and, therefore, proposition made by the service providers, that cost of the
existing ports is completely recovered within 7 years and no further
14
payment should be applicable with sunset clause for Port charges, is not
sustainable in present scenario.
Issue 7: Clubbing of existing Ports:
All E1s working as on 1st April 2007 should be clubbed together to calculate
the slab rates for charges payable after 1st day of April 2007 as per the
Schedule II.
25. The earlier slabs mentioned in the Schedule I to the
Telecommunication Interconnection (Port Charges) Regulation, 2001 were
fixed keeping in view of the fact that the interconnection provider may
have to expand / upgrade their exchanges sequentially and from time to
time. To meet such expansion and up-gradation requirements, the
interconnection provider might have made the investment for upgrading
their exchange as per the demand raised by interconnection seeker from
time to time. Therefore, Authority is of the view that clubbing of the
charges for all such existing ports at this stage would be unreasonable on
financial grounds to interconnect provider.
Issue 8: Review of Port charges:
Regular review of Port charges, at least once a year, to account for any
reduction in the cost of equipment.
26. As far as regular review of Port charges, at least once in a year is
concerned, it may here mentioned that various issues including Port
charges relating to telecom sector are revisited by the Authority and there
is already a provision in the Telecommunication Interconnection (Port
Charges) Regulation 2001 that from time to time Authority may review
and modify Port charges.
15
Issue 9: Inclusion of cost of ports in determining termination
charge:
Cost of the Ports (including all associated equipments) should be included in
the termination charges rather than prescribing separate Port charges.
27. Inclusion of the Port charges in the termination charge will lead to
differential termination charge for the calls which are terminating in the
interconnection provider’s network and hence it may lead to complex tariff
structure both for service providers and consumers. For calculating the
port charges, only incremental cost has been taken into account. The
Authority’s observation in this regard in Interconnection Usage Charge
(IUC) Regulation dated 29th October 2003 is reproduced below:
“63. ……… ………. The Authority also recalled that during the
calculation of Port Charges, only the incremental CAPEX for
provision of the port was considered although for providing ports,
there is a need for not only augmenting the switch capacities but
also other downstream parts of the network to handle the additional
traffic entering the network through these ports. The costs required
for augmentation of other downstream network elements to handle
the additional traffic, were left to be recovered through the IUC.”
Issue 10: Average Port Charges:
Average charges per E1 should be indicated for different slabs.
28. If average charges per E1 as suggested are to be specified then port
charges for 17 E1s will be less than the port charges for 16 E1s which will
create similar anomaly as was in “The Telecommunication
Interconnection (Charges and Revenue Sharing) Regulation 1999”. The
Authority recalled that during the above regime the new entrants
represented to the Authority that there was reluctance on the part of the
incumbent to supply Ports at the prices specified by the Authority in the
past. It was also represented by the BSNL that prevailing charges had an
anomaly in that these charges encouraged the interconnection seeker to
16
place more than the actual demand or actual requirements for Ports,
because annual Port charges for 8 Ports were of the same order as that for
33 Ports. It thus necessitated that the Port charges needed to be re-
evaluated and the existing anomaly to be corrected so that there should
not be any economic disincentive for provision of more ports. Therefore,
the Authority reviewed the port charges in 2001 and made the
Telecommunication Interconnection (Port Charges) Regulation, 2001 (6 of
2001). Therefore, the Authority is of the view that incremental slab system
of Port Charges is reasonable.
Issue 11: Sharing of Port Charges in view of traffic patterns and other
issues:
(a) POIs are used for both incoming and outgoing traffic and for that
reason why charges for Port not recovered on the basis of usage by
respective parties.
(b) Ports are used by both interconnection parties and interconnection is
a mandatory licensing requirement; then why Port should not be
provided on non-charging principle?
(c) All E1s in each exchange of BSNL / MTNL be combined for all
services within a seekers license for determining chargeable slab.
(d) Even after more than 10 years of interconnection the private
operators are still being treated as interconnection seeker by the
incumbent BSNL / MTNL.
(e) While private operators can assess and forecast the likely increase in
subscribers and traffic over a period of next one year, it will not be
possible for them to forecast the requirement of interconnecting
circuits / Ports for handling increased traffic from BSNL network to
their network. Therefore, each interconnecting party should place
demand on the second party for the Ports required to handle its
increased outgoing traffic over the next one year period.
(f) The demand on the basis of traffic projection on annual basis is
contradictory to the current scenario where demand is considered
firm only after the seeker makes the payment. Seeker may take
17
advantage of this clause by giving higher traffic projections and
thereby projecting demand for higher number of Ports and in turn,
taking advantage of lower Port charges though in the course of the
year he may give firm demand for less number of Ports. This may be
against the interest of interconnection provider and may also lead to
huge inventory.
(g) If the Port surrendered under one category (license / service) is
offered to be utilized by the same company under another service /
license then no surrender charges should apply.
(h) There should not be any surrender charges after three years.
29. The aforesaid amendment i.e. the Telecommunication (Port
Charges) Amendment Regulations, 2007 only makes amendments to the
principal regulations i.e. Telecommunication Interconnection (Port
Charges) Regulation, 2001 (6 of 2001), to the extent that Port charges
should be on the current cost of the network element and to align with
the present costing methodology adopted by the Authority in various
regulations/ tariff orders. There are many countries like United Kingdom,
Australia, Germany, Sweden, Ireland, Pakistan, Bahrain, Oman and
Malaysia etc. where the concept of separate Port charges in addition to
Interconnect Usage Charges is prevalent. The Authority, therefore is of
the view that system of the Port charges should continue at present.
Issue 12 Clarification with respect to applicable Port charges for
different scenario:
Stakeholders have also requested to explain charges to be paid by the
interconnection seeker to an interconnection provider for different scenario
emerging out of demand of seeker and provisioning by provider at different
point of times. They further requested for clarifications with respect to
regulation 2A as inserted in the principal regulations by the
Telecommunication (Port Charges) Amendment Regulations, 2007. An
illustration with two cases clarifying the Port Charges is as follows:-
Illustration: If a seeker applies for 100 E1s and:
18
Case 1: Provider provides 50 E1s only
Case 2: Seeker takes 50 E1s only although provider is ready to provide
all the 100 E1s
In both the cases the queries raised for explanation are:
(i) What is the charge to be paid?
(ii) How it is different from the scenario that Seeker applies for 50 E1s
and provider provides 50 E1s?
(iii) What happens, if seeker gives a staggered demand spread over two
quarters, will he still get slab benefit of total E1s demanded on six
monthly basis?
30. The analysis regarding the above illustrations is explained in the
following Table-A:-
Table-A
Interconnection Seeker demanded for 100 E1s on the basis of traffic
projection (in Erlangs) on half yearly basis
Sr.
No.
Description Case-I
Provider provides 50 E1s only
Case-II
Seeker takes 50 E1s only
although provider is ready to
provide all the 100 E1s
(a) Interconnection
Provider is ready
to Provide
50 E1s 100 E1s
(b) Seeker takes 50 E1s 50 E1s
(c) Applicable Slab
No. of ‘Ports’: 65 to 128 PCMs
{As per sub-regulation (4) of
Regulation (2A)}
Rs.{14,48,000+(N-64)*11,500}
taking N=100
No. of ‘Ports’: 32 to 64 PCMs
{As per sub-regulation (5) of
Regulation (2A)}
Rs.{9,84,000+(N-32)*14,500}
taking N=50
(d) Liability of
Seeker to pay
total Port
Charges
Rs.18,62,000 for 100 E1s
(Using the formula given at
(c) above)
Rs.12,45,000 for 50 E1s
(Using the formula given at (c)
above)
(e) Invoice or
Demand note to
be raised by
Interconnection
Provider
Rs.12,45,000 for 50 E1s
{= 9,84,000+(N-32)*14,500}:
taking N=50
Rs.12,45,000 for 50 E1s
{= 9,84,000+(N-32)*14,500}:
taking N=50
(f) Invoice or
demand note to
be raised for
remaining Ports
Amount payable for
remaining 50 Ports
= (d) minus (e)
Rs.6,17,000
{=Rs.18,62,000 minus
Rs.12,45,000}
At Later stage, if Seeker asks
for 50 E1s then seeker has to
pay Rs.12,45,000 again.
19
(g) How it is
different from
the scenario
that seeker
applies for 50
E1s and
provider
provides 50 E1s
Seeker has to pay the
charges for 50 E1s with
taking into account the slab
of No. of Ports 33 to 64 PCMs
i.e. Rs.12,45,000.
Subsequently if seeker
requests for further 50 E1s
then he has to pay Rs.
12,45,000 and benefit of
higher slab will not be
available.
No Difference
(In this case it is presumed
that seeker needs 50 E1s
only)
Note regarding staggered demand:
If seeker gives staggered demand for the total number of ports
spread over two quarters (six months) at a time, on the basis of traffic
projection on six monthly basis in one go, he will get the benefit of
applicable higher slab for total E1s so demanded. In case the
interconnection provider is not able to meet the demand for the total
number of ports in one occasion or as per the staggered demand made on
six monthly basis, based on traffic projection, then also interconnection
seeker will get the slab benefit for the ports so demanded. However benefit
of higher slab shall not be applicable if interconnection seeker demands at
different points of time within six months.
20
Table-1
NETWORK ELEMENTS REQUIRED FOR EXPANSION OF SWITCH /
EXCHANGE
S.No. Name of the Equipment
Port Terminals
1 SMT Basic Equipment
2 SMT Processor
3 16 LR Interface
4 8 PCM Module-120 Ohms
CCS 7 Signalling
1 SMA Basic Equipment
2 CCS 7 Coupler
Processor
1 MAS Access Unit
2 Memory Board
3 SMC Basic Equipment
4 Processor Unit
Switching Matrix
1 Switching Matrix Interface
2 MAS Access Unit
3 MCX Matrix 1 branch
4 MCX Helping 1 branch
5 MCX Coupling 1 branch
6 MCX Matrix O/P 1 branch
7 DC/DC Convertor
Mechanical
1 UE Rack
2 UC Rack
3 XA Rack
4 Rack cladding
Cable, Connector
1 16 pair HF Cable (meters)
2 SMT 32 PCM Convertor
3 SLIM Rack for 8 Modules
4 DDF Module for 8 PCMs
5 Inter suite runway
6 Basis Cords
7 Cords Set- Rack
8 CordSet
9 Cordset MCX
10 128 pair cable
11 Power cables
Software
1 basic platform software
2 ISUP-N Interface Software
21
Batteries & Power Plant
1 Power Plant
2 Batteries
3 Powere-40 outputs distrib. Module
4 Power Distribution Panel - 48 V
5 Power Distribution Panel-220 V
Miscellaneous
1 Installation Material
2 Tools & Testers
3 Spares
4 DDF Tools MSU
5 Documentation
Page 1 of 18
TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE GAZETTE OF INDIA, EXTRAORDINARY, PART III,
SECTION 4
TELECOM REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF INDIA
NOTIFICATION
New Delhi, the 18th September, 2012
THE TELECOMMUNICATION INTERCONNECTION (PORT CHARGES)
(SECOND AMENDMENT) REGULATIONS, 2012
(No. 18 of 2012)
File No. 409-3/2011-I&FN.---------- In exercise of the powers conferred
upon it under section 36, read with sub-clauses (ii), (iii) and (iv) of clause (b)
of sub-section (1) of section 11 of the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India
Act, 1997 (24 of 1997), the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India hereby
makes the following regulations to further amend the Telecommunication
Interconnection (Port Charges) Regulation, 2001 (6 of 2001), namely :-
1. (1) These regulations may be called the Telecommunication
Interconnection (Port Charges) (Second Amendment) Regulations,
2012.
(2) These regulations shall come into force on the first day of October,
2012.
2. In the Telecommunication Interconnection (Port Charges) Regulation,
2001 (6 of 2001), after regulation 2A, the following regulation shall be
inserted, namely:-
“2B. Port charges on or after the 1st October, 2012. - -
(1) Every interconnection seeker shall, on or after the 1st day of
October, 2012, make his demand, for every Point of
Interconnection for the total number of Ports required by him on
or after the said date to the interconnection provider.
(2) Every interconnection seeker shall make demand under sub-
regulation (1) on the basis of traffic projection (in Erlangs) on half
yearly basis.
Page 2 of 18
(3) Every interconnection provider shall charge, on or after the 1st day
of October, 2012, the Port charges in accordance with the Port
charges specified in Schedule III to these regulations and raise the
demand note or the invoice, as the case may be, for the Ports
demanded on or after the said date by the interconnection seeker
under sub-regulation (1) and (2).
(4) The Port charges for every Port demanded, allotted and provided
before the 1st day of October, 2012 shall be charged on or after the
said date in accordance with the Port charges specified in
Schedule III to these regulations and the interconnection provider
shall raise the demand note or the invoice, as the case may be, for
such Ports provided by him before the aforesaid date accordingly.
(5) Nothing contained in the Schedule III to these regulations shall
apply in case the interconnection provider and the interconnection
seeker mutually agree to charge and pay charges lower than those
specified in the Schedule III to these regulations.
3. After the Schedule II to the Telecommunication Interconnection (Port
Charges) Regulation, 2001, the following Schedule III shall be inserted,
namely:-
SCHEDULE III {See regulation 2B}
PORT CHARGES
Item Port Charges
(1) Date of
implementation
1st October, 2012
(2) Coverage Charges for ‘Ports’ (other than the Port charges
for internet, which are specified in Schedule VI of
the Telecommunication Tariff order 1999)
(3) Port Charges
Port Charges (in Rs.)
per port per annum
for providing port in
MSC
Port Charges (in Rs.) per
port per annum for
providing port in Tandem/
TAX Switch
4,000 10,000
Rajeev Agrawal
Secretary
Page 3 of 18
Note 1: The principal regulations were published vide notification dated 28th
December 2001 (6 of 2001).
Note 2: ‘The Telecommunication Interconnection (Port Charges) Amendment
Regulations, 2007 (1 of 2007) were notified on 02.02.2007 to be effective
from 01.04.2007
Page 4 of 18
Explanatory Memorandum
A- Port Charges
1. A ‘port’ means a place of termination on a switch/distribution frame
to provide a point of access or interconnection for ingress and egress
of traffic between the two interconnecting networks. The bandwidth of
the port is 2.048 Megabits per second. The ‘port charges’ are payable
by the interconnection seeker to the interconnection provider for
terminating the interconnection links on the network interface of the
interconnection provider.
B- Background
2. The Authority notified ‘The Telecommunication Interconnection (Port
Charges) Regulation 2001’ on 28.12.2001. The regulation, inter alia
specifies the port charges payable by the interconnection seeker to the
interconnection provider as below:
Table 1
S.No. No. of Ports
'Port' charges
(Ceiling of Rs. per port)
1 1 to 16 PCMs N * 55,000
2 17 to 32 PCMs 8,80,000 + (N-16) * 30,000
3 33 to 64 PCMs 13,60,000 + (N-32) * 20,000
4 65 to 128 PCMs 20,00,000 + (N-64) * 15,000
5 129 to 256 PCMS 29,60,000 + (N-128) * 14,000
Where ‘N’ refers to the number of ports demanded by the
interconnection seeker within the capacity ranges under the column
‘No. of ports’.
3. Section IV of ‘The Telecommunication Interconnection (Port Charges)
Regulation 2001’, provides that the Authority may, from time to time,
review and modify port charges. The Authority may also at any time,
on reference from an affected party, and for good and sufficient
reasons, review and modify the port charges.
Page 5 of 18
4. After following a consultation process, the Authority notified ‘The
Telecommunication Interconnection (Port Charges) Amendment
Regulation 2007’ on 02.02.2007 to be effective from 01.04.2007, vide
which, the revised port charges are as below:
Table 2
S. No. No. of Ports 'Port' charges (in Rs.) per annum
1 1 to 16 PCMs N * 39,000
2 17 to 32 PCMs 6,24,000 + (N-16) * 22,500
3 33 to 64 PCMs 9,84,000 + (N-32) * 14,500
4
65 to 128
PCMs
14,48,000 + (N-64) * 11,500
5
129 to 256
PCMs
21,84,000 + (N-128) * 10,500
Where ‘N’ refers to the number of ‘ports’ within the capacity ranges
under the column ‘No. of Ports.
5. BSNL challenged the abovementioned regulation in Hon’ble TDSAT,
mainly on the ground that TRAI has, vide its regulation, overridden its
agreement with private service providers and that TRAI does not have
power to override interconnect agreement between the service
providers. BSNL also contended that lowering the port charges was
wrong, illegal and incorrect as the cost of main equipment and total
expenses were not taken into account by the TRAI. AUSPI also filed
an appeal in TDSAT, requesting to consider inclusion of costs at
interconnection seekers network while deciding port charges.
6. Hon’ble TDSAT passed the judgment on 28.05.2010, wherein appeal
filed by BSNL was allowed. Hon’ble TDSAT observed that TRAI
indisputably can make, modify or alter the Port charges in exercise of
its power under Section 11 (1) (b) of the Act. Appeal of AUSPI was
dismissed vide Hon’ble TDSAT’s judgment dated 24.05.2010.
Page 6 of 18
7. In its appeal, BSNL also raised an issue pertaining to Gateway Switch.
On this issue, it is mentioned that Gateway Exchange or Interconnect
exchange is one of the way of interconnecting various networks.
Establishment of Interconnect Gateway Switch does not obviate the
need for port and, therefore, their charges. The earlier exercise
initiated by TRAI through issue of Consultation paper on Interconnect
Exchange cum Inter-carrier Billing Clearing House for Multi-Operator
Multi-Service Scenario on 13th April 2004, could not be concluded as
there was no consensus within the stakeholders. The Authority
decided to set up an Expert Group to give comprehensive
recommendations on all the aspects and issues connected with
Interconnect Exchange cum Inter-Carrier Billing System. As per the
Terms of Reference of the Expert Group, apart from TRAI other
members of the Group were from DOT, TEC,C-DOT, BSNL, Reliance,
Bharti, MTNL, Tata, Hutch, Idea, VSNL & Data Access.
8. In a meeting of the Expert group held on 13th January 2006, BSNL
informed that they have submitted its Interconnect Exchange Model to
DOT, as DOT was also working on the subject. Subsequently, in the
meeting held on 6th September 2006, it emerged that an industry
committee has been constituted under the chairmanship of Director
BSNL. It was concluded in the meeting of expert group in TRAI that
once the committee set up under the chairmanship of Director BSNL
finalises the various issues under its purview, some result would come
out and the same can act as an input for the Expert Group. After
receiving the report of this Committee, if required, Expert Group can
look into Interconnect Exchange taking into account the trends
towards NGN, need for optimum utilization of infrastructure etc.
9. TRAI has followed up the issue with the industry committee through
Director (Operations), BSNL as its Chairman. However, no report has
been received by TRAI till date.
Page 7 of 18
10. Now, migration to Next Generation Networks (NGN) has started and
the major telecommunication operators in India have already
implemented IP based core transport network for carrying voice and
data traffic. In some cases IP/Ethernet elements have extended into
access and aggregation networks. In the changed circumstances,
instead of reviewing TDM switch based interconnect exchange
concept, in view of the advancement in technology, extension of
networks, entry of various new operators, TRAI is in process of
studying that whether peer-to-peer interconnection, IP based
interconnection exchange or a combination would be preferable. A
comprehensive consultation paper in this regard would be issued,
separately.
11. Against the TDSAT’s judgment dated 28.05.2010, civil appeal no.
6068 has been filed by TRAI before Hon’ble Supreme Court, inter-alia,
on the grounds that TDSAT has no jurisdiction to look into the validity
of regulations made by TRAI, the same being sub-ordinate legislation.
On merit of prescribing port charges, Civil appeals have also been filed
by COAI, AUSPI and Sistema Shyam. BSNL in its appeal has
challenged the direction of the Hon’ble TDSAT contained in judgement
dated 28.05.2010 which does not allow BSNL to charge Port charge at
higher rate for interregnum period.
C- The Present Exercise to Review Port Charges
(i) Letter dated 18.08.2011 to service providers to furnish relevant
information:
12. In view of the various representations received from the industry
associations’ viz. Cellular Operators Association of India (COAI) and
Association of Unified Telecom Service Providers of India (AUSPI) and
the Court’s order, the Authority decided to review the port charges in
order to align the port charges with the prevalent costs of the relevant
equipment. To provide fair opportunity and to maintain transparency
in the review of the port charges, letters were sent to the service
providers and their industry associations on 18.08.2011 requesting
them to furnish the following information by 19.09.2011:
Page 8 of 18
(a) What interfaces/ network elements/ equipment shall be taken
into consideration for determining port charges? Please explain
with the detailed note, justification and diagram, clearly
indicating cost recovery mechanism for each element involved.
(b) Explain the approach/ model/ costing methodology to be
adopted for determination of port charges. Give justification for
adopting the proposed approach, model or methodology and
also provide details of the assumptions used in the model, if
any.
(c) Provide list of interfaces/ network elements/ equipment
required for expansion of switch/ exchange for provisioning of
additional ports. Separate list should be provided for each
category of switch used for Fixed Line Service/ GSM Mobile
Service/ CDMA Mobile Service/ NLD service/ ILD service.
(d) Provide costs and capacity of each interfaces/ network
elements/ equipment listed above.
(e) Provide cost model in excel sheet to calculate port charges along
with adjustments and justification for all assumptions used.
(f) Whether port charges are specified by the regulator in other
countries? If yes, what is the approach/ methodology being
followed by the regulator in determining these charges?
(g) Any other relevant information related to subject along with all
necessary details.
(ii) Consultation Paper dated 09.05.2012 on ‘Review of the
Telecommunication Interconnection (Port Charges):
13. In response to TRAI’s letter dated 18.08.2011, the service providers
and their industry associations submitted the desired information to
TRAI. Due cognizance has been given to the inputs received from the
service providers and a Consultation paper dated 09.05.2012 was
issued on ‘Review of the Telecommunications Interconnection (Port
Charges). In the consultation paper, comments received from the
service providers and their industry association on TRAI’s letter dated
18.08.2011 have been described briefly and on the basis of the cost
Page 9 of 18
inputs received from the service providers the telecommunication
interconnection (port charges) have been estimated. Keeping in view
the current CAPEX costs of an E1 port in GMSC and TAX exchanges,
consultation paper proposed that the ceiling of annual port Charges,
as specified in The Telecommunication Interconnection (Port Charges)
Regulation, 2001 may be revised as per the following Table:
Table- 2.7 of the Consultation Paper
Proposed Revised Ceiling of Annual Port Charges for
MSC and Tandem/ TAX Exchanges
S.
No.
Type of Switch
Port Charges
(Ceiling of Rs. Per Port)
1 MSC 4,000
2 Tandem/ TAX Exchange 10,000
The above proposal was presented for the comments of the
stakeholders. The last date for comments and counter comments of
the stakeholders was 08.06.2012 and 18.06.2012 respectively.
(iii) Comments received from stakeholders on the Consultation paper:
14. On the Consultation Paper dated 09.05.2012, 14 stakeholders
including 9 service providers, 2 associations, 1 consulting firms and 2
consumer groups sent written comments that were uploaded on
TRAI’s website. Counter comments were received from one service
providers’ association.
D- Examination of the main comments/ issues raised by the
stakeholders: Some of the main Comments received from the
stakeholders on the specific issues are summarized under the
respective issue and dealt with in the paragraphs following thereafter.
Page 10 of 18
15. Ceiling of Annual Port Charges for Tandem/ TAX Exchanges
15.1 In response to TRAI’s letter dated 18.08.2011, six service providers
have submitted current CAPEX for E1 ports for TAX exchanges,
ranging from Rs. 24,000 to Rs. 46,430. The same have been provided
in Table 2.2 of the consultation paper. For ready reference Table 2.2 of
the consultation paper is reproduced below:
Table 2.2 of the Consultation Paper dated 09.05.2012
Current CAPEX of an E1 Port for TAX exchanges
B.
S.
No
Service
provider/
Industry
associatio
n
Current
CAPEX of
an E1 port
(Rs.)
Name
of
switch
Remarks
1
Service
provider-2
46,430
Mix of
DTAX
and IP
TAX
switche
s
Costing methodology is weighted average
CAPEX. Per circuit cost of main/expansion
TAX equipment (TDM/IP-TAX) procured for
the last five tenders have been taken into
consideration. The service provider-2 has not
provided the costs of individual network
elements required for expansion of the
switch.
2
Service
provider-3
44,145
NSN
make
The cost has been considered on the basis
minimum configuration of the switch.
3
Service
provider-4
45,000
OCB
Switch
The cost per E1 (allocated cost) is calculated
by dividing the cost of the individual element
by its capacity. The summation of these costs
provides the allocated cost per E1.
4
Service
provider-5
40,450
OCB
Switch
Based on 128 E1s configuration
5
Service
provider-6
24,000 IP TAX Per line price of IP TAX is Rs. 800.
6
Service
provider-7
45,000 -
The cost per E1 (allocated cost) is calculated
by dividing the cost of the individual element
by its capacity. The summation of these costs
provides the allocated cost per E1.
15.2 In the consultation paper, for estimation of ceiling rates of port
charges, TRAI has taken the highest value of the CAPEX per E1 port
as submitted by the service providers i.e. Rs. 46,430. In response to
the consultation paper, some of the service providers commented that
TRAI has not furnished any justification for picking up higher cost
quote from the service providers as against the lowest quote. Some of
them have suggested that a mean of the highest and lowest figure
could have been more appropriate than using the highest figure.
Page 11 of 18
Another suggestion was to consider cost of the most efficient operators
so that inefficient cost of a service provider should not be loaded on
the seeker.
15.3 In this regard, it is mentioned that the port charges specified in the
“Telecommunication Interconnection (Port Charges) Regulation, 2001”
are the ceiling rates and the service providers are permitted to charge
alternative lower rates on the basis of their mutual agreement. Hence,
for calculation of ceiling rates, it may be more appropriate to consider
highest cost submitted by service providers as against the mean of the
highest and lowest or lowest figure.
15.4 In its comments to the consultation paper, BSNL mentioned that they
found that TRAI has calculated cost of providing one port E1 on the
basis of cost data submitted by BSNL for latest IP TAXs i.e. Rs
46,430/- per port. In this regard BSNL mentioned that indicative cost
of Rs 46,430/- provided by them is only the incremental cost of
upgrading the TAX (not the network) required to provide 1 E1
connectivity. They submitted that the incremental cost of all network
elements i.e. TAX, Media, Transmission Systems, Local switches and
other supporting infrastructure need to be taken into account before
arriving at fair cost of providing one E1 port to other service provider.
Also, the incremental costs incurred in providing one E1 port varies
and depend on number of ports being provided, as, after certain limit,
Control part of switching equipments also need to be up-graded.
Therefore incremental cost needs to be considered in different slabs as
was done in Port Charges Regulation’2001 and even 2007.
15.5 It was also submitted by BSNL that Partial provision of IP TAX in their
network has not resulted into any CAPEX saving for them as these
IPTAX has replaced TDM TAXs who have not outlived their life and
hence recovery of CAPEX done on TDM TAXs was not completed.
Further, the number of IPTAXs and capacity is very less in
comparison to overall network. Therefore, in real terms, there was not
Page 12 of 18
reduction of incremental cost being incurred by them due to induction
of IPTAXs.
15.6 The Authority has noted that while requesting the service providers to
furnish relevant information, the Authority vide its letter dated
18.08.2011 has clearly asked the service providers as to what
interfaces/ network elements/ equipment shall be taken into
consideration for determining port charges. They were also asked to
explain with the detailed note, justification and diagram, clearly
indicating cost recovery mechanism for each element involved. In its
response to the TRAI’s letter, BSNL vide its letter No. 1-16/2011-
Regln/243 dated 2.11.2011 furnished complete list of
interfaces/network elements/equipments pertaining to IP TAX and
TDM TAX to be considered for determination of port charges. Although
BSNL has not provided the costs of individual network elements
required for expansion of the switch, however, BSNL was completely
aware with the network elements required for expansion of IP TAX/
Switch/Exchange. The Authority has observed that cost of Rs.
46,430/- per port is not the indicative cost given on the basis of latest
IP TAXs but it has been calculated by BSNL on the basis of overall
weighted average per circuit cost considering Main/expansion TAX
equipments (TDM/IP TAX) procured for BSNL network for last five
tenders.
15.7 As regards the point regarding inclusion of incremental cost of all
other network elements i.e. Media, Transmission Systems, Local
switches and other supporting infrastructure in the port charges, the
Authority has noted that this is already established principle that
costs of Media, transmission systems, local exchanges and other
network elements are not relevant towards port charges and these
were left to be recovered through IUC. Inclusion of costs for other
network elements towards ports would result in double recovery of
these costs. The Authority’s observation in this regard in
Page 13 of 18
Interconnection Usage Charge (IUC) Regulation dated 29th October
2003 is reproduced below:
“63. ……… ………. The Authority also recalled that during the
calculation of Port Charges, only the incremental CAPEX for
provision of the port was considered although for providing ports,
there is a need for not only augmenting the switch capacities but
also other downstream parts of the network to handle the
additional traffic entering the network through these ports. The
costs required for augmentation of other downstream network
elements to handle the additional traffic, were left to be recovered
through the IUC.”
15.8 Regarding the point that port charges should be on the basis of slabs,
the Authority has noted that the cost inputs have been provided by all
the service providers on per E1 basis and not on the slab basis. Even
in response to the consultation paper, BSNL has not submitted any
slab wise data. The Authority has also observed that the cost data
submitted by BSNL, shows that procurement in the last five tenders
have been done by BSNL for large capacities of main/expansion TAX
equipments (TDM/IP TAX) and not for small quantities of E1s. In view
of the above, the Authority finds that prescribing ceiling for per E1
Port Charges is appropriate as compared to ceiling for slab wise
charges.
15.9 For estimation of Port Charges, the calculations in the consultation
paper have been made considering the following:
(a) CAPEX per E1 port = Rs. 46,430
(b) Useful life of the equipment = 10 years
(c) Method of depreciation – Straight line method
(d) Rate of Return (Pre-tax Weighted average cost of capital) =15%
(e) Overhead on CAPEX recovery = 10%
On the basis of above, the average annual cost (averaged
over 10 years) per E1 port for TAX Exchange was estimated as Rs.
9,321. Majority of the service providers, in their submissions, have
taken useful life of the equipment to be 10 years. However, M/s
BSNL, in their calculation for TAX Exchange, have assumed the
Page 14 of 18
useful life of equipment to be eight (8) years. Accordingly they have
taken depreciation of 12.5% per annum for eight years using straight
line method of depreciation. In the consultation paper, the Authority
has also estimated port charges considering the useful life of the
equipment, as submitted by BSNL i.e. eight years and accordingly
the annual depreciation as 12.5% per annum. The average annual
cost (averaged over eight years) per E1 port for TAX Exchange comes
out be Rs. 10,693. Giving due weight to the comments of BSNL as
well as other service providers, the Authority reconfirms its proposal
as given in the consultation paper and decided to prescribe the
revised Ceiling of Annual Port Charges for Tandem/ TAX Exchanges
as Rs. 10,000 per port.
16 Differential port charges for GMSC and TAX switch:
16.1 In response to consultation paper, some of the service providers
submitted that prescribing different port charges for MSC and
Tandem/ TAX Exchange switch is discriminatory as it will lead to
higher payment to one operator and lower payment to other operators
for the same equipment. It was also mentioned by them that the
consultation paper does not provide any justification/explanation for
considering different CAPEX for these two switches. They submitted
that the CAPEX for connectivity to both these types of switch is same
as no extra equipment is required for TAX exchanges/ Long distance
exchanges and therefore there is no reason to shift from past
precedence of uniform port charges.
16.2 The Authority has noted that in their response to TRAI’s letter dated
18.08.2011, some of the service providers have submitted that TRAI
should determine a separate charge for mobile port interconnections
by taking cognizance of the relevant traffic, flow balance between the
interconnection provider and interconnection seeker. They have also
submitted the cost of provisioning of ports in their Gateway Mobile
Switching Center (GMSCs).
Page 15 of 18
16.3 The Authority has also noted that in the ‘The Telecommunication
Interconnection (Port Charges) Regulations, 2001’, it has prescribed
ceilings for port charges on the basis of calculations for Tandem/TAX
switch. However, at that time the fixed network was predominant.
Most of the cellular operators are not having direct connectivity and
they are routing their traffic through TAX. In contrast, the present
situation is completely different. As on 30th June,2012 the subscriber
base of wireline services is only 3.26 % of total subscriber base and
almost all mobile service providers have direct connectivity amongst
them, hence, they need not route their traffic through TAX switches.
In view of the above, in the present review exercise, the Authority find
it more logical and appropriate to estimate port charges for GMSC and
Tandem/ Trunk Automatic Exchange (TAX), separately, on the basis
of respective costs.
16.4 Current CAPEX of E1 Port for GMSC, as provided by the service
provider/association was given in Table 2.1 of the consultation paper.
For estimating the port charges, TRAI has taken into account the
highest value of the CAPEX i.e. Rs.19,182 per E1 port as submitted by
the service providers for Gateway Mobile Switching Center (GMSC).
16.5 For estimation of Port Charges for GMSC, the calculations in the
consultation paper have been made considering the following:
(a) CAPEX per E1 port for GMSC = Rs. 19,182
(b) Useful life of the equipment = 10 years
(c) Method of depreciation – Straight line method
(d) Rate of Return (Pre-tax Weighted average cost of capital) =15%
(e) Overhead on CAPEX recovery = 10%
On the basis of above, the average annual cost (averaged over 10
years) per E1 port for GMSC was estimated as Rs. 3,851. The
Authority reconfirms its proposal as given in the consultation paper
and decided to prescribe the revised Ceiling of Annual Port Charges for
providing port in MSC as Rs. 4,000 per port.
Page 16 of 18
17 Applicability period for charges:
17.1 Regarding applicability/ time period for review of port charges, the
service providers have submitted time period which is ranging from 6
months to 5 years. It may be mentioned here that various issues
including Port charges relating to telecom sector are revisited by the
Authority from time to time and there is already a provision in the
Telecommunication Interconnection (Port Charges) Regulation 2001
that from time to time Authority may review and modify Port charges.
Hence, the Authority will keep close watch and if requires, either suo-
motu or on the basis of requests received from the service providers, it
may review the port charges.
18 Sharing of cost by Provider’s network and subsume
Telecommunication Interconnection (Port Charges) in
Interconnection Usage Charges.
18.1 Some of the service providers have submitted that the provider
network should also bear a proportion of the costs of interconnect,
commensurate with the flow of traffic. A few service providers were of
the opinion that TRAI must align the port charges on the basis of
usage by merging it with termination charges to maintain the level
playing field between the operators. In this regard, it may be noted
that as far as principle of payment of charges is concerned, this is not
the subject matter of present consultation paper. This aspect has also
been clearly brought out in the consultation paper itself. The present
review exercise is limited to the revision of port charges which have
been specified in ‘The Telecommunication Interconnection (Port
Charges) Regulations’ and following the principles established in the
principal Regulation. The seeker/ provider and related principals are
governed by “The Telecommunication Interconnection (Reference
Interconnection Offer) Regulation, 2002 dated 12th July 2002.
Page 17 of 18
19. Other issues:
19.1 In response to the consultation paper it has been submitted by MTNL
that the commercial terms already entered into between the port
provider and inter-connection seekers or to be entered into may not be
remotely regulated by TRAI. MTNL submitted that in CA No.-
D28298/2010 in Hon’ble Supreme court they have contended that
TRAI can not frame regulations , which would overpass the
agreements entered into between telecom operators. The case is
pending before Hon’ble Supreme Court and the matter is subjudice.
Besides Hon’ble Supreme court also observed that the tribunal had
also directed TRAI to start afresh the process of fixing the port charges
and made an obiter dictum as "Whether the delegated legislations can
be ruled upon (by) TDSAT... We would have to decide. This question
would reoccur and would come again and again," Therefore ab initio
the consultation process initiated by TRAI on the plea that the court
ordered it to do so in para1.5 of chapter- 1 is not correct and at this
stage there should be no attempt to determine the matter which is sub
judice.
19.2 MTNL also commented that in the litigation, on the applicability of the
new rates for ports on the basis of consultation process, court
intervened and issued an interim order that the new rates shall be
made applicable only to the new ports applied and provided after the
date of application and not to override the earlier mutually agreed
rates between interconnection providers and receivers against
undertaking and Bank guarantees for the difference amounts.
However this point on applicability is also not finding any place in the
consultation paper which inevitably leads to continuation of litigation.
19.3 Regarding issues raised by MTNL in Para 19.1 and 19.2 above, it is
mentioned that without prejudice to its rights and contentions, the
Authority has, in exercise of its statutory functions, undertaken an
exercise to determine the port charges. As on date there is no
impediment to the statutory functions of TRAI to make regulations on
Page 18 of 18
Port charges. On the contrary, in para 40 of the said judgment it was
clearly held that “TRAI indisputably can make, modify or alter the Port
charges in exercise of its power under Section 11 (1) (b) of the Act”. In
para No. 63 of its judgment, Hon’ble TDSAT has in fact directed the
TRAI to give a fresh look to the matter. The aforesaid judgment of
Hon’ble Tribunal has been challenged by different service providers
and by the Authority before the Hon’ble Supreme Court on different
grounds and interim relief was also prayed for but no interim stay of
the judgment dated the 28th May, 2010 was granted by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court. The interim orders passed do not prevent the TRAI
from conducting the fresh exercise for reviewing the Port Charges.
19.4 BSNL/ MTNL have also referred to judgment of TDSAT dated
27/04/2005 and the pendency of C.A. No. 3298/2005 before the
Hon’ble Supreme Court. As Hon’ble TDSAT has expressly ruled that
TRAI has power to make, modify or alter the Port Charges under
Section 11(1)(b) of the TRAI Act, the judgment of Hon’ble TDSAT in
RIO matter has no bearing. The appeal in that matter pending in
Apex Court also. Thus, there is no restrain order which prevents TRAI
from exercising its statutory powers and the TRAI is competent to
proceed with the review exercise in pursuance of consultation paper
issued on 09/05/2012.
Previous and next
All provisions of The Telecommunication Interconnection (Port Charges) Regulation 2001
Questions people ask
Is annexure E - A of the Telecommunication Interconnection (Port Charges) Regulation 2001 still in force?
No repeal of the Telecommunication Interconnection (Port Charges) Regulation 2001 is recorded.