LawGrids logoLAWGRIDS.ORG

Form III, The All India Services (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1969: FORM III

The All India Services (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1969 - Form III

Text of form III

FORM III

FORM III STANDARD FORM FOR REVOCATION OF ORDER OF SUSPENSION ORDER WHEREAS an order placing Shri ...........(name and designation), under suspension, was made/was deemed to have been made by..............on.............. Now, therefore, the President/undersigned, in exercise of the powers conferred by Rule..........(here mention the relevant rule) hereby revokes the said order of suspension, with immediate effect. Signature Name and designation of the authority competent to revoke the order of suspension No…….. Dated, the………………… Copy to Shri…………..(name, designation and address of the officer during suspension). Copies should also be endorsed to the Treasury Officer/Pay and Accounts Officer, to the Cash and Accounts Section of the Department; to the Establishment Section for making an entry in the Service books to the Appointing Authority, if the order is made by some other authority; and to the lending authority (in case of a borrowed officer). 300 GOVERNMENT OF INDIA’S INSTRUCTIONS/DECIONS/ORDERS (I) GOVERNMENT OF INDIA’S INSTRUCTIONS TO STATE GOVERNMENTS FURNISHIG THE REVISED PROFORMA FOR TIMELY AND COMPLETE REFERENCE TO UPSC I am directed to invite a reference to letter No. 6/6/72—AIS(III), dated the 8th January, 1973 issued by the Department of Personnel on the subject mentioned above, and to say that as a sequel to the amendment of Article 311(2) of the Constitution and the provisions contained in Rule 9, 19 and 24, of the All India Services (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1969 it is no longer necessary to issue a show cause notice in cases where the disciplinary authority proposes to impose any of the major penalties or where it is proposed to enhance an existing penalty. As a result some changes in the proforma to be used for consulting the Union Public Service Commission have become necessary. It has also been found necessary to make certain modifications in items 1, 2, 4, 7, 12 and 13 of the proforma. Revised proforma which may hereafter be used for consulting the U.P.S.C. is forwarded herewith. 2. It has been observed by the Commission that, even though the proforma clearly provides that it should be signed by an officer of the State Government etc. making the reference, in some cases the proforma is forwarded to the Commission without ensuring that entries contained herein are appropriate and reflect the correct position. The importance of making correct entries in the proforma cannot be over emphasised. It is, therefore, requested that it may kindly be ensured that reference to the Commission in disciplinary cases are made to the Commission in the prescribed proforma complete in all respect, duly signed by an officer of the State Government. [D.P & A.R. letter No. 11018/7/82—AIS (III), dated the 13th July, 1983.] ANNEXURE Particulars relating to the disciplinary case referred to the Union Public Service Commission with letter No............................. Date............................. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- *1. Name of accused officer and the Service to which he belongs. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- *2. (i) Whether confirmed in the Service. (ii) Date of such confirmation. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------  Inserted vide DP & AR Notification No.6/9/72-AIS(III) dated 05.07.1972 (GSR No.872, dt.19.07.1975) 301 3. Post held: (a) Designation. (b) Scale of Pay. (c) Pay Drawn. (d) Date from which Pay shown against (c) drawn. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 4. Date of next increment. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5. Date of Birth. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 6. Date of Joining Govt. Service. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 7. Date when due to retire or date of actual retirement in case of persons who have already retired. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 8. (a) (i) Amount of monthly pension admissible. (ii) Amount of monthly pension sanctioned. (b) (i) Amount of gratuity admissible (ii) Amount of gratuity sanctioned. (This information is required only in respect of cases of recovery from or withholding of pension/special additional pension) ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 9 (a) Appointing authority. (b) Punishing authority. (c) Appellate authority. 10. Whether an oral enquiry, if required, under the rules has been held. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 11. Name and designation of the Enquiry Officer, appointed, if any. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 12. Whether all the relevant documents, in original, particularly the following have been enclosed with the letter seeking the Commission’s advice/letter forwarding the case to the Central Government in the case of certain major penalties, appeals and memorials). (A) In the case of original enquiries: 302 (i) Papers relating to preliminary enquiry, if any. In case the preliminary enquiry as done by S.P.E. their report together with all the depositions recorded by them. (ii) Suspension order, if any. (a) Order revoking suspension, if any. (iii) Order of the Competent Authority for joint / common proceedings. Where issued, if two or more Govt. servants are involved in the case. (iv) Charge-sheet with the statement of imputations of misconduct or misbehaviour and other enclosures. (v) Reply of the accused officer to the charge sheet. (vi) Order of appointment of the Inquiry Officer. (vii) Order appointing the Presenting officer. (viii) Record of the oral inquiry: (a) Daily order sheet (b) Correspondence file of the Inquiry officer. (c) Depositions. (d) Questions put to the accused officer by the I.O (e) Statement of defence before the Inquiry officer (f) Written briefs of: (i) the Presenting Officer. (ii) the Charged Officer. (g) Inquiry Officers’ report. (ix) Miscellaneous documents regarding evidence such as exhibits, statements etc. referred to in items (i) to (viii) above. (x) Sanction of the Central Govt. for institution of departmental proceedings, where necessary. (xi) Show cause notice for withdrawing/withholding the pension. (xii) Reply of the accused officer to the show cause notice (B) In the case of appeals: In addition to the documents specified under (A) above, the following: (i) Order of the punishing authority. (ii) Appeal, if any, of the accused officer. (iii) Comments on the appeal as required under rule18(4) of the A.I.S. (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1969. (C) In the case of Memorials: or Suo Motu Review In addition to the documents specified under (A) & (B) above, the following: 303 (i) Orders, if any, on the appeal. (ii) Memorial, if any, from the accused officer. (iii) Note indicating the reasons for modifying the existing order of penalty and precise extent of such modification. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 13. Miscellaneous documents such as extracts of relevant Rules, Codes Acts, Judgements, Manuals etc., referred to in the charge-sheet, statement of allegations, statement of defence, Inquiring Authority’s Report, reply to show cause notice, appeal, State Government’s comments. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 14. In case where no enquiry has been held and factual and procedural points have been raised in the officer’s explanation. A note explaining such points. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 15. Whether comments on procedural points, if any raised by the officer in his explanation to the charge sheet/reply to show cause notice/appeal, have been given. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 16. Whether complete and up to date confidential roll of the officer has been enclosed. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Signature _________________________ Name in Block Letters of officer of the State Govt. signing the statement: ____________ Designation ___________________ Date ___________________ Telephone Number _________________ II INSTRUCTIONS TO STATE GOVERNMENTS TO KEEP IN MIND THE JUDGEMENT OF SOME COURT CASES ON THE QUESTION OF STANDARD OF PROOF IN DEPARTMENTAL PROCEEDINGS. 1. A copy of the Ministry of Home Affairs’ D.O. Letter No. 24/25/62-AVD, dated 26-5- 1962 along with extracts from some judgements of High Courts which were circulated among Vigilance Officers to apprise them of the establishment law on the question of “standard of proof” in departmental enquiries against Government servants is enclosed. The same issue came up for consideration before the Supreme Court in the case of India Vs. Sardar Bahadur (1972). A copy of the judgement of the Supreme Court in this case is also enclosed. 304 2. It is requested that State Governments may kindly keep in mind the observations of the Supreme Court, especially the observations of the Court reproduced below, while dealing with disciplinary cases against the members of the All India Services:— (i) “A disciplinary proceedings is not a criminal trial. The standard of proof required is that of preponderance of probability and not proof beyond reasonable doubt.” (ii) “A finding cannot be characterised as perverse or unsupported by any relevant materials if it is a reasonable inference from proved facts.” This observation has been made in the context of the facts as stated in para 14 of the judgement. (iii) Where there are some relevant materials which the authority has accepted and which materials may reasonably support the conclusion that the officer is guilty, it is not the function of the High Court exercising its jurisdiction under Article 226 to review the materials and to arrive at an independent finding on the materials. If the enquiry has been properly held the question of adequacy or reliability of the evidence cannot be canvassed before the High Court. (iv) “Now it is settled by the decision of this Court in State of Orissa V. Vidyabhushan Mahapatra (6) that if the order of punishing authority can be supported on any finding as to substantial misdemeanour for which the punishment can be imposed, it is not for the Court to consider whether charge proved alone would have weighed with the authority in imposing the punishment. The Court is not concerned to decide whether the punishment imposed, provided it is justified by the rules, is appropriate having regard to the misdemeanour established.” [D.P. & A.R. letter No. 11018/2/75—AIS(III), dated 30th June, 1975.] Copy of D.O. No. 24/75/62-AVD, dated 26-5-1962. 1. You may perhaps be aware of the decisions of certain courts in which it has been held that officers holding inquiries in departmental proceedings are not under any obligation to follow strictly the rules of evidence as laid down in the Evidence Act or the procedure prescribed in the Criminal Procedure Code. In this connection, I forward herewith relevant extracts from the judgements of the courts for your information. 2. I shall be grateful, if you would kindly bring these decisions to the notice of all authorities dealing with disciplinary cases, as the principle of these decisions, if followed, should enable the competent authority to deal with disciplinary cases more expeditiously. ******** (All Vigilance Officers) III. VIOLATION OF RULE 20 OF THE AIS(CONDUCT) RULES, 1968 REGARDING CONSUMPTION OF ALCOHOL BEVERAGES IS A GOOD AND SUFFICIENT REASON FOR TAKING DISCIPLINARY ACTION 1. The provisions contained in rule 20 of the All India Services (Conduct) Rules, 1968, are of special importance in the context of the latest endeavor to reduce the consumption of alcoholic beverages and drugs. While it is expected that every member of the All India Services will scrupulously adhere to the provisions of the All India Services (Conduct) Rules, 1968, mentioned above, it is also expected of the disciplinary 305 authorities to keep a strict watch on the conduct of members of the All India Services in regard to matters covered by the aforesaid Rules. Violation of any of the provisions of rule 20 of the All India Services (Conduct) Rules, 1968 will constitute a good and sufficient reason for taking disciplinary action against a member of the All India Service. While any of the penalties specified in rule 6 of the All India Service (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1969 can be imposed on a member of an All India Service for good and sufficient reasons after following the prescribed procedure, the disciplinary authorities should take a very serious view of any violation of rule 20 of the All India Services (Conduct) Rules, 1968,and should not hesitate to impose the severest punishment on such members of the All India Services who are proved guilty of violating the said Rule. 2. I am to request that the contents of this letter may be brought to the notice of all members of the All India Services working under the State Government. [Extract of letter No. 11017/1/76—AIS(III), dated 5-2-76.] IV. PROVIDING LEGAL AND FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE TO RETIRED GOVERNMENT SERVANT-EXTENSION OF GOI O.M.No. 28022/1/75— Estt.(A), DATED THE 20TH JANUARY, 1977 TO MEMBERS OF THE ALL INDIA SERVICES. 1. The instructions contained in this Department’s Office Memorandum No. 28022/1/75—Estt.(A), dated the 20th January, 1977, are extended to the retired members of the All India Services. [letter No. 11018/3/77-AIS(III), dated 29-4-77.] (i) Copy of D.P. & A.R. letter No. 28022/1/75—Estt.(A), dated 20th January, 1977 1. A question has been raised whether, and if so, under what circumstances, Government should provide legal and financial assistance to a retired Government servant for the conduct of legal proceedings instituted against him by a private party in respect of matters connected with his official duties or position before his retirement. This has been considered by the Government and it has been decided that the provisions contained in paragraph 2(c) of the Ministry of Home Affairs’ O.M.No. 45/5/53- Estt(A), dated 8th January, 1959. (Copy enclosed) should be extended also to be retired Government servants. Accordingly, the provisions contained in the aforesaid paragraph, with the exception of the provision regarding grant of advance from Provident Fund, will apply also to Government servants who have retired from service other than those who have been compulsorily retired from service as a measure of punishment. Further, the amount of interest free advance that may be granted to a retired Government servant will be subject to a maximum limit of Rs. 500/-. 2. The form of declaration to be obtained from a retired Government servant when the Government undertakes his defence and the form of Bond to be obtained from him, if advance is granted to cover legal expenses, are enclosed as Annexure ‘A’ and ‘B’ to this Office Memorandum. 3. The provisions regarding consultation with Union Public Service Commission and the authority competent to take decision in each case will be the same as those contained in Ministry of Home Affairs Office Memorandum dated 8th January, 1959. (ii) Copy of MHA O.M. No. 45/5/53—Est(A), dated 8-1-59. 306 1. A question has been raised whether, and if so, under what circumstances, Government should provide legal and financial assistance to a Government servant for the conduct of legal proceedings by or against him. The following decisions which have been taken in consultation with the Ministries of Law and Finance and the Comptroller and Auditor General are circulated for information and guidance. 2. (a) Proceedings initiated by Government in respect of matters connected with official duties or position of the Government servant. Government will not give any assistance to a Government servant for his defence in any proceedings, civil or criminal instituted against him by the State in respect of matters arising out of or connected with his official duties or his official position. Should, however the proceedings conclude in favour of the Government servant, Government will entertain his claim for reimbursement of costs incurred by him for his defence, and if Government are satisfied from the facts and circumstances of the case that the Government servant was subjected to the strain of the proceedings without proper justification they will consider whether the whole or any reasonable proportion of the expenses incurred by the Government servant for his defence should be reimbursed to him. (b) Proceedings in respect of matters not connected with official duties or position of the Government servant. Government will not give any assistance to a Government servant or reimburse the expenditure incurred by him in the conduct of proceedings in respect of matters not arising out of, or connected with, his official duties or his official position, irrespective of whether the proceedings were instituted by a private party against the Government servant or vice versa. (c) Proceedings instituted by a private party against a Government servant in respect of matters connected with his official duties or position. (i) If the Government on consideration of the facts and circumstances of the case consider that it will be in the public interest that Government should themselves undertake the defence of the Government servant in such proceedings and if the Government servant agrees to such a course, the Government servant should be required to make a statement in writing as in Annexure A and thereafter Government should make arrangements for the conduct of the proceedings as if the proceedings had been instituted against Government. (ii) If the Government servant proposes to conduct his defence in such proceedings himself, the question of reimbursement of reasonable costs incurred by him for his defence may be considered in case the proceedings conclude in his favour. In determining the amount or costs to be so reimbursed, Government will consider how far the Court has vindicated the acts of the Government servant. The conclusion of proceedings in 307 favour of the Government servant will not by itself justify reimbursement. To enable the Government servant to meet the expenses of his defence, Government may sanction, at their discretion, an interest free advance not exceeding Rs.500/- or the Government servant’s substantive pay for three months, whichever is greater, after obtaining from the Government servant a bond in the form reproduced as Annexure B. The amount advanced would be subject to adjustment against the amount, if any, to be reimbursed as above. The Government servant may also be granted any advance from any Provident Fund to which he is a subscriber not exceeding three months’ pay or one half of the balance standing to his credit, whichever is less. This advance will be repayable in accordance with the rules of the Fund. (d) Proceedings instituted by a Government servant of his being required by Government to vindicate his official conduct. A Government servant may be required to vindicate his conduct in a Court of Law in certain circumstances, [vide Ministry of Home Affairs O.M. No. F. 25/32/54-Estt(A), dated 8th January, 1959]. The question whether costs incurred by the Government servant in such cases should be reimbursed by the Government and if so; to what extent should be left over for consideration in the light of the result of the proceedings. Government may, however, sanction an interest-free advance, in suitable instalments, of any amount to be determined by them in each case on the execution of a bond by the Government servant in the form reproduced in Annexure B. In determining the amount of costs to be reimbursed on the conclusion of the proceedings, the Government will consider to what extent the Court has vindicated acts of the Government servant in the proceedings. Conclusion of the proceedings in favour of the Government servant will not by itself justify reimbursement. (e) Proceedings instituted by a Government servant suo motu, with the previous sanction of Government to vindicate his conduct arising out of or connected with his official duties or position. If a Government servant resorts to a Court of Law with the previous sanction of Government to vindicate his conduct arising out of or connected with his official duties or position, though not required to do so by Government, he will not ordinarily be entitled to any assistance but Government may, in deserving cases, sanction advances in the manner indicated in sub-para c(ii) above, but no part of the expenses incurred by the Government servant will be reimbursed to him even if he succeeds in the proceedings. 308 3. Clause (d) of article 320(3) of the Constitution requires consultation with the Union Public Service Commission on any claim of Government servant for the reimbursement of the costs incurred by him in defending legal proceedings instituted against him in respect of acts done or purporting to be done in the execution of his duty. In other cases consultation with the Union Public Service Commission is not obligatory, but it will be open to Government to seek the Commission’s advice, if considered necessary. 4. The question whether a case falls under article 320(3)(d) of the Constitution so as to require consultation with the Commission may at times be difficult to determine. It may be stated generally that the consultation is obligatory in a case where a reasonable connection exists between the act of the Government servant and the discharge of his official duties. The act must bear such relation to the official duties that the Government servant could lay a reasonable but not a pretended or a fanciful claim that he did it in the course of the performance of his duties. 5. The appropriate authority for taking decision in each case will be the administrative Ministry of the Government of India concerned who will consult the Finance and Law Ministries, where necessary. The Comptroller and Auditor General of India will exercise the powers of an administrative Ministry in respect of the personnel of the Indian Audit and Accounts Department. 6. In so far as persons serving in the Indian Audit and Accounts Department are concerned, these orders are issued in consultation with the Comptroller and Auditor General.

Previous and next

All provisions of The All India Services (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1969

Questions people ask

Is form III of the All India Services (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1969 still in force?

No repeal of the All India Services (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1969 is recorded.