Notification regarding Extension of Haryana Housing Board Act to UT of Chandigarh
Notification - The Punjab Reorganisation Act, 1966
- Kind: Notification
- Under: The Punjab Reorganisation Act, 1966
Text of this notification
i
The Haryana Housing Board Act,
1971
(As extended to Chandigarh)
(See Chd. Admn. Gaz. Part X (Extra) dated 13-3^1975 page 34-35)
No. GS.R. 7 (£)~ In exercise of the powers conferred by section B7 of the
Punjab Reorganisation Act, 1966 (3 L of I9<SG), the Central Government hereby
extends to the Union Territory o f Chandigarh, the Haryana Housing Board Act,
1971 (Haryana Act 20 of 1971) as in force in the State of Haryana at the date o f
this notification, subject to the following modifications.
An Act to provide for measurers to be taken to dsat with and satisfy the
need of housing accommodation. .....
Be ft enacted by the Legislature of the State of Haryana in the Twenty-
second year of the Republic of India as follows :—•
' [ S t a t e m e n t o f O b j e c t s a n d R e a s o n s
Next to food and clothing, housing is the hasic necessity of mankind. The
housing problem has become serious on account of the phenomenal increase in
population. Rapid industrialisation has led to the congestions in urban areas. The
concentrat ion of almost all industries in urban areas and the comparat ive high
wages paid to the factory workers coupled with the lack of sufficient opportuni
ties in the rural areas have resulted in a large scale shift of population from vil
lages. With the object of easing the housing problem by constructing more houses
and raise Standards in the types of houses, the State Government have been imple
menting various housing schemer 'sponsored by the Government of India. Under
these schemes financial assistance in the shape of loans as well as grants is given
to the employers, local bodies, individuals, and co-operative societies of individuals
and industrial workers. The loan with interest at the rate payable to the Govern
ment of India plus 1/2 per centum as administrative charges is recovered in 15/25
annual equated instalments. Since the formation of the State of Haryana Rs. 1.57
crorc have been so disbursed.
2 . To tackle the stupendous problem of housing sufficient funds are required.
The funds, which are being allocated each year in the plan and out of L.I.C. funds
are very meager with the result that the problem continues. To meet the increas
ing demands for houses, Government resources alone are not sufficient. To'supple-
ment Government resources It was, therefore, imperative to mobilise additional
resources oy raising loans and debentures for housing schemes as •well as to
secure loans out of Central Revolving Fund, which is being created by the Gov
ernment of India with Rs. 200 crores.
3 . With a view to achieve the aforesaid object the matter was considered in
the conference of ministers for Housing, Urban Development and Town Planing
held at Bangalore from 18th to 20th June, 1969. The consensus of opinion was
1. Sec Haryana Govt. Gaz. (Extra) 1971 at Pnge 122
[ 4S7 ]
488 Haryana Housing Board Act, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh)
that the statutory State Housing Boards are the best agencies for tentative and
speedy implementation of the housings programmes. Accordingly, it is proposed to
constitute a Ifaiyana State Housing Ooard- Hence the Haryana Housing Board
Bill, 1971J
****
CHAPTER I
PRELIMINARY
1. Short title, extent and commencement* (1) This Act may be called the
Haryana Housing Board Act, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh).
(2) ft. exlundti to the whole ot the '[Union territory ot Chandigarh].
(3) It 3hnll come into force on such date as the [Administrator] may by
notification appoint in this behalf.
COMMENTARY
Excessive delegation - Notification - Extension of the Act to Chandigarh
-The notification Issued on 15.12.1986 by the Central Government under Section
87 of the Punjab Reorganisation Act, 1966 was challenged by a batch of appeals
on the ground of excessive delegation and abdication or effar.fiment legislative
powers and concept ot vacuum - After a detailed discussion on the various au
thorities on the subject and mainly relying upon Re Delhi Laws Act, 1951 SCR
747 it was held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court that the said provision otlaw is
constitutionally valid and is not repugnant to existing law - Extension of Punjab
Act, 1985 to Union Territory Chandigarh does not conflict with the existing law in
the Union Territory -There being only one notification under Section 87 the ques
tion of successive notification docs not arise-Alltho appeals dismissed, upholding
the decision of Full Bench of Punjab and Haryana llijdi Court in 1988 (1KR430 -
Rarnesh Birch unci utfiers v. Union of India and others, 1989 I IRK 399 S.C.
Delegation of power - Once it Is held that the delegation of a power to
extent a present existing law is justified a power to extend future laws is a neces- ,
sary corollary - Ramssh Birch v. Union of India and others, 1989 HRR 399
S.C.
Extension of laws - I t was contended by the Appellant's counsel that ex
tension of the lawa of another State to Chmidigaih is permissible so long as there
is a vacuum of laws .on any- particular subject within the Union Territoiy and a.
transplantation of law from elsewhere, is neither necessary nor valid - Repelling
ike cpnbnlion pflhu learned pgunscl'U.was held that so ton£ as thp provisions of.
the'extended law are Wot. repugnant to. an> Apt drParliamferit in ;force,ui.thei.Union
Territory, there ts nb reasoni to construe the scripe*p'fSection ,87 Jn, this rosiricled ;
manners suggested by counsel:- B^^esH^Btrchmd others y. Union qf;lridja-'-
and others, 1989 H R R 3 9 9 S . C - - . .'•,,"••' ;••">.- •<;-
2, Definitions.--- In this Act, unless the eontext otherwise requires,
(a) "adjoining area" means auch area aa may be specified to be an adjoining
area under section 31;
' [(*&) "Administrator" means the Administrator of the Union Territory of
Chandigarh appointed by the President under Article 239 of the
Constitution;]
(b) "Board" means the '[Housing Board, Chandigarh] established and
constituted under section 3;
• Subs, by Chd. Admn. Gax. Notification dnied 1.1-3-1975 at page 34-35
I. [Jiserted by Chd. Admn. Gaz. Nolificailon dated 13-3-1975 at page 34-35
Haryana Housing Board Act , 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh) 489
(c) "Board premises" means any premises belonging to o r vesting in the
Board or taken on lease by the Board or entrusted to the Board under
this A c t for management and use for the purposes o f t h i s Ac t ;
(d) "bu i ld ing materials" means such commodities or articles as are specified
by the ' [Admin is t ra tor ] by not i f icat ion to be bui ld ing materials for the
purposes o f t h i s Act ;
(e) "bye - laws" means bye-laws made under section 75;
( f ) "Cha i rman" means the Chairman o f the Board;
' [ ( f f ) " C h i e f Executive Of f i ce r " means the C h i e f Exsoutive Of f i ce r o f
the B o a r d ] :
(g ) ^ "competen t a u t h o r i t y " menus any person au tho r i sed by the
' [Admin i s t ra to r ] , by not i f icat ion, to per form the funel iuns u f LIIL-
competent authority under chapter V I tor such area as may be specified
in the notif ication;
(h) "hous ing scheme" means a housing sulieme made under this A c t ;
( i ) " L a n d " includes benefits to arise out o f land and things attached to the
earth or permanently fastened to anything attached to the earth ;
( j ) " looa l author i ty" means *f,the C h i e f Administrator exercising powers o f
a Mun ic ipa l i t y Or any funct ionary thereof under xnl> section (2) o f
section 7-A o t t h q Capital o f Punjab (Devwlupment and Regulat ion)
Ac t , 1952 (Punjab Ac t 27 o f 1952} o r a Gram Panehayat const i tuted
under the Punjab Cram Panehayat Act , 1952 (Punjab A c t 4 o f 1953),
or a Parichayal Sainit i or a Z i l a Porlflhnd constituted under the Purtfab
Panchnynt Samities nnd Z i l a Parishads Act , 1961 (Punjab A c t 3 o f
1961), or an improvement Trust constituted under the Punjab Town
Improvement Act , LP22 (Puryab A c t 4 o f 1922) ;
( k ) " M e m b e r " means a member o f the Board and includes the ^Cha i rman
and Ch ie f Executive O f f i c e r ] ;
(I) "premises" means land, any bui ld ing or part o f a bui ld ing and Includes.—
CO gardens, grounds and out-houscs, i f any, appertaining to such bu i ld ing
or part o f a bu i ld ing; and
( i i ) any f i t t ing aff ixed to such bui ld ing or part o f n bui ld ing for the more
benef ic ia l enjoyment thereof,
(m) "prescr ibed means prescribed by rules;
(t l ) " p rog ramme" means the annua! housing programme prepared by the
Board under sectiuj i 2 3 ;
(o) "Regu la t ions" means regulations made under section 74;
(p ) " r e n t " means the amount payable to the Board in respect o f the
occupation o f the Board's prem ises and includes the charges for water
and electr ic i ty payable in respect o f water nnd electr ic i ty used or
consumed in the premises;
(q) "Secretary" means the Secretary o f the Board;
( r ) " T r i b u n a l " means the Tr ihnnal specif ied under section 4 6 ; and
(s) "yeai ".means the year commencing on the fs tdey o f A p r i l and ending
nn the 31st day o f March.
* Subs, by Chd. Admn. Claz. Notification dnicd 13-3-1975 at page 34-35
1. (nsflrted by Hr. Act 27 of ISSOanwiindtdtoChd. vide d id . Adinn.Qaz. (extra) dated 2-4-1991
2, Subs, by' Hr. Act 27 of J 980 as extended to Chd. vjde Chd. Admn, Gas, (extra) doted 2-4-1951
490 Haryana Housing Board Act, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh)
CHAPTER If
ESTABLISHMENT OF T H E BOARD
3. Establishment and constitution of Board. - 0 ) With effect from such
date as the '[Administrator! may, by notification appoint in this behalf, there Shalt
be established for carrying out the purposes of this Act a Board to be Knownas
"the '[Housing Board, Chandigarh]", with headquarters at such place as the [Ad-
mTnis t rm^rna^spec^^ ^ ^ ^ aforesaid, be a body corporate having
perpetual succession and a common seal, and, subject to any restriction by or
under this Act or the rules made thereunder, shall have the power to acqu ire, hold,
administer and transfer property, movable or immovable, and to enter into con
tracts, and shall by the said name sue or be used and do all such things as are
necessary for which it is constituted. .
(3) For the purposes of this Act and the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 the
Board shall be deemed to be a local authority. ,
Explanation.-The purpose of this Act referred to in sub-section (3) includes
the management and use of lands and building belonging to or vesting m the Board
under or for the purposes of this Act and the e x c i s e of its rights over and with
respect to such lands and buildings for the purposes of this Act.
L[(4) The Board shall consist of a Chairman, a Chief Executive Officer and
seven other members appointed by the Administrator]. ;
(5) The '[Chairman, the Chief Executive Officer] or a member may at any
time resign his office by submitting his resignation to the '[Administrator] :
Provided that the resignation shall not take effect until it is accepted.
(6) Until the Board is established and constituted in accordance with the
provisions of the preceding sub-sections, the '[Administrator] may constitute a
Board consisting of one person, who shall be an "[officer employed in connection
with the affairs of the Union Territory of Chandigarh], to be appointed by the
•1 Administrator], anda Board so constituted shall, as from the commencement of
this Act *[- ] be deemed to be the Board established and constituted
for the purpose of carrying out all the provisions of this Act.
* * *
4. Non-applicability of East Punjab Art 3 of 1949. - The East Punjab
Urban Rent Restriction Act, 1949, shall not apply nor shall be deemed to have
ever applied to any land or building belonging to or vesting in the Board under or
for the purposes of this Act, and as against the Board to any tenancies or other
like relationship created by the Board in respect of such land or building but shall
apply to any land or building let to the Board.
www v * C O M M E N T S
Applicability of Rent Act -Allotment of houses made by Housing Board
Authorities on Hire Purchase Basis - Provisions of Rent Control Act would be
applicable to the allottee and his tenants 6r sub tenants,- An allottee can,induct a
tenant in the allotted premises - Section 4 or thw Act is no bar to the applicability of
E P Rent Act - AJqy-Kashyap v. Smt, MohiniNijliawan, 2004 H.R.R. 387 F,B.
.Provisions of the Act are applicable to the houses allotted under Haryana
Housing Board Act, 1971 (As applicable to Chandigarh) - It is apparent from die
prov isions of Section 4 of the Act read with Regulations 42,44 and 45 of Chandigarh
Housing Board (Allotment, Management and Sale ofTenemenls) Regulation, \979
*~s"ubs. by Chd, Admn. Gaz. Notification fated I3.3-I975at page 34-33
I Subs by Hr Act 27 Of 1980 as extended to Chd. vide Chd. Admn. Goz. (extra) dt,2-4-l99l
2. Omiltcd by Chd. Admn. Caz. Nolifiwtiori dated 13-3-1975 at page 34-35
Haryana Hou3injj Doard Act, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh) A9l
-> The relationship between the Board and the allottee woul.l hr* thnt ^f*
and its tenants - Allottee of Housing Board hasa rifft b ^ f f l , 5 ?L w ! * " ° W n c r
relationship between the ullortcp fcunTi.- * ! l \ m d u c l a s u l v f e n an t arid
Limited'scase A I R 1953 a i r in H i « ! n ? 1 A C o ~ 0 P e ^ ^ Housing Society
is permitted to take up the pi™ of ap»Iicatk>iof S e c l f o n A S & U J ? ? ^ £ n a n j
Kashyap v. A « . M , t o „ Nljhmv(m> 2?04 (1) I /f l R f 8 7 F S ** ^
aha la's case' 999 H R R S t , £ J? l ,8 inef t
J
deiVm!d i n ^ ^ " " j w w i
t r a i n e d N E M S S , n S t c d feSS^™1!! 1 rm£Hencd«¥*»r<*unot ha
599 ^vis ion accepted ^ RumaSharma v Afe//o>- (7/?^^, 2004(1) [T.R.R.
(a holds any office or place of profit under the Board- '
(y is an undischarged insolvent-
Sr Ji i t « convicted uf any offence involving moral tumitude
1(8)I m the opinion of the' {Administrator} - ^Piti ide.
(i) has become incapable uf acting or
(H) is otherwise unfit to continue as a member.]
* Subs, by Ctidi Admn. Gna. Notification daiaf I-i i K I T * . — m 7 " ~ " — • • • - —
492 Haryana Housing Board Act, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh)
(2) A person shall not be disqualified under clause (d) or clause (e) of sub
section (1) or be deemed to have any share or interest in any contract or employ
ment within the meaning of the said clause, by reason only of his or the incorpo
rated company of which he is a Director, Secretary, Manager or other salaried
officer having a share or interest in any newspaper in which any advertisement
relating to the affairs ofthe Board is inserted.
(3) A person shall not also be disqualified under clause (d) or clause (e) or
sub-seotion ( l ) or be deemed to have any share or interest in any incorporate
company wh ich has any share or interest in any contract or employment with, by
or on behalf of, the Board, by reason only of his being a shareholder of such
C°mP<p ro 'vided that such person discloses to the '(Administrator] the nature and
extent of the shares held by him.
7. Ten/is of office and conditions of service. - (1) Every member shall
hold office for a period of three years from the date of his appointment:
Provided that after the expiry ofthe period of his appointment, a person shall
be eligible for reappointment as member.
(2) Every member shall receive such salary and allowances as may be pre-
scribed *<•
(3) The salary and allowances to the member shall be paid from the fund of
the Board and such salaries and allowances and other conditions of service shall
be such as may be prescribed.
' r7-A * {Chairman, Chief Executive Officer and other members) to
hold office during pleasure of Administrator. - Notwithstanding anything contained
in section 3 or section 7 or any other provision of this Act the Chairman, Chief
Executive Officer and other members of the Board, shall hold office during the
pleasure ofthe Administrator]. . . , . « . f i r™. •
8. Filling of vacancies. - ( I ) Tf a vacancy occurs in the office of '[Chair
man, Chief Executive Officer or other member] by death, resignation, removal,
disqualification or otherwise, the vacancy shall be filled by the [Administrator] by
appointing a new ^Chairman, Chief Executive Officer or other member] to that
office. . ~«- L u i
(2) A ^Chairman, a Chief Executive Officer or any other member] ap
pointed to'fill the vacancy shall, notwithstanding anything contained in section 7,
hold office for the unexpired portion of the term of his predecessor.
9. Proceeding* presumed to be good and valid. - N o disqualification of,
or defect in the appointment of, any person acting as a ^Chairman, a Chief.Ex-
ocutlve Officer] or a member shall be deemed to vitiate any act or proceeding of
the Board if such act or proceedings is otherwise in accordance with the provi
sions of this Act.
10 Temporary absence of members. - If any member of the Board other
than the *[Chairman and the Chief Executive Officer] is by infirmity or otherwise
rendered temporarily incapable of performing his duties or is absent or on leave or
on any other ground not resulting in the cessation of his membership, die [Adminis
trator] may appoint another person to officiate for him and perform his duties
under this Act, or any rule or regulation made thereunder.
1 Inserted by Hr. Act 20 or 1979 as cxlendcd to Chd. vide Chd. Admn. Gaz. (extra) dt. 2-4-1991
2. Substituted by Hr.Act 27 oT 1980 as extended lo Chd, vide Chd. Admn. Gxs. (extra) dt. 2-4-1991
at page 333
Haryana Housing Board Act, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh) 493
11. Officers and servants of Board - (1) The '[Administrator] may appoint
a Secretary of the Board on such terms and conditions of s e m c e as it may deem fit-
(2) The Board may create such other posts and appoint such other officers
and servants thereto as it may consider necessary for the efficient discharge of its
duties:
1 {Provided that the previous sanction of the Administrator shall be obtained
for this purpose in respect of such categories of posts as may be specified by him
from time to time, by notification.}
(3) Subject to the provision of sub-section (1), the conditions of service,
functions and duties of the officers and servants or the Board shall be such as
may be determined by regulations.
12. Provident Fund. - (1) The "[Administrator] shall establish a Contribu
tory Provident Fund for the officers and servants of the Board and such Provident
Fund (hereinafter called "the Fund") sha!J, notwithstanding anything contained in
section S of the Provident Fund Act, 1925, be deemed to be a Government Provi
dent Fund for the purposes of the said Act.
(2) The Board shall in respect of each of its employees who is a subscriber
to the Fund, pay into the Fund such portion of the contribution in such manner as
the '[Administrator] may, from time to time, determine,
13. General disqualifications of officers and servants, - Mo person who
has directly, or indirectly, hy himself or his partner or agent, any share or interest
in any contract, by or on behalf of the Board, or in any employment under, by or on
behalf of the Board, otherwise than as an officer or servant thereof, shall become
or remain an officer or servant of the Board.
14. Appointment of Committees. - Subject to any rules made under this
Act, the Board may, from time to time, and for any^particular local area appoint
one or more committees for the purpose of discharging such duties or performing
such functions as it may delegate to them and any such committee may discharge
such duties or perform such functions with due regard to the circumstances and
requirements of that local area.
15. Meetings of the Board, - The Board shall meet and shall from time to
time make such bye-laws with respect to the day, time, place, notice, management
and adjournment of its meetings as it minks fit, subject to the following provisions,
namely: -
i[(a) an ordinary mooting shall be held at least once in three months;]
(b) the Chairman may, whenever he thinks fit, call special meetings;
(c) Every meeting shall be presided over by the Chairman and in his absence
by any member chosen by the members present at the meeting for the
occasion;
(d) the quorum for every meeting shall be '[one-half] of the number of
members actually serving for the time being;
(e) all questions at any meeting shall be decided by a majority .of. the
members present and voting and in the case of equality of votes, the
person presiding shall in addition to his vote as a member, have second
or casting vote; and
(f) the minutes of the proceedings of each meeting shall be recorded in a
book to be provided for the purpose and a copy of such minutes shall
be forwarded to the '[Administrator] in the department concerned.
a_i ^ • ^ ^ M I H I —_i i i u m u u u • • ——-- — — - - - - - - — - • - - - - - - — - - - - - — — - - — — - — — — - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ mM -— — — — - - - - - - - - ^mmmm-mm i _ _ - « u «
* Subs, by d id . Admn. Gaz. Nvtifieatipn dated 13-3-1975 at page 34-35
1. Subs-' by Hr. Act 10 of 1989 M extended to Chd, vide Chd. Admn, Gfiz. (extra) dt. 2-4-1991
2. mserted by Hr. Act No. 8 oFI973 published on 23-4-1973
494 Haryana Housing Board Act, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh)
16. Association of parsons with Board. - (1) The Board may associate
with itself, any person whose assistance or advice it may deem fit for carrying into
effect any. of theproyisirms of this Act. " - ' . • - •
(2) A personasso^iated with the Board.under s'ub-seotion (1) for any pur
pose shall have the right to take part in the meetings of the Board relevant to that
purpose; but shall not have the right to vote.
(3) The Administrator may, by order, depute its representatives to attend any
meeting of the Board, on such items or subjects as the '[Administrator] may
specify, but such representatives shall not have the right to vpte.
17. Power to make contracts- - The Board may enter into and perform or
require the performance of all such contracts as it may consider necessary or
expedient for carrying out any of the purposes of this Act.
MIS. Execution of contracts. - (1) Every contract shall be made in the
name of the Board by z[the Chief Executive Officer] or such other officer of the
Board as may bo authorised by i t ;
Provided that no contract involving an expenditure of twenty lakhs rupees or
more shall be made without the previous sanction of the '[Administrator].}
(2) Sub-section ( I ) shall apply to every variation or abandonment of a con
tract or estimate as well as to an original contract or estimate.
(3) Every contract '[for and] on behalf of the Board shall, subject to the
provisions of this section, be entered into, in such manner and form, as may be
prescribed. . . . . , . . ... - ,
(4j Acon t rac tno t made or executed as provided in this section and the rules
made thereunder shall not be binding on the Board.
C O M M E N T A R Y
A p p o i n t m e n t of C h a i r m a n - Where the appointment of the Chairman was
for three years as mentioned in the notification under S. 3 of the A c t Subse
quently the notification was withdrawn. It was held that the Chairman was work
ing properly without suffering any disability during his tenure as such was entitled
to complete the full tenure and an order to withdraw the notification was quashed
- S.S. Virdi v. Chandigarh Administration and others. 1991 (1) Rev. L.R. 25
' [19. (Omitted)
C H A T T E R I I I
H O U S I N G S C H E M E
20, Duty of Board to undertake Housing Schemes. - Subject to the pro
visions of this Act and subject to the cont rofor the '[Administrator], the Board
may incur expenditure and undertake works in any area for the framing and ex
ecution of such housing schemes as may consider necessary from time to time or
as may be entrusted to it by the *[AdministratorJ-
2 1 . Matters to be provided for by Housing Scheme. - Notwithstanding
any thing contained in any other law for the time being in force, a housing scheme
may provide for all or any of the following matters, n&mely ;-
(a) acquisi t ion by purchase, exchange or otherwise of any property
necessary for or affected by the execution of the scheme;
(b) acquisition by purchase, exchange o r otherwise of any land, division of
the same into plots and the sale thereof after developing itor otherwise
* Subs, by Chd. Admn. Gaz. Moiification dated 13-3-1975 at page 34-35
1. Substituted by Hr. Aoi No. 9 of 1973
2. Subs, by Hr. Act27on980asoxlcnJ«lnjClnl. videChd, Admn. Gas, (extra) dt, 2-4-1991
3. Section 19wflsomilted by Hr. Act No. B of 1973 published or 23-4-1973
Haryana Housing Board Act, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh) 495
4
to co-operative societies or other persons, in accordance with the
scheme;
c) laying or re-laying out of any land comprised in the scheme ;
d> distribution or rc-distribution of sites belonging to owners of property
comprised iti the scheme;
(c) the closure or demolition of dwel lings or portions of dwellings unit for
human habitation;
(f) demolition of obstructive buildings or portions of buildings;
(g) the construction and re-construction of buildings, their maintenance
and preservation ;
(h) sale, letting or exchange of any properly comprised in the scheme
(i) construction sind alteration ofs t reetsand back Janes ;
(j) drainage, water-supply and lighting of the area included in the schemes;
(k) parks, playing-fields and open spaces for the benefit of any area
comprised in the scheme and the enlargement of existing parks, playing
fields, open spaces and approaches;
(1) sanitary arrangements required for the area comprised in the scheme,
including the conservation and prevention of any injury or contamination
to rivers or other sources and means of water supply ;
(m) accommodation For any class of inhabitants, industries, institutions,
offices, local authorities, Co-operatives or Corporate bodies;
(n) advance of money for purpose of the scheme;
(o) facilities for communication and transport;
(p) collection of such information and statistics as may be necessary for
the purpose of this A c t ; and
(q) any other matter for which, in the opinion of the ' [Administrator], it is
exped ien t to m a k e provis ion with a v iew to p rov ide hous ing
accommodation and, or, to the improvement or development of any
area comprised in the scheme or any adjoining area or the general
efficiency of the scheme.
Explanation. - For the purposes of this section the '[Administrator] may,
on the recommendation of the Board, by notification, specify area
surrounding or adjoining the area included in a housing scheme to be
the adj o i n i ng area.
2 2 . No homing scheme f(> be made fQr area included in improvement
scheme or be inconsistent with town planning scheme. - ( I ) No housing scheme
shall be made under this Act for any area for which an improvement scheme has
been sanctioned by the ' [Administrator] under the Punjab Town Improvement
Act, 1922, or any other enactment for the time being in force, nor any housing
scheme made under this Act shall contain any thing which is inconsistent with any
of the matter included in a town planning scheme sanctioned by the '[Administra
tor], under ' [ the Haryana Municipal Act, 1973] ; or any other enactment for the
dme being in force.
(2) If any dispute arises whether a housing scheme made under this Act
includes any area included in an improvement scheme sanctioned under any en
actment referred,to in sub-section ( I ) or contains anything inconsistent with any
matter included in a town planning scheme sanctioned under the '[Haryana Mu-
* Subs, by Cll4Admii. Gaz. Notification dated 13-3-1975 oi page 34-33
1. Substituted b y Hr. Act 27 o f 1980 as extended! to Chd.
49G Haryana Mousing Board Act, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh)
nicipal Act, 1973] or any other enactment For the time being in force, the same
shall be referred to the '[Administrator] whose decision shall bE final.
.23. Preparation and submission of annual housing programme, budget
and establishment schedule.—(I) Before (he first day of December in each
year the Board ^sha'Il prepare and forward to the '[Administrator] in such form as
may by. prescribed-
••'"' ' •'".• (i) a. program me
! •£:'.:'•'•' . '•' 00'*' budget for the next year ; and
• .-• •^ . :( i i j ) a schedule of Che staff of officers and servants already employed and
'.' 'to be employed during the next year,
(2) The programme shall contain, —
(i) such particulars of housing schemes which die Board proposes to execute
whether in part or whole during tlie next year as may be prescribed;
•:\..- (iij the particulars ofany undertaking which the Doard propose to organise
orexecute during the next year for the purpose of production orbuildiiig
' materials; and
(Mi) such other particulars as may be prescribed.
(3) The budget shall contain a statement showing the estimated receipts and
expenditure dn-capita! and revenue accounts for the next year.
Z4. Sanction to'programme, budget and establishment .schedule. - The
.^.[Administrator] may^sanction thbprogramme, budget and the schedule of the
1 . stapfrdf officers and servants forwarded to it with such modification as it deems
"fit;- '••'•'->•. v ^ r s ? ; ^ • . - ; • = . : •v':;; v - > . : x .... . .
25. 'Publicatio^t''-oy\Sffne^ioMd-prp^rtifttme, - The '[Administrator] shall
publish the programme san.ctiohed.by it under seotion 24 in the '[Chandigarh Ga-
..,. sette.l
" "•:'-.;,26. Supplementary programme and budget, - The Board may, at any
time, duririg^he year, in respect of which a programme has been sanctioned under
section 24 submit a supplementary programme and budget and the additional sched
ule of the staff, if any, to the '[Administrator] and the proves ions of sections 24 and
25 shall apply to such supplementary programme.
, ,. , 27. Variation of programme by Board after it has been sanctioned. -
The Bd'ard rhay,:at any time, vary any programme or any part thereoFsanctioned
by the'[Administrator] ;..
Provided that no such variation shall be made if it involves anexpenditure in
excess often per centum of the amount as originally sanctioned for the execution
ofany housing scheme included in such programme or affects its scope or pur
pose.
28. Sanctioned housing scheme to be executed. - After the programme
has been sanctioned and published by the "[Administrator] under sections 24 and'
25, the Board shall, subject to the provisions of section 27, proceed to execute the
housing scheme included in the programme.
29. Publication of housing scheme in the Official Gazette. - (1) Before
proceeding to execute any housing scheme under section 28, the Bo<ird shall by
notification publish the scheme. The notification shall specify that the plan show
ing the area which is proposed to be included in the housing scheme and the
surrounding lands shall be open to inspection ofthe public at all reasonable hours
at the office of the Board.
(2) If within two weeks from the date of the publication of the housing
scheme any person communicates in writing to the Board any suggestion orob-
* Substituted by Chd, Admn. Caz. Notification dated 13-3-1975 at page 34-35
http://san.ctiohed.by
Haryana Housing Board Act, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh) 497
•
jection relating to the scheme, the Board shall consider such suggestion or objec
tion and may modify the scheme as it thinks fit.
«•• ^lTn° B°^ thaI! the"} by notification publish the final scheme. The notifi
cation shall specify that the plan showing the area included in the final scheme and
the surrounding lands and other particulars as may be prescribed .shall be open to
inspection of the public at all reasonable hours at the office of the Board.
W lnepubIicatiorjofanotcficatronundersiifvsection{3)shaHbeconclusive
evidence that the said scheme has been duly framed.
„ ttJS'J^n*{fr & Board for purposes of housing scheme of land vested in
a local authority. - (1) Whenever any street, square or other land, or any part
thereof situated in any area of a local authority and vested in the local authority is
required lor the purpose of any housing scheme sanctioned by the '[Administra-
rorj, tile 1 ioarrl shall give notice accordingly to the local authority.
« . 1 ' Where ,t,he loc.al authority concurs, such street, square or other land, or
part thereof, shall vest In the Board.
• . *®) 35?°.t?i
tf]w? '.3 any d i sP" te the matter shall be referred to the VAdmin-
lstratorj. The [Administrator] shall, after hearing the parties, decide the matter.
I lie decision of the [Administrator] shall be final. If the ^Administrator] decides
that such street, square or land shall vest in the Board, it shall vest accordini*iy
W Nothing in this section shall affect the rights or powers of the local au
thority in or over any drain or water works in such street, square or land
31, Compensation in respect of land vested in Board. - (1) Where anv
land vests in the Board under the provisions of section 30 and the Board makes a
declaration that such land shall be retained by the Board only until itrevests in the
™S,n S S 7 ? " P*£ °if ^ u ^ °r/n °Poti S p a c e u n d c r s e c t i o n 34» n o compensation shall be payable by the Board to the local authority in respect of that land
{J.) Where any land vests in the Board under section 30 and no declaration h
S S f i S S T S u b - S e c t i o ? & in aspect of the land, the Board shall payto S &
authority as compensation a sum equal tn the value of such land
hnA
( U ' m u a n y C ? S e ^ C I ? t h c U o a r d h a s m a d e a declaration in respect of any
S ! t r m a ^ b " f e C t * P ° ° V h ? ? ° ? r d r* t a i n s ° r d i s P ^ s of the land contrary to
Hie terms of declaration so that the land does not re-vest in the local authority, the
feenrdni™ £?£ I? * * , 0-0°' auth°lil? compensation in respect of such land in accordance with the provisions of sub-section (2).
n n „ , 3 1 Power of Board to turn or close public street vested in it. - m Thc
Sblfc S E £ £ d J r V S C O n t i n u e ^ P u b , i c u s e of* ° r Permanently close, any public street vested in it or any part thereof.
«nv n S ? ! ^ n e ? r thf ^ a r d d i s o o n t i n u e s t h c P^Iic use of, or permanently closes,
™ £ffh«^ ° hw .eaaonable means of access to be substituted in lieu of the
Hon £ £ ° S e ° n t I t , e d ' °v t h ? s t r e ? t . o r P a r t hereof and pay reasonable compe l* !
oubll? t^Z^f^? 1S e f ! l l t l e d ' o t h e r w i « than V a mere member of the
C m such dfscontuanclofSosing 0 m e H n S °f "™ ^ h a S S U f f e " d d a m a * *
tiQn r<? W ? ie t e2T'u'1!? t ^ compensation payable to any person under sub-sec-
concS. ; • B o a r d . s h a " make al lowance for any benefit accruing to him from the
^ r ?k'f*u ti" ° r , m P r o v c m e n t ofany other public street at or about the
ttnnl ?J a t i - h e p U 5 h 0 T C t ? r p a r t t h e r e o f - o n a c c o u n t of which the compcr,™-tion is paid, is discontinued or closed, *™»™
* SubsMiutcd by Chd. Admn. Gaz. Noiifiealion dated 13-3-1975 at page 34-35*
498 Haryana Housing Board Act, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh)
(4) When any public street vested in the Board is permanently closed under
sub-section (1), the Board may sell or lease so much of the same as is no longer
33. Reference to Government in case of dispute under section 31 and
32. - if there is any dispute as to whether any compensation is payable under
section 31 or section 32 or as to the amount of compensation payable under sec
tion 31 or section 32, as the case may be, the matter shall be referred to the
Tribunal- .
34. Vesting in the local authority of streets laid out or altered ana open
spaces provided by Board under housing scheme. - (1) Whenever the [Ad
ministrator] is satisfied.-
(a) that any street laid out or altered by the Board has been duly levelled,
paved, metalled, flagged, channeled, sewered and drained in the manner
provided in the programme sanctioned by the '[Administrator] under
section 24 or varied under section 27 or modified under section 29;
(b) that such lamps, lamps-posts and other apparatus as the local authority
considers necessary for the lighting of such street and as ought to be
provided by the Boardhave been so provided ; and
(c) that water and other sanitary conveniences have been duly provided in,
such street;
the '[Administrator] may declare the street to be a public street, and the street
shall thereupon vest in the local authority and shall thenceforth be maintained,
kept in repair, lighted and cleaned by the local authority.
(2) When any open space for the purposes of ventilation or recreation has
been provided by the Board in executing any housing scheme, it shall on.comple-
tion be transferred to the local authority concerned, by resolution of the Board,
and shall thereupon vest in, and be maintained at the expense of, the local author
ity. .
(3) If any difference of opinion arises between the Board and the local
authority in respect of any matter referred to in the foregoing provisions of this
section the matter shall be referred to the '[Administrator] whose decision shall
be Final.
35. Other duties of Board. - 11 shall be the duty of the Board to lake
measures with & view to expediting and cheapening construction of buildings and
the Board may for that purpose do all things for. -
(a) unification, simplification and standard isationof building materials;
(b) encouraging pre-fabrication and mass production of house components;
(c) organising or undertaking the production of building materials required
for the housing scheme ;
(d) encouraging research for discovering cheap building materials and
evolving new methods of economic construction;
(e) securing a steady and sufficient supply Of workmen trained in the
work of construction of buildings.
36. Board to assume management of requisitioned lands. - The Board
shall, if the '[Administrator] so directs, and subject to the general control of the
"[Administrator], assume management of all or any of the lands requisitioned by
or under authority of the '[Administrator].
* Substituted by Chd, Admn. Gaz. Notification dated 13-3-1975 at page 34-35
Haryana Housing J3oard Act, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh) 499
*
37. Reconstitutiott of plots. - A housing scheme may provide, —
(a) for the formation of a reconstituted plot by the alteration of the
boundaries of an original plul ,
<b) whli the consent of the owners that two or more original plots each of
which is held in ownership in severally or in joint ownership shall, with
or without alteration of boundaries, be held in ownership In common
as a reconstituted p lo t ;
(c) for the allotment of a plot of any owner d is possessed of land in
furtherance of the housing 3cheme; and
(d) for the transfer of ownership of plot from one person to another.
38. Schemes entrusted to Board by YAdminlslralorj. - The provisions of
section 21 and section 23 to 19 (both inclusive) shall not be applicable to any
housing aohemc entrusted to the Board by the '[Administrator] except to such
CKtent and subject to HIIUII mortifications as may be specified in any general or
special order made by the '[Administrator] and every such order shall be pub
lished in the 'fChandigarh Gazette].
**+
C H A P T E R I V
Acquis i t ion a n d Disposa l of L a n d
39. Power tu purchase, lease or acquire land, - m The Board may enter
into an agreement with any person or the '1 Administrator] For the acquisition from
him by purchase, lease or exchange, of any land which is needed for ihc purposes
of a housing scheme or any interest in such land or for compensating the owners
nf any such, right In respect of any deprivation thereof or interference therewith :
'[Provided that the previoua approval of the Administrator .-shall be obtained
in case oFpurehase or exchange involving land worth more than fifty lakhs rupees
or lease for inure than five years.]
(2) The Board may, from such date as the '[Administrator] may appoint by
notification in this behalf, also take steps for .the compulsory acquisition of any
land or any interest therein required for the execution of a housing scheme in the
manner provided in the Land Acquisition Act, 1394. as modified by this Act- and
th* acquisition of any land or any interest therein For the purpose ofthis Act shall
be deemed to LB acquisition for a public purpose within the meaning of thv Land
Acquisition Act, 1894.
10. Bcttcrucnt charges. - ( l ) When by the making nfa housing scheme the
value of any land in the area comprised in the scheme will, in the opinion of the
Board he increased, the Board in framing the scheme may declare that Letter-
ment charges shall be payable by the owner of the land ur any person having an
interest therein in respect of the increase In value of the land from the execution
Drth« scheme.
(2) Such increase in value shall bo the amount by which the value of the land
on the completion of the execution of the scheme estimated as if the land were
clear of the buildings exceeds the value of the land prior to the execution of the
scheme estimated in like manner and the betterment diarizes shall be one - half of
Such increase in value.
(3) Such betterment charges .shall also be leviable in respect of any land not
comprised In the scheme but adjacent to the area comprised in the scheme.
(^Notwithstanding anything contained in subject ion (1) and (3), in respect
of any land used for agricultural purposes at the time of the execution o f t h e
• Substituted by Chd. Admn. Gst Notification dated 13-3-1975 nl pane 34-35 ~ "~
1. Substituted by Mr. Act No. 10 nf 1989 as extended to Ch&ndigorh published on 2-4-1991
500 Hnryana Mousing Roarri ACT, 1971 (AS (mended ro Chandigarh)
schemes the betterment charges shall be leviable by the Board in accordance
with such procedure as may be prescribed, only otter such land is used, or con
verted for use for non agricultural purposes.
4L Notice io person liable for betterment charges, - (1) The Board shall
give notice in the prescribed form to «ny person, who Is the owner of or fins
interest in the land in respect of which the betterment charges are to be levied and
shall give such person an opportunity to be heard.
(2) After hearing such person or if such person is required to appear before
the Board, the Board shall proceed to assess the amount of betterment charges.
(3) Where the assessumiiL of buUcruieiil charges proposed by this Board is
accepted by the person concerned within the period prescribed, the Assessment
shall be final.
(4) If the person concerned does not accept the assessment proposed by the
Boards the matter shall be referred to the Tribunal,
(5) The Tribunal shall, after holding an enquiry and after hear! ng the person
concerned assess the amount of the betterment charges payable by the person.
42. Agreement for payment of betterment charges. - (1) Any person
liable to pay betterment charges in respect of any land may at his option instead of
paying the same to the Board, execute on agreement with the Board, to leave the
payment outstanding JIS a charge on his interest in the land, subject to the payment
in perpetuity of interest at such rale as may be prescribed.
(2) Every payment due from any person in respect of betterment charges
and every charge referred to in sub-section (1) shall, notwithstanding anything
contained in any other enactment and notwithstanding the execution of any mort
gage^ or charge, created either before or after the commencement of this Act, be
the first charge upon the interest of such person in such land.
43. Recovery ofbetterment charges. - All sums payable in respect of any
land by any pereon in respect of betterment charges under section 40 or by any
person under an agreement under section 42 shall be recoverable on behalf of the
Board as arrears of land revenue.
44. Power to dispose of land. - Subject to any rules made by die '[Admin
istrator] under this Act, the Board may retain, lease, sell, exchange or otherwise
dispose ofany land, building or other property vested in it and situate in the area
comprised in any housing scheme sanctioned under this Act.
COMMENTARY
Allotment or houses - Escalation of price - It was stipulated in the bro
chure that price escalation if any, would not exceed 10% of the original price -
Development Authority Is bound by terms of agreement In view of provision of
Section 10 of Contract Act 1872 - Authorities raised 4-1/ times in price keeping
aside the terms of agreement - Act of Authorities obviously is violative of Article
14 ofthe Constitution as well as provisions of Section 15 of Contract Act- Price
cHiiiinL excised l.he prescribed limits - In such case Author!lies are required to
satisfy the court that escalation in price Is not done In arbitrary and erratic manner
- Prashant Kumar s case (2000)4 S.C.C. 120 distinguished and D.D.A. b case
A.I.R. 1995 S.C. 1 followed Kanpur Development- Authority v. Suit. Shccla
Devi, 2004(1) II,R.R. 1 S.C.
AHulnicnl tifH.T.G. huuses - Discriiiiiuaiiun - The (musing Rt.mrtl allot
ted houses in favour of some officers and ignored the petitioner who was similarity
situated - Order wholly unjustified - Shri L.R. Roojam v. Shri K. Banarji, Chief
Commissioner, 1985 H.R.R. 220.
* Substituted by Chd. Adtnn. Gaz. Notification dated 13-3-1975 ai pugc 34-35
Haryana Housing Board Act, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh) 501
Al lo tmen t - Revised policy of industrial sites forth© establishmentof print
ing presses called into question in writ petition - Revised Policy does not suffer
form any act of arbitariness - Appellants formed a separate class - All persons
who have applied for industrial sites For establishing printing presses were grouped
together- N o descrimination -Appeal dismissed- Constitution of India, Article 14
- Paradtsh Printers v. Union Territory of Chandigarh, 1938 H.R.R. 409 S.C.
— T h e petitioner was allotted a flat way back in 1987 when she was regis
tered at Sr. N o . 536 in the category of HIG (L) I houses but she was refused
possession thereof on one pretext or another - The Board is debarred by its own
conduct from raising baseless objection at such a belated stage when prices have
gone sky rocketing - She cannot possibly apply for a plot of the same area for the
prices prevalent in the year 1987 - Respondent directed to hand over the posses
sion of the flat to the petitioner - Inder Bir Kattr v. The Chairman Chandigarh
Housing Boald, 1 993 HRR 578.
Al lo tmen t - Incomple te const ruct ion - Respondent allottee had been
informing the appellant Board, time and again, for making the flat residcntiable by
putting up fittings and fixtures without which the flat remains only in a skelton
form - It was being used for storing cement by the Board - Respondent without
completion of construction of flat cannot be compelled to execute the agreement
to pay the revised rate of the Hat with interest- Dismissing the appeal of Board it
is directed to comply with the directions of the High Court issued vide its order
dated 2.2.1993 - Bihar State Housing Board v. Lai it Ram, 1997 H.R.R. 243 S.C.
-—-The petitioner applied for theal lotmentofa Flat under a Scheme "foronc
and al l" - She depositee! a sum of Rs. 4,000/- and later on Rs. 50,000/- for allot
ment of House in Sector 45-A - She wrongly stated in her application that no
member of her family was owning any residential house or plot in Chandigarh/
Panchkuta or Mohali while her husband had already been allotted a house - She
realizing her mistake, wrote to the Board to cancel her husband's house to enable
her to have the second house in Sector 45-A allotted to her but no reply was given
by the Board -After having been directed by the Hon'blo High Court to hear her
in this respect, the Board cancelled her allotment of Sector 45-A and ordered Rs.
54,000/- to be forfeited under Regulation No . 6 (2) of Regulation 1979 - Held the
order of the Board cannot be sustained - The petitioner had acknowledged her
in istake - She was not given any opportunity to explain her position by the authori
ties - Forfeiture of the entire amount of Rs. 54,000/- of a Class III employee is a
heavy loss - However, forfeiture of Rs. 4,000/- deposited with the application
would meet the ends of justice - The respondent is directed to refund Rs. 50,000
to the petitioner with interest at the rate of 12% per annum - Smt. Ram Dulari v.
Union Territory, Chandigarh, \994 HRR 67.
_ Al lo tment of flat -Appellants were allotted plots and were delivered pos
session of the same in the year 1988 by the respondent-Total payment was made .
by them as agreed - Demand made by Development Authority for additional pay
ment from the appellants is not justified as they had paid the entire co3t of the Hat
as agreed between the parties - Order of the High Court on, the ground of limita
tion cannot be sustained as the objections in this regard were still pending before
the Authority for consideration - Sanjay Place Group Housing Association v.
Agra Development Authority, 1994 HRR 154 S.C.
Al lo tmen t of G o v e r n m e n t houses - Cancel la t ion - On an inquiry it was
found that the petitioners who were allotted government houses, had sublet the
same and In-consequence thereof their allotment was cancelled - Held, the mere
fact that a cyclostyled order was passed, does not prove that there was no appli-
502 Haryana Housing Board Ad't, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh)
nation urmiud by the authorities concerned - Balwupt Sin^jh v. Chief Secretary
Government Punjab 1989 H.R.R. 620 D.B.
Allotment of house - The petitioner, an applicant for the allotment of a
houso, was at the 1st serial number in the woiting list fo< ihc allotment-Allegedly
his seniority was ignored and respondent No, 4 was allotted the house as the later
had an influence in the corridore of the Housing Board - [t wa3 found that respon
dent No. 4 had a preferential right whose claim was inadvertently ignored by the
Housing Board - It would not be proper to nullify the allotment of numerous people
who are not even party in the case - However, the respondent Board was d irected
lu consider the petitioner's ease sympathetically fur allotment of another house -
Mritanjay Dosaj v. Haryana Housing Board and others 1994 H.R.R. 265.
-—Discretion - Petitioner deposited Rs. 1,000/- with an application invited by
Housing Board for allotment of houses - Petitioner was unsuccessful for allot
ment in draw of lots - No objection was filed against the allotment through draw of
lots All the allottees were not impleaded - No reply about the letter giving option
of choice of plots was given by petitioner - Moreover, writ petition was filed after
a delay of more than one year - There i3 no illegality in the allotment - Shamir
Singh v Chandigarh Housing Hoard, 1995 H.K.K. 499.
Allotment Rules - Violation - Respondent had applied for allotment of a
plot in Patna under the Scheme of Allotment -An undertaking was given that in
case there was any allotment in the name of any member of the family including
himself he would inform the Allotment Authority in this respect- First allotment
was made in his name within the Municipal limit of Patna with delivery of posses
sion Second allotment in the name of respondent was also made in the same
vicinity No information was given to Authorities about first allotment violating
terms of affidavit- Cancellation of second allotment by Autliuulics is legally valid
- No citizen can be allowed to have second allotment within the same municipal
area under the Allotment Rules- Order of High Court sustaining (ho allotment on
equitable grounds quashed - Rules 2, 9 and 14 of the Rules for Settlement of Land
Acquired and Developed by the State Govt, of Patna - Bihar State Housing
Board w Satya Narayan Prasad, 1998 H.R.R. 153 S.C.
Application of mind - Illiterate Chairman • Petitioners were allotted
houses by respondent with a tentative price of Rs. 35,000/- which was deposited
by petitioners in the year 1977 - Subsequently, it was in 1981 that fresh cost of
construction was computed to the tune of Rs. 62,8007- - It w,as alleged that Chair
man of the Board being an Illiterate person had disposed of their ease without
applying his mind as he could not understand either Hindi or English - There Is
force in this contention -A quasi judicial Authority should apply its own mind and
should not depend on the assistance of his staff- This kind of practice can neither
he appreciated nor meefc the ends of justice - Haryana Housing Doard was di
rected to keep in mind what is being observed herein for future - Parmanand v.
Chairman, Housing Hoard tTaiyanuh 1996 H.K.K. 559.
Arbitrary act - Increase in price - Chandigarh Administration increasing
the price uf the allotted plots in any arbitrary and unreasonable manner- Interferr
enCe In the arbitrary act of the Administration under Article 226 of the Constitu
tion is amplyjustified - Major General Ram Singh (RetdJ v. Chandigarh Housing
Board, 1991 HRR375.
—Allotment - The petitioner deposited 10% cost of the house to be allotted
to him under a Scheme of the Housing Board, Haryana in Sector 29. Faridabad -
He was allotted registration No. 645 - Having remained unsuccessful In the allot-
iiienl he was assured that his registration number would remain intact for allot-
Haiyana Housing Board Act, 1971 (aa extended to Chandigarh) 503
merit in Sector 3 for the allotment of house He deposited the additional price of
the house as demanded by the Board - Again he .was not allotted any house
though there ware 774 houses available while his registration No. was 645 - Peti
tioner was obviously entitled to allotment of a house in Sector 3 where the Board
was allotted 40 acres of land for the construction of houses - Respondent- Board
W M directed to accept the demand of the petitioner and allot nim a house in
Sector 29 or 3 at the rate prevalent at the date of original application - Svrj'tt
Singh's case AIR 1980 P & H 65 distinguished - Anil Kumar Chawla v. Hous
ing Board tiaryana 1994 H,R,R. 267.
Cancellation of allotment — An LIG flat was allotted to petitioner on the
basis of income category— Monthly income shown as Rs. 4712/- whereas he was
drawing gross salary of R$. 5715 - Maximum limit for allotment of LIO flat was
fixed at Rs. 5500 - Show cause notice about cancellation of flat is not illegal as
petitioner was not eligible for the allotment Petition dismissed - Pawan Kumar
v State of Haryana, 2009(2) Haryana Law Reporter 213 D.B.
Cancellation of plot - Automatic cancellation - Where the allottee nei
ther conveyed acceptance nor paid the amount asked for within 30 days of the
receipt of allotment letter, it was held, that allotment stands automatically can
celled under Regulation 5 (5) of the Regulation 1978 - Smt, ArimaLuthra v. State
of Haryana, 1987 (2) PLR 124 = 1986 Rev. L.R. 324.
Cancellation of plots - Opportunity - In S.K Oass v, Slate of Haryana,
198S PLJ 123 D.B. where-the allotments of plots were made to various persons
out of the discretionary quota of the Government made by successive ministries
and at the instance of Lok Dal ministry orders of cancellation of allotments of
residential plots were made. These orders of cancellation were challenged before
the Hon'ble Pb. & Hr, High Court - Whereupon the Division Bench made the
following observations: That blanket order of cancellation is liable to be struck
down (i) Where the Government did not apply its mind or acted arbitrarily or
where no guide lines were laid for allotting plots carved out of green belts or areas
reserved for public purposes (ii) Where allotee started construction after getting
plans sanctioned (iii) where HUD \ did not apply its mind at all before issuing
letter of cancellation, (iv) Where no show cause notice was given for cancellation
as po_<rt decisional hearing would not meet ends of justice (v) Where the bona fide
purchaser lor consideration from the original allottee was protected by Section 41
Of Transfer of Property Act.
Held, further that Courts always have control over arbitrary acts of Execu
tive authority, The executive authority is required to discharge its function in good
faith and farely and not in arbitrary way. Unchecked power is alien to rule of law
W&iJt.Dass v. State of Haryana 1988 PLJ 123 =- 1988 (1) PLR 430 - 1988
RlRi.IL 370.
.Compound i n t e r e s t - A s per terms of allotment letter respondent Housing
Board was al lowed to charge fair price of plot within 7 years of date of allotment
- Ft included expenditure on construction of tenements and payment made towards
enhanced compensation of land acquired alongwith 15% interest compounded
quarterly on enhanced amount of compensation - It was never challenged by
original allottee who went on depositing installments as per schedule hi the facts
of the case, petitioners are not entitled to raise objection against charging of
compound Interest - Petition dismissed - Hartley Singh v. Housing Board
Haryana, 2009(2) Haryana Law Reporter 627
Discrimination - A press corrspondent, subsidised in house rent by State
Government - Chandigarh Administration cancelled the allotment, taking the view
http://RlRi.IL
504 Haryana Housing Board Act, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh)
that allottee was a mere licensee as the subsidy in rent was withdrawn by the
State government - Held, such a stand on the publ ic authority is not in consonance
with the constitutional ohligation of the Government and its functionaries - Order
of the Chandigarh Administration held to be illigal - Rajinder Kumar v. U.T
Chandigarh, 1983 H.R.R 410.
Enhancement of price - Petitioners were allotted houses at the rate of Rs.
1,20,700/- for ground floor and Rs. 1,15,700/- for the 1st floor-Additional price of
Rs. 20,500/- and 19,600/- was demanded for Increased cost of construction and
Rs. 626V- and Rs. 2906A respectively on account of compensation of land - No
justification was given for the enhancement of price and only justification was
given that the work of construction by earlier contractor was not completed within
time - The action of the Board enhancing the price cannot be sustained and is
violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India - Krishan Lai v. Housing
Board Haryana, 1994 HRR 207.
—Petitioners were allotted multi-storoyed flats at Manimajra by the respon
dent Board - In category I tentative price of the flat was Rs. 4 Lacs and in
category II it was Rs. 3 lacs - Subsequently the price was enhanced to Rs. 6-25
lacs and 4.75 lacs respectively, to be deposited by the petitioners - No reply was
given to the representation made to the Board - Held, there is no justification for
increasing the price arbitrarily - Notice of enhancement of prlee field liable to be
quashed - However, it will be open to the Board to take fbrther action in accor
dance with the terms and conditions of the contract in question - Dalbir Singh
Bhagat v. Chandigarh Administration, 1993 H.R.R. 514 D.B.
—'The Chandigarh Administration decided toatlotsome land forconsrructionn
often shops to Chandigarh Housing Board at the rate of lis. 500/- per sq, yard -
The Board, thereafter invited application for allotment of these shops in the year
1983 and again in 1986 -The allottees were issued demand cum allocation letters
demanding Rs. 3.5 lakh each plus balance amount of Rs. 1,5 lakh to be paid after
the delivery of possession of the shop - It was in the year 1989 that the Board
fixed and demanded Rs. 12,05,514/- against the tentative price of Rs. 5,00,000/-
as advertised earlier - Held, the price as demanded by the Chandigarh Adminis
tration vide its letter dated 31.10.1989 is hereby quashed with the direction that
the allottees may be given possession of the shops at the rate of land as advertised
earl ier - Major General Ram Singh (Retd,) v. Chandigarh Housing Board,
I991HRR375. - *
Escalation of price - In the instant case an LIG house was allotted at the
cost was Rs. 45,000/- - Subsequently allottee was informed that escalation cost
was raised to Rs. 2,08,000/- as final cost i.e. 4-7, times of original cost - As per
terms of brochure price could be raised upto 10% only - Allotment authorities
acted in an arbitrary manner not only in enhancing the price but also in delaying
the possession - Order of High Court yetting aside the escalation of price upheld -
Kanpur Development Authority v. Smt. Sheela Devi, 2004(1) H.R.R. 1 S.C.
Instalment - Reduction in period - Petitioners were allotted houses by
the respondent -Total amount was to be paid in instalments spread upto 10 years
- Period of payment reduced from 10 years to 8 years - The action of respondent
redacting the period is illegal and not binding on the petitioner - The order of
reducing the period cannot be sustained - Krishan Lai v. Housing Board
Haryana, 1994 H.R.R. 207.
Interest on deposit - Respondent, Housing Board Haryana agreed to com
plete the construction of allotted house within 2 years from the date of allotment -
Haryfltia Housing Board Act, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh) 505
i
Petitioners deposite'd the amount in the year 1980 and 1982 - Houses were allot
ted in the year iy«y - Petitioners held entitled to interest on their deposits at the
rate which is paid by the Nationalized banks in Saving Hank Account - Ki'lshan
Lai v. Housing Board Haryana. 1994 HRR 207
Misuse of premises - Misuse of premises by allottee who laiscd
unauthorised construction on allotted land-Though allottee hecamft absolute owner
ofallottcd plot still local authority has jurisdiction to regulatethe violations or misuse
of property by the allottee - Commissioner or any other officer authorized by
Corporation has discretionary power to compound any offence u/s 383 of Maryann
Municipal Corporation Act - But such power should be exercised with abundant
caution by authority concerned - Sut-esh Kumar v. Municipal Corporation,
Faridabad, 2006(2) HRR 306 D.B.
Power of resumption - Constitutional power - No constitutional invalid
ity can be imputed to power of resumption under the Act, The very concept of a
planned urban development is now a well recognised social norm of a welfaie
State challenge to constitutionality ufpruvisions uFAel on the basis ofprinclples
enunciated on Otga Iblls case AIR 198(3 S.C 180 cannot be sustained - Sural
Shlgh v. State of Haryana, 1990 PLJ 126 D.B.
—Weapon of hist resort - Where construction ofbuilding was to be started
within two years as per condition of allotment letter The allottee could not stmt
construction within the stipulated period as the actual possession of the plot was
not delivered to him by the authorities. Held, order of resumption on the ground of
failure to construct the building within the said period is wholly arbitrary. Power of
resumption must be used as a weapon of last resort with ^reat caution by the
authority under the Act - D.N. Kajriwal w State of Haryana. 1987 PLJ 532.
Pricing - Petitioners were allotted houses at the tentative price oFRs. 15,000/
- per house - Subsequent price was revised to Rs. 62,H007- due to rise fn aost of
building material,,, labour charges and other reasons - Petitioners had given their
consent for such increase from time to time.- There is no illegality in the demand
of enhanced price by the Board - Moreover, Courts cannot go into the question of
ijricingofhoustjs- Petition dismissed -Parmanand'v. Chairman. Housing Board
laryana, 1996 H.R.R. 559.
Resumption and Natural justice - Where no notice was issued to guard
ian of the petitioner who was a minor, the resumption order was quashed - Sural
Singh v. Stale ofllarya/ia, 1990 PLJ 126 D.B.
Resumption and opportunity - Where the order of resumption was in
respect ofbuilding in occupation uftenants along with the owner it was held that
both owner as well as tenant are entitled to be heard before an order of resump-
Lion is passed. In the absence of any material to show the issuance of such notice,
the order of resumption was qtKished - Surat Singh v, State of Haryana, 1990
PLJ 126 D.B.
Transfer of plot - One Smt. Prem Lata was allotted an MIG House on hire
purchase basis - Price of the dwelling unit was fully paid and all formalities were
completed within the stipulated period - The provisional permission for the trans
fer of allotted plot in favour of Ihe petitioner was granted by the Board - Transfer
fee was deposited after the stipulated period with in wh teh the affidavit and indem
nity hond was to be furnished - Delay in deposit of fee and other document not to
stand in the way of transfer of the plot - The Board is directed to intimate the
amount of conveyance du«d charges to be deposited by the petitioner within 15
days and then to transfer the dwelling unit rn the name of thg pctif ioncr Mis. M.
Bali v. Hoi/sing Board Haryana, Chandigarh, 1994 1IRR 88,
506 1 Tar/ana Housing. Board Act, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh)
UnnutlioiUed Construction - A dwelling unit was allotted to petitioner
under the c a l o r y of "Economically weaker scclion" at Maloya eu cniy at
Chandigarh who raised unauthorized construction on Government land -Allplineiit
c l S w for violation of term, of allotment letter^ Pttitiom* *toP{£>« ". J " g
for long period - No relief granted to him - Petition dismissed - Suraj u Union
Territory Chandigarh, 2008{2) l iRR6'34 L>.B.
v3id/invftlid order of allotment - Mere reminding through * l*«*fr to take
possession of a house which already is allotted to another person, cannot be termed
Ss a"order of allotment - Sumer Chand Bhalt v. Tfie Housing Board, Haryana,
l 9 W Violations of conditions - Cancellation - Peliuui.ei was allotted an HtG
House under Self Financing Scheme- The main cond.t .on of allotment was that
no family member of Allottee should be owning any house within the h mfc of
Tricity i o Chand igarh. Mohall and Panchkula - But in the present case husband
X i was owning house in Panchkula ancI this fact was not disclosed by
petitioner She had suhmTtted a false affidavit in this regard - Pet.tfoner can ^ c k
no relief from the Ouurt in this regard or. allotment was »8h«y ^ l l c d by auftorifr
below - Petition dismissed - Shasta Bala v. Chandigarh Housing Board, 2014(2}
Harvana Law Reportei 52G D.B.
Violation of legal provision - Encroachment - Show cause nofcu -
nrlevancc of the petitioner is against a show cause not.ee by respondent tor
encroachment on government land and issuance of notice w .^^'T'
authority - The plea that issuance of notice under Punjab Capital Act and also
under Housing Hoard Act is against law - Held the objection is without any men
in view of decision rendered by this Court in Paramjeet Singly case deeded on
A T ?n I ? (CWP No 10970 of 2007) when it was held that i apital of Punjab ACtt
1952 is applicable to urban as well as rural area of UT, Chandigarh as envisaged
by section 4 of the Punjab Reorganisation Act, L966 The objection is repelled -
But as no opportunity of hearing after issuance of notice and passing of an order
was given to the petitioner, the impugned outer is not legally susUnnable- Impugned
Older quashed - Case remanded to pass an order after hearing the petitioner -
Petition allowed - RS. Sawhneyv. Chandigarh HousmgBoard, 2012(1) Haryana
Law Reporter 499 D.B,
CASES UNDER CONSUMER P R O T E C T I O N ACT, 1986
The Housing activities carried on by the Statutory Authoritiesi or P»vafe
builders come within die purview of the Consumer Protection Act WW - as held
in Luchurw Development Authority v. M.K. Gupta's case 1994 (1) CPC I 3.C.
. It has been observed in this case by the apex Court that when any statutory
authority develops land or allots a site or construct a house for the benefit o t
common man, it is as much service as hy the builder oi a contractor -The caseu
dealing with the subject of plots, flats or houses decided under the Consumer
Protection Act are being discussed below > . _
Allotment - Allotment made by Housing Board to 235 members ot the
respondent/society - Society introduced6 new memhers which delayed the allot
ment of additional land- Housing Buard not liable foi delay in allotment which
was caused by Society itself- Chandigarh Housing Board v. Krishan Kvmar
C W , 2009(2) CPC 390 N.C.
http://not.ee
Haryana Housing Board Act, 19/1 (as extended to Chandigarh) 507
t
Allo tment t h r o u g h lot tery - Demand of extra charges for allotment of
corner plot as per rules is not illegal even if it is a draw of allotment by lottery -
Estate Manager, M,K Housing Board v. Rajesh Kumar Gupta, 2010(1) CPC
376 S . C
Convers ion in freehold N.O.C. - Pctitioncr/OP refused to issue NOC
3ua allotted house fbr conversion it in freehold on vague grounds — Kora below
irected OF to issue NOC - Impugned order held to bo justified - 2012(2) CPC
362 N .C .
Demand of inflated pr ice - All the authorities below d ismissed the plea of
the pel it inner who raised false demand against the allottees —Continuity of frivolous
litigation should be discouraged Petition dismissed with penal cost of Rs. 1 l a c -
2013(1) CPC 630 S,C.
Ex t r a charges for c o r n e r plot - Demand of extra charges For allotment
of corner plot as per rules Is not illegal even if it is a draw of allotment by lottery.
lottery- Estate Manager. M.P. Housing Board v. Rqjssh Kumar Gupta, 2010(1)
CPC 376 S C -
Hous ing a l lo tment - Allotment under Hire Purchase Agreement - Mous
ing Board demanding enhanced price illegally — Complainant not liable to pay .
enhanced price Deficiency in seiviee proved - Housing Board Haiyana v
Lekh Raj, 2009(3) CPC 686 Hr.
H o u s i n g Board - Allottee transferring plot to another person against terms
nf allotment - N o t entitled to relief for delay in delivery ofpossess ionby Houaing
Board - Chandigarh Housing Board v. Kapur Singh Qrewal, 2000(1) CPC
112 Chd.
—Allottees not entitled to raise the question ofpricing of flats or plot under
the Consumer Protection Act - Punjab Housing Development Board v. All
India Defence Personnel Welfare Association (Regd.), 1995(1) CPC 310 N.C.
-—Application for allotment of house in violation of Rules - Cancellation of
allotment by Housing Board justified - Preeti Ahluwalla v. Chandigarh Hous
ing Board, T 999(1) CPC 6S Chd.
—Authority of Housing Board in fixation oFprice of plot/flat is not open to
challenge under Consumer Protection Act - National Consumer Awareness
Group (Regd.) Chandigarh v. The Hovstng Commissioner, Punjab Housing
Development Board, 1997(2) CPC 60P N.C.
—Board not bound Lo pay repair expenses unless proved by cogent evi-
donoe by allottee complainant - Chairman, Tamil Nadu Housing Hoard v N
Sivasailam, 1996(2) CPC 337 N.C.
_ Cancellation of allotment of house due to violation of Regulation - Board
m liahle tn refund after deducting 10% of deposited amount • Chandigarh Hous
ing Board V. Surindcr Pall Sons, 2004( 1) CPC 413 N.C.
—Complainant taking possession of house without any protest - Claim for
amount allegedly spent on house, cannot be accepted - Sushi! Kumar Gupta v.
Housing Board Haryana and Anothert 1996(H) CPC 35 Chd.
—Complainant who had deposited Rs. 1,10,000/- for house allotment was
not allotted the house for three years - Housing Board held liuble to compensate
the complainant - U.P. Avas Evam Vikas Partshad (Housing and Development
Board) n C.P. Sharma and Others, 1991 CPC 327 N.C.
—Complainant 's house was reallotted to another person as ha had failed to
comply with the necessary condition - Housing Board not liable fnr definient ser
vice - Ramrsh Chand v. Chandigarh Housing Board, ,1996(2) CPC 25 Chd,
503 Harynna Housing Board Act, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh)
—Complaint against charging of escalated price by Housing Board - Order
of State Commission awarding escalation cost upto 20% and direction toremove
the defects upheld - Harendra v. M.P Qrih Nirman Mandal, 2002(2) CPC 131
N C.
Complaint regarding allotment of defective house is maintainable under
the Consumer Protection Act - Dilbagh Rai v. Housing BoardJTaryana, 1994(2)
CPC 435 N.C.
Cracks appeared in the walls of flat allotted to complainant - Housing
Board held liable to pay Rs. 25,000/- to complainant - Prof. R. Shanmugasundaram
v. Tamil Nadu Housing Board, 1997(2) CPC 384 N.C.
Delay in allotment of house without sound reasons - Housing Board is
guilty of deficiency in service - Rajasthan Housing Board, Jaipur v. Dr. Veer
Singh Mehta, 1997(1) CPC 412 N.C.
Del?y in delivery of possession of flat due to non- supply of water and
electricity- Housing Board not liable for delay-/1 . Oopala Subramaniam v. Vice
Chairman, A,P.H.H., Hyderabad, 1995(2) CPC 223 N-Q
Delay of 7 years in delivery of possession of allotted house - HUDA is
liable to pay 18% on deposit starting from two years afterdate of deposit- H. U. D.A.
v. Deviea Jaswal, 2003(1) CPC 111 N.C. - , u
—Demand of balance amount from allottee was made in 1992 by Housing
Board - Payment was made in 199* - Allottee directed to pay 12% interest for
delayed period - M.P. Housing Board v. Jagat Kishore Khare, 2002(1) CPC
186 N.C „ . „ J j r , c , c . -
Directions can be issued to the Housing Board for removal ot detect in
the houses - Directions concerning schools or roads facilities cannot be issued -
Secretary, Orissa State Housing Board v. The Chandra Sekfiarpur Housing
Board Colony Unnayan Samiti, 1994(1) CPC 376 N.C.
—Housing Board cannot be burdened with a disproportionate compensation
by consumer Fora - Bihar Stale Housing Board v. Frio Ranjan Roy, 1997(2)
CPC 430 S.C.
—Housing Board charging higher price than 10% of the indicated price of
plot and delaying the possession - Allottee entitled to refund of excessive price
with 18% interest - M.P. Housing Board K Ashok Chandra Varshmy, 2003(2)
CPC 7 N C
—Housing Board delayed possession of flat for three years after receiving
payment - Directed to pay Rs. 22,000 as compensation - Chandigarh Housing
Board y. Daljit Singh 2001(2) CPC 133 Chd.
Housing Board failed to complete construction of house within stipulated
period - Hetd guilty of deficiency in service - Rajasthan Housing Board v R.C.
Bhandari, 1997(1) CPC 465 N.C.
—Housing Board failed to construct house in agreed time after payment -
Directed to refund entire amount with interest after deducting 20% of initial de
posits - Bihar State Housing Board v. Gauri Shankar Singh, 2003(2) CPC 262
N C
"' —Housing Board failed to construct the houses in time due to paucity of
funds - Deficiency in service not proved - Prem Lata (Mrs,) V The Punjab
Housing Development Board. 1994(1) CPC 25 Pb.
—Housing Board misleading complainant about grant of loan from his em
ployer cancelled allotment despite payment of initial price - Housing Rnard di
rected to refund the amount with 18% interest - Allam Aslam v. The Chairman,
Tamil Nadu-Housing Board, 2003(2) CPC 505 N.C.
i.
I
Haryana Housing 3oard Act, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh) 509
— I lousing Board though is statutory Body is not exempted from the provi
sions of the Consumer Act - Directed to make its Rules "fair and jus t" to the
public - Punjah Housing Development Board v. Shri Anil Shanna, 1991 CPC
601 Chd.
—Hous ing board, respondent not receiving the cheque though due to mis
take of another statutory body - Respondent is not at fault - Dr. Sunii Kumar
Wad/jwa v. U. P. Avas Evam Vihas Parishad, 1991 CPC 523 N.C.
— M I G flat constructed by the Housing Board found in dilapidated condition
- Board directed to refund enf ire price with 12% p.a. interest and costs - Housing
Board, Haryana through its Chief Administrator v. Shri Ramesh Kumar Cioel,
2002(2) CPC 362 Chd.
— N o Objection Certificate denied to allottee who failed to raise construc
tion - Order uf cancellation of plot is unjustified - Chairman, Tamil Nadu Hous
ing Board v Pitchaimuthammal, 1996(2) CPC 339 N.C.
— N o n delivery of possession of house despite payment of full amount -
Housing Board directed to pay Rs. 5U,00U/- as costs - Rajasthan Housing Board
v. Prakash Chand Jain, 2001(2) CPC 661 N.C.
—Pricing policy of Housing Board cannot be challenged under the Con
sumer Protection Act - Housing Board Haryana v, Kartar Singh etc. etc.,
1995(1) CPC I N.C.
— T h e MRTP Commission based it is finding on unfair trade practice against
Housing Board on no evidence - Order of Commission set aside - Rajasthan
Housing Board v. Smt. Parvati Devi ate, 20UU(2) Cl'C i y y S ,C
-—Total price of flat paid - Delay of 7 months in possession - Housing Board
directed to pay 12% interest on deposited amount - Chandigarh Housing Board
u Shri Harjinder Singh, 2002(2) CPC 316 Chd- .
— U n d u e delay in sanction of zoning plan resulting in delayed pnssussiuw uf
plot - Housing Board directed to pay 9 % p.a. interest on deposited amount -
Krishan Kumar Goei, Advocate v. Chandigarh Housing Board, 2003(1) CPC
396 Chd.
—Wife allotted a house - Hushand rightly declined allotment by Chandigarh
Housing Board - P.S. Sawhney v. Chandigarh Housing Board, 1999(2) CPC
229 N .C .
H o u s i n g complex - No provision for providing lift in agreement - Com
plaint regarding lack of facilities of lift dismissed - / . Parthasrthy v, M/s,
Homejiyiders Housing Promoters Ltd., 2002(7.) CPC 94 N.C.
H o u s i n g cons t ruc t ion - Delay in construction of house by Development
Authority within time due to factors beyond its control - Deficiency in service not
proved - SomimurtUura v. The Mysore Urban Development Authority, 1994(2)
CPC 414 N . C .
• —Delay of seven years In delivery of possession of allotted house - Com
plainant held entitled to compensation - HarbanS Singh V. Lvcknow Develop
ment Authority, 1994(1) CPC 3K1 N.C.
Hous ing loan - Provisions of Bihar Coop. Society Act no bar ty complaint
against charging of higher interest on housing loan - Ram Deo Singh (a). Ram Dev
Prasad Singh v. Bihar State Housing Coop. Federation Ltd., 2003(2) CPC
564 N.C.
Housing scheme - Complainant deposited Rs. 3000A in 1989 as registra
tion amount lor allotment - Scheme abandoned in 1996 without reason - Com
plainant entitled to 18% interest nn deposits - Punjah l/rhan Development Atf
thority v, Shri Jnder Pal Singh, 2002(1) CPC 389 N.C.
5 10 Haryana Housing Board Act, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh)
—House not allotted even after receipt of 55% price - Authorities directed
to refund deposits with 18% interest - George Thomas it Ght&iabad Develop
ment A uthority, 1999( 1) C PC 183 N.C.
Housing service - Delay in delivery of possession by six years - Opposite
parties liable to pay 18% interest on deposited amount - S.K. Jain v. H,U,D,A.,
20040) CrC 33 K C -
—Extra amount as alleged wa$ not charged from complainant - OP not
liable For deficiency in service - Jugal Kishore Mahasfavari v. BhQpal Devel
opment Authority, 2002(1) CPC 19TN.C.
—Housing Board accepted request 61 ullotee to accept the instalment as in
cn-?c of hire purchase Board can not resile from its undertaking - Petition dis
missed - Raj. Housing Board v Murali Lai Jaiman, 2003(1) CPC 110 N.C.
—PUDA failed to deliver physical possessionof allotted house - Directed to
pay Rs. 500/- p.m. till date of delivery of possession along with Its. 20,000/- -
Punjab Urban Planning & Development Authority v. Ram Murti, 2002(1)
CPC 559 N.C.
—Undue delay in delivery of possession of hOUSO - Award of interest @
18% after two years upheld - GD.A. v. R-G. Swcena, 2002(2) CPC 82 N.C.
—Undue.delay in delivery of possession of house r OP Greeted to pay 16,5,%
interest on deposited amount-? 'Leptmah Kumar Harwani v. M,P, State Co-op.
Homing Complex. 2003(1) GPC-229 N.C.
Judgement iu rem — Judgement iu.rem is binding not only to parties but
upon all the world^-2009(1) CPC 443'RC; • .-" •.':„. j ~ '
Limitation - Cause uFaeliuii arose in-1998 when possession was delivered
- Complaint Filed in 2002 without explaining delay is barred by limitation -
Chandigarh Housing Board v. Krishan Kumar Gael. 2009(2) CPC 390 N.C.
Price of Hal— Price re-determined in LPA whose complainant was not a
party - T,PAjudgement norbinding upon ailottec complainant—2009(1) CPC 443
N . C . • • - ' ' " . - . ' • • • • ' . .
Rate of interest - District Forum-allowing complaint directed OP to pay
compensation and cost with 16% interest - Interest being On higher side reduced
from 16°/a to 12% r Rest of the order left undisturbed - Madhya Pradesh Hom
ing Tiaard v. CIS. Ddkeria,. 2009(3) CPC 678N.C . .
Review —An orderpassed by the pora. cannot be reviewed in the name of
correction of typographical error - M.P.,Housing Board v.Jagdish Prasad
Maheshwari, 2010(2) CPC 451 R C ; >^^ ' , - ; . , ; . './' ••:;..;< .
Typographical error1- An order passed by die Fora.eannot be. reviewed in
the name of correction of typographical error - M.P. Homing Board v. Jagdish
Prasad Maheshvfari, 20,10(2) CPC 451 N.C.
45, Disputes.regarding rc-constittttion of plots. - ( i ) Where by the mok- "
ing of a housing scheme, any plots compHsed-injhca^aineludcd In.the scheme
are reconstituted or any person is dispossessed, the Board shall after making such
inquiry as it thinks FIE award to. the person affected by such re-constitutipn or .
dispossession such compensation as Udccrris reasonable. If the person J3 dissatis
fied with the decision of the Board inihe motter,;hc,may informthe.Doard'accbrd-
ingly. The Board shall there up oirrefcr the matter to tup Tribunal, \, '"•''•'••:
(2) The Tribunal shall then after making an inquiry dcteimhie the amount of' •;'
compensation and direel the Board lu pay the same (o the.person euncemed.
Harytuiii Housing Board Act, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh) 5 11
CHAPTERV
Tribunal
drf. Trthunat. - TheTrihunal shall he the District Judge having jurisdiction
In the area concerned.
47. Duties of Tribunal. - The Tribunal shall-
(a) decide whether Hiiy compensation is payable under section 31 ,
(b) decide the amount of compensation in matters referred to It under
section 33 ,
(c) decide disputes relating to betterment charges referred to it under
section 41 ;
(d) decide disputes and the amount of compensation to be awarded under
section 45 : and
(e) decide such other matters as may be prescribed by the rules made in
this behalf.
4S. Powers ofand procedure before Tribunal, - (1) In making enqulrlesthe
Tribunal shall have and exercise n3 for as may bo the same powers and follow the
same procedure as under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
(2) bveiy order made by the Tribunal tor the payment of money and for the
delivery of the possession or removal of any structure shall be enforced by the
District Court as it it were the decree of the said Court.
(3) The proceedings before the Tribunal shall be deemed to be judicial pro-
ceedings within the meaning of sections 193 and 228 of the Indian Penal Code.
49. Decision of Trihunai to be final - The decision of the Tribuna I on any
matter referred to it under this Act shall, subject to the provision of section 50, be
final.
50. Appeal to the High Court. - The Board or any person aggrieved by a
decision of the Tribunal may within three months from thedatenf the, decision or
such further time as Mm High Court may for sufficient cause allow, appeal to the
High Court and the High Court shall pass such orders on the appeal as it thinks fit.
CHAPTER VI
Power to Evict Persons from Board Premises
51. Power to evict persons from Board Premises- - (1) if the competent
authority is satisfied,—
(a) that the person authorised to occupy any Board premises has—
(i) not paid rent lawfully due from him in respect of such premises for
a period of more than two months J or
(II) sublet, without the permission ofthe Board the whole or any part of
such premises ; or
(Hi) Otherwise acted in contravention of any nf the terms, expre.<tsed or
Implied, under which he is authorised to occupy such premises ;
ur
(b) that any person is in unauthorised occupation of any Board premises:
the competent authority may, nutwithstandinganything contained In any law
for the time beiuy in force, by nutioe served by post or by affixing a copy of it on
the outer door or some other conspicuous part of such premises, or In such other
manner as may be prescribed, order that the person as well as any other person
wliu may be in occupation of the whole or any part ofthe premises, shall vacate
them within out: month from the date ofthe service ofthe notice:
Provided that no such Order shall be passed unless the person has been
afforded an opportunity to show cause why such order should nut, be made.
5 12 Havana [lousing Doard Act, 1911 (as extended to Chandigarh)
(2) IFany person iftCusps or fails to comply with an order made under sub
section (I.), the competent authurily may evict the person from, and take posses
sion of the premises and may Tor that purpose use Such force as may be neces
sary.
(3) If a person, who has been ordered to vacate any premises under sub
clause (1) or sub-clause (HI) of clause (a) of SUb-seotion (1), within thirty days of
the date of service of the notice n( snd i longer time as the competent authority
may allow, pays to the Board the rent in arrears or carries out or otherwise com
plies with the terms contravened by him to the satisfaction ot the competent au
thority, as the case may be, the competent authority shall, in lieu of evicting auch
person under subsect ion (2), coned its order made under sub-section (1) and
thereupon such person shall hold the premises on the same terms on which he
held them immediately before such notice was served on him
C O M M E N T A R Y
Allo tment - Housing Buurd - Eviction - Entire payment was made for
allotment of house including mf«iest- Prescribed date forpayment was 30 3 1US2
- Only minor amount (Ks. HOW- only) was deposited after d.c said date - Col lector
passed an order of eviction against petitioner under Section 51 of Haryana Hous
ing Board Act for not depositing (he entire amount before the proscribed date -
Order of eviotion not legally sustainable - Petitioner was neither in unauthorised
possession nor he had defaulted in payment of rent etc. but he was an owner of
die shop when order of ejectment was passed against her - Petition accepted -
Raj Kumar V. Housing Board Haryana, 2004(1) H.R.R. 380
Cancellat ion of house iiilutmunt - Discretionary powers- Petitioner (orici-
rial allottee) depositing Rs. 10,000/- wiUiin the stipulated period in pursuance oTa
loner issued by the Chairman of the Housing Roard Haryana. Payment for addi
tional amenities also agreed to be made - Acceptance thereof by the Hoard also
made - Housing Roard communicating a letter to the new allottee of the house in
dispute informing hiin to take the possession thereof- No opportunity of the hear
nig given to the original allottee - Order of the Housing Board liable to he set aside
- Order quashed - Sumer Chant/ Bhatt v. The Housing Board Haryana 1984
Misuser -The petitioner was allotted a dwelling unit in Maloya colony under
Economical Weaker Section Scheme - He raised unauthorized construction in front
of his house On Government land and Started a Karyana shop (herein - Authorities:
concerned cancelled the allotment and forfeited the deposited amount - Before
cancellation of allotment many notices were served on him but the same weren't
responded- to - Petitions filed by him were dismissed as time barred giving rise to
pr&sent writ petition The order of eviction was [WSsed in 2002 whereas petition was
tiled in 2007 - Moreover he did not make any attempt to remove the violation even
during pendency of proceedings No relief can be given to petitioner for his Callous
?oJ> " Petition dismissed - Sura) v. Union Territory. Chandigarh, 2008(1) MRR
^ • • ' " * * * * *
S?,* Power to recover '{rent, loan] or damages as arrears of land revenue. -
(1) Subject to any rules made by the "[Administrator] in thisbchalfand without
prejudice to the provisions of section 51 , where any person is in arrears of rent
payable in respect of any Bnnrd prcmi3C3 ^ o r arrears of instalments payable in
• Sub3lflutcd by Chd. Aditm. Gaz. Nutificntinn daicd 13J-197*5 at papa 31*35
1. Substituted by Hr.ActNo. 10 or 19SP ss extended to Uituidigarh published on 2-1-1991
2. Jusertnri tiy Hr.ActNo. 10 Of I98f ns extended lv Churidj>.fii-h published OJI 2-4-1991
Haryana Housing Board Act, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh) 5 13
respect of any Joan advanced by the Board for construction, reconstruction or
repair of a house] the competent authority may, by notice served by punt or by
affixing a copy of it on the outer door or some other conspicuous part of such
premises, or in such other manner as may be prescribed, order that person to pay
the same within such time not being less than thirty days as may be specified in
the notice. If such person refuses or fails to pay the arrears of rent 2[or the
arrears of instalment of loan] within the time specified in the notice, such arrears
may be recovered as arrears of land revenue.
(2) Where any person is in unauthorised occupation of any Board premises,
the. competent authority may, in the prescribed manner, assess such damages on
account ofthe use and occupation ofthe premises as it may deem fit, and may by
notice served by posts, or by affixing a copy of it on the outer door or some other
conspicuous part of such premises, or in such other manner as may be prescribed,
order that person to pay the damages within such time not being less than thirty
days as may be specified in the notice. If any person refuses or fails to pay the
damages within the time specified in the notice, the damages may be recovered
from him as arrears of land revenue.
C O M IVIKNTARY
Arrest and recovery of loan - Where the terms of agreements make it
clear that the Government has first to proceed against the property mortgaged
and sell the property in oase the House Building Society loan is not paid by the
loanee - It was held that the Government being bound by the terms ofthe agree
ment, has first to proceed against the mortgaged property - The amount could not
be recovered by arrest of the members ofthe Society in the first instance - State
of Punjab v Dharam Singh, AIR 1985 S.C. 1751
Auction of the site — Deduction - Petitioner failed to deposit balance
6QVa amount and surrendered the plot — Housing Board refunded the deposited
amount after deducting 10% amount as per terms of auction of site — Deduction is
justifiedI - Hem Raj Housing Board Haryana, 2014(1) H.L.R. 283 D.B.
Injunction Against recovery - The order of fixing liability was passed in
violation of principle of natural justice - The party affected was not provided
proper opportunity of hearing before passing the Impugned order - Order held to
be void - Civil Court can grant injunction against the recovery - M/s. K.K. Indus
tries v. Union of India and others, 1988 PLJ 588.
Recovery of a r rears as land revenue - There are eight steps postulated
under Section 67 of the Punjab Land Revenue Act, under sub-heads (a) to (h)and
arrest and detention ofthe person of defaulter is one step - Where the petitioner's
husband, obviously in arrears of House Building Society, was straightaway put to
arrest and detention without resorting to other steps envisaged under Section 67
ofthe Act, the order of detention was set aside by the Division Bench of the
Punjab and Haryana High Court - It was held that arrest and detention of a per
son, in such cases, should be the last resort and arrears should be recovered firstly
by other means of recovery under the Punjab Land Revenue Act - Gomti Devi v.
Kalka Co-operative House Building Society, 1988 P.L.J. 416 (D.B.) = 1989
(2) Rev. L.R. 296.
A A A
S3. Rent to be recovered by deduction from salary or wages In certain
cases. - (I) Without prejudice to the provisions of section 51 any person, who is an
employee ofthe "fAdministrator] or a local authority and.who has been allotted
* Substituted by Chd. Admn. Gaz. Notification dated 13-3-1975 at page 34-35
514 Maryana Housing Board Act. 197 L (us extended to Chandigarh)
any Board premises, may execute an agreement in favour of the "[Administrator]
providing that the '[Administrator] ftr the local authority, as the case may be,
under or by whom he is employed, shall be competent to deduct from the salary or
wages payable to him such amount as may be specified in the agreement and to
pay the amount so deducted to the Rnard in satisfaction of the rent due (torn him
in respect of the Board premises allotted to him.
(2) On the execution of such agreement, the '[Administrator] or local au
thority, as the case may be. shall, ifso required by the Doard by requisition in
writing make the deduction of the amount specified in the requisition from the
salary or wages of the employees specified in the requisition in accordance with
the agreement and pay the amount so deducted to the Board.
ir53-A. Penalty- - ( I) If any amount due under the Act or the rules made
there under is not paid by any person in compliance with the orders of the compe
tent authority, such authority may, after Riving such person an opportunity of being
heard, impose upon him a penalty not exceeding twenty five per cent of the amount
due, if it has reason to believe that the person liable to pay the amount has willfully
failed to pay the some.
(2) If the penalty imposed under sub-section (1) is not paid within a period of
thirty days the same shall be recoverable as arrears of land revenue].
54. Appeal. - a[( l) Any person aggrieved by an order of the competent
authority may within thirty days from the date of—
(i) the service of notice under section S1 or section 52; or
(ii) the imposition of penalty under section 53-A prefer an appeal to the
'[District Judge ot the uistriet in which the premises of the Roardare
Situated or such other Judicial Officer in that District as the
'{Administrator} may, in consultation with the High Court, appoint in
this behalf].
Provided that the appellate officer may entertain the appeal after the expiry
of the said period orthirty days, if he is satisfied that the appellant wfi3 prevented
by sufficient cause from filing the appeal in time].
(2) Where an appeal ia preferred under sub section (1), the appellate officer
may stay the enforcement ofthe order of the competent authority for such period
ana on such conditions as he deems tit.
(3) Every appeal under this section shAll he disposed of hy thB appellate
officer as expeditiously as possible.
COMMENTARY
APPEAL
Appeal is a continuation of original cause - An Appellate Authority is
competent to correct an error committed by the lower Authority, without remand
ing the case back - The power of remand should be used with groat circumspec
tion - Om Parkash and others v. Joint Director Panchayat Punjab 1987 PLJ
273 - 1987( I )PLR674 .
Creature of Statute - Legislature can impose conditions for exercise of
euch right - There is no reason why the legislature while granting the right of
+ Substituted by Chd. Admn. Gat Notification dated 13-3-I97S ttt page 34-35
I. Inserted by Hr. Act No. 47 ftf l<J7d
2.8cu Hr.AulNo. 47 of 1974
3. Substituted vide Chandigarh Administration Ga?,. Nohflefttion tinted 2-4-1991 nt page 339
Haryana Housing Quuid Act, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh) 5 IS
•
appeal cannot impose condition for the exercise of 3uch right 30 long as the
conditions are not so onerous as to amount to unreasonable restriction rendering
the right almost illusory - Setft Nand Lai and another v. State of Haryana and
others • AIR 1980 S.C. 2097.
Merger -Appellate hearing is a rehearing of the whole subject matter and
when a decree is passed in appeal, the first riftr.rftft merges in the appellate decree
- Sadhu Singh v Dharam Dev etc, AIR 1980 S.C 1654.
Pywisr -An appellate Court has the same powers as conferred on the Courts
of original jurisdiction - A decree passed by an Appellate Court is deemed to be a
fresh decree - Once appeal is filed against the decree the Appellate court has
seision of the whole matter - Shrimati Glta Devi v. EC. Haryana 1937 PLJ 265.
Revision - A person who is not a party to an order is not entitled to file a
revision against the impugned order - Statu ofHaryana v. Vinod Kumar, 1986
<1) PLR 222 - 1986 PLJ 161 (F.B.). See also 1985 HRR 570,
Right of Appeal - It is vested right of litigants which accrues at the date of
filing ofeuit- Rightofappeal is governed by law prevailing at rhedate of institu
tion of the suit and not at the date of fllins of appeal - Suit. Kurtar Kaur v. State
ofHaryana, AIR 1986 (P & H) 99 - 1985 Rev. L,R. 137.
- Right of an appeal is a substantive right- It is not a procedural maiter-ft
cannot be restricted in the absence of an express provision to the contrary - Such
provision should not be construed narrowly - Kanzhi Ram v. Subcdar Shri Ram
etc. AIR 1980 (P&H) 145 : 1980 Rev. L. R. 225 : ILR (19S0) 2 F&l-l 195.
Statutory right - Appeal is a Statutory right - Litigant cannot claim their
right unless It is provided in the Slalule - Absence of such right in Statute does not
render it unconstitutional - Subedar Munshi Ram and another v. Stato of
Haryana - 1979 PLJ (F.B.) 489.
Subsequent events - Appeal Is a rehearing of the case - Appellate Court
entitled to take into account subsequent event - Santakh Singh v, Lajja Ram,
AIR 1986 (P & II) 34<J - 1986 Rev. L.R. 444.
LIMITATION
Acknowledgement - Mortgagee's right - Where the receipts of consid
eration ofniorlgage money did not indicate that their makers intended to admit the
substr ing mortgagfis and that the right to redeem was subsisting thosii receipts
will not amount rn an acknowledgement within the meaning of S. 19 uf (lie Limi
tation Act - Bachint Kaur v, Gvrnam Kaur - 1991 ll.R.R. 28.
Cause of action - Time starts from the date when the cause of action first
accures - Successive deailassd7 plaintiffs right does not furnish fresh causes of
action in view oF Section 58 of Limitation Act - Saudager Singh v. Hamam
Kaur, 1987 PLJ 248 - 1 9 8 7 (I) PLR 591.
Condonation - It if. not necessary that a written application u/s 5 or the Act
should be necessarily made - Cnnrinnntion of delay can be permitted on oral re
quest of the party - Partap Singh v. State of Haryana 1979 PLJ 48 D.B.
Condonation of delay - Where the legal representative? of the deceased
respondent has been brought on record earlier too, the appellant connot say that
they had no knowledge that the LR's of the deceased appellant were to be brought
on a record - Plea of lack of knowledge of period of limitation not accepted -
Application for setting aside abatement proceedings after one year alter the death
ofthc deceased appellant was dismissed, beingbarred by time - Jai Ram v. .fagat
Ram 1991 H.RR. 102.
Extension of time - Presumption - Where the, decree-holder was al
lowed to deposit the amount ofsecunty after the due date without extending the
516 Haryana Housing Board Act, ] 971 (as extended to Chandigarh)
time - It was held that extension of time is presumed to he allowed even if no
application was filed in this regard - Amar Nath Jain v. Ram Parkash Dh/r -
1988 H.R.R- 47.
•—Where the grounds of condonation i,c. negligence of the counsel etc.
were not proved - Hwld, applicant cannot get any relief-Application for condona
tion dismissed - The United India Insurance Company v. Svbhash Chander
CJupta <md others - 1988 H R R . 297.
—Delay - Allotment of dwelling unit made in 1989 was cancelled against
which Wi it petition was filed in 1999 - Petitioner had been making repeated repre
sentation regarding patent mistake committed by Housing Flcwim but without any
suoceaa Board failed to pay any attention to the repeated requests otflllottce and
no decision was convyed - Ohjectinn regarding belated prayer for relief through
writ petition cannot be objected to by Board and cannot be allowed to take advan
tage of its own mistake and inaction - Smt, Shashi Bala v, Chandigarh Housing
Board, 2001 HRR 232 D.B.
Limitation Courts are bound to took into the question of limitation even if
no plea is taken by party in this regard - Cannmani Anasuya v. Parvatini
Amarendra Chowdhary. 2008(1) HRR 476 PLC
Mistake of Court -There is no time limit to correct Court's own mistake -
Cliaimaat cannot be penalised for mistake of Court - Kartar Singh v. State of
Haryana - 1986 PLJ 206.
Mistaken advise - Litigant bona fide pursuing hie case in wrong court -
Time should be excluded - Badlu v Shiv Charm. 1980 PLJ 214 = See also 1987
HRR 28.
Redemption - Acknowledgement - The land, in dispute, was mortgaged
by A in favour of B in the year 1921 who sold his mortgagee rights in favour of C
in the year 1954 -The 3uit for the redemption was filed in 1973 - Limitation must
be deemed to have started from the original mortgagee in the year 1921 and not in
the year 1954 - Mohan Singh v. Jogar Singh 1991 H R R . 93.
Time spent for copy - Benefit of day on which judgment is pronounced
and time spent fur obtaining copy, should be given under Section 12 (1) and (2) of
Ihe Act - Kashmir Singh v. MC. Kamut 1983 PL; 22 - See also 1986 HRR 665.
Void order - Once an aggrieved parly is dispossessed in y icwofa void
order - Limitation will start from the date of dispossession and outer limitation is 3
years - State of Punjab v. Gurnam Kaur 1984 PLJ 389.
—When order is not void or without jurisdiction. Article 100 will apply -
Kalia and another v. Chandu Lai - 1984 PLJ 360.
—Question of limitation docs not arise where an order is void and without
jurisdiction - Sueh orders can be ignored without getting them set aside - Sanvan
Kumar v. Shy am Manglu 1989 H.R.R. 641.
Void or nan set order - It is necessary to have such orders set aside •
Snr.h cases, arc governed hy Art. 68 and not by Art. 100 of the Limitation Act -
Rqfinder Singh v. Gur Charon Singh and others - 1984 P I J 360,
—Delay in depositing the security was caused because of the nun holding of
the Court by the Presiding Officer being on leave and not because of the judge*
ment-debtor - Security was deemed to have been filed within, time - Delay of four
days ts condoned - Mukhtiar Singh v. M/s. Pakhar Singh Amir Singh and
others- 1988 H.R.R. 583.
—An action for enforcing a right Hied within the period of limitation as fixed
by (aw cannot be thrown nut merely on the ground of delay - Dr. M.K. Satpekar
v. Sum! Kumar Shamsuttder Chavdharl - 19SS H.R.R. 533.
Haryana Housing Board Act, i 971 (as extended to Chandigarh) 517
r
55. Finality vf utters wid bar of jurisdiction of Civil Courts. - (1) Save
as otherwise expressly provided in this Act, every o*dw njade by a competent
authority or nn appellate ofHcer under this chapter shall be final and shall not be
called in question in any original suit, application or execution proceedings.
(2) No Civil Court shall have jurisdiction to entertain any suit or proceeding
in respect of any matter of which the cognizance can be taken of and disposed of
bv any authority, empowered by this Act or the rules made thereunder.
COMMENTARY
JURISDICTION
Jurisdiction - Allottee became absolute owner • Local authority under the
Housing Board Act still has power to regulate the violations by allottee - Svresh
Kumar v. Municipal Corporation, Faridabad, 2006(2) HRR 106 D.B.
Adjudication - Debt Settlement Officer to adjudicate upon the qucstjon
whether a loan is a deb! or a person is a debtor - In absence of any such decision
Civil Court can go into the matter after giving proper opportunity to the parties • If
the Civil Court comes to the conclusion that the matter is covered by the provi
sions of the Act • It must stay its hands - Bhola Singh v. Lachhman Doss 1980
PLJ 232 (DB)= 1980 RLR 546
Consent -An order without jurisdiction is non-est - Consent does not make
the order legal and cannot iuvest the Court with jurisdiction - Saraswati D&vl v.
Sanl Rum and otters, 1983 PL J 249. ,
Interpretation - Is well accepted principle of interpretation or statutes that
tho soope of the provisions of an Act would firstly hnvc to he determined per force
of the language used or employed by the legislature in the legislation - The objects
and reasons would be considered when the language of the Act is capable of two
interpretations - Natural meaning of the language should be adhered to Vijay
Kumar Bhambari v. Ram Nath Bnjaj 1990 H.R.IL 151.
—Unless there is anything repugnant in the subject or context - In view of
this qualification, the court has not only to took at Hits words but also to examine
the context and collocation hi the light of the object of the Act and the purpose for
which a particular provision was : lade by the legislature - Smt. Pushpa Devi and
others, v. Mttkhi Ram I990 H.R.R. 123 (S.C.)
The Central Government is empowered to extend to the Union territory
not only the original enactment of the State Legislature but also the averments
thereto made by the State Legislature - Ramenh Uriah etc. u Union of India
and others - 1989 HRR 398 (S.C.) - 1988 HRR 433 (FB) upheld.
Lack of jurisdiction - Question ofj urisdiction can be raised first time even
at the times ofsecond appeal Where the original Court is lacking the jurisdiction -
It can be raised even at the time of execution when the decree is a n,ullity - Ajtt
Mohinder Singh v. Smt. Bhuni and others. AIR 1987 (P & H) 167 1986
Rwent LHWS 48. ' «. . . . n- t
Merger - The order of the Add!. Director C/H was affirmed by the Single
Judge of the High Court and the same was maintained in L.P.A dismissing the
Civil Writ Petition - Civil court cannot proceed into the matter on the doctrine of
merger - Darshan Singh v. Sub Judxe lit. Class, ffoshiarpur - 1988 H.R.R.
483.
' —Where the possibility of settlement, was more in the High Court than any
elsewhere it was held that the High Court Was proper Forum to dispose of the
case - Order of the High Court remitting the case to tho tiial.Court was set aside
by the Supreme Court - Abbey Singh Surana v. The Indian Rayon and Indus
trial Ltd.- 1988 H.R.R 506.
518 Haryana Housing Board Act, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh)
Non s*t order - A person who was not a party to an order passed by a
Tribunal against him can fi le a suit for dteultinitiun to the effect that the Order is not
binding upon him, and non est so for as he is concerned - Such person is not
entitled to get such order declared void but can seek declaration that the order qua
him is inetteotive - State of Haryana v. Vinod Kumar and others, AIR 1986 (P
&. H) 407 RB. - 1986 Rev. L.R. 331.
Pleadings - It is an established principle of law that for determining the
jurisdiction of the court, pleas oTth« plaintiff in the plaint arc to be taken into
consideration - Chief Secretary of Punjab v, Chawaii, 1980 PLJ 10,
—Question of jurisdiction can be decided by taking into consideration pleas
in the plaint of the plaintiff- Karnalt SlngJi v. Jaggar Singh, AIR 1984 (P & H)
294 - 1034 (2) LLR 143 - See also 1PS7 HRR 530.
—Question of jurisHic-.tinn ran be determined from the ease pleaded in the
plaint - Chandu La! v. S.K. Chhiber 1983 PLJ 559,
Preliminary issue - An issue does not cease to be an issue of law by the
mere fact that it contains some conditions of purchase order based upon some
facts - The issue should be treated as a preliminary issue as an issue of law - M/
S. United Vanaspati Lid. v. M/$. Shfi Vardhman SalvaX Private Ltd. - 1988
H.R.R. 641.
Concurrent jurisdiction - An Application for appointing an arbitrator was
pending in one Court while another Court in the same matter proceeded to extend
tht? time fur the appointment of any arbitrator, it was held that the second COUtt
has no jurisdiction to proceed in the matter - Ncfiru Ram Gael Engineers v.
Haryana State. 1989 H.R.R. 218.
CHAPTER VU
Finance, Accounts and Audit
56. Hoard's Fund, - (1) The Board shall have a fund culled the Housing
Board Fund.
(2) The Board may accept grants, subventions, donation and gifts from the
Central Government or' [ ] a local authority or any individual or body, whether
incorporated or not, for all or any of the purposes of this Act.
(3) All moneys received by or on behalf of the Board by virtue of this Act,
all proceeds of land or any other kind of property sold by the Board, at! rents and
all interest, profit and other money accruing to the. Board, shall constitute the
Housing Board Fund.
(4) Except as otherwise directed by the '(Administrator], all money and
receipts specified in the foregoing provisions and forming part of the fund of the
Board shall be deposited in the State Bank of India or in any Scheduled Bank ora
Co-operative Bank or invested in such securities as may be approved by the
*i Administrator].
(5) Such accounts shall be operated upon by such officer as may be authorised
by the Board.
Explanation. - For the purposes of this section, a Scheduled Bank shall
moan a Bunk included in the Second Schedule to the Reserve Bank uf India Aet,
1934.
• Substituted by Chi. Admit. Gaz. Notification dated 13-3-1975 at page 34-35
1. Omitted vide Chandigarh Administration Gaz. Notification dated 13-3-1975 at page 34-35
Haryana Housing Board Act, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh) 519
t
57. Application of the Housing Board Fund - All property, the Housing
Board Fund, and all otherassets vesling in the Board shall be held and applied by
it, subject to the provisions and for the purposes or th is Act.
58. Expenditure in ease of urgency, etc - (1) Where in the opinion of
the Board circumstances of extreme urgeuey have arisen, it shall bo lawtul tortne
Doard to moko for the purpose of this Act in any year an expenditure of such
amount as may be prescribed, notwithsUmd jug the fact that such expenditure nan
not been inoluded in its annual programme or supplementary programme sanc
tioned by the '[Administrator] or the variation of the programme made under
section 28. _
CI) Where any sum is expended under circumstances of extreme urgency
as provided in uub section (I), a report thereof indicating the source from which it
is proposed to meet the expenditure shall be nmde by the Board as soon as prac
ticable to the'[Administrator]. . , , , . . . . . . , „ + „ !
(3) The Board may, within the budget sanctioned by the [Administrator],
approve appropriation not exceeding such ;i mount as may be prescribed frorn one
head to another and from one miuui head to another under the smnu major head
and submit a Gtatemuiit of such ^appropriation to the, "[Administrator].
59. Subventions and loam to Board- (I) The '[Administrator] may from
time to time make subventions to the Board for the purposes of this Act on such
terms and conditions as the '[Administrator] may determine.
(2) The TAdminislratui ] may from time to time advance loans to the Board
on such terms and conditions not inconsistent with the provisions Of this Act as the
'[Administrator] may determine.
60. Power ofBourd to borrow* - (\) The Board may from time to time,
with the previous sanction of the '[Administrator] and subject to the provisions of
this Act and to such conditions as may be prescribed in this behalf borrow any
sum required for the purposes of this Act.
(2) The rules made by the '[Administrator] for the purposes of this section
may empower the Board to borrow by the issue of debentures and to make ar
rangements with bankers,
(3) All debentures issued hy the Board shall be in such torm as the Board,
with the sanction of '[Administrator], may from time to time, determine.
(4) Bvery debenture shall be signed by the '[Chief Executive Officer] 2 [—
(5) Loans borrowed and debentures issued under this section may be guar
anteed by the " [ C l i I l t r a ' Governmeull as to the repayment of principal and the
payment of interest at such rate as may be Fixed by the "[Central Government].
61. Accounts and Audit - (1) The Board shall cause to be maintained
proper books of accounts and such other books as the rules made under this Act
may require and shall prepare in accordance with such rules as annual statement
of accounts. , J . J „ •
(2) The Bornd shall cause iuj accounts to be audited annually by such
persons as the '[Administrator] may direct.^
^Substituted by Chd. Admr. flax.Notification dated 13-3-l°75 Bt peR* 34-J5
1 Substituted by Ifr. AetNo. 27 of I9S0 as extended to Chandigarh
2 Omitted vide Chamflgarh Administration Oat Notification doted 3 3-3-I97S at page 34-35
520 Haryana Housing Board Act, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh)
(3) As soon as the accounts of the Board have been audited, the Board shall
send a copy thereof together with a copy of the report of the auditor thereto to the
* [Administrator]; and shall cause the accounts to be published in the prescribed
manner and place oopies thereof on sale at a reasonable price.
(4) The Board shall comply with such directions as the '[Administrator]
may after perusal of the report of the auditor, think fit to issue.
62. Concurrent and special audit of accounts, - (1) Notwithstanding
anything contained in section 61, the "[Administrator] may order that there shall
be concurrent audit of the accounts of the Board by such person as it thinks fit.
The "[Administrator] may also direct a special audit to be made by such person
as it thinks fit of the accounts of the Board relating to any particular transaction or
a class or series of transactions or to a particular period.
(2) Where an order is made under sub-section (1), the Board shall present
or cause to be presented for audit such accounts and shall furnish to the person
appointed under sub-section CO. such information as he may require for the pur
pose of audit.
63. Transfer of assets and liabilities* - (1) The "[Administrator] may
transfer to the Board building, land or any other property, movable or immovable,
for use and management by the Board on such conditions and limitations as the
'[Administrator] may deem fit, for the purposes of this Act.
(2) The '[Administrator] may transfer to the Board such schemes or works
in progress, with all their assets and liabilities as arc run or managed by the "[Ad
ministrator], subject to such conditions and limitations as the '[Administrator] may
deem fit to impose for the purposes of this Act.
C H A P T E R V m
Miscel laneous
64. Report - The Board shall, before such date and in such form and at
such intervals as may be prescribed, submit to the '[Administrator] a report on
such matters as may be prescribed, and the '[Administrator] shall cause such
report to be published in the '[Chandigarh Gazette].
65. Statements and returns. - The Board shall submit to the '[Administra
tor] such statistics, returns, particulars or statements in regard to any proposed or
existing housing schemes at .such times and in such form and manner as be pre
scribed or as the '[Administrator] may from time to time direct.
66. Power to entry* - The '[Chief Executive Officer] or any person either
generally or specially authorised by the Chairman in this behalf may, with or with
out assistants or workmen, enter into or upon any land, in order—
(a) to make any inspection, survey, measurement, valuation or inquiry;
(bj to take levels ;
(c) to dig or bore into sub-soil;
(d) to set boundaries and intended lines of work ;
(e) to make such levels, boundaries and linesofworks and cutting trenches;
or
+ Substituted by Chd. Admn, Gaz. Notification dated 13-3-1975 at page 34-35
I. Substituted by Hr. Act No. 27 of 1980 as extended to Chandigarh doted 2-4-1991
Haryana Housing Briard Ant, 1971 (as extended In Chandigarh) 521
(f) to do anyother thing, whenever it is necessary to do so, for any of the
purposes of this Act or any rules made or scheme sanctioned there
under:
Provided that —
(i) no suoh entry shah bo made between sunset and sunrise ;
(ii) no dwelling house and no public building which is used asa dwelling
place, shall be so entervd, except with the consent of the occupier
thereof, and without giving the said occupier at least twenty-four hours
previous written notice of the intention to make such entry ;
(iii) sufficient notice shall in every instance be given, even when any
premises may otherwise be entered without notice, to enable the
inmates of any apartment occupied by women to remove themselves
to some pait of the premises where their privacy will not be
disturbed;
(iv) due regard shall always be had, so far as may be compatible with the
exigencies of the purposes for which the entry is made, to be the
social and religious usages of the occupants of the premises entered.
67. Notice of suit against Board. - No person shall Institute any suit against
the Board or against any officer or servant of the Board or any person acting
under the orders of the Doard, for anything done or purporting to have been done
in pursuance of this Act, without giving to the Board, Officer or servant or person
concerned two month's previous notice in writing of the intended suit and of the
cause thereof, nor after six months from the date of the act complained of.
68. Triennial valuations of asserts and liabilities of Board. - The Doard
shall triennially have a valuation of its assets and liabilities made by a valuer ap
pointed with the approval of the '[Administrator]:
Provided that it shall be open to the '[Administrator] to direct evaluation to
be made at any time it may consider necessary.
1 [68-A Delegation. - The Board may, by resolution, authorise that any power
exercisable by it under this Act or the rules or regulations made thereunder, ex
cept the power to make regulations, may also be exercised by the Chief Executive
Officer].
69. Member Officers and servants of Board to be public servants, - All
members, officers and servants of the Board shall be deemed, when acting or
purporting to act in pursuance of any of the provisions of this Act, to be public
servants within the meaning of section 21 of the Indian Penal Code.
70. Indemnity^ - No suit, prosecution or legal proceedings shall lie against
any person for anything which is in good fatth done or purported to be done under
this Act.
71. Power of Government to give direction to Board, - The '[Adminis
trator] may give the Board ouch directions ns in its opinion are necessary orexps
dient for carrying out the purposes of this Act, after giving an opportunity to the
Board to state its objections, if any, to such directions and after considering the
said objections and if shall be the duty of the Board to comply with such directions.
****
* Substituted by Chd. Admn. Oaz. Notification dated 13-3-1975 at page 34-35 -
1. Inserted by Hr, Act No. 27 of 1980 as extended to Chandigarh published on 2-4-ly91
522 Haryana Housing Board Act, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh)
1T72. Control of Administrator over Board. - (1) The Administrator shall
exercise superintendence and control over the Board and its officers andI ma*call
for such information *s it may deem necessary and, m the ©vent of his being
S t f t a d S» the Board is not functioning properly or .s abusing its powers or is
S t y of corruption or mismanagement, he may, by notification, suspentheBoard.
Provided that the Board shall be reconstituted, within a period of one year
from the date of its suspension in the? prescribed manner.
(£) When The Board is suspended under sub-section (1), the following con
sequences shall ensue, namely :—• . , j-h-JnFT™
00 all members of the Board and its committees, including the Chairman
4 of the Hoard, shall, from the date of the notification, vacate their
(l/l all DOJSTS, duties and functions, which under the provisions of this Act
or any regulation made thereunder, are to be exercised by the Board
or any committee thereof or by the Chairman of the Board, or by any
other officer of the Board, shall, during the period of suspension, be
exercised and performed by such person (to be called the Special
Officer) as may be appointed by the Administrator in this behalf:
Provided that the Special Officer may, subject to the approval of the
Administrator, delegate any of hts powers, duties or functions to such
other person as he may think fit; _
(c) all properties, includingthe Board Fund, vested in the Board shall, until
it is, re-constituted, vest in the Central Government].
!r72-A Apnea/. - (I) Save as otherwise expressly provided in any other
provision of this Act, an appeal shall lie from anoriginal or appellate order of any
officer of the Board or the Chairman under this Act or any rule or regulation made
iCicun cr — ^ C h a i n n a n w h e n t t t e o r d 0 f i s made hy any officer of the Board ;
(b) to the Board when the Order Is made by the Chairman.
(2) Every such appeal shall be preferred within a period of thirty days of the
date of communication of the order:
Provided thnt the Chairman or the Board as the case may be, may entertain
the appeal after the expiry of the period of thirty days if it is considered that the
appellant was prevented by sufficient cause from Filing the appeal in time.]
™ COMMENTARY
Alternative remedy - Civil writ - The new allottee of the house obtaining
an interim order restraining theallotment authorities from cancelling his allotment
- The original allottee of the house not filing any appeal under section 7Z-A against
the re-alfotment of the house In the name uf the new allottee - Pica of the allottee
to the effect that the petitioner (original allottee) was not entitled to file a writ
DBtiliun as an alternative remedy was available to him, is not tenable - bummer
Chand Bait v. The Housing Board Haryana, 1984 H.R.R. 9.
Alternative remedy - Writ petition - It is settled law that an appeal against
an order of Housing Board residing cost of houses which is determined by the
Board itself is not useful- It isonly when an order is passed by the Chairman in his
capacity as Chairman that the appeal lies to the Board - Fit. Lt. A.h. Khoste*
I.SiibsilULKdby Hr. AaNo . 20 of 1979 ad extended to Chandigarh published nn 2-4-1991 page
333
2. Fromou by Mr. Act No, 28 of 1976 osexlonded to Chandigarh published on 2.4.1991 pfiee335
Haryana Housing Board Act, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh) 523
case (CWP No, 1S95 of 1984) followed - Pannanandv. The Chairman Mow
ing Board Haryana, 1996 HRR 559.
—The petitioner, an Army Officer, made necessary deposits And was regis
tered for the allotment ofhouse - Failed to deposit the amount within stipulated
period as the letter of demand could not be received at his village address - Cir
cumstances for delayed deposit fully explained - Non speaking and brief order nf
cancellation on technical grounds cannot be sustained - Housing Board directed to
allot the house to petitioner within 3 months - Existence of alternative remedy is
no bar to seek the justice under Art. 226 of the Constitution - Jag Mohan Sharma
v. Sinie of Haryana, L993 HRK 37S.
NATURAL JUSTICE
—Allotment - The provisions of Regulation 6 (2) of Chandigarh Housing
Board Regulation, 1979 undoubtedly authorise the Board to forfeit the depositor
eancel the allotment in case the contents of the affidavit filed by the applicant are
found to be false - However, it is an enabling provision - It is incumbent on the
Board to examine the facts and circumstances ot each case before passing any
such older - Suuh an order cannot be passed mechanically - Where the petitioner
was not given proper opportunity to explain her position about the alleged false
statement, the order of cancellation and forfeiture was held not to be justified -
Smt, Ram Duluri v. Union Territory, Chandigarh, 1994 HRR 67
—Before a person is black listed by an Authority, he must be given a notice
- Order without any uuliee is against law and cannot be sustained - Raphu Naih
Thahtr v. State of Bihar, 1989 H.R.R. 46.
~ ^ T h , e r u , c o f o a t u r a i i " a t ' c e will apply unless application thereof is specifi
cally ruled out by the Statute - State of Haryana V. Ram Kishan, AIR 1988 S.C.
—Audi alteram partem -The Order, wherein Principle of audi ultrem partem
was not applied was held not maintainable - Order passed at the back of the
affected person was set aside - Bachan Strtgh v, State of Punjab, 1988 PLJ
265.
—Principal of Nemo judex cause sua - (No one should be made a judge in
his own oauae) - A man cannot sit in appeal against his own order - Gwcharan
Stnghv, State of Punjab, 1988 PLJ 471 D.B, and SantJlam v. Stale ofHtmaehal
Paradcsh, AIR 1989 IS II.P.
—Rule of natural justice will apply where exercise of power under the Stat
ute would result m civil consequences to citizen - Rules to be followed unless
excluded by Statute itself - Baidev Singh v. State of Punjab, 1987 PLJ 24U
Opportunity - Allotment must be held illegal by the Authorities before can-
celling tho plot allotted to lijm - Allotmentbad in Jaw Is no ground for denying the
opportunity of hearing - Shri Gurdash Ram v. State of Punjab, 1980 PLJ 13 -
Hearing to allottee is essential before cancellation of allotment - Sir Sinsh v
Statt qf Punjab, 1982 PLJ 276,
Jurisdiction - Order passed at the back of an interested party Is without
jurisdiction tmd can be challenged in Civil Court - Tbjcnder Kaur v. M. Q. Tarn
Tarn, 1983 PLJ 336,
Notice - A notice is must by the authorities beforerecovering the arrears or
loan as areare of land revenue - Authorities not to be the Judges In their own
cause - Tirath Singh v. State of Punjab, 1982 PLJ 305.
Order-Officer on original side should ncvcrscck approval of his proposed
orders from his superior, Appellate or revisional Officers - Tata Singh v, Mithu
Singh and others - 1987 PLJ 116.
521 Haryana Housing Board Act, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh)
'[72-B. Revision. ^The Administrator may either suo mote- or on an appli
cation of a party, oall for and examine the record of any proceedings or decision or
oider passed by the Board, Chairman, Chief Executive Officer or Officer of the
Board for the purpose of satisfying itself as to the legality or propriety of any
decision or order paused and if in any case it shall appear to the Administrator that
nny such decision orordei should be modified, annuled or revised, the Administra
tor may, after giving the persons affected thereby an opportunity of being heard,
pass such order thereon as it may deem fit.]
73. Power to make rules. - (1) The '[Administrator] may, by notification
and subject to the condition of previous publication, make rules for carrying out
the? purposes of this Act.
(2) In particular and without prejudice to the generality of the toregoing
power, such rules may be made for all or any ortlie following purposes, namely—
(a) the salary, allowances and condiLiuns of service of members under
section?; . . . , , ,
(b) the manner and form in which contracts shall be entered into under
suction 18; L J . , , * . —
(c) the form of annual housing programme, budget and schedule of staff
officers and servants, particulars of housing schemes and other
particulars to be contained in the programme under section 23;,
(d) the form of notice under section 41 ;
(c) the rate of interest under section 42 ;
(f) the forms of notice under section* 51 and 52 and any other manner in
which they may be served;
(g) the procedure to be followed in taking possession of any Board premises
under section 51;
(h) the manner in which damages under section 52 may be assessed;
(i) the manner in which appeals may be preferred under section 54 and
the procedure to be followed in such appeals;
0) the conditions subject to which the Board may borrow any sum under
section 60; , « » - • . « - *
(k) the manner of preparation, maintenance and publication of accounts
under section 61;
(I) the date before which, the form in which, the interval at which and the
matter on which reports shall be submitted under section 64;
(m) the time at which and the form and manner In which statistics, returns,
particulars and statement shall be submitted under section 65;
(n) Ihe rummer in which the Board shall be superseded and reconstituted
under section 72; _
(o) specifying the bye-laws contravention of any of which shall be an
offence; and
(p) any other matter which is to be or may be prescribed under this Act.
(3) '[ ] A A A *
* Substituted by (Jhd. Admn. OHZ. Notification dated 13-3-1975 at pagc3405
1 Inserted by Hr,ActNo. 10 ofl93fi as extended to Chandigarh published on 2-4-195" I
2 Omiiiod vldcChd. Admn. Co*. (Exim) Noli Mention dated 13-3-1975 at pa«e 34-35
Haryana Housing Board Act, 1971 (as extended to Chandigarh) 525
*
74. Regulations. - The Board may, tram time to time with tiic previous
sanction ofthe' [Administrator] by notification, make regulations consistent with
this Act and witli any rules made thereunder, -
(a) for the management and use of buildings constructed under any housing
scheme;
(b) the principles to be followed in allotment of tenement and premises;
and
(c) for regulating its procedure and the disposal of its business.
75. Power to make bye laws. - (I) The Board may make bye-laws, not
inconsistent with this Act and the rules and regulations made thereunder, which
may be necesniiry or expedient for the purpose of carrying out its duties and
functions under this Act.
(2) No bye-laws made by the Board shall come into force until it has been
confirmed by the "[Administrator] with or without modification.
(3) All bye-laws made under this section shall be published In the '[Chandigarh
Gazette].
76. Penalty for contravention of bye-taws. - Whosoever contravenes a
bye-law made under section 75 the contravention of which is prescribed as an
offence shall, on conviction, be punished with imprisonment for a term which may
extend to one month or with fine which may extend to five hundred rupees or with
both.
77. Penalty for obstructing etc. - If any person -
(a) obstructs any person with whom the Board ha* entered itito n crmtrncf,
in the performance or execution by such person of his duty or of anything
which lie Is empowered or required to do under this Act; or
(b) removes any mark set up for the purpose of indicating any level or
direction necessary to the execution of works authorised under this
Act; !
he shall, on uunvicliun, be punished with imprisonment for a term which may
extend to one month or with fine which may extend to five hundred rupees or wlili
both.
78. Authority for prosecution. - Unless otherwise provided, no court shall
take cognizance of any offence punishable under this Act except on tlie complaint
of, or upon information received from the Board or some person authorised by the
Board, oy general or special order, in this behalf.
****
79. Registration of documents executed on behalf of Board. - (1) Not
withstanding anything contained in the Indian Registration Act, 1908 (Central Act
XVFof 1908), it shall not be necessary forthe Chairman toappearin person orby
agent at any registration officer in any proceeding connected with registration of
any insu UIUBHI executed by him in his official capacity on behalf of the Board or i f
to sign as provided in section i>8 of that Act. ;
(2) Where any instrument is so executed, the registration officer to whom
such instrument is presented for registration may, if he thinks fit, refer to the
Chairman for information respecting the same, and on being satisfied ofthe ex
ecution thereof, shall register the instrument. I
**** !
* Substituted by Clid. Attum. GtLt. NolifiwiLiuu djiicil 13-3-1975 at page 34-35
i
•
l«
!:
526 Haryana Housing Board Act, 1571 (as extended to Chandigarh)
SO. Dissolution of Board, - ( t ) The State Government may be notification
declare that with effect from such date as may be specified in the notification, the
Board shall be dissolved.
v -]
(2) With effect from the date specified in the notification under sub-section
(a) all properties, funds and duos which are vested In and realisable by the
Board shall vest in and be realisable by the "[Central Government];
(b) all liabilities enforceable against the Board shall be enforceable against
the '[Central Government] to the extent of the properties, funds and
dues vested in and realised by the "[Central Government].
(3) Nothing in this section shall affect the liability oFthe'r^rLrr1 ' Govern
ment] in respect of loans or debentures guaranteed under sun-sent inn (5) of sec
tion 60.
ft***
81. Removal cf difficulties. - (1) If any difficulty arises in giving effect to
the provisions of this Act, in consequence of the transition tn the said provisions
from the provisions of the Acts in force immediately before the commencement
of this Act, the '[Administrator] may by notification make such provisions as appear
to it to be necessary or expedient for removing the difficultly.
(2) If any difficulty arises in giving effect to the provisions of this Act Other
wise than in relation fo (he transition from the provisions of the Acts in force
before the commencement of this Act, the '[Administrator] may by notification
make such provisions, not inconsistent with the provisions of this Act, as appear to
it to be necessary or expedient for removing the difficulty.
* * * * *
+ Substituted by CM. Admn, Gaz, Notification dated 13-3-1975 at page 34-35
I. Omiitod vide CM. Admn. (Jaz. (l&tra) NolitUtttian dated 13-3-1973 at page 34-35