Refund of 4 Additional Duty of Customs (4 CVD) in pursuance of Notification No.102/2007- Customs dated 14.9.2007 - Special Drive for clearance of pending 4 SAD refund claims - Circular No.18/2010-Customs, dated 8.7.2010
Circular - The Customs Act, 1962
- Kind: Circular
- Under: The Customs Act, 1962
Text of this circular
Circular No.18 / 2010-Customs
F. No. 401/46/2008-Cus.III
Government of India
Ministry of Finance
Department of Revenue
Central Board of Excise and Customs
159A, North Block,
New Delhi -110001
8th July, 2010.
To
All Chief Commissioners of Customs / Customs (Prev.).
All Chief Commissioners of Customs & Central Excise.
All Commissioners of Customs / Customs (Prev.).
All Commissioners of Customs & Central Excise.
Subject: Refund of 4% Additional Duty of Customs (4% CVD) in pursuance of Notification No.102/2007-
Customs dated 14.9.2007 - Special Drive for clearance of pending 4% SAD refund claims - reg.
***
Sir / Madam,
Your kind attention is invited to the Notification No.102/2007-Customs dated 14.9.2007 and Board's
Circulars No.6/2008-Customs dated 28.4.2008 and No.16/2008-Customs dated 13.10.2008 regarding refund of
4% Additional Duty of Customs (4% CVD). Attention is also invited to the Board's Circulars No.24/2007-Customs
dated 2.7.2007, No.22/2008-Customs dated 19.12.2008 and No.7/2008-Customs dated 28.5.2008 which relate to
general refund cases.
2. In this regard, several representations from the trade and industry, associations continue to be received in
the Board complaining about the delay in refund of 4% CVD or denial of the refund on one pretext or the other,
causing them great hardship.
3. In view of the fact that all the doubts of the field formations had been clarified by the Board vide above
mentioned Circulars, it is viewed that there may not be any difficulty in timely disposal of refund claims. However,
on review of the pending refund claims as on 31.3.2010 at major Custom Houses, it has been noticed that more
than 80% of pending claims relate to 4% CVD cases. Hence, the Board has decided to further simplify the
procedure for claiming 4% CVD refund in the following manner.
4.1. In respect of Accredited Clients registered with Customs in terms of Circular No.42/2005-Customs dated
24.11.2005 (ACP clients), the amount of 4% CVD refund shall be sanctioned in full, on preliminary scrutiny of the
following documents: (a) TR-6 Challans (in original) for CVD payment; (b) VAT/ST payment Challans (in original);
(c) summary of sale invoices; and (d) certificate of statutory Auditor / Chartered Accountant, for correlating the
payment of ST/VAT on the imported goods with the invoices of sale and also to the effect that the burden of 4%
CVD has not been passed on by the importer to the buyer. The procedure for pre-audit for ACP clients shall be
done away with and detailed scrutiny should be done only at the stage of post-audit. The refund claims shall be
sanctioned within the maximum time period of 30 days in all such cases.
4.2. Submission of sale invoices shall be required only in electronic form (CD or other media) in respect of 4%
CVD refund cases and submission of paper documents is accordingly dispensed with.
5. In order to enable timely payment of refund in case of 4% CVD, a system of optional facility of directly
crediting the applicant's bank account, through RTGS (Real Time Gross Settlement) or NEFT (National
Electronics Funds Transfer) System is being prescribed. This facility is already functioning in Mumbai Customs
Zone-II and has been found useful for the trade. Hence, Board has decided to extend this facility on optional
basis to all other Customs formations also. Necessary authorisation for payment of refund amount directly to
Bank Account may be taken in such cases from the importer/ authorised signatory of the importer in the form
annexed. (Annexure-I)
6. Some field formations have also raised certain doubts whether the audited Balance Sheet
and Profit and Loss Account have to be examined in respect of the current financial year for scrutiny of unjust
enrichment aspect. It is stated that a large number of refund claims relating to the current year were held up for
want of such verification. In this regard, the issue has been examined by the Board and it has been decided that
the field formations shall accept a certificate from Chartered Accountant for the purpose of satisfying the
condition that the burden of 4% CVD has not been passed on by the importer to any other person. Further, the
importer shall also make a self-declaration along with the refund claim to the effect that he has not passed on the
incidence of 4% CVD to any other person. Hence, there is no need for insisting on production of audited Balance
Sheet and Profit and Loss Account in these cases. It may also be noted that recently the Board has also notified
the list of documents required to be filed by the applicant along with the refund claim (Annexure-II) which is also
displayed in the departmental website. Hence, other than these aforesaid documents, no other document would
be required in the normal course of granting 4% CVD refund.
7. Board also desires that the Commissioner of Customs shall personally monitor all cases of 4% CVD
refund claims pending for more than 30 days so as to ensure that these are disposed of within the overall time
limit of three months.
8. A suitable Public Notice and Standing Order may be issued for the guidance of the trade and
staff. Difficulties faced, if any, in implementation of this Circular may be brought to the notice of the Board at an
early date.
Yours faithfully,
Sd./-
(R. P. Singh)
Director (Customs)
Encl: As stated above.
Copy for internal circulation - As usual.
Annexure - I
Authorization for payment of refund amount directly to Bank Account
I.E.C. No. _______________ PAN No. _________________.
M/s ______________________________
Address: __________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
E-mail address:
Bank Account No.: __________________
Bank Name: ______________________
Bank Address: ______________________
11 digit alphanumeric IFS Code : ________________
I declare that the above particulars are correct. I authorize payment of refund amount for my refund
claims filed at ______________________ Custom House to my above mentioned Bank Account through NEFT /
RTGS after deduction of Bank's service charges at the rate of 0.09% and applicable NEFT / RTGS charges as
per RBI guidelines.
Name of the Authorised signatory /
Representative of the Importer
Signature :
Date:
Place:
Certified that the above details are correct.
Signature of Bank Branch Manager along with the official Seal
Annexure - II
Sl.No. Type of
refund
claim
Section /
notification under
which filed
Illustrative list of documents to be filed by applicant along with
Application for refund claim in prescribed form (Customs Series
Form No.102 as given in Part 5 of Customs Manual)
3
Refund of
4% SAD
Notification No.
102/2007-Customs
dated 14.9.2007
1. Document evidencing payment of the Special Additional Duty
(SAD).
2. Invoices of sale of the imported goods in respect of which refund
of the said SAD is claimed.
3. Documents evidencing payment of appropriate sales tax or value
added tax, as the case may be, by the importer, on sale of such
imported goods.
4. Certificate from a statutory auditor / CA who certifies the final
accounts in respect of correlation of VAT payment, payment of 4%
SAD amount and unjust enrichment as prescribed in Board's circular
No.6/2008-Customs dated 28.4.2008 and 16/2008-Customs dated
13.10.2008.
5. Copy of the Consignment Sale Agreement. (in case of sale through
consignment agents / stockists).
6. Self-declaration / Affidavit (for e.g. in case of submission of
invoice in soft form in lieu of paper documents, in case of fulfillment
of the doctrine of unjust enrichment to the effect that the applicant
has not passed on the incidence of 4% SAD to any other person).
7. Any other document considered necessary in support of the claim.
Circular No.6 /2008-Customs
F. No. 401/104/2007-Cus.III
Government of India
Ministry of Finance
Department of Revenue
Central Board of Excise and Customs
North Block, New Delhi.
28th April, 2008.
To
All Chief Commissioners of Customs / Customs (Prev.).
All Chief Commissioners of Customs & Central Excise.
All Commissioners of Customs / Customs (Prev.).
All Commissioners of Customs & Central Excise.
Principal Chief Controller of Accounts (C&CE).
The Chief Departmental Representative, CESTAT.
All Directorates under CBEC.
Subject: Procedure to be adopted for refund of 4% Additional Duty of Customs in
pursuance of Notification No.102/2007-Customs dated 14.9.2007 - regarding.
***
Sir / Madam,
I am directed to state that various representations from importers, exporters, trade and
industry associations and references from some of the Customs field formations have been
received in the Board seeking clarification regarding refund of 4% Additional Duty of
Customs leviable under sub-section (5) of Section 3 of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 in
pursuance of Notification No.102/2007-Customs dated 14.9.2007.
2. The Board has examined this matter in consultation with the Customs field
formations. The following procedure may be adopted by the field formations in order to
settle expeditiously the refund claims arising out of the exemption provided vide Notification
No.102/2007-Customs dated 14.9.2007.
3. Manner of refund and its receipt:
Your attention is invited to the instructions communicated vide F.No.354/129/2007-
TRU dated 14.9.2007 at the time of issue of the Notification No.102/2007-Customs dated
14.9.2007. It is reiterated that the scheme of refund of 4% Additional Duty of Customs has
been notified through an exemption notification, and hence, the conditions as prescribed only
in the said notification will apply. All refund applications under the aforesaid notification
shall be received by the concerned field formations in their Centralized Refund Section, and
the applicants would be given proper acknowledgement. The status of these refund claims
shall also be displayed in the online database of customs duty refunds maintained by the
respective Commissionerates.
4. Time - Limit:
4.1. In the Notification No.102/2007-Customs dated 14.9.2007, no specific time limit has
been prescribed for filing a refund application. Under the circumstances, a doubt has been
expressed that whether the normal time-limit of six months prescribed in section 27 of the
Customs Act, would apply. In the absence of specific provision of section 27 being made
applicable in the said notification, the time limit prescribed in this section would not be
automatically applicable to refunds under the notification. Further, it was also represented
that the goods imported may have to be despatched for sale to different parts of the country
and that the importer may find it difficult to dispose of the imported goods and complete the
requisite documentation within the normal period of six months. Taking into account various
factors, it has been decided to permit importers to file claims under the above exemption upto
a period of one year from the date of payment of duty. Necessary change in the notification
is being made so as to incorporate a specific provision prescribing maximum time limit of
one year from the date of payment of duty, within which the refund could be filed by any
person. It is also clarified that the importers would be entitled to refund of duties only in
respect of quantities for which the prescribed documents are made available and the claims
submitted within the maximum prescribed time of one year. Unsold stocks would not be
eligible for refunds.
4.2. It is also clarified that only a single claim against a particular Bill of Entry should be
permitted to be filed within the maximum time period of one year. Filing of refund claim for
a part quantity in a bill of entry shall not be allowed except when this is necessary at the end
of the one year period. Further, since the Sales Tax (ST) / Value Added Tax (VAT) is being
paid on periodical or monthly basis, even in case of bills of entry where the entire quantity of
goods are sold within a month, all such cases shall be consolidated in a single refund claim
and filed with the Customs authorities on a monthly basis. In other words, there would be a
single refund claim in respect of one importer in a month irrespective of the number of Bills
of Entry (B/Es) processed by the respective Commissionerate.
4.3. With the extension of time limit and the requirement to file claims on a monthly basis,
Board feels that the number of refund claims should be manageable for disposal within the
normal period of three months. Further, in the absence of specific provision for payment of
interest being made applicable under the said notification, the payment of interest does not
arise for these claims. However, Board directs that the field formations shall ensure disposal
of all such refund claims under the said notification within the normal period not exceeding
three months from the date of receipt.
5. Documents to be enclosed with refund claim:
5.1. Notification No.102/2007-Customs dated 14.9.2007 prescribes the documents that
shall be enclosed along with the refund claim. In order to ensure sanction of refund properly,
it is clarified that the document evidencing payment of ST/VAT (in original) duly issued by
or acknowledged by the concerned ST/VAT authorities shall be submitted by the importer. A
certificate from a Chartered Accountant or any other independent authority certifying
payment of ST/VAT would not be acceptable in lieu of the original documents.
However, a certificate from the statutory auditor / Chartered Accountant, who certifies the
importer's annual financial accounts under the Companies Act or any statute, correlating the
payment of ST/VAT on the imported goods (in respect of which refund is claimed) with the
invoices of sale, would be required along with the original tax / duty payment documents as
proof of payment of appropriate ST/VAT for the purpose of para 2(d) & (e) of the said
notification.
5.2. For the purpose of refund under this notification, it is reiterated that appropriate Sales
Tax or VAT means Sales Tax or VAT in case of Intra-State sales and Central Sales Tax
(CST) in case of Inter-State sales.
5.3. The exemption contained in the said notification envisages that the importer shall file
a refund claim for 4% CVD ("said additional duty of Customs") paid on imported goods and
shall pay on sale of the said goods "appropriate Sales Tax or VAT as the case may
be". Hence, it is clear that there is no stipulation in the notification that the exemption is
available only if the rate of ST/VAT is equal to or higher than the rate of additional duty of
Customs; nor is there a condition that if the rate of ST/VAT happens to be lower than 4%, the
refund would be restricted to the lower amount. As such, it is clarified that it will not be
appropriate to reduce the refund amount in such a situation and the entire 4% CVD, if
otherwise found eligible, shall be refunded.
6. Unjust enrichment:
6.1. The 4% CVD exemption under the said notification is operated through a refund
mechanism, wherein the importer would have to first pay the said 4% CVD at the time of
importation and, thereafter, can claim refund of 4% CVD on production of documents
showing that the appropriate ST/VAT has been paid. Hence, the purpose of granting this
exemption is to ensure that the importer pays either 4% CVD or the appropriate ST/VAT and
not both. It is not the intention of the Government to allow the importer to recover the 4%
CVD from the buyer as well as to claim refund of this amount from Customs. Hence, the
principle of unjust enrichment needs to be examined in each case before sanction of refund
under this notification. However, considering the voluminous transactions and the
documents involved in the cycle, from import to sale, it was felt that it would be expedient to
allow the importer to submit a certificate from the statutory auditor / Chartered Accountant
who certifies the annual accounts of the importer, that the burden of 4% CVD has not been
passed on by the importer to the buyer and to fulfill the requirement of unjust enrichment.
6.2. In view of the above, it is clarified that the doctrine of unjust enrichment will apply to
4% CVD refunds Scheme under the said exemption notification issued in terms of Section
25(1) of the Customs Act, 1962. However, importers may produce a certificate from the
statutory auditor/Chartered Accountant who certifies the importer's annual financial accounts
under the Companies Act or any statute, explaining how the burden of 4% CVD has not been
passed on by the importer and to fulfill the requirement of unjust enrichment. In addition to
the aforesaid the importer shall also make a self-declaration along with the refund claim to
the effect that he has not passed on the incidence of 4% CVD to any other person.
7. Other miscellaneous issues:
7.1. As regards the other doubt expressed by certain field formations on the effective date
of the operation of refund scheme, it is stated that the said notification No.102/2007-Customs
was issued on 14.9.2007. Accordingly, it is clarified that only those cases where 4% CVD
was paid on or subsequent to 14.9.2007, will qualify for refunds under this scheme subject to
fulfillment of prescribed conditions.
7.2. In respect of the doubt that whether the stamping or hand-writing of declaration in the
invoice would be acceptable for the purpose of fulfilling the condition as mentioned in para
2(b) of the said notification, it is clarified that a stamp on the invoice (to state that no
CENVAT Credit is admissible) should suffice for the purpose of para 2 (b) of the said
notification.
7.3. On the issue that in case of 4% CVD having been paid through DEPB Scrip, whether
refund could be paid by cash, it is clarified that instead of refunding the duty in cash, the
amount eligible for refund should be re-credited on the relevant DEPB Scrip.
8. In view of the above clarifications, you are requested to kindly take further necessary
action in the matter. The above instructions are being issued so that necessary administrative
arrangements are made to deal with 4% CVD refund claims and the refund claims are
sanctioned properly. Accordingly, all the concerned Commissioners of Customs / Central
Excise may kindly ensure for proper implementation of these instructions of the Board.
9. A suitable Public Notice and Standing Order may be issued for the guidance of the
trade and staff. Difficulties faced, if any, in implementation of the Circular may be brought
to the notice of the Board at an early date.
10. Hindi version will follow.
Yours faithfully,
(Aseem Kumar)
Under Secretary (Customs)
Tel. 2309 4182
Fax: 2309 2173
Internal circulation - As usual.
Circular No.16/2008-Customs
F. No. 401/104/2007-Cus.III
Government of India
Ministry of Finance
Department of Revenue
Central Board of Excise and Customs
159A, North Block,
New Delhi -110 001.
13th October, 2008.
To
All Chief Commissioners of Customs / Customs (Prev.).
All Chief Commissioners of Customs & Central Excise.
All Commissioners of Customs / Customs (Prev.).
All Commissioners of Customs & Central Excise.
All Directors General under CBEC.
Principal Chief Controller of Accounts (Cus & CX).
Subject: Clarification on refund of 4% Additional Duty of Customs (4% CVD) in
pursuance of Notification No.102/2007-Customs dated 14.09.2007 - regarding.
***
Sir / Madam,
Your kind attention is invited to the Board's Circular No.6/2008-Customs dated
28.4.2008 containing instructions on the procedure to be followed by the Customs field
formations while making 4% CVD refund in terms of Notification No.102/2007-Customs
dt.14.9.2007.
2. Subsequent to the issue of the above circular, the trade and industry associations have
raised some more issues needing clarifications and in some cases relaxations of the
procedural requirement for expeditious sanction of refund claims. Further, certain field
formations have also made references on some of the issues raised by the trade. The various
issues raised in the above references have been examined in the Board and the following
clarifications are issued on each of points raised:
(i) Time-limit for filing of refund claim: It was already clarified by the Board that
importers will be permitted to file 4% CVD claims upto a period of one year from the date of
payment of duty. As stated in para 4.1 of the Circular No.6/2008-Customs, an amending
notification to this effect specifically providing for one year period from the date of payment
of the additional duty of customs (4% CVD) was issued vide Notification No.93/2008-
Customs dated 1.8.2008 amending para 2(c) of the above-said notification. This may be
taken note of and pending refund claims involving more than six months period, if any, may
be disposed of accordingly.
(ii) Early processing of refund claims: There have been a number of requests from the
trade that the 4% CVD refund claims should be processed within the prescribed period of
three months time. This aspect has been explained in detail in para 4.3 of the Board's Circular
No.6/2008-Customs. Hence, the jurisdictional Commissioners and Chief Commissioners at
respective Custom Houses / zones may ensure that there is no delay in the disposal of the 4%
CVD refund claims in terms of Notification No.102/2007-Customs. Further, the status of the
refund claims should be placed on the website of the Commissionerate and updated
periodically for monitoring of timely disposal of refund claims. Wherever refund claims are
sanctioned necessary defacement of the original bill of entry may be carried out in order to
ensure that in no case refund is entertained on the same grounds for same goods covered
under a bill of entry again. In case of refund claim not being disposed of in three months, the
matter should be reported to the Board within a fortnight mentioning the reason for delay and
any area of doubt which needs to be clarified.
(iii) Sale invoices to be submitted in soft form for claiming refund: It has also been
represented that number of copies of sale invoices are required to be produced in view of the
Condition No.2 (e) (ii) of the Notification No.102/2007-Customs dated 14.9.2007. As these
are voluminous, it is difficult for the importers as well as the Department to handle such
invoices in hard copy. This issue was examined in specific reference to Section 4 of the
Information Technology (I.T.) Act, 2000 which provides that any information or any other
matter, which is required under any Law to be made in writing or printed form, could be
submitted in an electronic form provided it is accessible for use or subsequent reference. In
view of the fact that this provision applies notwithstanding anything contained in any other
law, the legal requirement of submission of copies of sale invoices would be fulfilled if the
same is provided in electronic form. In the I.T. Act, 2000, 'electronic form' has been defined
and it includes information stored in optical or magnetic media.
Therefore, it is clarified that the importers could submit the copy of invoices in
electronic form (including the form of CD) as prescribed in Information Technology Act,
2000, for the purpose of fulfillment of the condition in para 2 (e) (ii) of the Notification
No.102/2007-Customs dated 14.9.2007. The electronic media containing the information
about sale invoices should, however, be submitted along with a paper declaration by the
applicant indicating the invoice numbers contained in the media and subscribing to their
truthfulness.
(iv) Declaration for non-admission of Cenvat Credit: In terms of condition 2 (b) of
the Notification No.102/2007-Customs, the importer who wishes to avail the refund of 4%
CVD, is also required to make a specific declaration in the sale invoice that no Cenvat credit
would be admissible in respect of 4% CVD. This ensures that there is no double benefit on
account of refund to the importer and Cenvat Credit to the purchaser. Hence, the request for
dispensation of such declaration by certain importers who are not registered with Central
Excise authorities and to allow 4% CVD refund to these importers on the basis of their status
of registration with Central Excise, as non-registered dealer is not found to be acceptable.
(v) Payment of ST/VAT by cash or input tax credit: It has been brought to the notice
of the Board that the ST/VAT credit is available with the importer due to credit of ST/VAT
paid on local purchase of other products. In such cases, although the imported goods are sold
and ST/VAT is being paid on such sale, instead of cash payment, the input tax credit is used.
Hence, it was represented that payment of ST/VAT by input tax credit adjustment should be
acceptable in lieu of ST/VAT paid challan.
In terms of the requirement under para 2(d) of the said notification, it is stated that
appropriate ST/ VAT is to be paid by the importer on sale of goods. The importer can then
claim the refund of 4% CVD paid at the time of import. It is noticed that most of the
ST/VAT legislations provide for payment of ST/VAT by utilizing the input tax credit. If the
Sales Tax Authorities accept payment of ST/VAT through cash or adjustment of input tax
credit, the same shall be treated as effective discharge of ST/VAT payment on imported
goods. Further, Board had provided in its earlier Circular that a certificate from statutory
auditor/Chartered Accountant correlating the payment of ST/VAT on the imported goods
with the invoices of sale, along with supporting documents of proof of payment of
appropriate ST/VAT is acceptable for the purpose of 4% CVD refund. Hence, it is clarified
that discharge of ST/VAT liability by the importer, through cash or other authorised form of
payment to the concerned ST/VAT authority or input tax credit adjustment, could be
accepted by Customs field formations for the purpose of fulfillment of the condition in para 2
(d) considering sanction of refund of 4% CVD.
(vi) Submission of original copy of ST/VAT Challan: The difficulties expressed by
the importers in submission of original Tax paid challans for evidencing payment of ST/VAT
at more than one port was examined. Importers pay the appropriate ST/VAT to the concerned
State Government where the sale of imported goods is effected. There is a genuine difficulty
in case of importers selling the goods through various States or those importing goods at
various ports and subsequently, selling in different States to obtain the original copy of
ST/VAT challan evidencing payment of appropriate ST/VAT for the purpose of claiming 4%
CVD refund with various Customs Commissionerates at different ports Further, payment of
ST/VAT after adjusting input tax credit is made through different forms such as deposit of
cash, cheque, demand draft or other authorised mode of payment through banking channel or
payment directly to the ST/VAT Department. In some States, even e-payment is also
accepted.
The aforesaid request of the trade has been considered and keeping in view the
difficulties faced in submitting original challans, it has been decided that alternatively, the
importers may submit copies of ST/VAT challan or copies of ST/VAT payment document in
different forms evidencing payment made to the bank or ST/VAT Department towards
ST/VAT along with a certificate from the Chartered Accountant, who either certifies the
importer's financial records under the Companies Act, 1956 or any ST/VAT Act of the State
Government or the Income Tax Act, 1961, confirming the payment against the aforesaid
documents. This would be considered sufficient to fulfill the requirement in terms of para
2(e)(iii) of the Notification No.102/2007-Customs dated 14.9.2007. Hence, the Customs field
formations shall accept the copies of ST/VAT challans/documents along with the certificate
of the said Chartered Accountant, while receiving the 4% CVD refund claim. However, the
importers may be required to submit the original ST/VAT payment challans or other similar
documents, in doubtful cases for verification by Customs authorities, which shall be returned
to the importer after verification.
(vii) Unjust enrichment and its Certification by Chartered Accountants: It is
represented by the trade that for the purpose of satisfying the condition that burden of 4%
CVD has not been passed on by the importer to any other person, a certification from an
independent Chartered Accountant may be accepted by the Customs authorities.
In this regard, it is stated that the intention of the Government is not to allow the
importer to recover 4% CVD from the buyer and to claim the refund from Customs as
well. The only method to ensure this is to make it conditional to satisfy the principle of
unjust enrichment. In this regard, in the earlier circular, it has been provided that the
importer may produce a certificate from the statutory auditor/CA who certifies that Annual
Accounts of the importer (under the Companies Act, 1956 or any statute) to the effect that the
burden of 4% CVD has not been passed on by the importer to the buyer. The provisions
contained in the various Sales Tax Laws prevailing in various States provide for Audit of the
books and accounts for the purpose of ascertaining the correctness of ST/VAT payment /
Input Tax Credit. Further, Section 44AB of the Income Tax Act, 1961 provides that certain
persons carrying on business or profession exceeding the prescribed limit are required to get
their accounts audited by "an Accountant" explained therein.
Considering these provisions, it is clarified by the Board that the 'statutory auditor /
Chartered Accountant' mentioned in para 6 of the earlier Board's circular refers to "Chartered
Accountant" within the meaning of section 2(1)(b) of the Chartered Accountants Act,
1949. However, it is clarified that the Customs field formations shall accept the certificate
given only by such a Chartered Accountant who either certifies the importer's financial
records under the Companies Act, 1956 or any ST/VAT Act of the State Government or the
Income Tax Act, 1961, in order to fulfill the requirement of the condition that the incidence
of duty burden has not been passed on by the importer to any other person for the purpose of
refund of 4% CVD. A certificate by any other independent Chartered Accountant would not
be acceptable for this purpose.
(viii) Consignment Agents: It is represented by certain importers who operate through
consignment agents / stockists, that the imported goods are held by these agents / stockists in
the capacity of bailee. The goods are sold by them on behalf of the importer and the payment
for the sale is made to the importer. These agents also pay the appropriate ST/VAT on behalf
of the importer and get the same reimbursed from the principal i.e. importer. Unlike in other
transactions, while the bill of entry for imported goods under consignment sale is filed by the
importer and the bill of entry will be in the name of the importer, the sale invoices are issued
by the said consignment agents / stockists in their own names. Hence, it has been requested
by these importers that refund of 4% CVD in such cases should be allowed to them based on
the correlating documents evidencing payment of ST/VAT by their agents / stockists.
It is observed that in 'consignment sale' transaction, goods are dispatched to
Consignment agents by importer as Principal; and the imported goods remain the property of
the importer. Similarly, the responsibility of Stockist is confined to stocking of goods and
forwarding such goods to persons and places as instructed by the importer. Hence
Consignment agent/stockist sells goods on behalf of the importer. The said agent collects
sales proceeds and remits the same to importer; however he may recover his commission,
godown charges, insurance charges etc., from the importer. In terms of the various State
ST/VAT laws, 'sale' is defined to mean transfer of property in goods for a valuable
consideration. For the purpose of ST/VAT, transfer of property involved in the sale of
imported goods, through an agent, by whatever name called, whether for cash or for deferred
payment or other valuable consideration, shall be deemed to be a sale, by such agent.
Further, consignment agent/stockist who has the authority to sell the goods belonging to the
importer/ principal on their behalf is also included in the scope of the term 'dealer' under the
ST/VAT Act, and the said agent/stockist are required to pay appropriate ST/VAT on sale of
such goods. In these transactions, normally, an Agreement is entered into between the
importer and agent, which provides for the terms and conditions of sale and offers a
commission for the work done by the agent / stockist. Payment of ST/VAT on behalf of the
importer may also be specified as one of the arrangement as per such agreement. Since such
sale is an accepted form of commercial transaction, payment of ST/VAT made by such
agents and submission of ST/VAT challan by the agents on behalf of principal (Importer) is
permitted by ST/VAT authorities.
In view of the above, it is clarified that in case of sale of imported goods by importer through
consignment agent/stockist, refund of 4% CVD shall be granted by Customs field formations,
subject to the condition that the Consignment agent/ stockist has been authorised to sell the
imported goods in terms of the agreement entered into between the importer and consignment
agent/stockist and that each of the sale invoices issued by the consignment
agent/stockist indicates that the sale is made by him on behalf of the importer in the capacity
of consignment agent/stockist. These conditions shall be verified by the Customs officers
before sanction of 4% CVD refund claims in these cases. Further, in such cases, it is also
required that the applicant submits a certificate from a Chartered Accountant appointed by
the importer, who either certifies the importer's financial records under the Companies Act,
1956 or any ST/VAT Act of the State Government or the Income Tax Act, 1961, to the effect
that appropriate ST/VAT has been paid by consignment agent/stockist on behalf of importer
and that the importer, in turn, has paid or reimbursed the ST/VAT to his consignment
agent/stockist along with the correlation of ST/VAT payment with 4% CVD paid on
imported goods.
(ix) Submission of refund claim for part of goods in a consignment: Several importers
have represented that the refund claim should be sanctioned even prior to the said one year
period in cases of part sale where a significant part is already sold and an undertaking is
furnished by the importer that no more refund claim would be filed for the remaining
part. Moreover, in some cases, there may be short landing or part of the consignment is
unlikely to be sold due to some defects, damage etc. In such cases too, the importers may
prefer to claim refund for such part of consignment that were actually sold. In the earlier
circular issued, it was clarified that 4% CVD refund claims shall be filed on a monthly
basis. Further, it was stated that filing of refund claim for part quantity covered in a bill of
entry shall not be allowed except when this is necessary at the end of the one year period
prescribed.
It is needless to specifically mention that where certain quantity of goods were lost or
short-landed or damaged resulting in sale of part quantity and the importer submitting a
refund claim for the quantity that was sold along with the declaration that for the remaining
quantity they would not claim refund, the claims shall be entertained even for part quantity by
the Customs. However, since some Customs field formations have raised this doubt, it is
hereby clarified that in such cases as stated above, the filing of refund claim for part quantity
shall be accepted by the Customs field formations during the same month and such cases
need not await till the end of the one year period.
3. In view of the above clarifications, you are required to take further necessary action in
the matter without any delay. All pending 4% CVD refund claims must be attended to and the
refund claims sanctioned within the prescribed time limit. In view of the resentment in the
trade on this matter, the Chief Commissioners should ensure that prompt action is taken to
dispose of the claims. A status report about the disposal of claims filed till 30.06.2008 may
please be sent to the Board by 15.11.2008.
4. A suitable Public Notice and Standing Order may be issued for the guidance of the
staff and trade. Difficulties faced, if any, in implementation of the Circular may please be
brought to the notice of the Board at the earliest.
Yours faithfully,
(M.M. Parthiban)
Director (Customs)
*****
Circular No 01/ 2012-Customs
F.No.401/46/2008-Cus.III
Government of India
Ministry of Finance
Department of Revenue
Central Board of Excise and Customs
North Block, Room No. 253-A,
New Delhi, the 5thJanuary 2012.
To,
All Chief Commissioners of Customs / Customs (Prev.).
All Chief Commissioners of Customs & Central Excise.
All Commissioners of Customs / Customs (Prev.).
All Commissioners of Customs & Central Excise.
Subject: Refund of 4% Additional Duty of Customs (4% CVD) in terms of Notification
No. 102/2007-Customs dated 14.09.2001-regarding.
Sir / Madam,
Your kind attention is invited to the Circular No. 18/2010-Customs dated 8th July,
2010), vide which Board has simplified procedure for sanction of refund of 4% SAD in case
of ACP importers. Vide Para 4.1 (d) of the Circular No.18/2010-Customs, dated 08.07.2010
it was provided that the amount of 4% CVD refund shall be sanctioned in full, on preliminary
scrutiny of the documents and certificate of statutory auditor/Chartered Accountant, for
correlating the payment of ST/VAT on the imported goods with the invoices of sale and also
to the effect that the burden of 4% CVD has not been passed on by the importer to the buyer.
However, as Para 6 of the said Circular only Charted Accountant can issue a certificate that
incidence of burden of 4% CVD has not been passed on by the importer to the buyer.
2. Representations have been received in the Board for amending Para 6 of the said
Circular to make it in consonance to Para 4.1 (d) ibid to enable Cost Accountants to issue the
Certificates as statutory auditors for the purpose of refund of 4% CVD.
3. The matter has been examined in the Board. Board noted that the Circular
No.18/2010-Customs dated 08.07.2010 disentitles Cost Accountants in regard to issue of
requisite certificate though they may be statutory auditors of the importer. Board also
observed that several States currently recognize Cost Accountants for purpose of VAT audit
and it would be a hardship to trade already using statutory auditors/Cost Accountants to get
required certificate for amount of 4% refund from Chartered Accountants. Therefore, as a
measure to facilitate the trade Board has approved the amendment of the Circular
No.18/2010 Customs dated 08.07.2010 so as to authorize Statutory Auditors/ Cost
Accountants/ Chartered Accountants to issue a certificate, certifying that burden of 4% CVD
has not been passed on by the importers to any other person.
4. Accordingly, para 4.1(d) and Para 6 of Board Circular No.18/2011-Customs, dated
08.07.2010, stands modified to above extent.
5. Suitable Public Notices or standing orders may be issued to guide the trade / industry
and officers.
(Vikas)
Under Secretary (Customs-III/VI)