Tribunal under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 in High Court of Delhi, in the matter of Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eleam (LTTE)
Notification - The Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967
- Kind: Notification
- Under: The Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967
Text of this notification
tf*R#tfo ^ o T^ro-33004/99 JQB£H** RECT). NO. P. L.-33004/99
(Hie (Baxette of <3udia
EXTRAORDINARY
WT II—T3T^ 3_^tr -^us (ii)
PART II—Section 3—Sub-section (ii)
PUBLISHED BY AUTHORITY
U 2368] ^f^^,¥nc^R,f l^WIT11,2012/3ni f7^T20, 1934
Na 2368] NEW DELHI, TUESDAY, DECEMBER 11,2012/AGRAHAYANA 20,1934
^ f ^ f t , 11 1W*K, 2012
m.m. 2869(3T).—^fa W<m ^ W r f ^ S rsb^l*dN ( fW*T) SfWPm, 1967 (1967 ^T 37) ( fa3
I^ 'W^M^^I^^^T3rfvfWT^?T7FTT' t ' ) '^ t VRr3^"5^~^RT (1) SKIT^T Vlfad-tf ĴT "SRfa ̂ * ^ "fl* T̂OT m<b\<
^ TJ? * T ^ R ^ TOT^TRtre, 3TOT*JTCST, W\ I I , f^3,^~W^ ( i i ) 3 W*® 14 "Rf, 2012 ̂ t y^lRflcl 3Tf*RpHT
•HVj|'<*m3T?. 1062(3?) 5RT fa«A«(H 3I?*K4" sffa cTfoeT ̂ R ( f ^ ^ t f f ̂ T ^ W ^ fa<i * $ l iRT t ) ^ fafaf^g
W l f̂fWcT %*TT «?I;
^ ^ H^leH^t «fRcT ^ TTiR^, SRTTtlT̂ T, m1! I I , ̂ 3 , ^ - 1 3 ^ ( i i ) W cfRRS 6 ̂ T, 2012 ^ M+lRfld 3ffa^RT
« W + n̂.3TT. 1303(3?) OTf¥MfaP5'fs*i4l<*>dN (FWKUI) 3rf*WT ( f ^ SUtf $-«<£ i7?^"3^T 3#|+<u| <b$\ 7TCT
^ «^l«n ^ % Q ; SFTT 1eT^: ^ t fafafa<?£ f̂rffercT f ^ *rrt ^TT ^rcfa ^rc^r m ^ n ^ f , 14 TR$, 2012 ^ t "3̂ ?r 3 # T W T
3 ^ " 3 ^ 3 T t e R ^ ^ H ^ a # T f r R m ^ VTCr(4)^t^-*TRI (3) ^ T ^ " ? r f 3 ^ ^ T ^ ^ f ^ 7 W*TC,
2 0 1 2 ^ ^ F 3 T I ^ T ( f ^ W ^ ? ^ W^"3^T3T%T^FfTTRTt) T%*?T «TT;
SfcT: 3T«1 ctl^l^ *U+K, "3351 3?f*ITW? eft qRT 4 ^ ^1-VRT (4 ) ^ 3^«<u( ^ "333 aflfaOT •% STT̂ T =pt
(f¥fa 3TM 3?t>^n 3 w t )
[ m U I-11034/l/2012~3TTf V$-l]
*#^ wrf, "*f*p<T 'sf^r
4564 GI/2012 (1)
2 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY |PARI- II- -Siic. 3(ii)|
MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS
NOTIFICATION
New Delhi, the 11th December, 2012
S.0.2869(E).— Whereas, the Central Government, in exercise of
the powers conferred by sub-section (1) of section 3 of the Unlawful Activities
(Prevention) Act, 1967 (37 of 1967) (hereinafter referred to as the said Act) declared,
vide notification of the Government of India in the Ministry of Home Affairs, published
in the Gazette of India, Extraordinary, Part II, Section 3, Sub-section (ii), number
S.O.1062(E), dated the 14th May, 2012, the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam
(hereinafter referred to as LTTE) to be an unlawful association ;
And whereas the Central Government, in exercise of the powers conferred by
sub-section (1) of section 5 of the said Act, constituted, vide notification of the
Government of India in the Ministry of Home Affairs published in the Gazette of India,
Extraordinary, Part II, Section 3, Sub-Section (ii), number S.O.1303(E), dated the 6th
June, 2012, the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Tribunal (hereinafter referred to as
the said Tribunal) consisting of Mr. Justice V.K. Jain, a Judge of the Delhi High Court;
And whereas the Centra! Government, in exercise of the powers conferred by
sub-section (1) of the section 4 of the said Act, referred the said notification dated
14th May, 2012 to the said Tribunal on the 11th July,2012 for the purpose of
adjudicating whether or not there was sufficient cause for declaring the LTTE as
unlawful association ;
And whereas the said Tribunal, in exercise of the powers conferred by sub
section (3) of section 4 of the said Act, made an order (hereinafter referred to as the
said order) on the 7th November, 2012 ;
Now, therefore, in pursuance of sub-section (4) of section 4 of the said Act, the
Central Government hereby publishes the order of the said Tribunal, namely:-
TRIBUNAL UNDER THE UNLAWFUL ACTIVITIES (PREVENTION) ACT, 1967
COURT NO. 20 HIGH COURT OF DELHI, NEW DELHI
In the matter of Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE)
07.11.2012
Present: Mr. A.S. Chandhiok, ASG with Mr. Jatan Singh and Mr. Neeraj
Ch^udhari, Central Govt. Standing Counsel, with Mr. Gurpreet
Parwanda and Ms. Monika Tyagi, Mr. Ravjot Singh and Mr. Tushar
Singh, Advocates along with Mr. Ramesh Kumar Suman, Director, and
[*TFT I I — ~ m ^ 3( i i ) ] *TK<T ^T TT^m : 3mT*m*T
Mr. Narinder Kumar, Under Secretary, Ministry of Home Affairs, Govt.
of India, New Delhi.
Mr. Vaiko along with Mr. Dev Das, Mr. Asaithambi and Mr. G.
Ananthaselvam.
Mr. M. Yogesh Kanna, Advocate for State of Tamil Nadu along with Mr.
Abhash Kumar, IPS, Inspector General of Police, Internal Security,
Chennai, and Mr. G. Sampath Kumar, IPS, Superintendent of Police,
'Q' Branch, CID, Chennai.
Mr. Anil Kumar Koushal, Registrar, Unlawful Activities (Prevention)
Tribunal.
1. Vide Notification dated May 14, 2012 published in Part II Section 3-Sub-
seGtion(ii) of Gazette of India (Extraordinary), Central Government, in exercise of the
powers conferred upon it by sub-section(l) and the proviso to sub-section(3) of
Section 3 of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967, declared the Liberation
Tigers of Tamil Eelam (the LTTE) as an unlawful association and also directed that
the notification shall, subject to any order that may be made under Section 4 of the
said Act, have effect on and from the date of its publication in the official gazette.
2. Vide notification dated 6th June, 2012 published in Part II Section 3-Sub-
section (ii), Central Government, in exercise of the powers conferred upon it by sub-
section(1) of Section 5 of the Act, constituted "the Unlawful Activities(Prevention)
Tribunal", consisting of me, for the purpose of adjudicating whether or not there is
sufficient cause of declaring the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (the LTTE) as an
'unlawful association'.
3. Vide letter dated 11 th July, 2012, Government of India, Ministry of Home
Affairs, forwarded a resume of the facts on which its notification is based, including
the aims and objectives of the LTTE, to the Tribunal.
The documents annexed to the resume comprise Constitution of the Peoples
Front Liberation Tigers (PFLT), details of the cases registered by Government of
Tamil Nadu and the arrest made therein, details of the evidence to show that LTTE is
still having strong presence in Tamil Nadu and an illustrative list of the activities of the
LTTE, which had come to notice since last proscription on the organization was
imposed in May, 2010. Copies of notifications publishing the orders of the earlier
Tribunals upholding were also annexed to the resume.
4. Section 4(2) of the Act provides that on receipt of reference, the Tribunal shall
call upon the association affected by the notice in writing to show cause within 30
days from the date of such notice, why the association should not be declared
unlawful. Accordingly, vide order dated 17th July, 2012, it was directed that the
notice under Section 4(2) of the Act be issued to LTTE to show cause within 30 days
as to why it be not declared unlawful within the meaning of the Act.
5. Rule 6 of the Unlawful Activities(Prevention) Rules, 1967 deals with service of
notice issued under Section 4(2) of the Act and reads as under:-
4 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY (PART II—SBC. 3(ii)|
"6. Service of notice issued by the Tribunal- Every
notice referred to in sub-section (2) of Section 4 shall be
served on the affected association in such manner as the
Tribunal may think fit and all or any of the following modes
may be followed by the Tribunal in effecting service of such
notice, namely:-
(a) by affixing a copy of the notice to some conspicuous
part of the office, if any, of the association; or
(b) by serving a copy of the notice, where possible, on the
principal office bearers, if any, of t he association, by
registered post or otherwise; or
(c) by proclaiming by beat of drum or by means of
loudspeakers the contents of the notification in the
area in which the activities of the association are
ordinarily carried on."
Pursuant to the order dated July 17, 2012, the notice to LTTE was published
on 24th July, 2012, in 47 editions of the newspapers mentioned in Annexure-1 to the
affidavit dated 22.08.2012 by Shri Ramesh Kumar Suman, Director, Internal
Security-I, Ministry of Home Affairs. The notice was also displayed on the notice
boards of all Collectorates, Taluk Offices, Revenue Divisional Offices, Police
Headquarters, District Police Offices and Police Stations in Tamil Nadu. The notice
was also published in all Tamil Nadu editions of one English Daily newspaper "The
New Indian Express" and one Tamil Daily, Dhina Thanthi (Daily Thanthi). A news
item with respect to the service of notice was also broadcast in the news bulletin of
All India Radio on 24.07.2012 and also telecast in prime bulletin of Doordarshan on
the same date. The notice has also been uploaded on the official website
www.mha.nic.in of Ministry of Home Affairs on 19.07.2012. The notice was also
displayed on the website www.mha.nic.in which is the official website of Ministry of
Home Affairs on 19.07.2012. The notice was also published in a Sri Lankan
newspaper "The Island" on 17.8.2012 and a Sri Lankan Tamil Daily "Virakesari" on
14.8.2012. The notice issued by the Tribunal was translated into Tamil and
broadcast on all the channels of All India Radio, Chennai from 26.07.2012 to
06.08.2012. Adequate publicity to the notice issued by the Tribunal was also given
by All India Radio from 26.7.2012 to 28.7.2012. Since the last notice in terms of the
order of the Tribunal was published on 17th August, 2012 the objections/reply could
have been filed on or before 16th September, 2012.
6. Vide order dated 27th August, 2012, it was directed,that the next sitting of the
Tribunal would be held at Chennai on 28th September, 2012 and 29th September,
2012 at 11 AM. The Central Government and Government of Tamil Nadu were
directed to give publicity in one Tamil newspaper published from Chennai, and in
"Hindu" (English) published from New Delhi and Chennai as well as through media
with respect to trie date, time and place of the sitting of the Tribunal. In compliance
of the directions of the Tribunal, the notice issued by the Registrar of the Tribunal,
notifying the date, time and place for sitting of the Tribunal was published in "Hindu"
(English) published from Chennai and Tamil newspaper "Thina Thanthi" on 25th
September, 2012. The notice was telecast on Doordarshan in prime time bulletins at
•, n T T T - -m*mm* - ~"~ '
http://www.mha.nic.in
http://www.mha.nic.in
[•RFT 11—W^ 3(ii)] *TKcT ^ HmZ : $mmw 5
8.15 PM and 10 PM and on 12 noon on 23"* September, 2012. The notice was also
broadcast on All-India Radio in various news bulletins.
Section 4(3) provides for cause being shown not only by the banned
association but also by any of its office bearers or members, the reply/objections,
therefore, could be filed by LTTE as also by any of its office bearers or members. No
objections/replies were, however, filed on or before 16th September, 2012 either by
LTTE or any of its office bearers or members.
7. A petition under Section 4(3) of the Act was filed by one Mr. V.Sivanesan
before the Tribunal, through Shri M.Radhakrishnan, Advocate, on 28th October,
2012. The petitioner claimed to be the coordinating Director of Switzerland Branch
of European Political Sub Division of LTTE in Switzerland. The petition was
dismissed vide order dated 28th October, 2012 holding that neither the petitioner had
been authorized by LTTE to appear and act on its behalf nor had he been able to
satisfy me, even prima facie, that he was either an office bearer or a member of
LTTE. It was also noted in the course of the order dated 28th October, 2012 that
despite the extensive publicity given to the notice issued by the Tribunal and sittings
held at Chennai on 28lh September, 2012 and 29th September, 2012 which were also
attended by Mr. M.Radhakrishnan, Advocate, no appearance on behalf of LTTE or
any of its office bearers or members had been filed at any time prior to
27 October, 2012. It was also noted that there was absolutely no explanation as to
why the petitioner had not approached the Tribunal prior to 27th October, 2012
despite extensive publicity given to the notices issued by it as also to the notices with
respect to the hearings which were scheduled at Chennai.
8. The notification dated 14.05.2012, inter alia, reads as under:-
"Whereas the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (hereinafter
referred to as the LTTE), is an association based in Sri
Lanka but having its supporters, sympathizers and agents in
the territory of India;
And whereas, the LTTE's objective for a separate homeland
(Tamil Eelam) for all Tamils threatens the sovereignty and
territorial integrity of India, and amounts to cession and
secession of a part of the territory of India from the Union
and thus falls within the ambit of an unlawful activities;
And whereas, the LTTE, even after its military defeat in May
2009 in Sri Lanka, has not abandoned the concept of 'Eelam'
and has been clandestinely working towards the 'Eelam'
cause by undertaking fund raising and propaganda activities
in Europe. The remnant LTTE leaders or cadres have also
initiated efforts to regroup the scattered activists and
resurrect the outfit locally and internationally;
And whereas, the separatist Tamil Chauvinist groups and
pro-LTTE groups continue to foster a separatist tendency
amongst the masses and enhance the support base for
**> M &tf )Z-2-
6 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY |PAKI II--SEC. 3(ii)|
LTTE in India and particularly in Tamil Nadu. It will ultimately
have a strong disintegrating influence over the territorial
integrity of India. Hence, the strong need continues to exist
to control all such separatist activities by all possible lawful
means;
And whereas, cases were registered under the Unlawful
Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 against LTTE, pro-LTTE
elements and chauvinist groups since the last Notification
No.SO 1090 (E), dated 14-05-2010, i.e., between May 2010
and February 2012, besides cases under the provisions of
Explosive Substances Act 1908, Foreigners Act 1946, Indian
Penal Code, etc.
And whereas, the Diaspora continue to spread through
articles in the Internet portals, anti-India feeling amongst the
Sri Lankan Tamils by holding the top Indian political leaders
and bureaucrats responsible for the defeat of the LTTE.
Such propaganda through Internet, which remains continued,
is likely to impact W I P security adversely in India;
And whereas, for the reasons aforesaid, the Central
Government is of the opinion that the LTTE is an unlawful
association and there is a continuing strong need to control
all such separatist activities by all possible means;
And whereas, the Central Government has the information
that,-
(i) the activities of the LTTE remnant cadres, dropouts,
sympathizers, supporters, who have been traced out
recently in the State of Tamil Nadu suggest that the
cadres sent to Tamil Nadu would ultimately be utilized
by the LTTE for unlawful activities;
(ii) the activities of pro-LTTE organisation and individuals
have come to notice of the Government of India that
despite the ban in force, attempts have been made by
these forces to extend their support to the LTTE;
(iii) the LTTE leaders, operatives and Supporters have
been inimically opposed to India's policy on their
organization and action of the State machinery in
curbing their activities."
9. It is stated in the resume dated 11 th July, 2012 that as per the constitution of
People's Front Liberation Tigers(PFLT), which is stated to be the political front of
LTTE, the objectives of the organization include
(a) to fight for the right of self-determination of the Tamil and Muslims;
[*TFT I I - ^ P S 3 ( i i ) ] «TRcT ^T W T 3 : aTOTqT^T 7
(b) to protect and preserve the geographical identity and integrity of the traditional
homelands of the Tamils and Muslims.
It is further stated in the resume that LTTE is an association based in Sri
Lanka but having sympathizers, supporters, agents and operators in the territory of
India and on account of linguistic, cultural, ethnic, historical and geographical affinity
between the Tamils in India and those in Sri Lanka, the association has the capacity
to make inroads and gain local support in Tamil Nadu and certain pockets of
southern India. It is also alleged in the resume that LTTE continues to look at Tamil
Nadu as a base for carrying out anti-India activities. It is further stated that the
association has been assiduously cultivating the Tamil chauvinist elements who are
inspired by the Tamil Eelam concept of a separate Tamil homeland, to the extent of
secession from India. It is alleged that LTTE cadres started infiltrated in the State of
Tamil Nadu, under the guise of refugees and the outfit continues to use Tamil Nadu
as a base for securing its Logistical requirements. It is further stated that despite
suffering a huge loss, at the hands of Sri Lankan forces in terms of elimination of its
top leadership and loss of territorial control in the North of Sri Lanka, recent reports
reveal that LTTE still has a strong presence in Tamil Nadu and remnant
leaders/cadres/operatives are re-grouping for separate Tamil Eelam and wrecking
revenge on the traitors (Government of India) and enemies (Government of Sri
Lanka). It is further alleged that LTTE's objective for a separate homeland for Tamils
is still its forefront agenda, which threatens the sovereignty and territorial integrity of
India, amounting to attempt of secession of a part of the territory of India and thus
falls within the ambit of unlawful activities. It is also alleged that in a recent incident
Indian Embassy in Rome received a Closed Cover in its dak on 18th January, 2012
and the closed cover was found to contain two pen sized explosives without
detonator. A photocopy of a paper supporting LTTE was also found inside this
cover. It is also alleged that demonstrations were held and members of
organizations pasted wall posters in Tamil Nadu urging establishment of Tamil
Eelam and release of LTTE cadre in Tamil Nadu prison and recognition of LTTE. It
is further stated that members of various pro-LTTE organizations released wall
posters felicitating LTTE Leader Prabhakaran, on his birthday i.e. on 26th November,
2011, and also paid tribute to LTTE martyrs, claiming that Tamil Eelam was the thirst
of Tamils. They also demanded support for Transnational Government of Tamil
Eelam.
10. The following witnesses have been examined by Central Government and the
Government of Tamil Nadu to satisfy the Tribunal that there is sufficient cause for
declaring LTTE as unlawful association:-
(i) PW-1 Ramesh Kumar Suman, Director Internal Security-I Division, Ministry of
Home Affairs, Government of India, New Delhi.
(ii) PW-2 G. Sampath Kumar, IPS, Superintendent of Police, 'Q' Branch, CID,
Chennai
(iii) PW-3 G. Rengasamy, Inspector of Police, 'Q' Branch CID, Trichy.
(iv) PW-4 M.S. Bhaskar, Inspector of Police, Law and Order, Chengalpattu Town
Police Station, Kanceepuram District.
(v) PW-5 Rajeev Gandhi, Sub-Inspector of Police 'Q' Branch CID, Trichy
(vi) PW-6 R. Rajbabu, Inspector of Police, 'Q' Branch, CID, Villupuram
(vii) PW-7 V. Chandran, Inspector of Police, 'Q* Branch CID, Chenfiai City
8 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY (PART I I - SEC. 3(ii)|
(viii) PW-8 R. Selvarani, Sub-Inspector of Police, Video Piracy Cell,
CB/CID, St. Thomas Mount, Chennai
(ix) PW-9 R. Venkateshwaran, Inspector of Police, District Crime Record Bureau,
Sivagangai
(x) PW-10 S.A. Seenivasan, Inspector of Police, Crime, B-l, North Beach PS,
Chennai.
11. PW-3 G. Rengasamy, Inspector of Police, 'Q' Branch CID, Trichy, Tamil Nadu
is the Investigating Officer of Crime No. 1/2010 registered under Sections 120(B) IPC
r/w 10 (b) (ii), 13(1)(2) of Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967, Section 5(a) of
Explosive Substances Act, 1908 and Section 14(a)(b), 14A(b) of Foreigners Act,
1946. Three persons, namely, V. Chandrakanthan Nagarasa @ Satheesh @ Tamil
@ Tamil Selvan, Subramaniyam Arulkulasingharn @ Ramesh @ Myndhan @ Siva
and Selvan @ Selvarasa, all Sri Lankan Tamils were arrested in the above-referred
case, During the course of investigation, he interrogated accused Mr. Subramaniam
(A-2) and Selvarasa (A-3) and recorded their statements Ex.PW-3/4 and PW-3/6
respectively. English version of those statements are Ex.3/5 and Ex.3/7 respectively.
According to the witness, Accused No. 2 had told him that he and Accused No. 3
were members of LTTE cadre and that one Mr Seelan had asked him to meet
accused Chandrakanthan Nagarasa (A~1), who also was from LTTE cadre.
Accused No. 2 further told the witness that Seelan was a French National In-charge
of LTTE cadre in France, who had come to Chennai and had met him in January,
2010. Accused No.2 further told the witness that he, along with Accused No. 3, had
gone to Trichy, taking detonators with them and had met Accused No. 1 there. At
Trichy, accused No. 1 took the detonators from them and kept the same in the
bakery in which he was working. Accused No. 2 further told the witness that on
19.06.2010, he along with accused No. 3 had gone to Trichy, met accused No. 1
there and next day, they were to take those detonators illegally through
Rameshwaram. The witness has identified his signature on the seizure memo
Ex.PW-3/11. English version of that memo is Ex.PW-3/12. He has also stated
accused No. 2 had told him that the detonators were being taken to Sri Lanka for
being used by LTTE there, for committing blast.
Accused No. 3 told the witness that he was a member of LTTE cadre and
while working with LTTE, he had come to know accused No. 2, who was working
with the Intelligence Wing of the organization. Accused No. 3 further told the witness
that Seelan, a French National introduced him to accused No. 1 in Trichy and he and
accused No. 2 had given detonators to accused No. 1 in Trichy in January, 2010.
Accused No. 3 also told the witness that on 19.06.2010, he, along with accused No.
2, had gone to Trichy to take detonators to Sri Lanka for being provided to LTTE and
they were arrested, while taking the detonators to Sri Lanka. On questioning by the
Tribunal, the witness stated that Sri Lankan passport of accused No. 1 was seized
from him though no passport or other valid travel document was found with accused
No. 2 and 3 who had entered India illegally. He also stated that the accused had told
him that the detonators had been procured from various quarries though the
particulars of those quarries were not given to him. The detonators, according to the
witness, are used for carrying blast at quarry sites for mining purposes.
12. PW-5 Rajeev Gandhi, Sub-Inspector of Police 'Q' Branch CID, Trichy, is the
police officer on whose complaint, Crime No. 1/2010 was registered. He has stated
"<"wlffl!'''l!"W"w"" ' ' ' H.,W-i.ff*r.
[*rr*TlI—T3"S3(ii)] *TRcT ̂ JT <NH^ : 3 W I W I 9
that on 20.06.2010, he received a reliable information that some Sri Lankan Tamils
were engaged in smuggling of explosive materials to Sri Lanka at Sri Sai Nagar near
K.K. Nagar. He reached that place and at about 10.45 PM, accused
Chandrakanthan Nagarasa came there walking. He had a travel bag with him. He
attempted to escape on seeing the police party, but, was caught and interrogated in
the presence of two independent witnesses. He then made a statement which was
recorded in the presence of two witnesses. In the statement, the accused told him
that he was a citizen of Sri Lanka, a member of LTTE cadre, had undergone arms
training and was attached to the Intelligence Wing of LTTE. After war in Sri Lanka,
he came to Chennai by Air on a Sri Lankan passport and met Seelan, In-charge of
LTTE in France. The accused further told the witness that in February, 2010
accused Selvarasa @ Selvan came with another LTTE cadre, namely, Ramesh and
met him at NSK Ceylon Bakery in Trichy. They decided to procure explosives for
utilizing the same in Sri Lanka. In February, 2010, Ramesh and Selvarasa brought
three bags of explosives and kept at the bakery. On 20.06.2010, Ramesh and
Selvarasa came to the bakery and took one bag each of explosives. The third bag
containing explosive was taken by accused Nagarasa. He was arrested on the way
and 1500 ordinary detonators and 200 electric detonators were seized from him.
The confessional statement recorded by this witness is Ex.PW-3/8 and its English
version is Ex.PW-3/9. The confessional statement also bears signatures of Village
Administration Officer Tr. Kanagaraj and Village Assistant Thiru Kaliyamoorthy, in
whose presence it was recorded. The witness has also identified his signatures on
the Seizure Memo Ex,PW3/11 which also bears the signatures of the Village
Administration Officer and Village Assistant. The English version of the Seizure
Memo is Ex.PW-3/2. During questioning by the Tribunal, he stated that though no
document had been recovered from accused No. 1, who had admitted that he was a
Sri Lankan citizen, who had come to India to smuggle detonators to Sri Lanka, for
use of LTTE.
13. PW-6 R.Rajbabu, Inspector of Police, 'Q' Branch, CID, Villupuram has stated
that on 12.06.2010 at about 2.15 AM, the Engine Guard of Salem Express, which
was passing near Perani railway station on Trichy-Chennai Railway Line, felt some
unusual sound/jerk on the railway track and informed the station master, who, in turn,
informed the Engine driver of Rock Fort Express which was proceeding towards
Chennai. The driver of that train received a caution order at Mundiyampakkam
railway station and slowed down the speed of the train at Perani signal. He noticed a
gap of 2.5 metre broken rail and a crater of 3 feet depth on the railway track. On the
place of occurrence, one pamphlet was also found. A case in this regard was 6
registered vide Crime No. 259/2010 under Section 307 IPC, Section 3 of Explosive
Substances Act, 1908, Section 4 of PPD Act, 1984, Section 3 r/w 13(1) of Unlawful
Activities (Prevention) Act, 2004 and 150 (2)(b), 151(1)(2) of Railways Act, 1989.
The pamphlet which he had seized from the spot is Ex.PW-6/4 and the English
translation of the pamphlet has been given in para 3 of the affidavit of the witness.
During his examination before the Tribunal, the witness stated that the spot referred
in para 3 of the affidavit was visited by him and a gap of 2.5 metre broken rail and a
crater of 3 feet depth on the railway track was noticed by him.
The English translation of the pamphlet found at the railway track as given in
para 3 of the affidavit of the witness reads as under:-
10 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY |PAKT II—SKC. 3(ii)|
"Indian Government!
We condemn the visit of blood thirst wolf Rajapakshe to India and also
condemn Indian Government and Tamil Nadu Government for supporting the
annihilation of Tamil race. O Tamil— If we still keep silent they can't understand our
silent sufferings.
by His Excellency Prabhakaran's younger brothers."
14. PW-10 S.A. Seenivasan, Inspector of Police, Crime, B-l, North Beach PS,
Chennai has stated that on 14.08.2011 at about 09.00 AM when he was on patrol
along with other police officials, two persons, namely, Jesuraja and Ganesan were
found standing near Anakaputhur bus stand in a suspicious manner and were
questioned. Jesuraja was found in possession of three gelatin sticks and about 10
metre of wire which he was carrying in a bag. Ganesan was found carrying
EVEREADY batteries and three detonators, which he had kept in the bag being
carried by him. Those articles were seized and a case under Section 5 of Explosive
Substances Act, 1908 was registered. After obtaining police remand of those two
persons, he recorded confessional statement of accused Jesuraja in the presence of
Village Administrative Officers Mr. Ambrose and Mr. Kupuswamy. Pursuant to the
statement made by Jesuraja, he went to his residence and seized the articles
mentioned in para 4 of his affidavit vide memo Ex.PW-10/5. The confessional
statement of Jesuraja recorded by the witness is Ex.PW-7/4, whereas its English
version is Ex.PW-7/5. According to the witness, the accused Jesuraja had, inter alia,
told him that they were keeping detonators and batteries to damage public
properties, attract the attention of the Central and State Governments, organize a
bomb blast in Tamil Nadu and create chaos and confusion in the State, to show their
anger against the Central and State Government on killing of Tamil people and LTTE
cadres in Sri Lanka. The accused also told him that he was a member of Tamil Nadu
Liberation Front and according to the witness, there is linkage between Tamil Nadu
Liberation Front and LTTE since the cadres of Tamil Nadu Liberation Army were
trained by LTTE. The accused also told him that he was a member of Tamil Nadu
Liberation Army. According to the witness, there is a linkage between LTTE and
Tamil Nadu Liberation Army since the cadre of Tamil Nadu Liberation Army was
trained by LTTE.
15. PW-8 R. Selvarani, Sub-Inspector of Police, Video Piracy Cell, CBCID, St.
Thomas Mount, Chennai has stated that permission was granted to Thiru A.C. Raja,
Headquarters Secretary, Naam Thamizhar Katchi, to hold demonstration between
10.30 hrs and 11.30 hrs on 10.07.2010 in front of District Collector Office, Chennai.
She has further stated that at about 10.00 AM on that day, about 250 persons
carrying flags and banners embedded with image/portrait of LTTE leader
Prabhakaran in their hands and wearing the shirts and vests imprinted with his
photograph of LTTE assembled in front of District Collector Office, Chennai. Thiru
Seeman, Chief Coordinator of Naam Thamizhar Katchi gave a speech alleging
therein that Indian Army had gone to Sri Lanka, committed atrocities and indulged in
sexual assaults against Tamil womenfolk living there and thereby committed ethnic
carnage. Thiru Seeman supported the banned organization LTTE and threatened
that if Tamil fishermen are attacked, no Sinhalese student studying in this land can
return back alive to Sri Lanka. The proceedings of the demonstration were got
-«^w«M.«MpfH>iM>ii II • i«'i»ti( »"i f" i b ->ww^w<f mm**
[Wl II—W^ 3(ii)] Wd ^T TTTO : 3TOTWT
videographed and the special report submitted by the witness with respect to the
demonstration is Ex.PW-8/2. English version of her report is Ex.PW-8/3, whereas
the CD containing the speech delivered by Thiru Seeman is Ex.PW-8/4.
16. PW-2 G. Sampath Kumar, IPS, Superintendent of Police, 'Q' Branch, CID,
Chennai, has proved the constitution of Peoples' Front of Liberation Tigers (PFLT),
Ex.PW-2/4 and has stated that PFLT is the political wing of LTTE. He has also
proved the map Ex.PW-2/8 which includes some part of India as Greater Tamil Nadu
and the article Ex.PW-2/7 on Tamil Nadu Liberation Front (TNLF), which has been
downloaded from a website which is still alive. This witness has filed two volumes of
documents along with his affidavit. The first volume filed with his affidavit is Ex.PW-
2/2, whereas the second volume is Ex.PW-2/3. Volume 2, according to the witness,
comprises the cases registered against LTTE members, judgments delivered in
those cases and related matters.
17. PW-1 Ramesh Kumar Suman is Director, Internal Security-I Division, Ministry
of Home Affairs, Government of India, New Delhi, who has been dealing with this
matter. He has filed 06 volumes of documents which are Ex. PW-1/2 to PW-1/6 .
The volume Ex. PW-1/5 contains secret documents for the perusal of the Tribunal
and the Central Government is of the view that it would not be in the public interest to
disclose the documents contained in volume 5.
He has stated, on the basis of information and material received from the
State of Tamil Nadu and various intelligence agencies, that though LTTE is based in
Sri Lanka, it has sympathizers, promoters, agents and operators carrying on various
activities in India as well and it continues to look at Tamil Nadu as a base for carrying
out anti-India activities. According to him, the Central Government has information
which shows that LTTE continues to practice violent, disruptive and unlawful
activities, which are prejudicial to the territorial integrity and sovereignty of India. Its
activities continue to pose threat and are detrimental to the sovereignty and territorial
integrity of India. He has further stated that even after its military defeat in Sri Lanka,
LTTE has not abandoned the concept of Eelam and has been clandestinely working
towards the said cause through various activities and the LTTE cadres have also
initiated efforts to regroup them and resurrect the organization, locally and
internationally. He has stated that the information received by the Government of
India indicates that LTTE has been nursing strong grudge against India due to (i) the
ban imposed in India on the organization; (ii) sharing of intelligence by India with Sri
Lankan agencies; (iii) grant of military hardware and training to Sri Lankan Security
Forces by India and (iv) India's perceived silence over air attacks carried over by Sri '
Lankan Air Forces on the alleged civilian targets in Northern Sri Lanka. He has
claimed that the remains of LTTE continue to remain in force amongst expatriate
Tamils of India, sections of these elements subscribe to a strong anti-India policy and
they are also trying to reach out to militant groups from maoist to Sikhs, operating
against India, as a part of their desire for revenge against India. He has also stated
that though the struggle of LTTE is against Government of Sri Lanka, its larger and
ultimate objective is to form a larger Tamil country, including some areas of India
where Tamils are living, the Tamil Eelam concept still remains a goal amongst pro-
LTTE organizations and in spite of the ban on the organization being imposed, the
remnant cadres/agents/sympathizers continue to arrive in Tamil Nadu in the guise of
refugees of Sri Lanka and if their activities are not curbed, it would cause grave
12 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY (PART II—SEC. 3(ii)|
threat to the sovereignty and territorial integrity of India and security of various high
dignitaries.
18. The expression "Unlawful Association" has been defined as under in Section
2(p)oftheAct:-
"Unlawful Association" means any association-
(i) which has for its object any unlawful activity, or which
encourages or aids persons to undertake any unlawful
activity, or of which the members undertake such
activity; or
(ii) which has for its object any activity which is
punishable under section 153A or section 153B of the
Indian Penal Code (45 of 1860), or which encourages
or aids persons to undertake any such activity, or of
which the members undertake any such activity;
Provided that nothing contained in sub-clause shall apply to
the State of Jammu and Kashmir."
The expression "Unlawful Activity" has been defined as under in Section 2(o)
of the Act:-
"Unlawful Activity", in relation to an individual or association,
means any action taken by such individual or association
(whether by committing an act or by words, either spoken or
written, or by signs or by visible representation or
otherwise),-
(i) which is intended, or supports any claim, to bring
about, on any ground whatsoever, the cession of a
part of the territory of India or the secession of a part
of the territory of India from the Union, or which incites
any individual or group of individuals to bring about
such cession or secession; or
(ii) which disclaims, questions, disrupts or is intended to
disrupt the sovereignty and territorial integrity of India;
or
(iii) which causes or is intended to cause disaffection
against India;"
19. The expressions "Unlawful Activity" and "Unlawful Association" as contained
in the Act came up for consideration before the Supreme Court in Jamaat-E-islami
Hind v. Union of India (1995) 1 SCC 428 and the following view was taken:-
"An "unlawful activity", defined in clause (f), means "any
action taken" of the kind specified therein and having the
consequence mentioned. In other words, "any action taken"
Tr'TUTT""'"' """*Tirrr
[*TPT II—W5 3(H)] •mx\ ^T VWft : 3Wltmut 13
by such individual or association constituting an "unlawful
activity" must have the potential specified in the definition.
Determination of these facts constitutes the foundation for
declaring an association to be unlawful under sub-section (1)
of Section 3 of the Act. Clause (g) defines "unlawful
association" with reference to "unlawful activity" in sub-clause
(i) thereof, and in sub-clause (ii) the reference is to the
offences punishable under Section 153-A or Section 153-B of
the Indian Penal Code. In sub-clause (ii), the objective
determination is with reference to the offences punishable
under Section 153-A or Section 153-B of the IPC while in
sub-clause (i) it is with reference to "unlawful activity" as
defined in clause (f). These definitions make it clear that the
determination of the question whether any association is, or
has become, an unlawful association to justify such
declaration under sub-section (1) of Section 3 must be based
on an objective decision; and the determination should be
that "any action taken" by such association constitutes an
"unlawful activity" which is the object of the association or the
object is any activity punishable under Section 153-A or
Section 153:B IPC. It is only on the conclusion so reached in
an objective determination that a declaration can be made by
the Central Government under sub-section (1) of Section."
20. As regards the nature of inquiry contemplated by Section 4(3) of the Act,
Supreme Court in Jamaat-E-lslami Hind (supra) held as under: -
"11 The nature of inquiry contemplated by the Tribunal
requires it to weigh the material on which the notification
under sub-section (1) of Section 3 is issued by the Central
Government, the cause shown by the Association in reply to
the notice issued to it and take into consideration such
further information which it may call for, to decide the
existence of sufficient cause for declaring the Association to
be unlawful. The entire procedure contemplates an objective
determination made on the basis of material placed before
the Tribunal by the two sides; and the inquiry is in the nature
of adjudication of a lis between two parties, the outcome of
which depends on the weight of the material produced by
them. Credibility of the material should, ordinarily, be capable
of objective assessment. The decision to be made by the
Tribunal is "whether or not there is sufficient cause for
declaring the Association unlawful". Such a determination
requires the Tribunal to reach the conclusion that the
material to support the declaration outweighs the material
against it and the additional weight to support the declaration
is sufficient to sustain it. The test of greater probability
appears to be the pragmatic test applicable in the context.
14 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY (PART II—Stc. 3(ii)|
17. The reference to the Tribunal is for the purpose of
adjudicating whether or not there is sufficient cause for
declaring the Association unlawful. Obviously, the purpose is
to obtain a judicial confirmation of the existence of sufficient
cause to support the action taken. The confirmation is by a
sitting High Court Judge after a judicial scrutiny of the kind
indicated. This being the nature of inquiry and the purpose
for which it is conducted, the materials on which the
adjudication is to be made with opportunity to show cause
given to the Association, must be substantially in
consonance with the materials required to support a judicial
determination."
In State of Madras v. V.G. Row AIR 1952 SC 196, Supreme Court, inter
alia, held as under:-
"These grounds, taken by themselves, are factual and not
anticipatory or based on suspicion. An association is allowed
to be declared unlawful because it 'constitutes' a danger or
'has interfered or interferes' with the maintenance of public
order or 'has such interference for its object', etc. The factual
existence of these grounds is amenable to objective
determination by the court,.
(emphasis supplied)"
Holding that the test of factual existence of grounds, amenable to objective
determination by the Court, for judging the reasonableness of restrictions placed on
the right conferred by Article (1) to form associations, is equally applicable in the
scheme of Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967, Supreme Court in Jamaat-E-
Islami Hind (supra), inter alia, held as under;
"19 It is, therefore, this test which must determine the
meaning and content of the adjudication by the Tribunal of
the existence of sufficient cause for declaring the association
to be unlawful under the Act. A different construction to
equate the requirement of this Act with mere subjective
satisfaction of the Central Government, when the power to
declare an association to be unlawful depends on the factual
existence of the grounds which are amenable to objective
determination, would result in denuding the process of
adjudication by the Tribunal of the entire meaning and
content of the expression "adjudication."
Referring to the concept of natural justice, which is implicit in such
adjudication, the Apex Court, inter alia, observed as under: -
"21. To satisfy the minimum requirements of a proper
adjudication, it is necessary that the Tribunal should have the
means to ascertain the credibility of conflicting evidence
TT "g f i r 'Hr " " " ' ' •""* MII i I — H "
[Wl U—-QP5 3(H)] *TR<T ^ T TF5TO?f : 3 T O T W n 15
relating to the points in controversy. Unless such a means is
available to the Tribunal to determine the credibility of the
material before it, it cannot choose between conflicting
material and decide which one to prefer and accept. In such
a situation, the only option to it would be to accept the
opinion of the Central Government, without any means to
test the credibility of the material on which it is based. The
adjudication made would cease to be an objective
determination and be meaningless, equating the process
with mere acceptance of the ipse dixit of the Central
Government. The requirement of adjudication by the Tribunal
contemplated under the Act does not permit abdication of its
function by the Tribunal to the Central Government providing
merely its stamp of approval to the opinion of the Central
Government. The procedure to be followed by the Tribunal
must, therefore, be such which enables the Tribunal to itself
assess the credibility of conflicting material on any point in
controversy and evolve a process by which it can decide
whether to accept the version of the Central Government or
to reject it in the light of the other view asserted by the
association. The difficulty in this sphere is likely to arise in
relation to the evidence or material in respect of which the
Central Government claims non-disclosure on the ground of
public interest.
22. The scheme of the Act and the procedure for inquiry
indicated by the Rules framed thereunder provide for
maintenance of confidentiality, whenever required in public
interest. However, the non-disclosure of sensitive information
and evidence to the association and its office-bearers,
whenever justified in public interest, does not necessarily
imply its lion-disclosure to the Tribunal as well. In such cases
where the Tribunal is satisfied that nondisclosure of such
information to the association or its office-bearers is in public
interest, it may permit its non-disclosure to the association or
its office-bearers, but in order to perform its task of
adjudication as required by the Act, the Tribunal can look into
the same for the purpose of assessing the credibility of the
information and satisfying itself that it can safely act on the
same. In such a situation, the Tribunal can devise a suitable
procedure whereby it can itself examine and test the
credibility of such material before it decides to accept the
same for determining the existence of sufficient cause for
declaring the association to be unlawful. The materials need
not be confined only to legal evidence in the strict sense.
Such a procedure would ensure that the decision of the
Tribunal is an adjudication made on the points in controversy
after assessing the credibility of the material it has chosen to
16 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY (PART II—SEC. 3(ii)|
accept, without abdicating its function by merely acting on
the ipse dixit of the Central Government.
25. Such a modified procedure while ensuring confidentiality
of such information and its source, in public interest, also
enables the adjudicating authority to test the credibility of the
confidential information for the purpose of deciding whether it
has to be preferred to the conflicting evidence of the other
side. This modified procedure satisfies the minimum
requirements of natural justice and also retains the basic
element of an adjudicatory process which involves objective
determination of the factual basis of the action taken.
26. What is the fair procedure in a given case, would
depend on the materials constituting the factual foundation of
the notification and the manner in which the Tribunal can
assess its true worth. This has to be determined by the
Tribunal keeping in view the nature of its scrutiny, the
minimum requirement of natural justice, the fact that the
materials in such matters are not confined to legal evidence
in the strict sense, and that the scrutiny is not a criminal trial.
The Tribunal should form its opinion on all the points in
controversy after assessing for itself the credibility of the
material relating to it, even though it may not be disclosed to
the association, if the public interest so requires,
27. It follows that, ordinarily, the material on which the
Tribunal can place reliance for deciding the existence of
sufficient cause to support the declaration, must be of the
kind which is capable of judicial scrutiny. In this context, the
claim of privilege on the ground of public interest by the
Central Government would be permissible and the Tribunal is
empowered to devise a procedure by which it can satisfy
itself of the credibility of the material without disclosing the
same to the association, when public interest so requires.
The requirements of natural justice can be suitably modified
by the Tribunal to examine the material itself in the manner it
considers appropriate, to assess its credibility without
disclosing the same to the association. This modified
procedure would satisfy the minimum requirement of natural
justice and judicial scrutiny. The decision would then be that
of the Tribunal itself."
21. Two questions primarily arise for consideration of the Tribunal, the first
question being as to whether LTTE, as an organization stands wholly decimated or
continues to survive despite the military setback suffered in by it in Sri Lanka and the
second being as to whether there was cogent and relevant material before the
Central Government, justifying formation, of an opinion that this is an unlawful
association within the meaning of Section 2(p) of the Act.
"TTll""'¥""""" ' "-"'"'TfT WIM '
. fi IH ID I * .'I «l | •• HWmMNMtMIHMM***
[W] I I — ^ j ^ 3 ( i i ) ] 'IRcT ĴT TT3R̂ T : 3TOTVRWT 17
LTTE Continues To Survive
22. It has come in the deposition of PW3- G.Rengasamy and PW5 Rajiv Gandhi
that three members of LTTE cadre who procured ammunition in India for use of LTTE
in Sri Lanka, were arrested on 20th June, 2010 along with the ammunition. They
admitted being members of LTTE and procuring ammunition for use by it, albeit in Sri
Lanka. This happened after LTTE was banned vide notification dated 14th May
2010.
It has also come in the deposition of PW-10 -S.A. Seenivasan that as late as
in 14th August, 2011, two members of TNLA, cadre of which are trained by LTTE,
were arrested with explosives near Anakaputhur bus stand in Tamil Nadu. The
explosives were meant for blast in Tamil Nadu, to register protest, inter alia, against
killing of LTTE cadre in Sri Lanka, which clearly indicates a connection between
LTTE and TNLA.
PW-6 - R.Rajbabu found a gap in broken rail line and a crater on railway
Track, on Trichy Chennai Rail line on 12th June, 2010, after LTTE was banned vide
notification dated 14th May, 2010. The pamphlet found on the spot seems to have
emanated from LTTE cadres.
The deposition of PW-8 - R.Selvarani shows that on 10th July, 2010, after ban
on LTTE on 14th May, 2010, a large number of persons, carrying flags and banners
and wearing vests and shirts, depicting photograph of LTTE Chief Prabhakaran on
them, held a demonstration opposite office of the Collector in Chennai. This
evidence clearly shows that LTTE does not stand decimated and its cadres continue
to operate in the State of Tamil Nadu, though their strength may have substantially
dwindled, on account of the setbacks suffered by it.
Link Between LTTE and PFLT
23. It is stated in the affidavit of PW-1 Mr. Ramesh Kumar Suman that LTTE was
established in 1974 under the name of "Liberation Tigers" and changed its name to
"Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam(LTTE) in the year 1976 with Mr. V.Prabhakaran as
its Military Commander and it has declared "Liberation of the Traditional Homeland of
Tamils and establishment of an independent sovereign, socialist State of Tamil Nadu"
as its ultimate objective. He maintains in his affidavit that despite struggle of LTTE
being against Government of Sri Lanka, the larger objective of the organization is to
form a larger Tamil country, which would include some areas of India where Tamils
are living and if the ban on LTTE is lifted, it is likely to be highly detrimental to be
sovereignty and territorial integrity of India.
In his affidavit by way of evidence, PW-2 Mr. G.Sampath Kumar has stated
that LTTE had given to itself a Constitution, a copy of which is annexure 'B' (Volume-
II of his affidavit) and that People's Front of Liberation Tigers(PFLT) is a political
front of LTTE, which was formed on 5th May, 1976. He has further stated that Tamil
National Retrieval Tribunal (TNRT) is an underground organization which was formed
at the instance of LTTE and the objective of this outfit is to fight for an independent
homeland for Tamils, which would eventually extend the boundaries of Tamil Nadu to
form a Tamil Nation including what now comprises Tamil Nadu and certain areas in
Sri Lanka. According to him, this organization has close ties with LTTE. He has
THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY J PART II- SEC. 3(ii)|
further stated that another organization namely Tamil Nadu Liberation Army(TNLA)
also has close ties with LTTE, the objective of TNLA is secession of Tamil Nadu from
the Indian Union and the organization professes armed struggle as the only way to
achieve independence. The objective of TNLA, according to the witness, which
draws inspiration from LTTE, is also secession of Tamil Nadu from Indian Union. He
has also stated that another underground organization Tamil Nadu Liberation
Front(TNLF), which is a front organization of TNLA, has exhibited, on internet, a map
of Greater Tamil Nadu, which encompasses some areas of Sri Lanka, Tamil Nadu,
Kerala, Lakshdweeps and Maldives. The map is annexure P-3 to the affidavit of the
witness.
24. There is no rebuttal to the deposition of PW-2 - Shri G. Sampath Kumar that
PFLT is an organization formed by LTTE and is its political wing. LTTE has not come
forward to file any objection/reply/written statement, despite extensive publicity given
to the setting up of the Tribunal and the hearings scheduled before it, through print as
well as electronic media. Therefore, the evidence produced by the Central
Government and Government of Tamil Nadu remains practically unrebutted,
unchallenged and undisputed. In fact, even Mr. Vaiko admitted that PFLT was at one
time formed by LTTE. LTTE has not come forward to claim that it has no connection
with PFLT and it does not subscribe to the Constitution of this organization filed by
the Government. A perusal of Gazette notification dated 16th December, 1998
publishing the order dated 13th November, 1998 passed by an earlier Tribunal under
Section 4(3) of the Act would show that during the proceedings before the Tribunal
LTTE was represented by Mr. N.Chandrashekhran, Advocate . It further shows that
the Constitution of PFLT, which has been filed before this Tribunal, was also filed
before that Tribunal and reliance was placed upon it to show that the larger objective
of LTTE was to include Tamil areas of India as a part of Tamil Eelam, thereby posing
a real and serious threat to the sovereignty and integrity of India. It further shows
that during cross-examination by Mr. Chandrashekhran, counsel for the LTTE, the
witness deposing on behalf of Government stated that in the opinion of Government,
Tamil Homelands, mentioned in the Constitution of PFLT, meant the inclusion of
Tamil speaking areas of the Indian Union as well in the Tamil Eelams, though the
same was not specifically mentioned in the Constitution of PFLT. The witness further
stated that the inference which could be drawn from the objectives of the
organization, as stated in its Constitution, was that its larger objectives, given
geographical continuity and ethnic affinity, would include Tamil areas of India as well.
The order passed by the Tribunal would show that the counsel representing LTTE did
not dispute the assertion of the Government that PFLT was a wing of LTTE itself and
that the objectives of this organization are not the objectives of LTTE.
A perusal of the Gazette Notification dated December 7, 2000, publishing the
report of the next Tribunal dated 13th November, 2000 would show that during the
course of hearing LTTE was represented by the same counsel Mr.
N.Chandrashekhran and again reliance was placed by the Government on the
abovereferred Constitution and the inference drawn from it with respect to the
ultimate objectivfe of the LTTE. The order shows that the witness of the Government
stated before the Tribunal that Government of India had taken note of the
Constitution of the LTTE where it stated that the objective and ideology of the LTTE
was to protect and preserve the geographical identity and integrity of the traditional
homelands of Tamils and Muslims. He maintained that in the opinion of the
" " " " ' t f T l f f " " 1 1 1 " ' f""11 *"' *"' * « w w * w j i ' • ••' i
[*nr n—-s^ 3(ii>] «nTcr ^ Tî m : araT*rrFT 19
Government Tamil Homeland' mentioned in the Constitution of PFLT meant the
inclusion of the Tamil speaking areas of the Indian Union as well as the Tamil Eelam.
Though Mr. Chandreshekhran claimed that traditional homelands of Tamils and
Muslims mentioned in the Constitution meant the homeland only within the territory of
Sri Lanka and that Government of India had not correctly understood the notion of
Tamil Eelam, he did not claim that PFLT was an organization unconnected with
LTTE. He did not say that there was no link between LTTE and PFLT and did not
claim that LTTE did not endorse to the objectives of PFLT, as stated in its
Constitution. In these circumstances, it is difficult to say that there is no material
before this Tribunal to show that PFLT is an arm of LTTE itself.
25. The Tribunal which passed the orders on 13th November, 1998 and 13th
November, 2000 did not accept the contention that LTTE did not aim to include any
part of India to Tamil Eelam or that this was not the objective of the LTTE to form a
homeland for all Tamils, including the parts of India in that homeland. The Tribunal
thereby accepted the interpretation given by the Government to the objectives
contained in the Constitution of PFLT which was treated to be the Constitution of
LTTE. The Tribunal did not accept the contention of Mr. Chandreshekhran that the
traditional homelands of Tamils and Muslims mentioned in the Constitution meant a
homeland only within the Territory of Sri Lanka.
26. The Tribunal which upheld the ban, imposed vide Notification dated
14.5.1998, while confirming the declaration made by the Central Government, inter
alia, held as under:
".....Though, the immediate struggle of the LTTE is against
the Government of Sri Lanka for the establishment of Tamil
Eelam in the North East provinces of Sri Lanka, its larger and
ultimate objective is to form a larger Tamil country including
areas of India where the Tamils live and thus pose a threat to
the sovereignty and territorial integrity of India...."
A perusal of the order passed by the Tribunal which upheld the Notification
dated 14.5.2000 declaring LTTE to be an unlawful organization shows that the order
banning the organization was challenged, inter alia, on the following grounds:
(i) that the LTTE is a political organization representing
the Tamil people living in Sri Lanka who are being
subjected to genocidal oppression deprived of basic
human rights and systematically discriminated against
and persecuted as a people by Sri Lanka Government
dominated by the Sinhala people
LTTE neither disrupts nor presents any threat to the
sovereignty and territorial integrity of India and is not
an unlawful association as defined under the laws of
India and other international laws;
(ii) That the LTTE has no connection with any
organization that engaged in unlawful activities in
India;
(Hi) That the LTTE's activities do not fall within the ambit of
an unlawful activity "
20 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY |PART II -SRC. 3(ii)|
It was also submitted before the Tribunal that the Eelam meant only Ceylon
(Sri Lanka) and Tamil Eelam meant the Northern & Eastern provinces of Sri Lanka,
where the majority of Tamil population lives. This was also the contention of the
counsel representing the LTTE that neither Tamil Nadu nor any other part of the
world, where the Tamil lived, had ever been referred to as 'Eelam', either in the
ancient literary account or in the Government records. It was also submitted that there
was no evidence to show that the LTTE wanted to create Tamil Eelam including parts
of India. Rejecting the contention, the Tribunal, inter alia, held as under:
".....the larger objective of the LTTE and its supporters is to
fight for a separate homeland for Tamils not only in the
northern and eastern parts of Sri Lanka but even also in
India, thus affecting the sovereignty and territorial integrity of
India and Tamil Nadu.
Xxxx.
Though the immediate struggle of the LTTE is against the
Government of Sri Lanka for the establishment of Tamil
Eelam in the north east provinces of Sri Lanka, its larger and
ultimate objective is to be form a larger Tamil country
including areas of India where Tamil lives and this pose a
grave threat to the sovereignty and territorial integrity of
India.
Whether LTTE can be said to be an unlawful association:
27. As noted earlier, one of the aims and objectives of PFLT is to protect and
preserve the geographical identity and integrity of the 'traditional homelands of
Tamils and Muslims'. The contention of the learned Additional Solicitor General is
that it is the State of Tamil Nadu which has traditionally been considered to be the
homeland of Tamil and therefore, the ultimate objective of LTTE is to integrate
traditional Tamil areas of India with the Tamil speaking areas of Sri Lanka and such
an act constitutes 'unlawful activity' within the meaning of Section 2(o) of the Act,
being intended to bring about cession of a part of the territory of India. Since LTTE
has not come forward to appear before this Tribunal to contest the stand taken by the
Government with respect to the aims and objectives of LTTE/PFLT and the previous
Tribunals have not accepted the contention of the organization that it does not aim to
include parts of India to Tamil Eelam, I see no reason to reject the interpretation
given by the Government to the objectives set out in the Constitution of PFLT, which
is a part and parcel of LTTE. As rightly submitted by the learned Additional Solicitor
General, nothing prevented LTTE from coming forward to the Tribunal and take a
categorical stand that it does not subscribe to any such objective which is aimed at
cession of a part of the territory of India and does not advocate integration of one or
more parts of India with the Tamil speaking parts of Sri Lanka. But, in the absence of
any rebuttal from LTTE, there is no good ground to reject the unrebutted and
11 T f l " " " ' " I f r i f ' ^ ' l f " ""*" ' ' ' ' " • l » 1 M " P W I M linn n
[w\ n—'ops 3(H)] *m?r ^r TFTO : ^TOT^RDT 21
uncontroverted case of the Government with respect to the abovereferred aim and
objective of LTTE.
Though no map, indicating the areas comprised in the traditional homeland of
Tamils and Muslims, referred the constitution of PFLT, has been placed on record by
the Government. A copy of the map of Greater Tamil Nadu published by Tamil Nadu
Liberation Front has been filed. A perusal of the map would show that parts of'State
of Tamil Nadu have been shown as part of "Greater Tamil Nadu" in this map. The
demands of TNLF, as displayed on the home page of the organization comprise
'secession of Tamil Nadu from the artificial so-called Indian Union', 'the Re-
Unification of Eelam with liberated Tamil Nadu', 'the Re-Unification of Kerala with
liberated Tamil Nadu' and 'the Restoration of lost lands to Greater Tamil Nadu,
including the Kolar Gold Fields, Malnadu, Lakshadweep Islands, Maldives, and
Mauritius'. It has come in the deposition of PW-2 Mr. G. Sampath Kumar that TNLF
is an underground front organization of TNLA, the objective of which is cession of
Tamil Nadu from Indian Union and this organization has close ties with LTTE. It has
also come in the deposition of PW-10 that the cadre of TNLF and TNLA are trained
by LTTE. This part of his statement seems to be based upon the information
gathered by the witness from the accused persons, who were arrested in the case
investigated by him and, therefore, cannot be said to be without any basis. The
submission of learned Additional Solicitor General was that the areas of Tamil Nadu,
shown in the map published by TNLF, are the areas which have been described as
traditional homeland of Tamils and Muslims in the constitution of PFLT. Since LTTE
has not come forward to controvert the case of the Government in this regard and to
say that it has no connection with TNLF and TNLA, does not subscribe to the
concept of Greater Tamil Nadu espoused by TNLF in the map published by it and
does not support the demands of TNLF, as displayed on the internet, it will be
difficult to reject the case set up by the Government in this regard. This very map
was relied upon by the Government before the earlier Tribunals in support of its
contention that LTTE subscribed to the cessionist demands of TNLF as displayed on
the website. In the years 1998 and 2000, the Tribunals rejected the plea of LTTE
that the interpretation of the Government with respect to its objectives was incorrect
and upheld the ban on the organization. But, the order passed by the Tribunal was
not challenged by LTTE by way of judicial proceedings and the organization
continued to be banned. This indicates that the view taken by the previous Tribunals
came to be accepted by LTTE. The learned Additional Solicitor General, therefore,
is right in contending that the orders of the previous tribunals, not accepting the
stand taken by LTTE in this regard, in the years 1998 and 2000 by itself was a'
relevant material available to the Government, to continue the ban vide notification
dated 14th May, 2012. In fact, this very map has been relied upon by the Government
before other Tribunals as well, and accepted by them by upholding the ban.
Since one of the objectives of LTTE is cession a part of the territory of India, it
becomes an 'unlawful association' within the meaning of Section 2(p) of the Act and
the Central Government, therefore, had sufficient cause for declaring the LTTE to be
an unlawful association on this ground alone.
28. It has come in the deposition of PW-8 R. Selvarani and her report Ex.PW-8/2
that about 250 persons carrying flags and banners having image/portrait of LTTE
leader Prabhakaran embedded on them in their hands and wearing shirts and vests
*
>
22 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY [PART II—SET. 3(ii)|
imprinted with his photograph, had demonstrated in front of District Collector's Office,
in Chennai on 10.07.2012. The report further shows that Thiru Seeman, Chief
Coordinator of Naam Thamizhar Katchi had delivered a speech in that gathering
alleging that Indian Army had gone to Sri Lanka, committed atrocities and indulged in
sexual assaults against Tamil womenfolk living there and thereby committed ethnic
carnage. The demonstration was got videographed and the VCD of the same is Ex.
PW-8/4. The fact that the persons, who participated in the demonstration, were
carrying flags and banners embedded with images of LTTE leader Mr Prabhakaran
and were wearing shirts and vests having his photograph printed on them, indicates
that the above-referred demonstration was organized by LTTE through its cadre or
its sympathizers/supporters. Since LTTE has not come forward to claim that it had
no hand in organizing the above-referred demonstration. The Tribunal would be
justified in inferring that the rally was organized at its behest and the speech made
during the rally had its blessings.
To accuse Indian Army of indulging in sexual assaults against Tamil
womenfolk living in Sri Lanka and committing ethnic carnage there is certainly an
'unlawful activity' since it causes or at least is intended to cause disaffection against
India. The persons listening to such accusations are likely to form a serious negative
opinion with respect to the moral and character of Indian Army, which, in turn, is
bound to cause disaffection against India as a country. There is no evidence before
the Tribunal that the accusations made by Thiru Seeman are correct. No one has
come forward to justify these wild allegations. If it is falsely alleged that the Army of
a country committed acts of rape of womenfolk and ethnic carnage in another
country, it is likely to give rise to hatred against the country to which that army
belongs. The accusations made in the above-referred demonstrations against Indian
Army were general in nature, instead of being confined to a few unruly elements
amongst the army men who went to Sri Lanka as part of Indian Peace Keeping
Force Indian Army is a pride of the nation and any attempt to portray it as a force
indulging in heinous acts such as rapes and ethnic carnage is bound to tarnish the
image of the country as a whole. Accusing the force in general, of committing such
heinous crimes is bound to give rise to hatred in the minds of those innocent persons
who are gullible enough to believe such wild and unsubstantiated allegations.
29. I agree with Mr. Vaiko, General Secretary of MDMK, that giving speeches in
support of Sri Lanka Tamilians or condemning the acts of atrocities, if any,
committed against them in Sri Lanka cannot be objected to and does not constitute
an unlawful activity. The natural sympathy amongst people of Tamil Nadu, for the
Tamils in Sri Lanka needs to be understood and accepted by all of us, including
Government of India and Government of Tamil Nadu. The outrage in Tamil Nadu,
leading to protests and demonstrations to express solidarity with Sri Lankan Tamils
and criticize the activities alleged to have been committed against them needs to be
viewed in a correct perspective and cannot be a ground for banning an organization
as 'an unlawful association'. But, to accuse Indian Army of committing heinous
crimes, such as, rapes and ethnic carnage without even attempting to substantiate
those allegations, is certainly an act intended to cause disaffection against India as a
country because if the image of Indian Army, in general, is sullied in such a manner,
it is bound to tarnish the image of India as a country and thereby give rise to
disaffection against it. In fact, the whole objective of making such wild
»•'»'•»•«*• • ""w*irrr , ,w |! , 'f"'1111" ,*"""" •," •"' ~ »mi^»w*»*«*#'i* -••* i »•
[W\ II—T§PS 3 ( i i ) ] *TTCcT ^T TpSTT^ : 3WI*IKU| Z3
unsubstantiated allegations against Indian Army seems to be an act intended to
bring India "as a country into disrepute and invite hatred against it.
30. Mr. Vaiko submitted that Tamils in India are aggrieved and deeply hurt on
account of the serious atrocities have been committed against Tamilians in Sri Lanka
where a large number of Sri Lankan Tamils have been brutally killed by Sri Lanka
Army. If it is true, I agree with him that criticizing and condemning such acts1 and
even supporting LTTE to the extent it counters such atrocities would not constitute
an unlawful activity within the meaning of Section 2(o) of the Act. But, there can be
absolutely no justification for condemning Indian Army which went to Sri Lanka as a
Peace Keeping Force by accusing it of rape of Tamil womenfolk and ethnic carnage,
without substantiating those allegations.
31. It has come in the deposition of PW-6 R. Rajbabu that on 12.06.2010, he
noticed a gap of 2.5 metre broken rail and a crater of 3 feet depth on the railway
track on Trichy/Chennai railway line. A pamphlet was also found on the spot, which
condemned not only the visit of Sri Lankan President to India, but also the Indian
Government and Tamil Nadu Government for supporting the annihilation of Tamil
race. Criticizing and opposing the visit of Sri Lankan President to India is not an
unlawful activity. But, besides condemning the visit, this pamphlet also accuses
Government of India and Government of Tamil Nadu for supporting the killing of
Tamilians in Sri Lanka. There is no evidence of Government of India or Government
of Tamil Nadu having supported killing of Tamil population in Sri Lanka. Therefore,
to accuse Indian Government and Government of Tamil Nadu of supporting such
killings is an act intended to cause disaffection against India, particularly amongst
Tamil populace in India and abroad. Anybody coming across against such a
pamphlet and believing allegation made therein to be true, is bound to form a
negative impression against India as a country for supporting killing of innocent
civilians in Sri Lanka. The pamphlet purports to have been written by persons, who
described themselves as "Prabhakaran younger brothers". Prabhakaran being the
late leader of LTTE, and the organization having not come forward to disown the
incident and the pamphlet left at the spot, the logical inference would be that the
pamphlet was thrown by LTTE cadre, who also committed the act of breaking the
railway line and digging a crater on the railway track. An act of this nature is bound
to attract wide publicity on account of very serious nature of the act of breaking
railway line and digging a crater on railway track. The obvious purpose of the act,
therefore, seems to give publicity to the accusation made in the pamphlet thrown on
the spot, thereby creating negative feelings against Government of India and
Government of Tamil Nadu. Such an act constitutes 'unlawful activity' within the
meaning of Section 2(o) of the Act.
32. The deposition of PW-3 G. Rengasamy and PW-5 Rajeev Gandhi would show
that three members of LTTE cadre, namely, V. Chandrakanthan Nagarasa @
Satheesh @ Tamil @ Tamil Selvan, Subramaniyam Arulkulasingham @ Ramesh @
Myndhan @ Siva and Selvan @ Selvarasa had tried to smuggle detonators from
India to Sri Lanka for use of LTTE. The detonators were purchased by Mr.
Subramaniam (accused No. 2) and Selvarasa (accused No. 3) from nearby stone
quarries, at the instance of one Seelan, who was a French National, In-charge of
LTTE in France and were handed over to accused No.1 for being kept in the bakery
in which he was working at Trichy. As many as 1500 ordinary detonators and 200
24 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY |PART II—SEC. 3(ii)|
electric detonators were seized from the accused Nagarasa, in the presence of two
public witnesses.
In their confessional statement, all the three accused admitted that they were
members of LTTE cadre and had come to India to procure ammunition for use of
LTTE to Sri Lanka. It is true that no attempt was made by the Investigating Officer of
the case to get their statement recorded before a Magistrate. But, the Tribunal is not
a Criminal Court and is not holding a criminal trial, Section 25 of Evidence Act, which
renders the confession recorded before a police officer inadmissible in evidence,
does not ipso facto apply to the proceedings before it. Section 9 of the Act expressly
stipulates that the Tribunal, in holding any inquiry under sub-section (3) of Section 4
shall, as far as may be, apply the procedure laid down in the Code of Civil Procedure
for investigation of claims.
In Jamaat-E-lslami Hind (supra), Supreme Court held that the inquiry by the
Tribunal is in the nature of adjudication of a lis between two parties, the outcome of
which depends on the weight of the material produced by them. It was further held
that such a determination requires the Tribunal to reach the conclusion that the
material to support the declaration outweighs the material against it and the
additional weight to support the declaration is sufficient to sustain it. The test of
greater probability was approved by the Apex Court to be the pragmatic test
applicable in the context. The Apex Court held that the procedure to be followed by
the Tribunal should be such which enables it to assess the credibility of conflicting
material on points and controversy. The Apex Court held that the material before the
Tribunal need not be confined only to legal evidence in the sense and the scrutiny
before the Tribunal is not a criminal trial. The Tribunal, however, is expected to
assess the material produced before it and satisfy itself of its credibility. Therefore,
even the confession made to a police officer would constitute material which the
Government could have considered while banning LTTE and the Tribunal also can
take into consideration while passing an order under sub-section (3) of Section 4 of
the Act, after verifying the statement from the person to whom it was made. Since
the police officers, who recorded the confessional statement of these three persons
of LTTE cadre, have been examined before the Tribunal, the contemporaneous
documents, evidencing the confession have been produced and more importantly,
the confessions find corroboration from the recovery of detonators, I see no good
reason to exclude this material from consideration. Since LTTE has not come
forward to file any reply/objections, the evidence produced before the Tribunal in this
regard remains virtually unchallenged and there is no occasion for comparative
assessment of the material of two adverseries. Therefore, the Government has been
able to show that the members of LTTE cadre had come to India to smuggle
ammunition to Sri Lanka for use of LTTE. I have earlier held that the larger objective
of LTTE is to form an independent State by including parts of Indian territory in it.
Therefore, the act of smuggling ammunition into Sri Lanka by LTTE cadres is an
action which is intended ultimately to bring about cession of a part of the territory of
India, the objective of LTTE being to merge parts of Indian territory with certain parts
of Tamil speaking areas of Sri Lanka. The Government has thus been able to show
that LTTE cadres are engaged in unlawful activity in India by smuggling ammunition
from India to Sri Lanka.
,. ( ,| ..<.'< ""*fl| , ," l**|ffff*^"V I IM'" '" ' MW*"fW
[̂ TFT II—T3*S 3(ii)] *TRcT ^ TTsm : a r a m i ^ 25
33. In his written submissions, Mr Vaiko has submitted that in People's Union for
CM! Liberties and Anr y. Union of India: (2004) 9 SCC 580, Supreme Court had
taken a view that mere expression of sympathy for Tamil in Sri Lanka for whom
LTTE had become sole representative does not amount to supporting as terrorist
organization and Section 29 of Prevention of Terrorism Act (POTA) would not cover
any expression or activity which does not have the element or consequence of
furthering or encouraging terrorist activity or facilitating its commission. He submitted
that mere expression of sympathy or arranging a meeting which does not intent or
design and does not have the effect to further the activities of any terrorist
organization or commission of terrorist acts do not fall within the mischief of Section
21 of POTA.
The view taken by the Apex Court was the offences under Section 20 or 21 or
22 needs positive inference that a person has acted with intent of furthering or
encouraging terrorist activity or facilitating its commission. It was held that these
Sections are limited only to those activities that have the intent of encouraging,
furthering, promoting or facilitating the commission of terrorist activities. This
judgment seems to have no application to the issues involved in the present inquiry.
There can hardly be any dispute with the proposition that merely sympathizing with
LTTE or supporting the cause of Sri Lanka Tamilians espoused by it does not
constitute any unlawful activity as defined in the Act. But, if the members Of the
cadre indulge into activities which are intended to bring about cession of a part of a
territory of India or to cause disaffection against India that would certainly amount to
an unlawful activity within the Section 2(o) of the Act.
34. In his written submission, Mr. Vaiko submitted that this is not the objective of
LTTE to establish an independent sovereign State for ail Tamils living in different
parts of the world and it wants an independent State only for those Tamils living in
Sri Lanka. He further stated that this is not the objective of LTTE to take any part of
territory belonging to India. However, I am unable to accept this contention for the
reason that LTTE has not come forward to take such a stand and in the absence of
the association coming forward to dispute the claim, the material produced by the
Government to show that the ultimate objective of this organization is to create an
independent State comprising not only Tamil speaking parts of Sri Lanka, but also
certain parts of Tamil Nadu which are considered to be the traditional homeland for
Tamils and Muslims, cannot be rejected. Mr Vaiko also submitted that way back on
14.05.1976, a conference of Akhilla llankai Tamil United Front, held at Vattukottai
had passed a resolution stating therein that the State of Tamil Eelam will consist of
the people of Northern and Eastern provinces of Sri Lanka though Tamil speaking
people living in another parts of the world, may opt for citizenship of Tamil Eelam.
However, there is no material on record to show that the resolution, relied upon by
Mr Vaiko, was endorsed by LTTE. As noted earlier, the organization has not come
forward to declare before the Tribunal that it does not want cession of any part of
India or secession of a part of Indian territory from the Union and the earlier
Tribunals have not accepted its contention that Tamil Eelam is confined only to
certain Tamil speaking areas in Sri Lanka. Mr Vaiko submitted that a map of Tamil
Eelam, which used to be displayed on the Dais during address by LTTE leader
Prabhakaran, did not include any part of territory of India and this map is the official
map of Transnational Government of Tamil Eelam, making it quite clear that the area
26 THE GAZETTE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY |P,w II -Sa. 3(ii)|
of Tamil Eelam comprises only territorial area within the Island of Sri Lanka. Since
Mr Vaiko does not represent LTTE, I am unable to accept his submission as the
stand of LTTE before the Tribunal. Nothing prevented LTTE from coming forward
and taking the stand canvassed by Mr Vaiko.
35. Had the LTTE come forward in a proper manner to participate in the inquiry,
declared that (a) it has no connection with TNLA, TNLF or any other organizations
advocating cession of a part of Indian Territory or secession of an Indian territory
from the Union, (b) does not want any Indian territory to form part of Tamil Eelam, (c)
did not accuse Indian Army of raping Tamil women and indulging in ethnic carnage in
Sri Lanka; and (d) did not accuse Indian Government and Government of Tamil
Nadu of supporting killing of innocent Tamils in Sri Lanka, there could have been
justification to say that it is not or has ceased, to be an 'unlawful association' within
the meaning of Section 2(p) of the Act. But, that has not happened during the course
of this inquiry. All the allegations against the organization remain uncontroverted, the
evidence produced before the Tribunal remains unrebutted, and there has no
occasion to weigh the evidence produced by two contesting parties and decide
evidence of which party outweighs the evidence of the other. The evidence which
has been produced by the Central Government and the Court of Tamil Nadu before
this Tribunal cannot be said to be so intrinsically unbelievable and unreliable as to
warrant rejection even in the absence of being controverted by the opposite party i.e.
LTTE.
LTTE is one of the organizations listed in the Schedule meaning thereby that it
is a terrorist organization within the meaning of the Act. Section 2(m) of the Act
defines Terrorist Organization' to mean an organization listed in the Schedule or an
organization operating under the same name as an organization so listed. Section 35
(1)(c) empowers the Government to remove an organization from the Schedule.
Section 36 provides for an application being made to the Central Government to
exercise its powers to remove an organization from the Schedule and such an
application can be made either by the organization or by any person affected by the
inclusion of the organization in the Schedule as a 'terrorist organization'. In case
such an application is rejected, the applicant may seek a review by the Review
Committee to be constituted by the Central Government under Section 37(1) of the
Act. The Chairman of the Review Committee is to be a person who is or has been a
Judge of a High Court, The Review Committee is competent is allow an application
for review against rejection and to remove an organization from the Schedule. If such
an order is made by the Review Committee, the Central Government is obliged to
make an order removing the organization from the Schedule. However, no
application has so far been made by the LTTE or by any person affected by its
inclusion in the Schedule, for removing the name of the organization from the list.
Consequently, the LTTE continues to be a 'terrorist organization'.
36. Prior to issue of Notification dated 14.5.2012, LTTE was declared 'unlawful
association', vide Notification dated 14.5.2010. Three members of LTTE Cadre
namely Nagarasa, Subramaniyam and Selvarasa, who were attempting to smuggle
explosives to Sri Lanka for use of LTTE, were arrested thereafter on 20.6.2010 and
ammunition was recovered from them. The rail line was found broken and the
[•'"'""flilp'T""" ——7TT IH)II ii i , (mi. m »'N -f>\ m m n w
[iflTf n ^p is 3(ij)] tjm «FT tMW : STCTTSJP̂T 27
pamphlet .condemning the Indian Government and Tamil Nadu Government was
recovered on 12.6.2010. Inflammatory speech by Thiru Seeman was delivered at
Chennai on 10.7.2010. All this happened after issue of notification dated 14.5.2010.
Two other members of LTTE Cadre namely Jesuraja and Ganesan were arrested
and detonators were recovered from them on 14.8.2011, much after notification
dated 14.5.2010 and the ban on the organization being confirmed vide order dated
12.11.2010. These facts and circumstances clearly indicate that LTTE continues to
survive and persist with its activities, though its cadre strength may have dwindled on
account of the military setback suffered by it in Sri Lanka. The Central Government,
therefore, had sufficient ground, in the light of the material available to it, to continue
the ban on LTTE, so as to ensure that the organization does not gain momentum and
does not spread its activities, taking advantage of absence of the ban on it.
37. For the reasons stated hereinabove, I am of the considered view that there
was enough, cogent and relevant material before the Central Government, giving
rise to sufficient cause for declaring the LTTE to be an 'unlawful association1 within
the meaning of Section 2(p) of the Act. The declaration made by the Central
Government vide Notification dated 14.5.2012 published in Part-ll, Section 3 Sub
Section (ii) of the Gazette of India (Extraordinary), declaring the Liberation Tigers of
Tamil Eelam (LTTE) to be an unlawful association is hereby confirmed.
November 7, 2012
(JUSTICE V.K. JAIN)
UNLAWFUL ACTIVITIES (PREVENTION) TRIBUNAL
[F. No. 1-11034/1/2012-IS-l]
DHARMENDRA SHARMA, Jt. Secy.
Printed by the Manager, Government of India Press, Ring Road, Mayapuri, New Delhi-l IOOG-1
and Published by the Controller of Publications, Delhi-l 10054.