The Unlawful Association (Prevention) Tribunal order dated 27.02.2008 consisting of Mr. Justice Mukul Mudgal, declaring Deendar Anjuman as an Unlawful Association
Notification - The Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967
- Kind: Notification
- Under: The Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967
Text of this notification
Tf^tfo^toT^o-33004/99 * REGD. NO. D. L.-33004/99
UMtMonit
(Baxette of 3ndia
EXTRAORDINARY
STHT II-^TTJ^ 3-*&t-Wr5 (ii)
PART II—Section ̂ ^Sub-section (ii)
PUBLISHED BY AUTHORITY
U 381]
No. 381]
f
^ firefly , -qr^ 20, 2008/tPTFJ5T 30/ 1929
NEW DELHI, THURSDAY, MARCH 20, 2068/PHALGUNA 30,1929
Hf f^ft , 20 W$, 2008
^T-^RT (4) ^ 3FJSRTJT 3 "33<T 3rf?T5F̂ r ^ 3W&T ^ t
ÊT. 3ft 5 4 2 ( 3 T ) . - " ^ k TR^K 3 ftf«lftn?5K
IsMUxrflH (ft̂ RWT) 3?fafWT, 1967 (1967 ^ 37) ^ t
STRT 3 ^ t ^T-*TR! (1) 1RT 3TOT *lI*uT ^T TPfa ^ f̂ f
*TRcT TOSR ̂ iJF H5lMq ^ 3TfsRrâ T ̂ RsZJT ^T. 3TT. 1481
3RPRT fJRT <0H<K 3F*FFT ^ fsffa
W F R ^ ^ H?IICU ̂ 5t 3#RJEFTTwn^FT. an. 1597 (ST),
t ^ P 25 Rw*«K, 2007 SRT ftftr fa^ fib^l+dlM (ft^RT)
r
sfa, ^ h ? ^R^R ^, -5^T STfafWT efft *TRT 4 ^ t
^T-t*RF (1) 5RT TT̂rT ¥lRkl4 ĴT 3TCffa F̂R̂ ?nj ^F Tribunal consisting of Mr. Justice Mukul Mudgal, Judge
H+lftkl ^Rcft f ; 3?*^ :
[ m U 14017/7/2008-T^T. 3R&-IH]
3RTOT ^ I R Wf, ^p?T ^rf^
MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS
NOTIFICATION
New Delhi, the 28th March, 2008
S.O.542(E).-—Whereas, the Central Government in
exercise of the powers conferred by sub-section (1) of
Section 3 of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967
(37 of 1967), declared the Deendar Anjuman to be unlawful
association vide notification of the Government of India in
the Ministry of Home Affairs number S.O. 1481(E), dated
the 29th August, 2007;
And whereas, the Central Government in exercise of
r
the powers conferred by sub-section (1) of Section 5 of the
said Act constituted the Unlawful Activities -(Prevention)
^T-9RT (3) 5RT 3RTT VlfawT F̂T 3TCfr ^R^ ^ , aiftrq^RT
^fem ^T. 3IT. 1481 (3T).f f̂ % 29 3RR<T; 2007 f̂ >̂t M
-srNqi ̂ t gfe ^R^ ̂ , ^Tfe 27 "^TR ,̂ 2008 ̂ ^ 3T1̂ F
(fT^Rq) 3?fafw*, 1967 (1967 ^T 37) ^t R̂T 4 5̂t
of the High Court of Delhi vide notification of the
Government of India in the Ministry of Home Affairs number
S.O, 1597 (E), dated 25th September, 2007;
And whereas, the Central Government in exercise of
the powers conferred by sub-section (1) of Section 4 of the
said Act referred the said notification to the said Tribunal
on 27th September, 2007 for the purpose of adjudicating
whether or not there was sufficient cause for declaring the
r
said association as unlawful;
And whereas the said Tribunal, in exercise of the
powers conferred by sub-section (3) of Section 4 of the
said Act made an order on the 27th February, 2008
1055 GI/2008 (1)
2 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA: EXTRAORDINARY [PART II—SEC. 3(ii)]^
confirming the declaration made in the notification number
S.0.1481(E), datedthe 29th August, 2007;
Now, therefore, in pursuance of sub-section (4) of
Section 4 of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967
(37 of 1967), the Central Government hereby publishes the
order of the said Tribunal, namely:
BEFORE THE UNLAWFUL ACTIVITIES
(PREVENTION) TRIBUNAL
In the matter of:
L
T
Gazette Notification dated 29-8-2007 declaring
Deendar Anjuman as an unlawful association.
And in the matter of:
Reference under Section 4 of the Unlawful Activities
(Prevention) Act, 1967.
CORAM:
HON'BLEMR JUSTICE MUKUL MUDGAL
Present: Mr. Sidharth Mridul, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Sanjay Katyal and Mr. Shailendra Sharma,
Advocates for UOI
Mr. Mushtaq Ahmed and Mr. Hameed Pasha,
Advocates for Deendar Anjuman Organization
with Moulvi Syed Basha, Former General
Secretary, Deendar Anjuman Asifnagar,
Hyderabad, A.P. With Dr. Md. Bashiruddin
Ahmed.
Mr. S. B. Faria, Advocate for the State of Goa.
Ms. Subhangi tuli , Advocate for State of
Maharashtra. Mr.H.N. Nilogal, Advocate for the
State of Karnataka. Mr. A.K. Rao, Advocate for
the State of Andhra Pradesh. Mr. S.P. Singh
Premi, Registrar of the Tribunal.
Mr. Y.K. Baweja, Director with Mr. Hardeep
Singh, Under Secretary, Ministry of Home
Affairs, Govt, of India.
In Re: Deendar Anjuman
ORDER
1. By Notification S.O. 1481(E) dated 29th August,
2007, the Central Government in exercise of the powers
conferred by the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967
(hereinafter referred to as 'the Act') had inter alia expressed
the opinion that the activities of the Deendar Anjuman
necessitated its being declared as an unlawful association.
The said Notification reads as under:
r
"MINISTRY OFHOME AFFAIRS
•t
NOTIFICATION
New Delhi, the 29th August, 2007
S.O. 1481(E).—Whereas the Deendar Anjuman is
having links with Pakistan, and is indulging in activities
which are prejudicial to the security of the country, having
the potential to disturb peace and communal harmony and
to disrupt the secular fabric of the country;
*-
And whereas, the Central Government in exercise of
the powers conferred by sub-section (1) of Section 3 of the
Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 (37 of 1967),
declared Deendar Anjuman to be an unlawful association
vide notification number S.O. 373(E) dated the 28th April,
2001. The Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Tribunal was
constituted for the purpose of adjudicating whether or not
there is sufficient cause for declaring the Deendar Anjuman
as unlawful association and the Tribunal upheld the ban
vide its Order dated 27th October, 2001. Deendar Anjuman
continued to be indulged in activities for which it was
banned earlier, a fresh ban was imposed on Deendar
Anjuman vide notification No. S.O. 479(E) dated the 26th
April, 2003. The Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Tribunal
was constituted for the purpose of adjudicating whether
or not there is sufficient cause for declaring the Deendar
Anjuman as unlawful association and the ban was upheld
by the Tribunal vide its Order dated 23rd October, 2003. As
Deendar Anjuman continued to be indulged in activities
for which it was banned on earlier occasions, a fresh ban
was imposed on Deendar Anjuman vide notification No.
S.O. 672(E) dated the 17th May, 2005. The Unlawful
Activities (Prevention) Tribunal was constituted for the
purpose of adjudicating whether or not there is sufficient
cause for declaring the Deendar Anjuman as unlawful
association and the ban was upheld by the Tribunal vide
its order dated the 14th November, 2005;
And whereas, the Central Government is also of the
opinionthat,
(i) during May to July, 2000, the Deendar Anjuman
engineered bomb explosions in Church premises and
other places in the States of Andhra Pradesh,
Karnataka and Goa;
(u) the said organization was engaged in distribution of
objectionable anti-Christian literature and pamphlets,
and in espionage activities;
(iii) the said organization has links at Mardan in Pakistan
and has been organizing bands of disgruntled
Muslim youths in India into a militant outfit for
launching Jehad with the avowed objective of total
Islamisation of the sub-continent;
(iv) the said organization planned to create disturbances,
particularly by promoting hatred and creating
suspicion and ill-will among the Christians and
Hindus as well as among other communities;
k.
(v) the said organization had directed its activists to
attack Christian institutions with the objective of
embarrassing the Government, particularly in the
international community and weakening it internally;
r
and
4
(vi) the said organization had plans to target major
infrastructural installation including railways, telecom
network, electricity grids, oil refineries and defence
installations;
\
And whereas, the Central Government is also of the
4
[qmil—^^3(ii)] T̂O >̂T
I U - fca. for «he aforesaid reasons, « « W d « r
Deendar Anjuman are detrimental to the peace, communal
harmony, internal security and maintenance of secular fabric
of the Indian society, and that it is an unlawful association;
Now, therefore, in exercise of the powbrsconferred
by sub-section (1) of Section 3 of the Unlawful Activities
(Prevention) Act, 1967 (3 7 of 1967); the Central Government
hereby declares the Deendar Anjuman to be an unlawful
association;
And whereas, the Central Government is further of
the opinion that if the unlawful activities of Deendar
Anjuman are not curbed and controlled immediately, it will
take the opportunity to
r
(i) create tension among the Christians and other
communities with a view to disrupting the social
fabric and tarnish the secular credentials of the
country;
(u) re-organize itself and indulge in sabotage of vital
installations.
•
And whereas, the Central Government is also of the
opinion that having regard to the activities of Deendar
Anjuman as mentioned above, it is necessary to declare it
as an unlawful association with immediate effect, and
accordingly, in exercise of the powers conferred by the
proviso to sub-section (3) of Section 3, the Central
Government hereby directs that this notification shall,
subject to any order that may be made under Section 4 of
the said Act, have effect from the date of its publication in
the Official Gazette".
•
2. Thereafter by Notification No. S.0.1579 (E), dated
20-9-2007 all the powers exercisable by the Central
Government was also conferred on the State Governments
and the Union Territory Administrations in relation to
Deendar Anjuman. This Notification reads as follows:
M MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS
NOTIFICATION
New Delhi, the 20th September, 2007
J
S.O.1579 (E).— Whereas, in exercise of the powers
conferred by sub-section (1) of Section 3 of the Unlawful
Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 (37 of 1967), the Central
Government%have declared the "Deendar Anjuman" as an
unlawful association vide S.O. 1481 (E), dated 29th August,
2007 published in the Gazette of India, Extraordinary, Part
II, Section 3, Sub-section (it) of same date.
Now, therefore, in exercise of the powers conferred
by Section 42 of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act,
1967 (37 of 1967), the Central Government hereby directs
that all the powers which are exercisable by it under Sections
7 and 8 of the said Act shall be exercised also by the State
Governments and the Union Territory Administrations in
relation to the aforesaid unlawful association."
3. This Tribunal was constituted pursuant to
Notification 1597 (E), dated 25-9-2007 published in the
Gazette of India, Extraordinary on the same date. This
Notification reads as under:
re : 3jmfclKul 3
"MINISTRY OFHOME AFFAIRS
NOTIFICATION
r J
New Delhi, the 25th September, 2007
S.0.1597 (E).—In exercise of the powers conferred
by sub-section (1) of Section 5 of the Unlawful Activities
(Prevention) Act, 1967 (3 7 of 1967), die Central Govemment
hereby constitutes the "Unlawful Activities (Prevention)
Tribunal" consisting of Mr. Justice Mukul Mudgal, Judge
of the High Court of Delhi for the purpose of adjudicating
whether or not there is sufficient cause for declaring the
Deendar Anjuman as unlawful association."
L
4. On 1st October, 2007, a preliminary hearing was
held, on which date the learned senior counsel for the Union
of India Mr. Sidharth Mridul along with Shailender Sharma,
Central Government Panel Counsel for Union of India, Ms.
Shubhangi Tuli, Advocate, for the State of Maharashtra
with Mr. P.S. Khatarkar, Additional Dy. Commissioner of
Police and Mr. R.T. Bagwe, A.I.O., S.I.T., Maharashtra,
Dr. Vasanta Kumar Gonu, Inspector of Police, CID, Andhra
Pradesh, Mr. Y.K. Baweja, Director along with Mr. Hardeep
Singh, Under Secretary, Ministry of Home Affairs were
present. It was ordered that notice be issued to Deendar
Anjuman under sub-section (2) of Section 4 of the Act.
The notice was directed to be served in the same manner
as the Notification banning Deendar Anjuman had been
served by the Central Government, i.e. through publication
in the Daily National and local Newspapers circulated and
published in the States of Andhra Pradesh, Maharashtra,
Karnataka and Goa as well as by broadcasting on radio
and television. Notices were also ordered to be served by
pasting them on the Notice Board of the office of each
District Magistrate/Tehsildar at the Headquarters of the
District or Tehsil as feasible. Notice was also ordered to be
served on Deendar Anjuman by publication in a Daily
Newspaper circulated in the locality where they have
establishments or presence in the State of Andhra Pradesh
and outside. Notice was also ordered to be served on all its
office bearers, at their respective addresses or, if under
r
detention, through the concerned Superintendent (Jail). It
was directed that notices be served within two weeks from
1 st October, 2007. It was further directed that the Central
Government and State Governments should produce
relevant documents and other material in their possession,
. "i
on which they intend to rely and they should also produce
the evidence by way of affidavits of the concernedofficials
who effected the service along with the supporting
documents. The proceedings were thereafter adjourned to
2nd November, 2007.
5. On 2nd November, 2007, the Tribunal noted that
notices as directed vide order dated 1st October, 2007 had
been served by publication in the National and local
Newspapers in English and in vernacular language by the
States of Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh, Goa and
-- - . -
Maharashtra. It was also noted that the contents of the
notice had also been broadcast over the All India Radio by
the States of Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh and Goa mid
4 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA: EXTRAORDINARY [PART II—SEC. 3(ii)]
1
telecast by Doordarshan by all these States. The notices
had also been served at the headquarters of Deendar
Anjuman at Asif Nagar, Hyderabad to the members of the
banned organization in Hyderabad and had also been
pasted at prominent places in the Collectorate, Tehsildar,
Mamaldar office in all the four states including the Police
Stations. This was on the basis of affidavits of service filed
by die States of Andhra Pradesh and Maharashtra. The
State of Goa was directed to file the affidavit in original
before the next date of hearing. The State of Karnataka was
directed to file its affidavit within one week from 2nd
November, 2007. Mr. Mushtaq Ahmed, counsel for the
Deendar Anjuman had also appeared after service was
effected on him on 15th October, 2007. He was directed to
file a reply by 21st November, 2007 and was also directed
that all documents, written statements and submissions
etc. be filed and be made available with a copy of the English
Translation where these documents are in any other
language. It was also directed that evidence by way of
affidavit was to be filed by 20th November, 2007 by the
Central and State Governments and an advance copy to be
served to the counsel for Deendar Anjuman. The next
hearing was held on 22nd November, 2007 and the written
objections were filed by the learned counsel for the
organization with an advance copy to the learned counsel
for the Central Government as well as to the respective
States. The learned counsel for the Central Government
further submitted that it was not feasible to record evidence
at Delhi and accordingly suitable dates may be fixed for
recording evidence in all the four States to enable the
Central/State Governments to produce the witnesses before
the Tribunal. It was also requested by the learned counsel
for the Central Government that since the period of
reference expires on 28th February, 2008, the recording of
evidence of witnesses may be fixed as per the following
schedule:
18th to 20th December at Bangalore
27th to 28th December at Mumbai
29th to 30th December at Pune
17th to 19th January at Panaj i, Goa
29th to 31 st January at Hyderabad
6. Mr. Musthaq Ahmed, counsel appearing for the
organization stated that service may be effected through
the counsel as far as the organization was concerned. It
•
was also directed by the Tribunal that all the aforesaid four
State Governments should give due publicity in the local
newspapers and through media regarding the dates of
sitting and venue of the Tribunal. The matter was to be
listed for recording of evidence of the States and the public
witnesses accordingly.
On an application moved by the learned counsel for
the organization for the pre-ponement of dates at Bangalore,
Mumbai and Pune, it was directed by the Tribunal that the
dates at Mumbai and Pune had already been fixed with the
consent of the learned counsel for the Government and
organization. However, the dates for the sitting of the
Tribunal at Bangalore were directed to be preponed to 17th
of December, 2007.
7. The Tribunal held the hearings from 17th
December, 2007 to 12th February, 2008 where the evidence
of witnesses were recorded. The witnesses also made
oral deposition on oath, proving their respective affidavits
and documents filed. The counsel for the Deendar
Anjuman also cross-examined the said witnesses.
A. Hearings commenced in Bangalore, Karnataka on
18th December, 2007? (The Karnataka State witnesses are
henceforth referred to as KSWs)
(i) KSW-1— Shri Shankar, ACP, North Division,
KSW2— Shri Mehaboob Khan, Police Inspector, KSW5
L
Shri Jackson D'souza, Sub-Inspector, Sub-Urban P.S.,
KSW6—Shri Nisar Ahmed, Police Inspector, Kundagol
P.S. and KSW7 —Shri Victor D'souza, ACP North Division
deposed to the effect that:
(a) SH. Muneeruddin Mullah and Rishi Hiremath
were the two main accused against whom cases
had been registered at Dharwad and Hubli in the
State of Karnataka. These were the same co-
accused who were being tried for the bomb blast
cases in special courts in Bangalore, Karnataka.
Rishi Hiremath was the Joint Secretary of the
Hubli branch of the organization and
Muneeruddin Mullah was the secretary of the
Hubli branch of the organization.
•
(b) These accused persons had the common
intention of creating disharmony and
disaffection between the two classes, i.e., the
Hindu and Christian communities.
(c) The organization was still conducting meetings.
clandestinely arid circulating literature in Hubli
and Dharwar Corporation. The aim of the
organization was to disturb the communal
harmony between Hindus and Christians. The
objective of the members of the Deendar
Anjuman was to create disharmony amongst
religious communities.
(d) It was their opinion that if the ban on the
organization was removed then there would be
communal disharmony in the area.
(e) KSW^2, further deposed that the organization
was still conducting clandestine operations
and spreading disaffection between Hindus and
Christians purportedly in the name and garb of
organizations such as Vishwa Hindu Parishad.
(ii) KSW-3—Shri Ashok, Circle Inspector of Police
deposed that:
(a) On 25th December, 2004, three accused persons
by the name of Sayed Mohammed Umar Faruq,
Sayed Magdum Hussain and Mohammed
flPin—^TO3(ii)] ^Rcf ^T TF3R5C : 3W|t | |<u| 5
Nasaruddin @ Manohar being the followers of
the organization, knowing fully well that the
Deendar Anjuman was a banned organization,
were propagating the aims and objectives of
the organization by disputing the literature and
collecting funds for the activities of the
organization in Jumma Masjid, Soundatti,
Belgam District.
(
(b) That the members of the organization were still
r
distributing pamphlets and conducting
meetings clandestinely. This knowledge was
based upon credible information received by
him through his resources.
(a)
(iii) KSW-4 Ramanna,
RamapurP
(a) Sayed Abdul Razaak @ Jamin AH an
active member of Deendar Anjuman organiza
tion was propagating the principles of the or-
ganization and conducting the meeting in his
house at Upparahalli, Tumkur, inspite of the
ban against the organization.
(b) That the members of the organization
were still distributing pamphlets and conduct
ing meetings clandestinely. This knowledge
was based upon credible information received
by him through his resources.
(iv) KSW-7 deposed that:
(a) The intelligence input report main
tained in their office clearly demonstrated that
even after the ban on 17th May, 2005 the ac
tivities of the organization were still continu
ing. On a question asked by the Tribunal as to
whether he had any inputs on these activities,
if continued, after the ban imposed on 29th
August, 2007, he aps posed. He also submit
ted the intelligence report in a sealed cover
which was taken on record.
B. Hearings commenced in Mumbai, Maharashtra
on 27th December, 20071 (Henceforth the State witnesses
are termed as SWs).
(i) SWl-Shri Bhimrao Namdeorao Shingade,
Police Inspector, SW2-Shri Deepak Dynoba
Shinde, API, Sonpeth P.S., SW3 - Shri
Balasahed Bhanudas Waghmode, Dy. Super
intendent of Police, Maharashtra, SW4 - Shri
Rafik (Yusuf Shaikh, Police Inspector, SW5 -
Shri Bhikanrao Shamrao Bibne Police Inspector,
SW6 - Shri Ranjit Dadasaheb Dhure, Police
Inspector, SW7 - Shri Mohan Anant Rao
Vidhate, Sub Inspector, SW8- Shri Mahesh
Madhukar Joshi, Police Inspector and SW10-
Shrihari Dagadu Munde, Police Inspector,
Local Crime Branch deposed to the effect that:
The members of the organization were respon
sible for the bomb blast in the States of Andhra
Pradesh, Karnataka and Goa.
(b) The organization indulged in anti-national
activities and tried to disturb the peace and
harmony of the country.
(c) The accused connected in the various crimi
nal cases were active members of pro-Pakistan
organization Deendar Anjuman which was
responsible for anti-national incidents.
(ii) SW9-Shri Pramod Shripad Khatavkar, Addl. Dy.
Commissioner (Security), SID, Maharashtra stated that:
(a) Lifting the ban at this juncture would encour
age the militant organizations and its members
in regrouping themselves in pursuance of their
avowed militants activities to embolden the
activists of the organization to embark upon
morecinister plans affecting the internal
security, unity and communal harmony of the
nation. Since 2001 till the present date, activi-
ties of the said organization had been con
trolled by the government only because of
continuous operation of the ban. If the ban
was not upheld the activities of the organiza
tion would restart damaging the secular fabric
of the society and create rifts between differ
ence religious groups and spread disharmony
and would be detrimental to national integrity
•i \
and sovereignty.
(b) The remaining 10 cases were still pending in
various courts in Maharashtra. If the ban was
lifted it would adversely affect the interest of
the prosecution and would also affect the
adjudication of the aforesaid pending cases. It
was also stated that Zia-ul-Hasan was the chief
of the militant organization, namely, Jamat-e-
Hizbul Mujahideen, who was residing at
Mardan, Pakistan and as per the intelligence
report he was still in touch with the abscond
ing accused members of the organization.
C. Hearings commenced in Goa on 18th January,
2008.
(i) SW11-Shri Om Prakash Kudtarker, Superin
tendent of Police, AHC, Goa deposed to the effect that:
(a) The ban imposed on the Deendar Anjuman
Organization was necessary in order to main
tain the peace, tranquility, law and order apart
from protecting the sovereignty and integrity
of the country.
(b) The accused No. 1 Mirasab Koujalgi was a mem- -
ber of Deendar Anjuman but some of the wit
nesses stated that he was the Member-Secretary
of the Batkurki Unit in Karnataka of Deendar
*
6 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA: EXTRAORDINARY [PART II—SEC. 3(H)]
Anjuman. The basis of making his statement
that he was the Member-secretary was not only
the confessional statement ofthe accused but
the statement ofthe proposed witnesses also.
-- His deposition was based upon the testimony
of Babusab Sayed and he also showed the
said testimony to the Tribunal.
j
D. Hearing commenced in Hyderabad on 27th Janu
ary, 2008.
(i) SW12-Shri M. Ganpathi Rao, Police Inspector,
CID, Hyderabad, and SW13- Smt. Bhavna Saxena, Super
intendent of Police, Crime Investigation Department (CID),
Hyderabad, deposed to the effect that:
(a) The proclaimed ostensible aim of the organ
ization was to promote peace and common har
mony in universal brotherhood, but its hidden
agenda was Islamization of entire India which
was evident on a perusal of a written and
bounded literature found at the office of
Deendar Anjuaman, Asif Nagar, Hyderabad.
(b) The bye-laws ofthe organization clearly says
that only those persons would be the member
ofthe organization who had done Bayyath and
was a Muvalligh and every Kalma reciting
(Muslim) could only become member of the
Deendar Anjuman Organization.
(c) The main objective ofthe activists ofthe orga
nization was the Islamization of the whole
country by adopting illegal means like 'Nifaq*
(hatred) *Saria' (acquiring money by adopting
illegal means) and 'Jehad' (waging holy war).
(d) Zia-ul-Hasan, the Amir of Deendar Anjuman
in India and Jamat-e-Hizbul Mujahiddin in
Pakistan had been coordinating anti-Indian
national activities like sabotage, subversion,
espionage etc. directly as well as through his
sons, particularly, Javed Pasha and Zahid
Pasha.
w
\
(e) The main slogan ofthe Organization was "Allah-
e-Hidayat" which means 'Islamisation was the
only way to achieve their goal' and therefore
they propagated Islamization by administer-
(0
ing Bayyath (Oath).
In pursuance of its hidden agenda and ideol
ogy, the various followers ofthe Organization
residing in India and Pakistan and other places
abroad had acquired explosive substances,
fire-arms and other lethal weapons and caused
widespread desecration of places of worship
and disruption of religious assemblies.
(g) Deendar Anjuman organization had links with
Jamat-e-Hijbul Mujahiddin. The organization
had also not disowned its connection with
Zia ul Hassan, the Deendar Anjuman Chief,
based in Pakistan and the founder ofthe orga
nization. Sayed Basha, the alleged ex-general
secretary ofthe Organization was the father in
law of the accused Izhar Beg who had been
convicted in CRNo. 35 of 2000.
(h) In Andhra Pradesh, 14 cases were booked
against the followers of Deendar Anjuman and
they were tried by the Specially designated
Additional Metropolitan Sessions Judges
J •
Court. The main conspiracy case which ended
in conviction against the 39 accused clearly
visualize the ultimate goal ofthe Organization.
L
(i) The accused activists of, Deendar Anjuman,
even after convictions had^not disowned the
leadership of the prime accused Zia-ul-
Hassan and his sons who were residing at
Mardan, Pakistan. The followers of Deendar
Anjuman, under the influence of prime accused
Zia-ul-Hassan who is also the chief of mili
tant organization "Jamat-e-Hizbul Mujahidin"
operating from Pakistan may again indulge in
subversive activities to achieve their ultimate
goal of Islamization ofthe entire country. There
was information available to the effect that
Zia-ul-Hassan was still in touch with the other
r
accused persons who were absconding and
also the other members of Deendar Anjuman
in India, giving financial and logistic support
for anti-national and subversive activities,
to achieve their ultimate goal to islamize
the entire country.
4
\
8. The defence witnesses were examined on 19th
January, 2007 at Bangalore and again on 11th and 12th
February, 2008 at Hyderabad. The evidence ofthe witnesses
were recorded and the witnesses also made oral deposition
on oath, proving their respective affidavits and documents
filed. The counsel for the respective States and the Union
of India also cross-examined the said witnesses.
A. On 19th December, 2007 at Bangalore the follow
ing defence witnesses wefre examined, DWI Noorullah Baig,
DW2 Rehana Kauser, DW3 Mohsin.
(i) DWI to DW3 deposed to the effect that:
(a) Deendar Anjuman Organization believes in
peace, love, amity, brotherhood, communal
harmony, national integration, peaceful co-
existence and its office bearers had preached
and worked for the same. The organization
propagated "Panch Shantimarga ".
(b) The religious leaders, such as priests, saints,
monks and Gyanis from different religions had
been invited for participating in the Interna
tional Religious Conference held by the
qPTII—ia^3(ii)] R̂cT m TFsnra : 3TOT*m?T 7
organization on 26th, 27th, 28th, February 1988,
13th, 14th, 15th January, 1992 and 30th
November, 1 st and 2nd December 1995. The
preachers of the organization had also been
invited in the religious functions by the Hindu,
Sikh and Cristian leaders such as 4th and 5th
World Religious Conferences.
(c) For the last 80 years, there had been no com
plaint against the organization and the ban
should be lifted as the organization had not
been able to work for the international unity
&nd peace.
(d) The members of the organization were simple,
innocent and poorly dressed but highly
educated with comparative religious studies.
(e) Their affidavit was based on what they had
heard and believed. They had also heard about
the Organization through other people and
attended the functions of the organization.
B. The remaining defence witnesses DW4 Sh. Nadir
Masdusi, DW5 Sh.Abdul Raheem, DW6 Sri Pandita Pedda
Matham rachaveera Devara, DW7 Mohammed Baquer
Hussain Shaz, DW8 Sadaqat Hussain, DW9 Mohammed
Yousufuddin Khan, DW10 Jos'hep Raju Pastor, DW11
Mohammed Jafar Sadiq, DW12 Syed Basha and DW13
Mohd. Bashiruddin were examined from 11th to 12th
February, 2008 at Hyderabad.
(i) DW5 deposed to the effect that:
(a) The ex-Amir of the organization was Moulana
Mohammad Jafer Sadiq Saheb and its eight
previous Amirs were known to him.
^
(b) The Deendar Anjuman was an independent
organization working for spreading the mess
age of peace and love and had nothing to do
with some Deendar Anjuman in Mardan,
Pakistan.
r
(c) The Deendar Anjuman Organization was a liv
ing epitome of Hindu, Muslim and Christianity
as its office bearers were invited to deliver ser
mons in religious organizations organized by
other religious associations.
(d) The organization follows all the fundamental
principles of Islam and that the organization
had no hidden agenda except the agenda of
love and peace which was tangible and visible.
(ii) DW6toDW10statedthat:
(a) There was no justification to ban the organiza-
i
tion as it had been wrongly spread that this
organization was engaged in illegal activities.
(b) The aims and objects of this organization were
to spread the message of love, peac
brother-hood, tranquility and also work for in
ternational peace.
(c) Some of the Muslim Ulemas were creating
hatred among the members of the organization
and between Hindus and Muslims for their
ulterior motives and vested interests by un
successfully propagating that the office
bearers and the members of the organization
were not Muslims and were engaged in illegal
activities.
_ H
(d) The Deendar Anjuman was an independent
organization working for spreading the mess
age of peace and love and had nothing to
do with some Deendar Anjuman in Mardan,
Pakistan.
(e) The organization follows all the fundamental
principles of Islam and that the organization
r
had no hidden agenda except the agenda of
love and peace which was tangible and visible.
(f) The ex-officer bearers of the organization were
a living example and symbol of Hindu, Muslim,
Christian and Sikh unity as they attend their
religious functions and invited them to attend
the functions organized by the organization.
(g) The ex-Amir of the organization was Moulana
Mohammad Jafer Sadiq Saheb and its eight
previous Amirs were known to him.
(hi) DW 11 stated that:
(a) He was the ex-Amir President of the organiza
tion, he Was elected as Amir in the year 2000
and there were eight previous Amirs.
(b) The organization had been working since 1924,
but it was banned in the year 2000 by leveling
certain false charges. The organization had
been working for peace and brotherhood,
communal harmony and national integration
together with universal peace through its five
fundamental principles of world peace.
-.
(c) There was no justification to ban the organiza
tion as it had been wrongly spread that this
organization was engaged in illegal activities.
r
(d) The aims and objects of this organization were
to spread the message of love, peace, brother
hood, tranquility and also work for interna
tional peace.
(e) Some of the Muslim Ulemas were creating
hatred among the members of the organiza
tion and between Hindus and Muslims for
4
their ulterior motives and vested interests
by unsuccessfully propagating that the officer
bearers and the members of the organization
were not Muslims and were engaged in illegal
activities.
8 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA: EXTRAORDINARY [PART II—SEC. 3(ii)]
(f) The Deendar Anjuman was an independent
organization working for spreading the message
of peace and love and had nothing to do with
some Deendar Anjuman in Mardan, Pakistan.
(g) The organization follows all the fundamental
principles of Islam and that the organization
had no hidden agenda except the agenda of
love and peace which was tangible and visible.
(h) The ex-officer bearers of the organization were
a living example and symbol of Hindu, Mus
lim, Christian and Sikh unity as they attend
their religious functions and invited them to
attend the functions organized by the organi
zation.
(i) The ex-Amir of the organization was Moulana
Mohammad Jafer Sadiq Saheb and its eight previous Amirs
were known to him. v
(iv) DW12 stated that:
(a) The main aim of the organization was to pro-
mote peace, love, amity, brotherhood, religious
tolerance and international peace. The members
of the organization had comparatively studied
all the important religious scriptures of die world
and designed five fundamental principles of
world peace.
(b) He had also attended meetings organized by
the various leaders in the States of Andhra
Pradesh, Karnataka, Orissa, Maharashtra and
other places of India. He had also participated
in International conferences organized by the
organization throughout India and delivered
lectures.
(c) The organization in Hyderabad had its own
constitution and no one controls this organi
zation from outside India. There was no other
Deendar Anjuman except the Anjuman which
was situated in Hyderabad. The organiza
tion had nothing to do with Deendar
Anjuman situated in Mardan, Pakistan and
Moulvi Zia-ul-Hasan had no connection with
the Deendar Anjuman Organization in India.
(d) The organization had no hidden agenda as
stated in the police records in many FIRs of
various States, such as Maharashtra, Andhra
^
Pradesh and Karnataka.
(e) The organization truly and practically per
sonified and epitomized the Hindu, Muslim,
Christian and Sikh unity.
> (f) The organization had been made a scapegoat
for the bomb blast that occurred in various
States in the year 2000 only because the officer
bearers were poor and defenceless.
«
(g) There was no justification for the 1st, 2nd and
3rd ban of the organization and there was no
justification for the present ban for the 4th time.
There must be fresh ground for each ban.
(v) DW13 stated that:
(a) The public witnesses examined at Bangalore
had deposed falsely that the organization did
not believe in the finality of the prophethood
of Mohammad. He gave copies of advertise
ments and pamphlets to show the finality of
Prophet Mohammad.
1
9. The evidence of the public witnesses, PWI
Mr. T.R. Akbar Khan, PW2 Muneer Ahmed and PW3
Moulana Khalid Baig Nadvi were recorded at Bangalore
on 19th December, 2007.
s
• L
A. PWI stated that:
(a) The founder of the organization was one
Siddique Hussain and he claimed that he was
a reincarnation of Basaveswara and declared
that he was also a part of prophethood. There
fore the declaration of the founder of the orga
nization was against the principles of Islam.
(b) The organization under the guise of preaching
peace-is spreading disturbances among the
communities.
(c) On 2nd July, 2000, a function was held by the
organization and he stated that after the func
tion they protested and informed the police of
their illegal activities.
(d) Even today, its members namely Mohsin and
Sawood were carrying illegal activities at
Tumkur by spreading their literature to vari
ous children and he got their pamphlets from
the school going children.
B. PW2 stated that: *
(a) The organization though claimed to spreading
peace but actually they were the real terrorist
and in support of this contention he produced
a printed book.
>-
h
(b) Even today, they were not restrained from their
illegal acts in spite of the ban on them. He
received a letter dated 13th December, 2005
from the Central Jail, Bangalore where it was
narrated that the members of the organization
belonged to Hizbul Muzahiddin of Pakistan.
(c) The members of this organization namely
Zamin and family of Muzibur Rehman who
were ex-communicated from Tumkur are now
i
spreading the ideology of the organization at
Pillana Garden, Bangalore.
C. PW3 stated that:
(a) The members of the organization had
published such type of literature which
[qrcn—Tare3(ii)] *?R<T^TIF5m: 3TOmR̂ T 9
provoked the religious sentiments and created
disharmony amongst all communities.
(b) The main plan of the organization was to
eliminate the Hindu, Christian and Muslim
communities and their religious places. The
organization had said in its literature that they
will not stop their activities and keep silence
until they destroy the temples.
(c) The so-called proclamation of the organiza
tion that they aim for promoting unity among
Hindu and Muslims was only a guise to
propagate militancy.
(d) In spite of the ban on the organization the
prominent members of the organization namely
Muzibur Rehman, Raihana Kouser, Zammen,
Mohsin and Ayaz and others were conduct
ing their activities secretly and trying to enroll
the members to the organization.
10. The Central Government Witness,
Mrs. B. Bhamathi, Joint Secretary to the Government of
India, Ministry of Home Affairs, CGW -1 was examined in
Delhi on the 4th and 6th of February, 2008, who deposed to
the following effect:
(a) The Deendar Anjuman was linked to Jamaat-
e-Hijbul Mujahideen. The organization has not
disowned its connection with Zia-ul-Hassan,
the Deendar Anjuman Chief based in Pakistan
L •
even after the exposure of the module and
after the ban.
(b) The agencies are of the opinion that consider
ing the antecedents of Deendar Anjuman and
its potential to carry out anti-national activi
ties, the ban should be imposed for a period of
two years.
- . •
(c) As a consequence of the ban, the activities of
Deendar Anjuman have become latent and
clandestine and there is every likelihood of
these activities witnessing a quantum spurt if
the ban against the organization is lifted. The
Deendar Anjuman activists who have not dis
sociated from the organization despite the ban,
and are absconding and/or released from jail,
will in the absence of the ban indulge in large
scale unlawful activities, as in the past which
would be prejudicial to the security and
integrity of the country.
11. An application was filed by the learned counsel
for the Union of India claiming privilege on the reports
filed by the Field Officers against the Organization. By its
order dated 18th February, 2008 the Tribunal examined the
Field Officers at Bombay on 23rd February, 2008 to check
the credibility of the reports filed by the Central and State
Intelligence Agencies. A perusal of the said reports showed
that in public interest the identity of the Field Officers, who
r
had filed the reports, and the contents of the said reports
a
ought not be disclosed. Therefore, the application claim
ing privilege in respect of the reports filed by the Field
. • ,
Officers against the Organization was allowed. On the ques
tion of credibility of the witnesses who had filed the Intel
ligence Reports, the Tribunal passed the following order
on 18th February, 2008 in accordance with the law laid
down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of
Jamaat-e-Islami Hind v. Union of India, 1995 (1) SCC 428:
An earlier application under Section 5(5) of
the Unlawful Activities Act, 1967 read with Rule 3(2)(a) of
the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Rules, had been filed
by the Central Government on 4th February 2008 for
perusing the informations/inputs rendered by the Central
Intelligence Agencies and the Field Agencies which would
be provided as per the directions of this Tribunal without
disclosing the contents of the same to the banned outfit or
to any third party, and thus, grant privilege from disclosure
with respect to the inputs/informations in view of the
confidentiality and protection of non-disclosure in the
public interest. Reply to the said application was filed by
the Deendar Anjuman Organization on 12th February, 2008
stating therein to see and access the credibility of the
material sought to be claimed as privilege by the Central
Government and whether confidentiality of such material
is warranted and if disclosure will cause any harm to the
public interest. It was prayed before this Tribunal to
devise a procedure by which it could satisfy itself of the
credibility of the material without disclosing the same to
the organization if public interest so required.
The following position of law empowering the
Tribunal to devise the procedure by which it can satisfy
itself of the credibility of the material without disclosing
the same to the ofganization when public interest so
requires, has been laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in the case of Jamaat-e-Islami Hind v. Union of
India, 1995(1) SCC 428:
20. The scheme under this Act requiring
adjudication of the controversy in this manner makes
iplicit that the minimum requirement of natural
justice must be satisfied, to make the adjudication
meaningful. No doubt, the requirement of natural
justice in a case of this kind must be tailored to
safeguard public interest which must always
outweigh every lesser interest. This is also evident
from the fact that the proviso to sub-section (2) of
Section 3 of the Act itself permits the Central
Government to withhold the disclosure of fects which
it considers to be against the public interest to
disclose. Similarly, Rule 3(2) and the proviso to Rule
5 of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Rules, 1968
also permit nondisclosure of confidential documents
and information which the Government considers
against the public interest to disclose. Thus, subject
to the nondisclosure of information which the Central
Government considers to be against the public
interest to disclose, all infonnation and eWdence relied
on bv the Central Government to support the-
\
a
* * 4
jv£56l °&
*
10 THE GAZETTE OF H
• • „ ; _ • _ - • — — •*••• • __ _ • • r - - - n , ^ — | i . . , ; ^ . . . T , - ^ — • : . ; _ . — » — — _ • _ . . . ' • .
- i j
declaration made by it of an association to be
unlawful, has to be disclosed to the association to
i " r r
enable it to show-cause against the same. Rule 3
also indicates that as far as practicable the rules of
evidence laid down in the Indian Evidence Act, 1872
•i
must be followed. A departure has to be made only
• " _ ^
when the public interest so requires. Thus, subject
to the requirement of public interest which must
undoubtedly outweigh the interest of the association
and its memberŝ the ordinary rules of evidence and
requirement of natural justice must be followed by
the Tribunal in making the adjudication under the
Act.
- _r
21, To satisfy the minimum requirements of a proper
; adjudication, it is necessary that the Tribunal
should have the means to ascertain the credibility
y •
of conflicting evidence relating to the points In
T
controversy. Unless such a means is available to the
Tribunal to determine the credibility of the material
before it,it cannot choose between conflicting
material and decide which one to prefer, and
accept. In such a situation, the only option to it would
be to accept the opinion of the Central Government,
without any means to test the credibility of the
material on which it is based. The adjudication made
would cease to be an objective determination and be
meaningless, equating the process with mere
H " * fa "
acceptance of the ipse dixit of the Central
Government. The
requirement of adjudication by the Tribunal
contemplated under the Act does not permit
abdication of its function" by the Tribunal to the
Central Government providing merely its stamp of
approval to the opinion of the'Central Government.
The procedure to be followed by the Tribunal must,
therefore, be such which enables the Tribunal to
itself assess the credibility of conflicting material on
any point in controversy and evolve a process by
which it can decide whether to accept the version of
the Central Government or to reject it in the light of
the other view asserted by the association. The
difficulty in this sphere is likely to arise in relation
to the evidence or material in respect of which the
Central Government claims non-disclosure on the
ground of public interest.
r "
22. It is obvious that the unlawful activities of an
association may quite often be clandestine in nature
and, therefore, the source of evidence of the unlawful
activities may require continued confidentiality in
public interest. In such a situation, disclosure of the
source of such information, and, may be, also full
particulars thereof, is likely to be against the public
interest. The scheme of the Act and the procedure
for inquiry indicated by the Rules framed thereunder
provide for maintenance of confidentiality, whenever
required in public interest. However, the
r
nondisclosure of sensitive information and evidence
: EXTRAORDINARY [PART II—SEC. 3 (ii)]
to the association and its office-bearers, whenever
justified in public interest, does notnecessarily imply
its non-disclosure to the Tribunal as well. In such
cases where the Tribunal is satisfied that
nondisclosure of such information to the association
or its office-bearers is in public interest, it may permit
its non-disclosure to the association or its office
bearers, but in order to perform its task of adjudication
as required by the Act, the Tribunal can-look into the
same for the purpose of assessing the credibility of
the information and satisfying itself that it can safely
act on the same. In such a situation, the Tribunal can
devise a suitable procedure whereby it can itself
examine and test and the credibility of such material
before it decides to accept the same for determining
the existence of sufficient cause for declaring the
association to be unlawful. The materials need not
be confined only to legal evidence in the strict sense.
Such a procedure would ensure that the decision of
w
F
the Tribunal is an adjudication made on the points in
controversy after assessing the credibility of the
material it has chosen to accept, without abdicating
its function by merely acting on the ipse dixit of the
Central Government Such a course would satisfy
the minimum requirement of natural justice tailored
to suit the circumstances of each case, while
protecting the rights of the association and its
members, without jeopardising the public interest.
This would also ensure that the process of
adjudication is not denuded of its content and the
decision ultimately rendered by the Tribunal is
reached by it on all points in controversy after
adjudication and not by mere acceptance of the
opinion already formed by the Central Government.
26. Judicial scrutiny implies a fair procedure
to prevent the vitiating element of arbitrariness.
What is the fair procedure in a given case, would
depend on the materials constituting the factual
foundation of the notification and the manner in which
. •
the Tribunal can assess its true worth. This has to be
determined by the Tribunal keeping in view the nature
of its scrutiny, the minimum requirement of natural
justice, the fact that the materials in such matters are
not confined to legal evidence in the strict sense,
and that the scrutiny is not a criminal trial. The
Tribunal should form its opinion on all the points in
controversy after assessing for itself the credibility
of the material relating to it even though it may not
be disclosed to the association, if the public interest
so requires.
27. It follows that, ordinarily, the material on which
the Tribunal can place reliance for deciding the
existence on sufficient cause to support the
1 • w
declaration, must be of the kind which is capable of
judicial scrutiny. In this context, the claim of privilege
on the ground of public interest by the Central
Government would be permissible and the Tribunal
[WII—-g^:3(ii)] HRrf Vftl IMW : 3rcPJR"F 11
is empowered to devise a procedure by which it can defines 'unlawful activities'. The second part of Section
satisfy itself of the credibility of the material without
disclosing the same to the association, when public
2(o) relates to disaffection of religious communities. The
notification of the Government of India dated 29th
interest so requires. The requirements of natural August, 2007 clearly demonstrates the main objective of
justice can be suitably modified by the Tribunal to
examine the material itself in the manner
the organization was to spread disaffection between
different religious communities. The Central Government
appropriate. To assess its credibility without is of the opinion that the ban be imposed with immediate
disclosing the same, to the association. This modified effect as disorganization is likely to :
(i) Re-organize itself and indulge in sabotage of minimum
i
of natural justice and judicial scrutiny. The decision
would then be that of the Tribunal itself."
In accordance with the above position of law
the sealed cover of the documents on which privi
lege had been claimed was opened and perused by
me on 14th February 2008 and those documents were
ordered to be re-sealed by the Registrar of the Tri
bunal It was also ordered that such field officers
on whose inputs confidential reports are based be
examined in camera on 19th February, 2008. The
application for rescheduling of the next date of
hearing is allowed and this application is taken up.
In view of the above position of law laid down
by the Hon'ble Supreme Court, all the field officers
on the basis of whose reports, privilege had been
claimed were to be examined in camera by the Tribu
nal on 19th February, 2008....
w
12. The learned Senior counsel for the Union of
India Shri Sidharth Mridul, submitted as follows:
»
(a)
(b)
The Preamble to the The Unlawful Activities
(Prevention) Act, 1967, (hereinafter referred to
as the "Act") provides for the more effective
prevention of certain unlawful activities of in
dividuals and associations and dealing with
terrorist activities and for matters connected
therewith. The amendments precedes the Act
and the main aim is to provide more effective
pretention of certain unlawful activities.
The expression 'unlawful association* has been
defined in Section 2(p) of the Act which reads
as follows:
"unlawful association" means any association
(i) which has for its object any unlawful activity,
or which encourages or aids persons to un
dertake any unlawful activity, or of which the
members undertake such activity; or
(ii) which has for its object any activity which is
punishable under section 153-A or section
153-B of the Indian Penal Code (45 of 1860), or
- i
which encourages or aids persons to undertake
any such activity, or of which the members
undertake any such activity; Provided that
nothing contained in sub-clause (ii) shall
apply to the State of Jammu and Kashmir. «
Section 2(p) is divided into two parts which are dis
junctive. The first part is in relation to Section 2<jo) which
vital installations;
r
(ii) Create tension between the Christian and
other communities with a view to disrupting
the social fabric;
(iii) Create a wedge between different communi
ties by making the blame to appear on the
majority community;
(iv) Discredit the government; mid
(v) Cause embarrassment by tarnishing the secular
credentials of the Indian polity.
The main objective of the organization is to weaken
India by engineering communal strife, sabotaging elements
of the infrastructure and damaging its vital installations,
can be summed up as follows :
(a) Deendar Anjuman Organization has been
engaged in distribution of objectionable anti-
Christian literature and pamphlets and in es
pionage activities.
(b) Deendar Anjuman has links at Mai dan in
Pakistan and has been organizing bands of
disgruntled Muslim youths in India to a mili
tant outfit for launching Jehad with the
avowed objective of total Islamization of the
sub-continent.
(c) Deendar Anjuman planned to create distur
bances particularly by promoting hatred and
creating suspicion and ill-will among the
Christians and Hindus as well as among other
communities.
\
(d) Deendar Anjuman has directed its activities to
attack Christian institutions with the objective
of embarrassing the government, particularly
in the international community and weakening
it internally; and
(e) Deendar Anjuman had plans tortarget major
„ infrastructure! installations including railways,
telecom network, electricity grids, oil refineries
and defence installations.
(c) The counsel submitted that the following
witnesses deposed to the effect that the organization is
creating disaffection between the various religious com
munities and is indulging in anti-national activities.
(i) The deposition on behalf of the Centra! Govern-
•t
ment witness Smt. B. Bhamati clealrly ±>tiy$ that the in
put received from the Intelligence Agencies indicate that
12 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA: EXTRAORDINARY [PART II—SEC. 3(H)]
i t
despite the imposition of ban, Deendar Anjuman has
managed to keep its network alive through clandestine
activities and meetings. Her deposition also refers to the
inputs received from the intelligence agencies and from
various States Governments about the activities of the
Deendar Anjuman. The witness further deposed that many
r
cases have been registered against the memb|rs of Deendar
Anjuman.
(ii) KSW-1 Shri Shankar deposed that the organiza
tion is still conducting its meetings clandestinely and
circulating its literature in Hubli and Dharawar. He further
deposed that the aim of the organization is to disturb the
communal harmony between Hindus and Christians.
(iii) PW 1 deposed to the effect that pamphlets were
distributed by the volunteers of the organization which
were received by him from some school children which
shows a manner of Namaz which is contrary to what is
stated in the "Quran
(iv) A number of accused, such as Rishi Haremath,
,Meera Saheb Kaujalgi and Zakir who had been arrested
after the bomb blasts had given confessional statements
under Section 164 Cr.P.C. to the effect that the organiza
tion was creating disharmony and disaffection between
the members of the different religious communities and is
indulging in anti-national activities. The Central Industrial
Security Force Headquarters reported that on the basis of
a report received from the Andhra Pradesh Police, com
puter floppies containing details regarding the Nuclear Fuel
Complex, Electronics Corporation of India (Hyderabad),
National Remote Sensing Agency, Balanagar (Hyderabad)
and other key installations have been recovered from
the suspected Deendar Anjuman activists arrested in con
nection with the bomb blasts in Church premises, Mosques
etc. in Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka during May-June,
2000.
(v) SW 12 M. Ganpathi Rao, who was examined in
Hyderabad, had produced a CD (Compact Disk) which had
speeches by Zakir on the death of Mr. Ghani. Although
the speeches were prior to the time of ban but shows ac
tivities of the organization which are anti-national.
(d) The Deendar Anjuman Organization was set up
in 1924. The history of creating communal disturbances
came into light in 1934 by L.M. Brown, the then District
Magistrate, Dharwar, had bound over Moulana Siddique
Channa Basavesw^ra (the founder of Deendar Anjuman
Sect) and his followers under section 108 of the Criminal
Procedure Code, 1908 for creating communal disharmony.
During 1948, the Nizam Government declared Deendar
Anjuman as unlawful and had arrested its founder with 241
members who were subsequently interned. Syed Zia-ul-
Hassan, the son of Maulana Siddique, the present Chief of
Deendar Anjuman, had migrated to Pakistan in 1948 and
had settled at Shakir Manzil, Karyan Road, Mardan,
Pakistan. He has set up another outfit known as Jamaat-e-
Hizbul Mujahideen in Pakistan, which operates from bases
in Mardan, Lahore, Karachi, Faisalabad, Rawalpindi,
Sargodha etc. He used to visit India every year during the
annual Urs in the memory of his late father whose tomb I
located at Deendar Anjuman Ashram, Asif Nagar,
Hyderabad. During such visits, Zia-ul-Hassan and his sons
had engaged themselves in organizing a band of dis
gruntled Muslim youth of the community into a militant
outfit for launching Jehad in India, with the avowed objec
tive of total Islamisation of the sub continent. It was dur
ing one such visit in October 1999 that Zia-ul-Hassan had
spelt out his plans to create disturbances particularly by
promoting hatred between the Christians and the Hindus
as well as between other communities. He had specifically
directed a group of his followers to attack Christians so
that there would be international pressure on the Govern
ment of India and the government would be weakened.
While resolving to hoist Anjuman flag on the Red Fort in
Delhi after intrusion into India on horseback through
Kashmir with 9 lakh Pathans in April-May 2000, Zia had
exhorted his followers to create a conducive situation for
/
welcoming him, by carrying out sabotage all around in the
southern States.
(e) Deendar Anjuman has pockets of influence in
the States of Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka, Maharashtra and
Goa. Some volunteers of Deendar Anjuman had come to
adverse notice for their involvement in communal activi-
i t
ties in Hyderabad during December 1990. This Organiza
tion had also come to notice for fomenting caste tensions
between the Dalits and the non-Dalits in Maharashtra and
coastal Andhra by deliberately defiling the statues of
Dr. Ambedkar in 1997. In fact, two of their volunteers Zakir
and Mohd. Khalid Chaudhary who were killed in die Maruti
Van Bomb blasts in Bangalore on 9.7.2000 along with seven
other activists of Deendar Anjuman had visited Pakistan
during September 1992 for arms training.
(f) Deendar Anjuman organization is a communal
organization whose hidden agenda is to spread Islam in
India by adopting illegal means "Nifaq" (hatred), "Sariya"
(acquiring money by adopting illegal means) and "Jehad"
(waging holy war).
(g) Deendar Anjuman has links with Jamat-e-Hijbul
Mujahideen. The organization has not disowned its con
nections with Zia-UI-Hassan, the Deendar Anjuman Chief
based in Pakistan and the founder of Deendar Anjuman
even after the exposure of the module and after the ban.
Zia-ul-Hassan, the Amir of Deendar Anjuman in India and
Jamaat-e-Hizbul Mujahiddeen in Pakistan, has been co
ordinating anti-India activities like sabotage, subversion,
espionage etc. directly as well as through his sons, par
ticularly Javed Pasha and Zahid Pasha. His composite plan
of subversion, sabotage and espionage is inclusive of:
(i) creation of hatred between communities (Nifaq)
(ii) collection of funds (Sariya)
(iii) training of activists (Tarbiyat)
(iv) targeting of infrastructure
(v) targeting of VIPs
(h) Deendar Anjuman organization has been engaged
in distribution of objectionable anti-Christian literature and
* [Will—T5TO3(ii)] HRff^TTFSm: ^ymKU| 13
amphlets and in espionage activities. Deendar Anjuman
has directed its activists to attack Christian institutions
with the objective of embarrassing the Government,
particularly in the international community and weakening
it internally.
(i) The objective was to weaken India by engineering
communal strife, sabotaging elements of the infrastructure,
and damaging its vital installations, so that 'Kargil type
attack' by Pathans under the leadership of Zia-ul-Hassan
against India could be executed. He had offered to equip
Deendar Anjuman members with weapons and explosive^
^
which he proposed to clandestinely induct into India
L
through the Indo-Bangladesh border and through some
landings with the help of fishermen near Balasore (Orissa)
coast for being transported to the southern States inside
baskets under fresh betel leaves.
(j) The learned Senior Counsel for the State concluded
his arguments by submitting that the organization, inspite
of the ban imposed upon them thrice, has not denounced
their objective of spreading disaffection amongst different
religious communities and indulging in anti-national
activities. The organization has not also discontinued their
l
association with Zia-Ul-Hassan, against whom red corner
r
notices have been issued.
13. Mr. Mushtaq Ahmed, the learned counsel for the
Deendar Anjuman organization during the arguments
submitted as follows:
(a) The ban imposed on the organization has to be
based on factual foundation as per the law laid down by
r
the Hon'ble Supreme Court in case of Jamaat-e-Islami
HIND. 1995(1) SCC 428.
"The decision to be made by the Tribunal is "whether
or not there is sufficient cause for declaring the Association
unlawful." Such a determination requires the Tribunal to
reach the conclusion that the material to support the
declaration outweighs the material against it and the
additional weight to support the declaration test applicable
in the context."
Thus, the justification of the ban in view of the
counsel for the organization has to be based on factual
foundations and the ipse dixit opinion of the Central
Government should not be approved. He then went on to
, • .
submit that the evidence of the witnesses who deposed
against the organization cannot be taken as a sustainable
factual foundation for the justification for imposing the
ban on the organization.
(b) KSW-1 was examined in Bangalore. On being
cross examined he has stated that the organization was
indulging in clandestine activities and information in this
regard was provided by the secret informers. He was trying
to evade the source by which he had acquired this
information. He further did not show any intelligence report
to this effect. He also did not remember the time and date
when these clandestine meetings had taken place. KSW -
7 only said that if the ban was lifted the activities of the
organization would continue. Thus, all the witnesses in
y
the State of Karnataka had deposed to the same effect and
no reason has been assigned as to why the ban on the
organization should be imposed.
(c) SW-1 to SW-9, who were examined in the State of
Maharashtra only deposed in relation to the past activities
current o
)n. There
overtact shown
courts have bee
(d) SW-12 M. Ganpathi Rao and SW-13 Bhavana
Saxena, who deposed in the State of Andhra Pradesh, have
stated the grounds of ban in their affidavits which are
identical but no evidence with regard to them has been
shown. In para 10 of his affidavit, SW-12 has stated that
the confidential sources have indicated that clandestine
activities are still continuing and the ban on the organization
shpuld not be lifted. This is the central foundation for
banning the organization which is only based on opinion
and belief of the central and State agencies but no factual
foundations with regard to it have been demonstrated. In
para 10 (i) of his affidavit SW 12 has said that the ban on
•t
the organization cannot be lifted in anticipation of the fact
that the activists of the organization may again indulge in
anti-national activities especially in creating disharmony
among various religious communities. But, however, only
on the ground of suspicion the justification of the ban on
the organization cannot and should not be upheld as this
is not in accordance with the factual foundation as laid in
the case of Jamaat-e-Islami Hin
(e) SW-11 who deposed in the State of Goa, only
referred to old and pending cases in para 8 of his affidavit
and did not produce any sort of legal and factual evidence
to justify the ban on the organization.
(f) CG W1 has deposed to the effect that the present
President of the organisation is Syed Zia-ul-Hasan. This
statement is not correct as a list of all the presidents of the
organization for the past 15 years has been mentioned in
the affidavit of the organization. She has also stated that
the organization had purchased a farm which is also not
correct as the members of the organization are very poor
and no details of the said farm have been given. Para 1 to
23 of Ae affidavit is only the repetition of the history of the
organization and recounts details of all the old and pending
cases. The factual foundation of the ban has been given in
paragraph 24 and 25. The last part of para 24 mentions that
the agencies are of the opinion that considering the
antecedents of the Deendar Anj uman Organization and its
potential to carry out anti-national activities, the ban has
r
to be imposed. However, as laid down in the case of
Jamaat-e-Islami Hind, there should be a factual matrix on
which the ban has been imposed. There is no iota of
evidence produced on factual foundations to the effect
that ban should be imposed and only on the basis of opinion
the ban cannot be justified. In para 26 of her affidavit she
has mentioned that the activities have become latent and
• .
clandestine and there is all likelihood that if the ban was
not imposed the organization will revive itself to carry out
14 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA; EXTRAORDINARY [PART II—SEC. 3(ii)]
its objectives. In para 28 it has been stated that the
organization was likely to reorganize itself. However,
likelihood and also the previous bans cannot be the grounds
for the imposing further ban. There must some concrete
foundation for the ban. The grounds of justification by
the Central Government based on the opinion formulated
by the Central Agencies that the ban should be imposed
are only found on suspicion. There has been no evidence
to show that the organization Was carrying on its
clandestine and ostensible activities. The activists of the
organization are poor, charitable and hand-to-mouth people
and are actually 'fakirs'.
(g) It is also pertinent to note here that no one had
claimed privilege in their affidavit and it was only after the
examination of police witnesses in Hyderabad that the
privilege was claimed in respect of the reports filed by the
various field officers of Central and State level agencies. In
such mitigating circumstances, the ban imposed on the
organization cannot be upheld specially when the
fundamental rights of the organization guaranteed under
Article 19( IX c) are being violated.
(h) The learned counsel for the organization referred
to the fact that the language of all four notifications is
almost the same and the whole emphasis is on the old
cases and only stale grounds have been mentioned for the
justification of the current ban imposed. Since in spite of
the order of this Tribunal dated 6th February 2008 the earlier
notifications have not been shown to be supplied to the
counsel for the organization the Tribunal must proceed on
the assumption that the assertion of the counsel for the
organization that all the four notifications/affidavits were
identical, is correct.
(i) The learned counsel for the organization referred
to the provisions of the Act mentioned in the Schedule in
which the organization has already been listed as a 'terrorist
organization' at S.No.23 and stated that this whole exercise
is futile if the organization has already been listed as a
'terrorist organization'.
(j) The learned counsel for the organization then
summarized his arguments by stating that the grgund to
claim privilege on the reports filed is not appropriate as the
reports of such Field officers are not beyond the scrutiny
of this Tribunal. The ban is not justified as there is no
sufficient cause and no factual foundation to impose the
present ban. Further, weighing the evidence of Central
Government witnesses and the defence witnesses the case
of the organization stands on a higher pedestal and
therefore, as per the law laid down mJamaat-e'IslamiHind's
case, the continuation of the ban was not justified. He
referred to an Urdu quote to define the social position of
the organization "narrow devout Muslim took me as Hindu
and Hindu thinks that I am Muslim." Further emphasizing
on the non-justification of the ban he said that there was
not sufficient cause for the ban, the activists of the
r
organization spread love and amity and practice the
principle of brotherhood relentlessly.
14. Shri Sidharth Mridul while rebutting the argumentP^
advanced by the learned counsel for the organization
submitted as follows:
(a) DW -11 in his testimony has stated that the
organization published the book Imam-ul-Zihad and the
English translation which makes the objective of the
organization very clear and present the true picture of the
organization, which is to create disharmony between the
various religious communities.
r
(b) There is not only relevance of the past
antecedents and conduct of the organization in imposing
the ban on the organization but factual foundation is also
present. The objective of the organization is tQ carry out
overt acts by targeting Hindus and Christians and by
. • ,
targeting the Dalits with the ultimate objective of creating
disharmony among various religious communities and
indulging in anti national activities. The Central Government
must take preventive action in order to prevent the
organization from carrying out its mala fide intention.
(c) On the question of claim of privilege the learned
counsel referred to the provisions of Sections 123,124 and
125 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 which are as follows:
"123. Evidence as to affairs of State.-No one shall
be permitted to given any evidence derived from
unpublished official records relating to any affairs of State,
except with the permission of the officer at the head of the
department concerned, who shall give or withhold such
permission as he thinks fit.
124. Official communications.- No public officer
shall be compelled to disclose communications made to
him in official confidence, when he considers that the public
interest would suffer by the disclosure.
[125. Information as to commission of oflences...No
Magistrate or police officer shall be compelled to say whence
he got any information as to the commission of any offence*
and no Revenue officer shall be compelled to say whence
he got any information as to the commission of any offence
against the public revenue.
Explanation.—"Revenue officer" in this section
means an officer employed in or about the business of any
branch of the public revenue.]"
k.
A perusal of the provisions of the above mentioned
Act shows that without the permission of the officer at the
head of the department concerned no one shall be permitted
to give any evidence from unpublished official records
relating to any affairs of the State and further no police
officer shall be compelled to say how and when he got any
information as to the commission of any offence.
Consequently, the claim of privilege cannot be denied
merely because it was claimed after the intelligence
witnesses sought to rely upon and produced the secret
reports.
• L
15. A perusal of the testimony of the defence
witnesses does establish that the aims and objects of the
organization cannot per se be faulted. The witnesses have
deposed that the organization promotes peace among
[qPTII—^TO3(ip] ^Rcf ?X\ TT5TT=r : STOTOTFT 15
various communities, organizes intra religious conferences
and such conferences have involved the participation pf
religious leaders of various faiths. The organization in
defence had given the evidence of Christian and Hindu
Religious leaders affirming the peaceful and secular nature
of the organization.
The above testimony of the witnesses appearing for
the organization peace among various religions cannot be
termed illegal or objected to.
The public witnesses particularly those who deposed
in Bangalore against the organization namely T.R.Akbar
Khan, Muneer Ahmed and Moulana Khalid Baig Nadvi,
clearly appeared to be motivated by an apparent bias
against the organization. Their testimony appeared to be
motivated and did not inspire confidence. Their testimony
to the effect that the members of the organization were
carrying on objectionable activities without giving any
particulars and were not true followers of Islam thus cannot
be given credence and accordingly is not being relied upon.
The objections of these witnesses that the organization was
not following Islam by not portraying Mohammed as the last
Nabi could not be sustained as the organization professed
and established its full faith in the teachings of Islam.
The CDs produced as evidence by the State
Government and by the organization have been seen and
perused by me. The CD of the UOI does not give any
evidence in relation to the current activities of the
organization. The CD of the organization only relates to
the apparent activities of the organization like holding of
intra religious conferences.
This Tribunal therefore, while not finding any fault
with the professed activities of the organization, is thus
required to take into account and consider the plea of the
Union of India and the statement of the State Witnesses to
the effect plea of the Union of India and the statement of
the State Witnesses to the effect that it is the clandestine
and not the apparent activities of the organization and the
organization's continued link with Zia-ul-Hasan who is an
absconding accused stationed in Pakistan which furnish
sufficient cause for continuing the ban.
16 (i) KSW-1 Shri Shankar, KSW-2 Shri Mehaboob
Khan, KSW-3 Shri Ashok, KS W-4 Shri R. Ramanna, KSW-
5 Shri Jackson D'Souza and KSW-6 Shri Nisar Ahmed
examined at Bangalore deposed to the effect that the
members of the Organization were still distributing
pamphlets and conducting meetings.clandestinely to
propagate the principles of the Organization. AH these
witnesses have deposed that the activities of the
organization were continuing and there were clandestine
meetings being conducted by the activists of the
organization. However, since no particulars of the
clandestine meetings such as the date and time have been
furnished, the testimony of these witnesses cannot be relied
upon for establishing that the clandestine meetings were
held. KSW-4 Ramanna also did not specify the time and
date as to how and when the clandestine meetings were
conducted.
r
(ii) KSW-7 Mr. Victor D'Souza examined at Bangalore
also deposed that the intelligence input report maintained
in their office clearly demonstrated that even after the ban
on 17th May, 2005, the activitiesof the organization were
still continuing. ,
(iii) SW-9 Shri Pramod Shripad Khatavkar, examined
at Mumbai, deposed that the activities of the organization
had been controlled only because of the continuous
operation of the ban and lifting of the ban at this juncture
would encourage the militant organizations and its members
in regrouping themselves in pursuance of thpir avowed
militant activities affecting the internal security, unity and
communal harmony. He further stated that Zia-ul-Hasan,
who was the chief of the Pakistan Organization and residing
at Mardan, Pakistan was still in touch with the absconding
accused persons of the organization. Apart from the above
witness, none of the witnesses in Maharashtra i.e. SW1-
Shri Bhimrao Namdeorao Shingade, SW2-Shri Deepak
Dynoba Shinde, SW3- Shri Balasahed Bhanudas
Waghmode, SW4- Shri Rafik Yusuf Shaikh, SW5- Shri
Bhikanrao Shamrao Bibne, SW6- Shri Ranjit Dadasaheb
Dhure, SW7- Shri Mohan Anant Rao Vidhate, SW8- Shri
Mahesh Madhukar Joshi and SW10- Shrihari Dagadu
Munde, deposed about any current activities of the
organization and had deposed only about the past conduct.
Therefore, their evidence is not of any relevance in respect
of the current ban on the organization dated 29th August,
2007. • , .
. • ,
(iv) SW -110m Prakash Kudtarker, who deposed at
Goa only spoke of the incidents of 2000, hence his testimony
is of no relevance in respect of the current ban on the
organization dated 29th August, 2007.
J
(v) SW-12 Mr. M. Ganpathi Rao and SW-13 Smt.
Bhavana Saxena, examined at Hyderabad, also deposed
that/eVen after the ban, the organization had not disowned
• .
the leadership of the prime accused Zia-ul-Hassan and
his sons who were residing at Mardan, Pakistan. The
followers of Deendar Anjuman, under the influence of
prime accused Zia-ul-Hassan who was also the Chief of
militant organization "Jamat-e-Hizbul Mujahiddin"
operating from Pakistan may again indulge in subversive
activities to achieve their ultimate goal of Islamization of
the entire country. Deendar Anjuman organization had
links with Jamat-e-Hizbul Mujahiddin. The organization
had also not disowned its connection with Zia-ul-Hassan,
the Deendar Anjuman Chief, based in Pakistan and the
1 L
founder of the organization. Sayed Basha, the alleged Ex-
General Secretary of the Organization was the father in
law of the accused Izhar Beg who had been convicted in
CR No. 35 of 2000. They also stated that Zia-ul-Hasan
was still in touch with the other accused persons who
were absconding and information to that effect was
available and he was also reported to be giving financial
and logistic support for anti-national and subversive
activities to achieve his ultimate goal of Islamization of
the entire country.
\6 .____ THE GAZETTE OF n
(vi) The CGW-IB. Bhamathi, Joint Secretary to the
Government of India, Ministry of Home Affairs, examined
at Delhi deposed to the effect that:
(a) The Deendar Atfjuman was linked to Jamaat-e-
Hijbul Mujahideen. The organization has not disowned its
connection with Zia-uI-Hassan, the Deendar Anjuman Chief
based in Pakistan even after the exposure of the module
and after the ban.
(b) As a consequence of the ban, the activities of
Deendar Anjuman have become latent and clandestine and
there is every likelihood of these activities witnessing a
quantum spurt if the ban against the organization is lifted.
17. Most of the State witnesses have deposed to the
past activities of the organization prior to or during the
earlier bans and this Tribunal is, therefore, not considering
such testimony. The only testimonies which this Tribunal
- i .
•i
is taking into account which relates to activities which are
in proximity of the ban i.e. 29th August, 2007 or thereafter.
The past activities are only relevant to furnish the
antecedents of the organization but cannot ipso-facto
constitute sufficient cause stipulated under Section 4 of
the Act.
The summary of the evidence of witnesses thus
indicate that ostensibly the activities of the organization
cannot be faulted and it is contended that there is material
on record which is established by the Secret Intelligence
Reports to show that the Union of India was justified in
having sufficient cause to impose the impugned ban on
the organization. It has been stated that the ban has
prevented the organization from carrying on the
objectionable though clandestine nature of its activities.
I am henceforth considering the evidence of those
witnesses only who, in my view, have given testimony
having a specific bearing on the current and not the past
activities of the organization, which may establish sufficient
cause for continuing the ban.
18. After a perusal of the reports on which the state
had claimed privilege and on examination of the field
officers and their reports to verily the credibility of the
reports filed, I have come to the conclusion that the
following inputs in the various intelligence reports filed
have a bearing on the current activities of the organization:
(i) Secret Report marked SRI showed that during the
subsistence of the ban, the activists of the organization
collected funds on 24th 25th & 26th September, 2007.
(ii) Secret Report marked SR2 relating to activity of
1st March, 2007 showed that financial help was being
provided to the accused persons connected to the
organization and this money was being used to influence
the Muslim youth to join the organization and participate
in its activities secretly. Another report marked SR3 relating
to the activity of 5th October, 2007 was filed to the same
effect that the Muslim youths are being asked to join the
organization secretly. The report SR3 also disclosed that
the activities were being carried out in even after the ban
was imposed on 29-8-2007.
i: EXTRAORDINARY [PART II—SEC. 3(ii)]
, r
(iii) Secret Reports also showed that the umbilical
cord with Zia-ul-Hasan has not been severed and is likely
to be revived if the ban is lifted. Zia-ul-Hasan and his six
sons are all absconding from Indian Courts and have red
corner notices issued against them are still active in Pakistan
and have maintained contacts with the members of the
organization. This fact has been further mentioned in the
reports filed by the field officers marked as SR4, SR6 and
SR7.
(a) Secret Report marked SR4 showed that in July,
2007,-one accused Mehar S/o Jaleel Chaudhary, who was
the accused in Deendar Anjuman Case and senior follower
of the faith, communicated with Syed Zia-UI-Hasan, DA
Chief in Pakistan. Thereafter, the said Mehar also had
telephonic conversations with Zia Ul-Hasan. The said Zia-
UI-Hasan is an absconding accused in Deendar Anjuman
case in India.
(b) A perusal of tlfe Secret Report SR6 further
revealed that two workers' of the Organization after the
imposition of the present ban 29th August, 2007 came to
Gulbarga from Hyderabad on 24th September, 2007 and
collected donations for the organization by visiting shops/
residences in Khaja Bandenawaj Dargah Marg, Muslim
Chowk in Gulbarga city and left Gulbarga on 26th September
2007.
(c) Secret report marked SR7 relating to activities of
15th and 16th October, 2007 showed that the activists of
the organization were collecting funds to strengthen the
organization. They have been establishing contacts with
the activists of SIMI, LeT and other organizations and also
trying to spread discord between different religious
communities.
19(a) The testimony of KSW 7 Victor D'souza that
activities of the organization were continuing even after
r
the ban on 17th May 2005, is verified by the above S.R.
Nos. 2, 3 and 7. Secret Report marked SR 2 showed that
financial help was being provided to the accused persons
connected to the organization and this money was being
used to influence the Muslim youth to join the organization
and participate in its activities on 1 -3-2007 secretly. Another
report marked SR 3 was filed to the same effect that the
Muslim youths are being influenced and instigated. SR 3
related to activity of 5-10-2007 during the period of trial in
District Sessions Court and after the imposition of the
present ban. Secret report marked as SR 7 showed that the
activists of the organization were collecting funds to
strengthen the organization. They have been establishing
contacts with the activists of SIMI, LeT and other
organizations also trying to spread discord between
different religious communities.
(b) The assertion of SW 9 Pramod Khatavkar, SW 12
M. Ganpathi Rao and SW 13 Smt. Bhavana Saxena that
Zia-ul-Hasan, the Chief of the Pakistan based organization,
residing at Mardan in Pakistan, was still in touch with the
absconding accused persons is supported by the Secret
. •
Report No. 4. Secret Report marked SR 4 showed that in
July, 2007, one accused Mehar s/o Jaleel Chaudhary, who
[^mil—7sP^3(ii)3 / HRcT ĴT TT3R5T: .3WI*IK«I 17
was the accused in Deendar Anjuman Case and senior
follower of the faith, communicated via SMS with Syed
Zia-ul-Hasan, DA Chief in Pakistan. Thereafter, the said
Mehar also had telephonic conversations with Zia-ul-
Hasan. The said Zia-ul-Hasan is an absconding accused in
Deendar Anjuman case in India.
20. The relevant position of law laid down by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Jamaat-e-lslami Hind (supra)
in paragraph 20 thereof is as follows:
"20, The scheme under this Act requiring adj udication
of the controversy in this manner makes it implicit that the
minimum requirement of natural justice must be satisfied,
to make the adjudication meaningful. No doubt, the
requirement of natural justice in a case of this kind must be
tailored to safeguard public interest which must always
outweigh every lesser interest. This is also evident from
the fact that the proviso to sub-section (2) of Section 3 of
the Act itself permits the Central Government to withhold
the disclosure of facts which it considers to be against the
public interest to disclose. Similarly, Rule 3(2) and the
proviso to Rule 5 of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention)
Rules, 1968 also permit nondisclosure of confidential
documents and information which the Government
considers against the public interest to disclose. Thus,
subject to the non-disclosure of information which the
Central Government considers to be against the public
interest to disclose, all information and evidence relied on
by the Central Government to support the declaration made
by it of an association to be unlawful, has to be disclosed
to the association to enable it to show-cause against the
same. Rule 3 also indicates that as far as practicable the
rules of evidence laid down in the Indian Evidence Act,
m
1872 must be followed. A departure has to be made only
when the public interest so requires. Thus, subject to the
requirement of public interest which must undoubtedly
outweigh the interest of the association and its members,
the ordinary rules of evidence and requirement of natural
justice must be followed by the Tribunal in making the
adjudication under the Act."
In the above quoted passage, the Hon'ble Supreme
Court has held that the requirement of natural justice must
be tailored to safeguard public interest. It has also been
held that the public interest must always outweigh every
lesser interest which may naturally include the interest of
the organization. This is the impact of Section 3 (2) of the
Act permitting the Central Government to withhold the
disclosure of facts which it considers to be against the
public interest to disclose.
Section 3(2) of the Act reads as follows :
"3. Declaration of an association as unlawful—
T *
(l)xxxxxxxx
(2) Every such notification shall specify the grounds
on which it is issued and such other particulars as the
Central Government may consider necessary:
Provided that nothing in this sub-section shall require
the Central Government to disclose any fact which it
considers to be against the public interest to disclose."
Rule 3(2) and the proviso to Rule 5 of the Unlawful
Activities (Prevention) Rules, 1968 also permit non
disclosure of confidential documents and information which
the Government considers against the public interest to
disclose. Rule 3(2) reads as follows:
"4. Tribunal and District Judge to follow rules of
evidence—
(l)xxxxxxxxxxx
(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in the Indian
Evidence Act, 1872 (1 of 1872), where any books of account
or other documents have been produced before the Tribunal
or the Court of the District Judge by the Central Government
and such books of account or other documents are claimed
by that Government to be of a confidential nature then, the
Tribunal or the Court of the District Judge, as the case may
be, shall not,
(a) make such books of account or other documents
a part of the records of the proceedings before it; or
-V
(b) allow inspection of, or grant a copy of, the whole
of or. any extract from, such books of account or other
documents by or to any person other than a part to the
proceedings before it.
Rule 5 reads as follows:
"5. Documents which should accompany a
reference to the Tribunal—
Every reference made to the Tribunal under sub
section (1) of section 4 shall be accompanied by
(i) a copy of the notification made under sub-section
(l)ofSection3,and
(ii) all the facts on which the grounds specified in the
said notification are based :
• •
Provided that nothing in this rule require the Central
Government to disclose any fact to the Tribunal which that
Government considers against the public interest to
disclose."
Since Rule 3(2) and Rule 5 and Section 3(2) of the
Act hold the field, the secret intelligence reports particularly
S.R. Nos.2,3,4 and 7, on the basis of which ban has been
upheld could not be disclosed to the organization.
21. In paragraph 22 of the judgment in Jamaat-e-
Islami Hind (supra) the Hon'ble Supreme Court held as
follows:—
r
"22. However, the non
disclosure of sensitive information and evidence to
• . ,
the association and its office-bearers, whenever
justified in public interest, does not necessarily imply
its non-disclosure to the Tribunal as well. In such
cases where the Tribunal is satisfied that non
disclosure of such information to the association or
its office-bearers is in public interest, it may permit
its non-disclosure to the association or its office
bearers, but in order to perform it$ task of adjudication
as required by the Act, the Tribunal can look into the
18 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA: EXTRAORDINARY [PART II—SEC. 3(ii)]
N
^
same for the purpose of assessing the credibility of
the information and satisfying itself that it can safely
act on the same. In such a situation, the Tribunal can
devise a suitable procedure whereby it can itself
examine and test and the credibility of such material
before it decides to accept the same for determining
the existence of sufficient cause for declaring the
association to be' unlawful. The materials need not
be confined only to legal evidence in the strict sense.
Such a procedure would ensure that the decision of
the Tribunal is an adjudication made on the points in
controversy after assessing the credibility of the
material it has chosen to accept, without abdicating
its function by merely acting on the ipse dixit of the
Central Government. Such a course would satisfy
the minimum requirement of natural justice tailored
r
to suit the circumstances of each case, while
protecting the rights of the association and its
members, without jeopardising the public interest.
This would also ensure that the process of
adjudication is not denuded of its content and the
decision ultimately rendered by the Tribunal is
reached by it on all points in controversy after
adjudication and not by mere acceptance of the
opinion already formed by the Central Government.
In the above extracted passage of the judgment, the
Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that the non-disclosure
to the organization does not prevent the disclosure to the
Tribunal and the Tribunal is required to assess the
credibility of such confidential information/inputs so as to
satisfy itself that /'/ can act safely on the same. The
procedure of assessing such information has to be devised
by the Tribunal and it has been held that the materials need
not be confined only to legal evidence in the strict sense.
Consequently, even though the secret reports may not
constitute the legal evidence in the strict sense, these
reports nevertheless satisfy the requirement of being such
material on the basis of which the Tribunal may safely act.
The Tribunal held a hearing where all the field officers
along with their secret intelligence reports were examined
in camera. The said m camera hearing enabled this Tribunal
to come to the conclusion that the reports were credible
• . •
and worthy of reliance. The secret intelligence reports have
been put In a scaled cover after examining them and they
are accordingly marked for perusal in case the need for the
same arises.
22. The Tribunal has sustained the ban on the basis
of the above secret report but is constrained to observe
that the ban has only been sustained on the basis of secret
reports filed by the Central and the State investigating
agencies, which reports have been held to be privileged.
The decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Jamaat-e~
Islanti Hind (supra), has laid down the law that after
devising the procedure for examining the veracity of
documents claimed to be privileged, the Tribunal may take
into account the credibility of such documents. This
Tribunal has examined the Field Officers and their reports
in camera and after examining such secret intelligence
reports which in view of the public interest have been held
to be privileged, has found such reports to be credible and
thus, the Tribunal has found the existence of sufficient
cause to sustain the ban.
23. It may appear unfair that an organization is banned
on the basis of inputs constituted by secret intelligence
reports which cannot be divulged to it. However, this
Tribunal has considered the sensitive nature of such
privileged reports filed by the Central and State
investigating agencies and has found that in the interest
^ of public security and national interest, such reports ought
not to be made public. Thus, the public interest subserved
in preserving the confidentiality outweighs the interest of
the organization under ban in being privy to such reports.
The Tribunal has concluded that such reports verifying
the depositions of KSW-7 Shri Victor D'Souza, ACP, North
Division, SW-9 Shri Pramod Shripad Khatavkar, Addl. Dy.
Commissioner (Security), SID, Maharashtra, SW-12 Shri
M. Ganpathi Rao, Police Inspector, CID, Hyderabad, and
SW-13 Smt. Bhavana Saxena, Superintendent of Police,
• h
Crime Investigation Department (CID), Hyderabad, along
with such deposition constituted sufficient material to
continue the ban. The Tribunal has also noticed that largely
the ban is imposed on antecedents of the organization
• _
based on past incidents and the inputs of the secret
intelligence reports which suggest current unlawful
activities. It would have not been possible to upheld the
ban if the deposition of KSW-7 Shri Victor D'Souza, ACP,
North Division, SW-9 Shri Pramod Shripad Khatavkar, Addl.
'Dy. Commissioner (Security), SID, Maharashtra, SW-12
Shri M. Ganpathi Rao, Police Inspector, CID, Hyderabad,
and SW-13 Smt. Bhavana Saxena, Superintendent of
Police, Crime Investigation Department (CID), Hyderabad
had not been supported by SRs 2, 3,4 and 7. There does
not appear to be any other fresh material apart from the
above 4 depositions of KSW7, SW9, SW 12 and SW13
supported by the said secret intelligence reports being SR
Nos. 2, 3, 4 and 7 which may have sustained the ban
against the organization. This is a factor which must be
kept in mind in considering whether the ban needs to be
continued in future.
s
24. In view of the above, I am satisfied that there is
^
sufficient cause found under Section 4(3) of the Act for
confirming the declaration of Deendar Anjuman as a
banned association issued under Sub-section (1) of Section
3 of the Act. Accordingly the declaration dated 29th
August, 2007, declaring Deendar Anjuman as an unlawful
association is confirmed in terms of Section 4 of the Act.
The reference is answered accordingly.
February 27,2008 (Justice Mukul Mud gal)
Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Tribunal
[F.No. 14017/7/2008-NI-ffl]
ARUN KUMAR YADAV, Jt Secy.
Printed by the Manager, Govt, of India Press, Ring Road, Mayapuri, New Delhi-110064
and Published by the Controller of Publications, Delhi-110054.