Compliance to the recommendations of the CAG
Circular - The Environment (Protection) Act, 1986
- Kind: Circular
- Under: The Environment (Protection) Act, 1986
Text of this circular
No.J-11013/71/2016-1A.I(M)
Government of India
Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change
(Impact Assessment Division)
*** **
Indira Paryavaran Bhawan,
Jor Bagh Road,
New Delhi — 110003
Dated: 25th October, 2017
CIRCULAR
Subject: Compliance to the recommendations of the CAG — Reg.
It is to inform that CAG has carried out a Performance Audit of Impact
Assessment (IA) Division and submitted a report on environment clearance and post
clearance monitoring (Report No.39 of 2016). Copy of the Report has already been
circulated and it is also available on the website of C&AG. In this report a number of
recommendations have been given for further streamlining the functioning of IA
Division.
2. In view of the above, all Member Secretaries / Directors / Joint Directors
working in IA Division are requested to adhere to the following recommendations of
performance audit with immediate effect.
Revalidation of data with respect of grant of ToR / EC to be carried out on
regular basis with NIC.
ii.
While scrutinizing the EIA Reports, may ensure that they are as per the
ToR, comply with the generic structure, baseline data is accurate and
concerns raised during the public hearing are adequately addressed.
The EIA Reports / EC letters should clearly mention cost of activities under
EMP and ESR along with the timelines for their implementation.
iv. EMP/EC conditions should be more specific for the area to be developed
under Green belt and species to be planted in consultation with Forest /
Agriculture Department along with post EC Third Party evaluation.
v. Copy of EC letter to these projects should be endorsed to CGWA to
ensure monitoring of ground water extraction.
vi. While appraising the EC application, the name and number of posts to be
engaged by the proponent for implementation and monitoring of
environmental parameters be specified.
vii. While prescribing the conditions of EC please mention installation of
monitoring stations and frequency of monitoring of various environment
parameters in respect of air, surface water, ground water noise etc.
Page 1 of 2
viii. While scrutinizing the EC application, should ensure that the EIA Report is
prepared by accredited consultant having no conflict of interest with any
Committee processing the case.
ix. The conditions of EC should be compatible with the nature and type of
project in order to avoid non- uniformity in similar kinds of projects.
x. The EIA Report should clearly mention activity wise EMP and ESC cost
details and should depict clear break-up of the capital and recurring costs
along with the timeline for incurring the capital cost. The basis of
allocation of EMP and ESC cost should be detailed in the EIA Report to
enable the comparison of compliance with the commitment by the Central
and State monitoring agencies. The capital and revenue expenditure
amount to be spent on EMP and CSR cost should be distinctly specified in
the EC letter. It should be ensured that there is a time bound action plant
for fulfilling the EMP commitment mentioned in the EIA Report to the EC
letter.
xi. On maintenance of separate account for EMP and ESC, EC conditions
should be more specific like opening a separate bank account and
accounting format with specific heads of accounts in order to provide
financial accountability by project proponents. This should be made
compulsory part of the Annual Environment Statement.
This issues with the approval of the Competent Authority.
(Sharath Kumar allerla)
Director / Scientist 'F'
To
1. All the officers of IA Division
2. Chairperson / Member Secretaries of all the SEIAAs/SEACs
3. Chairman of all the Expert Appraisal Committees
Copy for information to:
1. PS to Hon'ble Minister for Environment, Forest and Climate Change
2. PS to Hon'ble Minister of State for Environment, Forest and Climate Change
3. PPS to Secretary (EF&CC)
4. PPS to AS(AKM) / AS(AKJ)
5. PPS to JS(GB) / JS(JT)
6. Website, MoEF&CC
7. Guard file.
Page 2 of 2
Page 1
Page 2