12 October 2011 S.O.(E) 2353
Notification - The Insecticides Act, 1968
- Kind: Notification
- Under: The Insecticides Act, 1968
Text of this notification
rFrgJ rt. do \rf,o-l jg6al9
REGD, NO D, L,-J3OO4/99
ffiT
@he Gqzette of Slndio
slrffi
STSITIITUT
EXINAORDINARY
qrll ---qt'iB 3-_3lr-Eluis (iD
PART ll-S€ctbr 3--Subsection (ii)
rrfuqR t !-d6rfrrn
PUBLISTIED BY AUTHOR]ry
d. rror;
No 196!l
r$ffi , EqsR, ryFT 12, 2ot l,/srrft.F 20, 1933
NEW DELHI, WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER I 2, 20t liASvrNA 20. r933
+fr tnrq
(Ffr qd REfit-dr frqFr )
srfuq.fir
T$ ffi, 12 srqil{, 2oll
sr.sfl. 23s3(3r).-tRfu fu k-nF{-d *Tc }irflr fdFT}s, H rffi -nqd siq \-q.r mfq.
EftE-qr lE-qz ldfues Eq'f + sc q .,r.il qrdr t, v e.gm {r=q i{qfr*, d ft{id +s{ €iq +e..*E $H
el w:qFr+ sH t, Em qrm d s,+r0 +.ffisr' qi q-jFqd g,rcn e sqq c qTtsqT c ails fnni +
sl3uror i qs yrqlqfi sTs Ei G, ffi'yqq Eqqr c.-6 crqrrqr fs.(t t,mi f+c.rq + sth qiqe qI
ffiq qTq qrt trvd cTs }fr-fis{ri d sq i c-a srq) e,t .iTs EE €}qT *, .n oL *-*+ ERr q.l rE .qrq
t qt ee gw f+ fu fs-+fud *.rc +}*n fdHs, r q+rffi6 qrtdtfu+-Rqr sq 3rcr rcq,.-qr
q*afue= ffi'd (vr{s) st* ER-+, zo"z rref qrtd{H ffifrqi* 50x - erqq{qfffi s.u. {er ra{-r
sc*tt a.ffi' o,r ffiq erq f<qr r fu qd t-o, +q.n. 4 -ffiq fT+dr r +s{ fr_ltfua u6i. 3r{ s 3icr
ftd dT+:€i rTsFrfi vwt'd urot g< s{c'i EHr'c-f{frrqicr s-qfi 6-{+ eTirrir-d- clftnfus E, rrfliqt sre qqrqr 6er yEq-f{tvrq, + q-U+<n t ffi s *u qrsfrs.€c-fltdr frrd.q-+fr{or Hfrfd d.
T+"fid,si W ti d feq mq q+-f{d q1 r rrettrn fiqrpr sTnif{qq, rsos d sffd ,lrm s,{-6R Td{q qlqrur sdrd:fiR, ei. ernqo. aq5,6q1{sd g-*is-e em r+gm .I{Tcrr<il * e-ffi ers + td6e
ctftn$ ERr stqter d Hq qrqrttn:Fr qr-qreFr, EftcruTr { qdE srdq v* <rfu-o fo-qr rrqr gln qrqrqq
t erq'.lrir 6r qil-r fsqr qt r sts"Td r e-r qFea f+qr ts 4l +G" !.+{, M fr-+[ql + eqq-fr<vtfi,q tr+ fq,tn qqn- t, q, f{s-6 qrs qn rf, e. r
s+{ q-df6 +4qri R( E1'ri qrq + f{qd + qrer-+ q qc-d c( 5l: fr-+n o.O + qrE T6 Frofq
**r966|fipr+. s{FJFqq, 1968 (sr*qR sfqfr-q.q+FqtETrsrs) 61 qru 9(3) o era,iax-r
sq{ffi B-fld + *+6{q ux qqlen rqlertq shfr ({s+ eT-( srrc* * Fc q 6-6, Erq) Er{ firi sTs d{
3801 ct/201r (t)
2 THE GAZETTE OF INDI.A : EXTRAORDINARY IPARr Il-SEL.3(ii)l
1fr r+ F6-+lftdr fre{rrr (Fst Era S<rS *- sq d +,6r BKr) +) Ttr+{ur t
ffir+wr 3r?rqr srtl rse + frrrd w g+16r furnrfur t drt ,i s{a fi dE' I
3fu B-dfu srr$ i 30.06.2010 +t srq-6 3TTff 310fr i-d6 f *q(.s *
e?trr?r ra{rE} fiI fu fr sfrETr 6-ri fi fr('qa'fr ,rfr-d 6-ri 6r ftEtq frqr 3it-{
r+d €Bfr e Hre-d w BqR B-qr 3fk 3rqfr Rfit 3rrr$ +i c-{ild fr I
3it{ u-dfr 3rrr$ i ffipl 24 sit{ zz.or.zor 1, 22.02.2011 tllt 27.04.2011
6):iqd 3rrdl 314d, 3154 sik Stafi ffit d Hrff-d w A-{R fr;qr dqr s-ccrEt
1i1vffifus ffi+-d (cr{s) (ii)rffiB-s 20% (rfffr or{&ra sit{ (iii}+ffiqr€
107o aFq3i-d (sdta) 10,ft t fr(, +s* E-dft-d *Yq fr|+em REo, EC +ffi
S('tr€, it v.o-+a rrw 3df{-6r fr mn ffi 3ia *E+-f, +-qfi q6T 3{r"dsfi-6 6rfi
fi, rarw qrw qt'rrrur ylrTurtrr +i drfrs fA /frrftT +-{A 6T trq fuqr +dfr g+
3r*frs q-cmt d 3rrro1-r' 6i rifrfr'{q eiRE (drtr sFd f6qr rr{fl fi d?n 16 sfi
ffiq fuqr fu {*otururc*- dam 3fll;ng rr$ 3rdft-+' c-(mi ilqr q.i-+'{q fr +nen
fg+fu+ Ecr+a-dT) dcr HTq A ffi6 c-fi?tr fi 5qFrfi.rdr + 61.qUT rrTqT 9(3) +
sra-fra qf,r+-{urrnr+' st art +-ffi-fiq,f€ 597"+srqq-{ifua 596 orqtrIAfud 5"%
t* fgbdql-cd *qkd S-50s) T,r q-#+-{ur ffie ftq.r srcrBrFd fr-qr err 31tr
€rtr fr z16 G!i?T ft-{T fr-+ffiftqfs 5Q9i,+ sqqgpl;l syc fst f; ar-fi.ara +r
9(4) ti*-m-{u'n sn "-Ift-fl fuqT ffit-,rr,G*d fr-ql sRrqT I
y,k G-dfu 3rRS fi ffirat aeT Rsr-E c{ jstrEu srr-a} qr frqR 5rA +
Erd'dk q,I crFd + 15 aa * 3I{r mnvr a-ari * ftq zs.os.2o11 st fia\rs
G-S r6-d ded E+ilfrfr *iq cil+?rd frfro, + sc * ilrfl.sr-frr qT) si dt-s
frft B-EruRn qr fr frranr+ s{frfr{fi, 1968 fr qfr 27(2) + 3{EJia qrfu s.r
qqt+ +-ri fl +--*rq F{sR rdrn sct-+d 3-cqrd-36 frrmar+ :+frft+s, 1968 fI
qm9(3) fi s-crctd +qfr 6) drt q#fi'{sr e-firsrr* H-rFd +qt a-fr ft.qr ilrr r
3it{ B-dlfi *q('s A 3rri (-crfi t wralt +-ri t frq g qqr6 +.r yfrft+a
grq airn frs w mrt ti Fa go.o.zot1 fr+.r srq Egr arqr t
3lh a-dl6 S('q€ fi cfrfrfua +-{i dr& {rS grr t'+nftrr,-rlr i hdrfi
2t-.a6.2Aii fi'q* fr sft'f'ffi (ffirc-s fi Hi4 fir ilqr 6sq q66n anas ar t-aro
30.06.2011si crifrfi s-crq frqr r
l
Iqr,r r-Eo-s r(iD] qfft 6I $fq'i : stqTqREI
'
3itr a-df6 frEi+' 11.07.2011 6 sascar rd (aRT frqqs +i sfrfuff
ffiris frr.'4q aqr 10.08.2011 sI €-frdd Flqtlfd fi T$ t
3ifr rcfs. fit'<'s or chfffud +-l-i Erd 5:n rdft'rc-.ea A Ears
01.08.2011 t q-{ fr3E}s G''qT fr E-€ralit t qo arm d}I6I efr :llfl zr$ $ aqr
qa, frd<a +-{e 6q yat fdffI€ ffir}s efi e}g-i +l et6r t
JJ
3ifr ffiffi fudi6 10.8.2011 +t EFqEI sa-ad t Sq('€ fi r'aa f ('erfr,
gs rlatar q;f,rfi, s gttr rrr+4a, dr $ftqrad rt{ 3it-{ ftr€-fi 3it{ 3Trrs dir
ilrtr t do qsofu g{rar <4Rr crifrfi fraz-dT Ffi('m' dtII frqa-s + 3{FftEd
(€rH +t $ti *I d,dlfr 6t drc Gtq ?rqr I
3ik a-dP6 10.08.2011 t rfii@.6 q.{ {4RI gftfrm E.+arls ali^ zrq 3ltt
gd-drg 6I drtr@. 24.08.2011 FE]ifrf, fI T$ ffi drd
't
fi!\'s + r"rtu w
Frtrrd +-{fi 3o.o8 2o1t qt kr erqr t
3itr irdf6 fia.a.ff EERI ffi 24.08.2011 t 3lq-e q" * 3lfrftf,d,B-id.n fu(
7RI I
3it{ u-qf6 30.8.2011 4ll {iwa 3{frfi gd-dr$
'i
q"rtr gafr ffrm +-arfr, fr
shr irqTfrfr, 4r srfrffraa ,itg 3{tr ftTrgfi 3it{ 3IIT$ Er am t do c-€o*o
J
tr{"Tr a-drrl fraqa fuq qr' I
3i,r-r a-dl6 *r.ts fit 3Ilr t 30.06.2011,01082011 att z+oazotl t q-Ji
cdRT dqr 10.08.2011 3i|{ 30.08.2011 qi} flc-tr Td-dr$ rt fu=TRfra d-tqT(s
Ht<a Brr 4'(' :
(i) f* irfuftq?q fir rnn 27 + 31sR ffi 3{a.rtd Earfi 25.5.20tt +} dfue',
,6 f6+r rrqr qT, 6rGRr6'+ qd!q-{sr * ffi+.{ur Na r,-+an ffi:n t' qA
frranm6sqf+t"anEat?sqarveyldfrqffistBqerfi-f,6ti
fir €eTr+flI t arffi amrfr+ 6ffI 6GII 3lc.qtkr ritr nrsr{+ d srq" qRr
27 {-|-t ws (2) d oo-s (1) 6',I 5q$tq t, 'l
qe crEtrrd t fr 3Ic-fr ,,3iT t
qf{urFT 3T?rdI trs?I sr6n rdRI qlw fidt "* grftrr ql 3nrdr "riilaw
sAfr * spv ql7aeJ * 4t4'+4e sqanc gs aIT f "egv't B =+
frrdTrqrfi r.fra fr'rarem +-s q.qq * fr(' su-5 (1) + 3ia-ri-d f{frr,
6.qq6d+ * frq tl-fi Eql qsl t r.rar F*g nr$ sdt + ili :+q-ar a
4 THE GAZETTE OF INDTA : EXTRAORDINARY [Panr II-Src. 3(ii).1
ili fr isTr{dr | 1go-s (r) fr sft+fua fi ffi #dfq sr6R tt 3irhi
(fradrerfi d q-#fd 6ra t raT firi fr'r 3nlrr 3{?rdr 3Ti q-.;fl-+.wr Frrror tr=r
6i Ar€ +,ri (fr raa F+-qr zrqr eD 6.1 3ne?r crft-d 6-{ t.+fi t, ut a_O
HrFd fI Rrfr ,i, JFrd Tfl-S I ttrTr 27 d Bcrtkd {f, _fldff sd61Brt u,r
3r{gtur ;r6f B-qr am t r a d +"91o vGfiR e;cRT ,,si$ BTq fi rr$,, sitr a
,ifi-+,{sr +rftfr f$sr B, em 27G) * ft}E-d t t *. srq ,,q{reet
F+-qr aqT,, r
il+qta ffrrd Jt trRr 27(2) *. rsrqrrur erfut ei arzl 6rA + fu *H m-,* Er*;rfr H r
(ii) fr dEs tr sFilfud 3{*i"r., il6 silrq qdrfi{ur rt ffi dri + fr(, sffid
3rift-n qfiAft-o/ffiq an+ lar t uf hfufi 56qTg or E*aE t I qO
v-q ufirrur HRfr t frdr E :Ertq 3irrrn rfl. t r
"nfmi+ ra+a
frsor ahrfufiR rik qlrt w Fr6r q:afrdT :it* yn t,idq i.
3{rqr?r6 srq-qr fofrchTr, fifr sfi errfr d, ildRr ,tr} p 6r +iftn t Ers
#rarfttzit * qUfa*or 3it{ Er} } pqqa -+. fi OA. t ,
(iii) SIS i tsr F{e } fr(' +}$ *nft-+ 3r?l?rr 3,"q crdrrra a atd a(, sfr
qdffr{ur *'mc fi sfran *l sOra Fqr t r i*+-rur €Efr d iS smfit ;
s{rq d-i * fr(, *qa-€ 6} +.t har E* zooz ril* zorr fr s+_a 3?crd ilds.'ofi HrfiAdt fr friE fi 3fu :r+r€r n.Sar fr I qgr+rq €.ftfr fi
27.6.2007 +t r$ ZZZA d-dfi C ,,€frfr * M kqT fs cfmiq 6:6-d +_ri
:a'q.g€
s-ccrd fi E{etT defi e?{rfudr t sd* C fo1fi ilasrft * #A _AfI ,rg ?fi mrr grira c"fi-frrur flfrF t c-Efra ftn Bdrn + :r+rn pi :) r,q6 qef-dr t f6 Cffi rnnfr'd Tadrd 6r nd 3?crit fr ,,wen # *rla., t+f$mnrrfrt r
(iv) W ft a-E ga: €-dren if, c-trs-rur efrfr rsrfl ftrlqa sfrfr dir ffi,afl ,r$ S ffir r,-rqarn T& 3{fr6rfi 6{ $ r} .A
s.d_dr sfiqtT a
. snrT ft-qr qr deT ft!6+ Rqr qr I sro AOfiO {r}_"a, 65r++ r5rftftm
(*fr) en,To3ioco dqr:ro qsgto wr+r, Eriva fu_r B'd Eil, 2o1oit qfrd tr*sfr ffFA i sq jt Aq+-d R qr rrqr qT, q", ,oo,
fr rrffd smeTr sRfr + s.t fir4 rlr E-)qa;Afr fi ftqrS tzoio fl d
il"6'd dt o.frqi ?fi dfi fsfr.Ti + H.iu fr u"c- O 3flrnT6 rr_rtlqa*rfr .ff, r {g+- ar+ra fde'rsil gFfr a ,*" y;crqi Tr ,.+ o.t_** *
+S il+-#Er +?fi afr qrf
r
i
I
rt
I qrT ll-so-s 3(ii)] tII(d iFI TlGIq;I : 3I{[ttREr
(v) T6 B' fsfi 315fi d-d+. fr q*+-rur Hfrfr A {+{ a?T vr ca fui sik
{S gw fuur B yoa rcqrat fi Ei*cwr + rTrffd ,t +tS $Eq qr T6r ilfi't fu +,15 ak 6r{fr srd adt rlI r qfr+.tur Hftfr t gfr ca u-f,orfudr
Barrrr EaRI "MRlt + ilfitrrfit c6aat of sqq +.ri gv rqa frEqrrfr,,fI Hi4 firi fi Era;re qfffisr sfrfr fr ;i-c tfiqr fu umffrs
|df+-fr d?n gsh drtrrdit En 4qq ffr7ftss6 +-ri fr frq ffiq ,'Sn
rflrqi + ErS cfr"+,a d+.fr€l qra t *r-rur,, a-fr frqr erqrr nri qf afi
*d fuqr erqr fu'q*firrr +rfrft ,,666 fnl w qsrrd iln an-a srfr <'a
$8o3 qqtt'9
l/
,, ,/
,5
c$ft fi g+ar t qrq.d f cfrrAfitB l+drfi-d{ iln F€fi dtrnt fi 3rw* cfr E"d-e {I rltr fs nfi.R Ffr r.crCt d tlr t q$ a€ t rer li +.r
+i$ sitfuq a-fr t 1,, T6 atc f+qr arel.fu ter ,t 6qrfl fi q-sdt ,t d
*qrd ar qrqfi iqqtrr ilar t 3it{ ,,ffi:l;a tq t sfr 57+r ri;nq'.ror
t+qr zrqr H, Tfr "r Fd rcqrqt t cft-^+,,6T q;fl-{ qie fI mfg fidt a-€t t r
e-*{hfur€ 10 cfr?rd fr t m--d fr S q.drfr{ur sAfr (+€.r R stefi
td6 it atc E-qr rrq afFa fri q{ jls yiljd fi cfr ffas-c B o., oO ,t
ald fuqr f+. sEfr vr 7s {tFr6 +.r +}g @-a *arn afi t r t a-qra
qFdrfrd +.rffi +f $Tqnfid. E-ar i-i 6 e+m cf+-rur H.Efr i Fa
riqrd fr c-fren ma-E srft qr qpn + cfr.ilEfi $ qft1d s.-vr< t sc
d rrfr a B I +-dhtftsrs 50 cfrErd + ffiqfta s cfrerd iS dFr.ir
+ q*flry +,idtr ji a at rfir eqar ,i Eik a fi EB-fr ffit *
+'r+fa d ffi+- 3rLqq;r qr 3firrR crw Etdr t r Eslc-fr sfrft arnq.frfiur sftfr ar W M B +ffitqrs 3itr frqr*r].trd +.r ftafur
Gffi ('6 uro fi a-orar d s{fus. lril.firfi t, tq a-fi H rqnfi z16 {6tatr {fw jt \.trS Er;r sr 3{rrTrfrd t, 6rdTf+. 3.rr-g- +
firfe H fr. (.trS 50 * era ErrGfl-fi arrar t' fre Ble etr€z fr?rdrd +
a?fi-fiur, ml-tt * rrcr S r srisgt + qurr, q-qf6 E,1ur rrqn *.fr(,
trr (.fiS so + xt;T rr+-a qr+l fr Td-dr ,t m-q H, afi qC rroa qr+, gt
g.'ar f's{Eq- errdrfi effidr fl-fi.qrfar F I Ss+ qfrunq+alsq qdF{ur
€ftfr t F-d 3-.!l-it 6) g<fsd;nn ce{rqen& cre t drq sfi ft.{F +-ri
i"frfi{ur {Rfr st T{T ErrT *t %dqfr t fu E-r r4il q{ar * rfa 3{qB-d
6 T}IE GAZETTE OF INDIA: EXTRAORDINARY lPenr II-Src. 3(ii)l
rfir 3r6nd' t ritrfrur +f fr{F 6-{ [fifr Brarqs a u-s'-fi t r A.fr
E.J-+R t fu4a f *mr s-a qfiRrffi fr qRr 27 t'sr€r".niq mq.Errdt 4.r
Erqfrr fuqr t aq *t$ firranm araa alftmEsrt E+ ilEq 3Erra 6-{ar
rtr r
q-6 F+. trftffi qonr aia ilrr 3rdF-fi csnfrdt * 3{rr}ct fr il-fi+rft
qfifi$rr sfrF aqr *a +rrqrt 6) 2Oo7 t t aqr frslc ;qrqlrfrar,
3r*flrilr t *+ fr errs +r ffiq iifrd t r tnil 3rRtct fi frrot * fi rrt
5sn ia q, 2oo7 fr qtrfr{ur HEfr i r+a -qrs} *' :rr+-syfrrrfirfi +.r
"Ffi-+rdfa qaqr;Ea fu-{r" 3if{ qO M trqr f6 q.fi-fr{ur f; ffi
5fud afr+ t A ,rS ?fi rrrr r+a rsrqi fr gcn d?rT cHrE + sE* *
ififr sfr ila-nrt 61 3rded ftfi+.rur Sfd *..{A sry a-& fr at efi r
trd dfr t arq, Erdifu fr(ry€ den &itqrd +€ L€rd Ffi-ard t frffi v-5a fi
dfE a d 6f* F".{c}tc €Eirr t Jili- a fr 6f+ s;q rstr t, fu-{ ,fi }rTqt-f,
?tg frsrd qmd jt w af+a $rq{Tfu+- Hrri ,t qq ;qrfu+ aslffii,
$ilcTa +;qr{',E-q -d*r 76.2010 +t tr(, rrq fu-q 6, %d-s*, f{S 6T
stlayf errR aqr c-sR fi Rft d y+a sccrqi ar ,,q*+sur cr-d 6-ci *
fr('$.*fr+. cunfut, + 3mlq + Hrfid fr *qw a eae.fu+fU f;qlrur a-arsr) atfu€ ilrfr hqr ;rqr t *-;r siqrr e ,l+q.-i ft-al+ ro.g zord
* inter *'a-ca s ilf fi 3rdfu t Ra AT\,-s d dffiFc fr snTr I H
qE-d freilr +-&{ r6ri + aro-qa +ar s(fiR 3ftr fia..(,-{T q{ qfi: fl-fdr&
frri 4l yknd qi{fr H * at6{r rs d-.n asfi-{ +c q6-qri * *fu-* t r
T6 1+- i€ Era fi 3{r?iql H B, #H ur+.r i "ilsfr€ +-ci-ar fl*sr
arfr 593 wrry qr arrrlar s-S u-fq tcqrdi + q.fl-+.{vr +} re +-r} +.r
frstrq +-{ frqr qr;
qE B' tsr rdfd 6far H f+. r{E-d rurara t 6A..d fuqi+-drq) fr siq
q-f,drd + frq Efi -qrfu-fi cffiqr Ar sr${rd q-6A fi m fr ,r€ H, :ra,
g+ar aufua cfffir fr qErfi 6:ri *.ss.ra H 3ik ffi Rrfr jt aE
grq*rfu+ EErefi anrrcrzl * user df{d t, 116 3{F;Iqr{.a-fi t ;
(vi)
(vii)
(viii)
(ix) q6 f4. ga-m fr' sftrBd r.qrd + tr Hr#/Hrs dra, rd+
a-+-trfirrssB-o drfft *- Erfrrq, il s-mrr 3rfrEa H +qifu t @
sfuHq-a 1999 + il6a fi(r<'s h q-trT-d *.e.A f rit-t S-s v-+r+ 5+*i
d-&ffta dff*. rvay 6o11* a-Ca Xfi a-r-e t E.a u-raiur m-d t ;
I
I rTrrr II-Erug 3( ii) ] qRil 4] {|!FI;I : $$qfcll
(x) rf fu, fs e+,n Fs qgar +f ErF/TqfErq€ +-.r tar Erfr(' r
3ik ,-cPfi, *(nlg fr ft q .orffi H ,rq r.T{t 3{tr gd-drg + atfla H rt
cEfro{q Frafrfra a-cqrr ctErurt h srq fi$fi d serq flffi rotrr hER
frr+ Trq
(i) 7fi-arem Ecrfr c-qRf t 3ilr F-+ araE qd ciJ Er€T t frn dBfl.
ui 1H fi ?fr + 3tt{ fs} 3ftfrd var} ar} sfrft.{rfi 3itr fut *
3l-d-Trta fst iEift-d a,Fdt 6t hffia fut ari fi rn-alr+-6r S 3
ri*+.rq Fftdrardt t Efrieur fr !+. Edqar;ar cffi-qr t fldtfs. z16
vf*ur e-5 gfdR-ff +-rA fi Rd sdtmr td ffiqR t fo 7E-arem
gtfra (.e ce{rfi R I qO nfrftqq fr {frq or ffi p I (fo-rw
cB-+r t ra-q c-r Fd-d-dr +-ri + frt go efr r.+e-* a-fi B-+r sr
s.rar t t g€ lflfl-d fr', trfufi'$ 6Tn fi G am qrar-a q-o t fu
3rrr$ fi vgu aMr +t fts{d fr a.-$ efi fu Ar(r€ 1w r++ fi fi-
dfuO t ldRrse s-acrd 6T qf+lw sfrE fs-qT ari r &vu+.r,anr.
y6rqT 4qr T6r t fu gr{E&' 27 h 3ra?id +,rffi s-{i +.frt
3{fi-dr{ {f, 3{rderfrdni +qr t, gqh ,qiq EaT"r f+. qmd t'd ceJ
etr€?-q t fr'i csa d rccrdt + Btfuff + Ert fr 3{rr$ C qfirsi (.d
r"aFc +t areE fr %d-srur l+qr flqr t r azq 16 t f+- rccrqi +
q*+-tur d sfisaT * fut frraa t erarara h drt d.*EqT ndd +
y+rsrfi *'ErE, (rfi mrfi=+. ais * 3fihr ffirq €-rtrr 4.m H a-i
3rk srq fr wfut h snrrR w trftr$ +i ar-cmn rftff-.qa *
a-qrE t rr-T4-d, qfr gndeqfi 61 +tffi +ri * ft-i 3at srq Tiqrfud
4-{e + frt s.O TEIr ?IT I fr-d'Bn$ rqgr +rErft-d sio d'fte4trglft *
dt q+a f6(, rrn t sit-{ T6'M Jik +fr c-{.? fi G rfi r ftsild
r€ strq fi qr<q +icrur rsrC+n +i re.a # G efi ffi Es,6
SrftG r-anr urtv qr arfua frqrum t r qtq qr-qq +irqrur
fr*norq, i?rtq ad fiu-smq (fififieq (,u-E \.$) t a *-ea qu f;
8 THE GAZETTE Of INDTA : EXTRAORDNARY
[PAR] Il-Sri 3(ii1]
c{-d 3rr$ + rye r6Fr sfr H r UrOr6 i uc m ftqfe Grqr t tu
M'S-dfrfr (3ril S(r(rs) + fut fr t*r-tt fir,rS lfi fui +-rq;+
t rs wrq t edq fr}lm i %d*qa # €1er 3flqfu6 3rd fi sc jt
ft'lqa fi rrFf Arrlfr ,rS r fs aiq t 3{r?rR rR, 3rrg i dIqS C
+-5r ur fu q;frfiur # ft-n rccrt ft arcn ssen qft gI dri, ffiftt fterd c-{.? fi ,rS rfr r 3rrr$ A FfratT H rrcr 3icrE mw H
3ik mfi qrt rsrd t qf+-{ur +} rEarfrs d-i } frt R$rftqr fi_
trd rfld t qrrd ii fiFrfi q3rr era-a qafr +i grq-drdr 3rrr$
(ERr 6Rq *, sq it dinqr erqr 3it-r dh) yan *.FrFd jt rrora c_6fr
+t src-drfir ir.n q#6rur fi fun-ft{rit +.r sEFiTd s:rar 6.RUr t sq ji
EirFrT mrTt {fftr$ r-oro aio 3rrr$ t sRr y{rlni t qar a_ar t f+.
3rrr$ * qrs slffi +t ftsd-d asr 6Fc-fr FdRr 4nkT q-<fr Jc;ars_{
ftfl-+Tur fi eB.qr + dilq t sfddr frqr urqr I wa 16 t fr.+qT
ftfr fterildt i +-FTfr fr war Aqkur +i es{rFfd fu-a ; ;66q uq
mc.fr {s} 6(r qdrfr-{ur gffiqT Ea"ar-H-s' t I $fuB-qF + 3r;-d?td
ry 1[*R"t fir grun 3tk e?Trfrdr +r rqtua qaqffir gBR-da
*.re t frt Tieq +t +.rrq rui qq q*+{q"s,fu *urrrr t I
T6 tsr rrqr t fu c*frrul *r"cB.qr +t csrTP{d a-gi t frd
fu+6p cffiqr * El;rcq t saHt-dr +-rdr B I qfr qfr.fi{ur cffi-cT +
a-d-"q t €-a-#l-dr B;qr ildr t ef q-O 3{fufi €Elr ils.€..sra n& t f6
sicr fi grer:il-r e.aTrfuaT 5p aoqr+a €EEa sq t f++r w s*. rq6 t'6 arefl{ f,rrdr t +?ttffi rffi.rut fr g*en 3i1-{ ye{rfflr *.
{@isa d *.-4 a.ra-d 3itr cg El+cq
"* Ari t s-sdt + sfiffi
wapr w:fi actf, 3r+r 6:r Fn-e B , eI F 5ff trufr 4 qf rcoc tfu ftra-a t dfla ri*frrur cffiqT 6-da. t *-d-d.-dr +-rar st{ ffi
cffrql t sItffa mfuirRrzfr fi Ean 3il-{ csilFrf,r t raiqra * efi
Frfar m-rar t , * of T Td fi gair mr6o ffi gg s,ffird;rfr't Fdf6 6s fuft fr qil-fiur ot*-* + eTd-"q e €4Eilar
fs-qI ,rqr t r :r.q-{ fi warT g sX s-affi +.cA fi mrr-{dr rsal B r
tr6r ilr.fs. qtr gren t sr€ild jt sa-$ar a-fi fu{n aqr t srd.-dr-
gwr +'ft-q frBTrd-ar ta +.rar B r rrf a d a,,-id 6H 3fr t sif{ a fi
+t$ <r+q;seTrar t ' {s firrd *:nt S f-onr arqr s}fiaTr {difi t
I
I
i
i
i
i
)
I
I
qFr rr-q!-s 3(iD] ql{d rFI IFFI'r : srglgltqT 9
f+'Ur6 s-flr"} t3rtrlq qE'sfsq fralur t 3{fr6, T{Ei arn rrqro fr
fdqrffidr t diifud H6-dTt Esn Bftn d ffi* f6'i funr ffi
3itfrs 61 6lfud frqrurqr ?II, si"q srd' + HT?r.sEr dtFrfi fr
3EirER Bcmildr + arrur ilTS i Ts yflr{ (effig soz *
€Eq{fBa sx fS1 t ri*+rq 61 s a-ri fr ffisr fr tr qfr
mffiH fit gar + {€qr-+.d €frd ftfi-flur cB-qr *.r ria-q +,rqq
{€rfir qSdI t a cdrfi{ur * datr d 3{r{s } gcsq fi Rla-f,€tt +
fi{. frI +rdrqTr +.rfi qFfr +{itB. cB,qr + riaq w 16 sTrt H 3ik
egrdt afih t rqrqrfi +r;n qFn r qfr qf il€t f+-qr apn, 3{rff s;rdr
€f6d qurtrr+t t ftlqrs fr clfrql fr ftnqqar t dEirr Jt nl*sdrs
5g6 frm 3ik fff$ Tfi ror+ fr 3i1.{ 3{fu+, ftrqtrrqi Affi r ts c-6R
+-d s{+R ri*fi{ur cB-qr d ffi ildd TsA 4I 3{c-fr ffi
fr 3rssa ildI 3lk fsh qfturnrssq qf+-{ur cfr-qr t 3fin-d rccgt
6'r gtm ilrfr, EtrS fr gd r.qrt t qdrs{ur *t A1R sri * ft-A
q*+-{ur sRF fi fusTfter +t q-6 SnR q6; +'rfr 6 pa+ m
+-rqfi fi $r t W 6'1 3rfift-6 ctrnfr fir qtrm ftqr rrqr r
$E'ftqq fi ilf,d q*+-ruT Hftfr 6i {s* $fratr ai qrr +ri C'aaa
r,ri t ?16 3rBidr{'t fu dd-+.$rr cfu'qT ,i ffiI +r+e rd sr-t
den cPfiqr * €Ttr €Ffl]-dr +-{-i t 1+-S sfr Tt.q 6-r ceTraerdt 6a fr
[rTTttt;r l+-qr or]r qf+- srtt-ca t+r lit it sffia rcqrq fr gwr +
3dr6afi €ffd, ?t{ +l;ffr €ERffilr / 3{rE-fi ar:r lar qdrfiur q'ffiqr
* €rer se.$m t fsAA 5*r qr srsrtrRur sq t tr-qr nfi Er+r sl
q-6dr f r
TEaRr+i fiI {frrrr, rS 7franm ft +-t sR FClar €tra, vdrfiu
rBfr aqr #a ur+r h +.rqifu+R it t r ttnv 9 (3 ,r), qrr 11 aqr
27 (2\ ) q-Fd t ffrrffir+t fi sHrerT fI ,r€ t rfjt t Eo €r rrman
il6f, ER fir a,$ t I T-d t frrrdt jt trft sfrerr + 3{rtrn q{ qff+{uT
cTi,gr +i ftw. Gr-i aq B- q rrffr lrd f crms fuqr q-qr ti r
q#ffr fi sfrar *r r+fuon qffiq €tTa +,ri +i $fu-an t sfr
drf#+. 5c t g9T g3{T t, st;qerT (rs ER c*fiur S+a ffi sr} t
(ii)
(iii)
39oz qd)\*z
l0 THE CAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY fPenr ll--Sec. 3(ii)] -
(iv)
(v)
qaqtq +t$ dg dg-*,rft ffi + <ra-g< tifro'tw +i E-Crar qr frrFd
rr+r +iarq nff il+r t f,rcarsrfrt t q**.{ur fi $fraiT tr6'FrffFzr
cqrdt t ffi qt risR ,t trranm qf+.{sr clfut tdRT 3Frarqr
erqtr
nfrRfua a"di C 16 q?Tr a-frf,r t B. 2oo7 jt r'+ sftfr Eonr v-ffi
flfraTr ffI ,6 ?fr ffiI 3{L:{qrdr d. fi. r's. strrc ila.rea dq4d
Btrr+ (s{Ecrr fflO, * fi a+ram, .rardra scfr}am (rsmd
ffrrd) iln (ra. $;t;iT, ffiordfd rrden+ 3rffi A fi ?fr I 2O1O d
+rfrffir aE fu)q-s Hftfr i fi S ffit wqerar Ei. A. fr. {r#rd,
r5re-+ ailfr|rrm (frfr), slT.T.3r.c. e fi S dqT BsA fl-*q *.sq jt
d. r's.*. gtnr, frelvfr als-r, Et (4e-fr) ufuar q"ar, +iq+-a fifum
@q-u.ar fuf,ra) S (' +. ildcrr?rq, sqfrtsr+ (frc Bfrr4 d,n grfr
ewder A-ftTrfr rfrq+ Bhm lrrr+a E-an1 srB-fr $ r fg frl'is-fr
g'Rfr i T6 Eos.q RqT f4, Gqtd * dFrfi + qr}Id i.T6 ?isi-{
3Traiqr B fu +-offiftqfs aqr ME-d * ftryur fi trqr-*irm r+-e
frcarer+ 6t gcar if srm'+ 6 I
q6 H-& H B' ffi *-dft-dT lrre fielry rEnr ('frtEBE Hs-d,
qfreAEE zoz r'+r* dFr+- a?.,r +-ffiftqfs 70% +;vt * mra *
cI'H q-Srfiul rFrrur qrr +l ft{€a s-{A + frt ddr6{ur HAfr A
frwfrEr fr * {dtt+. d*+-rsr +.{ri drd rym rift-o icrqt ari
3rrcTrqr ?rq'r qr 31t{ q-6 a-fr rs s€-i ga s-cqiqt 6r %€-tfe1-d clqT I 5s
+re t tst Fn H A ri"n-qvr €frfr i sqra s?crEt q; ft-i un, SlayJ* rra rrq +-Fcfut d +drf,d ct'rs-{ur s} F{rrd +-t-i fr frwltqr
nfr *I t t ga rerEt t frt qtrrwT lfiFrlur q;r 6t frrF a-ri mr
sffiff riff5-qur frfle drd <qra srifi-fi icrqt d srrdrd tr{ 3Trrnirfr B
d rcfldt *t gtur + 3rr6-ilfr + xTq s;rdtar +rar t rik fs c-+.R
maa arfr aar vrjgTt +- Rfr ilfuH 6r {i:flaET +t y;e a-dr t ffir
I trfl u-E!-s 3(ii)] ql(d 6] nnr$i : 3l{lltlt{sl ll
3teTr {s Etr4rq' fi sct{r{rs 1 i sFafua 6Rqt t rfr *r sr s+-fr
Bt
+ffiftqT-€ so%+lMqfrfi 5% fS dA-+' il Hrrd fr tftfu+-{uT
€Gfr A 22.02.2011 d g$ 3{q-fr 315fi d-d6 ii qr fuq fr-sT R
"dtfi-6 fr gteTr aqr ft-#nqt fi sqa-etrar *'+r*ur arn dfiowr +'niJ
ard r,artr 3fl;rs rR, 3f,fift-*, irdt fi are t riffiq fr[F ffiqr
BIq/EIqs frqr srct" ffi f,rean* rt sffi-q rr++q EI frqrf,d-dr EiT
qrqa (rilfrSo qra t'w 6 f+ur am H st (qrf,fl $rfi +i asf-dr t
a) ctrqTur Erdl 3rmrfi fi 3{rt} FdR +t qR -dr fi r rm$so c-dT+ fr
frl Es66or 6T srffFq q.d-+' t aqT F$ Erffrar w fr qftaTur Erdl
gra.rn EI cfr F+,rg ar*r fr czmd €r-ffJt *'sc fr a++a F+-{:r aal t,
ffi ffr rrrafi q-r * sfr Erfrialff c-drd 8'r rns * qrdr r rS rs
116 t a++a +.[i t ra-ar Bq srA Erd ftfua qfid fi €-,qf,F6
trsr+aaT sT q?IT raar t aqT €Fqs. fr m' vg fr sel d
€Tar;m-fiur +-ra t I qfq ('ilS50 arfl fr-q 6idr H di ftqr-ffidr {tu*'
rtfr t t TE-dFfr ffi 1971 + ftq-rr 19 it 6fr;Tcr-+1 +.r
ffiEa E?ft*-{sr Cffrfta-d fr-qr aqr H:
I
frcanmt ar
c?flq-tur
1u *'affrr atrr
qrfla, qr*r (Trfr
Fdqr+ffir) ytaroT
vlEsfr'cr rnOfir'
fi{ vf,Aoo
fr.znslBatars
aqr h qft('qtrq
qrir6'Erdr (Filqr
ElcIffidD YfrqrDr
vljsl'an cnfifrfi'fiK
qrfiso
fr.qrfrfirfirrs
fTil Tt
vrqn cfi
3rfu'5 frqma i s1- soo
€rtrrur Ecrf,d 501-5,000 2.001-20,000 Fd t'rf,T
ran ftqmd 5,000 t 3{fu-fi 20,000 t 3{fufi gd nt
M fr$ft-fr Eartr cE-a Es-fufila 3a6:,t + ggsn, srEwadra q.r sfr {u
frsrf,crdrt{6-r) 1,562.62 E.erqlffi4rfr t a-dfu +i@€ .61 221567
1-50ilF 3{ft-6 Eqr+a 1-200 gd ara
J
201-2,000 sd qrdr
J
12 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXI.RAORDINARY [Parr Il Src. 3(ri)]
E.rmrft;alrnq aii +dwr{fists+ fi tg Ecmddr 159.48
fr.enqlffiarff t r qf €c€ H fu Ta}cnFttrdr€ * ffigqdrrtta ffi Eqrea. t I
z16 deTr{dr t fr *a #t + frirur 6r EcrftaT fs + drE fr (Jtr 1s62.62
fr.rnqlffiflTff vd zzt.su E.anqlffia* + d-E d) rFft r ararF+ ra #t rr
Rarur Eqr+-a (159.48 FarerffiurO t il ffi efi $-q q-.+, t qqrqr Eqr+-d
t t t-sr g-€fr('rdf+, +f eR r+rmfit it e-.i+- sfu-q 3ftr+{ 6} ffi qr €-5f*.qr
6tfr t 3it{ rr+r +ifrrr rsh trffi afi qa r++e t ;qrar Ecr+d dET t r +iqr-dr
sdTrdt t fr('3n+,gr 3fltrsq+-drui) daitfr hn-ffift fr E-arqr 4qr t lS .Ea+or * qa
firranm $;qro 6rH-+'rfi r dd +r rlrror s-FttT i+,qr ild.r qG(, l, fg ren t
fr(r qdf+lur + t*Er aIe it q-6 €qE Fs t cmqr erqr t 16 q#+-isr sRfr +
fr;sn-ft{eit t qsn fde-a Ecr4a"T cmt €-fifi rq{t+a :n+gr q-FiTft +} tara
d rqi fl T6 FFc t t*. fr^,rur rcqra {f, q?:+ t;{IIqr frcr+a t 3r?.lt( €-8r gu
EsT+dnT EiT w u*r gu Evr-+aaT 4g + mrd C- +dc+rdrqns soo te
50 f,S t I Efla ecrd + qf+-{vr * Rr' ftfi-fiur sfrft * hn_
frftfi + -rq-en E'+vr * ra firarerfi fr ;qrEr Erft6Tr6 a tte + Tfl+fr ,i e-firot.
3iltRlrfi t r fs gag-c + srfra-( grt$ l17.07tgg7 +t:ndfa 169fi d-6*, d
,v-e fr <qnr Eft-s-a fun-E'{rit t 3""iufr + Ert rt €qr&fir'r a.q's}|{ s-acre +
c*"+-{rr 6i -t{adfta +{ Ecr lti *-f,fr a$ satin t caa.ra fi-ftng qar+r am *
ila 16 lfr q-+Tqi fr s{6 qq vrfr d c*6lqq-flTurq{ +l ercre d-AlF-csa F,{i €l
e+Efr fr I
Frdrg + df*n gv Ekr c{ e-6-s gt f* +qr +-eh:+r#,H <-a €rgqqfta.t-fr 6T
s"c)-qa lw q-.dt t ;rrrcr arF-+rr+' t r *q(.ff 6t a+n s zra rt nsr Erqr t B.
freloo €Eft !d $i{.fr 6T M a +..1e'5ffis a-a orgrs}qfta +.r szrtra
rya ue+i t;qra ilfr6R-6 t 6r-6 a-& dtfu T6 qef a-a {€t fi !-trS50 +rsqr qr
3{rtrTfud H B-dfu am} 4qfe H fr I'*SSO rr*r frea FfiFLq +i?T-dd 6r dEE
seTmdr i'fr(, Trt'-rr defi-frur + trsrs t sfi t I
s(,.qs h F€ il& +r snrffr ('u-s 3rrs sfuaraq fir ar*' t so-sa +r frqr e*r
FdtR qE frcarem fut it src-drqr#t i azn-+* a; 3rfr6c{ afi t r fui ,t
{*- + r.+en, srflwreffra srfiFzr 6c t hqr+d {gefi-d1 t ;-df6
+-dtqSfi$)-€ r-a frqmd $d qarl t I gr+r e-+s-a edtqrgfrdrs fi ntar
roa ftq-a661 *'srq:ra Eq'*d Aut (gd fio * snm t r qa u+ ffi F,fr Bffi 3TrS frrn-fr{sil + rysn $EHfr n& fi a.-g t r g-s.frq 3rr{S 61 314fi,
I
,
I
i
I
I
: I r{rq II-Eo-e i(ii)l qlfd i6l 1rqT, : J{IITttRsl
3mJR CT fuqr ?r-qr eIT I
(viii) s.r{a + dEa sffi 6rrflRft yfrF-qa.ffi.ar-q slk r*q fud H +
457 +rt+( d cfrEIfud rfr +rfi r
l3
' 315fi (d gtafi d-dn * S(,(.€ sl rdttqrFtlsts 50%+ srgq{A{fa s% fS qfrqEat frv mmls) * a-ra artr riaro.tor sHruFFr ilq€ ffi/ff.-rF{ Fri } grel il+-$rr-dlti *rr 6dA t 3mtr c{ grrTr (Fq EvtqdaT) +-r*uil. t 9(a) qfr+_tor qrrff
fu/Frg B(r aK' I trS +Rur t s{rrfrq q,rfr g{sn qftiII # dq 14.a.20.,,
q6i 3rqfr sqfr fr B.q 4q ari f'r +atqrEtrfu 50% + sqq5ft1na s% fS 61 9(4)ftt + qrqo frrixor t fr(r s{Ftrq f+.srat qra nqa^, ili *.anur arfr rorun' r ftfqtur, &r=T{ur, rtr{ur *i er+, } frq grft-d EtR-d crqr sR, qd (.m-freMt ard E?f+-{ur f fi rO ;rR, 6} +df+rr a.rar dm a-fi t r gc*' srq fitrRr 9(4) h rfa +ilfqr$funs 50x + srgqrsqta S% f,S rcc6 t ri"frfr{ur arefi gf,qr$'fr r+ral+eidr nfi t +dF6 qrrr 9(3) t 3{ilJrd t€r mt$ qfiflur
orri Erar;rfi'H ffi g{an Hn.gS fi diq fr a-$ t r
(vi) fdEflt f,r aiq t etfid 6(r q-s-a t 6'.Fq-fr fi rflrd + fr(, rd-d s-d ft(, aqqftffi #r ro ntt rmT stt-6t zr€ | Td: ft ,6 r-fiail S cf,r {il B. srrs r-+rtr
6Fqff t 3?crdt fi frq r6-d fr;q ,rq qJAfl"T :ltr +rE * 2Oo7 f f,r ,6 EfretT * difr.fi
rccrd * qtroloT * fr('sTrr +iiitfi :n-+qqrdBrt t Sdfu-d q-fi"Tt Aaffiftr fr:iR eqra
a-& ffrr rEr qr r eilcrd{ ?t€ #6 ar,-d * :ncflfu* aiq fi s*r s, u-carrt or +tg frvu
1{ B I
f{ailf,€tft h T-.q + frr, :nc-{rfu.6 ora-a t aea rBrrtra il. izra or:^ra fi a5a
frFfin fss f,r t+661 t frv mffi cffia ;rfi ilfi I t{T c-fi{, w a# B-6rd4r
eTFa6tr[ B- rsrrqn fqrrur gfuftqq fi a-6a +riarf 3rR frrdnfr 3rfrfi.q-q + ga-dr-d
aiar$ gar g.au H ffi +Tfi Erq fr rnq-ofuo s@ cffid etfi B.r <r-nr rq.an
Ffifr tt euB6 6 Bsd €rat;q Rf{il 3nrdr cw€Gq- 6rtEr$ + frv :ifuBa-A* rr*
d r s('rs +i affie s-d 3rlr frddnfr aftfr+s + a5a orffi fr{i fr }fr +tf e-eratnrff t I ddqfrFirl 4 +B rcorr i f{d 3{q-i cens6-fi. gk frfr6 rrfr.+n fl q-qIa
fuor t * fu + Bsffiftn + $-r6c fi('(.€ fi rcqlui +t $fueTE a +-ci h frr
frdRr+t fi glq6d *.sc fr t r ff..cann:rftfrq-a t ;rea +rtsrf j€ sEra 6r r*r.ff fi
rgvn f'rrarvr+i + JQd Eftc-aa + fr('t ffi araE ?rqr cer3i) a;t snfu.ff h E-d*ur* fr('icrq srTB"f, t I
(vii) s-r+Tr t cqr q{ 6rf {*-auftd 6riq.$ fi 3{r?16r .F'r +t$ m;rr aa' 6hr qrftr
rqtffi qRr 27(2) + n6-d sffi fs arri w jE-d Lqrd at t. q|a :nr$ fr fuErnrt t
?8e3 sd)n- E
I
t4 THE GAZETTE OF INDI,A : EXTRAORDINARY [Pem ll-Sec. 3(u,$
(ix) ilf,d 3it{ ffic, d q*6'{q TGITUIII{ fi am t fr fr-qrdl'€qq s-qat t ris dr-a'etr
FdBd B t rq o,.ryfr *- qfir{ur rglultt;r fr grg arq t gnr rgrqa i'ars +r €-dfd-{
mrar c-sarraa 3fl'{ q--d fr.qr t A {€ 3r{{ql T{ {6 a-6 -dr 6q-cqot t f6- das d'tsr
frg H-6+d-d c-{rqfi-d aff fr-m arar urfrv w t
(x) {g qrff-d rl{ srrrr?rT + G-{R 6.{i q{, rrcol. -qrq dE ir.F' a-6i 6tn Gtr ilfi'
qtrfirrr 6r sflfiqr 6t stqtrsr *i g$ ,irfr'* ETfr 3lh aaaE-"rtr Jtcr-it fi gnn dtitfi
o-q3f t FGcET 3ilr qqr+Fq t 3nfi-ara fi frr' Eqrr6 (:rqt-a @+qur efrfr) fI
arqar aftor 6fi *I grd?Tfr sfrB'q-fr Er uw ZllZy h a-5a offi fuq ilit{ {r ardt t t
:itr ra: sr< rtru-+fr+tw sRfr fi 314 fr, 315 fi 3itr 318 fi ffi d ff'r erg
frwfrari qr fa-qr* 6,ri, *ss d ('m €rES-s fI 3n{ + fr-dr6'30.6.2011, 01.8.2011 3ifr
24.8.2011 +i frI qf r€Effi tar 10.08.2011 3ik 30.08.201 1 61 3{rqtB-fi €a-dTfut d fr
,€ cqfrqt .'-'.rr 3tl-r$ €I i,t{ d fi ert eqfrqt qr fr-+r sG + dra qait-d-.dTr q-t
$rfu fiqr arar t ier ffi E-dIR-d *rc cl-+ara fro (rs S-cffinl fi ars fr
fl-.anlr yfufrqsrgos fr tna 9(3) fi d6d qffiEs ilrtr6r, ('ffifrr 20% (.{qr
eft'crfr, +ffircRsf€ 10% ariqrt cfrcTra git{ fficils 50x+ sr{qrfrBa 5"2 f dt
E'frfird 6 6t rifi-+w lraTurq'r t.aaqdRr 6.s fu-ql or-ar H I T6'r 16 sfi :n*r fuqr
urr t ft +ictrcrgm€ 50"2+sricnftE-a s"z t fr qftllrd t frr, rmr 9(4) + df,f, ssfi
rr*,fi'sr rrffTuFi;r F{R B! md t t gEim? +Fqfut eer-\T G-{q6.ra pa6 fi' Pl-,irfr t
Rq Ei dq SI :rqe fI 3fi^d-nfr fi dre g 1 1ffi+-rrr €ftft 3ik rcq sc+lt ge :+r*rJ
fir firql-aTq-f, sFfrt+a +ffi r
ll[r. q. l?-8/loo7 frfr -l { er"q+ 1g;1
q-<{ dr, ftifl+
--z<-
rIfG 6'l {ltiqn : 3T{lTtIRulITIFI II-gE-g 3(iD] r5
MINISTRY OF AGRICT]LTURf,
(Department of Agricultur€ and Coopcretion)
NOTIFICATION
New Delhi. rhe I 2th Oclober.201I
s.o. 2353(E).-Whereas following report! in media of improper payments by N4/s De-Nocil crop
/ piliCtioti'Ua, presently known as IWs Dow Agro Sciences lndia Pr.t. Ltd. Mumbai, a
subsidiary of lWs Dow Chemical Company based in USA, to Govemment officials il India, a
preliminary inquiry was conducted in which it was found prima facie that such payments were
made and the matter was entrusted to the Central Bureau of lnvestigation (hereinafter referred to
as CBI) for investigation and the investigation conducted b.v CBI has brought out that M/s De-
Nocil Crop Prorection Ltd. paid illegal gratification and extended pecuniary advantages to
Government officials for expediting registration of its products Acetamiprid Technical (Pride)
and irs 20% SP Formulations. chlorpyriphos 50o/o + cypermethrin 5% EC Ourelle) and
ch.lorpyriphos l0% Granules (Dursban 10 G) under the lnsecticides Act, 1968. M/s Agro Pack.
a product formulalor of the company, facilitated the palment of illegat gatification b)'
accumulating funds in their books by loading bogus incidental charges in their bills placed on
M/s De-Nocil and raised fund for bribing the officials of Registration Committee by muoal
agreement u,ith rhe company q.ith the approval of the Managing Director. A chargesheet had
been filed in the court of Special Judge, Ha4'ana at Ambala by CBI against Dr. R.L. Rajak.
former plant protection Adviser 1o Govemment of India and Shri Satvbroto Banerjee. consultant
appoinled b1 M/s De-Nocil. under the PreYention of comrplion AcL 1988 and the coun had
taken cognizance of offences. cBI also informed that investigation against Mr. Kevin Eden. the
then Managing Director of I4./s De-Nocil, a British national. is being continued.
Ard u'herea-s. after reconsideration of the matter in lighl of rhe findings of rhe
investigarion conducted by cBl, it had been decided that a review of the registration of the
above-mentioned products granted under section 9(3) cf the lnsecticides Act. 1968 (hereinaftcr
referred to as the Act) may be carried out by the Registration Committee (hereinafter refened to
as RC) and its recommendation on the .issue of cancellation or continuation of registration
conveyed to Department of Agriculture & Cooperation (hereinaf,er relerred to as DAC):
furd u,,hereas. RC, in its 3106 meeting held on 30.06.2010 decided to constilute a
committee to undertalie a fresh review of the products in question of DAS and the said
Cornrnitt-ee considered the matter and submitted its report 10 RC:
1
I
l6 TT{E GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY lPam Il-Sr-c. 3{ii)l
And whereas RC. considered the matter in its 314ft, 3l5h and 318fr meetings held on 24
& 27.01.2011,22.02.2011 alid,27.04.2011 respectively aDd decided to withdradcancel the
certificates of Registrafion obtained by IVl,/s. De-NociI crop protection Ltd., presently knourn as
DAS, a subsidiary of M/s. Dow chemicals company, USA for the products (i) Acetamiprid
Technical (Pride) (ii) Acetamiprid 2u/o Sp Formulation and (iii) Chlorpyriphos l0% Granules
@ursban I 0G) as these were obtained by the registrant by adopting unethical practic€s, and also
decided that the registration of Chlorpyriphos 50plo + Cyperrnethrin 5% EC (NurelleNurelle-
D/Nurelle D-505) issued to the registrant u/s 9(3) b€ withdrawn/cancelled because of uethical
practices adopted by the registrant and safety ftigher toxicity) of the fomrulation as well as due
to availability of altematives, and firther decided that subsequent 9(4) registarions issued for
Chlorpyriphos 5V/o + CyPrmethrin 5% EC shall also be withdrawn/cancelled;
And whereas having considered recommendations of RC and the material available on
record" a notice was issued to DAS (formerly known as lv{/s De-Nocil crop protection Ltd) on
25.05.2011 to show cause within I 5 days of receipt of the notice why the certi{icates of
Registration issued to the company u/s 9(3) of the lnsecticides Ac! 196g, for the above
mentioDed products should not be cancelled by the cental Govemment in exercise of po-*ers
n/s 27(2) of the Insecticides Act, 1968;
And whereas, DAS sought additional 3 weeks' time to consult their attorney whereupon
extension of time upto 30.06.201 I for frling the reply was given;
And u'hereas, M/s Dua Associates representing DAS, in a letter dated 27.06.2011 asked
for additional documents and also filed a preliminary reply dated 30.06-2011 to the show cause
notice;
And u'hereas additional documents w-ere provided to DAS r.ide letter of even number
dated I L07.201I and a hearing w.as fixed on I0.08.201 1;
And whereas, Dua Associates representing DAS. in a letter dated 01.08.201 I s-,aled that
only copies of a part of the documents had been supplied and while making additional
submissions also asked for specific documents to be supplied ro them;
And u-hereas in the hearing held on 10.08.201l, preliminary submissions were made by
the attomey Ms. Romola Kamani and Dr. Suresh Ramachandran, country Manager and Shri
fllimanav Gaur on behalf of DAS and Dr. s.K. K]rurana on behalf of clB&RC and plea for
supply of additronal documents of D.A,S rvas noted;
And *'hereas additional documents were supplied vide letter of even number dated
10.08.2011 and the date of hearing fixed on 24.08.2011 which was subsequently postponed to
30.08.2011 at the request of DAS;
t
.[qH lt-Ers-c i(ii) ] qlIil i5l TITIT, : 3i1[ql{ul 1,"
And whereas additional submissions were made by DAS in their letter dated 24.08.201 1;
And whereas in the final hearing held on 30.08.2011 submissions were made by the
attromey Ms. Romola Kamani and Dr. Suresh Ramachmdran, country Manager and shri
Atimanav Garn on behalf of DAS and Dr. S.K' Khurana on behalf of CIB&RC;
And whereas on behalf of DAS fotlowing substantive submissions were made vide
letters 30.06.201 1,01.08.2011 and 24.08.2011 and in hearings held on 10.08.201 I and on
30.08.201 l:
(i)Thataspersection2ToftheAc!underwhichnoticedated25.05.20llwasissued,
the only basis for cancellation of registration.of an insecticide is if use of the
insecticide-istikelyloiwolyesuchrisktohwnanbeingsoranimalsaslorenderil
earydient or necessary to lalre immediale action " Clause (2) of section 27' which is a
corollaryofclause(l),providesrhatifasaresultofitso'Uim,ifivestigation,oronthe
basisofa,report,rcceivelfromtheStateGovemmearld,afierconsultalionu,ith
theRegistrationCommioee'theCentralGovernmentis'satisfied'thatuseofsaid
insecticide, viz., the insecticide u,hich has been prohibited for sale/distribution/use
under clause (1) for the time being, is or is not likely to cause any such risk [as
menlioned in clause (l)] then the central Govemmetrt may pass such order (including
an order refusing to register the insecticide, or cancelling the certificate ofregistration
thereof (if grantetl) as it deems fit in the circumstances of a case The basic minimum
requirementssetforthinsection2Thzvenotbeenfollowed.Therewasneitheran
'investigation' undertaken by the Centrai Governm'ent nor was there any
'consultation' with Regisration Committee [as contemplated in section 27(2)] None
of rhe factors mentioned for invocation of the extraordinary power of section 27(2t
exist in the instant case.
(ii) That extraneous rationale mentioned in the notice is alleged illegal
gratilication/extension of pecuniary advantage for expeditilrg product registrations
which is the subject matter of ongoing judicial action' This aspect is not a
permissiblebasisforRegistrationCommittee'sconsiderationwhosejurisdiction
under the Act is limited oJy lo ,regisler insecticides sJler scrutinizing their formulae
and verifiing claims made by the importer or manufacturer' as lhe case mo1 be' as
regards their effcacy and safety to human beings and oimals
"
(iii)TlutDAChasresortedtosuccessivereviewsofregistrationsdespitetherebeingno
statutory or other provision for doing so' The Registration Commiuee examined and
review. erl the suDDorting materials ior the said products on two occasions' viz" in
?8D" 4 {7u-{
l8 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA ; EXTRAORDINARY lP.Aru II-sEi. i(ii[
2007 and in 2011 without asking DAS to participate in such reviews ' ln 227i
meetiDg of RC held on 27.M.2m7 '.The Committee concluded that no inJbrmolion
with reference to safety and efiicacy of this product were overlooksd at the fime of
grant of registration and the qplications were conplete as per guidelines of the RC
in vogue., This shows that any alleged palments have no connection to the 'safetv
and efficacy' of lhese products.
(ir) That an expert committee was then appointed by RC for re-review which was chaired
by the same oflicials who participated in and concluded the first review. Dr. T.P.
Rajendran. Assistant Director General @P). ICAR and Dr. S.K. Khuran4 SpecialiS
Gradej who were appointed as members of the expert committee constituted in June
2010 were also part of the review committee constituted in June 2007. The report of
the expert comnrittee (of 2010) was replete with conjectures and surmises and it did
not have a lot of necessary materiaVinforrnation in relalion to the issue. Nonetheless,
rhe expert. committee did not find any technical deficiency in the said products or
regi stration thereof.
(v) That in its 3156 meeting. RC upheld a.rd affirmed that there u,as nothing untoward or
even illegal as regards the registration of the said products. Despite DAC seeking a
.detailed note clarifoing technical aspects of the recommendations' from RC. none
uas prepared by RC. In its 3l8d meeting held on 27.04.2011. F-C noted that the
decision for withdra*al/cancellation of Acelamapirid Technical and its formulation
\\.as not taken ,due to anl,adterse technical ospccls o,f these products'. 1l vt'as furthcr
noted that rhe RC u.as s,zli.-r79e d on the elJicacy o.f target pests as u ell as on thc sq/el,'
tc human beings and animols of Acelamiprid Technical and its Jbrmulation. there is
no justification to completel)t elimirate the products from lhe country" It was also
noted that these products are u'idely used in cotton crop of the country and 'no
cdverse impact o.f these products has been reporled an agricullure .from any olher
country, u,here lhey are regisrered. ' In case of Chtorpyrifos 10% G also, RC (as
noted in its 318s meeting) is 'satisfied v,ith its bio eJficacy to turget pests and also
noted that there is no adverse impact of this formulation in agriculture'. These
statements undermine proposed action as RC did not view these Products as involving
'risk to humon beings or animols'. As to registration of Chlorp;riphos 50% +
cypermethrin 5% EC formulation, neither the said notice nor the minutes of various
meetings offer any scientific studies or gfounds. The conclusion of expert committee
and RC that combination of ctrlorpriphos and Clpermethrin is more hazardous than
individual components is not valid as it is based on numerical values of LDso in rats
and mice even though data shorvs that LDso values are well uithin the Worlci Heaith
orga:rization's classification of Ctass II for hazard polential. As per data rt-hile the
acute LD5s values for the combination pnxluct are numerically less than the
1
I
I qrq II-E!-c 3(ii)] qr{d i5l IIGItH : 3IIlgFul l9
individuat partners it does not represent a hazard potential more than the individual
partners, Consequentiy, RC has vioiateci section 27(2) b1' proposing cancellalton
even after finding the products safe and efficacious. Neither the Central Govemment
nor RC is permitted to canceUwithdraw registratiom of the aid products as sought by
the said notice. The Central Govemment has invoked the extiaordinary provisions of
section 27 in the past only in those circumstances uhen an insecticide posed risk to
human beings/animals.
(vi) That allegations of unethical practices and investigation by cBI have been in the
knowledge of RC and the Central Government since 2007 and pending adjudication
before the Courr ofrhe Special Judge. Ambala. It was in light ofiuch allegations lhar
in June 2007, RC .critically evaluated' the informatior/data of said products and
concluded that the granl ofregistrations was proper and no information with reference
to safety and efficacy of said products was overlooked at the time of grant of
registrations. Affer 3 1,ears, a show cause notice rvas issued for blacklisting DAS lor
alleged '..inethica! practices for obtaining registlaiioll' oi said products in u'ake of
unprecedented publicitl and propaganda pursuant to judgment delircred on
07.06.2010 by the Court of the Chief .ludicial I\4agistrate. Bhopal, in a pending
criminal trial in Bhopal Gas Leak case eYen though there is neither any corporate
connection nor an1' other connecljon benYeen DAS and anl' aspect of the Bhopal Cas
l.,eak case. The Central Govemmenl blacklisted DAS for a period of {ive years Vtde
order dated 16.09.2010. Despite taking such unduly harsh measure, the ceniral
Gorcrnment no\Y proposes to Vex D.AS again rvhich amounts to double jeopardy and
severe r ictimization.
(vii) Thar ir is apprehended that the centrat Government had made up ils mind to canccl
registrarions of the products around or at the same time of issuing the blacklisling
order:
(viii) That it appears as a judicial process for inquiry and trial into the alleged acts of
irnpropcr pa.'-ments has already' been set inlo molion. the notice amounts to
intcrlerence with the judicial process and is not $'arranted u'hile thc crinlinal case
remains pending before thc Courl;
(ix) Thal use of trade mark/brand names ofthe products mentioned in the notice, instead
of their technical/chemical names is improper as these are regislered trademarks ol'
DAS under the Trademarks Act. I999 and thus afford an entirel).' differenl proteclion
under the extant inlellectual property la\\'sl
(x) That. therefore. the notice desen'es to be recalled/revoked"i.r'ithdrau'n,
n T}IE GAZETTL OF INDIA: EXTRAORDINARY fP.ART ll -SE.. 3(ii)l
And whereas, the replies filed on behalf of DAS and submissions made in the hearings
have been coosidered by the competent authority in DAC with following observations point-
wise:
(D Insecticides are toxic suhtanc€s and require to be regulated with a view to prcvent
risk to human and animal health and matten connected therewith under the
Insecticide Act and the Rules ft'amed thereunder. Registration is a critical process in
regulation of insecticides as this process is responsible for scrutiny to ensure that the
insecticide is safe and efficacious. It is central to the scheme of the Act. Nothing
must be allowed to corrpromise the integrity of registration prccess. In the instant
case, investigation by CBI has brought out that bribe was paid to a key offrcial ofRC
to expedite registration ofspecific products of DAS (then De-Nocil). The issue raised
by DAS is whether the basic requirements necessary to take action under section 27,
i.e., 'invesligation', 'consullation with RC' nd 'satisfoction' with regard to risk of
the products in question to human and animal health have actually been followed,
The facts are that after publication of media reports regardlng payment of bribe for
expediting regisration of products, a preliminary inquiry was ordered by the Central
Government and on the basis of findings of that inquiry, CBI was asked to conduct
further inquir,v for action under Prevention of Comrption Act if required. The
inquiry conducted by CBI brougbt out details of bribery and to whom and how it was
paid. Bribe was paid to the then Plant Protection Adviser IPPA) rvho has been
charge-sheeted by CBI. PPA not only heads the Directorate of Plant Protection,
Quarantine & Storage (DPPQ&S) but is also a key member of RC. CBT has also
reported that the accounts of lr4/s De-Nocil (now DAS) u'ere manipulated shouing
bribe amourt as incidental expenses uith the approval of the then lv'lanaging Director
of t^he company. On the basis of this izvesrrgarion, RC u'as asked by DAC to canl'
out a fresh review of products for registmtion of which the bribe *as paid. RC got
the products revier,r'ed and recommended cancellation/withdraual of registration all
four products - in case of three products adoption of unethical practices by the
company *as cited as the reason by RC and in case of fourth product adoption of
unethical practices as wcll as of violation of a guideline of registralion were cited as
reasons. The int'estigotion by CBI utd consultation u,ilh RC have brought out that
unethical practice adopted by the company by bribing a key official of RC
compromised integnty of the process of registration. The question is whether such
bribery atrected assessment of safety of company's products. Maintaining integriry-
of registration process is critical to ensure proper assessment of safety and efficacy cf
insecticides so registered. under the .Act. It is obviorrs that bribery for ;nJflumging the
process of registration compromises integnty of the process. If integrity of
registation process is compromised, it is no longer possible to ensure that assessment
I
I
[.qrq IFsu:s 3(iD] qT(l EI Tl! Irj| : 3l{lTtlliul 7t
(ii)
(iii)
of safety and efficacy of the product has been properly done. This is a serious matter
because any deficiency in assessment of safety and efficacy of insecticides can have
adverse implications for human and animal health and also on effective protection of
crops from pests. Given this position, it is clear that compromising integrity .of
registration process by bribing also compromises assessmeDt of safety and efficacy of
insecticides subjected to such process. The argument that the safety of the products
was not affected is not tenable because a situation wherein integnty of registration
process is compromised has the potential of compromising safety of the product as
well. Even if the safety is not actually compromised, rhe porential for comprornising
safety is created. This is neither mere conjecture nor a rcmote possibility: In the
instant case, fresh rcview by RC has bmught out that an important guideline
conceming toxicity of combination products (i.e. product having more than one active
ingredient) was not adhered to without any justification on record and' therefore, RC
has recommended cancellation of registration of this product (Chlorpyriphos 50% +
cypermethrin 5o/o EC) inter alra because of higher toxicit-v of the formulation. If the
integnty of the registration process hcluding assessment of safety of insecticide has
to be mainfained, an act of bribery of member of RC in connection with registration
has to be viewed as an attack on integrity of the process and has to be dealt with
effectively. If this was not done, faith of stalieholders including the public in sanctity
of the process would falter; further, it would invite further such attacks. The cenral
Govemment would, therefore. be failing in its duty to uphold the integrit-v of
registration process and consequently the safety of products subjected to registration
process, if it did not accept the rccommendation of RC to cancel registration oi
products for r*'hich unethical practic€ of bribery was resorted to on behalf of tbe
company.
To enable RC to fulfrl its mandate under the Act, it is imperative that the integrity of
registration process is maintained and any act of compromising the process dealt with
effectively. As illegal gratification/extension of pecmiary advantage compromises
registration process, including assessment of safety of the product brought out in sub-
paragraph (i) above, it cannot be held as an exhaneous consideration'
Review of insecticides, including multiple revieus of the same insecticide' is well
withinthecomp€tenceoftheRegistrationCommitteeandtheCentralGovemment
[sectiong(3C)'sectionllandlT(2)].Severalinsecticideshavebeenreviewed;some
of them have been reviewed several times' ln a number of cases' based on such
rel,ierr,s,certificatesofregistrationhaveheencancelledortheirconditionsvaried'
The power of review of registration is a logical corollary to power of grant of
registtation. otherwise it would not be possible to var-v or cancel lhe registration once
granted in spite of new information that mighr come to lighl' Rerieu of registration
?9te 6t)tt-6
i
2. THE CAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY IPaRT n-SDc. 3(iil
of pesticides is a common practice adopted by the pesticide regisering authorities the
world over.
(iv) Facts on record show that the first review was carried out in 2007 by a committee
headed by Dr. B.S. Phoga! the then Joint Director (Weed Science), Shd V.
Bhatnagar, the then Deputy Director (Chemistry) and Shri L. Ananth, the then
Section Officer. The review carried out in 2010 was by an expert commifiEe headed
by Dr. T.P. Rajendran, Assistant Director General (PP), ICAR and having Dr. S.K.
Khurana Specialist Grade-I, Dr. (I\,Irs.) Sarita Bhalla, Joint Director (Toxicology),
Shri A.K. Bandopadhyay4 Deputy Director @ntomology) and Ms. Kamlesh Miglani,
.Assistant Director (Chemisry) as members. This expert committee inter alia
concluded th^l "taith regard to Nurelle D formulatio4 there is a serious
apprehension about the loricity of the mixture of Chlorpyriphos and Cypermethrin is
higher than that of the indiidual pesticides. "
(v) Ir is true that RC recommended cancellation of certificate of registration obtained by
M/s De-Nocil (now DAS) jn respect of the products Aceramiprid Technical,
Acetamiprid 20% SP formulation and CbJolpyriphos l0% Granules because of
adoption of unethical practices by the registrant and not because it found these
products unsafe. lt is for this reason that RC did not recommend cancellation of
registrations granted to othet companies under section 9(4) for the same products.
The case for cancellation of certificate of registration f<rr these products is based on
adoption of unethical practices by the registrant which compromised assessment of
safetv of the products and thereby created a likelihood of risk to humans and animals
u'hich cannot be ignored f<rr reasons enumerated in sub-parapxaph (i) of this
parapraph.
ln case of Chlorp-vriphos 50?ir + Clpermetlrin 5% EC formulation RC decided in its
3 l5s meeting held on 22.02.2011 that the registration lle "v'irhdrau cancelled
because of unethical praclices adopled by the regislranl and safey' of thc J'ormulalion
as well as due to ovailability af ulternatives. " Toxicity of the active ingredient in an
insecticide is measured in terms of LDso value r*hich denotes the (lethal) dose which
kills half of the tested population. LDso is a general indicator ofa substance's acute
toxicity and is usually expressed as the mass of substance administered per unit mass
of test subject, such as grams of substance per kilogram of body mass. Stating it tltis
way allows the relative toxicity of different substances to be compared. and
norrnalizes for the variation in rhe size of the animals exposed. Lower the LDso
value, higher is the toxicity. Rule 19 ofthe Insecticides Rules, 1971, lays down the
following classifi cation of insecticides:
1
I
t
1
I qrq - .-s!-s 3(iD] qRiI iFI II!trlEt : SI{ITqRsl 23
Classification ofthe
insecricides
As per toxicology data submitted by M/s De-Nocil, acute oral toxicity (rat) of
Cypermetbrin is 1,562.62 mg&g, that of Chtorpyriphos is 224.567 mg/kg and for
chlorpyriphos + cypemethrin it is 159.48 mg/kg. It is obvious that cypermelhrin is
less toxic than chlorpyriphos. It could be expected that toxicity of their combination
would lie somewhere in-between (i.e., between 1,562.62 mglkg and 224 567 mgkd'
Hou,ever, their combination gives a toxicity (159.a8 mg/kg) which is higher than
toxicity of either component. This is because synergism in chemicals in each active
ingredient occurs sometimes when they are combined giving rise to a combination
which is more toxic than either of its constituent ingredienrs. RC's guideline on data
requirements for combinalion products,states that " Evidence in support that the
combinqtion is not more huardous than individual insecticides should be submitted-'
ln the agenda note for registration of this producr it was clearly stated that "In fiet qf
aboye data submission on various toxiciry paramelers ds per the guidelines ol the
Regisrration commiltee it is erident lhat the combinotion product i-t more loxic than
the individuol components, i.e-, Chlorpy'iphos 500 and Cypermethrin 50 EC in case
ofacuteoraltoxiciryRatandacuteoralfuxicityMice.Asperguidelinesofthe
Registration Committee for the registration of combination product' the evidence is
reiuired in suPport that lhe combination is not more huardous than individual
insecticides." Despite this input, RC approved registration of the product in its l69s
meeting held on 17 .07 .1997 without specifying rcasons for ignoring the guidelines set
byitselfanditisonlyafterthefreshreviewfollowinginvestigationbyCBlthis
omissionwasbroughttolighrandRCrecommendedwithdrawaVcancellationof
certifi cale of regisfation.
During the hearl'rg, the issue whether combination of Chlorppiphos and
Cypcrmethrin is more hazardous than individual comPonents was debated' It was
argu"a oo behalf of DAS that the conclusion of expert committee and RC that
combioution of Chlorpyriphos and Cypermethrin is morc hazardous than individual
components is not valid as it is based on numerical values of LDso in rats and mice
I
I
I
Medium lethal dose
by rhe oral route
(acute toxicity) LD5s
mg/kg body weight
of test animals
Medium ledral dose
by iire dermal route
(dermal toxicity)
LD56 mg/kg body
weight oftest
anirnals
Identification band on
Gc lalrcl
LExtremely toxic I -50 l -200 Bright red
2.Highly toxic 51 - 500 201 - 2,000 Bright yellow
3.Moderately toxic 501 - 5,000 2,00t - 20,000 Bright blue
4.Slightly toxic More tlao 5,000 More tran 20,000 Bright green
3Fea c t)il'7
24 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA ; EXTRAORDINARY lP^Rr II-SEC. 3(ii)l
even though dala shows that LD5s values are well within the World Health
Organizatisn'5 classification of 91s"5 11 f6y hazard potential. This contention of DAS
was refut€d on behalf of Secretariat of CIB&RC for not being in conformity with the
classification of pesticides in the Insecticides Rules. As per classification in the
Rules, Cyperrretbrin is moderately toxic (bright blue) while Chlorpldphos is higlly
toxic @right yellow) Their combination is in highly toxic range ftright yellow) with
higher toxicity than that of Chlorplriphos. This is a situation which was not
permitted by RC's guidelines. Thercfore, RC's recommendations made in its 3146,
3156 and 3l8e meetings for withdrawaVcancellation of certificate of registration
issued under section 9(3) for Ch.lorpyriphos 50% + Cypermethrin 5% EC formulation
to DAS alongwith withdrawaVcancellation of 9(4) registrations on grounds of safety
(higher toxicity) are based on rational and valid criteria It is for this reason that it is
not possible to accept the conlention of Crop Care Federation of India made in their
representation dated 14.04.201 1 that 9(4) registration of Chlorpyriphos 50% +
Cl,permethrin 5% EC should be continued for having been widely accepted by Indian
farmers for broad-spectrum control of insect pesf.s in field crops, declared safe for
manufacture, storage, distribution and use and placed in the same classification as that
of solo formulations. Also, there is no need for hearing compariies holding
registrations of the product Chlorpytiphos 50% + Cypermethrin 5% EC under section
9(4) as rhey are not registrant under section 9(3) u'herein safety aspects are exanrined.
('t,i) Re'r'elations during the course of CBI's investigation necessitated another revieu'of
registrarions granted for the company's products earlier. Fiesh review brought out
that grant of registration 10 the company's products by RC earlier and subsequent
revieu, in 2007 ignored an important guideline relating to data requirements for
registration of combination products. These events have no conneclion with crirninal
trial in Bhopal Gas Leak case. For act of bribery, prosecution under criminal law
does not preclude proccedings for liabilities ofcivil nature under relevant laws. Thus
it wor:ld be erroneous to conclude tlat proceedings under the Prevention of
Comrption Act and those under the Insecticides Act constitute double jeopardy
which precludes only subsequent criminal proceedings. Double jeopardy does not
preclude ordinary civil or administrative proceedings agains a p€rson who already
has been prosecuted for the same act or omission. There is no commonality in
blacklisting of DAS and proceedings under the lnsecticides Act either. In
blacklising, the Central Govemment has simply exercised its administrative and
legal nght as a procurer of pesticides to not procure Producls of DAS in conformity
with guidelines of DGS&D. Proceedings uoder the Insecticides Act are for proper
regulation of insecticides as per the scheme ofthat law which includes measures for
prevention of risk to human beings and animals.
I qFr n-E!-s 3(iD] ql(il i6l Il!fl.:l : gT{llqRUI '25
(vii) No ground for apprehension of predetennined action on part of the Government
should exis as action under section 27(2) lns been taken up based on
recommendations of RC after due consideration of the matter.
(viiD Procredings under criminal law do not preclude proc€edings under the lnsecticides
Act which has different aims and objecs.
(ix) In the label and the leaflet which arc part of the certificate of registrariol b'rand
names of the products in question are also mentioned. When the company has
proposed and accepted association of chemical name with brand name in the
certificate of registration, it is disingenuous 10 argue at this stage that the notice
should not have reflected any such association.
(x) Having considered the matter in its entLety, it would not me€t the ends of juSice if
the serious damage caused to the integrity of the process of registration and thereby
impairing the capacity of tbe regulalor (i e., the Registration Committee) to
dispassionately and objectively assess ttre safety aspect of tbe products is allowed to
go by uithout action rmder 27(2) ofthe Act.
And now, therefore, having considered the recommendations of the Registration
Committee made in its 31+6, 3l5s antl 318h meetings, the submissions dated 30.06.201 l,
01.08.201 I and 24.08.2011 as also submissions made in rhe hearings held on 10.08.201 1 and
30.08.201 I on behalf of IWs Dow Agro Sciences and the submissions made on behalf of RC, it
is hereby ordered that the Certificates of Regisration for Acetamiprid Technical, Acelamiprid
20% SP Formulalion, ChlorpFiphos 107o Granules Formulation and Chlorpyriphos 50% +
Cypermethrin 5% EC Formulation under section 9(3) the Insecticides Act, 1968 in the name of
tnlls oe-Nocit crop Protection Ltd (now M/s Dow Agro Sciences) are hereby cancelled- lt is
also hereby ordered that all Certificates of Registration under section 9(4) for Chlorpyriphos
50% + Cy,permethrin 5% EC Formulation are cancelled. A period of two years is allowed for
disposingofexistingstocksbyrespectivecompanies.TheRegistrationCommitteeandState
Governments shalt ensure implementation of this order'
[F. No. l7-El2007 PP I (Vol. II!]
VANDANA JAIN. Director
Printed by lhc Manater, Govemment of India Press. Rlnt Road, MayaPufl' Ne\r lxlhr-ll
and Published b\ th. Conlrottrr of Publcations, Delhi-110054'
0064